Annotated Bibliography

NHERI and Dr. Brian Ray have been following, compiling, and disseminating all peer-reviewed and high-quality research on homeschooling and parent-led education since about 1984. Most dissertations and theses are not included. NHERI also conducts homeschooling research. The following bibliography is an essential resource to any person exploring or studying homeschooling research or conducting homeschool research.

Notes:

  • For best results with navigation and search, please view on desktop.
  • Listed URLs link to last known source. They will be linked if the source is still available. Note that we are currently in process of verifying and updating links.

Author Date / Year Title URL Keywords / Descriptors Annotation / Notes
Abbott, Myles B., & Miller, Jennifer A. 2006, November What you need to learn about homeschooling. Contemporary Pediatrics, 23(11), 48-50, 52, 56-58. http://www.modernmedicine.com/modernmedicine/Child+Behavior+and+Development/What-you-need-to-learn-about-homeschooling/ArticleStandard/Article/detail/385844 home education, homeschooling, pediatrics, children, medical, medicine, health, research, opinion “Effective health care for the homeschooled child requires understanding of the issues, an open line of communication to parents, and the vigilance to ensure that children not covered by the safety net of school screening get the care they need.” – online description 11/15/2001 from http://www.modernmedicine.com/modernmedicine/Child+Behavior+and+Development/What-you-need-to-learn-about-homeschooling/ArticleStandard/Article/detail/385844. Maybe mentions vaccinations, immunizations.
Abuzandah, Sameer 2020 Social skills for homeschooling students. Creative Education, 11(7), 1064-1072. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4236/ce.2020.117078. https://doi.org/10.4236/ce.2020.117078 Homeschooling, home schooling, home education, Education, Curriculum, Social Skills, Morals, socialization, peer-reviewed “This research was meant to provide insight into the impacts of homeschooling on the social life of homeschooled children. The study draws on learning theories from various scholars and theorists, such as Lev Vygotsky and Jean Piaget, to explain the basis of homeschooling in as far as social development of a child is concerned. The methodological approach of the study was multiple case studies with 12 participants, half of whom were students currently being homeschooled, and the rest were parent instructors. Semi-structured interviews were used to obtain qualitative data. The findings of the study showed that homeschooling generally enables children to acquire good morals and values, which are essential in social interactions with people. However, it became apparent that to foster the cognitive development of a child; one needs to be given some time to physically interact with peers, albeit in controlled environments under the supervision of the parents. The study concludes that homeschooling can enhance a child’s social skills, provided the necessary teaching approach is taken by the parent instructor to facilitate constructive social interactions with peers.”
Acker, Kathleen Ambruso; Gray, Mary W.; Jalali, Behzad; & Pascal, Matthew 2012, April Mathematics and homeschooling. Notices of the AMS, 59(4), 513-521. (Retrieved April 5, 2012 from http://www.ams.org/notices/201204/rtx120400513p.pdf). http://www.ams.org/notices/201204/rtx120400513p.pdf homeschooling, home education, law, policy, theory, philosophy, mathematics, gender Argue that the State is responsible for all children’s education and some homeschool children might not be getting the education the State – while mixing the ever-changing objectives of individual U.S. state-level governments and the federal government – believes they should get, then the State should much more tightly control private home-based education in all 50 of the United States. Argue the State should mandate all home-educated children be registered with the State, be vaccinated, be given achievement tests, and be monitored by the State, and that the State should do mandatory background checks on all parents who ask the State for the privilege of homeschooling. There are many problems in the logic and presentation of the authors. For example, they provide no empirical evidence that a problem exists that needs to be solved. They cite no research that a percent of home-educated students are performing academically below where they should be based on their academic aptitude or other traits. They cite no research that the home educated are at any higher risk of child abuse than are public-school or private-school students. In fact, they fail to cite the research that shows there is not even a correlation between the level of state control over homeschooling and the academic achievement of the home educated. Second, the authors do almost nothing to convince the reader that girls are at any special risk of not learning Algebra II or Geometry, let alone basic math or Algebra I, if they are home educated rather than taught in State-controlled schools. In fact, they provide no evidence that general society should be concerned about certain sub-populations of girls not learning as much math as other subpopulations. If research were to show that home-educated girls in conservative Christian homes were more mathematically literate than girls in State schools, would they recommend that public school girls be forced by the government to be homeschooled? Assuming for a moment that the authors’ interpretation and summary of court case law is reasonable and accurate, they provide no reason for the reader to believe that “case law,” the decisions of courts, of judges, should control the educational lives of Americans and their children. The authors provide no conceptual framework for why case law should govern their or the readers’ thinking and policy. aaa
ACT 2005 ACT high school profile report, h s graduating class 2005, hs graduating class, national report, Code 990-000. Retrieved 11/28/05 online http://www.act.org/news/data/05/pdf/data.pdf. 24 pages. Iowa City, Iowa: Author. http://www.act.org/news/data/05/pdf/data.pdf home education, research, academic achievement, college Reports three high school backgrounds and ACT Composite score for students from the three: homeschooled 22.5 [n=8,075, 0.68% of all students], “earned a GED” 19.1 [n=1,256, 0.10% of all students], and “all students” 20.9, n=1,186,251.
ACT [American College Testing, formerly] 1997 ACT high school profile; Home schooled composite report; HS graduating class 1997. Iowa City, IA: Author. academic achievement, college, home education Presents ACT scores for class of 1997. For the high school graduating class of 1997, ACT tested 959,000 students nationwide; of these, 1,926 were identified as home schooled. The home schooled scored, on average, in English at 23.0 compared to 20.3 for the national average. Their math average was 20.2 compared to 20.6. Reading scores were at 24.4 compared to the national average of 21.3. They scored in science reasoning at 22.0 compared to 21.1. And the home-schooled composite average was 22.5 compared to the national average of 21.0. According to the rule of thumb that a difference between groups of about one-third of a standard deviation (or more) is of practical significance, these home-school youth who were interested in college outperformed the national average in English and reading and on the overall composite of the ACT and there was little to no difference in terms of math and science reasoning skills.
ACT [formerly, American College Testing] 2004, August ACT high school profile report, h s graduating class 2004, hs graduating class national report, Code 990-000. Retrieved 8/19/04 online http://www.act.org/news/data/04/pdf/data.pdf. 24 pages. Iowa City, Iowa: Author. http://www.act.org/news/data/04/pdf/data.pdf home education, research, academic achievement, college Reports three high school backgrounds and ACT Composite score for students from the three: homeschooled 22.6 [0.67% of all students], “earned a GED” 18.9 [0.18% of all students], and “all students” 20.9.
Adams, Alice Celia 1983 A comparative study of values among Christian school parents, Christian school teachers, and public school teachers. Dissertation Abstracts International, 44(1), 0064A. Georgia State University, 158 p.
Adams, Blair, & Stein, Joel 1988 Wisdom’s children: Home education and the roots of restored biblical culture; necessity and possibility, general principles and particulars. Austin, TX: Truth Forum (Available from Truth Forum, 2433 North 43rd Street, Waco TX 76710). home education, philosophy, Christian worldview
Adams, Blair, Stein, Joel, & Wheeler, Howard 1989 Who owns the children? Compulsory education and the dilemma of ultimate authority. Austin, TX: Truth Forum (2433 North 43rd Street Waco TX 76710).. religion, Christian, constitution, law, legal, home education, private education
Adams, Melinda 2005 Optimizing homeschoolers’ experiences in museums. Master’s (M.A.) thesis, John F. Kennedy University. homeschooling, museums, education, collaboration Provides solid information and insight regarding homeschooling families and museums. Supports and promotes relationships between homeschooling community and museums. “My overarching aim was to explore the modern homeschool movement, current museum practices and how museums can better serve this unique community” (p. 13). “Clearly, the majority of homeschool families visits museums and supports them through memberships and participation in programs. They seek challenging museum programs and in-depth learning experiences for their children. Homeschool educators will travel great distances to participate in programs that are specifically designed to serve their needs. The homeschool educators’ preference for in-depth experiences goes beyond traditional programming and classes to include opportunities such as mentorship’s and volunteering. Homeschool families are enthusiastic about museums and view them as important resources in their children’s education” (p. 134). “There are striking parallels between the homeschooling movement—its philosophies and approaches to learning—and current museum educational practices. Museum programs that adhere to Constructivism and Vygotsky’s Zone of Proximal Development closely align with homeschooling philosophies in creating an ideal learning environment for homeschooled children” (p. 135). “The relationship between museums and the homeschool community is symbiotic. Ideally, both the institution and the homeschool community will benefit from forging a better relationship. By leveraging the strengths of the museum—object and place-based learning, subject experts, and authentic experiences—programs and learning opportunities can be expanded and tailored to homeschooled children, informal learners, and all visitors. In turn, the museums will be able to cultivate and maintain active memberships and volunteer bases, increase participation in educational programs thereby increasing funding, and create life long support for the institution” (p. 137).
Adcock, John circa 1995 In place of schools: A novel plan for the 21st century. Camberley, England: New Education Press Ltd. A book story which opens in late December 2029, schools as we know them now have largely disappeared; aided by a parent, children of age 4 to 13 are taught in their own homes, tutors' homes, community resource centers, and many other venues; professional personal tutors prepare individual study programs for their twenty pupils; childhood education is family-based and professionally assisted. Home education, fiction, family
Adkins, H. J. 2004 Investigating emotional intelligence and social skills in home schooled students. (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Western Kentucky University, Bowling Green. homeschooling, homeschool, research, social skills, socialization, emotional intelligence Tested homeschooled children in Grades 3 to 12. The children’s parents completed the Parent Form. The results showed that for both elementary (Grades 3–6) and secondary (Grades 7–12) students, children’s total social skills scores were significantly higher than the test norms. (Individual scale scores were not reported.) Parents’ ratings of their children’s social skills were also significantly higher than the norms, and ratings of problem behaviors lower.
Advanced Training Institute of America 1991 Advanced Training Institute information and application. Available from ATIA, Box 1, Oak Brook IL 60522-3001. Talks about interaction between families and businesses, lawyers, medical doctors, educators, and apprenticeship-type situations.
Agosti, K. 1981 For reinforcing basic skills... there's no place like home. Instructor, 91, 76-82.
Aiex, P. K. 1994 Home schooling, socialization, and creativity in children. Washington, DC: Office of Educational Research and Improvement, U.S. Department of Education. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 367 040). home education, socialization, creativity
Aikin [Aiken?], Wilford M. 1942 The story of the 8 year study. New York NY: Harper and Row. eight-year study. Many curricular and innovations in 30 schools of great demographic variety, 300 colleges and universities agreed to waive their entrance requirements for graduates of these 30 schools that experimented with curriculum, and these students did as well as or better in academics and the arts than those who attended the more traditional schools. Pages 20-21 may be of particular interest.
Aizenman, Nurith C. 2000, October 19 Blacks in Prince George’s Join Home-Schoooling Trend, The Washington Post, page A01. Published and retrieved 10/19/00 online http://washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A36262-2000Oct18.html. http://washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A36262-2000Oct18.html home education, black, blacks, minorities, reasons, population Explains that the increasing number of blacks homeschooling is for various reasons including better academics, teaching African American culture, religious training, proper social interaction and influence, and using appropriate learning styles. Connects the high rate of homeschooling among blacks in Prince George’s County to their relatively high wealth. Cites Patricia M. Lines as estimating there are 1.5 to 2.0 million homeschool students in the US today.
Alanna Bjorklund-Young & Angela R. Watson 2024 The changing face of American homeschool: A 25-Year comparison of race and ethnicity, Journal of School Choice, 18(4), 540-553, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2024.2422743 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2024.2422743 Changing trends; homeschool; school sector comparisons; student demographic characteristics “Abstract: We use nationally representative data to explore the racial composition of modern homeschoolers. Analysis of the National Household Education Survey suggests that the proportion of students of color homeschooling has increased modestly, from 25% in 1998–99 to 29% in 2022–23, suggesting less diversity than public school students but similar to the private school population. However, the Household Pulse Survey suggests more racial diversity in modern homeschooling, with 40% of homeschoolers being students of color. Regardless, both surveys show hundreds of thousands of homeschoolers of color across the U.S., and homeschooling narratives should be updated to reflect these students.”
Alaska Department of Education 1983 Centralized correspondence study. Juneau, AK: Author.
Alaska Department of Education 1983 Centralized Correspondence School [CCS]: Summary of the school district report card to the public. Juneau AK: Author. home education, research, academic achievement, state-sponsored, public schools, cooperation Academic achievement scores of CCS students on the Iowa Test of Basic Skills is largely above the national average.
Alaska Department of Education 1983 Intervention review. Juneau, AK: Author. An untitled report on a student achievement study for students on Centralized Correspondence Study.
Alaska Department of Education 1983-84 Centralized Correspondence Study handbook for grades K-12. Juneau, AK: Author.
Alaska Department of Education 1984 Summary of SRA testing for Centralized Correspondence Study April/May 1984. Juneau, AK: Alaska Author.
Alaska Department of Education 1985 SRA survey of basic skills and Alaska Statewide Assessment, Spring of 1985 [for Centralized Correspondence Study [CCS] Students]. Juneau, AK: Author. home education, research, academic achievement, state-sponsored, public schools, cooperation “For the second year in a row, CCS students have performed well above the national average, overall [in academic achievement]” p. 4. CCS students scored better on the Alaska Statewide Assessment than did their Alaska peers in conventional public schools.
Alaska Department of Education 1986 Results from 1981 CAT [for CCS]. Juneau, AK: Author.
Alaska Department of Education 1993 Centralized Correspondence School: Summary of the school district report card to the public. Juneau, AK: Author. public school, cooperation, home education, academic achievement Shows CCS students are scoring on average at about the 78th percentile on the Iowa Test of Basic Skills. These students are essentially home schooled, i.e., public schooled at home.
Alaska Department of Education and Early Development 2024 About Interior Distance Education of Alaska [IDEA], https://www.ideafamilies.org/about-idea/ https://www.ideafamilies.org/about-idea/" target=“_blank">https://www.ideafamilies.org/about-idea/ public school at home, tax-funded school at home, distance education, homeschooling IDEA is operated by Galena City School District, a school district under the authority of the Alaska Department of Education and Early Development. “Our Beginnings: The Galena City School District, a small village on the Yukon River, is known throughout the state for innovation in education. The district includes two other schools in addition to IDEA. The Galena City School educates local children in grades PK-12. Galena Interior Learning Academy is a boarding school for high school students that combines the best in educational methods with a focus on teaching practical vocational skills. In June 1997, the Galena City School District created an innovative homeschool support program. At that time, all of the correspondence programs in Alaska, whether state-wide or in-district, sent a standard grade-level curriculum package to enrolled families and graded all of the student’s work through the mail. Galena was the first district to recognize national statistics showing the excellent academic experience that most homeschoolers were providing for their children, and to honor the individuality of homeschool approaches. Galena hired several homeschooling parents to be on staff right at the inception of IDEA. Their primary role was to provide a homeschooler’s perspective on every element of the program as it was created and developed. IDEA was founded on the then-unique principle of honoring the parent’s ability to provide an excellent one-on-one tutoring experience, using individualized curriculum materials and educational methods. Much to the surprise of most educators in the state, 1157 students were enrolled that first year, and enrollment tripled the following year. IDEA enrollment continued to rise and is currently over 7,000 students, the biggest school in Alaska. As a result of IDEA’s unprecedented popularity, there are now many similar programs in Alaska. However, we were the first and we strive to be the best!”
Alberta Department of Education 1984, December A study of private schools in Alberta. Edmonton, Alberta: Alberta Dept. of Education Planning Services Branch. (ERIC Document No. ED256021). http://www.eric.ed.gov compliance A study of private schools within Alberta, Canada and their effect upon the public education sector.). (“Abstract: This study was commissioned by Alberta Education [Canada] to examine the development and organization of private schools in Alberta and to consider future directions. It examines the financial issues related to private schools, the effect of private schools on public school systems and on the education of children, and implications for public school jurisdictions and government. Possible alternatives are identified, and recommendations are made for future action. Part 1 is a discussion of the context, issues, and objectives of the study. Part 2 describes the elaborate four-phase process of the study: design, research requirements, data analysis, and final report. Part 3, the bulk of the report, is a discussion of conclusions and recommendations arranged according to 10 key policy issues: (1) rationale for private schools' continuation; (2) rationale and extent of provincial control over them; (3) nature of controls; (4) public funding for operating expenses; (6) categorization of private schools; (7) need for statutory controls; (8) need for administrative controls; (9) effect on public school system of private schools; and (10) role of Alberta Education in home schooling. Three appendixes list study participants and acknowledgements, the 10 resource papers incorporated in the study, and a glossary of terms” (retrieved 7/16/13 from http://www.eric.ed.gov). (legal); educational policy; elementary secondary education; financial policy; financial support; foreign countries; government role; government school relationship; homeschooling, home schooling; policy formation; private education; private school aid; private schools; public policy; school choice; school funds; school support, educational policy, government school relationship, private education, private school aid, private schools.
Alberta Department of Education 1984, May Gallup summary report. Edmonton, Alberta: Canadian Gallup Poll Ltd. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED251171). Educational Attitudes, Elementary Secondary Education, Private Schools, Public Opinion, Public Schools A study of 1,054 adults as to their schooling background.
Aleccia, Jonel 1991, August 25 Home ed. Mail Tribune, pp.1C, 10C. home education, parent attitudes
Alexander, Kelly King 2000, April Homeschooling: Is it right for you? Parents, 75(4), 114-120. home education, parents, decision, alternatives, opinion, research Discusses recent trends in homeschooling, response of parents to violence and murder at public schools like Columbine High School in Littleton, CO, presents research findings on homeschooling, and suggests nine steps parents take while deciding whether to home educate their children. Quotes Dr. Brian Ray and cites the work of the National Home Education Research Institute among other researchers and research.
Alexander, Sarah 2007, May 28 Revolutionary parenting [a book review]. Retrieved December 18, 2007 from http://www.intellectualconservative.com/2007/05/28/revolutionary-parenting/. http://www.intellectualconservative.com/2007/05/28/revolutionary-parenting/ “Only 5 out of 100 parents polled at a Christian Educators' Conference read to their kids. A review of Revolutionary Parenting by George Barna. A month ago at a Christian educators’ conference, the speaker took a poll. He wanted to know how many parents read the Bible to their children at least once over the past week. The results were alarming. Only 5 out of the 100 parents in the room responded affirmatively. ….. So, how does one become a revolutionary parent? Barna [George Barna, author of Revolutionary Parenting] has researched hundreds of families who have produced spiritual champions. ….. In your parenting, be intentional. Set goals for your family and their spiritual growth. ….. When Barna asked “young adults what they felt were the most significant mistakes that America’s parents have made, the second highest-ranked mistake was not spending enough time with their children.” This is yet another plug for spending quality time and reading the Bible with your children. Also, God commands it: You shall put these words of mine in your heart and soul, and you shall bind them as a sign on your hand, and fix them as an emblem on your forehead. Teach them to your children, talking about them when you are at home and when you are away, when you lie down and when you rise. ….. Another observation is that fathers have a deep yearning and sense that they need to provide a life of luxury for their child. The studies that Barna did indicate that children from this generation were not as upset by lack of things as they are by the lack of attention from their parent.”
Algario, Deborah 2019 Impact of structured teaching work systems on behavioral and academic achievement of homeschooled students with autism. Doctoral dissertation (Ed.D.), Grand Canyon University, Phoenix, Arizona. special education, autism, homeschooling, academic achievement, english language arts, goal attainment scaling, maladaptive behavior, structured teaching work systems “Abstract. The purpose of this quantitative pre-experimental study was to examine, to what degree, if any the use of structured teaching work systems increased academic achievement in the curricular area of English Language Arts and decreased maladaptive behaviors among homeschooled students with autism in grades K-8. Bandura’s cognitive-social learning theory, as well as Skinner’s behaviorist theory, provided the theoretical framework for the study. There were two research questions which sought to determine if the use of structured teaching work systems significantly increased students’ levels of academic achievement in ELA and whether the use of structured teaching work systems significantly decreased students’ levels of maladaptive behavior. Both variables were measured using the Goal Attainment Scaling instrument. The sample (n = 37) consisted of homeschooled students in grades K-8 that resided within the United States and had a diagnosis of autism. A Wilcoxon signed-rank test was used to analyze any differences in scores between pretest and posttest, for each of the research questions. The results of the test showed a statistically significant increase in student’s academic achievement in ELA and maladaptive behavior from pretest and posttest measures. The results of this study present evidence to support that the use of structured teaching work systems can assist in contributing to an increase in academic achievement in the curricular area of English Language Arts and a decrease in maladaptive behaviors among students in grades K-8 with a diagnosis of autism. Keywords: special education, autism, homeschooling, academic achievement, english language arts, goal attainment scaling, maladaptive behavior, structured teaching work systems” (p. v).
Alias, Norlidah; Rahman, Mohd Nazri Abdul; Siraj, Saedah; & Ibrahim, Ruslina 2013 A model of homeschooling based on technology in Malaysia. The Malaysian Online Journal of Educational Technology, 1(3), 10-16. alternative education, homeschooling, home education, Interpretive Structural Modeling Studies aims to design “… homeschooling learning and teaching models based on the latest technology in Malaysia” (p. 11) and “… identify the relationship between the elements involved in implementing learning and teaching activitiesin homeschooling by parents in Malaysia” (p. 11). Respects homeschooling parents as legitimate and knowledgable educators. “Homeschooling in Malaysia is a form of alternative education that emphasizes quality education based on moral values and belief in strengthening family ties. The purpose of this study is to produce a model of homeschooling technologybased learning activities in Malaysia as a guideline to improve the quality of education, curriculum and organize the delivery of learning content and teaching for homeschooling children. This study used the Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM) process to develop a model and map the relationship between the elements involved in the homeschooling model-based learning and teaching technology. This study dismantled a complex system into several sub-systems using practical experience and knowledge of the conduct of homeschooling by parents in Malaysia. A group of eight experts have reached consensus on seven elements of technology based activities in homeschooling teaching and learning practice, namely: The Social Networking Sites; Online Materials Development; access information via the Internet; M-Learning: Interactive Video Games, Digital stories and the Web Site (Web-Portal). The findings provide guidelines for homeschooling parents to plan teaching and learning activities based on priorities” (p. 10). “Homeschooling curriculumselectioninMalaysia is enteredonreligiousleanings or pedagogical aspects (Ebinezar, 2008). While teaching and learning activities planned in homeschooling are largely based on the latesttechnology. Thisis due to the existence of variousforms oftechnology that hasmade it possible for parents to share information, expertise, and problems in implementing teaching and learning activities. Hence the presence of various web sites and social sites to promote homeschooling is a bridge into the teaching and learning process of homeschooling children” (p. 14). ISM), Malaysia
Alias, Norlidah; Siraj, Saedah; Rahman, Mohd. Nazri Abdul; & Dewitt, Dorothy 2013 Homeschooling in Malaysia: The implications for teacher services. Malaysian Online Journal of Educational Management, 1(2), 10 – 18. alternative education, homeschooling, home education, reasons, Interpretive Structural Modeling Apparently promotes a statist and non-individual-liberty/development purpose for education, including that done in homeschooling, in the following: “The importance of homeschooling has increased the demand for and the supply of recognized and accredited courses for certification at diploma, degree and post-degree levels in education over the internet. The impact of this curriculum is on policy makers as well as the implementers of the homeschooling curriculum for an appropriate curriculum to meet the educational needs of homeschoolers. The supply-and-demand for qualified teachers and experienced professionals to meet this requirement must be generated to ensure that this generation of homeschoolers meet the educational aspirations of the country, especially nationalism and national identity” (p. 15). “Homeschooling offers an alternative choice for parents concerned about the formation of the child’s spiritual, physical and academic needs. Through proper pedagogical practices, parents who have grievances against the mainstream education system can ensure their chidlren are educated (Collom, 2005; Ruslina et.al., 2012; Ebinezar, 2008; Mohd Nazri et.al., 2012). Teacher services need to be planned carefully to meet the educational needs of homeschooling in Malaysia. The existence of alternative education today has impacted mainstream education in terms of curriculum implementation or the enrolment in schools. The different forms of technology tools can accelerate the evolution of homeschooling based on the sharing of information, expertise and by providing platforms for implementing activities in a collaborative teaching and learning environment for homeschoolers. Hence the impact of homeschooling on the services of teachers in the present and future, not only transforms the dimension of teaching services but also demands a change in the patterns and organizational of responsibilities of teachers in mainstream schools” (p. 16). “Abstract: In Malaysia, homeschooling is a form of alternative education that emphasizes quality education based on moral values and belief in strengthening family ties. The purpose of this study is to produce a Factor Selection Model of homeschooling which is based on the connotation that parents reject the public school system. This model can be used as a guideline to improve the quality of the education system in terms of teacher services quality. This study uses Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM) as a process to develop a model and map the relationship between the elements in the Factor Selection Model of homeschooling in Malaysia. This study dismantles the complex system into several sub-systems using the practical experience and knowledge of parents conducting homeschooling in Malaysia. A group of fifteen experts reached a consensus on six elements for selection of homeschooling: Religious and ethical reasons; Family Lifestyle and Parenting; Demographics; Home Environment; Special Needs of the Child; and Educational Philosophy. The findings can provide guidance to policy makers and curriculum implementers on policies which need to be developed related to homeschooling curriculum design and teacher training (teacher services). The findings also highlight the short and long-term implications for the organization of the homeschooling curriculum and its practice in mainstream schools, and for teachers' needs and efficiency in future” (p. 10). (ISM).
Allen, Cheri 1984 Learning is a family affair: A guide for parents of young children. ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. 272 303. "Part of a three-volume series, this guide is intended for parents of young children of preschool through kindergarten age. The purpose of the guide is to provide ideas and activities to help in ;the development of various basic skill areas which will be important for children's later success in school" Resources in Education, 21(12), 123. Focuses on self-concept, discipline, the learning environment at home, language, listening skills, motor development, pre-reading, numbers, and thinking skills).
Allevo, R. 1982 Review of Teach your own by John Holt. Journal of Education, 164, 297-301.
Allie-Carson, Jayn 1990 Structure and interaction patterns of home school families. Home School Researcher, 6(3), 11-18. home education, family structure and relationships, parents, socialization Available from National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309 “In general, the majority of families in this study did tend to congregate in the upper right quadrant of the Circumplex Model. However, a closer examination appears to indicate that these families continue to stay in the upper right quadrant and to have higher scores for both cohesion and adaptability than is true for the general population of families with school age children in more conventional school settings. [paragraph] Although these families tended to be highly adaptive, they appear to have been able to achieve a kind of dynamic equilibrium between stability and change. For example, most of these families had been home schooling for more than one or two years. [paragraph] The presence of this kind of equilibrium suggests that there are stabilizing forces within home school family systems which allow most of these families to accommodate higher levels of both adaptability and cohesion than the population of families whose children are more conventionally schooled” [p. 17]
Allis, Sam 1990, October 22 Schooling kids at home. Time, 136(17), 84, 86.
Allred, Meghan K. 2024 Home Educators’ Experiences Teaching Beginning Readers: A Phenomenological Study. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Liberty University, https://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/doctoral/6210 https://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/doctoral/6210 homeschool, homeschooling, home educators, early literacy, beginning reading, reading models, comprehensive reading program, Gagné, conditions of learning theory, phonics “Abstract. The purpose of this phenomenological study was to investigate how home educators describe their experiences teaching literacy to beginning readers in the United States. The theory guiding this study was Gagné’s conditions of learning theory as it relates to the literacy teaching experiences of presenting literacy content, eliciting performance of literacy skills, assessing literacy performance, and enhancing literacy retention and transfer in homeschool settings. The central research question was: How do home educators describe their literacy teaching experiences for beginning readers? A transcendental phenomenological approach was used to explore the shared homeschool experience of teaching beginning readers. Participants were selected through purposive and snowball sampling techniques. Qualitative data was collected through questionnaires, individual interviews, and focus groups and was analyzed to find common themes among the participants’ statements. Results show that the majority of participants want their children to develop a love for reading. They do this by reading aloud to their children, making reading a consistent part of their daily routine, doing things to help their children avoid frustration and pressure while learning to read, and individualizing their children’s reading and literacy education. They felt that children were ready to read when they showed the desire and intrinsic motivation. All but one participant used a phonics-based reading curriculum. Parents described teaching beginning reading as sometimes challenging. They also said that they became more relaxed over time as they gained confidence in their teaching abilities and saw their children succeed at their own pace.”
Almasoud, Sahar; & Fowler, Samantha R. 2016 The Difference in the Academic Achievements of Homeschooled and Non-Homeschooled Students. Home School Researcher, 32(1), 1-4. curriculum, education, homeschooling, non-homeschooling, academic achievement, college, transition, parents, gender, peer-reviewed “The size of the study sample was (𝑁𝑁= 44); 22 of them were students who were home-schooled at least in secondary school. Home-schooled participants were taught by parents, guardians, and/or tutors. Parents or guardians directed the educational development of their home-schooled children throughout high school. The other 22 participants were traditionally schooled students whose education took place in a formal setting of a public or private high school.” (p. 2). “Student academic achievement was defined as a student’s final grade point average (GPA) on achieving his/her bachelor’s degree” (p. 3). “Abstract. The purpose of this study was to investigate if there is any significant difference in the success of home-schooled and non-home-schooled students after a year of study at a private university in the Southeast United States. The university has five major academic colleges with strong emphases on science, engineering, technology, and mathematics. An ex post facto research design used grade point average upon completion of a bachelor’s degree to determine whether there was a significant difference between the academic achievements of both groups. A statistically significant difference was found between the overall GPA’s of home-schooled students and traditionally schooled students. Undergraduate students who were home schooled had a higher GPA mean compared to undergraduate students who were non-home-schooled. These results support some, but not all, of what has been shown from previous studies in the literature with regards to the academic achievement of home-schooled students in college” (p. 1). “Participants were the students who enrolled either on campus or online at a STEM-focused private university with a diverse population of students consisting of 30.94% international students from 101 different countries with the remaining students from 47 states. Half the university’s students were enrolled in the College of Engineering, while others were distributed among the College of Science, College of Aeronautics, College of Business, and College of Psychology and Liberal Arts. The average SAT I score for freshmen was 1150, compared to the national average of 1010. All students accepted into the university had a B+ or higher in math and science classes in high school, and over 90% had a 3.0 or above grade point average (GPA) in high school. The size of the study sample was (𝑁𝑁= 44); 22 of them were students who were home-schooled at least in secondary school. Home-schooled participants were taught by parents, guardians, and/or tutors. Parents or guardians directed the educational development of their home-schooled children throughout high school. The other 22 participants were traditionally schooled students whose education took place in a formal setting of a public or private high school. They were required to attend classes every day. Their sources of knowledge were usually limited to the school environment, their teachers, library books, and their peers. Participants included 14 females and 30 males ranging in age from 17 to 28 years old” (p. 2). Ex post facto research design, cross-sectional and descriptive and causal-comparative in a sense. Not matched, not multivariate. Peer-reviewed.
Altman, Mickey D. 1985 Legal implications of home instruction with emphasis on the state of Washington. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Washington State University, Pullman. Law.
Alvord, S. T. 2003 Comparison of perceived social self-efficacy and self-esteem between home and traditionally educated college students (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 3093976) homeschooling, homeschool, college, adult, socialization, social self-efficacy, self-esteem Found that in the first few weeks of college, previously homeschooled students were judged by their professors to be less socially confident than others, though the students themselves did not agree.
American Educational Research Association 1995 Annual meeting program, AERA, April 18-22, 1995, San Francisco [CA]. Washington, DC: Author. research, social services, school-based services, school-linked services, integrated services, comprehensive services, government, policy Theme of the annual meeting is “parnterships for a new America.” Many presenters at the meeting promoted the concept that state (public) schools must become sites of comprehensive social, psychological, and physical health services for children (see, e.g., sessions 50.61 & 56.12). These are also called school-based or school-linked or integrated or comprehensive services. According to these people, apparently, “it takes a village to raise a child” (old African proverb). The village, to them, must strongly rely on public schools, along with many other segments of society, to gathering around an innocent baby to protect him, to teach him, and to love him [James, K. C., 1996].
American Humanist Association and Jason Michael Holden v. United States of America; Federal Bureau of Prisons; Federal Correctional Institution Sheridan 2014 Case 3:14-cv-00565-HA Document 33 Filed 10/30/14. legal, court, federal court, religion, secular humanism US District Court finds that “Secular Humanism” is a religion. “Moreover, the Ninth Circuit appears to be moving toward the view that the "disparate treatment of theistic and non-theistic religions is as offensive to the Establishment Clause as disparate treatment of theistic religions." Faith Ctr. Church Evangelistic Ministries v. Glover, 480 F.3d 891, 902 (9th Cir. 2007 Bybee, J., dissenting). Such a view is consistent with longstanding Supreme Court jurisprudence. In Torcaso v. Watkins, the Supreme Court said that the government must not "aid those religions based on a belief in the existence of God as against those religions founded on different beliefs." 367 U.S. 488, 495 (1961). Among these latter religions, in a footnote the Court included Secular Humanism. Id. at 495 n. 11. Therefore, the court finds that Secular Humanism is a religion for Establishment Clause purposes and that plaintiffs have alleged sufficient facts to state a claim for relief that is plausible on its face. Iqbal, 556 U.S. at 678. (page 11, Opinion and Order)
American Legislative Exchange Council 2000, August 25 name of study unknown?? education, spending, economics, financing, academic achievement Study finds there is no correlation between increased spending and student performance. The study reported on state education performance, noting that Minnesota's public school performance ranked highest in the nation, spending at an average of $6,245 per student. The District of Columbia's public school performance ranked last, even with spending $8,670 per student. ALEC Chairman Ray Hynes said, "This study shows the path of least resistance fails our children, and that throwing more money at the problem is not the answer." Over the last decade, spending per pupil has increased by 23 percent nationwide in real dollars, yet our public schools continue to perform poorly.
Amsden, Diana Avery 1980, November/December Two generations of home schooling. Mother Earth News, pp. 46-47.
Anania, J. 1982 The effects of quality instruction on the cognitive and affective learning of students. Dissertation Abstracts International, 44, 2025A. tutor, tutoring, achievement Probably addresses tutoring and academic achievement.
Anderson, Sloan Okrey; & Lough, Benjamin J. 2019/2021 Sexual and gender minoritized youth in Christian home schools: Perceptions of climate and support. Journal of LGBT Youth, 18 (4), https://doi.org/10.1080/19361653.2019.1700404 https://doi.org/10.1080/19361653.2019.1700404 LGBT youth, adolescents, educational policy, family, religion, homophobia, suicide, mental health Abstract: In 2014, Leelah Alcorn, a homeschooled transgender teenager in the United States, died by suicide after enduring months of social isolation and her parent’s repeated efforts to change her gender identity. Sexual and gender minoritized (SGM) youth who are, like Leelah, homeschooled in the U.S. do not have access to the institutional and relational supports afforded to SGM youth in public schools. This study examines how variations in educational setting, family support, internet access, and peer relationships influence mental health outcomes in a sample of 651 sexual and gender minoritized (SGM) young adults who were primarily homeschooled in Christian homes. Participants reported extremely high rates of mental illness (87%) suicidal ideation (72%), suicide attempts (22%) self-harm (66%), and substance abuse (29%). Regression analysis revealed that a positive family attitude toward SGM people (although rare) and access to the internet were the most significant protective factors against negative mental health outcomes in this sample. This study explores the unique vulnerabilities of SGM youth in Christian homeschool settings and has implications for educators, policy makers, health care providers, and mental health and social service professionals. To our knowledge, this is the first study to explore the experiences of homeschooled SGM youth.”
Andrade, Albert G. 2008 An exploratory study of the role of technology in the rise of homeschooling. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Ohio University, Instructional Technology (Education). Retrieved April 2, 2020 from http://rave.ohiolink.edu/etdc/view?acc_num=ohiou1204138318 http://rave.ohiolink.edu/etdc/view?acc_num=ohiou1204138318 homeschooling, homeschooling; technology; internet; private education; communication, qualitative research, barriers, obstacles “Abstract: The purpose of the research was to understand the relationship between the advent and wide-scale diffusion of computer and communication technologies and the growth of home education in the U.S. As a qualitative study, 27 practicing and former homeschool parents from the greater Albany, NY region were recruited to participate in five focus group interviews. Questionnaire, one-on-one interview, and participant reflection data were collected, coded, and analyzed as well. As a group, participants perceived that modern media and internet technologies, along with several confluent social, political, and economic forces had facilitated, and perhaps fuelled, growth in homeschooling in the U.S. Participants felt that access and use of modern technologies had enabled their capacity [overcome barriers?] to educate their children at home. Most participants perceived that modern technologies helped provide the emotional and intellectual capital needed to make the leap to homeschooling. Results indicated that computer and communication technologies had helped parents lower informational, interpersonal, instructional, and psychological barriers of entry during the process of deliberation leading up the decision to homeschool. Once participants had committed to homeschooling, modern technologies helped them create, access, and sustain communities of practice. In addition, results showed that technology had helped participants energize latent or percolating ideologies of choice, individualism, and parental sovereignty. Future investigation should broaden the scope of the research to identify and examine the political, social, and cultural forces [barriers, overcoming barriers] that, along with modern technology, have enabled the growth in homeschooling the U.S. Future research should aim to validate and extend the findings from this study in an effort to develop an explanatory framework for understanding the modern homeschooling phenomenon.”
Angelis, Kristine L. 1998 The evolving relationship between home schoolers and their local public schools. (ERIC document number ED417483). home education, homeschooling, history, public schools, cooperation “The history of home schooling and its increasing interrelationship with public schooling are detailed. Demographic information on the home school population, a definition of home schooling, reasons to home school, and beliefs surrounding this practice are offered. A brief history of home schooling going back to the Colonial period of the United States is then provided, including the evolution of compulsory attendance laws, problems for home schooling, and the legality of home schooling. Legal issues are explored at length, with a focus on Supreme Court decisions that have affected home schooling, the role of private education, and the academic achievement of home schoolers. An analysis of public-school cooperation with home schoolers features examples such as dual enrollment, eligibility requirements for sports, and academic achievement. Some of the advantages and disadvantages are discussed, along with the internal problems that home schooling can engender. The paper closes with a profile of home schooling, outlining ideas to benefit public schools and the role of parents in such endeavors [ERIC abstract].”
Angus, M. 1979 Innovations in rural education: The Isolated Students' Matriculation Scheme in Western Australia and the Chidley Educational Centre. Studies in Rural education, 3, 1-46. Achievement; socialization.
Anthony, Kenneth V, & Burroughs, Susie 2012 Day to day operations of home school families: Selecting from a menu of educational choices to meet students’ individual instructional needs. International Education Studies, 5(1), 3-17 Home school, homeschooling, home education, educational choice, parental control, curriculum decision-making published by Canadian Center of Science and Education). (Used case study as the methodology, of four homeschool families in southeastern United States. This is not about Canada homeschooling. Authors appear to have a solid understanding of homeschooling and present a fair perspective on what is involved if these families are fairly representative of US homeschooling families in general. “The purpose of this study was to gain an in depth knowledge of the day to day activities of home school families in order to better understand the instructional techniques and curriculum decisions that contribute to the success of home education as an educational treatment. Of particular interest were home education practices that could be useful in traditional education settings” (p. 3). “Abstract: This study examined the day to day operations of home schools. The case study method was used with four families from a larger pool of families that held membership in a home school organization. Data was gathered using interviews, observations, and artifacts. Findings suggest that these families operated their home schools using traditional methods to reach progressive goals. The families operated their home schools much as a person in a restaurant would choose food from a menu. They identified instructional goals and selected methods from a variety of choices available to them including courses taught through a home school cooperative, community colleges, online courses, video instruction, and individual study. Public schooling was not an option available to them. Traditional schools can learn from this home school model as it serves as a resource that supports individual learning goals rather than as the sole distributor of knowledge in a community” (p. 3). “What can be learned from this study of four home school families that helps outsiders and critics better understand home schooling or is applicable to traditional schooling? First the families operated their home schools using a combination of traditional and progressive approaches. Though their primary teaching strategies were traditional, they used them to achieve a progressive end. Their goal was a well rounded, liberally educated adult who could learn and think on his or her own. The second finding was that the primary instructional method was reading. The families viewed the author of a book as the teacher and the reader as the pupil. Reliance on reading as an instructional method resulted in greater learner independence. They felt that the best way to learn was for the learner to grasp difficult ideas through reading. Traditional schools can adopt a similar view of reading and education as well as retreat from the testing mentality and begin to focus on teaching the whole student. Of particular interest is the idea that the families viewed education as a process. They did not tie education to a specific location or institution. They treated the education of their children as a diner does a menu. They chose the educational opportunities they wanted from a wide variety and implemented them. The choices on their menu included courses at the cooperative, online courses, courses taught by other people in the community, video courses, and dual enrollment at community colleges. Interestingly, the autonomy that these families exercise in educational decision making is not available in many traditional school settings. Children in traditional schools are generally required to receive their entire curriculum from the school with little option to go outside of the school to replace a course offered in the school. This provides a model that schools could adopt that might make them more relevant in the communities they serve. Schools would cease to be the only place associated with learning in a community and would become one of many resources available to families.” (p. 11).
Anthony, Kenneth V. 2013 Declarations of independence: Home school families’ perspectives on education, the common good, and diversity. Current Issues in Education, 16(1): 1-14. home education; autonomy; religion; parental control; common good; citizenship; diversity “Abstract: This study examined the perspectives of home school families regarding the rights, interests, and responsibilities of family and state over education. These families viewed the common good differently than critics of home schooling. They believed the diversity of curriculum and worldview in their home schools positively impacts the common good by increasing the overall diversity of society. These families situated the practice of home schooling within the exercise of religion inserting a Constitutional challenge into the debate over home schooling. The voices of these families, their declarations of independence from the educational norm in our nation, challenge our views of what really is the common good, what diversity we value, and what activities we include in our definition of the free exercise of religion.”
Anthony, Kenneth V. 2015 Educational cooperatives and the changing nature of home education: finding balance between autonomy, support, and accountability. Journal of Unschooling and Alternative Learning 9(18). homeschooling; nontraditional education; parent involvement; parents as teachers; partnerships in education “Abstract: Four families' experiences in an educational cooperative and the impact on their home schools are detailed in the study. Results indicated that the families were highly dependent upon the cooperative. The cooperative signified a compromise for the families between the freedom of home schooling and the accountability and support provided by a school. These findings are important for traditional education. Just as home schools are evolving and developing institutions that look something like schools, schools can change too. One way is for the traditional school to operate as a family and community resource rather than the sole purveyor of knowledge.”
Anthony, Kenneth V. & Burroughs, Susie 2010 Making the Transition from Traditional to Home Schooling: Home School Family Motivations. Current Issues in Education, 13(4). Retrieved from http://cie.asu.edu/ http://cie.asu.edu/ home education, motivations, home schooling, parental control, curriculum decision- making “Abstract: This study examined the motivations of families that operate home schools. Four intact, religiously conservative families were interviewed and observed over one year. Findings showed that families were motivated by multiple factors to leave traditional schooling and begin home schooling. Additionally, the motivations to home school influenced the families’ instructional practices. Finally, results indicated that the decision to home school was a positive decision for the families, not an outright rejection of traditional schooling. This study reveals the complex motivations to home school and may assist administrators, teachers, and policymakers in traditional schools induct and retain families considering home schooling.”
Anthony, Kenneth V. & Wildmon, Mark 2021 Be careful what you ask for: The pitfalls of using home school families as a pattern for traditional school family involvement. Paper presented at MidSouth Education Research Association 2021 Annual Conference at New Orleans, November 2021, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/355917916_Be_careful_what_you_ask_for_The_pitfalls_of_using_home_school_families_as_a_pattern_for_traditional_school_family_involvement https://www.researchgate.net/publication/355917916_Be_careful_what_you_ask_for_The_pitfalls_of_using_home_school_families_as_a_pattern_for_traditional_school_family_involvement homeschooling, parental involvement, public schools “Conclusion. Our study demonstrates that there are homeschool practices that parents with children in traditional schools can adopt as PI [parental involvement]. The PI that can be brought over from homeschooling expands on the concept of PI as defined in the literature. It shifts the focus of PI from supporting school-based learning to learning that happens in the home and encourages the development of learning independence. These homeschool practices in effect expand the view of PI to include an • Expanded concept of where learning should take place- home and the world as a classroom • Expanded concept of partnership between parent and child in learning • Expanded role of the student in learning • Expanded role of parents’ influence over school-based learning (curriculum) [p. 11 ends] We also demonstrated that many of the barriers to traditional school PI act as motivators for some families to homeschool. If schools want to increase PI, they must satisfactorily address these barriers with families or risk the families abandoning traditional schooling for homeschooling. Finally, the critics are right. There are many practices that traditional school families can adopt from homeschool families to increase PI but are the schools ready to cede control to families as many of these PI actions have the potential to shift control of education from the schools to the homes. Are the schools ready for parents to exercise increased influence over education decisions about curriculum? When the critics encourage all parents to be more like homeschool parents, they are opening the door to a significant shift in the qualitative nature of PI. The desired result is most likely more of the actions similar to the PI listed in Table 1, but home school PI is different. The expanded view of PI could potentially challenge the preeminent role of schools in education and result in conflict between parents and schools, either serving as a barrier to productive PI or serving to motivate some parents to abandon traditional schools in favor of homeschooling. Be careful what you ask for!” (p. 11-12).
Anthony, Kenneth V.; & Wildmon, Mark 2023 Broadening the concept of parent involvement Homeschool families as a pattern for traditional school parent involvement. Journal of Unschooling and Alternative Learning, 17(33), 26-57. parental involvement in school, homeschool, parent engagement in academics “Abstract: Parental Involvement (PI) research indicates that PI is positively associated with academic success and that for the past forty years researchers, teachers, and administrators have encouraged greater levels of parental involvement in schools to improve overall student achievement. This research reviews at home learning activities conducted by homeschool families that traditional school families can adopt as PI. Our analysis of homeschool families’ PI that could be adopted by traditional families led to several conclusions discussed within this review. The expanded view of PI could potentially challenge the preeminent role of schools in education and result in conflict between parents and schools, either serving as a barrier to productive PI or serving to motivate some parents to abandon traditional schools in favor of homeschooling.”
Appea, Pamela 2001 Teach your children well: African American Homeschoolers. Africana.com. Retrieved 6/8/01 online http://www.africana.com/DailyArticles/index_20010131.htm. http://www.africana.com/DailyArticles/index_20010131.htm home education, minorities, minority, black, African American Explains that the homeschool movement is growing rapidly, including among blacks. “ “Many minorities have finally recognized that government-run education, whose officials and teachers have told them for over 50 years that public schools would 'save them,' has not and cannot do so,” said Brian Ray, president of the National Home Education Research Institute. Ray says that roughly 30,000 to 50,000 African American children are home-schooled, but cautions that these numbers are estimates, since there are no reliable surveys on minority homeschooled children. But Ray notes that groups such as the newly-created National Black Home Educators Resource Association, based in Baker, Louisiana, are starting to find a voice.”
Apple, Michael W. 1982 Education and cultural reproduction: A critical reassessment of programs for choice [ch. 14, pp. 503-541], in Robert B. Everhart (Ed.), The public school monopoly: A critical analysis of education and the state in American society. philosophy, critique, public school, choice, reform Cambridge, MA: Ballinger Publishing Co., Subsidiary of Harper & Row, Publ., Inc. Michael W. Apple, in his chapter 14, entitled “Education and cultural reproduction: A critical reassessment of programs for choice,” says that in his analysis he is adopting “... a neo-Marxist perspective” [p. 505]; says one must consider the control of both culture and economy to understand what public schools do; talks much of class, production, means of production, and so forth; regarding turning education more into a capitalistic market situation and “... seemingly establishing a more pluralistic market ..... The symbolic benefit of choosing one’s school may tend to be exactly that, symbolic. The material benefits may continue to recapitulate the structure of inequality” [p. 529] [i.e., with respect to how much money one makes, what kind of job one has, and “... one’s relationship to the control and production of cultural and economic capital” [p. 505]] which is negatively affected by the promotion of “possessive individualism” [p. 528]; Apple’s concern is whether an education system ...
Apple, Michael W. 1993 Official knowledge: Democratic education in a conservative age. New York, NY: Routledge. philosophy, sociology, politics, curriculum, public schools Emphasizes “large-scale social forces” such as racism, classism, and sexism [p. 2]. Accuses Apple, a white-anglo, explains racism experienced by his black African-American son Paul and how “Their [large-scale social forces such as racism and sexism] effects are visceral” [p. 2]. His definitions of the common good and justice are, he says, based on an ethical and political principle and any social act “... ‘will be judged against the likelihood that it will result in linking equity, sharing, personal dignity, security, freedom, and caring’ This implies that we need to assure ourselves that the course we follow, inquire into, and analyze ‘will dignify human life, recognize the playful and creative aspects of people,’ and see others not as objects to manipulated or to be ‘freed’ to follow the dictates of the ‘invisible hand’ of the market, but as co-responsible subjects involved in the process of democratically deliberating over the ends and means of all of their institutions” [p. 3]. Apple is apparently Marxist or neo-Marxist [p. 3]. A key assumption of Apple’s thesis is the following: “The current conservative agenda in education has little interest in this position [his ethical and political principles and definition and vision regarding justice and equity and democratic deliberation just presented]. As I show later on, it has cleverly transformed the very meaning of democracy so that it is disconnected from the sentiments I express in the previous paragraph. In this regard, one of the hallmarks of the conservative agenda is its unremitting attack on education” [p. 3]; however, author probably really means it is an attack or critique of public, state-run schooling and its modus operandi, not really an attack on education per se. “But, the political and educational response of the Right leads in exactly the wrong direction, not only for children such as Paul [his son] but for the majority of people in this society. [new paragraph] For example, the conservative restoration is based on a de-integrative strategy that has as one of its results the creation of a ‘divided and amoral political community.’ The de-integrative character is visible in the withdrawal of the Right from corporatist arrangements which at least provided [page 3 ends here] safeguards and limited financial an political benefits to people” [p. 4]. Constantly presents divisive, group-based language; unapologetically stereotypes “the Right” as being very bigoted toward, if not hating, all these groups [p. 4]. “While there is a formal right for everyone to be represented in the debates over whose cultural capital, whose knowledge ‘that,’ ‘how,’ and ‘to,’ will be declared legitimate for transmission to future generations of students, it is still the case that, as I noted in the preceding chapter, a selective tradition operates in which only specific groups’ knowledge becomes official knowledge [of texts and curriculum materials used in schools]” [p. 65].
Apple, Michael W. 1996 Cultural politics and education. New York, NY: Teachers College Press. education, philosophy, sociology, history, politics, public schools Advocates heterogeneity, pluralism, and the local, not class, race, and gender hierarchies [p. xi]. Does not like “capitalist relations” which he says are constituted out of race, class, and gender relations [p. xi]. On the other hand, “... we too often assume ... that everything that exists within the educational system bears only the marks of domination. It’s all capitalist; it’s all racist; it’s all patriarchal; it’s all homophobic” and says he and others must be careful about the presentation of such ideas [p. xvii]. It appears he considers himself to be a neo-Marxist [p. xii]. Claims there are structurally generated inequalities in public education [p. xii]. Claims there are structurally generated inequalities in education [p. xiv]. “Many of us have quite ambivalent feelings about the place called school. All of us who care deeply about what is and is not taught, and about who is and is not empowered to deal with these issues, have a contradictory relationship to these institutions. We want to criticize them rigorously and yet in this very criticism lies a commitment, a hope, that they can be made more vital, more personally meaningful and socially critical. If ever there was a love/hate relationship, this is it. ..... ... in schools, I certainly do not want to act as an apologist for poor practices [in schools]. Yet, [p. xv ends here] during an era when--because of rightist attacks--we face the massive dismantling of the gains (limited as they are) that have been made in social welfare, in women’s control of their bodies, in relations of race, gender, and sexuality, and in whose knowledge is taught in schools, it is equally important to make certain that these gains are defended. [new paragraph] Thus, there is another clear tension in this volume. I want to both defend the idea of a public education, and a number of the gains that do exist, and at the same time to criticize many of its attributes” [p. xvi]. Appears he admits schooling has partially been an imposition on the politically/culturally inept but also sometimes public schools have helped the weaker win against the dominant [p. xvi]. Seems he thinks only state-run and tax-funded schools can be progressive and democratic. Author is apparently committed to advocating tax-funded schools even though they are fraught, according to him, with problems, including pushing the ideological agendas of one group on another. A summary of his concerns and beliefs is given in p. 5-8.
Apple, Michael W. 1998 Are markets and standards democratic? [a review of the book Devolution and choice in education: The school, the state and the market by Whitty, Power, and Halpin]. Educational Researcher, 27(6), 24-28. Apple takes an apparently neo-Marxist approach to reviewing this book. Says the research shows the market did not encourage diversity. Implies that must use public schools to right social ills and force persons to not avoid “the Other”--those different from themselves.
Apple, Michael W. 2000 The cultural politics of home schooling. Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 256-271. homeschooling, philosophy, critic, criticism, negative criticism, opposition Criticizes and opposes the practice of home education. On the other hand, Apple (2000) develops his negative criticism of homeschooling by focusing on conservative and religious homeschoolers, who have “… made their decision based on religious convictions, a large proportion have” (p. 257 rather than on homeschoolers “... who have not made their decision [to homeschool] based on religious convictions ..... I focus largely on this group, in part because it constitutes some of the most committed parents and in part because ideologically it raises a number of important issues” [p. 257]), links these homeschoolers with a conservative restoration in education, those who making advances against common sense, those who are anti-state, and anti-school and concludes: “In my mind, the task is to disentangle the elements of good sense evident in these concerns [e.g., too much bureaucracy in institutions and an overly-managerial state] from the selfish and antipublic agenda that has been pushing concerned parents and community members into the arms of the conservative restoration. (p. 269) ..... If schools do not do this [e.g., follow models of schooling that are committed to social justice and fairness in schools where teachers and students want to be], there may be all too many parents who are pushed in the direction of antischool sentiment. This would be a tragedy both for the public school system and for our already withered sense of community that is increasingly under threat” [p. 270]. Apple is careful in his piece to single out only “right wing” or “conservative” homeschoolers for his criticism and linked them to traits such as anti-state, anti-school, anti-public, a “… withered sense of community …” [p. 270], advances against common sense, and selfishness. “To better comprehend the antistatist impulses that lie behind a good deal of the home schooling movement, …” [p. 263]. Apple writes, “We now have emerging evidence ... that points to the fact that social justice often does lose with the expansion of home schooling in some states. ..... Religiously motivated home schoolers are currently engaged in exploiting public funding in ways that are not only hidden, but in ways that raise serious questions about the drain on economic resources during a time of severe budget crises in all too many school districts” [p. 268]. Apple implies the need for more state control of homeschooling, especially if “public money” is involved [p. 269].
Apple, Michael W. 2002, circa Righting wrongs and interrupting the right. Retrieved 4/12/04 online http://www.unc.edu/depts/antrho/talks/apple.pdf, 34 pp. http://www.unc.edu/depts/antrho/talks/apple.pdf education, philosophy, activism, politics, religion “Over the past decade, I have been engaged in a concerted effort to analyze the reasons behind the rightist resurgence—what I call “conservative modernization”—in education and to try to find spaces for interrupting it” [p. 1].) .
Apple, Michael W. 2005 Away with all teachers: The cultural politics of homeschooling. In Bruce S. Cooper (Ed.), (2005), Home schooling in full view: A reader. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing. home education, philosophy, opinion, negative criticism, negative critic Clearly identifies religious homeschoolers with those who “cocoon” themselves and who are fearful of “the Other.” “This ‘cocooning’ is not just about seeking an escape from the problems of the city (a metaphor for danger and heterogeneity). It is a rejection of the entire idea of the city. Cultural and intellectual diversity, complexity, ambiguity, uncertainty, and proximity to the Other – all these are to be shunned [citation] … In place of the city is the engineered pastoral, the neat and well-planned universe where things (and people) are in their rightful place and reality is safe and predictable” [p. 80]. Caricatures religious homeschoolers as being strongly motivated by fear – for example, being fearful of “the Other,” the state, a “loss of specialness,” and “becoming uniform in the wrong way” [p. 80-85]. Claims homeschoolers, especially religious ones, attack the state and are anti-state [p. 82-83].
Apple, Michael W. 2006, December 21 The complexities of black home schooling. From www.TCRecord.org. http://www.TCRecord.org http://www.tcrecord.org/Content.asp?ContentId=12903 http://cockingasnook.wordpress.com/2007/03/07/michael-apple-expert-on-black-homeschooling-now/ home education, philosophy, blacks, African Americans, minorities, social, political, opinion, negative criticism Retrieved first paragraph 5/25/07 online http://www.tcrecord.org/Content.asp?ContentId=12903, and retrieved 6/22/07 online http://cockingasnook.wordpress.com/2007/03/07/michael-apple-expert-on-black-homeschooling-now/ “There is now a (slowly) growing home schooling movement among traditionally oppressed groups – such as African Americans.” Core argument is basically encapsulated in the following neo-Marxian excerpts: (1) “Thus, I ultimately come down, just barely, on the negative side. There may indeed be short-term gains for a limited number of children – and this should not be dismissed since we must do everything we can to prevent the loss of even more children of color.  However, just as in the case of the support of vouchers by organized groups of people of color, in the long run, this is not an adequate response to the crisis (see Apple & Pedroni, 2005).  Since we know it is social movements that are the driving forces behind lasting educational change (Apple, 2006; Anyon, 2005), individualized atomistic decisions to school one's child at home – while thoroughly understandable – cannot build momentum for the large scale transformations that are necessary” (2) “We should not criticize black parents who home school their children. But a more powerful response in the long term requires that we redouble our efforts to create more responsive, democratic, and critical educational institutions for those children who are all too easily seen as the "Other" in this society and its schools.” One should ask Apple when he promotes redoubling of efforts for black children – For how long should African American parents leave their children in state-run, professionally and union-controlled institutional schools – that Apple admits are problem-filled – another 52 years like the period since the Supreme Court case Brown v. Board of Education?
Arai, A. Bruce 1999, September 6 Homeschooling and the redefinition of citizenship. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 7(27). Retrieved 7/19/02 online http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v7n27.html. http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v7n27.html home education, citizenship, socialization, philosophy, sociology, political science, research “There has been little consideration of the importance of homeschooling for the more general issue of citizenship, and whether people can be good citizens without going to school. This paper reviews the research on homeschooling, as well as the major objections to it, and frames these debates within the broader issues of citizenship and citizenship education. The paper shows that homeschoolers are carving out a different but equally valid understanding of citizenship and that policies which encourage a diversity of understandings of good citizenship should form the basis citizenship education both for schools and homeschoolers” [abstract].
Arai, A. Bruce 1999 Homeschooling and the redefinition of citizenship. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 7(27), 1-15. homeschooling, citizenship, philosophy, institutional schools Author has a very solid and research-informed understanding of homeschooling and the arguments for and against it. Appears positive toward homeschooling as an alternative and acceptable way to form good citizens compared to state/public and/or private institutional schooling. Recognizes that homeschooling might be done in a way that is not good for a child or community. “Various models of citizenship have been proposed and debated (see Delanty, 1997 for a good review of the major positions), but there is no single vision of citizenship which is acceptable to all. Perhaps this is not surprising given that citizenship is a fundamentally political concept. Similarly, there are many different proposals about the nature and content of citizenship education” (p. 7). “Moving beyond homeschoolers responses to criticisms levelled at them to the larger body of research on homeschooling, there is evidence to suggest that homeschoolers appear to be involved in a process of constructing an alternative vision of citizenship for them and their children, albeit largely implicitly. Consistent with the notion of multidimensional citizenship, homeschoolers are involved in combining a different mix of attributes to become good citizens. In particular, they emphasize participation and the importance of family as the basis of a different definition of citizenship” (p. 8). “While the form and content of citizenship education among homeschoolers is clearly different from what children receive in school, it is not an inferior experience. Homeschoolers, in other words, can be good citizens. Here I have argued that homeschoolers, despite being accused of not being good citizens, are actually engaged in a process of defining their own vision of what it means to be a citizen. They clearly do not believe that compulsory schooling is a necessary prerequisite of adequate citizenship and they prefer to stress the importance of family and participation in public activities as the basis of their understanding of the good citizen” (p. 9). “In addition, homeschooling parents and children must recognize that they are not just keeping their kids at home, and that they are not just making a statement about parental rights in education. Rather, they are also helping to define and shape what it means to be a citizen of their country. They must be prepared to think in these broader terms, and to recognize that what they are doing has some good elements and some bad elements, just as citizenship education in schools has strengths and weaknesses. In other words, homeschooling is not just about where kids will learn their ABCs, it affects the very definition of what it means to be a member of a society” (p. 10). “Abstract: Homeschooling has grown considerably in many countries over the past two or three decades. To date, most research has focused either on comparisons between schooled and homeschooled children, or on finding out why parents choose to educate their children at home. There has been little consideration of the importance of homeschooling for the more general issue of citizenship, and whether people can be good citizens without going to school. This paper reviews the research on homeschooling, as well as the major objections to it, and frames these debates within the broader issues of citizenship and citizenship education. The paper shows that homeschoolers are carving out a different but equally valid understanding of citizenship and that policies which encourage a diversity of understandings of good citizenship should form the basis citizenship education both for schools and homeschoolers." (p. 1).
Arai, A. Bruce 2000 Reasons for home schooling in Canada. Canadian Journal of Education/Revue canadienne de l’education, 25(3), 204-217. elementary secondary education; foreign countries; homeschooling, home schooling; interviews; nontraditional education; parent attitudes; parents; barriers Author appears to have a deep and accurate understanding of reasons or motivations for homeschooling. “Abstract: Why do parents in Canada choose to home school their children? This article presents the results of qualitative interviews with 23 home-schooling [homeschooling] families in Ontario and British Columbia and compares these results with previous research in other jurisdictions, particularly the United States. The findings suggest that Canadian home-based educators have very different reasons for choosing home schooling than their U.S. counterparts. Possible explanations for these differences are discussed” (p. 204). Author astutely observes the following: “But more recently, parents who do not face the same legal and attitudinal barriers may view home schooling as one educational option among many. These parents may not have the strong philosophical commitments of earlier generations. Despite its current notoriety in the mass media, home schooling is certainly easier to arrange for now than in the past. Because many earlier battles about the legality of home schooling have been resolved, parents can at least try home schooling without the strong value commitments required in previous eras” (p. 208). “Previous studies have found two distinct groups of home schoolers: ideologues and pedagogues. These studies also showed that many home schoolers are motivated by their own negative experiences in school or by their desire to strengthen or preserve the unity of the nuclear family, to live an alternative lifestyle, and/or to assert their right to determine their children's education. However, only two of the parents I interviewed had begun home schooling because of their own bad experiences in school, and only a few said they were attempting to live an alternative lifestyle through schooling at home. In addition, the ideologue-pedagogue dichotomy does not capture very well the different reasons that people gave for starting home schooling. These parents chose to teach their children at home for a variety of reasons, and many had both pedagogical and ideological objections to public schooling. This may be an indication of the broad appeal of home schooling among Canadian parents” (p. 215).) notes
Aram, Dorit; Meidan, Inbal Cohen; & Deitcher, Deborah Bergman 2016 A Comparison between homeschooled and formally schooled kindergartners: Children's early literacy, mothers’ beliefs, and writing mediation. Reading Psychology, 37(7), 995-1024. homeschooling, home schooling, literacy, comparison “Abstract. The study characterized children’s literacy, mothers’ beliefs, and writing mediation of homeschooled compared to formally schooled kindergartners [in Israel]. Participants were 60 children (ages 4–6) and their mothers (30 in homeschooling). At the children’s home, we assessed children’s literacy, maternal beliefs, and video-recorded mother–child joint writing of a birthday invitation. Results showed that homeschooled children had lower literacy levels than those formally schooled. Homeschooling mothers reported lower levels of belief in learning activities and demands from their children and showed lower levels of writing mediation. Maternal writing mediation predicted children’s writing, beyond the child’s phonological awareness and schooling (home vs. formal)” (p. 995). “Sixty kindergarteners, ages 4–6 (M = 59.62, SD = 8.29), and their mothers participated in the study. The children in the homeschooling group (n = 30) are being raised and educated at home and did not take part in any formal educational framework. The children in the formal schooling group (n = 30) participated in preschool and kindergarten settings. Each group was composed of 9 boys (30%) and 21 girls (70%)” (p. 1002). Matched homeschool and formal schooling students on age and gender only. “Our results showed that there were significant differences between the homeschooling and formal schooling groups in their letter knowledge and name writing, favoring the formal schooling group. This is in contrast to studies that showed better performance of homeschooled children compared to their formally schooled peers (e.g., Ray, 2000, 2010; Rudner, 1999). An explanation of these differences may relate to the educational philosophy of the families who homeschool. Recent research has noted an important distinction between more structured homeschooling compared to unstructured homeschooling [p. 1013 ends] (Martin-Chang, Gould, & Meuse, 2011). Some of the literature also refers to this as homeschooling versus unschooling (Heller Degani, 2003). Unschooling, a term coined by Holt (Farenga, 1999), refers to homeschooling without the use of a set curriculum, which instead relies on the motivation and drive of the learner. In our study, the mothers expressed ideas and beliefs favoring unschooling. Martin-Chang et al. (2011) found that children homeschooled in an unstructured format had the lowest scores on standardized tests compared to both formally schooled children and those homeschooled in a structured format. Adhering to an unschooling pedagogical philosophy may provide some insight into the poorer performance of the homeschooled children in our study. The advantage that the formally schooled children showed in letter knowledge and word writing to some degree reflects the Israeli education system. In Israeli preschools, the Hebrew alphabet is formally part of the curriculum from age 3 and is part of everyday activities (Sverdlov, Aram, & Levin, 2014). Children’s name writing is part of the formally schooled child’s life from the age that he/she enters the education system” (p. 1014). “It was interesting to learn that there were no significant differences between the groups regarding phonological awareness” (p. 1014). “On top of these explanations, the differences in findings between the two groups in early literacy may relate to the age of the children in the study. Nearly all studies of homeschooling assessed children in elementary and high school. To our knowledge, this is the first study to explore those who homeschool kindergarten aged children. It may be that the mothers in this study who homeschool would be inclined to increase their focus on early literacy when their children reach grade school age, and results regarding achievements would vary” (p. 1015). Authors note that a limitation of their study follows: “In the present study, the homeschooling group believed mainly in “unschooling” (Farenga, 1999)” (p. 1018).
Archer, Jeff 1999, December 8 Unexplored territory. Education Week, 19(15), 22-25. http://www.edweek.org/ew/ewstory.cfm?slug=15home.h19 research, overview, review, home education (Also online http://www.edweek.org/ew/ewstory.cfm?slug=15home.h19). Examines that state of research on home schooling. Reports the positive findings about the performance of the home schooled. Discusses several limitations of the research and quotes several researchers who have studied home schooling. This is a periodical widely read by educators nationwide.)
Archer, Jeff 1999, February Home study. Teacher Magazine. Online http://www.teachermagazine.org/tm/tmstory.cfm?slug=05home.h11. http://www.teachermagazine.org/tm/tmstory.cfm?slug=05home.h11 home education, research, evaluation, analysis Summarizes some of research on home schooling and the limitations of the research. “Despite the limitations of Rudner’s and Ray’s studies, their conclusion that kids who are homeschooled tend to do well should not be dismissed outright, observers say. ‘If you take the Rudner study and all the others,’ [Patricia] Lines says, ‘you could do a meta-analysis, and you would find them all coming out with homeschooling students testing above the norm. At some point, I’m willing to step out of the role of researcher and say that homeschooling does no harm academically. I would not be willing to say the same kids would do differently in schools.’” “Patrick Farenga, president of Holt Associates, an alternative education clearinghouse named after the late school critic John Holt, agrees. ‘I do share the feeling that at some point the researchers who are trying to take the schools’ measurements and apply them to homeschooling are comparing apples and oranges,’ he says. ‘But at the same time, I don’t think there should be no research—just a different kind of research.’”
Archibeque, Jennifer 2000, November 30 Taking the home-schooling leap. The Albuquerque Journal. Retrieved 1/29/01 online http://www.abqjournal.com/mountain/189974mtvnews11-30-00.htm. http://www.abqjournal.com/mountain/189974mtvnews11-30-00.htm home education, reasons, public school, academic achievment, philosophy “Jerry Anderson, co-director of the Albuquerque Public Schools' Student, School and Community Service Center, said parents choose home schooling for a variety of reasons. But he said dissatisfaction with public schools is usually at least part of the motivation. "The organization of a public school and public-school curricula have more to do with controlling the largest amount of kids for the least amount of money and not with how kids learn," said Anderson. As co-director of what amounts to a customer-service center for APS parents, Anderson has many duties. One of them is assisting families with home-school registration. "I've been the liaison between the home-schooling community and the district for about 15 years, and I've learned a lot about home schooling because I've worked with a lot of home schoolers," Anderson said. Although home-school families have some things in common, they are as diverse as any other group. Some people home school their children because of their religious or spiritual beliefs. Others do it because they are dissatisfied with the public education system. Anderson said home schooling provides small class size and customized instruction that are difficult to achieve in a public school. Many home school parents agree. ..... When it comes to curricula, a variety of methods are available to home-school families. Some families follow an eclectic approach, where they pick and choose curricula as they go. Others choose a more structured approach using correspondence courses. Some incorporate religious teachings into their curriculum. ..... Anderson said home schoolers, as a group, tend to do well academically. "If you look at their aggregate test scores compared to those of public-school students, generally home schoolers score better," said Anderson, adding that it makes sense that they would fare better. "Small class size and customized instruction provide an enormous advantage," he said. But he also noted that data on home schoolers can be biased because most home-school students come from middle- or high-income families. "We know there are strong linkages between students with higher socio-economic backgrounds and performance in school," Anderson said. ..... Ruthanne and her husband, Dan, decided to home school their children for both religious and academic reasons. "When my mother went to public school in the 1950s, she studied the Bible, and the school system was supportive of what was going on in the home and church," Ruthanne said. "But now it has been completely eliminated and replaced with ideologies that are contradictory to the Christian faith." Ruthanne said she understands that children who attend public school have many different beliefs, and she respects that parents don't want their children indoctrinated in a faith that is contradictory to their family beliefs. That is one reason she and her husband decided to home school their children. An academic benefit to home schooling is that home-school parents can customize each child's education to fit the child's interests, Ruthanne said. She uses what is known as an eclectic approach to home schooling, meaning she picks and chooses different curricula and doesn't follow any one method. "With history and science, I like to give them a rich environment and let them pursue their interests," said Ruthanne. "We go to the library a lot."”
Arends, Hank 1987 Christian Curriculum offers an Alternative. Statesman-Journal. May 14, Salem, OR: 56.
Argument: School choice would destroy American education, the 2000, May The Journal, p. 3. [available from Summit Press, PO Box 207, Manitou Springs CO 80829]. education, alternatives, school choice “School choice would be ‘a death sentence for public schools struggling to serve disadvantaged students; draining all good students out of poor schools.' —Sen. Edward Kennedy. 'Free market economics works well for breakfast cereals, but not for schools in a democratic society. Market-driven school choice would create an inequitable, elitist educational system.’— Keith Geiger, Then-President of the National Education Association. The Facts: If giving regular Americans the opportunity to choose a private school will destroy America’s educational system, then why is it OK for wealthy liberals to choose private schools for their children? President Clinton and Hillary chose a private school for daughter Chelsea, as (did the Vice President for his kids. Jesse Jackson sent his kids to private schools. The list goes on and on. ‘It is fashionable these days to say that choice is ‘not a panacea. . . . [W]e think reformers would do well to entertain the notion that choice is a panacea ... It has the capacity all by itself to bring about the kind of transformation that, for years, reformers have been seeking to engineer in myriad other ways ... [W]e think the best way to achieve significant, enduring reform is for states to take the initiative in withdrawing authority from existing Institutions and building a new system in which most authority is vested directly in the schools, parents, and students.’—John E. Chubb and Terry M. Moe, Senior Fellows at the liberal Brookings Institution, in Politics, Markets and America’s Schools. Private schools are the choice of 14 percent of Americans, but 50 percent of U.S. senators who answered a new Heritage Foundation survey send their kids to private schools, as well as 34 percent of members of the House of Representatives. Only 8 percent of Hispanic Americans can send their children to private school, yet 44 percent of the members of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus answering the Heritage survey send their kids to private school. Blacks able to choose private schools also total 8 percent, but four times that proportion-- 32 percent--of the members of the Congressional Black Caucus choose private schools for their children.” -- [from] Rush Limbaugh, “Rush Classic”
Arizona Families for Home Education 1993, September-October Arizona home educators say NO to public resources. Arizona Home Education Journal, p. 1-4. resources, public resources, accountability, needs, rationale, reasons, cooperation Reports on doctoral dissertation research by Phillip Adams who started his study with the premise that "...home educators would desire to use public facilities in large numbers, if only public officials presented these facilities in a better light and were more responsive to the possible relationship. The survey's data, as presented to Journal readers...convinced him otherwise because his conclusion accepts that the vast majority of the home education community would not support the broad and cooperative program he had envisioned" (p. 1). Presents reasons for home educating, data that few home educators use public school facilities, and data showing that most home educators are unwilling to submit to accountabilites to the state.
Arkansas Department of Education 1986 Arkansas Department of Education news release, July 21, 1986. Little Rock, AR: Author.
Arkansas Department of Education 1987 Arkansas Department of Education news release, July 27, 1987. Little Rock, AR: Author.
Arkansas Department of Education, Student Assessment 1998, February 17 Personal communication with Yvette Dillingham, program support manager. achievement, home education, public Dillinger provided standardized achievement test scores of home school students in grades 5, 7, and 10 taken in September 1997. Their national percentiles in basic battery were 59, 61, and 60, respectively.
Armon, Joan 1982 Is homeschooling for everyone? Mothering, Summer, 85-88.
Arnoldsen, Larry M. 1988 The teaching of reading in home schools. Contemporary Issues in Reading, Fall, 47.
Arnoldsen, Larry M., & Williams, David The import of home schools for teacher education. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans, Louisiana, April 1988.
Arons, Stephen 1978 Is educating your own child a crime? Saturday Review, November 25, 16-19.
Arons, Stephen 1981 Value conflict between American families and American schools. ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 210 786. National Institute of Education, Grant NIE-G-79-0161, 146 p.
Arons, Stephen 1983 Compelling belief: The culture of American schooling. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill Book Co., 228 p., hard cover. education, censorship, home education, private Christian schools, history, philosophy Amherst, MA: University of Massachusetts Press, re-published it in 1986, 228 p., paperback. A careful examination, via a lawyer's case study approach, of book censorship, home schools, and "subculture" private biblical Christian schools. Stimulates thinking about basic assumptions concerning education. Balanced approach to the concept of censorship. Well written by a legal scholar. Reports on a Massachusetts homeschool court case in which the family “... claimed no religious basis for their convictions about family values and the meaning of life. They were conscientious objectors without religious identification” [p. 81]. Further explains that homeschool “... families have touched a raw nerve in American society, and the reaction to them points to substantial ideological contradictions in local schooling and national culture” [p. 88].) Soon thereafter, a professor of legal studies (Arons, 1983) offered great detail about a family in Massachusetts who “… had taught there two oldest sons at home some years earlier” and were now planning a home-education curriculum for their eight-year-old son. The parents held that it was about pedagogical approaches and values related to what education means and does not mean, and they “… claimed no religious basis for their convications about family values and the meaning of life” (p. 81). Arons describes the ensuing battle with the public school district and how the entire issue was about who should hold power and control over the child’s education. The legal studies professor summarized it as follows: “The crucial issue on this point is whether the government may so regulate a legislatively sanctioned alternative to public schooling that its distinctive quality is eliminated or contorted. In spite of the negative view that both court and Constitution have taken in the past for government monopoly on education, the desire to hang on to power seems to have prompted the Amherst school authorities to claim “absolute discretion” in passing judgment upon home education plans and to dismiss the parents’ plan and values as “pet educational theories.” (p. 81
Arora, Tiny (C.M.J.) 2006 Elective home education and special educational needs. Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs, 6(1), 55–66. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/ Home education, homeschooling, special educational needs, special education, flexible schooling, extended schools, elective home education “Abstract: This paper reviews the literature on home education with reference to special educational needs (SEN). A rapid expansion in home educating families is noted. Parents present a variety of reasons for this, including those with concerns about the provision for their child's SEN. In one Local Education Authority (LEA), data were obtained through questionnaires from 65 families when they first registered their children for home education. In addition, 12 families, who had been home educating their children for more than 2 years, were interviewed about their experiences. Many of the children involved had SEN, but most of the parents and children expressed satisfaction with their present arrangements. However, there was often a feeling expressed that they would have preferred their children to have attended school, if their special needs could have been met. Implications for education services policy and schools’ practice are discussed” (retrieved 7/9/13 from http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com).
Ash, A. Gayle 1992 Survey of central Texas public school teachers on homeschooling—early trends. Available from author at P.O. Box 668, Belton TX 76513.
Ashburn, Exie B. 1983 Parents as educators: A case study of three families. Dissertation Abstracts International, 45(1), 0076A. The Ohio State University, 107 p.
Association of Christian Schools International 1992 Year after year testing shows that ACSI students score at or above the national average at every grade! In ACSI Teachers' Conventions 1992-93, Portland, Oregon, October 1-2, 1992 [program], p. 50-51. LaHabra, CA: Association of Christian Schools International. academic achievement, private, Christian, public Provides graphs and tables of standardized achievement test (Stanford Achievement Test) scores for ACSI, other private, and national norm; ACSI students average from 64th to 76th percentile in grades K-12.
Attaran, Mohammad; Maleki, Soghra; & Alias, Norlidah 2013 “We Are the Etcetera”: Homeschooling in the Iranian society. Life Science Journal, 10(2), 1405-1413. Retrieved 7/11/13 from http://www.lsj-marsland.com/uploadfiles/AB15fe20130614153715/B01534-lsj-part20130614.pdf. http://www.lsj-marsland.com/uploadfiles/AB15fe20130614153715/B01534-lsj-part20130614.pdf homeschooling, formal education, school, parents Authors appear understanding of and sympathetic toward Iranian parents’ decision to homeschool despite the fact that it appears to be firmly looked down upon by society. Say that these parents are risk takers. “Abstract: The aim of this study is to explore the situation of homeschooling in Iranian system of education. The results of this study derive from a qualitative research performed in 2012. The research population was selected by snowball method. The participants were interviewed. The interviews were semi-structured. The concepts in each interview were extracted. Similar concepts were classified and primary and secondary contents were extracted. The data discussed was based on theoretical foundations. The study showed that all parents in the sample come from middle and upper-middle class of the Iranian society and are highly educated. Participants’ involvement in the education of their children and risk-taking in this regard was high. They didn’t have a positive view toward the formal system of education, but their decision for homeschooling their children was mostly educational (which is influenced by the ideas of Rousseau and Dewey), not ideological. They consider the formal system of education as a unilateral system, which destroys the creativity of children, merely emphasizes memorization, and neglects some subject like sport, English language, music and arts. According to them, school is a closed space where everybody should take a seat, just listen and hide their real personality. The Iranian homeschooling method is not limited to the textbooks and carries on mostly in natural space. It is mainly based on short-term skills, is not time-bounded and is flexible like its global counterparts. The findings show that this kind of education has increased parents’ relationship with themselves and their children. Their children are self-adjusted and independent in learning. However, because of the novelty of this kind of education, and its non-legal state, it is not accepted by the society at this stage. Occasionally, the homeschooling children and their parents confront several different challenges including mocking, anxiety about the future of their children etc.” (p. 1405). “The current study showed that Iran schools’ centralized system cannot respond to the needs of Iranian parents of the study sample and the parents with financial and educational facilities take out their children out of the public system. Although this trend is at its initiatory level, it is carried out despite the discontent of Iran's educational system. As some of the curriculum experts in Iran have said, it is necessary that the formal system reduce its level of centralization (Mehrmohammadi, 2007) and focus on liberalizing curricula” (p. 1412).
Audain, Tunya 1987 Home education: The third option. The Canadian School Executive, April, 18-21, 24.
Audain, Tunya 2011 John Holt's eureka Moment. Education Revolution: The Magazine of Educational Alternatives, #64, Spring/Summer 2011. For all issues, see: AER0 ARCHIVES https://www.educationrevolution.org/store/magazine/archives/ https://www.educationrevolution.org/store/magazine/archives/
Aurini, Janice 2004 Educational entrepreneurialism in the private tutoring industry: Balancing profitability with the humanistic face of schooling. Canadian Review of Sociology/Revue canadienne de sociologie, 41(4), 475–491. tutoring, entrepreneurialism, competition, homeschooling parenting Appears homeschooling receives minor attention in this paper. “Abstract: Based on a two-year study of private tutoring entrepreneurs in Ontario, Canada, this paper examines the increased legitimacy of educational entrepreneurialism. This legitimacy is changing the nature of schooling by supporting market solutions to education “problems” and the belief that competition and de-bureaucratization encourages accountability, efficiency and consumer responsiveness. The private tutoring industry provides an exemplary case study. No longer simply a means to generate additional income, the private tutoring industry now promises full-time business opportunities for well-educated investors from a variety of educational and occupational backgrounds. Lacking teachers' claims to professional authority, educational entrepreneurialism is further bolstered by the emerging culture of intensive parenting and educational customization. Surprisingly, the tutoring franchise proves to be a particularly effective vehicle for balancing profit goals with the more humanistic face of schooling.”
Aurini, Janice; & Davies, Scott 2005 Choice without markets: Homeschooling in the context of private education. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 26(4), 461-474. homeschooling, choice, markets, ideology, private education, parenting, individualism, research, human capital, ideology, philosophy, sociology, expressive logics Provides an insightful, balanced, and fairly accurate portrayal of the homeschool community and its history and motivations. “Abstract: Homeschooling is enjoying new‐found acceptance in North America. Drawing on a variety of secondary sources and our own data from Ontario, Canada, we find that homeschooling is growing steadily, and is becoming an increasingly legitimated form of education. To understand these changes, we review prevailing sociological explanations that focus on the rise of neo‐liberal ideology, and pressures of class reproduction and human capital requirements. We document the contributions of these theories and note their limits for understanding the rising popularity of homeschooling. We then situate homeschooling within a broader context of private education, distinguishing segments that encourage market‐consumer, class reproduction, human capital and ‘expressive’ logics. The combination of large investments of time and effort with highly uncertain outcomes makes homeschooling the most expressive form of private education, which we trace to the burgeoning culture of ‘intensive parenting.’” “Many forms of private education are growing in Canada, including private schools, tutoring businesses, preschool, vocational colleges and homeschooling. As an aggregate, they are very diverse-attracting clients that span social strata and levels of schooling, with motives ranging from religious to consumerist to elitist to expressive. This multi-faceted nature is not readily accommodated by any one all-encompassing market-consumer, class reproduction or human capital theory. Within this context, homeschooling is growing and enjoying a new-found legitimacy in North America. As homeschooling diversifies, newer recruits tend to be closer to the cultural mainstream, seeking individualized attention for their children, reflecting the culture of intensive parenting. Unlike other private alternatives, it is animated less by logics of market calculation, class reproduction, or human capital than by an expressive logic. Any theoretical explanation of homeschooling must recognize its loose connection to instrumental goals like financial payoff or skill enhancement, and look to its multiple and diffuse aims. Homeschooling thus represents a choice without markets. Homeschoolers strongly assert their right to choose yet do not espouse a market ideology, since for many both bureaucracies and markets can potentially threaten the sanctity of their families. Rather than championing educational competition and rigor, many desire a kinder and gentler form of schooling that allows them to evade anonymous bureaucracies or consumer markets. They strongly voice the language of choice without adopting other [p. 471 ends] components of neo-liberal doctrines, such as the beneficial impact of academic competition and the necessity of educational markets. They hail their right to choose educational alternatives and fault the impersonality of mass public schools, but other- wise avoid endorsing neo-liberal doctrines. They seek freedom from bureaucracy, but rarely equate that freedom with markets or instrumental calculation. Increasingly, their quest is articulated by the culture of intensive parenting, with its focus on the unique needs of the child. In turn, that culture is lending legitimacy to their claims. As homeschooling grows, it is slowly penetrating the mainstream, allied to the burgeoning choice movement, while remaining aloof from its more economistic tendencies” (p. 472).
Aurini, Janice; & Quirke, Linda 2011 Does market competition encourage strategic action in the private education sector? Canadian Journal of Sociology/Cahiers canadiens de sociologie 36(2) 2011, 173-197. market hypothesis, market competition, private education, private, schools, tutoring, school choice, homeschooling, Canada Mentions homeschooling only once: “We interviewed key actors in the private education field — the head of a private school lobby group, educational consultants, representatives of [p. 181 ends] the Canadian Franchise Association, and home-schooling organizations. The first author also conducted a participant observation study, tutoring in a learning centre franchise for one year” (p. 180-181). “Abstract. According to the market hypothesis, market forces encourage schooling organizations to strategically outsmart their competition in ways that improve the quality of teaching and learning. Based on eighty interviews with private education owners or managers in Toronto, Ontario [Canada], we find little evidence that entrepreneurs respond to competition in the way that the theory predicts. Market competition does not inform how entrepreneurs understand their role in the wider education sector or how they make sense of their actions. Instead, entrepreneurs tie their program, hiring, and customer service decisions to an ideological commitment to students, defining themselves as educators. Our data suggest that this perception guides their actions more than market forces. This paper opens the black box of private education organizations, and offers a nuanced addition to mounting research that challenges the connection between market competition and school performance” (p. 173). An online search for 8865-30819-1-PB.pdf leads to this article.
Author unknown or publication or organization Eagle Forum and The Eagle Trust Fund. The Phyllis Schlafly Report and Education Reporter, Box 618, Alton, Illinois (IL) 62002-0618.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1985, March 25 Education at home: A showdown in Texas. Newsweek, p. 87. Law. Reasons for home schooling include religion, avoiding "secular humanism" in schools, and academic aspects.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1979 Education is a community function. Phi Delta Kappan, September, 2.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1985 Education societies in London. Scottish Educational Review, 17(2), 132-134. Also, in CIJE, May 1987, p. 80, No. EJ 347 873; one of the descriptors was "home schooling."
Author unknown or publication or organization 2001, January 15 Education Week on the Web. Quality Counts 2001: A Better Balance: Standards, Tests, and the Tools to Succeed. http://www.edweek.com/sreports/qc01/ http://www.edweek.com/sreports/qc01/articles/qc01story.cfm?slug=17states.h20 public schools, education, reform, accountability, achievement tests, minority, minorities, black Published 1/10/01 and retrieved 1/15/01 online http://www.edweek.com/sreports/qc01/ [Then this URL links to many parts of the report “A Better Balance.”] “States have invested enormous energy and political capital over the past decade in raising academic standards in American schools. A majority of parents and teachers believe those efforts are headed in the right direction. ..... But the fifth annual 50-state report by Education Week concludes that states must strike a better balance among standards, assessments, and the tools students and schools need to succeed. Without it, not only could standards-based improvement efforts stumble, but public support for public education also could totter. What's more, tens of thousands of students could fail to meet the goals their states have set for them, limiting the potential of today's children, with implications well into the future. Specifically, Quality Counts found, state tests are overshadowing the standards they were designed to measure and could be encouraging undesirable practices in schools. Some tests do not adequately reflect the standards or provide a rich enough picture of student learning. And many states may be rushing to hold students and schools accountable for results without providing the essential support.” From the “The State of the States” by Greg F. Orlofsky and Lynn Olson [retrieved 1/15/01 online http://www.edweek.com/sreports/qc01/articles/qc01story.cfm?slug=17states.h20] part of the report, “Student Achievement: This year's report has no new state-level results from the nation's testing program, the National Assessment of Educational Progress, known as NAEP. The most recent data are from the 1998 assessments. State results from tests in mathematics and science administered in 2000 will be out later this year. Thirty years of NAEP data show that overall achievement has increased gradually in reading and math—and stayed about the same in science— but that the gap between white and black students has been widening in the past 12 years.”
Author unknown or publication or organization 1973 Educational broadcasts of NHK. Special Issue of NHK Today and Tomorrow (Japan), October.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1981, June 5 Family receives split ruling. Times Education Supplement, (United Kingdom), 9.
Author unknown or publication or organization Growing Without Schooling. A bimonthly publication from: Growing Without Schooling, Holt Associates, 2269 Massachusetts Ave., Cambridge, MA 02140. Up-to-date, approximately 32 p. of all aspects of home centered learning from current legislative activity to reviews of literature to parents' and children's letters; continues with the "unschooling" approach of the late John Holt; and a section entitled "John Holt's book and music store"
Author unknown or publication or organization 1986 Home education: Is it working?. Dallas, Texas: Texas Home School Coalition.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1987 Home school pupils outscore public classroom counterparts. The Knoxville News-Sentinel, August 13, p.1.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1999, August 23 Home-schoolers fit right in at college. The Tennessean., p. 4B. College personnel say the home educated appear to be doing well academically and socially at college. Cite statements of Brian Ray and the National Home Education Research Institute.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1987 Home schoolers taking on state laws. Education USA, July 6, p. 334.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1984, September 15 Home schooling: An idea whose time has returned. [Interview with Dr. Raymond Moore.] Human Events, pp. 825-827.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1986, February 19 Home schools backed in Iowa. Education Week, p. 8. Law.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1984 Home studies goes legal. CoEvolution Quarterly, Summer, 110.
Author unknown or publication or organization Homeless [homeschooled] Teen Gets Perfect SAT Scores: Family moves into first real home. Published and retrieved 4/5/01 online http://thekcrachannel.com/sac/news/localnews/stories/news-localnews-57467220010405-1004458.html. http://thekcrachannel.com/sac/news/localnews/stories/news-localnews-57467220010405-1004458.html home education, adult, anecdote, academic achievement, college Reports that a teen in California named Trevor Loflin scored a perfect 1600 on the Scholastic Aptitude Test [SAT]. “The task is even more amazing considering that Loflin's family was homeless. ‘We went back and forth. Sometimes we were homeless. Sometimes we had an apartment. And then basically we just lived wherever we could find,’ Loflin said. Loflin not only got the score without the benefit of a home, he got it without a school, because he is home-schooled. He said that his mom has been a great teacher. ..... The family thanks their Baptist faith for seeing them through the tough times. They just moved in to their first real house in Sonora [California] a few weeks ago.”
Author unknown or publication or organization Legal manual for alternative schools. Referred to In New Schools Exchange, 1976, by Ed Nagel.
Author unknown or publication or organization Little Home Schoolhouse [newsletter]. Sandy Birch, editor. Dallas, Oregon.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1987, December 17 Minutes of the home schooling meeting. Held at headquarters of the National School Boards Association. Attenders: NASBE, Charles O'Malley [US Dept. Ed.], Michael Farris [HSLDA], American Association of Christian Schools, and Home Study International.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1982, March 12 Nobody screams about these children. Times Education Supplement, p. 21.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1987, February 22 Pastor jailed for home educating. Salt Lake Tribune. p. A5.
Author unknown or publication or organization Plymouth Rock Foundation. Home schools and Christian education. FAC-SHEET, #37.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1986, February 3 Private schools under siege. St. Louis Globe - Democrat, p. 8A. Law. Home and private schools as competitors to public schools.
Author unknown or publication or organization December 1988/January 1989 Resolutions: Proposed by leaders of state home-school organizations and passed by the general assembly at the 1988 national home-school convention. The Teaching Home, p. 11.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1980 Starting a home school. Country Journal, 7(9), 94.
Author unknown or publication or organization State vs. Riddle in West Virginia. National Association of Secondary School Principals [NASSP] Bulletin, 67, 118-120.
Author unknown or publication or organization Staub v. Staub [Toni J. Staub v. Brian L. Staub\, In the Superior Court of Pennsylvania, No. 1636 MDA 2007, J. A13018/08. Retrieved February 18, 2010 from http://www.superior.court.state.pa.us/opinions/A13018_08.PDF. http://www.superior.court.state.pa.us/opinions/A13018_08.PDF home education, legal, law, court case, research, academic achievement “Appellant (“Father”), Brian L. Staub, appeals from the order denying his petition for special relief brought pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1915.13.1 Therein, Father requested that the trial court prevent continued home schooling of the parties’ minor children by Appellee (“Mother”), Toni J. Staub. On appeal, Father asks us, inter alia, to adopt a clear but narrow rule that requires children to attend public schools when parents who share legal custody cannot agree on home schooling versus public schooling. We decline to adopt such a rule or presumption. To the contrary, we hold that the well-established best interests standard, applied on a case by case basis, [p. 1 ends] governs a court’s decision regarding public schooling versus home schooling. Utilizing this standard, we affirm the trial court’s order [p. 2].” “Additionally, she testified she felt that it was in her children’s best interests to continue with her home education program in light of the findings of her home schooling expert, Dr. Brian Ray. Id. at 119. ¶ 26 Dr. Ray, who, among other things, has reviewed thousands and thousands of home schooled children’s standardized test scores and portfolios over a 23-year period, testified that the children are “very high in the terms of their academic achievement.” N.T., 8/21/07, at 55. Specifically, regarding the children’s test scores, Dr. Ray testified that “[the children] are not only above average, but above average of the home-school average, which is above the public school average.” Id. Regarding their portfolios, Dr. Ray testified that “all [of] the basic subject areas are being addressed carefully and in detail, and in addition, they’re engaged in all kinds of activities beyond the, quote, basics of a public school or even a private school environment. They’re doing very, very well.” Id. at 58-59 [p. 13 ends]. With respect to the children’s social abilities, Dr. Ray testified that they had absolutely no trouble interacting with other children or adults. Id. at 68-70. Further, Dr. Ray testified that nothing indicated that the children would be better off by taking them out of their home education program and enrolling them in public school. Id. at 72-73. Finally, Dr. Ray testified that, in the home school context, “[c]hildren of parents who have higher education attainment score a little higher, but the correlation is . . . quite weak.” N.T., 8/21/07, at 62 [p. 14].” This court decision sets and important legal precedent that says public school may not be ordered by a court simply because parents are in disagreement about whether to public school or homeschool a child; the best-interest standards regarding children must be considered for any child, on a case-by-case basis. In other words, public/state schooling should not be considered the “default setting” for education for a child when parents disagree about a child’s education.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1978, December 4 Teaching children at home. Time, pp. 78, 81.
Author unknown or publication or organization Teaching Home, The. P.O. Box 20219, Portland, OR, 97220-0219. Sue Welch, Editor. General. Bimonthly magazine for those interested in or practicing home schooling. Provides in-depth articles on special topics each issue, e.g. computers, critical thinking, math. Regular column on home school research. One of highest quality home school periodicals.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1985 The attack on public education: North Carolina's experience. Unpublished manuscript available from: People for the American Way, 310 East Third Street, Winston Salem, NC 27101. Discussion of religious right involvement in educational policy making in North Carolina, including brief reference to home schooling activity.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1981, April 10 Values in the public schools: A prerequisite to teaching. Christianity Today, 16-18. Criticism of public school from the religious right.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1989, April 9 Victories for home schooling. The New York Times, Sec. 1, p. 27.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1983 Virginia home schoolers can't evade regulations by claiming that they run a private school. Phi Delta Kappan, 64, 444. The title sums it up.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1981, December 14 When a home is a school. Newsweek, pp. 112-114.
Author unknown or publication or organization 1980, September 22 When parents ask: "Who needs school?". U.S. News and World Report, p. 47.
Autrey, LaDonna 2021 Secondary schooling type and differences in academic self-efficacy and self-regulation. Doctoral dissertation (Ph.D.), Capella University. https://www.proquest.com/openview/c48df7dd09b796e1697066d86c7fd08e/1?pq-origsite=gscholar&cbl=18750&diss=y https://www.proquest.com/openview/c48df7dd09b796e1697066d86c7fd08e/1?pq-origsite=gscholar&cbl=18750&diss=y homeschooling, home education, research, college, university, adults, academic self-efficacy, academic self-regulation “Abstract: Secondary education modalities of homeschooling or traditional schooling were compared using self-efficacy for learning and academic self-regulation ability while in college. Gaps in the homeschooling literature include the influence of self-efficacy and self-regulation on learning outcomes. A quantitative non-experimental study was used with a convenience sample of 184 traditional undergraduate college students (44 homeschooled and 140 traditionally schooled) from 18 to 24 years of age. Participants completed the SELF, MSLQ, Parental involvement-Student Section, and demographic questions. An ANCOVA found homeschoolers had significantly higher academic self-efficacy but found no significant differences in academic self-regulation when holding parental involvement and SES constant. No significant difference was found between participants’ SES or parental involvement levels, so an ANOVA analysis was used and found homeschooled students had significantly higher academic self-efficacy but they did not differ on significantly from traditional students on academic self-regulation. Differences in academic self-efficacy could stem from differing pedagogical approaches and role students play in directing homeschool education not found in traditional schooling. Lack of difference found in academic self-regulation could stem from erratic answer patterns displayed on the MSLQ not found on the other surveys” (p. ii).
Avner, Jane A. 1989, July Home schoolers: A forgotten clientele? School Library Journal, 35(11), 29-33.
Avner, Jane A. 1992 A librarian looks at home schooling. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco CA, April 20-24.
Avner, Jane Adashko 1992 Information needs and information seeking behavior as a factor in the educational program of home schooled children: A qualitative study of five families educating at home. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, University of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Baath, J. A. 1982 Distance students' learning - empirical findings and theoretical deliberations. Distance Education, 3.
Bacharach, Verne 2002 Can science justify Preschool? Education Reporter, No. 202, p. 3-4. preschool, research, policy, academic achievement, school readiness Concludes, “Taken together, what do all these studies tell us? The first thing is that pre-K care programs have no effect on the intellectual development of children. There is no convincing evidence that you can raise children's IQ's by having them attend these programs. There is no evidence that pre-K programs improve school readiness or that they lead to increased academic achievement. At best, pre-K care programs don't appear to have any effect on children's behavioral development, although there is some evidence that these programs may increase the risk of behavior problems” (p. 3).
Badley, Hannah G.; Stewart, Jonah; Pichon, Latrice C.; Longuevan, Aeryn 2026 Navigating sexual health and gender identity in homeschooling contexts: A qualitative study of lived experiences. Sexuality Research and Social Policy. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13178-026-01351-4 https://doi.org/10.1007/s13178-026-01351-4 sexual health, gender identity, homeschooling, Constructivist Ground Theory, healthcare “Abstract Introduction Homeschooling has expanded rapidly in the United States over the past two decades and even more so in the post-COVID era. Yet little research has examined its implications for sexual and reproductive health education or gender identity development. Existing scholarship primarily centers parental motivations, leaving the lived experiences of homeschooled youth largely unexplored. Methods Semi-structured interviews were conducted between April and May of 2025 with 32 adults who were homeschooled during childhood and adolescence. Data were analyzed using Constructivist Ground Theory (CGT) to theorize sexual health education, healthcare navigation, and gendered educational experiences in homeschooling communities. Results Findings indicate that many participants experienced limited or inconsistent access to evidence-based sexual health information, particularly within conservative or religious homeschooling environments. Participants frequently described delayed healthcare engagement, reliance on informal information sources, and gendered expectations that shaped both educational content and identity development. Sexual and Gender Minority (SGM) participants reported heightened barriers related to stigma and isolation. Conclusions These findings underscore a critical gap in public health research and practice within homeschooling research and highlight the need for culturally responsive interventions to support equisexual health education and healthcare access for homeschooled populations. Policy Implications Future policy efforts should address the absence of standardized sexual health education benchmarks in homeschooling contexts and the limited public accountability mechanisms for ensuring equihealth literacy outcomes across education modalities.”
Badman, Graham 2009, June Report to the Secretary of State on the Review of Elective Home Education in England. (Ordered by the House of Commons to be printed on 11 June 2009.) https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/328186/Review_of_Elective_Home_Education_in_England.pdf home education, policy, law, legal, philosophy, state, government, United Kingdom, foreign, negative criticism, negative critic, statism London: The Stationery Office, https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/328186/Review_of_Elective_Home_Education_in_England.pdf Reviews home education, homeschooling, in the United Kingdom UK and makes recommendations to the state/government. Recommends significant changes in law and policy that would notably reduce parental rights, responsibility, and authority in the education and upbringing of children while increasing the power and authority of the state in same. Key points: Authors reports that in conducting the review: “to be limited to practice in England,” “structured interview with a range of stakeholders,” and “review was further informed by a literature review and consideration of practice and legislation in other countries” (p. 4). “Indeed, as the national Children’s Plan makes clear it is “Parents not Government that bring up children”3 and there is nothing in this report which sets out to contradict or modify this contention. However, there has to be a balance between the rights of the parents and the rights of the child. I believe that balance is not achieved through current legislation or guidance, and the imbalance must be addressed. Not to do so could result in the concerns for a minority being applied to the vast majority of caring, motivated home educating parents” (p. 3). “I have no doubt that the vast majority of these [20,000 to 80,000 home-educated] children and young people are safe and well but, that may not be true for all” (p. 22). “In addressing this issue I have tried to answer two fundamental questions: First, if there is abuse of children within the home education community, is it disproportionally high, relative to the general population? Secondly where abuse does exist, would a change of regulation with regard to elective home education have either prevented or ameliorated such abuse?” (p. 28). “To return to the two questions posed earlier. First, on the basis of local authority evidence and case studies presented, even acknowledging the variation between authorities, the number of children known to children’s social care in some local authorities is disproportionately high relative to the size of their home educating population. Secondly, despite the small number of serious case reviews where home education was a feature, the consideration of these reviews and the data outlined above, suggests that those engaged in the support and monitoring of [p. 31 ends] home education should be alert to the potential additional risk to children. So saying is not to suggest that there is a causal or determining relationship, but simply an indication of the need for appropriately trained and knowledgeable personnel. To that end, I recommend: …” (p. 31-32). “10. Issues Out of Scope of this Inquiry and the need for further research - In particular I am concerned by two issues. First, what constitutes ‘autonomous’ learning. Could it be, as many home educating parents have argued, it defies definition but provides the ultimate opportunity for children to develop at their own rate and expands their talents and aptitudes thought the pursuit of personal interest. Or, ….. 10.2 My second issue in part relates to the first. I am not convinced by the existing research studies on the outcomes for home educated children both in this country and elsewhere. ….. 10.3 Furthermore, little is known about the collective outcomes for home educated children in terms of their qualifications and employment” (p. 36). “The recommendations in this review do not go that far. I have sought to strike a balance between the rights of parents and the rights of the child, and offer, through registration and other recommendations, some assurance on the greater safety of a number of children” (p. 37). Ends with 28 “recommendations,” for example: 1. “That the DCSF establishes a compulsory national registration scheme, locally administered, for all children of statutory school age, who are, or become, electively home educated” (p. 38). 2. “That the DCSF review the current statutory definition of what constitutes a “suitable” and “efficient” education in the light of the Rose review of the primary curriculum, and other changes to curriculum assessment and definition throughout statutory school age. Such a review should take account of the five Every Child Matters outcomes determined by the 2004 Children Act, should not be overly prescriptive but be sufficiently defined to secure a broad, balanced, relevant and differentiated curriculum …” (p. 39). 7. “The DCSF should bring forward proposals to change the current regulatory and statutory basis to ensure that in monitoring the efficiency and suitability of elective home education: That designated local authority officers should: – have the right of access to the home; – have the right to speak with each child alone if deemed appropriate or, …” (p. 40). Concludes that ultimately it is the state’s proper role to control the education and upbringing of a child, while arguing that this conclusion is simply a way to ensure the “child’s rights” are protected and played out. Does not acknowledge that this is a philosophical and theoretical assumption that is contrary to many historically long-term philosophies and worldviews. Posits the state should have primary authority in controlling the education and upbringing of children and argues this from international law and the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. Commits the fallacy of moderation, for example, in using the following statement to argue for more control over home education: “International comparison suggests that of all countries with highly developed education systems, England is the most liberal in its approach to elective home education. Legislation from the 1930s banning elective home education still persists in Germany and most European countries require registration, whereas New Zealand demands that the “person will be taught at least as regularly and as well as in registered school.” The majority of other countries also have processes for registration and the systematic monitoring of elective home education and require evidence of progress, often specifically in mathematics and reading. 11.2 The recommendations in this review do not go that far. I have sought to strike a balance between the rights of parents and the rights of the child, and offer, through registration and other recommendations, some assurance on the greater safety of a number of children” [p. 24]. Argues for a significant increase in control over home-educated children’s lives and families. Argues that the state must be allowed to gather much personal and philosophical/educational information from the family. Argues that state officials must have access to the child’s family and home and to the child, and “… have the right to speak with each child alone …” [p. 40].) added to annotation
Bae, Eric, & Moore, Timothy E. 2025 Evaluation of the State of Connecticut Office of the Child Advocate review of children withdrawn from school for equivalent instruction elsewhere: A statistical perspective. Retrieved March 17, 2026 from https://www.nheld.us/uconn-statistics-experts-trash-the-document-that-started-it-all-the-child-advocates-report-urging-homeschool-regulation-in-connecticut https://www.nheld.us/uconn-statistics-experts-trash-the-document-that-started-it-all-the-child-advocates-report-urging-homeschool-regulation-in-connecticut homeschooling, home education, abuse, neglect, government report, review, analysis “This report provides an evaluation of the “Review of Children Withdrawn From School For Equivalent Instruction Elsewhere” report [by the Connecticut Office of the Child Advocate], dated May 5th, 2025. The aims of this report are to: i. examine the analytical aspects of the review, and ii. provide recommendations on how the findings of the review could be strengthened by more transparent data reporting, and more rigorous statistical analysis.” “Was the gold standard used by the OCA in her report? No. There was no statistical methodology. There is no formal descriptive analysis, nor any hypothesis testing. Is there a hypothesis or are the necessary steps to reach the reports conclusions presented? No, the hypothesis is unclear. ….. Did the OCA conduct a statistical analysis? No. The OCA report does not contain any statistical analyses. There is no formal descriptive analysis, nor any hypothesis testing. How would you describe her report? It is a descriptive report aimed at providing information on rates of DCF referrals for children withdrawn from traditional schooling over different time periods. The reason we refer to this as not a formal descriptive analysis or hypothesis testing is that no contrast is made to rates of DCF referrals for children who remain in traditional schooling environments. ….. Additional analytical challenges include: No attempt to control for the various covariates that are present and can explain the discrepancy in DCF referrals better than the homeschooling vs. traditional schooling.” “There may be biases in sampling or data collection. If DCF referrals are filed as a result/retaliation of students taken out of traditional schools for homeschooling, then the DCF referral is not an appropriate representation for abuse and neglect, hence does not represent the true rates of abuse and neglect in the traditional-to-homeschooling population. There is also no distinction in the types of DCF referrals, or the timing of the referrals based on when children were withdrawn. This makes even conclusions based on this data problematic, and potentially biased.” “Did the OCA conduct a normal analysis? The OCA report does not conduct any statistical analyses.” “Given the information provided in the report, the only inference that can be made is between “withdrawn to homeschooling” group and “withdrawn to private schools” groups. However, this does not seem to be the primary focus of the OCA report. What should be done for an appropriate statistical analysis, given the facts in the report? The report is missing crucial information to conduct appropriate statistical analysis. “ Given the information provided in the report, the only inference that can be made is between “withdrawn to homeschooling” group and “withdrawn to private schools” groups. However, this does not seem to be the primary focus of the OCA report.” “What should be done for an appropriate statistical analysis, given the facts in the report? The report is missing crucial information to conduct appropriate statistical analysis.” “Is there any way to check the figures for accuracy in her report to see if they are correct? There is no access to DCF records to see if the figures in the report are correct. Therefore, it is not possible to tell whether the OCA numbers are correct. Can one make reasonable or accurate inferences from a descriptive report versus a statistical analysis? In some descriptive reports, some reasonable or accurate inferences can be made. However, in the OCA report, this is not possible due to lack of information, specifically the lack of information on rates of referrals, etc. in children attending traditional schools (see above).” “Conclusion. From a statistical perspective, there is too little information presented in the report for any inference to be made. ….. Ultimately, there is no statistical analysis in this report that could be used to make any inference about the impact of homeschooling on DCF referral rates and whether the rates differ between homeschooled children and traditionally schooled children.”
Baer, Richard A. 1998 Why a functional definition of religion is necessary if justice is to be achieved in public education. In James T. Sears & James C. Carper (Eds.), Curriculum, religion, and public education: Conversations for an enlarging public square (pp. 105-115). New York, NY: Teachers College Press. religion, secular humanism, philosophy, politics, sociology, public schools, private schools Shows there has never been a comfortable consensus in America regarding what “nonsectarian” belief system should prevail in state-run schools. Explains why he says: “But is it really possible for a secular curriculum to be genuinely neutral with respect to religion? I think not. ..... Instead, I hold that liberal public schools cannot coherently transmit private values, and I hold that the transmission of private values is necessary for genuine education to occur” [p. 106]. In offering a functional definition of religion, Baer writes, “Paul Tillich described religion in terms of the category of ‘ultimate concern.’ mile Durkheim argued that secular stories and myths can provide ultimate meaning for a society just as well as those that are supernatural. Secular descriptions of reality, in other words, can function just like supernatural descriptions.” [p. 107]. “... evidence for the claim that our public schools are dominated by secular humanistic values and beliefs is overwhelming ..... In virtually all government public schools humanistic values and beliefs are taught about the nature of the good life and the good society, and many of these values and beliefs directly compete with and undermine traditional Christian and Jewish beliefs. In sharp contrast, the latter are routinely excluded from school curricula” [p. 107]. Secular humanism is a religion: “Writing as a nontheistic or secular humanist, John Dewey (1934) concludes his book A Common Faith with the words: ‘Here are all the elements for a religious faith that shall not be confined to sect, class, or race. Such a faith has always implicitly been the common faith of mankind. It remains to make it explicit and militant’ (p. 87). “Although Dewey’s claim that his humanistic faith was always ‘implicitly the common faith of mankind’ is simply mistaken, his statement about making it ‘explicit and militant’ was prophetic, and it is no wonder that thoughtful religious leaders reacted with alarm. Their concern was only heightened when Dewey (1929) proclaimed that by advancing a common culture America’s public schools ‘are performing an infinitely significant religious work’ (p. 514)” [p. 108]. “Secular instruction can be (and often is) just as ‘sectarian’ (in the sense of narrow-minded, bigoted, one-sided, and parochial) as religious instruction can be. And if this is the case, then we must ask: Does the state have the right to take a captive group of students and indoctrinate them in beliefs and values that will lead them to defect from the teachings of their church and their parents?” [p. 110]. “What actually happens in grades K12--to put the matter bluntly--is that students become the patients of whichever social engineers have the power to push their own values and beliefs on them” [p. 112]. “Perhaps more than any other current social issue, school choice will challenge us as Americans to make clear whether or not we believe in religious tolerance. Will we, in the tradition of Horace Mann, side with the National Education Association in supporting a monopoly system of government schools that are fundamentally vehicles for one or another cultural elite to exercise social control, or will we, in the spirit of the First Amendment’s religion clause, endorse school disestablishment and view the state’s role in education as that of guarantor of just access to education rather than that of religious mentor and moral tutor?” [p. 113].
Bahrampour, Tara 2010, February 21 Muslims turning to home schooling in increasing numbers. Washington Post. Retrieved February 22, 2010 from http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/02/20/AR2010022001235.html?sub=AR. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/02/20/AR2010022001235.html?sub=AR home education, reasons, religion, Islam, Muslim “Although three-quarters of the nation's estimated 2 million home-schoolers identify themselves as Christian, the number of Muslims is expanding "relatively quickly," compared with other groups, said Brian Ray, president of the National Home Education Research Institute. They do so, he said, for the same reasons as non-Muslims: "Stronger academics, more family time, they want to guide social interaction, provide a safe place to learn and . . . teach them [their] values, beliefs and worldview." Parents say it is an attractive alternative to public schools, with whose traditions and values they are not always comfortable, and Islamic schools, which might be too far away, cost too much or lack academic rigor. If Muslims have come to embrace home schooling later than others, it might be in part because so many Muslims in the United States are immigrants who might not be aware of the option.”
Bain, Susanne 2003, circa Home schooling: A better education for your child. Prescott, AZ: Andros Books Publishing.
Baker, Amy J. L., & Soden, Laura M. 1998 The challenges of parent involvement research.. ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. 419 030 98, ERIC/CUE Digest Number 134. http://www.ed.gov/databases/ERIC_Digests/ed419030.html parent parental involvement, academic achievement, research “Years of practice wisdom, theory, and related areas of research … strongly suggest that parents’ involvement in their children’s formal schooling is vital for their academic success, even though the research evidence is less than conclusive.” [Avaliable online, www.ed.gov/databases/ERIC_Digests/ed419030.html]
Baker, John 1989 Title not known but has article on home education in Law and Education Journal.
Baker, John S., Jr. Fall-Winter 1990-1991 parent-centered education. Educational Freedom, 24(1), 39-53. home education
Baker, Ken Physical education and home schooling [correct title?]. Doctoral dissertation (Ph.D.), University of Georgia. home education, research, physical education Qualitative study on homeschooling and physical education.
Baker, Linda 2001, January 9 From home school to public school, students face a variety of challenges. The Oregonian [newspaper], p. B4. home education, academic achievement, socialization, opinion, public school entrance Claims that the homeschooled do well academically and success socially depends on the uniqueness of the individual if they enroll in public schools.
Baker, Virginia Britt 1984 Teaching your child at home. Unpublished manuscript, P.O. Box 58800, Dallas, TX 75258. Religiously based "how to" manual; personal experiences teaching grades K-12).
Baker, Virginia Britt 1993, March Educational "choice." Free World Research Report, 2(3), 1-3. educational choice, tax credits, voucher, home education Contends that acceptance, by people with students in private schools or home education, of tuition tax credits and educational vouchers using tax money will inevitably lead to control by the government. Argues against involvement with tuition tax credits and vouchers. Author is a home education advocate.
Bakermans-Kranenburg, Marian J.; van Ijzendoorn, Marinus H.; & Bradley, Robert H. 2005 Review Of Educational Research, 75(1), 1-26. early childhood education, research, home environment “Abstract: Are preventive early childhood interventions effective in improving home environments, as assessed with the HOME inventory (Caldwell & Bradley, 1984)? The authors traced 48 published articles, presenting 56 intervention effects (N = 7,350). The combined effect size on the HOME total score was d = 0.20 (p < .001). Randomized intervention studies were effective, but the combined effect size was limited (d = 0.13). Nonrandomized studies showed inflated effects (d = 0.58). Interventions with middle-class, non-adolescent parents showed higher effect sizes than interventions with low-SES or adolescent samples. Effective interventions used a moderate number of sessions in a limited period and were home-based. Learning Materials, Involvement, and Responsivity showed significant intervention effects. Families in better living conditions profited more from parent education (the Matthew effect).”
Ball, William Bentley 1977 Litigation in education: In defense of freedom. Wichita, KS: Center for Independent Education.
Ball, William Bentley 1984 Parental rights in schooling. In Connaught Marshner, (Ed.), A blueprint for educational reform. Chicago, IL: Free Congress Research and Education Foundation.
Ball, William Bentley 1994 Mere creatures of the state?: Education, religion, and the courts, a view from the courtroom. Notre Dame, IN: Crisis Books. education, law, private schools, establishment, philosophy Focuses on Supreme Court cases such as Pierce v. Society of Sisters held “... the state would be permitted a narrow and limited regulatory role over schools in the name of the common good. But nothing in the Pierce decision suggested the state in the role of primary educator or, as superior educator, the standard setter for all educational endeavors. ..... Pierce was thus wholly consistent with the teachings of Catholics, Evangelicals, and Orthodox Jews on education and parental rights and in defense of religious schools and parental rights and duties” [p. 13]. “Why did the Catholic plea [in the mid-19th century and into the mid-20th century] for public aid to Catholic schools occasion a virtual crusade, first in the Pennsylvania legislature, then in the courts, to block such aid, to damn it and its sponsors as enemies of the Constitution, …” when there were already laws that allowed for public aid (i.e., taxes) “… for the support of schools maintained by religious societies” [p. 21]? The answer has to do with anti-Catholic sentiment. The Supreme Court in Lemon v. Kurtzman showed skewed bias against the Catholic Church and held it was unconstitutional for public funds to be used for religious K-12 schools while inventing unfounded and unconstitutional ideas about entanglement between the state and religion, the supposed wall of separation between church and state, promoted by professor Freund; the Lemon decision “... would not only void the Pennsylvania act but become, in the decades down to the present, the great legal instrument for the enforced secularization of the national culture” [p. 27]. Discusses how religious schools are enticed into compromising beliefs and teachings in order to receive tax moneys. Focuses on Supreme Court case Wisconsin v. Yoder which decided the four questions of the “Free Exercise Test” and that Amish children did not have to attend high school because it was against their religion. Focuses on Supreme Court case Rudasill v. Kentucky State Board of Education which determined whether children could only attend private schools that were state-approved. Discusses the “Guardians,” those employed by the state or who believe the state is the guardian of children’s education. Gives example of the maxim that the power to tax is the power to destroy in discussing the fact that parents who choose private education for their children must also pay public school tax [i.e., “double taxation”] for the education of others’ children; “To speak of this inequity [i.e., parents who choose private education paying twice: taxes for state schools and more for private curriculum or tuition] is not, however, to exhaust the subject of taxation in relation to education. Of equal significance is the character of the tax power as unlimited, and of even greater significance is the character of the tax power as an instrument for molding the citizenry for social ends” [p. 111].
Ballmann, Ray E. 1987 The how and why of home schooling. Westchester, IL: Crossway Books. home education, Christian perspective, philosophy, pracitce “First and foremost is the fact that the Bible states that educational responsibility lies firmly in parental hands. Deuteronomy 6 is one of the many Biblical passages that explicate the child-rearing and education responsibilities of parents” p. 16.
Ballmann, Ray E. 1991 How your family can flourish: A guide to Christian living in a post-Christian culture. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books. home education, Christian living Of several guiding principles stated, he says, "Guiding Principle: Parents who want their children to develop strong academic excellence, moral strength of character, and a healthy self-respect, to be socially well-adjusted, and to build spiritual depth and appreciation should seriously consider home education or a private Christian school." Mentions that public schools are not safe places in physical and drug and sexual terms, safety, p. 20
Bane, M. J. 1976 Here to stay: American families in the twentieth century. New York, NY: Basic Books, Inc. History of family policy making.
Banks, Adelle M. 2007, August 9 Study: Most young adults drop out of Protestant churches. Retrieved 8/9/07 online http://www.ethicsdaily.com/article_detail.cfm?AID=9296. http://www.ethicsdaily.com/article_detail.cfm?AID=9296 religion, religiosity, young adults, church attendance, education “(RNS) More than two-thirds of young adults stopped attending Protestant churches regularly for at least a year when they were between the ages of 18 and 22, a new study by LifeWay Research shows.”
Barber, Geoff 2001, February 20 Barber of Educational Testing Service to Brian D. Ray, February 20, 2001, personal communication. academic achievement, academic aptitude, college, adults Barber faxed to Brian Ray SATI (Scholastic Aptitude Test) 2000 results for college-bound seniors; categories and scores were as follow (group of seniors, Verbal score, Math score, then Total score): Non-religious independent, 547, 566, 1113; Home educated, 568, 532, 1100; Religious independent, 539, 532, 1071; Catholic independent, 525, 519, 1044; Public school, 501, 510, 1011
Barbosa, Luciane Muniz Ribeiro 2016 An Overview of the Homeschooling in Brazil: Analysis of Its Principles and Attempts of Legalization. Open Journal of Social Sciences, 4, 203-211. doi: https://doi.org/10.4236/jss.2016.44029. https://doi.org/10.4236/jss.2016.44029 Homeschooling, Right to Education, Concerted Cultivation, Brazil “Abstract. Homeschooling is a kind of education that is growing. The goal of this study is to review issues used against attempts to legalize homeschooling in Brazil, which have brought up questions about what the right to education is. It presents some themes and concepts of the New Institutionalism Theory in Education as an attempt to relate them to the debate that goes around the growth of the homeschooling movement in different places as well as a context connected to the “concerted cultivation” concept. Thus, this paper suggests that emergence of homeschooling in Brazil is not associated to the school choice movement, but to the growth of concerted cultivation and represents for the country a movement with strong political implications.”
Barclay, William 1959 Train up a child: Educational ideals in the ancient world. Philadelphia, PA: The Westminster Press. education, family, history, Roman, Hebrew, Greek, Christian mis?? Covers Roman, Greek, Hebrew, and early Christian education in a survey fashion.
Bardelas, R. 1980 A manual on secondary education programs for migrant students. Salem, OR: Oregon Migrant Education Service Center.
Barfield, Rhonda 2002 Real-life homeschooling: The stories of 21 families who teach their children at home. New York, NY: Fireside of Simon & Schuster, Inc.).
Barna Group 2001, August 20 Home school families have different backgrounds than commonly assumed. Published 8/20/01 and retrieved 8/22/01 online http://www.barna.org/cgi-bin/Home.asp, http://www.barna.org/cgi-bin/PagePressRelease.asp?PressReleaseID=96&Reference=A, and March 1, 2010 from http://www.barna.org/barna-update/article/5-barna-update/57-home-school-families-have-different-backgrounds-than-commonly-assumed. Ventura, CA: Barna Research Group. http://www.barna.org/cgi-bin/Home.asp http://www.barna.org/cgi-bin/PagePressRelease.asp?PressReleaseID=96&Reference=A http://www.barna.org/barna-update/article/5-barna-update/57-home-school-families-have-different-backgrounds-than-commonly-assumed http://www.nheri.org http://www.barna.org/cgibin/Home.asp http://www.barna.org/cgibin/PagePressRelease.asp?PressReleaseID=96&Reference=A home education, methodology, demographics, religion, minority minorities Based on a sample size of only 234 families nationwide, concludes that 51% of homeschool families are not born again Christians, homeschoolers are more likely than the national average to describe themselves as “mostly conservative,” only 15% are evangelical Christians, they have a higher incidence of Bible reading than the norm, a majority of homeschool households are non-white (split evenly between Hispanic and black families; race, ethnicity), and the household income of homeschool families is 10% below the national average. Several things should be considered when reading this report by Barna: 1. The findings and conclusions are based on responses from only 234 families out of an estimated 750,000 to 1,000,000 home-school families in the United States. (See http://www.nheri.org, click on research, click on Fact Sheet II.) 2. How did Barna define "home-school parent" in the study. They do not explain this. One does not, therefore, know which families using which educational methods are included in this sample. 3. Barna gives no accounting of the response rate. For example: What percent of families who were contacted answered the questions, and what percent did not/refused? 4. Barna gives no description of who the nonrespondents may or may not be; that is, What are their traits? 5. Why did it take 19 months to collect the data from a total of only 234 families? This is a relatively long stretch of time for this kind of research to cover. 6. When findings are significantly different from what has been found by a substantial body of research and experience in a field, it is very helpful to present possible reasons for the differences. For example, why are Barna's findings with respect to religious affiliation, racial/ethnic background, and likeliness to be registered to vote so different from the findings of previous research?
Barna Group 2003, December 1 A biblical worldview has a radical effect on a person's life. Retrieved January 22, 2015 from https://www.barna.org/barna-update/article/5-barna-update/131-a-biblical-worldview-has-a-radical-effect-on-a-persons-life#.VMF_zUfF8i8 https://www.barna.org/barna-update/article/5-barna-update/131-a-biblical-worldview-has-a-radical-effect-on-a-persons-life#.VMF_zUfF8i8 http://www.barna.org/cgibin/PagePressRelease.asp?PressReleaseID=154&Reference=A worldview, religion, religiosity, biblical, Christianity and 12/3/03 http://www.barna.org/cgibin/PagePressRelease.asp?PressReleaseID=154&Reference=A. (“The research indicated that everyone has a worldview, but relatively few people have a biblical worldview - even among devoutly religious people. The survey discovered that only 9% of born again Christians have such a perspective on life. The numbers were even lower among other religious classifications: Protestants (7%), adults who attend mainline Protestant churches (2%) and Catholics (less than one-half of 1%). The denominations that produced the highest proportions of adults with a biblical worldview were non-denominational Protestant churches (13%), Pentecostal churches (10%) and Baptist churches (8%). ….. Adults who have a biblical worldview possessed a somewhat different demographic profile than those who did not. For instance, individuals who attended college were much more likely than those who did not to have this perspective (6% versus 2%, respectively). Married adults were more than twice as likely as adults who had never been wed to hold such a worldview (5% versus 2%). Whites (5%) were slightly more likely than either blacks (3%) or Hispanics (3%) to hold this ideology. One of the largest gaps was between Republicans (10% of whom had a biblical worldview), Independents (2%) and Democrats (1%).”
Barna Group, The 2006, September 11 Most twentysomethings put Christianity on the shelf following spiritually active teen years. Retrieved September 5, 2016 from https://www.barna.com/research/most-twentysomethings-put-christianity-on-the-shelf-following-spiritually-active-teen-years/#.V84Uf5grKM8 Retrieved January 22, 2015 from https://www.barna.org/teens-next-gen-articles/147-most-twentysomethings-put-christianity-on-the-shelf-following-spiritually-active-teen-years) https://www.barna.com/research/most-twentysomethings-put-christianity-on-the-shelf-following-spiritually-active-teen-years/#.V84Uf5grKM8 https://www.barna.org/teens-next-gen-articles/147-most-twentysomethings-put-christianity-on-the-shelf-following-spiritually-active-teen-years http://www.barna.org/FlexPage.aspx?Page=BarnaUpdateNarrow&BarnaUpdateID=245 http://www.barna.org/barna-update/article/16-teensnext-gen/147-most-twentysomethings-put-christianity-on-the-shelf-following-spiritually-active-teen-years Christianity, Christian life, lifestyle, youth, young adult, religion, practice, religiosity, orthodoxy and retrieved 6/15/07 from http://www.barna.org/FlexPage.aspx?Page=BarnaUpdateNarrow&BarnaUpdateID=245. Retrieved 4/8/09 from http://www.barna.org/barna-update/article/16-teensnext-gen/147-most-twentysomethings-put-christianity-on-the-shelf-following-spiritually-active-teen-years. (“At the same time, the Barna research underscores how fleeting that influence may be: twentysomethings continue to be the most spiritually independent and resistant age group in America. Most of them pull away from participation and engagement in Christian churches, particularly during the “college years." The research shows that, compared to older adults, twentysomethings have significantly lower levels of church attendance, time spent alone studying and reading the Bible, volunteering to help churches, donations to churches, Sunday school and small group involvement, and use of Christian media (including television, radio and magazines). In fact, the most potent data regarding disengagement is that a majority of twentysomethings - 61% of today’s young adults - had been churched at one point during their teen years but they are now spiritually disengaged (i.e., not actively attending church, reading the Bible, or praying). Only one-fifth of twentysomethings (20%) have maintained a level of spiritual activity consistent with their high school experiences. Another one-fifth of teens (19%) were never significantly reached by a Christian community of faith during their teens and have remained disconnected from the Christian faith. For most adults, this pattern of disengagement is not merely a temporary phase in which they test the boundaries of independence, but is one that continues deeper into adulthood, with those in their thirties also less likely than older adults to be religiously active. Even the traditional impulse of parenthood - when people’s desire to supply spiritual guidance for their children pulls them back to church - is weakening.” “Kinnaman [i.e., David Kinnaman, the director of the research] offered several insights about the data: "Much of the ministry to teenagers in America needs an overhaul - not because churches fail to attract significant numbers of young people, but because so much of those efforts are not creating a sustainable faith beyond high school. There are certainly effective youth ministries across the country, but the levels of disengagement among twentysomethings suggest that youth ministry fails too often at discipleship and faith formation. A new standard for viable youth ministry should be - not the number of attenders, the sophistication of the events, or the ‘cool’ factor of the youth group - but whether teens have the commitment, passion and resources to pursue Christ intentionally and whole- heartedly after they leave the youth ministry nest."”
Barna Group, The 2007, April 9 Research shows parenting approach determines whether children become devoted Christians. Ventura, CA: Barna Research Group. http://www.barna.org/FlexPage.aspx?Page=BarnaUpdate&BarnaUpdateID=268 child training, youth, research, parents, family, education, discipleship, adulthood, Christianity, practice, faith Retrieved 4/22/08 from http://www.barna.org/FlexPage.aspx?Page=BarnaUpdate&BarnaUpdateID=268. “Another unique feature of Barna’s research was the assumption that people are created primarily for spiritual purposes. Consequently, the young adults who formed the foundation of the study met some unusual standards: . Knowing, loving, and serving God was identified as their top priority in life. 2. They described their faith in God as being of the highest importance. 3. Each of these young adults possessed a "biblical worldview," based on their responses to a series of questions about their view of life. In essence, they contend that absolute moral truth exists; such truth is defined in the Bible; God is the all-knowing and all-powerful creator and ruler of the universe; faith in Jesus Christ is the only means to salvation; Satan is a real being; Jesus Christ lived a sinless life on earth; and all of the principles taught in the Bible are true and accurate. 4. They believe that their main purpose in life is to love God with all their heart, mind and strength. 5. They are currently active in a vibrant community of faith, as demonstrated by their consistent engagement in worship, prayer, Bible study and spiritual accountability. ….. The book describes the six critical dimensions that were common to effective parents. Those dimensions, each of which included a variety of practices and perspectives, related to the priorities in the life of the parent; the mental entry points for parenting; the non-negotiable boundaries established for children; the importance of behaving like a parent; the critical values and beliefs needed by children; and the transformational goals identified and pursued” retrieved 4/22/08 from http://www.barna.org/FlexPage.aspx?Page=BarnaUpdate&BarnaUpdateID=268.
Barna, George 2007 Revolutionary parenting. Ventura, CA: Barna Books. http://www.amazon.com/Revolutionary-Parenting-Research-Shows-Really/dp/1414307608/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1198003683&sr=8-1 child training, youth, research, parents, family, education, discipleship, adulthood, Christianity, practice, faith, religiosity “The Revolution is underway, but in this new era, how can parents make a lasting impact in the spiritual lives of their children? To find the answer, George Barna researched the lives of thriving adult Christians [spiritual champions] and discovered the essential steps their parents took to shape their spiritual lives in childhood. He also learned surprising truths about which popular parenting tactics just aren’t working. Revolutionary Parenting goes beyond youth group and Sunday school and shows parents how to instill in their children a vibrant commitment to Christ.” As one reads this book, it appears to be an argument/apologetic for parent-led home-based education (i.e., homeschooling) despite the fact that the author does not explicitly make that point. In other words, the practices that lead to or “create” spiritual champions are those that are a part of what most Christian homeschool authors and speakers and leaders promote as sound, biblical homeschooling. Retrieved 12/18/2007 from http://www.amazon.com/Revolutionary-Parenting-Research-Shows-Really/dp/1414307608/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1198003683&sr=8-1.
Barnebey, Leslie Faulkner 1986 American university admission requirements for home schooled applicants, in 1984. Dissertation Abstracts International, 47(3), 798A. Ed.D., Brigham Young University, 188 p. "... to identify and compare the admission requirements of 210 selected four year public and private universities in the United States with respect to the admission of applicant who have been home schooled..... ... Carnegie type, size, and location were not significant in determining which universities had accepted home schooled applicants. ... the universities which had admitted these applicants accepted subjective criteria in lieu of high school transcripts. The admission officers from the universities which had accepted these applicants believed that these students were as likely as any other to succeed and did not feel that additional policies were required..." [DAI]. Very few admission officers expect a major increase in home schooled applicants.
Barratt-Peacock, John 1997, May The why and how of Australian home education, Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, LaTrobe University, Bundoora, Vic. 3083, Australia. home education, research, qualitative, reasons, rationale, ethnographic “Thesis Summary Why do some Australians choose to home educate their children and how do they implement that choice? [paragraph] To answer these questions a nation-wide data base was first built from face to face interview, documentary and observational evidence. The descriptive data thus obtained were analysed within a hermeneutical framework. They indicated that home education was chosen when the role of the family as keeper/creator of explanatory systems appeared to be challenged by the school. [paragraph] State regulation of home education is usually based on a schooling model. This research proposes a model of the home educating family as a community of learning practice having specific identifying features. Such a family has its own culture with attendant world views and rituals. Learning as a major orientation becomes an integral and inseparable aspect of the social processes of family membership. Children, being accorded a high degree of independent regard, personal autonomy and responsibility, become joint venturers with parents. Older children, with parents as mentor-guides, learn from visits to sites of authentic adult practice in the wider community. [paragraph] Procedural knowledge, obtained from shared skill based domestic activity, stimulates further learning leading to the acquisition of propositional knowledge via family conversation. Individual constructions are analysed and synthesised during family [p. 12 ends] conversation which becomes a process of validation and a means of generating knowledge. [paragraph] Whether in the family or local community, this research indicates that home education is firmly based in situated activity in the real world settings of full adult practice. [paragraph] A substantial range of learning techniques was observed, including role modelling, scaffolding, work in the zone of proximal development, observational learning and individual research based projects. [paragraph] variation [sic] in the practice of families and the degree of fit of model to practice were discussed and possible questions for further research noted” [p. 12-13] Report one researchers estimated there to be about 10,000 homeschool families in 1991 in Australia with a 20% per annum growth rate.
Barratt-Peacock, John 2003 Australian home education : A model. Evaluation and Research in Education, 17(2 & 3), 101-111. home education, home economics, home schooling, parent-child relationship, parents as teachers Abstract: If home education is not just school in another place, how can it be conceptualised and how does it work? This paper considers the peculiar set of relationships that characterise home-educating families and traces their extension out into the wider community. It further shows how, through the ongoing family conversation, experiences gained from domestic occupation and accompanied excursions into the field of authentic adult practice are problematised, built into the developing family worldview, and adapted by individual members for their own personal learning. It is proposed that a more useful model for home education characterises the family as a community of learning practice. Such a perspective views home education as the modern development of a tradition older than schooling in its response to the problem of secondary socialisation in a developed society [author abstract]
Barrett, Nanette 1985, January Education source book: The state legislators' guide for reform. Washington, DC: American Legislative Exchange Council. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED253939). Educational Change, Models, State Legislation A selection of suggestions for laws to grant parents local control over the education of their children.
Barrett, William B. 1950 The home education of a boy. New York, NY: Updegraff Press, Ltd., 120 p.
Barson, Leslie Safran 2006 Learner-managed learning and home education: A European perspective. Bramcote, Nottingham, United Kingdom UK: Educational Heretics Press. home education, homeschooling, foreign, political science, democracy, philosophy, homeschooling in practice Addresses topics such as “why many home-based educating families have found a learning system fit for a democracy,” “what home educating parents can teach the world about the nature of learning”[Table of Contents], examples of home education and learner-managed learning from France, Germany, and Switzerland.
Bartel, Daniel J. 1998 The Christian home school movement and the traditional church. Doctoral (D. Min.) dissertation, Covenant Theological Seminary. home education, research, religion, church, motivations, social effects Examines “... which motivations for operating a home school were most likely to cause conflict between traditional churches and Christian home school families” (abstract). Two populations studied were home school families and pastors of churches attended by home schoolers. Finds “... that renewal or reform-centered motivations were more likely to produce conflict than education-centered motivations” (abstract), some home school leaders/advocates were associated with conflict within churches more than were other home school leaders/advocates, the length of time a pastor had been associated with the Christian home school movement was significantly related to his perceptions of motivations and whether they would lead to conflict. “The heart of the conflict was identified by Presbyterian Church in America pastors as being the pride and legalism of both home school families and non-home school families” (abstract). “A lack of conflict was noted by pastors in churches which emphasized Christ-centered liberty in education choices and taught the covenantal responsibilities of parents toward their children. These two qualities point to a new paradigm, Covenant Education. This study indicates that strong measure need to be taken to bring the traditional church back to its roots in covenant education” (abstract).
Barth, R. 1979 Home-based reinforcement of school behavior: A review and analysis. Review of Educational Research, 49, 436-58.
Bartholet, Elizabeth 2019 Homeschooling: Parent rights absolutism vs child rights to education & protection. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3407414 homeschooling, home education, philosophy, law, parental rights, statism, abuse, education draft, forthcoming, in press, Arizona Law Review, 62(1), 2020. Retrieved June 21, 2019 from https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3407414 (“Abstract: This article describes the rapidly growing homeschooling phenomenon, and the threat it poses to children and society. Homeschooling activists have in recent decades largely succeeded in their deregulation campaign, overwhelming legislators with aggressive advocacy. As a result, parents can now keep their children at home in the name of homeschooling free from any real scrutiny as to whether or how they are educating their children. Many homeschool precisely because they want to isolate their children from ideas and values central to our democracy. Many promote racial segregation and female subservience. Many question science. Many are determined to keep their children from exposure to views that might enable autonomous choice about their future lives. Abusive parents can keep their children at home free from the risk that teachers will see the signs of abuse and report them to child protection services. Some homeschool precisely for this reason. This article calls for a radical transformation in the homeschooling regime, and a related rethinking of child rights and reframing of constitutional doctrine. It recommends a presumptive ban on homeschooling, with the burden on parents to demonstrate justification for permission to homeschool.”
Bartholet, Elizabeth 2020 Homeschooling: Parent rights absolutism vs. child rights to education and protection, Arizona Law Review, 62(1) (2020), retrieved April 30, 2020 from https://arizonalawreview.org/homeschooling-parent-rights-absolutism-vs-child-rights-to-education-protection/ https://arizonalawreview.org/homeschooling-parent-rights-absolutism-vs-child-rights-to-education-protection/ homeschooling, law, legal, child abuse, philosophy, ban, policy “This Article describes the rapidly growing homeschooling phenomenon and the threat it poses to children and society. Homeschooling activists have in recent decades largely succeeded in their deregulation campaign, overwhelming legislators with aggressive advocacy. As a result, parents can now keep their children at home in the name of homeschooling free from any real scrutiny as to whether or how they are educating their children. Many homeschool because they want to isolate their children from ideas and values central to our democracy, determined to keep their children from exposure to views that might enable autonomous choice about their future lives. Many promote racial segregation and female subservience. Many question science. Abusive parents can keep their children at home free from the risk that teachers will report them to child protection services. Some homeschool precisely for this reason. This Article calls for a radical transformation in the homeschooling regime and a related rethinking of child rights. It recommends a presumptive ban on homeschooling, with the burden on parents to demonstrate justification for permission to homeschool.” Author’s wording is somewhat ambiguous but appears to be claiming that homeschool children are at higher risk of abuse than are institutional school children, and offer no empirical evidence to support this claim. Author provides no empirical evidence to support the following claims: “This homeschooling regime poses real dangers to children and to society. Children are at serious risk of losing out on opportunities to learn things that are essential for employment and for exercising meaningful choices in their future lives. They are also at serious risk for ongoing abuse and neglect in the isolated [p. 3 ends] families that constitute a significant part of the homeschooling world” (p. 3-4). “It [being homeschooled] subjects many to serious health risks” (p. 14). “Child abuse and neglect characterize a significant subset of homeschooling families” (p. 14) “As noted above, homeschoolers tend to live in isolation, …” (p. 15). “Nevertheless, we know enough to know that homeschooling in its current unregulated form poses serious risks of abuse and neglect” (p. 15). The reports that author references do not support the claim that homeschool students are at more risk than institutional school students or serious (or disproportionate) risk of abuse or neglect. Author makes this claim, “And in any event, we know that a substantial percentage of homeschoolers are being deprived of the kind of education we should think of as minimally adequate. As discussed above, many religious homeschoolers object in principle to some core goals of public education” (p. 23), but gives no empirical evidence or premises to support the claims of either the first or second sentence; further, who decides the “… core goals of public education” and why should they apply to children whose parents did not choose public/state education but chose private education (e.g., Roman Catholic, Jewish, New Age, Christian, or Muslim private schooling or homeschooling private education?) .
Bartholet, Elizabeth 2022 Homeschooling. In Asal et al. (Eds), Exploring Norms and Family Laws Across the Globe, pp. 149-168, https://www.google.com/books/edition/Exploring_Norms_and_Family_Laws_Across_t/URllEAAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=Elizabeth+Bartholet&pg=PA149&printsec=frontcover https://www.google.com/books/edition/Exploring_Norms_and_Family_Laws_Across_t/URllEAAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=Elizabeth+Bartholet&pg=PA149&printsec=frontcover homeschool, homeschooling, legal, law, criticism, abuse, neglect, statism This chapter in a book makes the same basic claims as the author’s 2021 article, that there should be a presumptive ban on homeschooling. She makes claims about the implied rate of abuse and neglect of homeschool children without evidence-based research to support her claims. She is very negatively concerned about conservative Christians homeschooling their children because Bartholet wants them taught all of the ideological and philosophical and religious things that she holds dear in her worldview. “It is the religious ideologues who dominate the homeschooling movement. They founded the enormously powerful Homeschooling [sic] Legal Defense [p. 158 ends] Association (HSLDA), which has played the leading role fighting against regulation” (p. 158-159). “The new regime [of law] should place the burden on parents who want to homeschool to demonstrate that they have a legitimate need, and that they are capable of and committed to providing education comparable in scope to that provided in public schools” (p. 164). “What is needed is a true child rights movement” (p. 164). ?
Barwegen, Laura Mezzano, Falciani, Nancy K., Putnam, S. Junlah, Reamer, Megan B., & Stair, Esther E. 2004 Academic achievement of homeschool and public school students and student perception of parent involvement. School Community Journal, 14(1), 39-58, Spr-Sum 2004. public school, homeschool, ACT college entrance test, parental involmement (ERIC EJ794828) “The primary purpose of this study was to determine if the score of homeschool students on the national ACT exam remained higher than the score for public school students when the perception of parent involvement throughout their school career was factored” (p. 44). “This paper presents the results of a survey of 127 seniors in a diverse suburban high school to determine the impact of the subjects’ perceptions of parent involvement on their levels of achievement as measured by the standardized national ACT test. Independent-samples t tests were then used to assess whether there were any differences in achievement as reported in national test scores among students with a perception of a high level of parent involvement, students with a perception of a low level of parent involvement, and homeschool students. The findings of the study were that the perception of a high level of parent involvement does have a significant impact upon achievement. Students who perceived a high level of parent involvement performed significantly better on the national ACT exam than students who perceived a low level of parent involvement. There was no difference in academic achievement between public school students who perceived a high level of parent involvement and homeschool students. Key Words: parent involvement, academic achievement” [p. 39]. Suggests that the average home-educated student who takes the ACT does as well as the high-parental-involvement public school student who takes the ACT. How about comparing high-parental invovlement public school students to high-parental invovlement homeschool students?)
Basham, Patrick 2001, October 9 Home schooling: From the extreme to the mainstream. Paper copy, and retrieved 10/12/01 online http://www.fraserinstitute.ca/publications/pps/51/homeschool.pdf. http://www.fraserinstitute.ca/publications/pps/51/homeschool.pdf home education, research, opinion, academic achievement, socialization, Canada Published by the Faser Institute, 4th Floor, 1770 Burrard Street, Vancouver, BC, Canada, V6J 3G7. “By 1996, the respective provincial ministries of education put the number of home schooled children at 17,523, or 0.4 percent of total student enrolment—a 776 percent increase over just 18 years.10 However, Canada’s home schooling associations claimed a much higher figure—between 30,000 and 40,000, or approximately one percent of total student enrolment. By 1997, the home schooling associations claimed there were approximately 60,000 Canadian home schooled children (Eisler and Dwyer, 1997, p. 64). Today, it is estimated that there are more than 80,000 children being educated in private homes. If accurate, this suggests a doubling of the home schooled population in only a few years ... (p. 6)” “Although home schooling is neither desirable nor possible for all families, it has proven itself to be a relatively inexpensive and successful private alternative to public (and costly formal private) education. As such, it merits both the respect of regulators and the further attention of researchers” (p. 16).
Basham, Patrick, Merrifield, John, and Hepburn, Claudia R. 2007, October Home schooling: From the extreme to the mainstream, 2nd edition. Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada: Fraser Institute. Retrieved 7/8/13 from http://homeschooling.gomilpitas.com/extras/From_the_extreme_to_the_mainstream.pdf http://homeschooling.gomilpitas.com/extras/From_the_extreme_to_the_mainstream.pdf http://www.fraserinstitute.ca/Commerce.Web/product_files/Homeschooling.pdf home education, research, summary, synthesis, academic achievement, socialization, economics, public schools, private schools and retrieved 10/5/07 from http://www.fraserinstitute.ca/Commerce.Web/product_files/Homeschooling.pdf). (Review, synthesize, and summarize research and policy matters related to homeschooling in Canada and the United States. Do not conduct new basic research. “Of the thousands of studies published by The Fraser Institute, Patrick Basham’s 2001 study Homeschooling: From the Extreme to the Mainstream has had almost unique popularity and longevity. In 2006, five years after it was published, the study’s PDF was downloaded from our website more than 10,000 times, making it the most frequently viewed study apart from the newly released school report cards and the Tax Freedom Freedom Day calculator” (p. 3). Report in executive summary report that (a) “Home schooling continues to grow in popularity among parents in both Canada and the US,” (b) “There are good reasons to be suspicious about easy comparisons between the test scores of home schooled and other students, since it is difficult to ensure comparable testing conditions or levels of student participation, among other reasons. However, the number of scholars and studies comparing the two groups continues to grow, bolstering older studies,” (c) “ Many studies, Canadian, American, and international, have found that home schooled students outperform students in both public and independent (private) schools,” (d) “Home educated children enjoy no significant advantage if one or both parents are certified teachers,” (e) Surprisingly, several studies have found that home education may help eliminate the potential negative effects of certain socio-economic factors. Though children whose parents have university degrees score higher on tests of academic achievement than other home schooled children, home education appears to mitigate the harmful effect of low parental education levels. That is, public schools seem to educate children of poorly educated parents worse than do the poorly educated parents themselves,” (f) “Despite a widespread belief that home educated students are not adequately socialized, the preponderance of research suggests otherwise,” (g) Though the long-term effects of home schooling are less well studied, both Canadian and American findings on previously home schooled adults are encouraging. Canadian home-schooled students report a life satisfaction score well above their public school peers. American studies have found indications of a wide range of non-academic benefits from home schooling,” [p. 3 ends] (h) The widespread use of the Internet has helped the development of social connections and pedagogical resources of home schooling families,” (i) “Home schooling families reportedly spend less than US $4,000 per year per household on home schooling though that cost does place any value on the parents’ time. In the United States, the most recent figures show public school spending to be $9,644 per child” [p. 4]. Report is relatively fair and friendly toward homeschooling. Makes this empahsis: “There is one overriding lesson for policymakers to learn from this survey of home schooling. As home schooling researcher Isabel Lyman pithily described the American experience: “Home schooling has produced literate students with minimal government interference at a fraction of the cost of any government program” (Lyman, 1998)” (p. 18.
Bastiat, Frederick 1850 The law. Also retrieved 3/8/04 online http://lexrex.com/informed/otherdocuments/thelaw/main.htm. http://lexrex.com/informed/otherdocuments/thelaw/main.htm
Bates, Vernon L. 1988 Motivation and resource mobilization in the fundamentalist home school movement. home education, sociology, religion; research, home education, religion, Christian, politics A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Oregon Academy of Science, February, 1988. Four factors important to the motivation of home educators were religious background and present religious convictions (i.e., fundamentalist, evangelical, reconstructionist, and charismatic), family values (i.e., importance of the traditional family with only one working outside the home), the influence of peers on children (i.e., children are naturally evil and do bad things together that they wouldn't do alone), and anti-educational [or pro-home educational] (i.e., the National Education Association is acting like the devil) values.
Bates, Vernon L. 1990 Motivation and Resource Mobilization in the New Christian Right Home Schooling Movement. Home School Researcher, 6(1), 1-11. research, home education, religion, Christian, politics Blends "resource mobilization theory" (dealing with money and labor) with "strain theory" (dealing with dissatisfaction and emotions) to understand Christian home education. Posits that structural support (i.e., effective leadership, financial resources, and a network of dedicated believers), in part from the Christian Right, existed before the home schooling movement and helped it to expand. Home education is a way to live out traditional beliefs and certain emotions within the context of significant, developing social resources. See note at beginning of this bibliography on the availability of Home School Researcher.
Batterbee, Dennis J. 1992 The relationship between parent-child interactive systems and creativity in home schooled children. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, United States International University, San Diego, CA. home education, research, creativity, motivation, autonomy, instructional style Used Lawrence Williams' Home Schooling Instructional Survey and Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking-Figural Form A (TTCT); First hypothesis was that "... the parent-child interactive process that occurs within the home school setting is based on a format which encourages autonomy and intrinsic motivation within the child" (Abstract). Findings supported first hypothesis in relation to intrinsic motivation and moderately supportive in relation to autonomy. The second hypothesis "... assumed those children who are home schooled with the instructional focus centered upon producing autonomy and intrinsic motivation..." would score higher in creativity (Abstract). Findings supported the second hypothesis with respect to intrinsic motivation, but not with respect to the instructional relationship factor of autonomy. Provides creativity raw and normed scores for Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking-Figural but does not present national percentiles or other standard score. Some subcategories of creativity scores significantly positively related to number of adults in family, education of the home teacher, child’s age, age home schooling began, number of years home schooled [for 2 of 5 creativity subcategories], and number of years in conventional school; one of six subcategories significantly negatively related to household income.
Batterbee, Gayla C. 1992 The relationship of parent-child interactive systems to cognitive attributes in the home schooled child. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, United States International University, San Diego, CA. home education, achievement, learning environment, structure, autonomy, motivation Used Lawrence Williams' Home Schooling Instructional Survey to measure degree of emphasis on autonomy, intrinsic motivation, and structuredness. Emphasis on autonomy in child significantly positively related to achievement test scores; emphasis on internal motivation and degree of unstructuredness in learning format not related to test scores. Stanford Achievement Test scores at 63rd percentile in reading, the 60th in math, and the 56th percentile in language. Replete with demographic data: subject families in southern California, 74.6% fundamental Christian and 25.4% other Christian, 41% of families with $30,000-49,999/year and 49% at $50,000 or more/year, educational attainment of parent, reasons for home educating (better academic environment-13%, better social-emotional environment-14.5%, and impart fundamental Christian values-72.5%), ages of children, etc. Many correlations between demographic variables and test scores.
Baucham, Voddie T. Jr. 2021 Fault lines: The social justice movement and evangelicalism's looming catastrophe. Washington, DC: Salem Books, Regnery. ISBN-10: 1684511801. http://www.regnery.com social justice, biblical justice, education, schooling, homeschooling, worldview, religion The prevalence of the worldviews of Critical Race Theory/Intersectionality, the social justice moment, and promotion and advocacy of political groups like Black Lives Matters in government/public schools explains why many parents leave them for homeschooling. Argues that the aforementioned worldviews and thought groups are anti-biblical/Christian, anti-liberty, and anti-fact-based. “… Voddie Baucham, a preacher, professor, and cultural apologist, explains the sinister worldview behind the social justice movement and Critical Race Theory—revealing how it already has infiltrated some seminaries, leading to internal denominational conflict, canceled careers, and lost livelihoods. Like a fault line, it threatens American culture in general—and the evangelical church in particular” – www.regnery.com
Baugus, Brian 2022 An economic theory of home schooling. Lanham, Maryland: Lexington Books, Rowman & Littlefield. homeschooling, home schooling, economic theory, entrepreneurship “I analyze the dissatisfaction many parents have [with public schooling], show how entrepreneurship theory explains home schoolers, then examine the costs and benefits, look at the resistance and criticism, and speculate what might be next” (p. 11).
Baum, Robert 1986, May The home schooling of Andrew Wyeth. Gifted Children, 7(5), 1-3, 13.
Bauman, Kurt J. 2001, July Home schooling in the United States: Trends and characteristics (working paper series no. 53). Washington, DC: U.S. Census Bureau. Also retrieved 8/29/03 online http://www.census.gov/population/www/documentation/twps0053.html. http://www.census.gov/population/www/documentation/twps0053.html population size/growth, trends, demographics, reasons Estimates, based on national sampling, that there were 791,000 homeschool students ages 6 to 17 in the U.S. in 1999 but does not say for which month. Provides demographic traits and reasons parents say they decide to homeschool.
Bauman, Kurt J. 2002, May 16 Home schooling in the United States: Trends and Characteristics. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 10(26). Retrieved 5/23/02 online http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v10n26.html http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v10n26.html home education, research, demogrphics, growth, population, reasons for homeschooling “Abstract Home schooling is a subject of great fascination, but little solid knowledge. Despite its importance, it has received less research attention than some other recent changes in the educational system, such as the growth of charter schools. It could be argued that home schooling may have a much larger impact on educational system, both in the short and long run. This report uses the 1994 October CPS, and the National Household Education Survey of 1996 and 1999 to examine popular characterizations of the home school population. The article assembles evidence from several sources to confirm that home schooling is growing. It finds home-schooled children more likely to be middle income, white, from larger families, and from two-parent families with one parent not working. While some authors have described a division between religiously-motivated and academically-motivated home schoolers, this research finds more support for a divide based on attitude towards regular schools” [abstract]. “Compared with other recent changes in the educational system, such as the growth of charter schools, home schooling has received relatively little attention (Archer 2000). (Note 1) It could be argued, however, that home schooling could have a much larger impact on educational system, both in the short and long run.” “Conclusion. The data examined here show that it has established itself as an alternative to regular school for a small set of families, and is poised to continue its growth. In 1999 around 790,000 children between the ages of 6 and 17 around of 1.7 percent of the population that age were being schooled at home, and in the late 1990s the number was apparently growing. Home schoolers and their families were different from regular school attenders and their families, but the differences weren't that large. Some of the distinctive characteristics of home schoolers seemed to be decreasing. Home schoolers were likely to be non-Hispanic White, but there was some evidence of fading racial differences over time. Some distinctive characteristics of home schoolers seemed not to be changing very rapidly, but the characteristics needn't be thought of as limitations to future growth. Households with home-schooled children had moderate to high education and income and were located in the rural or suburban West. Home-schoolers were likely to live with two adults, with one not in the labor force or working part time. We have just begun to see the emergence of home schooling as an important national phenomenon. Unless the needs of parents are met in different ways, it is likely that home schooling will have a large impact on the school as an institution in coming decades.”
Bauman, Kurt J. 2005, February 16 One million homeschooled students. Teachers College Record, ID Number: 11756. Retrieved 6/6/08 from http://www.tcrecord.org/content.asp?contentid=11756. http://www.tcrecord.org/content.asp?contentid=11756 home education, homeschooling, policy, demographics, reasons, philosophy, reform, public schooling “Why hasn’t the announcement of more than a million home-schooled children in the United States created more interest and excitement? I suspect the reason is that none of us – not educators, not researchers, not the general public – know what to make of it. Our lack of knowledge and our lack of concern may be blinding us to one of the most important forces shaping education today, and it has come time to make sense of it. Homeschooling exists at the flashpoint of current educational policy. As it continues to grow, it will press against other trends and reshape them. How government and the educational community react to the homeschooling phenomenon will decide the future of American education. There is no other policy variable that comes close to its potential importance.”
Bauman, Michael 1999 The falsity, futility, and folly of separating morality from law. Christian Research Journal, 21(3), 20-23, 36-41. morality, law, ethics, education, philosophy Argues that, “To be consistent, those who object to morals-based laws would have to raise the same objection to all laws whatsoever, including the laws they themselves support” [p. 22]. Moral education of children is the function of both parents and the state [p. 36].
Baumrind, Diana 1996 A blanket injunction against disciplinary use of spanking is not warranted by the data. Pediatrics, 98(4), 828-831. corporal punishment, chastisement, discipline, spank, spanking, research, child training, behavior, misbehavior
Baumrind, Diana 2001 Does causally relevant research support a blanket injunction against disciplinary spanking by parents? A paper presented as an invited address at the 109th Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association, August 24, 2001. Retrieved 1/24/03 online http://ihd.berkeley.edu/baumrindpaper.pdf. http://ihd.berkeley.edu/baumrindpaper.pdf corporal punishment, chastisement, discipline, spank, spanking, research, child training, behavior, misbehavior “To Summarize These Results Prior to removing the few parents whose use of physical punishment was unusually severe for this population and controlling the methodological artifacts that could account for the associations, frequency of physical punishment was associated with detrimental child outcomes, as anti-spanking advocates such as Straus claim. However, once the Red zone families [i.e., “... frequent physical punishment with at least some intensity ...”] were removed, there were few significant associations left to explain between child outcomes and dimensional or categorical measures of normative physical punishment. Furthermore, the correlations with detrimental child outcomes of physical punishment did not exceed those of verbal punishment. When alternative explanations, including the adolescents’ self-reported favorable perception of their parents, are considered, there are no effects of normative physical punishment on child or adolescent outcomes. The apparent effects of NPP are explained by baseline child [p. 9 ends] misbehavior and third variables that contribute to a pattern of rejection and overcontrol in which reliance on physical punishment is embedded. The 3 children (all girls) of parents who totally abstained from spanking at all time points, were not more competent by adolescence than those whose parents spanked occasionally. All were prosocial, but two were very low on self-assertiveness and the one who was self-assertive and achievement-oriented manifested severe internalizing and externalizing symptoms.) Unexpectedly, even the presence of above-average frequency of normative physical punishment represented by the Orange zone did not attenuate at all the positive outcomes associated with Authoritative or Democratic parenting. Thus we found no evidence for unique detrimental effects of normative physical punishment. To my knowledge this is the only study using high quality data in a prospective longitudinal design to assess the effects of normative physical punishment, after controlling for the following methodological artifacts: shared source variance, the intervention selection bias introduced by baseline child misbehavior, and plausible third parenting variables that were associated with both frequency of use of normative physical punishment and detrimental child outcomes. This is one of the few studies to contrast the effects of normative physical punishment with another aversive disciplinary intervention, and to contrast the effects of “no spanking” with those of “low frequency” spanking” [p. 10]. “Larzelere (2001) points out that in his study the conditional use of spanking rather than reliance on spanking characterizes effective parents. Similarly, in our study Authoritative parents who used more than average frequency of spanking with their preschoolers, did not rely on this tactic and phased it out in favor of more negotiated strategies of parental control, were outstandingly successful” [p. 11]. Her two concluding sentences follow: “Methodologically strong studies have not established that normative physical punishment is a causal risk factor for the detrimental child outcomes with which it may be associated. Although a value judgment that spanking is wrong is properly defended by its adherents on ethical grounds, a blanket injunction against disciplinary spanking is not warranted by causally relevant scientific evidence” [p. 14].
Beaucar, Kelley O. 2001, July 18 Homosexual parenting studies are flawed, report says. Published 7/18/01 and retrieved 7/19/01 online http://www.worldnetdaily.com/frame/direct.asp?SITE=foxnews.com/story/0,2933,29901,00.html. http://www.worldnetdaily.com/frame/direct.asp?SITE=foxnews.com/story/0,2933,29901,00.html research methodology, politics of research, stakeholders, publishing Addresses the political and social nature and limitations of research findings on socially-sensitive or controversial topics being objectively presented to the public and within the academy.
Beaven, Claudia C. 1990 Living and learning: A phenomenological study of home education. Ph.D. doctoral dissertation, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor. (In Dissertation Abstracts International, 51, 2252A, 1991) home education .
Beck, Christian W. 2005 Home education – motives, numbers and social integration; a mirror image of educational politics? home education, research, demographics, population, reasons, politics, foreign, Norway Received from author 7/1/05; manuscript submitted circa June 2005 for publication in Norwegian Journal of Educational Research. “In this article, grounded in empirical studies, the aim is to clarify the numbers of home educated children in Norway, motives for home education and problems of social integration related to home education. Such aspects give political arguments in favour of home education and against home education. Home education can be seen as a mirror image for educational politics.”
Beck, Christian W. 2015 Home education and social integration. Chapter in Rothermel (Ed.), International Perspectives on Home Education. Hampshire, United Kingdom UK: Palgrave Macmillan. homeschooling, home education, research, socialization, social integration, minorities, marginalization, barriers Very theoretical, not statist, appears to be trying to understand homeschooling, insightful, seems to know and understand homeschooling very well. “Conclusion Home education, especially among the religiously motivated, has the potential to challenge social unity in Norway. Nevertheless, known home educated students appear to be well socialized. Those presenting the greatest challenge regarding social integration are perhaps the unknown home educators in Norway. In Norway, in part because of the political and demographic situation, home educators who are not known by authorities often have little or no communication with society, and there is no supervision of the quality of their practiced home education. Thus, here, there is a real possibility of socially segregating children and putting them at risk. [new parag.] Postmodern national societies are overloaded with subjective identity management tasks that are best handled at a local level and not on the national level (Bauman, 1997). When a centralized public school emphasizes universal national, secularized and objective values, home educating environments may be construed as subjective protests to such school values and, some postmodern home educating communities of shared religious values may actually present as a threat to social integration. Despite these views, home education generally can also be described as constructive and essential for maintaining social integration and social and knowledge diversity in postmodern societies. [new parag.] Most home educators want an atmosphere of open-mindedness and open communication with society (Beck, 2006). Such an atmosphere depends on Giddens’s (1988) concept: reciprocity of practices on individual, local and national levels. With such conditions, home education may be an integrated part in a more pluralistic public education” (p. 96).
Beck, Glenn 2010, March 5 From the March 5 edition of Fox News' Glenn Beck. Retrieved 3/8/2010 from http://mediamatters.org/mmtv/201003050058. http://mediamatters.org/mmtv/201003050058 education, public schools, philosophy Editor of this bibliography watched the video and transcribed what is quoted here, when Beck tells his TV audience: “And, here we are. We’re going through what’s been happeing in our public schools ….. We don’t even notice these things. ….. Sell a car if you have to. Get your kids out of this indoctrination [of public schools] or our republic will be lost.”)
Beck, Joan 1975 How to raise a brighter child. Simon and Schuster.
Beck, W. David, (Ed.) 1991 Opening the American mind: The integration of biblical truth in the curriculum of the university. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Book House. philosophy, Christian Ten professors explicate their disciplines, showing how each subject area relates not only to Scripture but to other branches of study; attempts to reopen the American mind to absolute truth, absolute value.
Becker, Sarah 2010 Badder Than “Just a Bunch of SPEDs”: Alternative Schooling and Student Resistance to Special Education Rhetoric. Journal of Contemporary Ethnography, 39(1): 60-86. http://jce.sagepub.com/content/39/1/60.short alternative schooling, special education, gender, race, troublemaking, identity, homeschooling Mentions homeschooling only once, as follows: “When a teen is “in danger,” as Lauren put it, a parent, teacher, or principal arranges a “team meeting” with her, the high school principal, the student, and his or her parents. They evaluate if CAN is the right place for him or her. Without CAN, options for these students would be residential treatment centers, home schooling, programs outside the community, dropping out, or getting a GED. CAN, like other alternative schools, is a last chance for students who might otherwise drop out or be kicked out” (p. 65). “Abstract: This study of a Northeastern alternative high school examines the salience of two discourses—one focused on students who have problems, the other on students who are problems—in the alternative schooling process. At Cromwell Alternative North (CAN), teachers and staff promoted a view of students as youth with “special needs.” In the students’ social world, having “special needs” was not awarded status like being a troublemaker was. Students at CAN therefore had to manage both discourses in their daily interaction with teachers and peers. Some students accepted special needs rhetoric, some rejected it. Most attempted to manage it creatively, being a problem in the eyes of peers and having problems in the eyes of teachers. Code switching between the two discourses, however, was not something all students could do. A handful of students—“shining stars”—managed both “SPED,” slang for special education students, and “bad” discourses to achieve the greatest social and academic successes at CAN” (retrieved 7/11/13 from http://jce.sagepub.com/content/39/1/60.short).
Beckham, Joseph C. 1985 Legal Challenges to Compulsory Attendance Laws. Topeka, Kansas: National Organization on Legal Problems of Education. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED268684).) Court Litigation, Government School Relationship, Private Schools, School Attendance Legislation, School Law
Beecher, Rhoda McShane 1982 Parent Education. In Harold E. Mitzel (ed.), Encyclopedia of Educational Research. New York: The Free Press, 1379-1382.
Beecher, Rhoda McShane 1984 Parent involvement: A review of research and principles of successful practice. Washington D.C.: National Institute of Education.
Beechick, Ruth 1988 You can teach your child successfully: Grades 4 to 8. Pollock Pines, CA: Arrow Press. About teaching your own children. Arrow Press, PO Box 899, Pollock Pines CA, 95726
Beechick, Ruth 1985 A home start in reading. Pollock Pines, CA: Arrow Press. About teaching your own grades K to 3 children how to read. Arrow Press, PO Box 899, Pollock Pines CA, 95726
Beechick, Ruth 1986 An easy start in arithmetic. Pollock Pines, CA: Arrow Press. About teaching your own grades K to 3 children how to do arithmetic. Arrow Press, PO Box 899, Pollock Pines CA, 95726
Beechick, Ruth 1986 A strong start in language. Pollock Pines, CA: Arrow Press. About teaching language to your own grades K to 3 children. “This manual will show you how to extend the natural method from spoken language to written language” [p. 1]. Arrow Press, PO Box 899, Pollock Pines CA, 95726
Beláňová, Andrea; Kostelecká, Yvona; Machovcová, Kateřina; & McCabe, Marta 2020 “Twofold otherness”: On religion, spirituality, and home schooling in the Czech Republic. Journal of Beliefs and Values, https://doi.org/10.1080/13617672.2020.1762384. https://doi.org/10.1080/13617672.2020.1762384 Home schooling; homeschooling, religion; spirituality; Czech Republic “Abstract: In the Czech Republic, home schooling is an increasing but still rare education practice. The country is at the same time not favourable to public demonstrations of religion. In such a specific context, we investigated the intersection of religion, spirituality, and home schooling. Drawing on a broad ethnographic research design, we identify three levels of strategies employed by religious or spiritual home-schooling parents to negotiate their ‘twofold otherness’. On the individual level, these parents significantly sought religious or spiritual support in their decision to home-school. On the societal level, the local community played a crucial role in assisting parents with home schooling. Simultaneously, fearing the reactions of home-schooling opponents, the families decided to keep their religion or spirituality to themselves. We conclude that the ‘twofold otherness’ is a vulnerable position for home-schoolers in the Czech Republic which forces the families to remain private about both their education style and spiritual or religious ideology.”
Beláňová, Andrea; Machovcová, Kateřina; Kostelecká, Yvona; & McCabe, Marta 2018 Justifying homeschooling in Czech Republic: How “good parents” and their children use time. Childhood, 24(4), 530-543. Good mother, homeschooling, parenting, social norms, using time, research “Abstract: In our study of Czech homeschooling families, we discovered that the unifying theme of their justifying narratives was how the families rearranged the norm of “good parenting,” defined as the amount of time families spent together. The parents argued the importance of sacrificing their own time and educating their children themselves. They distinguished themselves from parents who are not willing to attend the children’s needs as much. Finally, we show that homeschooled children also actively adopt the family time management” (p. 530).
Belfield, Clive R. 2004, January Home-Schooling in the US. Occasional Paper No. 88 from the National Center for the Study of Privatization in Education Teachers College, Columbia University. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228426754_Occasional_Paper_No_88_National_Center_for_the_Study_of_Privatization_in_Education_Teachers_College_Columbia_University http://www.ncspe.org/readrel.php?set=pub&cat=90 home education, opinion, policy, choice, privatization, philosophy New York, NY: National Center for the Study of Privatization in Education Teachers College, Columbia University, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228426754_Occasional_Paper_No_88_National_Center_for_the_Study_of_Privatization_in_Education_Teachers_College_Columbia_University and retrieved 1/23/04 online http://www.ncspe.org/readrel.php?set=pub&cat=90 Provides an interesting perspective on choice and privatization in education, specifically examining homeschooling. Offers a literature review that is lacking in scope and fails to include some important works related to his topics. Estimates of number of homeschool students in various states is probably in significant error. Homeschool students’ raw scores are higher in SAT Total, SAT Math, and SAT Verbal than public school and private-religious school students, and homeschool students’ score higher on SAT Verbal than private-independent school, while private-independent school students score (raw) on Total and Math higher than the homeschooled. Homeschoolers score higher on their SAT Total score and SAT Verbal score than would be predicted after controlling for many demographic and other variables, and score essentially at their predicted SAT Math score. Belfield reports, and this has been misrepresented by various reviewers of research on homeschooling, “(Also, home-schoolers actually perform worse than would be predicted on SAT-Math)” (p. 22). --- however, Belfield does not report whether this is a statistically significant difference and he omits reporting that the difference is only 0.028 SD less than the predicted score (Table 3), an insignificant practical amount.
Belfield, Clive R. 2004, June 29 Modeling school choice: A comparison of public, private-independent, private-religious and home-schooled students. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 12(30). Retrieved 12/6/04 online http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v12n30/. http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v12n30/ home education, choice, public school, private school, homeschool, parent’s employment, policy U.S. students now have four choices of schooling: public schooling, private–religious schooling, private–independent schooling, and home-schooling. Of these, home-schooling is the most novel: since legalization across the states in the last few decades, it has grown in importance and legitimacy as an alternative choice. Thus, it is now possible to investigate the motivation for home-schooling, relative to the other schooling options. Here, we use two recent large-scale datasets to assess the school enrollment decision: the first is the National Household Expenditure Survey (1999), and the second is micro-data on SAT [formerly called the Scholastic Aptitude Test] test-takers in 2001. We find that, generally, families with home-schoolers have similar characteristics to those with children at other types of school, but mother’s characteristics – specifically, her employment status – have a strong influence on the decision to home-school. Plausibly, religious belief has an important influence on the schooling decision, not only for Catholic students, but also those of other faiths [abstract].”
Belfield, Clive R. 2005 Home-schoolers: How well do they perform on the SAT for college admission? In Bruce S. Cooper (Ed.), Home schooling in full view: A reader, Chapter 11, p. 167-177. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing. college, adults, homeschooled adults, adult success Finds the homeschooled to have relatively high SAT scores compared to private-religious-school and public-school students but lower than private-independent-school students. After controlling for selected background variables, however, reports that “… the predicted SAT-total scores for home-schoolers and private-independent school students converge toward the mean: the home-school premium over private-religious school students falls almost to zero” [p. 174]. Does not explain well or make convincing argument for controlling for “state level SAT test-taking participation rate” [p. 174]. “So far at least, the results do not indicate home-schoolers are at a disadvantage” [p. 174]. This is reporting the same study as Belfield, Clive R. (2004, January). Home-Schooling in the US.; see notes on that study.
Bell, Debra A. 2013 Types of home schools and need-support for achievement Motivation. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Temple University. “Abstract: Along many dimensions, homeschooling is increasing, diversifying, and spreading globally. Yet little is known about the motivational climates and teaching strategies parents have adopted to promote academic achievement and motivation within their homes. Working within a self-determination theory (SDT) framework, this study used cluster analysis to examine the naturally-occurring types of learning environments created by 457 homeschool parents. Measures of support for autonomy, mastery goal orientation, and conditional regard were adapted for a homeschool context and used as constituting variables. Follow-up measures of need satisfaction, efficacy, student academic engagement, teaching practices and demographics were used to identify significant differences among groups. A five cluster solution best fit the data: a high need support group, low need support group and three groups of mixed need support. In general, the high need and mixed need support groups were associated with higher student engagement, need satisfaction, efficacy for homeschooling and frequent use of teaching strategies that promote autonomous motivation and support for student competence. The low need support group was significantly associated with lower need satisfaction and teaching strategies associated with control. Higher levels of academic engagement were reported for those students homeschooled longer and at higher grade levels. Male teaching parents (n = 29) reported significantly less need satisfaction and were significantly associated with the low need support group. Taken together, the findings extend self-determination theory to an important, emerging learning context. Results were consistent with findings in SDT research across other domains; thus, lending support to the universality of SDT’s main tenets.” Kewords: homeschooling, support, academic achievement, achievement, need satisfaction, efficacy, student academic engagement, teaching practices and demographics
Bell, Debra A.; Kaplan, Avi; & Thurman, S. Kenneth 2016 Types of homeschool environments and need support for children’s achievement motivation. Journal of School Choice, 10(3), 330–354. https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2016.1202072 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2016.1202072 achievement motivation, homeschooling, homeschool teaching practices, self-determination theory Abstract: Working within a self-determination theory (SDT) framework, this study used cluster analysis to examine the naturally occurring types of homeschool-learning environments parents (N = 457) have created. Measures of support for student autonomy, mastery goal structure, and use of conditional regard were adapted for a homeschool context and used as constituting variables. Follow-up measures of parental need satisfaction, efficacy, student academic engagement, teaching practices, and demographics were used to identify significant differences among homeschooling motivational profiles. A five-cluster solution best fit the data: a high need support profile, low need support profile and three profiles of mixed need support. In general, the high need and mixed need support profiles were associated with higher student engagement, need satisfaction, efficacy for homeschooling, and frequent use of teaching strategies that promote autonomous motivation and support for student competence. The low need support profile was significantly associated with lower need satisfaction and teaching strategies associated with control. Higher levels of academic engagement were reported for those students homeschooled longer and at higher grade levels. Male teaching parents (N = 29) reported significantly less need satisfaction and were significantly more represented in the low need support profile. These findings point to the utility of self-determination theory for characterizing the motivational environments of homeschools.”
Bell, Debra; & Kaplan, Avi 2020 Homeschooling Under Quarantine: A Practice Brief for Home Educators. A publication of the APA, Division 15. Retrieved September 21, 2020 from https://apadiv15.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/D15-Practice-Brief-Homeschooling-Under-Quarantine.pdf https://apadiv15.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/D15-Practice-Brief-Homeschooling-Under-Quarantine.pdf homeschooling, psychology, psychological needs, coronavirus, quarantine, Covid-19 “Why this works: Supporting people’s psychological needs for competence, autonomy, and relatedness facilitates motivation, growth, relationships, and wellbeing (Ryan & Deci, 2000). How to do it: Create an adjustable weekly structure that considers all household members’ needs, involves diverse activities and choice, incorporates both individual and social activities, and is negotiated through collaborative conflict management procedures. Whether in normative times, or at a time of pandemic, designing home life that includes homeschooling is challenging. It means and looks different for every household, and the design should change as people grow and circumstances shift. But, research-based principles can guide the planning and designing of a positive home life with homeschooling: Collaborate with the household members to support each member’s psychological needs for competence, autonomy, and relatedness (Ryan & Deci, 2000)” (p. 1).
Belz, Joel 1997 Rebels of the best kind: As educational structures change, keep your eyes on the homeschoolers. World, 12(23), 5. As Joel Belz (1997) notes, home education, policy, politics, opinion Weekly national news magazine commentator says: “What special interest group in American society right now may be most effective at lobbying the U.S. Congress? If you guessed that it’s a band of educators, you’d be right. But if you picked the National Educational Association--the very liberal union of public school teachers that is so active in public affairs--you might well be wrong these days. For according to Rep. William Goodling (R-PA.), a 22-year veteran of Congress and Chairman now of the influential Education and Labor Committee, the homeschoolers of our country, and especially those associated with the Home School Legal Defense Association, have developed more expertise than any other group in getting the attention of our nation’s lawmakers . . . . I would suggest that Rep. Goodling’s high praise of homeschoolers for their ability to win points in Congress may represent no more than the tip of an iceberg--that it’s only a precursor of other ways in which homeschoolers may more and more shape society far out of proportion to their numbers and acceptability to the rest of society” [p. 5].
Belz, Joel 2000, May 27 Too legit to quit. World, 15(1), 18. home education, opinion, philosophy, history, sociology, religion Argues that homeschooling is here to stay, even in its problems there’s promises.
Bendall, Lisa 2008, February How to raise a great student. Reader’s Digest, 172(1,030), 84-90. home education, Canada, foreign, success, academic achievement, reading Examines what parents do to help children be great students. First family discussed practices in home education. “Most important, there are books hundreds and hundreds of them, in every room of the house. The Rennicks [a homeschool family in Canada] began reading to their children early, instilling a love of books by ex-ample, not pressure. Today, all the kids read at or above grade level, according to online assessments Rennick uses. Books are central to the family's life. "We share books," says Rennick," and then we talk about them. It's really a family experience." This book-centric approach is spot-on, say education experts. "Parents reading at home to kids is absolutely critical," says Ian Cameron, professor of education at the University ofVictoria. "It gives the kids a good feeling about books. And if they think that parents value reading, they will be more inclined to put some time and effort into it" [p. 86].
Bendell, Jean 1987 School's Out. England: Ashgrove Press, 19 Circus Place, Bath BSA1 2PW. Account of one mother's experiences of educating two daughters at home.
Bennet, Harold Zina 1972 No more public school. New York, NY: Random House, 137 p.
Bennett, Daniel; Edwards, Elyssa; & Ngai, Courtney 2019 Homeschool background, time use and academic performance at a private religious college, Educational Studies, 45(3), 305-325, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03055698.2018.1446332 peer-reviewed journal https://www.tandfonline.com/action/authorSubmission?show=instructions&journalCode=ceds20 https://www.tandfonline.com/action/authorSubmission?show=instructions&journalCode=ceds20 https://doi.org/10.1080/03055698.2018.1446332 Academic performance; homeschool background; non-homeschool, home education, parental education; personality; student time use; peer-reviewed journal “Abstract: We study the effects of homeschool background and time use on academic performance among students at Patrick Henry College, a private religious institution with a 63-credit core classical liberal arts curriculum. Using ordinary least squares regression analysis, we examine four research questions: (1) Does time use influence academic performance? (2) Do homeschooled students perform differently than traditionally schooled students? (3) Does parental education moderate the impact of homeschooling on academic performance? (4) Does homeschooling moderate the impact of ACT scores on academic performance?” (p. 305). “Some uses of time hinder academic performance. ….. Homeschooling [versus not homeschooled] does not influence academic performance” (p. 317). “… there is no difference in academic performance between homeschooled students with college-educated parents and homeschooled students whose parents do not have a college education” (p. 318).
Bennett, H. B. 1966 New concepts in home study. The Home Study Review, 7, 14-24.
Bennett, Hal 1972 No more public school: A manual for innovators. New York, NY: Random House, Inc. and Berkely, CA: The Bookworks). (Explains how to take one’s child out of public school and educate him at home yourself and how to start a private school. Promotes child-centered education in which “The children move freely from one activity to another. They arefree to choose what they want to do -- instead of having the teacher make choices for them. The children learn through exploration and discovery
Bennett, William J. 1993 The book of virtues: A Treasury of great moral stories. New York, NY: Simon and Schuster.
Bennett, William J., Finn, Chester E., Jr., & Cribb, John T. E., Jr. 1999 The educated child: A parent’s guide from preschool through eighth grade. The Free Press. Discusses home schooling as a good educational alternative. Says that although critics of home schooling claim the home educated will not develop good social skills, research suggests the opposite. “We have the greatest respect for home schoolers. Mothers and fathers who choose this route make a huge commitment. They should not have to do so because there are no good schools available. In America in the twenty-first century, no family should feel it has to educate at home to educate well” [p. 604].
Benoit, Gary (Ed.) 1997, July 21 Educating for global control [special issue]. New American, 13(15). educational reform, history of education, politics of education, home education Articles on topics such as who should have authority over children’s education [e.g., parents or the state], how public education attempts to control people, article “The whole-language hoax,” propaganda in the classroom [e.g., on “gay rights”], Goals 2000, home schooling, article “The voucher trap: What government subsidizes it controls” [by William F. Jasper, p. 52-53], and article “Separating school and state.”
Benson, Reed Amussen 1981 The development of a home school. Dissertation Abstracts International, 42(2), 671A. Brigham Young University, Provo, UT, 196 p. Summary of home school movement, advantages to students, how to set one up; author taught [described as an experiment] his own eight children at home, reasons, legal aspects.
Bereiter, C. 1972 Schools without education. Harvard Educational Review, 42(3), 390-413.
Berg, Douglas H., Donlevy, James K., & Walker, Keith D. 2002 Public values and private rights in Canadian education: The Trinity Western University case. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans, Louisiana, April 1-5, 2002. “In May 2001, the Supreme Court of Canada determined that public values do not take precedence over private rights, as expressed through religious restrictions in a church sponsored private educational institution. In Trinity Western University v. College of Teachers (British Columbia 2001), a divided Supreme Court of Canada considered how Canadian society should adjudicate between conflicting rights when they are based upon very different value orientations” [p. 2].
Berger, Brigitte, & Berger, Peter L. 1984 The war over the family: Capturing the middle ground. Garden City, NY: Anchor Books. History of family policy and critical analysis of current trends.
Berger, Eugenia Hepworth 1981 Parents as partners in education: The school and the home working together. St. Louis, MO: The C. V. Mosby Co., 424 p. Extensive textbook. Home-school relationships.
Berger, Eugenia Hepworth 1983 Beyond the classroom: Parents as partners in education. St. Louis: The C. V. Mosby Co.
Bergin, Mark 2005, September 3 Here come the strings: Alaska's groundbreaking support for homeschools may be buried in state audits and new rulings. World, 20(34). Retrieved 9/1/05 online http://www.worldmag.com/displayarticle.cfm?id=10985. http://www.worldmag.com/displayarticle.cfm?id=10985 home education, state control, regulation, taxes, taxation, public-school-at-home programs, PSAH, philosophy “Since 1997, parents in Alaska have enjoyed state support for homeschool expenses with almost no academic restraint—provided any religious-themed teaching materials were purchased with private money. No more. "Here come the strings," said Peter Torkelson, a former state legislator who, along with his wife Lisa, is one parent who has resisted taking government money to homeschool his daughters. "They managed to avoid for a while what I thought would happen a long time ago." Armed with a new application of an old statute, Alaska's Department of Education and Early Development (EED) declared that teaching a majority of core subjects with religious-based materials—even those privately purchased—disqualifies parents from receiving government funds. It employed a 1966 law, which states, "Partisan, sectarian, or denominational doctrines may not be advocated in a public school during the hours the school is in session."”
Bergland, David 1984 The Nebraska seven. The Libertarian Forum, 18(1-2), 1-2. non-certified non-licensed private school, politics, philosophy, parental rights, history “Prison is not the happiest place to spend the holidays, but in Plattsmouth, Nebraska, seven fathers spent both Thanksgiving and Christmas in the Cass County Jail-while their wives lived as fugitives in a neighboring state-all for the “crime” of sending their children to a church school which had not been certified by the Nebraska Department of Education. Worse-the men had not been tried and found guilty of any charges. They were imprisoned when they invoked the Fifth Amendment at a court hearing, believing their testimony would later be used against them. Until they break down and agree to waive this Constitutionally protected right they must remain in jail, where they have already spent nearly three months. [new paragraph] This travesty of Justice is no surprise to those who have been following the underlying conflict. State officials and their allies in the education establishment have been stepping up their opposition to parents seeking alternatives to a government operated school system. Across the country, parents are increasingly disenchanted with government schools. They are aware of the billions of tax dollars poured into these institutions, while each year graduates emerge less literate and informed than their predecessors. Children are not receiving adequate instruction in such basic skills as reading and arithmetic. They are being engulfed in what the National Commission on Excellence in Education has called “the rising tide of mediocrity.” Parents are alarmed, and to [p. 1 ends] save their children from being swept away by this tide, many are removing children from government-operated schools, to teach them at home or in private schools where parents have direct control over subject material” [p. 1-2].
Berkebile, Candy 1994, September Home: The heart of education. Family Voice, 16(9), 14-15. Washington, DC: Concerned Women for America. home education, proponent Promotes home education from a Christian perspective.
Berle, A. A. 1913 The school in the home. New York, NY: Moffat, Yard and Co., 210 p. May discuss “dame” schools.
Berle, A. A. 1915 Teaching in the home. May discuss “dame” schools.
Bermudez, Andrea 1986 Examining the effects of home training on problem-solving styles. ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. 270 982. Home environment. Found a significant difference in problem-solving behaviors encouraged in Hispanics and Anglo homes, with Anglos tending to encourage analytic and self-dependent skills more often than Hispanic homes.
Berner, Ashley 2011 Making space for civilization: Educational pluralism. Comment Magazine, Fall, 2011, 74-78. education, philosophy, educational freedom, private education, public education, pluralism, choice, statism Addresses philosophy of education/schooling and argues for a particular form of educational pluralism that is ultimately controlled by the State. “Educational philosophy asks four key questions: What is the aim of education? What is the nature of the child? What is the role of the teacher? Who has ultimate authority? Each possible answer bears immediate consequences for the classroom” [p. 75]. Briefly and carefully answers the first three questions. Then writes: “Which takes us to the last question of educational philosophy, and it is essentially political philosophy: Who decides? When honest brokers disagree, who adjudicates? A good society in the twenty-first century must, it seems to me, find a way to embrace educational pluralism. That is, the State should establish certain standards which even strong disagreement may not overrule. These could include compulsory education up to age sixteen or seventeen; a strong curriculum that insures literacy and numeracy in the early years and that builds up the intellectual, emotional, physical, and even spiritual sensibilities of every child until graduation; a plan to sponsor individual interests, particularly at the upper grade levels; an agreement to promote civic and moral duty; the provision of adequate facilities and staff training across the system. Each of these components, of course, deserves its own essay!4 [p. 76].. But her approach here implies her, or society’s, answers to the other three questions are not political” and this final, fourth, question must be one answered by majority view or democratic vote. The answers to all four questions, however, are equally “philosophical” but author implies they are not. Quickly becomes clear that author is promoting statism when she writes, “… the State should establish certain standards which even strong disagreement may not overrule.” Why? She needs to lay her presuppositional worldview cards on the table. Later she writes, “.. —the least amicable is a state-control model,” [p. 77] but she has already promoted, to some degree, a “state-control model.” She claims the Netherlands “… is the freest nation with respect to education. Its government funds, on equal footing, over thirty different types of religious, ideological, and pedagogical schools while requiring certain academic standards and bureaucratic oversight” [p. 77] but does not operationally define “free.” “At the “least successful” end of the spectrum, we find the United States, whose educational system assumes that only a state-enforced uniform education can make one people out of many (e pluribus unum)” [p. 77] but she does not operationally define “least successful.” If “success” is defined as freedom to choose education by parents and children, then the author is ignoring the fact that in many states of the U.S. there is no State control over private education and therefore a large amount of freedom. She writes, “Educational pluralism is disconcerting, because by it we are agreeing that other parents may school their children in a model that we find off-putting, irrelevant, or even potentially dangerous. Educational pluralism also assumes that democratic sensibilities are actually enhanced, not diminished, by encouraging a variety of school types.10 Educational pluralism requires flexibility, social negotiation, and grace within a broad vision of the common good” [p. 78].
Bhatt, Rachana 2014 Home is where the school is: The impact of homeschool legislation on school choice. Journal of School Choice, 8(2), 192-212. http://www.tandfonline.com/ school choice, homeschooling, research, reasons, motives, barriers “Abstract: From 1982–1997, 35 states adopted legislation, referred to as homeschool rights, that explicitly granted families the right to educate their children at home. Using data from the National Household Education Survey, this article examines the impact that this legislation has had on the decision to homeschool a child versus the alternatives of attending a public or private school. We estimate a multinomial logit model of school choice where we condition on a variety of individual, county, and state level covariates that may influence this decision. We find the probability a young child is homeschooled increases meaningfully, by 1.4 percentage points, following the passage of homeschool rights [which is a reduction in barriers] in their state.” Retrieved February 8, 2016 from http://www.tandfonline.com/ ) New notes
Bhopal, Kalwant and Myers, Martin 2015 Marginal groups in marginal times: Gypsy and Traveller parents and home education in England, UK. British Educational Research Journal, 1-29. (doi:https://doi.org/10.1002/berj.3198). https://doi.org/10.1002/berj.3198 homeschooling, home education, sociology, socialization, marginalized, minorities Considers home education or homeschooling and Gypsy and Traveller groups as populations of marginalized people.
Bhopal, Kalwant and Myers, Martin 2018 Home schooling and home education: Race, class and inequality. United Kingdom: Routledge, Taylor and Francis Group. homeschooling, home education, race, class, inequality, inequity, research “…provides an original account of home education and examines ways in which the discourses of home education are understood and contextualised in different countries, such as the UK and USA. By exploring home education in the global and local context of traditional schooling, the book bridges a much-needed gap in educational and social scientific research. The authors explore home education from two related perspectives: firstly how and why home education is accessed by different social groups; and secondly, how these groups are perceived as home educators. The book draws upon empirical case study research with those who use home education to address issues of inequality, difference and inclusion, before offering suggestions for viable policy shifts in this area, as well as broadening understandings of risk and marginality. It engages and initiates debates about alternatives to the standard schooling model within a critical sociological context” – publisher, online.) The scholarly emphasis and original nature of Home Schooling and Home Education makes this essential reading for academics and postgraduate researchers in the fields of education and sociology, as well as for educational policymakers.
Bible 1984 New International Version, East Brunswick, NJ: International Bible Society. Deuteronomy 6: 7-9.
Bielick, Stacey 2008, December 1.5 Million Homeschooled Students in the United States in 2007. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2009030 home education, research, population size, reasons, demographics National Center for Education Statistics). Retrieved December 23, 2008 from http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2009030. (Use data from the National Household Education Surveys Program (NHES) interviews “… conducted with the parents of 10,681 [K-12] students, including 290 homeschooled students” in the U.S. in 2007. Estimates there were 1.508 million K-12 homeschool students in spring of 2007, with a 95 percent confidence interval of 1.277 to 1.739 million students. “The increase [p. 1 ends] in the homeschooling rate (from 1.7 percent in 1999 to 2.2 percent in 2003 to 2.9 percent in 2007) represents a 74 percent relative increase over the 8-year period and a 36 percent relative increase since 2003” [p. 2]. This is a population-size increase of about 8.3% per annum; it is a percent-of-school-age-children increase of about 7.3% per annum. “The three reasons selected by parents of more than two-thirds of students were concern about the school environment, to provide religious or moral instruction, and dissatisfaction with the academic instruction available at other schools (figure 2). From 2003 to 2007, the percentage of students whose parents reported homeschooling to provide religious or moral instruction increased from 72 percent to 83 percent. ….. The reason reported by the highest percentage of homeschoolers’ parents as being most important was [p. 2 ends] to provide religious or moral instruction (36 percent). For an additional 21 percent, the most important reason was concern about the school environment, and for 17 percent it was dissatisfaction with the academic instruction available at other schools” [p. 3]. “Other reasons” was selected by 20% in 2003 and 32% in 2007. “Other reasons parents gave for homeschooling include family time, finances, travel, and distance” [p. 2]. ““Most important reason for homeschooling” was asked differently in 2003 and 2007 and, therefore, cannot be compared across time” [p. 3]. Appears that the USDE’s 2008 study followed methods similar to those used by the USDE in 2003. However, it is not clear from the report how nonrespondents to the telephone survey and noncoverage might affect the homeschool population estimate and other conclusions based on demographic data. For example, based on research on homeschool parents and experience with them, this author hypothesizes that homeschool parents would be less likely than parents in general to respond to a telephone survey by the government. Readers of the report should also keep in mind that the findings are based on extrapolations from the responses of the parents of 290 homeschool students (out of an estimated 1.5 million students).
Bielick, Stacey, & Chapman, Christopher 2003, May Trends in the Use of School Choice: 1993 to 1999. (Report number: NCES 2003–031) Washington, DC: United States Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. Available 8/31/03 online http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2003/2003031.pdf http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2003/2003031.pdf Includes homeschooling in some of the analyses, not all. “Executive summary. Executive Summary. The National Household Education Surveys Program (NHES) provides a comprehensive set of information that may be used to estimate the use of school choice in the United States. Within the United States, school choice is primarily comprised of programs that allow students to attend any public school within or outside of their local school district, a magnet or charter school, a private school, or homeschool. This report examines data from three administrations of the NHES (1993, 1996, and 1999) in which children's parents were asked if their children attended their assigned public schools, public schools that they had chosen, private schools that are church-related, or private schools that are not church-related, and about their satisfaction and involvement with those schools. The report provides information about trends in the use and users of public schools of choice and private schools, and outcomes of these choices—parent satisfaction and involvement, and students’ plans for postsecondary education. The report also provides a brief analysis of homeschooled students. This report cannot answer questions about the availability of public school choice or other school choice programs. As figure A below shows, the percentage of children enrolled in public, assigned schools for 1st through 12th grades decreased from 80 percent in 1993 to 76 percent in 1999. The decrease in public, assigned school enrollment was almost completely offset by an increase from 11 to 14 percent in public, chosen school enrollment. Enrollment in private, church-related schools remained relatively stable at 7–8 percent between 1993 and 1999 and enrollment in private, not church-related schools was about 2 percent in each year [p. iv ends]. Characteristics of students in public, assigned and chosen schools and private schools. The trend away from public, assigned school enrollment and toward public, chosen school enrollment between 1993 and 1999 was most evident among students from low-income households. ….. In each of these years, Black students had a higher rate of enrollment in public, chosen schools than did White or Hispanic students in the 1st through 12th grades. Generally, a greater percentage of 1st through 12th grade students living in urban areas attended public, chosen and private schools than did students living outside urban areas. In all-three survey years, a higher percentage of 1st through 12th grade students living in two-parent households were enrolled in private, church-related schools than were students living in one-parent households. Students whose parents possessed at least a bachelor’s degree had a higher rate of enrollment in private schools, both church-related and not church-related, than students whose parents obtained at most a high school diploma, GED or less. First through 12th grade students with disabilities attended private, church-related schools at a lower rate than did students without disabilities. There were no differences detected between students with and without disabilities for other types of schools. Characteristics of Homeschooled Children. Homeschoolers are not mirror images of students in either public or private schools, differing from both on a number of characteristics. Homeschoolers differed from students in public schools in that their parents tended to be better educated. Homeschoolers were more likely to be White and to live in two-parent households than were students in assigned or chosen schools. Homeschoolers differed from private school students in fewer ways than they differed from public school students. Homeschoolers were less likely than private school students to live in households with annual incomes over $75,000. They were also less likely to live in the Northeast and inside urban areas and more likely to live in rural areas [p. vi ends]. Differences in parent satisfaction and involvement with their children’s schools. Choice makes a difference in parent satisfaction. Parents whose children attended either public, chosen schools or private schools were more likely to say they were very satisfied with their children’s schools, teachers, academic standards, and order and discipline than were parents whose children attended public, assigned schools (tables 3 and 6). Parents whose children attended private schools were more involved in activities at their children’s schools than were parents whose children attended public, assigned and public, chosen schools (tables 4a, 4b, and 7)” [p. vii].
Bielick, Stacey, Chandler, Kathryn, and Broughman, Stephen 2001, July 31 [print version] Home schooling in the United States: 1999 (NCES 2001-033). Washington, DC: United States Department of Education. Retrieved 8/2/01 and 12/8/05 online http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2001033 [online version released 8/1/01]. http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2001033 home education, research, demographics, reasons, population size, public school, cooperation, public school cooperation, equal access “Major findings from the Parent-NHES:1999 indicate: In the spring of 1999, an estimated 850,000 students nationwide were being homeschooled [and the 95% confidence interval was 709,000 to 992,000 students]. This amounts to 1.7 percent of U.S. students, ages 5 to 17, with a grade equivalent of kindergarten through grade 12. Four out of five homeschoolers were homeschooled only (82 percent) and one out of five homeschoolers were enrolled in public or private schools part time (18 percent). A greater percentage of homeschoolers compared to nonhomeschoolers were white, non-Hispanic in 1999—75 percent compared to 65 percent. At the same time, a smaller percentage of homeschoolers were black, non-Hispanic students and a smaller percentage were Hispanic students.
Bielick, Stacey, Lina Guzman, Astrid Atienza, & Andrew Rivers 2009, December Using a seeded sample to measure response among homeschooling households. Survey Practice, December 2009. Retrieved January 15, 2010 from http://surveypractice.org/2009/12/09/homeschool/. http://surveypractice.org/2009/12/09/homeschool/ home education, homeschooling, research, survey, sampling, population “Estimates of the size of the homeschooling population derived from government-sponsored surveys have been questioned because of concerns that homeschooling families may be less willing to participate in government studies. To estimate whether the response propensity of homeschooling households differs from that of non-homeschooling households, a sample of likely homeschooling households was seeded in a federal education survey. Cases in the seeded sample were treated to the same field procedures as the survey’s sample to allow comparisons of the two samples’ response patterns. While the seeded sample is an excellent method, in theory, for examining response propensity, the study revealed significant practical problems in implementing the study.”
Billings, H. K. 1975 Are schools destroying our children? Washington D.C.: Southeastern University Press.
Birch, A. Jane 1994 A Latter-day Saint home education: Passing on a goodly heritage. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Brigham Young University, Provo, UT.
Birch, Candy Solheim 1990 The Social Skills Evaluation Instrument. Unpublished manuscript available from College of Education, attn: Dr. Hancock, Grand Canyon University, 3300 West Camelback Rd., Phoenix AZ 85061. social skills, socialization, home education, research, assessment The instrument evaluates peer-to-peer social skills, various character traits assessed by instrument are drawn from the Bible, developed with the home education community in mind.
Bishop, Celia 1991 Home schooling parent support groups in Kansas: A naturalistic inquiry into their concerns and functions. A doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Kansas State University, Manhattan, 194 pp..
Black Alliance for Educational Options 2015 The state of education in black America 2015. Retrieved 2/24/16 from http://scoter2.baeo.org/downloads.php?download_id=442&filename=StateOfEducationInBlackAmerica2015_Report.pdf http://scoter2.baeo.org/downloads.php?download_id=442&filename=StateOfEducationInBlackAmerica2015_Report.pdf school choice, black, African American, minorities, academic achievement “The purpose of BAEO’s State of Black Education Report 2015 is to inform the American public about the contributions high-quality education options and parental-choice polices make to low-income and working-class Black families. Today, many Black schoolchildren enrolled in public and private choice programs experience academic gains in English language arts, math and science; participate in civic activities; and enroll annually in and graduate from postsecondary institutions — often becoming the first in their family to do so. ….. This report will fill the knowledge gap regarding the role of parental choice as part of this plan of action. Doing so will afrm the belief that Black children can and will achieve the highest academic levels when enrolled in supportive learning environments; promote why and how high-quality education options work; and encourage the expansion and enactment of new parental-choice programs.” (p. 16).
Blackie, James about 1990 Title? Regent University, Virginia Beach VA. A master's thesis on an effective home school model).
Blamires, Harry 1963, 2005 The Christian mind: How should a Christian think? Ann Arbor, MI: Servant Books. philosophy, worldview, biblical worldview, Christian worldview First sentence of the book: "There is no longer a Christian mind" (p. 3). “Idealists are the most tortured people in our midst. We get along very nicely with cranks and foreigners. We are tolerant of rogues and criminals. But idealists – those people who insist on logically relating principle to practice, end to means, purpose to process, goal to route – we have no time for them. Literally no time. There is too much to do. Their misgivings would slow us up, prevent us even from making a start. Besides they would set us all at each other's throats in fierce controversy if once they were allowed a sober hearing. The best thing is to shut them up” (p. 19). Author was in the United Kingdom.
Blandin, A. 2017 The home/school connection and its role in narrowing the academic achievement gap: An ecological systems theoretical perspective. Journal Of Research On Christian Education. 26(3). 271-292. homeschooling, research, review “This literature review seeks to evaluate previous studies on the topic of the home/school connection and its role in enhancing students’ academic achievement and narrowing the academic achievement gap. The ecological systems theory framework will facilitate the discussion of the importance of the home/school connection phenomenon. Perspectives pivotal to parental involvement and their interconnectedness with academic achievement and the academic achievement gap will be explored using a synthesis of prior research. The barriers impeding this partnership and strategies for removing them will be examined. Additionally, non-traditional solutions to the academic achievement gap such as individual faith will be addressed. Finally, implications of the home/school connection particularly for Christian educators will be presented.”
Blankenhorn, David 1995 Fatherless America: Confronting our most urgent social problem. New York, NY: Basic Books research, sociology, anthropology, family, father, fathers, fatherhood, children Harper Collins Publ. Bases his definition of the “good family man” on focus groups with middle class men from a variety of social/racial backgrounds; definition says he is a man who is a provider and protector, shows love of his wife and children through his actions, has biblical and moral values, and is flexible as a partner with his spouse [p. 208]. Blankenhorn’s subjects, who defined the “good family man,” spoke of biblical and moral values even though they were not all of Judeo-Christian faiths. That is, a good family man possesses these traits regardless of his religious affiliation. It appears, from the research on home education to date, that fathers who home educate their children are generally “good family men.” Claims that all children need a good family man in order for them and society to flourish. Explains and defines “the good family man” [ch. 11]. “The anthropological evidence suggests that the legitimacy principle--a responsible father for every child--is primarily a legal manifestation of the desire fore paternal certainty: the sure knowledge that this child is my child, not another man’s child. The reason is that paternal certainty is the most important precondition for paternal investment. Paternal investment, in turn, is an essential determinant of child and societal well-being. Of course, all three of these concepts--legitimacy, paternal certainty, and paternal investment--underlie and largely define a universal human institution with a much more familiar name: marriage” [p. 251] Suggests that children with a “good family man” as a parent are much advantaged in many ways over children who do not.
Bledstein, Burton J. 1976 The culture of professionalism: The middle class and the development of higher education in America. New York, NY: W. W. Norton & Co. education reform, alternative education, professionalism, colleges and universities, higher education, history, philosophy Claims that “The structuring of space and words [during the 1800s] belonged to a larger process: the professionalization of American lives” (p. 80). Professional structures, organizations, and schools emerged boldly during the late 1800s. The first university school for school teaching was founded in 1879. “The jurisdictional claim of that authority [of the professional] derived from a special power over worldly experience, a command over the profundities of a discipline. Such masterful command was designed to establish confidence in the mind of the helpless client. The professional person [including physicians, lawyers, ministers, and teachers] possessed esoteric knowledge about the universe which if withheld from society could cause positive harm. ..... Hence, the culture of professionalism required amateurs to ‘trust’ in the integrity of trained persons, to respect the moral authority of those whose claim to power lay in the sphere of the sacred and the charismatic. Professionals controlled the magic circle of scientific knowledge which only the few, specialized by training and indoctrination, were privileged to enter, but which all in the name of nature’s universality were obligated to appreciate” (p. 90).
Bliss, Barbara A. 1989, 20 February Home education: A look at current practices. Research Project, Michigan State University. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED304233). Educational Practices, Family Characteristics, Home Schooling, Parent Attitudes A report concerning 70 families who home-school: their procedures and opinions.
Bloedow, Timothy 1998, May Education options may collide: Different views on role of state might be irreconcilable. The Ottawa [Canada] Times, p. 4, 12. education reform, home schooling, funding Describes different educational options [e.g., home schooling, Christian schools] that are growing in popularity in Canada. Discusses their different views on government funding such as charter schools and vouchers and the idea that the government should not be involved at all in funding schooling or education. Home schoolers are the most independent-minded about education reform.
Blok, Henk 2001 The efficacy of home education; A review of results [translated title; original in Dutch]. Retrieved 12/21/01 online http://www.sco-kohnstamminstituut.uva.nl/pdf/effectiviteit.pdf. http://www.sco-kohnstamminstituut.uva.nl/pdf/effectiviteit.pdf home education, academic achievement, social development, socialization This summary in English received 12/21/01 from the author via e-mail. “Summary Although in many Western countries home education is a growing phenomenon, it is in the Netherlands almost non-existent. Dutch educational laws state that children are only allowed to receive their education at school. Home education is considered to be a threat to childrens' development. This article presents a review of -- mostly U.S. -- research on home schooling results. Main question is how home-schooled children develop in comparison with school children. It is concluded that home-schooled children receive on average better or even far better results in the cognitive domain (language, math, science, social studies), while in the social-emotional domain their development is not much different from school children. This positive result may be partly due to background factors, as the population of home-schoolers compares favorably with respect to social status, income and several related variables. It is hypothesized that the quality of the learning environment, including one-to-one instruction, could also be part of the explanation. The Dutch authorities are advised change the law in such a way as to permit parents to apply for home education.”
Blok, Henk 2004 Performance in home schooling: An argument against compulsory schooling in the netherlands. International Review of Education, 50(1), 39–52. Retrieved 7/9/13 from http://thuisonderwijs.net/artikelen/blok-performance-in-homeschooling.pdf. http://thuisonderwijs.net/artikelen/blok-performance-in-homeschooling.pdf homeschooling, academic achievement, socialization, review, synthesis, policy, regulation “Abstract – Although home education is a growing phenomenon in many Western countries, it is almost non-existent in the Netherlands. Under Dutch educational law, children must be educated in the school system. Home schooling is thought to endanger children’s development. This study examines – primarily American – analyses of performance in home schooling. Its leading question is: How do home-schooled children develop in comparison with school pupils? It concludes that home-schooled children perform better on average in the cognitive domain (language, mathematics, natural sciences, social studies), but differ little from their peers at school in terms of socio-emotional development. This positive finding may be attributed partly to socioeconomic factors. However, it is also suggested that the quality of the learning environment, including one-to-one tutoring, could also be a contributing factor” (p. 39). “Almost all of the studies discussed here point in the same direction. Homeschooled children stand out from their peers in schools in terms of scholastic achievement and – although less decisively – socio-emotional development. According to some studies, the average home-schooled child is ahead by a number of school years, which constitutes an undeniably strong lead. There is no evidence whatsoever to suggest that home-schooled children lag behind” (p. 48). “Moreover, the (static-group) research design [used for many/most of the studies] is weak. It will take more research – and better research methods – to gain a deeper understanding of the advantages and limitations of home schooling. Researchers should invest greater effort in using more sophisticated research methods, such as matching” (p. 49). “To the contrary, there is solid evidence indicating that home schooling is not, by definition, detrimental to the interests of children. The time has come, therefore, to review this policy of compulsory schooling. There appears to be no scientific basis for equating compulsory education with compulsory schooling. In other words, learning is possible – if not more effective – at home” (p. 50).
Blok, Henk, & Karsten, Sjoerd 2011, March Inspection of home education in European countries. European Journal of Education, 46(1), 138–152. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1465-3435.2010.01464.x/abstract home education, homeschooling, state regulation, UNCRC, children’s rights, child’s rights, negative criticism, negative critic, inspection, legislation, law, state control, review, Europe “Abstract: In many European countries and in North America, home education is a viable alternative for education at school. Parents who want to home school their child are legally allowed to do so, although some countries impose rather strict conditions. This article concentrates on the way authorities supervise or inspect the quality of home education. A comparison is made of inspection regulations in 14 European countries. Substantial differences were found, regarding among other things the function of inspection, inspection methods and the outcomes. Most countries do not have data on the effectiveness of inspection. It is recommended that governments screen their procedures for the inspection of home education using criteria such as transparency, consistency, and efficiency”; retrieved 3/2/2011 from http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1465-3435.2010.01464.x/abstract. (Authors write: “b. What are the functions of home education inspection? A common characteristic of all functions is that they centre on protecting the child’s interests. The interests of parents or society do not come into play” [p. 149]. “d. What are the results of the inspection? There are very little data on the results of the inspections. The least ambiguous are for Belgium (Dutch community) and France. In Belgium, in 2003–2004, some 20% of the assessments were negative. In 5% of these cases, penalty measures were imposed. When interpreting these data, we must take into account that they relate to a period when Belgium had no experience with the inspection of home education. The results may be more positive after a settling-in period. In France, a school attendance order was issued in 2% of the inspections in 2005” [p. 149]. “All the countries covered here take part in the UNCRC. Hence, they are bound by the children’s educational rights, as set down in articles 28 and 29” [p. 150]. “We assume that a government has an interest in a policy that is characterised by consistency, transparency, and efficiency. We make three recommendations based on this” [p. 150]. Recommendations: “We recommend that the various countries critically review their system according to whether it can provide the necessary input to pursue a consistent, transparent and efficient policy for home education” [p. 150]. “We believe, in accordance with the UNCRC, that the right of the child should prevail. We recommend that the individual countries critically consider the question of whether the obstacles raised take into account the interest of the child to develop in a multifaceted manner and the interest of the parents to guarantee an education that is consistent with individual religious or philosophical beliefs, as set out [p. 150 ends] in the European Convention on Human Rights (Protocol 1, article 2)” [p. 151]. “Our third recommendation is therefore that governments should review their procedures for home education inspection according to criteria such as transparency, consistency, and efficiency” [p. 151]. “Finally, it is not generally acknowledged that home education is a viable alternative. However, studies (Canadian, American and other countries) have found that many home-schooled students outperform those in public and independent (private) schools (Basham et al., 2007; Blok, 2004; Meighan, 1995). In this light, we believe that governments and researchers should give more attention to home education. Considering the apparently good results, it is surprising that many stakeholders still see this phenomenon as of marginal importance” [p. 151]. Authors do not address equal application of the law or UNCRC principles to state schools, private schools, and home education; this is problematic and raises the issue, Does anyone care whether children’s interests are being met in state-run schools or, Does anyone think that if parents should be held to standard X then so also should state-school systems and teachers? Authors’ failure to address equal application of law or principles to all forms of education/schooling begs many questions. If state-school students’/children’s educational interests are not being met, will someone – the state? – order them to private schooling or private home-based education? What if private-school educators or home educators had inspected Belgium’s and France’s (or any other nation’s) state schools? What percent of assessments would have been negative. What if third-party evaluators (and not state-school teachers nor professors who make their living training state-school teachers) had inspected state schools’ teaching methods and students’ academic achievement? What percent of evaluations would be negative, and then why not order private school or home education attendance for the children who were not meeting standards? Does the UNCRC demand access to education or certain measurable outcomes/effects for each child? Does not the UNCRC apply to all state-school children, too. Are state-school children inspected and if there is lack are they ordered to private institutional school or home education? From a more European or statist perspective, authors positive toward freedom to home educate; from a more U.S, classical liberal, or pro-home education freedom perspective, authors somewhat negative toward home-education freedoms.
Blokhuis, J.C. 2010 Whose custody is it, anyway?: ‘Homeschooling’ from a parens patriae perspective. Theory and Research in Education, 8(2), 199-222. http://tre.sagepub.com/content/8/2/199.short homeschooling, law, legal, statism Argues from statism, a statist worldview. “Abstract: Proponents of ‘homeschooling’ routinely claim it is legal for parents to rear their children as they see fit. This view ignores the parens patriae doctrine — the primary legal basis for the judicial regulation of custody and the legislative enactment of compulsory schooling laws for the benefit of all children. This article challenges claims that ‘homeschooling’ is legal (without qualification) with evidence of the continuing vitality of the parens patriae doctrine in two North American jurisdictions. In New York and Ontario, where ‘homeschooling’ is not statutorily prohibited, the state through its legislative and judicial organs continues to limit the custodial authority of ‘homeschooling’ parents on the ground that children’s independent welfare and developmental interests include exposure to public formative influences” (retrieved 7/8/13 from http://tre.sagepub.com/content/8/2/199.short) Probably bases argument for the power and authority of parens patriae on the idea of a child becoming an autonomous adult.
Bloom, A. 1987 The closing of the American mind: How higher education has failed democracy and impoverished the souls of today's students. New York, NY: Simon and Schuster.
Bloom, Benjamin 1980 All our children learning. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
Bloom, Benjamin S. 1984, May The search for methods of group instruction as effective as one-to-one tutoring. Educational Leadership, May, 1984, 41(8), 4-17. research, tutoring, mastery learning, academic achievement Asks, “... can researchers and teachers devise teaching-learning conditions that will enable the majority of students under group instruction to attain levels of achievement that can, at present, be reached only under good tutoring conditions?” (p. 4). “However, the most striking of the findings is that under the best learning conditions we can devise--(tutoring)--the average student is 2 sigmas [2 standard deviations of the control group] above the average control student taught under conventional group methods of instruction” (p. 6). “Using the standard deviation (sigma) of the control class, which was taught under conventional conditions [student in class with about 30 students per teacher, tests given periodically only for determining students marks/grades], it was found that the average student under tutoring was about two standard deviations above the average of the control class” (p. 5). Proposes that some approaches, such as mastery learning, might be as successful as tutoring. Bloom’s discussion of tutoring and mastery learning may explain why the home educated, who are basically tutored, have such high academic achievement.
Bluedorn, Harvey, & Bluedorn, Laurie 2001 Teaching the trivium: Christian homeschooling in a classical style. 640 pp. home education, pedagogy, philosophy, approach Explains how you can give your children the tools they need to teach themselves? Says that long ago students were first taught how to learn while today students are taught an encyclopedia of subjects -- trivia -- but they are not taught the basic skills of learning to discover, to reason, and to apply. They are not taught the Trivium. Explains how to homeschool in a classical style without compromising Christian principles. Tells how to give a classical education while keeping the critical screen of the Scriptures to for a Biblical model.
Blum, Virgil C. 1980 Education vouchers restore parent power. Christian Home and School, 58(9), 8-9, 20.
Blumenfeld, Samuel L. 1984 N.E.A.: Trojan horse in American Education. Boise, ID: The Paradigm Company, 284 p. homeschooling, home education, philosophy “Public school teachers, once loved and respected for their devotion to their profession, have become militantly politicized and are now the most active and powerful advocates of the political and social agendas of the radical left. The National Education Association, which represents 1.7 million teachers, has decided that its members are no longer satisfied with merely being public servants. They want to become political masters” [p. x]. Critiques the National Education Association. After discussing court case that involved homeschooling: the state, including its schools, “… ought not to be in the business of fostering “social development”” [in children and youth] [p. 258]; and, “So, now, being brought up on a farm and taught at home by one’s own loving parents is tantamount to being held in prison during one’s formative years, after which one is “released upon the world.” ….. But the courts and the superintendents blindly operate in a dream world where public schools actually know how to teach and their social environment is safe and healthy. The fact is that the schools are just the opposite, and that is why so many parents want to get their children out!” [p. 259]. “The humanist worldview now dominates American public education so completely, that the only escape is the private school or the home school” [p. 261]. Explains that one of the only escapes from humanism of schools is the private school or home education, p. 261.
Blumenfeld, Samuel L. 1986 How to tutor (second ed.). Boise, ID: The Paradigm Co., 298 p. Instructs parents in how to teach their children the three Rs: reading by intensive, systematic phonics, cursive writing; and basic arithmetic; ISBN 0941995-01-1 Available from The Paradigm Co., PO Box 45161, Boise ID 83711, or from Gregg Harris, listed herein.
Blumenfeld, Samuel L. 1993 Can conservatives thrive in the new Clinton era? The Blumenfeld Education Letter, 8(1), 1-6. public schools, politics, home education Explains that it is a grave error to send children to public schools with all the problems in them
Blumenfeld, Samuel L. 1997 Homeschooling: A parent’s guide to teaching children. Seacaucus, NJ: Citadel Press.
Board of Studies, Teaching and Educational Standards New South Wales (NSW) 2014 Academic Outcomes of Home Schooling: Review of Research and Analysis of Statewide Tests. New South Wales, Australia: Author. homeschooling, academic achievement, government, research, foreign, Australia “Under the Education Act 1990 home schooling is education delivered in a child’s home by a parent or guardian.” (p. 1). Report includes “…analysis of results in statewide assessments such as the National Assessment Program Literacy and Numeracy (NAPLAN) tests, School Certificate and Higher School Certificate. ….. The only achievement data available for currently home schooled students is that arising from students who voluntarily undertake the NAPLAN tests. Only a small minority of home schooled students (about 10%) choose to undertake the tests, and thus any results must be treated with extreme caution. The results indicate that this group of students scored significantly above the overall NSW average in nearly every test. The differences were largest in Reading, Grammar & Punctuation and Numeracy, where home schooled students’ average scores were typically about 70 marks (or about one standard deviation) higher than the NSW average. The differences were smaller in Spelling (about 40 marks) and Writing (about 20 marks). ….. the analysis showed that students who were previously home schooled [a group larger than the homeschool group previously mentioned] scored significantly higher in the Reading and Grammar & Punctuation tests, generally by about 20-25 marks (or about one-third of a standard deviation) in Reading, and 15-25 marks in Grammar & Punctuation. In Writing, Spelling and Numeracy, the home schooled student averages are generally not statistically significantly different from the overall NSW average. These results were consistent, regardless of the Year Levels being tested, and whether students have been registered for home schooling for shorter or longer periods.” (p. 1)
Boggs, Carol J. 1983 An analysis of selected Christian rearing manuals. Family Relations, 32(1), 73-80. Low level analysis of advice given to parents from prominent Christian writers.
Bolick, Clint 1987 The home schooling movement. The Freeman: Ideas on Liberty, 37(3), 84-89. home education, opinion, history, sociology, politics “Many home schoolers are rigidly traditional and scrupulously law-abiding, while others are long-time practitioners of civil disobedience. Some are fervently religious and have removed their children from mainstream schools because they are too secular, while others are nonbelievers who consider the public schools too religious” [p. 84].
Bolle, Mary Beth; Wessel, Roger; Mulvihill, Thalie 2007, November/December Transitional experiences of first-year college students who were homeschooled. Journal of College Student Development, 48(6), 637-654. http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/csd/summary/v048/48.6bolle.html http://www.nacada.ksu.edu/journal/28_2-annotated-bib.pdf homeschooling, homeschool, home education, research, qualitative methods, college, college transition, adult, Peer-reviewed Qualitative research. “Abstract: This study examined transitional experiences of first-year college students who were homeschooled in high school. It sought to determine if experiences of such students corresponded with Tinto's (1988, 1993) theory of student departure. The qualitative study found that there was little distinction between the transitional experiences of homeschooled students and traditionally educated students. During their first year of college, students experienced transitional issues such as loneliness, meeting others with different values, and dealing with greater independence. Academic and student support services, such as orientation, resident assistants, and campus programming, were influential institutional interventions in their transition to college” (Retrieved March 10, 2015 http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/csd/summary/v048/48.6bolle.html.) One source [“Annotated Bibliographies of Recent Research Related to Academic Advising,” retrieved February 27, 2012 from http://www.nacada.ksu.edu/journal/28_2-annotated-bib.pdf] reports that the authors had three research questions: 1. What transitional issues did homeschooled students encounter? 2. How did these issues relate to Tinto’s (1988, 1993) model of transition? 3. What institutional interventions facilitated or hindered homeschooled students’ transition? “There was little distinction between the transitional issues experienced by homeschooled students and the issues experienced by traditionally educated students, as described in the literature. The issues that participants encountered, such as loneliness, meeting others with different values, living in the residence halls, and greater independence, correlated with transitional issues of traditionally educated students. Like traditionally educated students, homeschooled students were both anxious and excited about leaving their homes and families to begin school. Whether excited or nervous, nearly all of the students experienced some loneliness upon arriving on campus. The students proactively sought to remedy their loneliness by stepping outside of their comfort zone to meet others. Once leaving their comfort zone, they seemed to make friends quickly. As the participants met others and made friends with people who had common interests, college began to feel like a home in itself. Additionally, the participants underwent transitions as they met others with different lifestyles and value systems. Although at times the students felt challenged, they seemed to be grateful for the opportunity to expand their horizons and worldview (p. 650). Peer-reviewed.
Bolle-Brummond, Mary Beth, & Wessel, Roger D. 2012 Homeschooled students in college: Background influences, college integration, and environmental pull factors. Journal of Research in Education, 22(1), Spring, 2012, 223-249. Retrieved February 29, 2012 from http://www.eeraonline.org/journal/files/v22/JRE_v22n1_Article_10_Wessel.pdf. http://www.eeraonline.org/journal/files/v22/JRE_v22n1_Article_10_Wessel.pdf homeschooling, homeschool, research, college, college integration “Abstract. How do pre-entry attributes of homeschooled students influence their college experience? What are their academic and social integration patterns? What role did outside factors play in their college experience? Using Tinto’s research as a foundation, this study examined the influence of pre-entry attributes on the college experience, academic and social integration patterns, and environmental pull factors of college students who were homeschooled in high school. The authors found that homeschooled students were equipped to succeed academically and socially. Outside influences encountered by the participants included work, family, and finances.” Authors found that college students who had been home educated, “… as all subpopulations of college students, has somewhat unique issues to contend with, due to their homeschooled background. However, these issues were not prohibitive of their college success. We found that they experienced college in many of the same ways that other, non-homeschooled students, did. In most regards, their undergraduate experiences were unidentifiable from the overall student population: they were normal college students” [p. 25].
Bond, Alan, & Bond, Jill 1999, Fall The second homeschool movement. The Home School Digest, 10(3), 63-64. philosophy, reasons, religion, home education Explains that many homeschoolers are currently focusing more and more on things that are not the most important in their childrens lives. For example, they are putting too much focus on field trips, academics, and getting services from tax-funded and public school homeschool programs rather than on biblical principles and godly thinking. Says that a second movement will have to arise, comprised of pioneer and likeminded homeschool parents, to instruct other home schoolers about God-ordained calling that should be the main reason for homeschooling among Christians.
Bongrand, Philippe 2019 Home education through the lens of municipal records: A case study in the Parisian suburbs. Peabody Journal of Education, 94:3, 328-341, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617586. https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617586 homeschooling, home schooling, legal, law, motives, motivation, reasons “Abstract. Research about home educators is often limited by a reliance on convenience-based samples. This paper explores an alternative source of information: written reports from inquiries held by the French public administration on every registered home-educated child. First, I depict how these inquiries are legally designed and how our research team has negotiated with government agencies to gain access to these reports. Then I discuss the case study of Cheny, a city located in the working-class suburbs of Paris. In Cheny, 70 children from 44 families were registered as home educated from 2011 to 2016. I use the city records to describe what the local authorities know and think about families who home educate their children and what this knowledge teaches us about the practice and public regulation of home education in France. I focus on the ability of these reports to provide us with information about parental motives. I also raise different questions about the value and weaknesses of such sets of data.”
Bonnett, Cara 2008, May 27 Home-schoolers of color: Worried about harmful labels and lower achievement, parents choose to educate their children themselves. Retrieved 5/29/08 from http://www.newsobserver.com/105/story/1086306.html. http://www.newsobserver.com/105/story/1086306.html home education, race, ethnicity, minorities, black, African American, opinion Explains that blacks/African Americans home educate for many of same reasons other do. Presents story that black parents care more about their individual children’s well-being than about some allegedly larger or greater good such as the advancement of a group of people via public schooling. “That year, [Dotty] Barco pulled all her sons out of Vance Elementary School in Raleigh. She has been home-schooling them since. The Barcos join an increasing number of black families in the Triangle and across the country who choose to home-school their children. Of the estimated 1.1 million home-schooled children in the U.S., about 10 percent are black, according to the most recent federal statistics from the U.S. Department of Education. ….. Still, black home-schooling families say they face skepticism -- even among friends and family. "Everyone has their eyebrows arched," said Kamela Heyward-Rotimi of Durham, who has been home-schooling her 9-year-old son, Kola, for six years. "[Friends said] 'You're home-schooling? That's for really radical white Christians in the mountains!' We questioned right along with them, [wondering], 'How is this going to work out?' Well, my son did very well on the Iowa [standardized test]. Now, when people ask, 'How is that working for you?' I can say confidently, 'It's working well.'" While public schools were a focus of the civil rights struggle, Barco said her decision has nothing to do with disregarding milestones like Brown vs. Board of Education, which led to school desegregation. It's about finding a good fit for her family. She can concentrate on reading with her oldest son, who is dyslexic. The entire family enjoys the looser schedule, and all the boys have more time to draw, play Pop Warner football and ride bikes outside with their friends.””
Boose, Robert E. 1984 Guidelines for equivalent instruction through home-schooling. Maine State Department of Educational and Cultural Services, Augusta, ME. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 274 049) "This document provides guidelines to aid local school officials in the adoption and implementation of equivalent instruction [underline added] rules and policies" Resources in Education, 22(2), 51.
Boss, Judy, & Boss, Kathy 1994 Is mandatory schooling inherently unjust? The Educational Forum, 58(3), 264-275. home education, philosophy, compulsory education laws, schooling Includes discussion of discuss the benefits of home education.
Boss, Suzie 1989, February 5 A is for at home: A report card on home schooling. Northwest, the Sunday Oregonian Magazine, 1 & 8-12. Brian Ray and Maralee Mayberry are quoted.
Bosswell, A. R. 2021 Homeschooling and Learners’ Academic Achievement: Evidence from the United States of America. Journal of Education, 4(5). Retrieved from https://www.stratfordjournals.com/journals/index.php/journal-of-education/article/view/875 https://www.stratfordjournals.com/journals/index.php/journal-of-education/article/view/875 Homeschooling,Learners’,Academic Achievement,United States of America “Abstract There is solid evidence that homeschooling has made notable gains in absolute numbers and percent of the school-age population in nations as diverse as Australia, Brazil, Canada, England, Japan, Mexico, South Africa, South Korea, Scotland, and Russia. Home education’s rebirth after about a century of quiescence has surprised many educators, sociologists, political scientists, historians, and theologians, and has captured the imagination and engagement of hundreds of thousands of families. One of the most common and widely accepted ways to assess the learning of students and the effectiveness of their educational environments is via academic achievement as measured by standardized tests.Through literature review, through scholarly articles, interviews, and a survey, research reveals that homeschooling will continue to be on the rise. Thus, homeschooled children tend to score higher or similar compared to regular children attending public schools. Children become more responsible for themselves, and have control of their education. Homeschooling is an alternative to education for children who do not adjust well. While homeschooling allows students to focus only on what is important to them, it makes learning more enjoyable, since they are learning at their own pace, and at the same time affects their academic achievement in many ways.There were an estimated 4.5 to 5.0 million homeschool students in grades K-12 in the United States during March of 2021 (roughly 8% to 9% of school-age children). There were about 2.5 million homeschool students in spring 2019 (or 3% to 4% of school-age children). Thehomeschool population had been growing at an estimated 2% to 8% per annum over the past several years, but it grew drastically from 2019-2020 to 2020-2021.There isincreasing evidenceon the extra sleep needed in teenage years, yet the conventional school system often requires students to stay up late finishing homework and get up early to rush to their morning classes. Homeschool offers some great advantages when it comes to scheduling: less rushing in the morning sets kids up for less stress overall in their day, longer sleep ins are important for mental and physical wellbeing as well as better focus andwork ethic throughout the day and homeschooled children can take breaks throughout the day as needed and are less likely to burnout and form negative associations with school and learning.Homeschoolersare becoming sought- after for higher education. Many colleges and universities have begun to modify their admission practices to not only allow for, but to encourage, homeschoolers to apply for admission.” Poorly written; adds close to nothing on the topic of homeschool research.
Bottero, Kathy 1983 The Open School Extended Program. 960 S.W. Jefferson, Corvallis, OR 97330. Information pamphlet, 5 p.
Boulter, Lyn T. 2017 A Comparison of the academic achievement of home school and public school students. International Journal of Business and Social Research, 07(03),ISSN 2164-2559, https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/208833446.pdf “ABSTRACT: This study added to existing data on home school effectiveness by comparing the academic achievement of 66 home school students with 66 of their grade-level peers in traditional public schools [from elementary, middle, and high school levels]. https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/208833446.pdf Education Attainment, Education System, K12 Learning, Schooling, Peer-reviewed journal The two groups of students were matched on gender, race, and grade level and were administered the Woodcock-Johnson Psychoeducational Battery III. No significant difference in overall academic achievement was found between the groups. Both home school and public school students had average or above average scores in reading, math, written language, and broad knowledge science, social studies, and humanities). The results further revealed a downward trend in math, reading and broad knowledge scores with increasing grade level. This trend suggests that home school and public school students experience a “developmental mismatch” between the changes that occur in adolescence and their school/home experiences, resulting in lower motivation, confidence, and academic performance.” Peer-reviewed journal
Boulter, Lyn, & Macaluso, Kristin 1994 Individualized assessment of home schooling education. Home School Researcher, 10(2), 1-6. Finds this small sample of home educated students "... demonstrated that in the content areas of Letter-Word Recognition, Passage Comprehension, Calculation, Applied Problems, Writing Samples, Science and Social Studies, they performed as well as or better than average according to standardization norms. This academic success may be explained, in part, by comparing the instructional methods used by home educators with nationally recognized criteria that defines effective teaching" [p. 4]. Most descriptions of home education indicate that home educators practice these criteria for effective instruction. These home educated children were somewhat below the national average in the areas of Dictation and Humanities.
Bowen, Beth 1987 Home schoolers excel. The Home School Court Report, 3 (1), 11.
Bowlby, John 1951 Maternal care and mental health. World Health Organization Monograph (Serial No. 2). http://whqlibdoc.who.int/monograph/WHO_MONO_2_%28part1%29.pdf http://whqlibdoc.who.int/monograph/WHO_MONO_2_%28part2%29.pdf http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2554004/pdf/bullwho00644-0006.pdf psychology, sociology, attachment theory, family, mother, father, motherhood, fatherhood, healthy child development, developmental psychology Retrieved December 15, 2011 from http://whqlibdoc.who.int/monograph/WHO_MONO_2_%28part1%29.pdf and http://whqlibdoc.who.int/monograph/WHO_MONO_2_%28part2%29.pdf see also, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2554004/pdf/bullwho00644-0006.pdf, for a searchable PDF of Part 1. Author presents one of his first formal explanations of attachment theory and supporting evidence thereof. “Among the most significant developments in psychiatry during the past quarter of a century has been the steady growth of evidence that the quality of the parental care which a child receives in his earliest years is of vital importance for his future mental health. . . . . . Largely as a result of this new knowledge, there is today a high level of agreement among child-guidance workers in Europe and America on certain central concepts. Their approach to cases, their investigations, their diagnostic criteria, and their therapeutic aims are the same. Above all, the theory of etiology on which their work is founded is the same. The basic principles of this theory of the origins of mental health and mental illness will be discussed more fully later. For the moment it is sufficient to say that what is believed to be essential for mental health is that the infant and young child should experience a warm, intimate, and continuous relationship with his mother (or permanent mother-substitute) in which both find satisfaction and enjoyment. Given this relationship, the emotions of anxiety and guilt, which in excess characterize mental ill-health, will develop in a moderate and organized way. When this happens, the child's characteristic and contradictory demands, on the one hand for unlimited love from his parents and on the other for revenge upon them when he feels that they do not love him enough, will likewise remain of moderate strength and become amenable to the control of his gradually developing personality. It is this complex, rich, and rewarding relationship with the mother in the early years, varied in countless ways by relations with the father and with siblings, that child psychiatrists and many others now believe to underlie the development of character and of mental health. A state of affairs in which the child does not have this relationship is termed 'maternal deprivation'. This is a general term covering a number of different situations. Thus, a child is deprived even though living at home if his mother (or permanent mother-substitute) is unable to give him the loving care small children need. Again, a child is deprived if for any [p. 11 ends] reason he is removed from his mother’s care. This deprivation will be relatively mild if he is then looked after by someone whom he has already learned to know and trust, but may be considerable if the foster-mother, even though loving, is a stranger. All these arrangements, however, give the child some satisfaction and are therefore examples of partial deprivation. They stand in contrast to the almost complete deprivation which is still not uncommon in institutions, residential nurseries, and hospitals, where the child often has no one person who cares for him in a personal way and with whom he may feel secure. The ill-effects of deprivation vary with its degree” [p. 12]. “It was said at the beginning of the first chapter that what is believed to be essential for mental health is that the infant and young child should experience a warm, intimate, and continuous relationship with his mother (or [permanent] mother-substitute), in which both find satisfaction and enjoyment. The child needs to feel he is an object of pleasure and pride to his mother; the mother needs to feel an expansion of her own personality in the personality of her child: each needs to feel closely identified with the other. The mothering of a child is not something which can be arranged by roster; it is a live human relationship which alters the characters of both partners. The provision of a proper diet calls for more than calories and vitamins: we need to enjoy our food if it is to do us good. In the same way the provision of mothering cannot be considered in terms of hours per day but only in terms of the enjoyment of each other’s company which mother and child obtain. Such enjoyment and close identification of feeling is only possible for either party if the relationships continuous. Much emphasis has already been laid on the necessity of continuity for the growth of a child’s personality. It should be remembered, too, that continuity is necessary for the growth of a mother. Just as the baby needs to feel that he belongs to his mother, the mother needs to feel that she belongs to her child and it is only when she has the satisfaction of this feeling that it is easy for her to devote herself to him. The provision of constant attention day and night, seven days a week and 365 in the year, is possible only for a woman who derives profound satisfaction from seeing her child grow from babyhood, through the many phases of childhood, to become an independent man or woman, and knows that it is her care which has made this possible. It is for these reasons that the mother-love which a young child needs is so easily provided within the family, and is so very very difficult to provide outside it. The services which mothers and fathers habitually render their children are so taken for granted that their magnitude is forgotten. In no other relationship do human beings place themselves so [p. 67 ends] unreservedly and so continuously at the disposal of others. This holds true even of bad parents – a fact far too easily forgotten by their critics, especially critics who have never had the care of children of their own. It must never be forgotten that even the bad parent who neglects her child is none the less providing much for him. Except in the worst cases, she is giving him food and shelter, comforting him in distress, teaching him simple skills, and above all is providing him with that continuity of human care on which his sense of security rests. He may be ill-fed and ill-sheltered, he may be very dirty and suffering from disease, he may be ill-treated, but, unless his parents have wholly rejected him, he is secure in the knowledge that there is someone to whom he is of value and who will strive, even though inadequately, to provide for him until such time as he can fend for himself. It is against this background that the reason why children thrive better in bad homes, than in good institutions and why children with bad parents are, apparently unreasonably, so attached to them can be understood. Those responsible for institutions have sometimes been resistant to acknowledging that children are often better off in even quite bad homes, is the conclusion of most experienced social workers with mental health training and is born out by the evidence of Simonsen and of Theis, already quoted. [p. 68].”
Bowling, Donna Weathers 1996 Selection policies of Christian school textbook publishers: Editorial criteria for reading and literature curriculum materials designed for use in Christian day schools and home schools. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, University of Arkansas. research, home education schooling, private schools, Christian, curriculum Calculates an “Index of Inclusiveness” for each of 42 publishers based on their inclusion of certain types of materials that have raised censorship or selection issues and describes the types of materials [e.g., from a non-Christian worldview, secular classics, traditional myths, legends, and fairy tales, modern fantasy, , science fiction, materials with evolutionary presuppositions] included by publishers. Examines statistical relationships between Indexes of Inclusiveness and publisher’s size, type of instructional environment or market intended, grade levels provided, type of curriculum organization, general or special focus of curriculum content, type or source of reading and/or literature materials provided, supply of materials from other publishers, affiliation with other organizations, and age; only outside source and special focus variables were significant.
Boyd, W. L. 1978 The changing politics of curriculum policy-making for American schools. Review of Educational Research, 48, 577-628. Politics of educational change.
Boyer, Ernest L. 1991 Ready to learn—A mandate for the nation. Available for $8 (as of 12/91) from Princeton University Press, 3175 Princeton Pike, Lawrenceville, NJ 08648. Funded by the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching, sets forth national strategy to ensure all children enter school well prepared, 7-step strategy: clinics in poor communities for mothers and preschool children, parent-education programs in every state and distribute a "parent-education guide," make sure all who need it get Head Start, promote "family friendly" work place policies such as unpaid leave for new parents, found a cable television channel devoted to educational needs of preschoolers, design network of outdoor and indoor parks and "street playgrounds" and school-readiness programs in libraries, museums, zoos, and shopping malls, urge communities, schools, daycare centers, and retirement villages to organize intergenerational programs involving elderly interacting with young children; report places a premium on promoting "a warm, supportive home environment, with lots of lively social interaction" and opportunities for language development.
Boyer, Rick 1993 The socialization trap. Rustburg, VA: The Learning Parent. home education, socialization 160pp., deals with issue of proper socialization for children and youth, Christian perspective, encourages parents to not place children in unplanned age-peer groups; author is an experienced home educator.
Boyer, Rick, & Boyer, Marilyn 1996 Home educating with confidence: How ordinary parents can produce extaordinary children. Elkton, MD: Homeschool Press.
Boyer, Wanda A. R. 2002 Exploring home schooling. International Journal of Early Childhood, 34(2), 19-29. http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF03176764 homeschooling, early childhood education, diversity, Australia “Abstract: The global early childhood guidelines of the World Organization for Early Childhood Education (Organisation Mondiale pour L’Éducation Préscolaire: O.M.E.P.) and the Association for Childhood Education International (A.C.E.I.) indicate that “every child should have the opportunity to grow up in a setting that values children, that provides conditions for a safe and secure environment, and that respects diversity” (International Symposium of Early Childhood Education and Care in the 21st Century: Global guidelines, 1999, p. 5). The guidelines also identify program policies to promote partnerships with families and communities. The concerns and needs of families who home school [homeschool, homeschooling] must play an important role in creating a new conception of the care and education of children. This article examines concerns expressed by families who home school in the context of the O.M.E.P. and A.C.E.I. guidelines, connecting the guidelines to recent literature in order to provide effective strategies for meeting parental needs and responding to the diverse responsibilities of educating young children today” (retrieved 7/11/13 from http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF03176764). Author is affiliated with the University of Victoria, Australia.
Brabant, C., & Bourdon, S. 2012 Educational Change and Reflexive Governance. Experimentation of an Appropriation of Change Model by Quebec Home Educators Groups. http://www.acelf.ca/c/revue/sommaire.php?id=35 Le changement en éducation et la gouvernance réflexive. Expérimentation d’un modèle d’appropriation du changement par des groupes de parents-éducateurs au Québec). Éducation et francophonie, Volume XL, numéro 1, printemps. Available on line at: http://www.acelf.ca/c/revue/sommaire.php?id=35. (“Abstract [via e-mail from author Brabant] This article tackles the question of change in education from the angle of its appropriation by parents who actively practice “learning as a family”, or who support their children’s education without full-time school attendance. This angle assumes that appropriating the process of change and the decision to apply the process corresponds to the appropriation of democratic mechanisms. A research-training, based on a pragmatic, reflexive and contextual approach to governance, attempted to create a collective actor able to participate in a thoughtful, active and democratic renewal of the school system. It also modelled the learning process for three groups of parents-educators. The analysis identified pragmatic learning, involving the group’s implementation of practical conditions for the realization of a project, and genetic learning, involving the creation of the collective actor, while targeting essential conditions for success of the approach. The resources supporting the process – the development of confidence, openness to outside resources, and the acquisition of discursive, reflexive, decisional and procedural abilities -- allowed the groups to move from a fearful and resistant position in relation to the school authorities to a more confident and open attitude, and to formulate suggestions for governing their practice. These results suggest that the implementation of support measures for collective initiatives, such as the “accompanied self-training” explored in this research, is an effective way to face the challenges of change in education.
Brabant, Christine 2006 Citizenship Education: A collaborative research with home educators. Paper presented at the European Conference on Educational Research Post Graduate and New Researcher Pre-Conference, University of Geneva, 11 September 2006 at the symposium "Transforming Life into Knowledge, The De-institutionalisation of Knowledge Transformation, How Home Education Challenges Our Picture of Education. http://www.leeds.ac.uk/educol/documents/165018.htm home education, research, socialization, common good, citizenship Retrieved 9/6/07 online from http://www.leeds.ac.uk/educol/documents/165018.htm. Abstract: “In liberal societies, which might be characterized as pluralistic and individualistic, schools are implicitly, and sometimes explicitly, expected to socialize youth and generate among them a sense of shared values. In Quebec, Canada, explicit mention of Citizenship Education was recently added to the compulsory primary and secondary school curricula. Most parents consider that Citizenship Education belongs in the territory of school educators, but what happens with Citizenship Education when children are home educated? This conference paper will review the recent literature, both favourable and unfavourable, that describes the social impact of home education. It will then present a research project designed to collect the perspectives of home educators about the knowledge and practices at stake in their conceptions of Citizenship Education, and simultaneously give them an opportunity to better develop and articulate those conceptions. This study is designed as part of a larger collaborative research project which aims to offer conceptual clarification and produce practical knowledge about Citizenship Education. That research is directed by Professor France Jutras (Université de Sherbrooke) and funded by the Social Science and Humanities Research Council of Canada” [abstract].)
Brabant, Christine 2007 For a reflexive governance of education: The example of home education in Quebec. Paper presented at the European Conference on Educational Research, University of Ghent, 19-21 September 2007. http://www.leeds.ac.uk/educol/documents/166121.htm home education, research, philosophy, governance, policy Retrieved November 7, 2007 from Education-line http://www.leeds.ac.uk/educol/documents/166121.htm. “Abstract. The author examines the case of Home Education in Quebec as an example of new challenges that coordination of education faces today. The theoretical framework used for this analysis is the "reflexive governance" and the "pragmatique contextuelle" (pragmatic and contextualised approach) developed by Belgian philosophers Jacques Lenoble, Marc Maesschalck and their colleagues. It is argued that the propositions drawn from these new ethics of governance can help solving educational problems related to the participation of different actors, such as the elaboration of norms with regards to Home Education.
Brabant, Christine 2008 Homeschooling. In Gary McCulloch & David Crook (Eds.), The Routledge International Encyclopedia of Education.
Brabant, Christine; & Dumond, Marine 2021 La gouvernance de l’apprentissage en famille: outils de régulation et approches types. Dans Éducation et sociétés, 1(45), 143-160. homeschooling, regulation, policy, law, legal “Abstract: The governance of family learning: regulatory tools and standard approaches With the development of the Family Learning movement in countries with widespread education, several states are revising their normative framework to better reflect this practice. The lack of satisfactory classification of Family Learning approaches has led to a review of scientific and legal literature on its regulations in more than thirty countries in every continent. The article presents the identified Family Learning regulatory tools, the pragmatic and operational classification created in six standard approaches: absence of interaction, support, intervision, control, prohibition and third powers. It combines recommendations formulated by the research.
Brabant, Christine; Bourdon, Sylvain; & Jutras, France 2003 Home education in Quebec: Family first. Evaluation and Research in Education, 17(2-3), 112-131. ERIC Document No. EJ789494. http://www.eric.ed.gov http://www.eric.ed.gov/ area studies; homeschooling, home schooling; foreign countries; curriculum enrichment; questionnaires; social influences; demography; socioeconomic status; motivation; parent attitudes; parents as teachers; decision making; family relationship; curriculum; child development; social development; language of instruction; French; religious factors; family environment; student needs, Canada “Abstract: In Canada, until now, no studies have focused on the practice of home education in the francophone province of Quebec. While the home-educating population in that province is tangible, it has remained largely unknown. Quebec's distinctive character on three fronts-- political, historical and cultural--make the application of results from the rare Canadian studies or data from the US home-educating population seem inappropriate. This research, conducted by questionnaire in 2003, documented the sociodemographic characteristics of Quebec's home-educating families and their motivations for home education. Beginning with a portrait of Quebec's particular context, this article presents the motivations underlying the choice of home education expressed by 203 Quebec families. The reasons why these families have chosen to homeschool are many and diverse; parents' rationales for their choices are wide-ranging and multidimensional. One particularity of the results is that no religious, philosophical or anti-state viewpoint seems to dominate the combined discourse. Seven motivational factors for home education were identified. Collectively, the respondents express the following as their main motivations for home educating their children: a desire to pursue a family educational project; an objection to the organisational structure of the school system; a desire to offer curriculum enrichment; and finally, a preoccupation with their children's socioaffective development. (Contains 6 tables and 5 notes.)” (retrieved 7/16/13 from http://www.eric.ed.gov).
Brabant, Christine; Bourdon, Sylvain; & Jutras, France 2004, automne L'école à la maison au Québec : l'expression d'un choix familial marginal [The home school in Quebec: the expression of a marginal family choice]. Enfances, Familles, Générations, Revue Internacional, number 1. Retrieved 7/8/13 from http://www.erudit.org/revue/efg/2004/v/n1/008894ar.html. http://www.erudit.org/revue/efg/2004/v/n1/008894ar.html homeschooling, Canada, reasons, motives, interview, research, pedagogy, ideology Appears to be a fair and dispassionate presentation of findings on reasons and motivations for homeschooling in Quebec, Canada. “Abstract: Home schooling is a borderline, though legal, option that is exercised throughout the world. Until now, there has been no in-depth study of this practice in Quebec and there has been no head count of the families concerned. This article deals with the reasons for choosing home schooling, as given by 203 Quebec families who responded to a questionnaire on the subject. The survey, carried out in 2003, was designed to document the families` representation of education, the reasons for their choice, their educational experience and their socio-demographic profiles. The reasons they gave were both numerous and diversified. The rationale of the parents’ decisions is both varied and multidimensional. One of the particularities of the results is that the discourse of these Quebec parental educators seems quite devoid of any religious, anti-State or philosophical overtones. For the participants as a whole, the basic factors that largely determined their choice were their desire to implement a family educational project, their objection to the modes of organization of the school system, a desire to offer an enriched learning experience and a concern with the socio-affective development of their children [paragraph 2].” Translated online: “Overall, these parents deeply involved with their children are mainly home school to pursue an education project in family and because they take a critical look at the education system, plans modes organization, lack of enrichment programs and the impact of education on social-emotional development of children.”
Brady, Michael S. 2003 Social development in traditionally schooled and home educated children: A case for increased parental monitoring and decreased peer dominance. Home School Researcher, 15(4), 11-18. home education, research, socialization, peer involvement, peer influence “While peer interaction may be important for successful personality development, the quality of these interactions is equally important. Children that live in a peer- dominant culture tend to be at greater risk for negative peer influences, such as rejection and deviance training. These social interactions find their strength by using the availability heuristic to alter the false consensus effect. Research has demonstrated that increased parental monitoring [e.g., in homeschooling] can increase successful socialization and personality development. The positive increase in social behavior may be due in part to the supervision and regulation of peer group membership and peer activities” [p. 18].
Brandt, Ronald S. (Ed.) 1993 Contemporary issues: Public schools and the Christian fundamentalists [Special issue]. Educational Leadership, 51(4), 4, 5, 6-11, 12-15, 16-21, 22, 23, 24-28, 30-34, 35, 36, 38-40, 41-43. public education, schools, religion, values, Christian, fundamentalists Examines whether public schools can accommodate Christian fundamentalists; articles include "Fundamental differences?," "When two worldviews collide," "A plea for the children," "A tug-of-war over tolerance," and "In search of common ground."
Brazelton, T. Berry, & Greenspan, Stanley I. 2001 The irreducible needs of children: What every child must have to grow, learn, and flourish. Perseus Publishing. http://www.loc.gov/loc/lcib/0011/kids.html child care, raising children, day care, daycare, public school, psychology, developemental psychology, education Retrieved 1/14/03 online http://www.loc.gov/loc/lcib/0011/kids.html “The Needs of Children Lecture Features Drs. Brazelton and Greenspan” by Audrey Fischer (November 2000) that explains what Brazelton and Greenspan have said and article implies the following information is in the book: “Dr. Brazelton was joined by his co-author Dr. Greenspan. While the two do not always agree on how to solve the problem, they both concur on the scope of the problem and share a clear vision of the seven basic or "irreducible" needs of children. Through their work, they have identified the needs for: continuous nurturing relationships; physical protection, safety and regulation; experiences tailored to individual differences; developmentally appropriate experiences; limit setting, structure and expectations; stable, supportive communities and cultural continuity; and the need to protect the future. The conversation, moderated by Washington Post family advice columnist Marguerite Kelley, focused primarily on the need for nurturing relationships. "As the politicians often ask, 'Are we better off now than 30 years ago?'" asked Dr. Greenspan. From the perspective of an eight-month-old baby, his answer is decidedly no, given the number of children in day care, the state of public education and the overloaded mental health system. Of particular concern to him is the lack of time given to children in today's fast-paced society. "These chains of interaction are building blocks of intelligence, self-esteem and ability to trust," said Dr. Greenspan. "The nurturing side of the equation is missing." Instead, he believes the trend is toward "survival of the fittest." Dr. Greenspan seems to be committed to at least one parent staying home with young children, and discussed the impact on children of parents who are too stressed to be closely engaged in their children's lives. Dr. Brazelton recognizes the need to involve fathers and the need for improved day care. Both agree that the vast majority of institutional day care centers, and nearly as many family day care providers, offer substandard care. ..... Dr. Greenspan wants parents to "cut back" on activities that take them outside of the home. He believes that if parents are educated about the critical importance of doing so, they will make the right choices. While Dr. Brazelton agrees that the first three years of life are a critical time in child development and ideally a time when they should be cared for by nurturing adults, he feels parents should continue to fight for better child care. "They will have to keep fighting because institutions are insensitive," he said. "Our public policy is driven by politics, not by science," echoed Dr. Greenspan. Both share similar concerns about meeting children's needs in our over-crowded public classrooms. Neither believe that higher standards, more testing or even better teacher training will fix the problem if, as a society, we just pretend to be committed to improving education. It will take, in part, reduced class size so that teachers can nurture students and appreciate their individual differences and learning styles. That will take money, which both believe is worth spending.”
Bredder, Charlene Catherine 2004, April 13 Home schooling, democracy, and the meaning of education. A paper [as of 4/19/04, not absolutely sure it is available as a paper] presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Diego, California, April 12-16, 2004. http://convention.allacademic.com/aera2004/view_paper_info.html?pub_id=5174&part_id1=10410 http://convention.allacademic.com/aera2004/AERA_papers/AERA_1071_15174a_2.PDF home education, research, sociology, philosophy, curriculum Author’s abstract retrieved 4/19/04 online http://convention.allacademic.com/aera2004/view_paper_info.html?pub_id=5174&part_id1=10410: “Education in the U.S. is traditionally seen as a public good, one that not only benefits society by promoting the most able to the most challenging positions, but also by establishing common cultural beliefs. Children go to school to learn to become good American citizens. The experience of school itself should support democracy. However, the growing home school movement challenges these notions of where democracy begins, and how it is supported. If schools are seen to play such a vital role in preserving democracy, what will happen if the trend of more home schoolers continues? This paper addresses beliefs about education, community, and democracy, and examines the tensions between beliefs and practices. This research suggests that education outside of traditional schools can support democratic ideals.” Author said at roundtable that her findings are that homeschooling is democratic in that it fosters individual responsibility, and she said that homeschoolers who stay home to be with their children have such a deep care/love for their children that they "redefine the meaning of love." She said that families participating in public-funded homeschooling (in California) is undemocratic because it puts organizational and bureaucratic pressures on families to be more of a bookwork/bureaucratic family (and not unschooling) and this state-controlled homeschooling bureaucracy is a bother to them; she says they participate in tax-funded homeschooling because they are unsure of themselves and their own abilities to teach; finds that this public-school homeschooling is undemocratic in that some of the homeschoolers have an atttitude of "we just have to do the workbook and get the public-funded computer and get the school paperwork done for the public schools without critically thinking about what we are doing or why and homeschool parents still have in their heads that public school classes "finish the math book" by the end of the year when they really do not; but, she added, even these public-school homeschoolers also get art, music, and science more than do those in institutional public schools and homeschoolers get a broader/richer curriculum; reports they are also undemocratic in that homeschooling focuses on the individual and his/her learning style and not on shared/selfless experiences.) .
Bredekamp, Sue. (Ed.) 1988 NAEYC position statement on developmentally appropriate practice in the primary grades, serving 5- through 8-Year olds. In Young Children, January 1988, 64-84. early childhood education, formal education, schooling The article is excerpted from NAEYC's [The National Association for the Education of Young Children] new expanded edition of Developmentally appropriate practice in early childhood programs serving children from birth through age 8, edited by Sue Bredekamp.
Brendan, Stocklin, & Enright Fall-Winter 1990-1991 Constitutionalism and the rule of law: New Hampshire's home schooling quandary. Educational Freedom, 24(1), 24-38. home education
Breshears, Shirley Mae May, 1996 Characteristics of home schools and home school families in Idaho. Unpublished doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, University of Idaho, Moscow. home education, research, demographics, reasons Provides descriptive statistics on family income, number of children, education level of parents, reasons for home schooling, satisfactions of parents, and so forth. Average income is $40,000, parents have two years of college, average of 3 children, 64% plan to home educate children through high school, 99% of families attend religious services on regular basis, children watch television average of 1.15 hours per day, 75% of parents read aloud to children every day, reasons for home educating [two main categories were positive reasons for home schooling and removing children from public schools for a variety of reasons; main reasons were to provide the best education possible for children [50%], include teaching family values and morals which are Bible-based and God-centered [24%], parents hoped to be influential in children’s character development, and wanting the Bible or Christian teaching to be an integral part of their curriculum [26%], greatest satisfaction was a close-knit family, hardest thing to accomplish is time management, 37% plan to take advantage of Idaho law which allows for dual enrollment in public and home schools, most emphasized subjects are reading/English, math, and Bible. Finds that 36% of the homeschool parents she studied “... said they were satisfied with home schooling because it allows the parent and child to develop a close relationship which includes being able to see the ‘light go on’ when the child catches on to a concept being taught. The comments related to the close parent/child relationship indicated parents know they are meeting the child’s social, spiritual, and educational needs in the best way possible” [p. 74]. Furthermore, the researcher found that “Twenty percent of the respondents [parents] listed family unity as a satisfying part of the home school experience. This includes building family values together, an education where the child can learn at their own pace in a non-threatening atmosphere, parents can know what is being taught, and parents are able to learn with the children or at least to review the material as their children learn it” [p. 74].
Brewer, T. Jameson 2021 Homeschooling: A Guidebook of Practices, Claims, Issues, and Implications. Brill Guides to Scholarship in Education, Volume: 6. United States: Brill.com homeschooling, home schooling, home education, review, philosophy, statism Publisher’s online description: “In this volume, the author offers an exploratory analysis of the history of homeschooling in the United States, current curricular practices, religious and political rationales for homeschooling, a critique of the claims by homeschooling advocates that the practice leads to greater efficiency and effectiveness, and what homeschooling and individualistic-oriented approaches mean for society. Teaching the next generation at home is, with little doubt, the oldest form of educating children. Yet, this simplistic understanding of “homeschooling” does not adequately capture the growth of homeschooling as a practice in the 21st century nor is it a widely accessible form of “school choice” for most families. While many parents keep their children out of formal schooling – public and private – for myriad reasons, what is clear is that homeschooling is the epitome of a conceiving of education as an individualistic good – a commodity – that can, or should, be done outside of a conception of the common good, a reasonable understanding of teaching as a profession, and the elevation of ideological echo chambers of information which can have deleterious impacts on the students who are homeschooled and society, broadly.” Author promotes a statist and socialistic worldview understanding of the education of children, and portrays homeschool parents as or claims they are overly individualistic and uncaring about their communities, the common good, and society in general, but cannot offer empirical evidence of this implied selfishness of parents who choose home education rather than government- or state-controlled or government- or state-run education and schooling. Author implies that the echo chambers related to institutional state-run schooling are healthier or more beneficial to children and society than are those related to parent-led home-based education. Author’s use (in Chapter 2) of one analysis of data, from non-representative sampling, regarding the abuse of children by one nonprofit organization that promotes more statism and more government control of homeschooling reveals the shoddy scholarship of the author; e.g., the nonprofit reported that any difference they found in abuse rates between the public schooled and homeschooled was not statistically significant but the author of this book reported that homeschool children were at greater risk of harm, which is found to be false when reading the nonprofit’s full report. Another example (in Chapter 2) of the author’s non-scholarship is where he cites an article as being written by Schillinger, Ray, Knapp, and Newman, n.d. but the article, in fact, is not written by those persons but the article is a compilation of information that the website owner patched together while attributing some of it to those persons; this is not scholarship.
Brewer, T. Jameson; & Lubienski, Christopher 2017 Homeschooling in the United States: Examining The rationales for individualizing education. Pro-Posições, 28(2), Retrieved September 5, 2017 from http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?pid=S0103-73072017000200021&script=sci_arttext http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1980-6248-2016-0040. http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?pid=S0103-73072017000200021&script=sci_arttext http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1980-6248-2016-0040 homeschooling, home schooling, home education, academic achievement, history, sociology, politics, opinion, economics, philosophy “Abstract. This article provides an exploratory overview of the history of homeschooling in the United States in addition to examining some of the claims made by advocacy organizations. There are two broad categories of rationales for homeschooling: (1) empirical — claims of greater efficiency, effectiveness, or pedagogical appropriateness; and (2) ideological – often informed by a religious or political disposition. A detailed discussion of both rationales is provided. First examined are claims made by homeschooling advocates related to effectiveness and efficiency, finding that this rationale does not have the same validity that ideological rationales like religion and safety may have. Finally, these rationales are cast against the backdrop of the aims of education as a mechanism for the collective good or for the individual good. Keywords homeschooling; homeschooling claims; collective good; individualization.” Authors commit the fallacy of poisoning the well by labelling research Brian Ray a homeschool advocate; reader must wonder why they do not label other researchers or themselves (e.g., as collectivist, collective/public-goodist or advocate, statist, devotees of Henry Giroux, or socialist); ergo, at one point they appear to be advocates of something but will not clearly reveal it to the reader. Authors cite only one study to falsely claim that “Homeschooling families are, in fact, characterized by a significantly higher median income than families who do not homeschool (Rudner, 1999).” In fact, various studies, taken together, show that that U.S. homeschool families are median income for families with school-age children. “While it is clear that homeschooled students perform well academically – and seemingly outperform their public school peers – what is not clear from the research is a direct causal link between the practice of homeschooling and the outcomes.” Authors suggest ambivalence about their own theoretical framework or fear of clearly promoting any policy when they write, “This brings the debate full circle to a discussion of the role of parents versus the state in overseeing what is best for children. The ideology that interprets rearing and overseeing childhood as the sole responsibility of the parent may facilitate environments not conducive to child safety or learning – even if rare, the concern still exists. On the other hand, the ideology that elevates the state’s role over the parent likely undermines the natural role of the parent in favor of social mechanisms – a practice that would undermine traditional conceptions of the autonomy of the United States family.”
Bridgman, Anne 1986, April 23 Preschool pressure, later difficulties linked in study. Education Week, 5(30), 1, 15. Report on 15-year study by the High/Scope Educational Research Foundation of Ypsilanti, Michigan concerning preschool effects. "... at age 15, those youths who had taken part in highly academic, teacher-controlled preschool programs reported twice as many instances of drug abuse and juvenile delinquency and up to five times as much involvement in property destruction and other violent acts as those who had attended programs stressing child-initiated activities" and the latter "... were more well adjusted generally, participating more in sports and other extracurricular activities and having better relations with their families" [p. 1].
Brimelow, Peter, & Spencer, Leslie 1993, June 7 The National Extortion Association? Forbes. education, teachers' unions, finances, economics Proposes a cause and effect and inverse relationship between the variables of the rise in power of the National Education Association as a teachers' union, teachers' salaries, and the cost of public education and the factors of the quality of public schools and SAT scores. Excellent analysis.
British Columbia Teachers' Federation 1990, September 14-15 Executive committee minutes. Vancouver, BC: Author. policy, teachers union States the federations opposition to home schooling.
British Columbia Teachers' Federation 1994, May 27 Personal communication policy, teachers union supporting statement to BCTF policy on home schooling, written memo from Al Cornes). Vancouver, BC: Author. (States the federations opposition to home schooling.
Bronfenbrenner, Urie 1970 Two worlds of childhood: U.S. and U.S.S.R.. New York, NY: Basic Books.
Brosnan, Peter 1991 Child competencies and family processes in homeschool families. Master’s of Education Thesis, University of Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Brougher, Jean September 8, 1987 Home school: some children never leave their house to go to school. Statesman-Journal, p. 18.
Broughman, Stephen P., & Swaim, Nancy L. 2006, March Characteristics of private schools in the United States: Results from the 2003-2004 Private School Universe Survey [NCES 2006-319]. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences. Retrieved 3/16/06 online http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2006/2006319.pdf. http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2006/2006319.pdf private schools, research, demographics, enrollment, population Authors note regarding the target population of the study: “Organizations or institutions that provide support for home schooling, but do not provide classroom instruction, are not included” [p. 1]. It appears, therefore, that homeschools and homeschool students are not included in this private school survey. “In the fall of 2003, there were an estimated 28,384 private elementary and secondary schools in the United States, a decrease of 889 from the 29,273 schools estimated in the fall of 2001 (table 1 and Broughman and Pugh 2004). Among the 28,384 private schools in existence in 2003–04 there was considerable diversity as to orientation and affiliation. Of the three primary types of private schools—Catholic, other religious, and nonsectarian—other religious schools were the most numerous, followed by Catholic schools, and then nonsectarian. . . . . . An estimated total of 5,122,772 students were enrolled in the nation’s private schools in the fall of 2003, a decrease of 218,741 from the estimated total of 5,341,513 students enrolled in the fall of 2001 (table 7 and Broughman and Pugh 2004). Private school students represented approximately 10 percent of the total public and private elementary and secondary” [p. 2].
Brouilette, Matthew J. 2001, July The case for choice in schooling: Restoring parental control of education. Portland, OR: Cascade Policy Institute. Retrieved 9/5/01 online http://www.CascadePolicy.org/pdf/edref/I_118.pdf. http://www.CascadePolicy.org/pdf/edref/I_118.pdf choice in education, public schools, history, philsophy Among other things, explains the rise of government [“public”] schooling in America and the end of free-market education. Promotes more parental control of education of children. Mentions home schooling a few times.
Browne, Harry 2005, January The Greatest Mistake in American History: Letting Government Educate Our Children. Notes from FEE. Retrieved 2/23/11 from http://fee.org/nff/the-greatest-mistake-in-american-history-letting-government-educate-our-children/. http://fee.org/nff/the-greatest-mistake-in-american-history-letting-government-educate-our-children/ education, public schools, reform, privatization, homeschooling, home education “Why can’t we just improve government programs? The answer is simple: force never works. Not only is coercion morally wrong, unjust and unfair; it is also inefficient. Any businessman knows that success can only be achieved by giving people what they want, not by trying to intimidate them. In other words it is impossible to reform the government schools. And the problem is not the teachers, or the administrators, or even the bureaucrats. The problem is the system. It simply doesn’t work. ….. And yet, according to writer and education researcher John Taylor Gatto, the literacy rate in America was far greater in the early 1800s than it is now. Many parents taught themselves and then “homeschooled” their children. They had no television, no radio, no computers, or any other modern way to learn about the world. People did whatever was necessary for their children, and I am confident they would do so in the future. Fortunately, today, it would be far easier for them” [p. 2].
Brownlee, Shannon, & Miller, Matthew 1997, May 12 Lies parents tell themselves about why they work. U.S. News and World Report, 122(18), 58-64. education, research, day care, parenting Reports on sociologist Arlie Hochschild’s book The Time Bind and explains that parents tell themselves lies such as we both work because we need the money (when most do not), our children are in good day care (while studies show that in most cases they are not), if only companies were more flexible I’d spend more time with my kids (yet most working parents ignore family-friendly policies that are in place), I’d be happy to stay home if my wife earned more income (while few will do so even if given the chance), and if only taxes were lower one of us could stay home with the children (while there is little evidene to support this); Hochschild finds parents do not want to stay home with the incessant demands and the few and little tangible rewards associated with staying home.
Bryant, Cheryl 1991, December 4 Roman Catholic homeschooling in north Texas. Unpublished manuscript by student at University of Dallas, Irving TX. Available from author at P.O. Box 399 Midlothian TX 76065. home education, Roman Catholic, religion
Brynard, Susette 2007 Home schooling as an open-learning educational challenge in South Africa. South African Journal of Education, 27(1), 83–100. home education, homeschooling, public school, partnerships, South Africa, barriers “Abstract: Despite current legislation which makes provision for collaboration between the public school sector and home schooling, it appears that much can still be done to move towards a closer partnership. Consequently, I investigated the possibilities of such a liaison. A literature review on the nature of home schooling in general was conducted as background to a qualitative investigation on the views of parents, educators and other role players of home schooling within the South African context. The findings showed that home schooling was an open learning educational system which provided opportunities to those learners who wished to participate, irrespective of the possible disadvantages. In conclusion it was found that co-operation between the education authorities and home schoolers was in the best interests of the individual's right to learn, and a symbiotic relationship between the two could benefit both of them” [p. 83]. “Because open learning refers to a learning process that eliminates certain obstacles [barriers] in the teaching-learning process (Strydom & Grimsley, 1996:1), home schooling can be regarded as such, but the degree of openness will depend on the way it is implemented (Brynard, 1998:177). Home schooling should never be regarded as a threat to any existing system of education in South Africa, but rather as complementary” (p. 84). “The development of instructional technology, such as the internet and various home schooling computer programs, have contributed to the tendency for parents themselves to provide their children's education, by making it easier [removing or reducing obstacles, barriers] for parents and more interesting for learners. The development of the internet has also helped learners to make contact with other learners and instructional systems world-wide (Natale, 1995:34)” (p. 89.) New notes
Buccini, Cynthia K. 2003 Homeschooled students make the grade at BU [Boston University]. Bostonia, Winter 2003. Retrieved 11/24/04 online http://www.bu.edu/alumni/bostonia/2003/winter/homeschoolers/ http://www.bu.edu/alumni/bostonia/2003/winter/homeschoolers/ home education, college, adult, anecdote “They [the home-educated] tend to be bright — past homeschoolers have been Trustee Scholars and students in The University Professors program, and their average SAT scores and GPAs are higher than their peers'. And they seem to defy the notion that homeschooled students, learning in isolation, fail to acquire the social skills necessary to succeed in college. "The conventional wisdom about homeschooling is that it's something people do privately, in their homes with the doors locked and the window shades drawn," says Mitchell Stevens, an associate professor of educational sociology at New York University and author of Kingdom of Children: Culture and Controversy in the Homeschooling Movement. "But in fact, homeschooling makes it possible for parents and their children to enter the wider community in much more flexible ways. Virtually every homeschooler you meet will give you evidence of exploiting that larger world beyond the conventional classroom. That's why you get the talent that brings kids through the doors of Boston University and Swarthmore and NYU." ….. Stevens agrees that their success is no surprise. "If you think about it, the kinds of skills that are valued in college — the ability to work independently, to generate one's own ideas, to follow through on complex tasks over long periods of time — are the things that homeschooling encourages." These students also are well prepared to interact with adults and students of different ages and backgrounds, he says. "They've spent a lot of time building relationships with people who are quite different from them in terms of age or life experience. I think that serves them well, even on the most rigorous campuses."”
Buchanan, Frederick S. 1976 How compelling is compulsory education? [Review of Compulsory education and the Amish: The right not to be modern]. The Review of Education, 2(4), 358-366.
Buchanan, N. K. (ed.) 2002 Innovative programs and homeschooling to meet the needs of gifted learners, Roeper Review , 24, (4).
Budajczak, Marek 2002 Edukacja domowa [“Home education,” I think]. Poznán, Poland: Rys Studio. home education, Poland, Polish, foreign To this author’s best knowledge, this is the first academic book on homeschooling ever published in Polish. Budajczak was a teaching and research professor in Sociology of Education Department, University of Adam Mickiewicz, when he wrote this book. Cites many research studies from the United States.
Budajczak, Marek 2004 Edukacja domowa. Gdansk, Poland: Gdanskie Wydawnictwo Psychologiczne. home education On home education in Polish; an academic treatise by Poland’s leading academic scholar on the topic of homeschooling.
Buddin, Richard, & Zamarro, Gema 2009, May Teacher qualifications and student achievement in urban elementary schools. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation. Retrieved 7/5/10 from http://www.rand.org/pubs/reprints/2010/RAND_RP1410.pdf. http://www.rand.org/pubs/reprints/2010/RAND_RP1410.pdf Teacher quality, teacher licensure, teacher certification, student achievement, two-level fixed effects, education production function “Abstract Teacher quality is a key element of student academic success, but few specific teacher characteristics influence classroom outcomes. This research examines whether teacher licensure test scores and other teacher attributes affect elementary student achievement. The results are based on longitudinal student-level data from Los Angeles. California requires three types of teacher licensure tests as part of the teacher certification process; a general knowledge test, a subject area test (single subject for secondary teachers and multiple subject for elementary teachers), and a reading pedagogy test for elementary school teachers. The student achievement analysis uses a value-added approach that adjusts for both student and teacher fixed effects. The results show large differences in teacher quality across the school district, but measured teacher characteristics explain little of the difference. Teacher licensure test scores are unrelated to teacher success in the classroom. Similarly, student achievement is unaffected by whether classroom teachers have advanced degrees. Student achievement increases with teacher experience, but the linkage is weak and largely reflects poor outcomes for teachers during their first year or two in the classroom” [p. 2].
Budiansky, Stephen 1994, September 12 10 Billion for Dinner, Please: With technology and free trade, the Earth can defy the doomsayers--and feed twice as many people. U.S. News & World Report. Retrieved Thursday, August 6, 2009 from http://www.usnews.com/usnews/news/articles/940912/archive_012059.htm. http://www.usnews.com/usnews/news/articles/940912/archive_012059.htm
Buehrer, Eric 1995 The public orphanage: How public schools are making parents irrelevant. Dallas, TX: Word Publishing. family, education, some research, public schools Argues that public schools have increasingly taken on the functions and responsibilities of the parents of the family; public schools to parents are like codependents to alcoholics. “Schools are attempting to become the new family for children. But schools are a dysfunctional family. Part of their dysfunction occurs because many of those involved (from politicians to educators) suffer from what could best be described as codependence, a relationship in which one person feels an overwhelming need to take over those responsibilities that should properly be in the hands of someone else. The term is most widely used to describe family members surrounding an alcoholic. Each member of the family, especially the spouse, begins to excuse the alcoholic's behavior and tries to fix the messes he or she makes. Codependents find themselves responding to the irresponsible behavior of the alcoholic by either trying to solve all the problems he or she causes or by being stern controllers of the addict. Either way, the codependent takes on more responsibility to make up or the alcoholic's lack of responsibility and enables that person to continue in his or her problem. This describes the ever-expanding programs in public education. To be sure, many parents act like the irresponsible alcoholic described above. Teachers have a legitimate complaint about the irresponsibility of these parents-their lack of interest and involvement, the lack of support for the student in the home, the lack of communication back [p. 17 ends] to the teacher on the child's progress. Not only are teachers justified in these complaints, they are justified in pointing out the difficulty they have in educating students who come from broken homes, abusive situations, and other family dysfunctions. Teachers are stuck with the mandate of teaching any child who shows up on their doorstep no matter what emotional, mental, and physical condition he or she arrives in [p. 18].” Argues that therefore the public schools must stop trying to do the things that the family should be doing. Provides much documentation.
Bullard, Julie A. 1987, July Characteristics of Montana home schools. Master's (in education) thesis, Northern Montana College. home education, characteristics
Bullard, Julie Anne, Pat Tierney August 6, 1990 Home Schooling: Prevailing Attitudes vs. Recent Facts. Teaching Home. A discussion of the differences between the general perceptions of home-schooling and the actual statistics of Home Schooling families in Montana. Attitudes, Validity, Attitude Change
Bumstead, Richard A. 1979 Educating your child at home: The Perchemlides case. Phi Delta Kappan, 61, 97-100. Review of home schooling law.
Burgess, Sue F. 1985 The legal aspects of home instruction. Dissertation Abstracts International, 46(7), 1785A, 1786A. Ed.D. from The University of North Carolina at Greensboro, 303 pp. Research. Conclusions include: (1) "courts generally uphold compulsory attendance laws" [p. 1785A], (2) "courts rule in favor of parents if fundamental rights are violated" [p. 1785A, 1786A], (3) courts not yet recognized constitutional right to home instruction, (4) arguments based on First Amendment's freedom of religion give little relief from compulsory attendance to home schoolers, (5) arguments based on Fourteenth Amendment's equal protection of the laws give little relief from compulsory attendance, (6) "an effective legal strategy for parents in states where home instruction is legal is to claim they were denied due process" [p. 1786A], (7) many courts finding terms in laws too vague, (8) "in assessing equivalence of home instruction to school attendance, judges focus on curriculum, competence of instructors, adequacy of materials, and regularity of instruction" [p. 1786A], (9) future political activity by home schoolers is expected both in states where home education is permitted and where it is not, and (10) "public school administrators will increasingly come into contact with home-schoolers throughout the 1980's" [p. 1786A].
Burkard, Tom, & O’Keeffe, Dennis 2005 Homeschooling: The case against compulsory school attendance laws. In Bruce S. Cooper (Ed.), Home schooling in full view: A reader, p. 229-249.  Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing.
Burke, A. J. 1984 Students’ potential for learning contrasted under tutorial and group approaches to instruction. Dissertation Abstracts International, 44, 2025A. tutor, tutoring, achievement Addresses tutoring, probably academic achievement
Burke, Arthur, & Wang, Changhua 2010, January A descriptive analysis of Idaho virtual charter school student academic performance from 2004 to 2009. Portland, OR: United States Department of Education, Regional Educational Laboratory (REL) Northwest. http://www.sde.idaho.gov/site/charter_schools/docs/ID%20VCS%20Draft%20Report_v4.pdf charter schools, virtual charter schools, public schools, public schooling at home, academic achievement Formerly available from http://www.sde.idaho.gov/site/charter_schools/docs/ID%20VCS%20Draft%20Report_v4.pdf One purpose of study is to compare academic achievement on the Idaho statewide assessment of students in virtual charter schools to that of students in noncharter public schools. Used scores on Idaho Standards Achievement Tests (ISAT; reading, mathematics, and language usage) and the Direct Assessment in writing and math (DWA/DMA) and demographic information. Organize data into three groups: “brick and mortar” charter schools, virtual charter schools, and other schools. In simple descriptive terms: “Students in virtual charter schools generally achieve proficiency in reading and language arts at lower rates than students in noncharter public schools. Students in virtual charter schools consistently achieve proficiency in mathematics at lower rates than students in noncharter public schools. Students in charter schools generally achieve proficiency at higher rates in all subjects than students in virtual charter schools and noncharter public schools” [p. 12], and, “With the exception of grade 5 reading, and reading and mathematics at grade 10, students in virtual charter schools have lower average achievement than students in noncharter public schools. Differences tend to be larger in mathematics than in reading or language arts. Students in charter schools tend to have higher average levels of achievement than students in the other types of schools” [p. 28]. After controlling for demographic variables such as gender, ethnicity, and economic status, “in all three ISAT subjects and both Direct Assessment subjects a lower percentage of students in virtual charter schools achieved proficiency compared to a matching group of students from public noncharter schools” [p. 43] and these differences were statistically significant.
Burke, Lindsey M. 2019 Bringing achievement home: A review of the academic outcomes of homeschooling students in the United States. Purcellville, VA: Home School Legal Defense Association. homeschooling, home schooling, home education, academic achievement, review, quantitative research, USA “This review of the literature [on the academic achievement effects of homeschooling] builds off reviews conducted by Ray (2017) and Kunzman and Gaither (2013), broadening the inclusion criteria in some aspects and narrowing it in others.20” (p. 5-6). Author reviews both peer-reviewed and non-peer-reviewed articles and report. Author does not review the outcomes of social and emotional development and success in adulthood (other than academic achievement in college/postsecondary education). Provides clear and helpful summary tables that show, e.g., author, year, design, sample size, findings, and whether the findings were positive or negative for homeschool students compared to other students or mixed result. A report, not peer-reviewed.
Burns, Patrick C. 1993, December A profile of selected characteristics of Arizona's home schooling families. Unpublished doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Northern Arizona University.
Buss, Emily 2012, Winter The gap in law between developmental expectations and educational obligations. University of Chicago Law Review, 79(1), 59-81. homeschooling, home education, private education, public education, law, regulation, law, legal, philosophy “To the extent any concrete and enforceable obligations to educate are imposed on parents or the state, these obligations are more narrowly focused on the conventional business of schools. Even within this narrower focus, educational obligations are thin, and only weakly enforced. While compulsory attendance laws require parents to send their children to school, the requirement commonly ends at age sixteen or seventeen—short of high school graduation, and well short of the education generally required for conventional adult success in our society.41 And even those school attendance requirements are readily waived where parents choose to teach their children at home. For home-schooled children, state oversight of that home education is generally minimal, and decreasing” [p. 69]. “The more serious limitation to state’s and parents’ educational obligations is the lack of connection between those obligations and the developmental expectations manifest in law. To the extent parents and state have any enforceable obligation to educate their children, that obligation is defined in narrow terms of academic achievement that are insufficient to prepare them for those adult rights and responsibilities they will be expected to undertake at eighteen” [p. 70]. “If we are to take greater responsibility for children’s achievement of our developmental expectations, every child-specific legal rule should trigger some reflection. We should ask what changes we expect children to undergo before they are subject to the adult rules and how those changes will occur” [p. 71].)
Buss, Emily, 2000 Without peers? The blind spot in the debate over how to allocate educational control between parent and state. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=224132 http://ssrn.com/abstract=224132 http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.224132 https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.224132 home education, schooling, parent’s rights, parental authority, best interest of child, law, legal, psychology, philosophy, regulation, policy, negative criticism, negative critc U of Chicago Public Law Working Paper No. 08. Retrieved 3/26/07 online http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=224132. Also available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=224132 or DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.224132. Online abstract: “Courts, policy makers and scholars have long struggled with the question of how to allocate educational control between parents and the state, particularly where parents' preferences are religiously motivated. While the debate reflects a broad range of viewpoints, these viewpoints share a common blind spot: They focus on the state's interest in imparting certain knowledge and skills, and ignore the state's interest in facilitating interactions among ideologically diverse peers. This paper argues that, particularly for older adolescents, the nature of their peer interactions has a far bigger impact on their development than does the content of their curriculum. Drawing on the psychological literature of child development, the paper suggests that exposing these older adolescents to ideologically unlike peers will facilitate identity development that best balances their interest in maintaining a sense of affiliation with their parent's religious community, on the one hand, and their interest in exercising autonomy in the making of religious choices, on the other. The paper raises questions about the appropriateness of home schooling and even private religious schools in the late teenage years, and considers measures short of prohibiting such forms of education that might encourage ideological mixing among these students.” “As significant as the courts decisions on home schooling are the legislative trends. Increasingly, states are abandoning educational requirements such as certification that make it difficult or impossible for parents to home school their children. Increasingly, regulations are crafted to serve the limited purpose of ensuring that children acquire the basic knowledge and academic skills offered in school. Increasingly, states are enacting provisions which expressly recognize parents’ right to home school, so long as they provide an “equivalent education,” or teach for an equivalent period of time” [p. 8]. “It does, however, suggest that courts and theorists alike have missed a big piece of children’s developmental experience, which, when taken into account, demands a fresh look at how we strike the balance between parent and State in the battle over educational control” [p. 46] but provides no research evidence that those adolescents not spending more time with peers are less prepared for “… a successful adulthood” [p. 45]. Is anti-parental rights from a Judeo-Christian and biblical worldview.
Butler, Robert W. 1994, July Home schooling: An effective setting for programmed learning. Unpublished doctoral (Ed.D.), California Coast University, Santa Ana, CA. home education, research, academic achievement, public schools, conventional schools In terms of standardized achievement test scores, the home educated who used programmed learning scored about 15 percentile points better than those using programmed learning in conventional schools and slightly better than home education students using other curriculum approaches. Statistical tests of significance not employed.
Butler, Shery 2000, September The “H” Word: Home Schooling. Gifted Child Today, 23(5), 44-50. http://gct.sagepub.com/content/23/5/44.short homeschooling, gifted, talented, computer, public services “Abstract: As a public educator, I frowned on parents who chose to teach their children at home—until I became one of those parents. My family moved to a rural town because of my husband's job. When my children entered the public school system, I was surprised to find limited services for the gifted and talented. Students with above-average ability were allowed unlimited access to the library and the Chapter One computer lab until school officials cited regulations that only students in the gifted program were permitted to use the lab. No other computers were available to students at the school” (retrieved 7/11/13 from http://gct.sagepub.com/content/23/5/44.short).
Butts, R. R. 1974 Public education and political community. History of Education Quarterly, 14, 165-183. A critique of current histories of education, with a plea for more research into the extent to which schools have contributed to political socialization.
Cahen, Leonard S., & Filby, Nikola N. 1979 The class size/achievement issue: New evidence and a research plan. Phi Delta Kappan, 60, 492-495, 538. Class size. Research.
Caldwell, Deborah Kovach 1999, January 30 Death to the schools: Leaders of religious right calling for a Christian exodus out of public education. Dallas Morning News , p. 1G. educational reform, policy, home schooling, private schools, opinion, separation of school and state, values, religion “Leaders of a rapidly growing movement of conservative Christians are urging followers to withdraw their children from public schools by next year in order to bring down the government school system. At least four organizations have sprung up around the country in recent months to press parents to abandon what fund-raising letters describe as ‘atheistic’ and ‘unclean’ public schools in favor of home schooling and Christian academies.” “This is dangerous hogwash, said Lee Berg, an expert on the religious right at the National Education Association in Washington. ‘Public education happens to be the foundation of democracy,’ said Dr. Berg ... ‘It’s where our diverse society learns to live with each other.’” “Dr. Berg also said some Christians use that explanation [that public schools undermine Christian values and teaching] as a cover for their real reasons for pushing home schooling and Christian academies in an attempt to abolish state-sponsored education: dislike of ethnic and racial minorities who attend public schools and a desire to make money by opening private schools that will need supplies and curricula.” Note: in personal communication with Lee Berg on July 28, 1999, he told me [Brian Ray] he has no hard data to show a correlational or causal link between home schooling and racism or white flight. The reporter says, “The movement is gathering steam at a time when the nation’s public schools are already under siege. Many schools are battling high-profile problems with violence, drugs, racial strife, funding and poor educational performance while facing challenges from the growing support for school voucher programs and charter schools.” The movement has gained the support of some influential conservative leaders and Christians. Movement leaders say that the culture cannot be renewed unless the education of children is done according to biblical teaching. Rev. E. Raymond Moore, founder of Exodus 2000, said, “We’re trying to stop pornography and eradicate abortion, and yet we have not been obedient to God on the biblical mandate for educating our own children. Perhaps the renewal of the culture could be as simple as the Christian church renewing its obedience to that biblical mandate” and he said “... if evangelical Christians exited en masse, ‘this event could seriously cripple the power [that] secularism now holds over our culture by holding our children as near-hostages in state schools.’” Marshall Fritz, founder of the movement and of the Separation of School and State Alliance and a Catholic, said, “There is no peaceful solution to the school wars other than the separation of school and state.”
Callaway, Sean 2004, Fall Unintended admission consequences of federal aid for homeschoolers. Journal of College Admission., No. 185, 22-28.
Callihan, David, & Callihan, Laurie 2000 The guidance manual for the Christian home school: A parent's guide for preparing home school students for college or career. Franklin Lakes, NJ: Career Press. home education, adults, adulthood, graduates, college, career Helps Christian homeschool parents gather all the information a high school guidance counselor usually supplies and helps parents make progress in getting their children where they want them to go as they prepare to lead them into the wider world.
Campbell, D. T., & Stanley, J. C. 1963 Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for research. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin Co.
Campbell, Joel 2003 Heritage of the Lord or creature of the state? Promoting parental rights in the modern era. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the National Christian Home Educators Leadership Conference, Virginia Beach, Virginia, September 24-27, 2003. philosophy, legal Home education, law
Canadian Gallup Poll Ltd. 1984 Gallup summary report. Edmonton, Alberta: Canadian Gallup Poll Ltd. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED251171). Includes topic of home schooling.
Cannon, Inge 1991 Educational funding. Frontline, 1(2), 20-22. home education, policy, legal, choice, private schools, vouchers, tax credits "History has proven that the only way we can keep our schools truly free from government...and intervention is to remain distinctly apart from any form of government aid or support" (p. 22).
Cannon, Inge P. 1998 Exploring the apprenticeship option for vocational training. In Mentoring your teen: Charting the course to successful adulthood by Ronald Jay and Inge Cannon. Taylors, SC: Education Plus. apprenticeship, vocational training, vocation “Historically, apprenticeship connotes "training in an art, trade, or craft, under a legal agreement defining the relationship between master and learner and the duration and conditions of their relationship." [Encyclopedia Britannica] European custom dating back to the Renaissance generally earmarked four stages in the apprenticeship hierarchy: novice, journeyman, craftsman, and master.” “As your teen moves through his apprenticeship experience, you'll find that the balance of responsibilities will shift from primarily academic content (terms and basic textbooks) to primarily "hands on" applications. However, in true apprenticeship there is never a time when the work should be exclusively textbook and research or exclusively "hands on." The secret to effective apprenticeship is a constant blend of both.”
Cannon, Inge P. 1999 Mentoring your teens. Education Plus, PO Box 1350, Taylors SC 29687. education, home education, teens, teenagers, mentoring Course on audiotapes with a syllabus on mentoring teenagers.
Cannon, Inge P. & Wayne, Janet & Pakes, Sandra, Ph.D. 1991 Awarding diplomas & administering standardized tests: How can your state help? testing
Capital Area School Development Association (CASDA) 1987, July 16 Annual school law conference. Albany, NY: University at Albany. (ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED292173) Constitutional Law, Court Litigation, Home Schooling, Principals, Public Schools, Religious Factors, Religious Organizations Contains four presentations: (1) "Preserving Diversity in Our Public Schools: Implications of the Alabama Textbook Case and the Tennessee Textbook Case" (Jay Worona); (2) "Law and Student Discipline" (Gunter Duly); (3) "Constitutional Rights of Teachers and Students" (Melvin H. Osterman, Jr); and (4) "Avoiding the Frustrations of the Education Law, Section 3020-a Process" (Jeffrey M. Selchick).
Cappello, Nancy M., Mullarney, Patrick B., & Cordeiro, Paula A. 1995 School choice: Four case studies of home school families in Connecticut. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco CA, April 18-24. research, home education, public schools, policy, special needs, disabilities, special education, cooperation Case study methodology found that "...families used a variety of teaching and assessment methods in their home schools; home schooled children behaved like typical kids as they were being taught; and principals were more supportive of home schooling than superintendents and central office administrators, including offering part-time enrollment options to home school students. Implications for future policy decisions are presented such as dual enrollment options and home schooling students with disabilities" [p. I, ii]. Promotes cooperation between home educators and public schools. Findings similar to another researcher that "... most [public school] administrators do not believe the data on the academic and socialization benefits of home schooling. In order for these myths to be dispelled, it is critical that current research on home schooling be presented to school administrators" [p. 47].
Cappello, Nancy Marcucci 1995 School choice: Four case studies of home school families in Connecticut. Doctoral dissertation, University of Connecticut at Storrs. research, home education, special needs, special education Includes topic of special needs or special education, uses case studies. Purpose was to examine how and why parents decide to home educate, how are home schools conducted, how do parents provide opportunities for children to socialize with friends and peers, what is the relationship between the families and local school districts, how do public school officials who monitor home instruction perceive home schooling and portfolio assessment, and what would be reasons these families would send or return their children to private or public schools. "...families who home school were serious about their choice to do so. They have committed time, money, and energy to provide their children an education that they believed was superior. In this study, there was observable evidence that children were achieving and that they were not isolated socially. The findings also suggest that the community of home school families, through their local support networks, are a great source of support for home school families; providing academic and socialization options for their children. On a limited budget, these industrious families have searched for materials and resources to enhance their children's learning and achievement" [p. 217]. "...school district personnel, especially superintendents and central office administrators were firm in their beliefs that home schooling could not provide a suitable educational experience and that home schooling children were disadvantaged socially. There is a disparity in what this research found and what superintendents and most school officials believe. ..... In order for these myths to be dispelled, it is critical that current research on home schooling be presented to school administrators" [pp. 217-218]. Encourages cooperation and partnerships between public school districts and home schoolers.
Cardel, Michelle; Willig, Amanda L.; Dulin-Keita, Akilah; Casazza, Krista; Cherrington, Andrea; Gunnarsdottir, Thrudur; Johnson, Susan L.; Peters, John C.; Hill, James O. Hill; Allison, David B. Allison; Fernández, José R. 2013 Home-schooled children are thinner, leaner, and report better diets relative to traditionally schooled children. Obesity: A Research Journal, 21(??), 1-7. homeschooling, homeschool, public school, conventional school, traditional school, health, weight, obesity, diet, cross-sectional design Cross-sectional study. Recruited “… 95 children aged 7-12 years, self-identified as non-Hispanic white (NHW) who were recruited in Birmingham, Alabama from 2005-2009. Recruitment was conducted at schools, churches, health fairs, and through newspapers, parent magazines, radio, and participant referrals. We did not employ recruitment strategies specifically designed to over-sample home-schooled children, and the majority of these children were recruited via participant referrals” (p. 2). Literature review states: “Rather, food eaten at home has been shown to provide more energy from low-nutrient, energy-dense foods than food eaten at school or other locations (16), suggesting that children who spend more time at home may be at risk for excessive weight gain” (p. 1) but did found that homeschool children were, if anything, less at-risk than institutionally schooled children. “Therefore, we examined whether HSC are at increased risk for excess adiposity and compare postulated modifiable determinants of child weight status (e.g., dietary factors, physical activity) between HSC [homeschooled children] and TSC [traditionally schooled children]” (p. 2). Between HSC and TSC, between HSC and TSC and controlled for age, sex, pubertal stage, and SES. “Abstract: Objective To examine and compare the relationships among diet, physical activity, and adiposity between home-schooled children (HSC) and traditionally schooled children (TSC). Design and Methods Subjects were HSC (n = 47) and TSC (n = 48) aged 7-12 years old. Dietary intakes were determined via two 24-h recalls and physical activity was assessed with 7 days of accelerometry. Fat mass (FM), trunk fat, and percent body fat (%BF) were measured by dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA). Results Relative to HSC, TSC demonstrated significantly higher BMI percentiles, FM, trunk fat, and %BF; consumed 120 total kilocalories more per day; and reported increased intakes of trans fats, total sugar, added sugars, calcium, and lower intakes of fiber, fruits, and vegetables (P < 0.05). At lunch, TSC consumed significantly more calories, sugar, sodium, potassium, and calcium compared to HSC (P < 0.05). Physical activity did not differ between groups. Traditional schooling was associated with increased consumption of trans fat, sugar, calcium (P < 0.05); lower intakes of fiber, and fruits and vegetables (P < 0.05); and higher FM, %BF, and trunk fat (P < 0.01), after adjustment for covariates. Conclusions These data suggest HSC may consume diets that differ in energy and nutrient density relative to TSC, potentially contributing to differences in weight and adiposity.” “Based on the daily energy need requirements outlined in Dietary Guidelines for Americans (28), both TSC and HSC were consuming excess calories. TSC reported greater consumption of excess calories (420 kcal/day) relative to daily overconsumption by HSC (300 kcal/day) [p. 3].” “Herein, we compared associations of diet, physical activity, and adiposity in home-schooling and traditional-schooling. Contrary to our hypotheses, TSC reported significantly higher energy intakes (both daily and at lunchtime meals), poorer diet quality, and higher levels of adiposity when compared to HSC, despite no differences in physical activity between the groups. Our findings suggest that HSC and TSC differ in regards to diet and adiposity parameters, but do not differ in time spent engaged in moderate to vigorous physical activity [p. 6].” “Higher intakes of calcium in the traditional school group, however, are beneficial and could be protective against the development of obesity (34), though neither group is reaching current recommendations for daily calcium intakes (28). With the exception of TSC consuming more calcium relative to HSC, to the extent that study variables describe diet quality, it appears TSC report poorer diet quality relative to HSC. One possible reason for this observation may be due to the school food environment” [p. 6]. “Robust measures of physical activity for 7 days indicated that there were no differences in time spent engaged in moderate to physical activity between HSC and TSC. This is consistent with research demonstrating physical activity did not differ between groups over 3 days, despite lower physical fitness in HSC relative to TSC (18 [reference])” [p. 6]. “In summary, given the large portion of time children spend at school; educational environments have the potential to impact nutritional intakes and physical activity levels. Though physical activity did not differ between groups, our data suggests that HSC are thinner, leaner, and report better diets compared to TSC. Large, longitudinal research studies are needed to further identify the etiology of the observed disparities in obesity-related variables between HSC and TSC” [p. 7]. Found that, if anything, TSC more at-risk than HSC. Personal e-mail communication from Cardel on December 2, 2013: 12/2/13 "Unfortunately, this was a secondary analysis of a much larger study and we did not collect comprehensive information regarding the children’s school information.  We were not able to collect private vs. public so that group was all compiled into the “Traditionally-schooled group.”.”
Carden, Phil 2002, May 4 Running a home in a schoolhouse: Something new in Tennessee education. The Tennessean [newspaper]. Published 5/4/02 and retrieved 2/14/03 online http://www.tennessean.com/local/archives/02/05/17897938.shtml. http://www.tennessean.com/local/archives/02/05/17897938.shtml home education, history, reasons, anecdote Repring of an article that originally appeared in The Nashville Tennessean Magazine on June 7, 1953 about a family that decided to homeschool or teach their children at home circa 1953.
Cardus 2019, September 19 2018 US Cardus Education Survey: Perceptions of high school experience and preparedness for life. Hamilton, Ontario, Canada: Author. https://www.cardus.ca/research/education/reports/cardus-education-survey-2018-perceptions-of-high-school-experience-and-preparedness-for-life/ private education, public school, Christian school, Christian education, homeschool, homeschooling, comparative research, graduates, adults, adults who were homeschooled, civic involvement, demographics, attitudes, satisfaction in life Retrieved December 27, 2019 from https://www.cardus.ca/research/education/reports/cardus-education-survey-2018-perceptions-of-high-school-experience-and-preparedness-for-life/ “The 2018 Cardus Education Survey (CES) marks nearly a decade’s worth of research into the effects of various school sectors on the academic, social, religious, and civic development of graduates in the United States. The Survey is now considered one of the most significant measures of nongovernment school outcomes. Cardus Education Survey reports capture the views from a representative sample of 1,500 randomly selected American high school graduates ages twenty-four to thirty-nine who were asked to complete a thirty-five- to forty-five-minute survey” (p. 1). “1. The 2018 CES respondents include 904 graduates who primarily attended public high schools, 83 respondents who primarily attended non-religious private schools, 303 graduates of a Catholic high school, 136 graduates of an evangelical Protestant school, and 124 who were homeschooled [and I am pretty sure that a sub-group of these were considered “religious homeschoolers”]. In order to isolate the school effect for each of [p. 1 ends here] these sectors, the analysis includes a large number of control variables for basic demographics (gender, race and ethnicity, age and region of residence), family structure (not living with each biological parent for at least sixteen years, parents divorced or separated, not growing up with two biological parents), parent variables (educational level of mother and father figure, whether parents pushed the respondent academically, the extent to which the respondent felt close to each parent figure), and the religious tradition of parents when the respondent was growing up (mother or father was Catholic, conservative Protestant, conservative or traditional Catholic). A control was also included for the number of years a private school graduate spent in public school [but did they include this control for homeschool students?]. Despite our efforts to construct a plausible control group, because families who send their children to religious schools or non-religious independent schools make a choice, they may differ from those who do not exercise school choice in unobservable ways that are therefore not accounted for in our study. Despite this, the CES use of an extensive survey instrument, together with its comprehensive application of control variables and resulting patterns of outcomes, assures us with a 90 percentile confidence interval for each coefficient of the accuracy of our school sectoral outcomes” (p. 2). On most measures, the homeschooled perceive their experiences and readiness for life (e.g., perceptions of high school experience, of high school climate, of were “perfectly well” prepared for interaction with culture and society, “perfectly or very well prepared for their job”) more positively than those from other schooling sectors/types. “Protestant school graduates and religious homeschool graduates felt less prepared for university than public school graduates.” Cross-sectional explanatory design, representative samples.
Cardus 2018 U.S. Cardus Education Survey: From the classroom to the workplace. Retrieved May 4, 2020 from https://www.cardus.ca/research/education/reports/cardus-education-survey-2018-from-the-classroom-to-the-workplace/ https://www.cardus.ca/research/education/reports/cardus-education-survey-2018-from-the-classroom-to-the-workplace/ homeschool, homeschooling, home schooling, graduates, graduation, occupation, research “The 2018 Cardus Education Survey (CES) marks nearly a decade’s worth of research into the effects of various school sectors on the academic, social, religious, and civic development of graduates in the United States. The Survey is now considered one of the most significant measures of nongovernment school outcomes. CES reports capture the views from a representative sample of 1,500 randomly selected American high school graduates ages twenty-four to thirty-nine who were asked to complete a thirty-five to forty-five-minute survey. The assessment comes at an important time—far enough away for these graduates to have had experiences in other educational institutions, in family and relationships, and in the workplace, and yet close enough to allow for some maturity, reflection, and recollection. The CES instrument includes a large number of controls for many factors in graduate development, such as parental education, religion, and income, in order to isolate a school sector’s particular impact (“the schooling effect”)” (p. 1). “Five smaller reports summarize the results of the 2018 survey. They focus on particular outcomes and themes of interest, including the following: (1) education and career pathways; …” (p. 2), this report. Religious homeschoolers are less likely than the public schooled to have taken certain science, math, and foreign language courses, but religious homeschoolers have higher grades in college. “The homeschooling sector is marked by a lot of variation. Religious homeschool graduates are likely to be found in entry-level as well as managerial or executive positions.” Religious homeschool graduates report lower household income than others.
Carin, A. A., & Sund, R. B. 1989 Teaching science through discovery (6th ed.). Columbus, OH: Merrill Publishing Co.
Carlson, Allan 1995 Preserving the family for the new millennium: A policy agenda. The Family in America, 9(3), 1-8. policy, home, family, home education "The most important of these reclaimed functions is the education of children. The autonomous household bears the obligation and natural power to transmit to children the spiritual doctrines and beliefs of the family, the customs and folkways by which the household lives, the practical skills necessary for the later creation of new households, and the knowledge required for successful engagement in the world of commerce. While outside agencies such as parent-controlled or religious schools can be usefully employed for part of these tasks, those households fail which abdicate the bulk of them to others. The education of children must be home-centered, where parents impart their visions, values, virtues, and skills to the new generation. These statements reinforce the historical significance of home schooling, rising throughout the globe in the last decade of the Second Millennium, as the necessary and powerful step in family reconstruction. Households, in turn, adhere to kin groups—extended or "stem" families—that give focus to ambition and talent, and grant protection to individuals from the grand ambitions of ideologues. These kin groups, in turn, form communities: villages, towns, or neighborhoods. A society of households and kin groups allows for a diversification of skills, within a context of general competence and an expectation of fair exchange. In such communities, the individual internalizes restraints on behavior, and children receive a kind of communal rearing in which the sharp edges or peculiarities found in each household can be tempered. This sense of close community also offers the only effective protection of individuals from pathologies within households, allowing a kind of social intervention to occur without threatening the normative pattern of family living" (p. 7, 8).
Carlson, Allan 1996 Will the separation of school and state strengthen families? Some evidence from fertility patterns, by Alan Carlson. https://nheri.org/home-school-researcher-will-the-separation-of-school-and-state-strengthen-families-some-evidence-from-fertility-patterns/ research, home education, history, demographics, sociology, fertility, parents Home School Researcher, 12(2), 1-5, https://nheri.org/home-school-researcher-will-the-separation-of-school-and-state-strengthen-families-some-evidence-from-fertility-patterns/ Explains that “From the very beginning, public school advocates aimed—as they had to—at undermining and displacing the family as the center of children's lives” and “Horace Mann of Massachusetts, . . . . . linked the `common school’ system to a vision of the total welfare state, where government simply assumed the role of parent. As he wrote in his school report for 1846:  `Massachusetts is parental in her government. More and more, as year after year rolls by, she seeks to substitute prevention for remedy, and rewards for penalties’” (p. 1). “But there is direct evidence of a strong linkage between the spread of mass state education and the decline of the family” (p. 2). “The state school, he [Norman Ryder] writes, serves as modern society's agent in the release of the individual from obligations to kin” (p. 3). “Ryder's work underlines here the vital importance of specific functions to family institutional strength. When families educate their own children, serve as the focus of religious life, and/or raise the largest share of their own food, the persons in these families are more likely to fix on them their first loyalties on the home. When these functions pass over to rival institutions, families lose these claims and so diminish as institutions when compared to their rivals. So we can indict, with justice, state education as a direct cause of family decline” (p. 3). Claims that the Roman Catholics, the Old Order Amish, and home educators are “laboratory experiments” of quasi-separation (from state-run education) and whether families in these situations can grow stronger. “Home education, viewed in this context, represents the return of a central function to the family. And as any home educator can testify, it also forces a fundamental reorganization of the family: in terms of the behavior of all its members, its relationship to the outside world, and its internal psychology. In short, home schooling families discover what it feels like to be `reinstitutionalized.’ I also would hypothesize that the act or intent of home schooling stimulates marital fertility, the standard measure of family renewal used in this paper” and “. . . in some respects the economic gain to the family of maintaining one parent as a teacher in the home increases with each additional child” (p. 4). Maintains that, “Home-schooling may be logical, but it is not easy, for it demands a stance athwart the pressures of modern state capitalism not dissimilar to that of the Amish. Not every family who begins the process succeeds. But those who do persevere will contain, I believe, both better parents and better children in the end” (p. 4).
Carlson, Allan 1997, October 20 The new pioneers. Citizen [published by Focus on the Family], 10-13. home education, history, research Discusses home education, home schooling, homeschooling.
Carlson, Allan 2001, March “The task for conservatism”: Family lessons from the New Agrarians. The Family in America, 15(3), 1-6. home education, family, sociology, agrarian Summarizes parts of his recent book The New Agrarian mind: The movement toward decentralist thought in 20th-century America by examining the positive and negative lessons to be drawn from the 20th-century Agrarian experience. Suggests nine positive lessons and four negative lessons. “The fourth negative lesson is the unexpected power of home schooling as a tool to restore and renew families and subsistence communities. From Bailey and Zimmerman to Agar and Berry, the Agrarian imagination faltered on the question of education. While all understood that the weakness of families derived, in large part, from the prior surrender of key family functions, none saw the possibility of restoring home-based education as a first step toward family reconstruction. Nor did they see that this step would be bonded to other actions of self-sufficiency, ranging from home births and maternal nursing to home gardens and simple [p. 5 ends] animal husbandry. Most of the agrarians called instead for curricular reforms in the existing schools. Even Ralph Borsodi, who successfully “home schooled” his own children in the 1920’s, failed to see its universal potential, calling instead for group education led by a new elite. [emphasis in original] [p. 6].”
Carlson, Allan 2002, April Toward a theory of the autonomous family. The Family in America, 16(4), 1-6. family, home education, sociology, political science, philosophy Author writes about this article: “Rather than a description of the current American social system, it [this version of the ‘fully traditional family’] might be seen as a vision of an alternate reality: one that might that might have existed before, one that may exist in some places today, and one that could exist again” [p. 1]. Discusses “the first societal bond: marriage,” “the second natural bond: the household,” “the power of household production,” “the third societal bond: the community,” “the fourth societal bond: the state,” and “the broadest societal bond: the nation.” Explains under topic of the household, “A central function of the household is the education of children, for which parents, supplemented by extended kin, are responsible. The household bears the obligation and natural authority to transmit to children the spiritual doctrines and beliefs of the family, the customs and folkways by which the household lives, the practical skills necessary for the later creation and sustenance of new households, and the knowledge required for successful engagement in the world of commerce. While outside agencies, such as apprenticeships and parent-controlled schools, may be usefully employed for part of these tasks, those households fail which abdicate the bulk of them to others. The education of children, properly engaged, must be home-centered, where parents impart their visions, values, virtues, and skills to the new generation. Relative to the world, each household exists as a small collective, organized on the principle of altruism. The members of a household share with each other on the basis of love and altruism without any accounting of individual gain or loss. Under some circumstances, this same principle of justice may extend to other kin, or even to small communities, where the generosity and altruism can be tempered by a practical knowledge of individual character and the discipline which a tight-knit community can bring to bear on its members. This form of small scale organization may exact a price through the loss of efficiency, but it more than recovers this cost through the emotional rewards that household and community life bring” [p. 4].
Carlson, Allan C. 1993 From cottage to work station: The family's search for social harmony in the industrial age. San Francisco, CA: Ignatius Press. history, research, family, home, home education, technology, economics Book. Interprets American social history while emphasizing the vital role of the family and household autonomy and the threats to the family imposed by industrial organization and the state. Holds that the U.S. was born an agrarian society, rather than a progressive consumerist society, composed of independent households rooted in land, lineage, and hierarchy. Explains that the social effects of industrialization, especially the divorce of labor from the home, has been a defining issue in American domestic life from the 1850s to the present. Traces the nature of the conflict between social harmony, especially focusing on the family, and industry. States his premises up front and clearly in the introduction, then states that he sees divergences from the family order of the past "...as a falling away from the universal [good] model rather than merely as change" (p. 5). Chapter one summarizes the assaults on family autonomy, while later chapters outline various attempts (e.g., "the family wage experiment," "the suburban strategy," "the religious possibility," "the `cold war' family," and "the professional temptation") to protect or advance the good family model and critically examines these five strategies to restore a foundation for family life in industrial society. “The first direct assault on family autonomy grew out of the reform school movement during the 1830’s. This movement, centered in the early years in New York and Pennsylvania, advocated removing poor and so-called neglected or delinquent children from parents and placing them in institutions to “prevent” them from entering a life of crime. In 1839, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court declared such actions constitutional. Twisting an ancient concept of English chancery law designed to protect the estates of orphaned minors, the court established a new doctrine in American law: parens patriae, literally “the parenthood of the state.” Justifying the termination of parental rights, the justices stated: “May not the natural parents, when unequal to the task of education or unworthy of it, be supplanted by the parens patriae, or common guardianship of the community?” This elevation of the state over the family rapidly expanded into a sweeping usurpation of American liberties. As the Illinois Supreme Court ruled in 1882: [quote begins, indented] It is the unquestioned right and imperative duty of every enlightened government, in its character of parens patriae, to protect and provide for the comfort and well-being of such of its citizens as, by reason of infancy, defective understanding, or other misfortune or infirmity, are unable to take care of themselves. The performance of this duty is justly regarded as one of the most important of governmental functions, and all constitutional limitations must be so understood and construed so as not to interfere with its proper and legitimate exercise. [quote ends] [new paragraph] Through logic of this sort, the family was stripped of elemental legal protection. [new paragraph] The same spirit animated the public school movement and the compulsory education laws that gave this movement power. Horace Mann and his fellow common-school enthusiasts sought to use state education to immerse the new Irish Catholic immigrants in Massachusetts in a special mix of religious Unitarianism [p. 18 ends] and political liberalism. At a deeper level, the school reforms cut into the fabric of the family economy, stripping children in large part of their economic value and removing parents from control of their offsprings’ [sic] upbringing. [new paragraph] The proponents of state schooling were rarely reticent about their motives. As one South Carolina school inspector, in arguing for a compulsory attendance law, explained in 1912: “The schools exist primarily for the benefit of the State rather than for the benefit of the individual. The State seeks to make every citizen intelligent and serviceable.” He mocked concern about “the sacred rights and personal privileges” of parents who kept their children at home: [quote begins, indented] The State has the right to carry the lawbreaking child to the reformatory or to jail to protect society. Has not the State as much right to carry the child to the school ... to train him to benefit society? Those who deny the right of the State to compel the parent to send his child to school are too frequently the offending parents themselves, sentimental theorists or vacillating politicians. [quote ends]” [p. 19]. Concludes, Reminds me why homeschoolers should not take any state tax money: “This interpretation presupposes that the biological family is a premodern entity, necessarily organized on nonmarket principles. Indeed, it sees the family as the social unit – the “cell of society” – that alone can successfully embody the socialist principle: “from each according to his ability, to each according to his need”. Family life survives only as the members of this small community defy, through tradition or intentions, the incentives or pressures that would transform all human actions into market exchanges or subsume them to globalist economic goals. When the family structure surrenders to market organization, it disappears as a meaningful entity with the power to hold or shield its members from the depredations of rival centers of authority” (p. 163). "First, and most important, the autonomous family is endangered by both unchanneled market forces and state authority. These two abstractions—the capitalist market and modern government—have a common interest in the decomposition of the family unit into its constituent parts: parents and children; males and females; old and young' mothers and infants. ...the market economy gains independent economic actors who can be reorganized with individuals from other weakened families into more efficient production units. Similarly, the state apparatus gains both taxable income and potential dependents, as newly ‘free’ individuals look for a measure of social security to replace the protections once afforded by family. The great error of many family defenders has been their eager turn to state coercive authority as a means of defending the family and traditions from the capitalist market" (p. 164). Claims that "...the promised technological rescue of family life rarely materializes" (p. 167). Telecommuting for work, home-based entrepreneurial ventures, and home schooling, even with the help of technology, still carry financial, emotional, structural costs that are not easy to overcome (p. 167). "The family's survival as an autonomous unit still requires that love and intimacy be concretely expressed through a common economic life of both production and consumption. Meaningful family survival depends on the building and maintenance of a true household economy, one that exists apart from the national and international economies and that reconciles the claims of the dependent young, old, and sick with the abilities and obligations of those able to work. Toward these ends, both men and women are still called home to relearn and recommit to the deeper meanings of the ancient words husbandry and housewifery" (p. 168). Briefly discusses home education in the late 1900s; says that home schooling, using technology (e.g., telecommunications, computers, etc.), is perceived by some to be one way to rescue family life, but that this rarely materializes and "... home schooling exacts a high structural, emotional, and financial price among families so engaged, costs rarely affected by the available electronic gimmickry" (p. 167).
Carlson, Allan C., & Mero, Paul T. 2005, March The natural family: A manifesto. The Family in America (Special Edition), 19(3), 1-37.
Carlson, Janet F. 2020 Context and regulation of homeschooling: Issues, evidence, and assessment practices. School Psychology, 35(1), 10–19, ISSN: 2578-4218 http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/spq0000335 http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/spq0000335 assessment, home education, homeschooling, regulation, state by state, psychology, socialization, social development, academic achievement, review of research Abstract: “The article discusses salient factors that influence the current context within which homeschooling occurs. Individual states have applied various approaches to establish regulations that both preserve the rights of homeschooling parents and fulfill the state’s obligation to ensure that its residents receive the education to which they are constitutionally entitled. Case and ethnographic studies or research involving small and selected samples often appear in outlets associated with homeschool advocacy groups or in outlets that are not mainstream. The paucity of empirical evidence derived from methodologically strong research paradigms has led to little certainty about many aspects of homeschooling, including its effectiveness in preparing an educated citizenry. From state to state, the understanding and definition of homeschooling vary widely, leading to equally wide variations in regulatory practices. The article documents and summarizes state-to-state variations in matters pertaining to homeschooling and offers recommendations to help school psychologists work more effectively with students who are educated at home” (p. 10). Author states that, “The primary goal of this article is to deepen practitioners’ understanding of the historical and legal elements that laid the groundwork for the current context in which home education exists and to illustrate how specific regulations governing homeschooling may affect the delivery of school psychological services” but notably muddles her main purpose by spending a significant portion of her paper offering a limited review of research on learner outcomes and alleged methodological limitations of homeschool research. Author’s statement in her abstract that “Case and ethnographic studies or research involving small and selected samples often appear in outlets associated with homeschool advocacy groups or in outlets that are not mainstream” (p. 10) is misleading, irrelevant, and is a committal of the fallacy of poisoning the well (see comment below that includes a reference to Ray (2017). Makes a useful point here – “Despite evidence that homeschooling seldom is an all-or-nothing enterprise, much of the research related to homeschooling forces a dichotomy, classifying students as being either homeschooled or conventionally educated, rather than some of each, making the results difficult to interpret and generalize (Howell, 2013)” (p. 14) – that Ray (author of this bibliography) has made before: All researchers should collect a full year-by-year educational history (grades K-12) on all subjects in a study that compares homeschool students to others. Carlson provides inaccurate and misleading information (essentially from other sources, p. 14, column 1) on who publishes research on homeschooling and whether the research is objective, valid, or reliable while she fails to cite B. D. Ray (2017, “A systematic review of the empirical research on selected aspects of homeschooling as a school choice”) that reviews dozens of studies by many different scholars published in various only peer-reviewed journals that show that homeschool students generally outperform institutional school students on three different learner outcomes. Some of author’s implications for psychology practitioners are wise and helpful (e.g., “In addition, some measures used to evaluate social-emotional or behavioral matters depend upon actual school-based situations or interactions and may not be appropriate for use in the home context” (p. 16).
Carlton, Brian 1999 A systemic view of the socialization of home schoolers. Private School Monitor, 20 (3), 7-9.
Carnevali, Sasha 2009, September 12. Per chi non suona la campanella [For whom the bell does not toll/sound]. Il Sole 24 Ore [a newspaper in Italy]. home education, Italy, foreign, liberty, freedom, philosophy, history Addresses homeschooling and focuses on its relation to freedom of thought and education in Italy and elsewhere.
Carpenter, Dick M. Mom likes you best: Do homeschool parents discriminate against their daughters? 2012 University of St. Thomas Journal of Law and Public Policy. homeschooling, home education, research, math academic achievement, perceptions, agency, gender, sex, gender gap, sex gap “Abstract: This study tests assertions by critics of homeschooling that parents who homeschool discriminate against their daughters and give preference to their sons in their educational pursuits. Specifically, the study asks three questions: (1) Is there a significant difference between male and female homeschooled students in educational indicators [e.g., math academic achievement/performance]; (2) Is there a significant difference in comparative perceptions of male and female student performance in math between homeschool and non-homeschool parents and between parents of male students and parents of female students; (3) Is there a significant difference in comparative perceptions of male and female student performance in math between homeschooled and non-homeschooled students and between male and female ninth grade students? Results indicate no significant differences in educational indicators based on gender” (p. 24).
Carper, James C. 1990 The revival of home education as a third orientation to schooling: Some thoughts. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 16-20, Boston, MA.
Carper, James C. 1992 Home schooling, history, and historians: The past as present. The High School Journal, April/May 1992, 252-257. home education, history Summarizes the history of home education, including references to home-centered education in America since colonial times. Asks whether home schooling is a way to return work and other activities to the home, or a reassertion of the nineteenth century "cult of domesticity" with mothers as the principal protectors/nurturers of children. “In general, then, seventeenth and eighteenth century parents—particularly the father—bore the primary responsibility for teaching their children ... Christian doctrine, vocational skills, and how to read and, to a lesser extent, write and figure ...” [p. 254]. Explains the relationship between home education and changing family roles and structures and how children are educated begs the attention of a variety of scholars. "How it [home education] relates to changing family roles and structures and the way we educate children now and in the future begs the attention of scholars of all stripes" (p. 256).
Carper, James C. 1999 Pluralism to establishment to dissent: Evangelical Christian and home schooling in historical and comparative perspective. A paper presented on at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, April 19-23, 1999.
Carper, James C. 2000 Pluralism to establishment to dissent: The religious and educational context of home schooling. Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 8-19.
Carper, James C. 2011 The public school as established church and homeschoolers as dissenters. A presentation at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 8-12, 2011, New Orleans, Louisiana.
Carper, James C. and Brian D. Ray 2002 Home schooling. In Joseph M. Hawes & Elizabeth F. Shores (Eds.), The Family in America: An Encyclopedia (Volume 2), p. 550-554. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO.
Carper, James C., & Hunt, Thomas C. 2007 The dissenting tradition in American education. New York, NY: Peter Lang Publishing, Inc. education, private schooling, home education, research, history, philosophy, sociology, politics Includes chapter 9 [of 10 chapters] entitled “Homeschooling redivivus: Accommodating the Anabaptists of American education.” “During the middle decades of the nineteenth century, Americans created the functional equivalent of the earlier state religious establishments. Supported by mandatory taxation, purportedly inclusive, and vested with messianic promise, public schooling, like the earlier established churches, was touted as a bulwark of the Republic and an essential agent of moral and civic virtue. As was the case with dissenters from early American established churches, some citizens and religious minorities have dissented from the public school system, what historian Sidney Mead calls the country's "established church.” They have objected to the "orthodoxy" of the public school, compulsory taxation, and attempts to abolish their schools or bring them into conformity with the state school paradigm. The Dissenting Tradition in American Education recounts episodes of Catholic and Protestant nonconformity since the inception of public education, including the creation of Catholic and Protestant schools, homeschooling, conflicts regarding regulation of nonconforming schools, and controversy about the propositions of knowledge and dispositions of belief and value sanctioned by the state school. Such dissent suggests that Americans consider disestablishing the public school and ponder means of education more suited to our confessional pluralism and commitments to freedom of conscience, parental liberty, and educational justice” [publisher’s advertising flyer, April 2007]. Planned chapter titles include “John Hughes: mis?? Catholic dissent in nineteenth-century New York City,” “The Christian day school movement: New Protestant dissenters,” and “Homeschooling redivivus: Accommodating the Anabaptists of American education.” “Mead, one of the outstanding historians of American religion in the latter half of the twentieth century, was among the first modern scholars to assert that public schooling functions as our established church. He argued that one of the prominent reasons for the development of compulsory public education in the United States was to “guarantee the dissemination and inculcation among the embryo citizens of the beliefs essential to the existence and well-being of the democratic society.” Such beliefs, he claimed, “are certainly religious.” Thus the state, he continued, “in its public-education system is and always has been teaching religion” because the stability of the nation-state requires a foundation of shared beliefs, the “religion of the nation” in his terms. “In other words,” he concluded, “the public schools in the United States took over one of the basic responsibilities that traditionally was always assumed by an established church. In this sense, the public school system of the United States is its established church”” (p. 2). “In sum, then, we contend that the public school is the functional equivalent of an established church, buttressed with religious language, expected to embrace all people, legitimating and transmitting an orthodoxy or worldview, and underwritten by compulsory taxation” [ p. 4]. “Though initially led and dominated by parents who embraced the progressive, child-centered pedagogy espoused by critics of institutional education such as John Holt, Paul Goodman, and Ivan Illich, conservative Protestants, deeply troubled by the de facto secularism and inflexibility of mass of [sic] public education and desirous of a reinvigorated family structure, accounted for most of the explosive growth as well as the leadership of the homeschooling “movement” in the 1980s and 1990s, and the concomitant clashes with state officials regarding the right of parents to teach their own children. In the new millennium, however, parents with increasingly diverse of [sic] educational philosophies/confessions/worldviews, including Jews, Catholics, Muslims, and assorted secularists, have [end p. 239] joined the ranks of the ‘Anabaptists’ of American education whose legal right to homeschool is now recognized in all fifty states” [p. 240]. “Distressed by the social and cultural tensions wrought by mid-nineteenth-century urbanization, industrialization, and immigration (which included a large number or Roman Catholics from Ireland) and energized by what Carl Kaestle has called the values of republicanism, Protestantism, and capitalism, educational reformers touted the messianic power of tax-supported, government-controlled schooling. Common schools, they believed, would mold a moral, disciplined, and unified population prepared to participate in American political, economic, and social life. Some reformers [p. 241 ends here] went so far as to view the common school as a substitute for the family. Horace Mann, for example, often referred to the state and its schools as “parental.” Private schools, on the other hand, were often cast as undemocratic, divisive, and inimical to the public interest” [p. 241-242].
Carper, James C., & Hunt, Thomas C. 2007 Homeschooling redivivus: Accommodating the Anabaptists of American education. Chapter in The dissenting tradition in American education. New York, NY: Peter Lang Publishing, Inc.
Carper, James C., & Layman, Jack 1997, Winter Black-flight academies: The new Christian day schools. The Educational Forum, 61, 114-121. private schools, racism, segregation, blacks, African-Americans Says regarding black, African-American, Christian schools “Their growth suggests that, like white evangelicals of the 1960s and 1970s, black evangelicals of the 1980s and 1990s are reconsidering their historic commitment to public education, sacrificing limited resources to establish and support schools that they believe will meet the academic and spiritual needs of African-American children” [p. 121].
Carper, James C., & Ray, Brian D. 1999 Religion, schooling and home schooling: Past and present. A paper presented at a meeting of the Public Religion Project, Chicago, Illinois, September 24, 1999.
Carper, James C., & Ray, Brian D. 2002, in press Religion, schooling, and home schooling: Past and present. In Edith L. Blumhover (Ed.), Religion, education, and the American experience: Reflections on religion and American public life.
Carper, James C., & Ray, Brian D. 2006 Conservative Christian strategies in education. In Rosemary Skinner Keller Rosemary Radford Ruether (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Women and Religion in North America, Volume 2. Bloomington and Indianapolis, IN: Indiana University Press.
Carrere, Thomas A. 1983, November 14 Legal aspects of home instruction. (ERIC Document Reproduction No. ED248580). Civil Liberties, Compulsory Education, Court Litigation, Home Schooling, Parent Rights, School Attendance Legislation A discussion of legal environment within which parents must home teach.
Carrere, Thomas A. Legal aspects of home instruction. Southern Regional Council on Educational Administration, November. ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED 248 580. Law.
Carson, Jayn 1990 See entry: Allie-Carson, Jayn. (1990).
Carson, Olivia 2009 Homeschoolers' perspectives on homeschooling. Doctoral dissertation (Psy.D.), George Fox University. homeschooling, home schooling, home education, socialization, social skills, social competence “Abstract: Literature suggests that home schooled children are as good as or better than their conventionally educated counterparts in the areas of academic content and skills. However, little research has addressed the social competence of homeschooled students. Furthermore, school cohesion has not received much attention as a relevant factor in homeschooling. Most studies of homeschooled students rely on standardized tests of achievement or homeschooling parents’ reports rather than asking homeschooled students themselves about their social experiences or how much they like their school setting. The purpose of the study was to assess homeschooled students’ views on homeschooling and their social competence. There were a total of 131 participants in the current study from homeschool, private school, and public school settings. The participants were in middle and high school. The Behavior Assessment System for Children, Second Edition along with a [p. iii ends] demographics survey with questions about school cohesion were given to obtain the information for the current study. Homeschooled students had similar reasons for being homeschooled as parents of homeschooled students had reported in previous studies. The 4 most common reasons were to “provide religious or moral instruction,” “chance for high educational achievement,” “dissatisfaction with public schools’ instructional program,” and “concerns about school environment.” Further, the majority of the participants reported that they enjoy being homeschooled. Finally, homeschooled students did not differ from private or public school students in their own assessment of their level of social skills and in whether they perceived that they were involved in sufficient quality or quantity of peer relationships. The implication of these results are that the homeschooled students have equal to better social skills than same aged peers. This, combined with previous research (Blok, 2004), suggests that those who are homeschooled receive similar education and social skills training as do their counterparts in the traditional school system. The current data contributes to studies indicating homeschooling as a viable educational choice” (p. iv).)
Carson, Robert E. & Coyle, Karin K 1989 Appraising the Appropriateness of a Basic Skills Test for Home-Schooling Parents. A symposium presentation at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco, March 27-31, 1989.
Carter, Steven 2001, February 2 OMSI visit a hit for home schooling. The Oregonian, p. B1 & B4. Also published and retrieved 2/2/01 online http://www.oregonlive.com/news/oregonian/news_week.ssf?/news/oregonian/01/02/lc_61homes02.frame. http://www.oregonlive.com/news/oregonian/news_week.ssf?/news/oregonian/01/02/lc_61homes02.frame home education, community resources, museum, field trips Oregon Museum of Science and Industry makes a special NASA homeschool day and expected about 150 homeschool students and parents but ended up with 744 attending. "Networking always has been a mainstay of home-schooling families, said Brian Ray, president of the National Home Education Research Institute based in Salem. They've gotten together in small groups and in conferences, and they've published newsletters. But the Internet has greatly increased communication. [new paragraph] "The word about ideas and events goes out so fast and so easily now," he said" [p. B1].
Casagrande, Marisa; Pennings, Ray; & Sikkink, David 2019 Rethinking public education: Including all schools that contribute to the public good (2018 US Cardus Education Survey), https://www.cardus.ca/research/education/reports/rethinking-public-education/ https://www.cardus.ca/research/education/reports/rethinking-public-education/ https://www.cardus.ca/research/education/reports/cardus-education-survey-2018-perceptions-of-high-school-experience-and-preparedness-for-life/ private education, public school, Christian school, Christian education, homeschool, homeschooling, comparative research, graduates, adults, adults who were homeschooled, civic involvement, demographics “After three iterations over nearly ten years (2011, 2014, 2018), the CES [Cardus Education Survey] is considered one of the most comprehensive and representative surveys of independent-school-sector outcomes in the United States. Based on this data, we can now say with confidence that while distinct patterns of thought and behaviour emerge according to which schools these young adults attended, the public-good contributions of these school sectors (Protestant, Catholic, non-religious, and homeschool), when broadly viewed, are overwhelmingly positive” (p. 5). “The following report marks nearly ten years of Cardus research into graduate outcomes in the United States. The report situates these findings, with emphasis on those from the most recent 2018 survey, at our particular moment in the United States” (p. 5). The report does not say but it is likely that the methodology (including sampling) for this study is the same as for that in the following report: Cardus. (2019, September 19). 2018 US Cardus Education Survey: Perceptions of High School Experience and Preparedness for Life. Hamilton, Ontario, Canada: Author. Retrieved December 27, 2019 from https://www.cardus.ca/research/education/reports/cardus-education-survey-2018-perceptions-of-high-school-experience-and-preparedness-for-life/ ) “The CES collects responses from a nationally representative sample of over 1,500 high-school graduates between the ages of twenty-three and forty from government schools and non-government schools, including non-religious independent schools, Catholic and Protestant schools, and homeschoolers, in both Canada and the United States.17” (p. 8). “17. Detailed reports of survey outcomes, organized by various themes, as well as a summary of the survey’s methodology can be found on the Cardus website, https://www.cardus.ca/research/education/ While the survey design heavily oversampled graduates of independent schools, only a very small number of respondents attended Jewish and Islamic high schools, which constitute increasingly important and growing sectors. Graduate responses from these schools were not included in the analysis due to the small sample sizes available. Though the charter-school movement is growing rapidly, it was in its infancy when graduates were in high school. The sample size of these graduates is also insufficient for separate analysis” (p. 8). “Religious-Homeschool Graduate Pathway The religious-homeschool graduate pathway is similar to that of the Protestant-school graduate on a number of measures and similarly distinct from the public-school graduate. Religious-homeschool graduates complete significantly fewer years of education than do public school graduates; indeed, they are on the lowest end of our graduate spectrum on this measure, completing on average just over one year less of schooling than public-school graduates. Religious-homeschool graduates are also about four times more likely to leave schooling entirely after graduating from high school. These graduates are more likely to be unemployed—in fact, over twice as likely to be unemployed as are public school graduates—and they report significantly lower household income as compared to the public-school graduate—in fact, about $10,000 lower” (p. 13). Do the authors break this down by the variable of sex/gender? Could it be that the lower levels of education and income reflect a different worldview of graduates of religious homeschooling that places more value on marriage and having families than on more formal education and higher income? “These graduates tend to trust the federal government, scientists, public school teachers or administrators, and the media the least of all graduates [p. 13 ends] and were most in agreement with the view that the dominant US culture is hostile to their moral/spiritual values” (p. 14). “They are less likely to be registered to vote in national elections and significantly less likely to vote in local elections than are public school graduates” (p. 14). The preceding finding regarding civic involvement is the opposite of the findings of Ray 2004 (Home educated and now adults) and Ray 2015 Gen2 Survey: A spiritual and educational survey on Christian millennials). “They are similar to public-school graduates, however, in terms of volunteering for political causes and with arts and cultural organizations. In terms of their relationships, religious-homeschool graduates were much more likely—indeed 1.5 times more likely—to include an immediate family member as one of their four closest ties. These graduates tend to have close ties with people of similar religious beliefs and traditional worldviews, and they report having lower numbers of close-ties they can confide in. They are also the least likely to have close ties with a university degree, and less likely to know an elected official or a corporate executive. Interestingly, these graduates were most likely to report that they have so much in life to be thankful for and less likely than all graduates, except for Protestant school graduates, to think that life often lacks clear goals or a sense of direction. The homeschooling sector is marked by a high degree of variation, making it difficult to discuss this as a “sector” in the same way. Home-schooling graduates seem to have a wide range of views and experiences, making it more difficult to draw a coherent picture of the typical pathway” (p. 14). It is impossible to know from the report the sample size of “religious homeschoolers” and how representative is the sample. The report refers to a website where the methodology can be found but this author could not find it. From another report by Cardus, it appears that maybe the sample size was 124 for homeschool graduates and only a subset of these was homeschooled. It is also not known from either report for how many years the homeschool graduates were homeschooled versus being in schools so the authenticity of the “homeschool treatment” is not known. The reader should take special note of the report’s authors comment that “Home-schooling graduates seem to have a wide range of views and experiences, making it more difficult to draw a coherent picture of the typical pathway” (p. 14).
Cavinsess, Ylonda Gault 2002, September Homeschooling rules. Essence [magazine; summarized 8/16/02 online http://essence.com/magazine/this_issue/ti_0902.shtml] http://essence.com/magazine/this_issue/ti_0902.shtml home education, minorities, minority, black, African American Explains growth in homeschooling among African Americans/blacks.
Cervone, Barbara Tucker, & O'Leary, Kathleen 1982 A conceptual framework for parent involvement. Educational Leadership, 40(2), 48-49. Parent involvement.
Chakrabarti, Rajashri, & Roy, Joydeep 2010, September Do Charter Schools Crowd Out Private School Enrollment? Evidence from Michigan. Federal Reserve Bank of New York Research Paper Series - Staff Report No. 472. Retrieved 2/23/2011 from http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1676941##. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1676941## charters, charter schools, private schools, instrumental variables, enrollment “Abstract: Charter schools have been one of the most important dimensions of recent school reform measures in the United States. Currently, there are more than 4,500 charter schools spread across forty U.S. states and the District of Columbia. Though there have been numerous studies on the effects of charter schools, these have mostly been confined to analyzing the effects on student achievement, student demographic composition, parental satisfaction, and the competitive effects on regular public schools. This study departs from the existing literature by investigating the effect of charter schools on enrollment in private schools. To investigate this issue empirically, we focus on the state of Michigan, where there was a significant spread of charter schools in the 1990s. Using data on private school enrollment from decennial censuses and biennial National Center for Education Statistics private school surveys, and using a fixed-effects as well as instrumental-variables strategy that exploits exogenous variation from Michigan charter law, we investigate the effect of charter school penetration on private school enrollment. We find some evidence of a decline in enrollment in private schools - but the effect is only modest in size. This finding is reasonably robust, and survives several robustness checks.”
Chamberlain, John 2001 The heart of the matter: Diary of a school year. Santa Fe, NM: Ginger Plum Press. Headmaster of private school that meets 4 days per week and 34 weeks per year and promotes strong classical academics and hearty physical work keeps diary of his year.
Chance, Paul 1985, August Does mother know best? Psychology Today, 10-11.
Chapline, Jake 1983 From home schooling to Harvard. Country Journal, 10(9), 25-27.
Charvoz, Adrienne, 1988, November Reactions to the home school research: Dialogues with practitioners. Education and Urban Society, 21(1) 85-95. Educational Research, Home Schooling, Parent Attitudes, Student Attitudes, Teacher Attitudes
Chatham-Carpenter, April 1994 Home vs. public schoolers’ relationships: Differences in social networks. University of Northern Iowa, Department of Communication Studies. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 361 784)
Chatham-Carpenter, April 1994 Home vs. public schoolers: Differing social opportunities. Home School Researcher, 10(1), 15-24, https://nheri.org/home-school-researcher-home-vs-public-schoolers-differing-social-opportunities/ https://nheri.org/home-school-researcher-home-vs-public-schoolers-differing-social-opportunities/ homeschooling, public school, socialization, social development, social contacts; peer-reviewed “Is there a significant difference in the size of home and public schooled subjects’ social networks? The 21 Home schooled subjects made a total of 1035 contacts, with a mean of 49.29 contacts per subject; the range in contacts was from 7 to 150. The Public schooled sample of 20 subjects made 1125 contacts, with a mean of 56.25 contacts/subject; the range in contacts was from 18 to 154. A t‑test (unequal variances solution) found the difference to not be statistically significant, t (38.8) = ‑0.6319, p < .5312.” Cross-sectional, explanatory study design. Subjects ages 12-18 with mean about 14.6. Controlled for background variable (e.g., socio‑economic status, residential location, church affiliation, parents’ marital status). No significant difference in size of social networks; homeschool students had more younger social contacts than did public school students; no significant difference in older social contacts.) Notes/annotation are
Chatmon, Catherine 2006 Exploring gender disparity in college aptitude among Christian college students from three school settings. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Regent University, Virginia Beach, VA. home education, research, college, adults, college aptitude, achievement aptitude, academic achievement, gender differences, gender disparity “There has been much discussion regarding the gap in achievement between traditionally educated males and females in elementary and secondary school. Research has demonstrated that typically conventionally educated males achieve at a higher level in mathematics during their elementary and secondary years, while females achieve at a higher level in literacy during their elementary and secondary school years. However, as students advance toward the end of their secondary years and begin taking the SAT, various studies concerning this measurement of college aptitude have revealed that males tend to achieve higher scores on both SAT-M and SAT-V. The purpose of this study was to examine gender disparity in college aptitude scores within three different school settings: home school, private school, and public school. The researcher obtained SAT-M and SAT-V scores from a nonrandom selection of Christian colleges. Gender differences were compared for home school, private school, and public school students on SAT-M and SAT-V scores. ….. The results were that there was no statistically significant difference between the scores of home-schooled males and home schooled females on SAT-V. There was a significant difference in SAT-M scores between home-schooled males and females, with males having the advantage. Similar results were observed in the private and public sectors. Additional findings compared the genders within the three school settings. The researcher determined that there were significant differences on SAT-V for both genders, but there were only significant differences on SAT-M for males. In each instance, homeschooled students fared better than their public and private educated counterparts. However, because the f test for gender by school type was non-significant, the simple effects results must be evaluated with caution.” [abstract].
Chavkin, Nancy Feyl (Ed.) 1993 Families and schools in a pluralistic society. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press. parent involvement, academic achievement, research Presents information to say that in America “... that minorities suffer disproportionately from inadequate education, unemployment, and other social and economic handicaps” [p. 1]. “Unfortunately, the educational system has been less successful in educating this growing minority population than it has the majority population ...” [p. 1]. Addresses how parent involvement clearly improves student academic achievement and gives special attention to how minority students and children from low-income families have the most to gain from such involvement [p. 2]. [Pages 1-17 are by Chavkin.
Chen, Stanford 1994, October 8 The learning link cooperation, public schools, home education and, Home-link draws praise of parents). The Oregonian (newspaper), p. C1, C4. (Explains the Home-Link technology center, full of state-of-the-art computers and peripherals, offered by the local public school district for use by home educators and their children for education. The center is staffed by public employees, brings more tax money to the district, and serves home educators; the concept is controversial among home educators and public educators.
Chen, Ying; Hinton, Christina; VanderWeele, Tyler J. 2021 School types in adolescence and subsequent health and well-being in young adulthood: An outcome-wide analysis. PLoS ONE 16(11): e0258723, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0258723 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0258723 homeschooling, homeschool, private school, public school, Schools, Religion, Educational attainment, Mental health and psychiatry, Socioeconomic aspects of health, Home education, Behavioral and social aspects of health, Medical risk factors Abstract: While past empirical studies have explored associations between types of primary and secondary schools and student academic achievement, outcomes beyond academic performance remain less well-understood. Using longitudinal data from a cohort of children (N =12,288, mean age = 14.56 years) of nurses, this study examined associations between the types of schools participants attended in adolescence and a wide range of subsequent psychological well-being, social engagement, character strengths, mental health, health behavior and physical health outcomes. Results in this sample suggested little difference between attending private independent schools and public schools across outcomes in young adulthood. There were, however, notable differences in subsequent outcomes comparing homeschooling and public schools, and possibly some evidence comparing religious schools and public schools. Specifically, there was some evidence that attending religious schools versus public schools was associated with a higher likelihood of frequent religious service attendance and becoming registered voters, a lower risk of overweight/obese, fewer lifetime sexual partners, and a higher risk of subsequently being binge drinkers; however, these associations were not robust to correction for multiple testing. Homeschooling compared with public schooling was associated with subsequently more frequent volunteering (ß = 0.33, 95% CI = 0.15, 0.52), greater forgiveness (ß = 0.31, 95% CI = 0.16, 0.46), and more frequent religious service attendance (Risk Ratio [RR] = 1.51, 95% CI: 1.27, 1.80), and possibly also with greater purpose in life, less marijuana use, and fewer lifetime sexual partners, but negatively associated with college degree attainment (RR = 0.77, 95% CI: 0.67, 0.88) and possibly [but not statistically significantly; p not less than 0.05 but p=0.05] with greater risk of posttraumatic stress disorder. These results may encourage education stakeholders to consider a wider range of outcomes beyond academic performance in decision-making.” Limitations include: “This study is subject to certain limitations. First, the participants were mostly non-Hispanic White and were all children of nurses. Findings of this study may not be generalizable to other populations. Specifically, because all of the students were children of relatively well-educated mothers, this group may have been more able than most to ensure high quality schooling for their children regardless of school type and also more likely to change school type if the particular public or private or religious schools in their area were deemed to be inadequate. ….. Further, the sample size of homeschoolers was relatively small (n = 187) in this study, which may have limited our statistical power.” Peer-reviewed.
Cheng, Albert 2013, August Does homeschooling or private schooling promote political intolerance? Evidence from a Christian University http://www.uaedreform.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/Cheng_EDRE_2013_06.pdf http://www.uaedreform.org/wpcontent/uploads/2013/08/Cheng_EDRE_2013_06.pdf homeschooling, home education, research, adult, values, tolerance, civics, politics, political tolerance, religion EDRE Working Paper No. 2013-06). Retrieved January 17, 2014 from http://www.uaedreform.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/Cheng_EDRE_2013_06.pdf. (“Abstract: Political tolerance is the willingness to extend civil liberties to people who hold views with which one disagrees. Some political theorists argue that the traditional primary and secondary public school system is the ideal institution for instilling political tolerance in children while private schools and homeschooling propagate political intolerance. Both private schooling — in particular, religious private schooling — and homeschooling have been viewed as institutions that propagate political intolerance by fostering separatism, religious fundamentalism, and an unwillingness to consider alternative worldviews or values. I empirically test this claim by using Sullivan, Piereson, and Marcus’s (1982) content-controlled political tolerance scale to measure the political tolerance levels of undergraduate students who (a) attend a fundamentalist Christian university but (b) have varying levels of exposure to different types of primary and secondary schooling (i.e., public schooling, private schooling, or homeschooling). I compare political tolerance levels between students with differing educational backgrounds by using ordinary least squares to regress political tolerance on years of private schooling and years of homeschooling, along with a rich set of demographic and ideological control variables. I find that (a) greater exposure to private schooling is not associated with any more or less political tolerance and (b) students with greater exposure to homeschooling tend to be more politically tolerant — a finding contrary to the claims of many political theorists” (p. 1).
Cheng, Albert 2014 Does homeschooling or private schooling promote political intolerance? Evidence from a Christian university. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/15582159.2014.875411 homeschooling, home education, research, private schooling, political tolerance, causal comparative Journal of School Choice: International Research and Reform, 8(1), 49-68. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/15582159.2014.875411 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2014.875411. Perhaps the first piece of research to address political tolerance amongst the home educated since the homeschooling renascence of the 1980s. It is a very well-designed and well-reported (causal comparative) piece of research. Adults who were home educated more years were significantly more politically tolerant that those who were public schooled more years, and there was no difference between the home educated and private schooled regarding political tolerance. The private schooled were not significantly different from the public schooled in terms of political tolerance. The instrument used is called the content-controlled political tolerance scale. “The study sample consists of 304 out of the approximately 4,000 undergraduates at the university—a private, Christian university in the western United States” (p. 56). “[Abstract] Political tolerance is the willingness to extend civil liberties to people who hold views with which one disagrees. Some have claimed that private schooling and homeschooling are institutions that propagate political intolerance by fostering separatism and an unwillingness to consider alternative viewpoints. I empirically test this claim by measuring the political tolerance levels of undergraduate students attending an evangelical Christian university. Using ordinary least squares regression analysis, I find that for these students, greater exposure to private schooling instead of traditional public schooling is not associated with any more or less political tolerance, and greater exposure to homeschooling is associated with more political tolerance” (p. 49). “Both of the results conflict with the belief that a common system of public schools is essential not only for all students but particularly for religiously conservative students to learn political tolerance. Instead of decreasing political tolerance among students who are more conservative in their religious beliefs, homeschooling is associated with greater political tolerance, and private schooling is not associated with any less tolerance. In other words, members of the very group for which public schooling is believed to be most essential for inculcating political tolerance (i.e., those who are more strongly committed to a particular worldview and value system) actually exhibit at least as much or more tolerance when they are exposed to less public schooling” (p. 64). Author cautions that “… this study is not sufficient to establish any causal relationships” (p. 64). “Two theories for why homeschooling may cause an increase in political tolerance were suggested earlier. First, students who are homeschooled may attain a greater degree of self-actualization because homeschooling is highly conducive to personalized instruction and enables students to be [p. 64 ends] taught a consistent worldview. Second, the religious values taught in a homeschooling environment as well as in many religious private schools are consistent with political tolerance and other values necessary for a liberal democracy” (p. 64-65).
Cheng, Albert, & Donnelly, Michael 2019 New frontiers in research and practice on homeschooling, Peabody Journal of Education, 94:3, 259-262, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617576. https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617576 homeschooling, home schooling, research, review, special issue Introduces this special issue on homeschooling. “On the research side, the number of empirical studies of homeschooling have also proliferated over the past several years, and the methodological quality of this work, though still limited, has improved in concert (Cooper, Spielhagen, & Ricci, 2016; Gaither, 2017; Maranto & Bell, 2017). The Peabody Journal of Education’s previous issues on homeschooling, in particular, mostly comprised reviews of research and theoretical arguments about homeschooling. Even among the few articles that represented original empirical research, a majority were qualitative or based upon small, nonrepresentative samples. The composition of these prior issues reflected the limited state of homeschooling research at the time (Kunzman & Gaither, 2013)” (p. 260).
Cheng, Albert, & Hamlin, Daniel 2022 Contemporary homeschooling arrangements: An analysis of three waves of nationally representative data. Educational Policy, 37(18), https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/08959048221103795 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/08959048221103795 homeschooling, home education, National Household Education Survey, typology of homeschooling “Abstract. Dramatic growth in the homeschool population in recent decades has coincided with an increase in the methods used to educate homeschooled children. However, researchers tend to treat homeschooled children as a uniform group without accounting for vastly different homeschooling arrangements. In this study, we examine the prevalence of four types of homeschool arrangements by pooling three cross-sectional waves of nationally representative data on American homeschool families (n = 1,468). Results indicate that most homeschool families supplement home education with cooperative instructors and private tutors, online education, and brick-and-mortar schooling. Families who do not use these resources are declining. They are also more likely to be White, less educated, and residing in the South region. Homeschool families whose children attend brick- and-mortar schools part-time are less likely to be White and more likely to reside in urban areas. Future research is needed to explore outcomes across different homeschool arrangements” (p. 1444).
Cheng, Albert; & Watson, Angela 2024 How do demographic characteristics of homeschooling households influence the way homeschooling is practiced? Journal of School Choice, 18(4), 479-500, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2024. 2422242 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2024 Homeschooling; home education; motivation to homeschool; homeschooling practices “Abstract: We articulate a theory suggesting that the way families practice homeschooling is based on practical constraints imposed by household demographic characteristics and ideological considerations. These theories are empirically tested using the 2012, 2016, and 2019 waves of the National Household Education Survey and a sample of 1,468 homeschooling families. Findings indicate that specific household characteristics such as family structure, labor force participation, and parents’ educational background are associated with how long a child is homeschooled and the resources families use to homeschool their children. Comparisons between homeschooling and non-homeschooling families are also made” (p. 479). Key statistics deduced from 2012, 2016, and 2019 NHES waves of National Household Education Survey surveys. Family size: “Homeschooling families are slightly larger than non-homeschooling families. The average household size across all three waves of the NHES for homeschooling families is 4.62 people compared to 4.05 for non-homeschooling families. ….. Specifically, homeschooled children [in 2019] have, on average, 1.5 siblings compared to the 1.0 siblings that non-homeschooled children have” (p. 488). Education level of parents and labor force participation of parents: “Regarding the educational attainment of parents and guardians, homeschooling and non-homeschooling families appear similar. For instance, about half of both homeschooled and non-homeschooled children had a parent or guardian who earned at least a bachelor’s degree in all three waves of the NHES. However, when it comes to labor-force participation, homeschooled children are much more likely than non- homeschooled children to have one rather than both of their parents or guardians working” (p. 489). Household income: “It is then, perhaps, not unexpected to see a greater proportion of non-homeschooling families represented among households with incomes greater than $100,000, while homeschooling families are slightly more likely to be in the lower income brackets” (p. 489). Who is the primary instructor parent? “Finally, as shown in the last rows of Table 1, mothers are most likely to be the primary instructor among homeschooling households. Mothers have been the primary instructor for three-quarters of all homeschooling families since 2012” (p. 489). Percent of school years homeschooled; this is a point-in-time cross-sectional presentation for K-12 students; so, if the student is in K, then homeschooled 100% of years; “The distribution is bimodal with about 33% of the sample being homeschooled for the entirety of their primary and secondary schooling and nearly 20% of the sample being homeschooled for one-fifth of the entirety of their primary and secondary schooling” (p. 491). They reference one other study, with n=140 having been homeschooled some out about 6,000 participants: “One study that relies on a sample of adults who have completed all of their primary and secondary schooling estimates that only one out of every 10 U.S. adults who have ever been homeschooled were homeschooled for the entirety of their schooling – a rate that is much lower than the 33% of students in the NHES sample (Hamlin & Cheng, 2022)” (p. 491). Predicting duration of homeschooling a child: “In Table 2, we present estimates of a model that uses household demographic characteristics to predict the duration of homeschooling among homeschooling families. Many of the coefficient estimates are consistent with our hypotheses” (p. 491). “Most children are never homeschooled for the entirety of their primary and secondary schooling. Nor does it follow that if a family decides to homeschool a particular child for all of his or her primary and secondary schooling, then they will make the same choice for all of their other children. This finding is important in understanding the true prevalence of homeschooling in the population. If children, even those within the same family, move in and out of homeschooling, then cross-sectional estimates can only reveal how many families are homeschooled right now, but not necessarily how many families have homeschooled in the past or are likely to in the future” (p. 495). “Additionally, the post-pandemic rise in hybrid schools and publicly-funded education options, like education savings accounts, will provide families with additional opportunities to homeschool. Insofar as the marginal family who is induced to homeschool because of these additional resources is demographically unlike the majority of current homeschoolers, we may observe a continuing diversification of the homeschool population. There will be an opportunity for future research to empirically examine these possible changes” (p. 496).) ?
Cheng, Albert; & Watson, Angela 2025 Diverse outcomes for a diverse population: Findings about homeschooled adults from the Cardus Education Survey, https://www.cardus.ca/research/education/reports/diverse-outcomes-for-a-diverse-population/ https://www.cardus.ca/research/education/reports/diverse-outcomes-for-a-diverse-population/ homeschooling, long-term compared to short-term homeschoolers, economics, mental health, civic engagement, spiritual formation, family formation, outcomes “Between October 10 and 22, 2023, the polling firm Ipsos Public Affairs administered the CES to members of KnowledgePanel, one of the largest representative panels of US adults. The sample comprised 2,350 adults aged 24 to 39 who completed at least high school. About 8 percent (or 181) of these respondents were homeschooled for at least one year between kindergarten and twelfth grade. As discussed above, these 181 respondents were grouped into three approximately equally sized groups: (1) short-term homeschoolers, who were homeschooled for one to two years, (2) medium-term homeschoolers, who were homeschooled for three to seven years, and (3) long-term homeschoolers, who were homeschooled more than seven years” (p. 9). So, n=181 were “homeschooled”; that is, homeschooled for at least one year during K-12. Of these, 36% were homeschooled 1-2 years, 27% 3-7 years, and 36% 8-13 years (not=100, rounding error). So, what we know about “long-term” homeschoolers from this study is based on a planned-to-be representative sample of 65 home-educated adults from across the United States. “Key Points: The Cardus Education Survey (CES), conducted in the United States in 2011, 2014, 2018, and again in 2023, examines a range of outcomes for a nationally representative sample of adults aged 24 to 39. Presented in this report are the economic, mental-health, civic, spiritual, and family-formation outcomes for the group of CES respondents who were homeschooled for a portion of their primary and secondary education. Adults who were homeschooled are disaggregated into short-term homeschoolers (who were homeschooled one to two years), medium-term homeschoolers (three to seven years), and long-term homeschoolers (eight years or more) and compared to adults who were never homeschooled, controlling for a range of demographic characteristics. Top-line findings: Diversity in terms of time spent in homeschooling: Adults who were homeschooled spent a wide range of time in that learning environment. Among them, 20 percent were homeschooled for only one year of their primary and secondary education, and 17 percent were homeschooled for all K–12 years. Educational attainment and employment: Bachelor’s and graduate degree attainment rates were similar between short-term homeschoolers and non-homeschoolers. But medium- and long-term homeschoolers were more likely than short-term and non-homeschoolers to have ended their education with a high school diploma or an associate’s degree. For all three groups of homeschooled adults, the likelihood of being employed full-time and having a household income above the median was lower relative to adults who were never homeschooled. Mental health and well-being: Compared to the other respondent groups, long-term homeschoolers exhibited the highest levels of optimism, gratitude, and life satisfaction. Long-term homeschoolers were also the least likely to “feel helpless dealing with life’s problems” and to report symptoms associated with depression and anxiety. Civic behaviors: Short- and long-term homeschoolers were more likely to have volunteered and given to charity in the past twelve months compared to medium-term homeschoolers and adults who were never homeschooled. Religious engagement: Homeschooled adults were much more likely to report that they believed in God and life after death and regularly engaged in religious practices. The prevalence of religious belief and practice increased with the number of years spent in the homeschool sector. Family formation: Compared to the other respondent groups, long-term homeschoolers were more likely to be married, had the lowest divorce rate, and had more children, on average.” “Using data from the 2023 CES, this report compares respondents who have been homeschooled for various durations of time for their primary and secondary education on a range of outcomes, including educational attainment, preparation for employment, mental health, civic engagement, faith, and family formation” (p. 35). Did well to collect 12-year schooling history of adults. Insightful analysis. Careful conclusions. Shows that there a some important and significant differences in adulthood between those who are homeschooled more years versus fewer years.
Cheng, Albert; Tuchman, Sivan; & Wolf, Patrick 2016 Homeschool parents and satisfaction with special education services. Paper Presented at the Global Home Education Conference 2016 http://www.ghec2016.org/sites/default/files/cheng2_special_education_satisfaction.pdf special education, special needs, special education services, satisfaction, homeschooling, home education, public schooling, Catholic schooling, private schooling, comparison, causal-compartive and cited with author’s permission given March 24, 2016). Retrieved March 24, 2016 from http://www.ghec2016.org/sites/default/files/cheng2_special_education_satisfaction.pdf (The researchers’ data came from the National Household Education Survey that is regularly collected by the US Department of Education and comprises nationally-representative U.S. households (n = over 17,000). In their analysis, they examined approximately 2,000 households who had children with disabilities. Parents responded to a series of survey questions including whether they have a student with disabilities and in which school sector (i.e., homeschool, conventional public school, public charter school, Catholic private school, religious non-Catholic private school, or non-religious private school) the child receives his or her education. Parents also responded to four different items to indicate, “… on a scale of 1 through 4, their satisfaction level with various dimensions of the special education services their child is receiving. Higher values signify greater satisfaction levels” (p. 11). The researchers only included homeschool families that reported receiving services from a local school district, another local government health or social agency, or a formal health care provider, and did not include those that provided special education services on their own to their own children. “Our results indicate that parents who homeschool their children with disabilities are more satisfied with special education services than parents who send their students to public or Catholic private schools” (p. 12). Overall, the scholars found that homeschool parents are more satisfied than parents who send their child to public and Catholic schools with the special education services that they are receiving. At the same time, they found homeschool parents to be less satisfied than parents who send their child to religious non-Catholic private schools with those services. “Assuming that parental satisfaction is an indication of quality, the results suggest special education services offered to parents who homeschool are not worse than services offered to parents in a variety of school settings. This finding undermines concerns that homeschooling is not a viable means to serve students with disabilities. Such results are also consistent with prior research which finds that students with disabilities are at least as effectively served in a homeschool setting as they would be in a traditional public school setting …” (p. 15).
Cheng, Albert; Tuchman, Sivan; & Wolf, Patrick J. 2016 Homeschool parents and satisfaction with special education services. Journal of School Choice, 10(3), 381–398. homeschooling; parent satisfaction; school choice; special education; special needs, peer-reviewed “Abstract. Homeschooling is controversial for a variety of reasons. One concern is whether families are sufficiently equipped to serve students with disabilities. We investigate this issue by assessing parental satisfaction with the special education services that their child is receiving in various educational sectors (e.g., homeschool, traditional public, public charter, and private). Using a nationally representative sample of U.S. households from the National Household Education Survey, we find that parents who homeschool are more satisfied than parents of children in traditional public schools and a variety of private schools with the special education services that they are receiving. Despite obvious selection bias in our sample, we view parental satisfaction as one of many important indicators for the quality of special education services. The results from this study suggest that homeschooling is a potentially beneficial option for serving students with disabilities, though additional research examining other student outcomes would be invaluable” (p. 381). Peer-reviewed journal.
Cherlin, A. 1983 Family policy: the conservative challenge and the progressive response. Journal of Family Issues, 4, 427-438. Review and analysis of current trends in family policy
Christenson, R. M. 1981 Clarifying "values clarification" for the innocent. Christianity Today, April 10, 36-39. Criticism of public schools from the religious right.
Christian Home Educators Association of California and Family Protection Ministries 2002 Why charter schools won’t work for Christians. Norwalk, CA: Christian Home Educators Association of California. home education, public school, charter school, philosophy, funding, costs Explains why public charter schools for children who are largely taught at home will not work, politically, and are not philosophically or biblically sound in their design and function. Shows why charter schools are public schools and not homeschooling and not under parents’ control.
Christy-Faith 2024 Homeschool rising: Shattering myths, finding courage, and opting out of the school system. Jossey-Bass. homeschooling, advocacy, research Online description: “Homeschool Rising is a guide for anyone interested in homeschooling their children, regardless of background. It busts through the myths surrounding homeschooling, reveals the failures of our current school system, and demonstrates how home education and loving, motivated parents can provide a solution for students and families everywhere. There are many assumptions made about homeschooling―that the child will be "socially awkward" due to lack of social interaction, that parents are not equipped to educate their children, that homeschooling is only for White, Christian, middle-class parents, and more. In Homeschool Rising, educator Christy-Faith offers insights from more than 20 years in the field and her experience working with thousands of students to debunk these myths and misconceptions. The truth is, homeschooling sets today’s students up for success in a way that traditional schooling no longer can. This authoritative yet casual and accessible guide provides parents the tools, courage, and knowledge to opt out of the school system and take charge of their children's education.” Written for the layperson.
Churbuck, David C. October 11, 1993 The ultimate school choice: No school at all. Forbes, 144, 145, 148-150. home education, computer, distance learning Interviews several families; mentions research; says many parents disgusted with public schools and not prepared to pay private school tuition are taking matters into their own hands; computer usage makes such education more plausible than a few years ago, according to author.
Churikova, Victoria 2000 Becoming Aboriginal: Experiences of a European woman in Kamchatka's wilderness. Northern Review, 22, 58-61. ERIC Document No. EJ635851. http://www.eric.ed.gov http://www.eric.ed.gov/ attitude change; conservation “Abstract: A Russian woman describes how living in remote Kamchatka helped her develop an aboriginal perspective. Chopping wood, hauling water, gathering food, alternately homeschooling her children and sending them to an ecological school, and interacting with local aboriginal people taught her the importance of conserving natural resources and living in peace. She established ecological schools that work with aboriginal communities” (retrieved 7/16/13 from http://www.eric.ed.gov). environment); cultural maintenance; ecology; experiential learning; females; foreign countries; homeschooling, home schooling; indigenous knowledge; indigenous populations; life style; personal narratives, Russia
Cibulka, James G. 1989 State regulation of home schooling: A policy analysis. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, March 27-31, 1989, San Francisco CA.
Cibulka, James G. 1991 State regulation of home schooling: A policy analysis. In J. A. Van Galen & M. A. Pitman (eds)., Home schooling: Political, historical, and pedagogical perspectives. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation.
Cizek, Gregory J. 1988 Applying standardized testing to home-based education programs: Reasonable or customary? Educational Measurement Issues and Practice, 7(3), 12-19. Excellent critique of the practice of using standardized tests with home educated students; implicitly teaches reader about validity of instruments and appropriate use of tests and norms; critiques the practice of using standardized tests in context of regulating home education. Explains that using percentile ranks to, for example, make judgments about the content mastery of a particular home educated student and the use of a selected percentile as a standard for judging the academic success of a family's home education is inappropriate.
Cizek, Gregory J. 1990 Home education alternatives vs. accountability. Educational Policy, 4(2), 109-125. testing, policy, law Evaluation of home-based programs is difficult but possible; need to consider proper role of testing.
Cizek, Gregory J. 1991 Alternative assessments: Promises and problems for home-based education policy. Home School Researcher, 7(4), 13-21.
Cizek, Gregory J. 1993 Home education research: On the right road? Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 12-16, 1993, Atlanta GA [as part of roundtable discussion "Judging and assisting home education: Issues in research and policy." research, research program, directions Surveys researchers who have published in the journal Home School Researcher during three recent years. About half the sample had never personally engaged in home education. There appears to be no coherent home education research agenda. "...home education research is apparently conducted by a diverse group of scholars, who do not necessarily comprise a `closed system' of non-objective advocates." ..... "...this research may be of interest to researchers concerned with other alternatives such as Catholic education, Protestant academies, or other private schools. Certainly the issues, problems, and trends identified by the home education researchers surveyed in this study may provide valuable insights for the others" (p. 11). Research on educational alternatives in general is important to educational reform. Research on home education might identify practices that could benefit American education in general. Research on learner outcomes should include the moral, spiritual, or religious outcomes that home educators say are important to them.
Cizek, Gregory J. 1993 The mismeasure of home schooling effectiveness: A commentary. Home School Researcher, 9(3), 1-4, https://nheri.org/home-school-researcher-the-mismeasure-of-home-schooling-effectiveness-a-commentary/ https://nheri.org/home-school-researcher-the-mismeasure-of-home-schooling-effectiveness-a-commentary/ home education, research, opinion, commentary, learner outcomes Asserts that "The problem is this: Nothing has been done to assess any outcomes related to the movement's primary, self-selected objective [i.e., "...the perceived spiritual, moral, or religious needs of their children"]." (p. 2); holds that researchers should address objectives other than simply academic achievement and measures of psychological development as they have been doing
Cizek, Gregory J. 1994 Religious education in home schools: Goals-outcomes mismatch? Religious Education, 89(1), 43-51. http://www.eric.gov Academic Achievement, Educational Research, Educational Trends, Elementary Secondary Education, Home Schooling, Moral Values, Nontraditional Education, Parent Attitudes, Parent Influence, Parent Role, Parent Student Relationship, Political Attitudes, Religious Differences, Religious Education, Social Attitudes, Teaching Methods “Maintains that the past two decades have seen a remarkable growth in alternative education options, particularly home schooling. Asserts that the parents' religious and moral beliefs are primary reasons for the home schooling movement. Reviews research on home schooling and calls for more relevant lines of inquiry. (CFR)” ERIC Number: EJ514170, abstract retrieved April 22, 2017 from www.eric.gov
Cizek, Gregory J., & Ray, Brian D. 1995 An analysis of home education research and researchers. Home School Researcher, 11(2), 1-9. home education, research review, analysis, research, critique Examine who is doing research on home education, which methodologies are commonly utilized, whether there is a coherent agenda for current investigations of home education, and what new areas for home education research are likely. Points out that the research is largely descriptive, correlational, and causal-comparative when addressing academic achievement. Finds other types of research being done, especially regarding other topics. “... home education research is apparently conducted by a diverse group of scholars, who do not necessarily comprise a ‘closed system’ of non-objective advocates” [p. 8]. “Additionally, surprisingly scant attention has been given to religious, spiritual, or pro-social outcomes ... This finding is especially surprising given that it is in contrast to the repeated observation that the primary motivation for most home educators reflects a moral, spiritual, or religious component ...” [p. 6].
Clagg, Christopher Adam 2011 A correlational study examining the institutional and faculty characteristics of acsi schools that produced national merit scholarship semifinalists in 2010. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Liberty Univerisity, Lynchburg, Virginia. National Merit Scholarship, school type, research Mentions homeschooling a few times but there is no real focus on homeschooling students.
Clark, Chap (Chapman R.) 2004 Hurt: Inside the world of today’s teenagers. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic. youth culture, sociology, education, research, parental involvement Based on his research, describes the abandonment of adolescents by adults and society, explores their “world beneath.” Chapters 5 [School] and 6 [Family], among other chapters, could be readily be used to make a strong case for why children and youth should be home educated. Proposes “five strategies to turn the tide of systemic abandonment” [i.e., the title of Chapter 13]. His five strategies are (a) “those who work with youth should be trained in the changing youth culture” [p. 178], (b) “those who serve adolescents must work together” [p. 179], (c) “those who serve adolescents must understand youth and provide boundaries” [p. 180], (d) “parents need to be equipped and encouraged to parent the changing adolescent” [p. 182], and (e) “communities must make sure that each student has a few adult advocates who know and care for him or her” [p. 183]. Contends that very few adults have an accurate knowledge and understanding of current youth culture. Does not raise the question, Do parents, especially Christian ones, have to settle for a reality that says a youth culture exists and that their children must be a part of it? Why not develop a family-based or church-based culture? Does not mention, as far as this author can see, homeschooling or home education. Does not clearly recognize that if youth are put into institutional schools then a youth culture will exist and that the problems he describes and diagnoses will likely never disappear and will likely grow even worse. Ignores fact that adults who are unrelated to the youth actually control their “youth” culture via marketing and propaganda. That is, systemically speaking, putting youth into institutional schooling and its immediate correlates – such as many school-related social events, sporting activities, and bus rides – prevents multiple strong and effective personal relationships between psychologically and spiritually healthy adults, especially the midadolescents’ parents; youth are abandoned by parents and will feel so if parents do not spend much time with them.
Clark, Charles S. 1994 Home schooling: Is it a healthy alternative to public education? The CQ [Congressional Quarterly] Researcher, 4(33), 769-792. history, research, opinion Provides current data on number of children home educated in the U.S., research findings, personal family stories, the question of whether home school students miss out on social and community life, home schooling laws in the U.S., a history of home education, whether home schooling threatens the public schools, arguments for and against home education, and explains how home educators showed their political muscle when they fought a provision in the United States H.R. 6 [February 1994] that could have been interpreted to mean that home school parents would have to be certified teachers.
Clark, Gordon H. 1955, August 17, delivered as a public address; 2009, May, published in The Trinity Review The Reformed Faith and the Westminster Confession. The Trinity Review, May-June 2009. Retrieved June 26, 2018 from http://trinityfoundation.org/journal.php?id=263 http://trinityfoundation.org/journal.php?id=263 education, Christian education, Christian schools, secular humanism, public schools, coercion, compulsory attendance, philosophy Explains that religion is taught in public schools; the religion is secular humanism or, basically, atheism. Argues that humanists do not want children to hear the gospel of Christ. Authors statement that “… those who oppose secularism and who want to give their children Christian instruction are branded as antisocial, undemocratic, and divisive” [p. 2] could easily be applied in the late 20th and early 21st centuries to those who oppose homeschooling, especially Christians home educating their children. “The strategy of the humanist is to occupy the time and the attention of children to such an extent that they will have no opportunity to hear the Gospel. The public schools with their compulsory attendance are to be used for the inculcation of secularism. And those who oppose secularism and who want to give their children Christian instruction are branded as antisocial, undemocratic, and divisive. Such events are straws in the wind that show how the humanists are using government agencies to curtail religious liberty. ….. From our benighted Christian viewpoint these humanists do not seem to have much understanding of the laws of logic. They take the principle of the separation of church and state and consider it reprehensible to use public school facilities for released time education. The American Civil Liberties Union will go to court against released time, but I have never heard of their opposing the use of tax money for anti-Christian instruction. They have never sued a university for teaching secularism. They will defend Communists; they will defend the publishers of obscene comic books; but when have they ever defended religious liberty or protested against the inculcation of humanism in tax-supported institutions? Consistency does not seem to be one of their virtues. ….. All the more honor to those congregations and pastors who take this part of their responsibilities seriously. And all honor to the few colleges that are Christian, not in name only, but in actual instruction. And all honor to those who are founding Christian primary schools where God is not ignored or treated as unimportant or non-existent. The opportunity and responsibility of establishing Christian grade schools is one that I should like to urge upon you. But time and my subject forbid.”
Clark, Gordon H. 1988 A Christian philosophy of education (2nd revised edition). Jefferson, MD: The Trinity Foundation, 258 pp. religion, philosophy, home education Orthodox Christian view of education, importance of family and church; very relevant to people who home educate for religious/philosophical reasons. “And ends or goals are far more important than technique. Scientific technique can only be a curse when it is headed in the wrong direction. ….. pedagogy is not a descriptive science, it is a normative science. It deals not so much with what is, but with what ought to be. ….. Views of what ought to be depend on our underlying philosophy. The anti-Christian educator wants to produce one kind of man, the Christian has chosen a far different goal. They may both talk about a complete man; but [p. 204 ends] that they mean different things is obvious when we quote perhaps the best verse in Scripture on the goal of education: “All Scripture is inspired of God and is profitable for teaching . . . for instruction in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, furnished completely unto every good work” (p. 204-205).) . annotation???
Clark, Kevin 1992, May Putting children to the test. Seton Home Study School, 9(5), 2, 3. home education, testing, achievement Relies heavily on Greg Cizek's article [Applying standardized testing to home-based education programs: Reasonable or customary?, 1988, Educational Measurement: Issues and Practice] to warn parents to not rely too heavily on a single standardized test score to make important decisions about their children and to educate legislators about limits of such test scores, says "Mandating norm-referenced test taking by home-school students does not meet the reasonability test" [p. 3].
Clark, Mary Kay 1992 Socialization. Seton Home Study School, 9(12), 2, 3, 7. home education, socialization Says it is a sad commentary that the most asked question of home educators is "But what about socialization?" rather than a concern about their academic education; need to clarify what is meant by socialization and to what and to whose world students in conventional schools are socialized; if they were being socialized to Christian principles and character, that would be fine.
Clark, Mary Kay 1993 Catholic home schools. [book] mis??
Clarke, Hal, Inc., Publishers 1995 The home school market: Market review, size and structure, demographics and socioeconomics, trends, forecasts, and marketing and selling resources. Boulder, CO: Author. home education, research, market, economics, demographics Provides review and description of the home school market’s past, and its present and evolving size, structure, and demographics so that individuals and corporations might know how to market or sell their products and services to home school families. The title summarizes the content and purpose of this report.
Class Size Matters 2012 Research studies showing the benefits of class size reduction. Retrieved February 8, 2012 from http://www.classsizematters.org/research-and-links-2/. http://www.classsizematters.org/research-and-links-2/ academic achievement, correlates, class size Provides useful list of links to studies about the correlates of academic achievement.
Clemente, Dale 2006 Academic achievement and college aptitude in homeschooled high school students compared to their private-schooled and public-schooled counterparts. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Regent University, Virginia Beach, Virginia. home education, college, adults, academic achievement, college aptitude Compares SAT scores of public-schooled, private-schooled, and homeschooled students attending seven non-denominational Christian universities and colleges. Finds that the average SAT total of the home-educated was the highest, the private-schooled was the middle, and the public-schooled was the lowest. Does not control for some important background variables in the comparison.
Clemente, Dale, & Chatmon, Catherine 2007, Winter Are home school students adequately socialized? Private School Monitor, 29(1), 1-12. home education, research, interviews, review, socialization, social development, emotional development “In recent years home schooling has enjoyed a resurgence in popularity. However, opponents of this educational method have expressed grave concerns whether homeschooled children are receiving interactions with other children (or socialization). In a review of the literature and through case studies, this study examines the validity of these assertions” [p. 1, abstract]. Authors interview three homeschool families. “Home schooled children appear to be adequately socialized and may perhaps surpass their traditionally educated counterparts on levels of social and emotional maturity” [p. 11].
Clements, Andrea D. 2004 Homeschooling: A Research-Based How-To Manual. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishing Group. http://www.rowmaneducation.com/Catalog/SingleBook.shtml?command=Search&db=^DB/CATALOG.db&eqSKUdata=1578861284 http://www.rowmaneducation.com/Catalog/SingleBook.shtml?command=Search&db=%5eDB/CATALOG.db&eqSKUdata=1578861284 home education, research, psychology, pedagogy Publisher reports: "Here is a concise handbook of trustworthy, research-based information about learning and teaching for those interested in homeschooling. It is also very helpful for teachers in other arenas such as private schools, public schools, and church education programs. Exhaustive coverage is not the goal, but a concise, user-friendly guide is [retrieved 1/8/07 online http://www.rowmaneducation.com/Catalog/SingleBook.shtml?command=Search&db=^DB/CATALOG.db&eqSKUdata=1578861284]
Clinton, Hillary Rodham 1996 It takes a village: An other lessons children teach us. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster. family, children, government, social services Presents many nostalgic and emotional stories about her childhood and the 1950s that praise the role of the family and neighborhood communities in raising children. Cleverly claims that society is unchangeably different from 1950s now, with mothers not staying at home, so society must adapt by encouraging government and organizations to protect, nurture, educate, and train children. Promotes the enlargement of state [government] control and size to raise children. This is, in many ways, the antithesis of what most home educators want and practice.
Cloud, John, & Morse, Jodie 2001 Seceding from school: Home sweet school. Time, 158 (8), 46-54. Also published 8/19/01 and retrieved online 8/20/01 http://www.time.com/time/covers/1101010827/index.html. http://www.time.com/time/covers/1101010827/index.html Cover story of Time magazine subheading says "The new home schoolers aren't hermits. They are diverse parents who are getting results — and putting the heat on public schools."
Coalition for Responsible Home Education 2025 The test score myth and homeschooled students’ academic performance, https://mcusercontent.com/89d5e9e2c3c3a1dbb77b9dae5/files/963084f7-d2ef-0517-bdb1-7049916dd101/The_Test_Score_Myth_and_Homeschooled_Students_039_Academic_Performance_.pdf?mc_cid=675b548139 https://mcusercontent.com/89d5e9e2c3c3a1dbb77b9dae5/files/963084f7-d2ef-0517-bdb1-7049916dd101/The_Test_Score_Myth_and_Homeschooled_Students_039_Academic_Performance_.pdf?mc_cid=675b548139 https://crhe.org/research/the-test-score-myth/ homeschooling, homeschooled adults, academic achievement, research, test scores see also https://crhe.org/research/the-test-score-myth/). (Claims that homeschool students’ academic achievement is not as high as unnamed sources say it is. CRHE makes many unfounded, false, and misleading claims. Their article is not sound as a scholarly review of research. It holds some valid points but overall is weak compared to a scholarly review that might make it into a scholarly journal.
Coalition for Responsible Home Education (CRHE) 2024 Homeschooling’s invisible children: Report of findings 2024. Coalition for Responsible Home Education (CRHE) https://www.hsinvisiblechildren.org/findings/ and https://www.hsinvisiblechildren.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/hic_report_2024.pdf Could also be cited as: Stewart, Jonah; Bartmess, E.; & Brosneck, M. (2024). https://www.hsinvisiblechildren.org/findings/ https://www.hsinvisiblechildren.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/hic_report_2024.pdf homeschooling, abuse, neglect, philosophy, legal, advocacy, policy Homeschooling’s … This is essentially a promotional piece to support and promote CRHE’s “Make Homeschool Safe Act” that urges lawmakers and other government officials to apply much more control and regulation over homeschooling than exists in most states. For example, they claim “First, since 2000, well over 100 homeschooled children12 have died from abuse that better policies could have helped prevent” (p. 5) but their data and analysis do not substantiate this claim; they offer no statistical analysis that empirically shows any correlation between degree of state control/regulation over homeschooling and rates of abuse, neglect, or fatalities.)
Coalition for Responsible Home Education (CRHE) 2025 Inside homeschool policy, https://responsiblehomeschooling.org/research/current-policy/ https://responsiblehomeschooling.org/research/current-policy/ homeschooling, policy, statism, state control, regulation, lobbying group “Currently [September 16, 2025], no state meets the standards for proper oversight outlined in our policy recommendations.”
Coalition for Responsible Home Education (CRHE)/Homeschooling’s Invisible Children (HIC; HSIC) 2015 Some preliminary data on homeschool child fatalities. Retrieved April 16, 2025 from https://web.archive.org/web/20150602050333/https://hsinvisiblechildren.org/commentary/some-preliminary-data-on-homeschool-child-fatalities/ and September 03, 2015 from http://hsinvisiblechildren.org and June 3, 2021 from https://hsinvisiblechildren.org/commentary/some-preliminary-data-on-homeschool-child-fatalities/ https://web.archive.org/web/20150602050333/https://hsinvisiblechildren.org/commentary/some-preliminary-data-on-homeschool-child-fatalities/ http://hsinvisiblechildren.org https://hsinvisiblechildren.org/commentary/some-preliminary-data-on-homeschool-child-fatalities/ https://web.archive.org/web/20150602050333/https:/hsinvisiblechildren.org/commentary/some-preliminary-data-on-homeschool-child-fatalities/ child abuse, child neglect, child fatalities, homeschooling, public schooling, private schooling, general population “First, a word about the HIC database. We use publicly available online news articles and, in some instances, court records to find and document the cases of severe abuse or neglect in homeschool settings.” “This finding does not yet reach the threshold for statistical significance, so at this point we cannot say conclusively that homeschooled students die from child abuse and neglect at a higher rate as other students”; that is to say, and the author clearly de-emphasizes this point, there is no statistically significant difference in child fatality rates between homeschool children and others.) The URL????
Cochran, Casey Patrick 1993, October Radical left meets Christian right: Educational separatism and the home school movement in the U.S., 1960-1985. A paper presented to the Faculty of the Division of Educational Studies at Emory University [Atlanta, GA] in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. home education, research, history, rationales, private schools, Christian schools, free schools Reviews scholarly interpretations of the historical origins of three educational movements: free schools, Christian schools, and home schools. Uses secondary sources. Well written, well documented, and clearly and convincingly places home education in historical context. "The emerging picture is generally clear, with the literature emphasizing the social forces which brought about the rising criticism of the public school, the growing alienation between family and school, the advent of the free schools and the Christian schools, and the appearance of the home school movement as an outgrowth of both--one element affiliated with the radical left, the other with conservative Christianity..." (p. 52). Says home education movement is impressive in its growth.
Cochran, Patrick Casey 1999 A radical ideology for home education: The journey of John Holt from school critic to home school advocate: 1964-1985. Home School Researcher, 13(3),1-10. home education, philosophy, history, John Holt, Christianity Author addresses three questions in his conclusions section. “First, Can children make correct decisions about education and other life issues without significant adult intervention? This question, of course, is enveloped in the larger question regarding man’s inherent nature. That is, does he naturally tend to behave rightly, truthfully, justly, et cetera? Or does man tend naturally toward selfishness, license, and moral convenience? As Pascal phrased it, is man an angel or a beast? Holt reasoned from the Romantic tradition, perhaps best exemplified by Rousseau’s Emile, which assumed the innate goodness of children and the corrupting influences of adult institutions on children. If only they could be left alone, Holt wrongly concluded, children’s goodness and curiosity would lead to correct decisions and eventually produce a truly democratic society peopled with happy, self-directed, self-educated individuals. ..... Second, Should children have the same rights as adults? This question, closely related to the first, concerns the role of children in the family and in society. Holt’s view of the institution of the family was ambivalent at best, thus strong traditional families appear almost optional in Holt’s scheme of things. Families did, however, represent a less oppressive environment than did schools. Though wary of parental authority, Holt saw homes as potentially less destructive of children’s rights than government-mandated schools, and considered parents a key to providing appropriate learning environments for their children. Perhaps Holt bowed to the realities of American life, and because of the need for parental involvement in the act of home education, he came to see parents as a key to the movement [p. 8]. “Third, Should the government operate schools and compel parents to send their children to them? This two-fold question is perhaps the most controversial and provocative raised by Holt. Especially after his exposure to the ideas of Ivan Illich, Holt came to see the institution of the school as inherently evil, destructive of children’s innate learning abilities, a tool of the rich to oppress the poor, and with no hope of reform. ..... While the dismantling of government-run school systems might be an attractive option to some, Holt’s reasons for suggesting such a thing are not so attractive. If the legitimacy of public education is to be debated, it should be done so on the immediate basis of parental rights and ultimately on theological grounds, not children’s freedom. It is obvious that parents bear the primary responsibility of meeting the needs of their children; it is equally obvious that this parental responsibility includes educational decisions and that governmental involvement in the educational arena can quickly become a usurpation of parental prerogative” [p. 9]. “Generally speaking, Holt’s educational ideology represents one of the two major philosophical strains which comprise the intellectual base of the present home school movement in the U.S. Holt exemplifies the ideology of freedom, popularized by the radical school reformers of the 1960s and 1970s and embraced by much of the counterculture. The second strain is the ideology of conservative Christianity, which far overshadowed the radical element within the home school movement, at least, it appears, through the decade of the 1980s. But that is another story for another day” [p. 10].
Cogan, Michael F. 2010, Summer Exploring academic outcomes of homeschooled students. Journal of College Admission, 208, 18-25. Also retrieved 12/20/10 from http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa3955/is_201007/ai_n54718392/ http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa3955/is_201007/ai_n54718392/ home education, homeschooling, college, adults, academic achievment, ACT, GPA, causal-comparative in a sense, peer-reviewed “Descriptive analysis reveals homeschool students possess higher ACT scores, GPAs and graduation rates when compared to traditionally-educated students. In addition, multiple regression analysis results reveal that students, at this particular institution, who are homeschooled, earn higher first-year and fourth-year GPAs when controlling for demographic, pre-college, engagement, and first-term academic factors. Further, binary logistic regression results indicate there is no significant difference between homeschooled student’s fall-to-fall retention and four-year graduation rates when compared to traditionally-educated students while controlling for these same factors. Still, the results should be carefully considered in regards to this particular institution as the study took place at one institution with a small sample size (N=76) [at one university]. Nonetheless, this study shows that this group of students outperforms their traditionally-educated peers when considering the GPA measures. Perhaps more importantly, this group of students performed at the same level as their peers when considering fall-to-fall retention and four-year graduation rates” [p. 24]. He was able to control for the independent variables of socioeconomic status, racial minority status, sex of participant, and more. “The institution participating in the study is a medium-sized private university with a Carnegie Classification of doctoral. The institution is located in a metropolitan area in the upper Midwest. The overall student population is nearly 11,000 with approximately 57 percent classified as undergraduates. Each fall, the institution enrolls a freshman class of approximately 1,320 students. The institution maintains a comprehensive data warehouse with a census file created on the 10th day of the semester. The majority of data used in this study was extracted from this census file. In order to answer the aforementioned questions, three datasets were developed. The first dataset consists of all incoming freshman students entering the institution during the fall semester between 2004 and 2009 (N=7,776). This dataset contains 76 students (approximately 1.0 percent) who reported attending homeschool prior to enrollment. This dataset will be used to describe student characteristics by high school type. The second dataset includes the same group of students entering the institution between 2004 and 2008 (N=6,424)” (p. 21). Dependent variables are first-year GPA, fourth-year GPA, fall-to-fall retention, and four-year graduation. Comparing students who were homeschooled prior to college enrollment to others. Controlled for variables SES, minority status, and sex of student. Peer-reviewed.
Cohen, D. K., & Rosenberg, B. H. 1977 Functions and fantasies: Understanding schools in capitalist America. History of Education Quarterly, 113-137. History of education, tracing relationship between schools and the state.
Cohen, Peter A., Kulik, James A., & Kulik, Chen-Lin 1982, Summer Educational outcomes of tutoring: A meta-analysis of findings. American Educational Research Journal, 19(2), 237-248. tutoring, effects, meta-analysis, academic achievement, attitudes, tutor, tutee, peer tutors Shows that school tutoring programs have positive effects on the academic performance and attitudes of those who are tutored; they outperform control students on examinations and develop positive attitudes toward subject matter covered in the tutorial programs. The average Effect Size (ES) in studies of the tutee’s achievement was .33. The average ES in studies of the tutee’s attitude toward subject matter was .42. Also shows the tutoring programs have positive effects on children who serve as the tutors; they gian a better uncderstanding of and develop more positive attitudes toward the subject matter covered. Participation in the tutoring had little or no effect on the self-esteem of tutors and tutees. These findings beg the question: If in-school, short-duration tutoring can cause such positive effects, what would be the effect of education that is based on tutoring, like homeschooling?
Cole, Michael 2010 What’s culture got to do with it? Educational research as a necessarily interdisciplinary enterprise. Educational Researcher, 39(6), 461-470. culture, instruction, open classroom, schooling, public school, philosophy Author begins to sound like a voice from the modern homeschool movement: “… the standard forms of mass schooling arose … anywhere in the world where societies have grown large enough and their economies complicated enough to make necessary a complex division of labor, which implies the need for (a) a lot of specialized cultural learning, (b) the use of mediational means, such as written language … and (c) restricted economic resources that make it necessary, and in some sense efficient, to have one person teach many novices at one time in a central location… . Not everyone can be average, let alone above average, in such a system. Power enters the scene as the power to exclude and credential” [p. 464]. Refers to other thinkers [Stallard & Cocker, 2001] “… whose vision provides a handy alternative to that of the Assyrian classroom or the open classroom, because it envisions the disappearance of the aggregated institution called “the school” altogether. In its place would be [quoting them] “a nation of home-based activities organized around small neighborhood learning clubs, linked through high-bandwidth Internet software. “Teachers” would operate as independent consultants, who work from home most of the time, and occasionally meet with ad hoc groups of students at a learning club. (p. 469) [Stallard & Cocker quote ends]” Lectures, what there were of them, would be available online. Project-based learning and multigenerational, overlapping, small communities of learners would converge virtually or face-to-face as conditions required” p. 469). Author goes on to explain one reason it is likely that schooling in most nations will not change: “The fact is that, despite pronouncements about the advent of an innovation and information economy, great masses of the American public (and I believe the same is true quite generally on the international scene as well) are not anxious to have their children at home all day. They do not want their children wresting authority from them, deciding for themselves what constitutes an interesting problem to work on; and they fear the social chaos that would result from such a change in the cultural foundations of the nation state” [p. 469]. The descriptions of what Cole would like to see in education/schooling are very similar to what is practiced by most families and groups within the current home-based education community.
Cole, Robert W., Jr. 1979 Education is a community function. Phi Delta Kappan, September, 2. Editorial. Critics of public schooling should consider that "... Literacy and learning begin at home - not in school."
Cole, Robert W., Jr. 1983 Every home a school. Phi Delta Kappan, 64, 386. Editorial.
Coleman, J. S., Campbell, E., Hobson, C., McPartland, J., Mood, A., Weinfeld, F., & York, R. 1966 Equality of educational opportunity. Washington, DC: U.S. Office of Education, National Center for Educational Statistics. public school, academic achievement, socioeconomic status, SES, income Surveys thousands of children throughout the United States and finds that children of low-income families do significantly worse in terms of academic achievement than those from families of middle and higher incomes and that the differences in achievement by socioeconomic status [SES] become greater as students advance through public school.
Coleman, James S. 1991 Policy perspectives: Parental involvement in education. Washington DC: Office of Educational Research and Improvement, United States Department of Education, 24 pp. parental involvement, achievement Available from Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington DC 20402 “If a child trusts an adult, whether a parent or a member of the community, and the adult is trustworthy, this relation is a resource on [p. 7 ends] which the child can draw when in difficulties, whether with schoolwork, with friends, with a teacher, or with other problems. ..... more generally, social capital held by a person lies in the strength of social relations that make available to the person the resources of others [p. 8].” Considers how parental involvement enhances social capital, which "...lies in the strength of social relations that make available to the person the resources of others" (p. 8), and thereby enhances student learning.
Coleman, James S. June 1991 Policy perspectives. Washington D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office. parent school relationships
Coleman, James S., & Hoffer, Thomas 1987 Public and private high schools: The impact of communities. New York, NY: Basic Books, Inc., Publishers. Social capital.
Coleman, James S., Hoffer, Thomas, & Kilgore, Sally 1982 High school achievement: Public, Catholic, and private schools compared. New York, NY: Basic Books.
Coleman, Sandy 2000, August 22 Completely at home with learning: Homeschooling growing among African-Americans. The Boston Globe, p. B1. home education, Black, Blacks, minorities, African-Americans, academic achievement, philosophy, sociology, religion, reasons “‘For black people in this country, there is a need for not letting our kids forget their history,’ said Alan Shaw, whose sons are 3, 6, and 7. ‘We shouldn't look to something that's been designed by the state as a way for us to teach our kids about their past and their future.’ Fueled by a desire to rescue their children from academic failure and neglect at the hands of overburdened public schools and determined to weave tight-knit families, more African-Americans and other minorities nationwide are deciding that when it comes to school, there's no place like home. This, even as they are accused of abandoning the very public school system that for decades minorities who fought to overcome separate and unequal education have been told is the ticket up and out of oppression. ‘Many of them have recognized that academically the public school system has not saved them,’ said Brian Ray, president of the National Home Education Research Institute, a nonprofit based in Oregon.” “‘It's a matter of commitment,’ said Missy Parker, a Southern Baptist who homeschools to teach religious values. She estimates that at least 200 African-American families in Detroit are homeschooling. ‘Most African-Americans wouldn't venture to do it because they didn't feel they were equipped. But, that's what the support group is for, so you don't have to do it on your own.’” “Some, like the Shaws, say the public school system is failing African-American children, who often end up at the bottom of achievement assessments. Results by race on the 1999 Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System showed black and Latino students behind whites in every category for every grade.”
Colfax, David, & Colfax, Micki 1988 Homeschooling for excellence. New York, NY: Warner Books. Three of the authors' home schooled sons have gone to Harvard.
Colfax, David: & Colfax, Micki 1992 Hard times in paradise: An American family's struggle to carve out a homestead in California's redwood mountains. New York, NY: Warner Books, A Time Warner Co.. home education, life style Includes a chapter about publicity the family received when Grant, the oldest, was accepted to Harvard University after years of home schooling.
Colfax, J. D. 1983, February Teaching your own. Country Journal, 10(2), 44-47.
College Board 2014a SAT 2014 college-bound seniors state profile report, U.S. home school students. New York, NY: Author.
College Board 2014b SAT 2014 college-bound seniors total group profile report, total group. New York, NY: Author. Retrieved June 7, 2016 from https://secure-media.collegeboard.org/digitalServices/pdf/sat/TotalGroup-2014.pdf https://secure-media.collegeboard.org/digitalServices/pdf/sat/TotalGroup-2014.pdf
Collin, M. 1983, December 12 Districts have uneasy alliance with home schools. Salt Lake Tribune, n.p.
Collom, Ed 2005 The ins and outs of homeschooling: The determinants of parental motivations and student achievement. Education and Urban Society, 37(3), 307-335. home education, research, homeschooling, parental motivations, reasons, academic achievement, race, minority, minorities, determinants, public-school-at-home, PSAH “Academic and pedagogical concerns are most important [as determinants of motivations], and it appears that the religious base of the movement is subsiding. Several major demographic variables have no impact upon parental motivations, indicating that this is a diverse group. Parents’ educational attainment and political identification are consistent predictors of their students’ achievement. Race and class—the two major divides in public education—are not significant determinants of standardized test achievement, suggesting that homeschooling is efficacious. It is concluded that homeschoolers are a heterogeneous population with varying and overlapping motivations” [abstract, p. 307]. Author draws sample of children and parents from a California public charter school that is called Home Charter that relies on home-based instruction. Many of these parents would call themselves homeschoolers but others in the homeschool community consider these to be public-school-at-home or government-school-at-home families, not private “homeschool” families. “The two great divides that public school children face – race and class – are inconsequential for student achievement among home-educated children” [p. 329]. “Three factors were found to have the same effects in the reading, language, and math achievement models … Students who are homeschooled by more educated parents have higher levels of academic achievement. ….. [p.329] Students homeschooled by more conservative parents also perform better on standardized tests” [p. 330]. “These findings [on academic achievement] also parallel much of the earlier research” [p. 331]. “This is a heterogeneous population with varying and overlapping motivations. Simplistic typologies cannot capture the complexities of homeschoolers” [p. 331].
Collom, Ed, & Mitchell, Douglas E. 2005 Home schooling as a social movement: Identifying the determinants of homeschoolers’ perceptions. Sociological Spectrum, 25: 273–305. home education, research, sociology, social movement “This article seeks to estimate the extent to which home schooling parents perceive themselves as social movement participants and to identify the factors contributing to such beliefs. The impact of collective action frames, feelings of efficacy, social network ties, and home schooling motivations are considered. Regression models are employed in an analysis of original survey data from an organized group of Southern California homeschoolers. Home schooling motivations are most salient in determining whether one interprets their activities as part of a larger movement. Social network tie indicators are largely unimportant in the models. The findings highlight the important role of organizational affiliation and integration. Homeschoolers without affiliations and those who are less integrated into their support organizations are not likely to feel as if they are part of a larger movement. Organizational integration—specifically” [abstract, p. 273]. “First, it is noteworthy to again mention the noneffects of the control variables. Demographic factors are often very important predictors of social movement involvement and beliefs. The fact that they have no explanatory power for Home Charter parents suggests that demographics may not be divisive for this population. Even religiosity—a major division underlying the motivation to home school—has no impact in the models. Despite the heterogeneity of homeschoolers, they have a commonality insofar as their backgrounds do not have any impact on the way in which they interpret their participation in this activity” [p. 295]. “The premise of this study is that home schooling is an alternative social movement. The extent to which home schooling parents perceive themselves as social movement participants was estimated with original survey data. Micro and meso theories of social movement participation were operationalized in an effort to identify the factors that lead homeschoolers to perceive their activities as part of a larger movement. The importance of organizational affiliation and integration at Home Charter suggests that homeschoolers without affiliations and those who are less integrated into their support organizations are not likely to feel as if they are part of a larger movement. Organizational integration—specifically attitudinal affinity—also appears to make parents become more narrowly focused upon their own children rather than the welfare of all children” [p. 300].
Colorado Department of Education 1988 Data on home school participation from 1976-1988.
Common, Ron W., & MacMullen, Marilyn 1986 Home schooling... a growing movement. Education Canada, 26(2), 4-7. Also in CIJE, January 1987, p. 58. CIJE No. EJ 341 771. "Discusses the status of home schooling in Canada, pointing out the rapid expansion of the movement and the unresolved points of difference between schooling and the research findings used in its support. Urges full cooperation between schools and home schoolers" [CIJE abstract]. Canada. Home-School cooperation.
Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Department of Education 1980,January 4 Memorandum: advisory opinion on home education.
Conder, Heather 2003 No Child Left Behind Act of 2001: Are homeschoolers sufficiently protected? Paper presented at the annual meeting of the National Christian Home Educators Leadership Conference, Virginia Beach, Virginia, September 24-27, 2003.
Conejeros-Solar, María Leonor, & Smith, Susen R. 2019 Homeschooling the gifted: What do we know from the Australian, Chilean and US context? In S. R. Smith (ed.), Handbook of Giftedness and Talent Development in the Asia-Pacific, Springer International Handbooks of Education, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-3021-6_72-2 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-3021-6_72-2 Gifted students, Homeschooling, Motivations, Socialization, Socialisation, Provisions, Research, International “Abstract: The homeschooling movement has steadily developed in the last couple of decades, especially in the USA. In Australia and Chile, the movement is still growing as an alternative to school education. The social growth of homeschooling entails visions of support and criticism. Some consider it an approach to meet and foster children’s interests and needs, and others consider it a private movement against public education and democratic societies. Motivations for homeschooling are mostly related to ideological and pedagogical conceptions in the way families approach homeschooling. In terms of research, in the last two decades, there’s been a growth in peer-reviewed publications to better understand its motivations, implications, educational provisions and outcomes. Homeschooling for gifted students in particular has little research, and the findings from the few studies that are available suggest that these families start homeschooling for different reasons compared to the general homeschool population. While research on homeschooling gifted students from the USA dominates, not much is heard about homeschooling research in Australia and even less is evident from the Chilean homeschooling experience. In this scenario, more research is needed about gifted homeschooling and the inner experiences these families and children face. This chapter presents findings from a theoretical review in an effort to contribute to the understanding of this educational provision for gifted children and delve deeper into the options these families have in the context of Australia, Chile and the USA” (p. 2).
Conley, Craig 1984 Learning free. Mothering, Winter, 84-85.
Connecticut, State of, Office of the Child Advocate 2018 Examining Connecticut’s Safety Net for Children Withdrawn from School for the Purpose of Homeschooling—Supplemental Investigation To OCA’s December 12 2017 Report Regarding the Death of Matthew Tirado, 28 pp. Retrieved March 22, 2026 from https://www.cga.ct.gov/kid/related/20180426_Informational%20Forum%20on%20Homeschooling%20and%20Communication/OCA.Memo.Homeschooling.4.25.2018.pdf Retrieved March 10, 2020 from https://www.ct.gov/oca/lib/oca/OCA.Memo.Homeschooling.4.25.2018.pdf https://www.cga.ct.gov/kid/related/20180426_Informational%20Forum%20on%20Homeschooling%20and%20Communication/OCA.Memo.Homeschooling.4.25.2018.pdf https://www.ct.gov/oca/lib/oca/OCA.Memo.Homeschooling.4.25.2018.pdf https://homeschoolingbackgrounder.com/two-invalid-studies-promoted-by-homeschool-critics/ homeschooling, home schooling, home education, abuse, risk, at-risk, neglect, fatality, government, policy, philosophy Vague blend of theoretical argument with some empirical evidence. They did not state that they used a representative sampling of school districts: “OCA reviewed six (6) school districts’ withdrawal/homeschooling practices, including the Hartford Public Schools where Matthew Tirado and his younger sister attended. The sampling of school districts included two large urban school districts, two small districts, and two mid-sized suburban districts” (p. 5). They described case examples from six school districts. There are no data and no finding about the rate of abuse or neglect of homeschool children. They described case examples of alleged child abuse or neglect from six school districts but presented no finding about the overall rate of abuse or neglect of students who were withdrawn from an institutional school to be home educated. Connecticut government does not use the terms “at-risk” or “risk” with homeschooling but clearly implies that the homeschooled are at some unstated risk because there is not enough government control (regulation) of homeschooling and not enough of a “safety net” for homeschoolers: “OCA strongly recommends that Connecticut stakeholders consider the unintended consequences of having no clear regulation for homeschooling and the impact on the safety net for children” (p. 14). The government says they need to “… strengthen the safety net for vulnerable students” while writing about homeschool students (p. 1) so clearly imply talking about homeschoolers. The government agency “… 4) recommends that Connecticut bring stakeholders together to consider a regulatory framework for homeschooling that will provide a safety net for withdrawn students, fulfill the state’s interest in ensuring children are educated while still supporting parents’ right to homeschool” (p. 2). Government agency wants to make sure that “… the state has a regulatory framework in place that permits a safety net for withdrawn children who may be removed from school [to homeschool] and denied an education.” (p. 3). This is a government-agency report, not a research study. There is no random or representative sampling of school districts for gathering data. A simple and well-done critique of the report lies about halfway down the this page https://homeschoolingbackgrounder.com/two-invalid-studies-promoted-by-homeschool-critics/
Connolly, Jacqueline 1985 The effect of parental home instruction in English skills upon achievement levels in grades three through seven. Dissertation Abstracts International, 46(7), 1873A, 1874A. Quasi-experimental, pretest-posttest control group design without randomization of population [urban parochial school]; treatment to experimental group was parental tutoring in English skills over eight-week period; Iowa Test of Basic Skills used as dependent variable measure; at alpha of .05, the tutoring program had no significant effect upon achievement levels of the children. Achievement, parent tutoring.
Conroy, Cathryn 1991, September Home is where the campus is. CompuServe Magazine, p. 13-20. Specifically addresses home schooling, among other education at a distance topics.
Cook, Kathleen B.; Bennett, Katie E.; Lane, Justin D.; & Mataras, Theologia K. 2013 Beyond the brick walls: Homeschooling students with special needs. Physical Disabilities: Education and Related Services, 32(2). Retrieved February 28, 2017 from https://scholarworks.iu.edu/journals/index.php/pders/article/view/12997 https://scholarworks.iu.edu/journals/index.php/pders/article/view/12997 homeschooling, home education, special needs, peer-reviewed journal “Abstract. The percentage of children with special needs receiving academic instruction at home has substantially increased since a resurgence of homeschooling during the 1990s. In light of this information, the purpose of this article was to provide an overview of the history and laws related to homeschooling, the characteristics of homeschool families, and the relevant issues that parents of children with disabilities encountered when choosing to homeschool. This is followed by a discussion of the reasons parents chose to homeschool their children with special needs, as well as the current state of research on homeschooling students with disabilities. Finally, suggestions related to homeschooling students with disabilities were made for future researchers, parents, and public school educators.” They mention ADHD. Peer-reviewed journal.
Cook, S. 1999, March 25 “Report card on home schooling in US: Study finds children taught by parents perform above national average.” The Christian Science Monitor. [Available online] (Reports on Rudner 1999 study of the home schooled.)
Coons, John E., & Sugarman, Stephen D. 1978 Education by choice: The case for family control. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Cooper, Bruce S. (Ed.) 2005 Home schooling in full view: A reader. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing. home education, research, philosophy, opinion, academic achievement, socialization, sociology, worldview, state versus family rights Edited book of chapters by authors from a wide variety of backgrounds and perspectives. Uses scholarly genre.
Cooper, Bruce S., & Sureau, John 2007, January/March The politics of homeschooling: New developments, new challenges. Educational Policy, 21(1), 110-131. http://epx.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/21/1/110 home education, research review, legal, philosophical, political, child abuse, child neglect, policy, public school, private school, negative criticism, negative critic “Homeschooling has developed from a small, isolated, parent-led effort to a vibrant national movement to lobby for and legalize K-12 education at home in all 50 states. Although a majority of homeschool families are Evangelical Christians, the others come from a variety of religious and nonreligious backgrounds, giving homeschooling a broad national political and social base. Homeschool families have organized regional and national associations, gained children’s access to after-school and even during-school classes and activities in local public schools, and increasingly gained entry to college. About 1.35 million children in the country are being officially homeschooled, making it a vital and expanding form of private education and political force in U.S. society” [abstract]. Alludes to possibility of child abuse in homeschool families that might be detected if children were in institutional schools. “A review of additional legal cases uncovers child abuse and lack of monitoring as well as other family and social issues that attendance and oversight in a public school might uncover. . . . . . Although these cases may be very rare, they do point out the need for some review and oversight to detect the situations” [p. 126]. “In some interesting ways, then, homeschool politics reaffirms the viability of local and personal political engagement. The success of homeschooling illustrates that parents and family are still the building block of a national and international political network. Although homeschool kids are taught individually or in small groups, they may also come to feel part of a vocal political, religious, and social grassroots community that knows and speaks its mind, reasserting a fundamental quality of grassroots democracy (Bielick et al., 2001). The movement is not without its critics: some who feel that children should go to school with other children and become part of the social fabric or those who see this as destroying the public school system. Despite political pressure to conform, homeschool families have become well informed, active, and influential—all qualities that are critical to the political life of society” [p. 128]. Also, abstract retrieved January 29, 2008 from http://epx.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/21/1/110.
Cooper, Bruce S.; Spielhagen, Frances R.; & Ricci, Carlo (Eds) 2016 Homeschooling in New View. Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing. homeschooling, home education, research, philosophy, academic achievement, socialization, law, legal, politics Contents: Preface: Setting the Stage, Bruce S. Cooper. I. Setting the Context. Chapter 1: Introduction to Recent Changes in U.S.A. Home schooling, Brian D. Ray. Chapter 2: The Legal Rights for Home School Families, Charles J. Russo. II. Understanding a Range of Perspectives. Chapter 3: Away with All Teachers: The Cultural Politics of Home schooling, Michael W. Apple. Chapter 4: Robbing the Cradle: State Power vs. Parental Rights in Human Rights, Michael P. Donnelly. Chapter 5: A Growing Trend: The Cases of Home schooling in North Carolina & Ohio, Lance Fusarelli, Andrew Saultz, & Andrew McEachin. Chapter 6: Are Homeschools Adequate Environments for Students with Learning Disabilities? Steven F. Duvall. Chapter 7: Socialization of Home School Children: A Communications Approach, Thomas C. Smedley. Chapter 8: The Willed Curriculum: A Self-Determined Approach to Learning at Home, Carlo Ricci. Chapter 9: Why Home Schooling Should be Regulated, Rob Reich. Chapter 10: Home schooling in Hindsight: A Parent’s Reflection, Venus Taylor. Chapter 11: Through the Lens of Home schooling, Nicky Hardenburgh. III. International Perspectives. Chapter 12: Can Families Be Trusted? An international perspective, Charles L. Glenn. Chapter 13: Home Schooling: A British Perspective, Sean Gabb. Chapter 14: Home schooling Regulation vis-a-vis Democratic Demands of Pluralism, Integration and Freedom in Spain, Ana Llano Torres. Afterword: Back to the Future? Home Schooling and the Evolution of Education, Frances R. Spielhagen.
Corbett, Michael 2008, May The Edumometer: The commodification of learning from Galton to the PISA. Journal for Critical Education Policy Studies, 6(1), 352-378. Retrieved 7/11/13 from http://www.jceps.com/print.php?articleID=125. http://www.jceps.com/print.php?articleID=125 commodification, learning, schooling, homeschooling, charter schools Mentions homeschooling in a footnote but there is no significant focus on homeschoolign in the paper. “[Note 1] In the United States and in the Britain there has been an ongoing weak critique of educational standardization that calls into question such national initiatives as the British National Curriculum and No Child Left Behind in the United States. Much of this critique, I would argue tends to accommodate the standardizing structural changes introduced into national education systems as fait accompli. It is important though to note that there has been a persistent group of anti-standardization scholars and lobbyists who have maintained the position that such tests are at least deeply problematic and at worst fundamentally distort educational practices. Some of these critics include Alfie Kohn in the United States, Marita Moll in Canada, and Guy Claxton in the UK. The rise of home schooling, alternative schools and charter schools also represent ways that parents who are critical of educational standardization have responded to and resisted the development of linear educational commodification” (p. 373). Author is from Acadia University, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Corfman, Mary Elizabeth 2017 Academic achievement and social skills of homes-schooled and traditionally-schooled adolescents. Doctoral dissertation (Walden University?). Publisher ProQuest Dissertations Publishing, Identifier ISBN: 9781369543506. academic achievement, social skills, socialization, conventional school, quantitative, comparison “Abstract. Past studies have indicated that home-schooled children perform above average in measures of achievement but these studies failed to include an assessment of social skills and failed to include samples of both home-schooled and traditionally-schooled students preventing a direct comparison between these two groups. The purpose of this study was to fill this research gap by addressing the following research questions: (1) Are there significant differences in academic achievement of home-schooled and traditionally-schooled high school students? The Economic Theory of Public Administration of Schooling suggests that home-schoolers will perform academically at least as well as traditional-schoolers; and (2) Are there significant differences in social skills levels of home-schoolers and traditional-schoolers? Social Learning Theory suggests that children learn positive social interaction from other children. The participants were high school students drawn from an ethnically and socio-economically diverse suburban area in the Lancaster and Bakersfield, CA area. A MANOVA was conducted to compare academic achievement and social skills of home-schoolers and traditional-schoolers. Statistical results indicated that there were no significant differences between the two groups in academic achievement but did indicate that students who were home-schooled score significantly lower in social skills than students who are traditionally-schooled. The positive social change implications of this study center on the need to attend to the socialization opportunities for students who are home-schooled. Parents who home-school or are considering home schooling will be able to use this information in planning their children’s education and social interactions with other students.”
Cotter, Cindy 1998, September/October Protect our freedom of educational choice. Home Education Magazine, 15(5), 29, 33. home education, public school support, cooptation, cooperation, philosophy, politics Discusses tax-funded, state-controlled, public school programs designed for home schoolers or education at home and philosophical and other concerns about the increasing number of these programs around the country. Addresses the problematic issue of clearly defining “homeschooling.” Author believes that “choice” is the sine qua non regarding this issue, without defending this a priori assumption that puts such a high value on her choice while disregarding the fact that tax-funded homeschool programs violate the choice of those who do not want to fund them with their own money via taxation, and states, “I welcome them [tax-funded homeschool programs], and I welcome the people in them. Preserving choice is what it’s all about” [p. 33].
Coulson, Andrew J. 2014, March 18 State education trends: Academic performance and spending over the past 40 years. Also, retrieved June 23, 2014 from http://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/state-education-trends. http://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/state-education-trends public schooling, public education, funding, spending, per-pupil expenditure, academic achievement, evaluation, research Finds public school spending, costs, and/or funding across the nation is negatively correlated with student academic achievement or learning as measured by the SAT test. “Executive summary: Long-term trends in academic performance and spending are valuable tools for evaluating past education policies and informing current ones. But such data have been scarce at the state level, where the most important education policy decisions are made. State spending data exist reaching back to the 1960s, but the figures have been scattered across many different publications. State-level academic performance data are either nonexistent prior to 1990 or, as in the case of the SAT, are unrepresentative of statewide student populations. Using a time-series regression approach described in a separate publication, this paper adjusts state SAT score averages for factors such as participation rate and student demographics, which are known to affect outcomes, then validates the results against recent state-level National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) test scores. This produces continuous, state-representative estimated SAT score trends reaching back to 1972. The present paper charts these trends against both inflation-adjusted per pupil spending and the raw, unadjusted SAT results, providing an unprecedented perspective on American education inputs and outcomes over the past 40 years” (p. 1). “In general, the findings are not encouraging. Adjusted state SAT scores have declined by an average of 3 percent. This echoes the picture of stagnating achievement among American 17-year-olds painted by the Long Term Trends portion of the National Assessment of Educational Progress, a series of tests administered to a nationally representative sample of students since 1970. That disappointing record comes despite a more-than-doubling in inflation-adjusted per pupil public-school spending over the same period (the average state spending increase was 120 percent). Consistent with those patterns, there has been essentially no correlation between what states have spent on education and their measured academic outcomes. In other words, America’s educational productivity appears to have collapsed, at least as measured by the NAEP and the SAT. ….. At one time or another over the past four decades, Alaska, California, Florida, and New York all experienced multi-year periods over which real spending fell substantially (20 percent or more of their 1972 expenditure levels). And yet, none of these states experienced noticeable declines in adjusted SAT scores—either contemporaneously or lagged by a few years. Indeed, their score trends seem entirely disconnected from their rising and falling levels of spending” (p. 57).
Couture, Laurie A. 2006, September/October Freeing Brycen: A single mom’s journey to adopt and unschool her child, Part 3. Life Learning, September/October 2006, 16-21. home education, unschooling, psychology, socialization, schooling, philosophy “He [Brycen, a home-educated boy] stated, ‘Public school is like a tiny box filled with stinging ants and homeschooling is like a wide open meadow full of freedom . . .” [p. 19].
Covey, Martin A.; & Covey, Kim A. 2001 Home schooling: A brief review. Families & Educational Reform, 6(1). Retrieved 7/15/13 from http://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/mfr/4919087.0006.103?rgn=main;view=fulltext. http://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/mfr/4919087.0006.103?rgn=main;view=fulltext homeschooling, academic achievement, socialization, Michigan Provides a very brief overview of research on homeschooling that is based on a very incomplete list of references and overall presents a positive portrait of homeschooling.
Cox, Rachel S. 2003, January 17 Home schooling debate: Is the movement undermining public education? CQ Researcher [Congressional Quarterly], 13(2), 25-48. home education, policy, philosophy, public schools, reasons, history, demographics, research, opinion Presents opinion, research findings, history, debate, pros and cons
Cox, William F. 1991 Home education as an expression of inalienable rights. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 3-7, 1991, Chicago, IL.
Cox, William F., Jr. 1997 The school prayer amendment: A false division between public education and the religious right. Religion & Education, 24(2), 68-73.
Cox, William F., Jr. 2000-2001 The original meaning of the establishment clause and its application to education. Regent University Law Review, 13(1), 111-143.
Cox, William F., Jr. 2003 Tyranny through public education: The case against government control of education. Washington, DC: Allegiance Press. philosophy, politics, sociology, education, policy, public schools, private schools, homeschooling, home education Argues, among other things, that education is a religious endeavor, parents have an inalienable right to raise their children free from government constraints on education, federal control of education and taxation for education is outside the legitimate authority of the U.S. Constitution, and government control of education at federal, state, and local levels is inherently tyrannical.
Cox, William F., Jr. 2005, March 16 It’s not just a bad law, it’s unconstitutional. Education Week, 24(27), 39.
Cox, William F., Jr. 2006 Parental educational responsibility: Is the medium necessarily the proper message in Christian schooling? Journal of Research on Christian Education, 15(2), 103-110.
Cox, William F., Jr. 2007 The inseparability of education and religion and implications for federal involvement in education. Evangelical Review of Society and Politics, 1(1), 42-64.
Cox, William F., Jr. 2012 A Psalm 78 perspective on education. Journal of Research on Christian Education. 21(2), 174-187.
Crampton, W. Gary 2011, March-May Scripturalism: A Christian worldview. The Trinity Review, 299, retrieved July 1, 2016 from http://www.trinityfoundation.org/journal.php?id=276 http://www.trinityfoundation.org/journal.php?id=276 Christianity, Biblicism, scripturalism, theology “Scripturalism is a world and life view. A worldview is a set of beliefs about the various issues of life. All persons have worldviews; they are inescapable. One’s worldview will determine how he views the entirety of life, the decisions he makes, why he does what he does, and so forth. And all worldviews have presuppositions which govern their system of belief; these presuppositions function as axioms from which all decisions are deduced. Scripturalism is that system of belief in which the Word of God is foundational in the entirety of one’s philosophical and theological dealings2. This system of thought avers that Christians should never try to combine secular and Christian notions. Rather, all thoughts are to be brought into captivity to the Word of God (2 Corinthians 10:5), which is (a part of) the mind of Christ (1 Corinthians 2:16). Our minds must be transformed “to prove what is that good and acceptable and perfect will of God,” as found in Scripture (Romans 12:2), i.e., our thoughts must progressively become God’s thoughts (Isaiah 55:6-9), which divine thoughts are only known by the Word of God. Scripturalism, then, teaches that all of our knowledge is to be derived from the Bible, which has a systematic monopoly on truth.”
Crater, T. D. 1981 The unproclaimed priests of public education. Christianity Today, April 10, 44-47. Criticism of public school from the religious right.
Crawford, Shelby J. 1987 Legislative Research: home-schooling in other states. Salem, Oregon.
Cremin, Lawrence A. 1961 The transformation of the school: Progressivism in American education, 1876-1957. New York, NY: Vintage Books, a division of Random House.
Cremin, Lawrence A. 1976 Traditions of American education. New York, NY: Basic Books.
Crossbourne, Trudy-Ann; & Everson, Kimberlee 2016 Factors that predict the decision to homeschool among African Americans. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Washington DC, April 8-12, 2016. https://convention2.allacademic.com/one/aera/aera16/index.php?cmd=Online+Program+View+Paper&selected_paper_id=1069699&PHPSESSID=lvl30v39fja8ufif7oubus7q16 homeschooling, home education, African Americans, reasons, motivations, minorities, academic achievement “With the current trend of homeschooling and the assertion of this method as a potential means of closing the achievement gap between African American and Caucasian students, research in this area is well needed. This study investigated the factors that have been identified as accounting for the differences in achievement and determined that these same factors were also predictors of whether or not African American parents opted to home school or to enroll their children in public or private institutions. These significant differences between parents who home school and those who do not, also contribute to student achievement. This makes it difficult to assert homeschooling as a possible solution for closing the gap” (retrieved 12/27/16 from https://convention2.allacademic.com/one/aera/aera16/index.php?cmd=Online+Program+View+Paper&selected_paper_id=1069699&PHPSESSID=lvl30v39fja8ufif7oubus7q16).
Crowson, Robert 2000 The home schooling movement: A few concluding observations. Peabody Journal of Education, 75 (1 & 2), 294-300.
Crumpton, Randall 1983 Home schools: Education for the 1980's?. Unpublished master's thesis, Amber University, place?
Currence, Cindy 1984, March 14 Bell urges more attention to role of home in schools' success. Educational Week, pp. 13, 18. Home-school.
Curry, Marilyn 1984 The motivations, procedures, and demographic characteristics of parents involved in home schooling. Unpublished manuscript, 15 Red Oak Road, Oreland, PA 19075. Survey of parents.
Curry, Marilyn 1985 Homeschooling: Why and how they are doing it. New Horizons, January, 1,3,4,13. Report of author's survey of home schoolers, primarily of religious backgrounds. Reasons.
Cushman, K. 1985 Living room as classroom. In Eastern Review November, pp. 28-32. Reprinted from New England Review, September 1986.
Cutler, William W., III 2000 Parents and schools: The 150-year struggle for control in American education. University of Chicago Press.
Daane, C.J. and Rakestraw, Jennie Fall-Winter 1990-1991 Home schooling: A profile and study of achievement test results in Alabama. Educational Freedom, 24(1), 54-58. home education, testing
Dahm, Leslie 1996, October Education at home with help from school. Educational Leadership, 54(2), 68-71. home education, policy, cooperation “But we believe that the visiting teachers [public school teachers who assists parents] are critical in making the concept work. They offer support, counseling, and suggestions at every step of the process. Offer is the key word: they do not force their views on parents. It is the parents who control their child’s education. They are responsible for planning the curriculum as well as teaching their child. They are free to incorporate their own values and philosophies” [p. 68]. Author is Coordinator, Home Instruction, Des Moines [IA] School Home Instruction Program.
Danford, Kenneth (Ed.) 2002 Liberated learners: Inspiring stories from North Star: Self-Directed Learning for Teens. Hadley, MA: North Star: Self-Directed Learning for Teens http://www.northstarteens.org home education, teens, youth, teenagers, adolescents www.northstarteens.org). (Provides stories from teens who are self-directed learners rather than attending school. Legally, those under age 16 comply with local homeschool laws and regulations.
Daniels, Martha W. 2002, July 23 Public schools in the United States: Agenda mills or academic institutions. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Madison University, Gulfport, Mississippi.
Daniels, Martha W. 2003 Public schools in the United States: Agenda mills or academic institutions. Victoria, BC, Canada: Trafford Publishing.
Danley, Elizabeth B. 1998 The use of scaffolding agents in homeschool learning environments of early adolescents. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Florida State University, Tallahassee. home education, research, qualitative, library, information studies, learning Qualitative study focusing on information seeking with the idea that librarians and other information professionals can learn from homeschool interactions.
D'Arcy, Kate 2014 Travellers and home education: Safe spaces and inequality. Trentham Books. http://ioepress.co.uk/books/social-justice-equality-and-human-rights/why-gypsies-and-other-travellers-home-educate/ home education, homeschooling, sociology, minorities, marginalized, Gypsies, Travellers “Elective home education (EHE) is a legal alternative to school in England but the statutory requirements for provision are remarkably vague. This book explores the use of EHE by Gypsy and Traveller families. The accounts of their experiences and their views about education spaces reveal the racism and discrimination their children encounter in school, and how Gypsies and Travellers still lose out when they opt for EHE. The voices of Gypsies and Travellers are seldom heard. The stories they tell here give insight into the stereotypical assumptions based on the pejorative portrayals that are peddled in the media and echoed in the mainstream literature, which too often shape the scripts of the education providers. Kate D’Arcy brings the insights offered by the Travellers together with a searching analysis of EHE provision to yield valuable new understandings about inequality in education. Travellers and Home Education is essential reading for teachers and educational managers, students, academics, policy makers and for the Traveller communities. The critical appraisal of race and racism will particularly interest those who are passionate about working towards social justice.” Retrieved July 27, 2015 from http://ioepress.co.uk/books/social-justice-equality-and-human-rights/why-gypsies-and-other-travellers-home-educate/.
Dardick, Geeta 1985 Independent study and the public schools. Mothering, Summer, p. 82-85.
Darner, Rebekka 2019 How can educators confront science denial? Educational Researcher, 48(4), 229-238. Retrieved May 7, 2020 from https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X19849415 https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X19849415 conceptual change; motivation; science education; survey research; science denial; philosophy Professors of education and practicing teachers and educators continue working to change children’s values, beliefs, fears, and other aspects of their “core personal identity” to move them to accept today’s “scientific consensus” on topics. “Evolution, climate change, vaccinations, and GMOs are scientific topics that potentially threaten one’s faith, sense of normalcy, confidence in parenting decisions, and sense of food safety. While understanding the scientific facets of topics subject to science denial is important, “science denial is less about science and more about deep fears and core personal identity” (Rosenau, 2012, p. 567; Sinatra, Kienhues, & Hoger, 2014). Emotion plays a role in both evidence evaluation (Garcia-Marques & Loureiro, 2016) and decision-making (Charpentier, De Neve, Li, Roiser, & Sharot, 2016). Thus, attending to identity and emotion is necessary for instructors attempting to foster science acceptance.” “I put forth the evidence-laden narrative (ELN) as one instructional tool that enacts these design principles and holds potential to reinforce science denying students’ identity and support basic psychological needs while engaging in critical evaluation of evidence.” “The ELN then concludes with the character making a science-informed decision that reflects the scientific consensus on the topic. ….. Indeed, Bhuva and Medina (2017) observed that science denial regarding vaccination was overcome when previously passionate anti-vaccination parents were convinced to vaccinate their children after reading about other parents’ experiences of having believed in anti-vaccination and then converting to pro-vaccination. It is worth investigating whether a similar outcome can be facilitated for students through use of ELNs.”
Daubenmier, J. 1990, February 8 Home Schooling, state standards can mesh. The Ann Arbor News, p. A12.
Davey, Katherine; Russell, Lisa; Thompson, Ron; & Bishop, Jo 2026 No other choice: The fracturing of reflexivity in families' pathways into (non-)elective home education in England. British Educational Research Journal, 00, 1–20. https://doi.org/10.1002/berj.70227 https://doi.org/10.1002/berj.70227 decision-making, educational choice, fractured reflexivity, home education, homeschooling “Abstract: In England, education is compulsory, but schooling is not: it is legal for families to home educate their children. This form of education is officially termed by the Department for Education as ‘Elective Home Education’. As this designation implies, many families home educate as a positive and preferential ‘choice’. For others, however, home education is not their desired first option. Drawing on a longitudinal research study that has explored the unfolding educational trajectories of home-educating families, this paper focuses on parents who feel they have no other choice but to home educate to resolve broader issues their children are experiencing in secondary school. Margaret Archer's concept of ‘fractured’ reflexivity provides a novel lens for unpacking the understudied processes through which such families move involuntarily into home education. It supports understanding of the considerable distress families can endure within the school system, and how this makes it increasingly difficult for parents to construct a pathway out of the situations they find their families in. Positioning the parents in this study as both courageous subjects and the ‘casualties’ of the modern education system's imperative to act reflexively highlights how their educational decision-making is conditioned structurally and frequently feels anything but free. Overall, the limited agency they experience when they de-register their children from school provides an important sociological challenge to the government's language of home education as ‘elective’.” Their data and findings are believable and match what some in the United States have found regarding both proactive (for homeschooling) and reactive (against institutional or public schooling) reasons for homeschooling one’s children.
Davies, Scott; & Aurinia, Janice 2003 Homeschooling and Canadian educational politics: Rights, pluralism and pedagogical individualism. Evaluation and Research in Education, 17(2-3), 63-73. homeschooling, Canada, politics, rights, pluralism, individualism Consider how, why, and whether homeschooling will continute to grow in Canada. Descriptions of the homeschooling community are accurate and insights and predictions are reasonable and believable. Although mention that some homeschoolers want no government control or regulation, possibly imply homeschooling will need to accept more state control if it is to grow. “Abstract: Homeschooling is becoming increasingly popular in Canada. Drawing on a variety of secondary sources and our own data from the province of Ontario, we advance three arguments. First, homeschooling is gaining legitimacy from the increasingly pluralistic nature of educational politics. Second, the lobbying tactics of homeschool advocates increasingly resemble other choice-seeking actors in education. Rather than expressing alienation from dominant political and cultural streams, most homeschool advocates frame their claims using the language of individual and parent rights. Third, as homeschooling enters the mainstream, more of its recruits are sharing in a burgeoning culture of ‘pedagogical individualism’ that prizes educational alternatives tailored to the needs of each unique child” (p. 63). “Fairly or not, mass public education is increasingly faulted for being insensitive and unresponsive to this imagined range of learning styles. As a result, private alternatives, particularly homeschooling, are being promoted through a language of rights, with homeschooling sometimes touted as the best choice to meet a child’s unique cognitive style. ….. Many existing homeschoolers, able to afford its time and expense, are willing to forfeit any financial support that would entail greater controls. ….. To grow further, then, homeschoolers will need to further elaborate their ‘rights talk’ to convince governments and the public that they are entitled to greater support, while attracting new members who will tolerate more regulation of their practice” (p. 71.)
Davis, Chris 1998, April 24 Keynote presentation to the Annual Meeting of the Massachusetts Homeschool Organization of Parent Educators, Boston, MA. home education, approach, style, pedagogy, philosophy Discusses, from biblical perspective, four types of time: eternal, practical, academic, and wasted.
Davis, Rebecca H. 2005, May 16 Homeschooling a personal choice not a movement. Teachers College Record, ID Number: 11876, Retrieved 7/28/05 online http://www.tcrecord.org/Content.asp?ContentID=11876. http://www.tcrecord.org/Content.asp?ContentID=11876 home education, reasons, academic achievement, socialization, research, review, economics, opinion, psychology, public schools “One of the most significant things that I think the non-homeschooling public needs to understand about the motivations for homeschooling is that in almost every case, the reasons are multiple.  Of the many homeschoolers I’ve questioned about their motivations for homeschooling, I’ve yet to hear a single-reason answer cited as a response. Of further importance, I believe, is the fact that I have yet to hear a homeschooler articulate his or her motivations for homeschooling without expressing that they gave the issue considerable, careful thought.  I’ve yet to hear a homeschooler say that they didn’t know why they did it or that they tried it on a whim.  The decision is usually taken after a careful (sometimes lengthy) process of deliberation, research, and (often) prayer.” “While the reasons that homeschoolers cite for their decisions are numerous, diverse, and often particularistic, homeschoolers embrace homeschooling in an era in which the public school system is experiencing a crisis of confidence that it is not likely to overcome in the near future (or ever).  No small part of understanding the growth in the number of homeschoolers is understanding this environmental variable.  Homeschooling has emerged as a successful alternative to a system that is largely believed to be a failure. Despite lingering methodological questions about homeschool versus public school comparative studies, what is clear is that homeschoolers are doing at least as well as the public school system without public school money and without need of government oversight.  It’s been suggested that homeschoolers may be saving the public millions annually.  The government and the public at large should thank us and leave us alone.”
Davis, Sarah Jeanne Hollister 2000 A survey of public school educators on the needs of home-schooled students entering the public school at the secondary level. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Wilmington College. homeschool, home education, transition, public school, attitude, opinion Explores the relationship between the public school educator and the homeschooler transitioning into the public school system at the high school level. Perceptions of public school educator regarding academic achievement, social development and parent involvement of both the previously homeschooled student and public school student were examined.
Davis-Kean, Pamela E.; Tighe, Lauren A.; & Waters, Nicholas E. 2021 The role of parent educational attainment in parenting and children’s development. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 30 (2), https://doi.org/10.1177/0963721421993116 https://doi.org/10.1177/0963721421993116 SES, socioeconomic status, parent educational attainment, parent occupation, family income, household income, academic achievement “Abstract: Socioeconomic status (SES)—indexed via parent educational attainment, parent occupation, and family income—is a powerful predictor of children’s developmental outcomes. Variations in these resources predict large academic disparities among children from different socioeconomic backgrounds that persist over the years of schooling, perpetuating educational inequalities across generations. In this article, we provide an overview of a model that has guided our approach to studying these influences, focusing particularly on parent educational attainment. Parents’ educational attainment typically drives their occupations and income and is often used interchangeably with SES in research. We posit that parent educational attainment provides a foundation that supports children’s academic success indirectly through parents’ beliefs about and expectations for their children, as well as through the cognitive stimulation that parents provide in and outside of the home environment. We then expand this model to consider the intergenerational contributions and dynamic transactions within families that are important considerations for informing potential avenues for intervention.” Addressess association and correlation between SES and academic success or perhaps academic achievement.
Davison, Kimberly 1992, July/August Schooling at home: Several south Mississippi families offer insight into the practice of home schooling. Mississippi, 21-26, 69. Home education, reasons, criticisms, socialization Families give reasons for home schooling, quotes from parents put home education in a positive light, quotes some public school attendance officers—one is slightly negative toward home education and thinks it needs to be more regulated while the other is very negative and critical toward home education and says things like "These children miss out on social development, group development, and development of other figures of authority besides the parent. ..... And they miss out on competition, in academics and in sports. ..... Home instruction is an alternative that is better than no education, but I feel they really should be in public schools. Teachers are trained to observe progress, problems, and troubles with development. Parents aren't" (p. 69).
De Jong, Norman. [DeJong] 1989 Education in the truth: Church, home, school. Lansing, IL: Redeemer Books. Education, Christian, Bible, homeschooling Discusses in ch. 10 “The responsible institution” that “In the history of education three separate institutions [the state, the church, and the home] have contested for the right and duty of establishing schools” [p. 130] and “Whoever persists in thinking of education as a secular and neutral activity will not be disturbed by our pluralistic system [in the United States]. Alarm over the inadequacy of the pluralistic answer can only come when the believer accepts the religious nature of all education” [p. 131] and subjecting children to the teachings of the church and the Christ-rejecting state schools “... the child is coerced to believe opposing philosophies” [p. 131-132]. “Scripture is very clear in its placement of educational responsibility” [p. 132]. “This incontrovertible placement of educational responsibility o the shoulders of parents is also expressed ...” [p. 133]. Is at least implicitly promoting homeschooling. Book.
DeAngelis, Corey A. 2020 Elites go to war on homeschooling — just when everyone’s doing it. Retrieved September 30, 2020 from https://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/elites-go-war-homeschooling-just-when-everyones-doing-it https://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/elites-go-war-homeschooling-just-when-everyones-doing-it homeschooling, law, legal, control, philosophy, anti-homeschooling “The article’s anti‐
DeAngelis, Corey A., & Dills, Angela K. 2019 Is school choice a “Trojan Horse?” The effects of school choice laws on homeschool prevalence. Peabody Journal of Education, 94(3), 342-354, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617584. https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617584 school choice, voucher, charter school, homeschool, home schooling, demographics, market share “The researchers asked, Do public and private school choice programs such as charters and vouchers increase or decrease the market share of homeschooling? “Abstract. School choice programs such as vouchers and charter schools expand lower cost schooling options for families. We examine how these expansions affect the prevalence of homeschooling. School choice programs may reduce homeschooling if parents that otherwise would have homeschooled their children instead use a school choice program. Homeschooling may increase if school choice programs act as a “Trojan Horse” by expanding government control in otherwise independent schools, pushing some families away from those options. We empirically examine the legitimacy of such claims by looking at the effects of public and private school choice programs on the market share of homeschooling. We use difference-indifferences to estimate whether voucher programs and charter schools influence homeschooling” (p. 1). “The outcome variable of interest, percent homeschooled, is measured in two separate ways: (1) state-reported figures of the homeschool share of the school-aged population and (2) the percent not enrolled in public or private schools for each state and year observation” (p. 3). “The explanatory variables of interest are voucher and charter” (p. 4). “Across most specifications and both measures of homeschooling, we observe decreases in homeschooling post-charter school laws, at least once the program has been in place for a few years. The effects for vouchers in our preferred specification are either statistically insignificant or suggest declines in home education once the voucher has been in place for a few years. The mixed results for vouchers may be a result of private schools moving away from supporting homeschooling in the wake of the adoption of a voucher program [emphasis added]” (p. 11).
Deckard, Steve 1986 Home Schooling Laws: All Fifty States. First Edition, 75 pp.. ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED 283304.
Deckard, Steve 2002, May High School Students' Attitudes toward Creation and Evolution Compared To Their Worldview. Impact #347, i-iv. Retrieved December 13, 2007 from http://www.icr.org/article/309/. http://www.icr.org/article/309/ home education, public schools, private schools, research, worldview, Christian, biblical, comparison, PEERS Test “Two survey instruments, the CWT (Creationist Worldview Test, Deckard, 1997) and the PEERS Test (Smithwick, Nehemiah Institute, 1995), were used to gather the data.1 The CWT test is a 51-item instrument constructed for the purpose of measuring views related to the creation/evolution controversy. The [p. i ends] PEERS Test is 70 items constructed for the purpose of measuring Christian views in politics, economics, education, religion, and social issues” [p. ii]. “Question 11 The last question focused on frequencies and magnitudes of public school students with Biblical theist worldviews when contrasted with home school and Christian school students. The results showed that 39 of the 132 participating students scored above 70.00 (the cutoff score for Biblical theist) on the CWT. Twenty of the 39 were home schoolers, while ten were Christian school and nine were public school students. For the PEERS results, five students scored as Biblical theist, four were home schoolers while one was a Christian school student. Home schoolers demonstrated the highest scores on both instruments (PEERS and CWT) in contrast to the 42 public school students who had the lowest scores on both instruments. Of the 42, only one scored in the Biblical theist range on either [p. iii ends] instrument, despite the fact that 37 of the 42 claimed to be born-again. This is alarming evidence of the damaging effect that the public/government school system is having on worldview development and the thinking of Christian youth. The Chi-Square Analysis showed a significant distribution from the home school, Christian school, and public setting. Hence it can be concluded that a positive correlation is present between having a Biblical theist worldview and mode of education” [p. iv].
Dedeaux, Roya J. 2012 An exploratory study on mental health and attitude towards psychotherapy among grown homeschoolers and homeschooling parents. Master’s thesis (Master of Science), California State University, Long Beach. homeschooling, home education, demographics, religion, reasons, mental health, happiness, family therapy, marriage and family therapy Abstract: “The present study explores the adult homeschooHng population in the United States. It examines several aspects of the culture, including their demographics and mental health characteristics, behavior, and attitude. The purpose of this study is to provide Marriage and Family Therapists (MFTs) with current and accurate information about this group in order to provide culturally appropriate mental health treatment for homeschoolers. The study had 1,052 respondents who had either been homeschooled as a minor, or homeschooled their children. The results indicated that several common assumptions about the homeschool culture are inaccurate, that homeschoolers as a group are well below clinical cut-off scores for anxiety and depression, and that several significant differences exist within the subcultures of the homeschooHng population. The implications for MFTs, limitations of the study, and ideas for future research are discussed.” “Homeschoolers appear to have fewer depressive symptoms than the general population. ….. It is generally accepted that age and depression have a positive correlation among the population. This study found that, among homeschool adults, there is a significant negative correlation. Homeschoolers who spent more time with other homeschoolers reported fewer depressive symptoms. Therapists may want to use this information to encourage clients to utilize homeschool support groups or organizations if this is a therapeutic issue.” (p. 86). “Implications for therapists exist within the scope of the mental health issue of anxiety. Overall, homeschoolers were found to have mean scores far below the clinical cut-off of 39-40. For individuals who had been homeschooled as children, anxiety decreased with age. ….. Grown homeschoolers and homeschooHng parents were found to have overall happiness levels that mirror the general population. Unschoolers had a higher mean score on the OHQ [overall happiness questionnaire? quotient?], showing more indicators of happiness.” (p. 87). “Although as a group homeschoolers exhibit less anxiety than the general population, it will still be advantageous to understand that according to the current study, people who exhibit more symptoms of anxiety also have a more negative attitude towards seeking therapeutic services” (p. 89).
Dee, Thomas S. 2023 Where the kids went: Nonpublic schooling and demographic change during the pandemic exodus from public schools: An essay for the learning curve. homeschool, growth, population size, public school enrollment, homeschool enrollment, private school enrollment, pandemic “Public school enrollment fell dramatically during the first two school years of the COVID-19 pandemic, with losses concentrated among the youngest students. But we know little about where these more than 1.2 million students went and what learning environments they are experiencing. This essay summarizes new data showing that increased homeschool enrollment and population loss each explain about one-quarter of the public school enrollment decline and that the smaller increase in private school enrollment explains substantially less, leaving more than one-third of the decline unexplained” (p. 1). Based on data from 22 states, number of homeschool students grew by 30.38% from the 2019-2020 to 2021-2022 school year.) ?
Deen, Edith 1963 Family living in the Bible. New York, NY: Harper and Row. A popular recounting of many of the family experiences in the Bible. While little technical biblical or linguistics material is discussed, the book is valuable for its systemization and analysis. Probably describes what we would today call homeschooling
Delahooke, Mona Maarse 1986 Home educated children's social/emotional adjustment and academic achievement: A comparative study. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, California School of Professional Psychology, Los Angeles, CA. home education, research, private school, causal-comparative, academic achievement, intelligence, social development Or in Dissertation Abstracts International, 47(2), 475A. Ph.D., California School of Professional Psychology, Los Angeles, 121 p. A non-experimental design included 28 home educated children with an average age of 9.2 years, and a comparison group [from private schools] of 32 children of average age 9.0 years; in a sense, causal-comparative. “Achievement test scores for the home and private school groups were in the average range, while the intelligence score estimates were in the above average range, ...” [p. 82]. Analysis of Covariance "... was conducted to determine if the groups would differ in the area of achievement, while controlling for the effects of intelligence" and univariate t-tests were used. Findings included: (a) "... no significant differences between the two groups on academic achievement levels or measured intelligence," (b) "... both groups scored in the well-adjusted range of the RATC [Roberts Apperception Test for Children]," and (c) "... significant differences were evident in the area of social relationships. The home educated children appeared to be less peer-oriented than the comparison group" [DAI]. “The home educated children appeared to be less peer-oriented than the comparison group. Subjects [p. xiii ends] educated in the private schools exhibited a significantly greater focus on peers and non-family individuals than did the home educated group” [p. xiv of dissertation]. "Home educated students were involved in extracurricluar activities: play groups (64.3% yes), organized sports (39.3%), organized clubs (32.1%), church related activities (100%), and other (67.9% yes p. 69 of dissertation).
Delaney, Angie Marie 2014 Perspectives of parents of students with disabilities toward public and homeschool learning environments. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Walden University, Minneapolis, Minnesota. disabilities, special needs, education, homeschooling, public schooling, attitudes, bullying, reasons, satisfaction “Abstract: Homeschool delivery to students is on the rise, particularly in regards to the education of students with disabilities. At this time, there is a lack of research on homeschooled students with disabilities. The purpose of this phenomenological study was to explore how parents choose a model of education for their children with disabilities. A purposeful sample of 3 distinct groups comprising 13 parents of children with disabilities was assembled: (a) parents who are homeschooling their child with a disability, (b) parents who have decided to enroll their child in the public school system after previously homeschooling, and (c) parents who may have or never have considered homeschooling their child but instead chose to have their child attend a public school. Open and selective coding techniques were used to identify significant themes in the participants’ responses. The results of the interviewed participants revealed themes of Needs, Flexibility, Child’s Request, and Bullying. These themes, especially parents stating that their child’s needs are met, were a significant reoccurring reason parents reported choosing the educational setting they did. Findings also included that overall satisfaction of parents of students with disabilities was higher among parents who had homeschooled than among parents with children in public school. Finally, topics of participation and communication between public schools and parents were explored in order to examine the possible influences of parent choice. Implications for social change include compromises from both schools and parents and a suggestion of a possible hybrid option for some students with disabilities.”
Delpit, Lisa 2003 Educators as “seed people” growing a new future. Educational Researcher, 7(32), 14-21. public schools, ethnicity, African American, philosophy, religion Promotes what she thinks is an effective education for African-American children and youth. Heavily spiritual and Afrocentric. Many statements are close to mirroring the claims of Christian educators. Discusses how black children are not well served by most public schools.
Democratic National Committee 2000, August 15 Bush and home schooling. Retrieved 8/15/00 online http://www.democrats.org/gopwatch/bushwatch/accountability/home.html. http://www.democrats.org/gopwatch/bushwatch/accountability/home.html home education, policy, politics, critics, negative criticism, negative critic Portrays Governor George W. Bush as lenient on homeschoolers and implies that Mr. Bush and the Texas government should hold homeschool parents accountable, via law or policy, for the learning of their children. Emphasizes the criticisms of homeschool law and homeschool parents made by teachers unions and government officials; gives inordinate space in the article to negative criticism of homeschooling and almost no space to positive aspects of homeschooling.
Dempster, Gregory M. 2015 The determinants of homeschooling: Evidence from the National Household Education Surveys (NHES) program. Home School Researcher, 31(4), 1-6. homeschooling, demographics, socio-economic factors, national surveys, parental and family involvement in educational choices, peer-reviewed “This research note represents an attempt to identify some of the major determinants of the decision to homeschool using a single, publicly available data set, the Parent and Family Involvement portion of the 2007 National Household Education Survey (NHES) conducted by the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES). Among the important findings of this study are the statistically significant impacts of household income, religious orientation, children’s gender, and self-identified race/ethnicity on the decision to home school a child” (p. 1). “Among the important findings of this study are the following. First, an often-posited relationship between religious orientation and the homeschooling decision has been confirmed. Families in which religion plays a major role, as evidenced by religious activity, are more likely to homeschool their children. Second, it is found that low-income families are also more likely to homeschool, presumably for the economic benefits of such a decision. Many such families might have otherwise decided on private schooling as an alternative choice, but find that the resources necessary are lacking. Third, a child’s gender is found to be a statistically significant indicator of the decision to homeschool, with females more likely to be homeschooled than males. Finally, the self-identified race/ethnicity of the parents is also a significant indicator, with Blacks, Hispanics, and Pacific Indians being less likely to homeschool after controlling for income and other factors. Each of these last two effects (gender and race/ethnicity) is particularly worthy of further exploration” (p. 4). Multivariate analysis. Peer-reviewed.
Denman, William F. 2007 A look at Christian home school co-op groups. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, International Bible College and Seminary, Independence, MO.
Denman, William F. 2009 A look at Christian home school co-op groups. Baltimore, MD: PublishAmerica. homeschooling, co-ops, co-operatives, support systems, support groups, research Apparently about the same as author’s 2007 doctoral dissertation.
Dennis, Jeanne Gowen 2004 Homeschooling high school: Planning ahead for college admission. Lynnwood, WA: Emerald Books. home education, adult, college admission, curriculum Helps parents and youth design a solid high school program that maximizes educational freedom and leads to successful college admission. Explores strategies for teaching difficult courses such as composition and laboratory sciences. Reviews research on colleges’ admissions requirements for home-educated students.
Dennison, Andrea; Lasser, Jon; Awtry Madres, Deidre; & Lerma, Yasiry 2020 Understanding families who choose to homeschool: Agency in context. School Psychology, 35(1), 20–27. https://doi.org/10.1037/spq0000341 https://doi.org/10.1037/spq0000341 homeschooling, homeschool, home education, home schooling, reasons, agency, families of color, black, African American, Latinx, students of color, psychology “Abstract: Many families elect to educate their children at home rather than enroll them in school. Whereas each family maintains its own reasons for deciding to homeschool, a factor for some families, including families of color, may be found in their response to institutions and systems that have historical roots in inequality, that have intentionally or unintentionally perpetuated inequitable outcomes for their children. This article considers the decision to homeschool in the context of families’ efforts to regain agency and self-determination. Implications for school psychologists are discussed and recommendations for policy and practice are provided.”
Deringer, Dorothy K. 1986 Computers for education in the home: Can schools tap their potential? Education and Computing, 2(1-2), 13-18. Also in CIJE, July 1987, No. EJ351 205. "Discusses the influence of home computers on school education and the effects of parental involvement in children's education. Trends in home computers in the United States are presented, and research projects examining home use of computers for education are reviewed" CIJE, 55.
Dermody, P. 1975 Aerospace education down under. Journal of Aerospace Education (Australia), November.
d'Escoto, David & Kim 2005 The little book of big reasons to homeschool. Aurora, IL: Dexios. home education, philosophy, religion, worldview, reasons Provides a Christian and biblical approach to why people should home educate their children.
Després, Blane 2011 Resistance to home education and the culture of school-based education. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 8-12, 2011, New Orleans, Louisiana. home education, homeschooling, research, systems thinking, resistance, movement, sociology, barriers Uses a systems thinking to understand why professional educators resist or oppose homeschooling, home education. “A part of understanding resistance to home education has to do with the culture of school-based education. For many it is not a definitive or even deliberate offense, but part of the culture of teaching, schooling and the grand culture in which schooling functions. Such resistance, especially at higher bureaucratic levels, might very well be misinformed, misguided and perhaps even blindly biased” [p. 2]. He is considering barriers to homeschooling by parents. “The main purpose of this project was to present findings from a review of the literature in an effort to expose the factors that inhibit home education growth and greater inclusion as a legitimate education practice irrespective of credentials, prior training or parental choice of education models. Systemic thinking applied in this case offers multiple strands of understanding home education, resistance and the role of education in culture” [p. 3]. “In the past three decades education has seen the rise of resistance as a cultural issue, championed as a pedagogical cause célèbre, for example, by Paulo Freire (1973), Henry Giroux (1995, 1983a, 1983b), or Jerome Satterthwaite, [p. 11 ends] et al (2003) and others. In these cases resistance, like the actions of national patriots is perceived as a necessary pursuit against the political dominance of the (perceived evil) culture in power. That culture in power is viewed as malevolent because, in practice, it seems to demonstrate preferences that are not inclusive of other cultural, ideological or political beliefs. Is this a possible interpretation of homeschooling and the counter perceptions of the status quo public schooling?” [p. 12]. “An anticipated outcome of this paper is that educators and researchers alike will consider revisiting the purpose of education, including home education, for the 21st century as a systemic necessity; not as a [sic] utilitarian or [p. 13 ends] instrumentalist function for local and global economies, but as the best opportunity to achieve the highest common good for children as persons” [p. 14].) Revised notes
Després, Blane 2013 A question of resistance to home education and the culture of school-based education. Peabody Journal of Education, 88(3), 365-377, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2013.798512. https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2013.798512 home education, homeschooling, philosophy, systems approach, public school, educators attitudes, barriers Author provides a theoretical and in-depth evaluation of why school-based educators resist homeschooling. He opens a philosophical and systems-based conversation on this topic. Address some barriers [e.g., professional educators, schooling or educational systems] to parents practicing homeschooling. “[Abstract] Public educator resistance to home education is not a definitive or deliberate offense but part of the culture of teaching, schooling, and the grand culture in which schooling functions. Such resistance, especially at higher bureaucratic levels, stems from a faith stance that might very well be misinformed, misguided, and perhaps even blindly biased. A reading of the roles of teachers and resistance to change from a systems thinking framework informs this work. The main purpose of this article is to present findings from a review of the literature in an effort to expose the critical factors that might inhibit home education growth, acceptance—especially by educators—and greater inclusion as a mainstream education practice. Systemic thinking application in combination with the topic of home education offers multiple strands of understanding home education, systems thinking, and resistance. This article furthers the discussion on home education and prompts educators and researchers alike to reconsider home education and educator roles for the 21st century not as utilitarian functions for local and global economies but as coworkers toward a perceived common goal for children” (p. 365). “In educational practice, resistance [to homeschooling] shows itself throughout the various levels of the system. Primarily this resistance is evident in entrenched teaching (styles, modes, delivery or philosophy), in hierarchical management styles, in top-down “reform” projects, and in community or parental expectations. Implementers of change must struggle with some or all of these strategic areas. With this in mind, resistance appears to be a normal function" (p. 370). “In the past three decades, education has seen the rise of resistance as a cultural issue, championed as a pedagogical cause c´el`ebre. Freire (1973); Giroux (1995, 1983a, 1983b); Satterthwaite, Atkinson, and Gale (2003); and others highlight this fact. In the case of these authors’ work, resistance, like the actions of nationalist patriots, is perceived as an ideologically motivated or necessary reaction against the political dominance of the (perceived as evil) culture in power. That culture in power may be viewed as malevolent because, in practice, it seems to demonstrate preferences that exclude or marginalize other cultural, ideological, or political beliefs. I suggest this plausible interpretation of homeschooling as a perceived counterculture practice (see Arai, 2000; Kunzman, 2010)” (p. 371). Thus the culture in power is a barrier to homeschooling or people choosing or practicing homeschooling. Mentions Canada a couple of times but does not focus on Canada.) Revised notes
DesRoches, Danika I.; Deacon, S. Hélène; Rodriguez, Lindsey M.; Sherry, Simon B.; Nogueira-Arjona, Raquel; Elgendi, Mariam M.; Meier, Sandra; Abbass, Allan; King, Fiona E.; & Stewart, Sherry H. 2021 Homeschooling during COVID-19: Gender differences in work–family conflict and alcohol use behaviour among romantic couples. Social Sciences, 10, 240, retrieved July 9, 2021 from https://www.mdpi.com/2076-0760/10/7/240 https://www.mdpi.com/2076-0760/10/7/240 COVID-19; gender inequalities; homeschooling; home schooling; school at home; work–family conflict; alcohol use Abstract: Homeschooling due to COVID-19 school closures is likely to increase conflict between work and family demands, potentially leading to adverse substance-use effects. We conducted a survey with 758 couples focusing on homeschooling, work–family conflict, and alcohol use (April 2020). The 211 homeschooling couples reported more work–family conflict than the 547 non-homeschooling couples; there also were stronger effects on family interference with work in women. Among the homeschooling couples, homeschooling hours were associated with greater partner drinking. In distinguishable dyad analyses by gender, women’s hours homeschooling were associated with greater drinking frequency by both parents. Men’s hours homeschooling were associated with lower drinking frequency in their partners. Increased work–family conflict in homeschooling couples is particularly worrisome given its link to increased stress and poor mental health. Moreover, women’s increased drinking may impede their ability to support their families during the pandemic. Men’s increased drinking could put homeschooling mothers at risk for escalating conflict/domestic violence, given links of male drinking to intimate partner violence. Finally, the protective-partner effects of men’s homeschooling hours on women’s drinking frequency suggests that more egalitarian division of homeschooling labor may have protective cross-over effects.”) New ???
Devins, Neil, & Zirkel, Perry A. 1986 Home instruction: Two views. (ERIC Reproduction Service No. 273 004) Also, In Jones, Thomas N. & Semler, Darel P. (Eds.), 1986, School law update. "The line separating permissible from intrusive state regulations is unclear. The extent of parental authority must be discerned through an entanglement of state court decisions. Zirkel argues that lower courts' decisions have been relatively consistent in rejecting constitutional amendment rights for parents. Contrary to Devins' contention, courts have narrowly interpreted the `Wisconsin v. Yoder' ruling to reject parents' free exercise challenges against state statutes. Many court decisions have rejected parental nonreligious constitutional challenges. Without constitutional mandates, the issues of regulatory standards are a slippery but central concern" Resources in Education, 22(1), 57. Law.
DeVoe, Dale, Kennedy, Cathy, & Lloyd, Crystal A. 1996 Physical fitness and activity characteristics of home schooled children. Home School Researcher, 12(1), 1-6. home education, research, physical fitness “Analysis of the data collected for this study indicated that the home schooled participants showed similar findings in physical fitness variables to values of reported average data” [p. 4, 5]. Anthropometric measurements (e.g., percent body fat), hamstring flexibility, factors measured by hand grip dynamometer tests were studied. “The results of this investigation demonstrate that the physical fitness and activity characteristics of the home schooled children in this investigation were comparable to average reported values which are derived primarily from conventionally schooled children” [p. 5]. Concluded that even though home school children had fitness characteristics which were similar to those of children in public schools, the home schooled were not particularly physically active. Recommends “...the development of a strong wellness education program in the home school environment with emphasis on positive attitudes toward physical fitness, especially in girls who eventually become mothers and influence their children's fitness behaviors. These findings also indicate the need to educate home schoolers about ways to provide physical activities for their children either at home by themselves or with others in support groups” [p. 5].
Diangelo, Robin 2018 White fragility: Why it’s so hard for white people to talk about racism. Boston, MA: Beacon Press. critical theory, critical race theory, racism, white fragility, education “As a result, we [White people in North America] are insulated from racial stress, at the same time that we come to feel entitled to and deserving of our advantage [over other races]” (p. 1). The teachings of this author and her worldview being often promoted in public government schools is one reason that many parents want their children never in or take out of public schools to be homeschooled.) ?
Dietrich, Eileen J. 2008 A Return to the Classics: The emergence of Christian and classical schools. Private School Monitor, 29(1), 1-8. private education, private schools, classical education, Christian education, pedagogy, philosophy, curriculum “The United States has 213 Christian and classical private schools -- with six more that are international; and all these schools are members of the Association of Christian and Classical Schools. They are distinguished for their classical curriculum and methodology as well as their commitment to teaching everything in the context of a Biblical worldview. While the Christian faith is their distinction from other schools, the classical methodology differs significantly from modern, “progressive” American education. Dorothy Sayers, a renowned British author and translator, who penned the influential essay, The Lost Tools of Learning, is credited with providing the basis for the classical education movement in the United States. In her essay which she orally presented at Oxford in 1947, Sayers claims that “although we often succeed in teaching our pupils „subjects,‟ we fail lamentably on the whole in teaching them how [p. 1 ends] to think…They learn everything except the art of learning” (Sayers, 1947). Sayers was an ardent classicist who revived the trivium as a means of mastering all other subjects” [p. 3]. “Classical educators believe that the school is an extension of the home; it is a place where the minds of children are engaged and the emphasis is on developing the whole child. Child development occurs in all areas including intellectually, spiritually, emotionally, and physically” [p. 7]. Bibliography author’s experience is that classical education is quickly gaining in popularity with homeschoolers during the 2000s.
Dill, Jeffrey S. & Elliot, Mary 2019 The Private Voice: Homeschooling, Hannah Arendt, and political education, Peabody Journal of Education, 94:3, 263-280, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617578. https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617578 homeschooling, home schooling, political education, philosophy “Abstract. What becomes of the political orientation of American education when children are educated in the home rather than in public schools? Homeschooling critics raise concerns over the larger consequences: political exit and even indoctrination. Drawing on a recent study of 62 interviews with 35 homeschooling families in 11 states in the USA, we offer a theoretical argument grounded in empirical observations and perceptions of homeschoolers themselves. Using the work of political theorist Hannah Arendt as a guide, we suggest that, contrary to critics’ claims of political exit over voice, homeschooling may provide the opportunity for some families to respond with a “private voice” that is politically robust because it is intentionally subversive to a (perceived) homogenous dominant culture. We thus argue that some homeschoolers offer an understanding of private life that is political without being “public,” and that they reconcile this irony by attempting to cultivate reflexive “thinking” in their children regarding questions of conformity, materialism, and plurality.”
Dills, Angela 2021, June 3 Is child abuse greater at school or homeschool? https://www.hks.harvard.edu/centers/taubman/programs-research/pepg/events/future-homeschooling https://www.hks.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/Taubman/PEPG/conference/homeschool-conference-slides-dills.pdf homeschooling, home schooling, child abuse, child neglect, abuse, neglect, fatalities or, “Homeschooling and child safety: Are kids safer at home?) Paper presented at Post-Pandemic Future of Homeschooling, June 3, 2021, online. Retrieved August 4, 2021 from https://www.hks.harvard.edu/centers/taubman/programs-research/pepg/events/future-homeschooling and https://www.hks.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/Taubman/PEPG/conference/homeschool-conference-slides-dills.pdf (Found no clear evidence of an increase in reported incidents of abuse in states that relaxed controls or bans on homeschooling. Considered data from 15 states. Collected data on violent deaths of children from the U.S. CDC and Child maltreatment fatalities and cases from the NDACAN. Author stated that these are preliminary findings) .
Dills, Angela 2022 Homeschooling and child safety: Are kids safer at home? Journal of School Choice, https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2022.2113355 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2022.2113355 homeschooling, abuse, neglect, mortality, research, quantitative, peer-reviewed “Abstract: Safety remains a key concern for parents and education policy makers. Homeschooling opponents argue that child abusers use homeschooling to isolate and harm their children while public school teachers and administrators, as mandatory reporters, reduce child maltreatment. Supporters of homeschooling argue that public schools expose children to bullying from their peers and that some school employees also mistreat children. In the 1980s and 1990s, most states adopted legislation clarifying a legal path for homeschooling. I conduct two-way fixed effects and event study analyses of the effect of homeschool rules on measures of child safety. Although most estimates are not statistically significant, some specifications find a statistically significant increase in child homicide rates in the years following homeschool legislation. Better understanding how a variety of educational options affect children’s safety continues to be a pressing aspect of education policy.” As an independent or predictor variable, she writes, "I focus on the effect of state-level legislation ... that clarified the legality of homeschooling." She examines whether this is related to or causes child maltreatment. All of her findings/differences, except one, were insignificant. See, Figure 5; this is an important point-in-time statistically significant finding. There were about 4 more homicides (per 100,000) at year 4 (statistically significant) and not significantly different at years 1, 2, and 3, and then it was lower (not statistically significant different from year 0) again at year 5.) My summary: The state-level legislation is: (a) not related to child mortality rates. (b) not related to child maltreatment, and (c) not related to child homicide rates at 1, 2, and 3 years following legislation, is correlated at 4 years, and then again is not correlated at 5 years following legislation, and the study does not classify the enacted legislation as more, the same, or less state control/regulation related to homeschooling. Author points out that for the government to control homeschooling more, must have empirical evidence there is a problem with homeschooling and this study shows none and then the solutions to the problem must be likely to solve the problem (that is not significant regarding homeschooling.
Divoky, Diane 1983 Home schooler's choice: "I'll teach myself." Learning, 78-79. Home school families generally "... feel that the schools are not providing the kind of environment they want for their children. They see the schools as places where parents can exert little control over the influences that will shape their children" (p. 78). School administrators might find it beneficial to cooperate with home schoolers.
Divoky, Diane 1983 The new pioneers of the home-schooling movement. Phi Delta Kappan, 64, 395-398. Describes home schooling as once a subversive activity but now a more respected educational alternative and movement with its own "gurus, publications, and support networks." Gives examples of educators who are positive toward home education, describes home schoolers, and indicates that although differences in philosophies and methodologies exist among home schoolers, they are similar in that they are willing to be different and take a socially unorthodox route to raising the kind of children they want. "And they are willing to be different, to take a socially unorthodox route to rearing the kind of children they want" (p. 397). Description, survey, policy making.
Dobson, James C. 1987 Dr. Dobson answers your questions. Focus on the Family, 11(2), 4-5. Working mothers. Response to Guidubaldi, et al. (1986) study. Critiques design of the correlational study, saying that not enough controls were included in the comparisons. Quotes a research design and statistics expert who criticizes the study.
Dobson, James C. 1992 The new dare to discipline. Wheaton, IL: Tyndale House Publishers, Inc. child training, parenting, research, home education, Christian perspective Explains that home schooling is an excellent educational alternative, especially for children slow to develop. “I will say this: If Shirley and I had it [sic] do over, we would have home-schooled our two children, at least for the first few years!” [p. 168]. Chapter that includes home schooling heavily relies on research by Brian Ray and the National Home Education Research Institute.
Dobson, James C., & Bauer, Gary L. 1990 Children at risk. Dallas, TX: Word Publishing. Family, education, society, etc.
Dobson, Linda 1998 Homeschoolers success stories. [book] [mis?? publisher]
Dobson, Linda 1998 The homeschooling book of answers. [book] [mis?? publisher]
Dolan, Lawrence J. & Haxby, Barbara Spring 1991 Helping children where they live. Equity and Choice, pp. 89-96. educational improvement, family influence
Donahue, Tara, & Plank, David N. 2003, March Michigan’s role in monitoring home schools. East Lansing, MI: The Education Policy Center at Michigan State University. Retrieved 4/9/03 online http://www.epc.msu.edu/publications/report/report15.pdf. http://www.epc.msu.edu/publications/report/report15.pdf home education, state regulation or state control, law, legal, philosophy, parental rights Argues that the state, rather than the parents, must have final authority over whether a child is being properly educated. Urges State of Michigan to assert more control and regulation over homeschool families. “If you live in Michigan, chances are you know somebody who is home- schooling his or her children. And, if you do, chances are you know more about the education those children are getting than the state of Michigan does” [p. 1]. “The fundamental question is thus whether the rights of the children as learners and citizens are separate from the rights of parents, and what [p. 4 ends] steps the state should take to protect the rights of both children and parents” [p. 5]. “Opponents of home school monitoring assert that parents are the primary authority figure in a child’s life, and that the state should have no role in how children are raised. Home school advocates argue that parents have a fundamental right to choose how their children will be educated, and that the state has no right to interfere in this choice. From this perspective, the rights of parents supersede the rights of their children, making the welfare of children solely the responsibility of their parents. Those of the opposing view hold that children have rights as learners, and that ignoring or neglecting these rights can result in educational neglect or abuse. When children are physically neglected or abused, they argue, society recognizes the state’s obligation to intercede in order to protect the child. Proponents of state monitoring maintain that the state has a similar right to intercede when a child’s educational development is neglected. In this view, education is a state interest as well as an individual right, because it is essential for good government and a strong economy” [p. 5].
Donnelly, Michael 2024 Data or ideology: What is driving homeschooling policy around the world, and why?, Journal of School Choice, 18:4, 683-696, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2024.2422251 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2024.2422251 Homeschooling policy; home education; data driven policy; comparative education policy; homeschooling regulation Abstract: “Does empirical evidence or ideology most influence homeschooling policy? It depends. Where empirical research and social experience abound, regulations seem less restrictive but where there is less data or experience policies seem more restrictive and ideologically driven. By comparing Europe and the United States with a look at South Africa, Canada and Brazil, I test this hypothesis. The article calls for policy makers to use empirical research not ideology to inform policy. The article suggests that as homeschooling gains social acceptance, more empirical research is conducted, and policymakers appear more inclined to adopt less restrictive policy..”
Donnelly, Michael P. 2011 Religious freedom in education: Real pluralism and real democracy require real choices for parents. International Journal for Religious Freedom, 4(2), 61-75. homeschooling, home education, legal, law, religious freedom, parental autonomy, parental rights, government restrictions on religion, family integrity, persecution, suffering, democracy and pluralism, human sexuality “Abstract: Modern governments increasing their role in education have caused increasing conflicts when parental religious or philosophical convictions conflict with values represented by school curriculum and activities. International human rights recognize the superior right of parents to control their child’s education and free nations must not impose unreasonable constraints on private schools and should permit their citizens to homeschool. However countries like Germany and Sweden do excessively regulate private schools and either oppress or highly disfavor homeschooling causing some to flee while others have sought, and in at least one case received, political asylum in the United States” [p. 61].
Donnelly, Michael P. 2012 a global perspective on freedom in education through the eyes of the homeschool movement. University of St. Thomas Journal of Law and Public Policy, 7(1), 51-69. homeschooling, home schooling, home education, freedom, liberty, philosophy, law, legal, likely not peer-reviewed
Donnelly, Michael P. 2016 State power versus parental rights: An international human rights perspective on home education. In Cooper, Bruce S.; Spielhagen, Frances R.; & Ricci, Carlo (Eds), Homeschooling in New View. Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing.
Dorian, Terry, & Tyler, Zan 1996 Anyone can homeschool: How to find what works for you. Lafayette, LA: Huntington House Publishers. home education, advocacy, philosophy “Must the statement anyone can homeschool be qualified? Probably—but in a much different way than your common sense may dictate. The qualifying ingredient is not educational credentials or socioeconomic standing—the qualifying ingredient is motivation. Anyone who wants to homeschool can” [p. 15].
Dornbusch, S., Ritter, P. & Lieberman, P. 1987 The relation of parenting style to adolescent school performance. Child Development, 58, 1244-1257.
Dotterweich, Douglas P.; McKinney, Michael M.; & Michael, Leigh Anne M. 2012, May 28 Economic impact of home and private schooling in Iowa (final report). Des Moines, IA: Network of Iowa Christian Educators NICHE). (“Executive Summary. This study examines whether home and private school students provide a net benefit or cost to the public education system in Iowa. Through interviews with knowledgeable public education officials and an examination of Iowa Area Education Agency records, 15,975 home school and 33,933 private school students are enrolled in the 2009 -10 school year. Certified Annual Reports for the State of Iowa indicate that the annual level of public school funding is $5.048 billion and $10,618 per public school student. Because non-public students help to fund the public school system but receive a rather small amount of state resources, they provide a net benefit to the public system in Iowa. The annual cost saving due to home and private school students in 2009 -10 is estimated to be between $88- $149 million for home school and $212-$339 million for private school students for a combined $300-$488 million using average total cost and property tax savings methods. This amounts to an average savings of between $632 and $945 per Iowa public school student” [p. 2].
Drazin, Nathan 1940 History of Jewish education from 515 B.C.E to 220 C.E. Baltimore, MD: The John Hopkins Press. Description of developments in the Jewish educational system from complete parental responsibility through higher, secondary, and elementary education. May explode myths for both pro- and anti- home schooling camps.
Dreher, Rod 2001, March 18 Victimized kids, you can go home again. New York Post. Published 3/18/01 and retrieved 3/20/01 online http://www.nypost.com/03182001/commentary/26726.htm. http://www.nypost.com/03182001/commentary/26726.htm home education, socialization, violence, public schools “Parents who home-school their children say the No. 1 question they get from others is: "Won't your kids miss out on proper socialization?" ..... Sick of her son being bullied, the dumbing-down of classwork and the way teachers and other kids made her gifted son feel like a freak, Storm took the boy out of school 21/2 years ago. "This was a loving child who was enthusiastic about life until I sent him to school, and he turned into a fearful, insecure person," she said. "Now I have my son back." Storm says escaping school bullying was "about 78 percent" of the reason she and her husband initially decided to home-school their two children, though they have been confirmed in their decision by how well the kids have done academically in a home setting. ..... Barbara Vanderslaw, a home-schooling mother of six who lives in the West Village, agrees, saying that safety was not a big reason she and her husband opted for home education. Still, she acknowledges it's a relief that her kids don't have to live with the fear they might be targets for bullies, or a random school shooter. "Why aren't these adults in the lives of these kids aware of what these kids are doing to one another?" Vanderslaw asks. "Maybe our society's ideas of socialization aren't so great after all." Even when home-schooled kids outperform others academically, skeptics will claim that children will become socially stunted if educated away from classrooms. "My husband likes to say, 'Do you really want your kids socialized by other kids, or adults?'" says Chris Hofer, a home-schooling mother of three from Ossining. "When you send them to school, you're putting them in a classroom with 30 kids their own age. That's not reality, either.””
Drenovsky, Cynthia K.; & Cohen, Isaiah 2012 The impact of homeschooling on the adjustment of college students. International Social Science Review, 87(1 & 2), 19-34. homeschooling, college, social development, socialization, academic achievement, peer-reviewed Cross-sectional, descriptive study. Conducted online survey of college students, and “… 185 responded, an 11.7% response rate.” “The online questionnaire included twenty-nine closed-ended items about educational background and present student engagement on campus. Several items from the National Survey on Student Engagement (NSSE) were included. The NSSE is a questionnaire that measures student participation in academic and extracurricular activities at four-year colleges and universities across the United States. (38) Items from the NSSE used in this study include: internship participation, student-faculty research, attendance at plays and concerts, and impressions of relationships with fellow students and faculty. To measure one's social and personal adjustment to college, the Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale was employed. This is a widely used ten-item measure of self-esteem that has demonstrated high levels of reliability over the years. (39) Another measure of adjustment used in the online survey is the Center for Epidemiological Studies-Depression Scale (CES-D). (40) This is a twenty-item code-ended inventory of self-reported symptoms of depression. (41) The CES-D is a reliable measure that has shown high levels of internal consistency. (42)” “The data collection efforts resulted in a sample of 185 undergraduate college students. Within this sample, 150 respondents had at least 1-3 years of homeschooling during their primary or secondary school years; 35 respondents had no homeschooling experience in their educational history. Nearly two-thirds of the respondents (64%) were homeschooled for 10-12 years of their primary and secondary education (see Figure 1). The average age of the respondents is 20.39 (SD=1.63). Sixty-one percent (113) of the sample is female; 39 percent (72) is male.” “As shown in Table 1, respondents who were homeschooled at any point during their primary or secondary schooling did not have significantly different levels of self-esteem compared to students who were never homeschooled. No other independent variable in the model has a statistically significant impact on self-esteem, with the exception of scouting, which decreased self esteem levels (p<.05).” “As shown in Table 2, respondents who were homeschooled at any point during their primary or secondary education have significantly lower levels of depression (p<.05).” Peer-reviewed.
Drury, Elizabeth Childs 2014 Beyond socialization, tolerance, and cultural intelligence: Sustainable cultural concern among evangelical homeschoolers. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Cook School of Intercultural Studies, Biola University, La Mirada, California. cultural intelligence, culture, home education, homeschooling, socialization, tolerance, cultural anthropology, sociology “Abstract: This qualitative study not only describes the intercultural capacities of 20 high-achieving, homeschooled, evangelical university students from diverse backgrounds, but also far surpasses this original aim by generating a new model that critiques and complements cultural intelligence theory (CQ). Debate regarding tolerance among homeschoolers has lacked adequate study because the right questions have been obscured by terminology too broad (socialization) and impossibly loaded (tolerance). This constructivist, grounded-theory study thus addresses the question through intercultural lenses. Chapter 2 reviews literature to propose a Process-Outcome Model of Socialization, a 10-pair categorization of critics' concerns, and introduces a reconceptualization of Perry's (1970) scheme of epistemological development for a faith-based university. Chapter 3 describes data-collection. In Southern California, strategies include participant observation, interview, focus-group, narrative, written reflection about Emerson & Smith's (2000) Divided by Faith, and case study response. In metropolitan DC, shorter measures confirm theoretical saturation. Chapter 4 presents 20 participants' intercultural journeys. Chapter 5 traces cognition. Chapter 6 outlines motivation, describing intercultural self-efficacy, initiative, and perceived value. Chapter 7 offers evidence of metacognition. Chapter 8 provides the missing piece--concern--as the connector of knowledge and desire, showing that the most intense reflection and regulation operate based on higher commitments metaphysical, existential, and ethical). Chapter 9 integrates core categories to present two new models. One shows the complementarity of CQ and concern. The other unites them as Sustainable Cultural Concern (SCC), a model explaining why some people grow in intercultural capacities while others do not. Three assertions underlie these models: a) concern is a meta-commitment that differs from motivation; b) CQ and border-crossing concern cooperate to sustain growth; c) a culturally-concerned person seeks to wed knowledge and desire according to concern. Though most participants display sustainable cultural concern, unconcerned outliers strongly suggest that homeschoolers and organizations should intentionally cultivate it. Methodologically, the models correct inconsistencies regarding homeschooling socialization and challenge the prevalence of quantitative studies. Theoretically, they highlight ambiguity and overlap in CQ domains and the disproportionate scope of metacognition. Practically, they guide personal evaluation of intercultural engagement and growth in perception (honor), understanding (humility), regulation (integrity), and volition (faithfulness).”
Dudzinski, Deanna, & Peters, Donald L. 1977 Home-based programs: A growing alternative. Child Care Quarterly, 6(1), 61-71.
Duffey, Jane Grenfell 2000 Home schooling children with special needs: A descriptive study. Doctoral dissertation (Ph.D.), The College of William and Mary, Virginia. home education, special needs, policy, law “This descriptive study sought to extend the knowledge base on home schooling to include the population of families with special needs children. The author compared the results of this study on special needs home schooled children to previous studies on the general population of home schoolers and presented case studies of four families. Through a nationally distributed survey, data was generated that provided demographics, educational backgrounds of both parents and students, and information about the content and process of the home school. The second phase of the study provided an in-depth look into the lives of four families who home schooled at least one special needs child. [new paragraph] The results of the survey suggested that home schooling families with special needs children were similar to their counterparts within the general population of home schoolers. The most significant difference was in the number of years special needs children were conventionally schooled. Special needs children, whose parents are more likely to seek help from outside sources, are enrolled in conventional schools longer, and were more likely to participate in part-time services than regular home schoolers. [new paragraph] The study recommended the development and implementation of public access policies at the state and local levels for home schooling families. Also, the study suggested a need for a collaborative relationship between home schooling families and their local educational agencies. Since this study was exploratory and descriptive in nature, further research is needed to address the efficacy of the practice in academic and social terms” [abstract, received from author via e-mail on April 2, 2000].
Duffey, Jane Grenfell 2002 Home schooling children with special needs: A descriptive study. Home School Researcher, 15(2), 1-13, https://nheri.org/home-school-researcher-home-schooling-children-with-special-needs-a-descriptive-study/ https://nheri.org/home-school-researcher-home-schooling-children-with-special-needs-a-descriptive-study/ homeschooling, home education, special needs, research, peer-reviewed “How Can the Home School be Structured, What are the Instructional Practices, and What is the Nature of The Curriculum? The surveys indicated that the respondents were resourceful in structuring their home schools. The parents often sought and used outside help in meeting the needs of their children. In addition to teaching their special needs children, the parents enrolled them in various therapies and counseling (76%). Twenty-four percent enrolled their children on a part-time basis in conventional schools. Additionally, 97% of the families were members of support groups and used support services.” “What are the Home Schooling Parents’ Perceptions of the Home Schooling Experience Concerning Academic and Social Progress? The overall perception of academic progress of the home schooled survey children by their parents was positive. Ninety-six percent claimed some academic progress whether test scores were noted or a less quantifiable measure used, such as an evaluation based upon an IEP. Eighty-nine percent of the survey respondents felt that their special needs children exhibited either average or improved social progress since home schooling. The parents noted that their special needs children participated in extracurricular activities on the average of 4.14 activities per child.” peer-reviewed journal.
Duffy, Cathy 1995 Government nannies: The cradle-to-grave agenda of Goals 2000 and outcome based education. Gresham, OR: Noble Publishing Associates. education, social policy, sociology Explains and documents how federal policy and outcome-based education will take away from the family its historical and traditional roles. Duffy writes: “Do parents have the right to pass on their beliefs to their children, or does the village [government] have the right to override parental convictions? Who determines the school agenda? Should parents have the right to reject all or part of an agenda determined by the village? I realize that these questions suggest fare more than a challenge to a few programs. They cut to the heart of educational philosophy in the United States. They even question the right of government to be involved in education at all” [p. 48].
Duffy, Matthew, (Ed.) 1997 Hothouse transplants: Moving from homeschool into the real world. Westminster, CA: Grove Publishing. home education, adults, adulthood, anecdotes, biography Presents a collection of firsthand stories of youth and young adults who were home educated.
Duggan, Molly 2010 Is All College Preparation Equal? Pre-Community College Experiences of Home-Schooled, Private-Schooled, and Public-Schooled Students. Community College Journal of Research and Practice, 34(1-2), pages unknown. College Preparation, Community Colleges, Public Schools, Home Schooling, peer-reviewed, homeschooling “The goal of this descriptive cross-sectional pilot study was to increase researcher knowledge of precollege preparation in three populations of traditional students attending a community college in a mid-Atlantic state: public-school students, home-schooled students, and private-schooled students. By its exploration of precollege experiences and their perceived impact among these three populations, this research extends the conversation on traditional student college preparation to include students from home-schooled and private-schooled backgrounds, two groups attending the community college in increasing numbers. Findings suggest that precollege preparation differs amongst the groups. Home-schooled students were more likely to credit their current abilities, skills, and knowledge to their previous educational experiences than were either of the remaining groups. Private-schooled student responses tended to be the next highest, followed by public-schooled student responses. In general, more home-schooled students rated themselves as above average and in the top 10% of their peers on their general academic ability, mathematical ability, reading comprehension, and their drive to achieve than the other student groups. More private-schooled respondents rated themselves as above average and in the top 10% of their peers on their study skills compared to the other groups, and more public-schooled respondents rated themselves as above average and in the top 10% of their peers on their computer skills and in their writing ability. Responses differed among respondents as to their intent to return to the community college within in the next 12 months although a two-sample t-test between proportions was not significant. Implications for research and practice are included. This is about what college students think is the source/cause of their college prep but not really compare a learning outcome. Peer-reviewed.
Duggan, Molly, & Sorey, Kellie 2007 Admissions' officers perceptions of and attitudes toward homeschoolers entering the community college. Paper presented at the 50th Annual Conference of the Council for the Study of Community Colleges, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, April 5, 2007. http://ww2.odu.edu/~mduggan/research/CSCC08homeschool.pdf homeschooling, research, home education, college, adults, college admission Retrieved 1/28/13 from http://ww2.odu.edu/~mduggan/research/CSCC08homeschool.pdf. “Abstract With the popularity of home schooling strengthening at the secondary level, the prevalence of homeschoolers now attempting to enter higher education is escalating. Despite this trend, many college admissions officers across the United States seem unprepared in evaluating these candidates for admission. This study explores admissions policies and procedures as well as the perceptions and attitudes of community college admissions officers toward the homeschooled applicant. Implications for community colleges and future research are also provided” [p. 2]. “NOTE: A version of this paper will appear in an upcoming edition of Journal of College Admission. Please do not cite without permission of the authors.”
Duin, Steve date unknown, pre-1991 Home-schooling, without the hysteria. The Sunday Oregonian: Northwest Magazine, p. 4.
Dumas, Tanya K., Gates, Sean, & Schwarzer, Deborah R. 2010 Evidence for homeschooling: constitutional analysis in light of social science research. Widener Law Review, 16(1), 63-87. homeschooling, law, policy, constitution, philosophy “[abstract] Homeschooling is a time-honored and widespread practice. It often presents, however, a conflict between the constitutional right of parents to direct the education of their children and the State’s right to impose regulations in the interest of ensuring an educated citizenry. The U.S. Supreme Court has made it clear that any regulation impacting this constitutional right must be “reasonable.” Courts have therefore generally resolved homeschooling cases by examining whether State regulation of homeschooling places an unreasonable burden on the rights of parents. The courts, however, have altogether failed to address another, more fundamental question: whether the State regulation, in fact, advances the State interest. A regulation that fails this criterion cannot be “reasonable.” Using a recent California appellate court case that initially upheld a regulation prohibiting parents from homeschooling their children unless they first obtained a state teaching credential, we show how recent social science research should impact the analysis. Instead of assuming away the issue of whether the regulation advances the State interest, we show that empirical research will allow courts to be able to answer this threshold question” (p. 63) “A state has a compelling interest in the education of its children and may adopt regulations to advance this interest so long as it does not violate the fundamental constitutional rights of parents. The test of whether a regulation is permissible has two prongs: it must both be narrowly drawn to avoid undue restriction of fundamental rights and serve the State’s compelling interest. The right of parents to control the education and upbringing of their children encompasses the right to teach them at home. The evidence presented in this Article demonstrates not that restricting homeschooling better serves a State’s interest in education, but that the opposite is true: that homeschooling serves, rather than defeats, this interest, and that this interest is best met by ensuring that parents remain free to homeschool their children if they wish to do so” (p. 87).
Dunlop, Lisa 1994 A school to come home to. Tampa, FL: DBLM Publications. ISBN 0-9648225-0-4 home education, fiction, novel A story about a young woman who starts homeschooling during her junior year in high school. One of very few books like this on the market.
Dunnigan, Soraya 1986, September This home does it with CLASS. The Standard, p. 10-11. CBN University, Virginia Beach, VA 23463. CLASS is acronym for Christian Liberty Academy Satellite School, a correspondence school that many home schools use.
Dunning, Paula 1997 Education in Canada: An overview. [Also available in French as "L'education au Canada: vue d'ensemble.”] ERIC No. ED414118. http://www.eric.ed.gov adult education; american indian education; colleges; educational practices; educational trends; elementary secondary education; financial support; foreign countries; governance; higher education; preschool education; private schools; public schools; teachers; vocational education “This reference book provides a basic understanding of how education works in Canada, from preschool to adult education. Chapter 1 examines Canada's elementary and secondary schools and covers: (1) decision making for public schools (roles and responsibilities of provincial, local, and federal governments); (2) paying for public education (revenue sources and allocation, public funding of "separate" religious schools, summaries of governance and finance for each province); (3) a profile of Canada's schools (student population, graduation rates, preschool programs, school organization, school day and year, textbooks and materials, elementary schools, secondary schools, diploma requirements for each province, bilingual education, language instruction for immigrant students, education for Native children, special education, school-based social services, private schools, special subject schools, home schooling, educational assessment, public opinion); and (4) teachers (the workforce, gender issues in the teaching profession, teacher education, teaching conditions). Chapter 2 explores postsecondary education in Canada, including: (1) overview (history, enrollment patterns, program choices, Native student participation, personal benefits, recent policy changes, portable courses and credits); (2) profiles of the university system and the community college system (admission requirements, programs of study, language of instruction, school year, tuition fees, accommodation, institutional governance, accountability, faculty, research); (3) highlights (cooperative education, distance education, international dimensions); and (4) financial support (institutional funding, student loans, tax supports for postsecondary education). Chapter 3 discusses lifelong learning and adult education in Canada, including vocational programs, apprenticeship training, the Canadian Labour Force Development Board, adult continuing education, and literacy programs. Chapter 4 looks at educational trends in Canada, including greater emphasis on curriculum outcomes and assessment, the technology revolution in the classroom, school-to-work transitions, trends in postsecondary education, and trends in skills development and training. A final section includes useful addresses and other contact information for provincial departments of education, federal agencies, and national education organizations” (abstract retrieved 7/8/13 from http://www.eric.ed.gov).
Duquette, Cheryll Ann; Stodel, Emma J.; Fullarton, Stephanie; & Hagglund, Karras 2011 Educational advocacy among adoptive parents of adolescents with fetal alcohol spectrum disorder. International Journal of Inclusive Education, 1-10. DOI:https://doi.org/10.1080/13603116.2011.557445. https://doi.org/10.1080/13603116.2011.557445 inclusive education; disability; special education needs; FASD; educational advocacy; parent advocacy, homeschooling Mentions the homeschooling that some of their subjects experienced. Homeschooling is referenced in a factual/neutral to positive way. Homeschooling is not a significant focus of this study. For example: “The mother of the boy whose teacher said he would never read commented, ‘I homeschooled him for two years, and he learned to read in two months’” (p. 10). “The purpose of this qualitative study was to examine the educational advocacy experiences of 36 adoptive parents of adolescents and young adults with fetal alcohol spectrum disorder (FASD) [in the United States and Canada]. The participants responded to a questionnaire and 29 of them also engaged in an in-depth individual interview. Data were analysed inductively. Emerging from the data were four dimensions of advocacy: awareness, information seeking, presenting the case and monitoring. It was also found that the Internet was an essential tool for parents to seek information and support from others, and that in some cases advocacy was a means for parents to obtain respect from educators and programmes and services for their children” (p. 1).
Duquette, Cheryll; Stodel, Emma; Fullarton, Stephanie; & Hagglund, Karras 2006 Persistence in high school: Experiences of adolescents and young adults with Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder. Journal of Intellectual & Developmental Disability,31(4), 219–2312006. Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder, adolescents, educational experiences, homeschooling Mentions the homeschooling that some of their subjects experienced. Homeschooling is referenced in a factual/neutral to positive way. Homeschooling is not a significant focus of this study. “Abstract Background This study examined persistence in high school among students with Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder (FASD) from the perspective of the adolescents themselves. Tinto’s (1975, 1997) Student Integration Model (SIM) provided the theoretical framework for the research. This model consists of three factors: background characteristics, academic integration, and social integration. Method A collective case study method involving 8 adolescents with FASD from Canada and the United States was used. Results Although the students did not meet the usual academic standards and had acquaintances rather than friends, they perceived themselves as academically and socially successful. It was shown that persistence occurred largely because of the strong support of, and advocacy by, the adoptive parents. Conclusions Parental advocacy is an environmental factor that may protect adolescents with FASD from dropping out of high school” (p. 219).
Durbin, Kathie 1986 A different kind of school. The Oregonian, Northwest Magazine, April 13, 5-9,22.
Durham, Stacey 2011 Dear Christian parents: An appeal for homeschooling. Published by www.dearchristianparents.com. http://www.dearchristianparents.com homeschooling, home education, philosophy, religion, reasons, Christian, Bible Offers a collection of twenty-five letters written to help Christian parents realize joy through homeschooling their children. Presents reasons for Christian parents to take on the task of educating their own children. Emphasizes biblical scripture and gives historical context. Appeals to Christian parent to consider homeschooling a very good thing. Discusses the Biblical pattern for educating children, the current state of public schools, parental rights in education, socialization for children, and other relevant issues. Attempts to write with a positive, non-judgmental tone.
Duvall, Steven 2021 A research note: Number of adults who homeschool children growing rapidly. Journal Of School Choice, 15(2), 215–224, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/15582159.2021.1912563 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/15582159.2021.1912563 Number of homeschool parents, population size, household pulse survey, homeschooling during Covid, homeschool, homeschooling, US Census Bureau Abstract: Following the onset of the Covid 19 pandemic, the US Census Bureau (USCB) conducted regularly scheduled surveys to assess the impact that the virus had on American families. These showed that the number of adults/parents with children who were taught entirely in their homes doubled between the spring and fall 2020. Though millions of these individuals are now teaching their children at home for the first time, it is difficult knowing how many of them will continue doing so after the pandemic wanes and schools reopen on a large scale. In the following, a brief description of the USCB surveys and their results will be provided, as well as suggestions for future research.” Estimates number of adults in households with homeschool children; does not estimate the number of homeschool students/children in the USA.
Duvall, Steven 2025 The Costs of Homeschooling Today. Court Report magazine, HSLDA Magazine 2025, Issue 1, https://hslda.org/post/the-costs-of-homeschooling-today https://hslda.org/post/the-costs-of-homeschooling-today homeschooling, cost, costs, cost per child, curriculum, expenditures "Looking at the information provided by the families surveyed, we found it costs an average of $1,295 to homeschool an elementary school student in 2024. That number goes up to $1,636 for students in middle and high school. Those averages tend to be lower in rural areas and higher in urban and suburban areas (for elementary, middle, and high school students). But the average in all categories is well below $2,000. ..... For example, most of the surveyed families spent around just $500 a year to homeschool elementary students—$800 less than the average. And many families who homeschooled upper-grade students also kept their costs at $500 a year, which is $1,100 less than average."
Duvall, Steven F. 1994, August 30 The effects of home education on children with learning disabilities. A paper presented to the Home School Legal Defense Association. (Available from HSLDA, see address below.) academic achievement, basic academic skills, academic engaged time, home education, research, quantitative, learning disabilities, special needs, causal-comparative Used a causal-comparative design to compare home educated and public school special education programs. "In conclusion, parents, even without special education training, provided powerful instructional environments at home that assisted students with learning disabilities to make significant improvements in their basic skills. This was possible because the low number of students involved in home schools, coupled with low levels of task management and inappropriate behavior, enabled high rates of AET [Academic Engaged Time] to occur. The greater AET rates in home schools, in turn, generally caused HS [home school] students to make more academic gains than students who received special education services at school" (p. 11).
Duvall, Steven F. 2005 The effectiveness of homeschooling students with special needs. In Bruce S. Cooper (Ed.), Home schooling in full view: A reader, p. 151-166. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing.
Duvall, Steven F. 2022, April 12 Homeschool surge still going strong, https://hslda.org/post/homeschool-surge-still-going-strong https://hslda.org/post/homeschool-surge-still-going-strong homeschool, homeschooling, population size, estimate Between paragraph 1 and paragraph 2, the pie graph chart entitled “Growth of homeschooling” contains “Based on this data, HSLDA [Home School Legal Defense Association] estimates 7-9 million school-age children are being homeschoold.” This estimate is likely much higher than the real number.
Duvall, Steven F., Delquadri, Joseph C., & Ward, D. Lawrence 2004 A preliminary investigation of the effectiveness of homeschool instructional environments for students with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder [ADHD]. School Psychology Review, 33(1), 140-158. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/02796015.2004.12086238 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/02796015.2004.12086238 home education, research, special needs, ADHD, peer-reviewed, academic learning time, academic engaged time “Abstract. An exploratory study that involved two male and two female elementary students with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) was carried out in homeschools and public schools. The general purpose of the study was to determine whether parents could provide instructional environments that facilitated the acquisition of their children's basic skills over time. Students were observed using the Mainstream Version of the Code for Instructional Structure and Student Academic Response (MS-CISSAR), an eco-behavioral direct classroom observation instrument that produces information on ecological, teacher, and student behavior processes. Pre and post standardized achievement test scores· and rate-based measures were analyzed to determine gains in reading and math for all students. The results indicated that homeschool students were academically engaged about two times as often as public school students and experienced more reading and math gains. The key variable appeared to involve student to teacher ratios that existed between the two settings” (p. 140). Matched-pair design and “a continuous baseline probe design … was used…” (p. 142). “… homeschool students were academically engaged about two times as often as public school students and experienced more reading and math gains” [p. 140]. Shows homeschool had equal or better learning environment and made equal or better academic achievement gains and parents’ highest education level was GED or high school diploma [p. 151-152]. Peer-reviewed journal.
Duvall, Steven F., et al 1999, January 23, submitted for publication, personal communication, Steven Duvall “Abstract. An exploratory study that involved four elementary and two junior high students with Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) was carried out in homeschools and public schools. home education, research, special needs, academic engaged time The general purpose of the study was to determine whether parents provided students with instructional environments that facilitated the acquisition of basic skills. The instructional processes and products of students who were taught at home by parents (n = 3) were compared to students taught by professional teachers (n = 3). A continuous baseline probe design was used to compare the instructional environments of both groups and determine their effects on academic gains over time. Students in each group were observed during the spring semester using the MS-CISSAR, an eco-behavioral direct classroom observation instrument that produces information on ecological, teacher, and student behavior processes. Pre [sic] and post [sic] standardized achievement test scores and rate-based measures were analyzed to determine gains in reading, math, and written language for both groups. The results indicated that homeschool students were academically engaged about 1 1/2 times as often as public school students. Furthermore, homeschool students made more progress in reading and math, and about equal gains in written language. It was concluded that parents could create powerful instructional environments for their children at home. In discussing the differences in academic engagement experienced by the two groups, the key variable appeared to involve student to teacher ratios that existed between the two settings. [dated 1/23/99]” AET), academic achievement, public school
Duvall, Steven F., Ward, D. Lawrence, Delquadri, Joseph C., & Greenwood, Charles R. 1997 An exploratory study of home school instructional environments and their effects on the basic skills of students with learning disabilities. Education and Treatment of Children, 20(2), 150-172. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ553895 https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ553895 home education, research, learning disabled, special needs, public schools, academic achievement, causal-comparative, peer-reviewed journal, academic learning time, academic engaged time Home-schooled students were paired with public school students with similar learning disabilities so something of a causal-comparative design. Homeschool students were taught by parents, all of whom had a bachelor’s degree or lower education level [two had no high school diploma or college degree, one had associate’s degree, and one had bachelor’s degree; p. 155]. Public-school students were taught by paraprofessionals, regular, or special education teachers, all of whom had a master’s degree or higher [p. 155]. Teachers in both settings used the same expository teaching format with demonstrations to introduce new topics. Students in both settings then engaged in discussions and, finally, worked independently on assignments. Public-school teachers used more methods than did home-school instructors to academically engage students. Several instruments used to measure things such as student and teacher behaviors, “instructional ecology,” academic achievement, and student and parent satisfaction with home schooling. Home school students were involved in AET [academic engaged time] 59.0% of the time versus 22.5% of the time for public school students. The home schooled spent 32% of their time involved in task management (e.g., manipulating materials, moving, talking about management issues, and hand raising) versus 48% of the time of public-school students. On competing behaviors (e.g., looking around, self-stimulation, inappropriate talk, non-compliance, disruptive, and self-abusive), home-school students spent 14% of their time while public-school students spent 34% of their time. (Totals may exceed 100% due to simultaneous behaviors.) Academic achievement gains favored the home schooled. The mean reading standard score gain for the home schooled was 2.8 while the public schooled decreased by 2.5. In the area of written language, home schoolers increased by 3.5 while the public schooled increased by 0.8. In math, both increased by 6.5. Of the 7 comparisons in which home- and public-school students could be paired according to WJ-R pretest scores involving specific disabilities, 2 involved reading, 1 math, and 4 written languages. “... [H]ome school students made more gains in comparisons involving reading, the one involving math, and three of four in written language. The remaining written language comparison ... involved equivalent home school and public school gains” (p. 163). “Generally, the measures of classroom ecology and achievement showed that home schools, when compared to special education programs, provided equal if not more advantageous instructional environments for children with learning disabilities” (p. 166). In general, the home schooled made more progress than public-school students on standardized tests. Duvall and his colleagues emphasized that the home schooled experienced a lower student-to-teacher ratio and received more individualized instruction than did students in special public-school programs even though the public-school programs involved small groups. They also pointed out that “... even though the parents were not formally trained [or certified] to use methods designed to increase AET such as direct instruction ..., mastery learning ..., cooperative learning strategies ..., or peer tutoring ..., they successfully engaged students at higher rates than those accomplished by special educators in public school classrooms” (p. 168). “Consequently, home schools yielded AET rates that were 2.6 times greater than those observed in public school special education programs which primarily involved small groups and whole class instruction” (p. 167). “The results indicated that home school students were academically engaged about 2 1/2 times as often as public school students. Furthermore, home school students made progress in reading and written language, and equal gains in math” (abstract, p. 150). Shows that “... parents can create powerful instructional environments for their children at home” (abstract, p. 150). Homeschooled performed equal or better than public school students [p. 163, Table 3 on p. 164, p. 167]. “In general, the home school students made more progress than public school students on standardized [achievement] tests” [p. 167]. Peer-reviewed journal.).
Dwyer, James G. 2016 Religious schooling and homeschooling before and after Hobby Lobby" (2016). College of William & Mary Law School, Faculty Publications, Paper 1822. Retrieved April 21, 2017 from http://scholarship.law.wm.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2860&context=facpubs http://scholarship.law.wm.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2860&context=facpubs homeschooling, home schooling, law, legal, philosophical, negative critique of homeschooling “The most serious incursions on religious liberty in America today are being inflicted on children by parents and private school operators through power the State has given them. This Article examines the potential effect of the Court’s Hobby Lobby decision on interpreting the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (“RFRA”) on both federal and state levels, detailing why the Court’s decision is irrelevant to addressing the incursions on liberty experienced by children subject to religious and home schooling. Ultimately, the Article finds that home schools and private schools are unfazed by the Hobby Lobby decision in their capacities as employers and educators because (1) unchanged free-exercise jurisprudence accords stronger constitutional protection to parents against state oversight, (2) religious schools are generally operated by religious entities whose RFRA standing is already well established, (3) Hobby Lobby interpreted a law that imposes restrictions only on the federal government, (4) federal laws governing employers generally exempt religious entities, (5) federal laws pertaining specifically to schooling do not apply to private schools, and (6) state legislatures already voluntarily leave religious schools entirely unregulated, except for some standard, superficial business regulations. Even with RFRA’s version of strict scrutiny post-Hobby Lobby, states could nonetheless regulate private and home schooling. The Article concludes that state inaction will continue as a result of a troubling pervasive indifference—stemming from societal attitudes and fundamental misconceptions about childrearing—toward children subject to these types of schooling” (p. 1393).
Dwyer, James G.: & Peters, Shawn F. 2019 Homeschooling: The history and philosophy of a controversial practice. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. homeschooling, home education, home schooling, philosophy, statism, history, law Author lays out on page 156 his 6 philosophical assumptions/axioms: “Summary: The analysis of state policy regarding homeschooling will proceed from these assumptions: 1. Children are persons. 2. No one has a “right"" to control the life of another person. 3. The child has the greatest interests at stake in connection with schooling. 4. The state must have the ultimate authority to determine what children’s interests are. 5. The state may not act on the basis of religious beliefs. 6. In establishing laws about schooling, the state acts as a fiduciary for children” (p. 156). However, their #5 is impossible because all beliefs, including Dwyer’s and atheists’ and Muslims’ et al. are religious --- e.g., “relating to or manifesting faithful devotion to an acknowledged ultimate reality or deity” merriam-webster.com Author appears to want to try to pre-empt any God-centered religious belief and enact his own secular humanism or some other religious belief as the rule over children’s lives. Authors refer to “… its [homeschooling] baleful effects on children intellectual development” (p. 89) but offer no empirical evidence to support this claim or implied claim. They make inaccurate claims about who does research on homeschooling and what is cited (p. 99) and cherry pick one study – that does not report a statistical difference between the homeschooled and non-homeschooled – to make a negative claim about homeschool students who intend to attend college (p. 99).
Eagan, Sarah Healy; VosWinkel, Faith; Ford, Julian D.; Lyddy, Christopher; Schwartz, Harold I. Schwartz; & Spencer, Andrea 2014, November 21 Shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School; Report of the Office of the Child Advocate. Hartford, CT: State of Connecticut, Office of the Child Advocate. Retrieved November 25, 2014 from http://www.ct.gov/oca/lib/oca/sandyhook11212014.pdf. http://www.ct.gov/oca/lib/oca/sandyhook11212014.pdf public school, homebound instruction, homeschooling, home education, violence, school shootings “5. AL’s [Adam Lanza, the shooter/killer at the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting] anxiety began to further impact his ability to attend school and in 8th grade he was placed on [public school] “homebound” status through his [public school] education plan—a placement for children that are too disabled, even with supports and accommodations, to attend school” [p. 7]. “7. The [public school] district provided little surveillance of AL’s [public school] homebound status, which lasted an entire school year” [p. 7]. “14. ….. By the spring of that [10th-grade] year, AL had again withdrawn from most of his [public school] classes and had reverted to working on his own or with tutors” [p. 7]. “16. AL completed [public] high school through a combination of independent study, tutoring, and classes at a local college” [p. 7]. “30. In the course of AL’s entire life, minimal mental health evaluation and treatment (in relation to his apparent need) was obtained. Of the couple of providers that saw AL, only one—the Yale Child Study Center— seemed to appreciate the gravity of AL’s presentation, his need for extensive mental health and special education supports, and the critical need for medication to ease his obsessive-compulsive symptoms” [p. 8]. “31. This report suggests the role that weaknesses and lapses in the educational and healthcare systems’ response and untreated mental illness played in AL’s deterioration. No direct line of causation can be drawn from these to the horrific mass murder at Sandy Hook. [emphasis in original] [p. 8]. “Key Recommendations [p. 9] ….. Education [p. 10] ….. “• The state/s should consider an audit of existing homebound practices and procedures, and a needs assessment of the population of students who are currently or who have been placed on [public school] homebound within a certain timeframe” [p. 11]. “A Note about Home-Bound Educational Placement versus Homeschooling. AL was not “homeschooled.” He was initially informally withdrawn from school by his family, provided a medical “excuse note,” and then via the special education planning process his IEP team agreed to a recommendation that he would be placed on homebound status. Homebound status is permitted by Connecticut education law when a child is deemed too disabled to receive services in school even with modifications and supports.54 For a child who is identified as eligible for special education services, the school district must provide instruction in the home so that the child can [p. 43 ends] maintain the continuity of his school program.55 The new IEP approving homebound placement must indicate what the instructional objectives will be in the restrictive setting. For an IEP team to approve homebound instruction, there must be a physician’s note that the child cannot go to school (with an expected date when the child could return). The recommendation must specify the severity of the child’s challenges or document that his or her presence endangers other children. Home-schooling, by distinction, is an option exercised by a parent who wishes to provide instruction to a child in the home or community that is, at minimum, equivalent to education provided in the public school setting” [p. 44]. There is nothing in this government report that recommends more government/State control/regulation of (private) homeschooling.
Eagleson, Bruce 2000, July What about abuse of the system? The CHAP eNewsletter, 1(1). (Retrieved 10/30/00 online http://www.chapboard.org/e_newsletter/20000728.txt) http://www.chapboard.org/e_newsletter/20000728.txt home education, public schools, criticism of home education, academic achievement Addresses the issue of what to do about the homeschool families who alleged neglect the education of or fail at educating their children. “What about those homeschoolers who abuse the system?" is a question heard from time to time as an argument for close supervision of homeschooling families. A statement such as "I heard of a family that didn't do any teaching" usually follows this comment. When I pursue the second comment I find out that it is usually hearsay. To date I have never found a first hand witness to a homeschooling family that didn't teach at all. This is not to say that there aren't any of these parents, just that they are rare. ..... Is there such a study related to homeschool abuse? There is useful data from a source that many would not expect me to quote. Each year the Pennsylvania Department of Education (PDE) releases data about homeschooling for the previous year. This is collected from the 502 school districts in Pennsylvania. They have the remarkable return rate of 100%. The data from 1999, the most recent year available, shows that there were 21,459 homeschooled students in Pennsylvania. Of these 21,459 students, the school districts identified 344 whom the school administrators felt were receiving an inappropriate education. The homeschool evaluators identified 95 students that were receiving an "inappropriate education." It should be noted that public school superintendents are not considered to be strong supporters of home schooling. It could be argued that they are what lawyers would call a hostile witness. According to the evaluators about .4% of homeschooled children are failing. Even the public school administrators would estimate only about 1.6% are considered to be failing.”
Eavey, C. B. 1964 History of Christian education. Chicago, IL: Moody Press, 430 pp. "Teaching in the home was basic in the plan God had for the education of His people. Children were a gift from God, and parents were responsible to God for teaching them. In accord with the principle being stressed today, that religious education is the concern of the family, parents were the child's first teachers and the home the fundamental educational institution throughout most of Jewish history. [new paragraph] There were no schools, in the modern sense of the word, among the Jews until after their return from captivity" p. 51.
Eberle, Nancy 1987, April 14 Does home schooling pass the test? Woman's Day, pp. 32, 37, 40. Fairly objective, anecdotal. Reasons for home education. Pedagogical approaches. Socialization. Demands on mother. "It seems to me that the most vital thing we can learn from these special parents is that the final responsibility for our children's education is ours" [p. 40].
Eckenwiler, W. 1994 An investigation of the role of a home school association in the lives of its members Doctoral dissertation.
Economist, The 2004, February 28 Home-schooling: George Bush's secret army. The Economist, p. 32-33.
Economist, The 2004, February 28 Dreaming of spires: A university for home-schoolers. The Economist, p. 33.
Eddis, Samantha 2007, December A comparative study of attitudes towards home education, held by state officials and home educators in England and Wales, and in Florida, USA. Doctoral dissertation (Ph.D.), Department of Political, International and Policy Studies Faculty of Arts and Human Sciences, University of Surrey. home education, research, foreign, international, England, Wales, Florida, USA, perceptions, sociology, politics, public school, history, philosophy Carefully gathers data and evaluates perspectives of state officials and home educators. Relies heavily on the theory of a “trilogy of interests” (per Reich) to frame and interpret findings. Editor of this bibliography has not been able to find any place where author recognizes that the trilogy-of-interests theory ignores that it is the state that ultimately determines what is a child’s interests and whether they are being met and therefore it is in fact not a trilogy but still the age-old dichotomy, state versus parent regarding the upbringing and education of children. “This study was built on the premise that home education is legal in England and Wales, as well as Florida, United States of America. State officials, responsible for monitoring home educators, were approached in 172 local education authorities (LEAs) in England and Wales, and 67 local school districts (SDs) in Florida for a postal questionnaire, and home education documentation. From the initial participants who responded (108 LEAs, 39 SDs), a further 18 state officials and 13 home educators gave telephone interviews on issues raised by the literature and quantitative data. The choice of two societies was based on an expectation that tension or discordant attitudes were likely between state officials and home educators, and more so in England and Wales than in Florida. This expectation was partly drawn from the past thirty years’ research defending home education as a suitable alternative to public or private school education. The limited number of studies investigating state officials’ or home educators’ perceptions also indicate tensions (Petrie 1992, Lowden 1993). The two groups of people were chosen as they have most opportunity to interact with, or be affected by, each other when complying with home education laws. Where issues such as curriculum control, socialisation, monitoring procedures and child protection concerns were drawn from the literature and quantitative documentation analysis, this study explored further through comparison with qualitative data. The multi-stage study used a case study approach to compare fundamental differences in attitudes between home educators and state officials. Whilst tension and discordance were expected, the interviewed individuals expressed a varying degree of attitude convergence, whilst remaining firm on certain issues. This study suggests changes in attitudes between state officials and home educators since Amanda Petrie’s 1992 study, recommending areas where further research can aid cooperative efforts between home educators and state officials” [abstract, p. ii]. “Furthermore, Chapter 6 complements the previous chapter by theoretically tackling the dichotomy of home educators’ and state officials’ views from a more conciliatory angle, using Rob Reich’s trilogy of interests for balance” [p. 7]. Reich’s “trilogy” comprises the state’s, parents’, and child’s interests. “In spite of different attitudes over various facets of home education, less tension was inferred than anticipated. This could be seen as a justification for home education in both societies, along the lines of promoting educational diversity and pluralism. It also adds weight to Stevens’ ‘normalisation’ phenomenon of home education. That compulsory education is a tenet of both societies necessitates the provision of public and private education, including home education. In this way, education is realised as a common or private good, accommodating the interests of the [p. 280 ends] state, the parents and the child. Thus, Reich’s trilogy of interests could already be at play, and more so in Florida as a consequence of compulsory registration and flexible evaluation choices. . . . . . I believed, as a result of this study, that tension could exist if an individual’s ideology of education or subjective reality of home education conflicted too strongly with others [i.e., state officials versus home educators]. Thus, for example, if a state official held a strong communitarian perspective, seeing state education as best, their perception towards home education would be coloured by their vision of a ‘good’ curriculum, socialisation, and suitable monitoring. Conversely, a libertarian-minded home educator advocating minimal intervention from the state would not accept compulsory registration or monitoring, or school-based secondary socialization. Neither extreme was identified in the data, though there were instances where perspectives were not totally inclusive of the other. In fact, Stevens’ concept of the ‘normalisation’ of home education as a social movement was much more visible from the American perspective than the British perspective.” [p. 281].
Edersheim, Alfred 1971 The life and times of Jesus the Messiah. Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Co. General historical work in scope that generally follows the organization of the life of Jesus Christ; several chapters that give insights into the social and educational environment affecting children.
Edersheim, Alfred 1976 or 1876? Sketches of Jewish social life in days of Christ. London: The Religious Tract Society. In contrast to "Life and Times" above, takes and exclusively topical approach; chapters on Jewish homes, the upbringing of Jewish children, home education in Israel, and schools, understand the New Testament view of children and education.
Education Week 2004, September 21 Home schooling. Washington, DC: Education Week. Retrieved 7/7/10 from http://www.edweek.org/ew/issues/home-schooling/. http://www.edweek.org/ew/issues/home-schooling/ home education, homeschooling, population size, history, issues, research, reasons for homeschooling, academic achievement, and opinion Addresses population size, history, issues, research, reasons for homeschooling, academic achievement, and opinion. On the growth of the homeschool movement, “…some experts argue that home schooling is the fastest-growing form of education in the country (Ray, 1997, 2001).” “One study of more than 20,000 home school students found that students’ median scores on standardized tests were typically in the 70th to 80th percentile, well above the national average. The study also found that 25 percent of home schooled students were enrolled one or more grades above their age-level public and private school peers (Rudner, 1999). These findings mirrored those from a 1997 study, which found that home educated students scored, on average, at or above the 80th percentile in all areas on standardized achievement tests (Ray, 1997). But such studies have drawn intense criticism from some educational researchers.” “While debates over the benefits and risks of removing children from traditional learning environments continue, the home school movement has carved out its place in America’s education system.”
Educational Resources Information Center [ERIC] 1986 Home schooling. ERIC Digest, No. 15. Prepared by Erik Nelson at ERIC Clearinghouse on Educational Management, College of Education, University of Oregon, Eugene OR 97403. Sections included are (a) How prevalent is home schooling?, (b) Is home schooling educationally sound?, 8 What are the laws governing home schooling?, (d) Why is home schooling controversial?, (e) what should public school administrators do about home schooling?, and (f) resources. Two pages.
Egalite, Anna J.; & Wolf, Patrick J. 2016 A review of the empirical research on private school choice. Peabody Journal of Education, 91, 441–454. school choice, homeschooling, comparisons “Abstract: Parents in the United States have had the legal right to choose the school their child attends for a long time. Traditionally, parental school choice took the form of families moving to a neighborhood with good public schools or self-financing private schooling. Contemporary education policies allow parents in many areas to choose from among public schools in neighboring districts, public magnet schools, public charter schools, private schools through the use of a voucher or tax-credit scholarship, virtual schools, or even homeschooling. The newest form of school choice is education savings accounts (ESAs), which make a portion of the funds that a state spends on children in public schools available to their parents in pending accounts that they can use to customize their children’s education. Opponents claim that expanding private school choice yields no additional benefits to participants and generates significant harms to the students “left behind” in traditional public schools. A review of the empirical research on private school choice finds evidence that private school choice delivers some benefits to participating students—particularly in the area of educational attainment—and tends to help, albeit to a limited degree, the achievement of students who remain in public schools” (p. 441).
Ehl, Dan 2008, January 15 Iowa funding cut impacts Mid-Prairie home-school program. Retrieved 01/15/2009 from http://www.zwire.com/site/news.cfm?newsid=20240969&BRD=1140&PAG=461&dept_id=151338&rfi=6. http://www.zwire.com/site/news.cfm?newsid=20240969&BRD=1140&PAG=461&dept_id=151338&rfi=6 home education, public school, voucher, public school at home PSAH, funding, economics Article demonstrates that putting a child into a public-school-at-home program (PSAH), even though some call it homeschooling, costs taxpayers (including those who put their children into PSAH) more than if the parents did not put their child in PSAH; on the other hand, genuine home-based education (i.e., private homeschooling) reduces the tax burden for all. “The mother of three [Andrea Farrier, who “homeschools” her children via the PSAH] quickly adds that she has nothing against public schools and technically is herself a public educator [because she works for the state-run PSAH program].”
Eldeeb, Mena Khairy; Diab, Tasneem; Alkubish, Yusr; & Qadhi, Saba 2024 Exploring Homeshooling: In-depth Meta-Analysis of its Impact on Learning Motivation and Factors Influencing Family Choices, International Journal of Learning, Teaching and Educational Research, 23(4), https://ijlter.org/index.php/ijlter/article/view/10065 https://ijlter.org/index.php/ijlter/article/view/10065 Motivation; Prisma; Homeschooling; Home Education; Alternative Education “Abstract. This study examines the impact of homeschooling, an increasingly popular alternative education, on learning motivation and the factors influencing families' decisions to homeschool. Employing a meta-analytical approach, this study aims to synthesize existing literature on these topics, offering a comprehensive overview of current knowledge. A search conducted on the Web-of-Science database yielded 18 relevant studies meeting the inclusion criteria. The decision to homeschool is inherently intertwined with family choices, influenced by personal family beliefs and values, dissatisfaction with conventional schooling, special health conditions, and religious or moral guidance. These decisions often reflect diverse cultural and societal contexts, emphasizing the contextual nature of homeschooling choices. Overall, results indicate a significant positive impact of homeschooling on learning motivation, as it enhances students' engagement and learning interests. Additionally, the study incorporates a PRISMA diagram and a table outlining the characteristics of the incorporated studies. This meta-analysis provides an updated overview of the homeschooling phenomenon and its implications for future education and practice.” This article adds close to nothing to what we know about homeschooling in 2024. It is a weak review of research.
Eldredge, Thomas 2004 Safely home. San Antonio, TX: The Vision Forum, Inc. home education, parent-led discipleship, education, history, religion, opinion, philosophy Describes reasons for breakdown of the natural family and why churches no longer seen as covenanting communities rather than a connection of completely independent individuals. History of education in mainly western civilization as it applies to taking the responsibility away from parents and the home.
Eley, Mark G. 2002 Making the homeschool connection. Educational Leadership, 59(7), 54-55.
Elkind, David 1987 Miseducation: Preschoolers at risk. New York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf. early childhood education, parent involvement, research Explains that undue pressure with instruction too early for young children can do lasting psychological and physical harm. “Advocates of the competent child convinced Congress to pass the Head Start legislation in 1964, which by 1965 provided comprehensive education and health care to more than half a million disadvantaged youngsters. ….. The image of child competence introduced in the 1960s was intended to remedy some of the social inequalities visited upon low-income children. But the publicity given the arguments of child competence was read and heard by educators and middle-class parents as well. ….. For this reason it was uncritically appropriated for middle-class children by parents and educators. While the image of childhood competence has served a useful function for low-income children and children with special needs, it has become the rationale for the miseducation of middle-class children both at home and at school” (p. 69). “Today’s parents give credence to the image of early-childhood competence often for unconscious but nonetheless quite powerful motives. ….. But even liberated middle-class parents question what is best for their children and at how young an age (Bowlby’s threat of maternal deprivation dies hard!). It takes away some of the guilt and uncertainty if we rationalize that in order to reach their full potential, young children need a great deal of intellectual stimulation, which can be provided only by academically oriented full-day early-childhood programs” (p. 70). “Early childhood is a very important period of life. It is a period when children learn an enormous amount about the everyday world. It is also the time during which young children acquire lifelong attitudes toward themselves, toward others, and toward learning. But it is not the time for formal academic instruction. To appreciate this truth, we need to see the early years for what they are and not through the lenses of social, political, and personal dynamics that provide a distorted image of early-childhood competence” (p. 71). Page 41 gives a rather negative impression of home education by speaking of a family that wanted superkids reading while still toddlers. Page 162 says it takes a lot of time, energy, and commitment to home school and often parents do quite a good job of it.
Elkind, David 1988 The hurried child: Growing up too fast too soon. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley Publishing Co., Inc. education, age appropriate, childhood, psychology, schools Holds that Americans expose their children to too many pressures, those that can lead to low self-esteem, teenage pregnancy, and suicide. Claims that by blurring the boundaries of what is age appropriate and expecting too much too soon, children are forced to grow up too fast and to mimic adult sophistication while they need and yearn for more child-appropriate innocence. Schools can cause burnout and too much stress in children.
Elliott-Engel, Amaris 2002, July 29 More Muslims home in to educate children. The Washington Times. Published 7/29/02 and retrieved 8/1/02 online http://www.washtimes.com/national/20020729 373097.htm and February 17, 2010 from http://www.hvk.org/articles/0702/225.html . http://www.washtimes.com/national/20020729 http://www.hvk.org/articles/0702/225.html home education, demographics, religion, Muslim, Islam, reasons Explains there is a growth in the number of Muslims homeschooling their children in the U.S. "More Muslim Americans are choosing to home-school their children, making them one of the fastest growing minority groups within the national home-schooling movement. Muslim parents are educating their children on their own for reasons common to most home-schooling families: improving academics and controlling social interactions. ..... "I didn't feel my son was in an atmosphere lending to who he was," said Afeefa Syeed, a mother of three from Sterling, who helped organize the summer camp. "Our public school system was set up to homogenize." ....."
Ellis, A.K., Cogan, J.J., & Howey, K.R 1986 Education and schooling. Introduction to the Foundations of Education. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, p. 138.
Ellul, Jacques 1965 Propaganda: The formation of men’s attitudes. Translated from the French by Konrad Kellen and Jean Lerner. New York, NY: Vintage Books, a Division of Random House. propaganda, political science, sociology, education, philosophy Explains the nature, strategy, and effect of propaganda. Shows propaganda is at work in all developed nations or those with mass media and modern communication technology. Ellul explains “horizontal propaganda” and how, to make it successful, the individual must be inserted into a small groups that are “… homogeneous, specialized, and small …” of 15 to 20 persons; then, related to this type of propaganda, he writes about the family: “A private and heterogeneous group (with different ages, sexes, and occupations), the family is a tremendous obstacle to such propaganda. In China, where the family was still very powerful, it had to be broken up. The problem is very different in the United States and in the Western societies; there the social structures are sufficiently flexible and disintegrated to be no obstacle. It is not necessary to break up the family in order to make the group dynamic and fully effective: the family already [p. 82 ends] is broken up. It no longer has the power to envelop the individual; it is no longer the place where the individual is formed and has his roots. The field is clear for the influence of small groups” [p. 83]. Further, related to horizontal propaganda, he writes: “… the American school is becoming more and more a simple mechanism to adapt youngsters to American society. ….. Horizontal propaganda … is exceptionally efficient though its meticulous encirclement of everybody through the effective participation of all present, and through their public declarations of adherence. It is peculiarly a system that seems to coincide perfectly with egalitarian societies claiming to be based on the will of the people and calling themselves democratic …” [p. 84]. “For propaganda to succeed, a society must first have two complementary qualities: it must be both an individualist and a mass society. ….. In actual fact, an individualist society must be a mass society, because the first move toward liberation of the individual is to break up the small groups that are an organic fact of the entire society. In this process the individual frees himself completely from family, village, parish, or brotherhood bonds—only to find himself directly vis-à-vis the entire society” [p. 90]. Further related to horizontal propaganda, he writes: “As long as solidly constituted groups exist, those who are integrated into them are subject to them. But at the same time they are protected by them against such external influences as propaganda. An individual can be influenced by forces such as propaganda only when he is cut off from membership in local groups. Because such groups are organic and have a well-structured material, spiritual, and emotional life, they are not easily penetrated by propaganda” [p. 91]. Describes how propaganda is a part of government-run, public schools. “Actually, the most obvious result of primary education in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries was to make the individual susceptible to super-propaganda” [p. 109]. For the Marxist (e.g., Mao Tse-tung), an “… ‘appropriate education’ … is to teach children a Marxist catechism, to give them a Marxist conception of the world in history and science [p. 283].” “Incidentally, this refusal to listen to new ideas usually takes on an ironic aspect: the man who has been successfully subjected to a vigorous propaganda will declare that all new ideas are propaganda. To the degree that all his stereotypes, prejudices, and justifications are the fruit of propaganda, man will be ready to consider all other ideas as being propaganda and to assert his distrust in propaganda. One can almost postulate that those who call every idea they do not share “propaganda” are themselves almost completely products of propaganda. Their refusal to examine and question ideas other than their own is characteristic of their condition” [p. 166]. “Such extensive alienation is by no means exceptional. The reader may think we have described an extreme, almost pathological case. Unfortunately, he is a common type, even in his acute state. Everywhere we find men who pronounce as highly personal truths what they have read in the papers only an hour before, and whose beliefs are merely the result of a powerful propaganda. Everywhere we find people who have blind confidence in a political party, a general, a movie star, a country, or a cause and who will not tolerate the slightest challenge to that god. Everywhere we meet people who, because they are filled with the consciousness of Higher Interests they must serve unto death, are no longer capable of making the simplest moral or [p. 173 ends] intellectual distinctions or of engaging in the most elementary reasoning. Yet all this is acquired without effort, experience, reflection, or criticism-by the destructive shock effect of well-made propaganda. We meet this alienated man at every turn, and are possibly already one ourselves” [p. 174]. “As we have frequently noted, these artificial needs assume considerable importance because of their universal nature and the means (the mass media) by which they are propagated. They become more demanding and imperative for the individual than his own private needs and lead him to sacrifice his private satisfactions. In politics as in economics, the development of artificial [p. 177 ends] needs progressively eliminates personal needs and inclinations. Thus, what takes place is truly an expulsion of the individual outside of himself, designed to deliver him to the abstract forces of technically oriented mechanisms” [p. 178].
Englemann, Siegfried, & Englemann, Therese 1981 Give your child a superior mind. New York, NY: Simon and Schuster, 317 p.
Ensign, Jacque 1997 Homeschooling gifted students: An introductory guide for parents, ERIC Digest #543. ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED414683. Reston, VA: ERIC Clearinghouse on Disabilities and Gifted Education. Retrieved 1/4/01 online http://www.ed.gov/databases/ERIC_Digests/ed414683.html. http://www.ed.gov/databases/ERIC_Digests/ed414683.html home education, research, talented and gifted Academic considerations. Homeschooling can offer increased flexibility and academic challenge. Flexibility is particularly important since many gifted students are uneven in their abilities. For example, a child may be several years ahead in math, but struggling with reading or writing. Some children excel in all areas and require academic challenges to remain motivated in school. Many of these students sit idly, waiting for the class to catch up (U.S. Department of Education, 1994b). A rigorous, academically challenging curriculum offers the opportunity to insert depth and breadth. For example, the use of primary or original sources and advanced reading material may lead the gifted learner into critical thinking about an academic subject area or an interdisciplinary approach to subject matter. Projects, hands-on learning, and problem-based learning may provide interesting approaches to academic content. Gifted homeschoolers enjoy opportunities to develop in multifaceted ways and pursue interests without time and curriculum constraints. Individual learning, tutorials, and small group classes are some of the options.”
Ensign, Jacque 1998 Defying the stereotypes of special education: Homeschool students. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Diego, CA, April 15, 1998. home education, research, special needs, learning disabled, LD, gifted, giftedness, talented, outcomes, alternative education “This paper questions accepted expectations for special education students that are found in current introductory textbooks for teacher education. By looking outside traditional systems, this researcher has found exceptions to many of the textbook patterns for academic and social development” (p. 2) for students with learning disabilities and giftedness by examining such students who are being home schooled. Parents said their philosophy toward the learning disability of their child included the concept that the disability is a big challenge but also a part of the strengths of the child. Regarding their pedagogical approaches for the learning disabled, “... parents noted that they went at the speed of the child, expecting the child to blossom when ready. All noted that they were constantly having to find ways to help the child accommodate to the learning disability ... but also encouraged acceleration in areas of strengths ...” (p. 3). “The hallmarks of the educational philosophies and pedagogies of the homeschoolers in this study are1) focus on the whole child rather than primarily on the child’s disability or extreme ability, 2) individualized attention, and 3) care, patience, and respect for the child to lead the teacher in both the timing and the content of what the child is ready to be taught. .....The educational outcomes for these homeschooled special education students are self-confident students who have developed academic skills at very uneven rates but who have usually achieved academic excellence by the end of high school” [p. 6, 7].
Ensign, Jacque 1998 Defying the stereotypes of special education: Homeschool students. ERIC Reproduction Service Number ED419318. Retrieved 7/3/07 online from http://www.eric.ed.gov/ERICDocs/data/ericdocs2sql/content_storage_01/0000019b/80/15/74/ec.pdf. http://www.eric.ed.gov/ERICDocs/data/ericdocs2sql/content_storage_01/0000019b/80/15/74/ec.pdf Gifted and learning disabled students.
Ensign, Jacque 2000 Defying the stereotypes of special education: Home school students. Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 147-158. special needs, gifted, homeschooling, home education, research, peer-reviewed journal “Abstract. This article discusses cases from my 9-year longitudinal study of 100 home school students. The article focuses on students who have been identified as exhibiting learning disabilities and giftedness. There has been widespread concern that parents who are not trained in special education cannot adequately teach children with special needs. This article chronicles the academic development of 6 special education students and examines their parents' educational backgrounds and pedagogical approaches. I conclude that these students have not followed the expected patterns for students with their classifications and they have not been taught with the same assumptions and techniques used by special educators. These cases raise serious questions about the stereotypes that influence current practices in special education” (p. 147). “In conclusion, these students with LD and giftedness have not been taught with the same assumptions and techniques used by special educators. The hallmarks of the educational philosophies and pedagogies of the home schoolers in this study are (a) focus on the whole child rather than primarily on the child's disability or extreme ability; (b) individualized attention; and (c) care, patience, and respect for the child to lead the teacher in both the timing and the content of what the child is ready to be taught. These students with LD and giftedness have not followed the expected patterns for students with their classifications. The educational outcomes for these home-schooled special education students may be summed up as follows: They are self-confident students who have developed academic skills at very uneven rates, but who usually have achieved academic proficiency by high school” (p. 157). Peer-reviewed journal.
Ensign, Jacque 2007, Fall Defying the stereotypes of special education: Home school students. Mensa Research Journal, 38(3), 55-61. home education, talented, gifted, special needs
Eric, Wearne Governing hybrid schools: Polycentricity and institutional change in American education policy. Journal of Institutional Economics, 22. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1744137426100733 https://doi.org/10.1017/S1744137426100733 education governance, education policy, hybrid school, Institutional Analysis and Development Institutional Analysis and Development “Summary: Hybrid and microschools have expanded rapidly in the United States. These models do not fit neatly within existing governance categories, raising questions about how authority, accountability, and decision-making are organised in American education. This paper applies Ostrom’s Institutional Analysis and Development framework, widely used in natural resource and infrastructure governance but rarely applied to education, to compare institutional arrangements in conventional public schools and hybrid schools, where education is co-produced by families and providers. The comparison generates five propositions about how differences in physical arrangements, actors, rule systems, action situations, and accountability mechanisms shape governance outcomes. Hybrid schools exhibit characteristics of polycentric governance that conventional schools largely lack. A section on economic implications examines demand, supply, and information-cost dynamics. The paper concludes that Ostrom’s framework reframes education reform not as a contest between markets and governments but as an evolving search for effective rule systems in a polycentric public economy.” Mentions homeschooling. IAD), microschool, polycentricity, homeschooling
Erickson, Donald A. 1993 Research that lies. Private School Monitor, 14(3 & 4), 1-19. home education, research, academic achievement, criticism of research Examines the controversy about whether private school students perform better academically than do public school students, addresses criticisms of research that finds private school students do better, considers allegation that private school students do better only because best students are skimmed from population into private schools, critiques the statistical control of background demographic variables in order to determine whether true learning differences exist, and argues that it is illogical and misses a most important point to try to control for all differences. With respect to scholars applying control after statistical control, he says, "The ultimate finding is predictable tautological idiocy — when your computer creates a world in which private and public schools are just alike, your comparisons will show — viola! [sic] — that they are just alike" (p. 12). Much of his discussion/critique is applicable to home education research and the requests by critics of home education that there should be stronger controls for background variables.
Erickson, Donald E. 2005 Homeschooling and the common school nightmare. In Bruce S. Cooper (Ed.), Home schooling in full view: A reader, p. 21-44. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing. home education, public schools, history, philosophy, common schools
Esbensen, Thorwald, & Richards, Philip H. 1976 Family-designed learning: A next step for individualized instruction. Belmont, CA: Fearon Publishers, Inc..
Esch, Mary 1991 Education alternatives hold growing appeal. Home schools now acceptable and popular. San Diego Union, p. C-5. home education
Esch, Mary 1991, June 29 Home education increasingly popular as U.S. schools continue to plummet. World,6(10), 12. home education).
Esposito, Joe 1996 Tangled web: The mastery learning/OBE/STW-TQM connection. education, outcome based education, OBE, total quality management, TQM, mastery learning, policy, government Available from Tulsa Eagle Forum, PO Box 470734, Tulsa OK 74147, tel. 918/252-4002; or, tel. 918/272-8111. Explains “A culmination of laws passed by Congress (with no public debate) is about to make radical changes in our lives - and especially in the lives of our children.
Evans, Dennis L. 2003, September 2 Home is no place for school. Retrieved February 3, 2012 from http://www.usatoday.com/news/opinion/editorials/2003-09-02-oppose_x.htm and retrieved 9/3/03 from http://www.usatoday.com/news/opinion/editorials/2003-09-02-opposee_x.htm. http://www.usatoday.com/news/opinion/editorials/2003-09-02-oppose_x.htm http://www.usatoday.com/news/opinion/editorials/2003-09-02-opposee_x.htm http://www.usatoday.com/news/opinion/editorials/20030902opposee_x.htm home education, opinion, philosophy, public schools, negative criticism, negative critic Evans, as of September 2003, is director of doctoral programs in education leadership at the University of California, Irvine; he was a public school principal for at least 17 years. Repeats common negative criticisms of homeschooling with no research evidence or other premises to support his claims. By writing, “Attending school is an important element in the development of the “whole child." Schools, particularly public schools, are the one place where "all of the children of all of the people come together." Can there be anything more important to each child and thus to our democratic society than to develop virtues and values such as respect for others, the ability to communicate and collaborate and an openness to diversity and new ideas? [paragraph 3]. Such virtues and values cannot be accessed on the Internet,” Evans implies that public schools are rather utopian places, public schools do not segregate children by socioeconomic class or race/ethnicity, and that children and youth who attend a (state-run) institutional school will much more likely learn these positive ideas and skills than will the home educated. His claim that “The isolation implicit in home teaching is anathema to socialization and citizenship. It is a rejection of community and makes the home-schooler the captive of the orthodoxies of the parents [period, paragraph 4],” underscores his ignorance of the research on homeschooling, his lack of understanding of how most homeschool families operate in terms of their social interaction within their communities, and his desire for children and youth to be more the captive of the orthodoxies of the state and its educational policy makers and thinkers who influence state-run education and less under the influence of the children’s own parents.
Evans, James T. 1999 EduCrisis: What to do when public schools fail. Houston, TX: West Eagle Publishing Corporation. education reform, public schooling, private schools, home schooling Describes home education as a positive alternative to public schools.
Evans, Thomas W. 1973 The school in the home. Harper and Row.
Everhart, Robert B. (Ed.) 1982 The public school monopoly: A critical analysis of education and the state in American society. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger Publishing Co., Subsidiary of Harper & Row, Publ., Inc.. education, philosophy, poltics, history, state control Authors include Clarence Karier, Robert B. Everhart, Charles Burgess, Joel Spring, George H. Smith, C. H. Edson, Michael S. Katz, Stephen Arons, Charles Lawrence III, Thomas J. LaBelle, Laurence Iannaccone, E. G. West, Donald A. Erickson, Thomas W. Vitullo-Martin, Roger A. Freeman, and Michael W. Apple. The topic of this book, “... the relationship between education and the state in American society ... is indicative of the growing public dissatisfacton with the expansion of the state power over the lives of more and more people, especially in the realm of eduaction” [p. xv]. Various chapters show that many are not satisfied with the government having a monopoly over education and controlling what goes into children’s minds. George H. Smith, in chapter 3, entitled “Nineteenth-century opponents of state education: Prophets of modern revisionism,” writes that 19th-century opponents of state education were known as “Voluntaryists” in England were scarcely referred to in history for quite some time and when they were mentioned “... they were portrayed in a highly unfavorable light” [p. 112]. Pro-state education theorists of the 19th century (e.g., Horace Mann, Sir James Kay-Shuttleworth) “... were fully committed to their principles, and they wished to see these principles implemented through systems of national education. Indeed, the nineteenth-century conflict over state education was an ideological clash of the first order. Rarely does one see a debate with such well-defined principles on both sides--or with such momentous practical consequences” [p. 112]. This edited book clearly suggests that the wrestling for control over state-run schools and, therefore inherently, over the minds of children (i.e., future citizens) is a constant battle between competing parties regarding who will control the future direction of society. Michael W. Apple, in his chapter 14, entitled “Education and cultural reproduction: A critical reassessment of programs for choice,” says that in his analysis he is adopting “... a neo-Marxist perspective” [p. 505]; says one must consider the control of both culture and economy to understand what public schools do; talks much of class, production, means of production, and so forth; regarding turning education more into a capitalistic market situation and “... seemingly establishing a more pluralistic market ..... The symbolic benefit of choosing one’s school may tend to be exactly that, symbolic. The material benefits may continue to recapitulate the structure of inequality” [p. 529] [i.e., with respect to how much money one makes, what kind of job one has, and “... one’s relationship to the control and production of cultural and economic capital” [p. 505]] which is negatively affected by the promotion of “possessive individualism” [p. 528]; Apple’s concern is whether an education system. Will. U. library.
Evolution of Parental Rights in Education, The 1987 Journal of Law and Education, 16(3), 339-49.
Fadare, Maria Cecilia M. Fadare; Carrera, Bituin B.; Fadare, Stephen A.; & Paguia, Daniel B. 2021 Parents' challenges of home-schooling children with autism spectrum disorder: A special journey. International Journal of Science and Management Studies (IJSMS), 4(4), 11-26. Retrieved July 19, 2021 from https://www.ijsmsjournal.org/2021/volume-4%20issue-4/ijsms-v4i4p102.pdf https://www.ijsmsjournal.org/2021/volume-4%20issue-4/ijsms-v4i4p102.pdf homeschooling, home schooling, home education, COVID-19, Hermeneutic Phenomenology, Parents of Children with ASD, Parent-School, Partnership, Special Education, special needs; peer-reviewed “Abstract: This phenomenological research analysed the experiences, challenges, and coping mechanisms of parents in the home schooling of children with autism spectrum disorder in the City of San Fernando La Union. The participants were eight (8) parents with children clinically diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder during the School Year 2020-2021. The data gathered using a semi-structured interview guide was thematically analysed. It was found that the participants were fully involved in the home-schooling of their children. Difficulties in the area of rules and authority, schedules and procedures, behaviour management, and parental worry and stress were the challenges encountered by the parents during the home education process. They addressed these transitional difficulties by capitalizing on a positive disposition, gaining support from family members, and through professional consultation. It was concluded that a renewed Parent-School Partnership is deemed necessary for the learning continuity of children with ASD. Based on these findings, the researchers have developed a thematic model which can be used as a guide to enhance home-schooling. In addition, a colloquium scheme as a support program was crafted to up skill parents’ home-schooling of children with ASD.”
Fager, Jennifer 1996 Tutoring: Strategies for successful learning. ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED431840.
Falbel, Aaron 1992 A conversation with Ivan Illich. Growing Without Schooling, 86, 23-24. Aaron home education, alternative, philosophy, Illich Falbel interviews Illich with respect to his thinking on home education, Illich says he does recognize home education as an outgrowth of the ideas he discussed in Deschooling Society, as a community of people saying "no" to the institution of school.
Falbel, Aaron, 1989 Friskolen 70: An ethnographically informated inquiry into the social context of learning. M.I.T.,p 214-215. A comparison of home schooling parents values to those of Friskolen 70.) Parents attitudes, social change
Falle, Bob 1986 Standardized tests for home study students: Administration and results. Method: Alaskan Perspectives, 7(1), 22-24.
Families for Home Education [Missouri] 1992, May Missouri School-College Relations Commission home school opinion survey of elementary-secondary public school districts in Missouri: FHE Report to the Board of Directors. (Available from Families for Home Education, 4400 Woods Road, Sibley MO 64088.) home education, research Critique of the opinion survey from perspective of home educators, data, interpretation, opinion.
Family Research Council 1992 Free to be family: Helping mothers and fathers meet the needs of the next generation of American children. Washington, DC: Author. (Available from FRC, 700 13th St., N.E. Suite 500, Washington DC 20005) research, family, education, delinquency, marriage, abortion Examines factors affecting the family, its proper functioning and its breakdown, and the effects of the breakdown of the family on children, communities, and society at large. Strongly emphasizes the benefits to children of the traditional family [married parents and children by birth or adoption]. Written to the layman, but replete with complete research citations.
Fantini, M. D. 1985 The what, why, and where of the alternatives movement. The Education Digest, 51(3), 139-142.
Farah, Joseph 2000, September 12 The government education monopoly. WorldNetDaily.com. Published and retrieved 9/12/00 online http://www.worldnetdaily.com/bluesky_btl/20000912_xcbtl_the_govern.shtml. http://www.worldnetdaily.com/bluesky_btl/20000912_xcbtl_the_govern.shtml philosophy, home education, politics Explains why the National Education Association teachers union, socialists, and fascists do not like home schooling and want to control it.
Farber, Peggy 2001, March/April The New Face of Homeschooling. Harvard Education Letter Research Online. Retrieved 3/16/01 online http://edletter.org/current/. http://edletter.org/current/ home education, public school, cooperation, politics, philsophy, public-school-at-home program, PSAH Explains the growth of state-run, tax-funded school-at-home -- or homeschooling -- programs offered by public school districts. Addresses motives behind the initiation and operation of the programs. Tells that school districts want to make money from the programs and develop friendly ties with the homeschool community while many within the homeschool movement think that the programs are a bad idea and will eventually lead to more state control of homeschooling while using more of the tax payers’ money.
Farenga, Patrick 1991, January/February Homeschooling research: Pushing the limits of measurement. Home Education Magazine, 8(1), 24, 25, 42-45, 50. home education, research, commentary, opinion "The thing one learns from reading homeschooling research, reports like the Eight-Year Study (by Aikin [Aiken?]), and reports on conventional schooling, is that our children have an astounding ability to learn under all sorts of conditions and theories. Let's do our best to avoid educational assumptions and incorrect measurements that threaten or constrict any learning possibilities" (p. 50).
Farenga, Patrick 2000 The beginner’s guide to homeschooling. Cambridge, MA: Growing Without Schooling Magazine. home education, application Helps people learn about homeschooling, home education; includes how-to stories, research findings, history, a bibliography, and resource listings.
Farenga, Patrick 2000, June 15 Personal communication to Brian D. Ray concerning the definition of “unschooling.” http://www.holtgws.com See also information on unschooling at http://www.holtgws.com.
Farenga, Patrick 2002 A brief history of homeschooling. Retrieved June 26, 2020 from https://homeschoolbase.com/brief-history-homeschooling/ and April 15, 2011 from http://www.hsc.org/prohistory.php https://homeschoolbase.com/brief-history-homeschooling/ http://www.hsc.org/prohistory.php home education, homeschooling, history, compulsory school attendance, compulsory education Provides succinct and fairly accurate history of modern homeschooling. “Homeschooling is radical, in the root sense of the word: in Latin, radicus means root. Compulsory schooling (forced attendance), and now, in the twenty-first century, compulsory education (forced learning) are very recent petals and offshoots of the root way humankind has historically nurtured its young into responsible adults and active citizens. Family, community, religious institutions, and work were all integrated into the daily lives and upbringing of children. Sometimes there were professional or informal tutors available that some families hired or shared to instruct children at various times for short periods each year; other families used daily chores, apprenticeships and internships to educate their children. Continuing in these traditions, similar arrangements are made by homeschoolers today.” Presents current homeschool movement as closely tied to language and ideas of Ivan Illich, then John Holt, then Raymond and Dorothy Moore. Inaccurately omits some key Christian thinkers and activists (e.g., Paul Calvin Lindstrom, Rousas Rushdoony, Samuel Blumenfeld) who were a crucial part of the early homeschool movement.
Faris, Paul 2006 Home education in canada: national poll of homeschooling families shows startling results. IMFC Review, No. Fall/Winter 2006, 14-16.
Farley, S. 1985, September 6 Keeping it in the family [home school scheme in Great Britain devised by World-wide Education Service]. Times Education Supplement, 3610, 25.
Farrington v. Tokushige, 273 U.S. 284 1927
Farris, Michael 1990, October/November Good enough to be left alone. The Teaching Home, 8(5), 37. home education, policy, cooperation, law, legal "Our purpose in sharing statistics and other information showing that home schoolers do well—very well indeed—is not to put down public or private schools. We are simply trying to prove that home schooling is good enough for us to be left alone."
Farris, Michael 2005 The Joshua generation: Restoring the heritage of Christian leadership. Nashville, TN: Broadman & Holman, Publishers.
Farris, Michael 2013 Tolerance and liberty: Answering the academic left's challenge to homeschooling freedom. Peabody Journal of Education, 88(3), 393-406. homeschooling, home schooling, home education, freedom, tolerance, human rights, regulation, law, legal, peer-reviewed Abstract: “Millions of children in the United States are educated in the home. Millions more receive their education from private institutions. For parents, a common reason for seeking alternatives to public education is the desire to ensure that they receive instruction in accord with their religious beliefs. In many cases, these beliefs include exclusive claims about the nature of God, salvation, or morality. Recently, several scholars have argued that, to achieve a diverse and tolerant society, homeschooling and private education should be abolished or severely limited. They have contended that “a liberal multicultural education,” which will expose children to different ideas and perspectives, is necessary for the preservation of democratic values. Homeschooling, they claim, leads to close-mindedness and intolerance because children are taught to affirm certain beliefs which imply that not all other traditions are equally valid. The argument that homeschooling should be banned or severely restricted, however, relies on illiberal and intolerant premises that have already been discredited as inconsistent with our constitutional liberties. Although tolerance may be a valuable objective, it cannot be forcibly imposed by using the state’s power to create philosophical homogeneity. True tolerance and diversity require a constitutional commitment to liberty for all, not a “constitutional norm” of silencing the “intolerant”” (p. 393). It was the National Socialists (Nazis) and Hitler of Germany who “… banned all forms of private education precisely to achieve philosophical unity” (p. 402), that is, to control children’s values, beliefs, and worldview.
Farris, Michael P. 1990 Home schooling and the law. Paeonian Springs, VA: Home School Legal Defense Association. home education, legal, law Gives home educators (and others) information on their constitutional freedoms related to the education of their children and on the laws regarding home education in the fifty states. Helps parents decide when and whether they should obey the law. Provides reader with insight to a legal (and Christian) perspective that strongly supports parents' rights to home educate.
Farris, Michael P. 1999 The home schooling father. Sisters, OR: Loyal Publishing [www.loyalpublishing.com] http://www.loyalpublishing.com Examines keys to success in family and marriage in home educating situation; uses biblical worldview; philosophical but with plenty of personal and practical explanations; quality paperback book. First published in 1992
Farris, Michael P. 1996, October 12 Keynote address: Forecasting patterns in academic data transmission and faith-oriented disposition refinement within decentralized homeocentric didactic modes. Speech presented at the Annual National Christian Home Educators Leadership Conference, Dallas, TX. home education, opinion, population size and growth, trends Farris, president of the Home School Legal Defense Association, once thought that the home education population would never exceed a clear minority of the school-aged population. Based on his recent experiences, advances in technology, public opinion about and the use of distance learning, and changes in society, Farris recently said, “Well, many of us have believed for a long time that home schooling would max out around about five to seven percent of the population. I have said that for many years. I withdraw that assessment . . . I see a day, and I believe I am going to live to see the day, where nearly half of American children will be home schooled for at least a significant portion of their academic training.”
Farris, Michael P. 1997 The future of home schooling: A new direction for home education. Washington, DC: Regnery Publishing, Inc. home schooling, research findings, future, futuristics, curriculum, technology, legal, law Begins with overview of home schooling using many statistics on family demographics and students’ academic achievement from Brian Ray’s nationwide study Strengths of their own. Emphasizes value of using the classical education pedagogy in home schooling and the ways that technology will increase the likelihood that a growing number of people will choose to home school their children. Also discusses concepts of “support groups of the future,” “home school-friendly churches,” “equal access to public school activities,” and “apprenticeships.” “With the simultaneous advent of homebound office workers who link to a central site via computer, I believe that home schooling has a nearly unlimited potential. It is not too much to believe that 40 percent of all children will receive at least some material portion of their education at home in the next ten to twenty years” (p. 81).
Farris, Michael P. 1997 Solid evidence to support home schooling. Wall Street Journal, March 5, 1997. homeschooling, home education, research, policy, law, legal, academic achievement, research "A new study by the National Home Education Research Institute again shows that home education is far more successful than public education." “"Home-school students score significantly higher on standardized achievement tests than their public-school counterparts do. While by definition public school students average at the 50th percentile on standardized tests, this nationwide study conducted by Brian Ray, president of National Home Education Research Institute, reveals that home schoolers have average scores between the 80th and 87th percentiles on every subtest (including reading, listening, language, math, science, social studies and study skills). The average score on the basic battery of skills is in the 85th percentile, while the average complete battery score is in the 87th percentile--a phenomenal 37-percentile differential." "The No. 1 political goal of home schoolers is quite modest. We just want to be left alone. Those who believe that government regulation is essential for success would do well to look at the cold, hard numbers that prove otherwise."
Farris, Michael P. 1998 Vida nueva -- New life in Mexico. The Home School Court Report, 14(6), 40, 37. home education, foreign, Mexico, religion, evangelism Describes the growth in attendance at Mexico’s only home school conference and states that “Although there were several American missionaries present, the vast majority of the crowd were Mexican nationals who were in the early stages of home schooling, or who were considering it for the near future” [p. 40]. Says the work of the Richardson family, missionaries from the U. S., “... is the prototype of the most important missions opportunity of our lifetime. They are serving as missionaries to the families in Mexico who are interested in home education. They understand the value of the opportunity to talk with people about their children and their educational needs, as a mans of opening the door for the Gospel. This is a formula which could sweep the world. Families need help. Home schoolers know how to help families. We know how to point people to a good education. And while we are at it, we get to introduce people to Christ” [p. 40, 37].
Farris, Michael P. 1999, December 1 Issue Backgrounder #18--The National Board for Professional Teaching Standard. Purcellville, VA: Home School Legal Defense Association. teacher qualifications, research, evidence, teacher certification Among other things, Farris summarizes a recent study conducted by the Thomas B. Fordham Foundation by Farris writing: “Problems with NBPTS Standards: There is absolutely no empirical evidence that the standards used in this certification process produce better teachers. The board develops these standards through round table discussions: One teacher will share what works best for her, and another will share his positive experience. Standards are built on "experiential research." NBPTS provides no evidence that these rigorously developed teaching standards contribute to student learning. One committee member explained that they "did not have time to [provide research evidence] and this was also not the committee's priority." Under the board's current structure, this "what feels good" method of standard setting is not likely to change anytime soon because directors of the board handpick their new members. Knowledge Requirements: The NBPTS certification rests on the belief that teaching is a complex discipline requiring a firm understanding of pedagogy--the art of teaching. As a result, content requirements in many subject areas are ignored. For example, two math experts, Branden and Raimi, who recently passed their certification, expressed their surprise at how much attention the NBPTS math standards devoted to the ways in which teachers should interact with students at the expense of basic content--such as long division. Instead of stressing 2 + 2 equals 4, teachers are exhorted to include different cultural approaches to mathematics.”
Farris, Michael P., & Woodruff, Scott A. 1999 The future of home schooling. A paper presented on at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, April 19-23, 1999.
Farris, Michael P., & Woodruff, Scott A. 2000 The future of home schooling. Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 233-255. home education, sociology, politics, philosophy, legal, future, history “Home schoolers of the future should judge their success not by the degree to which they surpass the struggling government schools, but by how closely the come to obtaining for their children the full potential of home schooling itself” (p. 242-243.) “In short, as large as the home school movement is today, it is only a shadow of what it will be 20 years from now. Because the future of individual home schoolers is bright, the future of the movement is bright. This promises a brighter future for America” [p. 254].
Fegley, John A. 1992 Home schooling in Connecticut. Home School Researcher, 8(4), 9-16. research, demographics, reasons, public schools, cooperation Examines demographic characteristics, reasons for home educating, “Although religion is an important part of their home school program, there are other values that are probably equally important. These values include: morality, self-determination of educational program and materials, family unity, and protection from negative influences” [p. 14], and relationships between home educators and local public schools.
Feigenbaum, Edward A., & McCorduck, Pamela 9183 The fifth generation. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, 275 p. Some words on home study; maybe p. 92, etc.
Feinberg, Walter 1999 “On the question of cultural evaluation.” A presentation made at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Session 38.09, April 19-23, 1999, Montreal, Quebec, Canada. Verbal statement during the presentation; Ray, author of this bibliography, confirmed the statement with Terence McClaughlin who also made a presentation and was on the panel with Feinberg.
Feinstein, Selwyn 1986, October 6 Domestic lessons: Shunning the schools, more parents teach their kids at home. The Wall Street Journal, p. 1, 17. A few cases cited; numbers of home schools estimated. Reasons for home schooling are considered, e.g. religious, love of children. Reports home school parents are better educated than general parent population, with 40% being college graduates and an additional 30% with some college.
Feldman, Jay, & Gray, Peter 1999, March Some educational benefits of freely chosen age mixing among children and adolescents. Phi Delta Kappan, 80(7), 507-512. research, age mixing, age integration, learning, socialization Finds age mixing among children and adolescents may have educational and other benefits. Researchers conclude, regarding age mixing, that (a) younger children actively use older children to learn and acquire skills and take responsibility for their own learning, (b) “… age-mixed play offers unique opportunities for creativity and the practice of skills” [p. 509-510], (c) it is sometimes a means of matching abilities, and (d) “Older children feel a sense of responsibility for younger children and develop an increasingly sophisticated understanding of that responsibility” [p. 511].
Felkins, Melissa 2018 Experiences of current or former homeschool students who report ADHD symptoms. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Walden University. homeschooling, home schooling, special needs, ADHD “Abstract Homeschooling is currently the fastest-growing educational population in the United States with an estimated 2 million students. Because 11% of school children have been diagnosed with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), there are likely to be many children with ADHD symptoms in the homeschooling population. The purpose of this study was to extend knowledge of the experiences of homeschooling in this population to assist students with ADHD as well as their parents and educators to make informed educational decisions. The multiple intelligences theory provided the theoretical framework for this phenomenological study. The key research question was focused on how current or former homeschool students who report ADHD symptoms describe their experiences in a homeschool environment. Perceptions were collected from 12 participants ranging in age from 12 to 21 years of age who were recruited using criterion sampling. Semi-structured interviews were conducted by phone or face-to-face. Data were analyzed using Moustakas’ modification of van Kaam’s structure. Through this process, the themes of individualization, self-concept, and experience of symptoms were identified. Specifically, the findings indicated that homeschooling children with ADHD symptoms is an individualized phenomenon and most students thrive in a structured yet flexible environment where tools and methods can be personalized. Participants developed individualized learning practices that would not be acceptable in a more traditional learning environment. This study contributes to the empirical literature promoting social change by providing foundational knowledge that can be built upon in future research to offer evidence-based information to this rapidly-growing population.”)
Fellows, Shatecca M. 2021 Salt & light: A phenomenological study exploring the lived experiences of parent educators and homeschool students in grades 7-12. Doctoral dissertation (Ph.D.), John Wesley School of Leadership, Carolina University. homeschooling, qualitative, lived experiences, parents, homeschool students, phenomenological, faith transmission “Abstract. This qualitative phenomenological will explore parental perceptions of faith development experiences of homeschooled youth in grades 7-12 facilitated by their parent-educator as they relate to authentic leadership. The researcher selected authentic leadership theory as an appropriate application for this study because of internalized moral perspective, balanced processing, self-awareness, and relational transparency components included within this model. Data was collected from a self-developed faith authenticity questionnaire and the Faith Maturity Scale (FMS) completed by the parents of homeschooler students. The study will produce spiritual, pedagogical, and relational contributions to the Christian church's future discipleship mitigation and retention efforts and advance the scholarly conversation regarding authentic leadership and organizational commitment. This researcher used purposeful sampling to sample a population of 13 of 25 parent-educators through a local cover school in Northern Alabama. This researcher sent all correspondence to the principal and parent-educators via her private email account, including the consent form, a faith authenticity questionnaire, and the FMS. This researcher identified four themes from the data: prayer, Biblical authority, transparency, and parental engagement.”
Fenton, Dale B. 1990 Survey of colleges regarding the admission of home schooled applicants. Available from Admissions Office, Wheaton College, Wheaton IL 60187. 755 institutions responded, 835 home educated students admitted by 252 institutions, asked about admissions offices beliefs about these applicants.
Fernandez, Happy 1980 New pieces in the school puzzle: parent's rights and power as new dynamics in the American school system. NASSP Bulletin, 64, 14-22.
Ficula, Teresa 1987 Psychosocial adjustment of adolescent school refusers placed on home study. DAI, 48(4), 1166B. The University of Utah, 132pp.
Field, Christine M. 1998 A field guide to home schooling: A practical guide for parents. Grand Rapids, MI: Fleming H. Revell.
Field, Christine, M. 2002 Help for the harried homeschooler: A practical guide to balancing your child’s education with the rest of your life. Colorado Springs, CO: WaterBrook Press. Addresses the title of the book. Written from a Christian/biblical perspective.
Fields-Smith, Cheryl 2015 Black homeschoolers: Nowhere left to go. In, Paula Rothermel (Ed.), International Perspectives on Home Education, Hampshire, England: Palgrave MacMillan, pp 278-285. homeschooling, black, African American, race, reasons, school reform “Abstract. Homeschooling in the US has stereotypically been perceived as a white, middle-class, religiously based phenomenon. Recent estimates suggest that the homeschool population is roughly equivalent to the charter school population at approximately two million students (Economist, 2012). Yet, the topic of homeschooling has been largely marginalized within the literature and even within the discussions of school choice. This ostracizing of homeschooling perpetuates the elitist stereotype of homeschool families. However, media reports and homeschool research experts suggest trends toward ethnic-minority families increasingly choosing home education over conventional schools. The increased diversity among homeschool families may be the result of neo-liberal policies, which place an emphasis on individual choice. Even within this school choice model, public schools will still be needed because not every family can homeschool and inequities exist in access to educational alternatives such as charter schools, magnet schools and private schools (Andre-Bechely, 2006 ; Orfield and Frankenberg, 2013). However, public school policymakers, practitioners and researchers should take note of, and learn all they can from Black home educators for school reform purposes. Authentic democracy happens when the voices in the minority are heard (Parker, 2003). Therefore, if school reformists want to know how to improve public schools, part of the answer must come from those families who have experienced them, but chose to homeschool” (p. 278).
Fields-Smith, Cheryl 2020 Exploring single black mothers' resistance through homeschooling. Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan Cham. https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007%2F978-3-030-42564-7#about minority education, parental involvement, Black homeschooling, homeschooling, single mothers, reasons, School Choice “This book expands the concept of homeplace with contemporary Black homeschooling positioned as a form of resistance among single Black mothers. Chapters explore each mother’s experience and unique context from their own perspectives in deciding to homeschool and developing their practice. It corroborates many of the issues that plague the education of Black children in America, including discipline disproportionality, frequent referrals to special education services, teachers’ low expectations, and the marginalization of Black parents as partners in traditional schools. This book demonstrates how single mothers experience the inequity in school choice policies and also provides an understanding of how single Black mothers experience home-school partnerships within traditional schools. Most importantly, this volume challenges stereotypical characterizations of who homeschools and why” - https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007%2F978-3-030-42564-7#about
Fields-Smith, Cheryl A. 2011 Reclaiming and redefining the “village”: Homeschooling among Black families. A presentation at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 8-12, 2011, New Orleans, Louisiana. home education, homeschooling, black, African American, community, minorities Provides evidence and explains that there is strong community amongst black homeschool parents, children, and families.
Fields-Smith, Cheryl, & Baker, Timberly L. 2023 Centering the lived experiences of rural Black homeschool families. Thresholds in Education, 46(3), link.gale.com/apps/doc/A781611308/AONE homeschooling, African American/Black families, rural education, culturally relevant methodology, reasons “Abstract: Compared to all other options, homeschooling provides parents with the most control over their children's educational experiences. The COVID-19 pandemic led to a surge in the U.S. homeschool population. Black families had the largest increase in home educators from 3.3% to 16.1% between April 2020 and October 2020. The emerging literature on Black home education has focused almost entirely on urban areas. This paper presents findings from a pilot study designed to begin to address the omission of rural setting representation in Black home education research literature. This qualitative study employed conceptual frameworks that value Black women's ways of knowing (e.g., Black Feminist Theory, Endarkened Feminist Epistemologies, and Critical Race Theory) to emphasize the role of participating mothers who represented a single-parent household or a household where the mother maintained primary responsibility for the home education of children.”
Fields-Smith, Cheryl, & Kisura, Monica Wells 2013 Resisting the status quo: The narratives of Black homeschoolers in Metro-Atlanta and Metro-DC. Peabody Journal of Education, 88(3), 265-283. homeschooling, home education, research, black, African American, family, minorities, reasons, motivations, agency, barriers, obstacles, co-ops, co-operatives Provides careful interview- and focus-group-based study of black homeschool parents and families. “[Abstract] Trends suggest that homeschooling continues to increase among black families. Yet, research on contemporary Black homeschooling remains scarce. Given black educational history [barriers?], the phenomena of Black families choosing homeschooling over public and private schools in the post-Desegregation era is worthy of investigation. Further, documenting the ways in which black homeschool families engage their children in learning will inform the needs of black education in conventional schools, public and private. The phenomenon of increasing black home education represents a radical transformative act of self-determination, the likes of which have not been witnessed since the 1960s and ‘70s. This work highlights the primacy of agency among black homeschooling families. Thus, contrary to the negative depictions of black families as disengaged from the educational pursuits of their children, we evoke hooks’s (1990) notion of homeplace to argue that black home education represents a vehicle of resistance to institutionalized racism and ideological mismatches between black families and their children’s educational needs” p. 265. “Homemaking is a “critical form of spatial praxis” that entails “reconfiguring a hostile and deeply racialized landscape” to foster “relationships of trust, positive reciprocity, cooperation, and care within and between black people” (p. 118). One way that this is demonstrated in the homeschooling community is through the creation of co-operative shared learning opportunities or co-ops [that reduces barriers and obstacles to homeschooling?]. Many of the homeschooling mothers in our studies expressed their reliance upon fellow homeschooling mothers (and networks) for academic, pedagogical, and emotional support. In this manner, co-ops can be viewed as an extension of the domestic homeplace” (p. 267). “In this study we examined what were the “push–pull” factors that motivated black families in the Metro-Atlanta and Metro-DC regions to exit traditional schools in favor of homeschooling their children” (p. 278-279). One push factor is the “culture of low expectations” (p. 279) of black, especially male, children in public schools. “Black parents are able to impart black cultural values to their children while exposing them to a global perspective. Throughout the study, parents acknowledged that homeschooling also allowed them to “slow down” their children’s exposure to what could be deemed as unsavory elements of school socialization (e.g., racism, violence, drugs, etc.) This was not a matter of sheltering them from “real-world” experiences but rather what parents expressed as engaging in “parenting,” which required that they play an active role in facilitating their child’s growth. In the words of homeschooling activist and mother Jennifer James (2006): “African-American families are taking a dramatic approach to the educational future of their children by adopting a collective and renewed stance on family-led learning.” Our research supports this assertion. But perhaps the significance of this research is that it transcends the discussion about the motivational factors and the benefits of homeschooling for black families" (p. 279). "What this study draws into sharp relief is a rare yet positive portrayal of black family life. Much of popular media and academic representations stereotypically depict blacks as largely living in one-parent, matriarchal, poor, and undereducated households. Contrastingly, most of the families in our studies were overwhelmingly two-parent, well educated, and middle class. In addition to [p. 279 ends] offering this alternative narrative about black family life, this research also suggests that the very existence of black homeschoolers, coupled with their mass exodus from conventional schools is a noteworthy sociopolitical statement. This is what makes homeschooling such a powerful and social declaration for black people. Considered in this way, homeschooling may be the most provocative and courageous act of self-determination and resistance undertaken by blacks since the decolonization and civil rights movements of the 1950s, 1960s, and 1970s (Ekoko, 2006)" (p. 279-280).) Revised notes
Fields-Smith, Cheryl; & Williams, Meca R. 2009 Sacrifices, challenges and empowerment: Black parents’ decisions to home school. Urban Review, 41, 369-389. http://www.eric.ed.gov Home Schooling, homeschooling, African Americans, black, Parent Attitudes, Beliefs, Race, Family School Relationship, Religion, Decision Making, Motivation, reasons, research, peer-reviewed This study examines home schooling among Black parents by providing insight to Black families' beliefs, concerns, and desires for their children's education. To date, the literature remains void of empirical work related to home education among African American families. However, the present study directly addresses this void. Findings demonstrated that parents' motivations to home school included issues related to race and home-school interaction. In addition, Black parents reported that religious beliefs influenced their decisions to home school. But, unlike their Caucasian counterparts, Black home educators described a more liberatory form of religion” (retrieved 12/29/13 from www.eric.ed.gov. “This study used qualitative methods to examine home schooling among Black families located within a southeastern metropolitan area” (p. 372).
Fineman, Martha Albertson 2009 Taking children’s interests seriously. In Martha Albertson Fineman and Karen Worthington (Eds.), What is right for children? The competing paradigms of religion and human rights, 229-37. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1516652 homeschooling, home education, private schooling, private education, theory, philosophy, law, legal, opinion, statism, state regulation, statism Burlington, VT: Ashgate Publishing Company. Also, retrieved November 9, 2012 from http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1516652 The following quotes and page numbers are from the online document: Argues that there are state interests, parental interests, and child interests regarding the education of a child, then asks the following: “The next obvious question is, how does the child’s interest manifest itself in this scheme where the state is foreclosed from meaningful regulation?” [p. 7]. “Indeed, the long-term consequences for the child of being home schooled or sent to a private school cannot be overstated. The total absence of regulation over what and how children are taught leaves the child vulnerable to gaining a sub-par or nonexistent education from which they may never recover. Moreover, the risk that parents or private schools unfairly impose hierarchical or oppressive beliefs on their children is magnified by the absence of state oversight or the application of any particular educational standards” [p. 14]. Implies that there is a smorgasbord of “rights” regarding a child’s education and, without much convincing theoretical framework, decides it is in all entities’ best interest for the State to have primary and final control over a child’s education. Fineman wants State education to reign supreme and to abolish, ban, and/or prohibit all private education, that is not controlled by the State [p. 17, see next quote]; i.e., ban all private schooling. Her worldview of statism is abundantly clear here: “Perhaps the more appropriate suggestion for our current educational dilemma is that public education should be mandatory and universal [emphasis added]. Parental expressive interest could supplement but never supplant the public institutions where the basic and fundamental lesson would be taught and experienced by all American children: we must struggle together to define ourselves both as a collective and as individuals. Perhaps when parents could not buy their children’s way out of a public system, they would begin to buy into the idea that we should all be concerned with every child’s opportunities, not just with those of our own” [p. 17].) revisions
Fineman, Martha, & Shepherd, George B. 2016 Homeschooling: Choosing parental rights over children's interests. University of Baltimore Law Review, 46(1), 57-106. homeschooling, home education, philosophy, law, legal, policy “For all of these reasons, homeschooling should be prohibited, as it is in many other countries” (p. 57). “Because of the harms homeschooling causes to children and society, it should be prohibited [emphasis added]. We reach this conclusion recognizing that even if homeschooling is prohibited, parents would still be the primary influences on children” (p. 96). “Homeschooling is the only educational environment that affords parents the highest level of control over the information that their children receive. To be clear, the question is not whether the state must recognize parents’ expressive interest in their children’s education. Of course it must. Instead, the question is where we draw the line separating that expressive interest from both the child’s interest in the ability to exercise freedom as an adult and the state’s interest in having citizens educated to understand and accept differences and diversity. The child’s interest in a diverse education aligns with the interest of the state. It is in the interest of both children and the state that children are educated to become citizens who realize that, although the values they have may not be shared by everyone, political compromises must be made in a democratic manner” (p. 106)) ?
Finklestein, B. 1976 In fear of childhood: relationships between parents and teachers in popular primary schools in the nineteenth century. History of Childhood Quarterly, 3, 321-335. History of home-school relationships.
Fischer, John H. 1974 Who needs schools? In William VanTil, (Ed.), Curriculum: quest for relevance, 2nd ed. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin Co., 432 p. School criticism.
Fleisher, D. & Freedman, D.M. 1983 Death of an American: The killing of John Singer. New York, NY: Continuum.
Florida Center for Reading Research 2012 Retrieved February 8, 2012 from http://www.fcrr.org/, http://www.fcrr.org/FCRRReports/PDF/SuccessAll.pdf, and http://www.fcrr.org/Interventions/pdf/teachingAllStudentsToReadSummary.pdf. http://www.fcrr.org/ http://www.fcrr.org/FCRRReports/PDF/SuccessAll.pdf http://www.fcrr.org/Interventions/pdf/teachingAllStudentsToReadSummary.pdf class size, one-on-one teaching, tutoring, phonics instruction, literature environment, cooperative learning, academic achievement, reading Small class size, one-on-one teaching, tutoring, phonics instruction, rich literature environment, cooperative learning, and other factors are significantly related to academic achievement and learning in reading.
Fortune-Wood, Jan 2000 Doing it their way: Home-based education and autonomous learning. Bramcote Hills, Nottingham, United Kingdom: Educational Heretics Press. home education, homeschooling, philosophy, history, socialization, pedagogy Begins with brief overview of the thinking of those who have significantly influenced the trend toward autonomous education like Karl Popper, John Holt, Ivan Illich, Alice Miller, John Taylor Gatto, and Roland Meighan. Part two explores autonomous home education. Analyzes the notion of necessary knowledge. Also examines the “... question of socialisation, questioning the relevance of school models of compulsory, age-related socialisation and the need for homogeneity, and proposing instead a model which allows for the social self to develop without compromising the child’s autonomy” [book cover].
Fortune-Wood, Mike 2005 The face of home-based education: Who, why, and how. Nottingham, United Kingdom: Educational Heretics Press. home education, research, demographics, reasons, pedagogical approaches, religion, United Kingdom, foreign Presents “part 1 of the results of research commissioned by The Centre for Personalised Education Trust” [front cover].
Fortune-Wood, Mike 2006 The face of home-based education 2: Numbers, support, and special needs. Bramcote, Nottingham, United Kingdom: Educational Heretics Press. home education, homeschooling, research, demographics, politics, policies, special needs, United Kingdom, UK, England Addresses topics such as how many children are home educated in the UK, the growth of homeschooling in the UK, students with “statements of special educational needs,” geographic distribution of home-educated children with a statement, provision of services to and for home educators such as local contacts, newsletters, legal advice, sourcing cheap and commercial learning resources, networking with other home educators, exam information, assistance in liaising with an LEA [local education agency], informal social support, legislation and current issues, curriculum materials, and support in dealing with statutory agencies, the view from Local Education Authorities, But what about university?, and special educational needs.
Foster, Christine 2000, November/December In a Class by Themselves. Stanford Magazine. https://stanfordmag.org/contents/in-a-class-by-themselves http://www.stanfordalumni.org/news/magazine/2000/novdec/articles/homeschooling.html/ http://www.stanfordalumni.org/jg/mig/news_magazine/magazine/novdec00/articles/homeschooling.html home education, homeschooling, college, admissions, Stanford University, cautious negative criticism, control, policy Retrieved 11/8/2021 from https://stanfordmag.org/contents/in-a-class-by-themselves Retrieved 7/14/10 from http://www.stanfordalumni.org/news/magazine/2000/novdec/articles/homeschooling.html/ and retrieved 12/4/00 from http://www.stanfordalumni.org/jg/mig/news_magazine/magazine/novdec00/articles/homeschooling.html). (“A wave of homeschoolers has reached the Farm--students with unconventional training and few formal credentials. What have they got that Stanford wants? And how do admission officers spot it?” “Jonathan Reider, '67, PhD '83, is a national expert on college-bound homeschoolers.” “The latest Stanford numbers show a rise in homeschooler applications. In 1999, the first year of tracking, 15 applied. Four were admitted, and all four enrolled. In 2000, there were 35 applications, more than double the previous year's. Nine were accepted, and five, including Butler, started classes on the Farm this fall. [new paragraph] That's a tiny subgroup, just 0.2 percent of the applicant pool. So why is the University interested? Admission officers sum it up in two words: intellectual vitality. [paragraph] It's hard to define, but they swear they know it when they see it. It's the spark, the passion, that sets the truly exceptional student--the one driven to pursue independent research and explore difficult concepts from a very early age--apart from your typical bright kid. Stanford wants students who have it. [paragraph] Looking very closely at homeschoolers is one way to get more of those special minds, the admission office has discovered. As Reider explains it: "Homeschooled students may have a potential advantage over others in this, since they have consciously chosen and pursued an independent course of study." [paragraph] Indeed, when he and his colleagues read applications last year, they gave the University's highest internal ranking for intellectual vitality to two of the nine homeschoolers admitted. And an astounding four homeschoolers earned the highest rating for math--something reserved for the top 1 to 2 percent of the applicant pool. [paragraph] "The distinguishing factor is intellectual vitality," says Reider. "These kids have it, and everything they do is responding to it.” ..... AMONG HOMESCHOOLERS who end up at Stanford, "self-teaching" is a common thread. Parents usually teach in the early grades, assigning and correcting work, but later shift to a supervisory role, spending more time tracking down books and mentors. Stanford-bound homeschoolers typically take several college courses before they apply. The admission office encourages this, both to help with evaluation and to give students a taste of classroom learning before they arrive on the Farm [Stanford]. ..... Homeschoolers tend to meet adults in the community during the day when they're out running errands, doing public service projects or seeking out mentors. ..... [Rob] Reich [a Stanford political scientist], MA '98, PhD '98, who describes himself as a cautious supporter of homeschooling, has another reservation: the practice is essentially unregulated in much of the nation, and even where regulations do exist, families interpret them loosely. Each state decides whether parents need any sort of certification to teach their children and must file reports on student progress with their local school district. Most states require no certification, although a handful demand that the instructing parent have a high school or college education. In California, parents can either arrange an independent study for their children through the local district or submit documents to gain classification as a private school. The statute does not give local districts the right to disallow a homeschool program and does not require standardized testing of these students.”
Foster, Christine 2007, Fall In a class by themselves. Mensa Research Journal, 38(3), 66-70. home education, talented, gifted, special needs
Foster, Julie 2000, May 5 Clinton wants to ‘organize’ home schoolers: ‘Your children have to prove that they’re learning on a regular basis.’ WorldNetDaily.com, online, http://www.worldnetdaily.com/bluesky_fosterj_news/20000505_xnfoj_clinton_wa.shtml (retrieved 5/8/00). http://www.worldnetdaily.com/bluesky_fosterj_news/20000505_xnfoj_clinton_wa.shtml home education, policy, opinion, government, President Clinton Reports that President Clinton thinks homeschoolers should be regulated by the government to meet government standards of learning and if they do not they should be forced to attend institutional schools. Clinton said, “We should say, 'Look, there's a good way to do this and a not-so-good way to do this,’” and require that home-schooled students meet academic benchmarks, he said. “But if you're going to do this,” he added, “your children have to prove that they're learning on a regular basis, and if they don't prove that they're learning then they have to go into a school -- either into a parochial or private school or a public school.”
Foster, Julie 2000, March 7 Education policy “a complete failure” Report: Pumping more federal money into system won't help. WorldNetDaily. http://www.worldnetdaily.com/bluesky_fosterj_news/20000307_xnfoj_education_.shtml education, finance, reform, money, funding, academic achievement, test scores online http://www.worldnetdaily.com/bluesky_fosterj_news/20000307_xnfoj_education_.shtml). (“Pointing to U.S. Department of Education statistics, a new report by the National Taxpayers Union says increased government education funds have not, and will not, improve the nation's degenerating schools. Americans spent an average of $6,548 per pupil in 1998 to educate the nation's children in public schools -- a record high, since two decades ago the number was $2,230 per child. But although spending has almost tripled, test scores have steadily dropped, earning the United States at least one distinction: the highest university dropout rates in the industrialized world -- 37 percent. [paragraph] Verbal Scholastic Assessment Test scores for both male and female high school students decreased from 543 points out of a possible 800 to 505 between 1967 and 1998. [paragraph] Critics of increased government spending say the test scores prove their point that money does not translate into academic success.”
Foster, Julie 2000, September 12 1. Candidates weigh in on home schooling: DNC attacks Bush for being ‘lenient' with home schoolers. WorldNetDaily.com. Published and retrieved 9/12/00 online http://www.worldnetdaily.com/bluesky_fosterj_news/20000912_xnfoj_candidates.shtml. http://www.worldnetdaily.com/bluesky_fosterj_news/20000912_xnfoj_candidates.shtml home education, law, policy, politics Explains Democrat National Committee wants home schooling to be much more tightly controlled by the state.
Foster, Julie 2000, September 20 Anti-voucher event held on campus: Children come home with campaign T-shirts. http://www.worldnetdaily.com/bluesky_fosterj_news/20000920_xnfoj_antivouche.shtml education, philosophy, politics published & retrieved 9/20/00 online http://www.worldnetdaily.com/bluesky_fosterj_news/20000920_xnfoj_antivouche.shtml in my quotes file Explains a political rally being held on public school property and supported by public school personnel probably in violaion of law.
Foulke-ffeinberg, F. X. 1995 Twilight of the universities. Edinburg, TX: Cui Bono Books (P.O. Box 3730, Edinburg TX 78540). 291+ pp. education, reform, postsecondary, college, university, home education, alternative education, distance learning, apprenticeship, economics Proposes how to solve the problems of higher education in the U.S.; the solution is dissolution. Enumerates in detail the abuses of power and “professionalism” by universities and their professors: financial, moral, ethical, educational, et cetera. Explains the advantages of at-home education, distance education, apprenticeships, and other alternatives to in-residence attendance at college. Uses academic writing style.
Fox, Linda P. 1987 Home school curricula: Constitutional issues. DAI, 48(5), 1069A. The University of North Carolina at Greensboro, 207pp.
Fox, Linda P. 1988, December Home school curricula. Home School Researcher, 4(4).
Fraley, R. Chris 2010 A brief overview of adult attachment theory and research. Retreived 12/27/2011 from University of Illinois at http://internal.psychology.illinois.edu/~rcfraley/attachment.htm. http://internal.psychology.illinois.edu/~rcfraley/attachment.htm psychology, sociology, attachment theory “Research on adult attachment is guided by the assumption that the same motivational system that gives rise to the close emotional bond between parents and their children is responsible for the bond that develops between adults in emotionally intimate relationships.”
Francis, David J., & Keith, Timothy Z. 2000 Self-esteem and home schooling socialization research: A work in progress. Home School Researcher, 14(3), 1-9.
Francis, David J., & Keith, Timothy Z. 2004 Social skills of home schooled and conventionally schooled children: A comparison study. Home School Researcher, 16(1), 15-24. http://www.nheri.org/content/view/37/27/ home education, research, socialization, social skills, public school, private school, matched-pair design, causal-comparative, peer-reviewed “Participants included 34 pairs of children between the ages of 5 and 18 and their parents; one child from each pair was home schooled [for at least two consecutive years], and the other was conventionally schooled [i.e., public school or private school]. ….. Due to the nonequivalent nature of the comparison groups (i.e., home educated vs. conventionally educated) the pairing procedure [based on friendship] was used to improve equivalency across the two groups.” “The Social Skills Rating System (SSRS) parent form was used to assess parents’ perceptions of their children’s social skills …” (p. 17). “The SSRS parent forms consist of an Elementary form (grades K-6) and a Secondary form (grades 7-12). These forms provide four social skill subscale scores (i.e., Cooperation, Assertiveness, Responsibility, and Self-control) in addition to Social Skills Scale Total Scores. The parent forms also surveys parents for Problem Behaviors, and yields a Total Problem Behaviors raw score that is generated from two subscales (i.e., Externalizing and Internalizing) …” (p. 18). “Specifically, home-educated children were found to have higher total social skill standard scores than the matched group of conventionally educated students (Means 113.12 and 107.15, respectively). The type of schooling (home vs. conventional) accounted for 12% of the variance explained in social skills (η² = .120), a moderate effect size using conventional rules of thumb” (p. 20). “A RANOVA was again used to examine the total problem behavior standard scores of the home and conventionally educated subjects (see Table 4). This analysis showed no statistically significant differences between the home and conventional students in terms of their problem behavior standard scores [F (1, 33) = .514, p = .478], and a small effect size (η2 = .015)” (p. 20). “The results from this study indicate that the home schooled children earned higher social skill standard scores than their conventionally educated peers. Although both groups earned social skills standard scores above the average in relation to the standardization sample, the home schooled children earned scores higher above the average in comparison to conventionally schooled children, means 113.1 and 107.1 respectively. These differences occurred despite the high degree of similarity between the groups [matched-pair design] and strongly suggest that home schooling had a statistically significant positive effect on the home schooled children’s social skills. Home schooled children also earned statistically significantly higher scores on the self-control component of overall social skills. An additional finding was that no differences occurred between the groups when measuring problem behaviors. The home schooled group did not differ from the conventionally educated group in their total problem behavior standard scores (M 94.50 and 96.38, respectively) or in any of the components of problem behaviors (internalizing, externalizing, or hyperactivity). Both groups were considered to have problem behaviors typical for their age, and were slightly better than average in relation to the standardization sample of the SSRS. The findings of this research suggest that home schooling does not appear to have any negative effects on the development of proper social skills. To the contrary, the results to this study suggest that the children benefited from an exposure to an education at home as their social skills appear to have been enhanced when compared to their conventionally educated counterparts. In addition, home schooled children show, on average, neither more nor fewer social skill problems than do conventionally schooled children” (retrieved January 18, 2008 from http://www.nheri.org/content/view/37/27/ Matched-pair design. Causal-comparative. Peer-reviewed.
Francis, David John 1999, November Social skills of home schooled and conventionally schooled children: A comparison study. Doctoral (Psy.D.) dissertation, Alfred University, New York, 106 pp. home education, research, socialization, psychology “... this study investigated whether home educated children’s social skills differed from the social skills of a matched comparison group of conventionally educated children. [paragraph] The results from this study indicate that the home schooled children earned higher social skill standard scores, and self-control scores than their conventionally educated peers. These differences in total social skills and self-control scores, were also found following the removal of five methodologically questionable subject pairs. These findings suggest that home schooling has a significant positive effect on children’s social skills. Although both groups earned social skills standard scores within the average range in relation to the standardization sample, the home schooled children earned scores higher in the average range, while the conventionally educated students earned scores lower in the average range, means 113.1 and 107.1 respectively (i.e., Mean 100, SD 15). [paragraph] Furthermore, it was hypothesized that the groups would not differ on the specific subscales of the SSRS measuring Cooperation, Assertiveness, Responsibility, and Self-control. The hypotheses were supported for the subscales measuring Cooperation, [p. 29] Assertiveness, and Responsibility as no differences were found on these scales; however, significant differences were indicated between the groups on the subscale measuring Self-control. Home schooled children earned higher scores in self-control than their conventional educated counterparts, means 2.29 and 2.00 respectively. Although both groups earned total self-control scores in the average range in relation to the SSRS standardization sample, home schooled children earned higher average total self-control scores, while their conventionally educated counterparts earned scores lower in the average range on the subscale measuring self-control. The above significant results taken in conjunction suggest that home schooling may not only have positive effects on children’s overall social skills, but may also influence specific social skills, such as self-control. [paragraph] Similarly, it was hypothesized that home and conventionally educated children would not differ on problem behavior subscales measuring internalized / externalized behaviors and hyperactivity. These hypotheses were supported as no differences were indicated between the groups. [paragraph] Finally, it was hypothesized that the groups would not differ in their total problem behavior standard scores. No differences were found between the groups on this scale. Both groups had problem behavior scores within the average range in relation to same age peers based on the standardization sample of the SSRS. [paragraph] Overall, these data suggest that home schooling has a positive effect on children’s social skills and may have resulted in the home schooled children having higher overall scores measuring social skills (i.e. Cooperation, Assertiveness, Responsibility, and Self-control) when compared to their conventionally educated counterparts. Moreover, home [p. 30] schooling appeared to have a particularly positive effect on the specific social skill of self-control. No differences between the groups were indicated on the scales measuring problem behaviors. Both groups earned equivalent and appropriate ratings within the average range for problem behaviors in relation to the SSRS standardization sample” [p. 31]. Points out limitations regarding representativeness of the sample.
Franzosa, Susan Douglas 1984 The Best and wisest parent: A critique of John Holt's philosophy of education. Urban Education, 19(3), 227-244. Posits that Holt is anti-Dewey in his philosophy and that homeschooling according to Holt would undermine the alleged good that comes from following John Dewey’s philosophy and worldview as applied to education and society. A thoughtful critique, criticism of certain aspects of thinking about home education, critic; referred to in Home School Researcher, 1(1), 4,5). (See Home School Researcher herein.
Franzosa, Susan Douglas 1991 The Best and wisest parent: A critique of John Holt's philosophy of education. In J. A. Van Galen & M. A. Pitman (Eds.), Home schooling: Political, historical, and pedagogical perspectives. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation. home education, critique, John Holt, philosophy Basically a repeat [possibly verbatim] of article by same title in 1984.
Freeman, B. 1981 How I slid into education's permissive pit and climbed out again. Christianity Today, April 10, 40-42. Criticism of public school from religious right.
Freire, Paulo 1970 The pedagogy of the oppressed (Myra B. Ramos, Trans.). New York, NY: Herder & Herder. education, schooling, philosophy, Marxixm Much schooling practice oppresses individual students and people groups in that it treats “... reality as if it were motionless, static, compartmentalized, and predictable” [p. 57] and exploits students [p. 40], and hinders their pursuit of self-affirmation as responsible persons [p. 40]).
Frenette, Marc 2007 Why are youth from lower-income families less likely to attend university? Evidence from academic abilities, parental influences, and financial constraints. Ottawa, Canada: Statistics Canada, Business and Labour Market Analysis. college attendance, research, socioeconomic status, NOT homeschooling State that he does not include homeschool students and other small-population groups in this study; that is, homeschoolers are not a part of the study.
Friesen, Lynda 1991 Choice in education. Sacramento, California: National Advocacy For Private Education. private education
Fritz, Marshall 1999, September A better brand of parent. The Freeman, 49(9), 8-11. education, philosophy, private education, home education, public schools, vouchers Explains why private schools and home schooling provide education superior to public schooling. Argues that keys to their success is that these parents and their sacrifice money and time for private education and therefore are more vested and have a greater interest in the education compared to when children receive an apparently “free” education in public schools. Explains why private schools and home schools should never take tax-money vouchers and that these would ruin private and home schooling.
Frost, E. A. 1987 A descriptive study of the academic achievement of selected elementary school-aged children educated at home in five Illinois counties. DAI, 48(7), 1589A. Northern Illinois University, 152pp. home education, academic achievement Studies children who have been home educated for two or more years and their academic achievement in reading and math. Involves 74 children in grades 3 to 6 in five counties in northeastern Illinois. “This group of 74 selected home-schooled students scored better than the national norms for all students in vocaabulary, reading, language skills, work study skills and mathematics” [p. 1589-A]. The “... relatively lower scores in the math computation subtest depressed the overall math scores” [p. 1589-A].
Frost, Eugene A., Morris, Robert C. 1988, Summer Does home-schooling Work? Some insights for academic success. Contemporary Education, 59(4), 223-27. homeschooling, Academic Achievement, Home Schooling, original research, peer-reviewed Reports on the growth of home-schools. Includes the results of one study and a summary of several others. Study of Illinois homeschool students (n=74 children from 58 families), homeschooled two or more years, and in grades 3 to 6. Researchers administered the Iowa Test of Basic Skills to the students and the test “… would provide national norm comparisons in the five basic academic areas” (i.e., vocabulary, reading, language skills, work study skills, and mathematics p. 225). For analysis, researchers divided students into three groups: (a) all students who participated, (b) children whose parents indicated their children “would be in a private school if they were not home-schooled,” and (c) “… 34 home-school students who were considered of “high socio-economic” status” (p. 225). “Frost and Morris (1988) found in a study of 74 Illinois homeschoolers that, controlling for family background variables, homeschoolers scored above average in all subjects but math.” “Notice [in Table 1] that in all cases [emphasis in original] the “average Tested Grade Equivalent Scores” were higher than the actual “School-Grade Level” these tested students would have normally been in” (p. 225); their percentiles ranged from 52 (0.05 SD) to 74 (0.64 SD) in Table 1. “The growing evidence that home-educated students are not disadvantaged academically by their home-school setting is becoming more apparent. If anything a case could be made for their “relative academic success”” (p. 226). The authors write, “Home-schooled students outperformed their traditionally educated counterparts in all areas (vocabulary, reading, language skills, and work study skills) except mathematics. That weak area, mathematics, is the focus of Table 2 …” (p. 226) but Table 2 reveals that the homeschool students’ average percentile scores were above average in 9 of 12 cells of Table 2. Also, the authors should write, “That relatively weak area …” Table 2 focuses on homeschool students’ math scores from 3rd to 6th grade. Despite the fact that the authors write, “Notice the general decrease in percentage [sic; should say percentile] from third to sixth grade in all [three math subtest] areas (exception being …)” (p. 226), they do not conduct a statistical analysis of the percentiles across the grade levels; a trained statistical eye might conclude, without doing a statistical test, that there is no significant difference across the four grade levels; in fact, the 6th grade “math computation” percentile is notably higher than the percentiles at the other three grade levels, and the average “math concepts” percentiles range from 63 to 68, all within stanine 6. Peer-reviewed
Frost, Gene 1988, Spring The academic success of students in home schooling. Illinois School Research and Development, 24(3), 111-17. Academic Achievement, Home Schooling A summary of four studies which concludes that home-schools students are not academically disadvantaged. The public schools should help these families with access to their larger support facilities.
Fugate, J. Richard 1998 What the Bible says about child training (2nd ed.). Elkton, MD: Full Quart Press child training, discipline, chastisement, home education, Christian, biblical of Holly Hall Publ. Available from Family Ministries, PO Box 1412, Fair Oaks CA 95628. Presents clear and simple study of discipline and child training based on a view that the Bible is the inerrant word of God; provides clear and detailed explanation of the use of chastisement and corporal punishment in the context of love and mercy; promotes home education.Very popular among home educators.
Fugate, J. Richard 1989 Starting a home school: Solutions to the most commonly asked home school questions. Tempe, AZ: Aletheia Division of Alpha Omega Publications.
Fugate, J. Richard 1990 Will early education ruin your child? Tempe, AZ: Aletheia Division of Alpha Omega Publications, 87 pp. homeschooling, home education, early childhood education Includes Appendix A, pp. 73-71, “An evaluation of research claims made by a leader in the home school movement,” by Brian D. Ray that evaluates some of the claims made by Raymond S. Moore regarding the harms of benefits of formal early childhood education efforts.
Fugate, J. Richard 1992 Will early education ruin your child (2nd ed.) Tempe, AZ: Aletheia Division of Alpha Omega Publications.
Fugate, J. Richard 1996 No place like home . . . school. Published by Family Building Seminars, 2401 W. Southern Ave. #219, Tempe AZ 85282. home education, Christian, philosophy, rationale, reasons Addresses common concerns that people have about home schooling. Covers the need for Christians to protect their children from negative peer pressure and from learning anti-God philosophy of humanism. Discusses dangers in public schools of drugs, violence, and the hopelessness that results from being taught evolution and the imminent destruction of the earth’s resources.
Fulbright, Leslie 2006, September 25 Blacks take education into their own hands: New ground: Once dominated by whites, homeschooling appeals to more African Americans. Retrieved 8/10/07 online http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2006/09/25/MNGLCLC58S1.DTL. http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2006/09/25/MNGLCLC58S1.DTL home education, minorities, black, African American “Although homeschoolers often are stereotyped as white and evangelical Christians, in 2003 about 9 percent of homeschooled students were black, and 77 percent were white, compared with a total student population nationwide that was 16 percent black and 62 percent white. Homeschoolers numbered 1.1 million in 2003, compared with about 49.5 million students in public and private schools, according to the most recent federal statistics from the U.S. Department of Education. The numbers of black and white homeschoolers rose about a third from 1999 to 2003 to encompass about 1.3 percent of U.S. black students and 2.7 percent of whites. Researchers say the number of black parents who are homeschooling their children may now be growing even faster.”
Furst, Lyndon G. 1992 Legal challenges to home schooling: A review of recent case law. Home School Researcher, 8(4), 1-8. law, legal, research Identifies several areas in which courts have risen to the defense of home schools; there are also areas in which "... the courts will not rule in favor of the home school but will instead support the power of the state to regulate such schools" [p. 6].
Furst, Lyndon G. 1994 Legal challenges to home schooling: An update for 1992-1993. Home School Researcher, 10(2), 7-14. law, legal, research Updates his 1992 piece in Home School Researcher. Considers cases related to testing requirements, divorce issues, bureaucratic procedures, and teacher certification. Gives much attention to the very significant Michigan Supreme Court cases.
Futrell, Mary H. 1988, August 29 Interview with National Broadcasting Company [NBC] "The Today Show" host]. National Broadcasting Company Television, New York, NY. (Regarding home schooling, the National Education Association's [of which Futrell was president] position, and research perspectives from Dr. Brian D. Ray of [then] Seattle Pacific University, and at Western Baptist College in Salem OR as of 9/91.
Gabb, Sean 2005 Home schooling: A British perspective. In Bruce S. Cooper (Ed.), Home schooling in full view: A reader, p. 99-227. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing. home education, foreign, United Kingdom, Britain
Gachoki, C.M. 2024 Household characteristics of hHome schoolers in Kenya. East African Journal of Education Studies, https://journals.eanso.org/index.php/eajes/article/download/2568/3222 https://journals.eanso.org/index.php/eajes/article/download/2568/3222 homeschooling, demographics, Kenya, descriptive “Abstract This study aimed to succinctly identify the unique characteristics of homeschooling households in Kenya. The study used a literature review, a survey, and insights from key informants’ interviews. The study found that households that homeschool their children in Kenya are made up of married couples, have multiple children and are well educated with at least a bachelor's degree. One of the household partners stays or works at home and is likely to be the mother since they provide teaching in these households. Only 32 percent have a separate dedicated classroom while 40 percent do not have a dedicated learning space. Along the same line, only about two-thirds of the respondents preferred a flexible schedule, while 7 percent had no learning schedule. Parents (mothers) are more likely to teach the younger children while households are likely to employ a teacher for the older children above 14 years. Moreover, the characteristics do not deviate significantly from findings in other jurisdictions. Homeschooling households in Kenya are likely to come from medium urban areas and use multiple curriculums. A small portion of homeschooling households do not follow any curriculum. Homeschooling in Kenya is driven by the need to provide personalized learning and not pedagogical or Christian persuasion.
Gadomski, Tara 2007, March 23 Faith fuels home education boom. BBC News. Retrieved 3/23/07 online http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/education/6486813.stm. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/education/6486813.stm home education, homeschooling, reasons, opinion Emphasizes the importance of religion in homeschooling in the US. Cites the work of the National Home Education Research Institute NHERI.
Gaebelein, Frank E. 1954 The pattern of God’s truth: The integration of faith and learning. Chicago, IL: Moody Press.
Gaither, Milton 2008, July 17 Cooper and Sureau on homeschooling politics. Retrieved February 1, 2010 from http://gaither.wordpress.com/2008/07/17/cooper-and-sureau-on-homeschooling-politics/ . http://gaither.wordpress.com/2008/07/17/cooper-and-sureau-on-homeschooling-politics/ home education, opinion, history, politics, religion, philosophy Defines homeschooling success by claiming it is reactive, and built on “… antigovernment sentiment, distrust of bureaucrats and experts, skepticism about the value of public schools, and a warm spot for mothers loving their kids.” “In my view the homeschooling movement has been so successful not because it was right-wing or because many of its most vocal leaders are outspoken Christians. Rather, its success stems from the fact that antigovernment sentiment, distrust of bureaucrats and experts, skepticism about the value of public schools, and a warm spot for mothers loving their kids are all very mainstream ideas. Homeschooling is as much an outgrowth of the leftist counterculture as the religious right, and as I argue in my book, both the left and the right were reacting in very similar ways against the same things, using quite similar rhetoric and political strategy. What was countercultural in the 1970s is now the American norm, just as blue jeans and t-shirts, formerly symbols of outsider protest, are now the American uniform. Anyone wishing for a good survey of what has happened and what is happening in homeschooling would be better served by looking elsewhere than this article.”
Gaither, Milton 2008 Homeschool: An American history. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan. homeschooling, history, negative criticism, negative critic
Gaither, Milton 2009, Winter Home schooling goes mainstream. Education Next, 9(1), 11-18. Retrieved April 15, 2014 from http://educationnext.org/home-schooling-goes-mainstream/. http://educationnext.org/home-schooling-goes-mainstream/ home education, homeschooling, virtual charter schools, public school at home, politics, philosophy “The increasing diversity of home schoolers and institutional configurations should not obscure the fact that many who home school still choose this option out of frustration with or protest against formal, institution-based schooling and seek to impart an alternative, usually conservative Christian, worldview to their children by teaching them at home. Yet it is also the case that increasing numbers who opt to home school do so as an accessory, hybrid, or temporary stopgap, or out of necessity given their circumstances. It is this newer group of home schoolers who are challenging the historical dichotomies between public and private, school and home, formal and informal that have played such an important role in the movement’s self-definition and in American education policy” [p. 18]. Relies too heavily on one 2003 study that collapsed to six the number of most-important reasons parents gave for homeschooling. “Most important” hides the multiple and nuanced reasons parents usually give. The overlap between “religion/morality” and “school environment” obfuscates what portion of the reasons is actually worldview/philosophy/religion-based. Claims homeschooling is no longer a “political movement.” Homeschooling clearly continues to be a political (and other) movement because its advocates know they must labor to keep fundamental parental rights over the education and upbringing of children recognized and protected from statist academics and government violation. They continually see attacks on their perspective and practice in courts, legislatures, and academic journals. As many have believed for millennia, one of their core beliefs is that parents have a right to not put their children under education controlled or “approved” by the state. Author is correct that the increase in tax-funded virtual charter schools blurs lines in the educational arena. Homeschool advocates do not have “animus toward government,” as author puts it (“Animus toward government was what bound leftist and conservative Christian home schoolers together in the 1970s and 1980s, and it is what has brought them back together to oppose virtual charters.”) but philosophically and politically oppose government control, based on what Frederick Bastiat called “legal plunder,” over the teaching, training, and indoctrination of children in a “free” nation. Homeschool advocates want to see state-run schooling diminish and private education increase. Homeschooling is a form of private and independent education. Virtual charter schools are public (government) schools at home (PSAH). Essential to homeschooling has been the liberty and choice of parents to educate their children as they chose and not under the control of the state. Home-education leaders know that PSAH essentially puts the public school into a family’s home and both legally and pedagogically increases state control and influence over children’s knowledge, values, and attitudes while diminishing the parents’.
Gaither, Milton 2009 Homeschooling in the USA: Past, present, and future. Theory and Research in Education, 7(3), 331-346. education, families, homeschooling, social movements, sociology “Abstract: This article first examines why the homeschooling movement in the USA emerged in the 1970s, noting the impact of political radicalism both right and left, feminism, suburbanization, and public school bureaucratization and secularization. It then describes how the movement, constituted of left- and right-wing elements, collaborated in the early 1980s to contest hostile legal climates in many states but was taken over by conservative Protestants by the late 1980s because of their superior organization and numerical dominance. Despite internal conflicts, the movement’s goals of legalizing and popularizing homeschooling were realized by the mid-1990s. Since that time homeschooling has grown in popularity and is increasingly being utilized by more mainstream elements of society, often in conjunction with public schools, suggesting that 'homeschooling' as a political movement and ideology may have run its course” (p. 331).
Gaither, Milton 2017 Homeschooling in the United States: A review of select research topics. Pro-Posições, 28(2), http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1980-6248-2015-0171 Retrieved September 5, 2017 from http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?pid=S0103-73072017000200213&script=sci_arttext http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1980-6248-2015-0171 http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?pid=S0103-73072017000200213&script=sci_arttext homeschooling, home schooling, home education, academic achievement, history, college, university, opinion “Abstract. The U.S. homeschooling movement has grown steadily since the early 1980s. In that time, a growing body of academic literature has been published that assesses various aspects of the phenomenon. This article first explains some of the methodological issues surrounding this literature as it has developed. It then summarizes the findings of the literature with respect to the following topics: the history of homeschooling, demographics (including parental motivation), academic achievement, and transition to college/adulthood. Keywords homeschooling; home education; academic achievement; curriculum.” Generalizes that “there may be at least a modest homeschooling effect on academic achievement,” that being positive for verbal “capacities” and to “weaken their math capacities” – but this is misleading wording since almost all studies show that homeschool students have higher than average math achievement even after background variables have been controlled. Perhaps author should have said that in some studies homeschool students’ math scores are not as high as their verbal scores. Author writes - “A second generalization that emerges from many studies on academic achievement is that homeschooling does not have much of an effect at all on student achievement once family background variables are controlled for”; this is an interesting choice of wording since the reader might wonder, Why did the author not write, Homeschooling appears to have a slight positive effect on achievement once background variables are controlled? The author appears to repeatedly downplay the positive academic achievement results associated with home education. Author writes, “A final consistent finding in the literature on academic achievement is that parental background matters very much in homeschooler achievement”; again, this is misleading. Parental background does not “matter very much” but is found to have a correlation in some studies; one must wonder, also, why the author does not point out that parental background matters very much almost always in studies of public school students. Regarding performance in college/university, “Most studies of this sort have found little to no difference on a wide range of variables between previously homeschooled and previously institutionally schooled students, though on a few measures homeschoolers consistently come out on top, if only by small margins. Several studies have found that homeschoolers outperform their institutionally schooled peers with similar demographic backgrounds in grade point average.” Overall, author reports that neutral to positive effects are associated with homeschooling. Author appears to go out of his way to conclude that there is nothing overall positive about homeschooling that is worth noting; nor does he report that there is anything negative associated with homeschooling. This begs the question for the reader: Why does the author not point out that if the effects of homeschooling are neutral to slightly positive, all without the professional and state-regulated certification of the teachers (i.e., parents) and without the more than $12,572 per year plus capital expenditures of tax dollars spent on USA public school students in 2017, is this not a significant research story?
Gaither, Milton 2018, January 26 The dark side of homeschooling: What the Turpin case teaches us about the lack of oversight on homeschooling in the US. Retrieved March 10, 2020 from https://publicseminar.org/2018/01/the-dark-side-of-homeschooling/ https://publicseminar.org/2018/01/the-dark-side-of-homeschooling/ homeschooling, home education, philosophy, law, legal, parental rights, critic, abuse, neglect Shows author is against allowing parents to have primary duty and authority in directing the education and upbringing of children. Author thinks that the civil government must control all children’s education/schooling by making it “legal” to homeschool when a different philosophy of law says that in a free society parents are free to educate children however they choose unless the government prohibits such a choice. Statism is clearly the author’s worldview, shown by his statement, “Things went back to normal in California, meaning that homeschoolers could simply register as private schools and then do as they pleased, free of all oversight — exactly what the Turpins did.” In other words, the state (civil government) must control all families and their children and not allow them to freely choose a mode and process of education. The following assertion also shows the statist worldview of the author: “But if calls like those of Assemblyman Joe Medina for a bill come to fruition, it is likely that well-organized homeschooling advocacy organizations with deep grassroots and deeper pockets will put relentless pressure on the legislature to kill the bill outright or to water it down. The result will be more of the same with little to protect children like the Turpins.” In other words, author argues that without more government control over all private-education children’s lives, there will necessarily be significantly more evil and harm being done against children than if the government were to control private education more. Author claims this with no empirical evidence to support the implied claim. Author’s article’s title itself implies that there is something fundamentally or essentially sinisterly evil or negative about parent-directed home/family-based education homeschooling, especially if it is not controlled by the state. Authors sets himself as a legal expert by declaring: “In 2008, a California Court of Appeals judge, relying on the precedents mentioned above, rightly noted that this widespread [homeschooling] practice was technically not legal.”
Gaither, Milton 2020 Homeschool deregulation and child abuse. Canopy Forum, December 10, 2020, https://canopyforum.org/2020/12/10/homeschool-deregulation-and-child-abuse https://canopyforum.org/2020/12/10/homeschool-deregulation-and-child-abuse homeschooling, home schooling, home education, child abuse, child neglect, philosophy Author promotes philosophical statism and claims that more government control over private home education homeschooling would significantly reduce an unspecified amount or rate of child abuse and neglect by homeschool parents. He offers no empirical evidence that homeschool children are at more risk than those in conventional institutional public schools and private schools. His claim is contrary to the finding that more state regulation of homeschooling is not associated with less abuse and neglect (c.f., Ray, Brian D., 2018, The relationship between the degree of state regulation of homeschooling and the abuse of homeschool children (Students)). The following by Gaither is a warped, inaccurate, and over-simplified presentation of a complex history of the modern homeschool movement: “In the 36 states with actual or implied statutory language about homeschooling, most in the 1970s left regulation up to local officials. In the late 1970s most local educational officials were tolerant of homeschooling, largely because the rare homeschooler in those years typically approached the school as a mild-mannered pedagogical progressive who wanted to experiment with a more liberatory pedagogy. But by the mid-1980s a much larger group of homeschoolers existed, most of whom were antagonistic Christian fundamentalists convinced that public education was indoctrination into godless secular humanism.”
Gaither, Milton. (Ed.) 2017 The Wiley handbook of home education. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons. homeschooling, home education, history, academic achievement, socialization, legal, law, racism, philosophy A collection of the latest (as of 2017) scholarship in all aspects of home education in the United States and abroad. Presents the latest findings on academic achievement of home-schooled children, issues of socialization, and legal argumentation about home-schooling and government regulation. Presents a global perspective on home education. The writing is purportedly accessible to students, scholars, educators, and anyone interested in home schooling issues.)
Galloway, Rhonda A. 1994 Home schooled and conventionally educated high school graduates: A comparison of aptitude for and achievement in college English. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Bob Jones University, Greenville, SC. home education, research, academic achievement, English, graduate, college, adult Public school, conventional Christian school, and home school graduates [n = 180] at a large, Christian liberal arts university were examined and compared for their college academic preparedness and college academic achievement; “...the home schooled students scored significantly higher on the ACT English subtest than did the conventional Christian school graduates. The second MANOVA showed no significant differences among the students on the variables dealing with composition skills. And the third MANOVA showed no significant differences among the students on the variables dealing with usage skills. Therefore, ... the home schooled students in this study demonstrate similar academic preparedness for college and similar academic achievement in college as students who had attended conventional schools. These findings are consistent with the existing research that reveals that home schooled students perform as well as, if not better than, conventionally educated students on academic achievement measures on the elementary and secondary levels” (abstract).
Galloway, Rhonda A. 1995 Home schooled adults: Are they ready for college? Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 18-22, San Francisco CA. (ERIC Reproducation Service No. ED384297.) home education, research, college academic achievement, adult, private schools, public schools, causal comparative Compares the academic preparedness and academic achievement, in terms of the subject area of English, among college students who had attended home schools, public schools, and conventional private schools. Finds, using MANOVA, that the ACT scores were comparable except that the home educated scored significantly higher on the ACT English subtest than did the private school students. MANOVA also reveals no significant difference among the three groups in terms of English composition and usage skills at the college level. Concludes that the home educated "... demonstrate similar academic preparedness for college and similar academic achievement in college as the students who have attended conventional schools" [p. 18].
Galloway, Rhonda A., & Sutton, Joe P. 1995 Home schooled and conventionally schooled high school graduates: A comparison of aptitude for and achievement in college English. Home School Researcher, 11(1), 1-9. home education, research, academic achievement, English, college, adult Basically, summarizes findings of Galloway’s 1994 dissertation. “The statistical analysis revealed that the home schooled students' ACT composite scores were comparable with the scores of the other groups of students; however, the home schooled students scored significantly higher on the ACT English subtest than did the conventional Christian school graduates” [p. 6]. “Yet, based on the results of this investigation, one may conclude that the home schooled students in this study demonstrate similar academic preparedness for college and similar academic achievement in college as the students who have attended conventional schools” [p. 7; and Tables 2-7 on p. 5-6].
Galloway, Rhonda A., & Sutton, Joe P. 1997 College success of students from three high school settings: Christian school, home school, and public school. A paper presented at the annual meeting of the National Christian Home Educators Leadership Conference, Boston, MA, October 10, 1997. home education, comparative, research, leadership, academic achievement Purpose was to measure the success of adults at a Christian university from three educational backgrounds. Used academic, cognitive, spiritual, affective-social, and psychomotor criteria for measuring success. Found the home schooled held significantly more positions of appointed and spiritual leadership and semesters of leadership service than did the Christian school group, but not significantly different from the public school group.
Galloway, Rhonda S., & Sutton, Joe P. 1999 Are adults who were home educated experiencing success in their adulthood? Private School Monitor, 20 (3), 4-6. home education, research, adult, graduates, academic achievement, cognitive, social, spiritual, and psychomotor Explains that the homeschooled are doing well in academic, cognitive, social, spiritual, and psychomotor areas into their adult years.
Gardner, Howard 1991 The unschooled mind: How children think and how schools should teach. Basic Books, division of Harper Collins Publishers, Inc. An excerpt from this book, entitled "Making schools more like museums" was in Education Week, 11(6 10/9/91), p. 40 and said that to configure education for the students of today we need "...to think of the ways in which the strengths of a museum atmosphere, of apprenticeship learning, and of engaging projects can pervade all educational environments from home to school to workplace. The evocativeness and open-endedness of the children's museum needs to be wedded to the structure, rigor, and discipline of an apprenticeship."
Gathercole, Rachel 2005, July/August Homeschooling’s true colors: Investigating the myths—and facts—about America’s fastest-growing educational movement. Mothering, July/August, 56-63. home education, demographics, reasons, pedagogical approaches, research findings, academic achievement, socialization, going to college, democratic participation General article on many facets of homeschooling such as demographics, reasons, pedagogical approaches, research findings, academic achievement, socialization, going to college, democratic participation, and allegations of child abuse and neglect.
Gatto, John Taylor 1991, circa Dumbing us down. Philadelphia PA: New Society Publishers.
Gatto, John Taylor 1998, November 14 A short, angry history of modern schooling and how it stimulates mindless consumerism. Keynote speech presented at SepCon 1998, the annual meeting of the Separation of School and State Alliance, Colorado Springs, CO, November 12-14. Available on audiotape from Separation of School and State Alliance, 4578 N First #310, Fresno CA 93726.
Gatto, John Taylor 2001; I got the most of the quotes below from 2000 author’s special pre-publication edition/2001 market edition—I’m pretty sure identical to 2001 The underground history of American education: A schoolteacher’s intimate investigation into the problem of modern schooling. Oxford, NY: The Oxford Village Press. education, history of American and other education, public schooling, compulsory schooling, private education, home education, research, philosophy, sociology, politics Provides detailed, well-documented, insightful, and infrequently heard discussion and critique of modern institutional schooling, especially compulsory and state- or government-controlled education. Writes from the perspective and experience of one outside of academia who clearly understands academia and from inside public schooling; he is a former New York State and New York City teacher of the year. Presents his writing with many features of a philosopher, artist, researcher, and experienced classroom teacher. “It took seven years of reading and reflection for me to finally figure out that mass schooling of the young by force was a creation of the four great coal powers of the nineteenth century. ..... This simple reality is hidden from view by early philosophical and theological anticipations of mass schooling in various writings about social order and human nature. But you shouldn’t be fooled any more than Charles Frenacis Adams was fooled when he observed in 1880 that what was being cooked up for kids unlucky enough to be snared by the newly proposed institutional school net combined characteristics of the cotton mill and the railroad with those of a state prison” [p. 37, author’s special pre-publication edition]. “School [in America] was looked upon from the first decade of the twentieth century as a branch of industry and a tool of governance” [p. 38, author’s special pre-publication edition]. “From the beginning, there was purpose behind forced schooling, purpose which had nothing to do with what parents, kids, or communities wanted; but instead was forged out of what a highly centralized corporate economy and system of finance bent on internalizing itself was thought to need; that, and what a strong, centralized political state needed, too” [2001, p. 38]. “Something strange is going on in schools and has been going on for quite some time. ..... we are experiencing an attempt, successful so far, to reimpose the strong-state, strong social class attitudes of England and Germany on the United States ... the very attitudes we threw off in the American Revolution. And in this counter-revolution the state churches of England and Germany have been replaced by the secular church of forced government schooling” [p. 59]. “After I spoke in Nashville, a mother named Debbie pressed a handwritten note on me which I read on the airplane to Binghamton, N.Y.: [new paragraph] We started to see Brandon flounder in the first grade, hives, depression, he died every night after he asked his father, “Is tomorrow school, too?” In second grade the physical stress became apparent. The teacher pronounced his problem Attention Deficit Syndrome. My happy, bouncy child was now looked at as a medical problem, by us as well as the school. [new paragraph] A doctor, a psychiatrist, and a school authority all determined he did have this affliction. Medication was stressed along with behavior modification. If it was suspected that Brandon had not been medicated he was sent home. My square peg needed a bit of whittling to fit their round hole, it seemed. [new paragraph] I cried as I watched my parenting choices stripped away. My ignorance of options allowed Brandon to be medicated through second grade. The tears and hives continued another full year until I couldn’t stand it. I began to homeschool Brandon. It was his salvation. No more pills, tears, or hives. He is thriving. He never cries now and does his work eagerly” [p. xxix].
Gatto, John Taylor 2003, September Against school: How public education cripples our kids, and why. Harper’s Magazine, September 2003, 33-38. public schools, public education, compulsory attendance, history, philosophy, reform, home education Asks, do we really need school? then writes, “Don’t hide behind reading, writing, and arithmetic as a rationale, because 2 million happy homeschoolers have surely put that banal justification to rest” [p. 34]. Explains the history of American public, state-run, compulsory attendance, “forced schooling” [p. 34]. “There you have it. Now you know. We don’t need Karl Marx’s conception of a grand warfare between the classes to see that it is in the interest of complex management, economic or political, to dumb people down, to demoralize them, to divide them from one another, and to discard them if they don’t conform” [p. 37]. “First, though, we must wake up to what our schools really are: Laboratories of experimentation on young minds, drill centers for the habits and attitudes that corporate society demands. Mandatory education serves children only incidentally; its real purpose is to turn them into servants. Don’t let your own have their childhoods extended, not even for a day” [p. 38].
Gaumont, Léo 2002 Home education and post secondary admissions. A paper presented at the 2002 Conference of The Association of Registrars of Universities and Colleges of Canada, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada, June 24, 2002. home education, research, college, university, admissions, policy Addresses homeschooling and admissions policies of colleges and universities. “Home education is the fastest rising educational alternative in North America. As the number of home educated students increases, more will be seeking admission into post-secondary institutions. This paper describes the general attributes of home education, reviews the results of the National Survey of Post Secondary Admission Requirements for Home Educated Students and addresses the problems created by this newly emerging phenomenon. Some suggestions are also given on what can be done to accommodate these students at a post secondary level. Some of the information presented has been gathered from various resources cited while a great deal has been collected through my 14 years experience as a home school dad, supervisor/facilitator and director of a willing non-resident school board registering and serving home educating families. Personal study and research of the home school admission practices of post secondary institutions as well as the preparedness of home educated students for post secondary level training over many years has resulted in an understanding of the issues related to home education and post secondary admissions” [abstract, p. 1].
Gemmer, T. 1987 Homeschoolers and the public library. ALKI: The Washington Library Association Journal, 3(3), 96-98.
George, Jim. Court tells state to explore options to taking children from parents 1991, September 10 Saint Paul Pioneer Press, p.7B. home education
Gergen, David 2000, June 19 No place like home. U.S. News & World Report, 128(24), 24. home education, opinion, education reform, research Describes successful adults who were home educated, like Jedediah Purdy, a 24-year-old graduate of Harvard University who recently authored a book, For common things: Irony, trust, and commitment in America today which is “... an insightful, well-written call for a return to core values and an abandonment of an ironic stance toward life” [p. 64] and the disproportionately high numbers of homeschooled youth in the 2000 National Spelling Bee in which the top three winners were homeschooled. Cites the National Home Education Research Institute’s estimate of the homeschool population size and other research. Mentions research showing the importance of a small student/teacher ratio and how this is the case in homeschooling. “Most high schools are organized like factories, discouraging a personal relationship between students and teachers. The Sizers write: “The loads per teacher are normally heavy--100 to 175 young people during each semester--and the rapid reassignment of students from course to course makes it likely that a large percentage of students are not known well. This creates a situation which is, unfortunately, welcomed by many students: anonymity means their freedom from all sorts of scrutiny and obligation. [new paragraph] It’s a long distance from anonymity in a classroom to a child working alongside an adult each day, but it’s a path that we must learn to travel. The future will belong to those children who, like Jed Purdy, are ‘freed to learn’” [p. 64].
Giles, Hollyce C. 1998 Parent engagement as a school reform strategy; ERIC/CUE Digest Number 135. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 419 031.)
Gill, David W. 1989 The opening of the Christian mind: Taking every thought captive to Christ. Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press. philosophy Offers sound, practical advice for the lifelong stewardship of our minds in the midst of a technologically oriented, pluralistic culture; describes the marks of a distinctively Christian mind.
Gilnet, Jennifer Johnson. (Ed.) May, 1990 Issues and Choices in Education. Response. Seattle Pacific University.) Parents attitudes, Home education, Private Education, Educational Change, Home education
Giménez-Dasí, Marta; Quintanilla, Laura; & Sarmento, Renata 2023 Psychological adjustment in Spanish children that are homeschooled vs those schooled in educational centres, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/373947276_Psychological_adjustment_in_Spanish_children_that_are_homeschooled_vs_those_schooled_in_educational_centres “Abstract: Families that decide to homeschool (HS) their children have increased significantly in recent decades. The situation of these families is very different depending on the country of residence. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/373947276_Psychological_adjustment_in_Spanish_children_that_are_homeschooled_vs_those_schooled_in_educational_centres Keywords: homeschooling; psychological adjustment; primary education; education policies; social development In Europe, situations vary from being legal with virtually no state regulation to being prohibited. These differences in regulation reveal the lack of consensus regarding the benefits and consequences of HS. the objective of this article is to contribute towards the knowledge regarding the impact that HS has on variables related to adjustment and social and emotional well-being of school-aged children with a Spanish population. The participants were 159 families with children aged between 8 and 11 years of age. Of these families, 75 schooled their children in public centres and 84 schooled their children at home. SENA Fernández-Pinto et al., 2015) questionnaire scaled for the Spanish population in its self-report and hetero-report version was used. Our results suggest that HS children score significantly lower in Depression and Somatic Complaints. In the other measures of psychological adjustment, no differences were found, according to the self-report. In the same sense, hetero-report results also show that the HS children score significantly lower in Depression, Attention problems and Willingness to study than the schooled children. Regarding the gender, significant differences are observed in both measures only in the group of schooled children.”
Giving Up on School: One Family's Story 2007 Education Canada, 47(3), 38-42. ERIC Document No. EJ771020. http://www.eric.ed.gov educational environment; public education; special needs students; learning disabilities; asperger syndrome; parents as teachers; homeschooling, home schooling; school effectiveness; elementary education; individualized instruction; parent school relationship; parent grievances “Abstract: Although this author expresses her belief in public education, and states that homeschooling her two sons was not her first choice, she describes how she feels that she was forced into this decision by a school system that was insensitive to the special needs of her children. She discusses the experiences of her two boys in a local, publicly-funded school, and how the school environment hurt her children emotionally, behaviorally, and academically. After seven years of trying to make the school system work for her children, she gave up. Rather than working almost full time to make the school work for them, she is now working more than full time to give them the education the school failed to provide. After two years, both boys are thriving. It took the first year to simply restore the confidence in themselves that years of school-induced stress had destroyed” (retrieved 7/16/13 from http://www.eric.ed.gov). Author is possibly from Canada.
Gladin, Earl Wade 1987, May Home education: Characteristics of its families and schools. Unpublished doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Bob Jones University, Greenville, SC. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED301925). Home Schooling, Nontraditional Education, Religious Education A study based upon a 62% response, or 253 families, drawn from 418 families listed in the home school mailing list of the Bob Jones University Press.
Glanzer, Perry 1998 Religion in public schools: In search of fairness. Phi Delta Kappan, 80(3), 219-222. education reform, religion, philosophy, curriculum, values, beliefs Provides evidence, including the research of Warren Nord, that public school curriculum is not religiously neutral. “In other words, textbooks answer these foundational questions in ways that show preferential treatment of secular answers and indirect antagonism of religious perspectives” [p. 221]. Says educators, to solve the problem, promote the “equality of exposure” model in which children are to be exposed to a whole variety of ideological perspectives and stories. “The major problem with this approach, though, goes much deeper. The ‘equality of exposure’ model treats education less as a search for truths—the learning or disregarding of which might have lifelong or eternal consequences—and more like an ice cream store. Knowledge and ideas are approached not with a sense of importance but as matters of taste” [p. 222]. Claims that reforms such as vouchers or tax credits are: “In fact, they are actually the only approaches that can avoid violating the free exercise clause of the First Amendment. Any other system, including the current one, discriminates against those parents who, for conscience’s sake, wish to give their children a religious education” [p. 222]. Glanzer omits that the separation of school and state is another approach that would avoid constitutional problems.
Glanzer, Perry L. 2008 Rethinking the boundaries and burdens of parental authority over education: A response to Robert Reich's case-study of homeschooling. Educational Theory 58(1), 1-16. http://www.eric.ed.gov homeschooling, home education, state regulation, law, legal, philosophy, parental rights Abstract: “Rob Reich's claim that fruitful discussions about the balance among state, parental, and children's educational interests would benefit by contemplating the widespread phenomenon of homeschooling is a welcome suggestion. His policy recommendations, however, place an unjustified burden on parents to show the adequacy of homeschooling arrangements instead of placing the burden on the state to clarify commonly agreed-upon outcome measures. In this essay, Perry Glanzer argues that Reich places the burden on parents by overstating the threat that the freedom given to homeschooling parents represents to the interests of liberal democratic states and children. Reich, Glanzer contends, also underestimates the state's tendency to use regulation to weaken the civil society essential for liberal democracy. To counter Reich's proposal, Glanzer offers recommendations regarding the proper limits of parental authority in education in general and in the case of homeschooling in particular” [abstract, retrieved July 19, 2012 from http://www.eric.ed.gov
Gleason, G. T., (Ed.) 1967 The theory and nature of independent learning. Scranton, PA: International Textbook.
Glenn, Charles L. 1987 “Molding” citizens. In Richard John Neuhaus (Ed.), Democracy and the renewal of public education (pp. 25-56). Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company. public education, history, philosophy, state control In discussing the development of this agenda for state-directed education, it is useful to borrow a distinction from the debates over education policy that took place during the French Revolution. “Instruction,” in these debates, meant the teaching of the basic and advanced skills useful to economic life, while “education” meant the development of attitudes, loyalties, and values. Schooling at virtually all times and places has included both of these objectives, in a varying mix; even post-secondary vocational programs, for example, lay stress on inculcating attitudes toward work as well as work-related skills” [p. 26-27]. “My purposes here are to demonstrate this proposition and to show how Mann and others set about creating a system of popular education in the interest of their convictions about the necessary direction of American life” [p. 27]. “Within a few years, however, the emphasis shifted from improving the techniques and resources available within multiform arrangements for schooling to state action in the interest of a uniform system of education. Voluntary efforts lost credit. Local diversity was defined as a problem, and schools not accountable to the political process were condemned as a threat to the best interests of society. The goal became a transformation of popular schooling into a powerful instrument for social unity. [new paragraph] In Massachusetts the “common school revival” was essentially an effort by a Unitarian/Whig minoritythe “new class” of the dayto reshape popular beliefs and values after a single pattern. State action was necessary, in this minority’s view, primarily to overcome the undesirable diversity of teaching associated with the education of many childrenfrom poor as well as prosperous familiesprovided by various private and church-connected schools. This diversity was seen as harmful to progress, to social and national unity, and to the goals of the liberal elite. Particular concern was expressed about the perpetuation of religious fanaticism in schools where, as Mann observed in his First Report (February 1838), “children are taught from their tenderest years to wield the sword of polemics with fatal dexterity.” It was hoped that the common school could, by inculcating “the beautiful and sublime truths of ethics and natural religion,” protect the rising generation from falling into the “opposite extremes” of becoming “devotees on the one side or profligates on the other” [p. 28].
Glenn, Charles L. 1988 The myth of the common school. Amherst, MA: University of Massachusetts. 400 pp. ISBN 0-87023-602-4. public schooling, education, private schools, religion, history, philosophy, common school Documents the contention surrounding the creation of the tax-funded “common school” in several nations. “In the United States, as in France and the Netherlands, the mission of the common school was defined largely in terms of the creation of convictions and loyalties, of shaping a common mind or soul for the nation. So defined, the control and specification of the content of instruction were obviously of critical importance, as was the participation of all children, or at least those of the common people, in state-directed schooling. ….. They [non-state, ethnic parochial schools] were struggling against what Ravitch describes as ‘the popular myth that the public schools had single-handedly transformed immigrant children into achieving citizens.’ This was the dominant myth of American education in the nineteenth century, and it has persisted with undiminished force in the twentieth, despite all evidence that public schools are in no sense “common” and that the assimilating forces of modern life itself create more uniformity than my be good for us” [p. 261]. Regarding public schools, California superintendent of public instruction says: “Here we are with an institution that is essential to this democracy, to this society. It is the way we pass down our values” and public schools are the only way we will be able to assure our students will be taught correctly so that “... this democracy and freedom and liberty and individual choice that you like is going to survive ...” [Honig as quoted in Glenn, p. 284]. “Honig overlooks the fact that millions of Americans over the past century have been educated in schools not under government control, without noticeably divisive effect” [Glenn, p. 285] and an even larger portion of Americans were not attending state-controlled schools before that when our nation was birthed and matured quite remarkably. The majority of American parents would choose private schooling rather than state-run schools if they felt they truly had the choice and Black parents appear to be more interested in authentic choice than do white parents [p. 284]. Carefully documents and explains that both religious and moral instruction had always been essential elements of common (public-run) schools, that a significant portion of state-school advocates wanted children in them to “... grow up ‘with the state, of the state and for the state’” [p. 146], and that “... the mission of the [common, public] school itself became more rather than less truly ‘religious’ over this period [i.e., late 19th through mid-20th century; italics in the original]. The common school and the vision of American life that it embodied came to be vested with a religious seriousness and exaltation” [p. 178].
Glenn, Charles L. 2000 The ambiguous embrace: Government and faith-based schools and social agencies. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. http://www.capenet.org/pdf/Outlook285.pdf private education, reform, funding, philosophy, government I think the publisher’s year 2000 catalog says: “This is a time of far- reaching change and debate in American education and social policy, spurred in part by a rediscovery that civil-society institutions are often better than government at meeting human needs. As Charles Glenn shows in this book, faith-based schools and social agencies have been particularly effective, especially in meeting the needs of the most vulnerable. However, many oppose providing public funds for religious institutions, either on the grounds that it would threaten the constitutional separation of church and state or from concern it might dilute or secularize the distinctive character of the institutions themselves. Glenn tackles these arguments head on. He builds a uniquely comprehensive and persuasive case for faith-based organizations playing a far more active role in American schools and social agencies. And, most importantly, he shows that they could do so both while receiving public funds and while striking a workable balance between accountability and autonomy.” There are definite effects upon faith-based schools when they take government money/taxes; the book is full of the effects and many of them are negative from the perspective of keeping a strong, core, faith-based (e.g., Christian) mission and practice once taxes are taken. “Second – and equally dangerous – the [secular, professional] norms may come to be accepted by those who give direction to the organization as representing a better definition of good practice than that to which the school or agency was originally dedicated. This leads to a loss of nerve, a “pre-emptive capitulation” [footnote 12] that surrenders to the world even before its demand is made, a “seduction of the Samaritans” in Loconte’s evocative title” (p. 246). “But schools cannot be neutral; all [all] education conveys religious understandings, that is, a set of beliefs, values, and sentiments that order social life and create purpose for human activity. These may be comprehensive ideals that ennoble the person and reach out broadly to others, or they may narrowly focus only on advancing material self-interest” (p. 250). “Whatever the immediate reason, the long-term effect [of receiving public funds, tax dollars] is to reduce the distinctiveness and flavor that they [faith-based organizations, agencies, schools] are able to offer to the social service mix” (p. 257). ““The net result of those regulations, no matter how well-intentioned, “was to kill a lot of local initiative and flavor.” It’s the cumulative effect of regulatory “pinpricks” and “duck-nibbles” that private schools should guard against to protect their integrity, he [Dr. Charles Glenn] argued” retrieved November 15, 2016 from http://www.capenet.org/pdf/Outlook285.pdf
Glenn, Charles L. 2005 Homeschooling and compulsory state schooling. In Bruce S. Cooper (Ed.), Home schooling in full view: A reader [chapter 3]. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing.
Gloeckner, Gene W., & Jones, Paul 2013 Reflections on a decade of changes in homeschooling and homeschooled into higher education. Peabody Journal of Education, 88(3), 309-323, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0161956X.2013.796837 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0161956X.2013.796837 homeschooling, home education, college, college admission, adult, peer-reviewed “This article reviews selected research on successes of homeschooled students over the past decade. The article raises several methods issues, especially related to sampling issues and recent changes in some state laws. In addition the article reviews research collected from college admission’s officers’ on their perceptions and attitudes relate to homeschooled students. The comparative results of the studies reported in this review, combined with the data collected from college admission officers provides evidence that homeschooling is an effective alternative path to college for the children of many families” (p. 309).
Glueck, Michael Arnold, & Cihak, Robert J. 2002, December 12 The real reason the state opposes homeschooling. Retrieved 9/17/04 online http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=29966. http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=29966 “It's called "soft dictatorship" – government's attempt to control every aspect of American life for your own good or for the good of the children. The ultimate issue is power. This week's example: government's assault (at all levels) on the homeschool movement, which now includes threats to send homeschool parents to jail. Government's great fear in this matter is not that the kids are being short-changed or abused – it's that they might be getting a better education than the government-educrat de facto monopoly can provide and that the word might get out. ….. The game gets rough. In Illinois, according to the Chicago Tribune, truant officers arrive in police cars, bearing letters telling parents to come to "pretrial hearings" At least one officer told a parent "we can take your children away." ….. In many other states, such as Louisiana and Montana, education or legislative officials threaten "tighter" regulation and other laws or policies which seem to have the goal of making it more difficult for parents to educate their own children at home.”
Goertzel, V. & Goertzel, M. 1962 Cradles of eminence. Boston MA: Little Brown & Co.
Goff, Karen Goldberg 2003, April 27 Learning with friends. The Washington Times, retrieved 5/1/03 online http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20030425-82878656.htm. http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20030425-82878656.htm home education, news, socialization, athletics, sports, cooperatives Reports how homeschool families often work with others in academic, atheletic, and other cooperatives to provide their students with other than what can be provided by only the family. “As home-schooling has grown in popularity, so has the cooperative spirit among families, says Brian Ray, president of the National Home Education Research Institute. Mr. Ray's organization estimates that more than 1.5 million American children are home-schooled and that the numbers are growing annually. In the densely populated Washington [DC] area, that means opportunities abound to team up for subjects, go on field trips as groups, hold a prom, print a yearbook or play in a band. “I always liked to call home-schooling 'home-based' education," says Mr. Ray, who also estimates that the average home-schooler is involved in five outside activities. "It is never just Billy tied to his mother's apron strings. Being with other children has been a key part of home-schooling all along in one way or another. The allegation that home-schoolers are isolated is so far from the truth.””
Golden, Daniel 2000, February 11 Home-schooled kids defy stereotypes, ace SAT test. Wall Street Journal, p. A1, A16 (also online). home education, research, opinion, population size, academic achievement, performance in college Describes home schooling as being close to a mainstream educational choice now, that the home schooled are doing very well academically, and colleges are welcoming the home educated. They perform well on tests such as the ACT and SAT before applying to college. In response to this fact, “Sandra Feldman, president of the American Federation of Teachers, says the test data don't cast doubt on the value of teachers. "Why draw any grand conclusions?" she asks, since so few home-schoolers take the SAT and ACT. "I just say I'm happy for them. These are parents who are very highly motivated, teaching their kids at home and doing a very good job," she says. She adds, however, that public schools need to do more to challenge gifted students if they are to avoid losing some of them to home-schooling” [p. A16] Feldman’s statement is a much more polite and accommodating approach to home schooling than that of spokesmen of the National Education Association that are documented in this bibliography. “‘Home-schoolers bring certain skills--motivation, curiosity, the capacity to be responsible for their education--that high schools don’t induce very well,’ says Jon Reider, Stanford’s senior associate director of admissions” [p. A16].
Golden, Daniel 2000, April 24 Home schoolers learn how to gain clout inside the beltway: A powerful lobbying force, parents wage campaigns through phone and fax; George W.’s ‘big promise.’ Wall Street Journal, p. A1, A6. home education, policy, politics, sociology, political science, lobbying Describes the strong influence--disproportionately large compared to their numbers--of the homeschool community on educational policy nationwide. “‘When I started home-schooling, I was worried that we were withdrawing from society,’ says another [lobbying] trainee, Jo Hershy [homeschool parent] of Lancaster, Pa. ‘But now I feel we have the best of both worlds. We home-school, and we influence educatioal policy nationwide. Do they ever. Although often portrayed as an isolated fringe group, parents who teach their children at home have become inside-the-Beltway pros, wielding enough clout to help block a Clinton administration bid for national student testing, launch their own political action committee and push their concerns into the midst of this year’s presidential race. Despite relatively small numbers-an estimated million to 1.5 million of the nation’s 53 million schoolchildren are taught at home-their ability to overwhelm Congress and state legislatures with phone calls, faxes, e-mails and visits has won them a unique status as educational conscientious objectors, in the form of exemptions from compulsory attendance laws and state tests. But home schoolers aren’t content to be left alone. Suspicious of any federal intervention in what they consider a family matter, they are rallying resistance to the bipartisan coalition of government, business and academic leaders seeking more accountability and higher standards in K-12 education” [p. A1].
Golden, S. 1982, November 12 At home - computers in home teaching. Times Education Supplement, 41-42. Computers.
Goldhaber, Dan 2005, March 29 Teacher licensure tests and student achievement: Is teacher testing an effective policy? CRPE working paper # 2005_4. http://www.crpe.org http://www.crpe.org/cs/crpe/download/csr_files/wp_crpe4_tchlicensure_mar05.pdf student academic achievement, public school, teacher qualifications licensure licensing Seattle, WA: Center on Reinventing Public Education, Daniel J Evans School of Public Affairs, University of Washington, www.crpe.org. Retrieved 7/5/2010 from http://www.crpe.org/cs/crpe/download/csr_files/wp_crpe4_tchlicensure_mar05.pdf. “So should states be using these tests [i.e., Education Testing Service’s (ETS) Praxis series of tests] to determine eligibility to teach? That depends on one’s perspective. On the one hand, if states are seeking criteria to ensure a basic level of quality, than a licensure test appears to be one that does have a relationship to student achievement. And, licensure performance appears to be a much better predictor of teacher effectiveness than some other teacher characteristics and credentials. Specifically, the literature on teacher effects, as well as the findings presented here, do not suggest a very strong relationship between teacher degree level and student achievement. On the other hand, the magnitude of the effect of changes in licensure performance is quite small” [p. 16].
Goldhaber, Dan D., & Brewer, Dominic J. 2000, Summer Does teacher certification matter? High school teacher certification status and student achievement. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 22(2), 129-145. student academic achievement, teacher certification, teacher licensure, policy Examine the relationship between high school students’ academic achievement in math and science and teacher certification status. “Although teacher certification is pervasive, there is little rigorous evidence that it is systematically related to student achievement” [p. 141]. “… we find evidence [in this study] in math [but not in science] that teachers with subject-specific training (a mathematics degree or certification) outperform [by about 0.10 of the s.d., p. 139] those without subject-matter preparation” [p. 141]. “However, contrary to conventional wisdom, mathematics and science students who have teachers with emergency credentials do no worse than students of teachers with standard teaching credentials, all else equal. This result should, at the very least, cast doubt on the claims of the educational establishment that standard certification should be required of all teachers. In fact, we believe it is incumbent on those who expound such a position to demonstrate that such training systematically leads to better teaching; in our data we find little evidence for this position” [p. 141].
Good, Heather M. 2005 The forgotten child of our Constitution: The parental rree exercise right to direct the education and religious upbringing of children." Emory Law Journal 54, 641-79. legal, law, political theory, legal theory, philosophy
Good, Thomas L., & Brophy, Jere E. 1987 Looking in classrooms (4th ed.). New York NY: Harper & Row, Publishers. mastery learning, tutoring, achievement, teacher effectiveness “Until relatively recently in human history, only the children of the rich and powerful received formal education. This education typically took the form of private individualized tutoring. Such tutoring is the method of choice for most educational purposes, because both curriculum (what is taught) and instruction (how it is taught) can be individualized and because the teacher can provide the student with sustained personalized attention....” p. 352.
Goodlad, John I. 1984 A place called school. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
Goodman, Joan F. 1992 When slow is fast enough. New York, NY: Guilford Press. special needs, handicapped, research Argues that the home environment is the best for special needs children.
Goodman, Paul 1962 Compulsory mis-education and the community of scholars. New York, NY: Vintage Books education, college and university education, critique, reform, philosophy a division of Random House). (“A challenging critique of the present structure of American education” [book cover].
Goodson, Barbara Dillon & Swartz, Janet P. & Millsap, Mary Ann Spring 1991 Working with families. Equity and Choice, pp. 97-107. home education
Goodson, Barbara Dillon, Swartz, Janet P., & Millsap, Mary Ann 1991, February Working with families: Promising programs to help parents support young children's learning, executive summary. Cambridge, MA: Abt Associates Inc. parental involvement, learner outcomes Available from publisher at 55 Wheeler Street, Cambridge, MA 02138-1168. Full report available from U.S. Department of Education, Office of Planning, Budget and Evaluation, Room 4049, 400 Maryland Ave., S.W., Washington, DC 20202-4110
Gorder, Cheryl 1987 Home schools: An alternative - you do have a choice. Tempe, AZ: Blue Bird Publishing. An argument for home education as a legitimate alternative, although perhaps not the best choice for every family.
Gorder, Cheryl 1987 Home schools: An alternative - you do have a choice. Tempe, AZ: Blue Bird Publishing. An argument for home education as a legitimate alternative, although perhaps not the best choice for every family.
Gordon, Edward E. 1983 Home tutoring programs gain respectability. Phi Delta Kappan, 64, 398-399.
Gordon, Edward E. 1983 Home tutoring programs gain respectability. Phi Delta Kappan, 64, 398-399.
Gordon, Edward E., & Gordon, Elaine H. 1990 Centuries of tutoring: A history of alternative education in America and Western Europe. Lanham, MD: University Press of America. 437 pp.. home education, tutoring, philosophy, methodology Fascinating history of tutoring, "domestic education," "monitorial schools," "dame schools," and so forth; explains that the vast majority of this period was permeated, if not dominated, by a combination of parents and hired tutors teaching children in the home; includes three pages [p. 318-320] on the contemporary home education movement; interweaves philosophy and methodology of education of different times. Calls for an alliance between school teachers and tutors to meet the educational needs of society; much detail, fascinating analysis from 1500 B.C. to modern home schooling movement.
Gordon, William M. 1991 Home schooling. ERIC reproduction service number ED332291. home education, homeschooling, history, legal, law “A discussion of compulsory attendance legislation and issues relevant to home schooling are presented in this report. The first section offers a literature review and discussion of the socialization and academic achievement arguments. Section 2 provides a chronologically ordered summary of cases that address such issues as qualifications of parents as teachers, student evaluation and certification, religious freedom, state educational standards, and special needs students. The third section presents an analysis of state laws in relation to compulsory attendance laws and the legal status of home schooling. State statutes are classified in terms of state regulation of home schooling, instructional matters, and student assessment” [ERIC abstract].
Gothard, B. 1991 Advance apprenticeship training. Available from Advanced Training Institute of America, Box 1, Oak Brook IL 60522-3001. home education, apprenticeships
Gothard, B. 1991 Advance apprenticeship training. Available from Advanced Training Institute of America, Box 1, Oak Brook IL 60522-3001. home education, apprenticeships
Gottesman, Roberta 1982, January Religion and the schools. Principal, 61(3), 57-58.) Court Litigation, Religion, School Attendance Legislation, State Church Separation
Gottesman, Roberta 1982, January Religion and the schools. Principal, 61(3), 57-58.) Court Litigation, Religion, School Attendance Legislation, State Church Separation
Gould, Ryan, & Sturtevant, Arnold (eds.) date unknown A Quechooling... As parents home schooled, they became aware of new factors of which they were not originally aware. home education, research, motivation, rationale, interview, reasons The most surprising of these and the most commonly noted by home school parents was a new sense of family unity and socialization" (p. 4))
Gould, Ryan, & Sturtevant, Arnold (eds.) date unknown A Queridge, MA 02138-1168. Full report available from U.S. Department of Education, Office of Planning, Budget and Evaluation, Room 4049, 400 Maryland Ave., S.W., Washington, DC 20202-4110) parental involvement, learner outcomes
Grady, Sarah, Bielick, Stacey, & Aud, Susan 2010 Trends in the Use of School Choice: 1993 to 2007. Statistical Analysis Report (NCES 2010-004). National Center for Education Statistics April 2010. Retrieved 12/15/10 from http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2010/2010004.pdf. http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2010/2010004.pdf school choice, demographics, home education, homeschool, population size, public school, charter schools
Grant, Barry 2007 Education without compulsion: Toward new visions of gifted education. Mensa Research Journal, 38(3), 7-17. home education, public schools, private schools, compulsory attendance laws, compulsory schooling, compulsion, law, legal, philosophy, gifted education, talented and gifted
Grant, Billie-Jo; Wilkerson, Stephanie B.; Pelton, deKoven; Cosby, Anne; & Henschel, Molly 2017 A case study of k–12 school employee sexual misconduct. [This project was supported by Award No. 2015-CK-BX-0009 awarded by the National Institute of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, U.S. Department of Justice.] Retrieved January 22, 2018 from https://docs.wixstatic.com/ugd/b75d1b_119eeff7f31d4d2898c39084011a4da2.pdf https://docs.wixstatic.com/ugd/b75d1b_119eeff7f31d4d2898c39084011a4da2.pdf child abuse, student abuse, sexual abuse, sexual maltreatment, school personnel, public school, teacher abuse As of September 2017, the United States Department of Justice was still relying on research from before 2004 that showed “… school employee sexual misconduct, the sexual abuse and misconduct of K–12 students by school employees, is estimated to affect 10% of our nation’s students” (p. 1).[10] The actual percent might have been higher in 2004 and it might have been even higher in 2017 but data have not been available to determine this. Furthermore, these data do not include the physical or psychological abuse of students by school personnel. The authors gave the following finding to the Department of Justice: “Thus, despite clear policies and laws requiring reporting and potential legal consequences for failing to do so, only an estimated 5% of school employee sexual misconduct incidents known to school employees are reported to law enforcement or child welfare personnel, … A 1994 study in New York State found that only 1% of the 225 cases superintendents disclosed to researchers were reported to law enforcement or child welfare and resulted in license revocation …” (p. 5). That is to say, a small portion of sexual misconduct acts by school personnel that are known by school personnel are ever reported to the proper government authorities. Who are these school personnel offenders? “Offenders include all types of school employees, such as teachers, school psychologists, coaches, [bus drivers,] principals, and superintendents” (2).
Grant, Billie-Joe; Wilkerson, Stephanie B.; Pelton, deKoven; Cosby, Anne; & Henschel, Molly 2017 A Case Study of K–12 School employee sexual misconduct: Lessons learned from Title IX policy implementation. National Criminal Justice Reference Service, United States Department of Justice. Retrieved July 30, 2020 from https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/grants/252484.pdf https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/grants/252484.pdf public school, sexual misconduct, sexual abuse, child abuse, sexual harassment, research “An estimated 10% of K–12 students will experience sexual misconduct by a school employee by the time they graduate from high school. Such misconduct can result in lifelong consequences for students including negative physical, psychological, and academic outcomes” (p. ii). “Definitions of school employee sexual abuse and misconduct of students, and the terms used to describe it, vary. 2 For this study, researchers use the term school employee sexual misconduct to encompass sexual abuse or misconduct with a child (contact or noncontact, criminal or ethical violations) by any K–12 school employee, including teachers, coaches, administrators, volunteers, and staff members, while caring for that child in a K–12 school setting. Sexual abuse may include sexual activities with a child that are considered crimes3 ; sexual misconduct is a broader term that includes abuse but also encompasses acts that are not criminal but may violate ethical codes (i.e., sexual contact with a student who is over the age of consent—16 in many states—is not a crime, but is typically prohibited by school policy)” (p. 1).
Grant, Tobin 2009, February 11 Do Christian schools make students more religious? A new study says they might, but adds that parents and peers have more influence. http://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2009/februaryweb-only/106-31.0.html public education, private education, homeschooling, religion, religious practice, youth, peer influence Christianity Today. Retrieved February 12, 2009 from http://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2009/februaryweb-only/106-31.0.html. Title and subtitle tell a lot about the content of the article
Graves, Bill 2000, September 13 Expert says parents can play role in curbing violent entertainment: Some turn off the television or monitor access, while others educate their children at home. The Oregonian, p. C1, C6. http://www.oregonian.com/ home education, violence, culture, philosophy Daily newspaper online; published and retrieved 9/13/00 online http://www.oregonian.com/. (“Many parents are drawn to home schooling in large part to protect their children from violence and crude values promoted by the entertainment industry, said Brian Ray, president of the National Home Education Research Institute in Salem. Ray said the entertainment industry has had a big indirect influence on the growth of home schooling enrollment, ...”
Gray, D. W. 1998 A study of the academic achievements of homeschooled students who have matriculated into post-secondary institutions. Dissertation Abstracts International, 59, 021. Doctoral dissertation, University of Sarasota, Sarasota, Florida, 1998. home education, research, college, graduates, adults, academic achievement, success Finds no significant differences between homeschool and conventional school students at three institutions in Georgia (public university, private university, and private college) on the SAT scores, English grades, or cumulative GPAs.
Gray, Peter; & Riley, Gina 2015 Grown unschoolers evaluations of their unschooling experiences: Report I on a survey of 75 unschooled adults. Other Education: The Journal of Educational Alternatives, 4(2), 8-32. unschooling, homeschooling, grown unschoolers, adults, graduates, educational freedom, self-determination, self-directed education “Abstract Seventy-five adults, who had been unschooled for at least the years that would have been their last two years of high school, responded to a survey about their experiences. Their responses indicated that their parents generally played supportive, not directive roles in their education and played bigger supportive roles for those who started their unschooling early than for those who started later. The great majority of respondents reported that they were very happy with their unschooling. Nearly all of them valued the freedom it gave them to pursue their own interests in their own ways, and many reported that unschooling promoted their capacities for self-motivation, self-direction, personal responsibility and continued learning. A minority said they experienced a learning deficit as a result of unschooling, and most of those said they easily made up that deficit when they needed to. Most said they had satisfying social lives as unschoolers, and many commented on the special value of having friends of a wide range of ages. Only three respondents said they were unhappy with their unschooling, and those three all said that they were socially isolated, in dysfunctional families with mothers who were psychologically depressed and fathers who were uninvolved.”
Gray, Steven 1992 Why some parents choose to home school. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, University of California - Los Angeles. home education, research, reasons, quantitative Explores why parents choose to home school.
Green, Christa L. 2005, May Home-schooling as an extreme form of parental involvement. Master’s (M.S.) thesis, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee. “This study’s results suggested that parents decide to home-school for reasons similar to those motivating many public school parents’ decisions to become involved in their children’s school-based education: parents believe that they should be active in their children’s education, they believe have the ability to help their child succeed in school learning, and they perceive that contextual factors in their lives make involvement or home-schooling possible. This study’s results also suggested that an additional set of personal beliefs and values contribute to parents’ decisions to home-school. Specifically, these results suggested that parents who home-school are motivated not only by the psychological and life-context variables that contribute to many public school parents’ decisions about involvement in their children’s schooling, but also by their values about family and religious issues, ideological beliefs about the appropriateness of public school curricula for their child, pedagogical beliefs about the appropriateness of public school teaching practices for their child, and beliefs about the public school’s ability to deal with their child’s individual needs. These results suggested that parents’ choose to home-school for reasons that are somewhat more diverse than implied in earlier home-school literature. For example, general unhappiness with all aspects of public schools appears to play a larger role than the pedagogical or ideological motivations first suggested by Holt (1983) and Moore (as described in Basham, 2001; see also Van Galen, 1988; Knowles, 1988). At the same time, several parents in this study also expressed positive reasons (not reactions) for choosing to homeschool their children” [p. 25]. Home education, research, reasons
Green, Christa L., & Hoover-Dempsey, Kathleen V. 2005, April 15 Home-schooling as an extreme form of parental involvement. Presentation at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, April 11-15, 2005. http://convention2.allacademic.com/index.php?click_key=1&publication_id=10414&cmd=Search+Load+Publication&PHPSESSID=4001225fce364718faabc664e9958b74 home education, parental involvement, research “Although home-schooling is growing in popularity (Bielick, Chandler & Broughman, 2002), little systematic research has focused on this population. Using Hoover-Dempsey and Sandler’s (1995, 1997) model of parental involvement and ethnographic studies of home-schooling (e.g. Knowles, 1988), we examined parents’ motivations for home-schooling. Parents of 150 home-schooled elementary children completed questionnaires assessing psychological motivation (role construction and efficacy), life context variables, and personal beliefs related to home-schooling. Analyses offered support for reliability and validity of measures; substantively, they indicated that what parents believe they can do (efficacy; life context), should do (role activity beliefs), and what they have experienced (personal beliefs, valence toward school) were all related to home-schooling. Findings provide theoretically grounded information essential to understanding families’ home-schooling decisions” (abstract retrieved 4/18/05 online http://convention2.allacademic.com/index.php?click_key=1&publication_id=10414&cmd=Search+Load+Publication&PHPSESSID=4001225fce364718faabc664e9958b74.) .
Green, Christa L., & Hoover-Dempsey, Kathleen V. 2007 Why do parents homeschool? A systematic examination of parental involvement. Education and Urban Society, 39(2), 264-285. http://eus.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/39/2/264 home education, homeschool, parental involvement, reason, reasons, school choice “Although homeschooling is growing in popularity in the United States, little systematic research has focused on this population. Grounded in the parental involvement literature, this study examines why parents decide to home-school. Parents of 136 homeschooled elementary children completed questionnaires assessing constructs derived from the parental involvement literature and personal beliefs identified in the homeschooling literature as important to parents’ decisions to homeschool. Results suggest that home-schooling parents appear to be motivated by an active role construction, strong sense of efficacy for helping the child learn, and positive perceptions of life context. Homeschool parents’ beliefs about the values, content, adequacy, and methods of public school education appear to be implicated less strongly in their decisions. Findings are discussed with reference to the development of a systematic and theoretically grounded knowledge base on parents’ motivations for involvement in their children’s education” retrieved 10/17/07 from http://eus.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/39/2/264. “The findings from this study suggest that parents decide to homeschool for reasons similar to those motivating many public school parents’ involvement in their children’s education: Specifically, these homeschool parents believe they should play an active role in their children’s education, believe they have the ability to help their child succeed in school learning, and perceive that contextual factors in their lives make involvement or homeschooling possible. Thus, constructs that have been useful in explaining parental involvement in the public school system appear to be also useful in understanding parents’ choices of other forms of education for their children. Results also demonstrated that parental involvement constructs could be used to predict homeschool rather than public school participation. This suggests that parental involvement constructs, traditionally used to predict public school involvement, may be conceptualized as constructs useful in predicting parental involvement in many different educational settings” (p. 281).
Green, Tanya L. 2001, May/June Homebodies: Home education soars, and families benefit. Family Voice, 14-18. Published by Concerned Women for America, Washington DC.
Greenberg, Susan H., & Foote, Donna 2000, April The boom in home schooling. Newsweek/Score [magazine; no volume, issue], pp. 62-64, 66-67. home education, technology, Internet, population growth Emphasizes idea that the availability of the Internet is encouraging record numbers of parents to homeschool their children.
Greene, J. P. & Mellow, N. 1998 Integration where it counts: A study of racial integration in public and private school lunchrooms. A paper presented at the Meeting of the American Political Science Association, Boston, Massachusetts, September, 1998. [Online: http://www.schoolchoices.org/roo/jay1.htm] http://www.schoolchoices.org/roo/jay1.htm education, research, racism, integration, segregation, minorities Finds more racial integration in private schools than in public schools.
Greene, Jay P. 2000, September The Education Freedom Index. Civic Report, Number 14 http://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/cr_14.htm home education, research, private schooling, public schools, educational choice, educational freedom, academic achievement, degree of state control, state regulation, policy, education reform, philosophy, math academic achievement, NAEP Published by the Center for Civic Innovation at the Manhattan Institute). Retrieved 12/6/00 and 5/24/07 online http://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/cr_14.htm. “In this report, we estimate the extent and nature of education freedom in each state, using a new Education Freedom Index (EFI). The purpose of collecting evidence on the range of education options in each state and assembling them into EFI is three-fold. First, we want to show the remarkable differences in educational freedom among the states. Second, like the Economic Freedom Index and the Political Freedom Index after which EFI is modeled, we seek to make educational freedom a concept that becomes the subject of policy debate. Third, we test whether states that increase the amount of education freedom are also likely to experience an improvement in academic achievement. We find that students in states that have higher scores on EFI also have higher scores on standardized tests, even after controlling for other demographic and policy factors. Ranking States on the Education Freedom Index The Education Freedom Index is composed of measures of five types of educational options: 1.the availability of charter school options; 2.the availability of government assisted private school options (e.g. vouchers); 3.the ease with which one can home school one’s child; 4.the ease with which one can choose a different public school district by relocating; and 5.the ease with which one can send a child to a different public school district without changing residence.” The most-free state is Arizona, while Hawaii is the least-free. “For many, freedom is a good in its own right. They contend it is desirable for policymakers to promote education freedom simply because it makes available to families a broader set of options to satisfy their diverse needs and priorities. But does freedom in education also boost student achievement? The evidence suggests that it does. According to a simple regression that predicts the percentage of students scoring “proficiently” on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) by each state’s EFI score, a state that has a one point higher score on the EFI can expect an additional 5.5% of its students to test as proficient. Given that the average state has 26.5% of its students scoring at the proficient level on the 1998 Reading NAEP, the 1998 Science NAEP, and the 1996 Writing NAEP, an increase of 5.5% is quite an improvement.” “From other regressions that use the EFI to predict SAT scores, we would expect that a one point increase in the Education Freedom Index score for a state would lead to a 21 point increase in the average SAT verbal score and a 22 point increase in the average SAT math score. Put simply, states with more education freedom have higher average student achievement.” “But does education freedom actually cause higher student achievement? Proving causation with relatively few cases (there are only 50 states) cannot be done with certainty. Even to suggest that education freedom helps contribute to student achievement requires controlling for other factors that might explain that achievement. Accordingly, we constructed a simple model that uses the Education Freedom Index scores to predict student achievement in each state, controlling for the percentage of minorities in each state, median household income in each state, per pupil spending on education, and the average class size. [paragraph] As can be seen in Table 13 , the results are striking. Even after controlling for these other factors, EFI is a significant predictor of student achievement. We would expect that a one point rise in EFI for a state would increase the percentage performing proficiently on NAEP by 5.5%. In contrast, a one percentage point increase in minority population would lead to a .3% decline in the percentage of students performing proficiently, while a $1,000 boost in median household income would lead to a .3% increase in the percentage of students performing proficiently on NAEP. (Per pupil spending and average class size in each state have no significant effect on the percentage of students who perform proficiently on NAEP.)” “We observe similar results when we use the model to predict SAT scores.” “Increasing education freedom is one of the most practical ways for policymakers to improve the quality of education.” “Conclusion Freedom matters in education. Simply providing families with additional options in the education of their children has a larger independent effect on student achievement than increasing education spending or reducing class size. In addition, the magnitude of the benefit of education freedom for student learning is comparable to the benefit of significantly increasing median household income. Note, too, that it is far easier for state policymakers to expand education freedom than it is for them to increase median household income by several thousand dollars. Education freedom is not only a good in and of itself, but it also appears to help students learn.”
Greene, Jay P. 2002, January 2001 Education Freedom Index. Civic Report, No. 24. http://www.manhattan-institute.org/pdf/cr_24.pdf home education, research, private schooling, public schools, educational choice, educational freedom, academic achievement, degree of state control, state regulation, math achievement, NAEP Published by the Center for Civic Innovation at the Manhattan Institute). Retrieved 5/24/07 online http://www.manhattan-institute.org/pdf/cr_24.pdf. (“In September 2000 the Manhattan Institute released the Education Freedom Index, which measured the extent of government-subsidized or -regulated educational choices offered to families in each state. That report also contained statistical analyses that suggested a relationship between the amount of education freedom in a state, and the level of academic achievement demonstrated by its students. This second edition of the Index documents significant changes regarding the choices offered to families. This year’s report also reaffirms the relationship between education freedom and academic achievement, adding some improvements to the statistical model. The results are good news for those who believe that parental control over the education of their children is central to good education policy” [p. 1]. “3. Home-Schooling Choice. The home-schooling score consists of the percentage of students home- schooled in each state, which has not been updated since last year’s EFI, and an updated ranking of each state’s regulatory environment for those choosing home-schooling compiled by the Home School Legal Defense Association” [p. 1]. “The dependent variable in the model is the NAEP [National Assessment of Educational Progress] 8th grade math results from 2000, the most recent state test results available” [p. 7]. Editor’s note: The NAEP scores would be acquired almost, if not totally, exclusively from public-school students, not from private-school or homeschool students. “Despite these limitations, the observable relationship between education freedom and student achievement remains strong. Where families have more options in the education of their children, the average student tends to demonstrate higher levels of academic achievement” [p. 7].
Greene, Jay P., & Forster, Greg 2004, September The Teachability Index: Can disadvantaged students learn? Education Working Paper No. 6. Retrieved 9/17/04 online http://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/ewp_06.htm#01. New York, NY: Center for Civic Innovation at the Manhattan Institute. http://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/ewp_06.htm#01 public school, learning, educational choice, finance, disadvantaged, special needs “These claims are rarely subjected to serious scrutiny. This study, the first of its kind, systematically measures the teachability of students by examining sixteen social factors that researchers agree affect student teachability. Combining these factors into a single Teachability Index provides the first-ever valid measurement of whether schools are facing a student population with greater challenges to learning.” Examines extent to which money spent on public schools, degree of choice in schooling, and other factors relate to academic achievement or learning.
Greene, Sue S. 1984 Home study in Alaska: A profile of K-12 students in the Alaska Centralized Correspondence Study Program. ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 255 494. Study of "state-sponsored" home schooling. Reports demographics, etc.
Green-Hennessy, Sharon 2014 Homeschooled adolescents in the United States: Developmental outcomes. Journal of Adolescence 37, 441-449. Homeschooling, home education, Adolescence, Substance, Delinquency, Social isolation, Peer-reviewed journal, risk, at-risk In nationally representative sample, author compares four groups of adolescents: weaker religious affiliation traditional school, stronger religious affiliation traditional school, weaker religious affiliation home-school, and stronger religious affiliation home-school. Logistic regression controlled for several demographic variables. Author carefully lays out limitations of study, evaluation of possible reasons for findings, and appears to have an in-depth knowledge of related research on homeschooling. “Schooling Subjects were initially asked, “Have you attended any type of school at any time during the past 12 months?” Respondents who answered yes were classified as traditionally schooled. Those youth who either stated they did not know or who answered negatively were asked if they had “… been homeschooled at any time during the prior 12 months?” If respondents answered yes to this second question they were classified as homeschooled. Respondents who denied either being in school or homeschooled were not included in this study” (p. 443). “Abstract: The mission of schools has broadened beyond academics to address risk behaviors such as substance use, delinquency, and socialization problems. With an estimated 3.4% of all U.S. youth being homeschooled, this study examines how U.S. homeschoolers fare on these outcomes given their lack of access to these school services. Adolescents (ages 12-17) from the 2002 through 2011 National Surveys of Drug Use and Health (NSDUH) were divided based on school status (home vs. traditional schooling) and religious affiliation (stronger vs. weaker). Controlling for demographic differences, homeschoolers with weaker religious ties were three times more likely to report being behind their expected grade level and two and a half times more likely to report no extracurricular activities in the prior year than their traditionally schooled counterparts. This group was also more likely to report lax parental attitudes toward substance use. Findings suggest homeschoolers with weaker religious ties represent an at-risk group” (p. 441). “Frequency of religious service attendance was measured by asking, “During the past 12 months, how many times did you attend religious services?” Responses were dichotomously divided into less than 25 times (weaker religious affiliation) or 25 times or more in the prior year (stronger religious affiliation). Participants also were asked to rate from strongly agree to [p. 442 ends] strongly disagree how important their religious beliefs were to them, how much their religious beliefs influenced their decisions, and how important it was that their friends share their religious beliefs” (p. 443). “Schooling Subjects were initially asked, “Have you attended any type of school at any time during the past 12 months?” Respondents who answered yes were classified as traditionally schooled. Those youth who either stated they did not know or who answered negatively were asked if they had “... been homeschooled at any time during the prior 12 months?” If respondents answered yes to this second question they were classified as homeschooled. Respondents who denied either being in school or homeschooled were not included in this study” (p. 443). “In total 0.6% of the sample (n = 1094) reported being homeschooled. Homeschooled youth were further subdivided into groups with stronger (n = 658) and weaker religious affiliations (n = 436). Traditionally schooled students also were divided into stronger (n = 111,673) and weaker (n ¼ 52,721) religious groups” (p. 443). It appears that this study does not tell us or discern for how many years the subjects/participants had been homeschooled before the data were collected. Delinquency: “Bivariate analyses indicated that religious homeschoolers were less likely to report being booked or arrested (1.6%) than religious traditionally schooled students (3.3%) or less religious homeschoolers (9.7%), X2 (3) = 1273.96, p < .001, V = .089. Contrary to expectation, no statistically significant difference was found between less religious homeschoolers and the reference group” (p. 444). Substance disorders: “As with delinquency, having strong religious ties was a buffer against having a substance disorder, with the two nonreligious groups not being significantly different from one another (Table 2). Again, bivariate analyses revealed religious homeschoolers were the least likely to have a substance disorder (3.0%), as compared to 6.1% of religious traditionally schooled and 15.8% of less religious homeschoolers, X2 (3) = 1755.65, p < .001, V = .103” (p. 445). “Over one-third (34.7%) of all homeschoolers with weaker religious ties reported that their parents would not strongly disapprove if they were to engage in at least one substance misuse behaviors; in contrast, such lax parental substance attitudes were seen less frequently in the religious traditionally schooled (8.5%) and religious homeschooled (6.5%) groups, X2 (3) = 4073.57, p < .001, V = .158. Lastly, the groups differed with whether they reported receiving any substance preventative services in the prior year, X2 (3) = 981.88, p < .001, V = .077. More homeschoolers, either with weaker (18.2%) or stronger (11.4%) religious ties, denied having received any substance prevention message in the prior year than was the case for more (2.5%) and less religiously (5.3%) inclined traditionally schooled teens” (p. 445). “That the less religious homeschoolers were three times (OR ¼ 3.0) more likely to report being behind expected grade level compared to the reference group was consistent with hypotheses. That religious homeschoolers were twice (OR ¼ 2.0) as likely to report being behind expected grade level compared to the reference group was not. Having stronger religious ties appeared to have only had a modest buffering effect on self-reported grade level among homeschoolers” (p. 445). “This discrepancy could reflect the inexact nature of the academic outcome variable used in this study, which was based on adolescent self-report. On the other hand, some have questioned prior findings given concerns regarding sample representativeness (Martin-Chang et al., 2011)” (p. 446). “Compared to youth with a similar weaker level of religious affiliation, less religious homeschoolers were two and a half times more likely to report that they had not engaged in any extracurricular activities in the prior 12 months (OR = 2.6), with 23.4% of this group being isolated in this way (Table 2). Contrary to expectation, religious homeschoolers were approximately 60% less likely to report such activity isolation than the reference group, controlling for demographics (OR = 0.4)” (p. 446). “Interestingly, homeschooled youth reported noteworthy involvement in school-based activities in the last year (55.0% of stronger and 51.2% of weaker religiously affiliated homeschoolers); in contrast, 89.8% of stronger and 79.2% of weaker religiously affiliated traditionally schooled youth were involved in school-based activities during the last year” (p. 446). “This study suggests that this distinction [ideologues compared to pedagogues] continues to be helpful in understanding the social and academic needs of subgroups of homeschoolers. Although this study does not directly assess pedagogical philosophy among the less-religiously affiliated homeschoolers, linking the findings to Van Galen’s dichotomy may be productive in attempting to understand the data” (p. 446). “Despite some lack of variability in source of activities, religious homeschoolers showed many strengths in terms of outcomes, being the least likely to be delinquent or substance disordered of the four groups. Consistent with prior literature (Salas-Wright et al., 2012), religious affiliation appeared to serve as a buffer against these externalizing behaviors. ….. Less religious homeschoolers, the group that may be more analogous to Van Galen’s “pedagogues,” appeared to struggle more than their religious counterparts. While not more likely to be delinquent or have a substance disorder than traditionally schooled students with similar levels of religious affiliation, over a third of less religious homeschoolers (34.7%) reported their parents had lax attitudes towards them misusing substances and 18.2% denied having received any substance prevention messages in the prior year” (p. 446). “While directionality of the relationships between outcome variable and homeschooling cannot be ascertained, these results indicate that less religious homeschoolers are experiencing academic and social difficulties [compared to more religious homeschoolers but not compared to “traditionally schooled” adolescents], as well as some suggestion of increased risk for later substance misuse. This group would benefit from services to help assist with these difficulties, whether that help be provided via an institution such as school or within the family structure remains to be determined” (p. 447). Peer-reviewed journal.) annotatoin
Gribble, Karleen; & English, Rebecca 2016 Helping children with home education: How home education can enable good educational outcomes for children and young people in out-of-home care. International Journal of Child, Youth and Family Studies, 7(2): 240–256, DOI: https://doi.org/10.18357/ijcyfs72201615720. https://doi.org/10.18357/ijcyfs72201615720 Homeschooling, home education, maltreatment, learning success, peer-reviewed journal “Abstract. Children who experience maltreatment in their families may be placed in out-of-home care. A large, and increasing, number of children are being raised in these settings in Australia. ….. It is generally believed that schools are best placed to serve the educational needs of these children. However, there is extensive evidence that schools are unable to facilitate learning success for many children in out-of-home care. This paper argues that because home education can provide a low- stress environment and individually tailored learning, it can be an effective method of education for children and young people in out-of-home care.” Peer-reviewed journal.
Griffith, Mary 1997 The homeschooling handbook. [book] [mis?? publisher]
Griffith, Mary 1998 The unschooling handbook. [book] [mis?? publisher]
Griffith, Mary 1999, Autumn An Unschooler's Lament: What's So Hard To Understand? Paths of Learning: Options for Families & Communities, 1(2), 17-21. home education, opinion, pedagogy ERIC No. EJ600023 reports: “Common elements among unschooled families include an environment conducive to exploration and experimentation, adult models and facilitators of learning, and underlying trust that children will learn. Public education limits its expectations of children to narrow standards of behavior and academic achievement, whereas unschooling allows children to direct a process that prepares them for their future. Skeptics' arguments are discussed.”
Griffiths, A. T. 1989 Ethnographic perspectives of selected home school families in Pennsylvania (Doctoral dissertation, Lehigh University, Bethlehem, PA, 1988). Dissertation Abstracts International,49, 1759A.
Grigg, William Norman 1996 Does the state own your children: Traditional family values are under attack from parens patriae. The New American, 12(14), 4-10. policy, education, philosophy, opinion, home education Claims that many leaders in the U.S. ascribe to parens patriae, the “parenthood of the state.” Gives examples of public schools and government officials disregarding the authority of parents to raise and educate their children.
Groll, Stephanie 2001, Summer Unschooling America: Having the guts to leave a crippling school system. Fabula magazine. Retrieved 8/23/01 online http://www.fabulamag.com/archives/matters/0108_unschooling.htm. http://www.fabulamag.com/archives/matters/0108_unschooling.htm home education, unschooling Explains unschooling vs. homeschooling especially in context of youth who decide to not be in institutional schools and largely direct their own education.
Groover, S. V., & Endsley, R. C. 1988 Family environment and attitudes of homeschoolers and nonhomeschoolers. (Report No. PS-019-040). Athens, GA: University of Georgia, Department of Child and Family Development. (ERIC Document Reproducation Service No. ED 323 027) home education, learning environment, family
Gross, R. 1979 Future directions for open learning. National Institute of Education. ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED 185 892.
Grossman, Robert J. 2001, November Home is where the school is. HR Magazine http://www.shrm.org/hrmagazine/articles/1101/default.asp?page=1101grossman.asp home education, employment, employers, college, graduates, human resources, academic achievement, socialization published by Society for Human Resource Management). Retrieved 4/30/02 online http://www.shrm.org/hrmagazine/articles/1101/default.asp?page=1101grossman.asp. “‘At some point, every homeschooling parent hits a brick wall,’ says Cafi Cohen, author of Homeschoolers’ College Admissions Handbook ... and a parent of two homeschoolers now in their 20s and working. ‘None of us has the expertise to do it all, but we do have the expertise to be good networkers, to find people who do have the skills and are enthusiastic about teaching,’ Cohen says. ‘My job was to help uncover options, and there are a lot of them,’ including correspondence schools, community resources and now the Internet.” Regarding the question of socialization of homeschool students: “‘Homeschooling doesn’t mean you’re locking your kid up every day,’ sociologist [Mitchell] Stevens says. ‘Typically there are support groups, gym classes [and] socials. Kids often are involved in part-time jobs [and are] active in church groups.’ ‘It’s basically a non-issue,” adds Greg Cizek, associate professor of educational research at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. “If anything, research shows that because parents are so sensitive to the charge, they expose them to so many activities.’ ..... No two public schools are alike, homeschoolers argue. ‘We tend to overemphasize the civilizing impact of conventional schools,’ Stevens says. ‘The typical school is not a haven of diversity. Public schools are widely segregated by class and race.’ ..... In the final analysis, if you’re hiring, homeschoolers may be a good investment. Cutting through the stereotypes, [Patricia] Lines, who has studied the movement for many years, perhaps says it best. ‘If I didn’t know anything about someone other than their education background, I’d rather hop into a foxhole with a homeschool kid than one from public school. The homeschool kid will be a little better educated and dependable. It’s just the law of averages.’”
Growing Without Schooling 1990 Teacher criticizes schools. GWS, No. 76, 3. home education, reform, excellence Excerpts from speech of John Taylor Gatto accepting New York City Teacher of the Year award. Speaks of home education.
Guidubaldi, John, Nastasi, B. K., Cleminshaw, H. K., & Perry, J.D. 1986 Maternal employment and child adjustment: Results of a nationwide study. Paper presented at the 94th Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association, August, 1986, Washington, D.C., 43 p. Working mothers. These authors say, in one form or another, and the news media has widely reported on it saying that children of working mothers do better academically. See response by James Dobson (1987).
Gunn, Colin; & Fernandez, Joaquin 2012 IndoctriNation: Public schools and the decline of Christianity. Green Forest, AR: Master Books.
Guppy, Neil; & Davies, Scott 1999 Understanding Canadians' declining confidence in public education. Canadian Journal of Education I Revue canadienne de l'education, 24(3), 265-280. Retrieved 9/10/13 from http://blogs.ubc.ca/newproposals/files/2009/03/guppy_davis.pdf. http://blogs.ubc.ca/newproposals/files/2009/03/guppy_davis.pdf public education, public schooling, public attitude, public opinion, homeschooling, choice Mention homeschooling, home schooling, but homeschooling is not any kind of focus of the paper. “Yet, applying Loveless' reasoning to the Canadian case raises problems. First, in Canada, unlike in the U.S.A., a growing minority of people are voting with their feet and leaving the neighbourhood public system in search of alternatives (e.g., private schools, home schooling, virtual schools, charter schools). At least among a vocal minority of Canadians, public criticism and public action coincide; both indicate that Canadians have less confidence in their public school system than U.S. citizens have in theirs” (p. 277).
Gustafson, Sonia K. 1987 A study of home schooling: Parental motivations and goals. A senior thesis, Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ. home education, research, demographics, reasons, etc Sampled from a directory of the secular organization Growing Without Schooling [Holt Associates]. Reasons for home schooling in descending order of importance were quality of teaching, social atmosphere, moral atmosphere, too young for school, religious education, specific problems, and influence of others [p. 88] About 34% of parents basic biblical.
Gustafson, Sonia K. 1988 A study of home schooling: Parental motivation and goals. Home School Researcher, 4(2), 4-12.
Gustavsen, Gunnar Arvid 1980 Selected characteristics of home schools and parents who operate them. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Andrews University, Berrien Springs, MI. Dissertation Abstracts International, 42(10), 4381A, 4382A. home education, research, reasons, demographics, successful home schools Ed.D. dissertation. Identifies a segment of U.S. population likely to operate home schools. Recommends state boards of education restudy home schools as a valid method of education. Encourages cooperation between home schoolers and local schools.
Guterman, Oz. & Neuman, Ari 2019 Reading at home: Comparison of reading ability among homeschooled and traditionally schooled children. Reading Psychology, 40,169-190. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/02702711.2019.1614123 https://www.tandfonline.com/action/authorSubmission?show=instructions&journalCode=urpy20 research, reading, reading ability, academic achievement, homeschooling, public school, comparison, peer-reviewed Retrieved November 30, 2020 from https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/02702711.2019.1614123 [peer-reviewed per https://www.tandfonline.com/action/authorSubmission?show=instructions&journalCode=urpy20] “Abstract: The homeschool framework differs significantly from the traditional school setting. Earlier research has shown differences between homeschooled and other children in language skills, but no study has examined how homeschooling is related to the acquisition of the different components of reading. The present research examined several reading skills, comparing these two groups. The findings indicated that the homeschooled children achieved lower results in reading comprehension, but not in listening comprehension. The homeschooled children were also found to have broader general knowledge than the other children did. The gap between the groups in reading was associated with lower levels of phonological awareness. These findings might be attributed to the different methods used to teach reading in the two frameworks.” The mean age of participants was 9.18.
Guterman, Oz. & Neuman, Ari 2020 Personal attachment and internalizing and externalizing problems with Israeli school-goers and homeschoolers. School Psychology, 35(1), 41-50. [peer-reviewed per https://www.apa.org/pubs/journals/spq?tab=4] https://www.apa.org/pubs/journals/spq?tab=4 homeschooling, home education, socialization, social development, psychology; attachment theory, internalizing problems, externalizing problems, attachment anxiety; peer-reviewed Cross-sectional, explanatory study design. Age of children mean of 9.2. Controlled for background variables of age, socioeconomic status. No difference in internalizing and externalizing problems of the child “Abstract: The increased scope and percentage of children being homeschooled raise questions about the impact of this framework on the child’s world. One of the issues that has not been adequately studied with regard to homeschooling is whether the emotional and personal problems of parents have greater impact on children who are homeschooled. The present research, conducted in Israel, examined this question from the perspective of attachment theory, which focuses on how people relate to intimate relationships. Previous research has shown an association between the attachment of parents and emotional and behavioral characteristics of their children. Against this background, the present research compared a group of homeschooling mothers and children with a group of mothers who sent their children to school (a total of 101 children; mean age, 9.2 years). These groups did not differ in age and socioeconomic status. The comparison focused on variables beyond these and also considered the degree of structure of the homeschooling practiced. The findings indicated a correlation between mother’s attachment anxiety and internalizing and externalizing problems of the child. However, no correlation was found between attachment avoidance and these problems, and no difference was found between the two groups in terms of these correlations. The results contribute, among other things, to understanding the association between homeschooling and behavioral and emotional problems.”
Guterman, Oz; & Neuman, Ari 2016 Schools and emotional and behavioral problems: A comparison of school-going and homeschooled children. The Journal of Educational Research, 1–8 [online]. Attachment security, behavioral problems, depression, emotional problems, homeschooling, school-going, home schooling, peer-reviewed [Same as: Guterman, Oz; & Neuman, Ari. (2017). Schools and emotional and behavioral problems: A comparison of school-going and homeschooled children. The Journal of Educational Research, 110(4), 425-432] “Abstract. Much attention has been focused recently on the deepening crisis in the education system. Researchers have attributed these problems to the school environment. One method for examining this claim is to compare specific emotional and behavior problems among children who attend schools and children who do not. This study examined three aspects of children's emotional world—emotional and behavioral problems, depression, and attachment security—in a group of children attending school and a group of homeschooled children [in Israel], matched for socioeconomic background and research procedure. The findings indicated a lower level of depression among the homeschooled children; no difference was found between the groups in attachment security. With respect to emotional and behavioral problems, no difference was found in internalizing problems, but more externalizing problems were found among the school-going than the homeschooled children, in 9–10-year-olds and 11–12-year-olds, but not in 6–8-year-olds.” “In the present research, we addressed one of the aspects of the education crisis, namely, the suggestion that schools might `contribute to the development of emotional and behavioral problems among students. For this purpose, we compared school-going children with a matched group of homeschooled children in terms of a number of emotional dimensions. The data indicated that the level of depression among children who attended school was higher than that among the homeschooled children, and no difference was found between the groups in terms of attachment security. The findings also revealed that the level of externalizing problems among children who attended school was higher than that among their homeschooled counterparts, and no difference was found between the groups in the level of internalizing problems. In addition, the findings on externalizing problems indicated a difference between the groups only in Grades 3–4 and 5–6, and not among the children in Grades 1–2” (p. 5). Peer-reviewed.
Guterman, Oz; & Neuman, Ari 2017 Schools and emotional and behavioral problems: A comparison of school-going and homeschooled children. The Journal of Educational Research, 110(4), 425-432. same as: Guterman, Oz; & Neuman, Ari. (2016). Schools and emotional and behavioral problems: A comparison of school-going and homeschooled children. The Journal of Educational Research, 1–8 [online].
Guterman, Oz; Neuman, Ari; & Gill, Efrat 2024 Home schooling and the future labor market: Is There an adequate educational answer for the extensive changes in the labor market? Education Sciences, 14(7), 800; https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci14070800 https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci14070800 constructivist learning; future labor market; homeschooling; postmodern era; 21st century skills and competencies Opinion article. “Abstract: Abstract: Various aspects of human existence are changing, and these changes are having a significant effect on the current and future labor market. Some occupations are estimated to be at high risk of disappearing over the next several decades, others are at medium risk, while some are at low risk. At the same time, new trades are emerging. In order to successfully cope in an era where changes occur so frequently and so rapidly, and to be a part of the current and future labor market, we need to utilize a certain set of skills and competencies that is often referred to as “21st century skills”. This opinion paper argues that homeschooling is an education path that takes into account the extensive rapid changes in the 21st century as well as in the labor market and strives to give children the skills and competencies to cope with them successfully.
Guterson, David 1990, November When schools fail children: An English teacher educates his kids at home. Harper's Magazine, 58-64.
Guterson, David 1992 Family Matters: Why homeschooling makes sense. New York, NY: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers. home education, advocacy Author is a home school father and public school teacher.
Haan, Perry, & Cruickshank, Cam 2006 Marketing colleges to home-schooled students. Journal of Marketing for Higher Education, 16(2), 25-43. home education, college admissions, college admissions markets, college, adults, summary, research, opinion “This non-empirical paper examines issues related to the home school movement as they apply to colleges and universities hoping to attract these students to their institutions. It explores the unique characteristics of home-schooled students who apply to colleges and universities. Recommendations are made to institutions of higher education for attracting more home-schoooled students” [abstract, p. 25].
Haberman, Martin 1991, November 6 Catching up with reform in teacher education. Education Week, 11(10), 36, 29. teacher education, certification Lauds the idea and effects of alternative certification for teachers.
Hadeed, Henry V. 1991 Home schooling movement participation: A theoretical framework. Home School Researcher, 7(2), 1-9. sociology, home education Integrates concepts from home schooling and social movement literatures to develop a framework that interprets participation in the home schooling movement as a wedding of distinct private and public spheres of action. Posits that the movement is a collection of loyalties brought about by "frame alignment processes" and mediated by distinct "grievance modalities;" home education is an organized collective action that allows individuals a way to alleviate personal grievances. "... a framework emerged that interprets home schooling movement participation to be a wedding of diverse private and publics [sic] spheres of action, a `collection of loyalties,' brought about by frame alignment processes and mediated by distinct grievance modalities" p. 7.
Hadeed, Henry V. 1993 Social movement recruitment of home schooling parents: A study of frame alignment. Unpublished doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, University of Southern California. home education, research, sociology
Hafer, Gary R. 1991 An analysis of writing instruction in the home school. (Doctoral dissertation, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN, 1990). Dissertation Abstracts International, 52, 141A.
Hagar, Sheila 2001, July 22 Home school. Oregonian, July 24, 2001, p. F1 & F2. Explains that people homeschool for many reasons and those who think they cannot or never will sometimes end up homeschooling their children.
Hagen, Timothy 2011 Safe, just, and smart: Home education as an essential option for families in Albania and around the world. Social Studies, 2 (5), 77-84. homeschooling, compulsory education, liberal, home, school, education, Albania, classical liberalism, philosophy Holds parent-led home-based education, homeschooling, protects child from the power of the State and promotes liberal education, and superior academic achievement for students. “Education is a self-evident necessity for all children. Children need to learn the technical skills to be productive and the moral and social skills to live an ethical life in community. The reformer Martin Luther (1524; 1529; 1530) issued an early call for mandatory schooling to equip students with the skills needed for an informed, competent society that valued the critical pursuit of truth. Yet lived history shows that mandatory educational systems have been misused to indoctrinate children. A solution that decentralizes educational power and upholds the ideal of a liberal education should address this problem. Research and philosophy show that an educational system that gives more choice to parents is safe, just, and smart. Specifically, home education, that is, parent-directed education, provides a check to the power of government, accords with natural law, and provides superior academic results. Home education should therefore be permitted in Albania and worldwide” (p. 77).
Hager, Daniel 1999, September The central fallacy of public schooling. The Freeman, 49(9), 20-23. education, philosophy, history, public schooling, indoctrination, separation of school and state, private education Provides historical documentation about the motives behind public education often being control and indoctrination of children and citizens, including both in colonial days and later in the United States. “Under totalitarian regimes, the subjugation of parental belief systems to those of the state is blatant. Schoolchildren are propagandized into the doctrines of the leadership, their thoughts molded to the state’s purposes. But even under a “democratic” regime the state operates manipulatively for its own ends. Those who govern generally like to continue governing. Their governance is more easily maintained when the governed are passive and docile. The state propaganda machine must convince the citizenry of government’s benevolence. Schoolchildren are taught, as in the Young America article, that government “gives” them things and “does” things for them. Government schools inevitably become battlegrounds for control by ideological adversaries. The nature of the indoctrination changes as advocates of particular ideologies wax and wane in their power to influence curricula. The constant is that parents have relinquished direct control over what their children are taught to believe” [pp. 20-21]. “Proponents of public schooling argue against the complete privatization of schooling on the grounds that the poor would not be able to afford tuition and that some parents would not provide schooling for their children, leaving them “uneducated.” However, the rampant levels of ignorance, subliteracy, and hostility to learning that characterize tax-funded schools argue that the present system is itself not serving the best interests of students. Instead it is clear whose interests are being advanced. Fifty-four years ago the writer in Young America was moved to emphasize in italics that era’s apparently high tax rates. since then the average tax burden has doubled. Yet, as one of my acquaintances has commented, “Americans today are in a stupor.” In other words, the tax-supported school system has triumphed. Americans are behaving exactly the way those who govern desire them to behave” [p. 22]. “Children who are turned over to the state become molded by the state. Most parents cannot conceive of a totally privatized alternative because they themselves have been indoctrinated by public schooling to believe in its alleged necessity. However, it is fallacious for parents to think that children can escape government schooling without having their traditions and beliefs subverted. “Free” schooling is seductively attractive in the short run, but it has long-term costs. The dismantling of tax-funded schooling will not be accomplished until more and more parents say, “My child does not belong to the state” [p. 23].
Hahn, K., & Hasson, M. 1996 Catholic education: Homeward bound. [book] mis?? publisher
Hail, Darol W. 2003, September The impact of state regulation upon the home schooling movement as measured by specific descriptive factors. Doctoral dissertation (Ed.D., educational leadership), Sam Houston State University, Huntsville, Texas. 117 pp. “What is the relationship between state home schooling regulation, as measured by the categories regulated and non-regulated, and the following five descriptive categories: (1) scores on ACT [American College Testing] exams; (2) percentage of home schoolers of the school-aged population; (3) ratio of public school teacher to students;(4) growth rate of home schooling as reported by state departments of education; and (5) growth rate of home schooling …” [abstract]. “there was no statistically significant difference between regulated and non-regulated states in the areas of ACT achievement scores, percentage of home schooled students of the total school age population, the ratios of public school teachers/students, or the enrollment trends of home schoolers from either state department information or HSLDA information. An additional finding occurred in that gaps in data collection reflected the uncertainly of state departments regarding the accuracy of data. Through correspondence nearly all individuals contacted, regardless of their state’s regulation category, believed that the numbers were under-representative of the home school population” [abstract]. “Non-regulated states. No state requirement for parents to initiate any contact or state requires parental notification only. In this category states allow for home school with only minimal requirements on the part of the guardian” [p. 10-11] “Regulated states. States require parents to send notification of achievement test scores and/or professional evaluation, plus other requirements (e.g. curriculum approval by the state, teacher qualification of parents, or home visits by state officials). This category consists of any state that has more than the basic requirements for home school” [p. 11] “ACT scores were examined for all fifty states and the District of Columbia. When the average mean of home school scores was compared between the regulated and non-regulated states, there was no statistical significance for any of the four years examined. The reasons for the lack of significantly different scores are varied” [p. 84].) Descriptors: home education, academic achievement, college prediction, college success, college predictor, ACT test, research, policy, state regulation, academic achievement
Ham, Ken, & Beemer, Britt 2009 Already gone: Why your kids will quit church and what you can do to stop it. New Leaf Publishing Group/Master Books. religiosity, religion, type of schooling, home education, homeschool, private school, public school Study 1,000 young adults who attended church as children/youth and left church attendance by their 20s or 30s (i.e., “dropouts” from church). Authors imply that there was no difference between the subjects (young adults who had “dropped out of church attendance”) depending on whether they had been public schooled, private schooled, or homeschooled in high school (and this was not a focus of their study). Careful analysis of their survey questions and data, however, suggests that adults who had been homeschooled in high school may be underrepresented in their sample of 1,000 (n=34, 3.4%). That is, since they were studying those who attended conservative and evangelical churches and about 3% of the general population were home educated during the 1980s, it is likely that more than 3.4% of the conservative and evangelical children and youth had been homeschooled and that perhaps having been home educated in high school is associated with a disproportionately lower church dropout rate in their sample. Authors did not ask subjects their schooling history (e.g., public school, private school, homeschool) during their grades K-8 years.
Ham, Ken; Kinley, Jeff; & Beemer, Britt 2015 Ready to return: Bringing back the church's lost generation. Master Books. http://www.amazon.com/Ready-Return-Bringing-Churchs-Generation/dp/089051836X education, Christianity, philosophy “Having grown up in church, an alarming percentage of people have now traded in the timeless beliefs of Scripture for a more comfortable, postmodern faith or secular worldview. They have waded so deep into the culture that the current has swept them away with the pluralism of biblical compromise and secular indoctrination. Ready to Return explores: Why this is happening, and more importantly, what can be done about it to help bring back a godly generation New persuasive research that clearly reveals shocking details about views on the Church and faith by people in their 20s, known as millennials Conclusive evidence we cannot ignore, showing a lack of effective biblical apologetics in homes and churches, compromise with secular beliefs, secular education, and failures on the part of previous generations, contributes greatly to this dilemma. – retrieved January 15, 2016 from http://www.amazon.com/Ready-Return-Bringing-Churchs-Generation/dp/089051836X).
Hamilton, Scott W. (Ed.) 2008 Who will save America’s urban Catholic schools? Dayton, OH: The Thomas B. Fordham Institute. www.edexcellence.net. http://www.edexcellence.net private education, Roman Catholic schools, home education, homeschooling, public opinion “Chaput declared 2006 as the “Year of the Catholic School” in Denver - so there would be a concentrated time for parishes to celebrate and discuss Catholic schools and talk about the importance of their ministry. It was one of the key steps in the branding and marketing effort, and the move greatly boosted the attention given the schools. The emphasis on developing talking points for priests and parents is driven in part by Denver’s competitive climate, Thompson says. Charter schools, the variety of public schools, home schooling and private schools threaten to erase any enrollment gains that get made. The situation remains fragile, and it’s unknown whether all the schools can survive.” (p. 49) “The Glover Park Group conducted a nationwide telephone survey of 800 adults between March 6, 2008 and March 16, 2008. The margin of error on a sample size of 800 is +/-3.5 percent. The margin of error on subgroups is higher, due to the lower sample size. Oversamples of 250 Catholics, 100 African Americans and 100 Hispanics were also conducted. The total number of Catholics interviewed was 509, with a margin of error of +/-4.3 percent. ….. [p. 112]. “Perceptions of Different Types of Schools When asked to grade a variety of school types, adults give private schools the highest ratings (69 percent A/B grades). Catholic schools (58 percent A/B) and public schools are viewed similarly (55 percent A/B). • Home schools are most likely to get a failing grade (15 percent D/F) [among opinion of all adults regarding private, Catholic/parochial, public, home, and charter schools].” [p. 113]. On opinions on various forms of education: granted, the margin of error was at least +- 3.5% (p. 112), but it is still interesting to see the relatively negative opinion about homeschooling by adults in general, and Roman Catholic adults in particular (p. 113), especially considering the fact that official Catholic teaching says parents are the primary teachers of their children, and should be, and that research shows relatively high academic achievement and strong social/emotional development for the home-educated and that they have relatively high success in adulthood [e.g., community service, civic engagement, college completion].
Hamlin, Daniel 2019 Do Homeschooled students lack opportunities to acquire cultural capital? Evidence from a nationally representative survey of American households. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617582 homeschooling, home schooling, socialization, social activities, cultural capital Peabody Journal of Education, 94:3, 312-327, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617582. Retrieved June 12, 2020 from https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617582 “Abstract. Experiences at school may create valuable opportunities for children to acquire cultural capital. One concern for homeschooled children is that they may be deprived of these opportunities. However, homeschool families may enable opportunities for their children to acquire cultural capital through participation in activities outside of formal instructional time. This study investigates this possibility by comparing cultural and family activities between homeschooled students and their public school peers. The analyses use data from a nationally representative survey (National Household Education Survey, 2016) containing a substantial number of respondents who homeschool their children (n = 552). Descriptive results indicated that formal instruction in music, arts, literature, and foreign language is lacking in nearly 40% of homeschool households. Yet, relative to public school families, homeschool families report statistically higher participation in cultural and family activities. While patterns observed in this study are only descriptive, overall evidence suggests that homeschool families may provide opportunities for their children to acquire cultural capital through greater participation in cultural and family activities” (p. 312)
Hamlin, Daniel 2024 Contemporary Homeschooling, Persistent Debates, and the Need for a New Generation of Research. Journal of School Choice, 18(4), 697-712, https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2024.2422247 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2024.2422247 homeschooling, research, quantitative, methods, research agenda “Abstract: Homeschooling has grown into a large and highly diverse segment of American education. However, empirical studies of homeschooling have remained methodologically underdeveloped. The purpose of this article is to chart an agenda for a new generation of research on homeschooling. A narrative review of quantitative research published since 2000 is undertaken to identify gaps in the current evidence base. This review indicated that prior work is generally limited by small samples, uniform operationalizing of homeschool practice, and cross-sectional data sources. This article then concludes by describing strategies that researchers can use to address the limitations of previous studies.”
Hamlin, Daniel, & Cheng, Albert 2022 Homeschooling, perceived social isolation, and life trajectories: An analysis of formerly homeschooled adults. Journal of School Choice, https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2022.2028338 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2022.2028338 homeschooling; social isolation; life outcomes; socialization; home education; home schooling, peer-reviewed “Abstract. A longstanding critique of homeschooling is that it isolates children from mainstream society, depriving them of social experiences needed to thrive as adults. Although a small number of empirical studies challenge this criticism, this research tends to be derived from self-reports of homeschooling parents about their children. In this study, analyses of qualitative interviews (n = 31) and survey data (n = 140) of adults who were homeschooled as children are performed. Most interview participants described conventional and unconventional social experiences that they felt had satisfied their social needs while being homeschooled. Participants who were homeschooled for all or most of their K-12 education had less exposure to mainstream school-based social opportunities but reflected that homeschooling had not hindered their ability to navigate society effectively. Analyses of survey data seemed to echo this finding. Across four social and life outcomes (i.e. college attendance, household income, marital status, and subjective wellbeing), no statistical differences were observed between short-term homeschoolers (1–2 years) who spent nearly all of their K-12 education in brick-and-mortar schools and long-term (10–12 years) and substantial (3–9 years) homeschoolers who had less exposure to mainstream social opportunities available in brick-and mortar schools. This study advances the literature by drawing on qualitative and quantitative data from formerly homeschooled adults and by differentiating homeschoolers based on how many years they were homeschooled” (p. 1). Well done mixed-methods study. Sound methods and appropriate conclusions that follow from the data. “In some households, strong religious commitments when coupled with home schooling appeared to have an insulating effect. However, a number of adults who were raised in religious households noted how their parents had raised them in a particular faith tradition and had worked to expose them to other religious perspectives and cultures. Even among those who were ostensibly more insulated, there was a degree of openness that was exemplified through a recognition of different cultures and an ability to question the religious culture in which they were raised” p. 14. “When reflecting on the influence of homeschooling on their social and life trajectories, nearly all participants highlighted their own personal characteristics and individual personalities as being more salient than the experience of homeschooling itself” p. 15. “Nearly all of the homeschooled adults in this study described life circumstances that indicated that they were navigating broader society relatively well as adults, even in the case of two participants whose homeschooling experiences might be characterized as socially isolating. Employment, higher education, and marriage were largely the norm in the sample. All participants had networks of friends and family and many were highly active in local community organizations. Several also worked in the public or private education systems as administrators, classroom teachers, and paraprofessionals. Twenty-eight of 31 participants felt that homeschooling had given them positive social opportunities, experiences, and skills that they drew on as adults” p. 16. “Social acculturation. All formerly homeschooled adults in the sample eventually moved on to mainstream institutions. In the transition out of homeschooling, most adults found that their transition into higher education or the workforce was smooth from a social standpoint, but they highlighted an early process of social adaptation where they had to learn mainstream social norms, and, in some instances, overcome social gaps between the interactions they were accustomed to as homeschooled children and social expectations in higher education or workforce settings. Several adults recalled having culture shock at first” p. 17. “Overall, no statistical differences on the four social and life outcomes [i.e., household income above $50,000, attended college, divorce/separated, and subjective well-being] are observed between short-term homeschoolers (1–2 years) who spent nearly all of their K-12 education in brick-and-mortar schools and long-term (10– 12 years) and substantial (3–9 years) homeschoolers who had less exposure to mainstream social opportunities available in brick-and mortar schools. The results of these statistical analyses seem to fit with those of formerly homeschooled adults’ perceptions of their experiences in that they provide little evidence that homeschooling is generally harmful to one’s perceived social and life outcomes” p. 19-20. “To explore this difference further, data on formerly homeschooled adults (n = 140) from the Understanding America Survey 2016–2019 [of 6,000 adults] were investigated across four measures of social and life outcomes (i.e., attainment of higher education, income, marital status, and subjective wellbeing)” (p. 3). “Figure 1 presents the number of years that each respondent to the survey was homeschooled. Nearly one-third of those reporting that they were homeschooled did so for only one year of their K-12 education. Approximately 45% of the sample reports being homeschooled for only 1 or 2 years. An additional 44% of the sample was homeschooled for 3 to 9 years so these individuals had considerable experience with both homeschooling and attending a public or private school. In the [p. 18 ends here] sample, 39% of those reporting homeschooling in the range of 3 to 9 years also attended a private school at some point during their K-12 education, while 30% of those reporting 1 or 2 years of homeschooling attended a private school at some point. Only 11% of the sample reports homeschooling for 10 to 12 years and less than 10% report having been homeschooled for all 12 years of their education. Homeschooling was not more or less common at any particular grade level – between 30 and 40% of respondents were homeschooled at any given grade level in the sample” (p. 18-19). However, Figure 1 does not include the category of 13 years, which would be K-12 it appears that something is missing. Some 11% were homeschooled 10-12 years, so if one were to add K, maybe it would be something like 15% or more were homeschooled 10-13 years; we apparently do not know from this UAS survey. This is only one study with a sample of only n=140 adults who were homeschooled for at least one year. “Discussion. A longstanding critique of homeschooling is that it may lead to socially isolating children, and as a result, make it difficult for them to navigate society in adulthood. ….. In this study of formerly homeschooled adults, findings were nuanced. While there was little evidence that homeschooling is generally a socially isolating practice that leads to poor outcomes in adulthood, qualitative interviews suggested that social flourishing in homeschool settings is dependent on both the particular social interests of the child and the attentiveness of the homeschooling parent to these interests. In this respect, homeschooling can ostensibly provide a high degree of customization that presents fitting social opportunities for children according to their personal interests and attributes, but the appropriateness of homeschooling for a child may vary by these factors as well. ….. Furthermore, parental efforts appear to be critical (Wyatt, 2008). Interviews indicated that homeschooling worked well from a social standpoint when homeschooling parents were attentive to the child’s social interests and these interests could be served without attending a brick-and-mortar school” p. 20-21. “It is worth mentioning that findings indicated that although there are certainly homeschooling parents who are not attuned to their child’s social needs, most homeschooling parents seem to be attentive to the social needs of their children” (p. 21).) ? Comments revised
Hamlin, Daniel, & Peterson, Paul E. 2022 Homeschooling skyrocketed during the pandemic, but what does the future hold? Education Next, https://www.educationnext.org/homeschooling-skyrocketed-during-pandemic-what-does-future-hold-online-neighborhood-pods-cooperatives/ https://www.educationnext.org/homeschooling-skyrocketed-during-pandemic-what-does-future-hold-online-neighborhood-pods-cooperatives/ homeschooling, history, debate, philosophy, trends, growth “Another trend is the use of hybrid models, in which home-schooled children also attend public and private schools or even local universities part-time.”
Hammer, Joshua 1984, September 17 The education of Robert Allen. People Weekly, 22, 32.
Hammons, Christopher 2008 Fifty educational markets: A playbook of state laws and regulations governing private schools. Indianapolis, IN: Friedman Foundation for Educational Choice. Retrieved September 5, 2013 from http://www.edchoice.org/CMSModules/EdChoice/FileLibrary/295/private_schools_laws&regs.pdf. http://www.edchoice.org/CMSModules/EdChoice/FileLibrary/295/private_schools_laws&regs.pdf private schooling, private education, laws, state regulation, free market, free enterprise, educational competition, education choice “There is a widespread misperception that private schools avoid government oversight or are “unregulated.” In fact, private schools are subject to a wide variety of laws and regulations that run the gamut from reasonable rules to ensure health and safety to unreasonable rules that interfere with school curricula, preventing schools from pursuing the educational approaches that work best for their students. Partly because the public is largely unaware of this body of regulations, it is not often subject to public scrutiny, and thus there is less incentive to reform unreasonable laws and regulations. This report analyzes the laws and regulations that govern private schools in all 50 states. It documents the extent to which private schools are regulated. A full list of the laws and regulations governing private schools in each state is available on the website of the Friedman Foundation. The degree of regulation varies considerably from state to state. This report also evaluates the laws and regulations in each state to measure the extent to which they allow a true educational marketplace to flourish” (p. 5). Table 2 is “Grades and scores by state.”
Hanáčková, Andrea 2015 Homeschooling in the Czech Republic with Regard to ELT. Bachelor’s thesis, Department of English Language and Literature, Masaryk University. homeschooling, parents, young learner, learn, acquisition, individual approach, second language, first language, motivation, research, questionnaire, interview, observation, primary education, lesson plan, interests, English teaching, foreign, Czech Republic “Abstract: The bachelor thesis “Homeschooling in the Czech Republic with Regard to ELT” deals with aspects of teaching English to young learners at primary level within homeschooling and the parents’ role as tutors of English language. The theoretical part pays attention to concept of homeschooling and reasons in favour of this alternative form of education. The thesis provides an overview of the situation abroad and describes a brief history of homeschooling in the Czech Republic. The theory of the thesis deals with young learners, their characteristics and how they learn a second language. Most importantly, it focuses on homeschooling parents and their approaches to second language teaching. In the practical part, first part of the research is carried out by a method of questionnaire with eight participating parents. The research investigates general aspects of English teaching practice within homeschooling. Then the main qualitative research is conducted by methods of interview and observation in two homeschooling families. The aim is to reveal how the parents approach their role of teachers of English and what principles of second language acquisition they follow” (p. 4).
Hanna, Linda G. 2012 Homeschooling education: Longitudinal study of methods, materials, and curricula. Education and Urban Society, 44(5), 609-631. http://www.eric.ed.gov Home Schooling, homeschooling, Longitudinal Studies, Interviews, Questionnaires, Family Retrieved February 28, 2017 from www.eric.ed.gov: “In a comprehensive study of two-hundred fifty homeschooling families in urban, rural and suburban areas of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, the researcher examined all aspects of the instruction, materials and curricula employed by the families in a ten-year longitudinal study from 1998 through 2008. The researcher conducted interviews and gathered questionnaire data from: 1) all of the families in the sample in 1998, and 2) those families still residing within the same designated district in 2008. Significant changes occurred in the demographical data and the families' instructional programs. Within the methods/materials/curriculum data, increases occurred in the: 1) use of prepared curricula (religious and non-religious), 2) the acquisition of more textbooks from local school districts, 3) use of the public library, 4) technology applications, 5) consultation with instructional specialists/teachers, and 6) greater networking with other homeschooling families. In their pooling of resources, sharing of expertise, and communicating with other homeschooling families, the homeschoolers had upgraded and diversified their choices of pedagogy and their modalities for delivering instruction. (Contains 6 tables.) Peer-reviewed journal. Sociological Unit), Urban Areas, Suburbs, Rural Areas, School Districts, Curriculum, Textbooks, Public Libraries, Social Networks, Public Schools, Demography, Parent Attitudes, Motivation, Teaching Methods, Qualitative Research, Statistical Analysis, School Role, Educational Resources, Information Sources, Student Needs, Special Needs Students, Religious Factors, Ideology, Well Being, Teacher Characteristics, Technology Uses in Education, Shared Resources and Services, School Choice, Expertise, Peer-reviewed journal
Hannah, Linda G. 2012 Homeschooling education: Longitudinal study of methods, materials, and curricula. Education and Urban Society, 44(5), 609–631. homeschooling, home education, alternative education, curriculum “Abstract: In a comprehensive study of two-hundred fifty homeschooling families in urban, rural and suburban areas of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, the researcher examined all aspects of the instruction, materials and curricula employed by the families in a ten-year longitudinal study from 1998 through 2008. The researcher conducted interviews and gathered questionnaire data from: 1) all of the families in the sample in 1998, and 2) those families still residing within the same designated district in 2008. Significant changes occurred in the demographical data and the families’ instructional programs. Within the methods/materials/curriculum data, increases occurred in the: 1) use of prepared curricula religious and non-religious), 2) the acquisition of more textbooks from local school districts, 3) use of the public library, 4) technology applications, 5) consultation with instructional specialists/ teachers, and 6) greater networking with other homeschooling families. In their pooling of resources, sharing of expertise, and communicating with other homeschooling families, the homeschoolers had upgraded and diversified their choices of pedagogy and their modalities for delivering instruction.” (p. 609
Hanson, Buddy 2009 How to de-program yourself from all of the blasphemous ideas you learned in public school. Tuscaloosa, AL: Hanson Group. education, home education, public schools, Christian, biblical, philosophy, religion, curriculum Presents a biblical and Christian perspective on the purpose of education and how, where, and by whom the education of children should be executed. “The debate over where and how to educate our children will continue to rage as long as we debate it according to man’s reasons. But when God’s reasons are presented the answer becomes crystal clear” [back cover].
Hanson, Roy 1991 Vouchers and educational choice: The great debate. A debate presented at the Annual National Christian Home Educators Leadership Conference, October 10-12, 1991, Herndon, Virginia. educational choice, vouchers, home education Hanson is legislative consultant for Christian Home Educators Association of California, argued strongly against home educators taking any monies from the state, saying that where public money goes there will also be government control of curriculum, etc.
Hanson, Roy M. 1992, March/April Our greatest threat: Compromise. Private/Home Educators of California Legal-Legislative Update, March/April, 1, 2. Available from Family Protection Ministries, 910 Sunrise Ave. Suite A-1, Roseville CA 95661
Hanson, Roy M., Jr. 1992, September 01 Summary analysis of scholarships (vouchers) for private education. Available from Family Protection Ministries, 910 Sunrise Ave., Suite A-1, Roseville, CA 95661. vouchers, educational choice, home education Argues that the biblical teaching is that education of minor children is 100% the responsibility of the parents and the money to do so should come directly from the fruit of the parents' labor.
Hanson, Terje Ann 2000, August Homeschooling in Alaska: Extreme experiments in home education. Master's thesis, University of Alaska - Fairbanks, 119 pp. home education, homeschooling, research, public-school-at-home, PSAH Includes a quote from public school official that money his district receives for their tax-funded school-at-home [homeschooling] program helped fund a public-school (charter school) boarding school project).
Hardenbergh, Nicky 2004 Through the Lens of Homeschooling: A Response to Michael Apple and Rob Reich. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Diego, California, April 12-16, 2004.
Hardenbergh, Nicky 2008, March 30 Validity of high stakes standardized test requirements for homeschoolers: a psychometric analysis. Otherwise Instructed: Issues In Education. Retrieved December 21, 2009 from http://otherwiseinstructed.com/docs/validityofhighstakeshomeschooltesting.pdf. http://otherwiseinstructed.com/docs/validityofhighstakeshomeschooltesting.pdf home education, research, academic achievement testing, testing issues, theory, philosophy “In this paper, I demonstrate, through reference to the extensive psychometric literature, that the psychometric tool prescribed in current high stakes homeschool policies, a normreferenced standardized test, is invalid for use in a high stakes testing policy. Norm-referenced test scores may not validly be used to determine if a student meets a given standard of performance. I go on to examine another testing tool proposed by some policymakers: the state-specific high stakes criterion-referenced tests administered to public school students in every state. While theoretically valid for determining a standard of performance, such tests would be problematic for use in the homeschooling context. I end by reviewing the setting of cut points on high stakes tests, showing that, to a very large extent, the entire controversy of high stakes testing can be reduced to the question of the validity of the cut point. After considering the psychometric evidence, I conclude that [p. 2 ends] current and proposed high stakes standardized requirements for homeschoolers are baseless. Policies based on such requirements are a waste of taxpayer dollars and a needless imposition on homeschooling families” [p. 3].
Hardenbergh, Nicky 2005 Through the lens of homeschooling: A response to Michael Apple and Rob Reich. In Bruce S. Cooper (Ed.), Home schooling in full view: A reader, p. 97-108. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing. home education, praxis, practice, philosophy
Hardenbergh, Nicky 2015 Validity of high stakes standardized test requirements for homeschoolers: A psychometric analysis. In Paula Rothermel (Ed.), Rothermel, Paula. (Ed.). (2015). International perspectives on home education: Do we still need schools? London, United Kingdom: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 111-135. homeschooling, home education, high stakes testing, accountability, academic achievement; home education, research, reasons, reason, rationale, foreign, Australia “The issue of high stakes testing occupies a large portion of today’s educational policy discussions. Public and private debates about testing policies are animated and multi-faceted. One very small facet of the topic, however, rarely emerges into public view. In this chapter, I refer to those policies that require the use of standardized tests as a high stakes assessment of home education” (p. 111). “Non-public school students, including homeschoolers, are not, by definition, students enrolled in public school. Non-public school students are not educated at public expense, nor do they receive high school diplomas from the state. Non-public school students are simply not accountable to state officials in the same way as public school students are. Therefore, the state-specific accountability tests that are valid for use in the public schools are not necessarily valid for use in non-public schools” (p. 130). Harding, Terrence John Arthur. (1997, September). Why Australian Christian Academy families in Queensland choose to home school: Implications for policy development. A dissertation constituting part of the requirements for the master’s degree, Queensland University of Technology, Kevin Grove, Queensland, Australia. (“This study explored the reasons why Queensland families in the Australian Christian Academy chose home schooling. One hundred and sixty five families returned survey questionnaires and thirteen home school families were interviewed to provide data which was subsequently analysed and categorised. Broadly speaking, home school families indicated six major categories of reasons which motivated them to choose home education. These categories of reasons were religious, academic, parenting, social, pragmatic and special needs. Home school families articulated a deep commitment to their views about life which thus affected their views about their children and their children's education. This study provides an understanding of human motivations which have precipitated the home school movement among these families. It also presents a platform from which Australian Christian Academy administrators may develop future policy. The study raises awareness of key issues in the minds of home schooling parents concerning the development of their children” [p. 2].
Hardenbergh, Nicky 2016 Through the lens of home schooling: A response to Michael Apple and Rob Reich. In Cooper, Bruce S.; Spielhagen, Frances R.; & Ricci, Carlo (Eds.), Homeschooling in New View. Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing. homeschooling, home schooling, home education, regulation, philosophy “I still consider myself a liberal, but I know longer believe in a role for the state in the regulation of home education” (p. 151). Explains that she does not share the same “philosophical/religious worldview” (Christian, biblical) as Scott Somerville and Brian Ray (p. 152).
Hardenbrook, Weldon M. 1987 Missing from action: Vanishing manhood in America. Nashville, TN: Thomas Nelson Publishers.
Harding, Terry, and Farrell, Ann 2003 Home schooling and legislated education. Australia and New Zealand Journal of Law and Education, 8(2), 127 – 135. home education, legislation, child protection, law, legal, philosophy “Abstract. Home schooling, as an alternate model of education, is emerging as a growing educational phenomenon throughout Australia. This paper critiques home schooling as an educational expression of parental responsibility for the education of children. Issues of child protection and duty-of-care are examined in the light of relevant legislative frameworks. Current notions of state and parental responsibility for educational provision are discussed in the light of critical theories” [p. 127]. “Currently, all states and territories, except Victoria, have education acts that assume that the state has responsibility for the education of children. Essentially, these states reserve powers over home educators in two areas. First, they assume power to give permission to parents to operate as home educators. Second, they assume power to give approval of the curriculum content of home-schooled children. Parents who educate their children at home without government permission in these states, face the possibility of legal sanction” [p. 129]. “The difference between the ‘non-permission route’ and the ‘permission route’ as found among home [p. 129 ends] schoolers illustrates two seemingly antithetical stances to the question: Who is responsible for the education of children: Parents or the state?” [p. 130].
Hardon, John 1998, November Father Hardon on home schooling. Seton Home Study School, 15(11), 4-5. education, home schooling, Roman Catholic, philosophy, religion Catholic priest explains Roman Catholic position on education and why Catholic home schooling is necessary. Emphasizes parents’ responsibility and authority in saying “... parents are to provide for the religious eduaction and upbringing of their children” [p. 4].
Hardy, Lawrence 2001, August Learning without school [subtitle: Who home-schools and why? A growing movement raises questions for your district]. American School Board Journal, 188(8), 14-19. Also available 7/20/01 online http://www.asbj.com/current/coverstory.html. http://www.asbj.com/current/coverstory.html home education, public school, cooperation, academic achievement, socialization Written to an audience of public state school board association members, addresses academic achievement, socialization, growth in the homeschool population, and degree to which homeschoolers and public school districts interact and cooperate with one another. End of one section [p. 19] implies that some homeschoolers may choose to not have children in public state schools due to their own racism.
Harmony Union School District 1988 Contract Learning Program Handbook. Occidental, California.
Harper, Amelia 2005 An exclusive interview with Douglas Gresham. Retrieved December 4, 2007 and January 13, 2009 from http://www.homescholar.org/Lewis%20articles.htm#Interview. http://www.homescholar.org/Lewis%20articles.htm#Interview home education, philosophy, pedagogy Author explains Douglas Gresham is a son of Joy Davidman, wife of the late C.S. Lewis. Gresham speaks on home education, homeschooling. “Gresham: Homeschooling and why I advocate it is not a matter of whether the schools are good or bad, though obviously I would rather children went to good schools than to bad ones, if go to school they must. It is that, as someone who has been trained and works in the field of post-childhood abuse trauma, and has devoted considerable thought to the matter, I have formed the opinion that the entire concept of school is flawed. In fact, it is a terrible mistake. Look what we do: we observe what God has designed, a pair of parents, one of each sex, and two pairs of grandparents, often with a few aunts and uncles thrown in. In fact, a Family. This is the unit designed by God Himself for the specific purpose and ministry of raising each new generation. Then what do we do? We take the child and remove him from this carefully designed support group of parents and close family members, all of whom share a genetic bond with the child, and plunge him into a mass group of his peers, all of whom are as ignorant and as demanding as he is, with one adult stranger supervising. In terms of the psycho-emotional development of the child, this is complete madness.”
Harris, Gregg 1984 Christian Life Workshops, Inc., P.O. Box 2250, Gresham OR 97030. home education, support, conferences, workshops, training Provides workshops and literature on home education. One of most widely known home school speakers in the U.S.
Harris, Gregg 1988 Home school education. In H. Wayne House (Ed.), Schooling choices: An examination of private, public, and home education, Portland, OR: Multnomah Press.
Harris, Gregg 1988 How did home schooling begin? In H. Wayne House (Ed.), Schooling choices: An examination of private, public, and home education, Portland, OR: Multnomah Press. history, philosophy, religion, homeschooling “The historical roots of home education go all the way back to the original members of society, the first family. Obviously Adam and Eve were the only teachers their children knew. But since then, in most cultures and time periods, the child’s tutors were his parents and the home was his primary schoolhouse” (p. 181).
Harris, Gregg 1988 The Christian home school. Brentwood, TN: Wolgemuth and Hyatt, Publishers, Inc. Argues that home education is the preferred method of educating children, that it is a return to a historical practice, and that it is an acceptance of parents' God-given responsibility. Gives parents much practical information on how to home educate. Provides researcher with perspective of one of the best known Christian advocates of home education. Author is one of the most popular speakers (of Christian Life Workshops, Gresham OR) on the subject in the United States. Talks about helping children be delighted in learning good things [p. 64]; other places Harris has called it delight-directed education [e.g., p. 47].
Harris, Gregg 1995 The Christian home school. Gresham, Oregon: Noble Publishing Associates. Basically same as the preceding entry, Harris, 1988.
Harris, J. John, 3rd, & Fields, Richard E. 1982 Outlaw generation: a legal analysis of the home-instruction movement. Educational Horizons, 61(1), 26-31, 50, 51. Law. Includes comments about socialization.
Harris, Rebecca 2004 A different kind of classroom: Alternative schools battle tyranny and fascism. Retrieved 9/4/04 online http://www.salemmonthly.com/news.html#news3. http://www.salemmonthly.com/news.html#news3 “There are some who choose to learn without actual schools: homeschoolers. They seek flexibility and customization that teachers in traditional schools can only dream about, according to Brian Ray, PhD., founder and director of Salem’s National Home Education Research Institute, which publishes the academic journal Home School Researcher . About 1500 registered homeschoolers live in Salem-Keizer [Oregon], according to Sandy Salter, homeschool coordinator for the Willamette Education Service District. “Some of us researchers think it’s grown at least 7 percent per year for the last 5 years, all over America,” Ray said. “In reality it is a complete myth that only a four-year-college-degree person can teach Billy that the letter A has three sounds.” Compulsory, standardized education often occurs in “tyrannical and fascist” nations, according to Ray. He’s surprised that some others in the education field think it necessary. “They think that the state really needs to have the authority to compel parents to teach beliefs other than the parents’,” Ray said. “You’d think that that belief would have disappeared with Germany in the 1940s.””
Harrison Pollock, Dorothy J.A. 1994 The right hand of fellowship: Home education in Nova Scotia and ideological challenge. Master’s (M.A.) thesis, Saint Mary's University, Canada, 150 pp.
Harrison, Laurie R. 1982 Management module: Parent involvement, a study of state management practices: looking back at Title I and toward Chapter 1. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Education. Try: Research In Education, August 1983. Explains that approximately 2/3 of the States plan either to encourage parent involvement in their local education agencies or to take an active role in ascertaining whether or not the agencies are consulting with parents.
Harrison, Suzanne 1996 A qualitative study of motivational factors for choosing to homeschool: Experiences, thoughts, and feelings of parents. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Gonzaga University, Spokane WA, 265+ pp. home education, research, qualitative, reasons, rationales, motivations Studies 12 mothers. “The twelve mothers were categorized into two general groups: the `pull-out’ group and the `just `cuz’ group” [p. 238]. The pull-out group had removed their children from public schools due to negative experiences with the public schools. The just `cuz group focused on positive and pro-active reasons for home schooling. “Similarities between the two groups of mothers did emerge. All of the mothers felt homeschooling created a positive family relationship and strengthened the family unit” [p. 238]. “These mothers generally believed they were more qualified to meet the needs of their children better than were the schools. For the `pull-out’ group, this belief was based upon negative experiences with public schools and for the `just `cuz’ group, it was part of the parents' philosophies about education. Although perspectives were diverse, all of the mothers expressed beliefs that represent their educational philosophies and which motivated them to homeschool. Positive convictions about the value of education were shared and when a mother believed the education of her child was not met, she took action to ensure an appropriate education was occurring. The `pull-out’ group was not willing to sit idly watching their children fail and the `just `cuz’ group chose an avenue for success from the beginning of their children's education. All of the mothers wished for their children to succeed academically, keeping in mind the needs of the individual child. The mothers were also interested in character building and their children's self-esteem. One mother commented, `Each child has a different ability and I believe the schools need to look at that’” [p. 239]. A “just ‘cuz” mother said, “A more religious environment was not the only reason [for us to homeschool] -- a private school isn’t as good as the one-on-one following their abilities and interests that we do with homeschooling.” “I guess my philosophy mainly is that religious beliefs are first, the best way for children to learn is second, and self-esteem is third.” “Homeschooling is about freedom, the freedom to choose” (p. 235).
Harvey, Elaine Kelsey 1999 High hopes: A qualitative study of family values guiding “home schooling” education in the multi-ethnic environment of Hawai'i. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, University of Hawaii. home education, research, qualitative, reasons, values, philosophy “Suspecting that the incongruency among home, school, and peer cultures lies more in the expectations and values of each than in pedagogy, per se, this study looked at values of families in Hawai’i of varied ethnic backgrounds who chose to educate their children at home. It sought the particular values that the parents perceived as important, from what cultural sources and experiences the values were derived, and what means they used to convey them to their children. The study also probed advantages and disadvantages parents perceived in home schooling, factors about schools contributing to decisions to home school, and circumstances tending to sustain or discontinue home schooling. As a result, this study offers an in depth [sic] understanding of meanings mothers attach to often-heard reasons for [abstract, p. vi] home schooling. It identifies values mothers connect with good learning environment and proper preparation for adulthood, including balance, integrity, responsibility, respect of self and others, flexibility to accommodate family needs, love, acceptance, trust, and a lifelong love of learning. Finally it proposes a model for parent-guided education that acknowledges every child’s need for an adult advocate/mediator who will insure that the child’s educational career has continuity, direction, purpose, relevance, and balance” [abstract, p. vii]. Harvey’s “model of parent-guided education” [p. 191ff] includes 19 elements such as the following: “1. A child will benefit if some one person or persons guide the child through the educational process, connecting later experiences with earlier and proceeding toward appropriate life-enhancing objectives,” “2. Parents believe they have an inseparably linked right and responsibility to prepare children for adult success” [p. 193], and “8. Parents realize that their children face boundaries or borders ... and various ‘worlds’ of family, peer and school cultures” [p. 196]. Offers a complex understanding of families’ values and how and why these guide home- and family-based education.
Hassan, Hashibul; Islam, Asad; Siddique, Abu; Wang, Liang Choon 2024 Telementoring and homeschooling during school closures: A randomized experiment in rural Bangladesh. The Economic Journal, https://academic.oup.com/ej/advance-article/doi/10.1093/ej/ueae014/7625592 https://academic.oup.com/ej/advance-article/doi/10.1093/ej/ueae014/7625592 Telementoring, homeschooling, Covid-19, school closure, primary education, randomized experiment, rural Bangladesh; foreign This is from the Accepted manuscripts but prior to copyediting or typesetting. They can be cited using the author(s), article title, journal title, year of online publication, and DOI. They will be replaced by the final typeset articles, which may therefore contain changes. The DOI will remain the same throughout: “Abstract. Using a randomized experiment in 200 Bangladeshi villages, we evaluate the impact of an over-the-phone learning support intervention (telementoring) among primary school children and their mothers during Covid-19 school closures. Postintervention, treated children scored 35% higher on a standardized test, and the homeschooling involvement of treated mothers increased by 22 minutes per day (26%). We also found that the intervention forestalled treated children‘s learning losses. When we returned to the participants one year later, after schools briefly reopened, we found that the treatment effects had persisted. Academically weaker children benefited the most from the intervention that only cost USD 20 per child.”
Hasson, Mary Rice 2012 The changing conversation around homeschooling: An argument for more data and less ideology. University of St. Thomas Journal of Law and Public Policy. homeschooling, home education, ideology, philosophy, policy, law, empirical evidence, progressivism, critique, quantitative research, qualitative research Provides a rare and much-needed response to negative critics of homeschooling and those who want the state to control/regulate homeschooling more based on philosophical presuppositions and presumptions about homeschooling practices that are not based on empirical evidence. “Against this backdrop of change -- as homeschooling stakes a favorable claim on public opinion and the number of homeschooling families soars -- the public conversations about homeschooling have changed as well. These conversations, however, increasingly reflect conflicts over values, ideologies, and worldviews more than they reflect differences over educational pedagogy, practice, or outcomes. Progressive theorists have stepped up both criticisms of homeschooling and call for tighter state regulation of homeschooling. Some of these scholars express concern less over whether homeschooled children learn to read, write, and do math [p. 11 ends] adequately, and moreover whether homeschooling instills "illiberal" attitudes, produces children who are "ethically servile" to their parents, or fails to produce children committed to the "constitutional norm of tolerance." The common thread running through these criticisms seems to be the belief that the children of religious, usually Christian, homeschoolers will be less capable of functioning as autonomous citizens in a democratic society and less committed to ideals of "diversity" and "tolerance," as defined by progressives” (p. 12). “I address instead some similar, troubling aspects of the work of three scholars, all strong critics of homeschooling: Professor Rob Reich of Stanford University, Professor Kimberly A. Yuracko of Northwestern University Law School, and Professor Catherine J. Ross of George Washington University Law School." Their general arguments for stringent regulation can be countered by strong constitutional arguments based on parents' rights, religious freedom, and free speech [emphasis added]. My aim here, however, is a more limited one: to argue that their work relies on presumptions based on ideology rather than on empirical data and that children, and society, will be served better by encouraging more research rather than engaging in an ideological rush to judgment. My analysis has two parts: the first examines examples in their work of factually unsupported assumptions about homeschooling itself; the second highlights the lack of empirical data to support the supposed link between [p. 12 ends] homeschooling and certain presumed harms” (p. 13). “These scholars not only fail to offer credible data to support their general assumptions that homeschooling families are typified by narrow, inadequate intellectual and educational patterns," they also fail to consider existing research that casts doubt on the accuracy of their assumptions” (p. 14). “In light of the political activism that characterizes the homeschool community, it is not credible to assert that homeschooled children fail to engage ideas, values, and beliefs that oppose their parents' values. The real issue for progressives seems to be how homeschooling families are likely to engage the ideas and values with which they disagree. Given their religious and political beliefs, conservative or religiously-oriented homeschooling parents may indeed present 'progressive' values and beliefs in a negative light and take pains to prepare their children, with facts and arguments, to counter those progressive values and beliefs. But such is the dynamic of a free society that shuns state-imposed viewpoints or viewpoint discrimination and respects the free exercise of religion.94 Progressives' criticisms seem to boil down to little more than a complaint that homeschooling families do not present opposing beliefs and values in a favorable light. The proposed remedies seem to favor a government-mandated platform, through mandated curriculum or testing, designed to ensure that progressives' beliefs and values are presented in a positive light, creating the opportunity to persuade homeschooled children to abandon their parents' beliefs and values” (p. 17). “All three theorists substitute ideological presumptions, instead of credible empirical data, as the underpinning for their claims that homeschooled children fail to encounter or engage opposing viewpoints or belief systems. Worse, they would mandate servings of progressive ideology as the force-fed solution to a non-existent problem” (p. 19). “Policymakers would do far better to encourage additional research and to examine existing data, which, though not robust, suggests that other factors lead to conclusions at odds with the presumptions of these scholars. Kunzman and Gaither observe …” (p. 21). “In sum, these scholars presume a link between an education that they presume is inadequate and as a result of the harm they presume would result, they urge states to impose strict regulations on homeschooling families, requiring them to "promote," in their own homes, beliefs and values they strongly oppose.12 4 Conclusion: Let Data, Not Ideology, Drive The Conclusions The willingness of homeschooling critics to rely on ideological rhetoric to drive policy towards educational uniformity, based on a platform of progressive values and viewpoints, instead of encouraging more research and exploration into the actual results of homeschooling is troublesome. Policymakers would do well to recall the importance of the Supreme Court's ruling in Pierce, as described by Professor Edward McGlynn Gaffney …” (p. 22). “Diversity, in the macro rather than micro sense, may in fact be well served by homeschooling, through the variety of styles, philosophies, and methods of its practitioners.'2 6 Future assessments of homeschooling will benefit from a nonideological framing of the issues and a better factual foundation for discussion. Rather than imposing more state regulation over homeschooling, on the basis of ideological assumptions and little data, policymakers should encourage scholars to identify research gaps in the data on homeschooling outcomes and to undertake additional rigorous quantitative and qualitative research. An emphasis on research may benefit educational reform more generally as well, as research may yield insights into alternative ways to spur academic success for all children. Surely we can agree that the resolution of policy conflicts over homeschooling begins with a general commitment to rigorous research and a willingness to avoid facile assumptions or conclusions, driven by ideology” (p. 23).
Hauck, Lauren E. 2024 A comparison of academic achievement and psychological symptoms in homeschooled and traditionally schooled children: Accounting for demographic and family characteristics. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, draft, Department of Psychology, Northern Illinois University. homeschooling, academic achievement, psychological symptoms, socialization, causal comparative Abstract (draft): The prevalence of homeschooling is increasing, especially in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic. However, methodologically strong research examining how children's well-being may differ based on their schooling type (i.e., homeschooled vs. traditionally schooled) is rare. This study is a response to a call for advancing the methodological rigor and expanding our understanding of family contributions to differences between homeschooled and traditionally schooled children’s adjustment. Thus, the study aims to determine if differences between homeschooled and traditionally schooled (i.e., attending public school) children’s academic and emotional adjustment are present after accounting for both family demographic characteristics and parenting and home factors. This study collected data from 51 homeschooled and 51 publicly schooled children (ages 6–11) and their mothers. Children completed the WIATIII Achievement Test and an interactive computer-based measure of socioemotional adjustment (i.e., DOMINIC) while mothers completed questionnaires regarding parental discipline, parenting style, parenting stress, and the home environment. Covariate analyses determined a significant difference in demographic characteristics between schooling groups such that the homeschooling group had more intact families, mothers who were not employed, mothers who identified as religious, and male children than the traditionally schooled group. However, no differences emerged between schooling groups in parenting factors nor home characteristics. A consistent pattern emerged such that homeschooled children scored lower on standardized measures of reading, math, and writing, even after controlling for demographic variables. No differences were found between homeschooled and traditionally schooled children’s internalizing and externalizing symptoms. Findings contribute to the literature regarding homeschooled children’s academic and emotional development, including academic domains needing further attention (i.e., writing) and protective demographic characteristics of homeschool families.” In a regression model with many variables controlled, School sector/type did not explain reading scores, externalizing or internalizing behaviors (Table 8), but did Math and writing scores. How did she get her sample, participants? Did she control for how many years each child was homeschooled or conventionally schooled? Did she use standardized scores (e.g., z-score) for analysis, or percentiles? Will academic achievement be different when the children are older, such as 15-17? Did the researcher find out whether the objectives of the homeschool and institutional school teachers/schools were similar?
Haupt, Angela 2007, May 23 14-year-old is second girl to win National Geographic Bee. Retrived 7/2/07 from http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/2007-05-23-geography-bee_N.htm. http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/2007-05-23-geography-bee_N.htm home education, national geography bee competition “WASHINGTON — For the first time in 16 years, a girl took home the top prize Wednesday at the National Geographic Bee in Washington, D.C. Caitlin Snaring, 14, of Redmond, Wash., a home-schooled eighth-grader, correctly identified the former imperial capital of Vietnam as Hue. She becomes the second female champ since the bee began in 1989. Snaring, who won a $25,000 scholarship and a lifetime membership in the National Geographic Society, answered every question correctly during both the 10-round final and Tuesday's preliminary rounds. It's amazing," she said with flushed cheeks and a wide grin. "I knew I could do it. I studied so much, I knew everything I could possibly know. And I hope that by winning today, I inspire other girls to try geography, because the world is the greatest subject I've ever learned."
Havens, Joan Ellen 1991 A study of parent education levels as they relate to academic achievement among home schooled children. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, Fort Worth TX. Home school students scored above average in all 18 subtests of the Stanford Achievement Test, ranging from 2 to 6 grades above their estimated school grade, scores higher in reading and language than in mathematics and spelling; no relationship between student scores and (a) teacher certification status of mothers [p. 78-81, Table 18], (b) previous teacher training of mothers, nor (c) parents' educational levels [p. 92-97; e.g., Table 43 and Table 44 on p. 96 and p. 97].
Havermann, Judith 1998, May A private rescue mission. Citizen [magazine by Focus on the Family], 12(5), 16-17. education, choice, private, public, vouchers Describes rapidly growing number of privately-funded vouchers to help poor low-income families choose and send their children to any private school of their choice and the enthusiastic response of families to the offers to help them get their children out of public schools and into schools of their choice.
Hawkins, Ronald E. 1983 Home influence: Key to education. Fundamentalist Journal, 2(8), 19-21.
Hayes, Larry 1985, October 16 John C. Holt remembered as a `champion of children.' Education Week, p. 17.
Hayes, Lenore Colacion 2002 Homeschooling the child with ADD (or other special needs): Your complete guide to successfully homeschooling the child with learning differences. Prima Publishing. home education, special needs, learning disabilities Addresses topics of mental and physical disabilities related to biochemical or genetic difference or resulting from an accident during birth or later in childhoold or dieatary factors and environmental allergens, the pros and cons of formal diagnosis, homeschool friendly services and resources for the child, and so forth. Author says parents are a child’s best experts.
Hazard, William R. 1981 Flight from the public schools. Compact, 14(4), 22,23.
Healy, Jane M. 1991? Endangered minds: Why children don't think and what we can do about it. Says environment in which child grows up can influence way brain cells grow and connect, brain that watches countless hours of television will be different and this is may be why so many children at school can't think, don't read, or who must take drugs like Ritalin to concentrate, much television may lead to lack of vigilance-ability of brain to stay attached to a task it doesn't want to do, though little research on this.
HEAV'N: Home Educators Association of Virginia Newsletter 1991, January/February General assembly session coming. By staff, page 1. home education, policy, law, cooperation, public school, criticism "...the Virginia School Boards Association has actively lobbied in the General Assembly against both the Religious Exemption Provision and the Home Instruction Statute, the two home schooling avenues that encompass the large majority of home schooling families in Virginia" p. 1.
Hedin, Norma S. 1990 A study of the self-concept of older children in selected Texas churches who attend home schools as compared to older children who attend Christian schools and public schools. Doctoral dissertation, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, Fort Worth, TX.
Hedin, Norma S. 1991 Self-concept of Baptist children in three educational settings. Home School Researcher, 7(3), 1-5. There was no difference in self-concept among the three educational settings (home, Christian, and public), but as a group the children from Baptist churches had high self-concepts. In findings, states "This can be interpreted to mean that children who attended Texas Baptist churches had significantly higher self-concepts than the normative population of public school children" (p. 3). "this may indicate that other factors, rather than educational setting, more significantly enter into self-concept development. These factors many [sic] include such areas as parental self-concept, relationships with parents, individual academic achievement, or other factors as revealed in previous studies ..." (p. 3).
Hegener, Mark, & Hegener, Helen 1988 The Home School Reader. Tonasket, WA: Home Education PRESS, 156 pp..
Hein, Margaret Gill 1982 Attendance policy. In H. E. Mitzel (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Educational Research, volume 1. New York, NY: Macmillan Publishing Co., Inc., 518 p. One reference to Michigan superintendents being opposed to home instruction and no required attendance, although "A large number [of superintendents] admitted that compulsory attendance laws were not effective in producing high-quality education" (p. 179).
Heinz, Donald 1983 The struggle to define America. In Robert C. Liebman & Robert Wuthnow (Eds.), The new Christian right. New York, NY: Aldine Publishing Company. Discusses struggle between contending mythologies and symbol (family, school, television) production-has applications to home education movement.
Hellyer, Janie Levine 1998, September/October Public school programs and our community. Home Education Magazine, 15(5), 24-25. home education, public school support, cooptation, cooperation, philosophy, politics Discusses tax-funded, state-controlled, public school programs designed for home schoolers or education at home and philosophical and other concerns about the increasing number of these programs around the country.
Henderson, A. 1987 The evidence continues to grow: Parent involvement improves student achievement. Columbia, MD: National Committee for Citizens in Education.
Henderson, Anne T., & Berla, Nancy. (Eds.) 1994 A new generation of evidence: The family is critical to student achievement. Washington, DC: National Committee for Citizens in Education. ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 375 968 [PS 022 797]. academic achievement, parent involvement “Noting that the most accurate predictor of student achievement is the extent to which the family is involved in his or her education, this report presents a collection of research papers on the function and importance of family to a student’s achievement and education in school and the community” [ERIC abstract]. “Major findings indicate that the family makes critical contributions to student achievement from the earliest childhood years through high school, and efforts to improve children’s outcomes are much more effective when the family is actively involved” [ERIC abstract].
Henderson, Nancy 1987 Teaching your kids at home. Changing Times, March, pp. 83-87.
Hendrickson, Borg 1989 Home school: Taking the first step. Kooskia, ID: Mountain Meadow Press.
Henegar, Justin M. 2014 Homeschooling and financial literacy: A qualitative analysis. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Kansas State University, Manhattan, Kansas. financial literacy, homeschooling, home education, research, qualitative, elementary education, secondary education “Abstract. Financial literacy has become a prominent topic of discussion since the latest economic downturn. Although many studies reveal that our youth’s financial literacy is low, no study to date provides an overview as to how our youth are learning financial literacy concepts. This dissertation seeks to explore how homeschooling families prepare their children to be financially literate. This [qualitative] study reviewed four sensitizing concepts: (a) communication, (b) engagement, (c) outside influences, and (d) parental perspectives based on the learning theory: Legitimate Peripheral Participation. Twenty primary educators in homeschooling families from a variety of states were interviewed for this study. Out of the twenty participants, eight were classified in the elementary age group, five were classified in the middle school age, and seven were classified in the high school age. Each sensitizing concept was examined for each school age group. This exploratory study found that parents who homeschool tend to focus on three main topics of personal finance: debt or the avoidance of debt, savings, and budgeting. Little evidence suggests that parents help their children with the mechanics of these behaviors. There were three important findings extracted in this study. First, the results suggest that homeschooling parents need to become better prepared to teach their children about money, and second, that personal finance should be thought of as a core subject in the elementary age years in lieu of just a life skill. Finally, this study found that there is a large focus around personal finance topics in the elementary age years and the high school years, with little attention to personal finance behaviors for the middle school age group. The results of this study provide those entities that advocate improved financial literacy an understanding as to the “how” parents who homeschool prepare their kids to understand money” (p. v). “Foremost, in conducting the literature review, the researcher found no other qualitative research that sought to evaluate how educators and/or parents teach financial education. Thus, the present research will be one of the first to provide the literature with a qualitative viewpoint” (p. 115). “This research found that parents have done little to prepare themselves to teach personal finance to their children. Many of the participants identified their experience in running the family finances as the way they have prepared themselves to teach personal finances to their kids. Parents, specifically homeschooling parents, should adequately prepare themselves to teach personal finances like any other subject. By familiarizing themselves with the topics and concepts of personal finance, primary home educators will be better prepared to discuss personal finance” (p. 119). Author carefully notes the limitations of qualitative research and the fact that he drew his limited sample from only two homeschooling forums (p. 122-124).
Henke, Robin R., Choy, Susan P., Chen, Xianglei, Geis, Sonya, Alt, Martha Naomi, & Broughman, Stephen P. 1997 America’s teachers: Profile of a profession, Report No. NCES 97-460. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education, Office of Educational Research and Improvement. teacher certification status, public schools, elementary, secondary “Because of this wide variation in certification among states, it is not surprising that national data indicate not all teachers who taught in elementary and secondary schools were fully certified in the field they taught most often. It is also something of a challenge to determine the degree to which the incidence of teaching without full certification is a problem. In 1993–94, approximately 4 percent of teachers who taught in public elementary or secondary schools were not certified at all in the subject area they taught most often (the main assignment field). Others had some, but not full, certification in the main assignment field: about 2 percent held probationary certification (they had completed all the requirements except for the completion of a probationary teaching period); about 4 percent held provisional or temporary certification (they still had requirements for certification to meet); and less than 1 percent held emergency certification (they still had to complete a certification program figure 3.4). [SOURCE: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, Schools and Staffing Survey: 1993–94 (Teacher Questionnaire)]” [p. 32]; i.e., report is saying, it appears, that over 95% of all teachers during the mid-1990s are certified teachers but not necessarily in the field/subject they taught most often; in fact, probably over 99% are certified in some teaching area.
Henke, Robin R., Kaufman, Phillip, Broughman, Stephen P. 2000, October Issues related to estimating the home-schooled population in the United States with National Household Survey data, NCES 2000-311. Washington, DC: United States Department of Education, Office of Educational Research and Improvement. home education, research, population size, estimates Explains methods used in two USDE-funded studies that provided data from which the homeschool population could be estimated and problems inherent to the data and methods. Tries to account for discrepancies in two different estimates of the population size. One estimate was a point estimate of 345,000 K-12 students in the fall of 1994 and the other 636,000 students in the spring 1996. Explains that error sources are difficult, if not impossible, to determine in these surveys and therefore it is almost impossible to ascertain the accuracy of the two estimates.
Hensley, S. C. 1995 Homeschooling children with special needs. [book] [mis?? publisher]
Hern, M. 1996 Deschooling our lives. [book] [mis?? publisher?]
Hersch, Patricia 1998 A tribe apart: A journey into the heart of American adolescence. New York, NY: Fawcett Columbine. family life, youth, research Studies suburban youth culture and describes teens who are without meaningful contact with their parents who are busy pursuing “success.”
Hess, Tom 1996 Home education is on the move. Focus on the Family Citizen, 10(9), 10-12. home education, politics, research “Home schoolers are well-educated, politically savvy and growing in numbers. Even Congress has taken notice” [p. 10]. Quotes Dr. Brian Ray on research findings, including the statement, “The myth is that home schoolers have separated and disengaged form society. The fact is, they’ve separated but they’re still engaged” [p. 11].
Hewison & Tizard 1980 Parental involvement and reading attainment. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 50, 209-215. Cited and summarized in ERIC Digest #E497, Communicating with Culturally Diverse Parents of Exceptional Children, with a number and date at the top saying ED333619, May 91; the digest says, "Even instruction by highly competent specialists at school does not produce gains comparable to those obtained when students are tutored by their parents at home” (Hewison & Tizard 1980).
Hewitt Research Foundation 1985 North Dakota trial results pending. The Parent Educator and Family Report, 3(2), 5.
Hewitt Research Foundation 1985 The parent educator and family report. Hewitt Research Foundation, P.O. Box 9, Washougal, WA 98671-0009. General. Bimonthly newsletter concerning all aspects of home schooling
Hewitt Research Foundation 1986 On home-schooling figures and scores. The Parent Educator and Family Report, 4(2),1,2.
Hewitt Research Foundation 1986 Study of home schoolers taken to court. The Parent Educator and Family Report, 4(1), 2.
Heyneman, Stephen P. 1997 Jim Coleman: A personal story. Educational Researcher, 26 (1), 28-30. research, academic achievement, demographics, race, socioeconomic status Uses strengths and errors of James Coleman to illustrate the limitations of survey research and how researchers must be willing to re-evaluate their theories. “`It isn’t poverty which drives [achievement test] scores of U.S. students down,’ I said [to Coleman], `or race, or even minority status, but rather impoverished spirit. It is the general lack of a desire to learn and this, in turn, is affected by public policy. ..... In general, children in the United States are provided with too much opportunity and too few obligations; too much choice and too few responsibilities’” [p. 29]. Much of Heyneman’s research shows no relationship between socioeconomic status and academic achievement.
Hildebrand, John 2007, February 22 Feds: Students' skills sink but grades rise. Newsday.com. Retrieved 2/23/07 online http://www.newsday.com/news/nationworld/nation/ny-liread0223,0,1381292,print.story http://www.newsday.com/news/nationworld/nation/ny-liread0223,0,1381292,print.story http://www.newsday.com/news/nationworld/nation/ny-liread0223%2C0%2C7886420.story?track=mostemailedlink public schools, grades, grade inflation, academic achievement, research also available 2/23/07 online http://www.newsday.com/news/nationworld/nation/ny-liread0223%2C0%2C7886420.story?track=mostemailedlink). (“Twelth-graders' reading skills have hit a new low, but their grades continue to climb, according to federal officials who suspect the nation's schools are inflating grades.”
Hill, Catherine; & Kearl, Holly 2011 Crossing the line: Sexual harassment at school. Washington DC: AAUW. Retrieved October 12, 2016 from http://www.aauw.org/files/2013/02/Crossing-the-Line-Sexual-Harassment-at-School.pdf http://www.aauw.org/files/2013/02/Crossing-the-Line-Sexual-Harassment-at-School.pdf sexual harassment, school children, public schools, abuse Based on a nationally representative survey of 1,965 students in grades 7–12 conducted in May and June 2011, Crossing the Line: Sexual Harassment at School provides fresh evidence about students’ experiences with sexual harassment, including being harassed, harassing someone else, or witnessing harassment. ….. Just Part of the School Day. Sexual harassment is part of everyday life in middle and high schools. Nearly half (48 percent) of the students surveyed experienced some form of sexual harassment in the 2010–11 school year, and the majority of those students (87 percent) said it had a negative effect on them” (p. 2).
Hill, David 1993, February Teach your children: For the Gutersons, school is a family affair. Teacher Magazine, February, cover, 16-22. reasons, socialization, practice Story on the Guterson family, of whom David, the father, recently wrote the book Family Matters. Describes the family's life, reasons for home education: "The Gutersons believe that homeschooling allows them to offer their children what the public schools simply cannot: individualized learning in a loving, nurturing environment" [p. 16], and socialization; positive article about home education.
Hill, Jonathan P.; Den Dulk, Kevin R. 2013 Religion, volunteering, and educational setting: The effect of youth schooling type on civic engagement. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 52(1):179–197. http://thearda.com/Archive/Files/Codebooks/NSYRW1_CB.asp home education, private education, religious education, public education, homeschooling, volunteer, volunteerism, civic engagement, graduates, adults, emerging adulthood, faith-based schooling, adolescence “Research on civic engagement shows that volunteering rates decline as young people move from adolescence into emerging adulthood. Using panel data spanning this period of the life course, we examine the impact of secondary schooling type—public, Catholic, Protestant, private nonreligious, and homeschool—on sustaining volunteering into emerging adulthood. We apply a framework that posits pathways between secondary schooling and sets of opportunities to volunteer embedded in institutions and social networks. We also posit a link between schooling type and durable motivational dispositions to volunteer. Results indicate substantial differences by schooling type, although our measures of opportunity structure and motivation do not adequately account for these differences. Those educated in Protestant secondary schools are considerably more likely than other young people to continue to volunteer, even accounting for potential spurious influences. Those schooled at home or in private nonreligious settings are significantly less likely to continue volunteering. We conclude by discussing two alternative accounts that should be addressed in further research: one focused on the role of habituated social practices and the other focused on differences in organizational efforts to link adolescent volunteering to emerging adult volunteering. Keywords: education, volunteering, emerging adulthood, faith-based schooling, adolescence.” “But in rejecting several hypotheses, we can say affirmatively that schooling type is an independent predictor of whether adolescent volunteers will become adult volunteers. By itself, that conclusion is intriguing and important for those who are invested in the civic engagement of young people” [p. 195]. The authors never give the sample sizes for various types of schooling, but personal communication (Hill, March 21, 2013) revealed n=60 for homeschoolers (at age 18-23, Wave 3 of the survey). Further, in Wave 1, when the youth were ages 13 to 17, of those being homeschooled, only 38 had been homeschooled for 4 or more years of their school years (retrieved March 29, 2013 from http://thearda.com/Archive/Files/Codebooks/NSYRW1_CB.asp) and it seems unreasonable to consider a high-school aged youth genuinely “homeschooled” if he had been home educated for 3 or fewer years. A sample size of 38 to 60 is a very small sample for drawing conclusions about a national population that was probably hundreds of thousands of home-educated young adults at the time (2007-2008). Authors fail to include many pieces of relevant research literature in their review of literature and discussion sections.
Hill, Mary E. V. Six ways to make home school fail. Unpublished manuscript, Salt Lake City, UT.
Hill, Paul T. 2000 Home schooling and the future of public education. Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 20-31.
Hill, Peter C., & Edwards, Evonne 2013 Measurement in the psychology of religiousness and spirituality: Existing measures and new frontiers (ch. 3). In K. I. Pargament (Ed.), APA Handbook of psychology, religion, and spirituality: Vol. 1. Context, theory, and research. religion, religiosity, Christianity, measurement, test “A primary purpose of this chapter is to provide brief reviews of reliable and valid measures of various aspects of religiousness and spirituality” [p. 52]. “Measures of religious orthodoxy have largely been limited to the Christian tradition. Fullerton and Hunsberger's (1982) 24-item Christian Orthodoxy (CO) Scale was originally tested among almost 2,300 respondents representing 10 Christian believer groups, mostly in Canada and Australia. Internal consistency on this likert-type measure (-3 to +3; strongly disagree to strongly agree) is very high (n = .97 and .98 among the 10 groups) with total scores ranging from 24 to 168 (a constant of 4 was added to each item's raw score). High mean interitem correlation coefficients ranging from .57 to .70 suggest considerable redundancy among some items and that the operationalization of the concept may be quite narrow. Ashortened six-item measure that correlates highly with the longer measure was later developed (Hunsberger, 1989).” [p. 58].
Hines, P. M. 1993 Home schooling in Arkansas: A study of attitudes, family characteristics and student achievement. Dissertation Abstracts International, 54, 07A. [Doctoral dissertation.]
HIPPY (Home Instruction Program for Preschool Youngsters) 1984, November/December Children Today, 13, 2.
Hirsch, E. D. 1987 Cultural literacy: What every American needs to know. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin Company.
Hirsh, Aaron 2019 The changing landscape of homeschooling in the United States. CRPE, Reinventing Public Education, July, 2019. Retrieved January 4, 2025 from https://crpe.org/wp-content/uploads/homeschooling_brief_final.pdf https://crpe.org/wp-content/uploads/homeschooling_brief_final.pdf homeschooling, hybrid schools, school choice, co-operatives, school improvement, alternative education, fragile communities, SES “This brief describes the state of homeschooling in the U.S. in 2019. Section I explores the changing demographics of homeschoolers. Section II gives an overview of new forms of homeschooling, including hybrid models. Section III outlines the variety of state policies that govern homeschooling” (p. 1). “The proportion of American families opting to homeschool is growing quickly, especially among black and Hispanic families. For that reason alone, it is a movement worth understanding and watching. Why are so many families making this choice and are there ways in which public education might better meet their needs? What do homeschool families lose or gain by opting out of the public system? How do different forms of homeschooling collaboratives function? The ways in which homeschool families are curating and blending a variety of education and social learning opportunities has interesting implications for how education can be more agile and customized to suit each student’s and each family’s needs. A new nonprofit organization in Connecticut, Workspace Education, is promoting itself as a “co-learning” space, where families and educators can access a wide portfolio of online, microschool, and homeschool opportunities through a membership model. In the future, might public education offer a broader spectrum of offerings and codesign these kinds of portfolios of learning pathways with families? Is there an untapped market for families that want greater customization within public education? CRPE will continue to pursue these broader questions” (p. 6).
Hochschild, Arlie Russell 1997 The time bind: When work becomes home and home becomes work. New York, NY: Henry Holt & Company, Inc. http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0805044701/qid=1006564622/sr=12-1/002-9785693-3180046 sociology, psychology, parenting, day care This sociologist reportedly finds that parents see staying at home with children as full of incessant demands and offering little tangible reward so they want to leave their children and go to work, even though they may not admit this. “This isn't another book about how the American economy is forcing workers into impossible time squeezes. In fact, Amerco and other Fortune 500 companies seem quite accommodating, offering plenty of family-friendly programs from part-time options to jobsharing. The somewhat disturbing surprise? People aren't cutting back their hours. In fact, both spouses in a typical two-job family are spending more and more time at work--not necessarily because there's more to do, or even because they're afraid of losing their jobs. They're fleeing the pressures and increasing uncertainties of home life and escaping to work, where they can feel in control, and maybe even have some fun. Peppered with astonishing facts and unexpected perspectives, The Time Bind is a fascinating, disturbing read for anyone trying to achieve a sense of balance within a busy working life” -- from editorial review by Amazon.com retrieved online 11/23/01 http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0805044701/qid=1006564622/sr=12-1/002-9785693-3180046
Hodge, David R.; Salas-Wright, Christopher P.; & Vaughn, Michael G. 2016 Behavioral risk profiles of homeschooled adolescents in the United States: A nationally representative examination of substance use related outcomes. Substance Use & Misuse, 52(3), 273-285. Retrieved March 5, 2020 from https://doi.org/10.1080/10826084.2016.1225094 https://doi.org/10.1080/10826084.2016.1225094 Homeschooling, adolescents, substance use, latent class analysis, religion, risk, at-risk “Abstract. Background: The homeschool population continues to grow in size and now accounts for 3.4% of all students in the United States. Objective: Given the heterogeneous nature of the population, this study examines the relationship between different types of homeschoolers and a number of substance use related outcomes. Methods: To conduct this study, we used pooled data (2002–2013) from the National Survey on Drug Use and Health (NSDUH). Respondents aged 12–17 who reported they had been homeschooled at any time during the previous 12 months were classified as homeschoolers (N = 1,321). Latent profile analysis (LPA) was conducted to identify latent subgroups of homeschoolers and multinomial regression was executed to assess the relationship between the subgroups and perceived substance use risk, availability, and past 12-month use. Results: The LPA yielded four subgroups, which were summarized as (1) highly religious and engaged, (2) limited parental monitoring, (3) high parental warmth and support, and (4) secular permissive. Of these, the highly religious and engaged subgroup was the least likely to report using substances. Conclusion: The results underscore the variation that exists among homeschoolers and the importance of examining the relationship between different types of homeschoolers and outcomes of interest” (p. 1). They address risk but compare sub-groups of homeschool students; they do not find or conclude that homeschool students are at-risk of anything compared to institutional school students or non-homeschool students. Addresses concepts of risk and at-risk.
Hoelzle, Braden Ryan 2013 The transmission of values and the transition into adulthood within the context of home education. Journal of Research on Christian Education, 22, 244–263. homeschooling, adulthood, values, religion, transmission, Christianity, peer-reviewed The current study explored the transmission of values and beliefs and the transition into adulthood within the context of home education through semi-structured open-ended interviews with four formerly home-educated young adults. The interviewees described their relationship with their parents as strong both now and while homeschooling but the younger two participants did not show clear signs that they closely maintained their parents’ religious beliefs. All participants indicated that their transition to adulthood contained some transitional bumps but the difficulty of these bumps was mitigated by a strong parent-child relationship. The youngest participant seemed to be in the midst of a transitional strain” (p. 244).) ?
Holt Associates 2000, June 15 Personal communication from Patrick Farenga [e-mail in which he defines unschoolng]. See also information at: www.holtgws.com. http://www.holtgws.com
Holt, John 1964 How children fail. New York, NY: Pitman Publishing Corporation.
Holt, John 1982, March Can we save the school's? No, and they're not worth saving. Progressive, 46(28).
Holt, John 1984, July The home-schooling question. Parents' Magazine, 59, 112.
Holt, John Caldwell 1969 The under achieving school. New York, NY: Dell Publishing Co., Inc.
Holt, John Caldwell 1978 John Holt on "Growing Without Schooling." The Ratcliffe Quarterly, 64(1), n.p. (reprint?).
Holt, John Caldwell 1980 See listing under Mother Earth News.
Holt, John Caldwell 1981 Teach your own: A hopeful path for education. New York, NY: Delacorte Press/Seymour Lawrence, 369 p.
Holt, John Caldwell 1982 How children fail, revised ed.. New York, NY: Delta/Seymour Lawrence.
Holt, John Caldwell 1982, April 30 More parents saying "no" to school. Newday, n.p. (reprint?).
Holt, John Caldwell 1983 How children learn, revised ed.. New York, NY: Delta/Seymour Lawrence.
Holt, John Caldwell 1983 How schools can cooperate with home schoolers. The Education Digest, 49 (October), 2-5.
Holt, John Caldwell 1983 Schools and home schoolers: A fruitful partnership. Phi Delta Kappan, 64, 391-394. home education, homeschooling, cooperation, public schools, research Argues that public schools should fully cooperate with home schoolers rather than just grudgingly tolerate them. Believes that cooperation may yield ideas and methods that may solve some of the schools' worst problems. Maintains that home schools are most important to conventional schools as a free laboratory research project that can be used to study the way children learn in the presence of friendly and concerned adults. “To give even as much as a single hour per day to silent reading (thus taking time away from reading instruction) would strike most educators as a dangerously radical experiment. [new paragraph] Not in the foreseeable future can we imagine a school district saying to its students, “You can read anything you like, and as much as you like, and we aren’t going to grade you on it.” ..… Nor are we likely to see large-scale and long-term research conducted to find out whether frequent testing actually helps children learn or only hinders them, or whether other methods of evaluating learning might not be better than the standardized testing now almost universally used. We are equally unlikely to see any research that questions or examines any other standard assumptions and practices in education. [new paragraph] There is only one place where this kind of research is likely to be carried out on a large enough scale and for a long enough time to yield significant results. That place is in the homes of families who are teaching their own children. This is the main reason why the home-schooling movement is so important to schools. It is – in effect, though certainly not by design – a laboratory for the intensive and long-range study of children's learning and of the ways in which friendly and concerned adults can help them learn. It is a research project, done at no cost, of a kind for which neither the public schools nor the government could afford to pay” (p. 393). “But even the most attentive, perceptive, and thoughtful classroom teachers could never elicit from their students the amount and intensity of feedback that home-schooling parents typically get from their children, because parents know and understand their children so much better” [p. 393].
Holt, John Caldwell 1983 Schools and home schoolers: A fruitful partnership. Education Digest, 49, 2-5.
Holt, John Caldwell 1983, December 14 Same cure won't help schools. USA Today, n.p.
Holt, John Caldwell 1983, December 2 Home schooling lets a child's mind grow. USA Today, n.p.
Holt, John Caldwell 1984 School's out: Why teachers fail. Progressive, pp. 32-33.
Holt, John Caldwell 1984 Why teachers fail. The Education Digest, December, 58-60. Holt describes educational metaphors that distort reality: (1) education as an assembly line in a bottling plant, (2) students in a school as laboratory rates in a cage being trained to do a trick, and (3) school as a mental hospital, a treatment institution. Criticizes testing and the stress placed on students.
Holt, John Caldwell 1984, January/February So you want to home-school. Mother Earth News, 139-140.
Holt, John Caldwell date unknown, pre-1991 John Holt's statement to the Minnesota Legislature. Unpublished. Available from Holt Associates, Boston, MA.
Holt, John Caldwell date unknown, pre-1991 The constitutional basis of home schooling. Unpublished. Available from Holt Associates, Boston, MA.
Holtrop, S. D. 1996, October Individualization starts at home. Educational Leadership, 54(2), 74-76. Home education, pedagogy, curriculum “Our family, by contrast to those who believe in a supposed golden age of three Rs education, is more interested in what is best for the individual learner—taking into account personality differences and stages, not ages. ..... We prefer to call it interest-initiated home schooling” [p. 74]. “Home schooling is not for everyone, just as sailing or attending college or having children is not for everyone” [p. 76]. Author is a professor of education and a home educator.
Home School Legal Defense Association 1990, Christmas [December] How may home-schooled children are there? Home School Court Report, p. 5. Based on 1990 study by Brian Ray [A nationwide study...] of the National Home Education Research Institute, HSLDA estimates 630,418 children living in home education families and of these 474,165 are of school age.
Home School Legal Defense Association 1992 Stanford Achievement Test group summary scores by grade. (Available from Home School Legal Defense Association—see address herein.) academic achievement, home education HSLDA collected the scores of 10,750 students, grades kindergarten through 12, and reported the percentile scores in reading, mathematics, and language at the various grade levels. The scores ranged from a low of the 56th percentile to a high of the 84th percentile, with a majority of the percentile scores in the 70s.
Home School Legal Defense Association 1992, January/February Home schoolers win EEE [Educational Entrance Examination] case. The Home School Court Report, 8(1), 1, 4. testing, parental qualification, test validity, regulation, law Deals with issue of whether a test used to qualify persons for admission to teacher education programs should be used to determine whether parents are qualified to teach their own children, and deals with validity of the EEE for this use.
Home School Legal Defense Association 1992, January/February Sports participation granted with public schools. Home School Court Report, 8(1), 15, 16. cooperation, legal, legislation, home education, sports, interscholastic activities "`A dream come true!' That is how some Oregon home schoolers reacted when learning about a law enacted recently by the Oregon State Legislature. Gary Lineburg, a home school parent, spearheaded the legislation to allow home schoolers to participate with public school students in interscholastic activities (competitions between schools in sports, music, debate, etc.) [sic-no period after close parenthesis]" p. 15. Available from Home School Legal Defense Association—see address herein.
Home School Legal Defense Association 1993, January/February Financially strapped school districts try to "enroll" home schoolers. Home School Court Report, 9(1), 5, 6. legal, law, money, finances, home education County departments of public education in California are encouraging local school districts to initiate independent study programs (ISP) that enroll the home educated. The public schools then receive the "Average Daily Attendance" money for that student. The article goes on to explain how "Some districts do not stop at offering an ISP; some are trying to intimidate [via correspondence and special items on forms completed by private schools] home schoolers into using their program" (p. 5).
Home School Legal Defense Association 1993, May/June DeJonges celebrate victory at Michigan Supreme Court. Home School Court Report, 9(3), 1, 2. law, legal, court, home education, religion, teacher certification Michigan Supreme Court voted (after the case being in litigation for eight years) "... to exempt families who home school due to their religious beliefs from the state requirement that students be taught by a state certified teacher" (p. 1). The court decided that Michigan school officials failed to show that teacher certification was the least restrictive means of ensuring that children are educated. This may prove to be the most significant home education case in the past twenty years history.
Home School Legal Defense Association 1994, April 26 Personal communication with Christy Farris, public relations director. Paeonian Springs, VA. Reports growth rate of HSLDA membership is in range of 15% to 40% per year last few years.
Home School Legal Defense Association 1994-1995 Home schoolers score significantly above national average. Home School Court Report, 10(6), 3. home education, research, academic achievement "... home-schooled students again scored significantly above the national average on standardized achievement tests administered during the spring of 1994. These latest group summary scores for grades kindergarten through twelve include the work of more than 16,000 children from all fifty states" [p. 3]. On average, they were at the 79th percentile in reading, 73rd in language, 73rd in mathematics, and the 77th in basic battery. 54.7% of these students were in the top quarter of the norm group. Data were analyzed by Dr. Brian Ray of the National Home Education Research Institute.
Home School Legal Defense Association 1996, September/October District of Columbia. Home School Court Report, 12(5), 9. minority, minorities, race, racial, urban, city, support “HLSDA has been working closely with leaders of Urban Homeschool Movement, an assemblage of families in and around the city dedicated to building a viable city-wide home school group. Affiliation is not limited to families in the city but is open to any home schooler who longs to see godly children raised at home by righteous families in the city. For more information on the Urban Homeschool Movement, contact Joyce Wardwick at 202-310-1934 (answering machine only)” [p. 9]. Personal communication to this author from Scott Somerville (12/10/96) of HSLDA regarding the Urban Homeschool Movement says, "White and black home schoolers in the DC metropolitan area have been meeting together since April, 1996 to find ways for the existing home school community in the suburbs to serve the newer generation of home schoolers in the city."
Home School Legal Defense Association 1998 School boards [in Kansas] target home schooling as bad public policy. The Home School Court Report, 14, 3, 15.
Home School Legal Defense Association 19mis?? [circa 1983] to present The Home School Court Report, 4(4). home education, law, legal Available from HSLDA, PO Box 3000, Purcellville VA 20134; President, Michael P. Farris. Informs home educators about current court cases on, issues regarding, and threats to home education. Uses the perspective of legal experts who are Christian. Provides opinions regarding specific issues.
Home School Legal Defense Association 1998, November/December Grand Junction [Colorado] recruits home schoolers. Home School Court Report, 15(6), 14. home education, law, policy, public school cooperation, public school Urges home school families to not participate in public-school or tax-funded home school programs. “As a matter of policy, HSLDA does not accept membership (or continue membership of) any student who participates in a public school outreach program where the school asserts primary authority over the child’s education. If the public school regards that student’s enrollment status as less than full-time, then, in order to obtain or retain membership status for the student, HSLDA must be assured that the parent is providing at least 51% of the student’s entire course of instruction and that the family’s home education program is free from government direction or supervision. Although HSLDA is open to families who participate in part-time programs of this sort, we strongly urge our member families to be cautious of them. Our experience across the states, in fact, has given us many good reasons to advise home schooling families to avoid the public schools altogether whenever possible. When something looks ‘to good to be true,’ it usually is.”
Home School Legal Defense Association 1999, January 14 750 colleges which have accepted home schoolers. Purcellville, VA: Author. home education, college admission, adults Lists colleges and universities that which have admitted students who were home educated.
Home School Legal Defense Association 2002, June 26 The Problem with Home-based Charter Schools: HSLDA's Position in the Charter School Debate. Published 6/26/02 and retrieved 8/5/02 online http://www.hslda.org/docs/nche/000010/200206260.asp. http://www.hslda.org/docs/nche/000010/200206260.asp home education, public education, school choice, charter schools, philosophy, politics, funding Explains why the HSLDA writes: “HSLDA encourages every home schooling family to be informed--know your U.S. and state constitutional rights, read your state home schooling law, and consider carefully the implications of a decision to enroll in a home-based charter school.” They say this because home-based charter schools (a) create a little public school in your home, (b) result in more profit for public schools, (c) limit parental freedom & brings regulation, (d) restrict religious freedom, and (e) have an adverse effect on private education because, “When individuals accept state funds for private activities, the distinction between the state and the private sphere is blurred, self-government is weakened, and the state is further unleashed from the bounds of law to intrude upon the personal lives of its citizens.”
Home School Legal Defense Association 2003, April 7 Michigan study recommends state regulation of homeschoolers. Retrieved 4/9/03 online http://www.hslda.org/hs/state/mi/200304070.asp. http://www.hslda.org/hs/state/mi/200304070.asp home education, law, philosophy, accountability, state control, state regulation, legal “The report observes that there are an estimated 100,000 "missing" students in the state of Michigan who are homeschooled by their parents without any state regulation. The report argues that Michigan has a constitutional responsibility to educate its children for the common good and that the current homeschool law does not allow the state to fulfill this responsibility: ‘[T]he lack of even minimal requirements conveys the message that parents are not accountable to anyone for their child's education.’ .....” “This [current Michigan] law, in addition to all other authority referred to above, clearly establishes that parents have the right to choose homeschooling. The burden to prove the family is not home educating is carried by the school district. The homeschool families are presumed to be fulfilling this law unless the school district has probable cause or credible evidence that they are not.” “Contrary to the opinion of some, research demonstrates that there is no positive correlation between state regulation of home schools and performance of homeschool students. According to Dr. Brian Ray, president of the National Home Education Research Institute, the degree of governmental regulation has no significant effect on the academic performance of homeschoolers.”)
Home School Legal Defense Association 2003, June 6 Federal court insists charter schools are "public schools." Retrieved 6/27/03 online http://www.hslda.org/hs/state/oh/200306060.asp. http://www.hslda.org/hs/state/oh/200306060.asp
Home School Legal Defense Association 2003, July 17 The growing black homeschool movement. Retrieved 8/10/07 online http://www.hslda.org/docs/hshb/46/hshb4614.asp. http://www.hslda.org/docs/hshb/46/hshb4614.asp minorities, black, African American
Home School Legal Defense Association 2004 Rating colleges & universities by their home school admission policies. Retrieved 5/28/04 online http://hslda.org/docs/nche/000002/00000241.asp. http://hslda.org/docs/nche/000002/00000241.asp
Home School Legal Defense Association 2007, February Home school issues in the 110th Congress. Issues Analysis, February 2007. Retrieved 5/28/07 online http://nche.hslda.org/cap/110th_Congress_Handout.pdf. http://nche.hslda.org/cap/110th_Congress_Handout.pdf home education, policy, legal, No Child Left Behind Act [NCLB] Discusses the federal The No Child Left Behind Act [NCLB] and reports the following: “No provision in NCLB shall be construed to affect any private school that does not receive funds under the Act, or to affect any home school.”
Home School Legal Defense Association 2009 Research on domestic and custody cases involving home schooling. Retrieved 6/17/09 from https://www.hslda.org/docs/nche/issues/c/custodyresearch.pdf. https://www.hslda.org/docs/nche/issues/c/custodyresearch.pdf home education, legal, law, family law, custody, domestic law Packet comprised of an overview of relevant research such as homeschool children’s academic achievement with parents who are not certified teachers, court case decisions, et cetera. Written and developed from an advocacy of homeschooling position.
Home School Legal Defense Association 2009 Respondent's [Romeike] pre-hearing brief in support of asylum or withholding of removal. Retrieved March 16, 2015 from https://www.hslda.org/hs/international/Germany/RomeikeBrief.pdf. https://www.hslda.org/hs/international/Germany/RomeikeBrief.pdf homeschooling, legal, Germany, rights, philosophy, asylum “In the 2003 Konrad case, the German Federal Constitutional Court reasoned that Germany may legitimately suppress the homeschooling movement because "[t]he general public has a justified interest in counteracting the development of religiously or philosophically motivated 'parallel societies' and in integrating minorities in this area" (p. 2).
Home School Legal Defense Association 2010, May 14 Brief of amicus curiae Home School Legal Defense Association, Christian Home Educators of New Hampshire, and Catholics United for Home Education in support of Petitioner, in the matter of Martin Kurowski and Brenda Kurowski, State of New Hampshire Supreme Court, Record No. 2009-0751. Purcellville, VA: Author. home education, homeschooling, family law, legal, custody, divorce, religion, philosophy A significant court cased related to homeschooling and divorce and child custody decisions makes it to a state supreme court. Research and other information is cited. Religion is an obvious factor.
Home School Legal Defense Association 2013 Summary of [homeschool] laws. Retrieved August 17, 2013 from www.hslda.org. Purcellville, VA: Home School Legal Defense Association. http://www.hslda.org
Home School Legal Defense Association 2016, September 9 Homeschool market survey. Presentation at national homeschool leadership conference, Asheville, North Carolina. homeschooling, home schooling, home education, demographics, reasons, HSLDA Studied homeschoolers nationwide (pretty sure a representative sample) and members of HSLDA. Nationwide, found 4 groups: (1) Educated Educators 17% OF HOMESCHOOLERS, gave as important reasons for homeschooling, teach moral values (46.4%), and were (.17x.46=8% of all say teach moral values); Values Oriented Conservatives 31% of all, 95.6% report a desire to teach moral values (.31x.96=30% of all) and 67% report religious instruction (.31x.67=21% of all); (3) Driven to Alternatives 15% of homeschoolers, Estimate religious instruction at 10-40% (.15x.25=4% of all); (4) Stretched and Searching 37% of homeschoolers, Teaching moral values (29% .37x.29=11% of all), and religious instruction (5.8%) were lower in this segment compared to all other segments (.37x.06=2% of all); teach moral values = about 72% of all homeschoolers, and religious instruction = about 32% of all homeschoolers.
Home School Researcher 1985 to present Brian D. Ray, Editor, National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Research. Quarterly publication for dissemination and review of information related to the research of home education. Includes statistics and technical information. Scholarly, refereed journal; probably only publication of its kind.
Homeschool Alumni Reaching Out & Coalition for Responsible Home Education 2015, February 1 A Complex picture: Results of a 2014 survey of adult alumni of the modern Christian homeschool movement, installment 2: demographics. Retrieved January 27, 2022 from https://responsiblehomeschooling.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/haro-survey-1.pdf . https://responsiblehomeschooling.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/haro-survey-1.pdf homeschooling, home education, research, survey, criticism, negative, adults, graduates of homeschooling, attitudes, values, beliefs, child abuse, abuse Is based on data collected in Stollar, 2014, A complex picture: …” Survey research on graduates of homeschooling who were raised in Christian homes. Examines demographics, attitudes toward having been homeschooled, practicing homeschooling with their children, sexuality, social services, and more. The study is totally descriptive within the non-random and non-representative (of homeschool graduates) sample of adults (p. 4). Presents many demographic and descriptive statistics; e.g., gender ratio, what percent were satisfied with the educational instruction they received. Majority report not having experienced abuse in childhood. “About a quarter of respondents (23%) consider spanking a child to be inherently abusive. (Figure 43)” (p. 28). “Figure 41: Frequency of types of abuse typically defined in state law, % of respondents who experienced this type of abuse; Emotional abuse 30.0%, Educational neglect 17.0%, Physical abuse 16.2%, Economic abuse 8.9%, Sexual abuse 4.8%, Medical abuse 4.3%” (p. 27).
Homeschoolingbackgrounder.com 2020 What is homeschooling? Retrieved October 9, 2020 from www.homeschoolingbackgrounder.com http://www.homeschoolingbackgrounder.com homeschooling, definitions, theory “Homeschooling is parent-directed, family-based education. Parent-directed means the parents have deliberately chosen to take responsibility for the education of their children, controlling both the education process and the curriculum (course of study). Family-based means the center of educational gravity is the home, with other resources being secondary. Parents may choose to partner with other homeschooling parents in cooperatives or support groups to provide portions of the education. They may also choose to have others assist in the education process (such as grandparents, older siblings or tutors like music teachers).”
Honawar, Vaishali 2000, June 2 H-O-M-E schooling spells a winner. The Washington Times. Online http://www.washtimes.com/metro/default-20006222527.htm, retrieved 6/2/00. http://www.washtimes.com/metro/default-20006222527.htm academic achievement, national competition, home education “Home-schooled students Thursday [6/1/00] won the top three spots in the National Spelling Bee, one week after the first-place winner had placed second in the National Geography Bee.” “Of the 248 participants in this year's spelling bee, 27 were home schoolers, up from 19 last year, and 178 were from public schools.” Raises interesting questions about why homeschoolers do well disproportionately compared to their numbers; i.e., only about 1% to 2% of school children are homeschooled but 11% of these contestants were homeschooled.
Hood, Mary 1994 The relaxed home school: A family production. Westminster, MD: Ambleside Educational Press.
Hood, Mary 1997 The joyful home schooler. Cartersville, GA: Ambleside Educational Press.
Hood, Mary 2002 The enthusiastic home schooler. Cartersville, GA: Ambleside Educational Press.
Hood, Mary E. 1991 Contemporary philosophical influences on the home schooling movement. Home School Researcher, 7(1), 1-8. Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. home education, philosophy, essentialism, progressivism, perennialism, and existentialism Analyzes books, magazines, workshop materials, and curriculum resources in order to determine the nature of the philosophical ideas influencing the home schooling movement. Associates Gregg Harris and The Teaching Home magazine with essentialism, Raymond Moore with progressivism, Charlotte Mason proponents with perennialism, and John Holt with existentialism.
Hood, Mary E. 1998, May 22 “More like a family, less like a school.” Presentation at the Florida Parent Educators Association’s Annual Florida Homeschool Convention. Talks about and advocates “relaxed home schooling” rather than attempting to recreate institutional, structured schooling at home.
Hood, Mary Krueger 1990 Contemporary philosophical influences on the home-schooling movement. Unpublished doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, University of Alabama at Birmingham.
Hoogh [de Hoogh], Simone 2007, Fall Home-education: A successful educational experiment? Mensa Research Journal, 38(3), 35-39. home education, talented, gifted, special needs
Hoover-Dempsey, Kathleen V., & Sandler, Howard M. 1997 Why do parents become involved in their children’s education? Review of Educational Research, 67(1), 3-42. education, parental involvement, research, conventional schools Includes in introduction, “Across a range of studies, there has emerged a strong conclusion that parental involvement in child and adolescent education generally benefits children’s learning and school success (e.g., ... [several references given])” (p. 3). Review psychological theory and research critical to understanding why parents become involved in their children’s elementary and secondary education. Posits that three major constructs are central to parents’ basic involvement decisions: (1) parents’ beliefs about what they are supposed to do in their children’s education, (2) parents’ sense of efficacy deals with the extent to which parents believe that they can exert positive influence on children’s educational outcomes through their involvement, and (3) parents’ perceptions that the child and school want them to be involved. Many programs designed to increase parental involvement will fail if these three factors are not successfully addressed.
Hoppert, Marguerite Brown 1980 The design and evaluation of the education component of a Home Base program. Dissertation Abstracts International, 41(1), 95A.
Hornick, Joshua 1993 Science instruction of home schooled teenagers. Home School Researcher, 9(1), 1-10. home education, research, interviews, qualitative, science education Used interviews to explore the science learning of these teenagers; "My principal finding was that parents do not teach science to their teenage home schoolers; the home schoolers teach themselves or are taught by some other source. Knowing this, the important issue is no longer, `Does the parent have enough background in science to teach it well?,' which was a major concern to the mother in Family #3 (whose oldest child was 13, so she may not have realized that her son would soon be teaching himself). The issue becomes, "Does the parent know how to (1) support inquiry, (2) encourage curiosity, and (3) locate resources?" (p. 7, 8)
Hornick, Joshua 1993, May Science instruction of teenagers in home schools. Unpublished manuscript presented to School of Education, The City College, The City University of New York. home education, qualitative research, science education Available from Joshua Hornick, 147 W. 95th Street Apt. 3 F, New York NY 10025-6649 Qualitative research finds that "...by the time homeschoolers are teenagers, their parents no longer teach them science; they learn it on their own or from non-parental sources. ..... Parents continue to play an important role in encouraging curiosity, providing resources, and allowing the homeschooler to have adequate flexibility in her schedule to pursue scientific investigation. Home teachers' background in science does not seem to be an indicator of the quality of the methodology used in their teenage homeschoolers' science education" [p. 47, 48].
Horsburgh, Fergus Bruce Norman 2005 Homeschooling within the public school system. Master’s thesis, Simon Fraser University, British Columbia, Canada. homeschooling, public school at home, public schooling, voucher, policy, public schooling, funding Recognizes the tensions and conflicts associated with parents wanting to be in control of their children’s education while also wanting public tax funding to support their home-based public schooiling that the parents want to call homeschooling. Finds also that the school districts want the tax funds they get for enrolling these students and are therefore willing to not require all parents to follow all the rules in order to get them as customers. Finds that some public school districts do not require parents to follow all the rules or regulations. Points out that some individuals and organizations (e.g., HSDLA of Canda) are opposed to public-funded “homeschooling” and warn that it brings the control of the state into the home. “This tendency [“… that school districts sometimes skirt around the formal ministry mandates”] could be motivated by the very real need to retain parents, and therefore the per-pupil funding that goes along with them” (p. 101).“Parents mentioned these relaxing of rules in a positive way” (p. 93). “Abstract: Homeschooling through the public school system is a relatively new trend in education. This qualitative study focuses on the experiences of six families participating in public school homeschooling programs in British Columbia, Canada. (Parents were interviewed and the interviews were recorded with transcripts becoming the primary data for this research.) Parents' motivations for homeschooling through the public system, rather than homeschooling on their own, are centered on financial advantages, in terms of refunds, and on support and guidance from trained teachers. Parents perceive public school classrooms negatively. Lack of attention to individual learning styles, large class-sizes, grade-aged groupings, teacher style, and negative socialization in and outside of the classroom are common criticisms. Conclusions of the study include suggestions for teachers and program organizers. The wider community, including different aged children, mentors, and elders are commonly viewed as unused resources” (p. iii). “School districts would be wise to steer a course that takes into consideration the needs and concerns of parents who show every willingness to go to the district that best meets their needs. Efforts should also be made to learn from the experiences of hoemschoolers and possibly discover new tools, strategies, and directions for change in a system seen by many as needing reform” (p. 113).
House, E. Wayne. (Ed.) 1988 Schooling choices: An examination of private, public, and home education. Portland, OR: Multnomah Press.
Houston, Robert, & Toma, Eugenia 2003 Home schooling: An alternative school choice. Southern Economic Journal, 69(4), 920-935. https://www.jstor.org/stable/1061658 https://www.jstor.org/stable/1061658 http://econpapers.repec.org/ homeschooling, barriers, demographics, law, legislation “Abstract: There is a fairly large, evolving literature on school choice. This literature addresses the factors that influence the choice between schools in the public and private sectors. Overlooked by this literature, however, is the growing segment of school enrollment in home schools. This article empirically examines the decision to educate children at home. The empirical results suggest that the decision to home school depends on the expected quality of schooling the home unit can produce relative to that available from alternatives. More specifically, our results indicate that women's educational attainment helps explain home school enrollment, that greater heterogeneity of income within a public school district increases home enrollment, and that stricter regulations [barriers] decrease home school enrollment” (retrieved February 12, 2016 from http://econpapers.repec.org/) Find that homeschooling frequency is influenced by the degree of female educational attainment in an area. Examine whether the decision to home school is affected by state laws requiring home school students to have their achievement assessed by standardized exams and find that there are fewer home school students in states which mandate testing.
Howard Center for Family, Religion, and Society 2003 The natural family. Retrieved 3/21/03 online http://www.profam.org/thc/thc_tnf.htm. http://www.profam.org/thc/thc_tnf.htm family, society, sociology, philosophy “The Howard Center for Family, Religion, and Society believes... the natural family is the fundamental unit of society; that it is the basis of all healthy and progressive civilizations. The best definition of the natural family we know of because we helped to craft it) comes from the second World Congress of Families gathering. ‘The natural family is a man and woman bound in a lifelong covenant of marriage for the purposes of: the continuation of the human species, the rearing of children, the regulation of sexuality, the provision of mutual support and protection, the creation of an altruistic domestic economy, and the maintenance of bonds between the generations.’ Our use of the term ‘natural family’ is significant in many respects. First, the term signifies a natural order to family structures that is common across cultures, historical, and overwhelmingly self-evident. Second, the term signifies a wholly defensible expression. ‘Natural’ is not ‘nuclear,’ which would limit its scope, nor is it ‘traditional,’ which would burden its utility in public discourse. It is what it is, a totally self-evident expression. Third, the term ‘natural’ precludes incompatible constructs of the family as well as incompatible behaviors among its members. Fourth, the ‘natural family’ is a positive expression. It does not require a discussion of negative incompatibilities to define itself.”
Howard, J. Paul R. 2001 Cross-border reflections: Parents' rights to direct their children's education under the U.S. and Canadian constitutions. Education Canada, 41(2), 36-37. ERIC Document No. EJ643756. http://www.eric.ed.gov http://www.eric.ed.gov/ compulsory education; constitutional law; court litigation; elementary secondary education; foreign countries; homeschooling, home schooling; parent rights; parochial schools; public education; united states history Author does not indicate how he thinks the Supreme Court of Canada should rule regarding parents’ rights regarding directing a child’s education and upbringing. “What is most disappointing, however, is that in the only case [in Canada] where the issue of whether a parent has a liberty right under s. 7 to educate his child as he thinks fit was squarely placed before the Supreme Court of Canada for consideration, a majority of that Court avoided the thorny question altogether. In Jones v. The Queen, the accused, a pastor of a fundamentalist Christian church, who educated his own and other children in his church’s basement, was accused of violating Alberta’s compulsory education provisions because he had not obtained from the local school board or the provincial Department of Education the proper exemption available for instruction in the home setting or private schools. ….. The notion that parents should have a constitutionally protected right to direct their children’s education has many intriguing consequences, such as, if the state cannot prohibit a parent from sending a child to a private, parochial or alternative school does that also necessarily mean that the state must fund those placements; the implications of the Pierce line of reasoning for the school voucher debate; and, more fundamentally, whose right is this anyway - the parent’s or the child’s? But none of these or other contentious issues will ever be addressed if our courts adopt a “decide-only-if necessary-and-duck-if-possible” demeanour” (p. 37). “Abstract: The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that a state law compelling a child's attendance at a public school constitutes a violation of the parent's liberty interest under the 14th amendment. In Canada, however, courts have held that their equivalent to the 14th amendment does not encompass the liberty of parents to choose how to educate their children” (retrieved 7/16/13 from http://www.eric.ed.gov).
Howell, Charles 2003 Justice, inequality, and home schooling. Home School Researcher, 15(3), 1-9. home education, philosophy, policy, political science Presents what is at issue in the debate about homeschooling and privatization. Philosophical analysis trace the logic that leads people from factual claims to conclusions about how we ought to live and how children ought to be educated.
Howell, Charles 2005 Parental duty and the shape of the future. Home School Researcher, 16(3), 1-14. home education, research, philosophy, sociology, history, legal, state control, parental rights Argues that parents have more at stake than does society in the “Cultivation—encouraging belief, modeling action, pointing out consequences …” (p. 12) of their children’s lives, and that in cultivating them parents exercise thoughtful decision making about the short-term good of their children and strategic thinking about long-term consequences of their educational decisions for their children, their families, and society at-large.
Howell, Charles 2011 Who, if anyone, should support homeschooling? A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 8-12, 2011, New Orleans, Louisiana. home education, research, homeschooling, paradigms, sociology, politics, public schools Uses Thomas Kuhn’s concepts of “normal science” and scientific revolutions to understand the resistance of professional educators to homeschooling. “To explain the resistance to homeschooling, one needs to take a step beyond ideology into a research arena sometimes referred to as science studies or social studies of science. This research program, which dates back to Kuhn in the mid-1960’s, takes as its central premise that scientific inquiry cannot be viewed as the pure embodiment of [p. 1 ends] hypothetico-deductive reasoning, but in addition reflects the social structure in which scientists are embedded, which enables certain aspects of inquiry and constrains others. In other words, science is not disinterested inquiry, but rather an inquiry shaped and directed by the concerns of human actors and reflective of their beliefs and desires” [p. 2]. “There is considerable evidence that the dismissive attitudes Ray [2011] criticizes are attributable to the continued strength of longstanding assumptions by educational researchers about what is worth studying and how it should be studied—that is to say, by a dominant paradigm in a period of normal science. The research Ray cites is criticized because it does not fit the established research paradigm: samples are not truly random, confounding variables are not properly controlled for, homeschooling inevitably entails self-selection. Even when these objections are refuted, however, homeschooling is simply not relevant to many of the questions that preoccupy researchers, funding agencies, dissertation directors, and university personnel committees: for example, how to use class [p. 2 ends] time to foster improved student learning, how best to involve parents in school activities, how to reorganize schools to enhance student achievement, how to improve rates of attendance. One of the characteristics of normal science is that it is self-reinforcing. That is, it generates a social structure that provides powerful incentives for conformity. Some of these incentives for conformity to the dominant paradigm of educational research are obvious: for example, teaching in schools is a licensed occupation, and can thus generate income streams to universities. Homeschooling cannot. Schools are more expensive than homeschooling, and can thus support hosts of professional experts and managers. Schools require enormous public expenditure and thus require public supervision and control. Homeschooling does not” [p. 3]. “Within the education profession, under the dominant paradigm, hardly anyone. For education professionals, public education works—not, necessarily, in generating optimal learning outcome for students, but definitely in generating salaries, tenure lines, grant funding, research problems, publication opportunities, and conferences in hospitable locations. From a purely hypothetico-deductive standpoint, education professionals ought to be very interested in homeschooling. From a practical standpoint, however, except for a few outliers like the people in this room, it’s hard to see how it could be considered a worthwhile investment of their time. Luckily, Kuhn assures us, dominant paradigms don’t last forever. Those of us who recognize the potential of homeschooling need to start shaping the next one. To do so successfully, we need to be acutely aware of the existing research supporting the current paradigm, and not start from the assumption that it is misguided or no longer [p. 6 ends] relevant. Despite the ideological shortcomings of those who oppose or dismiss homeschooling, the new paradigm will need to acknowledge and accommodate the findings of their research” [p. 7].
Howell, Judy R. 1989 Reasons for selecting home schooling in the Chattanooga, Tennessee vicinity. Home School Researcher, 5(2), 11-14.
Howshall, Marilyn 1998 The lifestyle of learning approach. Available from Howshall Home Publications, PO Box 1750, Eatonville WA 98328.
Huber, Elaine 2004 Unexplored territory: Writing instruction in Pennsylvania homeschool settings, grades 9-12, part I. Home School Researcher, 15(4), 1-10.
Huber, Elaine 2004 Unexplored territory: Writing instruction in Pennsylvania homeschool settings, grades 9-12, part II. Home School Researcher, 16(1), 1-13.
Huber, Lois Elaine 2002 Unexplored Territory: Writing instruction in Pennsylvania Homeschool Settings, Grades 9-12. Doctoral disseration (Ph.D.), Indiana University of Pennsylvania, The Graduate School and Research, Department of English. home education, research, writing, instruction, language arts “This exploratory, descriptive study investigates the nature of the writing instruction that Pennsylvania's parents offer the high school level students they homeschool. Such knowledge is significant for several reasons. First, during the 1999-2000 school year, Pennsylvania homesehool parents taught 1.1% of the state's students to write. Second, there is a dearth of information on high school level writing instruction in homeschools. The study conducts four focused inquiries related to such writing instruction: (a) what available research and data inform home-based writing, (b) how homeschool families are best characterized, (c) what living accommodations, learning structures, and writing practices homeschool families use, and (d) how family-specific living choices and teaching practices impact writing experiences and composing processes. Homeschooling is conceptualized as (a) a social movement formed around alternative educational interests, (b) a form of family-specific culture, and (c) a family-based system of private education. The data in this study originate from searches of little-known primary homeschool sources, participation in homeschool events, and informant interviews. Semi-structured topical interviews with seven parents and nine students detail each family's choice to homesehool, living and learning structures, and the relationships that facilitate learning to write. Student texts illustrate the "products" of that instruction. After rigorous analysis, the data of these primary sources, events, and interviews are reported as case study narratives that support four conclusions: (1) Homeschool writing instruction is a little-explored curricular activity. (2) Homeschool families are best characterized as social innovators, as customized social units, and as educational cooperatives that. integrate writing into their living and learning. (3) Homeschool families segregate or integrate their living and leaming and structure or relax their instruction in ways that develop the writing skills they value. (4) Homeschool living choices and teaching practices impact the range of writing that students experience and the sophistication of their composing processes. The exploratory nature of this study foregrounds the need for further focused research into a little-known curricular phenomenon” (abstract, p. iv-v).
Hudson, Kathi 1992 Reinventing America's schools, Volumes 1 and 2: A practical guide to components of restructuring & non-traditional education. Published by and available from Citizens for Excellence in Education, Box 3200, Costa Mesa CA 92628. educational improvement, reform, religious, religion Provides an evaluation of a "plethora of new ideas" that have been promoted for improving schooling; Volume 1 considers outcome based education, multiculturalism, school-based (site-based) management, length of school day/year, social services on campus (e.g., at-risk students and families, parenting training, home visitation programs, Parents as Teachers, early intervention, positive parental involvement and support); Volume 2 considers whole language, cooperative learning, interdisciplinary teaching methods, peer counseling, nongraded/ungraded classrooms, tracking, and reality math; Volume 3 considers holistic approaches, vocational education, assessment testing, and technology in the classroom; CEE's believes in helping children achieve academic success, develop godly morals, and understand the importance of traditional American values.
Hudson, Kathi 1993 Reinventing America's schools, Volumes 3: A practical guide to components of restructuring & non-traditional education. Published by and available from Citizens for Excellence in Education, Box 3200, Costa Mesa CA 92628. See Hudson, K., 1992).
Huerta, Luis A.; Gonzalez, Maria-Fernanda; & d'Entremont, Chad 2006 Cyber and home school charter schools: Adopting policy to new forms of public schooling. Peabody Journal of Education, 81(1), 103-139. http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1207/S15327930pje8101_6#.UdyYNvnbOSo homeschooling, not private homeschooling, public school at home, charter schools, virtual schools, policy, accountability “Abstract: Cyber and home school charter schools have silently become a prominent part of the charter school movement. These alternative school models differ from conventional schools by relying on parents and the Internet to deliver much of their curriculum and instruction while minimizing the use of personnel and physical facilities. This article examines how recent developments in California and Pennsylvania have resulted in public scrutiny of cyber and home school charters and led to considerable debate and demands for public accountability. Our findings outline the need to modify regulatory frameworks to accommodate cyber and home school charters, the consideration of the differing financial allocations for schools that operate with reduced personnel and facilities, and the division of financial responsibility between state and local educational agencies” (retrieved 7/9/13 from http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1207/S15327930pje8101_6#.UdyYNvnbOSo).
Huffman, Gilbert T. 1986 Teacher certification in home schools: Emerging constitutional issues. DAI, 48(2), 257A, 225pp.
Huggins, Shelly 2016 “Whatever it takes”: A case study of our child’s alternative path to literacy. Journal of Unschooling and Alternative Learning, 10 (20). Dyslexia, Alternative Education, Reading Interventions, homeschooling, home education “As public school educators, my husband and I struggled with making alternative academic choices for our child with learning differences. Choosing the alternative path was not easy or clear cut for us. This is a reflective record of the journey toward getting my son “Whatever it Takes” to help him learn. The article chronicles intuition about the early warning signs of learning differences.The article discusses the merits of the private school experience, the homeschooling experience and ultimately a modified and personalized learning plan that made learning natural, while preserving my son’s confidence, self-esteem and integrity. Detailed in the article are the discussions concerning the many educational, instructional and sociological decisions that are necessary to individualize instruction to meet an individual’s needs.” Peer-reviewed.
Hughes, Martin, Carmichael, Helen, Pinkerton, Gill, & Tizard, Barbara 1978 Recording children's conversations at home and at nursery school: A technique and some methodological considerations. Child Psychological Psychiatrist, 20, pp. 225-232.
Hull, Victor 1987 Home vs. classroom for some, schooling's a family job. Los Angeles Times, April 15, pp.1, 16-17.
Hunt, Rebecca N. 1996 Learning in the library: An assessment of library services to homeschoolers. Feliciter, 42(7-8), 62-69. http://www.eric.ed.gov homeschooling, academic achievement; educational philosophy, educational quality, home schooling, library instruction, library services, misconceptions, outreach programs, parent participation, public libraries, religious factors, socialization, user needs Appears friendly toward homeschooling. “Abstract: This paper seeks to dispel misconceptions about home-schooled children--that they are brainwashed, poorly socialized, or receive poor education. Public libraries can serve the needs of this user group by increasing staff awareness of both the Christian and the "unschooling" philosophical camps, keeping communication lines open about collection policy, or arranging for bibliographic instruction and other special programs. (LAM)” (retrieved 7/11/13 from www.eric.ed.gov, ERIC No. EJ529776). Feliciter is a national magazine dedicated to serving the Canadian library and information services community (of Canada). (information), youth, Canada
Hunt, Sara E., 2002 American compulsory schooling and American freedom. Purcellville, VA: Home School Legal Defense Association.
Hunt, Thomas C., & Carper, James C. 2007, October 25 Don't make public schools a state church: Education, like religion, must be a matter of freedom of conscience. Christian Science Monitor. Retrieved December 11, 2007 from http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/1025/p09s02-coop.htm. http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/1025/p09s02-coop.htm philosophy, education, public school, law, policy, home education, compulsory attendance, compulsion, taxation “Americans would revolt if the government forced them to join a state-established church. They guard too fiercely their liberty of conscience, guaranteed by the First Amendment. Yet when some parents choose not to submit their children to the government-operated school system – whose curriculum and culture embody beliefs and values with which they disagree – they still must pay taxes to support the system. Even then, they often face opposition. We contend that the conduct of schooling in the United States should be determined by the rights of conscience of parents, in accord with the democratic nature of our society and our confessional pluralism. Parents who choose not to send their children to public schools should not be subject to harassment. Nor should they be forced to support the state system as well as their preferred educational arrangement. . . . . . Most recently, a small but rapidly growing number of parents, a majority of whom are conservative Christians, have chosen to educate their children at home. Holding to the proposition that parents have the primary right to direct the education of their offspring, a right affirmed by the Supreme Court several times since the landmark Pierce v. Society of Sisters decision of 1925, they are the most radical dissenters yet. Like earlier dissenters, most home-schooling families believe the public school system transmits an orthodoxy alien to their belief system. As a matter of conscience, they feel bound to provide an education congruent with their worldview. And like other dissenters from earlier state churches and the current functional equivalent, the public school system, these parents have had to pay taxes to support a government-privileged institution as well as the costs of the education they prefer, been occasionally harassed, and sometimes hauled into court. . . . . . The role of government in a democracy should be to see that the public is educated, not to mandate, directly or indirectly through financial policies, one particular form of education. When the government privileges a specific set of propositions of knowledge and dispositions of value and belief, it has established the educational equivalent of a state church. Such an arrangement is just as incompatible with liberty of conscience, as were the established churches of America's early history.”
Hunt, Thomas C., & Carper, James C. (Eds.) 1993 Religious schools in the United States K-12: A source book. New York, NY: Garland Publishing, Inc. religion, schools, denomination, research, home education, history Contains annotated bibliographies of the various schools: "Christian" denominational [North American Calvinist, Seventh-day Adventist, Roman Catholic, Quaker, Amish/Mennonite, Christian day schools, Episcopal, Lutheran], Greek Orthodox, Jewish, Black Muslim, and home education [by Brian D. Ray], and an annotated bibliography of the question of governmental relation to these schools from 1985 to 1992; each chapter begins with a historical overview essay
Hunter, R. 1994, September The home school phenomenon. Unicorn, 20(3), 28-37. home education, history Outlines resurgence of home education as an alternative form of full-time educational delivery. Examines its relatively rapid growth within Australia and elsewhere over the last decade through individual homeschools supported, in some cases, by networks of home educators is examined. Addresses dilemmas and opportunities these developments have provided for both home educators and formal education supervisors or authorities are also addressed.
Hunter, Roger 1995 The home education phenomenon: Paradoxes of individualization and internationalization. Paper presented at The Comparative and International Education Society, 39th Annual Meeting, 1995. mailto:r.hunter@edn.gu.edu.au home education, homeschooling, Australia, international, history, policy Presented by Roger Hunter, Faculty of Education, Griffith University, Brisbane, Australia 4111, r.hunter@edn.gu.edu.au “Abstract: This paper outlines the resurgence of home education as an alternative form of full-time educational delivery, with relatively rapid growth within western societies over the last decade. ….. Dilemmas and opportunities …”
Hurlbutt, Karen 2011 Experiences of parents who homeschool their children with autism spectrum disorders. Focus on Autism and Other Developmental Disabilities, 26(4). autism, developmental disabilities, homeschooling, Peer-reviewed journal “Abstract. Teachers may be inadequately prepared for the increasing number of students being identified with autism spectrum disorders (ASD), as students with ASD may not respond to traditional methods of instruction. Some parents of children with ASD are concerned with educational programming available through public school systems and are turning to homeschooling. Ten parents from nine families participated in this qualitative study to share their experiences, opinions, and perceptions of homeschooling as compared to instruction in public school settings. Four themes emerged from the data analysis, along with one overarching theme. The 10 parents who homeschool their children with ASD believe they have found a treatment plan that works, and their perception has been that the school has been either (a) not willing and/or (b) unable to provide effective programming. An unexpected finding was that homeschooling goals and interventions varied across the families.” Peer-reviewed journal
Huseman, Jessica 2015, February 17 The Rise of Homeschooling Among Black Families: African American parents are increasingly taking their kids' education into their own hands—and in many cases, it's to protect them from institutional racism and stereotyping. Retrieved February 17, 2015 from http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2015/02/the-rise-of-homeschooling-among-black-families/385543/. http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2015/02/the-rise-of-homeschooling-among-black-families/385543/ homeschooling, Black, African American, news, home education, minorities “Marvell is one of an estimated 220,000 African American children currently being homeschooled, according to the National Home Education Research Institute. Black families have become one of the fastest-growing demographics in homeschooling, with black students making up an estimated 10 percent of the homeschooling population. (For comparison’s sake, they make up 16 percent of all public-school students nationwide, according to the National Center for Education Statistics.)”
Ice, Christa L., & Hoover-Dempsey, Kathleen V. 2011 Motivations for involvement and student proximal achievement outcomes in homeschooling and public schooling settings. Education and Urban Society, 43(3) 339–369. homeschool, home education, parental involvement, reasons, motivations “Abstract: A notable increase in the number of U.S. families choosing to homeschool their children in recent years has underscored the need to develop more systematic knowledge about this approach to education. Drawing on a theoretical model of parental involvement as well as research on families’ social networks, this study longitudinally examines home- and public-school parents’ motivations for home-based involvement in their fourth through eighth grade children’s education at two time points. The study also examines whether involvement activities predicted student proximal achievement outcomes (academic self-efficacy, intrinsic motivation for learning, and selfregulatory strategy use) across the two groups. Results suggest that parental self-efficacy for involvement, specific invitations from the child, and parent social networks are positively related to home-based parental involvement across the groups, although home- and public-school parents recorded significantly different perceptions of personal self-efficacy, role activity beliefs, social networks, and child proximal achievement outcomes. Findings are discussed with reference to implications for future research and practice” (p. 339).
IdeaSpektrum 2007, March 7 Ein in Deutschland verbotenes Erfolgsmodell. IdeaSpektrum, Number 10, p. 21-22. Published by www.idea.de. http://www.idea.de Germany, homeschooling, home education, interview, international Author interviews a US expert, Brian Ray. Article is in German; interviewer was Mr. Mockler.
Illich, Ivan 1974 Deschooling society. In William Van Til (Ed.), Curriculum: Quest for relevance, 2nd ed.. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin Co., 432 p. School criticism.
Indiana State Teachers Association 19960-1997 Resolutions of Indiana State Teachers Association, 1996-1997. Indianapolis, IN: Author. The Indiana State Teachers Association (ISTA), an affiliate of the NEA, believes “... that a child’s educational and social development is best taught in a public school setting ...” and not in home schooling (p. 168). Furthermore, home school students “... should participate in state or locally mandated testing programs in suitable settings and in other assessments conducted by the school district” (p. 168). Institute for Research on Educational Finance and Governance (IFG). (1982). Choice in education: are tuition tax credits the answer? IFG Policy Notes and Policy Perspectives, 3(1) [Winter 1982]. (Available free from: Assistant Director of Dissemination, IFG--CERAS Building, Stanford University, Stanford CA 94305-1691; very interesting series of 2-page papers by various educators; titles are : "Uniformity and diversity," "Private vs. public," "The public interest in education," "A legal dilemma," "Understanding the private sector," "Issues of equity," "Sorting students into schools," "Public support, public regulation," "Comparing public and nonpublic schools," "Factors influencing choice," "Is there a private school advantage?," "What will it cost?," "Public support for nonpublic education," "The future under tuition tax credits," "Should we agree to go?"
Inhelder, B., & Piaget, J. 1958 The growth of logical thinking from childhood to adolescence A. Parsons & S. Milgram, Trans.). New York, NY: Basic Books, Inc.
International Dyslexia Association 2012 Why homeschool a student with dyslexia? Author: Baltimore, MD. Retrieved March 16, 2017 from https://dyslexiaida.org/homeschooling-fact-sheet/ https://dyslexiaida.org/homeschooling-fact-sheet/ homeschooling, home education, dyslexia, special needs “Homeschooling has emerged as a viable choice for many families. Homeschooling may also be an option for a child with dyslexia. A student with dyslexia requires direct, systematic, and individual instruction in reading and spelling, and traditional schools do not always provide adequate levels of service. Moreover, services may be offered at the expense of subjects in which a child with learning disabilities may excel such as art, sports, or music” (p. 1). “What are some of the benefits of homeschooling? The most obvious benefit is that homeschooling allows for the necessary individualization in all subject areas, including reading, spelling, composition, and comprehension. It allows a student to focus on areas of interest and allows parents to develop lessons based on those interests. The homeschooled child is free from measuring progress and skills against peers without learning differences. A child can work at an individualized pace in a program that directly addresses unique needs. Homeschooling may provide an alternative to the premium on speed, conformity, and rigid scheduling and standardized testing that is required in many traditional educational settings. Homeschooling for children with and without dyslexia allows for enriching experiences on a daily basis: cooking, music, field trips, and hands-on learning. In many locations, homeschooling parents have formed support groups so the homeschooling experience becomes socially rewarding for students and parents. A skilled carpenter may, for example, offer carpentry lessons to children in exchange for Spanish lessons by a native speaker. Many homeschoolers argue that traditional schooling in a room of twenty to thirty students and one or two adults can be more socially [p. 1 ends] isolating for a child than a home education program that makes good use of local resources” (p. 1-2).
Iowa Home Educators Association, 1990 Proven to work Home Education. A pamphlet covering topics such as: Scholastic Achievement, Socialization, Children's Welfare, Factors to consider. Using various studies and references to extol home education.) Home Education, Achievement, Excellence
Isenberg, Eric 2006 The choice of public, private, or home schools (Occasional Paper No. 132). New York: National Center for the Study of Privatization in Education, Teachers College, Columbia University. review, switching, part-time homeschooling, homeschooling Some of this paper is published in Isenberg, 2007. See findings on part-time homeschooling or switching to/from homeschooling to/from public school or private school in Isenberg (2007).
Isenberg, Eric J. 2007, June What have we learned about homeschooling? Peabody Journal of Education, 82(2&3), 387 – 409. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/01619560701312996#d1e143 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/01619560701312996#d1e143 home education, research, reasons for homeschooling, academic achievement, population size; review, switching, part-time homeschooling, homeschooling “[Abstract] “This article discusses quantitative research on homeschooling, including the available data, pitfalls of using the data, estimates of the number of homeschooled children, part-time homeschooling, and why families homeschool. I compare research on homeschooling to research on charter schools, voucher programs, and private schools.” Posits that, from a research perspective very little is really known about homeschooling. Provides an inadequate literature review and totally ignores significant research that has been done over the past 25 years. For example, does not include a major US Department of Education study that was published three years before publication date of this article. Also, for example, claims that no data exist on the academic achievement of the home educated that are worth considering, while ignoring several useful studies on the topic. Offers interesting analysis on correlates of choosing to homeschool one’s children (e.g., religious beliefs, school-age sibling in household, household income. Summarizes self-reported reasons for homeschooling found by National Household Education Survey in previous studies. “Families who homeschool a child tend to send that child to school in other grades, use conventional schools concurrently with homeschooling, or send other children to school (Isenberg, 2006). Pooling the 1996 and 1999 data, 55% of homeschooling households with more than one school child [p. 397 ends] sent at least one other child to school. For households with three or more children, the distribution of children homeschooled is bimodal, with peaks at one child and all children. Families who self-report homeschooling for religious reasons are much more likely to homeschool all their children.16 Some children are homeschooled part-time and attend school part-time. Combining data from the 1999 and 2003 NHES, 21% of homeschooled children also attended a school. Most attend for few hours per week; very few homeschooled children attend school for the majority of their schooling hours (Bielick et al., 2001; Isenberg, 2003a). Lines (2000) discussed some cooperative programs between school districts and homeschoolers. In addition, there is a high degree of attrition. The 1996 NHES collects data on homeschooling in past years for focal children who are either currently homeschooled or currently enrolled in school. There is a large quit rate in homeschooling after the 1st year;only63%ofhomeschooledstudents continue to the 2nd year. After that, annual survival rates are much higher, with point estimates ranging from 73% to 94% for Years 2 to 6. Religious homeschoolers quit at lower rates than secular homeschoolers. By the end of 6 years, 15% of secular homeschoolers are still homeschooling. Even among religious homeschoolers, attrition decreases their numbers significantly, so that only 48% are still homeschooling after 6 years (Isenberg, 2006)” (p. 397-398).
Isenhour, James K. April 7, 1995 The future of homeschooling, a featured panel. Panelist at the Annual Global Village Schools National Conference, Atlanta, GA, April 5-8, 1995. home education, future, technology, computers Focused on the use of technology in distance learning by home educators and private, correspondence, and umbrella schools with whom they interact.
Jabine, Angie 1987 Homemade schools. Willamette Week, 13(45), p. 1, 8-12.
Jackson, Daniel 2012, February 21 Muslim families turn to home-schooling. The Washington Times. Retrieved February 22, 2012 from http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2012/feb/21/muslim-families-turn-to-home-schooling/?page=all#pagebreak. http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2012/feb/21/muslim-families-turn-to-home-schooling/?page=all#pagebreak homeschooling, home education, Muslims, Islam, religion, reasons ““Discussion with home-school leaders across the nation indicates that the number of Muslims in home-schooling is expanding relatively quickly, compared with other groups,” said Mr. Ray, who speculated that part of the rise could be attributed to the growth — and increased confidence — of the American Muslim population in general.” “Ms. Ndiaye said that the Muslim home-school movement is still in its “infancy,” following the path blazed by evangelical Christian practitioners, who make up more than 70 percent of the U.S. home-school population. Home-schoolers in general tend to excel academically, performing 15 to 30 percentile points higher on standardized tests than students in public schools, according to National Home Education Research Institute. “The Muslims looked at that and said, ‘We can do those same things,’ ” she said.”
Jackson, Glenda 2008 Australian home education and Vygotskian learning theory. Journal of Australian Research in Early Childhood Education 15(1). home education, research, Vygotsky, Vygotskian learning theory, Australia, teaching and learning practices Abstract: “An analysis of 'Australian home education and Vygotskian learning theory' investigates the practices of Australian home educators in light of Vygotskian learning theory. Australian home education research began in 1978 when a young teacher used his home to offer an education program based on progressive ideals (Ennis 1978). Since that time, research on Australian home education has continued. A review of available Australian home education research literature indicates that the practices used in home educating families generally reflect many of the best practices for learning as expounded by Vygotskian theorists such as Vygotsky, the Neo-Vygotskians, as well as Rogoff, Lave and Wenger. A review of the literature on Vygotskian theories of learning and the connections to known Australian home education.”
Jackson, Glenda 2009 More than one way to learn: Home educated students’ transitions between home and school. Unpublished doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Monash University, Clayton. http://arrow.monash.edu.au/hdl/1959.1/83110. http://arrow.monash.edu.au/hdl/1959.1/83110 home education, public school, transition, into and out of On student transitions into and out of home education.
Jackson, Glenda 2016 Australian home educated students on self-regulation opportunities at home and in school. Cogent Education, 3(1). home education, home–school, homeschool, self-regulation, self-direction, socialization, agency, autonomy, historical sociocultural theory, self-determined learning, student voice, adults Qualitative research methods. “Abstract; Self-regulation is a core life quality and human right in democratic societies. The views and experiences of Australian students who had transitioned between home education and conventional schools were sought to explore the similarities and differences between two educationally diverse systems. Through qualitative research using guided interview questions these students were asked to identify similarities and differences in their experiences of home education and conventional schooling that were then analysed through grounded theory and interpreted through historical sociocultural theory. Students identified and highly valued three types of opportunities for self-regulation while learning at home, which were not available to them while attending conventional schools. Cultural differences between home and conventional schools were identified as major contributing factors to these different opportunities to engage in self-regulation. This research illustrates ways conventional schooling could learn to develop more effective programmes to achieve this highly valued characteristic from home education practices and better prepare students for an engaged and effective adult life.”
James, Heather 1985 Home schooling: Ancient axiom recently revived. (Available from author, 21 LaCassie Ct., Walnut Creek, CA 94596.)
James, Kay C. 1996, February Transforming America. Imprimis, 25(2), 1-5, 7. sociology, education, politics, philosophy, it takes a village Explains that an old African proverb says: “It takes a village to raise a child.” Many social planners are repeating this proverb. James says the village is, presumably, a collaboration of all the different segments of society gathering around an innocent baby to protect him, teach him, and love him. These segments of society would include both institutions and groups of people. James claims, however, three fundamental problems arise with the use of the African proverb. “First, children do not belong to the village or to the community or to the government. They belong to parents and the village exists as a resource for these families. Second, even if we did believe this to be true, the village no longer exists. And third, what the village liberals seek to build is, in truth, simply big government” (p. 1).
Jasper, William F. 1997 The voucher trap: What government subsidizes it controls. New American, 13(15), 52-53. school choice, voucher, vouchers Posits that any educational program that is subsidized by tax money will be controlled, to one degree or another, by the government.
Jeglic, Elizabeth L.; Calkins, Cynthia; Kaylor, Leah; Margeotes, Krystyn; Doychak, Kendra; Blasko, Brandy; Chesin, Megan; & Panza, Nancy 2022 The Nature and Scope of Educator Misconduct in K-12. Sexual Abuse, 35 (2), https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/10790632221096421 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/10790632221096421 https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cga/public-school-enrollment sexual abuse, sexual maltreatment, sex abuse, public schools, teachers, educator, school “Abstract: Educator sexual misconduct is a serious problem in the United States (U.S.), with a 2004 Department of Education report estimating that 9.6% of K-12 students in the U.S. had experienced either verbal, visual, or physical educator misconduct at some point during their school career. However, since that report almost 20 years ago, there have been few large-scale studies examining the extent of the problem. As such, the current study, which uses a large sample from recent high school graduates in four U.S. states, offers updated data on the nature and scope of sexual misconduct in educational settings. Overall, 11.7% of the 6632 participants reported having experienced at least one form of educator sexual misconduct during Grades K-12, with 11% reporting sexual comments and less than 1% reporting other forms of sexual misconduct (e.g., receiving sexual photos/messages, being kissed, touched sexually, or engaging in sexual intercourse/oral sex). Those who reported misconduct showed significantly more difficulties in current psychosocial functioning than those who did not report educator misconduct. Academic teachers most often perpetrated the abuse (63%), followed by coaches and gym teachers (20%). Educators who engaged in sexual misconduct were primarily male (85%), whereas students who reported experiencing educator misconduct were primarily female (72%). Rates of disclosure to authorities were very low (4%) and some sexual grooming behaviors like gift giving (12%) and showing special attention (29%) were reported. These findings will be discussed as they pertain to the prevention of sexual misconduct within educational settings.” The 11.7% would be about 5,800,000 public school students in 2022 (11.7% of 49.6 million https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cga/public-school-enrollment ) ?
Jenkins, T. P. 1998 The performance of home schooled students in community colleges. Doctoral dissertation, Texas A & M University-Commerce. home education, research, college, graduates, adults, academic achievement, success Finds full- and parcommunity college homeschool students’ average first-year GPAs higher than non-homeschool graduates and homeschool graduates outperform peers in reading and mathematics on the Texas Academic Skills Program.
Jeub, Chris 1994 Why parents choose home schooling. Educational Leadership, 52(1), 50-52.
Jeynes, William H. 2000 The effects of attending a religious school on the academic achievement of children. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 27, New Orleans, Louisiana. private school, religious schools, public schools, academic achievement Using 1992 NELS data and statistical controls for background variables, “... those children attending religious schools performed better academically than those who did not. The students attending religious schools included all private religious schools included in the [NELS] study. ..... The results also indicate that black and Hispanic students, as well as children of low socioeconomic status, performed better academically in religious schools than in non-religious schools. These results suggest that students attending religious schools, in general, perform better academically than students attending non-religious schools” [p. 2]. “The results support the notion that religious schools benefit children to an extent that significantly surpasses any explanations that can be attributed to racial and socioeconomic factors alone” [p. 10].
Jeynes, William H. 2005, May A meta-analysis of the relation of parental involvement to urban elementary school student academic achievement. Urban Education, 40(3), 237-269. ERIC Document Reproduction Service Number EJ690782. academic achievement, elementary schools, parental involvement Peer-reviewed journal. “Results indicate a significant relationship between parental involvement overall and academic achievement. Parental involvement, as a whole, was associated with all the academic variables by about 0.7 to 0.75 of a standard deviation unit. This relationship held for White and minority children and also for boys and girls” [abstract, ERIC].
Jeynes, William H. 2007 The relationship between parental involvement and urban secondary school student academic achievement: A meta-analysis. Urban Education, 42(1), 82-110. ERIC Document Reproduction Service Number EJ748034. academic achievement, secondary schools, parental involvement Peer-reviewed journal. “The results indicate that the influence of parental involvement overall is significant for secondary school children. Parental involvement as a whole affects all the academic variables under study by about 0.5 to 0.55 of a standard deviation unit. The positive effects of parental involvement hold for both White and minority children” [abstract, ERIC0].
Johnson, Burke 2001 Toward a new classification of nonexperimental quantitative research. Educational Researcher, 30(2), 3-13, https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X030002003 https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X030002003 https://doi.org/10.3102%2F0013189X030002003 research methodology, research design, nonexperimental quantitative research, peer-reviewed Explains various nonexperimental research designs that are common to homeschool research. Helpful to homeschool researchers in planning and understanding research on home-based education. Peer-reviewed.
Johnson, Kathie Carwile 1991 Socialization practices of Christian home school educators in the state of Virginia. Home School Researcher, 7(1), 9-16. Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
Johnson, M. K., & Amundsen, C. 1983 Distance education: A unique blend of technology and pedagogy to train future special educators. Unpublished manuscript, University of Alaska, Anchorage.
Johnson, Meg Home Education Resource Center Newsletter. P.O. Box 124, Mt. Vernon, NH 03057.
Johnson, Phillip E. 1995 Reason in the balance: The case against naturalism in science, law, and education. Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press. education, curriculum, philosophy, religion, law, science Lays out argument that the established religious philosophy of America is naturalism or modernism (or metaphysical naturalism [p. 170], scientific naturalism, or liberal rationalism) [p. 37]. “Naturalism is a metaphysical doctrine, which means simply that it states a particular view of what is ultimately real and unreal. According to naturalism, what is ultimately real is nature, ..... [p.37] To put it another way, nature is a permanently closed system of material causes and effects taht can never be influenced by anything outside of itself--by God, for example. ..... Naturalism gives priority to natyural science as a way of describing reality ...” [p. 38]. Explains that modern college and public school curriculum is based on naturalism [ch. 8].
Johnson, Sarah Anne 2010 A descriptive analysis of homeschooling children with autism. Master’s (M.A.) thesis, California State University, Sacramento, California. homeschooling, autism, reasons “Abstract: ….. As the rates of autism have continued to increase, it is speculated that there may be more families who choose to homeschool their children with autism and related disorders, although the exact number is unknown. There are no statistics showing the number of families who homeschool their children with autism. The purpose of the study is to analyze homeschooling children with autism from the parent perspective including the overall parental perception of homeschooling a child with autism, the reasons for homeschooling, the benefits, and the challenges [p. v ends]. Sources of Data Twenty-nine participants from California and thirteen participants from out–of state were recruited through three main sources: California regional centers, the California Homeschool Network, and Internet support groups. Data were collected through a survey utilizing open and closed ended questions sent via the website Survey Monkey. Findings and Conclusions Reached The current study found that parents chose to homeschool their child with autism due to an overall dissatisfaction with the school district. Within the theme of dissatisfaction, seven main categories were found: concerns with the appropriateness of placement; a perceived low level of support from the school; dissatisfaction with quality; a lack of progress; mistreatment by students or staff; the desire for religious or moral based instruction; and multiple reasons. Benefits to homeschooling a child with autism were found to be similar to parents who homeschooled children without developmental delays. Challenges varied and included finding the right type of socialization, financial difficulties with one parent staying home, and lack of free time for the parent homeschooling. The researchers concluded that parents who homeschool their children with autism are a unique subgroup within the homeschooling population and community. They may have less free time than typical parents and more financial difficulties; however, they believe that they are giving their children the best education possible. Additional research is needed to examine how services are delivered to children with [p. vi ends] autism and how school districts respond to parents when they feel the district does not have a placement that meets their child’s individual needs” (p. v-vii).
Johnston, Mary 1957 Roman life. Chicago, IL: Scott, Foresman and Co. General and readable study of life styles in both Roman Empire and Republic; chapters on family life, children, and education.
Jolly, Jennifer L., & Matthews, Michael S. 2018 The shifting landscape of the homeschooling continuum. Educational Review, 72(3), 269-280. https://doi.org/10.1080/00131911.2018.1552661 https://doi.org/10.1080/00131911.2018.1552661 Homeschooling, informal education, gifted education, framework “Abstract: In 1988, Van Galen proposed two distinct categories to describe homeschooling parents – ideologues and pedagogues. Her model has been widely cited in the homeschooling literature. In the 30 years since the introduction of these identifiers, homeschooling in the United States has experienced tremendous growth due to a number of intersecting contextual and societal events, which suggests a need to re-examine Van Galen’s initial binary categories. Education reform, enacted through standards-based curriculum and assessment, school choice presented as a mechanism to improve the educational experiences of the country’s most vulnerable students, greater acceptance of homeschooling as a legitimate school choice, and the diversification of families choosing homeschooling as an alternative to traditional forms of K–12 schooling have all contributed to homeschooling’s explosive growth and a corresponding need to revisit homeschooling’s conceptual framework. This article proposes an enhanced framework for defining homeschooling, which better reflects the what of school and how of schooling that contemporary homeschooling families employ.”
Jolly, Jennifer L.; Matthews, Michael S.; & Nester, Jonathan 2013 Homeschooling the Gifted: A Parent’s Perspective. Gifted Child Quarterly, 57(2), 121-134. http://gcq.sagepub.com/content/57/2/121.short homeschooling, research, gifted and talented, reasons, challenges, public schools “Abstract: Homeschooling has witnessed a dramatic growth over the past decade. Included in this population are gifted and talented students, yet despite this growth there has been no appreciable increase in the research literature. To better understand the gifted homeschooling family, researchers interviewed 13 parents of homeschooled children their parents identified as being gifted. Four major themes emerged from the data: (a) parents know best, (b) isolation, (c) challenges, and (d) family roles. Findings reveal that these parents decided to homeschool only after numerous attempts to work in collaboration with the public school and that the mothers bore the primary burden of responsibility for homeschooling in these families. Though the move to homeschooling alleviated many of the issues experienced in public school, it brought a different set of challenges to these families. This exploratory study establishes a better understanding of why parents of gifted children ultimately decide to homeschool” (retrieved 7/8/13 from http://gcq.sagepub.com/content/57/2/121.short
Jones, Dylan 1990, December 11 More parents turn their homes into classrooms. USA Today, 8D.
Jones, Erika 2010 Transition from home education to higher education: Academic and social issues. Home School Researcher, 25(3), 1-9. Retrieved 3/4/2010 from http://www.nheri.org/Volume-25-Issue-3/Transition-from-Home-Education-to-Higher-Education-Academic-and-Social-Issues.html. http://www.nheri.org/Volume-25-Issue-3/Transition-from-Home-Education-to-Higher-Education-Academic-and-Social-Issues.html home education, research, adults, college success, socialization, academic achievement “The target population included all undergraduate students from a 4-year Christian university in Southern California. The 215 study participants were volunteer undergraduate students who attended the same institution. The sample was categorized into three subsample groups based on the number of years a student attended a public, private or home school” (p. 2). “Abstract: The purpose of this study is to understand academic and social attitudes among undergraduates who have been home educated as primary or secondary students and to learn from their transition to university. A comparative study of 215 undergraduates was conducted in 2005, via questionnaires, to determine if academic and social differences exist between university students who have been previously home educated versus their conventionally schooled peers who attended public or private school. This report concentrates on a subsample of 28 undergraduates who were home educated for at least seven years. The focus of this report considers their educational background, their attitudes toward home education, their readiness for university, and their perceived level of academic and social success as undergraduate students in comparison to their peers. Although not statistically significant, findings indicate the home-educated subsample achieved superior scores on standardized college entrance tests, maintained a higher cumulative grade point average in university studies and were more socially involved in campus activities than the public and private school subsamples. Yet, results also show areas for growth among the home-educated subsample—they felt slightly less confident than their peers when writing term papers, delivering speeches and indicate they shied away from class discussion at a higher rate. Despite this slight disadvantage during their transition to university, the home-educated subsample felt they adjusted to college life at relatively the same rate as the public school subsample.”
Jones, Paul 2007, Fall First year college performance: A study of home school graduates and traditional school graduates. Mensa Research Journal, 38(3), 62-65. home education, talented, gifted, special needs
Jones, Paul, & Gloeckner, Gene 2004, Fall A study of admission officers’ perceptions of and attitudes toward homeschool students. Journal of College Admission, No. 185, 12-21.
Jones, Paul, & Gloeckner, Gene 2004, Spring First-year college performance: A study of home school graduates and traditional school graduates. The Journal of College Admission, No. 183, 17-20. home education, research, college, graduates, adults, academic achievement, success “The samples for this study consisted of 55 first-year, degree seeking, home school graduates who enrolled in Colorado four-year public college or universities from 1998 to 2000. Once the home school sample was identified, a random sample of 53 traditional high school graduates (public, private, parochial, etc.) who met the same criteria of the home school sample and matched by the home school institution (n = 53)” (p. 18). It was a matched-sample design. “Although not statistically significant, the average first-year GPAs, credits earned in the first year, ACT Composite test scores, and ACT English, Mathematics, Reading, and Science and Reasoning subtests for home school graduates were all higher than traditional high school graduates. Although the sample was relatively small, the ACT Composite test score results for home school graduates was an average of 22.8, which matched identically to the national average in 2000 for home school students (ACT 2000). The national average for all students in 2000 was 21, which was nearly identical to the 21.3 average for the traditional high school graduate. Found no significant differences on any dependent variables. The academic performance analyses indicate that home school graduates are as ready for college as traditional high school graduates and that they perform as well on national college assessment tests as traditional high school graduates” (p. 20).
Jones, Paul, & Gloeckner, Gene 2007, Fall First-year college performance: A study of home school graduates and traditional school graduates. Mensa Research Journal. http://www.mensafoundation.org/Sites/foundation/NavigationMenu/Publications/Journal/Samplearticle/SampleArticle.htm home education, research, college performance, college students, academic achievement [Reprint of Jones & Gloeckner 2004 in The Journal of College Admission]. Retrieved October 29, 2009 from http://www.mensafoundation.org/Sites/foundation/NavigationMenu/Publications/Journal/Samplearticle/SampleArticle.htm. “Although not statistically significant, the average first-year GPAs, credits earned in the first year, ACT Composite test scores, and ACT English, Mathematics, Reading, and Science and Reasoning subtests for home school graduates were all higher than traditional high school graduates. Although the sample was relatively small, the ACT Composite test score results for home school graduates was an average of 22.8, which matched identically to the national average in 2000 for home school students (ACT 2000). The national average for all students in 2000 was 21, which was nearly identical to the 21.3 average for the traditional high school graduate. The academic performance analyses indicate that home school graduates are as ready for college as traditional high school graduates and that they perform as well on national college assessment tests as traditional high school graduates. The results of this study are also consistent with other studies on the academic performance of home school students compared to traditional high school graduates (Galloway 1995, Gray 1998, Jenkins 1998, Mexcur 1993). These results also suggest that a parent-guided K-12 education does not have a negative effect on a student’s college success.”
Jones, Richard A. 2008, February 27 Wrapping up the school choice challenge. Retrieved February 28, 2008 from http://www.americanvision.org/articlearchive2008/02-27-08.asp. http://www.americanvision.org/articlearchive2008/02-27-08.asp home education, public schools, private schools, philosophy, religion, Christianity Writes from a biblical, conservative, perspective.
Jones, Thomas N. & Semler, Darel P. 1986 School law update, 1986. Topeka, Kansas: National Organization on Legal Problems of Education. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED272991). Court Litigation, Government School Relationship, School Law
Jorgenson, Tina Marie 2011 Homeschooling in Iowa: An investigation of curricular choices made by homeschooling parents. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, University of Iowa. Available February 20, 2014 from http://ir.uiowa.edu/etd/1235/. http://ir.uiowa.edu/etd/1235/ homeschooling, home education, curriculum, Iowa, language arts, math, public schools, religion, regulation, demographics Presents a fair and dispassionate description of the findings and of homeschooling. Is relatively neutral about whether the state should regulate homeschooling more, as indicated by the following: “While requiring curricula to be monitored would increase the accountability of home school families, there has been no study to date that has found a significant link between the level of state regulation and home school students’ academic achievement” (p. 78). Implies she thinks that state/public schools are somehow responsible for the education of homeschool students with the following: “The findings from this study suggest that the home schooling movement will continue to be an important factor for Iowa school systems. Therefore, it is important that all school personnel be aware of the nature of the home schooling movement given that the responsibilities of educators do not end at the classroom door but extend to those being educated at home as well” (p. 83). “Abstract: Parents and caregivers across the nation are seeking ways to restructure education and provide new opportunities for their children. Among the alternative educational options, home schooling seems to be at the forefront. The research pertaining to home schooling is growing; however, there are still areas that need considerable attention. The purpose of this study was to investigate selected aspects of home schooling, also known as Competent Private Instruction (CPI) in Iowa, mainly the choice of curriculum and factors associated with that choice. The current study examined (a) the demographic characteristics of the selected population, (b) the type of curriculum used by home schooling families, (c) demographic characteristics associated with the type of curriculum chosen, (d) the adoption of a faith based curriculum, and (e) the demographic characteristics associated with the adoption of a faith based curriculum. Primary data were obtained for 4 of 12 area educational agencies (AEAs) in Iowa for the school years 2003-2004 and 2004-2005 from information provided on Form A, which was required by the Iowa Department of Education to be completed by home school families. These data were grouped into regions for easier comparisons. Results of the data analysis indicated that the demographic characteristics of the selected population were similar to those reported in national studies. Parents primarily chose a prepackaged curriculum for both reading and math instruction, and the majority of the curriculum in all areas was largely faith based. In addition, the region of Eastern Iowa was significantly more faith based than the Western or Central region. No significant interactions were found between age, gender, or days of instruction and the type of curriculum or the adoption of a faith based curriculum” (p. 1). “The results of the current study indicated that the majority of families (84.5%) chose to use a prepackaged curriculum overall for their home school lessons. When looked at independently for reading and math, the same results were found, with 72.5% of families choosing a prepackaged curriculum for reading and 94.6% using one for math. According to Gold and Zielinski (2009), prepackaged curriculum has traditionally been the most popular choice by home school families. However, these results differ from those obtained over 10 years ago in which Ray (1997) [in a nationwide study] found that 71% of home school families designed their own curricula, compared to 24% who used a complete curriculum package. The results indicating that more home school families chose prepackaged curricula over custom designed curricula could be due to the increase in materials available for home school families from various publishing companies” (p. 77).
Joudry, Patricia 1975 and the children played. New York, NY: Tundra Books, 174 p.
Justice, Georgina 2025 Latinx families homeschooling: A community cultural wealth analysis of parent involvement. Journal of Latinos and Education, 1–17. https://doi.org/10.1080/15348431.2025.2550740 https://doi.org/10.1080/15348431.2025.2550740 Homeschooling, Latinx education, parent involvement, Community Cultural Wealth, home education, Latino, Hispanic “Abstract: With rates of homeschooling similar to those of the general population, Latinx parents in the United States choose to homeschool their children for a range of reasons. This qualitative study with 3 interview and 32 survey participants reveals how Latinx parents draw on Community Cultural Wealth in their practice of homeschooling. Bringing Latinx families into the conversation as active and engaged participants in the movement of home education, this study highlights how Latinx homeschooling parents act from a position of strength, from the aspirations they have for their children, and with their cultural and linguistic resources.”
Kabiri Laura S.; Mitchell K.; Brewer W.; & Ortiz A. 2018 How healthy is homeschool? An analysis of body composition and cardiovascular disease risk. Journal of School Health, 88(2):132-138. Retrieved February 5, 2019 from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/josh.12588 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/josh.12588 homeschool, home schooling, child and adolescent health, community health, physical fitness and sport, physical education, physical fitness Cross-sectional descriptive study of a convenience sample of only homeschool children. “The purpose of this research was to describe the body composition of elementary school-aged homeschool children, assess their corresponding risk of CVD [cardiovascular disease], and determine any factors related to CVD risk among this population” (p. 135). “ABSTRACT; BACKGROUND Public school children regularly participate in school‐based physical activity, physical education, and fitness testing. However, almost 2 million American children are homeschooled. The purpose of this research was to assess the body composition of elementary school‐aged homeschool children and their corresponding cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk. METHODS This research explored the body composition and CVD risk of 145 homeschool children aged 5–11 years using body mass index (BMI), percent body fat, and waist circumference. Chi‐square and Mann‐Whitney U tests examined differences in CVD risk within the homeschool population. RESULTS Overall, homeschool children had average BMI z‐scores (SD [range]) with a mean of −0.11 (0.97 [−3.47 to 2.53]). Unhealthy classifications were seen in 11.2% of the sample by BMI, 19.6% by percent body fat, and 49.7% by waist circumference. Statistical analysis revealed no difference in CVD risk between sexes (χ2(1) = 0.062, p = .804) or ethnicities (χ2(1) = 0.927, p = .336) but increased prevalence in children aged 5–9 years (U = 1427, z = −4.559, p < .001). CONCLUSIONS Almost half of elementary school‐aged homeschool children showed increased risk for CVD and need regular assessment of central adiposity” (p. 132). Cross-sectional descriptive study design, not explanatory or predictive or causal-comparative, so should not assign any causation or “risk” to homeschool schooling type versus public school or private school or the general population. Authors discuss a given percent of homeschool students in this or that risk category but there are no comparative data with non-homeschool students. For example: “This increased central adiposity resulted in almost half of the sample being classified as increased risk for CVD” (p. 136). Fittingly, the authors wrote: “Future studies should determine the same risk for CVD as measured by waist circumference in the public school population as well” (p. 137); despite this recommendation, however, authors then went on with confusing language that implied that home-educated children are at-risk compared to non-homeschool children: “… homeschool children show increased risk of CVD secondary to high levels of central adiposity regardless of BMI or fat mass. Due to the increased prevalence of CVD risk as measured by waist circumference among this population, homeschool children …” (p. 137).
Kabiri, Laura S.; Brice, Kendall R.; Rodriguez, Augusto X.; Perkins-Ball, Amanda M.; & Diep, Cassandra S. 2020 Health-related fitness in homeschool versus public school adolescents. American Journal of Health Education, 51(2). Retrieved February 19, 2020 from https://doi.org/10.1080/19325037.2020.1713261 https://doi.org/10.1080/19325037.2020.1713261 homeschooling, homeschool, public school, health education, physical fitness, physical education, health, peer-reviewed, comparison Cross-sectional, descriptive study (p. 2). “Abstract. Background: Despite the known benefits of physical fitness in adolescence, the growing and at-risk homeschool adolescent population has been largely overlooked in current research. Purpose: The purpose of this study was to compare health-related fitness including body mass index (BMI), cardiorespiratory fitness, and muscular fitness between homeschool and public school adolescents. Methods: Homeschool adolescents ages 12–17 years (n = 66) completed the Progressive Aerobic Capacity Endurance Run (PACER), curl-up, and 90° push-up portions of the FitnessGram® to assess cardiorespiratory fitness as well as abdominal and upper body strength and endurance. T-tests and chi-square tests were used to compare results to public school children (n = 66). Results: There was no significant difference in BMI between groups. Homeschool adolescents had significantly lower cardiorespiratory fitness and abdominal, but not upper body, strength and endurance. They also showed significantly lower health classification rankings in cardiorespiratory fitness and upper body, but not abdominal, strength and endurance. Discussion: Homeschool adolescents showed significant deficits in health-related fitness that could negatively impact both current and future health. Translation to Health Education Practice: The homeschool community has a need for health education to address deficits in health-related fitness. This study can aid health educators in planning and implementing targeted, effective interventions in the future” (p. 1). Cross-sectional, descriptive study design. After obtained samples, then matched public school and homeschool students on age and sex to get n=66 pairs, so not a matched-pair explanatory or predictive or causal-comparative design. “This study illuminates health education needs in a growing and at-risk population. In short, homeschool adolescents showed significantly lower levels of cardiorespiratory fitness and both abdominal and upper body muscular fitness compared to their age and gender matched public school peers but no difference in body mass index. Thus, the homeschool community has a need for health education to address deficits in health-related fitness” (p. 5) but it is a cross-sectional descriptive, and not explanatory, study so authors’ methods and findings do not support the claim that homeschool students are at-risk compared to others.
Kabiri, Laura S.; Butcher, Allison; Brewer, Wayne; and Ortiz, Alexis 2019 Youth physical health and years in American homeschools: Are they related? Health Promotion International, 2019, 1–6. Available February 20, 2020 from https://academic.oup.com/heapro/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.1093/heapro/daz047/5492359 https://academic.oup.com/heapro/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.1093/heapro/daz047/5492359 homeschooling, home education, health promoting schools, physical fitness, physical education, health, health risk, children, adolescent, peer-reviewed, cross-sectional methods, risk, at-risk Cross-sectional descriptive study of a convenience sample of homeschool students. Abstract: “Homeschooling is a growing trend in the USA and abroad with both reported consequences and benefits to youth physical health. The purpose of this study was to examine whether changes in youth physical health could be related to the number of years a student spends in homeschool. Body composition (body mass index and body fat), muscular fitness (lower extremity, abdominal and upper extremity) and cardiorespiratory fitness (Progressive Aerobic Capacity Endurance Run) were assessed in 211 youth ages 5–17. Data analysis showed weak or non-significant relationships between years in homeschool and all aspects of youth physical health. Time spent in homeschool is weakly or not at all related to multiple aspects of youth physical health. Parents and policy makers should not be concerned with detrimental physical health effects of homeschooling on youth” (p. 1). “Perhaps most important, the lack of change in body composition classification over years spend in homeschool may indicate a corresponding lack of increased or decreased risk of cardiovascular disease (Sahoo et al., 2015). Our study found no significant relationship between years in homeschool and body composition when reported as BMI (rs ¼ 0.107, p ¼ 0.124) or %BF (rs ¼ 0.070, p ¼ 0.315)” (p. 4). “However, whether or not homeschooling impacts youth body composition positively, negatively or not at all, this study shows that the effect is unrelated or compounded over time” (p. 4). Authors used term “risk” as applied or not to homeschool students several times in the article in the literature review and elsewhere but then concluded: “Perhaps most important, the lack of change in body composition classification over years spend [sic] in homeschool may indicate a corresponding lack of increased or decreased risk of cardiovascular disease … Our study found no significant relationship between years in homeschool and body composition when reported as BMI [body mass index] …” (p. 4). Cross-sectional descriptive study, convenience sample.
Kabiri, Laura S.; Messineo, Ashley; Gattu, Nikhil; Ray, Brian D.; Iammarino, Nicholas K. 2021 Health-related physical fitness and activity in homeschool: A systematic review with implications for return to public school. Journal of School Health, 91(11), 948-958 https://doi.org/10.1111/josh.13080 https://doi.org/10.1111/josh.13080 physical activity; physical fitness; homeschool; health educator, home education, homeschooling, home schooling, peer-reviewed “Abstract: BACKGROUND The purpose of this systematic review is to summarize what is known about health-related physical fitness (cardiovascular endurance, muscular strength and endurance, flexibility, and body composition) and physical activity among homeschool youth. Findings from this study have implications for all American youth as they return to public school from mandated schooling at home during the COVID-19 pandemic. METHODS Database engines identified over 22,000 articles with 82 abstracts screened for further review. Of these, 18 full-text articles were additionally screened with 10 cross-sectional articles included in the final review. Articles were condensed into a standard review template and findings were summarized by topic. RESULTS Cardiovascular endurance findings were inconsistent. Abdominal, but not upper body, muscular strength and endurance were significantly lower in homeschool students. There were no reports on flexibility. Body composition was generally healthy in homeschool students and no differences in physical activity were seen. CONCLUSIONS Research on health-related physical fitness in homeschool youth is limited and descriptive. Further testing and potential remediation may be needed for cardiovascular endurance, muscular strength and endurance, and flexibility in homeschool youth and their public school counterparts as they return to campus. However, existing literature supports healthy body composition and physical activity in this population.”
Kabiri, Laura S.; Mitchell, K.; Brewer, W.; & Ortiz, A. 2017 Motor skill proficiency among homeschooled children. Journal of Motor Learning and Development, 5(2), 336-345. homeschool, home schooling, home education, motor development, pediatrics, sports, physical education, physical fitness, peer-reviewed journal probably This is a “… cross-sectional exploratory study …” (p. 338). “Abstract: Almost 2 million American children are homeschooled but no information is currently available regarding motor skill proficiency within this population. The purpose of this research was to describe motor skill proficiency among homeschooled children and assess differences in homeschooled subgroups. This cross-sectional study screened 73 homeschooled children aged 5–8 years for overall motor skill proficiency using the Bruininks-Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency, Second Edition, Short Form (BOT-2 SF). Independent t tests examined differences in motor skill proficiency within the homeschooled population. Mann-Whitney U tests examined differences in motor skill proficiency classification within significantly different subgroups. Homeschooled children demonstrated average motor proficiency. Significantly different motor proficiency was seen among homeschooled children participating in 3 or more hours of organized sports per week, t(71) = 2.805, p = .006, 95% CI = 1.77, 10.49, and whose primary caregiver was employed versus unemployed, t(71) = –3.875, p < .001, 95% CI = –13.29, –4.26. Mann-Whitney U tests revealed significantly different motor skill proficiency classification in these same subgroups. Overall, homeschooling showed no detrimental effect on motor skill proficiency. Participation in 3 or more hours of organized sports per week or having an unemployed primary caregiver may improve motor skill proficiency among this population.” Cross-sectional exploratory study.
Kabiri, Laura S.; Mitchell, Katy; Brewer, Wayne; & Ortiz, Alexis 2017 Muscular and cardiorespiratory fitness in homeschool versus public school children. Pediatric Exercise Science, 29(3), 371-376. Retrieved February 5, 2019 from https://journals.humankinetics.com/doi/pdf/10.1123/pes.2017-0028 https://journals.humankinetics.com/doi/pdf/10.1123/pes.2017-0028 homeschool, muscular fitness, cardiorespiratory, exercise performance, physical fitness, physical education This is a descriptive, cross-sectional study and not explanatory, predictive, or causal-comparative. “ABSTRACT Purpose: The growth and unregulated structure of homeschooling creates an unknown population in regard to muscular and cardiorespiratory fitness. The purpose of this research was to compare muscular and cardiorespiratory fitness between elementary school aged homeschool and public school children. Method: Homeschool children ages 8–11 years old (n = 75) completed the curl-up, 90° push-up, and Progressive Aerobic Capacity Endurance Run (PACER) portions of the FitnessGram to assess abdominal and upper body strength and endurance as well as cardiorespiratory fitness. Comparisons to public school children (n = 75) were made using t tests and chi-square tests. Results: Homeschool children showed significantly lower abdominal (t(148) = -11.441, p < .001; χ2 (1) = 35.503, p < .001) and upper body (t(148) = -3.610, p < .001; χ2 (1) = 4.881, p = .027) strength and endurance. There were no significant differences in cardiorespiratory fitness by total PACER laps (t(108) = 0.879, p = .381) or estimated VO2max (t(70) = 1.187, p = .239; χ2 (1) = 1.444, p = .486). Conclusion: Homeschool children showed significantly lower levels of both abdominal and upper body muscular fitness compared with their age and gender matched public school peers but no difference in cardiorespiratory fitness.” “The deficits seen in both upper body and abdominal muscular fitness indicate the potential for other health related differences among homeschool children, including increased risk for cardiovascular and cardiometabolic disease, decreased bone health, and lower self-esteem (28,2,27)” (p. 9) but this is a cross-sectional study so should not use the term at-risk.
Kabiri, Laura S.; Rodriguez, Augusto X.; Perkins-Ball, Amanda M.; & Diep, Cassandra S. 2019 Organized sports and physical activities as sole influencers of fitness: The homeschool population. Journal of Functional Morphology and Kinesiology, 4(1):1-8. Retrieved February 5, 2019 from https://www.mdpi.com/2411-5142/4/1/13 https://www.mdpi.com/2411-5142/4/1/13 sport; conditioning; physical activity; children; adolescents, homeschool, home education; physical education, physical fitness Cross-sectional descriptive study of only homeschool students. “Abstract: Homeschool children may rely solely on organized sports and physical activities to achieve recommended levels of physical activity and fitness. The purpose of this study was to investigate differences in fitness levels between homeschool children who did, and did not, participate in organized sports or physical activities, and then examine relationships between hours per week in sports or physical activities and cardiorespiratory fitness as measured by portions of the FitnessGram® test battery. Organized sports/physical activity participation information was gathered on 100 children ages 10–17 years who completed tests of upper, abdominal, and cardiorespiratory fitness. The current investigation revealed that participation alone was not associated with higher levels of physical fitness as assessed by the 90° push-up test or curl-up test nor was time in participation related to cardiorespiratory fitness as assessed by the Progressive Aerobic Capacity Endurance Run (PACER). These activities alone may be insufficient for meeting physical activity recommendations and improving physical fitness. Therefore, children and adolescents educated at home may need additional opportunities to participate in unstructured daily physical activity.” “Despite existing research on the benefits of participation in organized sports among children and adolescents, one population that has been overlooked in such research is homeschool children and adolescents, who may be at increased risk for cardiovascular disease and adiposity [19]” (p. 2) but authors do not apply the term at-risk or risk to homeschool students, and do not find that they are at-risk as compared to non-homeschoolers; compared two groups of homeschool students to one another. Cross-sectional descriptive study comparing two groups of homeschool children.
Kaestle, C. F. 1976 Conflict and consensus revisited: notes toward a reinterpretation of American educational history. Harvard Educational Review, 46, 390-396. Criticizes the argument that there is consensus about what public schools should be and what they should teach.
Kaestle, C. F. 1978 Social change, discipline, and the common school in early nineteenth century America. Journal of Interdisciplinary History, 9, 1-17. History of changing relationship between parents and teachers.
Kaestle, C. F., & Vinovskis, M. A. 1978 From apron strings to ABC's: parents, children, and schooling in nineteenth-century Massachusetts. In J. Demos & S. S. Boocock (Eds.), Turning points: historical and sociological essays on the family. American Journal of Sociology, 84, Supplement. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. History.
Kafai, Yasmin B.; Fishman, Barry J. & Bruckman, Amy 2002 Models of educational computing @ home: New frontiers for research on technology in learning. AACE Journal, 10(2), 52-68. Norfolk, VA: AACE. Retrieved 7/10/13 from http://www.editlib.org/p/10723. http://www.editlib.org/p/10723 schools, public schools, educational technology, computers, homes, family, homeschooling Do not include homeschooling students and families in this study but offer the following intriguing reference to homeschooling: “There is an additional area in which computers are used for education in the home that we have chosen not to address at length in this article: home schooling [homeschooling]. While it could be argued that home schooling represents a valid location for educational computing in the home, in this article we take the term “educational computing” to mean computing that is linked in various ways to learning that takes place in formal school settings. This is because schools face particular contextual constraints that home schooling does not deal with, such as large class size, limited length of school day and year, and so on. Computers have been suggested as remedies to many of the instructional challenges that schools face, and it is the more recent move to various forms of home-based computing linked to school-based instruction that capture our attention here. In other words, we look at the computer use at home as an extension of computer use in schools and examine ways these extensions may be accomplished. In this review, we pay attention to factors such as families’ socio-economic status and computer ownership, provision of computer hardware and Internet access, the curriculum integration, and the educational goals for the computer activities that have in the past been found to impact computer use at home” (p. 56). “Abstract: To date, the major emphasis of educational technology researchers has been the development and use of educational technologies within school settings. Noticeably absent has been research and considerations that focus on the home as a computer-based learning environment and potential connections between school and home learning. Given the increasing presence of computers in homes, the authors argue for an explicit research focus on the various ways that computers in homes can be used to create rich learning environments or extend school-based learning environments. To that end, this article discusses various models of educational computing in the home that are linked to learning in school, along with critical issues for consideration by researchers who choose to venture into this emerging area” (p. 52).
Kafer, Krista 2003 School choice 2003: How states are providing greater opportunity in education. Washington, DC: Heritage Foundation. Retrieved 8/26/03 online http://www.heritage.org/Research/Education/Schools/loader.cfm?url=/commonspot/security/getfile.cfm&PageID=45331. http://www.heritage.org/Research/Education/Schools/loader.cfm?url=/commonspot/security/getfile.cfm&PageID=45331 public schools, private schools, home education, policy, research Rod Paige, the 7th U.S. Secretary of Education, writes in his foreward, “The American people are demanding change: --More than half a million children are enrolled in roughly 2,700 charter schools nationwide --Approximately 2 million children are homeschooled; ....." [p. vii]. Includes statistics on traditional public schools, public charter schools, and private schools including enrollment, teacher-pupil ratio, number of schools, and other data; the newest results of the National Assessment of Educational Progress math, science, and reading tests and other academic indicators; and a snapshot of the history of school choice in each state updated regularly.
Kagan, J. 1977 The child and the family. Daedalus, 106, 33-56. History of family policy.
Kamarck, Elaine Ciulla, & Galston, William A. 1990, September 27 Putting children first: A progressive family policy for the 1990s. Washington, DC: Progressive Policy Institute. family, economic, education Available from publisher at 316 Pennsylvania Avenue, S.E., Suite 555, Washington, DC 20003 "Public programs cannot fully substitute for healthy families and should not try. Instead, government should work to stabilize families and to enhance their child-rearing capacity. ..... We present policies that support and compensate families as they carry out their critical social role--providing for the economic and moral well-being of children. As we will see, a large body of evidence supports the conclusion that in the aggregate, the intact two-parent family is best suited to this task. Making this premise our point of departure takes us towards policies that reinforce families and away from bureaucratic approaches that seek to replace family functions" (p. 2)
Kammann, Megan 2015 Homeschool regulation: Directive without direction. Master’s thesis, presented as partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Education (Research) of Murdoch University 2015. homeschooling, home education, regulation, policy, goals, objectives, academic achievement, testing “Abstract. Literature and first-hand accounts assert that home education and schooling are fundamentally different forms of education and that homeschooling has long been associated with positive educational outcomes. In 2012, the Western Australian School Curriculum and Standards Authority directed all Western Australian schools and home educators to begin implementing the Australian Curriculum (a Foundation to Year 10 syllabus specifying yearly-delineated content). Home educators received no explanation as to how they could apply such a detailed, fixed syllabus to their unschool-like settings and the only assistance offered came in the form of a reference to the official Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority website. The aim of this research is to determine how homeschooling parents perceive this directive, how (or if) they intend to satisfy its obligations and whether evidence suggests that superior educational outcomes are likely to result. It is argued that parents’ perceptions of homeschool requirements are of critical importance as accurate evaluation of home education is extremely difficult particularly if parents choose to eschew registration. A qualitative paradigm with an interpretive phenomenological emphasis was utilized to understand parents’ responses, actions and decisions. To this end, semistructured, in-depth interviews were conducted in March 2013 with thirteen home educators. Participants were recruited from Perth and south-west Western Australia using purposive and snowball sampling. The findings of this study indicate there is a wide disparity in parents’ willingness to adopt the Australian Curriculum into their homeschool settings. Some parents indicate an inclination to adjust the way they report educational experiences rather than to modify their actual practices. This study concludes that imposing a regulatory framework intended for mainstream schools onto home educating families actually restricts the use of flexible practices which have significantly contributed to the positive educational outcomes of homeschooled children in the past (p. iii).
Kane, Pearl Rock 2001 The state of private schooling in the United States. Monitor., 21(3), 7-14. private education/schooling, choice, home education schooling education In context of private and non-government schools, addresses diversity, faculty recruitment, school choice and competition, affordability, and the role of private education in public policy. In conclusion, writes, “Parents will always want their children educated with a particular religious or moral persuasion; and families will likewise desire a more personal and academically rigorous curriculum than is found in most public schools--and have the inclination and means to pay for it. Private schools serve the interests of such families, but they also serve the common good because a better-educated populace is in the best interest of a democracy” [p. 14].
Kane, Pearl Rock 2003 Choice and freedom [an interview of Milton Friedman by Pearl Rock Kane]. Education Next. Retrieved 6/27/03 online http://www.educationnext.org/20031/57.html. http://www.educationnext.org/20031/57.html “Right now, as a matter of fact, one of the biggest growth areas has been home schooling. There are more children being home schooled than there are in all of the voucher programs combined [says Friedman]. ..... Friedman: In a way that’s evidence of the failure of our current education system. There is no other complex field in our society in which do-it-yourself beats out factory production or market production. Nobody makes his or her own car. But it still is the case that parents can perform the job of educating their children, in many cases better than our present education system. I don’t know what other programs would emerge. Neither you nor I is imaginative enough to dream of what real competition, a real free market, could produce, what kind of innovations would emerge [says Friedman].”
Kane, Pearl Rock (Ed.) 1992 Independent schools, independent thinkers. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass Publishers.
Kanter, R. M. 1972 The organization child: experience management in nursery school. Sociology of Education, 45, 186-212.
Kantrowitz, Barbara, & Wingert, Pat 1998, October 5 Learning at home: Does it pass the test? Newsweek, 132(14), 64-70. Online http://newsweek.com/nw-srv/issue/14_98b/printed/cover/ed0114_1.htm http://newsweek.com/nw-srv/issue/14_98b/printed/cover/ed0114_1.htm home education, general, population size Cover story gives overview of the home schooling movement and present status. Provides glimpses into lives of several home school families. Discusses academic achievement, social activities, positive findings of research, concerns of critics, and growth of the movement. Says there are about 1.5 million K-12 home school students in the U.S. Quotes Brian Ray. “In a recent NEWSWEEK Poll, 59 percent of those surveyed said home-schooled kids were at least as well educated as students in traditional schools. ‘Home schoolers' image is not wacko, fringe, lunatic-type people anymore,’ says Brian Ray, president of the [National] Home Education Research Institute in Salem, Ore., a nonprofit group. ‘Today almost everyone knows a home schooler, so it's more socially acceptable." [p. 66] and cites research of the National Home Education Research Institute. Presents famous home educated persons. Fairly balanced report on home schooling.
Kantrowitz, Barbara, McGinn, Daniel 2000, June 19 When Teachers Are Cheaters: As the pressure to improve test scores increases, more administrators are fixing the numbers. Newsweek. [Online http://newsweek.com/nw-srv/printed/us/sr/a20927-2000jun11.htm, retrieved 6/12/00] http://newsweek.com/nw-srv/printed/us/sr/a20927-2000jun11.htm educational reform, standards, accountability, public schools “It's bad enough when kids get kicked out for cheating. But as the school year ends, an alarming number of teachers and principals face charges of fixing the numbers on high-stakes tests that determine everything from whether an individual kid gets promoted to an entire district's annual budget. Although there are no firm statistics, school officials agree that the problem has become much worse in the past few years as more states have adopted testing as a way to audit national and state educational standards. In theory, the exams ensure that teachers pass on the right lessons. The problem is that high scores—not high standards —have become the holy grail.
Kaplan, George R. 1994 Shotgun wedding: Notes on public education's encounter with the new Christian right (Special Report). Phi Delta Kappan, 75(9), K1-K12. education, religion, worldview Uses secular thinking to examine "... the new Christian Right's designs for and mindset with regard to education..." (p. K2). "Today's Christian Right is no ragtag mob of bumpkins, weirdoes, and snake handlers. Nor do its rank-and-file members feel comfortable with the assertion of Michael Farris, the Religious Right activist [and president of the Home School Legal Defense Association] who ran a strong but losing Republican campaign for the lieutenant governorship of Virginia in 1993, that public schools are a `godless monstrosity' and a `multibillion-dollar indoctrination machine'" (p. K2).
Kapplow, H. 1983 My home is my school. East-West Journal, September, 40.
Karman, Dick, & Karman, Dorothy 2002 Timeline of Oregon homeschool freedoms. Retrieved 3/12/03 online http://www.oceanetwork.org/publications/article.cfm?id=41. Portland, OR: Oregon Christian Home Education Association Network. http://www.oceanetwork.org/publications/article.cfm?id=41
Karoly, Lynn A. 2005 County-level estimates of the effects of a universal preschool program in California. Arlington, VA: Rand Corporation, Labor and Population. early childhood education, preschool, program, disadvantaged children, at-risk children Claims long-term financial benefits to the state for universal preschool program in California, based on one program study done in Chicago that author says showed long-term benefits to persons and the state.
Kaseman, Larry, & Kaseman, Susan 1991, January/February Does homeschooling research help homeschooling? Home Education Magazine, 26-27, 46-49. research, participation in research, home education, opinion Basically argues that individual families' testimonies are more effective in influencing policy makers than are research findings; raises warnings about home educators participating in research; seems to give too much credit to the ideas that researchers might have some kind of hidden motive to harm the home education movement or that participation in research will inadvertently cause home school families to be influenced by or become more like the conventional education system that they want to avoid. "There are two major reasons why homeschoolers should not participate in research: First, research poses a serious threat to homeschooling because it increases the opportunities for increased control and regulation of homeschooling. Second, even if research did not have serious risks, it still would not be the most effective way to communicate information about homeschooling to others. It is much more effective for homeschoolers to share their personal experiences, to show how well homeschooling works for their families, and how important it is that homeschooling exist as an alternative that is not controlled by conventional schools or the government" (p. 49).
Kaseman, Larry, & Kaseman, Susan 1993, May/June "We're the government and we're here to help you" The trouble with collaboration. Home Education Magazine, 10(3), 20-25. home education, cooperation, collaboration, government Warns home schoolers about dangers of involvement with government agencies; cautions them to be careful about collaboration with government representatives.
Kauffman, Bill 1994, September The Child Labor Amendment debate of the 1920's: Or Catholics, mugwumps, and farmers. The Family in America, 8(9), 1-16. family, home, education, policy, government control Presents chronology of the Child Labor Amendment to the Constitution of the U.S., especially paying attention to the arguments of the proponents and eventually the winning sentiment of the extraordinary coalition of opponents that included rural Southern Protestants, Northern working-class Catholics, anti-feminists, localists Progressives, domestic manufacturers, those who believed "The home is the castle!" [p. 9], farmers who defended the family farm, and Mugwump wisemen. Explains the desire of many, including some women, to liberate social consciousness by freeing women of domestic duties and turning over the rearing and education of children to trained experts and government agencies. Opposition to the amendment "... warned of Congress interfering `in the discipline of every household. [It will] ...take from parents the right and duty to educate and guide their children'" [p. 12]. The amendment was never ratified.
Kaya, Tulay 2015 An evaluation of the historical development and recent state of homeschooling in the USA. Turkish Journal of Sociology, 1, 3/30, 99-118. Homeschooling, the USA, Alternative Education, 1960s, Social Movements, Sociology of Education Abstract “Abstract: At the end of 1960s, a time when the requirement to attend formal education institutions for a more promising future was commonly acknowledged, homeschooling emerged as a practice in which parents themselves undertook responsibility for educating their children instead of directing them to professionals. Having emerged as a social movement in the educational field, homeschooling is an alternative choice of education that is practiced legally in many countries besides the USA. One of the basic conclusions of this study, in which an overview of the emergence of homeschooling in the USA and its current situation have been taken, is that homeschooling, after emerging as a reaction against institutional education, has lost its marginality; and that in parallel to its legitimization, it has been transformed into a segment of institutional education today” (p. 99).
Kealoha, Anna 1995 Trust the children. mis?? home education, alternative schooling, public school An activity guide for homeschooling, blendschooling, and alternative learning.
Kearney, Katheryn 1984, May/June At home in Maine: Gifted children and homeschooling. G/C/T, pp. 15-19. home education, talented and gifted, interview, academic, socialization “No less a gifted inventor than Thomas Edison was taught at home by his mother, after she removed him from school when his teacher said he was ‘addled.’ And though we tend to think of our large consolidated school districts as the norm, we must remember that it was not too many years ago -- less than fifty, in fact -- when most children lived, worked, grew up, and were schooled within the context of a close-knit home and community, where often only a few families provided the population for a one- or two-room schoolhouse” [p. 16]. “Why would parents choose to educate a child, especially a gifted child, at home?” [p. 16]. Interviews two families with gifted children and explores what they do and why they were successful. “Both families designed an extensive, individualized curriculum for their children, taking into account special abilities and interests” [p. 16].
Kearney, Katheryn 1999 Gifted children and homeschooling: Historical and contemporary perspectives. In Starr Cline & Kathryn T. Hegeman (Eds.), Gifted education in the twenty-first century: Issues and concerns. New York, NY: Winslow Press. Places home schooling in an historical context, especially with respect to the gifted. States that, “Many gifted children are homeschooled because public or private school did not work out for them or because the special needs of the child cannot be adequately met in a regular school setting [emphasis in original]. In this area, gifted homeschoolers seem to differ from other homeschoolers, whose parents frequently cite religious beliefs or family preference as the major reason for choosing homeschooling.” Addresses the questions, “How do I know if homeschooling is right for our family?,” “How do families of the gifted begin a homeschooling program?,” “How do I develop an appropriate homeschooling curriculum for a gifted child?,” “What about socialization?,” and “What about college?” Discusses the future of homeschooling and gifted children.
Keeves, J. P. 1975 The home, the school, and achievement in mathematics and science. Science Education, 59(4), 439-460. Or, Home Environment and School Study Report, (1974),4. Or ERIC Reproduction Service No. EJ 133 343. Science. Math. Investigates primary to high school; research paradigm proposed that changes in the outcomes of education are a function of the type of environment and the dimensions of the environment in which the individual learns.
Kelley, Steven W. 1991 Socialization of home schooled children: A self-concept study. Home School Researcher, 7(4), 1-12. home education, socialization, self-concept, anxiety, psychology, peer-reviewed Explains it is difficult to succinctly define the term socialization. Socialization involves acquiring the knowledge, skills, and dispositions that make persons more or less able members of society, the process by which children learn the ways of socieyt and how best to function as part of it, or learning how one ought to feel and behave and what one ought to value. Uses the Piers-Harris Children’s Self-Concept Scale to measure self-concept as an important component of socialization. Examines 67 home school children (average age of 9.7 years, average of 3.4 years of being home schooled, approximately equal number males and females) in 14 suburban Los Angeles cities. Apparently grade levels 2 to 10 were involved. Results “Testing of the hypotheses in the first category showed the home educated group scoring more positive in self-concept measures with significant differences beyond the .001 probability level between (a) the level of self-concept in the home schooled sample and the self-concept norms for the global scale of the PHCSCS, (b) the self-concept of those children who have been home schooled for two or more years and the norms of self-concept in the conventionally schooled sample, and (c) the self-concept of those home schooled children who have never attended a conventional school and the self-concept norms of the conventionally schooled sample [i.e., the PHCSS norming group from Pennsylvania]. Although differences in the PHCSCS subscales were not part of the hypotheses testing, significant differences were found in four of the six subscales (see Table 1)” [p. 8]. The regression model with all nine variables failed to yield a significant correlation coefficient at the .05 probability level ( = .05). A second analysis, however, determined three variables to have correlation coefficients significant at the .10 probability level ( = .10). The three best predictors of high self-concept in the second analysis were the number of children in the home school (F1, 65 = .0644), the home school operator's educational level (F2, 64 = .0767), and the socioeconomic status of the home schooled child (F3, 63 = .0943)” [p. 8]. Concludes, “The self-concept of home schooling children in suburban Los Angeles was significantly higher (p<.001) than the norms of conventionally schooled children on the global scale of the PHCSCS. A low anxiety level could be a contributing factor, since more than 50% of the home school sample were above the 90th percentile on the Anxiety subscale of the PHCSCS. More contact with significant others, parental love, support, and involvement, peer independence, and a sense of responsibility and self-worth may be other contributing factors” [p. 9; and see Table 1 on p. 8]. Cross-sectional, descriptive. Compared homeschool students to instrument’s norm group. Peer-reviewed.
Kelly, Katy 2000, September 25 False promise: Parking your child in front of the computer may seem like a good idea, but think again. U.S. News & World Report, 129(12), 48-52, 54-55. education, technology, computer, computers, critical thinking, young children, developmentally appropriate practices Explains that for several years many thought early use of computers by young children would greatly benefit them (e.g., intellectually), “But a growing number of educators, child development experts, and doctors are beginning to speak out against early computer use, especially when coupled with regular television watching [p. 48]. Too much ‘screen time’ at a young age, they say, may actually undermine the development of the critical skills that kids need to become successful, diminishing creativity and imagination, motivation, attention spans, and the desire to persevere. [new paragraph] Last week, ...” [p. 50].
Kelly, Philip P. 2006 Educational neglect and compulsory schooling in Idaho: 13,954 reasons to take action, 2004 – 2005. Boise, ID: College of Education, Center for School Improvement & Policy, Boise State University. http://csi.boisestate.edu/pdffiles/Educational%20Neglect%20Legislative%20Brief.pdf http://www.nheri.org/modules.php?name=Content&pa=showpage&pid=32 home education, public school, private school, policy, law, educational neglect, compulsory schooling, philosophy Retrieved 2/15/06 online http://csi.boisestate.edu/pdffiles/Educational%20Neglect%20Legislative%20Brief.pdf This is a brief/summary of Kelly, Barr, and Weatherby 2005 or 2006] Claims that school-age children who are privately home educated (homeschooled) or privately schooled and not registered with state agencies – even if the law does not require such registration – are “missing” and “educationally neglected.” Author, however, provides essentially no empirical data to support claims and conclusions. In fact, it is possible that the data reported could be used to argue just the opposite of author’s recommendations. See a review of Kelly 2006 online [retrieved 2/15/06] http://www.nheri.org/modules.php?name=Content&pa=showpage&pid=32
Kelly, Philip, Barr, Robert, & Weatherby, James 2005 [or 2006] Educational neglect and compulsory schooling: A status report. Center for School Improvement and Policy Studies Final Report, 2004 – 2005. http://www.idaho-post.org/MDteams/documents/EducationalNeglectFinalReport.pdf home education, research, philosophy, policy, academic achievement, law, legal, risk, at-risk Boise, ID: College of Education, Boise State University. Retrieved 1/26/06 online http://www.idaho-post.org/MDteams/documents/EducationalNeglectFinalReport.pdf Essentially, and without any empirical foundation, equates a compulsory age child not being registered with the state’s education agencies with “educational neglect” and being a “missing student.” By linking homeschooling with educational neglect, clearly implicitly links homeschooling with child abuse by way of the following statement and more: “Fourth, educational neglect’s co-occurrence with other forms of neglect/abuse greatly complicates identification and treatment of educational neglect” [p. 4]. Confuses philosophical and theoretical views of the state’s responsibility for and authority over the education of children with research methods. Claims that if US census data and state education agency records about the number of school-age children in a state are different, sound conclusions can be made. For example, assumes that if census data show more children exist than do state education agencies, then the difference in children are “missing” and clearly imply they are at high risk of being “educationally neglected.” Authors ignore that in many states law does not require private school and private homeschool students to be registered with state education agencies. Asserts that more oversight and control by the state will ensure that fewer children will be “missing” and fewer will be “educationally neglected” but provide no data to support this claim. In fact, a quick analysis by a reader of the authors’ data [from pages 13-14 and Appendix F, p. 58] shows that there is a positive correlation between the degree of control and oversight by the state and the percent of unaccounted for “missing” school-age children in the state. Authors conclude, among other things related to education in general, that the law should be changed in Idaho such that all homeschool children must be compelled to register with the state and be annually subject to standardized achievement testing. Provide no evidence that this will help homeschool children in particular or all children in general. Do not address whether private institutional schools and private-school children should also be controlled by the state. They use the term at-risk at risk but do not define it. “Commissioned by the Governor’s Taskforce for Children at Risk.”
Kendall, Ingeborg U. V. 1982 School at home: Teach your own child. Laguna Beach, CA: ICER Press.
Kennedy, A. M. & Gust, D. A. 2005 Parental vaccine beliefs and child’s school type. Journal of School Health, 75, 276-280. http://www.pkids.org/immunizations/publications.html health, vaccines, vaccinations, homeschooling, home education, research, beliefs, school type, public school, private school “This study examined the vaccination beliefs of parents with children in different educational settings, with a specific focus on homeschools, which are least likely to be influenced by and subject to the rules that apply to the public education system, including those mandating immunization. While this study is cross-sectional, and therefore unable to address causality regarding parental beliefs, these results can be used to suggest and highlight potential differences in the beliefs and behaviors of parents, which will be explored further in future research. These results also can be used to guide the development of tailored messages for use in vaccine communication with parents, research that has been previously suggested as a way of addressing differences in vaccination coverage levels between different types of schools. Methods: Data from the 2003 HealthStyles survey were used for analysis. HealthStyles has been administered every year since 1995 as a follow-up to the ConsumerStyles mail panel survey. ConsumerStyles is produced from a panel of 600,000 households representing a range of demographic characteristics who have agreed to respond to periodic mail surveys. Results: Parental Parental beliefs regarding vaccine safety and importance differed depending on their child’s school type (Table 3). Overall, 73% of parents believed vaccines are safe or very safe. This proportion was lower among homeschooling parents (52%), than among public (73%) and private school (74%) parents (p = 0.05). Concern that vaccines may cause learning disabilities also was higher among homeschooling parents (30%) than among public (13%) and private (18%) school parents (p = 0.02). Regarding the importance of vaccines, 86% of parents believed vaccines were important or very important to children’s health. Again, this proportion was lower among homeschooling parents (54%) than among public (87%) and private (88%) school parents (p < 0.01). A similar pattern was seen when parents were asked about their concerns regarding severity of and susceptibility to vaccine-preventable diseases. At 25%, homeschools had the largest proportion of parents who were concerned that vaccines are given to prevent nonserious illnesses, compared to 10% and 4% of public and private school parents, respectively (p < 0.01). Similarly, 25% of homeschool parents were concerned that vaccines were given to prevent illnesses that children are unlikely to get, compared to 13% of public and 8% of private school parents (p = 0.04)” [retrieved 1/4/2012 from http://www.pkids.org/immunizations/publications.html].
Kennedy, Earl Andrew 2008 Homeschooling as reflexive modernity. A master’s thesis (M.S.), North Carolina State University, Raleigh, North Carolina. homeschooling, reflexive modernity, research, philosophy, reasons “Although still a substantial minority, there now exists a sizable and growing population of parents in the United States making the decision to educate their children themselves, in their own homes. Curiosity, skepticism and often misperceptions abound about this group of people. Scholarly inquiries into the world of homeschooling have tended to focus on parental motivations to homeschool, characteristics of homeschoolers, homeschooling methods and homeschooling outcomes, usually measured by standardized test scores. Perhaps the largest body of research has sought to sort and classify homeschoolers according to various typologies. Research to date has shed a great deal of light on what appears to many a somewhat shadowy niche of American society. While helpful, many of these studies are severely limited and have sometimes produced, I will argue, misleading results. Using in-depth qualitative interviews with homeschooling families in North Carolina, I explore some of these issues. I will argue that none of the various homeschooling typologies work when compared to the lived experiences of actual homeschooling families. I suggest that a concentration on what homeschoolers have in common is more useful than attempts to subdivide and force them into ill-fitting typologies. I explore the connections between sociological theories of modernization and homeschooling. Specifically, I adapt and expand theories of reflexive modernity and argue that homeschoolers are best understood as social innovators at the micro-level through a practiced reflexive-modernization. I conclude with a discussion of the implications of designating homeschoolers as ‘reflexively modern’” (no page number).
Kennedy, John W. 1997, July 14 Home schooling keeps growing. Christianity Today, p. 68. home education, research Relies heavily on new nationwide study and its report, Strengths of their own—home Schoolers across America by Brian Ray to explain family demographics, children’s socialization activities, and academic achievement of the students.
Kerman, K. 1982 Homeschooling... day by day. Mothering, Spring, 93-95.
Kerman, K. 1983 Should I teach my kids at home? Friendly Plots, P.O. Box 1792, Media, PA, 19063. Handbook for parents to aid in their decision whether to home school; considers the family's beliefs, the child's learning styles and needs, the parents' resources, and other
Kerman, Kate 1981 Our experiment in home education. Green Revolution, 38(2), 6-9.
Kersey, John 2006 The Belgian state versus home schooling: The persecution of Dr. Alexandra Colen and Dr. Paul Belien. Libertarian Alliance, p. 1-7. London, England: Libertarian Alliance. Retrieved 6/20/06 online http://www.libertarian.co.uk/lapubs/educn/educn038.pdf. http://www.libertarian.co.uk/lapubs/educn/educn038.pdf home education, politics, philosophy, liberty, freedom, international, Belgium Describes the state’s persecution of homeschool parents Colen and Belien.
Khalili, Donya, & Caplan, Art 2007 Off the grid: Vaccinations among homeschooled children. Journal of Law, Medicine, and Ethics, 35(3), 471-77. http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1748-720X.2007.00169.x home education, health, medicine, law, legal, opinion, vaccinations, immunizations “To protect public health, states require that parents have their children immunized before they are permitted to attend public or private school. But for homeschooled children, the rules vary. With the spectacular growth in the number of homeschooled students, it is becoming more difficult to reach these youth to ensure that they are immunized at all. These children are frequently unvaccinated, leaving them open to infection with diseases that are all but stamped out in the United States with immunization requirements. States should encourage parents to get their homeschooled students vaccinated through enacting the same laws as those used for public school students. This could be done by enforcing current laws through neglect petitions or by requiring that children be immunized before participating in school sponsored programs. As most states require some filing to allow parents to homeschool their children, it would be easy to enact laws requiring that homeschooled children be immunized or exempted before completing registration” [abstract retrieved 4/28/08 from http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1748-720X.2007.00169.x].
Kienel, Paul A. (Ed.) 1978 The philosophy of Christian school education (rev. ed.). Whittier, CA: Association of Christian Schools International. education, Christian, religion, philosophy Chapter 1 “The theological basis for the philosophy of Christian school education” by David L. Hocking, p. 7-28, says “The family is the basic unit of Christian education. ..... When our philosophy of eduction [sic] causes us to take that role and responsibility away from the parents, we are definitely in violation of the plain teaching of God’s Word” [p. 23].
Kilgore, Peter 1987, January Profile of families who home school in Maine. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED295280). http://www.eric.ed.gov/ Home Schooling, Parent Attitudes, Parent School Relationship, Public Schools, Religious Factors, School Attendance Legislation A description of the Home School environment within the home and within the larger society of Maine. “Despite these limitations, this paper attempts to describe the reasons why parents choose home schooling, instructional methods and materials used, evaluations used to measure student progress, parental attitudes toward home and public information, and the extent of cooperation between home schoolers and public schools. Also provided research design, and 86 footnotes”; retrieved 8/19/10 from http://www.eric.ed.gov/.
King, Gerald M. 1983 Home schooling: Up from underground. Reason, 14(12), 21-29. Law.. Home schoolers are working around the law.
King, Justin October 1986 Nebraska's home schools. Journal of the New York State School Boards Association, 13-14. Also in, CIJE, March 1987, p. 84. "The 1977 court case of a Nebraska home school that was not accredited and not approved by the Department of Education is reviewed and the State's position summarized. Nebraska regulations for exempting schools from accreditation requirements are explained. Comments are made on trends in home schools and private education in Nebraska" CIJE.
King, Stephen M. 2005 The liberal state thesis regarding parental authority, children’s rights, and homeschooling: How far. Home School Researcher, 16(3), 15-24. Retrieved 3/4/2010 from http://www.nheri.org/Volume-16-Issue-3/The-Liberal-State-Thesis.html. http://www.nheri.org/Volume-16-Issue-3/The-Liberal-State-Thesis.html home education, education, philosophy, political theory Presents a strong case for a Judeo-Christian worldview, as opposed to a liberal state (i.e., strong state) perspective, position regarding authority over a child’s education.
Kingston, Skylar T., & Medlin, Richard G. 2006 Empathy, altruism, and moral development in home schooled children. Home School Researcher, 16(4), 1-10. http://www.nheri.org/Volume-16-Issue-4/Empathy-Altruism-and-Moral-Development.html home education, homeschooling, research, empathy, altruism, moral development, socialization, peer-reviewed Subjects matched on some factors but not most. “Eighty children from grades 3 through 5 and their parents participated in this study. The home school group consisted of 13 boys and 17 girls with an average age of 9.9 years. There were 8 third graders, 10 fourth graders, and 12 fifth graders in this group. None had ever attended a public school. The public school group consisted of 20 boys and 30 girls with an average age of 9.7 years. There were 15 third graders, 24 fourth graders, and 11 fifth graders in this group. None of these children had ever been home schooled. There was no attempt to match home school and public school participants––it was recognized that there would be differences between the two groups that could influence the results of this study. For example, all the home schooled children were Caucasian, whereas only 83% of the public school children were. All but one of the home schooling families were Protestant, while in the public school group, 34% were Protestant, 43% were Catholic, and 23% had either another religious affiliation or none at all. However, the modal income level for both home schooling and public school families was the same––$50,000-75,000 per year––and a chi-square analysis revealed no systematic difference between the groups in the proportion of families at each income level” [retrieved 3/30/2011from http://www.nheri.org/Volume-16-Issue-4/Empathy-Altruism-and-Moral-Development.html]. “Homeschooling parents were more concerned with teaching their children their values and religious beliefs, and more convinced that their children’s education reinforced this endeavor, than public school parents. They were also more confident that their children had embraced the values encompassed in their education. The two groups of parents did not differ, however, concerning whether they wanted their children to decide for themselves what values to believe in. Compared to public school parents, home schooling parents reported slightly more prosocial behavior in their children. In general, the attitudes toward religion and values expressed by home schooling parents were positively related to children’s prosocial behavior” [retrieved 3/30/2011 online]. Peer-reviewed.
Kink, Linda Lee 1983 An analysis of Sacramento area parents practicing home schooling. Unpublished master's thesis, California State University, Sacramento, CA.
Kirkpatrick, David W. 2004, September Millions of students affected by sexual misconduct in public schools. School Reform News, 8(8), 1, 8. public school, sexual abuse, sexual harassment, law "Remarkably, while such events [sexual misconduct in public schools] are regularly reported, there has been no massive media coverage, no public outrage, and no rush of lawsuits against either individual educators or public school districts. 'When the Catholic Church faced a similar scandal there was extensive outrage and investigations were launched by the Church, the media, and the public, and rightfully so,' commented Tony Perkins, president of the Family Research Council. 'Similar scrutiny should also follow these revelations about our nation's public education system where attendance is compulsory'" [p. 8].
Kirschner, Joseph 1991 The shifting roles of family and school as educator: A historical perspective. In J. A. Van Galen & M. A. Pitman (Eds.), Home schooling: Political, historical, and pedagogical perspectives, ch. 7, pp. 137-158. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation.
Kitchen, Paul 1991 Socialization of home school children versus conventional school children. Home School Researcher, 7(3), 7-13.
Kitchen, Ronald E. 1987 A news release regarding two home schoolers and their status at Annapolis.
Kittel, Gerhard, (Ed.) 1964ff Theological dictionary of the New Testament. Ed. and translated by Geoffry W. Bromiley. Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Co. Religion. To use this book, you must learn the Greek alphabet well enough to look up the New Testament words for children and education; then there is a wealth of material on conditions that affected children at the time the New Testament was written.
Kitto, D. 1981, July 10 Doing it their way. Times Education Supplement, p. 18-19.
Kjos, Berit 1995 Brave new schools: Guiding your child through the dangers of the changing school system. Eugene, OR: Harvest House Publishers. education, public schools, values, philosophy, Christian, social change Examines educational issues, especially in public schools, related to the global village, the international agenda, new ways of thinking, establishing a global spirituality, saving the earth, silencing the opposition, SCANS and the school-to-work manual, and outcome-based education or OBE. Uses Christian biblical worldview to evaluate trends and practices in public and other schools. Provides a biblical response to accusations that parents are being intolerant, judgmental, arrogant, or narrow-minded.
Klein, Carol 2006 Virtual charter schools and home schooling. Cambria Press. Retrieved information 8/7/2014 from http://www.cambriapress.com/cambriapress.cfm?template=3&bid=31&font=2. http://www.cambriapress.com/cambriapress.cfm?template=3&bid=31&font=2 charter schools, virtual schools, public schools, homeschooling, home education, research Studies interface between government public charter schools and homeschoolers, at least some who think they are homeschooling.
Klenk, Jack 2010 Who should decide how children are educated? Washington, DC: Family Research Council. family, school choice, public schools, private schools, home education, homeschooling, policy, vouchers, charter schools “In opposition to the idea that parents have rights to guide their child’s upbringing stands the philosophy that children belong to the state” [18]. “Public education in the U.S. has become highly professionalized and unionized. This change has led to a dramatic shift in power from parents and the public to public school employees. John Dewey and his fellow Progressives put in place lasting organizational reforms with the goal of shifting power from local politicians to educational professionals. This shift also reduced the influence that parents had over the education of their children.” [p. 19]. “Can parents regain authority over their children’s education? Despite the barriers, some parents are recovering a degree of their lost authority. Here are some positive developments: …” [p. 21]. “Homeschooling is perhaps the ultimate in parental involvement. Parents who homeschool do not just choose schools for their children, they also do the teaching – usually in cooperation with other homeschooling parents – in their own homes. The rapid growth in the number of children whose parents make that commitment is one of the most significant developments in American education in recent years” [p. 24]. Writes positively toward vouchers to be used in any school. “People of good will who are concerned about the condition of families and the state of education need to think creatively and act courageously to empower parents to become more actively involved in the education of their children. If they start with a determination to put parents first, [p. 26 ends] they can take a fresh look at old assumptions and structures, and seek to modify the system accordingly. The current educational system, created in the early nineteenth century, is overdue for a modernization that will make it more flexible, less bureaucratic, and more family-friendly. To be authentically public, it must serve all parents without discrimination, parents from the whole public, not just those whose children attend one category of schools” [p. 27].
Klicka, Chris 2001 U.S. Supreme Court: Parent’s rights are fundamental. A review of Troxel vs. Granville.
Klicka, Christopher J. 1991, May The myth of teacher qualifications. Available from the Home School Legal Defense Association, PO Box 3000, Purcellville VA 20134. "In conclusion, nearly all existing research on teacher qualifications or state regulations demonstrates that they have no significant relation to student performance. In fact, teacher qualification requirements have no positive correlation with even teacher performance" (p. 4).
Klicka, Christopher J. 1992 The Right Choice: The Incredible Failure of Public Education and the Rising Hope of Home Schooling. Gresham, Oregon: Noble Publishing Associates. philosophy, public schools, Christian, religion, law, achievement, research Strong Christian apologetic for home education (homeschooling).
Klicka, Christopher J. 1993 The right choice: The incredible failure of public education and the rising hope of home schooling (rev. ed.). Gresham, Oregon: Noble Publishing Associates. http://www.hslda.org/courtreport/V4N2/V4N201.asp philosophy, public schools, Christian, religion, law, achievement, research “It is clearly the parents’ primary responsibility to teach their children “so that your days and the days of your sons may be multiplied” (Deuteronomy 11:21). These commands to educate our children, of course, cannot be accomplished once a week at Sunday School. It involves a comprehensive approach to education on a daily basis. The commands of God should be taught to our children when we sit in our home, when we rise up, lie down, and when we travel. In other words, all the time” (p. 103; also retrieved 12/29/09 from http://www.hslda.org/courtreport/V4N2/V4N201.asp). “Therefore, parents must be careful to provide their children with an education whose content reflects God and is based on His Word” (p. 107). “Even though parents are commanded to give their children a biblical education, they must also protect them from “negative socialization.” The Scripture warns, “Do not be deceived: Bad company corrupts good morals” (1 Corinthians 15:33). Proverbs 13:20 states, “He who walks with wise men will be wise, but the companion of fools will suffer harm.” The public schools fail miserably in the area of socialization, with the abundance of crime, drugs, immorality, and gang warfare rampant in the school system. Home schooling enables parents to fulfill this responsibility by fostering positive socialization” (p. 106).
Klicka, Christopher J. 1995 The right to home school: A guide to the law on parents’ rights in education. Durham, NC: Carolina Academic Press.
Klicka, Christopher J. 1997, September/October Home schooling is alive and well in South Africa. Home School Court Report, 13(5), 6-7. home education, foreign country, South Africa, law, policy, history Explains that the law and policy regarding home schooling in South Africa is in the early stages of development. “At each of the meetings, the [government] officials seemed to be convinced of the validity of home schooling and the need to avoid stifling it with unreasonable regulations. A working relationship between the home schoolers and these government officials is off to a good start” [p. 7]. “Already, several provinces have drafted interim regulations which call for parents to be licensed and registered by the Department of Education. In the months and years to come, home schoolers in South Africa will be facing many of the same legislative and legal struggles that we in the United States have already gone through” [ p. 6].
Klicka, Christopher J. 1997, Spring National Center for Home Education recommendations. The Journal of College Admissions, Spring, 1997, 14-15. home education, college admission, adult Provides recommendations on college admission policies regarding the home schooled
Klicka, Christopher J. 1998, November 19 Home school students excel in college (special report). Available from the Home School Legal Defense Association, 17333 Pickwick Drive, Purcellville VA 20132. home education, college admissions, research, opinion, success in college, academic achievement Discusses several pieces of information about home school students and their admission to and performance in college. Mentions a nationwide survey of colleges and their admission policies regarding the home educated. Says Harvard University takes up to 10 home schooled applicants per year and quotes David Illingworth, a senior admissions officer at Harvard, “In general, those kids do just fine” [p. 2]. The Dartmouth College admissions officer explains, “The applications [from home schoolers] I’ve come across are outstanding. Home schoolers have a distinct advantage because of the individualized instruction they have received” [p. 3]. Jeff Lantis of Hillsdale College in Michigan says, “Home schoolers are consistently among our top students, in fact home schoolers have won our distinct Honors Program the last three years in a row. We tend to look very favorably upon home schoolers applying to our college” [p. 3]. James Walters, dean of admissions at University of North Carolina - Chapel Hill, says all the home schoolers he has enrolled “... are performing above average academically” [p. 3]. A 1991 letter from Thomas M. Rajala, director of admission at Boston University, says, “Boston University welcomes applications from home schooled students. We believe students educated at home possess the passion for knowledge, the independence, and the self-reliance that enable them to excel in our intellectually challenging programs of study” [p. 3]. Klicka’s organization recommends that colleges adopt specific written home school admission policies which reflect seven points and concepts that Klicka lists.
Klicka, Christopher J. 1999 College Admissions Policies (Issue Backgrounder #21). Purcellville, VA: Home School Legal Defense Association [received via e-mail on 4/26/00]. home education, college attendance, policy Summarizes studies that address the college or postsecondary education of homeschooled students. Provides the National Center for Home Education's Recommended College Admission Policies.
Klicka, Christopher J. 1999 Home-school families: Involved or isolated? Private School Monitor, 20 (3), 9-11.
Klicka, Christopher J. 2000 Home schooling: The right choice. Sisters, OR: Loyal Publishing. philosophy, public schools, Christian, religion, law, achievement, research Strong Christian apologetic for home education.
Klicka, Christopher J. 2001 Home schooling: The right choice, an academic, historical, practical, and legal perspective. Nashville, TN: Broadman & Holman Publishers.
Klicka, Christopher J. 2002 The heart of home schooling: Teaching and living what really matters. Nashville, TN: Broadman & Holman. homeschooling, home education, family, biblical worldview, religion, philosophy
Klicka, Christopher J. 2002, August Home schooling in the United States: A legal analysis. Available from Home School Legal Defense Association, PO Box 3000, Purcellville VA 20134. Law. Summarizes the laws regarding home education in the United States, and categorizes them according to type of law. Some of the categories are certified teacher without exception, approval, equivalent instruction, regular and thorough instruction, comparable instruction, private or church school, and standardized testing or evaluation. Includes a one-page summary (including quotes from the laws) of the law for each state and territory. Updated at least annually. Includes appendix on research and academic performance statistics. Author emphasizes that giving the summaries does not constitute the giving of legal advice.
Klicka, Christopher J. 2004, August Home schooling in the United States: A legal analysis. Available from Home School Legal Defense Association, PO Box 3000, Purcellville VA 20134. home education, law, legal, states, achievement testing Law. Summarizes the laws regarding home education in the United States, and categorizes them according to type of law. Some of the categories are certified teacher without exception, approval, equivalent instruction, regular and thorough instruction, comparable instruction, private or church school, and standardized testing or evaluation. Includes a one-page summary (including quotes from the laws) of the law for each state and territory. Updated at least annually. Includes appendix on research and academic performance statistics. Author emphasizes that giving the summaries does not constitute the giving of legal advice.
Klicka, Christopher J. 2007, June Home schooling in the United States: A legal analysis. Purcellville, VA: Home School Legal Defense Association, www.hslda.org. http://www.hslda.org
Klugewicz, S.L., & Carraccio C.L. 1999, July Home schooled children: A pediatric perspective. Clinical Pediatrics (Phila), 38(7):407-11. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10416097 homeschooling, home education, research, survey, opinion, health, pediatrics, child “Abstract: To explore the attitudes and self-assessed knowledge of pediatricians regarding home schooling and determine whether practices provide preventive services typically rendered by the school system, we surveyed pediatricians in Wisconsin and Maryland (high versus low rates of home schooling, respectively). Of the 598 (53%) responding, only 18% supported home schooling. They judged home-schooled children to perform at an average (58%) or below average (12%) level on standardized tests and regarded them to be less mature than their peers (51%). These opinions differ from studies published in the educational literature. Many practitioners do not perform routine vision (18%) or hearing (83%) screens or monitor for overdue immunizations (71%). As pediatricians and child advocates, we need to become more knowledgeable about home schooling and provide preventive services for these children”; retrieved 7/1/13 from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10416097
Knafle, June 2001 Religions in fiction for junior and senior high students. Reading Improvement, 38(1), 12-21.
Knafle, June & Wescott, Alice Legenza 1993 Public, private, and homeschool children's perceptions concerning forgiveness and retribution [roundtable discussion, pages with data but not full-length paper distributed at roundtable]. Presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Research Association, April 12-16, Atlanta GA. [Knafle was at U. of Illinois at Chicago.] research, home education, affective
Knafle, June D., & Wescott, Alice Legenza 1994 in press Home schoolers learn to read. The Reading Professor, 16(2), p. ?. research, home education, reading, television, literacy, extracurricular activities Found that, compared to students in public schools, there was a extraordinary high level of reported oral reading in the home school families, both to children and by children at all age levels, and parents attributed their children's reading strength in vocabulary knowledge, literal comprehension, and interpretive comprehension to reading much to their children. Another major difference was that most of the parents used a beginning reading program with a strong phonics strand; in fact, some used only phonics without accompanying stories or with very few stories. Parents appeared to be sensitive to the individual reading needs of their children and attempted to meet those needs. Home school children also differ from public school students in that the home educated participate in a very low amount of interactive oral reading with peers, especially in the reading of plays. The home educated had extraordinary low levels of television watching and participated in a large number of extracurricular activities, especially church and physical education activities. Suggests there needs to be cooperation between public schools and home educators to facilitate the integration of the home educated into public schools when the parents choose to put them in those schools.
Knafle, June D., & Wescott, Alice Legenza 2005 Home school graduates and their mothers talk about literacy instruction. Home School Researcher, 16(2), 1-12. research, home education, literacy instruction, reading, phonics “Some findings were expected and in accord with other studies, such as the intense nature of phonics instruction, which continued until mastery, often beyond the grade levels of public school phonics instruction. Failure was not an option for graduates or their mothers in this area. Also in accord with other studies was the extensive amount of oral reading by graduates and their families, in many instances into high school grades, another clear difference from public school instruction. The home school mothers were single-minded in their instruction in these two areas especially. Spelling was often given extensive instruction time, and grammar was given varying amounts of time and materials, depending upon individual differences of the graduates. Vocabulary was generally not taught separately, but rather integrated into unit studies, a major difference from public schools. Another major difference from public schools was the unstructured nature of comprehension instruction. Writing was a frequent activity for most of these graduates. Literature was almost exclusively classic and traditional; the fiction read by the graduates was usually not current, probably reflecting conservative and/or Christian traditions. Graduates and their mothers spoke about their many unit studies and special literacy projects, about their extensive involvement in co-ops, and about how the mothers handled reading problems. The mothers’ commitment to their children’s literacy success was clearly evident throughout the interviews. Finally, almost all the graduates said they would home school their own children at least through elementary grades” [p. 11].
Knez, Kathleen M. 1985, June Schools as a cause of behavior disorders. Home School Researcher, 1(2), 3-5.
Knowles, J. Gary 1985 Home schooling: A non-traditional educational methodology. Unpublished draft manuscript, University of Utah, College of Education, Salt Lake City, UT.
Knowles, J. Gary 1987, December 3-6 Understanding parents who teach their children at home: The value of a life history approach. Paper presented at the First Joint Conference of the Australian and New Zealand Associations for Research in Education, University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand. homeschooling, reasons, barriers [A revised version was been published in Journal of Contemporary Ethnography, 1991] "Surveys of home schools, and the parents who operate them, ignore the vital human element. . . . Life histories seemed to be a way of linking the past with the present, important for understanding the deep structured positions of home school parents. . . . Results verify that home schooling motives are complex and congruent with trends evidenced in the life histories of most participating parents. Central were parents' experiences in school. Many had serious problems. Past experiences often seem to be more important than present educational conflicts as inducements for home schooling" [p. 2]. Revised notes
Knowles, J. Gary 1987, June Review of An overview of home instruction, by Patricia M. Lines. Home School Researcher, 3(2).
Knowles, J. Gary 1987, October Instructional patterns and practices in the home schools. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Northern Rocky Mountain Educational Research Association, Park City UT.
Knowles, J. Gary 1988 Introduction: The context of home schooling in the United States. Education and Urban Society, 21(1), 5-15.
Knowles, J. Gary 1988 Parents’ rationales and teaching methods for home schooling: The role of biography. Education and Urban Society, 21(1), 69-84. homeschooling, home education, research, reasons, rationales, barriers Uses biography to explore why parents decide to home school their children. The four groups of rationales are related to (1) family environments of the home school parents, (2) parents’ schooling and other learning experiences, (3) contemporary problems children experienced in schools [e.g., irreligious tone and lack of morality in schools and society at large, a type of safety], and (4) parents who believed they could provide a superior learning climate. Does he get into push and pull factors or proactive and reactive reasons for homeschooling? ?????
Knowles, J. Gary 1988 Understanding parents who teach children at home: The value of a life history approach. Home School Researcher, 4(1), 9-19.
Knowles, J. Gary 1989 Cooperating with home school parents: A new agenda for public schools? Urban Education, 23(4), 392-411.
Knowles, J. Gary 1991 "We've grown up and we're OK": An exploration of adults who were home-educated as students. A paper presented at the 13th National Conference of the New Zealand Association for Research in Education, November 28-December 1, 1991, Knox College, Otago University, Dunedin, New Zealand. home education, adults, long term effects, attitude May cite but do not quote without permission. The adults live rural and urban areas throughout U.S. and Canada, are employed in variety of professions and occupations although many have jobs that allow for independence, flexibility, and (in some cases) creativity, exhibit wide range of political viewpoints and religious affiliations, a majority reflected a clearly positive attitude toward their home education and early family experiences, and findings suggest that these adults are not even moderately disadvantaged in ways that critics of home education claim they would be.
Knowles, J. Gary 1991 Fox in the chicken coop or goose in the nest laying a golden egg? Reflections on researching home schools. Home Education Magazine, 8(1), 15-17, 39-41, 49. home education, research, opinion Sound research has potential to improve the education of children regardless of where they are educated; research on non-home school topics can assist home schoolers and home school research "... can ultimately be of great value in many educational settings" (p. 49). In order to evaluate the research project and to decide whether to participate, consider whether the researcher is open and honest about his research agenda, whether he treats your points of view with respect, and whether he offers to share the outcomes with you.
Knowles, J. Gary 1991 Parents' rationales for home education. Journal of Contemporary Ethnography, 20(2), 203-230.
Knowles, J. Gary, & Browning, Kimberly G. 1990 Home schools, social capital, and parents' biographies: The importance of early experiences. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Boston, MA, April 17-20.
Knowles, J. Gary, & Browning, Kimberly G. 1991 Characteristics of home education and their influence on public and private schools in four western states. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 3-7, Chicago IL.
Knowles, J. Gary, & de Olivares, K. 1991 "Now we are adults": Attitudes, beliefs, and status of adults who were home-educated as children. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Chicago, IL, April 3-7, 1991. home education, research, adults, grown children, qualitative Used surveys and life history techniques to study adults who were home educated; findings suggest these people grew up with advantages that contributed to their independent view of society and their role in it; they are not homogeneous or amenable to easy categorization as a group, located throughout the U.S. and Canada in rural and urban areas, employed in a variety of professions and seem to be concentrated in occupations that allow for independence, flexibility, and/or creativity; they exhibit a wide range of political views and religious affiliations; a majority express a clearly positive attitude toward their home education and family experiences; they don't exhibit characteristics that suggest they are disadvantaged in any way as a result of their home education experience; they have no grossly negative perceptions of living in a pluralistic society; home schools may have advantages that have been unrecognized to this point.
Knowles, J. Gary, & Duschaine, M. 1992 Stories and lives of home-educated adults: Beyond the veneer of religious and pedagogical ideologies. Manuscript in preparation, The University of Michigan, Ann Arbor MI.
Knowles, J. Gary, & Hoefler, V. 1988, April An exploratory case study of how parents think about developing enhanced parent-child relationships in home school settings: Bonding or tying the apron strings? Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association: New Orleans, LA.
Knowles, J. Gary, & Muchmore, James A. 1994 "Yep! We're grown-up home schooled kids — and we're doing just fine, thank you very much". home education, research, adults, older, success, social, policy Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 4-8, 1994, New Orleans, LA. Used lengthy survey w/ closed- and open-ended questions to collect data from 53 respondents in the United States and Canada; 10 of these were selected for extensive semi-structured interviews. "In spite of the overall diversity among the ten adults [interviewed], they often expressed similar values, especially those regarding morality and society. Respect for individual differences and a concern for others, for instance, were values shared by all of them. About half, however, expressed the feeling that society had lost its morality and that there was no teaching of right and wrong in the public schools. ..... Another value that these individuals held in common was being responsible for one's action and helping to solve society's problems. half of the adults felt that our society had become too dependent on the government and that too many people looked toward the government for help instead of doing things for themselves" p. 19. "Spirituality and religion were other values that were common to the majority of the group" with 7 saying religious commitments were very important in their lives (p. 20). "The life history interviews, in concert with the survey responses, suggest that these adults were by no means a liability to society. While most were earning relatively moderate incomes, none were unemployed, and none were on any form of welfare assistance. There was also no evidence to suggest they were not actively participating in their communities... Invariably, however, high levels of autonomy and independence were the common hallmarks of these individuals. Not only were these traits highly valued, but they was [sic] also evident in their work patterns" (p. 21). "Contrary to the commonly expressed criticism that home education is synonymous with social deprivation, these adults pointed to the value of being able to interact with a wide range of people, instead of being exposed primarily to age-group peers, as is the case for those attending formal schools. ..... There is currently no extensive and compelling evidence to support the fears that critics of home schools have consistently expressed over the two decades since 1970..." (p. 23). "We feel that neither public schools nor home schools are well served by these kinds of statements [i.e., policy positions toward home education of the National Association of Elementary School Principals 1989-1990 and the National Education Association 1988], which are not based on substantial evidence C and certainly not research evidence... To the contrary, the evidence presented in this study suggests that some home schools may have positive characteristics that have hitherto gone unrecognized" (p. 24).
Knowles, J. Gary, & Muchmore, James A. 1995 Yep! We're grown-up home-school kids--and we’re doing just fine, thank you. Journal of Research on Christian Education, 4(1), 35-56. home education, research, adults, older, success, social, policy, religion, peer-reviewed Use mailed surveys and life history interviews to study 53 adults who were home educated. Ten adults were purposively chosen for the interviews “... in order to represent as much diversity as possible across attributes such as age, sex, race, family background, formal school attendance, present and past residential locations (both geographically and on an urban/rural continuum), and vocation” [p. 39]. “We especially sought a representation of those with no formal education or with unstable employment records so as not to overlook what may represent the least productive and most occupationally unstable of this population ... [who] would be more like the kinds of `products’ that the critics of home education have implied would be the `result’ of children being taught at home” [p. 40]. The 10 adults “... often expressed similar values, especially those regarding morality and society. Respect for individual differences and a concern for others, for instance, were values shared by all of them” [ p. 48-49]. “... they grew up with specific advantages that contributed to their independent views of society and their roles in it. ... they were employed in a variety of professions and occupations, with many concentrated in occupations that allowed for independence, flexibility, and creativity. ... the majority of the adults reflected a clearly positive attitude toward their home education and family experiences. Moreover, these adults did not appear to exhibit characteristics that imply that they were disadvantaged as a result of their home education experiences, as critics of home education suggest. ..... Even in a time of growing unemployment, these people were gainfully employed and productive members of their communities. Currently, no extensive and compelling evidence supports the fears that critics of home schools have consistently expressed over the two decades since 1970 ...” [p. 52]. Peer-reviewed.
Knowles, J. Gary, Marlow, Stacey E., & Muchmore, James A. 1992 From pedagogy to ideology: Origins and phases of home education in the United States, 1970-1990. American Journal of Education, 100(2), 195-235. home education, history, philosophy Links recent emergence of home education to philosophies of educators "...who wrote on issues of reform during the late 1960s and early to mid 1970s" (p. 227), however, "When contemporary home schools are examined, it becomes clear that they are not closely tied to the liberal roots of home education" but are tied to "...ideological [versus pedagogical], conservative, religious expressions of educational matters, which symbolized the conservative right's push toward self-determinism" (p. 227). The five phases of the movement are (a) contention about public schools, (b) confrontation between the public school personnel and the state and home educators, (c) cooperation between public school boards and home school parents, (d) consolidation among home educators, their support groups, and their social networking, and (e) compartmentalization of within the movement according to various religious perspectives, organizational affiliations, and emerging leaders in the movement; authors interpret home education's growth as a rational and legitimate educational choice by increasingly large numbers of families.
Knowles, J. Gary, Mayberry, Maralee, & Ray, Brian D. 1991, December 24 An assessment of home schools in Nevada, Oregon, Utah, and Washington: Implications for public education and a vehicle for informed policy decision, summary report. home education, research, demographics, policy, religion, politics, science, gender roles, cooperation U.S. Department of Education Field Initiated Research Project Grant #R117E90220 Contacts: Knowles, Dept. of Ed., U. of Michigan, Ann Arbor MI 48109; Mayberry, Dept. of Sociology, U. of Nevada, Las Vegas NE 89154; Ray, National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309 [503/364-1490]). (Largest study of its kind with nearly 1,500 families participating in four states; deals with select demographic characteristics, religious and political characteristics, the public and formal school-home school relationship, and "needs" and "wants" of home educators; much detailed data; more analyses of data on various other topics [p. 51] will be done in years to come.
Knowles, J. Gary, Ray, Brian D., & Mayberry, Maralee 1992 Lessons from the home front: Some of the ways in which home education can inform and link with formal schooling. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Association of Teacher Educators, February 15-19, 1992, Orlando FL. home education, cooperation, public schools May cite but do not quote without permission, work in progress.
Knowles, J. Gary. (Ed.) 1988 Understanding home schools: Emerging research and reactions [Special issue]. Education and Urban Society, 21(1). Research. Opinion.
Knox, Barbara L; Starling, Suzanne P.; Feldman, Kenneth W.; Kellogg, Nancy D.; Frasier, Lori D.; & Tiapula, Suzanna L. 2014 Child torture as a form of child abuse. Journal of Child & Adolescent Trauma, 7(1), 37-49. http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs40653-014-0009-9 Non-accidental trauma, Physical abuse, Psychological maltreatment, Neglect, Starvation, child abuse, homeschooling, institutional schooling, schooling, family This is a “non-consecutive case series” cross-sectional descriptive non-experimental study, so has nothing to do with rates of torture in different school sectors. “Abstract. This paper describes clinical findings and case characteristics of children who are victims of severe and multiple forms of abuse; and proposes clinical criteria that indicate child abuse by torture. Medical records, investigation records, and transcripts of testimony regarding a non-consecutive case series of 28 children with evidence of physical abuse, neglect, and psychological maltreatment, such as terrorizing and isolation, were reviewed for types of injuries, duration of maltreatment, medical and physical neglect, social and family history, and history of prior Child Protective Services (CPS) involvement. The median age was 7.5 years (9 months to 14.3 years). Thirty-six percent died. Duration of abuse ranged from 3.5 months to 8 years (median 3 years). Ninety-three percent of children were beaten and exhibited cutaneous injury; 21% had fractures. There were 25 victims of isolation (89%), as well as 61% who were physically restrained and 89 % who were restricted from food or water. All of the children were victims of psychological maltreatment; 75 % were terrorized through threats of harm or death to themselves or loved ones and 54 % were degraded and/or rejected by caregivers. Nearly all children were medically neglected. Half had a history of prior referrals to CPS. The children in this case series were physically abused, isolated, deprived of basic necessities, terrorized, and neglected. We define child torture as a longitudinal experience characterized by at least two physical assaults or one extended assault, two or more forms of psychological maltreatment, and neglect resulting in prolonged suffering, permanent disfigurement or dysfunction, or death. Keywords: Non-accidental trauma Physical abuse Psychological maltreatment Neglect Starvation” Retrieved December 10, 2015 http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs40653-014-0009-9. (“This social isolation typically involved preventing the child from attending school or daycare. Twenty-nine percent of school-age children were not allowed to attend school; two children, though previous enrolled, were dis-enrolled by their caregiver and received no further schooling. An additional 47% who had been enrolled in school were removed under the auspice of “homeschooling.” This “homeschooling” appears to have been designed to further isolate the child and typically occurred after closure of a previously opened CPS case. Review of these cases found no true educational efforts were provided to the homeschooled children. Their isolation was accompanied by an escalation of physically abusive events.” However, they did not provide summary statistics on how many years the child had been (allegedly) homeschooled or in institutional school. Vaguely state that their case studies are not meant to be representative of all such torture abuse cases: “This series and paper is limited in that it is a select and by no means, inclusive series, of abuse cases. They have been chosen to be illustrative of the phenomenon of torture, but cannot be considered a consecutive case series for statistical analysis.” Study was not designed to be and authors did not claim that the purpose was to determine the rates of torture associated with different types of schooling.) annotation
Knutson, Asha 2007, July Mothers’ experience of pulling their children out of school in order to homeschool. Doctoral dissertation (Ph.D.), University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN. home education, research, qualitative, public schools, philosophy, transition “This hermeneutic phenomenological study explores an understudied aspect of homeschooling in the unfolding stories of mothers’ lived experiences of struggling with schools, choosing homeschooling, and making the transition from school to home. The philosophical and methodological underpinnings of this study are based on the work of van Manen (1997), Polkinghorne (1988), and Berger and Luckman (1967). Given that individuals’ personal stories are rooted in a historical and sociocultural context, I look for meaning in narratives at both the cultural and individual levels. I first trace the evolution of the different historical and sociological meanings of school and homeschool in order to provide the historical and sociocultural context for understanding the lived experiences of the mothers. While each mother had a unique experience pulling her child or children out of school based on her specific history and circumstances, within the context of the mothers’ stories, a single plot emerges, with several supporting sub-plots. Using the analogy of a literary story, I describe the main plot as including: (a) the setting: school as a place where the child must go; (b) foreshadowing: the mothers sensing that something is not right; (c) conflict with the school: expressing voice to taking action; and (d) the dénouement: transitioning to homeschooling. I conclude by exploring the potential contributions of this study to new knowledge, practice, and public policy” [abstract, p. iii].
Koetzsch, Ronald E. 1997 The parents’ guide to alternatives in education. Boston, MA & London: Shambhala. home education, alternatives, history, reasons, opinion Subtitle is “the first in-depth guide to the full range of choices in alternative schooling with all the information you need to decide what kind of education is right for your child.” Chapter 20 is entitled “Homeschooling” and says, “Until the public school system came into being, parents had the responsibility and the right to educate their children. Most parents taught their children to read, write, and do arithmetic at home, and also taught practical and vocational skills. Well-to-do families might have engaged a tutor or sent their children to a private academy. For most families, though, the education of children at home by parents and other family members was the norm, as it had been in all cultures, literate and nonliterate, throughout human history” [p. 131]. Provides more history and explains that the state took the right and responsibility to education children away from the parents but that not all parents were happy with this arrangement — to wit the resistance to mandatory, universal, public education in many areas of the United States. Due to compulsory attendance laws and the fact that industrialization was taking many men and women away from the household, “From the late 1800s until the 1970s, homeschooling virtually vanished from the American cultural landscape. ..... But from the mid-1970s and continuing today, homeschooling has enjoyed a renaissance” [p. 131]. Surveys the importance of John Holt in history of modern home schooling then the fact that more recently “About 80 percent (at least eight hundred thousand) of all homeschooled children are from conservative Christian families” [p. 132]. Discusses reasons for home schooling and advantages and disadvantages of home schooling. Mentions the National Home Education Research Institute.
Kohn, Alfie 1988, April Home Schooling: Parents who educate their children at home face little official opposition--but a very demanding responsibility. The Atlantic, 261(4), 20-25. home education, opinion Among other things, offers an estimate that there were about 200,000 students home schooled in 1988.
Kolenc, Antony Barone 2010, Summer Fair and impartial? Homeschooling and judicial bias. The Old Schoolhouse, 40-43. home education, homeschooling, legal, law, court cases “Prejudice against homeschooling should be on the decline. More and more families educate at home each year. What’s more, this teaching method often produces better results than either public or private schooling. But a review of court cases reveals that some judges hold a personal bias against homeschooling. This article will explore why these pre-judgments still exist and what parents can do about it. There are four danger zones where homeschoolers must beware of judicial bias” [p. 40].
Konishi, Chiaki; Hymel, Shelley; Zumbo, Bruno D.; & Li, Zhen 2010 Do school bullying and student–teacher relationships matter for academic achievement? A Multilevel Analysis. Canadian Journal of School Psychology, 25(1) 19–39. bullying, public school, private school State that homeschool students and a few other small-population groups were excluded from the study. That is, homeschooling was not included.
Konnert, William & Wendel, Josef 1988, May Here's what your board should know when parents ask about home schooling. American School Board Journal, 175 (5), 43-44.) Boards of Education, Home Schooling, School Attendance Legislation, School Law
Koonce, Jeffrey B. 2007 The transitional experience of home-schooled students entering public education: How can public schools better serve the home-schooled student’s transition to public education? Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, University of Missouri-Columbia. homeschooling, public school, cooperation Abstract: “This dissertation studied the transitional experience of home-schooled students in central/south central rural Missouri whose families decided to place them into the public school setting. Since the public school environment is markedly different from the home school setting, there was the assumption that home-schooled students would have transitional needs that could be addressed by the public school in order to help these students adapt better to their new educational setting. Families who had home schooled and then sent their children to public school were identified and interviewed. Pedagogical and ideological reasons for home schooling and then for sending students to public school were explored. Additional information provided feedback on the transitional experience and what parents and public schools could do to make the segue between home and public education smoother. Results indicated that the primary issue preventing home-schooled students from experiencing a smooth transition to public school was the negative perceptions by public school personnel. Participants acknowledged the need for both home school families and public school officials to be tolerant and understanding of each other. Participants presented several practical ideas that would benefit public school perception and reception of home-schooled students into public education. Since this research focused on a convenience sample from rural south/central Missouri, these findings could be a springboard for transitional experiences of home-schooled students in suburban and urban areas. Other areas for further study include identifying which home school curriculums are most effective in producing academically sound students, what traits are common among effective home school families, and how public school officials actually perceive the home-schooled students they receive” (p. vii).
Koslicki, Indigo; & Dent, Sara 2026 Always under lockdown: Exploring prevalence of self-reported abuse among homeschooled students and alumni in the United States. Child Abuse & Neglect, 176. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chiabu.2026.108076 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chiabu.2026.108076 homeschool, homeschooling, abuse, neglect, self-report, non-representative sample, child maltreatment, maltreatment “Abstract Background There is little research about homeschooled children's experiences of abuse and neglect that is quantitative and not funded by private interest groups. What exists is typically published in education journals rather than child abuse and neglect journals, thus limiting scholars' and practitioners' exposure to such research. Homeschooled children's isolation and prolonged proximity to their parents or guardians compounds the issue of lack of research. Objective The current study examines the prevalence of several types of child maltreatment among a sample of homeschooled children and alumni in the United States and examines relationships between abuse/neglect and self-reported adverse experiences and suicidal ideation. Participants and settings All posts from the r/HomeschoolRecovery subreddit from 2023 were collected, coded, and then collapsed by individual user (n = 716) to examine self-reported experiences. Methods Posts were coded using a literature-based codebook to conduct a quantitative content analysis. Logistic regression models were then conducted to test exploratory hypotheses. Results Much of the sample reported adverse outcomes and educational neglect, and nearly a third reported social isolation. Physical, emotional, and spiritual abuse were significantly correlated with nearly all other forms of abuse and neglect. Logistic regression models showed medical neglect and emotional abuse to significantly increase the likelihood of adverse outcomes, and social isolation significantly increased the likelihood of suicidal ideation. Conclusions While exploratory, this study is among the first to systematically code self-reported abuse experiences from a marginalized population that is difficult to track and protect. Opportunities for future studies are presented to expand this research subfield.” Authors’ review of research is clearly biased against free and independent homeschooling and for state-controlled homeschooling, heavily relies on a review of Kunzman and Gaither which holds logical fallacies and inaccuracies, and shows clear biases against Christians who homeschool and against the HSLDA. The review is loaded with theoretical bias, as in this unsupported claim based on a non-representative sampling of literature review: “The relatively deregulated state of homeschooling in the U.S. is neither accidental nor separable from the classed, racialized, and religious foundations outlined in this section. Consequently, the phenomenon of COVID-19 homeschooling, as well as ongoing policy debates, must be situated within this sociopolitical context.” Authors abstract begins with fallacy of poisoning the well and the following false statement, “There is little research about homeschooled children's experiences of abuse and neglect that is quantitative and not funded by private interest groups.” Mention “… Home School Legal Defense Association (HSLDA) and their funded scholars” but HSLDA has not funded any research projects in many years and studies of abuse, neglect, and maltreatment have not been funded by HSLDA. The following is an unsupported and false claim: “With much of homeschool research sourced by interest groups such as the HSLDA, …” Authors wrongly dismiss as irrelevant or unimportant research published in education journals; extreme bias is shown by the authors.
Kostelecká, Yvona 2010 Home education in the post-communist countries: Case study of the Czech. International Electronic Journal of Elementary Education, 3(1), 29-44. home education, homeschooling, homeschooling legislation, Czech Republic, post-communist countries, research Abstract: The paper analyzes the emergence of home education in European post-communist countries after 1989. The case of the Czech Republic representing the development and characteristic features of home education in the whole region is studied in detail. Additional information about homeschooling in other post-communist countries are provided wherever they are available in order to provide a more comprehensive picture of the issue. The driving forces and history of home education after 1989 are described. Current homeschooling legislation is analyzed with special attention paid to the processes of the legal enrolment of individuals into home education, supervision and assessment of educational results. The article concludes that despite the existence of country-specific characteristics, many features of home education in post-communist countries are similar. These generally include the rather strict regulation of home education and the high importance of schools as both gate-keeping and supervising institutions” (p. 29).
Kostelecká, Yvona; Kostelecký, Tomas, Kaščák, Ondrej; & Valášková Vincejová, Eva 2026 Who is in favour of the choice to homeschool in Czechia and why? International Studies in Sociology of Education, 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/09620214.2026.2686376 https://doi.org/10.1080/09620214.2026.2686376 Homeschooling, Czechia, neoliberal governance, anti-establishment attitudes ABSTRACT: To gain deeper insight into the factors behind support for homeschooling in Czechia, we used representative survey data collected in February 2024. Analysis of the public opinion data suggests that homeschooling in Czechia is not tied to religious conservatism or populist distrust of elites, nor is it related to mistrust of the state or its political representatives. Instead, homeschooling appears to function primarily as pragmatic ‘escape route’ for children whose needs are not met in mainstream schools, for example due to poor educational quality, psychological distress, or academic failure, and it reflects a context-specific negotiation between parental autonomy, institutional regulation, and broader socio-cultural transformations in a post-communist society.”
Kostelecká, Yvona; Kostelecký, Tomáš; Beláňová, Andrea; & Machovcová, Kateřina 2020 Home-Education in Czechia: Twenty Years of Experience. In R. English (Ed.), Chapter 11, DOI: https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-7998-6681-7.ch011. https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-7998-6681-7.ch011 homeschooling, Czech, Czechia, history, law, legal “Abstract: The chapter deals with the development of home-education in Czechia since its legalisation in 2004. It analyses the way home-education works in a specific Czech legal and institutional context. An analysis of the available data showed a rapidly growing popularity of home-education since its legalisation. The concentration of home-schoolers under the supervision of just a handful of basic schools specialised in home-education was observed which was enabled by the legalisation of home education given parents are able to choose a school for their children regardless of their place of permanent residence. Although the law stipulates quite strict conditions for practicing home-education under the supervision of schools, the free school choice empowered home-educating parents are much more free to practice education however they liked as the administrative authorities were in a client-provider relationship with parents which gave parents power” (p. 139).
Kostelecká, Yvona; Kostelecký, Tomáš; Kaščák, Ondrej; Komárková, Terezie; & Klapálková, Veronika 2025 Homeschooling as an extension of school choice in the Czech Republic after the COVID-19 pandemic? International Studies in Sociology of Education, 34(3), 337-361, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09620214.2024.2422588 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09620214.2024.2422588 Homeschooling; school choice, COVID-19 pandemic; Czechia; public opinion “ABSTRACT: The aim of the study was to examine the homeschooling and its recent development in Czechia as part of the school choice debate. The study analyses the different attitudes towards homeschooling among different groups within the Czech population and the underlying demographic, socioeconomic, and ideological factors that may be behind these differences, as well as analysing the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on this form of education in Czech society. The analysis of the nationally representative data shows that public support for homeschooling increased significantly after the COVID-19 pandemic, reaching its highest level in 2023. We found that the typical supporter of homeschooling tends to be a younger, highly educated person who lives in the large city or in its suburbs, is committed to democratic and liberal principles, is critical of totalitarian systems, and sees the legal possibility of homeschooling as an extension of the existing school choice.”
Kostelecka´, Yvona 2012 The legal status of home education in post-communist countries of Central Europe. International Review of Education, 58, 445–463, DOI https://doi.org/10.1007/s11159-012-9298-0. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11159-012-9298-0 “Abstract: As new laws on education were gradually adopted in post-communist states after 1989, the countries also dealt with the problem of how to include home education in their own legislation. This article investigates the development of legislation on home education in five states of post-communist Central Europe: the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Slovenia, Poland and Hungary. This analysis of the legal environment for home education confirms on the one hand that these countries’ approach is similar in many aspects. Generally, laws tend to regulate home education rather strictly, all home-educated children must be enrolled at some school, and these schools are mandated by the state to serve as supervisory bodies for home-educated children. This legal arrangement puts the parents of home-schooled children in a very subordinate position in relation to the school. Despite these restrictions, however, the states have gradually opened up the option for home education to quite a broad pool of potentially interested people. On the other hand, the findings show that there are also significant differences between individual countries. These differences provide a good illustration of the fact that, despite historical, economic and cultural similarities, political institutions and state bureaucracies in individual states act autonomously, which leads to different policy outcomes” (p. 445). Keywords Home education, Home schooling, homeschooling, Alternative education, Legislation, law, legal, Post-communist Central Europe, Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, Slovakia, Slovenia
Kourti, Isidora; Charitaki, Garyfalia; & Kypriotaki, Maria 2026 A comparative assessment of homeschooling experiences, practices, support, and arithmetical attainments in Greece and the UK. Education Sciences, 16(8), 1298. https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci16081298 https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci16081298 homeschooling; special educational needs; disabilities; arithmetical attainments; parental experiences; Greece; UK “Abstract: This preliminary study aims to compare homeschooling in Greece and the UK in terms of experiences, arithmetical attainments, parental motivations, implementation practices, and support structures. For this purpose, we employed a multiple case study design, enrolling a total of five Greek and fifteen British homeschooling families. Results suggested that the Greek parents primarily chose homeschooling in response to their child’s severe and complex medical needs and reported limited access to support systems. British parents provided more varied motivations, higher engagement with educational resources, and stronger integration into informal support networks. The sample of UK children demonstrated higher arithmetical attainment than the Greek sample. Cultural, structural, and regulatory factors appear to shape homeschooling experiences differently across the Greek and UK educational systems. Differences also emerged in terms of daily routines, access to support, and parental confidence. Results are discussed in relation to educational provision and policy development.”
Krauss, Glen E. 1991 A comparison of achievement between home, public, and Christian schools: An historical perspective. Available from Sun-Lex international, P.O. Box 2670, Bellview FL 32620. research, history, academic achievement Includes historical overview of education/schooling with respect to when it occurred in the home vs. outside the home; presents academic achievement test score data; not very technical) .
Krivanek, Rosamund 1988 Social development in home based education. Master’s thesis, University of Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Kuhn, Thomas S. 1962, 1970 The structure of scientific revolutions, second edition, enlarged [1970]. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press. normal science, philosophy of science, paradigm Normal science. Science does not progress through steady accumulation of objective facts independent of the researcher. Instead, it operates within paradigms—shared frameworks of assumptions, values, methods, and exemplars that shape what questions are asked, what counts as evidence, how data are interpreted, and what counts as "success" or a legitimate problem. Normal science is "puzzle-solving" within a paradigm; anomalies eventually trigger crises and revolutionary shifts to new paradigms.
Kunnecke, Jacqueline Addington 1978 Perceptions of educational linking agents and family spokespersons about home-based learning. Dissertation Abstracts International, 40, 691B-692B.
Kunzman, Robert 2005, Summer Homeschooling in Indiana: A closer look. Education Policy Brief, 3(7), 1-8. http://ceep.indiana.edu/projects/PDF/PB_V3N7_Summer_2005_Homeschooling.pdf home education, homeschooling, review of research, policy, law, legal, philosophy, public schools, reform, negative criticism, negative critic Bloomington, IN: Center for Evaluation & Education Policy, Indiana University. Retrieved June 6, 2008 from http://ceep.indiana.edu/projects/PDF/PB_V3N7_Summer_2005_Homeschooling.pdf. “Homeschooling is quickly becoming a significant educational phenomenon. According to the Indiana Department of Education, the number of Indiana homeschooled children has increased by 400 percent over the past eight years, with a current enrollment total of 22,403. Furthermore, this number likely understates the true number of Indiana homeschooled students, and reflects a constant refrain in research on homeschooling: very little comprehensive data exist on homeschooling demographics, practices, and outcomes” [p. 1]. “The Indiana State Teachers Association (ISTA) has approved a resolution (A-15) on homeschooling that advocates the adoption of a range of additional regulatory standards. Among these, ISTA urges that homeschool teachers meet the state requirements for licensing; annual permission be required for homeschooling based on professional evaluation of planned curriculum; homeschool programs be monitored by local school administrative personnel; and that students should participate in state or locally mandated testing (ISTA, 2005). A recent survey of Indiana superintendents also revealed a desire for additional regulation of homeschooling in the state” [p. 4]. Author provides a notably inadequate, non-representative, and limited review of research on the academic performance and social and emotional development of the home educated, leaving the reader with the inaccurate impression that almost nothing is known, based on research, in these two areas. “In terms of empirical research, the most frequently cited study by homeschool advocates confirms that at least a segment of homeschool students score two to four grade levels and 20 percentage [sic; should be “percentile”] points higher on a nationally recognized achievement test (either the Iowa Test of Basic Skills or Tests of Achievement and Proficiency Rudner, 1999). But the study’s author himself acknowledges that participants were an unrepresentative sample of homeschoolers and the study was not a controlled experiment; therefore, it prevents us from making reliable extrapolations to the general homeschooling population or comparing homeschoolers’ performance with the broader student population (Welner & Welner, 1999). Similar limitations occur in a separate study of SAT scores (Belfield, 2004) [p. 4]. “Again, however, comprehensive empirical evidence is lacking [regarding the social and emotional development of the home educated]” [p. 4]. “Medlin (2000) sought to bring greater precision to the question in his review of dozens of studies focused on homeschooler socialization. He concluded that the evidence, while still preliminary, suggests that homeschooled children are engaged in their community, acquire necessary rules of behavior, and demonstrate social maturity and leadership skills. Medlin emphasized, however, that more and better research is needed before definitive conclusions about homeschooler socialization can be drawn” [p. 4]. “Some educators and policymakers worry that homeschooling provides additional cover for instances of child abuse (as well as child abduction, often resulting from custody disputes). Although it is true that horrific cases of child abuse have occurred in families claiming to be homeschooling, we do not have data revealing whether the frequency is greater than in families whose children are educated in institutional settings. Some argue that when children attend traditional school settings (whether public or private), adults have regular opportunities to observe signs of abuse. The level of homeschool oversight necessary to similarly detect abuse, however, would be substantial. Most typical homeschool oversight mechanisms — registration/enrollment, curriculum approval, instructor certification, and testing — would provide little or no indication; only regular, face-to-face interaction with government representatives would likely make a difference in this regard” [p. 5], and author is likely correct in this conclusion. Makes reasonable case for why the state trying to control the inputs (e.g., qualifications of parents, curriculum or viewpoints to be taught) to homeschooling are impractical and unreasonable. Author clearly reveals his philosophical and political perspective that the state has a fundamental right to control children’s education that supersedes that of the parents’ right when writes the following about homeschooling, a form of private/non-tax-funded education: “In spite of these challenges, however, this analysis is not intended as a recommendation that Indiana avoid exercising any additional oversight. For instance, ascertaining that all homeschoolers are developing very basic levels of literacy and numeracy seems a reasonable expectation and an important safeguard for children and their futures. (This would also necessitate a policy that both clarifies that all Indiana homeschoolers are required to enroll/register and provides a mechanism by which compliance could be verified by state officials.) But we must also be mindful that adding layers of oversight to homeschooling can become very intrusive, and good intentions mixed with poor execution will undoubtedly result in greater suspicion and resistance on the part of homeschoolers, rather than a willingness to find common ground that will continue to protect the interests of parents and their children” [p. 6]. Properly notes, as the editor of this annotated bibliography has for many years preceding 2009 stated in testimony before state legislatures, that if the state is going to lay controls on homeschooling as a form of private education then it must lay the same controls on other forms such as private schools: “Even more important from a legal standpoint, however, is the recognition that homeschooling is not recognized as a separate educational category in Indiana; policy cannot compartmentalize homeschooling apart from all nonpublic, nonaccredited schooling. Any efforts to impose greater regulation would need to apply that same oversight to that broader realm as well — raising the degree of complexity and expense significantly [p. 6]. Posits that public-school personnel and homeschoolers should encourage “… greater participation by homeschoolers in extracurricular activities and specialized coursework” and this “… offers an opportunity for collaborative interactions between homeschool and public school students, something that would hopefully broaden the perspectives of both groups and ultimately strengthen our vital civic fabric” [p. 6]. The following inexplicably ignores much of what is known from 25 years of research on homeschooling: “In conclusion, it is worth returning to the underlying refrain throughout much of this analysis — we simply do not have enough comprehensive, reliable data on homeschoolers’ demographics, philosophies, or practices. Without this insight, it will be difficult to craft policies that respect the interests of parents, children, and our democracy” [p. 6]. A synthesis of research from about 1980 from a combination of quantitative and qualitative research by both allegedly “neutral” and “biased” researchers and the publications of homeschool practitioners and advocates give a relatively reliable and consistent presentation of the demographics, philosophies, and practices of home-education families.) .
Kunzman, Robert 2009 Understanding homeschooling: A better approach to regulation. Theory and Research in Education, 7(3), 311-330. homeschooling, philosophy, theory, law, politics, policy “Abstract. Drawing from six years of qualitative research, this article analyzes the broad range of proposed and existing homeschool regulations throughout the United States. It argues that current homeschool regulations — and most proposals for how to improve them — misjudge the complexity of such an endeavor; state resources are misused and the basic interests [e.g., basic literacy and numeracy, p. 324] of children are not protected. Theoretical arguments about the relative interests of parents, children and the state are important to consider, but our policies must also recognize the limits of what we can and should demand of this unique form of nonpublic schooling. A more modest approach to regulation that focuses on basic skills testing would ultimately be more effective at helping the students who need it most” (p. 311). Author’s policy proposal is “… aimed at balancing the relative interests of parents, children and the state” (p. 314). Kunzman’s statist and democratist worldview/personal conceptual framework/philosophy is clearly evident, although he never forthrightly lays it on the table, as he promotes ultimate state control and power over the education of home-educated children. He writes, “… I disagree with HSLDA’s [Home School Legal Defense Association] general resistance to all forms of regulation [of private homeschooling] …” (p. 316). Never makes a philosophical case for his claims about children’s “interests” and for the State having ultimate power and control to determine what are these interests and how they will be controlled by force of law (p. 316-317); that is, again, he does not state his presuppositions or axioms about these important matters. ““A complete absence of regulation obviously provides the most latitude for parents to educate their children as they see fit, but runs the greatest risk of neglecting the interests of children and the state. Extensive regulations (such as a prescribed curriculum or licensure requirements for parents), on the other hand, jeopardize the flexibility that makes homeschooling an effective [p. 323 ends] educational choice for many families, and may offer relatively little added benefit compared to more modest requirements” (p. 323-324). “What about regulations aimed at protecting other vital interests, such as children developing personal autonomy, and society needing citizens capable of democratic self-rule? In both cases, even if we recognize them as important goals, there is little consensus about what the threshold standards would be or how the state could reliably measure whether students meet them” (p. 324). “As someone who studies civic education for a living, I also have a particular vision of what civic virtue entails – but I would be extremely wary of a society that insisted that everyone echo my vision or risk not being able to homeschool their children” (p. 325). “But I also believe that a liberal democratic society needs to tread lightly when it comes to defining the boundaries of possible good lives, and even in specifying the virtues of good citizenship. In a real sense, our liberal democracy must risk its own well-being as it strives to persuade rather than compel its citizens to be generous listeners, tolerant neighbors and willing to compromise in the face of reasonable disagreement” (p. 325). Author argues for government-mandated basic skills testing (e.g., literacy, numeracy) but appears to ignore the fact that such testing of public school students does not guarantee student learning and there is no significant consequence when public schools fail on this; public school children are not remanded to private school or homeschool. Makes an extremely important admission, as he should, that state control of private homeschooling logically argues for state control of all “nonpublic” (i.e., private) education/schooling (p. 328) and this should cause great concern amongst all advocates of Catholic, evangelical Christian, Jewish, Muslim, New Age, agnostic, atheist, and all other types of institutional schooling.
Kunzman, Robert 2009 Write these laws on your children: Inside the world of conservative Christian homeschooling. Boston, MA: Beacon Press. home education, homeschool, homeschooling, qualitative, private school, philosophy, law, legal, policy, reasons, religion, negative criticism, negative critic Studies, in-depth, six “conservative Christian homeschooling” families in the United States [p. 2, 7]. Addresses “four central questions” in his study; they relate to the actual daily practices of “teaching and learning,” whether the children are being taught to be “thinking for themselves,” what is these families’ understanding of “Christian citizenship,” and what are their thoughts on “homeschool regulation” [p. 9-10]. Author appears to ineluctably be drawn, by his implied statist worldview, to the conclusion that all homeschool families (i.e., parents and children) should have their educational lives controlled (i.e., regulated, he calls it) by the state. Properly admits and acknowledges the following: “Any efforts to establish testing or add other requirements [to homeschooling], therefore, would need to apply to the broader realm of non-public, nonaccredited schools of which homeschooling is a part – raising the degree of complexity and expense significantly” [p. 211]; this statement should send a clear signal, perhaps a red flag, to all advocates of freedom in education and no state control over private educational choices or arrangements (e.g., Roman Catholic schools, Lutheran schools, Christian day schools, “non-sectarian” independent schools, Jewish schools, pagan schools, etc.). Promotes statism as author implicitly believes the state has prior and higher authority than parents in deciding what are the “vital interests of children or society” and that state control over children’s lives should be based on “general [state, societal] consensus” [p. 219] and concludes that private-school students (i.e., homeschool students and, by implication, all children attending private schools) should be forced by the state to undergo “basic skills testing” that is under the authority of the state and, implicitly, all private-school students should be registered with the state [p. 219].
Kunzman, Robert 2010, October Homeschooling and religious fundamentalism. International Electronic Journal of Elementary Education, 3(1), 17-28. http://www.iejee.com/3_1_2010/17_28.pdf home education, homeschooling, Christian fundamentalism, Muslim, religion, philosophy “This article considers the relationship between homeschooling and religious fundamentalism by focusing on their intersection in the philosophies and practices of conservative Christian homeschoolers in the United States. Homeschooling provides an ideal educational setting to support several core fundamentalist principles: resistance to contemporary culture; suspicion of institutional authority and professional expertise; parental control and centrality of the family; and interweaving of faith and academics. It is important to recognize, however, that fundamentalism exists on a continuum; conservative religious homeschoolers resist liberal democratic values to varying degrees, and efforts to foster dialogue and accommodation with religious homeschoolers can ultimately help strengthen the broader civic fabric [Abstract, retrieved 2/15/2012 from http://www.iejee.com/3_1_2010/17_28.pdf]. “Nevertheless, religious conservatives likely remain the largest subset of homeschoolers, at least in the United States. The relative freedom and flexibility of homeschooling allows parents to craft an educational environment that reflects their values and priorities, and religious conservatives find such an option particularly appealing. This essay explores the relationship between homeschooling and religious fundamentalism, and suggests four ways in which homeschooling provides an educational setting especially conducive to reinforcing core fundamentalist principles. The point of such a comparison, however, is not to imply that homeschooling inherently fosters religious fundamentalism. The structural flexibility of homeschooling, and the space it provides both literally and ideologically, lends itself to countercultural movements of all kinds. For instance, it also supports a socially progressive critique, which is where the modern homeschooling movement gained early inspiration, in the writings of John Holt (Gaither, 2008)” (p. 18). “Furthermore, when we raise concerns about the lack of ethical pluralism in the fundamentalist homeschooling context, it’s worth considering how much ethical diversity our public schools provide. ….. Even encouraging homeschool students to enroll part time in selected classes can get them involved in the life of the school and broader community in important ways. Some fundamentalist homeschoolers charge that such an approach is an attempt to defuse their resistance and liberalize their children. I would see it instead as an attempt to include religious conservatives in a civic conversation about how to live together despite our ethical differences” [p. 25]. Presents thoughtful insights about “religious” homeschooling, especially at the end of article. “Stereotypes of religious homeschooling often involve parents creating brainwashed automatons, unable to think for themselves and either sequestered from society or determined to impose their worldview on others. But consider what it means to homeschool, whether religiously motivated or not, in a society where at least 95 percent of the population does otherwise (and far more in Europe). By virtue of their freedom to shape their child’s education in almost any way they choose, homeschoolers are pushed to grapple with several vital and profound questions: What are the central purposes of education? What kind of person do I want my child to become? How can I make their learning experience the best it can be? One might argue that the rest of us, and the schools we support and send our children to, neglect such fundamental questions far too much. A persistent conversation about the values that inform such schooling, and an ongoing consideration of how it can invite and involve as much of the public as possible, remains a vital civic task” [p. 26]. Appears, as in other articles author has written, to want more/much of “the public” – the State, that is? – involved in the lives of home-educated children and their families: “A persistent conversation about the values that inform such schooling, and an ongoing consideration of how it can invite and involve as much of the public as possible, remains a vital civic task” [p. 26].) .
Kunzman, Robert 2012 Education, schooling, and children's rights: the complexity of homeschooling. Educational Theory. Retrieved April 2, 2020 from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1741-5446.2011.00436.x https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1741-5446.2011.00436.x homeschooling, home schooling, philosophy, legal, law, regulation, theoretical “Abstract: By blurring the distinction between formal school and education writ large, homeschooling both highlights and complicates the tensions among the interests of parents, children, and the state. In this essay, Robert Kunzman argues for a modest version of children's educational rights, at least in a legal sense that the state has the duty and authority to enforce. At the same time, however, it is important to retain a principled distinction between schooling and education—not only to protect children's basic educational rights, but also to prevent the state from overreaching into the private realm of the home and family.”
Kunzman, Robert, & Gaither, Milton 2013 Homeschooling: A comprehensive survey of the research. Other Education: The Journal of Educational Alternatives, 2(1), 4-59. Retrieved 7/2/13 from http://www.othereducation.stir.ac.uk/index.php/OE/article/view/10/55. http://www.othereducation.stir.ac.uk/index.php/OE/article/view/10/55 homeschooling, home education, research, review, synthesis, academic achievement, reasons, motivation, socialization “Abstract: This article provides a comprehensive summary of the English-language research and scholarship on homeschooling, organized into the categories of demographics, curriculum, academic achievement, socialization, law, relationships with public schools, transition to college/adulthood, and international homeschooling. The 351 texts used in this review were culled from virtually the entire universe of English-language academic texts on the topic—more than 1,400 total. Scholarship was evaluated using three primary criteria: quality of scholarship, significance or influence, and distinctiveness of insight. This review sought to answer the following questions: What primary topics or themes are addressed in the literature? How effective are the methodology and analysis performed? What does the research reveal about homeschooling, and what questions remain unanswered?” [p. 4]. Authors offer some helpful insights, but not many, into the state of research to date. Unfortunately and in an anti-scholarly manner, consistently commit the fallacies of poisoning the well and guilt by association regarding various studies and researchers rather than carefully discussing methodology and letting the reader decide for himself/herself about the value of the research. For example, mention the funding sources of some studies but not of other studies. Are biased to mention when some studies are funded by a private “advocacy organization” but do not mention other studies funding sources and do not mention that one of the authors is funded by state/tax funds and state entities (e.g., state universities) and agents of the state (e.g., professors at state/public universities) are prone to favor the norm, statism, neo-Marxism, critical theory, liberalism or progressivism (not, i.e., classical liberalism), and state control over education. The authors of this study should state their worldview biases if they are going to write, in a balanced way, about what they seem to think are the biases of certain researchers cited in their article. If this were a balanced “survey of the research” then if they state the funding source of one study they should mention the source for all studies; if they state one funding group or research is “advocacy” then they are implying others are not so they should state their criteria for determining advocacy, neutrality, or antipathy and inform the reader about each funder and researcher, but they do not. Ignore specific elements of certain studies and get wrong (or misrepresented) specific details of certain studies (e.g., regarding Ray, 2010 nationwide study) and fail to mention significant available data on some topics (e.g., state-provided data on homeschool students’ academic achievement). An example of failing to include very important information is the authors’ discussion of Pennings et al. (2011) and not stating the sample size of 89 or fewer (out of 2,000 subjects in the study) who had been homeschooled and who were homeschooled for an unknown number of years. The presentation of studies is often done in an imbalanced way that makes it appear the authors might not be motivated to be carefully balanced and fair, or do not even recognize their own imbalances. Discuss press releases by an “advocacy organization” about only some studies on homeschooling, that the authors want to criticize, when press releases are basically irrelevant to scholarship. Authors of this article appear to be engaged in some ax-grinding and have some kind of political or worldview point to make considering how non-scholarly and imbalanced their paper is at various points. They claim, “Given this persistent corroboration across two decades we might conclude, tentatively, that there may be at least a modest homeschooling effect on academic achievement—namely that it tends to improve students’ verbal and weaken their math capacities” (p. 17) but they references they cite, carefully analyzed, do not support this claim. The homeschooled might not score as high in math as in reading and language, but the evidence as of 2013 does not suggest that homeschooling “… weaken[s] their math capacities.” Probably not outright promoting state control/regulation of homeschooling.
Kunzman, Robert, & Gaither, Milton 2020 Homeschooling: An updated comprehensive survey of the research. Other Education: The Journal of Educational Alternatives, 9(1), 253-336, https://www.othereducation.org/index.php/OE/article/view/259 https://www.othereducation.org/index.php/OE/article/view/259 homeschooling, home education, review, research, academic achievement, socialization, social development, adults, trends Helpful review of research especially in terms of updating some things. However, these authors continue (from past articles) to commit the fallacy of poisoning the well when writing about certain researchers (e.g., Ray). They are biased in terms of reporting the worldviews and funding sources of a very few researchers but not all; this is anti-scholarly and biased. They appear to work very hard to find anything negative they can about homeschool students. Makes the serious error (p. 272) of lumping Alaska government-run correspondence schooling with homeschooling to make a statement about public school graduation rates; very confused. This claim is false: “First, Brian D. Ray’s National Home Education Research Institute (NHERI), which for decades was the dominant player in homeschooling research and the most visible proponent of research-based homeschooling advocacy, has become far less active in recent years even as university-based research has increased” (p. 254). Consistently negatively criticize the methods of various studies (e.g., not representative samples) that found positive things related to homeschooling and use fallacy of poisoning the well regarding authors but when report on Knox et al. 2014 (on torture, abuse) Kunzman and Gaither make no mention that it is not a representative sample and was not intended to be. Their entire two long paragraphs on abuse and neglect (p. 286-287) uses non-representative-sample reports and non-scholarly studies to cast much aspersion on homeschooling related to abuse and neglect when throughout the article they have been negatively critiquing most studies that associate anything positive with homeschooling. This is a very imbalanced approach to critiquing methods in studies and reports; e.g., authors write, “Drawing from an incomplete but growing database, the Coalition for Responsible Home Education [CRHE] (2020) asserts that homeschoolers’ children are at disproportionate risk of dying from abuse” (p. 287) and yet the CRHE database is not representative and the organization who the authors cite report no statistically significant difference between the homeschooled and others regarding children’s deaths. This review of research is subtly discriminatory, generally against any positive findings associated with homeschooling, throughout but the reader will not see this unless he/she is intimately familiar with the studies and reports that are covered. Authors claim, “Given this persistent corroboration across three decades we might conclude, tentatively, that there may be at least a modest homeschooling effect on academic achievement— namely that it tends to improve students’ verbal skills and weaken their math capacities” (p. 271) but a careful analysis of the studies they cite does not support this claim. For example, both Belfield and Qaqish (cited) deal with students who are going on to college and not general K-12 achievement. Belfield’s two studies are not in peer-reviewed journals and he does not state that the non-homeschooled do statistically significantly better than expected than the homeschooled. Qaqish found very small differences, practically speaking. The homeschooled might not score as high in math as in reading and language with confounding variables controlled, but the evidence as of 2020 does not suggest that homeschooling “… weaken[s] their math capacities.” In their section with, “Studies thus far have found, so far as the limited data allow, that different regulatory climates correlate weakly or not at all with the percentage of homeschoolers in a state, the rate of growth in homeschooling, homeschooler test scores, or any other variable studied (Bhatt, 2014; Hail, 2003; Levy, 2009; Stewart & Neeley, 2005). Ray and Eagleson (2008), for example, found no correlation between degree of state regulation of homeschooling and SAT scores of 6,170 test takers self-designating as homeschoolers in 2001,” (p. 290), they fail to cite two key studies on this topic (Ray, 2000, 2010); this is poor or biased scholarship. The authors cite one of themselves (Kunzman, 2009) as favoring more state government control/regulation of homeschooling than many states currently exist (thus promoting statism) but do not appear as a co-authorship to be promoting state control regulation.
Kurtz, Kitt Ellen 2003 Home education: An authentic educative practice, end results and social implications for a post modern age. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation , Ashland University, Ashland, Ohio. home education, research, qualitative, adults, socialization, careers, graduates “This study examines experiences of eleven Christian home-educated adults, exploring influences that shaped adult work, relationships, and social identity” using interviews, documents, and observations. “Results suggest this sample has (1) successfully completed higher education and/or established careers; [sic] (2) demonstrated positive engagement in a diverse society, and (3) achieved original parental objectives. In conclusion, data suggest home education is an authentic educative practice that fosters human development holistically, attending to nurture heart, soul, mind, and strength. End results suggest social implications for a postmodern age” [p. iv, abstract].
Kuthimba, Elizabeth Nzisa 2019 Effect of home education on reading motivation. Master’s thesis, Strathmore University, Nairobi, Kenya. “ABSTRACT. The purpose of this research was to investigate the effect that home education has on reading motivation of its pupils aged 8-11. Home educated children within the sample space were drawn from three Nairobi regions of one home educators’ network. The study utilized Wigfield’s motivated reader model whose Motivated Reader Questionnaire (MRQ) tool, assesses self-beliefs goals, and values, of readers to determine reading motivation. Reader self beliefs were measured by self-efficacy, work avoidance and challenge subscales. Reader values were measured by social, grades, compliance subscales. While reader achievement goals were measured by curiosity, involvement, recognition and competition sub-scales. Fifty three indicators of these 11 aspects of reading motivation were tested among emerging readers leading the study to the conclusion that home education has no effect on reader self-beliefs, goals and values. The study correlated home educated pupils on all the aspects of reading motivation on all the 53 indicators of MRQ using the Chi Square statistic. The study found that 3 of 53 indicators of reading motivation had a significant relationship with years spent in home education. The study also analysed the strength of relationship between years in home education and reading motivation and found the relationship to be moderately strong and lacking predictive capability. Girls had a stronger beliefs, goals and values on reading motivation than boys. The study confined its observations to the home education situation in Kenya. The study recommended reading motivation be addressed among budding readers within the age bracket. Recommendations concerned home educators, and parent-led interventions. The researcher anticipated interaction between Kenyan education policy makers and home educators with a view to improve basic education provision locally” (p. iii).)
Kutter, Pauletta Offutt 1987 The home schooling movement in central Kentucky. Home School Researcher, 3(4), 1-3.
Kyazze, Godfrey Olga 2019 Assessing the viability of homeschooling in Uganda. Master’s thesis, Uganda Christian University, Mukono, Uganda. homeschooling, demographics, survey, quantitative, philosophy, history Survey of homeschool families in Uganda. Quantitative methods research. "It is also important to note that the argument of parents not being able to educate their own children at home because they are illiterate is based on a narrow view of what is education” p. 56. "Nature grants it to parents to educate their children (Tarcov, 1999); but also, biblically speaking, education of children is a divine mandate to parents3. The basic question at stake in our Uganda's education system is, whose role is the education of a child? The common wrong assumption is that it is primarily the government's duty to educate the nation. This contradicts principles of nature and most studies available. It would be therefore important for policy makers to consider granting more powers and freedom in a country like Uganda to parents so they can take more or full charge of the education of their children, as it is in other countries such as the USA" (p. 59).
Lacitis, Erik 1988 High-tech era is spawning a generation of lonesome children. The Seattle Times, October 31, p.2.
Lagos, Julio Alberto 2011 Parental education rights in the United States and Canada: Homeschooling and its legal protection. Doctoral Thesis in Canon Law at the Pontificia Universitas Sanctæ Crucis Facultas Iuris Canonici. homeschooling, parental rights, state rights, children’s rights, state, regulation, control, policy, academic achievement, Roman Catholicism Focuses on the United States and Canada. “This study will address the fundamental issue of what rights parents have and what are the limits to mandatory public schooling. We will see that home education involves disparate interests: the best interests of the child, compulsory state education, and the parental right to educate their children according to one’s beliefs and convictions. The specific object of this thesis is to investigate the legal aspects of homeschooling in English- and French-speaking North America and draw conclusions as to the parental right to homeschooling and the proper limits to state authority. We will review the laws and policies that currently regulate home education in the United States and Canada. In addition, the study will analyze judicial decisions in those countries that consider the interplay of legal rights related to homeschooling. Where does the parental interest give way to state intervention? Or, to put it another way, where does the family yield to the wider community? (p. 7). Includes a focus on Roman Catholic magisterial documents and the Code of Canon Law of 1983 regarding parental rights in education. Presupposes, philosophically, that the State has some fundamental or a priori right and duty to make sure and/or control whether children are receiving the education the State deems right, appropriate, or correct. Author is, in a sense, a statist. “Our study indicates that states have the obligation to permit structures or methods outside the public school system such as private schools and homeschooling, although they retain the right to regulate such schooling. After all, without some type of monitoring for basic literacy and scientific achievement, how will parents and schools be cognizant of the quality or shortcomings of the child’s academic achievement? (p. 261). “This leads necessarily to the conclusion that teacher certification has no correlation to homeschooled student outcomes and would be an unreasonable burden on parents who choose homeschooling and deter the state’s interest in education. Periodic formal assessment of homeschooled children, whether the standardized tests taken every year as the public school students in that state, testing in a form mutually acceptable to both parent and the state, or qualitative evaluations, may be the most suitable compromise between state and parents.Periodic testing of homeschoolers favours a successful educational outcome by assuring a good education for children while also respecting a parent’s right to oversee their education and upbringing. If the real issue underlying homeschooling statutes and regulation is the education of children and not the manner in which that education is given, then these recommendations will ensure that children receives an education without undue state interference. ….. This thesis supports a relatively laissez-faire approach to regulating homeschooling, in so far as most evidence indicates that parents are resourceful and sufficiently organized to provide a quality education.” (p. 268-269).
Lahrson-Fisher, Ann 1998, September/October Coping with hybrid homeschool public school programs. Home Education Magazine, 15(5), 27-28. home education, public school support, cooptation, cooperation, philosophy, politics Discusses tax-funded, state-controlled, public school programs designed for home schoolers or education at home and philosophical and other concerns about the increasing number of these programs around the country. “Hybrid Programs represent the needs of the Second Wave of homeschoolers. They are the backfill between traditional schooling and regular homeschooling. If we want to see the movement continue to grow, we may have little choice: we must provide private hybrid alternatives or accept what the public sector offers” [p. 28]; author misses the rather obvious point that “hybrid homeschool public school programs” (in the title of her article) are what the public sector is offering.
Laird, Bret M. 2021 Family, government, and church: Relating three jurisdictions of divinely delegated authority. Wapwallopen, PA: Shepherd Press church, state, family, jurisdictions, spheres of authority, spheres of jurisdiction, government, civil government and The Master’s Academy International). (“Western governments are growing increasingly hostile to both the family and the church. This creates an urgent need to equip parents, church leaders, and individual believers with biblical answers to three vital questions: What should a believer's attitude and perspective be toward human government? How can we know when we are supposed to submit to government (Romans 13:1) and when we must "obey God rather than men" (Acts 5:29)? How can we know when governments have exceeded the limits of their divinely ordained jurisdiction and intruded on authority which God has given exclusively to the church or to the family? In his careful exposition of Romans 13 and other key passages, Pastor Bret Laird provides readers with biblical principles and a decision-making paradigm which they can use to navigate our increasingly complex socio-political landscape” (description Amazon.com).) ?
Lancaster, Phil 2003 The future of home schooling. Published 2/13/03 and retrieved 2/14/03 online http://www.visionforumministries.org/sections/hotcon/ht/education/futureofhomeschooling.asp. http://www.visionforumministries.org/sections/hotcon/ht/education/futureofhomeschooling.asp home education, private schools, Christian education, philosophy, public schools, history In many ways this is a response to Steve M. Schlissel’s 2003 article “The end of home-schooling.” “However, it seems like cooperative education could also simply be what it appears: The application of the principle of the division of labor for the optimum use of family and community resources. It is a big leap to conclude that since we may benefit from having someone else teach our children chemistry that we need to move completely beyond home education toward institutional schooling.” “As for the "dominion headquarters" of future men not being the home, I beg to differ. The home is the dominion headquarters for everyone. While the entire scope of a woman's dominion task is home-centered, the man also must be home-centered in the sense that he must succeed at home or he cannot be a real success outside the home where he is also called to take dominion (1 Tim. 3:5). His dominion role does not end in the home, but it certainly begins there. Boys can have home-based training and still have plenty of exposure to other manly environments. My sons are home schooled, but they have built houses, worked with tractors, volunteered to save lives on the rescue squad, dispatched wild dogs with two-by-fours and guns, and killed a deer with a knife. Their home-based schooling has had no lack of out-of-the-home dominion work. And, by the way, is the artificial environment of a school classroom the future "dominion headquarters" of boys?” “While he seems to strain to find arguments against home education, Pastor Schlissel seems to pass lightly over the profound strengths of the practice. As we saw, he acknowledges the spiritual, social, academic, and familial benefits of home schooling. Not too shabby, that list. What else is there? Home schooling sounds superior in most every way. Yet he clearly believes that Christian community schools would provide a superior academic training. But where is the evidence of the superiority of classroom schooling?” “It would be a giant leap backward for Christians to abandon home education in favor of establishing new institutional schools. We ought to stick with our wildly unregulated, dreadfully inefficient, hopelessly homey system, simply because it works better than any other system in terms of achieving the goals God sets before Christian parents. But we ought to have the humility to be teachable and to improve the model of home education. Some form of cooperative home-based education seems to me to be the mature form of what we have begun. And by all means, we ought to have academic excellence as one of our goals, just not at the expense of the more fundamental Christian values.”
Lande, Nancy circa 1998 Homeschooling: A patchwork of days -- share a day with 30 homeschooling families. Windy Creek [publisher].
Lande, Nancy 2000 Homeschool open house: Interviews with 55 families. Windy Creek Press [publisher]. home education, interviews, daily life Interviews homeschool families and provides views into their daily lives; shows the great variety of families, lifestyles, pedagogical approaches in existence in the contemporary homeschool movement.
Lane, Dixie Dillon 2026 Skipping school: A history of American homeschooling and how it went mainstream. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans. homeschooling, home education, book, history, qualitative and quantitative, research Overall, a solid history of the modern homeschooling movement and she does well tying it in to the history of parental influence and control throughout the history of American education. Lane shows fuzziness and ambiguity in her definition of homeschooling; for example, she considers public schooling at home to be homeschooling if the parents consider themselves to be homeschooling that child: “For the purpose of this study, I define home schooling by what I consider its most important characteristic: as a form of education outside of conventional classrooms that is characterized by high levels of parental influence, direction, and even control. When a parent both understands himself as a homeschooler and retains dominant influence over the child’s day-to-day schooling, this is homeschooling.  Thus, in this book, a child who studies out of workbooks at the kitchen table counts as a homeschooler; a child who attends a twice-a-week co-op in which parents take turns teaching classes of students different subjects also counts as a homeschooler; and a child who does his schoolwork on a computer through a public school homeschooling curriculum that designates the parent as a “learning coach” is also homeschooled. Yet in this last case, for example, if that same child’s parents do not consider themselves to be homeschooling, then that child is not homeschooled” (p. 14.)
Lapin, Daniel 1993, November Parents versus the state. Crisis [magazine] education, religion, Judaism, public schools, state, philosophy Lapin is Rabbi of Pacific Jewish Center, senior fellow at the Claremmong Institute, and president of Toward Tradition. Explains that the Bible provides “... a rigning endorsement of parental authority [regarding education] ..... Government can help parents, but it may not appropriate their primary role.”
Lapin, Daniel 1999 America’s real war. Sisters, OR: Multnomah Publishers. culture, politics, sociology, religion, philosophy, education, Judaism, Christianity Lapin, a Jew, writes: “Both American Christians and American Jews who are serious about their faith believe that the family is the fundamental building block of society ..... Both would agree that fear of the Lord is the foundation of all wisdom and both would agree that parents know better than children and should be respected by their children. What is more, both would agree that these ideas regarding the organization of human society are the direction of God rather than the rational conclusions of clever humans” [p. 141]. “Any student who has been deprived of knowledge of God commences his scientific studies at a disadvantage. One of his handicaps will be the temptation to attribute anything that seems mysterious to coincidence. This trap awaits because a world without God is obviously a world without purpose. It is a world of randomness” [p. 159]. Emphasizes essentiality of the traditional family (i.e., a married father and mother with children) to with parents teaching and involved in the lives of their children.
Lareau, Annette 1989mis?? Home advantage. mis???
Lareau, Annette & Benson, Charles 1984 The economics of home/school relationships: A cautionary note. Phi Delta Kappan, February, pp. 401-404.
Large, Tim 2000, September 2 Stay-at-home kids shunning the system. The Daily Yomiuri, p. 7. http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/index-e.htm http://www2.gol.com/users/milkat/articles.html#stay http://www.asahi-net.or.jp/~ja8i-brtl/articlesLocal.html home education, reasons, opinion Otemachi, Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo, Japan [http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/index-e.htm]. Retrieved 11/22/00 online http://www2.gol.com/users/milkat/articles.html#stay and retrieved 6/19/02 online http://www.asahi-net.or.jp/~ja8i-brtl/articlesLocal.html. Discusses growth of home schooling in Japan and reasons for its growth.
Larzelere, Robert 1994 "Should the use of corporal punishment by parents be considered child abuse? -- No," in Mason and Gambrill (eds.), Debating children's lives, pp. 204-9. corporal punishment, chastisement, discipline, spank, spanking, research probably, child training, behavior, misbehavior
Larzelere, Robert E. 1996 A review of the outcomes of parental use of nonabusive or customary physical punishment. Pediatrics 98, Supplement, 824-28. corporal punishment, chastisement, discipline, spank, spanking, research, child training, behavior, misbehavior
Larzelere, Robert E. 2002, June A comparison of two recent reviews of scientific studies of physical punishment by parents. Retrieved 1/24/03 online http://people.biola.edu/faculty/paulp/Larzelere02.html. http://people.biola.edu/faculty/paulp/Larzelere02.html corporal punishment, chastisement, discipline, spank, spanking, research, child training, behavior, misbehavior “Rather, these results confirm my suspicion that the detrimental outcomes associated with nonabusive physical punishment are due to the excessive misbehavior that leads to more physical punishment. Excessive misbehavior is reflected even more strongly in more common types of disciplinary tactics, such as nonphysical punishment and disciplinary reasoning. We cannot continue to lump all forms of physical punishment together to make an overall assessment that applies to all applications. Rather, we need to discriminate between more vs. less effective ways of using each disciplinary tactic. How parents use any disciplinary tactic is more important than what tactic they use – whether we are considering disciplinary reasoning, nonphysical consequences, or physical discipline. Especially with 2- to 3-year-olds, disciplinary reasoning works better if it is backed up when necessary, first by nonphysical punishment, and then, if warranted, by occasional nonabusive spanking or something equivalent.9 13 This is consistent with the strongest causal evidence about physical punishment: Nonabusive spanking reduces subsequent noncompliance and fighting in 2- to 6-year-olds when used by loving parents to back up milder disciplinary tactics, such as reasoning or time out. Nine studies support this conclusion, and no study contradicts it. To be sure, a brief room isolation has proven to be equally effective as a spank back-up in enforcing cooperation with time out in clinically defiant 2- to 6-year-olds.14 Further, nonphysical punishment works as effectively as physical punishment in backing up reasoning in 2- to 3-year-olds.10 Nonetheless, when two disciplinary tactics are equally effective on the average, they are each more effective for some children some of the time than the other alternative. That was demonstrated in Roberts and Powers (1990).14 Moreover, the most effective way to reduce subsequent fighting in my best study occurred when mothers combined reasoning, a nonphysical consequence, and a nonabusive spanking.9 The evidence to date supports a conditional sequence model of optimal disciplinary tactics.13 For 2- to 6-year-olds, parents should establish a solid foundation of a positive, loving parent-child relationship. They should emphasize proactive teaching – an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. When misbehavior occurs, they need effective responses, beginning with verbal correction and reasoning. Disciplinary reasoning becomes more effective by itself when backed up periodically with nonphysical punishment. When a 2- to 6-year-old refuses to cooperate with nonphysical punishment, such as time out, it needs to be enforced with something like a two-swat spank to the buttocks. Yes, there are alternatives that work better for a few children all of the time and for all children some of the time. But when spanking is used in this way at these ages, the evidence to date indicates it is effective, especially in getting children to cooperate more with the milder disciplinary tactics. In this way, parents can reduce the need to use spanking at all as the child gets older. Parents need more disciplinary options, not fewer ones. They also need to know optimal strategies for all aspects of discipline. Hopefully future research can build on these two reviews to provide parents with that information.”
Larzelere, Robert E., & Kuhn, Brett R 2005 Comparing child outcomes of physical punishment and alternative disciplinary tactics: A meta-analysis. Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review, 8(1). children, parenting, discipline, punishment, spanking, smacking, corporal punishment “This meta-analysis investigates differences between the effect sizes of physical punishment and alternative disciplinary tactics for child outcomes in 26 qualifying studies. Analyzing differences in effect sizes reduces systematic biases and emphasizes direct comparisons between the disciplinary tactics that parents have to select among. The results indicated that effect sizes significantly favored conditional spanking over 10 of 13 alternative disciplinary tactics for reducing child noncompliance or antisocial behavior. Customary physical punishment yielded effect sizes equal to alternative tactics, except for one large study favoring physical punishment. Only overly severe or predominant use of physical punishment compared unfavorably with alternative disciplinary tactics. The discussion highlights the need for better discriminations between effective and counterproductive use of disciplinary punishment in general” [abstract].
Larzelere, Robert E., Schneider, William N., Larson, David B., & Pike, Patricia L. 1996 The effects of discipline responses in delaying toddler misbehavior recurrences. Child and Family Behavior Therapy, 18, 35-57. corporal punishment, chastisement, discipline, spank, spanking, research probably, child training, behavior, misbehavior
Lattibeaudiere, Vivien 2000 Exploratory study of the transition and adjustment of former home schooled students to college life. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, University of Tennessee Knoxville. home education, graduates, success of homeschool graduates in college or university, academic achievement, social adjustment, socialization “Abstract. The practice of home schooling is a fast growing educational trend in the United States. Like students in traditional school settings, as home schooled children complete the equivalent of their high school education, many continue their education by enrolling in colleges and universities. However, yew little research has been conducted about the experiences of these students in college. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to describe the experiences of former home schooled students as they made the transition from the home school environment into the college culture, and to determine how they adjusted to college life. The conceptual framework for the study utilized a number of student development, adjustment and retention models, including Tinto’s reconceptualization of Van Gennep’s Rites of Passage theory. Twenty-five former home schooled students attending religiously affiliated colleges and public state universities were interviewed and completed the Student Adaptation to College Questionnaire (SACQ) Another data source consisted of interviews with 22 faculty and staff members identified by students at their institutions, who were able to speak to their experiences in college. The results of the study indicated that former home schooled in the sample were students were very well prepared for college. A number of skills they learned in borne schooling contributed to them making a relatively smooth transition into [p. v] the academic and social systems of their campuses. Students in the sample scored at the 88th percentile on the academic adjustment subscale, the 76th percentile on the social adjustment subscale and the 84th percentile on the emotional adjustment subscale of the SACQ, compared to the 50th percentile score of traditionally educated students in the questionnaire’s normative sample. All data sources consistently revealed that students attending religiously affiliated colleges were much better adjusted to college academically, socially and emotionally than their counterparts attending public universities. Furthermore, the longer students were home schooled, the better they adjusted to college. Overall, the results of the study indicated that students in the sample not only performed and adjusted well in college, hut also suggests that home schooling maybe a viable educational option for preparing students to succeed in college [p. vi].” Personal communication via e-mail from author on 5/22/00, “Twenty-five former home schooled students attending religiously affiliated colleges and public state universities in the state of Tennessee were interviewed and completed the Student Adaptation to College Questionnaire. Another data source consisted of interviews with 22 faculty and staff members identified by students at their institutions, who were able to speak to their experiences in college. Summary of Findings The results of the study indicated that all of the students in the sample, with the exception of one student, had positive home school experiences that contributed to their transition and adjustment to college. ..... On a whole, former home schooled students in the study performed and adjusted very well to college life. Students in the sample scored at the 88th percentile on the Academic Adjustment subscale of the Student Adaptation to College Questionnaire (SACQ), compared to the 50th percentile score of traditionally educated students in the questionnaire's normative sample. Former home schooled students in the sample had a mean earned GPA of 3.52. ..... All data sources consistently reflected that the longer students in the sample were home schooled, the better their adjustment to college in all areas. ..... Overall, the results of this study indicate that, on the whole, former home schooled students in the sample performed very well academically in college and adjusted well to the social and emotional demands of college life. The findings also suggest that former home schooled students in the sample adjusted very well academically, socially and emotionally to college compared to traditionally educated students in the normative sample of the Student Adaptation to College Questionnaire. The comparison between former home schooled students and traditionally educated students in this study must be interpreted with caution, however, because the study was limited in scope and was not an empirically controlled experimental study utilizing statistically comparable samples.”
Lawrence et al. v. South Carolina State Board of Education. Opinion No. 23526. Heard October 31, 1991--Filed December 9, 1991 1991 home education, certification, teacher qualification, parent qualification, legal, test validity, testing ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED338719. (This court decision reverses Farris and Black of Home School Legal Defense Association v. South Carolina State Board of Education, which found that the Education Entrance Examination (EEE) was properly validated for use in testing home school instructors as regulated by Sout Carolina Code. IOX Assessment Associates claimed the EEE was valid. Dr. Brian Ray testified in the case. This South Carolina Supreme Court case finds that the State's validation process fails to meet a standard of reasonableness, and the requirement that parents pass the EEE is unenforceable under the home schooling statute.
Laws, Richard Dwight 1985 The use of micro-computers to enhance parent support in the home for teaching reading to first and second grade students. Dissertation Abstracts International, 47, 156A. Computers. "The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of a series of letters, generated by a micro-computer, that are sent home by the teacher to solicit and instruct parents to assist in the instruction of reading to their children" (p.156A). There were found positive effects (not statistically significant) in the following four areas: (a) teacher use of the system, (b) parent attitudes toward the school, 8 amount of time parents spend teaching their children, and (d) reading scores.
Lazarus, Stephen 1999, July 19 Ten commandments politics. Capital Commentary [newsletter], p. 1. education, choice, reform, private, public Published by The Center for Public Justice, 2444 Solomon's Island Rd Ste 201, Annapolis MD 21401). (Writes, "Let's give all citizens the freedom to attend publicly supported schools that are genuinely faith-based and linked to particular religious traditions, such as Christianity, Judaism, or Islam. ..... [new paragraph] Parents bear the primary responsibility for educating their children, and they should be able to choose from a variety of locally controlled, faith-based or secular schools supported by the public" [p. 1]. Fails to explain that all schools--all education, including “secular”--is, ultimately, religious or faith-based; therefore current public schools are faith-based.
Lechtreck, Roy Fall-Winter 1990-1991 Book reviews. Educational Freedom, 24(1), 59-63. research
Lechtreck, Roy Fall-Winter 1990-1991 Home schooling: Introduction. Educational Freedom, 24(1), 1-2. home education
Ledson, Sidney 1983 Raising brighter children. McClelland and Stewart.
Lee, Renee C. 2008, August 25 Leaving the learning at home: More blacks choosing to teach their own children. Houston Chronicle, retrieved 8/25/08 from http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/front/5964005.html. http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/front/5964005.html black, blacks, African Americans, minorities, news, opinion, pedagogy, philosophy, history “Once seen by many blacks as something only whites do, home schooling has steadily gained momentum in the black community in the past eight years and is expected to continue to grow, say home school experts. "Ten years ago, there were not that many people of color home schooling," said Brian Ray, president of National Home Education Research Institute in Salem, Ore.”
Leicht, Kevin T.; Walter, Tony; & Sainsaulieu, Ivan 2009 New public management and new professionalism across nations and contexts. Current Sociology, 57(4), 581-605. institutional theory, neoliberalism, new professionalism, new public management, postindustrial society, professional accountability, homeschooling, school choice, Canada Mention homeschooling only a few times. There is no notable focus on homeschooling. “These ideas about educational markets and school choice have spawned one of the most polarized debates in contemporary education. For our purposes, what is important is to consider the impact of choice initiatives on teacher professionalism. School choice is often premised on a philosophy of parental authority that challenges institutional experts such as teachers and principals. Choice-seekers usually demand that educators comply with their wants for a particular schooling philosophy. Teachers often oppose choice as an overly ‘consumerist’ intrusion into public schooling. Further, choice can erode teacher authority by allowing parents to dictate the terms of schooling and facilitating the employment of noncertified teachers” (p. 594). “Abstract: The professions in the West are undergoing unprecedented calls for greater accountability and efficiency in service delivery. This article links these changes to recent developments in institutional theory that emphasize shifting salience of technical over symbolic organizational environments. The analysis of the adaptations to these changes in French and British healthcare, Canadian education and US managerial consulting suggest that country-specific responses to neoliberal institutional pressures are highly path dependent. The article concludes by suggesting a research program for the future study of the cross-national responses of professional groups to neoliberal economic and political ideologies” (p. 581).
Leichter, Hope Jenson (Ed.) 1977 The family as educator. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
Leithart, Peter J. 2008 The New Classical Schooling. The Intercollegiate Review, 2008, Spring, 3-12. Retrieved 7/15/13 from http://www.mmisi.org/IR/43_01/leithart.pdf . http://www.mmisi.org/IR/43_01/leithart.pdf classical schooling, classical education, the trivium, private schools, homeschooling Mentions homeschooling a few times and how some homeschoolers are using the classical approach to education. Homeschooling is not a notable focus of this paper.
Lellis, Paula F. C. 2026 Legal discourse on homeschooling in Brazil a corpus-based study, 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2026.2664337 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2026.2664337 Corpus linguistics; court decisions; educational legitimacy; homeschooling; legal discourse; Brazil “Abstract. This study examines how Brazilian courts construct the legal legitimacy of homeschooling through judicial discourse. Using Corpus Linguistics and Critical Discourse Analysis, it analyzes 113 rulings (2015–2025), of which 108 reject homeschooling. Courts operationalize the right to education through compulsory enrollment, treating non-enrollment as illegal regardless of evidence of learning. Judicial language centers on State duty and legal obligation, while largely ignoring learning processes, outcomes, and children’s development. References to core academic skills are nearly absent. This reveals that legal reasoning prioritizes institutional criteria over actual learning, effectively excluding home education from recognition, even when demonstrably provided.”
Leo, J. 1992, September 14 Sneer not at 'Ozzie and Harriet'. U. S. News and World Report, 113(10), 24.
Leppert, Mary, & Leppert, Michael 1999 or 2000 The homeschooling almanac 2000. Rocklin, CA: Prima Publishing.
Leue, Mary M. (Ed.) 1992 Challenging the giant: The best of SKOLE, the Journal of Alternative Education. ERIC Document No. ED356930. http://www.eric.ed.gov childrens rights; community control; community schools; educational change; educational environment; elementary secondary education; experiential learning; folk schools; homeschooling, home schooling; nontraditional education; participative decision making; small schools; theory practice relationship Mentions or focuses on homeschooling in several places in the document. This is like a book or collected works. One article is entitled, Homeschooling and John Holt's vision” and the author is Pat Farenga. This is not a research-based collection. “Abstract: Beginning in the mid-1960s, thousands of small alternative schools sprang up across the United States and Canada. These schools varied widely in programs and policies, but common factors among them were a disenchantment with conventional schooling, a desire to reform education, and (frequently) the belief that schools should be controlled by the population served, including children. The National Coalition of Alternative Community Schools was formed in 1976. Its journal from 1985 to 1990 was SKOLE (from a Greek word for the type of dialectical activity conducted by Socrates). This volume contains selected articles published during that period. Six articles profile small alternative schools: Shaker Mountain School (Burlington, Vermont); Sudbury Valley School (Framingham, Massachusetts); Metropolitan School of Columbus (Ohio); the Free School (Albany, New York); L'Ecole d'Humanite (Goldern, Switzerland); and Central Park East (New York, New York). Other articles and reprints discuss teaching the American Constitution; child-adult relationships in learning situations; alternative schools in early America; a high school student's perspective on alternative versus conventional education; community-building processes in a national coalition of educators; homeschooling, experiential learning, and the vision of John Holt; children's theater as education; refuting Gardner's theory of multiple intelligences; peace education; what's wrong with public education; the outdoors as "school"; movement education; teaching, learning, and schooling in the works of Piaget, Skinner, and Dewey; and comparisons of learner outcomes of children schooled at home and in school. Also included are four poems and three book reviews” (p. 1 retrieved 7/16/ from the full document retrieved from http://www.eric.ed.gov).
Leuffen, Renata Winter 1991 Home education: An international right. Education Now, (11), 22. home education
Levy, Tal 2007, November Homeschooling and racism. Journal of Black Studies (November 2007): 1-19. http://gaither.wordpress.com/2008/07/18/levy-on-homeschooling-and-racism/ home education, research, law, legal, philosophy, race, racism, minorities, minority A review of Levy’s work entitled “Levy on Homeschooling and Racism” (by Milton, Gaither, July 18, 2008, retrieved 9/5/08 from http://gaither.wordpress.com/2008/07/18/levy-on-homeschooling-and-racism/) reports the following: “Levy calls his approach “Diffusion Research,” a methodology that looks at how a reform spreads and tries to ascertain why certain locations adopt the reform early and others late. Here are Levy’s 13 hypothetical reasons why states might have passed homeschool-enabling legislation: 1. The richer the state, the more likely it will pass a homeschool law 2. The less urbanized a state, the more likely to pass a law 3. The less populous a state, the more likely to pass a law 4. More Christian fundamentalists, more likely to pass a law 5. More African Americans, more likely to pass a law 6. More racial integration in schools, more likely to pass a law 7. More Republican the state government, more likely to pass a law 8. Less powerful the National Education Association in a state, more likely to pass a law 9. Less a state spends on public schools, more likely to pass a law 10. Fewer available public school teachers, more likely to pass a law 11. Lower high school graduation rate, more likely to pass a law 12. If a state is located next to a state that has recently passed a homeschool law, it will be more likely to do so. 13. The more states in a region that have a law, the more likely a state is to pass one. After laying out these hypotheses and explaining why he thought they might explain a state’s adoption of homeschool law, Levy put each to the test using a sophisticated regression analysis. In an appendix he explains where and how he acquired data for each variable. The results of his analysis are pretty interesting. Only 8 of his 13 hypothetical variables were statistically significant, and some of his hypotheses actually got things backwards: Regarding demographic variables, his hypothesis was correct that less populous states were more likely to pass a law, and he was right as well about areas with more conservative Christians and more racial integration. But the number of blacks and the level of urbanization were not significant factors, nor was per capita income. The take-home message here is that homeschooling laws were more likely to be passed in states with a lot of small town and rural citizens whose schools were experiencing high levels of racial integration. ….. Levy’s political hypothesis was completely wrong. In fact it was Democrat-controlled state governments that were more likely to pass homeschooling laws. Reading his discussion of this point makes it clear that Levy was surprised by this finding and doesn’t know quite what to make of it. ….. Levy’s education quality hypothesis was also wrong. It turns out that the states that spent the most on public schools were actually MORE likely to pass homeschooling laws. NEA membership levels and high school graduation rates were insignificant. Finally, Levy’s geographic hypothesis was wrong as well. He found that states whose neighbors had recently enacted homeschool laws were actually a bit less likely to pass legislation than states without neighbors who had done so.”
Lewis, Amanda E. 2001 There is no “race” in the schoolyard: Color-blind ideology in an (almost) all-white school. American Educational Reserach Journal, 38(4), 781-811. public schools, racism, race Finds that “... explicit color-blind ‘race talk’ masked an underlying reality of racialized practices and color-conscious understandings ...” [p. 781, abstract]. “Conclusion. As I have tried to establish in this article, it is essential to talk about how race operates even in settings where people say it is not important. Race matters as much in (almost) all-White settings like Foresthills as it does in any multiracial inner city school -- perhaps even more so. In particular, if we continue to have an investment in a future of greater racial equity, we must confront the way race operates in White settings as much as we do in other settings. As Giroux (1998b, p. 132) states, “Education works best when those experiences that shape and penetrate one’s lived reality are jolted, unsettled and made the object of critical analysis.” Yet it is clear that in many way's the stakeholders in Foresthills will not throw out their arms in welcome of such jolting and unsettling changes. It is not an accident that dominant multiculturalism has remained primarily focused on minority students and more radical forms have remained at the level of theory, only rarely put to work in schools and even more rarely considered in White settings. [new paragraph] Still, if we recognize schools to be institutions responsible for challenging what is, and initiating new, more critical and more honest understandings of the world, then we must continue to try to imagine what this might look like, even in White settings. This involves both interrogating injustices and, as Giroux points out, investigating possible “contributions for humanity." This is not about laying blame on students. families, and schools, but working to try to imagine a different kind of public sphere in which schools are able to begin to fulfill the role in which they have long been cast -- that of the great equalizers. [new paragraph] In short, education that is critical, multicultural, and focused on racial justice cannot be reserved only for students of color. On multiple levels it is clear that the children in almost-all-White schools like Foresthills Elementary need critical multicultural education. Most immediately, the experiences of the “one Black child" in the class show that lack of discussion about race is neither benevolent, nor even neutral. As Stephen Carter (1997, p. 205) points out although students of color can learn how to cope and achieve within a racist context, they cannot end their victimization by themselves: [new paragraph, indented] Victims of oppression cannot stop their victimization. They can fight against it, protect themselves from its effects, learn to achieve in spite of it, but they cannot stop something they are not creating. Whites invented race and maintain racial oppression in all its forms: individual, institutional, and cultural. The White person who comes to feel this reality and is able to communicate it no longer looks to the victims for solutions to their oppression. [indentation ends]In this way it is crucial that Whites learn more not only about the reality of racial inequality, but also about their own rule in its reproduction. As the experiences and beliefs of those I interviewed demonstrate Whites who grow up in racially homogenous settings often do not have any idea of how race works or how their lives too are racialized” [p. 804].
Lewis, Melinda Keen 2002 Simply homeschooling. Granbury, TX: Lifestyle Learning. home education, pedagogy, philosophy, lifestyle of learning, relaxed Provides philosophical, pedagogical, and practical advice and tips on effective lifestyle of learning homeschooling.
Lewis, Terry 1985 School on trial: A positive alternative. Published by Christian School Consultants, P.O. Box 283, St. Vital, Manitoba, R2M 5C8, Canada. home education, Christian, history, philosophy, international Christian perspective, makes case for importance of home education, historical, biblical.
Lieberman, Myron 1989 Privatization and educational choice. New York, NY: St. Martin's Press, 386 pp. home education, privatization, reform Chapter on load shedding and uses home education as a prime example thereof; sections on vouchers.
Lieberman, Myron 1993 Public education: An autopsy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. economics, schools, public, private, discrimination, vouchers, tuition tax credits Makes case for why all of American education should be a part of the free market system. Chapter titles include “Producer-consumer conflict,” “The real costs of public education,” “The educational consequences of racial conflict,” and “Educational research and its agenda.”
Lieberman, Myron 1997 The teacher unions. New York, NY: The Free Press. public education, teacher unions, control of money, plan of action for reform The subtitle on the cover of the book, “How the NEA [National Education Association] and AFT [American Federation of Teachers] sabotage reform and hold students, parents, teachers, and taxpayers hostage to bureaucracy” tells much of what is the content of the book.
Lieberman, Myron 2002 Liberating teachers toward market competition in teacher representation. Policy Analysis, 450.
Liebowitz, Stan, & Kelly, Matthew L. 2018, November 13 Fixing the Bias in Current State K–12 Education Rankings. Cato Institute Policy Analysis no. 854. Retrieved July 18, 2019 from https://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/fixing-bias-current-state-k-12-education-rankings https://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/fixing-bias-current-state-k-12-education-rankings academic achievement, state-level, state scores, rank, ranking, NAEP Compare U.S. NAEP test scores in the states while adjusting for ethnicity of student, subject area, and grade level. “Our methodology is to compare state scores for each of three subjects (math, reading, and science), four major ethnic groups (whites, blacks, Hispanics, and Asian/Pacific Islanders) and two grades (fourth and eighth),17. for a total of 24 potential observations in each state and the District of Columbia. We exclude factors such as graduation rates and pre-K enrollment that do not measure how much students have learned. We give each of the 24 tests18. equal weight and base our ranking on the average of the test scores.19. This ranking is thus limited to measuring learning and does so in a way that avoids the aggregation fallacy. We refer to this as the “quality” rank. From left to right, Table 1 shows our ranking using disaggregated NAEP scores (“quality ranking”), then how rankings would look if based solely on aggregate state NAEP test scores (“aggregated rank”), and finally the U.S. News rankings.” Also develop an efficiency rating of the states that controls for amount of tax dollars/money spent on students’ public schooling.
Life LifeWay Research 2007, Spring Teen influences on church dropouts [PowerPoint Presentation] Retrieved 8/10/07 online http://www.lifeway.com/lwc/mainpage/0%2C1701%2CM%25253D200767%2C00.html. http://www.lifeway.com/lwc/mainpage/0%2C1701%2CM%25253D200767%2C00.html research, home education, religiosity, church attendance, adults “Methodology Survey of Young Adults ages 18-30 in April-May 2007 Sample size of 1,023 provides 95% confidence that sampling error does not exceed +3.1% Eligible respondents attended a Protestant church regularly (twice a month or more) for at least a year in high school The web survey utilized a representative national panel of Americans [slide 3]. “Other characteristics also have influence – school, Bible reading, and church members Attending a Christian school corresponds to lower dropout rates than other types of high schools (51% drop out vs. 65% of all 18-30 year olds surveyed) Attending home school [homeschool] corresponds to lower dropout rates than other types of high schools (56% drop out vs. 65% of all 18-30 year olds surveyed) 19% more of those who stay in church indicate they spent regular time reading the Bible privately (61% vs. 42% of dropouts) 15% fewer of those who continue attending indicate their impression of church members was that they were disapproving of those who didn’t meet their expectations regarding jobs, school, marriage, etc. (19% vs. 34% of dropouts)” [slide 11]. “Types of high school attended can have some impact on the likelihood a young adult drops out of church. There is no statistically significant difference in the dropout rate for those attending a public high school, but the dropout rate is lower for those attending home school or a Christian school (other than Catholic). Among young adults ages 18-30 indicating: Type of high schools attended Public: 65% dropped out Private (not Christian): 69% dropped out Catholic: 63% dropped out Other Christian: 51% dropped out* Home school [homeschool]: 56% dropped out* *Difference in percentages between those who “dropped out” and the total dropout rate for 18-30 year olds (65%) is statistically significant Note: Respondents could indicate attending more than one type of school. [survey questionnaire item] Q14a. Please indicate the type of schools/colleges you have attended? Base: Public (n=830) Private (n=64) Catholic (n=53) Christian (n=93) Home School (n=104)” [slide 47].
Lifestyle of Learning: A Christian Journal for Home Educators 1992 Available from Howshall Home Publications, 8533 Skookumchuck Rd., S.E., Tenino, WA 98589. home education, Christian, alternative Strong Christian emphasis, proponent of notebook approach to learning, talks of de-schooling and looking for biblical model rather than resorting to ways of conventional schools.
Linden, Norma Jean Freeman 1983 An investigation of alternative education: Home schooling. Dissertation Abstracts International, 44, 3457A. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, East Texas State University, Commerce, TX, 80 pp. (Also University Microfilms International, No. 8403319.) home education, research, academic achievement, reasons, public school cooperation Distinguishes factors representative of families involved in home education in Texas. Found that (1) the reason for home schooling for most parents is they think the public schools impose on children an ungodly, humanistic philosophy and negative influences, (2) most lived in suburban areas, (3) most were Protestant Christians, (4) the home educators think their home schools are successful, (5) the main formal educator is usually the mother, (6) the highest formal educational attainment by most parents was high school, (7) the most common family income was $10,000 to $14,999, (8) formal instruction was typically 2.5 hours/day, (9) standardized tests were the most common form of evaluation of learning, (10) most public school authorities did not lend support to the home schooling movement, and (11) there was little clarity on legal issues surrounding home schooling. Conclusions include: (1) home educators are sincere, hard-working, protecting children from problems of public schools, (2) most students were at elementary or middle school age, with academic rate at least equal to public school counterparts, (3) the phonics method extensively used for reading, (4) they receive little support from public authorities, and (5) home schooling appears to be a viable alternative for small segment of our population.
Lindley, Michael Ray 1985 The home schooling movement in the state of Indiana as perceived by public school superintendents. Dissertation Abstracts International, 46, 1465A-1466A. "The purpose of the study was to ascertain and report current attitudes of public school superintendents in Indiana regarding the problems associated with home schooling, and, to recommend solutions to the problems identified" [p. 1465A]. Considered U. S. constitutional issues of individual rights versus police power of the state. Used questionnaire to collect data. Findings support the following: "(1) Public school superintendents need to recognize the legitimacy of home schools as a legal alternative to public schooling. (2) Courts will not support public school superintendents in Indiana when prosecuting home schooling parents for violation of compulsory attendance statutes unless definitive proof exists that no structured education has been provided. (3) Compulsory attendance statutes as stated provide for a wide variation of interpretations and may lead to unnecessary litigation. (4) Requiring parents to prove teaching competency and establishing minimum state guidelines for home schools would assist in meeting the legislative intent of the compulsory attendance statute" [p. 1466A]. Law.
Linehan, Patricia 1992, September/October Homeschooling for gifted primary students. Understanding Our Gifted, 5(1), 1, 8-10. talented and gifted, individualization, socialization Speaks of reasons for home educating the gifted, the benefits of individualization or individualized instruction, how to be proactive rather than reactive as a parent, and how home education can provide good socialization for children.
Lines, Patricia 1983 Private education alternatives and state regulation. Journal of Law and Education, 12(2), 189-234. Also, in ERIC's CIJE, 15, 353, No. EJ283890. Law. Overview of state law as of 1983 and analysis of trends in "underground education," particularly in unapproved fundamentalist Christian and home schools. Discusses growth of underground educational movements, particularly unapproved home schooling and fundamentalist Christian schools. Reviews existing state regulation of private education, its constitutional and policy implications, and offers alternative recommendations concerning compulsory attendance laws. An appendix lists basic requirements of compulsory school attendance by state. Home education, law, review, policy
Lines, Patricia 1985 Compulsory education laws and their impact on public and private education. Denver, Colorado: Education Commission of the States, Law and Education Center. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED253963). Compulsory Education, Government School Relationship, School Attendance Legislation, School Law, School Policy Involves the entire United States.
Lines, Patricia M. 1982 State regulation of private education. Phi Delta Kappan, 64, 119-123. (Law.) private education, private schools homeschooling, home schooling, state regulation, law, philosophy “Those who choose home schooling often see public schools or publicly approve private schools as too traditional or too conservative. By contrast, the growing number of parents who send their children to fundamentalist Christian schools tend to feel that the public schools are too liberal or devoid of the moral and religious instruction that they see as crucial to children’s education. These disparate groups have two things in common: are rejection of the ideal of the U.S. public school as melting pot and a willingness to defy the law in the interests of their children” (p. 119). “Educators generally agree that it is nearly impossible to provide education without also imparting values” (p. 123).
Lines, Patricia M. 1985, May 15 States should help, not hinder, parents' home-schooling efforts. Education Week, pp. 24, 17. homeschooling, home education, law, philosophy, control Homeschooling is “home instruction” by parents. “Why are so many families doing it? Some object to the political or religious values they find in public schools. Some want to spend more time with young children before putting them in school, or with a child who is having trouble adapting to school and who needs individual attention at home. Whatever the reason, the burden parents undertake is enormous, and home schooling is not something they take on lightly. Parents--some of them former teachers--typically think through their teaching methods very carefully to meet the individual needs of their children.” “Why do state and local education professionals oppose home schooling? Some are up in arms because of the recent (and rapid) development of home-instruction support materials, such as the Packet on Accelerated Christian Education (PACE), which is produced by Accelerated Christian Education (ACE) in Louisville, Tex. ACE reports that 2,000 children are currently enrolled in its home-study program. A number of other religious distributors are producing home-instruction materials. Secular schools—such as the prestigious Calvert School in Maryland—also distribute home-instruction curricula, but the religious materials are showing the largest growth. ….. Educators who favor the standard public-school program--and its relative bias toward progressive education and secularism--do not like the packet, but it is difficult to say that a child will not learn from these materials.” It is apparent that the opponents of homeschooling want themselves, rather than parents, to be in control of what knowledge, values, and beliefs children are taught.
Lines, Patricia M. 1986, January 15 Home-school researcher affirms validity of data. Education Week, p. 26.
Lines, Patricia M. 1986, November Home instruction: An overview. Policy issues paper. Charleston, W. Va.: Appalachia Educational Lab. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED296453). Compulsory Education, Home Schooling, Outcomes of Education, Parent Child Relationship, Parent School Relationship, School Attendance Legislation A general report on schooling at home with both an historical and statistical view.
Lines, Patricia M. 1987 An overview of home instruction. Phi Delta Kappan, 68(7), 510-517. home education, research, law, cooperation “Home-schooling” (p. 510) and “home-schoolers” (p. 510) and “home instruction” (p. 510) references in this article is comprised of nearly entirely of parents privately teaching their children based in and out of the home; Lines does also include an Alaska state-run program which comprises about 1.6% of the home-school students about whom she writes. Presents home education to the professional educator with a brief summary of research regarding the numbers involved in the form of education, the academic performance of students, and the evidence regarding the social development of the children. Gives a synopsis of law and court cases pertinent to home education. Encourages cooperative relationships between public school officials and home schoolers. Is one of earliest articles including research findings that went to a broad educational readership.
Lines, Patricia M. 1989 Home instruction. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco, CA, March 27-31 1989.
Lines, Patricia M. 1991 Home education and constitutional liberties. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 3-7, 1991, Chicago, IL.
Lines, Patricia M. 1991 Home instruction: Characteristics, size and growth. In J. A. Van Galen & M. A. Pitman (Eds.), Home schooling: Political, historical, and pedagogical perspectives. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation. home education, numbers, demographics “… it seems likely that some 10,000 to 15,000 school-aged children were schooling at home in the early 1970s … and by the fall of 1988, between 150,000 to 300,000 schoole-aged children in home schools” (p. 10).
Lines, Patricia M. 1991, October Estimating the home schooled population (working paper OR 91-537). Washington DC: Office of Educational Research and Improvement, U.S. Department of Education. home education, demographics, numbers, estimate, policy A careful analysis using several methods to arrive at her estimate of 248,500 to 353,500 school-aged children (i.e., ages 5 to 18 which is basically grades K-12) being educated at home in the school year 1990-1991; speculates there were about 13,000 students in the late 1970s, 92,500 in the fall of 1983, 225,000 in the fall of 1988. “There are countless difficulties in making estimates or gathering information on the home schooling population” [p. 2].
Lines, Patricia M. 1993, November Homeschooling: Private choices and public obligations (working paper). Washington, DC: Office of Educational Research and Improvement, U.S. Department of Education. Establishes parallel between philosophy of the Antifederalists at the founding of the U.S. and home educators of today; includes discussion of Plato and Aristotle and roles of state vs. citizen; critiques Franzosa's (1991) critique of John Holt's philosophy, explaining that Franzosa didn't understand Holt and misrepresented home schooling; explains that home education families normally engage in community life, "Most homeschooling families are people who are exercising their individual rights to form closer ties within their immediate families and communities. Homeschoolers are tremendously loyal as family members. They are suspicious of television and other less intimate influences. They eat as a family, they socialize as a family, they attend church as a family, they become members of an extended religious community. [p. 24, 25] [new paragraph] They also become members of an extended homeschooling community. Many are reinventing the idea of school on their own terms. ..... Although they have turned their backs on a wide-spread and hallowed practice of sending children to a school located in a particular building, adhering to a particular schedule and program, they have not turned their backs on the broader social contract as understood at the time of the Founding. [new paragraph] To conclude, like the Antifederalist, homeschoolers are asserting their historic individual rights so that they may form more meaningful bonds with family and community. In doing so, they are not abdicating from the American agreement. To the contrary, they are affirming it" [p. 25].
Lines, Patricia M. 1994, February Homeschooling: Private choices and public obligations (revised) (working paper). Washington, DC: Office of Educational Research and Improvement, U.S. Department of Education. Revision, basically same as same author/title 1993.
Lines, Patricia M. 1994, February Homeschooling: Private choices and public obligations. Home School Researcher, 10(3), 9-26. home education, research, history, politics, social interaction, public policy “In fact, in most respects homeschoolers resemble the Antifederalists. Like the Antifederalists, they are a mixed lot. Many tend to be conservative and highly religious, while others are primarily secular and liberal. Antifederalist or homeschooler, liberal or conservative, these people often demonstrate libertarian tendencies. Almost all are decentralists in one way or another. Like the vast numbers of Antifederalists, the vast numbers of homeschoolers assert their right to an inner sphere of conscience and privacy, but not for the sake of selfish individualism. They assert it for the sake of belonging to a community of their own choosing” [p. 16]. “It is unlikely that Dewey was urging universal public school attendance. He was too dissatisfied with the typical public school” [p. 16]. “Dewey concludes that an ideal home environment would be the best school” [p. 16]. “This is not to say that Dewey would approve whole-heartedly of homeschooling. He would not” [p. 17]. “Dewey saw the home as the ideal model for the school, because he saw schools as divorced from social life, and from doing. Here Dewey and homeschoolers are in accord. Yet, Dewey hoped for reform of schools. Holt, and many homeschoolers, appear to believe that such reform is unattainable, at least in time to serve those who are children now” [p. 17]. “Although they [home school parents] have turned their backs on a wide-spread and hallowed practice of sending children to a school located in a particular building, adhering to a particular schedule and program, they have not turned their backs on the broader social contract as understood at the time of the Founding [of the United States]. ..... Like the Antifederalists, these homeschoolers are asserting their historic individual rights so that they may form more meaningful bonds with family and community. In doing so, they are not abdicating from the American agreement. To the contrary, they are affirming it” [p. 21]. This article is very similar to same title by same author, 1993.
Lines, Patricia M. 1995 Home schooling. ERIC Digest, Number 95. ERIC Number ED381849. Retrieved 4/25/08 online www.eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/recordDetail?accno=ED381849. http://www.eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/recordDetail?accno=ED381849 home education, homeschooling, summary, research, academic achievement, socialization Explains: “People disagree on whether home schooling is advantageous academically. Research has not determined whether the SAME children would perform better or worse in a public or private classroom, or in a home-schooling arrangement. Analyses of test scores are available, based on data from states that require testing or from home-schooling associations. Data from both sources may not be representative of home schoolers as a whole, however, because not all families cooperate with state testing requirements and private efforts rely on volunteers. Keeping these caveats in mind, virtually all the available data show that the group of home-schooled children who are tested is above average. The pattern for children for whom data are available resembles that of children in private schools. People also disagree about whether home schooling helps or hinders a child's social development. Children engaged in home schooling spend less time with same-aged children and more time with people of different ages. Most spend time with other children through support and networking groups, scouting, churches, and other associations. Many spend time with adults other than their parents through community volunteer work, running their own businesses, tutoring or mentoring arrangements, or other activities. There is no conclusive research suggesting that additional time with same-aged peers is preferable to more time with individuals of varying ages. Limited testing of a self-selected group of home-schooled children suggested above-average social and psychological development. ..... Other groups, such as the national American Civil Liberties Union, maintain that parents have a constitutional right to educate their children at home.”
Lines, Patricia M. 1996, October Home schooling comes of age. Educational Leadership, 54(2), 63-67. home education, population size, public opinion, policy, history, cooperation, public school Infers that over 500,000 K-12 children are home schooled during 1996-1997 academic year; a little over 1% of all school-aged children and about 10% of those who are privately schooled. “In fact, the most exciting development in the home-schooling world is the emergence of partnerships between public schools and home schools, an arrangement that educators in Alaska pioneered” [p. 65]. “Children engaged in home schooling spend less time with their peer group and more time with people of different ages. ..... No conclusive research suggests that time spent with same-aged peers is preferable to time spent with people of varying ages. ..... At the very least, anyone who has observed home-schoolers will notice a high level of sharing, networking, collaboration, and cooperative learning” [p. 66]. Author works for the United States Department of Education and National Institute on Governance, Policy, Finance and Management.
Lines, Patricia M. 1997, January Homeschooling: An overview for education policymakers (working paper). Washington, DC: Office of Education Research and Improvement, United States Department of Education. research, futuristics, law, academic achievement, opinion, home education Presents information on home education population size, summary of research findings on academic achievement, demographics, and reasons for home schooling, reasons for home schooling, rights and law/legal issues, the term to use for the practice (e.g., homeschooling vs. home schooling vs. home education), and the future of home schooling. “Clearly homeschoooling is here to stay, but it is not possible to predict when and at what level the growth will peak” (p. 16).
Lines, Patricia M. Date ? Compulsory education laws. Education Commission of the States, Suite 300, 1860 Lincoln St., Denver, CO 80295; number LEC-84-11. Law. State laws and litigation; data on number of people [home schoolers?] using commercial curriculum materials.
Lines, Patricia M. 1998, Spring Homeschoolers: Estimating numbers and growth. Washington, DC: United States Department of Education, Office of Educational Research and Improvement, National Institute on Student Achievement, Curriculum, and Assessment. home education, research, population size estimates, growth Uses various sources of data and methodology to arrive at an estimate. “Given the evidence provided here, the total number of homeschoolers in the 1990-91 school year seems to have been between 250,000 and 350,000 children nationwide; and around 700,000 to 750,000 in 1995-96. Based on limited evidence from four states, the number is still growing; the rate was between 7 and 15% from the 1995-96 school year to the 1996-97 school year, Assuming the larger growth rate, which is more consistent with past growth, the number could have reached about 1,000,000 children by the 1997-98 school year” [p. 1].
Lines, Patricia M. 2000, Summer Homeschooling comes of age. The Public Interest, No. 140, 74-85 [no volume, issue]. http://www.discovery.org/a/277 http://www.discovery.org/scripts/viewDB/index.php?command=view&id=277 home education, research, opinion, history, academic achievement, demographics, civic involvement, philosophy Retrieved December 20, 2010 from http://www.discovery.org/a/277 and April 18, 2008 from http://www.discovery.org/scripts/viewDB/index.php?command=view&id=277. Provides sweeping overview of history, population growth, demographic traits, curriculum materials and activities used, academic achievement of students, civic involvement, and the philosophical, pedagogical, and religious variety of those involved in homeschooling. Cites her own 1990 estimate of the population size, then says about 700,000 homeschoolers [students] during 1995-96, then writes, “If it keeps growing at this rate, there would be around 1.5 to 2 million children homeschooling by 2000-01 (about 3 to 4 percent of school-aged children nationwide) [p. 75]. “The rise of homeschooling is one of the most significant social trends of the past half century” [p. 74]. “It is too early to tell whether homeschooling will establish itself as a major alternative to the modern school. But some things are clear: Homeschooling is becoming more common and more widely accepted. American families from diverse backgrounds resort to homeschooling because they are dissatisfied with the philosophy, the content, or the quality of American schools. The great majority of homeschooling families are not separatists and isolationists but active members of civil society. They seek to improve this nation, but they want to raise and educate their children in the meantime. Ultimately, they may help to inspire a great renewal of American education, or at least preserve values and ideas that are out of fashion within the education establishment” [p. 85].
Lines, Patricia M. 2000 When home schoolers go to school: A partnership between families and schools. Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 159-186.
Lines, Patricia M. 2001 Homeschooling. ERIC Digest. ERIC Identifier: ED457539. home education, research, law, legal, opinion, academic achievement, college “Homeschooling -- educating children under the supervision of parents instead of school teachers -- has grown steadily over the past several decades. In an earlier era, many [p. 1 ends] children studied at home. But by the beginning of the twentieth century, schools had become commonplace and states had adopted compulsory school attendance laws. Only a few states allowed homeschooling as an exception to the attendance requirement. A few more required parents only to educate their children, without specifying the means. As a result, homeschoolers risked fines or jail sentences in most states. A lucky few lived in jurisdictions that would not prosecute homes schoolers. Other families found protection in public or private schools that allowed children to enroll in "independent study" and then sent them home. Most families just hoped to avoid notice. Gradually, state by state, the legislature, a state court, an attorney general, or a state board made homeschooling legal” [p. 1-2]. “Today homeschooling is legal in all states. State law generally requires homeschooling parents to file basic information with either the state or local education agency. Over half the states require some kind of evaluation under some or all of the homeschooling options available under state law. Usually, this evaluation involves testing of students, but some states accept portfolio evaluations or a teacher evaluation. Much less frequently, states have education or testing requirements for parents. Some states require submission of a curricular plan. Parents do not need teaching certificates. The United States Supreme Court has not explicitly ruled on homeschooling, though it is clear that reasonable regulations will be allowed. The Court has found constitutional problems with compulsory school requirements in Wisconsin v. Yoder (1972), a limited decision involving the Amish. Yoder has led some lower courts to extend more protection to homeschooling families with a religious orientation, compared with those with a secular orientation” [p. 3]. “Researchers cannot tell whether the same children would perform better or worse academically in a classroom or at home. State testing data do not necessarily reflect all homeschoolers because not all comply with the testing requirement. Other testing efforts rely on volunteers. Keeping that caveat in mind, where testing data are available, homeschoolers do well. For example, in Alaska, the state's Alyeska Central School has tested its homeschooling children for several decades. As a group they usually score above average in any subject area and at all grade levels. The largest study to date, commissioned by the Home School Legal Defense Association, involved 12,000 students tested through the Bob Jones University testing services. The homeschooled children placed in the 62nd to the 91st percentile of national norms, depending on grade level and subject area (Rudner 1999). At least one intriguing study suggests that student achievement for homeschoolers is not related to the educational attainment of the parent (Duvall and others 1997). This is consistent with tutoring studies that suggest the education level of a tutor has little to do with achievement of a tutored child” [p. 4].
Lines, Patricia M. 2003 Support for home-based education: Pioneering partnerships between public schools and families who instruct their children at home. A guide for state policymakers, local boards of education, and school administrators. http://www.eric.uoregon.edu/publications/action.lasso?database=products&-Response=detail.fmt&-token.start=&ProductID=EMOSHB home education, public school, cooperation, private school, philosophy, policy, population estimates, public-school-at-home, PSAH Eugene, OR: ERIC [Educational Resources Information Center] Clearinghouse on Educational Management. ERIC/CEM Accession Number: EA 032193. “The structure, and nomenclature, of homeschooling has changed radically in recent years. Children now learn through independent homeschooling, enrolled home study, home-based study, off-campus learning, parent-partnered programs, distance learning, and online virtual schools. Mix-and-match combinations of enrolled schooling and homeschooling are becoming more common. For example, a child may be homeschooled part-time and enrolled in home study part-time and use on-campus labs. To add to the perplexity, the number of homeschoolers is uncertain. No national or state lists of homeschoolers exist. Estimated numbers come from association member rosters, magazine subscription lists, and education agency registrations. When it comes to homeschooling, two points, however, are clear: The ranks of homeschoolers are steadily increasing, and there is a growing trend in forming partnerships between homeschooling families and public educators. This publication, by Patricia Lines, reports on the practices of states and school districts experimenting with such partnerships. Lines also provides valuable information and practical recommendations for public-school policymakers and administrators thinking about offering resources and guidance to support home-based education” [retrieved 4/4/03 online http://www.eric.uoregon.edu/publications/action.lasso?database=products&-Response=detail.fmt&-token.start=&ProductID=EMOSHB]. Implicitly, if not explicitly, promotes tax-funded public school-at-home programs. Section entitled “homeschoolers’ views on access to programs” [p. 60] essentially ignores the strong philosophical opposition to government involvement in homeschooling that is widespread among the homeschool community. Some of her sections are missing references to important recent literature.
Lines, Patricia M. 2009 Shackling the Imagination: Education for Virtue in Plato and Rousseau. Humanitas, 22(1 and 2), 40-68. philosophy, philosophy of education, statism, Plato, Rousseau, homeschooling, home education “This article explores some of the implications of radical new proposals for the education of an entire society, particularly those that usurp the traditional role of parents. To this end, the article examines the proposals of Plato (427 or 428–347 BC) and Rousseau (1712–1778)” (p. 41). “Constitutional democracies recognize private schools and homeschooling as legitimate ways to meet the requirements of compulsory education laws, but the record is not always perfect. Moreover, even the most liberal democracies regulate private education. To the extent that they do so, elected representatives and bureaucrats decide how to educate other people's children. This decision to compel and regulate education has the honorable purpose of producing law-abiding and productive citizens or, in old-fashioned terms, virtuous citizens. When individuals disagree on how to achieve such a goal, however, public efforts to control education can create havoc” (p. 40). “He [Plato] would ban private education, whether at home, in a private school, in a library, or on the street. Parents play a subordinate role: “Children must not be allowed to attend or not attend school at the whim of their father; as far as possible, education must be compulsory for ‘one and all’ [p. 42 ends] . . . because they belong to the state first and their parents second.” Neither parent nor child may delve more deeply into a subject or cut it short” [p. 42-23]. Plato was all about the state control controlling a child’s education and would not allow the family to do so, which is the same viewpoint of some academics now, centuries later (e.g., see Bartholet, 2020).
Linley, Lloyd 1999 Multi-age classes and high ability students. Review of Educational Research, 69(2), 187-212. ERIC Reproducation Service Number EJ600456. outcomes, academic achievement, cognitive, affective, high-ability students, gifted, multi-age, age mixing “Reviews research on multiage classroom organization as an option for high-ability students. Studies of cognitive and affective factors have consistently shown positive effect sizes. Discusses conditions under which positive effects are most likely and explores multiage classes as an alternative for high-ability children” [abstract, ERIC].
Lionini, Paolo 1980 (first printing 1980; copyright 1993). The Leipzig connection: The systematic destruction of American education. https://archive.org/stream/LionniTheLeipzigConnectionSystematicDestructionOfAmericanEducation1993/Lionni%20-%20The%20Leipzig%20Connection%20-%20Systematic%20Destruction%20of%20American%20Education%20%281993%29_djvu.txt https://archive.org/details/countryschoolof00gate/page/n1/mode/2up history of education, history of public schooling, history, philosophy, psychology Sheridan, Oregon: Heron Books. Also retrieved “full text”April 7, 2020 from https://archive.org/stream/LionniTheLeipzigConnectionSystematicDestructionOfAmericanEducation1993/Lionni%20-%20The%20Leipzig%20Connection%20-%20Systematic%20Destruction%20of%20American%20Education%20%281993%29_djvu.txt Thesis is that Wundtian psychology spread through the USA and had a huge negative impact on education, and that money with power and control along with psychology has destroyed public/state education in the United States. Explains significance of Wilhelm Maximilian Wundt, founder of experimental psychology, and his impact on western education and schooling. Also covers G. Stanley Hall, John Dewey, Edward Lee Thorndike, the Dewey School, the Laboratory School, Columbia Teachers College, James McKeen Cattell, James Earl Russell, Frank McMurry, conditioning, behaviorism, Watson, Skinner, John D. Rockefeller, Sr. and his money and his use of it to influence education, Frederick Taylor Gates, George A. Pillsbury, John D. Rockefeller, Jr., Wallace Buttrick, progressive education (p. 65), Abraham Flexner, control through money (p. 75), and strings and restrictions on education are attached to money gifts. “… that man is an animal, that his actions are actually always reactions, and that he can be studied in the laboratory in much the same way as an animal might be studied. Thorndike equated children with the rats, monkeys, fish, cats, and chickens upon which he experimented in his laboratory and was prepared to apply what he found there to learning in the classroom. He extrapolated “laws” from his research into animal behavior which he then applied to the training of teachers, who took what thy had learned to every corner of the Untitled Sates and ran their classrooms, curricula, and schools on the basis of this new “educational” psychology” (p. 32). On page 55-56, includes a quotes (imperfectly) the following retrieved online: “"In our dream, we have limitless resources and the people yield themselves with perfect docility to our molding hand. The present educational conventions fade from their minds; and, unhampered by tradition, we work our own good will upon a grateful and responsive rural folk. We shall not try to make these people or any of their children into philosophers or men of learning, or of science. We are not to raise up from among them authors, orators, poets or men of letters. We shall not search for embryo great artists, painters, musicians. Nor will we cherish even the humbler ambition to raise up from among them lawyers, doctors, preachers, politicians, statesmen, of whom we now have ample supply. ….. For the task that we set before ourselves is a very simple as well as a very beautiful one: to train these people as we find them for a perfectly ideal life just where they are …” (p. 6). “So we will organize our children into a little community and teach them to do in a perfect way the things their fathers and mothers are doing in an imperfect way, in the homes in the shop, on the farm" (p. 10) --- retrieved April 7, 2020 from https://archive.org/details/countryschoolof00gate/page/n1/mode/2up General Education Board, Occasional Papers, No. 1 "The country school of to-morrow," by Frederick T. Gates, 1916. “Wundtian psychology and Rockefeller money were now combined in an institution whose goal “was the construction of new curricula and the development of new methods.” [footnote 8] Next, textbooks were created. Standard teaching practices were revised, and a course of study organized on the principles developed at Teachers College by Thorndike and Dewey. Here was the full-fledged prototype” (p. 79). “By 1953, Wundtian psychology had reached out from Teachers College into virtually every public school in the land …” (p. 87). “Psychology currently constitutes the principal philosophical underpinning of our educational and, consequently, of our cultural outlook. From its largely bestial precepts major decisions in all walks of life are now made, and anyone attempting to determine the causes of a deep and lengthy national malaise must take into account psychol-[p. 88 ends]ogy's covert hegemony over the thought processes of the body politic, the body economic, and the body social. Institutionalized as "education," it has become our largest single public expenditure at local, state, and federal levels. The idea that Man is an exclusively physiological entity conflicts daily with the promise of a way of life conceived for, and attainable only by, men of free will. This idea (that Man is a stimulus-response animal) and the methods it implies, has played a critical role in transforming The American Dream into a national nightmare. It has turned our homes, schools, offices, stores, and factories into the battlegrounds of World War III; the draftees drift from encounter to encounter, increasing numbers succumbing as neurotic mental and spiritual casualties. The greatest number of victims, however, is in the 5-16 year-old range, as roughly one-quarter of the population is recruited into the compulsory federal behavior clinics cosmetically known as schools. Those willing to decide on the basis of their own experience and observations whether they (and their children) are animals or not, and who choose not to be, must begin now to openly repudiate psychology's stranglehold on our children's future and awaken their neighbors from the nightmare.” (p. 88-89).) revised
Lipsey, Mark W.; Farran, Dale C.; & Hofer, Kerry G. 2015 A randomized control trial of the effects of a statewide voluntary prekindergarten program on children’s skills and behaviors through third grade (Research Report). Nashville, TN: Vanderbilt University, Peabody Research Institute. Retrieved October 15, 2015 from http://peabody.vanderbilt.edu/research/pri/VPKthrough3rd_final_withcover.pdf. http://peabody.vanderbilt.edu/research/pri/VPKthrough3rd_final_withcover.pdf early childhood education, ECE, pre-Kindergarten, academic achievement, social skills, socialization, long-term effects, research “Research design. There are several components to the overall research design for this evaluation. The component reported here, and the one that provides the strongest test of the effects of TN‐VPK, is a randomized control trial in which children applying to TN‐VPK are admitted to the program on a random basis” (p. 1). “The first question concerned the effectiveness of the TN‐VPK program at preparing children for kindergarten entry. At the end of pre‐k, the TN‐VPK children had significantly higher achievement scores on all 6 of the subtests, with the largest effects on the two literacy outcomes. The effect size on the composite achievement measure was .32. This effect is of the same magnitude as Duncan and Magnuson (2013) reported for end of treatment effects for all pre‐k programs and larger than the average of programs enacted since the 1980s. At the beginning of kindergarten, the teachers rated the TN‐VPK children as being better prepared for kindergarten work, as having better behaviors related to learning in the classroom and as having more positive peer relations. They did not view the children as having more behavior problems and both groups of children were rated as being highly positive about school. The second question addressed was whether subgroups of children were differentially affected by TN‐VPK attendance. We examined a number of possible moderators of the pre‐k effects and found no relationships for gender, ethnicity, or age of enrollment. The moderators we did find were driven by interactions involving mothers’ education and children who at age 4 did not speak English. The TN‐VPK effects were the largest for children who were learning English and whose mothers had less than a high school degree. English language learners with more educated mothers had the next largest effect size. The effects for native English speakers whether or not their mothers had a high school degree were considerably lower. The third question we addressed involved the sustainability of effects on achievement and behavior beyond kindergarten entry. Children in both groups were followed and reassessed in the spring every year with over 90% of the initial sample located tested on each wave. By the end of kindergarten, the control children had caught up to the TN‐VPK children and there were no longer significant differences between them [p. 4 ends] on any achievement measures. The same result was obtained at the end of first grade using both composite achievement measures. In second grade, however, the groups began to diverge with the TN‐VPK children scoring lower than the control children on most of the measures. The differences were significant on both achievement composite measures and on the math subtests. The moderating effects of ESL status and mothers’ education were no longer significant, but it is interesting to note that whether or not ESL children experienced TN‐VPK, by the end of third grade, their achievement was greater than either of the native English speaking groups of children. In terms of behavioral effects, in the spring the first grade teachers reversed the fall kindergarten teacher ratings. First grade teachers rated the TN‐ VPK children as less well prepared for school, having poorer work skills in the classrooms, and feeling more negative about school. It is notable that these ratings preceded the downward achievement trend we found for VPK children in second and third grades. The second and third grade teachers rated the behaviors and feelings of children in the two groups as the same; there was a marginally significant effect for positive peer relations favoring the TN‐VPK children by third grade teachers” (p. 5).
Litcher, John H., & Schmidt, Steven J. 1991 Social studies in the home school. Social Education, 55(4), 239-241, 248. research, home education, social studies, curriculum, reasons, rationale Provides descriptive study of demographic variables, parents' reasons for home educating, and the kinds of teaching materials used, especially in social studies. "... it appears these parents care deeply about their children, wanting the best possible education for them at the cost of deep personal sacrifice. ... Also, parents' decisions to educate their children at a home school involve strong conviction about their children's moral and educational well-being as well as a rejection of institutionalized schooling as the place where this well-being can best be fostered. ...it appears many parents employ materials produced commercially. ...home school parents employ a wide range of supplemental materials in teaching social studies" (p. 241).
Llewellyn, Grace K. circa 1991 The Teenage Liberation Handbook. Eugene, OR: Lowry House Publishers.
Llewellyn, Grace K. 1998 The teenage liberation handbook: How to quit school and get a real life and education. Eugene, OR: Lowry House Publishers.
Loberfeld, Barry 2001, August Freedom of education: A civil liberty. Ideas on Liberty, 51(8), 26-32. education, liberty, freedom, choice, separation of school and state, philsophy, parental rights Argues that “Religious liberty includes both the freedom and the non-establishment of religion. Thus educational liberty would include not only the right of parents to determine the education of their children, but also the absence of any ‘public’ (government) school system and its apparatus of compulsory attendance and taxation. Or as many describe it: the separation of school and state, on par with the separation of church and state” [p. 26]. “A question: What are the objectives of the various ideological groups that are fighting to get their agendas into the public school system if not to “influence”-control-the minds of the young people therein conscripted? If it’s thought control when the government forces religious thought on these students (or anyone else) something no civil libertarian disputes-it is because it’s thought control when the government forces any kind of thought on them. Let families choose their educational affiliations and then we can say that Americans are fully trusted with the formation of their own opinions” [p. 30].
Loeb, Susanna, Bridges, Margaret, Bassok, Daphna, Fuller, Bruce, & Rumberger, Russ 2005, November 4 How much is too much? The influence of preschool centers on children’s development nationwide. Paper presented at the Association for Policy Analysis and Management, Washington, D.C., November 4, 2005. http://pace.berkeley.edu/Stanford_Berkeley_pr23DA13.doc research, early childhood development, preschool, academic achievement, cognitive development, social development, class, race Authors’ note: “This paper has undergone peer review and will appear in Economics of Education Review” (Paper and authors’ note retrieved November 10, 2005 online http://pace.berkeley.edu/Stanford_Berkeley_pr23DA13.doc . Authors found: “With few exceptions, center programs appear to advance pre-reading and math concepts while under cutting social behavior. The magnitudes of the estimates do vary, with children from middle-income homes experiencing the biggest gains in pre-reading skills. However, the relative magnitude of the effects for low income children is sensitive to the definition of the low-income group. When we use a more restrictive definition of poverty, that is, an income-to-needs ratio of less than 0.5 or very low parental education, we find that the poorest children in the sample enjoy the greatest academic returns to attending center programs [p. 11].” Authors conclude: “This study began with the question, How much might be too much when it comes to children’s attendance at preschool centers? Our findings show that the empirical answer depends upon which domain of child development is being examined. We found that average exposure to a center program before starting kindergarten is associated with about a 0.10 SD advantage in pre-reading and math skills. But attending a center also appears to suppress social development, including the child’s motivated engagement in kindergarten classrooms, self-regulation, and a variety of interpersonal skills, as reported by their teachers. These differing effects suggest that further research is needed to understand how time is spent during long hours inside centers and the overall quality of average programs [p. 14]….. In addition, the negative behavioral effects associated with center attendance, compared with parental care at home, are much greater for those who enter a center when younger than two years of age, and are particularly large for those who start at less than one year of age. For both low and high income children, starting a center program before the age of two is not particularly beneficial for cognitive development and appears to be detrimental for social development [p. 15]. ….. Our results for the intensity of attending a center program – measured in hours per week and months per year – are worrisome, while varying across different types of families and children. For children from low-income families, additional hours per week are associated with some gains in reading and math and display few detrimental effects on social development. But while high income children enjoy gains in pre-reading and math skills when attending centers at moderate levels of intensity (15 to 30 hours per week), they see no cognitive gains and substantially greater behavioral problems associated with additional hours of attendance [p. 15].” Authors were noticeably positive, overall, about enrolling children in preschool programs despite the fact that their findings in this study led them to issue cautions and warnings to other researchers, policy makers, education professionals, and the public regarding certain aspects regarding enrolling children in preschool. This study’s authors’ review of research generally corroborates this author’s [Ray] understanding of the extant body of research [as of the publication date of this Loeb et al. paper] on the effects of preschool attendance on the cognitive and social development of children; that is, studies are mixed regarding whether positive effects are found, and evidence of significant long-term (i.e., into adulthood) positive effects is slight. Even in this study, the short-term “positive” cognitive effects (e.g., in reading ability and math performance) of attending preschool are, in practical terms, nearly negligible, even if “statistically significant”. These researchers who appear to be generally positive about enrolling children in preschool were willing, however, to address the social developmental effects of preschool and report the findings, even “negative” effects they uncovered. Considering the research and experiential evidence that children spending time with parents who express love toward them and pay attention to them is better than what paid-staff institutions can do for children, why do not more professionals and researchers focus on the effects on children’s cognitive and social development if more parents were taught and encouraged to sit with their children around the supper table for 45 minutes per night and interactively and meaningfully converse with them and, in addition, read aloud to their children for 30 to 60 minutes per day from linguistically rich books?
Lofton, John 1988 Godzilla did his homework. The Washington Times, September 9, p. F3.
Lois, Jennifer 2010 The temporal emotion work of motherhood: Homeschoolers' strategies for managing time shortage." Gender & Society 24, 421-46. home education, homeschooling, motherhood; emotions; time; identity Abstract “Drawing on fieldwork and in-depth interviews with homeschooling mothers in the Pacific Northwest, the author reveals several ways the temporal experience of motherhood was emotionally problematic. The intensive demands of homeschooling left them stressed and dissatisfied with the amount of time they had to pursue their own interests. Mothers tried to allocate their time differently to manage these feelings, yet their efforts were unsuccessful, which led them to become frustrated and resentful. To resolve these troublesome feelings, mothers resorted to manipulating their subjective experiences of time through a process the author calls “temporal emotion work.” In the conclusion, the author examines the theoretical confluence of emotions and temporality, suggesting that the dominant form of motherhood is culturally defined as a “time-sensitive identity” and that “temporal emotions” are unique tools in managing the emotional difficulties inherent in the trajectories of some identities” [p. 421].
Lois, Jennifer 2009 Emotionally layered accounts: Homeschoolers’ justifications for maternal deviance.” Deviant Behavior 30, 201-234. home education, homeschooling, motherhood; emotions; time; identity; maternal deviance see title
Lois, Jennifer 2006 “Role strain, emotion management, and burnout: Homeschooling mothers’ adjustment to the teacher role. Symbolic Interaction 29, 507-30. home education, homeschooling, motherhood; emotions; time; identity; burnout see title
Long, Douglas E.; Gaetke, Lisa M.; Perry Stephen D.; Abel, Mark G.; Clasey, Jody L. 2010 The assessment of physical activity and nutrition in home schooled versus public schooled children. Pediatric Exercise Science, 22, 44-59. home education, research, homeschooling, nutrition, health, physical fitness, physical activity, caloric intake, public school, comparison, Matched-pair design Matched-pair design. “The purpose of this study was to descriptively compare the physical activity and dietary intake of public school (PSC) versus home schooled children (HSC). Potential parental and home influences were also examined. Thirty six matched pairs of public school-home school children aged 7–11 years participated in this study. Each participant wore an activity monitor and recorded their dietary intake concurrently for seven consecutive days. PSC had significantly more total and weekday steps, and spent more time in moderate-to-vigorous physical activity compared with HSC. There were no differences in dietary intake between the two groups. These results suggest differences in physical activity between PSC and HSC and encourage further study of public and home school environments, in relation to the obesity epidemic” (p. 44). Cross-sectional descriptive study; convenience sample of homeschool students where were then matched with public school students on age, sex, ethnicity, and BMI (“The lower weekday physical activity levels of HSC, without differences in weekend activity levels, may suggest that the lack of scheduled physical education classes, recess, or after school physical activity programs in home school curricula play a role in lower activity levels” (p. 53). “It is also important to note that, on average, neither child group met the current guidelines and recommendations for nutrition and physical activity. The American Dietetic Association (ADA) recommendations for children aged 2–11 years include consuming 25–35% of energy from fat (1), whereas other recommendations call for a reduction to less than 30% of energy from fat (23,48). This should be coupled with 60 min of MVPA on most, if not all, days of the week (31). We found that HSC actually consumed more energy from fat (33% vs. 32%) and on average, were less [p. 55 ends] active (34 min vs. 42 min MVPA) than their matched public school counterparts. It has also been proposed that children should accrue more than the recommended 10,000 step∙day¯1 recommended for adults (38)” (p. 55-56). Authors do not apply terms risk or at-risk to homeschoolers.
Lopez, Diane 19mis?? Teaching Children. Michigan City, IN: Child Light. home education Christian perspective, use work of Charlotte Mason.
Lord, Mary 2002, February 4 Teaching America: The new education bill promises a lot. Will it deliver? Stay tuned . . . U.S. News & World Report, 132(3), 28-29. Retrieved 1/28/02 online http://www.usnews.com/usnews/issue/020128/education/28education.htm. http://www.usnews.com/usnews/issue/020128/education/28education.htm home education, homeschooling, education reform, tax-funding “The 1,184-page No Child Left Behind Act, which President Bush signed into law January 8, will redefine and expand the federal role in public education. It treats schools like businesses, requiring annual performance evaluations and data-driven results. It provides more money, with less red tape, to turn around failing "factories." And it gives "consumers"students and parents a way to comparison shop” [p. 28]. After quoting one teacher -- “‘The key is to know every single kid,’ says Principal Attaway, a 26-year veteran educator” -- and the next-to-last sentence of the article saying, “Worse, rote could send dropout rates soaring,” the author ends the article with, “So here's your final question: Can you spell h-o-m-e-s-c-h-o-o-l-i-n-g?”
Lord, Mary 2002, March 4 A battle for children's futures. U.S. News & World Report, 132(6), 35-36. education reform, tax-funding, vouchers Describes battle over tax-funded vouchers that would allow students to attend private schools that has reached the U.S. Supreme Court. "My children will never go back to public schools. It's like sentencing them to death." -- Roberta Kitchen, an African-American [Black] Clevelend, Ohio bookkeeper who is in favor of tax-funded vouchers, p. 36.
Lorence, Jordan 1987, October A defense of the Tennessee textbook case. Communication Education, 36(4), 378-389.) academic freedom, censorship, home schooling, textbook bias, religious freedom
Lowe, Jane, & Thomas, Alan 2002 Educating your child at home. London: Continuum home education, pedagogy and New York, NY: Continuum). (Describes the homeschool movement, discusses methods of teaching children at home, and explores getting started in home schooling. Focuses on homeschooling in the United Kingdom.
Lubienski, Christopher 2000 Whither the common good?: A critique of home schooling. Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 207-232. home education, philosophy, reasons, sociology, politics, negative critique, negative criticism of home schooling, negative critic Argues that homeschool parents are essentially selfish [p. 229] as they epitomize the trend to make choices for the best education of their own children even though it might hurt other children’s chances [p. 209]. Homeschooling “... undermines the common good in two related ways” [p. 208]. In addition, he concludes that: “Hence, home schooling is a flight from the public production of values in a pluralist society. [p. 228] ..... Home schooling is a relativistic retreat from the public discourse, which is bankrupted of its former role as the space where people had the right and civic responsibility to participate in the public-political production of conceptions of the “good life” -- evident in the value of civic participation and virtue in early republicanism ….. As an extreme form of privatizing the purpose of education, home schooling denies democratic accountability and disenfranchises the community from its legitimate interest in education. This denial of the public interest does not only affect the education of home schoolers, but it also erodes the ability of the community to express its interest in the education of those remaining in the public schools as well. Certainly, public schools fail often in many areas. But they fail publicly, as public institutions, and, in that, we at least have the potential to address the issue” [p. 229].
Lubienski, Christopher 2003 A critical view of home education. Evaluation and Research in Education, 17(2 & 3), 167-178. Retrieved 1/2/08 on as erie0170167.pdf. home education, philosophy, opinion, research, public schools, common good, society, regulation, law, policy, negative criticism “The remarkable spread of home education needs to be considered in light of the arguments driving its growth. While acknowledging that there are many good reasons for individuals to choose home education, this analysis examines some of the most prominent assumptions and claims that advance the practice as a mass movement. Specifically, arguments regarding the rights and responsibilities of parents, and the impact of home education on students and schools are considered with regards to organisational theory, democratic governance and social science standards. These arguments promoting home education highlight the individualised or privatised focus of the phenomenon. The paper contends that home education amplifies the advantages and disadvantages of students’ background characteristics, yet such serious equity issues are too often disregarded in an emerging paradigm based on the pursuit of individual advantage” [p. 167]. “Of course, the public’s interest in the education of children has been institutionalised largely in the form of state-run school systems. For many homeschoolers, this form of governance is the essence of the incapacity of state-funded education systems to educate their children. The mass production model, applied to children through the apparatus of government, serves as the crux of constant conflict between various interest groups and ideologies, leading to faddish, impersonal and ineffective schools. Furthermore, the institutions of the state can function as a means of social control, and can limit opportunities for some groups. While there is certainly some truth to these views, on the other hand, education in the public sphere also serves as a source of liberation for some groups, expanding opportunity for many who would not otherwise have advantages from their home lives, and providing and creating a sanctuary for those in more oppressive home environments. Indeed, compared with the institution of the family, the institutions of state-supported education are better suited to promote equity – a central concern of a democratic and meritocratic society” [p. 175]. Author is, clearly, in the preceding excerpt arguing from the presupposition that democracy and equal-opportunity are the highest values in American society, rather than from another presupposition such as organic or God-designed institutions such as the family, rather than state-run institutions, are the best contexts for the teaching, training, and indoctrination of children and youth. Lubienski goes on to argue that homeschooling “is intended to frustrate” the efforts at giving all students an equal opportunity to advance socially in public schools by washing out one’s inherited advantages or disadvantages in life. Again, Lubienski offers no empirical premises to support the implied claim that state-run educational institutions are helping any given group – for example, one composed of disadvantaged black families of type X – more than would homeschooling for the same type of families. Lubienski also implies, in this critique of the homeschool movement, that its leaders would recommend that all parents, regardless of their level of social, educational, or economic disadvantage, should immediately begin homeschooling or withdraw their children from institutional schools and engage in homeschooling that involves no co-operative efforts among families and within local communities; this implication is unfounded and the level of atomization and lack of cooperative efforts among homeschoolers implied by the author is distorted.
Lubienski, Christopher 2003, January 17 Does homeschooling promote the public good? CQ Researcher [Congressional Quarterly], 13(2), p. 41. home education, research, opinion, philosophy, negative criticism Author answers the question with a “no.” “The accelerated movement toward home schooling reflects a serious threat to the collective good—a threat encouraged by organized efforts to withdraw from common endeavors such as public education” [p. 41]. “Home schooling fragments the public good into individual concerns that deny the public’s interest in the education of all children” [p. 41]. “Home schooling advances from a thin conception of the public good premised on negative notions of liberty: freedom from others, rather than freedom—indeed, responsibility—to be involved with other members of the community. Such an orientation negates the public’s legitimate interest in how children are educated” [p. 41]. Presents political and philosophical argument and claims with no basis in empirical evidence.
Lubienski, Christopher C.; Puckett, Tiffany; & Brewer, T. Jameson 2013 Does homeschooling “work”? A critique of the empirical claims and agenda of advocacy organizations. Peabody Journal of Education, 88(3), 378-392. homeschooling, home education, research, review of research, critique of research, policy “[Abstract] The phenomenal growth of homeschooling in recent years demonstrates not only the appeal of this educational approach but also the notable policy acumen of the homeschooling movement’s leading advocates. This analysis examines and critiques the empirical claims made by homeschooling proponents to justify further expansion and deregulation of the movement, and sheds light on the homeschool advocacy agenda explicit in those claims. Advocates often strongly suggest a causal connection between homeschooling and academic success, postsecondary attainment, and even enjoyment of life. Seemingly, these benefits are experienced all at a reduced cost per student. It is through such claims that homeschooling advocates have expanded the practice of homeschooling and have pressed for fewer state regulations and less oversight. This article outlines and challenges those claims, showing the tenuous basis for such conclusions. Instead, in an era when policymakers demand evidence of effective educational practices, we note the remarkable lack of empirical evidence on the effectiveness of this popular approach and suggest that continued efforts to claim such evidence exists indicates the desire of advocates to further advance what is largely an ideological agenda of deregulation as an end in itself” (p. 378).
Lubienski, Christopher, & Lubienski, Sarah Theule 2006 Charter, private, public schools and academic achievement: New evidence from NAEP mathematics data. New York, NY: National Center for the Study of Privatization in Education, Teachers College, Columbia University. “Without controlling for student background differences, private schools scored higher than noncharter public schools, as would be expected. However, this study examines these patterns further, determining whether they are due simply to the fact that higher proportions of disadvantaged students are enrolled in public schools, and the extent to which the gaps persist [p. 2 ends] after controlling for potential student- and school-level confounding variables, including measures of socioeconomic status, race/ethnicity, gender, disability, limited English proficiency, and school location. Overall, the study demonstrates that demographic differences between students in public and private schools more than account for the relatively high raw scores of private schools. Indeed, after controlling for these differences, the presumably advantageous “private school effect” disappears, and even reverses in most cases” [p. 3].
Lubienski, Christopher; & Brewer, T. Jameson 2016 Does home education “work”? Challenging the assumptions behind the home education movement. In Rothermel (Ed.), International perspectives on home education: Do we still need schools? England: Palgrave Macmillan. homeschooling, criticism, theory Probably same as an article one or both of them wrote with something like this title.
Lubienski, Sarah Theule; Lubienski, Christopher; & Crane, Corinna Crawford 2008, November Achievement differences and school type: The role of school climate, teacher certification, and instruction. American Journal of Education, 115, 97-138. Retrieved February 8, 2012 from http://www.classsizematters.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/lubienski.pdf. http://www.classsizematters.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/lubienski.pdf academic achievement, mathematics, public school, private school, research, classroom factors, teacher factors, instruction factors “Recent analyses challenge common wisdom regarding the superiority of private schools relative to public schools, raising questions about the role of school processes and climate in shaping achievement in different types of schools. While holding demographic factors constant, this multilevel analysis of National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) mathematics data on over 270,000 fourth and eighth graders in over 10,000 schools examines differences among schools on five critical factors: (1) school size, (2) class size, (3) school climate/parental involvement, (4) teacher certification, and (5) instructional practices. This study provides nationally representative evidence that both teacher certification and some reform-oriented mathematics teaching practices correlate positively with achievement and are more prevalent in public schools than in demographically similar private schools. Additionally, smaller class size, more prevalent in private schools, is significantly correlated with achievement” [abstract, p. 97].
Luck, Anneliese; Chen, Wan-Ting; Cuccaro-Alamin, Stephanie; & Prindle, John; Berrick, Jill Duerr; & Putnam-Hornstein, Emily 2025 Homeschooling and child maltreatment: A review of the regulatory context and research evidence in the United States. Child Abuse & Neglect 163 (2025) 107355, www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0145213425001103?dgcid=rss_sd_all "Abstract. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0145213425001103?dgcid=rss_sd_all An increasing number of families in the United States have opted for homeschooling as an alternative to the formal schooling system. Estimates suggest that in the United States, between 5 % and 11 % of the school-age population participates in homeschooling each year—more than 1.5 million students across the country. Recent high-profile cases of severe child abuse and torture among homeschooled children, however, have highlighted the lack of mechanisms for the detection and prevention of child maltreatment. Though these cases have raised awareness about the potential risks of homeschooling, calls for tighter regulations are often met with resistance. Homeschooling advocates argue that increased regulation in the private homes of families criminalizes parents without sufficient evidence of heightened risk. Meanwhile, critics posit that policy intervention is needed to protect the subset of students at increased risk of maltreatment given the deinstitutionalized and isolated nature of homeschooling settings. In this discussion article, we examine the evidence for heightened risk of abuse and neglect in homeschooling environments through both a review of research and an examination of the policies surrounding homeschooling and child maltreatment across U.S. states. Because of the lack of reliable data and the topic’s highly political nature, empirical evidence is limited. We found that although some states have attempted to add explicit child protections to homeschooling law, most efforts have been unsuccessful." This article adds very little to the scholarly work that already exists on this topic related to homeschooling. It is simply a review of information that already exists and had generally been already reviewed by Ray (2022, 2024), Ray & Shakeel (2022), and Dills (2022). Authors give inappropriately little attention to the most important studies in the field e.g., Ray & Shakeel, 2022; Dills, 2022). Authors falsely state that “Most research on homeschooling has been funded by advocacy organizations …” Authors falsely state that HSLDA funded four particulary studies/reports by Ray. Peer-reviewed. Authors imply throughout the theme that the civil government should enact more controls and regulations on homeschoolers so that it can collect more data on homeschool families to determine whether there is a problem for the civil government to solve. Authors call the existence of mandatory reporters and reporting in institutional schools “... traditional child protection mechanisms …” which is a perplexing thing to call a law that deals with child abuse and neglect and just happens to intersect with institutional schooling when no such laws existed for thousands of years in education history around the world and did not exist in the United States for over 100 years when most children were in a form of homeschooling and for almost 100 years of most children then attending institutional public and private schools in the United States. Authors conflate child abuse laws with schooling traditions and laws. Authors call many reports and non-scholarly papers “studies.” Essentially, authors find no scholarly empirical evidence that homeschooling should be controlled by the government to solve an abuse and neglect problem that apparently does not exist.) "Keywords: Homeschooling, Child maltreatment"
Luebke, Robert V. 1999 Homeschooling in Wisconsin: A review of current issues and trends. Wisconsin Policy Research Institute. home education, research Topics include the origins of home schooling in Wisconsin, the face of home schooling in Wisconsin [demographics], current concerns, the home schooling law. Estimates there are 20,000 to 25, 000 students home schooled in Wisconsin by fall of 1999. Bases some of his report on Ray’s 1997 nationwide study, Strengths of their own.
Luffman, Jacqueline 1997 A profile of home schooling in Canada. Education Quarterly Review, 4(4), 30-47. Also retrieved 7/17/13 from http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/81-003-x/81-003-x1997004-eng.pdf. http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/81-003-x/81-003-x1997004-eng.pdf homeschooling, research, home education, survey, overview, Canada, foreign, demographics, advantages and disadvantages, opinion Uses others’ research and government statistics to provide overview of home schooling in Canada. Promotes “partnerships” between institutional schools and homeschool families. “Home schooling, home educating or home-based education — a child participates in his or her education ‘at home’ rather than attending a public, private or other type of school. Parents or guardians assume the responsibility of educating their child and may develop their own curriculum guidelines” (p. 31). Discusses pros and cons of homeschooling. “There is little information on the characteristics of home-schooling families in Canada. Using information from home-schooling curriculum providers, Gerrard (1993) suggested that the largest group of home schoolers are from conservative Christian families who desire a traditional, value-filled learning environment. Controversial evidence exists about the academic achievements of home schoolers. In Ray’s 1994 study on Canadian home schoolers, 38% took a standardized achievement test. The results indicated that home schoolers far exceeded the national average on standardized achievement tests. However, high test scores do not necessarily indicate that home schooling is more advantageous; these students might do well in any educational setting. Furthermore, Ray’s study relied on individuals willing to volunteer information about their [p. 41 ends] home-schooling experience and were likely better educated and of higher social class than non-volunteers (Ray, 1994, p. 56). Clearly, more research is required on the motives, methods and achievements of home schoolers and their families” (p. 41-42). Reports there were approximately 17,500 registered home school students in Canada in the 1995-1996 school year which is about 0.4% of total elementary and secondary school enrollment; this does not include the non-registered or those home schooling through private schools. Home schooling is active and growing in the western provinces, particularly Alberta and British Columbia, with a 10% increase between 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 in the registered home school population in Western Canada. “The regional difference in home-schooling levels may be partially due to the receptivity to home education and the availability of resources for home-schooling families in some of the western provinces. For example, some school boards will make arrangements with home-schooling parents concerning the use of school libraries or other resources for the student” [p. 43]. “There are only two jurisdictions that guarantee some funding to parents who home school (Alberta and Northwest Territories) and they require that educational plans be approved” [p. 34]. Over 60% of the students were at the elementary level in 1995-1996. “Home schooling is not for everyone. Few parents are able to invest vast amounts of time, effort and energy into teaching their children at home. Furthermore, discussion on parental choice and alternative educational options within provincial educational systems may moderate future demands for home schooling. As provincial governments consider various options for parental choice in the public school system, careful attention is expected to be paid to the concerns of home-educating parents. Involving homeschooling families with conventional schools is believed to strengthen both the performance of home-schooled children, and the academic and social environment of traditional schools (Mayberry et al. 1995). Recent examples of collaborative initiatives suggest that clear guidelines and school partnerships with home schoolers would help to identify and track the progress of many home schoolers” (p. 44).
Luffman, Jacqueline 1998, Fall When parents replace teachers: the home schooling option. Canadian Social Trends, 50, 8. analytical products, children, homeschooling, home schooling, parents, provincial differences, school-age children “Focuses on home schooling in Canada. Provinces which have the most home schooling activity; Details on the regulations for home schooling; Reference to the Education Act; Finding that the majority of home schoolers are at the elementary level. INSETS: What you should know about this study (retrieved 7/17/13 from connection.ebscohost.com).
Lufler, Henry Jr. & Robert Kranz, Jr. 1897 Home Instruction in Wisconsin. The LaFollette Institute of Public Affairs.
Lufler, Henry S., Jr. 1988 Pupils. Topeka, Kansas: National Organization on Legal Problems of Education (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED305707). Court Litigation, Desegregation Litigation, Drug Abuse, School Law, Student Rights, Student School Relationship A report that discusses cases involving First Amendment rights in relation to both public and private school students and due process.
Luke, Catherine 2003, April 3 Home schooling: Learning from dissent. Canadian Journal of Educational Administration and Policy, Issue #25. Retrieved 7/10/13 from https://www.umanitoba.ca/publications/cjeap/articles/miscellaneousArticles/caluke.html. https://www.umanitoba.ca/publications/cjeap/articles/miscellaneousArticles/caluke.html homeschooling, reasons, public schooling, schooling, choice, market Does well at clearly and dispassionatly presenting homeschooling as a challenge to the assumptions implicit in the state/public school system of Canada, or of any nation. “While home schooling is at a considerable distance from and runs counter to many of the central principles of the public education system, I believe it has the potential to offer us an important and challenging critique of that system. Rather than dismissing home schooling as a choice that is irrelevant to public school reform, I believe educational reformers, administrators, and teachers have something to learn from parents who choose to teach their children at home” (paragraph 3). “Perhaps the most compelling and complex argument against home schooling is that home schooling is an inherently asocial and apolitical behaviour in the context of a democratic society. ….. Unless one can move to the position that individual fulfillment does in fact contribute to the greater good of society, home schooling is clearly moving away from the democratic theory that informs our public education system and in its quiet way presenting a serious challenge to the central tenets of both our educational and political systems.” “We need to ask some crucial questions about the conditions for learning, looking beyond the givens of the public school system: can children learn more readily in a non-authoritarian environment? do children learn better through contact with the real world outside the school and classroom? could children benefit from a more leisurely approach to learning where they could consider what they hear and observe in a more contemplative setting? what qualities do parents bring to their teaching that we may not be considering and nurturing when we select and train professional teachers? Is it possible that we have taken for granted the basic structures of the public system -- teacher training, school buildings, classrooms, textbooks and subject-organized curriculum -- to such an extent that we have been unable to even ask these questions effectively? We can hope that home schoolers in the future will open their lives to this kind of research in order, perhaps, to instruct the public school system about some fundamental principles of teaching and learning.”
Luke, Graham 2001 ?? Education, engineering and enlightenment; The three E's. State and home education contrasted. Home School Researcher, 14(4), mis??
Lundy, Garvey, & Mazama, Ama 2014 “I’m keeping my son home”: African American males and the motivation to homeschool. Journal of African American Males in Education, 5(1), 53-74. Retrieved March 28, 2017 from http://jaame.info/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/Lundy-2014.pdf http://jaame.info/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/Lundy-2014.pdf
Lupton, Paul E. 1983 Selected home and family factors affecting high school achievement. Dissertation Abstracts International, 44(9), 2681A. University of Wisconsin, Madison, 250 p. "Parents of high achievers tended to be slightly older, success oriented themselves, and they exerted pressure to succeed on their children. These parents also preferred conservative values but seemed comfortable in letting their children choose careers and life-styles that would be `fulfilling and satisfying'" [p. 2681A].
Lyman, Isabel 1998, January 7 Homeschooling: Back to the future? Cato Policy Analysis, 294. Retrieved 2/18/2011 from http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa-294.html. http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa-294.html mis?? “Holt, a humanist, became a cult figure of sorts to the wing of the homeschooling movement that drew together New Age devotees, ex-hippies, and homesteaders--the countercultural left” beginning in the 1970s.
Lyman, Isabel 2001, April 23 Motherhood Gets a Face-lift. The New American, 17(9). Published 4/23/01 and retrieved 6/19/02 online http://thenewamerican.com/tna/2001/04-23-2001/vo17no09_motherhood.htm. http://thenewamerican.com/tna/2001/04-23-2001/vo17no09_motherhood.htm home education, sociology, homeschooling, sexism, feminism, gender roles “Given the myriad higher education and career opportunities available to the fairer sex in post-feminist America, it is remarkable that there are still women who choose to become homemakers. But millions of American women do just that. And a number of those, largely driven by the decline in the nation’s educational standards, have reinvented themselves as home-schoolers. ..... But while most of these self-taught schoolmarms have learned to purchase curriculum as expertly as any seasoned school administrator and still make time to bake cookies, this is what they love about managing a home-school: the opportunity to spend an ample quantity of quality time with their children. ..... So, one wonders: Is a woman who commits herself so wholeheartedly to her children and their education a throwback to another era? Is this a giant step backward for womankind? Or, are these pioneers who defy categorization? Engage them in a debate about radical feminism — a movement whose leaders famously champion "Take Our Daughters To Work Day" — and the opinions that emerge are spirited. Pam, for example, believes she is "the epitome of what feminists say they are for and what they believe in." Yet sisterhood in the National Organization for Women isn’t for her. "I think ‘dictator,’ ‘hostile,’ ‘anti-male,’ and ‘anti-female,’ when I hear the word feminist," allows Pam. Cindi Grelen agrees: "A feminist is an angry person who is self-absorbed and on a desperate search for peace. ..... The ladies who form this new women’s movement, however, aren’t cruising through their tasks without adjustments. Consider the financial issue [of living on one income]. ..... Their sacrifices, fortunately, have resulted in close-knit families whose homes aren’t treated as a Motel 6 pit stop. As Christine writes in Home School Digest: "My house unapologetically reflects the fact that children are in residence. From the toys on the lawn to the projects scattered around the house, a visitor can readily see that this is a place of creativity and learning." Such is the attitude of the women who have chosen to teach their children at home rather than "sub-contract the child rearing," as Christine says. Cindi, frankly, is glad to avoid the "headaches of juggling loyalties to a boss vs. the children." "We can always have a career, but we only have our children for a short time," says Karla, summing up the prevailing sentiment.”
Lyman, Isabel 2002 The homeschooling revolution. home education A reviewer says it is an up-to-date introduction to the homeschooling revolution - its history, why people do it, how homeschoolers fare academically.
Lynch, Ella Frances 1914 Educating the child at home. New York, NY: Harper and Brothers Publishers, 214 p.
Lysakowski, R. S., & Walberg, H. J. 1982 Instructional effects of cues, participation, and corrective feedback: A quantitative synthesis. American Education Research Journal, 19, 559-578. tutor, tutoring, achievement Probably addresses tutoring and academic achievement.
Lyster-Mensh, Laurae 2000, November/December Is Homeschooling Sexist? Home Education Magazine, November/December 2000. http://www.home-ed-magazine.com/HEM/176/ndsexist.html home education, sociology, homeschooling, sexism, feminism, gender roles Published 2000 and retrieved 6/19/02 online http://www.home-ed-magazine.com/HEM/176/ndsexist.html. “There are prices to our choice to homeschool. Some are obvious and universal: We forgo a potential income and career advancement if we do return to outside work, and we work a long and unending day as full-time family members. There are other costs, though, that many of us seem unwilling to discuss. The greatest among them is a feeling of defensiveness when we face our communities and prevailing expectations for women. Sure, most non-homeschoolers speak of their admiration for our "patience" and "dedication." But for the majority of American families, outside education is a resource that makes their lifestyle possible: two incomes, with the freedom to volunteer, to maintain clean homes, and to enjoy lunches with adults. Homeschooling threatens the assumption that doing it yourself is a waste of resources. ..... Ironically, many homeschoolers are motivated to eschew schooling for their kids in a rejection of tradition. While some families still chooses to educate at home out of a rejection of the liberal morality of the schools, many famlies foreswear schooling for its conservative and conforming nature. For these families, inclined toward an egalitarian view of gender roles, women - and it is nearly always the mother who homeschools - have to reconcile the incongruity of taking the non-economic role in the family. The second aspect of the homeschooling division of labor that many of us like to ignore is the message to our daughters, and our sons, yet in different ways. Like my mother before me I assure my daughter that she has unlimited potential. She is intelligent, well read, and very engaged in the world. When I tell her she can do "anything she dreams of," what am I saying? Am I telling her she can strive toward being a homeschooling mother? Am I telling her not to? ..... If it is a problem that we face an exaggeration of gender role apportionment, then there are obvious solutions. Men could do more of the homeschooling, which does sometimes happen. Women could work more outside the home. Many families who choose homeschooling make a conscious downsizing of their lifestyles, not only to allow a single wage earner but also to free the spouse from permanent exile at work.”)
Lyubitskaya, Kristina; & Polivanova, Katerina 2021 Parental engagement: Why parents in Russia choose homeschooling and what problems they have to solve Journal of School Choice, https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2021.2018785 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2021.2018785 Homeschooling, home education, reasons for homeschooling, motivations, parental involvement, educational changes, add, barriers to homeschool, peer-reviewed “Abstract. Previous studies of homeschooling focus primarily on two areas: the demographic characteristics and socio-economic status of homeschoolers and the achievements of homeschooled children. Recently, however, the angle of research has shifted to the emotional and social results and emerging problems of homeschooling. Our paper presents the first attempt to investigate the reasons families in Russia choose homeschooling in the context of the historical changes that took place in the Russian education system in regard to the reasons families in Europe and the US choose homeschooling. In addition, this paper identifies the barriers homeschool families in Russia face and ways to overcome them. The study is based on survey data (N = 151) and interviews (N = 33) of parents in Russia. Our results indicate that parents struggle to define their role(s) in their relationships with their children during homeschooling while also encountering a lack of support and the misunderstanding of other family members. In addition to these difficulties, we identified organizational problems, including the transition to homeschooling, the lack of parental pedagogical competence, and the lack of special methods of individual education. A distinctive feature of Russian homeschooling, moreover, is that it remains parent-friendly, allowing the family to choose and organize the form of education for their children, and is developing rapidly while existing being in an institutional environment controlled by the state, with the legacy of the Soviet educational system.”
Macaulay, Susan Schaeffer 1984 For the children's sake: Foundations of education for home and school. Westchester, IL: Crossway Books.
MacDonald, Suzanne, & Marchant, Greg 1992 How home schoolers school: A study of home schooling parents' teaching practices. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 20-24, 1992, San Francisco, CA.
Machen, J. Gresham 1987, 1995, 2004 Education, Christianity, and the state. Unicoi, TN: The Trinity Foundation. education, philosophy, schools, public schools, state, private schools, religion, Christianity Chapters written by Machen in the early 1900s. “The reason why I am opposed to this proposal is that it represents a very ancient principle in the field of education which, it seems to me, has been on of the chief enemies of human liberty for several thousand years – the principle, namely, that education is an affair essentially of the State, that education must be standardized for the welfare of the whole people and put under the control of government, that personal idiosyncrasies should be avoided. This principle, of course, was enunciated in classic form in ancient Greece. It is the theory, for example, that underlies the Republic of Plato. But the principle was not only enunciated in theory; it was also, in some of the Greek states, put into practice. It is a very ancient thing – this notion that the children belong to the State and that their education must be provided for by the State in a way that makes [p. 87 ends] for the State’s welfare. But that principle, I think you will find if you examine human history, is inimical at every step to liberty …” (p. 87-88). In chapter entitled “The Christian School,” Machen writes: “In fact, science has served to improve enormously the techniques of tyranny in our day as over against the cruder tyrannies of fire and sword which reigned in the past. It is in accordance with an inexorable logic that Hitler is practising fiendish wickedness in Germany today in the name of science. [p. 135 ends]. . . . . When we turn from the gods [that science has replaced] shall we turn to God?” Machen shows that state-run schools (i.e., public schools) do not and cannot turn children, youth, and a nation to God, His principles, and His morality.
Machovcová1, Kateřina; Beláňová, Andrea; Kostelecká, Yvona; & Mccabe, Marta 2021 Homeschooling mothers: Precarious by choice? Human Affairs, 31, 73–88, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/humaff-2021-0007. https://doi.org/10.1515/humaff-2021-0007 homeschooling; gender and family; choice feminism; precarious work; care; research “Abstract: This article presents the findings of a study on homeschooling in Czechia. It focuses on the gender aspects of this uncommon educational decision. Based on forty-three individual interviews with homeschooling parents, the article’s unifying thread is interest in understanding how mothers are involved in the decision to homeschool, and how the practice is embedded in gendered relationships within the society. We explore the results from two perspectives. First, we consider how the choice to homeschool lies simultaneously in embracing and opposing cultural imperatives of good mothering. Second, we explore the precarious status of homeschooling mothers in relation to economic independence. By shedding light on individual choice within social structures, we situate the practice of homeschooling within the gender inequalities of today’s society” (p. 73).
Mackenzie, O., Christensen, E. L., & Rigby, P. H. 1968 Correspondence instruction in the United States. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
MacKenzie, William H. 1987 Home school's pot is hot. The Oregonian, March 29, p. C1 and C5.
Macleod, Flora 1984 Home based early learning project: A one-year evaluation. Early Child Development and Care, 15, pp. 185-202.
Madar, Michal Unger; & BenDavid-Hadar, Iris 2021 Does home schooling improve creative thinking and social competencies among children? Home schooling in Israel. Journal of School Choice, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2021.1977584 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2021.1977584 Homeschooling; public school; creative thinking; social competencies; COVID-19; peer-reviewed “Abstract: Homeschooling is on the rise in many Western countries, reflecting families’ growing preference for teaching their children at home, in a family environment. This increasing trend has a social derivative, as learning at home may develop alternative competencies. The objective of this research is to examine the effectiveness of homeschooling by analyzing the levels of creative thinking and social competencies among homeschoolers and by comparing these abilities to those of traditional learners. Participants included 549 schoolchildren between the ages of 8 and 12 (280 homeschoolers and 269 public school students). The participants were asked to fill in two questionnaires: 1) the Creative Thinking Drawing Production (TCT-DP) questionnaire to evaluate their creative thinking, and 2) the Social Competencies Rating System (SSRS) questionnaire to evaluate their social competences. The findings of the multiple regression analyses indicate that homeschoolers exhibit higher level of creative thinking and higher social competencies than traditional learners. Policy implications highlight the need to develop creative thinking and social competencies among traditional learners.”
Madden, M. M. (Ed.) 1986 Home study by correspondence. Method: Alaskan Perspectives [Special issue], 7(1).
Madden, Marilou (Ed.) 1986 Facts about Alaska's centralized correspondence study program (CCS). Method: Alaskan Perspectives, 7(1), 3.
Madden, Susan B. 1991, July Learning at home: Public library service to homeschoolers. School Library Journal.
Magers, Tanya Ann 1983 Problems associated with unaccredited private schools and home instruction programs and solutions to the problems as perceived by state education officials. Dissertation Abstracts International, 44, 2312A-2313A. Ball State University, 247 p. (Also University Microfilms International, No. 8327860.) "Major problems existed with state regulations regarding equivalent instruction, teacher qualifications, courses of study, and definition of a school" [p. 2313A].
Mahan, Bernice Marie & Ware, Brenda Joyce 1987, July Home-Schooling: Reasons some parents choose this alternative form of education, and a study of the attitudes of home-schooling parents and public school superintendents toward the benefits of home-schooling. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED286624).) Administrator Attitudes, Home Schooling, Parent Attitudes, Public Schools, School Choice, Superintendents
Maloney, Lawrence 1982, June 28 Now it's the "stay-at-home society." U.S. News and World Report, pp. 64-66.
Mand, Adrienne 2000, September 28 New college prepares to welcome home-schooled students. FoxNews.com. Retrieved 10/23/00 online http://www.foxnews.com/national/092800/homeschool_college_mand.sml. http://www.foxnews.com/national/092800/homeschool_college_mand.sml home education, college, university, homeschooled, graduates Describes Patrick Henry College that will open classes October 2, 2000 and is focused on recruiting students who were home educated. The college will provide a classical educatin, a Christian focus, and an emphasis on apprenticeships in governement.
Maness, D. C. 1988 To home school or not to home school: Selected characteristics of home school families in the Bartlesville, Oklahoma area and the Sioux Falls, South Dakota area. Doctoral dissertation, Oklahoma State University, Stillwater. Dissertation Abstracts International, 49, 10A (Order No. AAC8826670).
Maranto, Robert 2021 Between elitism and populism: A case for pluralism in schooling and homeschooling, Journal of School Choice, 15(1), 113-138, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2020.1856562 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2020.1856562 Home schooling; homeschooling, Bartholet; educational pluralism; educational elitism; educational populism; political science; abuse, child abuse “Abstract Inherently, populism questions elite values and expertise; thus, populists oppose and usually are opposed by elites. Here, I discuss how American Political Science treats elitism, pluralism, and populism, relying heavily on the U.S. Founders’ constitutional approaches limiting the power of factions to impose social and political uniformity. Second, I summarize how these models approach the provision of schooling, particularly school choice including homeschooling. In America, public education practice is dominated by elite bureaucratic experts supporting quasi-monopolistic factory models of schooling and unsupportive of the academic rigor some parents desire. Pluralist education as practiced in certain other nation states and historically may offer greater academic success and social peace through diversity, while enhancing achievement and equity. I use these discussions as foundations to critique Bartholet, who argues for severely restricting homeschooling to empower bureaucratic experts and disempower parents. I find it unlikely that such schemes can be implemented without animus against minority factions, and thus without degrading the social diversity inherent to pluralism” p. 113. “Second, Bartholet concludes that the studies indicating that homeschooled students do better academically and on some social dimensions reflect biased researchers, without noting potential anti-homeschool biases of other sources [is an excellent point that almost no scholar or journalist ever points out]. Systematic reviews by home education activist Ray (2017), but also by nonactivist Murphy (2014), conclude that homeschoolers’ seeming successes seem statistically real. That said, as Bartholet and Murphy each emphasize, nonrepresentative samples limit the conclusiveness of findings. Possibly, homeschooled students would have done even better, at least on easily measured outcomes, were they coerced to attend public schools” (p. 128). “The text itself has a Manichean character, with virtuous secular experts trying to prevent Christians from abusing children. . . . . . Generally, this text evinces deep discomfort with religious diversity at best, anti-faith bigotry at worst. This was probably not the author’s intent, but nonetheless raises concerns” p. 130. “In fact, about 1% of children annually are estimated to suffer abuse, and those rates seem to have declined in recent decades even as homeschooling has grown (Child Trends, 2019).”
Maranto, Robert, & Bell, Debra A. 2018 Homeschooling in the 21st Century: Research and Prospects, 1st Edition. Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon, United Kingdom: Routledge. homeschooling, home education Table of Contents: 1. The Fall and Rise of Home Education Angela Watson, Robert Maranto, and Debra A. Bell, 2. The Human Right of Home Education Michael P. Donnelly; 3. Homeschooling, Virtual Learning, and the Eroding Public/Private Binary Aaron Saiger, 4. Types of Homeschool Environments and Need Support for Children’s Achievement Motivation, Debra A. Bell, Avi Kaplan and S. Kenneth Thurman, 5. A Descriptive Survey of Why Parents Choose Hybrid Homeschools Eric Wearne, 6. African American Homeschool Parents’Motivations for Homeschooling and their Black Children’s Academic Achievement, Brian Ray, 7. Homeschooling is not just about Education: Focuses of Meaning Ari Neuman and Oz Guterman; 8. Homeschool Parents and Satisfaction with Special Education Services Albert Cheng, Sivan, Tuchman and Patrick J. Wolf; 9. Are Homeschoolers Prepared for College Calculus? Christian P. Wilkens, Carol H. Wade, Gerhard Sonnert and Philip M. Sadler; 10. Does Homeschooling or Private Schooling Promote Political Intolerance? Evidence from a Christian University, Albert Cheng.
Marchant, Greg, & MacDonald, Suzanne C. 1992 How home schoolers school: Ohio profiles. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco CA, April 20-24. home education, research, pedagogy, ideology, reasons, practice "The questionnaire data supported Van Galen's (1988) notion of ideologues and pedagogues. ..... There appeared to be qualitative differences in the approach and teaching style of the home schoolers based upon the reasons they cited for choosing to home school. [new paragraph] However, the interviews presented a less well defined picture of the differences associated with ideologues and pedagogues. Most of the parents seemed to be a blend of both, mixing their religious beliefs with pedagogical approaches" (p. 16).
Marchant, Gregory 1993 Home schoolers on-line. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 12-16, 1993, Atlanta GA. [Marchant was at Ball State University] research, computer, home education
Marchant, Gregory J. 1993 Home schoolers on-line. Home School Researcher, 9(2), 1-9. home education, research, computers, technology Explores home education families usage of on-line computer services; surveyed them via on-line; concluded these parents are (1) knowledgeable and sophisticated—"They knew materials and methods of instruction. They were knowledgeable of the laws that effected [sic] them, as well as the educational system(s) which they either knew how to take advantage of it, or knew which mechanisms existed that could be a possible threat to their home schooling," (2) "...armed to the teeth with educational materials and technology. They all have computers and use them," and (3) "This is a supportive [of one another] and at times defensive group of parents." (p. 8)
Marean, Joy A., Ott, Marc F., & Rush, Matthew 2002, December 10 From Homeschooling to the Ivy League: A look at admissions requirements, attitudes, and data from Ivy League schools with respect to homeschoolers. home education, research, college, college admissions, admission policy, adults Find that admissions officers view transcripts with trepidation and do not weigh them strongly; test results, e.g., SAT I, are weighed more heavily than transcripts because of their objectivity; homeschooled students are encouraged to submit more of these SAT II subject-based test scores; admissions officers are looking for objective letters of recommendation, preferably from outside the family; interviews are not required for homeschooled applicants any more than for others; 4 of the 6 Ivy League universities do not consider homeschooling a form of diversity affecting the admissions decision; admissions officers foresee a continued increase of applications from the homeschooled; admissions do not usually follow-up with students that have been homeschooled and do not have specific procedures in place to assess homeschooled applicants. Admissions officers focus more on their academic abilities than social skills. It is as challenging for homeschooled applicants to be accepted (18%) as it is for non-homeschooled applicants (20%). There have been concerns raised by detractors of homeschooling that these students lack social integration and social adjustment but both the literature reviewed and the interviews conducted suggest that socialization is not a negative factor in a homeschooler’s collegiate experience; however, “We concluded that homeschooled students are better prepared and more likely to succeed” [abstract].
Marean, Joy A., Ott, Marc F., & Rush, Matthew J. 2005 Homeschoold students and the Ivy League: Gaining admission to highly selective universities in the United States. In Bruce S. Cooper (Ed.), Home schooling in full view: A reader, p. 179-197. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing. home education, college, college admissions, adult
Marks, Gary Neil 2008, January Are father's or mother's socioeconomic characteristics more important influences on student performance? Recent international evidence. Social Indicators Research, 85(2), 293-309. http://www.springerlink.com/content/6216821112335761/ public school, academic achievement, parents SES socioeconomic status, mother’s education, mother’s educational attainment, father’s education, father’s educational attainment “Abstract Since the early 1970s the importance of mothers’ socioeconomic characteristics on their children’s educational and occupational attainment has been acknowledged. However, it is not clear if fathers’ characteristics have a stronger influence because men usually have stronger attachments to the labour market, or alternatively mothers’ characteristics are more important because of their greater role in children’s socialization. This study addresses this question by comparing the influence of father’s and mother’s education and occupation on student performance in literacy and numeracy using data from 30 countries. The impact of mother’s education is usually greater or comparable to that of father’s education. In contrast, substantially stronger effects for mother’s occupational status compared to father’s were rare. In most countries the impact of mother’s socioeconomic characteristics (education plus occupation) on student performance is comparable to that for father’s. Of the four indicators of socioeconomic background, father’s occupational status and mother’s educational attainment tend to have stronger effects, although many countries do not conform to this pattern. There are indications that the relative importance of mother’s characteristics have increased over time” [abstract, retrieved 5/19/08 from http://www.springerlink.com/content/6216821112335761/.] Finds in the U.S. that mother's education educational attainment is a relatively strong strong correlate of student reading and math achievement; in the U.S. for mother’s and father’s education level combined, R2 is 0.12 for reading and 0.15 for math, both p<0.001.
Marlow, Stacey 1992 Home schools, public schools, politics, and practice: Superintendents implementing home education policy in four Western states. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.
Marlow, Stacey E. 1991 Home school policy in four states: The match between case and statutory laws and administrative rules and regulations. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 3-7, Chicago IL.
Marlow, Stacey E. 1991 Six years after: An analysis of the implementation of the home-based education law in Washington State. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Chicago, IL, April 3-7, 1991. home education, public school cooperation, policy, research, law, legal Outlines the Washington home-based instruction law and presents responses of public school superintendents regarding the entry of the home educated into public schools; many require testing for grade placement, some place according to age, and some had no policy or experience with the situation. Explains some school districts encourage cooperation with home educators, while a few superintendents expressed overt hostility or negativity in their attitudes toward home educators. Suggests ways for superintendents to improve relationships with home educators.
Marlow, Stacey E. 1994, August Educating children at home: Implications for assessment and accountability. Education and Urban Society, 26 (4), 438-460. ERIC Reproduction Service Number EJ490353. Home Education, Accountability; Beliefs; Educational Assessment; Educational Policy; Elementary Secondary Education; Government Role; Home Schooling; Nontraditional Education; Parents as Teachers; Standardized Tests; State Government; State Programs; Test Use “Uses the home-education policy arena as a lens through which to view changing beliefs and practices about student assessment. The home-education policies of 10 states illustrate issues relating to accountability in public and private schools and the use of standardized tests” [ERIC abstract].
Marrou, H. I. 1956 A history of education in antiquity. New York, NY: Sheed and Ward, Inc. Education methods of Rome and Greece are discussed in detail; two good chapters on Jewish and Christian educational practices until about 500 A.D.; some interesting observations on what early Christians did with an acknowledged pagan school system.
Marsden, George 1997 The outrageous idea of Christian scholarship. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
Marshall, J. Dan, & Valle, James P. 1996, August 8 Public school reform: Potential lessons from the truly departed. Education Policy Analysis Archives,4(12). home education, school reform, public schools/education, reasons for home schooling “Abstract: In this article, the authors present data from a small study of 19 families who educate their children at home in rural Pennsylvania. Findings relative to why they opted out of the public education system and whether they would return are analyzed in light of a previously established construct (Ideologue/Pedagogue) before being used to critique and expand it in light of broader cultural concerns. The authors argue, overall, that home educators are asserting their historical option of cultural agency and schooling. (Note 1) If "school reform" is a bandwagon, then the parade is still in progress. Most of the grand proposals earlier composed by politicians, pundits, policy wonks, and professors have evolved into smaller, more locally pertinent endeavors by actual change participants (educators, students, parents and community members). In the worst case, the continuing accumulation of school reform efforts is understood as succeeding waves of perpetual hassle and silliness which disturb the basic soundness of business-as-usual. In the best case, such efforts become a representation of participants' commitment to the repetitive nature of the learning process: desiring to know and understand - acting upon these desires - making sense of and reflecting upon those actions - identifying new or different desires to know and understand. Thus, in the best case, school reform efforts should be here to stay. Those who care about examining and acting upon the quality of their local schools seek information from numerous sources, including their own experiences, outside consultants, beliefs and opinions collected from local, state, and national polls, and "the literature" of academia. But they seldom tap the one segment of their community which may provide the most unique perspective: parents who have opted out of the local public school system. We suspect that this group -- particularly those families who have taken it upon themselves to provide education at home -- may have something important to offer those working to change public education. In this article, we discuss our preliminary foray into the lives of several Pennsylvania home educators in light of public school reform efforts” (Abstract).
Marshall, Joanne M. 2000 In the world but not of it: Conservative Christian students in public schools. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans, LA, April 24-29, 2000. http://home.earthlink.net/~marshajo/AERA.paper.htm public school, Christianity, Christians, tolerance, beliefs, religion Online http://home.earthlink.net/~marshajo/AERA.paper.htm retrieved 7/12/00. “First, are these students’ conservative Christian beliefs tolerated in their public schools? The data seem to say: Usually, and certainly at the official level. Each of the seven public high schools attended by students in this study allows extracurricular Bible clubs to meet in the mornings before school, on school property, with the presence of a teacher, in accordance with legal requirements. What goes on in the classroom is harder to mandate, but it seems that when discussions about religious beliefs do occur in classrooms, then Christian beliefs are allowed to be part of that discussion. However, there are plenty of times when people skitter around topics that could lead to religious discussion, times when people avoid religious discussion entirely, and times when believers feel persecuted by non-believers.” “Second, how do conservative Christian students respond to situations when religion comes up or is avoided? It depends. Almost all of the students in this study tried to initiate or participate in discussions involving religious issues, and had specific examples and anecdotes to relate, some of which are given above. A few have withdrawn from the fray, depending upon the subject. One student drew a line between debatable issues and non-debatable ones and participated accordingly: .....” “Some students have withdrawn from class discussion because they don't think their classmates care about religious viewpoints unless they are made very personal. In other cases, exemplified most dramatically by the t-shirt incident described above, students feel persecuted by classmates or teachers and react strongly against that with prayer, or by feeling alternately enthused or discouraged. Interestingly, students seem to speak most eloquently about feeling separated from their peers not in terms of religious ideology, but in terms of moral behavior. Nearly all students talk about the difficulty of remaining sexually pure, or of the active drinking and drug scene, or of the swearing and sexuality displayed in school hallways. Their separateness from these activities is itself a witness to their faith, and many talk of being questioned about their behavior by friends and classmates.” “Finally, how do students feel about their public school experience? In order to answer this question, I asked students what kind of school they would enroll their future children in -- private, public, or home? More than half say they would choose the public school, though they often add that they would consult with future spouses and pray about it a lot. But they speak very highly about their own experiences, despite some of the more negative experiences some of them have had. Most say that they appreciate the public schools for exposing them to other viewpoints and for allowing them to share their own.”
Marshall, Nancy 1980 School at home. Country Journal, September, 90-95.
Marshner, Connaught (Ed.) 1984 A blueprint for education reform. Washington, DC: Free Congress Research and Education Foundation, Child and Family Protection Institute. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED250766). Educational Change, Educational Experience, Educational Improvement, Public Education Fourteen authors give their ideas as to how home education can be blended into the society that surrounds it.
Martin, Aaron T. 2010 Homeschooling in Germany and the United States. Arizona Journal of International & Comparative Law, 27(1), 225, 2010. homeschooling, Germany, constitutional law, education law, legal “Abstract: In March 2009, the Georgia House of Representatives passed House Resolution 850, urging the German Federal Government to legalize homeschooling. The resolution was one illustration of how advocacy groups throughout the United States have put pressure on Germany to change its draconian laws regarding homeschooling, laws that were enacted in 1938 during the Nazi regime. But while legislators are calling for Germany to change its laws, battles rage within the United States over the same issues. This Note evaluates the state of homeschooling in the United States and Germany, both by considering the historical development in each country and through analysis of current cases. Although Germany and the United States have very different approaches to homeschooling and parental rights over the education of children, similar pressures threaten the status quo in each country. For Germany to concede rights to parents would undermine its strong nationalistic education system; individual judges in the United States feel that our relatively liberal homeschooling laws threaten the fabric of our pluralistic society and concede too much to individual - and often religious - beliefs. In many ways, Germany and the United States are dealing with the same overarching policy questions despite their being democracies at very different stages of development. This Note helps to locate the normative questions that the countries will have to confront if they are going to develop any lasting policy on homeschooling.”
Martin, Jane R. 1992 The schoolhome: Rethinking schools for changing families. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. philosophy, home, education, family, public school Posits that the public school now fills many of the roles that were once nearly the sole domain of the family, and her "schoolhomes" should become the moral equivalent of the family, places of care, concern, and connection (is probably what she called it); many of the claims she makes would be agreed upon by home educators, but her solution is, in many ways, antithetical to the goal and practice of home education; written by a philosopher.
Martin-Chang, Sandra Lyn; & Levesque, Kyle 2017 Academic Achievement: Making an Informed Choice about Homeschooling. In Milton Gaither (Ed.), Wiley Handbook of Home Education. homeschooling, home education, home schooling, academic achievement, school choice, discovery learning “Abstract: It can be difficult for families to decide whether to educate their children in traditional classroom settings or at home. The decision is made ever more daunting in light of the fact that very little empirical research has examined the academic achievements associated with homeschooling. In the current chapter, we review what little scientific evidence has been collected regarding the academic achievements associated with homeschooling. In addition, we supplement this relatively scarce area of study by briefly reviewing two closely related fields, namely, discovery learning and providing structure for learning. We conclude that the crucial factor for fostering academic success is a structured approach that intermixes a high level of parental input along with guided instruction across meaningful learning experiences.”
Martin-Chang, Sandra; Gould, Odette N.; Meuse, Reanne E. 2011, July The impact of schooling on academic achievement: Evidence from homeschooled and traditionally schooled students. Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science/Revue canadienne des sciences du comportement, 43(3), 195-202. home education, homeschooling, public school, academic achievement, causal-comparative, matched-pair, structured, unstructured, Canada, Peer-reviewed Retrieved online mis?? pp. 1-8. (Compares academic achievement of homeschool and conventional/traditional school students, and sub-divides homeschooled into structured versus unstructured instruction with a causal-comparative design. “Abstract: Although homeschooling is growing in prevalence, its educational outcomes remain unclear. The present study compared the academic achievements of homeschooled children with children attending traditional public school. When the homeschooled group was divided into those who were taught from organized lesson plans (structured homeschoolers) and those who were not (unstructured homeschoolers), the data showed that structured homeschooled children achieved higher standardized scores compared with children attending public school. Exploratory analyses also suggest that the unstructured homeschoolers are achieving the lowest standardized scores across the 3 groups” [p. 1]. Used a match-pair design (matching homeschool to public school) and studied 74 children (37 solely homeschooled and 37 solely public school, or at least never homeschooled) between the ages of 5 and 10 years, with mean age of 7 years 11 months. “All of the mothers in the homeschooled group and all but one of the mothers in the public school group were married or living in committed relationships” [p. 3], and “mothers’ education and median income were slightly higher for the public school group” [p. 6]. Authors further divided the homeschool families into two groups, structured and unstructured, for analysis. “As shown in Table 2, the children who received structured homeschooling were superior to the children enrolled in public school across all seven subtests. To gain a broad perspective of the level of standardized achievement in each group, we conducted a multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) that included the scores from all seven Woodcock–Johnson subtests. ….. Thus, all seven subtests were used as dependent variables, and schooling group (public school and structured homeschool) was the independent variable. ….. Using Cohen’s convention (Cohen, 1988) that a medium effect size is approximately n2 [effect size squared?] = .06 and a large effect is n2 [effect size squared?] = .14, all the variables showed a medium or strong effect. ….. In conclusion, when comparing the test scores of the children attending public school and children receiving structured homeschooling, it becomes clear that the latter group has higher scores across a variety of academic areas. Moreover, there is no evidence that this difference is simply due to the family’s income or the mother’s educational attainment. ….. Owing to the small number of individuals in the unstructured homeschooled group, we conducted simple t tests comparisons on each of the Woodcock–Johnson subtests separately. ….. In conclusion, our exploratory analyses suggest that the unstructured homeschooled children generally score below their expected [p. 5 ends] grade level on the standardized test, and that even with this small sample, performance differences are relatively substantial” [p. 6]. “Our results suggest that structured homeschooling may offer opportunities for academic performance beyond those typically experienced in public school. Moreover, the design used in the current study suggests that the benefits of structured homeschooling cannot be accounted for by differences in yearly family income or maternal education” [p. 6]. “The evidence presented here is in line with the assumption that homeschooling offers benefits over and above those experienced in public school” [p. 6]. “However, our results also show that the homeschooling community comprises subpopulations and suggest that the clear advantage of homeschooling may be limited to situations where parents create structured environments, at least in terms of performance on academic tests” [p. 7] and, this editor would add, at the young ages of 5 to 10 as this study considered; and authors state, “This raises the question of whether a similar pattern would be observed with larger sample sizes, and if so, whether the children receiving unstructured homeschooling would eventually catch up, or even surpass, their peers given ample time” [p. 7]. “The fact that the public school children were achieving above grade level expectations on many of the Woodcock–Johnson subtests suggests that this discrepancy did not stem from the poor performance of the public school children but rather resulted from accelerated progress in the children receiving structured home- based education” [p. 7]. “Practical restraints such as the heterogeneity of the population and difficulties in obtaining adequate sample sizes make homeschooling a challenging field of study. Nevertheless, further inquiry is required if parents are to make informed decisions regarding the education of their children. Moreover, identifying the best practices associated with different types of education may facilitate teaching in both traditional and homeschool settings. As such, we hope that our findings act as a catalyst for further investigation into the benefits and limitations associated with different types of home-based education” p. 7. Peer-reviewed.
Marzano, Robert J. 1993-1994 When two worldviews collide. Educational Leadership, 51(4), 6-11. education, philosophy, curriculum Part of special issue of journal entitled "Contemporary issues: Public schools and the Christian fundamentalists"; posits that the main problem keeping secularist educators and Christians from seeing things the same way is fundamental differences in philosophical worldview.
Marzluf, P. 2009 Writing home-schooled students into the academy. Composition Studies, 37(1), 49-66. Peer-reviewed.
Mason, Charlotte 1904 Parents and children. London, England: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner, & Co., Ltd. home education, philosophy, pedagogy, method Mason was the founder of the Charlotte Mason College of Education, England. She stresses bringing a broad and stimulating education to a child in a noncompetitive, biblically-based way. Emphasizes parents’ importance and addressing children’s emotions, spirit, and intellect. Discusses parents as inspirers, rulers, etc.)
Mason, Charlotte 1989 Parents and children: The role of the parent in the education of the child. Wheaton, IL: Tyndale House. home education, philosophy, pedagogy, method A republishing of her 1904 book.
Mason, Charlotte 1989 A philosophy of education: Curiosity--the pathway to creative learning. Wheaton, IL: Tyndale House. home education, philosophy, pedagogy, method A republishing of her 1925 essay.
Mason, Gary 2004, Fall Homeschool recruiting: Lessons learned on the journey. Journal of College Admission, No. 185, 2-3.
Mason, James 2018 The civic virtue of private home education: Or how I learned to stop worrying and oppose so-called Education Savings Accounts for homeschoolers, https://read.nxtbook.com/hslda/the_home_school_court_report/fourth_quarter_2018_vol34_no4/the_civic_virtue_of_private_h.html https://read.nxtbook.com/hslda/the_home_school_court_report/fourth_quarter_2018_vol34_no4/the_civic_virtue_of_private_h.html homeschooling, funding, control, legislation, policy, school choice, Education Savings Accounts, ESA, voucher Addresses school choice topics such as Education Savings Accounts (ESA, ESAs), vouchers, and any tax-funded schooling education, especially as it might apply to homeschooling. Excellent argument for why homeschoolers should not accept government/tax funding and how government funding leads to government control.) ?
Matatics, Gerry 1993, February Biblical foundations of home schooling. Part 5: Socialization, or paganization? Seton Home Study School, 10(2), 5. Available from Seton School [Roman Catholic organization], P.O. Box 396, 1350 Progress Drive, Front Royal, VA 22630
Mathews, Jay 2004, July 27 Correcting misconceptions about home schooling. Retrieved 8/9/04 online http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A17676-2004Jul27.html. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A17676-2004Jul27.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wpdyn/articles/A176762004Jul27.html home education, opinion, public Author who once held misunderstandings about homeschooling corrects them.
Mathieson, D. E. 1971 Correspondence study: A summary review of the research and development literature. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University.
Matrician, Miki Kawashima 2011, May 1 Germany homeschoolers as "particular social group": Evaluation under current U.S. asylum jurisprudence. Boston College International and Comparative Law Review, 34(2), 438-462. http://lawdigitalcommons.bc.edu/iclr/vol34/iss2/4/ home education, homeschooling, parental rights, law, philosophy, asylum Retrieved October 17, 2011 from http://lawdigitalcommons.bc.edu/iclr/vol34/iss2/4/. )”Abstract: Thirty years after the enactment of the Refugee Act of 1980, the Board of Immigration Appeals and U.S. courts and have not reached consensus on a uniform definition for the protected category of “particular social group.” The lack of consensus has created much confusion and inconsistent results for applicants seeking asylum in the United States. This Note examines one family’s grant of asylum [i.e., the Romeikes, a German family who fled their native country to escape government persecution for homeschooling their children] as a vehicle for analyzing the two main approaches to “particular social group” and argues that the current treatment of the two standards as mutually exclusive by the BIA and the federal courts is inconsistent with the U.N. Guidelines. The Note concludes that U.S. jurisprudence on “particular social group” should mirror the approach of the U.N. Guidelines, which envisions broader protection under that category” [p. 439]. “While some groups constitute a “particular social group” under one standard and not the other, the U.N. Guidelines address this discrepancy. In the future, the BIA and the courts must uniformly adopt the standard provided by the U.N. Guidelines. Under the guidelines, the two standards do not comprise a two-pronged test; they constitute two distinct tests, and the satisfaction of one test should lead to a finding of “particular social group.” This approach will realize the vision intended by Congress in its enactment of the Refugee Act of 1980. In formulating a cogent standard, DHS, BIA, and the courts must not be blinded by fears of a flood of applicants. They should strive to fulfill the humanitarian obligations required by the Convention, to provide a safe haven for those in dire straits” [p. 462].)
Matthews, Michael S.; Jolly, Jennifer L.; Makel, Matthew C.; Almhawes, Ahmed; Daniels, Kimberleigh S.; & Wojciechowski, Julia H. 2024 Considerations of academically talented students' homeschooling families for returning to traditional schools. Gifted Child Quarterly, 68 (2), 137-153. https://doi.org/10.1177/00169862231222210 https://doi.org/10.1177/00169862231222210 gifted children, decision-making, parents and families, content analysis, homeschooling, advanced academics, school choice, reasons “Abstract: Parent-led, home-based education, or homeschooling, has grown rapidly over recent decades with participation rates increasing more than 100-fold to now nearly one in 25 students nationwide in the United States. However, the research base has not grown correspondingly, and homeschoolers remain understudied. We systematically surveyed a population of homeschooling families (N = 881 responses) who had reported homeschooling a high-ability student to learn more about their characteristics and perceptions. Specifically, we report a mixed-methods analysis of the survey responses addressing whether and why these parents would or would not consider returning their child to a traditional school setting. Respondents were predominantly mothers who reported a high level of formal education and who were primarily responsible for implementing homeschooling with their child. Qualitative thematic analysis of open-ended responses yielded five main themes: preference, academics, concerns about future educational opportunities, satisfaction, and well-being. Findings both support and extend prior research with this population.”
Mattingly, Cecil Nolan 1990 The instructional environments of selected formal home schools. Unpublished doctoral dissertation (Ed.D.), Peabody College for Teachers of Vanderbilt University, Major Professor: Jack W. Miller. Dissertation Abstracts International, 51(5), 1495A. (Order No. DA9027457) Eight conclusions made, great variety among home schools; much use of commercially-prepared, self-paced programs; on average, instructional environments are positive and productive; strengths and weaknesses mentioned.
Mattox, William R., Jr. 1999, March 19 Homeschooling benefits: Children less preoccupied with peer acceptance. San Francisco Chronicle , p. A23. home education, socialization, academic achievement Tells of high academic achievement of the home educated. “Moreover, homeschooled children tend to draw their primary social identity from their membership in a particular family rather than from their membership in ‘a tribe apart.’ That’s the phrase author Patricia Hersch uses to describe the conventionally schooled kids she followed through adolescence. According to Hersch, many school kids today feel isolated from the grown-up world and alienated from parents who fail to take an interest in their lives and to set boundaries for their behavior.”
Matz, Brian J. 2002 Moral development in Christian home schooling families. Purcellville, VA: Home School Legal Defense Association.
Mawson, Anthony R.; Ray, Brian D.; Bhuiyan, Azad R.; & Jacob, Binu 2017 Pilot comparative study on the health of vaccinated and unvaccinated 6- to 12-year-old U.S. children. Journal of Translational Science, 3(3), 1-12: DOI: https://doi.org/10.15761/JTS.1000186. Retrieved May 4, 2017 from http://oatext.com/pdf/JTS-3-186.pdf http://oatext.com/pdf/JTS-3-186.pdf https://doi.org/10.15761/JTS.1000186
Mayberry, Maralee 1988 Characteristics and attitudes of families who home school. Education and Urban Society, 21(1), 32-41.
Mayberry, Maralee 1988 Doing it their way: A study of Oregon's home schoolers. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Department of Sociology, University of Oregon, Eugene. home education, sociology, reasons, demographics Summarizes their social, economic, religious, political, and educational attitude characteristics. Uses a sociological analysis to identify commonalities and differences among home educators. Posits there is a wide diversity of values and beliefs within home education (i.e., the religious [Christian], New Age philosophy, socio-relational [e.g., themes were family unity, child development, negative peer influences, and the losses to both family and child if not home school, p. 148-149], and academic subgroups), and the decision to home school is linked to a generalized belief that America's social institutions do not protect the life style concerns and meaning systems of these people.
Mayberry, Maralee 1988 The 1987-1988 Oregon home school survey: An overview of the findings. Home School Researcher, 4(1), 1-9. home education, research, reasons, demographics, sociology Motivational categories or reasons for home schooling are religious beliefs, 65.2% of parents, academic achievement, 21.6%, socio-relationsl development and environment, 11.1%, and desiring an alternative or New Age orientation to education, 2.1%.
Mayberry, Maralee 1988 The home education movement: Characteristics of it membership. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Oregon Academy of Science, February 6, 1988, Portland, Oregon. home education, sociology General traits of families who home school include higher than average education level of parents, they are more non-denominational and higher in religious commitment than average, and they don't have much confidence in organized religion, public education, labor, and the press, and they think the government is spending too much money; lifestyle politics can explain home schooling choices; can use ideas of modernity and rationalization to understand the themes of loss and others; home educators exhibit the need to reintegrate the sacred into modern life and are committed to regaining control over one thing they can control — the family.
Mayberry, Maralee 1988 Why home schooling? A profile of four categories of home schoolers. Home School Researcher, 4(3), 7-14. home education, rationales, practices Describes the religious (Christian), New Age, socio-relational, and academic groups.
Mayberry, Maralee 1989 Home-based education in the United States: Demographics, motivations and educational implications. Educational Review, 41(2), 171-180. policy, cooperation, home education Says public school administrators should consider that many home educated students will one day be in their schools and should develop cooperative approaches with home education families.
Mayberry, Maralee 1990 Cultural cleavages and commonalities within and surrounding home education. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 16-20, Boston, MA.
Mayberry, Maralee 1991 Political and religious characteristics of home school parents in four western states. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 3-7, Chicago IL.
Mayberry, Maralee, & Knowles, J. Gary 1989 Family unity objectives of parents who teach their children: Ideological and pedagogical orientations to home schooling. The Urban Review, 21(4), 209-226. home education, reasons, cooperation Parents often home educate to maintain or develop family unity; need to encourage family unity in America so shouldn't try to hinder this activity; need to develop cooperation between public schools and home educators.
Mayberry, Maralee, Downey, Nancy, Ray, Brian D., & Knowles, J. Gary 1992 Parents as teachers: Problems and prospects. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Southern Sociological Association, April 1992, New Orleans, LA. home education, sociology, gender roles, role conflict "The purpose of this paper is to examine the role of mothers who are their children's primary teacher. Specifically, the paper will address the complex relations that prevail in home schools as mothers attempt to balance parenting and pedagogy" p. 1. Not widely disseminated—being revised [July 1992].
Mayberry, Maralee, Knowles, J. Gary, Ray, Brian D., & Marlow, Stacey 1995 Home schooling: Parents as educators. Newbury Park, CA: Corwin Press home education, research, quantitative, qualitative of Sage Publ.). (Presents data and conclusions from federally funded study of three western states; examines demographic data, reasons or rationales for home education, perspectives of public school superintendents, perceived needs and wants of home educators, sociological perspectives, history of contemporary home education movement; uses quantitative survey techniques and in-depth interviews; includes data from over 1,900 families and 125 superintendents; reasons for home schooling include parents think they are more pedagogically advanced than conventional school teachers and better able to provide a relevant and exciting curriculum for their children, the negative effects of large class size in conventional schools such as the inability of teachers to provide individual attention to students, parents are more in tune with and understanding of children’s unique needs, can more exclusively focus on the academic basics, and the scattered and increasing humanistic and liberal expectations of conventional schools are negative [p. 48]; different parents mention physical and sexual and drug safety [p. 57-58, 60, 63]. “The central issue around which the prevalent social movements of the era rally is individuals’ right [sic] to defend particular worldviews to which they are committed ..... In many ways, the home school movement has goals similar to other social movements. The family, an important site of private life, stands in contrast to public institutions, and it offers individuals a protective environment in which to maintain and propagate their particular values and beliefs” [p.101]. “The home school movement, perhaps to an extent greater than other movements of the era, exemplifies the principles of individualism and self-reliance, and the attempt to live in a way that is consistent with one’s worldview. ..... [In one sense,] the home school movement acts in response to the ‘colonization’ of the family by institutional forms such as public education. It protects family values and beliefs from state intrusion while simultaneously expanding the personal rights of parents by permitting them to adopt freely chosen lifestyles” [p. 102].) .
Mayberry, Maralee, Ray, Brian D., & Knowles, J. Gary 1992 Political and religious characteristics of home school parents: Results of an ongoing study in four western states. Home School Researcher, 8(1), 1-8. research, home education, demographics, religion, politics, reasons Presents data from Washington State and gives interpretation.
Mazama, Ama 2016 African American homeschooling practices: Empirical evidence. Theory and Research in Education, 14(1), 26-44. homeschooling, minorities, black, African American, reasons, motivations, pedagogical practices Same as Mazama, Ama. (2015). African American homeschooling practices: Empirical evidence. Theory and Research in Education, published online November 27, 2015. “Abstract. Despite a significant increase in scholarly interest for homeschooling, some of its most critical aspects, such as instructional daily practices, remain grossly understudied. This essay thus seeks to fill that void by presenting empirical evidence regarding the homeschooling practices of a specific group, African Americans. Most specifically, the purpose of this essay is to answer the following questions: Who teaches Black homeschooled children? How are they taught? And, what are they taught? What emerges is that while African American homeschooling practices vary widely based on parents’ teaching and learning philosophies and ultimate objective, a common tendency is the implementation of a curriculum inclusive of African/African American history and culture. Moreover, contrary to previous claims, this study does not lend credence to the notion that Black homeschooling is overly structured and rigid.”
Mazama, Ama; & and Garvey, Musumunu 2014 African Americans and homeschooling: Motivations, opportunities, and challenges. New York, Routledge, 144 pp.
Mazama, Ama; & Lundy, Garvey 2012, August 26 African American homeschooling as racial protectionism. Journal of Black Studies, 43(7) 723–748. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0021934712457042. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021934712457042 homeschooling, home education, research, black, African American, racism, agency “Abstract: Academic interest in homeschooling has increased over the past decade, as what was once perceived as a marginal development has, in fact, turned into a significant and growing phenomenon. There has been, in recent years, a noticeable surge in African American involvement in the homeschooling movement as well. However, there continues to be a general paucity of research on the motivations of homeschooling Black parents. It is the purpose of this article, using an Afrocentric lens, (a) to explore one of the main reasons African Americans increasingly choose to educate their children at home, namely, their strong desire to protect their children from the ill effects of school-related racism; (b) to provide a historical and philosophical contextualization of the African American experience with racism in schools; and (c) to present empirical evidence regarding African American motivations for Homeschooling” (p. 723).
Mazama, Ama; & Lundy, Garvey 2013, July 29, online African American homeschooling and the quest for a quality education. Education and Urban Society, XX(X) 1–22 (DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124513495273). https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124513495273 homeschooling, home education, black, African American, motivations, reasons, research “Abstract. Academic interest in homeschooling has increased over the last decade, as what was once perceived as a marginal development, has, in fact, turned into a significant and growing phenomenon. There has been, in recent years, a noticeable surge in African American involvement in the homeschooling movement as well. However, there continues to be a general paucity of research on the motivations of homeschooling Black parents. It is the purpose of this essay (a) to present empirical evidence regarding African American motivations for homeschooling; and (b) to explore in depth one of the main reasons why African Americans increasingly choose to educate their children at home, namely, African American discontent with the poor quality of the education available in American schools, both public and private. While discontent with the quality of education is also commonly cited by other ethnic groups, the African American definition of a satisfactory education stands out, as it is articulated within the context of a racially exclusive and discriminatory society, and often includes demands for cultural and historical relevance” (p. 1).
Mazama, Ama; & Lundy, Garvey 2013, Spring African American homeschooling and the question of curricular cultural relevance. The Journal of Negro Education, 82(2), 123-138. homeschooling, home education, black, African American, Afrocentricity, Protectionists, Culturalists Abstract: “Homeschooling, and academic interest in this phenomenon, have increased tremendously over the last decade. The surge of African American involvement in the homeschool movement has also become noticeable. However, there continues to be a general paucity of research on the motivations of African American parents that choose homeschooling. In order to capture the voice of African American homeschoolers, the authors conducted seventy-four interviews in the spring and summer of 2010 in several large U.S. metropolitan areas. The findings revealed that curricular considerations play a critical part, since many African American homeschoolers believe that a Eurocentric curriculum is bound to gravely interfere with their children 's self-esteem and sense of purpose” (p. 123).) .
McAlister, Diana 1992 An investigation of the characteristics and effectiveness of home schooling. Master's (M.Ed.) Thesis, Western Washington University (I believe), Bellingham WA. Basically a review of literature. Descriptors: achievement, socialization, social development, reasons/rationale, trends, research
McAlister, Diana, & Barnett, Mary Lou 1987 Home schooling and the high schooler. Unpublished manuscript. Written to assist home schoolers understand what is involved in receiving a G.E.D., which courses are basic to finding employment immediately after high school, what the requirements are to attend a community college, requirements to attend a university or 4-year college, and an explanation of college admission exams.
McAvoy, Rogers 1986, October Home-Bound Schools: An Alternative for Rural Areas. Paper presented at the Annual Conference of the National Rural and Small School Consortium, Bellingham, WA.
McCarthy, Rockne M., Skillen, James W., & Harper, William A. 1982 Disestablishment a second time: Genuine pluralism for American schools. Grand Rapids, MI: Christian University Press of William B. Eerdmans Publishing Co. education, public, private, philosophy, religion, taxation, history, reform Advocates disestablishing the state’s secular religion from being the one that is unequally promoted and protected by making only state schools the recipients of tax moneys. Makes case that today’s public schools really are sectarian and that private or “sectarian” schools may be tax funded without making society more culturally fragmented, and maybe it would be less so than it is today. Describes the consociational democracy of some European countries as a possibility of what might help solve educational problems of choice and equity in America. Excellent case for treating all parents and schools, regardless of to which type of school they choose to send their children or that the school is in an equitable and just manner and not giving unfair support to “public” schools.
McCarthy, Rockne, Oppewal, Donald, Peterson, Walfred, & Spykman, Gordon 1981 Society, state, and schools: A case for structural and confessional pluralism. Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Co. education, public, state, history, philosophy, private, taxation Explains and critiques in chapter 2 the three alternative social philosophies of individualism, collectivism, and pluralism. Explains the structural and confessional pluralism of Calvinism [p. 38-40]. Religious arguments for plurality in education. Says that a clean line of separation between private and public schools is a very modern development [p. 79]. Thomas “Jefferson’s thought, therefore, revealed a tension between his theoretical commitment to individualism and his pragmatic bent toward collectivism. ..... Thus the individualist must take some action to guarantee order in society. ..... Jefferson did not take a direct route to the state [guaranteeing order]. He turned instead to the school as the primary institution to guarantee the order and freedom he desired in society. In Jefferson’s thought the school gave up its autonomy to the state and became little more than a department of the state. And Jefferson saw nothing wrong with indoctrinating students into a philosophy of government as long as it corresponded to his understanding of orthodoxy. [new paragraph] ... Benjamin Rush ... saw that Jefferson’s program was but another form of sectarianism. ..... [but] he [Rush] followed the same route into pragmatic collectivism that Jefferson followed” [p. 85]. “He turned to public schools as an ideal instrument for Americanizing the new arrivals [to the country]. He unabashedly predicted that ‘our schools of learning, by producing one general and uniform system of educator, will render the mass of the people more homogeneous and thereby fit them more easily for uniform and peaceable government’” [p. 86]. Regarding Horace Mann, in the mid-1800s, “Mann was successful in that he convinced enough people that a system of public schools which championed a supposedly nonsectarian religion was essential to the well-being of the social, economic, and political order of the state” [p. 86]. “What Jefferson was not able to accomplish for public education in Virginia in the 1780’s and ‘90’s, Mann was able to accomplish in Massachusetts in the 1830’s and ‘40’s” [p. 87].
McCarty, Nadine 1992 Home schooling practices of selected families in northern San Luis Obispo [California] County. Paper presented to Dr. Palmer for graduate course in education, July 1992. home education research, motivation, rationale, pedagogy, curriculum Focuses on motivations of parents for home schooling, type of curricula used, instructional methods, instructional schedules, and advantages and disadvantages of home schooling. Uses personal interviews with very small sample of five home school families.
McCloskey, H. 1964 Consensus and ideology in American politics. American Political Science Review, 58, 361-382. Policy making).
McCluskey, Neal 2007, January 23 Why we fight: How public schools cause social conflict (Policy Analysis No. 587). Washington, DC: Cato Institute. Also retrieved January 15, 2009 from http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa587.pdf. http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa587.pdf public school, private school, educational choice, reform, voucher, civic education, philosophy, curriculum Conflict over fundamental values, “… whether over intelligent design, dress codes, controversial school books, or sundry other divisive topics” [p. 15] is common and consistent in U.S. public schools. Regarding conflict during the 2005-2006 school year, for which authors provides much documentation, he writes: “This [conflict] was not an aberration. American history is littered with an endless series of such conflicts, and the problem has only grown worse as public school systems have become more centralized and the [p. 15 ends] nation more diverse. These conflicts are not only inescapable under our monolithic system of official schools, they are actually caused by it. Different cultural, ethnic, and religious groups have no choice but to enter the political melee if they want to see their values taught and desires met by the public schools. So is American education doomed to eternal acrimony? Thankfully, it doesn’t have to be. If public education were driven by free parental choice, it could escape the Balkanizing battles that plague our current system, because individual parents could choose schools that comport with their values, and there would be no need to fight over public schools for which all must pay, but only the most politically powerful can control. And there is an upside to choice even beyond unity and social cohesion. Current research shows that private schools do a significantly better job of teaching kids to become good, active, knowledgeable, and tolerant citizens than do the public schools” [p. 16]. “The importance of freedom to democracy goes beyond social and economic integration, however. Freedom’s importance is, in fact, visible in civic education itself, where we find that students in private schools demonstrate both greater civic knowledge and greater tolerance for others than public school students” [p. 14] and gives reference. “In addition to creating better democratic citizens, private schools tend to be better racially integrated, a fact demonstrated best in school lunchrooms, where students exhibit truly voluntary integration” [p. 14] and provides reference.
McCluskey, Neal 2008, December 15 Unbearable burden? Living and paying student loans as a first-year teacher (Policy Analysis No. 629). Washington, DC: Cato Institute. Also retrieved 1/15/09 from http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/PA629.pdf. http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/PA629.pdf public school, teacher pay salary, political “Though overall salary data are useful, especially for understanding teachers’ basic pay, many researchers argue that it is not a full portrayal of teachers’ monetary compensation, in large part because it fails to account for actual time worked. With school calendars featuring many built-in breaks—including roughly two-and-a-half months in the summer—and school days averaging around only 6.5 hours in length, it is reasonable to suspect that teachers work fewer hours for their salaries than other professionals. Recent analyses of Bureau of Labor Statistics data taken from the National Compensation Survey confirm this suspicion. Looking at 2001 data, economist Richard Vedder compared teachers’ hourly earnings to those of numerous other professionals and found that teachers out-earned architects, mechanical engineers, biological and life scientists, and several other professionals. In 2000, the average hourly wage for a job defined as a “professional specialty” by the BLS was $27.49, reports Vedder, while the average wage for elementary school teachers was $28.79, secondary school teachers $29.14, and special education teachers $29.97.8 Using 2005 NCS data, the Manhattan Institute’s Jay Greene and Marcus Winters examined hourly teacher pay and arrived at similar findings. They discovered that the average public school teacher made $34.06 per-hour in 2005, 11 percent more than the average professional specialty and technical worker” [p. 3].
McCoy, Dana Charles; Yoshikawa, Hirokazu; & Kathleen M. Ziol-Guest, Kathleen M. 2017 Impacts of Early Childhood Education on Medium- and Long-Term Educational Outcomes. Educational Researcher 46(8), 474-487. Retrieved December 11, 2017 from http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.3102/0013189X17737739 http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.3102/0013189X17737739 early childhood education, effects, Head Start “Abstract: Despite calls to expand early childhood education (ECE) in the United States, questions remain regarding its medium- and long-term impacts on educational outcomes. We use meta-analysis of 22 high-quality experimental and quasi-experimental studies conducted between 1960 and 2016 to find that on average, participation in ECE leads to statistically significant reductions in special education placement (d = 0.33 SD, 8.1 percentage points) and grade retention (d = 0.26 SD, 8.3 percentage points) and increases in high school graduation rates (d = 0.24 SD, 11.4 percentage points). These results support ECE’s utility for reducing education-related expenditures and promoting child well-being.” These findings appear to be the case for children from some socioeconomic groups or classes (e.g., low-income).
McCoy, Ellen 1983, April Is school necessary? Parents, 57, 80.
McCracken, Chelsea, & Coleman, Rachel 2020 A meaningful measure of homeschool academic achievement: Statistical analysis of standardized test performance in Alaska public correspondence schools. Other Education: The Journal of Educational Alternatives, 9(1), 207-252. Retrieved September 8, 2020 from https://www.othereducation.org/index.php/OE/article/view/258 https://www.othereducation.org/index.php/OE/article/view/258 Alaska, homeschooling, correspondence schools, government schools, public schools, school at home, statistics, academic achievement This is not a study of homeschool academic achievement despite the title’s name and words. It is a study of government/state-run schooling at home. “Abstract. Non-traditional education has a long history in Alaska, where publicly-funded correspondence programs educate a large portion of the state’s children. Publicly-available data from these correspondence schools allows a state-wide comparison between the standardized test scores of traditional and correspondence students. We found that there was no overall difference between the scores of traditional and correspondence students. However, correspondence students who were Caucasian, non-disabled, and non-economically disadvantaged scored significantly lower than their counterparts in traditional school, while correspondence students of color, disabled correspondence students, and low-income correspondence students scored significantly higher than their peers in traditional school. Correspondence students in nearly every demographic category scored significantly lower than traditional students in math. We argue that these findings have important implications for homeschooling policy” (p. 188). The authors compared the “pass rates” on two different tests between government correspondence school students and government conventional (traditional) school students. First, they found that the overall SBA pass rates of government correspondence students were not statistically significantly different from those of government conventional school students. A more fine-tuned analysis, however, did find some differences. Second, government school “… correspondence students were significantly more likely to pass overall” (i.e., grade levels 10 to 12, overall) on the SGQE test than were government conventional school students (p. 206). McCracken and Coleman have provided an engaging look at the relative academic success of two types of public school students in Alaska. One group is engaged in government-run correspondence schooling and the other is in conventional institutional schools. Their study will likely add to the research base and debate surrounding whether students in conventional public institutional schools or public distance, virtual, blended, online, or correspondence schools are better off academically (Miron, Shank, & Davidson, 2018; Vasquez & Serianni, 2017). It is unusual and convoluted that the author’s main empirical and analytical focus throughout the study was comparing the academic achievement of two types of public/government school students but stated that doing so is “… with the purpose of contributing to the literature on the academic outcomes of homeschooling” (p. 191). In their discussion section, McCracken and Coleman spent considerable space comparing the findings of their study that compared the pass rates of government-controlled public correspondence school and government-controlled conventional school students to research findings on homeschooling. However, as the terms they use – “Alaska correspondence students,” “traditional school,” “correspondence education in Alaska,” and “correspondence programs like Alaska’s” – show, they did not study homeschool students as defined and considered by scholars, policymakers, lawmakers (including Alaska’s), and the general public for the past roughly 40 years.
McCubbin, Stephen 1985 The world-wide education service. Media in Education and Development, 18(2), 79-81.
McCulloch, Donald S., Slocum, Sarah, Kolegue, Cadia, & Montaudo, Sarah 2006, Fall Cynicism, trust, and internal-external locus of control among home educated students. Academic Leadership: The Online Journal, 4(4) http://www.academicleadership.org/articles/show/117/ http://www.academicleadership.org/emprical_research/Cynicism_Trust_and_Internal-External_Locus_of_Control_Among_Home_Educated_Students_printer.shtml home education, research, public school, private school, socialization, social development, cynicism, trust, locus of control, adult age, adults, college age, graduates, causal-comparative [peer-reviewed]. Retrieved 2/20/07 online http://www.academicleadership.org/articles/show/117/. Also retrieved 12/21/07 from http://www.academicleadership.org/emprical_research/Cynicism_Trust_and_Internal-External_Locus_of_Control_Among_Home_Educated_Students_printer.shtml. Used a quasi-experimental causal-comparative design to study one group of adults who were home educated and another who were “… traditionally schooled either in public or private schooling. . . . . .Ninety-one students between the ages of 15 and 21 were administered three scales:  a Cynicism scale (Moore, 1999), the Trust in People scale (Survey Research Center, 1969), and the Adult Nowicki-Strickland Internal-External Control Scale (Nowicki & Duke, 1974). . . . . . It was hypothesized that there would be a difference in groups on the measure of cynicism. Neither the total score nor the three subscales of this measure produced significant between group differences.  In fact, the averages for the total scale of cynicism were essentially identical (home-educated group, mean = 2.58; traditional group, mean = 2.57).  The groups were also very similar on strength of religious commitment, this makes the significant finding that home educated students have more trust in people all the more interesting.  Religion and cynicism cannot be used to explain this difference.  Something about the home-education experience may engender greater trust in people when compared to an equally religious traditionally schooled group. That home-education may be related in general to less cynicism is supported by this study.  . . . . . There was a significant negative correlation between years of home education and cynicism. This is supportive of a general hypothesis that more a person is educated at home, the less cynicism will be endorsed on this scale. Years of home-education did not correlate with any other scale including the trust scale.”
McCulloch, Donald S.; Savage, Alexandra; Schmala, Liz 2013 Admission officers’ impressions of homeschooled applicants in evangelical and nonevangelical colleges and universities. Christian Higher Education, 12(3), 215-224. http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/15363759.2011.598380 homeschooling, research, college, college admissions, opinion, attitude, Christian, religion, academic achievement, socialization Respondents impressions or opinions were that homeschooled applicants to college were “… below average socially and above average academically” p. 220. “A majority of admission officers working at CCCU [Council for Christian Colleges & Universities] schools selected the option that homeschooled applicants are “somewhat poorly adjusted socially,” while a majority of admission officers working at non-CCCU schools selected the option that homeschooled applicants are “on average similar to other students” …” (p. 221). However, the longer a person was an admissions officer, the less he/she thought the home educated were socially less skilled. “There was a significant relationship between years as an admission officer and disavowal of the socially awkward stereotype (r = .280, p < .01). Years as an admission officer did not predict any particular attitude related to the academic preparedness of homeschooled applicants, however. In summary, the longer an individual had been an admission officer, the less they endorsed the homeschooled stereotype” (p. 222). “Abstract: Impressions of admission officers toward homeschooled applicants were examined. Specifically, this study sought to ascertain whether the perceptions of admission officers adhered to the common stereotype that homeschoolers are brighter and yet socially less well-adjusted than average. The responses of 121 admission officers were analyzed across several variables to determine which were associated with the homeschooler stereotype. The variables explored were politically conservative versus liberal, level of religious commitment, working or not working at a Christian college or university, size of institution, and years of employment as an admission officer. Chi-square analyses revealed that admission officers working at member institutions of the Council for Christian College & Universities (CCCU) were found to be more likely to view homeschooled applicants as less socially adjusted than admission officers not working at member institutions of the CCCU. Correlational analyses indicated that the more politically conservative admission officers were, the more likely they were to view homeschooled applicants as academically superior, more likely to consider homeschooling their own children, and more likely to perceive their institution to be homeschooler friendly. Religious attitudes and size of insitution were not predictive. Years as admission officer tended to predict not endorsing the homeschooler stereotype. Potential explanations of the findings are discussed, including the possibility of confirmation bias. Some of the findings are counter-intuitive. Practical implications for those working as admission officers in Christian higher education are also presented” (p. 215). Retrieved 7/8/13 from http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/15363759.2011.598380.
McCurdy, Harold G. 1960 The childhood pattern of genius. Horizon, 2(5), 33-38. Lists three ingredients that are correlated to genius.
McCurdy, Jack 1985 Choices in schools: What's ahead and what to do. Arlington, VA: National School Public Relations Association, 57 p. One chapter on home education, with a fairly balanced perspective. Refers to home education as perhaps fastest growing form of alternative education.
McDannell, Colleen 1994 [or 1995] Creating the Christian home: Home schooling in contemporary America. In David Chidester & Edward T. Linenthal (Eds.), Sacred space in America. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press. research, home education, history, sociology Provides clear insights about the motivations and lives of Christian home educators; discusses how these people contemplate making their lives consistent with biblical teaching; this non-Christian historian asks questions that reflective Christian home educators must deal with.
McDonald, Kerry 2019 Unschooled: Raising curious, well-educated children outside the conventional classroom. Chicago, IL: Chicago Review Press Incorporated.
McDonald, Kerry 2020 Homeschooling more than doubles during the pandemic: State-level data show just how dramatic the surge in homeschooling has been. Retrieved December 29, 2020 from https://fee.org/articles/homeschooling-more-than-doubles-during-the-pandemic/ https://fee.org/articles/homeschooling-more-than-doubles-during-the-pandemic/ homeschooling, home education, growth, population size “Prior to the pandemic and related school closures last spring, there were just under two million homeschoolers in the US, representing about 3.4 percent of the total K-12 school-age population. According to recent polling by Education Week, that percentage has more than doubled to nine percent this fall, or nearly five million homeschoolers. This estimate mirrors related polling from Gallup in August suggesting that 10 percent of US students would be homeschooled this year.”
McDonald, Kerry 2020, December 30 Looking back on a year of mass homeschooling. Retrieved December 30, 2020 from https://www.forbes.com/sites/kerrymcdonald/2021/12/30/looking-back-on-a-year-of-mass-homeschooling/?sh=142b4bb725b2 https://www.forbes.com/sites/kerrymcdonald/2021/12/30/looking-back-on-a-year-of-mass-homeschooling/?sh=142b4bb725b2 homeschooling, home education, Covid-19, population size, growth “In March, I published an article here about the world’s homeschooling moment, noting that hundreds of millions of students worldwide were suddenly displaced from their classrooms and learning at home due to the Covid-19 response. At its peak, that number reached nearly 1.3 billion children learning at home, with varying degrees of remote connection to their school or district.” “In November, an Education Week survey found that homeschooling had swelled to nine percent of the US K-12 school-age population, or nearly five million students. This represents a dramatic jump from pre-pandemic homeschooling levels, when the number of homeschooled students numbered just under two million students, or about 3.4 percent of the K-12 population. According to the survey, many of the families choosing independent homeschooling this year are lower income, suggesting that they may not be able to afford private schooling options but may be dissatisfied with their district school and want something better.” “While most parents and students will be eager to return to their ordinary schooldays once the pandemic ends, the school shutdowns have inspired many families to take a closer look at their children’s education and to consider schooling alternatives. Perhaps they had been curious about homeschooling but lacked the catalyst to give it a try until now. Perhaps their children are learning more outside of a conventional classroom and appreciate greater educational freedom and personalization. Perhaps they have been pleasantly surprised by the panoply of high-quality, online learning resources available to them. Perhaps more flexible work schedules make more flexible learning options more feasible. This year, millions of new homeschoolers have discovered that learning without schooling is not only possible but preferable. For many of them, pandemic homeschooling may well become a permanent and positive educational change.”
McDonald, Kerry 2021 New census data show homeschooling tripled during the pandemic—and one key group is driving the surge. Retrieved September 6, 2021 from https://fee.org/articles/us-census-homeschooling-triples-diversifies-during-pandemic-response/ https://fee.org/articles/us-census-homeschooling-triples-diversifies-during-pandemic-response/ homeschooling, population size
McDow, Jennie 2023 Formerly homeschooled students' perceptions of their current life satisfaction. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Marymount University. https://orcid.org/0009-0003-3389-7539 https://orcid.org/0009-0003-3389-7539 adult, grown up, life satisfaction, socialization ) ?
McDowell, , Susan A. 2002 Home schooling as a key factor in a political election: A case study. Home School Researcher, 15(2), 15-21.
McDowell, Olivia Susan Atkisson 1998, May Home sweet school: The perceived impact of home schooling on the family in general and the mother-teacher in particular. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Peabody College of Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN. research, qualitative, quantitative, home education, mothers, women, women’s issues, gender role/roles, family impact Purpose “... was to determine the perceptions of the mother-teacher in home schooling families as to the impact of the home schooling process on the family in general, and on the mother-teacher in particular” [p. 2]. Studies 107 home schooling mothers for the quantitative portion of the study; studies 9 mothers for the qualitative and interview portion; researcher also observes 6 “home schooling events.” Mentions racial issues in that mothers said racial tensions existed in the schools and made them less than the best place for children to be, even though they, personally were not prejudiced (p. 286, 311). Concludes: “(a) mother-teachers perceive home schooling to have a positive impact on both their families and themselves, with some mother-teachers indicating that home schooling acts as a stress-reducing educational alternative; (b) the element of social integration which home schooling offers can be empowering to the mother-teacher; (c) there is no statistically significant difference in mother-teacher response by reason given for home schooling, income level, number of children home schooled, or number of years spent home schooling; (d) the major stressors in the lives of mother-teachers include housework, and concerns about their children learning what they need to be learning; and (e) those mother-teachers who are “forced” into home schooling experience the process in a more negative way than do those who would be considered “traditional” home schoolers” [abstract]. “In undertaking home schooling, I believe that home schooling mother-teachers are simply taking themselves out of the sometimes tense, often antagonistic school-community equation. They are taking for themselves that which was not freely offered, that is, power, governance, and control as concerns important aspects of their children’s education. In taking charge, however, mother-teachers not only assume control of their children’s education, but they also assume a new level of control in their own lives, as home schooling affords them the opportunity to more fully integrate and implement into their lives their personal values, norms, and beliefs about either roles and the appropriate enactment of said roles. In sum, then, the element of social integration w+hich home schooling can offer can be an extraordinarily empowering one to the mother-teacher. This, in combination with the stress-reducing aspects of home schooling ..., helps to explain — if only in part — the surprisingly consistent and overwhelmingly positive response from mother-teachers as regards home schooling and its impact” [p. 313-314]. “Classic home schoolers” are “... those who choose home schooling as their educational alternative, and who do not work full-time outside the home ...” and they “... apparently experience home schooling differently and in a more positive manner than do ‘pseudo’ home schoolers (those who feel `forced’ into home schooling, and who continue to work on a full-time basis outside the home)” [p. 302]. “Many ‘classic’ home schoolers perceive home schooling to have a positive impact on their families, especially in terms of (a) family flexibility, (b) socialization, (c) dealing with diagnosed attention deficit order [sic], and (d) the problems confronted in the public/private schools, including problematic racial tensions” [p. 303].
McDowell, Susan A. 1999 The perceived impact of home schooling on the family in general and the mother-teacher in particular: The quantitative study. Home School Researcher, 13(4), 1-21. home education, research, family, mother, women
McDowell, Susan A. 2000 The home schooling mother-teacher: Toward a theory of social integration. Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 187-206.
McDowell, Susan A. 2001 Home schooling as a key factor in a political election: A case study. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 10-14, 2001, Seattle, Washington. home education, politics, political candidates, civic involvement “Despite the growing acceptance of home schooling as an educational alternative, there are still certain segments of the population around the country for whom home schooling is something of a suspicious anomaly. Unfortunately for the home schooling political candidate who is the subject of this case study, such a segment made up enough of the voter base in his district to turn the tide against him in two political elections against the same opponent” [p. 4]. “Perhaps the most interesting aspect of this case study is the fact that the home schooling movement – despite its well-publicized victories in various legal battles, its steadily growing acceptance by the public at large, its powerful and effective lobbying group in Congress, and its national headlines for outstanding academic achievement – continues to be considered an unhappy “oddity” in some communities. Clearly, home schooling as an educational choice does not in and of itself sound the “death knell” for political aspirations, as many of the elected officials in Congress choose to home school their children.1 Obviously, however, the successful home schooling politician must have a constituency both receptive to and accepting of his or her educational choice” [p. 14].”
McDowell, Susan A. 2004 But what about socialization? Answering the perpetual home schooling question. Nashville, TN: Philodeus Press. home education, research, socialization Reviews research on the subject of the socialization and psychological and emotional devleopment of persons who are home educated. Concludes that they are doing well.
McDowell, Susan A., & Ray, Brian D. 2000 The home education movement in context, practice, and theory: Editors’ introduction [to special issue]. Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 1-7.
McDowell, Susan A., & Ray, Brian D. (Eds.) 2000 The home education movement in context, practice, and theory [Special issue]. Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 300 pp.
McDowell, Susan A., & Ray, Brian D. (Eds.) 2000 The home education movement in context, practice, and theory: Editors’ introduction [Special double issue]. Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 1-7.
McDowell, Susan A., Sanchez, Annette R., & Jones, Susan S. 1999 Participation and perception: Looking at home schooling through a multicultural lens. A paper presented on at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, April 19-23, 1999. home education, research, college students, attitudes, minorities, race Study college students and find, among other things, “Interestingly enough, African Americans (13.2%) were more than twice as likely as Caucasians (4.7%) to indicate that they would home school their children in the future, and almost twoice as likely (African Americans, 32.1%, Caucasians, 17.2%) to indicate that they might home schoo in the future” [p. 29].
McDowell, Susan A., Sanchez, Annette R., & Jones, Susan S. 2000 Participation and perception: Looking at home schooling through a multicultural lens. Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 124-146.
McElroy, Wendy 2002, February Can a feminist homeschool her children? Ideas on Liberty, 52(2), 8-11. homeschool, home education, feminism, sociology, philosophy “For this school of feminism [i.e., individualist feminism], freedom means having every peaceful choice possible and taking personal responsibility for all your actions. In this framework, on woman’s decision to stay at home [and homeschool] is not politically better or worse than another woman’s choice to become a CEO. Both are personal matters. Both express the core of true feminism: choice [p. 10].
McEntire, T. Wayne 2005 Religious outcomes in conventionally schooled and home schooled youth. Home School Researcher, 16(2), 13-18. home education, research, religion, religiosity, social behavior, socialization, peer, emotional, psychological, causal-comparative, matched sample close to matched-pair, peer-reviewed “The purpose of this study was to determine if outcomes of home educated students were commensurate with the religious objectives given by many as reason for choosing home-based education [p. 13].” Statistically significant differences on the Daily Challenges Inventory (DCI) were found between the two groups of students. “The total number of subjects in the conventionally schooled group was 228 and the total number in the home schooled group was 55. The total number of subjects included in the study was 283” (p. 14). “The population of this study was youth, grades 7-12, who attended Baptist General Convention of Texas (BGCT) churches with students in both home based and conventionally based educational settings” (p. 10). “Overall, DCI results support the supposition that home school parents are succeeding at influencing their children in terms of moral and religious attitudes and behaviors. Particularly, the home schooled group was found to be less likely to participate in behaviors that are potentially harmful. In terms of attitude and disposition, home school students seem to find life to have less tension, but do not seem to feel as upbeat and encouraged” (p. 15). “The home schooled group was significantly less likely to watch MTV; use drugs; lie to a parent, teacher, or other older person; attempt suicide; drink enough alcohol to be legally drunk; or gamble. Home schoolers were also significantly less likely to describe themselves as too busy, stressed out, angry with life, confused, or always tired. Conventionally schooled youth were significantly more likely to describe themselves as upbeat, encouraged, and seeking answers” [p. 14]. The results “support the supposition that home school parents are succeeding at influencing their children in terms of moral and religious attitudes and behaviors. Particularly, the home schooled group was found to be less likely to participate in behaviors that are potentially harmful. In terms of attitude and disposition, home school students seem to find life to have less tension, but do not seem to feel as upbeat and encouraged” [p. 15]. Causal-comparative, matched sample, close to matched-pair. Peer-reviewed.
McEntire, Thomas Wayne 2003 A study of the difference in religious outcomes between Baptist General Convention of Texas youth who are conventionally schooled and those educated at home. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, Ft. Worth, Texas. home education, research, worldview, behavior, sex, sexuality, beliefs, religion, religiosity, private school “Problem: The problem of this study was to determine the difference in Integrated Faith Maturity Scale scores and Daily Challenges Inventory percentages between youth from Baptist General Convention of Texas churches who are home schooled, and those who are conventionally schooled. PROCEDURES: The Faith Maturity Scale and the Daily Challenges Inventory were administered to youth in Baptist General Convention of Texas churches that have students in both home based [i.e., currently homeschooled] and conventionally based [i.e., at a conventional day school, either public or non-public] educational settings. A total of 283 usable surveys were scored with 228 being conventionally schooled and 55 having had at least some years of home schooling. A t-test for independent samples was used to measure differences in Faith Maturity Scale scores and one sample t-tests were used to find differences between Daily Challenges Inventory percentages across the two groups. FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS: The t-test for independent samples found no significant difference in any measures related to the Faith Maturity Scale (p = .05) . The one sample t-test revealed significant difference on fourteen items of the Daily Challenges Inventory. The home schooled group was significantly less likely to watch MTV, use drugs, lie to a parent, teacher, or other older person, attempt suicide, drink enough alcohol to be legally drunk, or gamble with their money (p = .05). Home schoolers were also significantly less likely to describe themselves as too busy, stressed out, angry with life, confused, or always tired (p = .05) . Conventionally schooled youth were significantly more likely to describe themselves as upbeat, encouraged, and seeking answers (p=.05). Gender was a significant factor in 11 DCI items with females less likely to watch an X-rated movie, view a pornographic magazine, physically try to hurt someone, or gamble (p = .05) . Females were significantly more likely to describe themselves as too busy, stressed out, always tired, and temperamental (p = .05) . Females were also significantly more likely to describe themselves as being upbeat and respected by others while being significantly less likely to mistrust people (p = .05)” (Abstract). Did some analyses according to the number of years students were homeschooled or conventionally schooled. “This study once again validates the choice of home schooling for parents who choose this avenue of involvement with their children. ..... Home school students showed to be significantly less likely to participate in 6 of the 14 undesirable behavioral items” [p. 87]. “The researcher offers the following possible explanations for the success of home school parents in mitigating against these harmful behaviors. 1. Home school parents influence their children. [p. 93] ..... Parents are afforded an extended time and place for this influence in home schooling. This includes opportunity to weave moral precepts in the curriculum and increased time for students to imitate adult behaviors. Even a family’s eating meals together on a regular basis has shown to help teens avoid risks such as drug use, sexual activity, violence, and suicide attempts. 2. Home schools provide surroundings conducive to moral restraint. They afford less peer pressure and an environment not hostile to Christians and Christianity [p. 94]. ..... 3. Home school families are more likely to have two parents in the home. ..... Adolescents from single parent families engage in risky behaviors at higher rates. 4. Home schooling parents may make more accurate assessment of the propensity of their students to do wrong and may be better prepared to take pro-active measures” [p. 95].) .
McGee, Jerry C. 1987, July 20 Compulsory education: An overview of the law. (ERIC Document Reproduction No. ED285249). Compulsory Education, Court Litigation, Home Schooling, School Attendance Legislation, School Law An historical summary concerning the shift from court cases which protect select groups' rights to teach outside the public school to those that grant the same rights to individuals.
McGee, Jerry C. 1988 Compulsory attendance vs. home instruction. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED298629). Compliance A history of prominent court cases concerning the rights of parents to control the education of their children. Legal), Compulsory Education, Court Litigation, Home Schooling, School Attendance Legislation.
McGhehey, M. A., Ed 1982 School law in changing times. Topeka, Kansas: National Organization on Legal Problems of Education. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED215400.) Court Litigation, Educational Legislation, School Law
McGraw, Ronald K. 1989 Selected aspects of home-schooling as reported by home-schooling parents and reported with perceptions of Indiana public school superintendents and principals of home-schooling in Indiana. Doctoral dissertation (Ed.D.), Ball State University, Muncie, IN, 229pp., Adviser: Thelbert L. Drake. Dissertation Abstracts International, 50(9), 2736A. (Order No. DA9003623) home education, public schools, cooperation, attitudes Six conclusions; public school principals and superintendents have negative perception of academic, instruction, and socialization quality in home schools; principals more willing to allow home-school families access to non-classroom activities than classroom; superintendents willing to allow home-school families access to participate in either classroom or non-classroom activities; less than 15% of families educating children at home use public school services while home schooling, however, over 85% might use public school services if made available.
McGrew, Ken 2011, June A review of class-based theories of student resistance in education: Mapping the origins and influence of Learning to Labor by Paul Willis. Review of Educational Research, 81(2), 234-266. student resistance, critical theory, Marxism, neo-Marxism "The resistance theory attributed to Willis is associated with an area of scholarship primarily referred to, though also known by a number of aliases, as critical theory (Anderson, 1989; Arnot, 2004; MacLeod, 1987/1995; McGrew, 2008; Morrow & Torres, 1995; Rogers, Malancharuvil-Berkes, Mosley, Hui, & Joseph, 2005). Contemporary critical theory emerges from a cluster of traditions within scholarship and activism that despite all being generally associated with the political Left in a variety of historical and national contexts often represented competing theoretical perspectives. Among the traditions that contributed to contemporary critical theory are Marxism; neo-Marxist theories such as those emerging with the Frankfurt School and the London Institute of Education; the focus on culture, relative autonomy, and hidden forms of power emerging with the Birmingham School and the New Sociology of School Knowledge; critical pedagogy; critical theories of race and gender; and, as I argue, the largely unacknowledged contributions of the Chicago School of subcultural theory in the United States along with the U.K. Manchester studies. Though sharing a name, differences of perspective between scholars in these associated traditions continue, with critical theorists unified around a set of assumptions and values more than a unified theory (Carspecken, 1996; Kincheloe & McLaren, 2005). Most of these traditions, however, do share a common ancestry to Karl Marx" (p. 235). Author gives more on critical theory.
McGroder, Sharon M 1990, March 29 Head Start: What do we know about what works. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation. http://aspe.hhs.gov/daltcp/reports/headstar.pdf http://aspe.hhs.gov/daltcp/reports/headstar.htm early childhood education, Head Start, compulsory school age, research, academic achievement Retrieved 2/23/07 online http://aspe.hhs.gov/daltcp/reports/headstar.pdf (also available 2/23/07 online http://aspe.hhs.gov/daltcp/reports/headstar.htm). “Path to-the Future: Long-term Effects of Head” [p. 3] . . . . . Results indicate that Head Start children more often avoided serious school problems, were less frequently retained in grade from kindergarten through sixth grade, had better attendance rates and lower attrition than non-Head Start children. Head Start children performed slightly (but non-significantly) better on achievement tests than their non-Head Start peers up to third grade, but there was no difference on achievement test scores from third to sixth grade (Copple, Cline, & Smith, 1987)” (p. 4). “Program Model Effects Study This 1987 study compared the relative effects on parents and children of three different Head Start delivery models (center-based, home-based, and a combination of center and home-based) of a grantee in rural Pennsylvania. Outcomes were measured from the time children were enrolled in Head Start through kindergarten. No difference was found in children's cognitive development across the three delivery models. Parents enrolled in the home-based model demonstrated greater gains in academic stimulation of their children; in the use of toys, games, and reading material; and in encouraging their children to learn. Home-based parents also demonstrated greater growth in knowledge of child development and parent empowerment. (University of Delaware, 1988)” (p. 4).
McGuire, Lisa Ann 2020 Exploring home educating parents’ technology choices and resulting satisfaction: A case study. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Grand Canyon University, Phoenix, Arizona. https://search.proquest.com/openview/00c61fd77e386c0ca04c066a87426856/1?pq-origsite=gscholar&cbl=18750&diss=y parents as teachers, home educating, homeschooling, home schooling, technology, pedagogy, content knowledge Retrieved June 6, 2020 from https://search.proquest.com/openview/00c61fd77e386c0ca04c066a87426856/1?pq-origsite=gscholar&cbl=18750&diss=y “The purpose of this qualitative case study was to explore how home educating parents’ technology choices and resulting satisfaction are influenced by technology, pedagogy and content knowledge. The conceptual framework used to explore this phenomenon was the technology, pedagogy, and content knowledge model. Three research questions were used in this study to address how the technology, pedagogy, and content knowledge influenced home educating parents’ technology choices, the reasons behind those choices, and their satisfaction with those choices. The purposive sample drawn from Central Midwestern homeschooling cooperatives through Facebook yielded 39 study participants. A qualitative methodology was used to address these questions to capture the realities of home education and generate thick description to understand the phenomena. The case study design created an empirical foundation using four data sources: the technological, pedagogical, and content knowledge model scale, an online questionnaire, in-depth interviews, and a focus group. The online questionnaire, in-depth interviews, and focus group were triangulated for analyses to address the three research questions. The research conclusions were that home educating parents were deliberate in their technology decisions and satisfied with how those choices impact their home education processes and outcomes” (p. v).) New ???
McHugh, Michael 1986 Home school achievement test requirements: are we on the right track? The Christian Educator, 2, p. 1-2.
McHugh, Michael Fall-Winter 1990-1991 Home school achievement test requirements: Are we on the right track? Educational Freedom, 24(1), 15-17. home education, testing
McHugh, Michael J. no date Home education: An expression of freedom. Available from the author, c/o Christian Liberty Academy, 203 E. McDonald Rd., Prospect Heights, IL 6007 0.
McIntire, Deborah, & Windham, Robert 1995 Home schooling: Answers to questions parents most often ask. Cypress, CA: Creative Teaching Press. http://www.eric.ed.gov http://www.eric.ed.gov/ homeschooling, home education, parent guide, curriculum, philosophy, United States, Canada Provides practical answers to parents’ questions, legal information, ideas on how to get started, teaching approaches, strategies, or models, how to choose curriculum, and more. “Abstract: This resource for parents draws upon research findings and the experience of home schooling parents to answer common questions about home schooling in the United States and Canada. Included is information on home schooling instructional approaches and curricula, record keeping, organizational tools, and practical tips. Chapter 1, "Initial Questions," addresses issues parents need to consider before starting home schooling, such as benefits to children, socialization opportunities, family support, and financial aspects. Chapter 2, "Organization," describes approaches to organizing the instructional day and gathering needed materials. Chapter 3, "Legal Requirements," discusses certification and recordkeeping requirements, notification/approval, and standardized testing. Chapter 4,"Curriculum and Instruction," delineates the basic concepts taught in language arts, math, social studies, and science for grades Kindergarten through 8; examines how to analyze a child's strengths and weaknesses to develop a better instructional program; discusses the textbook-driven, theme-driven, and interest-drive approaches to instruction; teaching several children simultaneously; and motivating children. Topics discussed in chapter 5, "Evaluation," include informal, diagnostic, and standardized tests; reading instruction, academic achievement of home schooled children, length of home schooling, transition to traditional school settings, common learning difficulties, and learning disabilities. Chapter 6, "Finding the Balance," discusses balancing the demands of home schooling with family life, avoiding burnout, and integrating values and beliefs in home schooling. Chapter 7, "Resources," contains reproducible forms and lists curriculum resources, government agencies, support groups, testing materials, commercial learning games, the 30-item annotated bibliography and a glossary” (retrieved 7/16/13 from http://www.eric.ed.gov).
McIntyre‐Bhatty, Karen 2008 Truancy and coercive consent: Is there an alternative? Educational Review, 60(4), 375-390. truancy, disaffection, absenteeism, coercion, alternative education, home education, homeschooling Appears to have a sound understanding of home education (homeschooling). “For truanting children with low self esteem, special educational or behavioural needs, or bullying issues, a home-based education may be a highly appropriate alternative to enforced school attendance. Given the sustained growth home education has achieved in recent years, 9 it is plausible that such practice has already become, as Belfield notes, a viable option for those dissatisfied with State schooling (Belfield 2002), and for those who wish to find an alternative to State or private provision for disaffected children” (p. 382). “Whilst home educating may be an overtly political act – based on a desire to wrest back education from the State in favour of a more personalised, individualised approach to learning – it may also be based on a desire to educate more closely in [p. 382 ends] accordance with the child’s needs, rather than those of the State. For State school students who may wish to question the axiom that school is a fundamental necessity in maintaining appropriate educational standards or social order, or who may consider their needs not to have been met by the State, protest through nonattendance is effectively considered a criminal act. Deregistration from school, in order to be home educated, is not” (383). “Given the firm link that has been established between persistent non-attendance, poor educational attainment levels, poor employment prospects and even criminality, it is unsurprising that there is such a strong focus placed on reintegrating nonattenders into State schooling. However, in the light of the lack of success of many of these schemes, and in the light of the government’s Every child matters agenda, which seeks to respect and listen more closely to the wishes of children, it would seem appropriate to refocus attention on alternative educational provision, and on home education in particular” (p. 385). “Abstract: This paper suggests that rather than criminalising or pathologising truancy as a ‘‘deviant’’ behaviour in need of either treatment or punishment, truancy should be considered as a rational enactment of dissatisfaction with State educational provision. It should be of little surprise that attempts to ‘‘solve’’ the truancy ‘‘problem’’ by recourse to coercion or legal action have proved ineffective. Indeed, such practices may exacerbate rather that ameliorate the truancy and exclusion ‘‘problem’’. While attempts to improve staff–student relations, curriculum relevance and the school environment may prove beneficial in encouraging some absentees to return to school, further attention should be paid to alternative educational provision, and in particular to raising the awareness among staff, students and parents of the legality and potential benefits home education [homeschooling] may offer for persistent school refusers.”
McKee, David, & McKee, Alison 1987, February 4 Not all home-schooling is for religious reasons [Letter to the editor]. Capital Times, Madison, WI. Reasons for home schooling include education and educational philosophy; e.g. traced back to "progressive education" of John Dewey and John Holt.
McKenna, Mary; & Willms, J. Douglas 1998 Co-operation between families and schools: What works in Canada. Research Papers in Education: Policy and Practice, 13(1), 19-41. ERIC Document No. EJ569477. http://www.eric.ed.gov http://www.eric.ed.gov/ educational policy; elementary secondary education; family school relationship; foreign countries; homeschooling, home schooling; parent participation; parent teacher cooperation; parents as teachers; partnerships in education; state government; volunteers Probably little or no focus on homeschooling. “Abstract: Examined parent-school cooperation initiatives across Canada by interviewing representatives from the provincial Departments of Education and analyzing government documents and literature. Results indicated that there has been considerable policy development and legislation leading to parent advisory committees, but movement related to parenting, volunteering, home learning, and community involvement is slower” (retrieved 7/16/13 from http://www.eric.ed.gov).
McKeon, Carolyn C. 2007 A mixed methods nested anaylsis of homeschooling styles, instructional practices, and reading methodologies. Doctoral dissertation (Ph.D.), Capella University. homeschooling, research, parental choice, homeschooling style, teaching style, reading methods, curriculum choices “Abstract: Today there is a growing concern for the academic, social, and spiritual state of the public school system in America. In many communities throughout the United States, public schools are no longer meeting the needs of its members. Parents and caregivers across the nation are seeking ways to restructure education, and provide new opportunities for their children. Among the alternative educational options, homeschooling seems to be at the forefront. The research pertaining to this educational phenomenon is growing in depth and breadth. However, there are still areas that need considerable attention. This mixed methods nested analysis will address what influences parental choice of homeschooling style, teaching style, and reading methods and curriculum choices. It is hypothesized that certain family characteristics influence a parent’s choice of homeschooling style, teaching style, and reading method or curriculum choice” (no page number; backside title page). “The findings of this study, while not necessarily generalizable to all homeschooling families nationwide because of its purposive sample, do offer significant insights into the lives of homeschoolers in America. This study shows that the dynamics are changing from what they were even a decade ago. Previous studies indicated mostly conservative Christians engage in homeschooling. In this study, the data showed that conservative Christians made up 57.3% of the respondents, while those who practice alternative religions and those who practice no religion at all made up 42.7%, which is the smallest gap reported to date in any homeschooling study between the two groups. Furthermore, the respondents of this study appear to be using a transformational approach to education rather than a transmission approach to education, which had not been previously addressed in homeschooling studies. Moreover, this study indicates that parents do evolve in their homeschooling practices and that they do not necessarily teach in a manner that reflects how they were educated as previously purposed in various homeschooling studies” (p. 139).
McKinley, Marcia J., Asaro, Jesika N., Bergin, Jamie, D’Auria, Nicole, & Gagnon, Katherine E 2007 Social skills and satisfaction with social relationships in home-schooled, private-schooled, and public-schooled children. Home School Researcher, 17(3), 1-6. http://www.nheri.org/content/view/211/27/ home education, socialization, social skills, private school, public school, cooperation, assertion, self-control Find mixed results on various subscales regarding which school background is associated with more positive scores [p. 4-5 of conclusions, Table 3 on p. 5]. “Results indicated that private-schooled children scored significantly higher than home-schooled children on measures of cooperation, assertion, self-control and overall social skills, as measured by the SSRS-Student Form. In addition, home-schooled children rated themselves as significantly lonelier than the private-schooled children on the Loneliness and Social Dissatisfaction Questionnaire, although no significant differences were found on the Peer Network and Dyadic Loneliness Scale. However, both private- and public-schooled children report experiencing significantly more conflict than home-schooled children in their closest friendships, as measured by the Friendship Qualities Scale (FQS). In addition, home-schooled children report more affective bonds with their closest friends than public-schooled do, again as measured by the FQS” (retrieved January 18, 2008 from http://www.nheri.org/content/view/211/27/).
McLaughlin, Donald; Drori, Gili; & Ross, Michael 2000, May School-level correlates of academic achievement student assessment scores in SASS public schools (NCES 2000-303). Washington, DC: United States Department of Education, Office of Education Research and Improvement. Retrieved February 8, 2012 from http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2000/2000303.pdf. http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2000/2000303.pdf academic achievement, class size, school climate, student behavior “The clearest result with respect to correlates of achievement is that average achievement scores are higher in schools with smaller class sizes. ….. The positive relation between small classes and achievement was stronger for secondary schools than for elementary schools. ….. There was limited evidence of a positive relation between teachers’ perceptions of the school’s behavior climate and achievement scores” [p. 50]. Mention school accreditation.
McManus, Una 2001, May 13-19 Home schooling graduating into the mainstream. National Catholic Register, p. 1, 7. home education, Roman Catholic, achievement, socialization, sociology Explains that homeschooling has become much more popular and socially acceptable than 10 years ago; mentions that a Catholic cardinal and William Bennett, the former U.S. Secretary of Education and a Catholic “sing the praises” of homeschooling. Addresses academic achievement and socialization.
McMillan, Barbara D. 1985 November/December Home education for gifted children. G/C/T(Gifted Child), n.41, p55-56.
McPherson, Miller, Smith-Lovin, Lynn, & Brashears, Matthew E. 2006, June Social isolation in America: Changes in core discussion networks over two decades. American Sociological Review, Vol. 71, 353–375. Retrieved 6/26/06 online http://www.asanet.org/galleries/default-file/June06ASRFeature.pdf. http://www.asanet.org/galleries/default-file/June06ASRFeature.pdf social, socialization, friendship, family “Have the core discussion networks of Americans changed in the past two decades? In 1985, the General Social Survey (GSS) collected the first nationally representative data on the confidants with whom Americans discuss important matters. In the 2004 GSS the authors replicated those questions to assess social change in core network structures. Discussion networks are smaller in 2004 than in 1985. The number of people saying there is no one with whom they discuss important matters nearly tripled. The mean network size decreases by about a third (one confidant), from 2.94 in 1985 to 2.08 in 2004. The modal respondent now reports having no confidant; the modal respondent in 1985 had three confidants. Both kin and non-kin confidants were lost in the past two decades, but the greater decrease of non-kin ties leads to more confidant networks centered on spouses and parents, with fewer contacts through voluntary associations and neighborhoods. Most people have densely interconnected confidants similar to them. Some changes reflect the changing demographics of the U.S. population. Educational heterogeneity of social ties has decreased, racial heterogeneity has increased. The data may overestimate the number of social isolates, but these shrinking networks reflect an important social change in America” [p. 353, abstract].
McQuiggan, Meghan; Megra, Mahi; & Grady, Sarah 2017, September Parent and family involvement in education: Results from the National Household Education Surveys program of 2016: First look. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education. NCES 2017-102. Retrieved September 26, 2017 from https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2017/2017102.pdf https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2017/2017102.pdf homeschooling, home education, demographics, population size, reasons Found that during 2015-2016: 3.3% of school-age children, 1,689,726 were homeschooled; that is, estimates that there were 1.7 million (1.69 million) homeschool children of ages 5-17 in the US during 2015-2016 year. “Tables 7 and 8 specifically examine characteristics of homeschoolers and homeschooling rates as well as reasons for homeschooling. Students enrolled in public or private schools for more than 25 hours per week are not included in homeschooling tables. Additionally, homeschooling tables are restricted to students ages 5–17, whereas students in grades K–12 could be younger than 5 or older than 17” (p. 2). Sampled n=552 homeschool children.) “The NHES:2012, which was the last time the NHES was administered, also used an address-based sample; however, there was no option to complete the survey online [as there was in 2016]. Prior to 2012, the NHES used random digit dial samples of landline telephones. Due to changes in the survey mode over the last few administrations, readers should use caution when comparing estimates with prior NHES administrations” (p. 1). “PFI [Parent and Family Involvement in Education] questionnaires were completed by a parent or guardian who knew about the sampled child. When weighted, the PFI data are nationally representative of students enrolled in kindergarten through grade 12, including children enrolled in private schools, enrolled in public schools, and homeschooled. The total number of completed PFI questionnaires was 14,075 (13,523 enrolled and 552 homeschooled children), representing a population of 53.2 million students either homeschooled or enrolled in a public or private school in 2015–16” (p. 1). Finds that there were a total of 51,644,000 “Number of students [ages] 5–17” students in the U.S. during 2015-16 (Table 7, p. 18). “The total number of homeschooled students in 2016 was 1,689,726 (standard error of 118,447.8)” (p. 18). That is, 1.689 million or 1.69 or 1.7 million. They mailed printed questionnaires to most of the households. “However, 35,000 of 206,000 sampled households were first asked to complete the survey by web in order to assess the feasibility of including a web-based administration in future NHES collections” (p. 23).
McShane, G., Walter, G., & Rey, J. M. 2004 Functional outcome of adolescents with ‘school refusal’. Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 9, 53−60. school refusal, Australia, homeschooling Homeschooling is mentioned by McShane et al. but is probably not a notable focus of their study. Study is based on subjects in Sydney, Australia. The following quote is from Christopher A. Kearney, 2008, School absenteeism and school refusal behavior in youth: A contemporary review, Clinical Psychology Review 28 (2008) 451–471: “McShane and colleagues followed 117 adolescents with school attendance difficulties 6 months and three years following inpatient or outpatient intervention. At 6-month follow-up, adolescents had either resumed schooling (47%), enrolled in home schooling or vocational college with some employment (23%), were unemployed (19%), enrolled in home schooling [homeschooling] (10%), or were fully employed (1%). At 3-year follow-up, adolescents were enrolled in home schooling or vocational college with some employment (36%), remained in school (22%), were fully employed (18%), were unemployed and not in education (16%), or were in home schooling (8% McShane, Walter, & Rey, 2004)” (p. 464-465).
McShane, Michael Q. 2021 Hybrid homeschooling: A guide to the future of education. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. alternative schooling, alternative education, homeschooling, hybrid homeschooling, philosophy Interesting perspective. Much of what he calles hybrid homeschooling but not homeschooling at all; it is simply an alternative form of institutional schooling that is not directed and controlled by the parents.
McShane, Michael Q. 2021, June 8 New large survey of homeschooling families lifts hood on homeschooling during COVID-19. Retrieved July 9, 2021 from https://www.edchoice.org/engage/new-large-survey-of-homeschooling-families-lifts-hood-on-homeschooling-during-covid-19/ https://www.edchoice.org/engage/new-large-survey-of-homeschooling-families-lifts-hood-on-homeschooling-during-covid-19/ homeschool, population size
Mead, Sara 2006, June The truth about boys and girls. Washington, DC: Education Sector, Retrieved September 18, 2008 from www.educationsector.org. http://www.educationsector.org public schools, academic achievement, special needs, gender, gender differences “In addition, a dizzying array of so-called experts have seized on the boy crisis as a way to draw attention to their pet educational, cultural, or ideological issues. Some say that contemporary classrooms [p. 3 ends] are too structured, suppressing boys’ energetic natures and tendency to physical expression; others contend that boys need more structure and discipline in school. Some blame “misguided feminism” for boys’ difficulties, while others argue that “myths” of masculinity have a crippling impact on boys.3 Many of these theories have superficially plausible rationales that make them appealing to some parents, educators, and policymakers. But the evidence suggests that many of these ideas come up short” [p. 4]. Says research indicates that in general White/Anglo boys recently are achieving (academically) as well as are girls but girls’ achievement levels may be climbing faster than boys’. In addition, however, she writes, “To be sure, there are good reasons to be concerned about boys—particularly low-income, urban, rural, and minority boys as well as those with disabilities. Whether or not our schools are to blame for causing these boys’ problems, they need to do a better job of working to address them. In particular, the disproportionate number of boys being identified with learning and emotional disabilities, suspended from school, and dropping out suggests that what our schools are doing doesn’t work very well for some boys. But with so much ideological baggage and so little real evidence influencing the public debate on boys’ achievement, how are policymakers, educators, and parents to know what to do?” [p. 18].
Medley, Donald M. 1982 Teacher Effectiveness. In Harold E. Mitzel (ed.), Encyclopedia of Educational Research. New York: The Free Press, pp. 1894-1903.
Medlin, Richard G. 1994 Predictors of academic achievement in home educated children: Aptitude, self-concept, and pedagogical practices. Home School Researcher, 10(3), 1-7. academic achievement, predictors, prediction, research, home education, parent education, teacher certification, aptitude, self-concept Uses the Piers-Harris Children’s Self-Concept Scale to measure self-concept, including academic self-concept of 36 students. School status self-concept scores were above average (mean = 72nd percentile). Homeschool students’ self-concept scores were above average [p. 3, Table 2 on p. 3]. Self-concept was significantly, positively related to achievement. “The mean SAT [Stanford Achievement Test] Complete Battery score for the group as a whole was 58.59 (SD=20.32), which corresponds to a percentile rank of 66” [p. 3]. “Academic achievement was best predicted by scholastic aptitude, and the relationship between the two variables was quite strong. However, achievement scores were higher than aptitude scores, indicating that ability alone could not explain the level of achievement observed. ..... Educational self-concept was high and was also a predictor of achievement, particularly for older children.” (p. 4). “Less direct instruction, a shorter school year, and less frequent use of rewards and grades for schoolwork were also related to higher achievement scores...” but it is unclear which direction cause and effect works between these variables (p. 5). “Achievement and aptitude scores were related to both the fathers’ and mothers’ level of education, and to mothers’ certification as a teacher. Although other research with much larger sample sizes has rather consistently found that neither parental education nor certification is related to achievement...” (p. 5).) “A series of t-tests indicated that the seven children whose mothers were certified teachers scored significantly higher in both academic achievement, t(32)=-2.06, p=.047 ...” [p. 4].
Medlin, Richard G. 1996 Creativity in home schooled children. Home School Researcher, 12(1), 7-13. home education, research, creativity “Sixty-two home schooled children and their parents—43 families in all—participated in this study. A total of 28 boys and 34 girls representing grades three through eleven were included ...” [p. 8]. Three subtests of the Structure of Intellect Learning Abilities Test [SOI-LA] were used to measure creativity and the Stanford Achievement Test (8th ed.) was used to measure academic achievement. Measures structure in home school program (1 to 5=very structured, M=3.45), how often they used rewards to motivate their children using (1 to 5=very frequently, M=2.40), how frequently they had included the following topics in their curriculum in the past year (1 to 5=very frequently): appreciation of art (M=1.88), techniques of art (M=1.95), appreciation of drama (M=1.71), dramatic productions (M=2.05), appreciation of literature (M=3.67), creative writing (M=3.40), and critical thinking skills (M=3.48), how satisfied they were with their home school (1 to 5=very satisfied, M=4.02), and how likely (1 to 5=very likely, M=2.19) they would be to send their children to a conventional school if an excellent one were available to them. “The mean figural, verbal, and math creativity scores for all grades combined corresponded to percentile ranks of 72, 71, and 76 respectively. The mean SAT Complete Battery score for all grades combined corresponded to a percentile rank of 71” [p. 9]. “Verbal creativity scores were correlated with the number of years children had spent in conventional schools, r(42)=.365, p=.009. Math creativity scores, in contrast, were correlated with the number of years children had been home schooled r(42)=.309, p=.023. Figural creativity scores and achievement scores were not significantly related to the number of years children had spent in either home schools or conventional schools” [p. 10]. “Verbal and math creativity scores were correlated with the amount of independent work by children in each home school day: r(41)=.295, p=.031, and r(41)=.301, p=.028, respectively. The correlation between figural creativity scores and the amount of independent work approached significance, r(41)=.250, p=.057. Achievement scores were also correlated with children’s independent work, r(42)=.263, p=.046” [p. 10]. “Contrary to expectation, no positive relationship was found between creativity and a variety of teaching practices including: the amount of structure, a non-traditional home school, allowing children to direct their own studies, and including art, drama, literature, creative writing, and critical thinking skills in the home school curriculum. These results agree with those of Williams (1990), ...” [p. 11]. “Perhaps, as Williams (1990) concluded, home schooled children are likely to be creative simply because the parents of creative children are drawn to home schooling, believing it to be more appropriate to their children’s abilities than a conventional education. It is also possible, however, that more intrinsic features of the home schooling environment—rather than specific instructional techniques—actually cause children’s creativity to increase ...” [p. 11].
Medlin, Richard G. 2000 Home schooling and the question of socialization. Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 107-123. Provides comprehensive review of research done to date on questions such as “Do home-schooled children participate in the daily routines of their communities?,” “Are home-schooled children acquiring the rules of behavior and systems of beliefs and attitudes they need?,” and “Can home-schooled children function effectively as members of society?” “What makes this question so puzzling is that different people mean different things by the word socialization. Some people mean social activity: giving children the chance to play with friends and participate in traditional extracurricular activities like sports, school plays, and the senior prom. Others mean social influence: teaching children to conform to majority norms. And some mean social exposure: introducing children to the culture and values of different groups of people. All these things may be a part of socialization, but socialization can be more accurately defined as “the process whereby people acquire the rules of behavior and systems of [p. 107] beliefs and attitudes that equip a person to function effectively as a member of a particular society” (Durkin, 1995b, p. 614) [p. 108]”. Concludes: “Although there are still far too many unanswered questions about home schooling and socialization, some preliminary conclusions can be stated. Home-schooled children are taking part in the daily routines of their communities. They are certainly not isolated; in fact, they associate with--and feel close to--all sorts of people. Home schooling parents can take much of the credit for this. For, with their children's long-term social development in mind, they actively encourage their children to take advantage of social opportunities outside the family. Home-schooled children are acquiring the rules of behavior and systems of beliefs and attitudes they need. They have good self-esteem and are likely to display fewer behavior problems than do other children. They may be more socially mature and have better leadership skills than other children as well. And they appear to be functioning effectively as members of adult society” [p. 119].
Medlin, Richard G. 2006 Homeschooled children’s social skills. Home School Researcher, 17(1), 1-8. home schooling, homeschooling, home education, research, public school, cooperation, assertiveness, empathy, and self-control Reviews previous research and concludes the following: “In conclusion, the available studies show either no difference between homeschooled children and other children, or a difference favoring homeschooled children. They suggest that homeschooled children’s social skills “are certainly no worse than those of children attending conventional schools, and are probably better” (Medlin, 2000, p. 116). The available studies, however, are few and often not focused on specific social skills. More research, especially from the perspectives of objective observers and of homeschooled children themselves, is clearly needed.” This study is of homeschool students in grades 3 through 6. Used the Social Skills Rating System, a self-report instrument, to measure social skills (i.e., Cooperation, Assertiveness, Empathy, and Self-Control subscales as well as a Total score) and compared homeschool scores to the norm group of the instrument. “These percentile ranks ranged from a low of 55 [0.13 z-score] for the fifth-grade boys to a high of 94 [1.55 z-score] for the sixth-grade boys. All of them exceeded the average for public school students in the standardization sample, the 50th percentile” (p. 4). “A series of t-tests was calculated to determine if mean Total scores for the children in this study were significantly different from those of the standardization sample (with groups matched for gender and grade). The results of this analysis are presented in Table 3” (p. 4) and 3 of the 8 t-tests were statistically significant. “Homeschooled children’s social skills scores were consistently higher than those of public school students. Differences were most marked for girls and for older children, and encompassed all four of the specific skills tested: cooperation, assertiveness, empathy, and self-control. Among homeschooled children, girls were more empathetic and assertive than boys, and at the lower grades, more self-controlled” [p. 5; see also Tables 3-11 on p. 4-5]. “There appears to be, therefore, a convergence of evidence from three different perspectives––parental report, objective observers, and self-report––that homeschooled children’s social skills are exceptional” [p. 6].
Medlin, Richard G. 2013 Homeschooling and the question of socialization revisited. Peabody Journal of Education, 88(3), 284-297. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0161956X.2013.796825 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0161956X.2013.796825 homeschooling, research, social development, psychological development, socialization, peer-reviewed “This article reviews recent research on homeschooled children’s socialization. The research indicates that homeschooling parents expect their children to respect and get along with people of diverse backgrounds, provide their children with a variety of social opportunities outside the family, and believe their children’s social skills are at least as good as those of other children. What homeschooled children think about their own social skills is less clear. Compared to children attending conventional schools, however, research suggest that they have higher quality friendships and better relationships with their parents and other adults. They are happy, optimistic, and satisfied with their lives. Their moral reasoning is at least as advanced as that of other children, and they may be more likely to act unselfishly. As adolescents, they have a strong sense of social responsibility and exhibit less emotional turmoil and problem behaviors than their peers. Those who go on to college are socially involved and open to new experiences. Adults who were homeschooled as children are civically engaged and functioning competently in every way measured so far. An alarmist view of homeschooling, therefore, is not supported by empirical research. It is suggested that future studies focus not on outcomes of socialization but on the process itself” (abstract, p. 284).
Medlin, Richard G. 2026 Homeschooling: Beyond Academic Achievement. Peabody Journal of Education, 101(1). homeschooling, intelligence, academic self-concept, academic intrinsic motivation, learning styles, thinking skills, creativity, parental teaching methods “Abstract. This article focuses on cognitive attributes other than academic achievement in homeschooled children. Research on intelligence, academic self-concept, academic intrinsic motivation, learning styles, thinking skills, and creativity is reviewed. This research suggests that homeschooled children perform better academically than would be expected from their intelligence alone, have good academic self-esteem, and show strong thinking skills and creativity. It is not clear whether they are more intrinsically motivated to learn than other children or what role learning styles may play in their development. Parents’ support for their children’s independence and self-determination is positively related to academic self-concept, academic intrinsic motivation, and creativity. The interrelatedness of these different attributes is discussed and directions for future research are suggested.”
Medlin, Richard G.; & Blackmer, Robin E. 2000 Academic intrinsic motivation in homeschooled children. Home School Researcher 14(2), 1-6. homeschooling, home schooling, academic motivation, academic achievement, causal comparative, peer-reviewed Analyzes academic intrinsic motivation in homeschooled children. Measures intrinsic interest in learning in children from three different educational settings: homeschools, a public school using grades for student evaluation, and a public school using portfolio assessment instead of grades. Also, homeschooled children’s academic achievement was tested and their parents’ attitudes and teaching practices were recorded to see what relationship these factors might have to academic intrinsic motivation. “The participants were 96 children [in grade levels 4 to 8] from three different educational settings: homeschools, a public school using grades for student evaluation, and a public school using portfolio assessment instead of grades” (p. 2). “The materials used in this research were the Children’s Academic Intrinsic Motivation Inventory (CAIMI Gottfried, 1986), the Stanford Achievement Test (SAT), Eighth Edition (Psychological Corporation, 1992), and a brief questionnaire for the homeschooled children’s parents” (p. 3). “HOMESCHOOLED CHILDREN WERE more intrinsically motivated in reading and less intrinsically motivated in math than children attending a conventional school using grades to evaluate students’ performance. There were no differences in intrinsic academic motivation between homeschooled children and children attending a school using portfolio assessment. Achievement scores for the homeschooled children in this study were above the national average for public school students (the 50th percentile) but not as high as those found in larger studies of homeschooled students (e.g., Rudner, 1999)” (p. 4). “This research produced other puzzling results as well. Among homeschooled children, intrinsic motivation was related to higher achievement only for social studies, and that relationship was weak. For math, intrinsic motivation and achievement were actually negatively correlated” (p. 5). Analyzed standardized achievement test scores in reading, math, social studies, and science. On test scores alone, found homeschool scores higher than national norm. Causal comparative, peer-reviewed.
Medved, Michael 1998 Saving childhood. Imprimis, 27 (9), 1-6 [published by Hillsdale College]. education, opinion, society, culture, values Charges that American popular culture and the public educational system are making war on children and destroying the innocence of childhood. “Unfortunately, the time children spend in school seldom serves to counteract this malign media influence; far more often it reinforces it” [p. 3]. “As Marie Winn observed in her wise 1981 book, Children Without Childhood, society has abandoned its old emphasis on ‘protection’ of kids and embraced a new priority of ‘preparation’” [p. 3]. “Instead of abandoning our young to today’s trendy cynicism, American families should exalt childhood innocence, hot just as an absence of information or an enforced ignorance but as a positive value in its own right, featuring three indispensable elements: security, optimism, and a sense of wonder” [p. 3]; then Medved explicates these three elements. Implies his children are home schooled. “It hardly helps children to depress them in the name of preparation and to convince them at an early age that life is random, chaotic, or doomed. Unless kids look forward to the future with anticipation and joy, the process of growing up will seem merely pointless and painful” [p. 4]. “The true antidote to pessimism isn’t some forced Pollyanna optimism--it is gratitude, expressed fervently and frequently” [p. 4] and “We need to acknowledge our appreciation for our country, for its founders and heroes, and for our own parents and grandparents. Above all, however, we owe a debt of gratitude to the Almighty, who has showered us with gifts and opportunities of an altogether unprecedented nature” [p. 4-5].
Meier, P. D., Minirth, F. B., & Wichern, F. 1982 Introduction to psychology and counseling. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Book House. psychology, affective domain, Christian, biblical Christian perspecitive on psychology and counseling; includes topics such as mental and emotional health.
Meighan, Roaland (Ed.) 1992 Learning from home-based education. Bramcote, Nottingham, United Kingdom: Educational Heretics Press. home education, homeschooling, practice, philosophy, policy, foreign, UK, United Kingdom, England Addresses topics such as “deschooling is not just for children,” firsthand anecdotal experiences of the practice of home education, “studies of children learning at home,” “making home-based education a normal and available option for all,” “adult chauvinism and children’s rights,” and recent developments in the UK
Meighan, Roland 1984 Home-based educators and education authorities: The attempt to maintain a mythology. Educational Studies, 10(3), 273-286. Also in ERIC's CIJE, Jan.-June, 1985, 447; No. EJ 312 844. Comparative Education, Educational Practices, Home Schooling, Mythology A discussion of home education in England; the myths and the truth. England. "Myths concerning home-based education in England are discussed. These include the myths that schooling is compulsory, that there is one right approach in education, that there is such a thing as professionalism, that local education authorities have the right to access and cooperation, and that there is consensus among home educators" (CIJE).
Meighan, Roland 1984 Political consciousness and home-based education. Educational Review, 36(2):165-173. Also in ERIC's CIJE, July-Dec. 1984, 156; No. EJ 299 053. England. "Discusses some of the myths surrounding home-based schooling... Myths refuted include compulsory education and the illusion that only qualified teachers can educate at home" (CIJE). Discussion of parents' political education as a result of their involvement in home education.
Meighan, Roland 1995 Home‐based education effectiveness research and some of its implications. Educational Review, 47(3), 275-287. http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0013191950470304#.UddUSvnbOSo homeschooling, home-based education, research, review, motives, motivation, reasons, socialization, academic achievementO “Abstract: In the UK, USA, Canada, Australia, New Zealand and elsewhere, a quiet revolution has been taking place. More and more families are taking the option of home‐based education in preference to school attendance. The evidence supports only two generalisations about this development. The first is that families display considerable diversity in motives, methods and aims. The second is that they are usually very successful in achieving their chosen aims. In the UK there have been several changes since a handful of families first began to co‐operate to form the organisation Education Otherwise in 1977. These include changes in motivation, in acceptance by Local Education Authorities, in the growth to a take‐up of about 10,000 families and in the questions posed by the home‐based education phenomenon. The basic question of ‘will the families cope?’ has given way to ‘why do they usually cope so easily and so well?’ Home‐based education effectiveness research demonstrates that children are usually superior to their school‐attending peers in social skills, social maturity, emotional stability, academic achievement, personal confidence, communication skills and other aspects. The lessons of this research, as to how the schooling system could be regenerated, are only just beginning to be appreciated. It questions all the fundamental assumptions underpinning schooling, as well as pointing to ways of regenerating and reconstructing education systems in general and schools in particular, in the direction of more flexibility, suitable for the post‐modernist scene. It gives us clues as to how we can de‐school schools by developing the Invitational School to replace the Custodial School” (retrieved 7/5/13 from http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0013191950470304#.UddUSvnbOSo).
Meighan, Roland 1995 John Holt: Personalised education and the reconstruction of schooling. Bramcote Hills, Nottingham, England: Educational Heretics Press. home education, reform, alternative education, philosophy, John Holt "One of my hopes in writing this review of John Holt's ten books is that it will help ensure that John Holt goes on working" [Introduction].
Meighan, Roland 2001 Learning unlimited: The home-based education case-files. Bramcote Hills, Nottingham, UK: Educational Heretics Press. home education, stories, case files, reasons, anecdotes Presents a number of stories, case files, from the experiences of home-based educating, homeschooling homeschool families, capturing some of the variety, pathos, difficulties, and excitement of the families.
Meighan, Roland 2005 Comparing learning systems: The good, the bad, the ugly, and the counter-productive. Bramcote, Nottingham, United Kingdom: Educational Heretics Press. education, home education, philosophy Presents philosohies of education and pedagogical approaches, says most families opting out of institutional schooling and into homeschooling or home-based education are reluctant educational heretics and trailblazers.
Meighan, Roland, 1997 The next learning system: And why home-schoolers are trailblazers. Bramcote Hills, Nottingham, United Kingdom: Educational Heretics Press. home education, research, opinion, future, futurist, trends, foreign country Uses research to substantiate claim that home-based education is effective by any measure. Explains why home schooling is a success (e.g., (a) natural learning and “dovetailing” in to the child’s behavior or responding naturally to the cues he gives to parents, (b) having and using direct access to an information-rich society, (c) adaptation to a wide variety of learning styles, (d) efficient use of time, (e) a non-hostile learning environment, (f) learner-managed learning, (g) the use of the “catalog curriculum approach” or making many curriculum options available at all times, (h) matching the logic of multiple intelligence theory, (i) adults serving as learning agents, learning coaches, and learning site managers, (j) plenty of first-hand experience, (k) the application of the various forms of discipline (i.e., authoritarian, autonomous, and democratic), and (l) we now know more about how the brain actually works. Explores and describes the “next learning system” with key ideas being (a) learner-managed learning, (b) a network of learning sites, (c) the catalog curriculum, (d) personal learning plans, (e) direct access to the information-rich society (e.g., via the computer and telecommunications), (f) teachers as learning agents, and (g) assessment on request.
Melnick, Steven A. 1999, September Quality control of home schooling in Pennsylvania. Middletown, PA: Pennsylvania State Data Center (PaSDC) http://www.psdc.hbg.psu.edu/psdc/Products_and_Services/Publications/Issue_Papers/Home_Schooling.html home education, research, policy, state regulation, opinion, academic achievement a Unit of the Institute of State and Regional Affairs at Penn State Harrisburg), 34 pp. Available from author at School of Behavioral Sciences, Pennsylvania State University, Harrisburg, 777 West Harrisburg Pike, Middletown PA 17057. Described online at http://www.psdc.hbg.psu.edu/psdc/Products_and_Services/Publications/Issue_Papers/Home_Schooling.html (retrieved 5/22/00 Uses survey data from public school districts and homeschool parents for analysis. Provides response rate for school districts but not for homeschool parents. Author provides no explanation of how public school districts arrive at their evaluation (i.e., grades such as A through F) of homeschool students’ academic work; the evaluation and assignment of grades appears to be simply the opinion of the person who completed the survey form. Author’s statistics on page 15 appear to be in serious error (e.g., percents of homeschool students’ work at the 5 grade levels totals 130% which does not match the survey instrument item on p. 32). Author does not address several important methodological issues. “Pennsylvania through Act 169, provides more structure and control of home schooling than do most states. Because of the mandates of the Act, public school districts in Pennsylvania expend more than $3.1 million per year to monitor home schooling, and this figure is growing annually. In some areas of the Commonwealth where home schooling is particularly popular, an undue financial burden is placed on certain districts to meet the requirements of the Act. Ninety-six percent of the school districts do not believe they should bear any additional expense of home schooling. The state should provide financial relief to those districts with the greatest need in the form of grants to help offset the growing drain on district resources. [new paragraph] Although both groups believe increased positive communication is desirable, there is an obvious disparity in how home schoolers and districts perceive their communication with each other. On the one hand, only 17 percent of home schoolers agree the district welcomes communication from them; 65 percent of the districts believe they welcome communication. The wide difference of perception on this issue indicates that both districts and home schoolers need to develop better communication strategies. While the two groups often perceive each other as the enemy, the reality is children schooled at home may not be able to take full advantage of the available resources without better communication. [new paragraph] There is little disagreement between groups that parents should monitor the progress of their own children. Although districts feel strongly that they should develop guidelines for student monitoring. parents do not. It is clear from district reports that most home schooled students do “A” or “B” work (78 percent). Parental monitoring does seem to be appropriate and effective, and districts do not need to place any further demands on monitoring for most students. [new paragraph] Unfortunately, about 23 percent of home schooled students submit work of “D” or “F” quality. In these cases, the district may need to monitor student progress more frequently and, if necessary, revoke the right to home school. [new paragraph] District policies van’ widely regarding participation of home schoolers in extracurricular activities and academic courses. There is some sentiment among the public schools, and overwhelming agreement among parents, that home schooled children should be permitted to use district facilities (e.g., computer labs, libraries, etc.). A large number of parents (75 percent) would like the option for their children to take selected academic courses at the local school, but almost two thirds of the districts (65 percent) disagree. [new paragraph] Because of the polarized viewpoints on extracurricular activities, academic courses and facility use, a wide inequity across districts exists in opportunities for home school students. Districts should develop more uniform policies in order to provide equity in educational opportunities to all students” (p. 23).
Meltzer, Lisa J., Shaheed, Keisha, & Ambler, Devon 2016 Start later, sleep later: School start times and adolescent sleep in homeschool versus public/private school students. Behavioral Sleep Medicine, v. 14, :140–154. homeschooling, sleep, sleep deprivation, health, public school, private school Abstract: “Homeschooled students provide a naturalistic comparison group for later/flexible school start times. This study compared sleep patterns and sleep hygiene for homeschooled students and public/private school students (grades 6–12). Public/private school students (n = 245) and homeschooled students (n=162) completed a survey about sleep patterns and sleep hygiene. Significant school group differences were found for weekday bedtime, wake time, and total sleep time, with homeschooled students waking later and obtaining more sleep. Homeschooled students had later school start times, waking at the same time that public/private school students were starting school. Public/private school students had poorer sleep hygiene practices, reporting more homework and use of technology in the hour before bed. Regardless of school type, technology in the bedroom was associated with shorter sleep duration. Later school start times may be a potential countermeasure for insufficient sleep in adolescents. Future studies should further examine the relationship between” (p. 1). Suggests healthier practices for the homeschooled. Does not say the homeschooled are at-risk
Mensa Research Journal. [no author] 2007, Fall Why not in public schools? Mensa Research Journal, 38(3), 85. home education, talented, gifted, special needs
Merrill, Dean 1983, September 2 A home school that didn't work. Christianity Today, 64, p. 18.
Merrill, Dean 1983, September 2 A morning in a home school. Christianity Today, 64, p. 20-21.
Merrill, Dean 1983, September 2 Schooling at mother's knee: can it compare? Christianity Today, p. 16-21. Personal accounts of home schoolers. Reasons. Religion.
Merry, Michael S., & Howell, Charles 2009, November Can intimacy justify home education? Theory and Research in Education, 7(3), 363-381. homeschooling, home education, attentive parenting, intimacy, socialization, family relations “Abstract: Many parents cite intimacy as one of their reasons for deciding to educate at home. It seems intuitively obvious that home education is conducive to intimacy because of the increased time families spend together. Yet what is not clear is whether intimacy can provide justification for one’s decision to home educate. To see whether this is so, we introduce the concept of ‘attentive parenting’, which encompasses a set of family characteristics, and we examine whether and under what conditions attentive parents risk loss of intimacy by sending their children to school; or, alternatively, whether they can avoid this risk by educating children at home. What we will determine is whether families who exhibit the specified characteristics are prima facie justified in educating their children at home under the conditions of interest. We argue that, for attentive parents, home education not only promotes greater intimacy, but also provides insurance against the loss of intimacy that may occur under certain conditions when children attend schools” [p. 363].
Merry, Michael S., & Karsten, Sjoerd 2010 Restricted liberty, parental choice and homeschooling. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 44(4), 497-514. home education, homeschooling, state regulation, children’s rights, child’s rights, negative criticism, negative critic, inspection, legislation, law, state control, review, Europe Give in-depth and thoughtful consideration to authority of the state versus parents over the education of a child and his or her interests or rights. Promote strong caution to state to not treat homeschooling as aberrant and to not over-regulate home education. Recognize that the state and institutional schools do not necessarily offer or guarantee the best education for children. Contrary to authors’ implied position on page 510, states should not, and in the U.S. do not, “grant … freedoms” or rights; states recognize those that are “natural” or from a Creator or God. Regarding page 511: the state’s role is not “protector of children’s interests” – it is to punish one who has done harm to another. Authors’ approach presumes that parents and the state are co-raisers, co-guardians, and co-disciplers of children; this is based on statism, not biblical scripturalism, and begins with the assumption that the family needs the state to function properly, that parents need the state to oversee them and make sure they properly raise their children, and essentially puts the state in the position of authority and power over proper childraising and the burden of proof on parents that they are not harming their children rather than waiting until there is evidence harm is being done then the state intervening. See Rothbard, 1999). Authors deal logically and pointedly with “liberal critics” of home-education and the freedoms that homeschooling implies by addressing their unsupported claims regarding home education’s weaknesses. “Yet in the main we may say that children, like all human persons, have an interest in wellbeing. Though broad in scope, wellbeing will minimally entail basic protections, nourishment, and education. But wellbeing will equally entail the capacity to take up pursuits (e.g. vocations and relationships) that will contribute to a flourishing life. Put more strongly still, wellbeing is related to the (future) interest in self-governance, viz., the capacity to direct one’s own life and to identify with it from the inside. ….. To avert unnecessary harms, liberal critics of homeschooling typically focus on its lack of public accountability. ….. There are a number of problems with this line of reasoning. First, it is curious that homeschoolers would be singled out here. ….. Second, liberal critics typically presume more than they prove and not infrequently cast hypothetical allegations of aims and outcomes for homeschoolers (or private schoolers) against idealised aims and outcomes of public schools … That is, public schools are cast as uniquely qualified to facilitate meaningful liberal virtues of civic intelligence and engagement. Yet not only is the basic claim highly questionable, especially for all sorts of marginalised [p. 508 ends] groups, it also of course ignores the fact that public schools promote (explicitly and through the hidden curriculum) all sorts of values both at odds with parents’ wishes as well as conditions favourable to the cultivation of autonomy … Third, putting aside for the moment the daunting logistical challenges associated with homeschool regulation, one is confronted with the immense difficulty of assessing for liberal virtues (among them ‘civic preparedness’, public reasonableness, multicultural tolerance and autonomy) in an uncontroversial way. ….. Here, then, is the crux of the matter: the liberty of parents to select an education they deem suitable for their own children, provided that parents’ own liberties do not unduly or improperly infringe upon the liberty of their children—which in any case is rather difficult to assess—is one that is consistent with a liberal democratic state aiming to facilitate a plurality of choices as well as the exercise of individual liberty” [p. 509]. “So a balance is needed. In the first section, we demonstrated that states do not grant unlimited freedoms; coercive restrictions of liberty by the state are justified when doing so ensures the expression of liberty for others. Indeed, liberty is not an all-consuming value, overriding all others. ….. To help avert the abuse of liberty, the distribution of authority—with neither parents nor the state controlling all of it—constitutes wise policy. ….. If the liberties of children are disregarded or thwarted through homeschooling or any other means, the state’s role as protector of children’s interests will trump that of the parents. That is, the best grounds [p. 510 ends] for restricting the liberty rights of parents to homeschool would be to avert the infringement of a child’s wellbeing, thus inhibiting its (future) liberty and capacity for self-governance. ….. Unless there is clear evidence of a child’s wellbeing being contravened, the restriction of legitimate liberty to choose among a range of reasonable educational options constitutes an injustice. ….. While the Netherlands does a better job than most in balancing parental liberty, children’s interests and state oversight, our examination of the homeschooling case exposes at least one worrying inconsistency. ….. By treating homeschooling as aberrant the Netherlands also risks illegitimately restricting parental liberty and misapplying its own constitutional principles of freedom of education to include only institutionalised schools” [p. 511]. From a more European or statist perspective, authors positive toward freedom to home educate; from a more U.S, classical liberal, or pro-home education freedom perspective, authors somewhat negative toward home-education freedoms. They are discussing barriers to parents choosing to homeschool.
Mertens, Barbara L. 1989 Home-Based Instruction Update. A report by the office of the Superintendent of Public Instruction, Washington State.
Messerli, J. C. 1965 Controversy and consensus in common school reform. Teachers College Record, 66, 749-759.
Metts, Wallis C., Jr. 1996, October Home sweet hassle. Educational Leadership, 54(2), 72-73. home education Discusses challenges and costs of home schooling [e.g., money, time, energy] but says they are all worth it. Describes his family's long-standing participation in homeschooling, highlighting efforts to provide socialization and service education, uphold academic standards, and integrate learning activities into everyday life. Shows homeschooling is a labor of love. Children benefit from experiencing the focused attention of caring adults, particularly their own parents. Author is a Professor of Communications at Spring Arbor College and a home educator.
Mexcur, D. 1993 A comparison of academic performance among public school graduates, conventional Christian school graduates, accelerated Christian school graduates, and home school graduates in three Christian colleges. Doctoral dissertation, Bob Jones University, Greenville, SC. home education, research, college, graduates, adults, academic achievement, success
Meyer v. Nebraska 1923 262 U.S. 390. law, legal, parents’ rights Supreme Court decision invalidated a state law “... because the law did not ‘promote’ education but rather ‘arbitrarily and unreasonably’ interfered with ‘the natural duty of the parent to give his children education suitable to their station in life. ...’ The Court chastened the legislature for attempting ‘materially to interfere ... with the power of parents to control the education of their own’” (from Christopher Klicka’s The right choice: Home schooling, 1993, p. 317-318).
Meyer, H. H. 1929, 1983 Education. In James Orr (Ed.), International Standard Bible Encyclopedia [ISBE], v. II, Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdman Publishing Co. (pp. 900-905). education, history, Jews, Judaism, biblical “All education is at first religious in the sense that religious motives and ideas predominate in the educational efforts of all primitive peoples. The degree to which religion continues preeminent in the educational system of a progressive nation depends on the vitality of its religion and upon the measure of its efficiency and success with which from the first that religion is instilled into the very bone and sinew of each succeeding generation. Here lies the explanation of the religious-educational character of Hebrew national life, and here, too, the secret of Israel's incomparable influence upon the religious and educational development of the world. The religion of Israel was a vital religion and it was a teaching religion” [p. 901]. Explains that even these nomadic people taught their children to read and write. “The home was the only school and the parents the only teachers. But there was real instruction .....; and again he [Moses] commanded ... to teach them the rudiments of learning (reading and writing) together with the laws and deeds of the ancestors, in order that they might not transgress or seem ignorant of the laws of their ancestors, but rather emulate their example” [p. 901].
Michigan Supreme Court 1993, May 25 People v. DeJonge (After remand), syllabus and opinion. "...the state failed to show that the teacher certification requirement is the least restrictive means of discharging its interest in the education of the [home schooling] defendants' children, requiring reversal of their convictions. ...the teacher certification requirement is an unconstitutional violation of the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment as applied to families whose religious convictions prohibit the use of certified instructors. law, legal, research, teacher certification, academic achievement, constitutionality Such families should be exempt from the dictates of the teacher certification requirement" (p. 1, Syllabus). Page 32 of the Opinion cites research by Dr. Brian Ray A nationwide study of home education: Family characteristics, legal matters, and student achievement, 1990) that found "...`there was no [statistically significant] [brackets in Opinion] difference in students' total reading, total math, or total language scores based on the teacher certification status...of their parents.'" One of the most significant court cases ever related to home education.
Milke, Mark 2010, November 8 School choice in Canada: Lessons for America. Backgrounder Heritage Foundation, No. 2485. Retrieved 7/18/13 from http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2010/11/school-choice-in-canada-lessons-for-america. http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2010/11/school-choice-in-canada-lessons-for-america school choice, private education, homeschooling, public schools, public school at home Homeschooling is a significant topic of this paper. Presents number of homeschool students in Alberta. “Alberta has been the most innovative, flexible, and supportive province in Canada as it concerns homeschooling” (p. 7). Implicitly, if not explicitly, promotes state/tax-supported homeschooling or public school at home programs. “Abstract: In Canada, the province of Alberta has long encouraged school choice. Historically, Alberta has had two school systems between which parents may choose: the “public” system and a “separate” system. Other Alberta choices include charter, private, and French-language schools. Homeschooling is encouraged and supported by the provincial government, and “blended” programs are available where children can take some courses at home and others at school. This large variety of educational choice has led to positive results. International test results have placed Alberta students among the world’s top performers, including immigrant children who fare equal to or better than non-immigrant children. In Alberta, parents expect—and have—a wide variety of educational options for how to educate their children, a policy outcome that American states should emulate” (p. 1).
Miller, Bryan G. 2000 Socialization and home educated children: An exploratory study. Home School Researcher, 14(2), 7-14. home education, research, socialization “As hypothesized, these home school parents were concerned about how their children interacted with others. ….. According to these parents, homeschooling provides advantages in socializing children in five ways” [p. 12]. “The most striking characteristic that these parents share, at least according to this researcher, is the emphasis that these parents place on the parent’s responsibility to guide the socialization of their children. These parents talked both about guarding their children from the negative aspects of socialization negative labels and peer pressure) as well as teaching positive components of socialization (being a friend, serving others, helping others grow). However, despite the high level of parental control, the parents also talked about “exposing them” to different types of behavior and social situations. What was unique was the emphasis these parents placed on assisting the children in interpreting those social interactions” [p. 13].
Miller, Dallas 1997, November Studies demonstrate value of home education. The Ottawa Times Leaders’ Forum, p. 7. home education, research “No one should think that home schooling is limited to ‘granola crunchers’ and ‘fundamentalist Christians.’” Mentions Ray’s 1994 study of homeschooling in Canada.
Miller, Darrow L. 2007 Nurturing the nations: Reclaiming the dignity of women in building healthy cultures. Colorado Springs: Paternoster: Thinking Faith. sex or gender roles, religion, Christianity, feminism, sexism, poverty, education, family, philosophy, sociology Deals with intersection of women, poverty, and worldview, and posits that one of the greatest causes of poverty and other ills is the lie that men are superior to women. Expounds on his view of the biblical role of women (and of men). Says God created women and men equal in value and different in role/function. Explains that both are mad in the image of God, a Triune Being, and that their functions are complementary. A woman’s role is crucial, just as important as a man’s, includes nurturing and teaching and managing a home. Explains that a woman is free to do many things in many spheres, biblically. Jesus called for neither sexism nor feminism. Explains four spheres of governance [p. 223]: individual in which every person must govern his or her own life; the family in which the husband is the loving and serving head, in authority, of his wife and family and “The wife is responsible to her own husband, but not to all men” [p. 224] with a multifaceted function; the church, in which “… every Christian is called into full-time ministry” and where “There is only one limitation placed on many men and all women: the office of episkope, meaning “overseership, charge, the office of an elder …” [p. 224]; and, “In civil society, there are no gender restrictions on work, service, and leadership” [p. 224]. “… it takes male and female to procreate and to take dominion. The family is at the start of this process, and women naturally nurture and teach in this setting. Both single women and mother have this as part of their calling. If the home is strong, the nation will become strong. If the home is dysfunctional, the nation will decline” [p. 242]. People should highly value and promote the roles of women in 1 Timothy 5:9-14, the roles of motherhood, succorer, and homemaker that include being one of two, if not the, key educator and instructor in values and worldview, and a manager of the home, an economist, that typically moves in and out of the marketplace. Clearly implies it is best for mothers to be nurturing and teaching their young children rather than putting them in daycare and preschool [p. 254-255]. Also focuses on how a biblical marriage draws people to and shows the rich and glorious relationship between Christ and His church of all believers, His bride.
Mills, Kathryn Jean 2009 An exploration of children in middle childhood`s homeschooling experience. Master’s thesis, University of South Africa. Retrieved 7/8/13 from http://uir.unisa.ac.za/handle/10500/3308. http://uir.unisa.ac.za/handle/10500/3308 homeschooling, qualitative, research, children’s perceptions, children’s experiences, learning style “Abstract: The study explores children in middle childhood’s experiences of homeschooling. The researcher makes use of a qualitative research design in the form of a case study, studying the participants’ experiences of homeschooling in their natural setting. The sample consisted of children in middle childhood who participated in semi-structured interviews exploring their individual experiences pertaining to learning at home, their familial relationships and their social learning in the homeschooling environment. Developmental aspects relating specifically to middle childhood are discussed and utilised along with the views of the participants in this study, those of experts, and literature reviews in order to gain a genuine understanding of the child’s experience of homeschooling.” “The empirical findings acclaimed family relationships as having a considerable influence on the participants’ experience of homeschooling, suggesting that homeschooling supports good relationships between participants and their families. The empirical findings demonstrated three areas pertaining to the participants’ relationships within their family. These areas were a strong sense of cohesion as a family unit, a unique bonding within the mother-child relationship and lastly the family environment as being experienced as a place of safety. The empirical findings substantiated previous research, indicating a sense of cohesion among family members as a result of homeschooling” (p. 81). “The empirical findings again demonstrated the family context, specifically being taught by their mother, as a positive feature of homeschooling. The researcher is of the opinion that the mother’s supportive teaching style in homeschooling contributes to the development of individual learning styles. Participants for instance each expressed experiencing a sense of freedom in asking questions, working at their own pace and in their own style. Lastly the empirical findings illustrated homeschooling as a learning environment, in which participants felt safe to explore and learn educationally and personally. Responses in this regard included Participant F describing how she felt the freedom to simply be herself at home. Participant A alluded that the reason for his experience of freedom is due to the fact that he feels completely relaxed because homeschooling allows him to spend time just with his family” (p. 82).
Minnesota Department of Education 2021, January 11 Update for Minnesota Nonpublic Education Council from Cindy Jackson to Minnesota Nonpublic Education Council Members. Roseville, MN: Author. homeschooling, growth, Minnesota Total number of homeschool students grew by 49% from the 2019-2020 to 2020-2021 school year.
Minnich, Steven H., & Midgley, T. K. c. 1986 Home schooling: A review of current thinking on issues in educational sociology since 1978. Unpublished manuscript, Department of Education, Eastern Washington University.
Mintz, Jerry [mis?? year] The almanac of education choices (book)
Mintz, Jerry [year mis??] The handbook of alternative education (book)
Mitchell, Earlene 1985, Fall The eight-year study: A story not to be forgotten. The Educational Forum, 50(1), 12.
Mohring, Bridget 1986, September Schooling children in the home. The Standard, p. 10. CBN University, Virginia Beach, VA 23463. Reasons for home schooling, socialization, law.
Moles, Oliver C. 1982 Synthesis of recent research on parent participation in children's education. Educational Leadership, 40(2), 44-47.
Monaghan, Peter 1989 Teach your children. Seattle's Child, February, 1 & 16-17.
Mondschein, Eric S. & Sorenson, Gail Paulus 1982, November Home instruction in lieu of compulsory attendance: Statutory and constitutional issues. Report presented at the National Organization on Legal Problems and Education Annual Convention, San Francisco, CA.
Monk, Daniel 2009 Regulating home education: Negotiating standards, anomalies and rights. Child and Family Law Quarterly, 21,(2), 155-184. home education, theory, political science, philosophy, policy, foreign, negative criticism, United Kingdom Concludes, based on theory and international law, that children have rights that the state cannot assume the parents will protect and that therefore the state must control home education and have access to (i.e., personally inspect and evaluate in-person) the home and children in which children are being home educated. Argues that the state must determine whether home-educated and other privately educated children are being exposed to values that the state deems important, even if they are contrary to their parents’ values. Alleges that his conclusion is based on protecting children’s rights but, in the end, obscures the fact that his conclusion is based on the philosophical presupposition that the state should have more authority over a child’s education and upbringing than should the parents. In the age-old debate over who controls a child’s upbringing, the author sides with the state or civil government. “Home education, or home schooling, is an issue that has attracted little attention and the legal framework has remained largely unchanged since 1944. However, the number of parents opting to home educate has been increasing steadily in recent years and the Government has now published guidance for local authorities and commissioned an independent review. This article reviews the current law, highlights the practical issues requiring clarification and identifies the connections with other policy developments such as Every Child Matters and the increasing regulation of the independent education sector. Critically evaluating the respective rights and interests of parents, children and the state it concludes that parents who opt to home educate should be required to register with local authorities. At the same time it argues that attempts to evaluate the content of home education can not be considered in isolation of broader political agendas and that the policy dilemmas confronting the forthcoming review touch upon complex questions about the meaning of education in a liberal democratic society [abstract, p. 155]. “Domestic [in the United Kingdom] and international law, in particular the UNCRC, all emphasise that the child’s right to education is fundamental and make clear that taking the ostrich approach would represent the state’s failure to comply with its own obligations to fulfil such a right. Moreover, while the law recognises the importance of respecting parents’ views, parents must also recognise that their children have rights independent of their own. It follows that parents who choose to home educate must acknowledge the legitimate interest of LAs, acting as the agents of the state, to monitor their provision. Parents who home educate are not simply performing a private duty but also a public function. For all these reasons the case for compulsory registration is logical, legitimate and compelling. But it is important to emphasise that this argument in no way suggests that home education, per se, is in any way less valid than school attendance. Both are equally capable of providing, or failing to provide, ‘efficient education’ – however this is defined. Compulsory registration alone would not adequately clarify the role of LAs and parents. Clearer guidance, arguably more than new statutory powers, are required to reassure LAs that access to the child and to the home are not simply legitimate requests. For it is hard to see how an LA can comply with its duties without seeing the child – whether these duties are premised on the educational or welfare needs of the child. Attempts to distinguish the two may impose a restrictive and artificial view of child development. The manner in which LAs carry out their duties is, of course, crucial and the current DCSF Guidance rightly emphasises the importance of developing supportive engagements with parents. In this respect much can be learned from good practice in various parts of the country. For this to be possible, however, adequate resources are required. There are grounds for asserting that where parents opt to home educate it should not create an additional burden on already overstretched LA education budgets. But, equally, one can argue that the corollary of requiring parents to acknowledge the public function of education is that the state accepts its own financial responsibilities. Indeed, in a context of increased support for diversity in education, increasing numbers of faith schools and state regulation of independent education more generally, one of the anomalies of home education is its current lack of publicly funded support. Such dilemmas make clear that home education can not be considered in isolation of broader political agendas. This is most acute in the context of defining ‘efficient education’. Making clear that this should include basic skills, as a minimum, is important and should be stated in new guidance. But civic education is far more problematic, both in theory and in practice. In this respect, home education poses not simply administrative problems but raises questions about both the meaning and purpose of education in a society based on liberal democratic principles and the role of the child in that process. The recent consultation process and forthcoming review may reflect the Government’s desire to resolve some of these issues. Alternatively it may, as is sometimes the case, simply be a way of forestalling making difficult decisions. If so, it may result in a continuation of the present situation, whereby the drawing of difficult lines is left to LAs and home educators – to negotiate in a localised, diverse and ad hoc fashion. Such an approach would be unsatisfactory given that home education is not just increasing but a phenomenon that has been described as a ‘quiet revolution’. The way in which it is perceived and regulated indicates how society views not only those engaged in the process, but also itself [p. 183-184].”
Montana Education Association 1989a, March 31 & April 1 Delegate Assembly New Business Item #3. Helena, MT. Opinion about home education
Montana Education Association 1989b, April 27 Letter from Eric Feaver, President of Montana Education Association, to Danita Hane. Helena, MT: Montana Education Association. Opinion about home education
Montana Education Association 1994 The 1994-95 MEA [Montana Education Association] leaders handbook. Helena, MT: Author. home education, teachers union, policy, public schools "The Montana Education Association believes home schooling programs cannot provide the child with [sic] comprehensive education experience. Pursuant to Montana law, the association further believes home schools must annually report their existence and conform with all other Montana laws that generally or specifically speak to home schools. The association opposes any attempt home schools might make to access certain public school curricular, cocurricular, and extracurricular programs and/or any attempt to receive public funding of the home school experience," Resolution E-9
Montana Human Rights Network 1999 So … what’s the deal with this Home schooling? Human Rights Network News, p. 9. homeschooling, statism, policy, law The Montana Human Rights Network (1999) was fighting for the state, rather than parents, to have more control over home-educated children. “The Network board has been very concerned about the so-called parents’ rights movement which advocates the idea that parents have absolute power [control] over children” (p. 9).
Montana Office of Public Instruction 1995, February 28 Letter written by Pat Wade, program assistant, to Brian Ray. Helena, MT: Author. home education, population growth, numbers States that the estimated number of registered students attending home schools was 1,957 in 1992-93, 2,334 in 1993-94, and 2,910 in 1994-95.
Montes, Guillermo 2006 Do parental reasons to homeschool vary by grade? Evidence from the National Household Education Survey, 2001. Home School Researcher 16(4), 11-17. home schooling, homeschooling, reasons, motivation, peer-reviewed In the recently released National Household Education Survey 2001 homeschooled families were surveyed again both in terms of their demographic characteristics and the reasons for homeschooling. Using this new data source, two research questions that have not been studied before with a nationally representative data set are investigated: 1. Do parents who homeschool children in early childhood (K-3rd grade) do so for different reasons than those who homeschool children in later grades? 2. Do the demographic characteristics of families who choose to homeschool children in early childhood (K-3rd grade) differ from those who homeschool older children? In general, younger and older homeschooled students are educated at home for the same reasons: parents believe they can provide them a better education (47%) and for religious reasons (41%). However, younger homeschooled students are twice as likely as their older counterparts to be educated at home because the parents object to what the school teaches. Younger homeschooled students are three times as likely to be homeschooled as a way to develop character and morality than older homeschoolers. These findings deserve closer scrutiny. The secondary analyses showed that about half of the families who object to what is taught in schools do not identify religious reasons for homeschooling their K-3rd grade child. Similarly, about 60% of the families who stated that a reason to homeschool was to develop character in their children did not identify religious reasons for homeschooling. Consequently, some parents may be objecting to non-religious content in schools.
Montes, Guillermo 2015 The social and emotional health of homeschooled students in the United States: A population-based comparison with publicly schooled students based on the National Survey of Children’s Health, 2007. Home School Researcher, 31(1), 1-9. https://www.nheri.org/home-school-researcher-the-social-and-emotional-health-of-homeschooled-students-in-the-united-states-a-population-based-comparison-with-publicly-schooled-students-based-on-the-national-survey-of-child/ behavior problems, social skills, socialization, participation in community, health survey, homeschooling, home education, social competence, emotional intelligence, National Survey of Children’s Health, United States, causal-comparative, peer-reviewed Retrieved March 13, 2020 from https://www.nheri.org/home-school-researcher-the-social-and-emotional-health-of-homeschooled-students-in-the-united-states-a-population-based-comparison-with-publicly-schooled-students-based-on-the-national-survey-of-child/ “[Abstract] Although there is substantial research on homeschooling and its correlates, much of the research has used samples that are likely to suffer from self-selection biases... In this article, we use the National Survey of Children’s Health (NSCH) 2007, a large survey collected by the US government to monitor the health of American children. Because the primary intent of the NSCH was not to study homeschooling but the health of American children it is likely that the degree of self-selection into the survey because of homeschooling is negligible. The purpose of this study was to determine if homeschooled students differed in social competencies and behavior problems or in their likelihood to participate in community activities compared to publicly schooled students on a U.S. population basis. Generally, this study failed to detect statistically significant differences between both groups in the NSCH Social Competencies scales both social skills and behavior problems subscales), in items measuring social competencies, behavior problems, or depressed mood, or in overall participation in community activities, including paid work. Thus, homeschooled students are not at risk for socialization problems in the U.S. There were three minor exceptions: homeschooled children were less likely to participate in sports, and were reported as less likely to “argue too much” or “care about doing well in school” by their parent. We note that the “care for school” item was worded in a culturally insensitive manner for the homeschool population and could be interpreted ambiguously by families who homeschool as either caring for formal schooling or caring for educational work in the homeschooling context. Thus, differences in this item must be interpreted with caution” (p. 1). “In this article, we use the National Survey of Children’s Health (NSCH) 2007, a large survey collected by the US government to monitor the health of American children. Because the primary intent of the NSCH was not to study homeschooling but the health of American children it is likely that the degree of self-selection into the survey because of homeschooling is negligible. The purpose of this study was to determine if homeschooled students differed in social competencies and behavior problems or in their likelihood to participate in community activities compared to publicly schooled students on a U.S. population basis” (p. 1). “The strength of this study is that it uses a nationally representative data set that was collected for purposes other than homeschooling research, thus self-selection biases into the study based on homeschooling status are likely to be very small” (p. 6). “The sample had 1,530 homeschooled students and 54,320 publicly schooled students [all of ages 6 to 17]. Because the focus of this article was comparisons between publicly schooled students and homeschooled students all subsequent analyses excluded privately schooled students. Demographic Differences Among Groups [heading, then paragraph break] Table 1 shows the demographic characteristics of the sample by schooling status. Both groups of students were comparable by age of the child (F=1.17, ns), and sex (F=1.63, ns). Minority students (15.6% vs. 28.6%, p≤.01) and Hispanic students (6.6% vs. 20.4%, p≤.01) were less likely to be homeschooled. Population estimates were that more than 150,000 minority and 66,000 Hispanic students in the 6-17 age range were homeschooled in the US in 2007. Homeschooling households were more likely to have a parent who had education beyond high school (77.7% vs. 64.8%, p≤.01). Marginally significant, households that homeschooled were more likely to be at or below 200% the federal poverty line (65.1% vs. 58.2%, p=.05), and were less likely to be affluent households, defined as at or above 400% FPL, compared to publicly schooled households (18.8% vs. 27.9%, p≤.01). In sum, homeschooled students were likely to live in less affluent white non-Hispanic households than their publicly schooled counterparts” (p. 4). “Parents of homeschooled students reported their child argued too much less frequently than parents of publicly schooled students (51.0% vs. 62.5%, p≤.01). This result persisted after controlling for the covariates of table 1 [included sex, age, household education, minority status, Hispanic ethnicity, and both the poverty and affluence variables as covariates, p. 4] in multivariate logistic regression (Adjusted Odds Ratio (AOR) 0.61, p≤.01) There were no statistically significant differences in any of the other problem behavior items indicating that the likelihood of parents classifying their child as bullies, disobedient, stubborn, worthless or depressed was unrelated to type of schooling. ….. Both groups were statistically indistinguishable in five out of the six items (respect for adults, getting along with other children, trying to understand other people’s feelings, trying to resolve conflicts, and completing homework). Homeschooled students were less likely to be rated as caring about doing well in school than publicly schooled students (80.8% vs. 86.8%, p≤.05), a result that persisted in multivariate analyses (AOR=0.57, P≤.05). ….. There were no statistically significant differences in the NSCH SCS behavior problem subscale … Table 3 shows the percentage of students by various types of community participation activities. Homeschooled students were less likely to have participated in sports teams or taken sport classes in the last 12 months than publicly schooled students (45.9% vs. 56.9%, p≤.01) but were more likely to participate in afterschool clubs and organizations (62.3% vs. 55.5%, p≤.05). Among those students who did not participate in either sports or clubs, homeschooled students were more likely to have attended in organized events or activities (36.4% vs. 23.9%, p≤.05)” (p. 4). “Homeschooled students were equally likely to participate in volunteer work or community service in school, church or community than publicly schooled students (83.0% vs. 76.3%, ns). The overall participation of both groups was quite similar (87.8% vs. 84.0%, ns). It is notable that more than 8 in 10 homeschooled students were engaged in outside activities. Multivariate analyses confirmed the results on sports (AOR = .57, p≤.01), but not those in afterschool activities (AOR=1.19, ns), or events (AOR= 1.57, ns). Finally, both groups were equally likely to be employed during the week prior to the survey (42.7% vs. 40.3%, ns)” (p. 6). “There were no detectable differences in the NSCH 2003 social competencies and behavior problem scales and indeed both groups had remarkably similar overall scores. Similarly, item analysis discovered that there were no detectable differences in the majority of the social competencies and behavior problem items between both groups. With regards to participation in activities, homeschooled students had similar overall participation as publicly schooled students” (p. 7). “First, homeschooled students were substantially less likely than publicly schooled students to be rated as arguing too much. This is somewhat remarkable because homeschooled students spend substantially more time with their parents than publicly schooled students. Homeschooled students must negotiate with their parents an additional set of complex educational tasks (e.g. curriculum, instructional practice, homework, balance between educational work and community activities, etc.). Thus, it was a positive finding to find out that they are able to accomplish these additional complex educational tasks and additional interaction time and yet argue less. The second item where significant differences were detected had to do with whether the student “cares about doing well in school.” Unfortunately, the wording of the item prevents us from reaching a definite conclusion because it is insensitive to the homeschool culture. ….. Third, homeschooled students participated less in organized sports than publicly schooled students. This is not entirely surprising because in the US sports are organized mostly by schools. ….. The lack of detectable differences in the other items is remarkable for two reasons: first, homeschooled households were on average less affluent than publicly schooled households and lower income is associated with increased behavior problems and lower social competencies. Second, compared with parents of publicly schooled students, parents of homeschooled children spend more time with their children and thus have greater opportunity to observe many of the behaviors and social [p. 7 ends] competencies asked in the items. So one could expect a greater frequency of behavior problems simply because of greater opportunity to both exhibit the behavior and observe it. Similarly, in some items related to educational work one would expect homeschooling parents would be “tougher” simply because they have better information than parents of publicly schooled students” (p. 8). “In sum, this study corroborates previous research summarized by Medlin (2013) that found no reason to be concerned about the socialization of homeschooled children in the United States. We concur with Medlin’s suggestion that future research should focus on the process of socialization in the homeschooling context instead of outcomes. In the larger context of arguments against homeschooling both from educators and policy makers, this research suggests that opponents need not be concerned about the socialization of homeschooled children and are either unfamiliar with or choose to ignore the cumulative empirical evidence (Ray, 2013)” (p. 8). Design is causal-comparative or explanatory or predictive. Peer-reviewed.
Montessori, Maria 1956 The child in the family: The basic principles of the world famous Montessori method.” New York, NY: Avon Books. education, Montessori method, pedagogy, philosophy
Montgomery, Linda R. 1989 The effect of home schooling on the leadership skills of home schooled students. Home School Researcher, 5(1), 1-10. home education, leadership, research, extracurricular activities, socialization, social development, causal-comparative Establishes that pre-college students' involvement in extracurricular activities and leadership experiences are good predictors of leadership in adulthood then compares home educated and conventionally schooled students in terms of such involvement; in a sense, causal-comparative. Subjects included parents and children from 50 urban, rural, and suburban home school families; 55 parents and 87 students, ages 10 to 21, were interviewed. “From the results of this study it would appear that home schooling is not generally repressive of a student's potential leadership, and may in fact, nurture leadership at least as well as does the conventional system” [p. 8]. “Third, home schooled adolescents are not isolated from social interaction with their peer group nor denied participation in a variety of at-home and out-of-home organized group activities. These students, as a group, are involved in teaching younger siblings, 4H Clubs, Boy/Girl Scouts and similar youth clubs, church youth groups and church responsibilities (such as assisting in the nursery) teaching Sunday school classes, and assisting with summer youth programs; nearly 80% of them are running their own businesses, such as paper routes, lawn care, taking care of neighbors' houses in their absence, babysitting, and so forth; over half take on volunteer or community service projects, such as being a Candy Striper in a hospital, visiting people in nursing homes, doing chores or babysitting for needy families, assisting in various ways at the Pacific Science Center, and a host of similar such activities; …” [p. 9]. Several patterns stand out as characteristic of home schooling, including, “First, home schooling students have as their models parents who are leaders and who demonstrate on an ongoing basis those traits that stand out in the literature as important leader traits ... Second, the message that home schooling children receive from their parents, both explicitly and implicitly, is that they are special people, valued and capable members of the family, cut from extraordinary cloth” [p. 8], “Third, home schooled adolescents are not isolated from social interaction with their peer group nor denied participation in a variety of at-home and out-of-home organized group activities. ... there were a number of students who reported having increased social contact and group participation because school required less of their time” [p. 9]. Concludes that the home educated are very involved in activities that predict leadership and home education “... may in fact, nurture leadership at least as well as does the conventional system” [p. 8].
Montgomery, Linda Ruth 1989 The effect of home schooling on the leadership skills of home schooled students. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation at Seattle University, Seattle WA.
Moo, G. Gregory 1999 Power grab: How the NEA is betraying our children. Washington, DC: Regnery Publishing, Inc. teachers union, education reform, politics, sociology, philsophy Discusses the agenda of the National Education Association (NEA) and provides a guide for teachers, parents, and communities to strengthen their voices in returning education to benefitting children. Shows that much of the taxpayers' money intended for the education of children and youth never makes it to the classrooms but instead ends up filling the NEA's coffers and promoting a liberal social agenda.
Mooney, Carolyn J. 1987 Politicians, schoolteachers, and education officials air ideas at commission sessions, but consensus is a rare commodity. The Chronicle of Higher Education, 33(45), 15,17 (July 22). Report on the annual meeting of the Education Commission of the States, a non-profit organization, in Denver, CO. Many topics discussed, including home schooling. "Later, at a breakfast meeting for state legislators, lawmakers from a number of states, including South Carolina and Minnesota, lamented the difficulties their legislatures had confronted while trying to establish controversial rules for parents seeking to teach their children at home. [new paragraph] One South Carolina legislator estimated that 5 per cent to the state's parents would prefer to educate their children at home. [new paragraph] Unfortunately, she added, not all of those parents felt they needed a college or even a high-school education to do so" (p. 17). Policy.
Moore, E. Ray 2002 Let my children go: Why parents mus remove their children from public schools now. Columbia SC: Gilead Media.
Moore, Glynnis Leigh 2002 Home schooling in South Africa as an alternative to institutionalized education. Master’s (M.E.), University of South Africa. homeschooling, home education, reasons, socialization, South Africa, stress, burnout Uses qualitative research methods. Offers limited recommendations regarding homeschooling based on findings. Literature review is not very good, and rather not current.
Moore, Raymond S. 1979 America's greatest educational system. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED192873). Educational Environment, Educational Quality, Educational Responsibility, Family Influence, Parent Responsibility, Public Schools America's greatest educational system is the family in the home.
Moore, Raymond S. 1982 Research and common sense: Therapies for our homes and schools. Teachers College Record, 84(2), 355-377. early childhood education, formal schooling, age Discusses research on early childhood education, importance of interaction with mother, lack of necessity of formal education [schooling] for the very young.
Moore, Raymond S. 1984 The cradle and the gap. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED250776). Early Childhood Education, Educational Change, Educational Improvement, Home Schooling, School Entrance Age Public schools take children away from the home too early. The home is still the best place to educate a child.
Moore, Raymond S. 1985 American schools: Some proven solutions. Family Research Council, 515 Second St., N. E., Washington, D. C 20002. Prepared by author for U. S. Secretary of Education meeting with educational leaders on June 24, 1985. Considers research on early childhood education. "We found genuine risk in enrolling children in formal school programs before ages 8 to 10 unless they were handicapped or acutely disadvantaged and required structured remedial programs (p. 3). Suggests that boys are at a greater risk than girls in formal education. Advantages of home schooling for the young are considered.
Moore, Raymond S. 1985 It depends on your aim. Phi Delta Kappan, 67(1), 62-64. early childhood education, formal schooling, age, academic achievement Early childhood education. Article is a reply to Parsons' article, p. 61-62. "And reviews by the Hewitt Research Foundation of more than 8,000 studies have failed to turn up any replicable research suggesting that normal children should be schooled before age 8" (p. 63). Comments that the Perry Preschool Project "... has for years focused more attention on the home (through weekly home visits) than has the typical early childhood education program" (p. 63).
Moore, Raymond S., & Moore, D. R. 1972 The dangers of early schooling. Harper's Magazine, 245, 58-62. Early childhood education.
Moore, Raymond S., & Moore, Dennis R. 1990 When delay isn't procrastination. In Continuing issues in early childhood education. Columbus, OH: Merrill Pub. Co. home education
Moore, Raymond S., & Moore, Dorothy N. 1975 Better late than early. New York, NY: Reader's Digest Press, 236 p. Topic is early childhood education.
Moore, Raymond S., & Moore, Dorothy N. 1979 School can wait: the natural child, the first years. Provo, UT: Brigham Young University Press, 281 p. With other authors: T. Joseph Willey, Dennis R. Moore, and D. Kathleen Kordenbrock. Early childhood education.
Moore, Raymond S., & Moore, Dorothy N. 1981 Home-grown kids. Beaverton, OR: Word Books.
Moore, Raymond S., & Moore, Dorothy N. 1982 Home-spun schools. Beaverton, OR: Word Books.
Moore, Raymond S., & Moore, Dorothy N. 1983 Better late than early. Beaverton, OR: Words.
Moore, Raymond S., & Moore, Dorothy N. 1984 Home style teaching: A handbook for parents and teachers. Waco, TX: Word Books Publishers, 204 p. Becoming a good teacher, teaching secrets not commonly practiced, learning theory, professional relationships, and appendices with resource information, civil rights, and well-known people educated at home.
Moore, Raymond S., & Moore, Dorothy N. 1986 When education becomes abuse: A different look at the mental health of children. Journal of School Health, 56(2), 73-75.
Moore, Raymond S., & Moore, Dorothy N. 1988 Home School Burnout. Brentwood, TN: Wolgemuth and Hyatt, Publishers.
Moore, Raymond S., & Moore, Dorothy N. 1990 Q: What do you really mean when you say no formal academics until ages 8 to 10.... The Moore Report, 2(4), 3. Moore's give their answer.
Moore, Raymond S., & Moore, Dorothy N. c. 1984 Do we really want preschool for all of our children? Washougal, WA: Hewitt Research Foundation, 6 p. Early childhood education.
Moore, Raymond S., Moon, R. D., & Moore, D. 1972 The California report: Early schooling for all? Phi Delta Kappan, 53, 615-621, 677. Early childhood education.
Moore, Raymond S., Moore, D. N., Willey, T. J., Moore, D. R., & Kordenbrock 1979 School can wait. Provo, UT: Brigham Young University Press. Early childhood education.
Moore, Raymond S., with Dennis R. Moore 1990 When delay isn't procrastination. In Continuing Issues In Early Childhood Education. Merrill Pub. Columbus OH. Studies showing the benefits of delaying structured education.) research, cognitive processes, skill development
Moran, Courtenay E. 2011 How to regulate homeschooling: Why history supports the theory of parental choice. University of Illinois Law Review, vol. 2011, 1061-1094. Retrieved July 11, 2012 from http://illinoislawreview.org/wp-content/ilr-content/articles/2011/3/Moran.pdf. http://illinoislawreview.org/wp-content/ilr-content/articles/2011/3/Moran.pdf homeschooling, home education, law, regulation, policy, philosophy “This Note explores the competing theories that have informed past and current homeschooling regulation. The author begins by chronicling the history of state education regulation and the advent of homeschooling. This history demonstrates that critics of homeschooling regulation base their theory on the incorrect assertion that education has historically been governed by parental choice. This history also shows that some past state regulations had the troubling objective of forcing minority groups to conform to the majority conception of education. Drawing upon this background, the author concludes that state regulation of homeschooling is appropriate but must be limited in nature. If state regulations serve to objectively and unobtrusively assess the adequacy of a homeschooled child’s education without dictating the methodology, then states can fulfill their role of providing adequate education without infringing on parents’ interests in their children’s education” [abstract, p. 1061]. Presents an overview of history of state regulation of education and many court cases. Never mentions research done during past 30 years that addresses whether there is any relationship between state control of homeschooling and homeschool student academic achievement (and that the research finds no relationship). Shows that trend is for U.S. to decrease regulation of homeschooling: “Ultimately, states are far from uniform in how they regulate homeschooling. What seems to be the common trend, however, is implementing little to no oversight at all. Nine states do not even require notice of the choice to homeschool, and many states require notice and nothing more. The scope of permissible state regulation will be explored in the rest of this Note, but it is clear that most states are abandoning their obligation to ensure that all children receive an adequate education.88” (p. 1071). Claims, “The generally accepted purpose of education provides the best answer. [note 264] There is a general consensus that the primary purpose of education is to provide children with basic knowledge, particularly in subjects like reading, writing, and mathematics [note 265]” [p. 1092] but this is author’s basic flaw; to claim an unsupported claim about a “general consensus” does not convince the reader of the consensus nor does it convince the reader that a general consensus about the purpose of education would merit State control of private home-based education, or private institutional schooling, for that matter. Author makes the serious error of ignoring the fact that the purpose of education for Christians parents is to bring up their children in the nurture and admonition of the Lord to the glory of God, which will likely include things like reading, writing, and arithmetic, under the authority of parents and not the State. Author recommends: “These objective and unobtrusive regulations would first require that parents notify their local school district of their intent to homeschool their children. This will provide knowledge to the school district and to the state that those children are receiving some form of education. The state should also require that certain mandatory areas be taught, like reading, writing, mathematics, and those annually tested by state standardized tests. These regulations should not, however, dictate the manner in which these subjects should be taught. Again, this will ensure that the generally accepted purpose of education, knowledge in basic subjects, is taught and also provide parents with the flexibility to determine how to teach these subjects. Finally, homeschooled children should be required to take the same statewide standardized tests as all other children” [p. 1093]. Many scripturally-minded Christians philosophically do not allow for authority over their children’s education to the State, unless they place them in State-run schools. Author implicitly proceeds from a statist and case-law-is-god perspective without admitting such. With the following conclusion, author still fails to clearly state that she accepts and promotes the philosophical/religious worldviews of statism and majority-control democratism as preferable to the worldview of biblical scripturalism and appears to err with the fallacy of moderation: “As more parents choose to homeschool their children, the desire to exercise more governmental control will undoubtedly become more tempting. A majority of Americans would probably agree that there is great benefit in ensuring that all children receive a comprehensive liberal education, but history has taught us that the cost of majoritarian control over education is too great. Although the state can and should ensure children receive an adequate education, even at home, once those requirements are met, parents should have the right to determine the nature of their children’s education” [p. 1094].
Moreau, Kathi 2012 Specific differences in the educational outcomes of those students who are home schooled vs. students in a traditional school setting. Master’s (M.A.) thesis, Northern Michigan University. homeschooling, review of resaerch, academic achievement, socialization Not original research. Review of research. “The outcomes to be reviewed include social skills, educational attainment, standardized testing results, and a look to the future of both educational methods” (p. 6).
Morgan, Phyllis T. & Rodriguez, Roy C. 1988, Fall Home school parents: A rural survey. Rural Educator, 10(1), 15-18. Home Schooling, Parent Attitudes, Parent School Relationship, Rural Education A report involving 40 rural and small-town New Mexico families which indicates that parents home-taught their children mainly to shelter them from the negative influences that they felt were found within the public education environment.
Morgan, Richard 2003, January 17 Homeschooling: Growing force in higher education. Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved 1/22/03 online http://www.hslda.org/docs/news/hslda/200301/200301161.asp. http://www.hslda.org/docs/news/hslda/200301/200301161.asp home education, college admissions, policy “The problem, the colleges argued, is that the Higher Education Act, which governs most federal student aid programs, restricts colleges from admitting students unless they have obtained a "recognized equivalent of a high school diploma." As a result, many colleges refuse to admit home schooled students unless they hold a General Education Development diploma or pass a federally approved test showing that they have an "ability to benefit" from a college education. To ease these restrictions, advocates for home schooling enlisted a heavy hitter: the Bush administration. In April, the Education Department issued guidance that would make it easier for colleges to admit home schooled students.” Article confuses issues of fair and equitable college admission standards with issues regarding laws about federal funding and student financial aid. Good examples of fundamental mistrust of homeschool parents and graduates and anti-homeschool philosophy are in the reporting and in quotes of college admission officers. For example: “‘What's to keep the parent from pushing the kid through high school, not teaching them anything, and then dropping them on society?’ asks Perry J. Diehm, associate director of financial aid at MidAmerica Nazarene University in Kansas.”
Morris, Amanda Sheffield; Jespersen, Jens E.; Cosgrove, Kelly T.; Ratliff, Erin L.; & Kerr, Kara L. 2020 Parent education: What we know and moving forward for greatest impact. Family Relations: Interdisciplinary Journal of Applied Family Science, 69(3), 520-542. parent education, barriers, parent support, support groups, child achievement, academic achievement, social development, emotional development Parents need support in learning to and in being good parents. “The available literature on parent education is growing rapidly. With numerous sources indicating that quality parenting is one of the best predictors of one’s developmental trajectory across the lifespan, it has become increasingly necessary to identify the most effective programs and tools for supporting parenting skills and promoting positive child development. In this article, we describe key aspects of the best evidence-based practices in the current parent education literature, including program implementation, program content, common themes, and an overview of some of the most promising parent education programs available for early childhood, middle childhood, and adolescence. Conclusions and suggestions for future work and applications are also discussed” (p. 520). “Research indicates that quality parenting is one of the best predictors of successful development, and the parent-child relationship sets the foundation for children’s learning [academic achievement], social and emotional development, as well as healthy adult relationships (Morris et al., 2013; Morris et al., 2017; Vandell et al., 2010). Increasingly, studies point also to caregiving influences of biology and health (e.g., epigenetics research, brain imaging studies) suggesting the critical role that parenting plays in the lives of families across generations, as well as the devastating effects of harsh and neglectful parenting on neurological development (Hays-Grudo & Morris, 2020; Teicher & Samson, 2016). Thus, it is critical for parents to have basic caregiving knowledge and access to high-quality parenting programs that are evidence based” (p. 520; p. 1 of PDF). Present that support of parents in groups, courses, and classes is important in helping parents become better parents, and better parenting is associated with higher academic achievement. “Studies have found that barriers [to attending programming], such as transportation and childcare, limit caregivers’ ability to attend parenting groups, particularly among low-income [p. 3 of PDF ends] and high-risk families (see Beasley et al., 2018). Other barriers to consider include the possible stigma associated with participating in a “parenting class” or a reluctance to invest time or resources into an unfamiliar experience” (p. 3-4). “Group leaders who are able to establish a comfortable environment and build flexible, supporting, and caring relationships with parents keep participants engaged in programs for longer periods of time, even across different cultural groups (Beasley et al., 2018)” (p. 4 of PDF)).
Morris, Barbara M. The Barbara M. Morris Report. P.O. Box 756, Upland, CA 91786. Bibliography of materials critical of the public schools from the religious right; several titles on home schooling.
Morris, Barbara M. 1979 Change agents in the schools: Destroy your children, betray your country. Upland, CA: The Barbara M. Morris Report. public schooling, change, values education, indoctrination, philosophy, teacher training, social change, parental involvement, indoctrination “A change agent is a person, organization, or institution that changes or helps to change the beliefs, values, attitudes or behavior of people without their knowledge or consent” [p. 15]. So, what are government [i.e., state, public] schools? They are administrative government agencies that exist to promote change. What kinds of change? Social change, political change, economic change, cultural change, religious change, change in our form of government. Total change. But specifically, change from what to what? Change from a Christian, sovereign nation to a Humanist/Socialist interdependent nation-state in a dictatorship euphemistically called a “global community”, with “world citizens” content with enslavement” [p. 17]. Why aren’t more parents aware of the “change in students the curriculum is intended to bring about” [quoting from a change agent]? Because they are not aware of the mechanics and facets of the change process - - the use of misleading “educationese”; the federally funded curricula; the federally funded programs that transform teachers into zealous missionary change agents. Most of all, parents are not aware of the “change in students the curriculum is intended to bring about” because they really don’t want to know what is happening behind those impenetrable closed classroom doors. If they “invaded” the alien territory of the classroom where they are not wanted, they might be forced y conscience to act upon what they see and hear. Sadly, many parents would rather not fight, not even for the welfare of their own children” [p. 68]. “Values clarification is the most popular approach to values education. . . It professes to be concerned primarily with the process of valuing. And this it can be made to appear [p. 100 ends] non-controversial and morally neutral. But as much as proponents of “values clarification” might abhor the McGuffey Readers, they are proffering a contemporary equivalent. The process of values clarification is not morally neutral but comes laden with a particular set of suppositions and assumptions” [p. 101] [is a quote from: National Endowment for the Humanities, Division of Education Programs, Education Projects Program. (1974, November). The ethical quest in a democratic society. Washington, DC: Author.]
Morris, Henry M. 1983 Education for the real world (2nd ed.). San Diego, CA: Master Books, 285 pp. philosophy, education, religion, family responsibility, home education Philosophy of education from Christian perspective, emphasis on God as creator.
Morrison, Kristan 2015 Homeschooling as an act of conscientious objection. Journal of Thought, Fall-Winter, 33-56.
Morse, Philip S., & Brand, Lillia B 1981 Home-style Learning. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
Mother Earth News 1980, July/August Plowboy Interview. John Holt: Teach your own children . . . at home. http://www.motherearthnews.com/Livestock-and-Farming/1980-07-01/The-Plowboy-Interview.aspx http://www.bloomington.in.us/~learn/Holt.htm home education, unschooling, philosophy, John Holt July/August Issue Number 64, p. 11-16. Also retrieved January 28, 2008 from http://www.motherearthnews.com/Livestock-and-Farming/1980-07-01/The-Plowboy-Interview.aspx. Also, retrieved December 3, 2007 from http://www.bloomington.in.us/~learn/Holt.htm. “PLOWBOY: What message did you try to convey with [your book] How Children Fail? HOLT: To put it simply, I pointed out that children do poorly in school because they're bored with the meaningless work . . . scared of being punished or humiliated . . . and confused by the fact that most teaching progresses from abstract concepts to concrete examples instead of-as would be more sensible the other way around. In essence I'd realized, from observing and teaching, that school is a place where children learn to be stupid! Most all youngsters are-by nature smart, curious, and eager to learn. In fact-as I pointed out in my second book, How Children Learn babies are such active, skillful seekers of knowledge that they learn more in the first five years of their lives than most older folks ever do in ten! PLOWBOY: Did you propose any reforms that you felt would help children learn? HOLT: I suggested we simply provide young people with schools where there are a lot of interesting things to look at and work with . . . but that we let the children learn in their own ways. If they have questions, answer the questions. If they want to know where to look for something, show them where to look. PLOWBOY: In other words, you feel that youngsters should choose what to learn rather than having the sequence or path of instruction determined for them. That idea represents a 180° turn from traditional education. HOLT: It certainly does, but it works: Students who are placed in an environment where they feel safe to explore and receive help when they need it will do fine. And I thought, at the time, that once I and others-like Jim Herndon, who wrote How to Survive in Your Native s Land . . . and George Dennison, the author of The Lives of Children showed enough people that fact, then surely everyone would want to try the "new" way of teaching. That's not what happened, of course. PLOWBOY: Weren't there lots of alterna- [p. 12 ends] tive [alternative] programs and open schools formed at that time? HOLT: True, similar ideas did become fashionable for a while. But-and it took me years to figure out this "but"-most of this country's so-called innovative education projects, and there were never very many for all the talk, were begun solely to get some of the money the U.S. government was offering for such programs. When that federal money ran out, the programs stopped” [p. 13]
Moynes, Riley E. 1984, Fall Megatrends and education's future. Education Canada, 24(3), 4-8. Administrative Principles, Computer Literacy, Information Science, Interpersonal Competence, Literacy Students should be trained to handle data structures using critical thinking skills.
Mrozek, Andrea 2012, August 30 Nurturing children: Why “early learning” doesn’t help. EReview: Latest Developments in Family Friendly Research, 12(18). Retrieved 7/11/13 from http://www.imfcanada.org/sites/default/files/ereview_august_30_12_0.pdf. http://www.imfcanada.org/sites/default/files/ereview_august_30_12_0.pdf early childhood education, socialization, attachment, homeschooling, research, Canada Homeschooling is not a significant focus of this paper but author refers to some homeschool research, using it to support the concept that children do not need institutional schooling for children to be properly socialized. “Ironically, some who advocate for homeschooling do so in order for proper socialization to occur” (p. 4). Author appears friendly toward homeschooling. “Children should start attending school later, not earlier, Canadian development psychologist Dr. Gordon Neufeld reveals. “Early learning” programs for young children have no benefits for kids, he adds. So why are governments running down the opposite track?” (p. 1).
Muchmore, James A. 2005, April 12 Michigan school superintendents' attitudes and practices regarding home schooling. Presentation at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, April 11-15, 2005. http://convention2.allacademic.com/index.php?click_key=1&publication_id=2225&cmd=Search+Load+Publication&PHPSESSID=4001225fce364718faabc664e9958b74 home education, research, public school, attitudes “The purpose of this paper is to update and expand a large-scale study on home schooling that was conducted in the early 1990s. A survey was mailed to every school superintendent in Michigan, with a response rate of 53%. Findings indicated that the superintendents’ attitudes toward cooperating with home school parents fell into three main groups. A sizable number took the position that if parents opted out of the public schools, then they were on their own; the school system owed them nothing. However, most of the superintendents wanted to cooperate with homeschoolers, and said they would assist if asked. The most common service provided to homeschoolers by the public schools were non-core classes such as band, chorus, and physical education. Nearly one-fifth of all the superintendents indicated that home schooled students would be allowed to enroll in any course offered by the district. Information gleaned through this study can be of vital importance as school officials attempt to come to grips with the growing number of home schools. Faced with a broad range of perceived attacks on public education--including the charter school movement, school vouchers, the takeover of Detroit’s public schools, and testing and accountability issues--it is encouraging that most of Michigan’s superintendents have not “written off” home schooling as another drain on their limited resources. This study suggests that there is great potential for homeschoolers and public school officials to collaborate in benefiting the learning of all children” (abstracte, retrieved 4/18/05 online http://convention2.allacademic.com/index.php?click_key=1&publication_id=2225&cmd=Search+Load+Publication&PHPSESSID=4001225fce364718faabc664e9958b74.
Mueller, Richard J., & Brunetti, Dyan 1989, March Testing problems of home-schooled children. The Clearing House for the Contemporary Educator in Middle and Secondary Schools, 62(7), 325-326.
Muhammad, Nisa Islam 2000, March 10 Mother Clara Muhammad: An example of Black womanhood. Final Call. Retrieved 1/12/06 online http://www.finalcall.com/national/savioursday2k/mother_clara.htm . http://www.finalcall.com/national/savioursday2k/mother_clara.htm home education, black, African American, religion, Islam, history “In the 1930s and ’40s, few Black women ventured off the path dictated by their slave master’s children.  The behavior, conduct and demeanor of Black women was more than predictable. And then out of the wilderness of North American came Mother Clara Muhammad, the late wife of the Honorable Elijah Muhammad, and together they established the Nation of Islam in America. Mother Clara, born Nov. 2, 1899, in Georgia, was a deeply religious and devoted Black woman. She married then-Elijah Poole in Georgia in 1917.” They had eight children. “Often, Mother Clara demonstrated strength and courage in the face of  virulent opposition to the Nation of Islam. They took their children out of the public school system and became pioneers for home schooling [in the 1930s or 1940s?]. But then home schooling was illegal. She relentlessly continued to maintain her household and raise her children while her husband went to jail for the right to self-educate their children and as a conscientious objector to World War II and all wars entered into by white America.”
Mullarney, M. 1983 Anything school can do you can do better. Dublin, Ireland: Arlen House. or, Anything school can do you can do better: The story of a family who learned at home. London, UK: Fontan/Collins. A mother's account of her daily "lessons" with her eleven children when they were young; argues convincingly that home is the best place for early learning.
Mullen, Nancy 1983, June 6 Unschooling -- a learn-as-you-go experiment for some. Christian Science Monitor.
Mulyadi, Seto; Rahardjo, Wahyu; & Basuki, A.M. Heru 2016 The role of parent-child relationship, self-esteem, academic self-efficacy to academic stress. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 217, 603–608. Academic stress; Homeschooling students, homeschooling, socialization, social development “Abstract. Homeschooling students can experience academic stress. Parent-child relationship, self-esteem, and also academic self-efficacy are assumed as factors influencing the academic stress. Do parent-child relationship, self-esteem, and academic self-efficacy have effect simultaneously to homeschooling students’ self-regulated learning? The purpose of this study is to measure the influence of parent-child relationship, self-esteem, and academic self-efficacy to academic stress on homeschooling students. The direct and indirect effect can be seen from the empirical model when fit the data. Subjects are 87 homeschooling students in Tangerang. Academic stress constructed from Ang et.al. (2009 α = 0.875), academic self-efficacy constructed from Bandura (1997 α = 0.907), self-esteem constructed from Rosenberg (1965 α = 0.758), parent-child relationship constructed from Brook et.al. (2012 α = 0.875). Structural Equation Model is used to analyze the data. The empirical model has goodness of fit. It explains the influence of parent-child relationship, self-esteem, and academic self-efficacy to academic stress on homeschooling students. The result shows that parent-child relationship has no direct effect to academic stress or indirect effect through academic self-efficacy. On the other hand there is indirect effect from parent-child relationship to academic stress through self-esteem. Parent-child relationship, self-esteem, and academic self-efficacy are good predictors to homeschooling students’ academic stress. But parent-child relationship only effects students’ academic stress through self-esteem and not strong enough to effects academic stress through academic self-efficacy. At this point, parents play important role to build positive self-esteem related to the homeschooling activities.”
Mungeam, Frank, Highberger, Alison, & McQuade, Liza (Producers) 12/5/93 Town Hall. Portland, OR: KATU Television Channel 2 education, reform, public, private, home, philosophy, opinion ABC network affiliate). (Jeff Gianola, Town Hall host. Program was on public, private, and home schooling and their advantages and disadvantages. Guest Norma Paulus, Oregon Superintendent of Public Instruction said, "You must remember that public schools are what made America great." Guest Brian Ray presented research showing positive effects of home schooling.
Murphy, Joseph 2012 Homeschooling in America: Capturing and assessing the movement. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin, a Sage Company. home education, homeschooling, research, academic achievement, socialization, adulthood success, theory, explanation, survey of research, synthesis, review, reasons, motives, demographics, academic achievement, socialization, adulthood, college, research methods, methods, definition of homeschooling Reviews and synthesizes about 30 years of research on the homeschooling, home-education movement. Does a very fine job, one of the most balanced, fair, and least bias-loaded summaries and overviews of research on the topic. Author is respectful and circumspect commenting on what he classifies as “critics,” “advocates,” and “analysts” of homeschooling and research on homeschooling. Does a good job of using a variety of terms for homeschooling (e.g., home-based education). Provides a description or definition of what is and what is not homeschooling on pages 6-7: “Using this framework, a student is homeschooled when (1) funding for the student’s education comes from the family, not the government; (2) the service is provided by the parents, not state-funded (or privately financed) employees; and (3) regulation of the enterprise is internal to the family, not the responsibility of the government (or another entity such as a religious body). The closer one is to the family/parent end of the continuum on each of these three dimensions, the more robust is the homeschooling …” (p. 6). Appropriately criticizes researchers for not addressing “outcomes” related to some of the key reasons parents give for choosing to homeschool (e.g., worldview development, stronger and healthier family relationships, less peer-dependence for the children). Gives a relatively fair discussion of the limitations and delimitations of the studies to date. Clearly presents the line of thinking or logic theories (e.g., p. 128) of negative critics of parent-controlled home-based education in a way that these critics are often not willing to do. Gives elements of classical liberalism and American liberty thinking some evenhanded and positive treatment. Clearly states, for the record, “First, we know more than some analysts suggest we do,” and that “… we know a lot less than advocates of homeschooling would have us believe” (p. 140). Puts the “control” issue out in the clear light (p. 59-60 as certain authors such as Brian Ray have done on many occasions, e.g., the Ray & Eagleson quote on Murphy’s p. 59). Does sound and clear job of explaining parents’ motives for homeschooling (p. 75-79). Does a much better job than most scholars at explaining that public schools are religious, as are private “religious” schools and as are Christian homeschoolers but he should have made it even clearer. Christian homeschoolers who want a clearly biblically holistic education for their children are not repulsed by the “non-religious public schools” but by the reality that the public schools are clearly religious and that religion is antithetical to Christianity (cf., Carper & Hunt, 2007, The dissenting tradition in American education, chapter 9, “Homeschooling redivivus: Accommodating the Anabaptists of American education.” On the other hand, there are a few concerns about this book. Seems to imply in some ways, as do many other writers who philosophically and/or politically treat State (public) schools as if they are the right (correct) default setting and/or the standard by which all other forms of education/schooling should be measured? For example, author gives much non-conditioned discussion of homeschool parents pulling away or withdrawing from State schools (p. 130) when many (most?) of these parents over the past decade or more have never sent their children away to the State schools for the government to have them (or monies that go with them). Fortunately, author very briefly got to this when he wrote, “… (or do not enter) …” (p. 131). Also, author appears to think the liberal democratic welfare State in the U.S. has waned a lot over the past couple of decades or so but does not support this claim, especially in light of Americans having elected a very-left president in 2008 and re-electing him in 2012, with national debt continuing to escalate, voters continuing to elect socialists (whether Democrat or Republican) representatives, the nation (taxpayers) bailing out failed private corporations, record high percentages of Americans on food stamps and welfare, parents are putting about 87% of all U.S. children into clearly left-leaning tax-funded State public schools, and so forth. Finally, in a number of places author says the research on homeschooling to date has not been of “high quality” or there is a “… limited body of high-quality research studies …” (p. 145) when it appears he mostly likely means to convey that there is a limited number of (a) causal-comparative studies, (b) studies that were able to ensure representative samples of homeschoolers, or (c) studies that allow many firm conclusions about questions we would like answered, or, in another vein, say/write that most of the studies to date involve limitations that make solid empirical conclusions about X, Y, and/or Z homeschooling topics unreachable since a study/its publication is of high quality if the researcher carefully lays out a review of related literature, develops a conceptual or theoretical framework, clearly states the purpose of the study, carefully describes his/her methods, clearly explains the study’s limitations and delimitations, does a good job of presenting the findings, and lays out conclusions that logically and fittingly flow from the findings and the study’s design, which is what many graduate students, academics, and independent researchers have done over the three decades preceding this book. “First, we know more than some analysts suggest we do. Important empirically grounded clues are visible, and tentative hypotheses are being formed. At the same time, we know a lot less than advocates of homeschooling would have us believe. Second, there is a growing body of evidence that reveals how homeschool students are performing academically compared to national norms on standardized tests” [p. 140]. “Here we pull together these explanations for the positive influence of homeschools on the academic and social learning of youngsters” [p. 153-154]. Professor Murphy posits three main variables in his theory of action. Consider the first: “If there is a beginning point in the logic of action for homeschooling’s impact, it is most likely parental involvement … It is also the keystone variable in the success algorithm. It includes the massive amounts of time and energy that parents invest in the education of their children …” [p. 155]. “Instructional program” is the second plank Murphy’s theory of action. While some critics of homeschooling are concerned that parents are not state-certified teachers, it appears they consistently offer their children one-on-one instruction, low student-to-teacher ratios, effective use of time, more academic learning time, “… a high degree of customization of learning experiences” [p. 157-158], considerable flexibility, more meaningful feedback between teacher and student, more extensive two-way dialogue between adults and children, an environment in which it is “… more difficult for a child to coast or hide in the crowd …” and “…easier for parents to teach using direct (authentic) experiences” [p. 159], and an execution of homeschooling as “… a good way to encourage student ownership of learning …” [p. 159]. The third and final plank of his theory is the “learning environment.” Research literature suggests that home-educated children find themselves in “… more productive learning environments than those often found in the average public school …,” “… a climate that is safe and orderly, a nonthreatening culture in which the academic work of school can unfold …,” and “… the elimination of the negative peer culture sometimes seen in conventional schools …” [p. 159]. “In its stead, one often finds a supportive culture that grows from committed families and loving parents …” [p. 159]. As part of this third variable, he notes the high levels of personalization involved in parent-led home-based education: “On a second front, a positive learning environment is made possible by the nurturing relationships that seem to be more easily forged in homeschools. ….. The key here is the development in homeschools of a highly personalized climate in which the child is known, cared for, and respected more deeply than is possible in models of collective schooling …” [p. 160]. Calmly, carefully, and engagingly pulls together decades of research on homeschooling to offer the reader a well-reasoned “speculative” model regarding “… what might explain the positive effects of homeschools on the academic and social learning of children” [p. 160] and graciously gives credit to others such as John Holt, Raymond Moore, and Brian Ray (2000, “Home schooling: The ameliorator of negative influences on learning?” and 2010 “Academic achievement and demographic traits of homeschool students: A nationwide study” for previously suggesting the planks for Murphy’s theory). Murphy’s is an exceptionally readable and engaging treatise for both the academic and layperson alike.) Revised annotation
Murphy, Joseph 2014 The social and educational outcomes of homeschooling. Sociological Spectrum: Mid-South Sociological Association, 34(3), 244-272, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02732173.2014.895640. https://doi.org/10.1080/02732173.2014.895640 homeschooling, research, methodology, outcomes, academic achievement, social skills, socialization, college, college performance, adult, sociology, review of research “Abstract: In this article, we provide a comprehensive review and analysis of the outcomes of homeschooling in America. We ground the work in an examination of the importance of homeschooling in society in general and education in particular. We provide an analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of the existing research base on homeschooling. With an eye on methodological weaknesses in the homeschool research, we compile on what is known about the outcomes of this social movement and educational reform. We document the impact of homeschooling on the social fabric of the nation (e.g., families) and the institution of schooling (e.g., student learning outcomes)” (p. 244). “Third, a fair amount of suggestive evidence has been compiled that homeschooling can damp down the effects found in public schools of family socioeconomic variables. Or as Collom (2003:329) so nicely captures it, "the two great divides that public school children face-race and class-are inconsequential for student achievement among home-educated children.” ….. For all of the reasons discussed herein, all of the current studies on homeschooling must be viewed as non-definitive. ….. Fourth, we want to revisit our cardinal caveat: there are a number of valid reasons why it is inappropriate to privilege academic achievement in the algorithm we craft to assess the impact of homeschooling” (p. 258). “The overall message is one that at best only allows us to report that research "suggests" certain findings. Existing findings need to be subjected to more scientific study. Given these limitations, the evidence currently at hand leads us to be cautious about too readily accepting the claims of homeschool critics that the academic and social well-being of youngsters is harmed by homeschooling” (p. 266).
Murphy, Joseph F. 2013 Explaining the change in homeschooling, 1970-2010. Home School Researcher, 29(1), 1-13. homeschooling, research, policies, economics, growth “[Abstract] In this article, the tremendous change in the homeschooling population over the last 40 years—from less than 20,000 students in 1975 to over 2,000,000 today—is analyzed. This is accomplished by unpacking the changes in the social, economic, and political fabric of the nation that created an environment conducive to homeschooling” (p. 1). “Under homeschooling, funding, provision, and to a large extent, regulation gravitate from the public to the private sector (Murphy, 1996)” (p. 1). “In this paper, the context that has allowed homeschooling to grow has been examined. The central argument presented is that prevailing economic, political, social, and cultural forces during most of the twentieth century precluded homeschooling from taking root. As those forces have been transformed, an environment conducive to homeschooling has materialized” (p. 13).
Murray, Bridget 1996, December Home schools: How do they affect children? Monitor [of the American Psychological Association]. (3 pages from American Psychological Association Internet web site). home education, some research, opinion, psychology Summarizes some demographics about home education. Cites concerns of some psychologists but mentions very little research related to psychological and social development of the home educated. Author’s presupposition is that attendance at conventional schools is the best and normal way to develop an individual’s social expertise and psychological health but gives no evidence to support this. Author says one psychologist “wondered” what would happen if parents taught a worldview that goes against society’s — in fact, research shows that this is precisely why many parents home educate their children and this expression of choice and freedom of thought is a valued part of the democratic American tradition. Ignores the research that shows the home educated and their families to be healthy and strong in terms of self-concept, family function, and other measures of social and psychological development.
Muscatine, Sonia M. 2020 Homeschooling and the right to education: Are states fulfilling their constitutional obligations to homeschooled students? Journal of Law and Education, 67.
Musgrove, F. 1960 The decline of the educative family. Universities Quarterly, 14, 377-404. Traces what the author sees as the declining importance of the family from the middle ages to present; very "pro-school" in tone, but a good historical overview tracing the roots of many of the family vs. school arguments being waged today.
Musumunu, Garvey, & Mazama, Ama 2014 The search for school safety and the African American homeschooling experience. Journal of Contemporary Issues in Education, 9(2), 24-38. homeschooling, reasons, motivations, black, African American, minorities, critical race theory “Interest in homeschooling has increased over the last decade, as what was once perceived as a marginal development has turned into a significant phenomenon. There has been, in recent years, a noticeable surge in African American involvement in the homeschooling movement as well. However, there continues to be a general paucity of research on the motivations of homeschooling Black parents. It is the purpose of this essay (1) to present empirical evidence regarding African American motivations for homeschooling; and (2) more specifically, to explore how parental concerns for safety are leading African American families to homeschooling. These concerns, the authors contend, bring to the fore a series of disturbing circumstances and preoccupations that are specific to African Americans” (p. 24). Interviewed 74 homeschooling parents across various regions of the United States. “In a provocative sense, the interviews illustrate the power of counter-storytelling as suggested by critical race theory. Counter storytelling affords the Black homeschooling parents to have their voices heard. A voice that has traditional been marginalized and rendered invisible both by the racist notion that African American parents are not involved in the schooling of their children and by the more publicized voice of white homeschooling parents. In accordance with the tenets of critical race theory, this study has demonstrated that (1) race is central to the experience of homeschooling African Americans, (2) the narrative of our subjects challenges the dominant ideologies that articulates the notion of color-blindness in the curriculum, where in fact the dominant and clear cultural orientation of most curricula is Euro-American, (3) black homeschooling parents have a great sense of self efficacy, agency, and social justice that leads to direct action to protect their children from insecurities of brick-and-mortar schools, and (4) through their private and public action to homeschool, African American parents give legitimacy to their experiential knowledge of the school system in America, which has largely been detrimental to children of African descent (Delgado & Stefancic 2012; Ladson-Billings & Tate 1995, Yosso, 2005) Finally it is important to realize that the desire of African Americans to educate their children in the face of great physical and psychological trauma is nothing new” (p. 35).
Mwanyumba T. F., Wamocha, L., & Buhere, P. 2022 Academic outcomes of homeschooled versus conventionally schooled children pursuing the Accelerated Christian Education curriculum in Kenya. Problems of Education in the 21st Century , 80(3). 474-486, https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1349000.pdf https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1349000.pdf academic outcomes, homeschooling, conventional schooling, comparative research, ACE curriculum “Abstract: In recent times, the Kenyan education sector has experienced increased cases of students' indiscipline in schools. However, the potential of homeschooling as a possible solution to such indiscipline has not been explored. Whereas critics of homeschooling posit that homeschooled children are inferior academically, proponents of this form of learning don’t think so. Therefore, this research compared the academic learning outcomes of homeschooled children and children in conventional school settings. The subjects in which scores were compared were math, English, and social studies. This research was anchored in the systems theory’s input-output model developed by Ludwig Von Bertalanffy and adopted the causal-comparative research design. The target population was children pursuing the Accelerated Christian Education (ACE) curriculum. A sample of 316 children was drawn, out of whom 272 participated in the research. Data were analyzed using independent samples t-tests. Results revealed that homeschooled children achieved significantly higher math, English, and social studies scores than children in conventional schools. The research concluded that homeschooling as an alternative form of education enhances children’s academic learning outcomes equally well and probably better than conventional schools. Therefore, the education sector in Kenya should consider legalizing homeschooling as an alternative form of education for some parents who want to detach their children from indiscipline cases that are majorly witnessed in conventional schools. Despite this research stating the case for legalizing Homeschooling in Kenya, a significant limitation was the reliance on the ACE curriculum and academic scores derived from one term’s performance. Therefore, future studies should consider panel data that caters for comparisons across diverse curricula over time.” Peer-reviewed.
Myers, Jeff, & Myers, Danielle 1996 Of knights and fair maidens: A radical new way to develop old-fashioned relationships. Available from Heartland Educational Consultants, PO Box 7000, Dayton TN 37321.
Myers, Linda Lou Hock 1990 An exploratory study of home schoolers: How do these students fare when they enter or return to public high schools? Unpublished doctoral dissertation (Ph.D.), Michigan State University, East Lansing MI. Dissertation Abstracts International, 51(5), 1449A-1450A. (Order No. DA9028672) home education, public school, cooperation The students are all unique in their previous experiences, school personnel had little awareness regarding home schools and home educated students, and many schools had not developed related policies.
Myers, Martin, & Bhopal, Kalwant 2018 Muslims, home education and risk in British society, British Journal of Sociology of Education, 39(2), 212-226, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01425692.2017.1406337. https://doi.org/10.1080/01425692.2017.1406337 Home education; home schooling; homeschooling, Muslim; Trojan Horse; risk; at-risk; Beck Case study, qualitative. “ABSTRACT The number of families who choose to home educate has significantly increased in the last decade. This article explores the experiences of British Muslims who home educate using data from a larger study exploring the views of a diverse range of families. Drawing on the work of Beck, we discuss how ‘risk’ is understood in relation to Muslim home educators. For these families, decisions to home educate were often made in response to identifying risks associated with their children attending school. At the same time, OFSTED has identified ‘risks’ of radicalisation associated with the ‘Trojan Horse’ affair which they linked specifically to Muslim families who home educate. We argue that Muslim families are both marginalised by the perception of ‘risk’ associated with radicalisation and also by their consequent decisions to home educate” (p. 212). “This article draws upon two case studies of Muslim families living in the West Midlands, (a large metropolitan county in England) from a wider project that explored the choices of different home educators [in 33 families] in the United Kingdom. The article examines how risk has been perceived and understood in the context of Muslim pupils who are home educated. It takes as its backdrop the ‘Trojan Horse’ affair in Birmingham, West Midlands, when suspicions and later evidence were uncovered of covert attempts to take over schools by Sunni Islamic groups (Clarke 2014). These events were linked by Michael Wilshaw, Her Majesty’s Chief Inspector of Schools,1 to an increasing number of families using home education as a cover for sending their children to unregistered madrassa schools (OFSTED 2016). In this article, we explore how Muslim families are both marginalised by the perception of ‘risk’ associated with radicalisation and consequent decisions to home educate.” (p. 212). “Both families’ decisions to home educate were driven by personal and individual circumstances often related to putting in place strategies to mitigate perceived risk in relation to their children and their education. According to Beck (1992, 21; original emphasis), ‘Risk may be defined as a systematic way of dealing with hazards and insecurities introduced by modernisation itself …’, and this resonates clearly with the experiences of Siddiq and Nadim’s families. Their decision to home educate can be understood as a reaction to modernisation; a reaction to a society which is marked by insecurities and dangers associated with the ‘other’. However, neither family positioned themselves primarily in terms of the cosmopolitan or globalised sense of risk suggested by Beck (1992). Instead risk was most clearly articulated in relation to something far more localised; in the racism experienced by both families at schools, in Nadim’s description of dangerous and poor neighbourhoods, and in Siddiq’s account of being ‘out of place’ in a white middle-class area. One consequence of occupying such spaces was to be identified as an ‘other’ or ‘outsider’ leading to their children encountering problems in school” (p. 221). “Whilst the identification and management of different risk reflected the agency of both families as reflexive individuals responding to Risk Society, it was also clear that both families had access to different resources” (p. 221). “Whilst both families identified risk in relation to the impact of attending school, the OFSTED [government agency] accounts suggest Muslim families who chose home education put their children ‘at risk’ of marginalisation and in some cases extremism. These fears include both threats around child safety and a wider ideological attack on ‘British values’. In many ways this distinction of risks identified by the families and those identified by the state and within public discourses is at the nub of home education choices. The same dilemmas are faced or identified across a range of different home-educating families but in each case they are identified within the specific characteristics of their identity. Whilst Siddiq in particular identified the globalised context in which his family’s actions might be translated into being understood as potentially creating the risk of a radicalisation, this bore little resemblance to his family’s daily life. Nadim appeared less aware of the discourses around the Trojan Horse affair, managing his children’s education in a manner that mirrored the concerns of OFSTED. In reality both families appeared more concerned with specific risks in their lives rather than the narrative of religious radicalization” (p. 222). “This article has examined two case studies of home-educating Muslim families to suggest that discourses of Muslim communities characterise them as a source of risk, related to their positioning as marginalised others. Home educators have been identified in the Badman Review (2009 [commissioned by a government agency]) and by OFSTED (2015b, 2016) as a category of parents who are putting their children at risk. One finding from this research has been that despite the heterogeneity of experience of different home-educating families, they are still classified within a singular, administrative category. OFSTED’s descriptions of Muslim home educators tend to identify a type of family who are not engaged in delivering home education. Rather than home educating, these families are identified as circumventing an engagement with schooling in order to access unregistered Islamic schools, and potentially putting children at risk of radicalization” (p. 223). “Beck (1992, 100; original emphases) suggests that when individuals are faced with risks, ‘temporary coalitions between different groups and different camps are formed and dissolved, depending on the particular issue at stake and on the particular situation’. When Muslims are demonized in society, in the Trojan Horse narrative for example, such social crises become individual crises in which Muslim families feel threatened by the society around them. Muslim home educators, however, tended to draw upon traditional family and community support to address issues in their children’s education, not quite mirroring Beck and not building the sort of extremist coalitions envisaged by OFSTED” (p. 224). Authors do not label the homeschool children at risk but discuss how the families or religiously affiliated Muslim homeschool parents, children, or and families are associated with risk by the individuals within society or by government agencies.
Nagel, Ed 1976 Educational alternatives: what choice do we have? New Schools Exchange (also In Mothering, vol. 6 or 7 ?).
Nagel, Ed 1979 A school without a school [home study through Santa Fe Community School]. Mothering, Summer 1979, p.46-48. Also In Tidbits Moussage National Association for the Legal Support of Alternative Schools, NALSAS) ca. 1983.
Nagel, Ed 1979 Home schooling: The epitome of parental involvement. Compact, 13(3), 32,31.
Nagel, Ed 1979 Should parents be allowed to educate their kids at home? Yes. Instructor, 89(3), 30. Law. Philosophy. "The natural responsibility to educate children belongs first and foremost to parents. But it is also a legal right." "... existing research indicates a child's greatest learning potential occurs in the first five years of life- which is usually at home."
Nagel, Ed, & Shannon, Thomas 1979 Should parents be allowed to educate their kids at home? Instructor, October, 30.
Naisbitt, J. 1982 Megatrends: Ten new directions transforming our lives. New York, NY: Warner Bros.
Naisbitt, John 1982 Megatrends: Ten new directions transforming our lives. New York, NY: Warner Books.
Nappen, Louis P. 2005 The privacy advantages of homeschooling. Chapman Law Review, Fall 2005; 73-109. Retrieved June 19, 2018 from http://www.chapmanlawreview.com/archives/1153 http://www.chapmanlawreview.com/archives/1153 law, legal, privacy, homeschooling, home schooling, home education “Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis emphasized that “the right to be let alone [is] the most comprehensive of rights and the right most valued by civilized men.” 286 This paper focuses on this one right as it concerns modern educational standards and is not presented to skew all the good that public school programs accomplish. Of course, government schooling presents many advantages, not the least of which may include: social, psychological and emotional benefits; better parental time-management; best use of family monies; 287 choice educational supplies, equipment, facilities and programs; and qualified staffs and certified teachers. Nonetheless, because the law does not currently or consistently mandate collection of personal information about homeschooled children, privacy is an often overlooked advantage of homeschooling in most states. Concerned parents, particularly those willing and able to choose their state of residence, should “shop” to find which states offer suitable educational and privacy advantages in line with their needs and desires. 288 Ultimately, parents who believe in the freedom to make decisions about their children’s private lives without government interference must decide how much personal and familial information is worth divulging in exchange for their children’s education” (p. 109).
Nash, Ronald H. 1990 The closing of the American Heart: What's really wrong with America's schools. Dallas, TX: Probe Books. home education, parental choice, educational improvement and reform Main problem is a collapse of morality based on an unchanging truth, that of the God of the Bible; educational crisis is manifested in functional illiteracy, cultural illiteracy, and moral illiteracy; schools of education should be abandoned; NEA is left-wing political agenda force; Christian schools are the best choice for Christians, and home education is possibly all right.
Nathan, Joe 1983 Shouldn't we give vouchers a try? Learning, August, 74-79. Vouchers.
Nathan, Joe 1987 How to choose a school for my child. (ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED290238). home schooling, parent influence, school choice Evaluates state plans for enhancing choice in schools.
National Alliance of Christian Home Education Leadership, The 2008 Exposing a Trojan horse (DVD video). homeschooling, home education, school choice, public-school-at-home programs, vouchers, philosophy, policy, legal, law Addresses questions such as (1) What “price” do parents pay to participate in these tax-funded government-run school/education programs? (2) What is the cost to the homeschooling movement, at large? (3) What will be the impact on future generations of Christian home educators? (4) Are homeschoolers inviting a Trojan Horse into their midst through these programs? The film interviews several well-known persons in the homeschool movement. Many talk about the hidden costs of participating in government-funded programs for home educators.
National Association for College Admission Counseling 2004, February The state of college admission 2003–2004. Alexandria, VA: Author. Retrieved 3/23/04 online http://www.nacac.com/downloads/secondstatecollege.pdf. http://www.nacac.com/downloads/secondstatecollege.pdf home education, college admissions, research “Just as in 2002, applications from homeschooled students continue to increase, although not as rapidly as applications from all students. In 2003, 40 percent of colleges and universities reported an increase in applications from homeschooled students, while 57 percent reported an equal number from the previous year. As Table 16 shows, the number of colleges that maintain formal evaluation procedures for applications from homeschooled students continues to rise” [p. 28].
National Association for the Education of Young Children 2020 Developmentally appropriate practice [a position statement]. Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved March 1, 2021 from https://www.naeyc.org/sites/default/files/globally-shared/downloads/PDFs/resources/position-statements/dap-statement_0.pdf https://www.naeyc.org/sites/default/files/globally-shared/downloads/PDFs/resources/position-statements/dap-statement_0.pdf education, young children, teaching and learning, developmentally appropriate practices [DAP] It is not difficult to imaging that the principles laid out by the NAEYC might be easier to apply in a parent-led home-based education (i.e., homeschooling, home education) environment than in an institutional school, especially one that is populated by teacher, instructors, aides, or educators who have no personal vested social capital interest in the students. NAEYC states, and it is notable that they do not mention families/homes in their opening statement, but do mention families and homes later in the document: “Each and every child, birth through age 8, has the right to equitable learning opportunities—in centers, family child care homes, or schools—that fully support their optimal development and learning across all domains and content areas. Children are born eager to learn; they take delight exploring their world and making connections. The degree to which early learning programs support children’s delight and wonder in learning reflects the quality of that setting. Educators who engage in developmentally appropriate practice foster young children’s joyful learning and maximize the opportunities for each and every child to achieve their full potential” (p. 1). “Purpose: Chief among the professional responsibilities of early childhood educators is the responsibility to plan and implement intentional, developmentally appropriate learning experiences that promote the social and emotional development, physical development and health, cognitive development, and general learning competencies of each child served. But what does it mean to be “developmentally appropriate”? This position statement, one of five foundational documents developed by NAEYC in collaboration with the early childhood profession to advance high-quality early learning for all young children, defines the term. The definition emerges from a set of evidence-based core considerations and principles of child development and learning, all of which are explained in the principles section of this statement. To support educators’ use of developmentally appropriate practice, this statement also identifies guidelines for decision making in six key areas of responsibility that correspond to the Professional Standards and Competencies for Early Childhood Educators” (p. 3). Principle 2: “All domains of child development—physical development, cognitive development, social and emotional development, and linguistic development (including bilingual or multilingual development), as well as approaches to learning—are important; each domain both supports and is supported by the others” (p. 9). Principle 3: “Play promotes joyful learning that fosters self-regulation, language, cognitive and social competencies as well as content knowledge across disciplines. Play is essential for all children, birth through age 8” (p. 9). Principle 4: “Although general progressions of development and learning can be identified, variations due to cultural contexts, experiences, and individual differences must also be considered” (p. 10). Under principle 4: “Development and learning also occur at varying rates from child to child and at uneven rates across different areas for each child. Children’s demonstrated abilities and skills are often fluid and may vary from day to day based on individual or contextual factors” (p. 10). Note that in the 2009 version of NAEYC’s position, Principle #3 was, “Development and learning proceed at varying rates from child to child, as well as at uneven rates across different areas of a child’s individual functioning.” Principle 6: “Children’s motivation to learn is increased when their learning environment fosters their sense of belonging, purpose, and agency. Curricula and teaching methods build on each child’s assets by connecting their experiences in the school or learning environment to their home and community settings” (p. 11). Principle 8, mastery learning: “Development and learning advance when children are challenged to achieve at a level just beyond their current mastery and when they have many opportunities to reflect on and practice newly acquired skills” (p. 12). Principle 9: “Used responsibly and intentionally, technology and interactive media can be valuable tools for supporting children’s development and learning” (p. 13). Under principle 9, “Young children live in a digital era in which technology and interactive media are pervasive. Given rapid changes in the types and uses of new media, the knowledge base of their effects on children’s development and learning continues to grow and shift. Emerging evidence suggests a number of cautions, including concerns about negative associations between excessive screen time and childhood obesity as well as negative impacts on toddlers’ performance on measures of fine motor, communication, and social skills” (p. 13).) .
National Association for the Education of Young Children (NAEYC) 1997 [copyright]; adopted July 1996 Developmentally Appropriate Practice in Early Childhood Programs Serving Children from Birth through Age 8: NAEYC position statement. Washington, DC: Author. (Retrieved 8/11/00 online http://www.naeyc.org/about/position/daptoc.htm) http://www.naeyc.org/about/position/daptoc.htm http://www.naeyc.org/about/position/dap3.htm education, young children, teaching and learning, developmentally appropriate practices [DAP] Develops theory for and delineation of developmentally appropriate practices (DAP), in terms of teaching and learning, for young children. Excerpts from the section entitled “Principles of child development and learning that inform developmentally appropriate practice” (retrieved 8/11/00 online http://www.naeyc.org/about/position/dap3.htm) follow: “1. Domains of children's development -- physical, social, emotional, and cognitive -- are closely rela-ted. Development in one domain influences and is influenced by development in other domains. ..... 2. Development occurs in a relatively orderly sequence, with later abilities, skills, and knowledge building on those already acquired. ..... 3. Development proceeds at varying rates from child to child as well as unevenly within different areas of each child's functioning. ..... 4. Early experiences have both cumulative and delayed effects on individual children's development; optimal periods exist for certain types of development and learning. ..... 5. Development proceeds in predictable directions toward greater complexity, organization, and internalization. ..... 6. Development and learning occur in and are influenced by multiple social and cultural contexts. ..... 7. Children are active learners, drawing on direct physical and social experience as well as cul-turally transmitted knowledge to construct their own understandings of the world around them. ..... 8. Development and learning result from interaction of biological maturation and the environment, which includes both the physical and social worlds that children live in. ..... 9. Play is an important vehicle for children's social, emotional, and cognitive development, as well as a reflection of their development. ..... 10. Development advances when children have opportunities to practice newly acquired skills as well as when they experience a challenge just beyond the level of their present mastery. ..... 11. Children demonstrate different modes of knowing and learning and different ways of representing what they know. ..... 12. Children develop and learn best in the context of a community where they are safe and valued, their physical needs are met, and they feel psychologically secure.”) .
National Association for the Education of Young Children (NAEYC) 2009 Developmentally appropriate practice in early childhood programs serving children from birth through age 8, adopted 2009. Retrieved February 25, 2021 from https://www.naeyc.org/sites/default/files/globally-shared/downloads/PDFs/resources/position-statements/PSDAP.pdf https://www.naeyc.org/sites/default/files/globally-shared/downloads/PDFs/resources/position-statements/PSDAP.pdf education, young children, teaching and learning, developmentally appropriate practices [DAP] “The purpose of this position statement is to promote excellence in early childhood education by providing a framework for best practice. Grounded both in the research on child development and learning and in the knowledge base regarding educational effectiveness, the framework outlines practice that promotes young children’s optimal learning and development. Since its first adoption in 1986, this framework has been known as developmentally appropriate practice” (p. 1). Most of important practices that the NAEYC explains and promotes are systemically a part of homeschooling (home education). It appears that the homeschooling environment would be more amenable to fulfilling the developmentally practices for children than would institutional schooling in which there are typically several, often up to 29, students per teacher (i.e., a relatively high student-to-teacher ratio). For example, under the section “Principles of child development and learning that inform practice,” Principle #3 is, “Development and learning proceed at varying rates from child to child, as well as at uneven rates across different areas of a child’s individual functioning.” This is one of the key principles that advocates of homeschooling have been pointing out and promoting since the late 1970s, claiming that homeschooling can honor and apply this principle much better than can institutional schooling. Those promoting home-based education also argue that Principle #7, “Children develop best when they have secure, consistent relationships with responsive adults and opportunities for positive relationships with peers,” can also be more consistently honored and played out in parent-led home-based education, in which nearly all children are engaged in co-operatives, scouting groups, church groups, 4H, and other activities with peers than in institutional schools.). .
National Association for the Legal Support of Alternative Schools [NALSAS] c. 1983 Tidbits Moussage general information exchange. Santa Fe, NM.
National Association of Elementary School Principals 1989-1990 Platform 1989-1990. Author: Alexandria, VA. home education, cooperation, public schools, policy Available from NAESP, 1615 Duke Street, Alexandria, Virginia 22314-3483, 703/684-3345. NAESP "...urges local and state associations to support legislation which...prohibits at-home schooling as a substitute for compulsory school attendance" p. 4.
National Association of Elementary School Principals 1993 Position statement on home schooling. Author: Alexandria, VA. home education, policy, professional organization, public school, opinion, opposition, criticism “NAESP asserts that this [quality education] is most effectively done through cohesive organization in formal settings in which resources can most beneficial1y be brought to bear. NAESP is concerned with the increasing number of individuals and groups who are avoiding education in the traditional setting in favor of at home schooling. Home schooling may: 1. deprive the child of important social experiences; 2. isolate students from other social/racial/ethnic groups; 3. deny students the full range of curriculum experiences and materials; 4. be provided by non-certified and unqualified persons; 5. create an additional burden on administrators whose duties include the enforcement of compulsory school attendance laws; 6. not permit effective assessment of academic standards of quality; 7. violate health and safety standards; and 8. not provide the accurate diagnosis of and planning for meeting the needs of children with special talents, learning difficulties, and other conditions requiring atypical educational programs. When alternative options such as home schooling have been authorized by state legislation, resources and authority should be provided to make certain that th9se who exercise these options are held strictly accountable for the academic achievement and social/emotional growth of children.”
National Association of State Boards of Education 1988 Home schooling. Author: Alexandria, VA.
National Association of State Boards of Education (NASBE) 1996, January Home schooling. Policy Update, 4(1), 1-2. Also retrieved 1/22/08 from www.nasbe.org/new_resources_section/policy_updates/PU_Home_Schooling_01.96.pdf. http://www.nasbe.org/new_resources_section/policy_updates/PU_Home_Schooling_01.96.pdf home education, policy, professional organizations, state boards, law, regulation, child abuse Recommends that "...decision makers should insure that policies have the following components: [a] Strictly enforced registration of home schooled children ... [b] Specific provisions for insuring the competency of the instructor... [c] Provisions for monitoring instructional outcomes... [d] Assurance that policies with regards to home schooling are aligned with state's current outcome-based standards and graduation requirements; [e] Provisions for probation and remediation when students do not achieve minimum outcomes... [f] Provisions for allowing home schoolers to participate in regular school programs such as band, science classes, sports or special programs... [g] Provisions for assuring that home schooled students meet the same state academic and attendance requirements for extracurricular activities that public school students must follow; [h] Provisions for reimbursing schools for providing home schoolers with access to school programs; [i] Provisions for identifying child abuse in the home." Appears to be a major change from NASBE's earlier [1988] lack of explicit opinion about home education policy; policy update dated January 1994 was almost identical to this policy update except this one inserted item here notated as “g.”
National Black Home Educators Resource Association 2001 NBHERA home page. Retrieved 6/8/01 online http://www.christianity.com/nbhera. http://www.christianity.com/nbhera Promotes homeschooling for black or African-American families. Organization located at 6943 Stoneview Ave., Baker LA 70714, tel. 225/778-0169. National Broadcasting Company (NBC Producer). (1988, August 29). The Today Show, interview on home schooling. New York, NY: Producer. (Guests were Mary Hatwood Futrell, President of the National Education Association, and Brian D. Ray, Editor of Home School Researcher.
National Catholic Educational Association 2000, April, revised; original 1996, September A reflection statement on homeschooling promulgated by the Department of Elementary Schools National Catholic Educational Association. Washington, DC: Author [1 page]. home education, private education, Roman Catholic, opinion, like a teachers union States the NCEA’s support of parental right and responsibility but implies that institutional Roman Catholic schools are better than homeschooling. Makes this claim without providing supporting premises. Uses a 1972 document of the Roman Catholic church, the date of which precedes the clear emergence of the modern homeschooling movement by at least a decade, to suggest that Catholic schools are the best for children and youth. “The Department of Elementary Schools of the National Catholic Educational Association (NCEA) reaffirms the teaching of the Catholic Church that parents are the primary educators of their children. Parents have the right and responsibility to choose the best means of educating their children. The Department further supports the constitutional right (Pierce v. Society of Sisters, 1925) of parents to choose the school that is best suited for their children. The Department of Elementary Schools reaffirms the statement of the American Catholic bishops, ‘Of the educational programs available to the Catholic community, Catholic schools afford the fullest and best opportunity to realize the threefold purpose of Christian education among children and young people’ (To Teach as Jesus Did, Section 101, 1972). ..... The Department of Elementary Schools realizes, therefore, that some parents choose, based on location, finances and personal reasons, to educate their children at home and respects this right. Catholic educational leaders should counsel parents on their grave responsibility to provide quality instruction. These leaders need to remind parents of their obligation to observe the requirements of religious education stipulated by their respective arch/dioceses and to provide their children with an opportunity to participate in the religious educational/catechetical program in their parish community. The Department is committed to working with parents, pastors, boards, and educators to ensure that quality Catholic education/catechesis is available to all children.” The NCEA is a private organization that provides leadership and service to Catholic education; its “... mission is to advance the educational and catechetical mission of the church and provide leadership and service to its members. The association also articulates the contribution of Catholic education to the church and society and proclaims the uniqueness of Catholic schools” (mission statement, personal communication, NCEA, 6/8/00 fax
National Catholic Educational Association 2014 United States Catholic elementary and secondary schools 2013-2014: The annual statistical report on schools, enrollment, and staffing. Retrieved 2/19/15 from http://www.ncea.org/data-information/catholic-school-data http://www.ncea.org/data-information/catholic-school-data “Total Catholic school student enrollment for the current academic year [2013-14] is 1,974,578.”
National Center for Fathering 1999 National Survey Commissioned by the National Center for Fathering: Fathers Involvement in Their Children’s Learning [table]. Shawnee Mission KS: Author. Retrieved 12/6/01 online http://www.fathers.com/research/involvement.html. http://www.fathers.com/research/involvement.html parenting, research, father, fathers, fathering, education “Survey of fathers,” had question that asked do you “Read to your child: everyday, 24.6%, 1-2x/wk, 22.7, 1-2x/mo, 7.8, 1x/3mo, 3.6, never, 40.2, don’t know, 0.3, refuse to answer, 0.7,” and another question asked, “Do you/does your child's father know the name of your child's teacher, yes, 56.5%, no, 43.5.”
National Center for Home Education 1991, August 21 Update on choice, America 2000, and public schools as social hubs. Memo. Available from National Center for Home Education, P.O. Box 125, Paeonian Springs, VA 22129. educational improvement
National Center for Home Education 1993, July Untitled. Available from National Center for Home Education, P.O. Box 125, Paeonian Springs, VA 22129. parental involvement, education, politics Collection of articles on parental involvement in schools, why parents try or give up having an impact, et cetera.
National Center on Addiction and Substance Abuse at Columbia University, The 1997, September 1997 CASA national survey of teens, their parents, teachers & principals. Retrieved 3/21/03 online http://www.casacolumbia.org/usr_doc/5885.pdf. http://www.casacolumbia.org/usr_doc/5885.pdf Reports: “Among the disturbing findings of this survey are these: --- Teens are more likely to see drugs sold at school than in the neighborhood--41 percent of high school students have seen drugs sold at their schools, while only 25 percent have seen them sold in their neighborhoods. --- Drugs have moved into the middle schools of America and many teachers seem cavalier about it: many middle school teachers (41 percent) believe that teens can use marijuana [p. 2 ends] every weekend and still do well in school. Half of high school teachers and principals (51 percent) feel the same way. --- One fifth of middle school teachers (19 percent) say students who appear to be drunk or high show up in their classes on a monthly or more frequent basis. Three fourths of high school students say their schools are not drug free, and 41 percent of high school students and 30 percent of all teens have seen drugs sold on school grounds. Yet many teachers and principals seem oblivious to this drug trade: only 12 percent of high school teachers and 14 percent of middle and high school principals report seeing drugs sold in school or on school grounds” [p. 3]. “Above all, teens, parents, teachers and principals should face the reality of what Pogo teaches: we have met the enemy and they are us. When teens, parents, teachers and principals want drug-free schools in America, we will have drug free schools” [p. 4]. “The affluence of the community where the school is located; whether the school is in an urban, suburban, or rural community; the percentage of minority students in the student body -- these characteristics bear little relation to the number of signs of trouble at school” [p. 8]. National Commission on Children, (1991). Beyond rhetoric a new American agenda for children and families. Washington D.C. (research).
National Commission on Children 1991 Beyond rhetoric: A new American agenda for children and families. Washington, DC: Author. family, education Also available from Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC 20402 Chapter 7: Increasing educational achievement; Chapter 9: Strengthening and supporting families
National Commission on Excellence in Education, The 1983 A nation at risk: The imperative for educational reform. Washington, DC: U. S. Government Printing Office. education reform Describes America’s government-run (state, public) schools to be in such a state that it was as if the U.S. had declared war on itself.
National Conference of State Legislatures 1988 Home Schools Paper. A discussion of the National Association of State Boards of Education, NASBE [National Association of State Boards of Education], position.
National Education Association 1988 The 1988-89 resolutions of the National Education Association. NEA Today, December, 17-24. homeschooling, home schooling, policy, NEA, teachers union “(Resolution "C-34. Home Schooling The National Education Association believes that home schooling programs cannot provide the student with a comprehensive education experience. The Association believes that if parental preference home schooling study occurs, students enrolled must meet all state requirements. Instruction should be by persons who are licensed by the appropriate state education licensure agency, and a curriculum approved by the state department of education should be used. The Association further believes that such home schooling programs should be limited to the children of the immediate family, with all expenses being borne by the parents. (88).")
National Education Association 1990 The 1990-91 resolutions of the National Education Association. Washington, DC: Author. home education, public education, cooperation, policy Resolution "C-39. Home Schooling The National Education Association believes that home schooling programs cannot provide the student with a comprehensive education experience. The Association believes that if parental preference home schooling study occurs, students enrolled must meet all state requirements. Instruction should be by persons who are licensed by the appropriate state education licensure agency, and a curriculum approved by the state department of education should be used. The Association further believes that such home schooling programs should be limited to the children of the immediate family, with all expenses being borne by the parents. (88,89)" p. 23, 24. The Eagle Forum’s Education Reporter, August 1998, No. 151, p. 4, reports that the NEA passed the same resolution [re-named resolution B-67] at its annual convention in New Orleans, LA in 1998
National Education Association 1998 The 1998-99 resolutions of the National Education Association. (online http://www.nea.org/). http://www.nea.org/ http://www.nea.org/resolutions/98/98a-1.html http://www.nea.org/resolutions/98/98b-65.html “A-1. Public Education. The National Education Association believes that public educational opportunities for every American must be preserved and strengthened. The Association also believes that public education is the cornerstone of our social, economic, and political structure and is of utmost significance in the development of our moral, ethical, spiritual, and cultural values. ..... The Association further believes that its members should support public education by sending their children to public educational institutions. (69, 98)” (online 7/1/99: http://www.nea.org/resolutions/98/98a-1.html) “B-65. Home Schooling. The National Education Association believes that home schooling programs cannot provide the student with a comprehensive education experience. When home schooling occurs, students enrolled must meet all state requirements. Home schooling should be limited to the children of the immediate family, with all expenses being borne by the parents. Instruction should be by persons who are licensed by the appropriate state education licensure agency, and a curriculum approved by the state department of education should be used. The Association also believes that home-schooled students should not participate in any extracurricular activities in the public schools. The Association further believes that local public school systems should have the authority to determine grade placement and/or credits earned toward graduation for students entering or re-entering the public school setting from a home school setting. (88, 98)” (online 7/1/99 at: http://www.nea.org/resolutions/98/98b-65.html).
National Education Association 1999 NEA 1999-2000 resolutions, B-67, home schooling. Online http://www.nea.org/resolutions/99/99b-67.html, retrieved 4/13/00. http://www.nea.org/resolutions/99/99b-67.html home education, professional, teachers union, philosophy, policy “The National Education Association believes that home schooling programs cannot provide the student with a comprehensive education experience. When home schooling occurs, students enrolled must meet all state requirements. Home schooling should be limited to the children of the immediate family, with all expenses being borne by the parents/guardians/caregivers. Instruction should be by persons who are licensed by the appropriate state education licensure agency, and a curriculum approved by the state department of education should be used. The Association also believes that home-schooled students should not participate in any extracurricular activities in the public schools. The Association further believes that local public school systems should have the authority to determine grade placement and/or credits earned toward graduation for students entering or re-entering the public school setting from a home school setting. (88, 99)”
National Education Association 2001 NEA 2000-2001 Resolutions. Washington, DC: Author. http://www.nea.org/resolutions/00/00a-1.html http://www.nea.org/resolutions/00/00b-68.html home education, teachers union, public, philosophy, politics Resolution A-1. Public Education, retrieved 8/6/01 online http://www.nea.org/resolutions/00/00a-1.html. (States, probably Resolution A-1 [see NEA, 2002 notes]: "The Association also believes that public education is the cornerstone of our social, economic, and political structure and is of utmost significance in the development of our moral, ethical, spiritual, and cultural values. The Association further believes that each state must maintain a system of public education that prepares its citizens to .....” Resolution B-68 Home Schooling (retrieved 8/6/01 online http://www.nea.org/resolutions/00/00b-68.html states “The National Education Association believes that home schooling programs cannot provide the student with a comprehensive education experience. When home schooling occurs, students enrolled must meet all state requirements. Home schooling should be limited to the children of the immediate family, with all expenses being borne by the parents/guardians. Instruction should be by persons who are licensed by the appropriate state education licensure agency, and a curriculum approved by the state department of education should be used."
National Education Association 2002 National Education Association resolutions 2002-2003. Washington, DC: Author. Received 11/26/02 via e-mail electronic file “Resolutions02-03.pdf” from Dbilal@nea.org. home education, teachers union, criticism, regulation Resolution A-1: “A-1. Public Education The National Education Association believes that public educational opportunities for every American must be preserved and strengthened. The Association also believes that public education is the cornerstone of our social, economic, and political structure and is of utmost significance in the development of our moral, ethical, spiritual, and cultural values. The Association further believes that each state must maintain a system of public education that prepares its citizens to—...” Resolution B-69: “B-69. Home Schooling . The National Education Association believes that home schooling programs based on parental choice cannot provide the student with a comprehensive education experience. When home schooling occurs, students enrolled must meet all state requirements. Home schooling should be limited to the children of the immediate family, with all expenses being borne by the parents/guardians. Instruction should be by persons who are licensed by the appropriate state education licensure agency, and a curriculum approved by the state department of education should be used. The Association also believes that unfunded home-schooled students should not participate in any extracurricular activities in the public schools. The Association further believes that local public school systems should have the authority to determine grade placement and/or credits earned toward graduation for students entering or re-entering the public school setting from a home school setting. (1988, 2002)” [p. 34].
National Education Association 2002 National Education Association resolutions 2002-2003. Washington, DC: Author. Received 9/22/03 via e-mail electronic file “NEAResolutions03-04.pdf” from Da'aiyah Bilal (Dbilal@nea.org). “[Resolution] A-1 Public Education The National Education Association believes that public educational opportunities for every American must be preserved and strengthened. The Association also believes that public education is the cornerstone of our social, economic, and political structure and is of utmost significance in the development of our moral, ethical, spiritual, and cultural values. The Association further believes that each state must maintain a system of public education that prepares its citizens to— a. Achieve functional proficiency in English, with emphasis on the development of basic reading, writing, speaking, and listening skills b. Compute effectively to procure and/or dispense services and materials c. Use critical thinking, creative thinking, and problem-solving skills d. Exercise attitudes of good citizenship, societal productivity, and global awareness e. Care for the environment f. Appreciate the aesthetic and moral qualities of life g. Formulate values that lead to continual growth and self-fulfillment h. Recognize and appreciate cultural, social, political, and religious differences i. Use leisure time effectively and develop sound physical health habits j. Develop skills in and/or an appreciation for the practical/vocational and fine arts. The Association believes that its members should support public education by sending their children to public educational institutions. (1969, 1998).” “[Resolution] B-69. Home Schooling The National Education Association believes that home schooling programs based on parental choice cannot provide the student with a comprehensive education experience. When home schooling occurs, students enrolled must meet all state requirements. Home schooling should be limited to the children of the immediate family, with all expenses being borne by the parents/guardians. Instruction should be by persons who are licensed by the appropriate state education licensure agency, and a curriculum approved by the state department of education should be used. The Association also believes that home-schooled students should not participate in any extracurricular activities in the public schools. The Association further believes that local public school systems should have the authority to determine grade placement and/or credits earned toward graduation for students entering or re-entering the public school setting from a home school setting. (1988, 2003).”
National Education Association 2006 National Education Association resolutions 2006-2007. Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved 5/13/08 from http://www.nea.org/annualmeeting/raaction/images/resolutions2006-2007.pdf. http://www.nea.org/annualmeeting/raaction/images/resolutions2006-2007.pdf “h. Charters should not be granted for the purpose of home schooling, including providing services over the Internet to home schooled students” (p. 10). “B-75. Home Schooling The National Education Association believes that home schooling programs based on parental choice cannot provide the student with a comprehensive education experience. When home schooling occurs, students enrolled must meet all state curricular requirements, including the taking and passing of assessments to ensure adequate academic progress. Home schooling should be limited to the children of the immediate family, with all expenses being borne by the parents/guardians. Instruction should be by persons who are licensed by the appropriate state education licensure agency, and a curriculum approved by the state department of education should be used. The Association also believes that home-schooled students should not participate in any extracurricular activities in the public schools. The Association further believes that local public school systems should have the authority to determine grade placement and/or credits earned toward graduation” (p. 36).
National Education Association 2008 Rankings and estimates 2008. Retrieved January 9, 2009 from http://www.nea.org/home/29402.htm. http://www.nea.org/home/29402.htm public schools, finance, economy, per-pupil expenditure Includes Table 1. Average Salaries ($) of Public School Teachers, 2007-08; Table 5. Current Expenditures ($) per Student in Public K-12 Schools, 2007-08 reports the average per-student for the US is $9,963; salaries, etc.
National Education Association 2014 2013-2014 NEA resolutions. Washington, DC: Author. http://www.nea.org/assets/docs/NEA-Rankings-and-Estimates-2013-2014.pdf National Education Association, NEA, teachers union, criticism; government schools, public school, costs, expenditures, per pupil expenditures, state by state “B-83. Home Schooling The National Education Association believes that home schooling programs based on parental choice cannot provide the student with a comprehensive education experience. When home schooling occurs, students enrolled must meet all state curricular requirements, including the taking and passing of assessments to ensure adequate academic progress. Home schooling should be limited to the children of the immediate family, with all expenses being borne by the parents/guardians. Instruction should be by persons who are licensed by the appropriate state education licensure agency, and a curriculum approved by the state department of education should be used. The Association also believes that home-schooled students should not participate in any extracurricular activities in the public schools. The Association further believes that local public school systems should have the authority to determine grade placement and/or credits earned toward graduation for students entering or re-entering the public school setting from a home school setting. (1988, 2006)” (p. 38).) National Education Association. (2014, March). Rankings estimates and rankings of the states 2013 and estimates of school statistics 2014. Retrieved March 13, 2015 http://www.nea.org/assets/docs/NEA-Rankings-and-Estimates-2013-2014.pdf. (The current expenditures for public k–12 schools per student in ADA for 2012–13 were $11,308 on average and $11,185 as the media across all the U.S. states and, e.g., $26,103 in Vermont (the highest), $11,570 in Oregon, 10,884 in Iowa, $7,021 in Arizona (the lowest, p. 57.
National Education Association 2015 Rankings estimates and rankings of the states 2014 and estimates of school statistics 2015. Retrieved February 5, 2016 from http://www.nea.org/assets/docs/NEA_Rankings_And_Estimates-2015-03-11a.pdf. http://www.nea.org/assets/docs/NEA_Rankings_And_Estimates-2015-03-11a.pdf costs, finances, expenditures, public school, per pupil expenditure Table 5.3, p. 85, says that the annual per pupil expenditure in 2014-15 in public schools in the U.S. is $11,732, and this does not include capital expenditures and research and development.
National Education Association 2016 Rankings estimates and rankings of the states 2015 and estimates of school statistics 2016. Retrieved April 23, 2017 from http://www.nea.org/assets/docs/2016_NEA_Rankings_And_Estimates.pdf http://www.nea.org/assets/docs/2016_NEA_Rankings_And_Estimates.pdf
National Education Association 2020 2020-2021 NEA resolutions. Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved September 28, 2020 from https://www.nea.org/sites/default/files/2020-09/NEA%20Resolutions_2020-2021.pdf https://www.nea.org/sites/default/files/2020-09/NEA%20Resolutions_2020-2021.pdf homeschooling, teachers union, union, philosophy, politics “B-83. Home Schooling. The National Education Association believes that home schooling [homeschooling] programs based on parental choice cannot provide the student with a comprehensive education experience. When home schooling occurs, students enrolled must meet all state curricular requirements, including the taking and passing of assessments to ensure adequate academic progress. Home schooling should be limited to the children of the immediate family, with all expenses being borne by the parents/guardians. Instruction should be by persons who are licensed by the appropriate state education licensure agency, and a curriculum approved by the state department of education should be used. The Association also believes that home-schooled students should not participate in any extracurricular activities in the public schools. The Association further believes that local public school systems should have the authority to determine grade placement and/or credits earned toward graduation for students entering or re-entering the public school setting from a home school setting. (1988, 2006)” (p. 37).
National Home Education Network 2002 Thoughts on protecting children in homeschooling families. Hobe Sound, FL: Author. Retrieved January 21, 2008 from http://www.nhen.org/LegInfo/?id=420. http://www.nhen.org/LegInfo/?id=420 home education, policy, philosophy, legal, law, child abuse “2. Traditionally, and in our constitutional system, the best way to protect children has been determined to be to presume that parents, rather than an agency of government, are "fit" to act in their child's best interests. We are all painfully aware that some parents do actually harm their own children. From viewing the horrific tragedies inflicted on some children by their parents, we tend to lose sight of the fact that the vast majority of parents fulfill their parental responsibilities in an appropriate and fitting manner.[1] For this very sound reason, our society presumes that parents are the proper agents to make decisions about their own children. 3. To remove the presumption of "fitness" from the entire class of parents who homeschool their children would be to harm the entire class of homeschooling children, simply because of the parents' educational choice.” “5. Seeking to protect all children through removing the presumption of fitness of all parents who homeschool their children would be inadvisable for reasons of policy, law, and practicality. Policy: An agency that seeks to protect children should not have a blanket policy designating an entire class of parents as unfit without indisputable empirical evidence that warrants such a special class designation. Law: Our constitutional system presumes that parents, unless evidence is shown to the contrary, are "fit" to make educational and childrearing decisions for their children.[3] Practicality: It is virtually impossible to conceive of a regulation that would have the practical effect of sorting out those few parents who might, in the future, victimize their children.”
National Home Education Research Institute 1990-present Performs basic research, publishes Home School Researcher and many other papers, clearinghouse of information, Brian D. Ray, Ph.D., President. National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
National Opinion Research Center [NORC] 2003 General Social Survey. http://www.icpsr.umich.edu:8080/GSS/homepage.htm http://www.icpsr.umich.edu:8080/GSS/about/credits/james.htm http://www.icpsr.umich.edu:8080/GSS/about/credits/thomas.htm http://www.icpsr.umich.edu:8080/GSS/about/credits/pete.htm social science research, national, nationwide, United States, opionion, issues “The GSS (General Social Survey) is an almost annual, "omnibus," personal interview survey of U.S. households conducted by the National Opinion Research Center (NORC) with James A. Davis, Tom W. Smith, and Peter V. Marsden as principal investigators (PIs). The first survey took place in 1972 and since then more than 38,000 respondents have answered over 3,260 different questions …” and “The mission of the GSS is to make timely, high-quality, scientifically relevant data available to the social science research community. Key features of the GSS are its broad coverage, its use of replication, its cross-national perspective, and its attention to data quality.” Data sets available online suggest that the cumulative number of respondents to the questionnaires during 1972-2000 number about 40,000 and their ages are about 18 to 89. Rretrieved 8/22/03 online http://www.icpsr.umich.edu:8080/GSS/homepage.htm.
Neal, Jeff 2020, August 14 Will online schooling increase child abuse risks? HLS Child Advocacy Program Director Elizabeth Bartholet ’65 and child welfare expert James Dwyer warn of dangers and call on officials to adopt new safeguards to protect children forced to learn at home. https://today.law.harvard.edu/will-online-schooling-increase-child-abuse-risks/ school at home, homeschooling, quarantine, Covid-19, child abuse, child neglect, law, regulation Retrieved September 22, 2020 from https://today.law.harvard.edu/will-online-schooling-increase-child-abuse-risks/ “HLT [Harvard Law Today]: Is there a chance that an increasing number of parents might want to homeschool now that they’ve been exposed to it for the first time? [James] Dwyer: I think there will be more interest. There are certainly some parents who have enjoyed spending more time with their children — I include myself among them. In a situation where it’s a choice between inadequate online instruction, paying for private schools, or having their kids home all the time and doing some homeschooling, I think a good number will choose the third option voluntarily, and consider it not so bad. And then a smaller number will say it’s actually great, and will keep doing it even after the public schools are open. I think those in that last category are probably less worrisome. There also might be some parents who’ve abused their children during this time and are afraid to have them go back to school even online and be seen by teachers, so might claim the homeschooling privilege for that reason. [Elizabeth] Bartholet: I agree that there could very well be some increase. Some parents have discovered that public schools are worse than they thought, and have been surprised at how little their kids have been learning. I also know that Home School Legal Defense Association advocates, the main lobbying force for a subset of the homeschooling community that opposes all homeschooling regulation, are joyfully rubbing their hands at the prospect of what they think might be a very significant increase. I think it’s hard to know how any increase in the homeschooling population might affect the prospects for the increased oversight that I think is important. Roughly three percent of the population is now homeschooled. Let’s say that increases to six percent post-COVID. Legislators and other policymakers may look at that and say, ‘Wow, now this is a big phenomenon, it may continue to grow. Of course, it shouldn’t be just this lawless world out there with no rules and regulations and oversight. Of course, this should be part of our overall regulated educational system.’ But it is also possible that some people who are homeschooling for the first time as a result of COVID think they’ve been doing way better than the public schools, are not used to being regulated in ways that hamper their freedom, and may therefore be resistant to any new regulation of homeschooling.”)
Nehemiah Institute 2000 Creation views vs. evolution views: Do they make a difference? (a white paper report). Lexington, KY: Author. home education, public school, Christian school, worldview, creationism, evolutionism, beliefs, religion Finds that a high school student’s beliefs about the veracity of the Bible and about the origin of life and species are related to his worldview, i.e., biblical theism vs. moderate Christian vs. secular humanism. Within a sample of high school students who were largely Christian, homeschool students had the strongest/highest biblical worldview scores on the Politics, Economics, Education, Religion, and Social Issues (PEERS) test and the strongest/highest creationist [versus evolutionist] scores on the Creationist Worldview Test [CWT]; on the PEERS, homeschoolers were the highest, then the Christian school and Christian youth group students who were attending public schools, then the public school group were the lowest.
Neill, A. S. 1960 Summerhill: A radical approach to child rearing. New York, NY: Hart Publishing Co.
Neitz, M. J. 1981 Family, state, and God: Ideologies of the right-to-life movement. Sociological analysis, 42, 265-276. Family policy, analysis of political themes of the religious right.
Nelson, Erik 1986 Home schooling. ERIC digest, number fifteen. Eugene, Oregon: ERIC Clearinghouse on Educational Management. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service NO. ED282348).) Home Schooling, Nontraditional Education, Private Education, School Attendance Legislation
Nelson, Mary Beth 1998 Beyond the stereotypes: Home schooling as a legitimate educational alternative. The High School Magazine, 6(2), 32-37. [published by the National Association of Secondary School Principals (NASSP)]
Nemer, Kariane Mari 2002 Understudied education: Toward building a homeschooling research agenda. National Center for the Study of Privatization in Education, Teachers College, Columbia University, Occasional Paper No. 48. Presents “… a tentative classification scheme …” of the motivations, generally ideological and pedagogical, of homeschool parents “… in order to promote awareness of and to initiate discussion about homeschoolers amongst the research community as well as to provide a foundation and a common language for this discussion” (p. 13). Uses a balanced, well-informed, and dispassionate approach to discussing the homeschooling community. Slightly implies that “… the communitarian ideal …” (p. 16) will be hindered if more families engage in homeschooling. “Abstract: Abstract Beginning with a brief history of homeschooling in America, I discuss literature describing today’s population of homeschoolers. Although older, the binary typology offered by Van Galen (1987, 1991) to categorize the motivations of homeschoolers is still utilized in much of the homeschooling literature. She breaks homeschoolers into two basic groups: the ideologues, who have ideological conflicts with schools, and the pedagogues, who dislike the pedagogy employed in traditional forms of education. Using Van Galen’s rubric as a starting point, I consider existing research about the characteristics and motivations of homeschoolers. Although this extant research is quite limited, it nonetheless highlights the need for an expanded framework. To this end, I offer my own suggestions for a slightly more detailed typology, arising out of my own homeschooling research. I conclude with a brief sampling of the types of knowledge and insight that homeschooling research may offer concerning the strengths, weakness, and future of American schooling” (p. 1). “Homeschooling research could also be a benefit to those who seek to improve traditional public school systems, form private schools, or establish alternative educational opportunities such as charter or magnet schools. For instance, such research would likely yield insights into factors [p. 16 ends] driving parental choice, techniques aimed at individualized instruction, multi-age learning, emulation of role-models and peers, child development and developmentally-appropriate learning, and issues of cultural reproduction and social stratification. Concerning this latter point, I am personally very interested in the impact that the recent surge, in numbers and diversity, of the homeschooling movement may have on educational equity, access, and democracy. What will become of the communitarian ideal if more and more families decide, as do some – but not all – homeschoolers, to filter society’s voice from their children’s education? Does the increased exercise of a choice to forego formal schools mean more democracy or does it impair democracy? How might the movement toward homeschooling drive policy shifts concerning tax laws and public school funding? These questions await scholarly analyses” (p. 16-17).
Nemer, Kariane Marie 2004, April Schooling alone: Homeschooling, democracy, and public school policy. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Diego, CA. home education, research, sociology, philosophy, politics, socialization
Nemer, Kariane Marie [yeas later by surname Welner] 2004, April 12 Schooling alone: Homeschooling and broader social concerns. Author’s abstract retrieved 41/9/04 online http://convention.allacademic.com/aera2004/view_paper_info.html?pub_id=4628&part_id1=21328: “An in-depth, qualitative study of homeschooling families in two states examines parents’ views of public education. http://convention.allacademic.com/aera2004/view_paper_info.html?pub_id=4628&part_id1=21328 http://convention.allacademic.com/aera2004/AERA_papers/AERA_1074_14628a.PDF home education, research, sociology, philosophy, politics, socialization One subset, named “autonomy-minded homeschoolers,” oppose public schools both in principle and in practice. However, a second subset, called “civic-minded homeschoolers,” emphasize their commitment to community-based social institutions such as public schools and decision-making which takes the needs of other community members into account. Yet, civic-minded homeschoolers withdraw their own children from these institutions and would only send them back if the public schools changed in very specific ways. As such, while these two groups of homeschooling parents voice quite different perspectives about public schools and their commitments to them, the practical outcome is still a withdrawal of their presence within public schools.”)
Neufeld, Gordon, & Maté, Gabor 2004 Hold on to your kids: Why parents need to matter more than peers. New York, NY: Ballantine Books. child development, peers, peer orientation, attachment, adults, parents, family, socialization Relies on attachment theory and addresses how peer orientation undermines family cohesion, interferes with healthy development, causes aggression and anxiety in children and youth, and fosters a hostile and sexualized youth culture. Explains that peer orientation also causes children to become overly conformist, desensitized, and alienated. “In the first days of school in kindergarten, a peer-oriented child would appear smarter, more confident, and better able to benefit from the school experience. ….. Thus, in the short term, peer orientation appears to be a godsend. ….. In the long term, of course, the positive effects on learning of reduced anxiety and disorientation [because of being comfortable with peers] will gradually be canceled by the negative effects of peer orientation” (p. 237). “When children go to school to be with one another, they are primed only to learn enough to not stand out, to remain with those their own age. Other than that, learning is irrelevant and can even be a liability to peer relationships. Anxiety also comes back to haunt peer-oriented learners. Because peer attachments are inherently insecure, anxiety often becomes a chronic condition. Peer-oriented kids are among the most agitated, perpetually restless, and chronically alarmed” (p. 237). “As discussed in previous chapters, aggression and disobedience are the legacy of peer orientation” (p. 239). “Peer orientation is not the only cause of disturbed attachments, but in our children’s world it is the major one. Viewed through the lens of attachment, the findings of the three lines of research could not be clearer in pointing to the risk of our young of [sic] becoming peer-oriented in our day cares and our preschools” (240). “The belief is that socializing – children spending time with one another – begets socialization: the capacity for skillful and mature relating to other human beings. There is no evidence to support such an assumption, despite its popularity. If socializing with peers led to getting along and to becoming responsible members of society, the more time a child spent [p. 241 ends] with her peers, the better the relating would tend to be” (p. 241-242). “To be sure, socializing plays a part in rendering a child capable of true social integration, but only as a finishing touch. The child must first of all be able to hold on to herself when interacting with others and to perceive the others as separate beings. This is no easy task, even for adults. When a child knows her own mind and values the separateness of another’s mind, then – and only then – is she ready to hold on to her sense of self, while respecting that of the other person. Once this developmental milestone is achieved, social interaction will hone the child’s individuality and hone his relationship as well” (p. 242). “Until children are capable of true friendship, they really do not need friends, just attachments. And the only attachments a child needs are with family and those who share responsibility for the child. What a child really needs is to become capable of true friendship, a fruit of maturation that develops only in a viable relationship with a caring adult. Our time is more wisely spent cultivating relationships with the adults in our child’s life than obsessing about their relationships with one another” (p. 244).
Neuhaus, Richard John (Ed.) 1987 Democracy and the renewal of public education. Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company. education, public schools, state, history, philosophy, private schools Includes chapters by Richard A. Baer, Charles L. Glenn, Rockne M. McCarthy, James W. Skillen, and Paul C. Vitz. Baer explains that public schools are not and cannot be value neutral in terms of what they teach. Glenn shows that public schools “mold” children, citizens, into whatever the schools want to mold them in terms of character and values they hold. Book suggests that the value and purpose of state-run schools must be reexamined and carefully evaluated.
Neuman, Ari; & Guterman, Oz 2016 Academic achievements and homeschooling—It all depends on the goals. Studies in Educational Evaluation, v. 51, pp. 1–6, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0191491X16300566 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0191491X16300566 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0191491X16300566 Homeschooling; Home education; Unschooling; Standardized assessment tests; academic achievements, academic achievement; CIPP model, peer-reviewed “Highlights • Academic achievement is used to compare homeschooling and school going children. • This is sometimes misguided. • Structured homeschooling share goals with schools. • Unstructured homeschooling might have different educational goals. • Therefore has to be evaluated differently. Abstract: This article discusses assessment of academic achievement in the context of home schooling or elective home education (EHE). It presents the argument that although academic achievement is used to compare between homeschooling and school learning, in many cases this comparison is misguided. The achievements of homeschooled children have been examined extensively, but the questions to be considered is whether or not the evaluation methods used were suited to the teaching and education taking place in the homeschooling context, and in particular whether these evaluation methods are compatible with the educational objectives of this framework. This question is fundamental to understanding the homeschooling phenomenon and also to the attempt to compare the achievements of students studying in schools with those of students learning in a homeschooling environment. The article opens with a brief description of the homeschooling phenomenon, introduces a short review of studies comparing academic achievement in this context, presents a number of basic concepts in the field of evaluation as well as an evaluation model relevant to the questions that form the basis of this study, and examines whether, and under what conditions, a comparison can be made between children attending school and those studying in the homeschooling framework” (retrieved April 19, 2017 from http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0191491X16300566 Peer-reviewed.
Neuman, Ari; Guterman, Oz 2017 Homeschooling Is Not Just About Education: Focuses of Meaning. Journal of School Choice, 11(1), 148-167, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2016.1262231 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2016.1262231 education and life; holistic perspective; homeschooling; home schooling; postmodern; premodern “ABSTRACT: This article explores the meanings parents attribute to homeschooling. The literature reveals two main approaches to this subject: a view of homeschooling as a pedagogical practice and a holistic perspective. Employing qualitative methodologies, we administered in-depth interviews to 30 mothers who engaged in homeschooling in Israel, in order to gain a better understanding of what homeschooling meant to them. Analysis of the interviews indicated that the participants attributed diverse meanings to homeschooling. These represented many themes, which were gathered into four super-themes: control, lifestyle, family, and child. The first two themes were emphasized more often than the latter two” (p. 148).
Neumana, Ari, & Guterman, Oz 2016 Structured and unstructured homeschooling: a proposal for broadening the taxonomy. Cambridge Journal of Education. Published online: 27 Apr 2016, DOI:https://doi.org/10.1080/0305764X.2016.1174190. https://doi.org/10.1080/0305764X.2016.1174190 Elective home education, EHE, homeschooling, unschooling, structured content, structured process, pedagogy, curriculum “Abstract. In recent decades, parental involvement in their children’s education has been steadily increasing. Perhaps the ultimate form of parental involvement is the phenomenon called elective home education – EHE (also known as homeschooling). It is customary to divide EHE into two categories according to the degree of structure: structured EHE and unstructured EHE (or unschooling). Advocates of structured learning study in the home framework according to a defined curriculum, whereas unstructured learning advocates study content determined in accordance with the child’s wishes, with no external dictates. This division relates to learning as one entity. This article proposes to distinguish between two dimensions of structure: content and process. In order to demonstrate this distinction, qualitative research was conducted in which 30 mothers who educate their children at home were interviewed and asked what they actually do within the framework of EHE. The research findings suggest that the two types of EHE are indeed different from one another with regard to the structure of the content of instruction and learning as well as the structure of the process. The article addresses the importance of broadening the traditional distinction (structured and unstructured EHE) to include content and process.”
New Age Journal 1989, January/February Where to learn about teaching alternatives. education, alternative, New Age Lists several organizations and periodicals, including some related to home education but not necessarily New Age in philosophy
New Mexico State Department of Education, Assessment and Evaluation and GED Unit 1998, February 17 Personal communication with Pat Rael of the department. academic achievement, home education, public Rael provided documents showing the achievement test scores of home school students in grades 3, 5, & 8 in 1995. Their national percentile scores in reading and math for these three grades were 60 & 55, 65 & 51, and 56 & 42, respectively. The public school student percentile scores were at or below the 50th percentile in both subject areas in these 3 grades.
Newlin, Eliza 1987, July 19 Learning at home: Advocates call out-of-school education civil right. Bucks County Courier Times, pp. 1, 10. Newspaper of circulation 70,000 near Philadelphia, PA. Reasons for home education. Law. Civil rights. Box with characteristics of home schoolers summarized by Brian Ray.
Nguyen, Kimberly H.; McChesney, Cheyenne; Rodriguez, Carlos Sánchez; Vasudevan, Lavanya; Bednarczyk, Robert A.; Corlin, Laura 2024 Child and adolescent COVID-19 vaccination coverage by educational setting, United States. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.puhe.2024.01.029 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.puhe.2024.01.029 vaccination, vaccination rate, vaccination coverage, vaccine hesitancy, Covid-19, education sector, in-person instruction, homeschooling “Abstract: Objectives The COVID-19 pandemic changed the setting of education for many children in the U.S. Understanding COVID-19 vaccination coverage by educational setting is important for developing targeted messages, increasing parents’ confidence in COVID-19 vaccines, and protecting all children from severe effects of COVID-19 infection. Study design/Methods Using data from the Household Pulse Survey (n = 25,173) collected from December 9–19, 2022, January 4–16, 2023, and February 1–13, 2023, this study assessed factors associated with COVID-19 vaccination and reasons for non-vaccination among school-aged children 5–11 and adolescents 12–17 by educational setting. Results Among children 5–11 years, COVID-19 vaccination coverage was higher among those who received in-person instruction (53.7%) compared to those who were homeschooled (32.5%). Furthermore, among adolescents 12–17 years, COVID-19 vaccination coverage was higher among those who received in-person instruction (73.5%) or virtual/online instruction (70.1%) compared to those who were homeschooled (51.0%). Children and adolescents were more likely to be vaccinated if the parental respondent had been vaccinated compared to those who had not. Among children and adolescents who were homeschooled, main reasons for non-vaccination were concern about side effects (45.4–51.6%), lack of trust in COVID-19 vaccines (45.0–50.9%), and lack of trust in the government (32.7–39.2%). Conclusions Children and adolescents who were home-schooled during the pandemic had lower vaccination coverage than those who attended school in person, and adolescents who were home-schooled had lower vaccination coverage than those who received virtual instruction. Based on the reasons for non-vaccination identified in this study, increasing parental confidence in vaccines, and reducing barriers to access are important for supporting COVID-19 vaccination for school-age children.” “Understanding COVID-19 vaccination coverage of children and adolescents by educational setting and reasons for non-vaccination is important for developing targeted vaccination promotion messages for diverse educational settings as well as to increase parents’ confidence in COVID-19 vaccines and protect all children from severe effects of COVID-19 infection.” This study is designed to reveal information to convince or indoctrinate or propagandize different groups of people, e.g., those who choose alternatives in education for their children, e.g., homeschooling. Very importantly, how did they define homeschool or homeschooled? Which iteration of the Pulse Survey did they use and how, at the time, did it define homeschooling. Does it really mean instruction at home in this study?
Niederjohn, Scott; & Flanders, William 2026 Private school choice and student performance in English/language arts: Evidence from Wisconsin’s parental choice programs, Journal of School Choice. https://will-law.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/JoSC-1.pdf and https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/15582159.2026.2698883 https://will-law.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/JoSC-1.pdf https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/15582159.2026.2698883 Educational policy; private schools; propensity score matching; school choice; vouchers “Abstract. This study examines the association between participation in Wisconsin’s private school choice programs and English Language Arts achievement using longitudinal administrative data from 96,241 students tested in 2018–2019 and 2022–2023. Propensity score matching compares voucher participants with similar public-school students, with exposure measured by years of participation. Sustained participation is positively associated with achievement growth. Statewide program participants gained approximately 0.14 standard deviations overall and 0.35 standard deviations after four or more years. Similar patterns appear in Racine. Findings suggest evaluations of school choice should emphasize long-term participation rather than short-term outcomes alone.” This study cannot disentangle at least three different things: 1. an effect of attending a private school; 2. an effect of receiving taxpayer funding/voucher eligibility; and 3. characteristics of the particular private schools that participate in the voucher programs. Authors should have at least briefly discussed in their review of literature that much research from the past has concluded that private-school students have outperformed public-school students long before tax-funded education welfare was expanded to private schooling; thus, if there is a benefit to students, the cause might be simply the private schooling sector and not the tax funding.
Nikiforuk, Andrew 1994, March The case for home schooling: Why more parents are turning kitchens into classrooms. Chatelaine [Published in Canada], p. 40. home education, Canada, opinion Explains that interest in and the practice of home schooling has dramatically increased in Canada. Parents are countering the three arguments often marshaled against the concept of home education: “Only misfits or back-to-the-landers choose home schooling,” “Parents can’t teach as well as trained teachers,” and “Home-schooled children suffer from uneven social development or isolation” [p. 40]. Explains that the evidence refutes these arguments.
Noel, Amber; Stark, Patrick; & Redford, Jeremy 2013 Parent and family involvement in education, from the National Household Education Surveys Program of 2012 (NCES 2013-028). Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics, Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education. Retrieved August 31, 2013 from http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2013/2013028.pdf http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2013/2013028.pdf http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch homeschooling, population, demographics, reasons from http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch). (Explain that their data for the National Household Education Surveys Program are “… nationally representative of students enrolled in kindergarten through grade 12, including children enrolled in private schools, enrolled in public schools, and homeschooled. The total number of completed questionnaires was 17,563 [397 homeschooled and 17,166 enrolled, p. 23] children), representing a population of 53.4 million students enrolled in kindergarten through grade 12 in 2011–12” (i.e., January through August 2012 p. 1). “Homeschool calculations follow previous homeschool reports by including children ages 5 through 17, in a grade equivalent to at least kindergarten and not higher than grade 12, and excludes students who were enrolled in public or private school more than 25 hours per week, and students who were homeschooled only because of temporary illness” (p. 21). Conclude that 3.4% – or 1,770,000 (1.77 million) – of U.S. K-12 students were homeschooled circa spring of 2012. The 95% confidence interval would be about 1.54 million to 2.00 million (pp. 17, 46). The reasons parents gave for homeschooling these children, in decreasing order of frequency chosen, were the following (and parents could choose more than one reason): (a) A concern about environment of other schools – 91%, (b) A desire to provide moral instruction – 77%, (c) A dissatisfaction with academic instruction at other schools – 74%, (d) A desire to provide religious instruction – 64%, (e) A desire to provide a nontraditional approach to child’s education – 44%, (f) Other reasons – 37%, (g) Child has other special needs – 17%, and (h) Child has a physical or mental health problem – 15%. When asked what is the most important reason for homeschooling, the parents answered as follows: (a) A concern about environment of other schools – 25%, (b) Other reasons – 21%, (c) A dissatisfaction with academic instruction at other schools – 19%, (d) A desire to provide religious instruction – 16%, (e) A desire to provide moral instruction – 5%, (f) A desire to provide a nontraditional approach to child’s education – 5%, (g) Child has a physical or mental health problem – 5%, and (h) Child has other special needs – (“reporting standards not met”). “’Other reasons’ parents gave for homeschooling include family time, finances, travel, and distance” (p. 18). The researchers also reported on the “locale of the student’s household” (e.g., city, suburban), the student’s race/ethnicity, parents’ highest educational level, and the family’s “poverty status.” The last time the federal government explored similar aspects of homeschooling was during the Spring of 2007, when they concluded there were 1.508 million K-12 homeschool students, or 2.9% of the U.S. K-12 population. Ergo, the federal government apparently concludes that the homeschool population has grown in absolute size (1.508 to 1.770 million students, by about 17%) and in terms of the percent of the school-age population (2.9% to 3.4%, by about 17%) over the course of 5 years, 2007 to 2012. Authors of the current study point out, however, that this time they used a mail survey as compared to a telephone survey being used in 2007; therefore one should use caution in comparing estimates from the different years. For another comparison, Ray (2011) estimated (using methods different from those used by both government studies) that there were 2.04 million K-12 homeschool students in the United States in spring 2010. Based on the estimates of research by the federal government and other studies, it appears that homeschooling continued to grow during the late 2000s and into 2012 but not as fast as during the 1990s and early 2000s. There was much similarity in reasons for homeschooling between the government’s 2007 and 2012 studies. One notable difference regarding the most important reason for homeschooling is that in 2012 “a concern about environment of other schools” was most frequently chosen as the most important reason and it was more often chosen than in 2007, and “to provide religious or moral instruction” was a little less frequently chosen as the most important reason in 2012.
Noel, Amber; Stark, Patrick; & Redford, Jeremy 2015, May Parent and family involvement in education, from the National Household Education Surveys Program of 2012: First look. Retrieved May 8, 2015 from http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2013/2013028rev.pdf. http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2013/2013028rev.pdf Does not provide estimates on homeschooling; read following quotes. “This report (NCES 2013-028.REV) is revised from an earlier version (NCES 2013-028) that was released in August 2013. This updated version is based on estimates that utilize the final NHES:2012 data, for which survey weights have been corrected. The correction in survey weights led to small changes in the estimates presented, typically of one to two percentage points. Estimates describing the homeschooling population of the United States have been removed from this revised version of the report so that more detail about how NCES estimated homeschooling in 2012 could be provided in a separate report. ….. For the complete homeschooling report and more discussion of methods used to estimate the homeschooling population, see Homeschooling in the United States:2012 (Redford and Battle forthcoming).” (p. 1).
Nolin, Mary Jo, Chapman, Chris, & Chandler, Kathryn 1997 Adult civic involvement in the United States: National Household Education Survey [NHES]. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education. Publication number NCES 97-906. Retrieved online 7/21/03 http://nces.ed.gov/pubs97/97906.pdf. http://nces.ed.gov/pubs97/97906.pdf
Nolte, M. Chester 1982 Home instruction in lieu of public school attendance. National Organization on Legal Problems of Education, Topeka, Kansas. Compulsory Education, Court Litigation, Out of School Youth, Parent Responsibility A discussion of the legal environment concerning home schooling.
Nord, Warren 2010 Does God make a difference? Taking religion seriously in our schools and universities. Oxford University Press. https://global.oup.com/academic/product/does-god-make-a-difference-9780199766888?cc=us&lang=en&# religion, schools, curriculum, philosophy, public schools “In this provocative book Warren A. Nord argues that public schools and universities leave the vast majority of students religiously illiterate. Such education is not religiously neutral, a matter of constitutional importance; indeed, it borders on secular indoctrination when measured against the requirements of a good liberal education and the demands of critical thinking. Nord also argues that religious perspectives must be included in courses that address morality and those Big Questions that a good education cannot ignore. He outlines a variety of civic reasons for studying religion, and argues that the Establishment Clause doesn't just permit, but requires, taking religion seriously. While acknowledging the difficulty of taking religion seriously in schools and universities, Nord makes a cogent case for requiring both high school and undergraduate students to take a year-long course in religious studies, and for discussing religion in any course that deals with religiously controversial material. The final chapters address how religion might best be addressed in history, literature, economics, and (perhaps most controversially) science courses. He also discusses Bible courses, and the relevance of religion to moral education and ethics courses. While his position will be taken by some as radical, he argues that he is advocating a "middle way" in our culture wars. Public schools and universities can neither promote religion nor ignore it. Does God Make a Difference? increases our understanding of a long and heated cultural conflict; it also proposes a solution to the problem that is philosophically sound and, in the long run, eminently practical” (retrieved October 12, 2016 from https://global.oup.com/academic/product/does-god-make-a-difference-9780199766888?cc=us&lang=en&#
Nord, Warren A. 1995 Religion and American education: Rethinking a national dilemma. Chapel Hill, NC: The University of North Carolina Press. public school education, religion, values, curriculum, textbooks Examines North Carolina public school textbooks, evaluates them regarding values and religion taught in them, offers suggestions for treating religion and religious teachings in a balanced and fair manner in state-run schools. Examines economics, home economics, and science texts. Explains that, “In the twenty-six hundred pages of these six economics texts, about a page and a half deal with religion — and they are silent after Calvin in 1550.” ..... Each of the texts defines the economic world in terms of the competition of self-interested individuals with unlimited wants for scarce resources ...” (p. 145). “Nonetheless, the texts are not devoid of values: the typical list includes economic efficiency, freedom, and growth. These values ... are asserted to be national values or goals ... (p. 147). “The books aim to convince students that they should think well of themselves, that it is important to have a positive self-concept, and that their greatest need is that of self-actualization. ..... None of the books even hints that there are religious conceptions of human nature, values, or decision making that may differ in significant ways from the views presented. Not only is religion ignored, so is morality and virtually any talk of conscience, obligation, duty, tradition, or historical community” (p. 148). “..... But there is no suggestion that one can choose right or wrong values ... (p. 149). “Five of the six [science] texts ... line up clearly in the evolution column, though the sixth is quite clearly out of line. ..... Each of the five contains substantial sections on evolution, running between twenty-one and fifty-four pages. ..... None contains any discussion or even any reference to creationism or creation-science, and none presents any argument to show that evolution did not take place” (p. 151). “There is something like a coherent worldview, a loosely structured set of philosophical commitments, which underlie and give shape to the texts — at least those texts I reviewed. ..... the philosophical commitments that define this worldview are the same commitments that support and make sense of the dominant cultural and intellectual institutions of modernity: the knowledge we acquire in the present is more valuable than the wisdom of the past; ... reason is ‘deconstructed’ into its scientific or narrowly utilitarian components, ...; ... science and social science provide us with our only true knowledge of the world. By implication, religion is irrelevant to understanding the world” (Nord, 1995, p. 159). “Indeed, I will argue that at least in its textbooks and formal curriculum students are indoctrinated into the modern (secular) worldview and against religion” (Nord, 1995, p. 160). “There is no neutral ground on which to stand in making judgments about content, causality, meaning, and truth. All terrain is contested ground. The natural and social sciences, various philosophies and religions, divide the world up in different and conflicting ways. Philosophical neutrality will inevitably prove to be a will-o’-the-wisp, for all authors approach their subject from within particular worldviews, with philosophical commitments that define for them what counts as important, as knowledge, as reasonable, as true. There is no such thing as a neutral point of view. To write a textbook is to take sides” [p. 165]. Education/schooling addressed on at least the following pages: 83, 108, 109, 110, 158, 283, 284, 288-289, 308.
North Dakota Education Association 1991, April North Dakota Education Association Resolutions, April 1991. Bismarck, ND: Author. Resolution on home education is similar to that of National Education Association
Novak, Kevin 2016 Abolition: Overcoming the Christian establishment on education. Forest, VA: Deconstructing the Coliseum. philosophy, Bible, Christian, worldview, compulsory school attendance, compulsory education, education establishment, history, homeschooling, private schooling, jurisdictions, spheres of sovereignty “Abolition is an idea whose time has come. The civil government’s days of dictating what ideas our children are exposed to, are numbered. The civil government school system is going to be abolished, as God never granted the civil government the right to use force and coercion to advance thought. Christians are on notice of this, as most of them foolishly think they can “reform” a civil government school system that should not exist in the first place. In this work attorney Kevin R. Novak talks about what no major Christian leader is willing to talk about, which is that even though the civil government school system is a tyrannical mechanism that commands our youth to think in anti-Christian terms, it must be abolished based on how God ordains the family government to raise children in the Lord’s nurture and admonition. Mr. Novak explains how America’s Christian leaders (the “Christian Establishment”) are, for a variety of reasons, responsible for the American decline. Lord willing, if Christians disregard the Christian Establishment we may have a revival” (Amazon.com, 9/13/2023)). ?
Novello, Mary K. 1998 For all the wrong reasons: The story behind government schools. Lanham, MD: University Press of America. education, history, politics, sociology, philosophy, collectivism, Marxism, classical liberalism, separation of school and state, public schools, homeschooling, home education Provides historical and political review and analysis of Rousseau, progressivism, Romanticism, collectivism, and nationalism “… and to determine their relevance to the history of educational thought” [p. v]. Covers the development of government schools, particularly in Prussia and then the United States. Argues “… for the separation of school and state. It is my opinion that this is the best, if not the only, way to return education to its proper status as an individual right and responsibility instead of a collectivist entitlement” [p. vi].
O’Laughlin, M. C. 1993 An investigation of public school leaders’ attitude toward home schooling. Dissertation Abstracts International, 54, 05A. [Doctoral dissertation.]
O’Toole, Kathleen 1999, May 19 School choice: Are parents' educational preferences all that matters? Stanford Report [online]. Published 5/19/99 and retrieved 7/29/02 online http://www.stanford.edu/dept/news/report/news/may19/reich-519.html. http://www.stanford.edu/dept/news/report/news/may19/reich-519.html education, public schools, home education, philosophy, statism, government control, regulation, policy “Recent trends toward privatizing schools and relieving them of state requirements wrongly imply that schools should mirror the desires of parents and ignore the public's interest in having citizens educated for democracy.” “Reich invited his listeners to disagree with him but stated his view that the nation is slipping too far into deregulated schooling. ‘The guiding idea behind privatization, whether it is vouchers, charter schools or home schooling, is that parents should be the sole decision-making agents about the kind of education their children receive. But this eviscerates the public or civic purposes of schooling.’”
Obamehinti, Feyi 2000, February Minorities and home schooling. Texas Home School Review, 4(1), 15, 23, 25. home education, minority, minorities, Black, African American, population, trends African American/Black woman who is involved in the Minority Homeschoolers of Dallas Metroplex [MHDM] describes seven minority, mainly Black, families who home school in Texas, including her family comprised of two parents and three children. “Lack of support and knowledge and fear as well have played a key role in the low number of minority home educators” [p. 15] and “With wide-open arms, patience, and love MHDM believes that the number of minority home educators will continue to increase dramatically into the 21st century. This will be due to public awareness, support, knowledge of what home schooling is, and faith in God and His living word” [p. 25].
O'Connell, Mary 1981, November Teaching kids the faith: Why some parents would rather do it themselves. US Catholic, 46, 18-24.
Oh, P. J. 2019 Homeschooling, freedom of conscience, and the school as republican sanctuary: The Romeike family case. Peabody Journal of Education, 94:3, 355-368, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617587. https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617587 homeschooling, home schooling, liberty, freedom, philosophy, freedom of conscience, school choice, educational freedom, political theory, politics “Abstract. This paper examines how stances and understandings pertaining to whether home education is civically legitimate within liberal democratic contexts can depend on how one conceives normative roles of the secular state and the religious neutrality that is commonly associated with it. For the purposes of this paper, home education is understood as a manifestation of an educational philosophy ideologically based on a given conception of the good. Two polar conceptions of secularism, republican and liberal-pluralist, are explored. Republican secularists declare that religious expressions do not belong in the public sphere and justify this exclusion by promoting religious neutrality as an end in itself. But liberal-pluralists claim that religious neutrality is only the means to ensure protection of freedom of conscience and religion, the actual moral principles. Each conception is associated with its own stance on whether exemptions or accommodations on account of religious beliefs have special legal standing and thereby warranted. The indeterminate nature of religion and allegedly biased exclusion of secular beliefs, cited by some when denying religious exemptions, can be overcome by understanding all religious and conscientious beliefs as having equal standing as conceptions of the good. Analysis of court documents from the Uwe Romeike et al asylum case are guided by these understandings, and relationships among themes are explored. In summary, some stances regarding home education may depend on one’s view of secularism, particularly in relation to whether one views religious neutrality as a means to ensure protection of freedom of conscience or an end in itself.”
O'Hare, Gerald 1983 An analysis of the development and operation of home school programs in New Jersey. Unpublished graduate project, Glassboro State College, Glassboro, NJ.
Oklahoma Education Association 1991-1992 The future is now: OEA handbook, 1991-1992. Oklahoma City, OK: Author. home education, regulation, policy p. 21 states "...home schooling programs cannot provide the child with a comprehensive education experience. ... Instruction should be by persons who are licensed by the state education licensure agency. The curriculum and a system for monitoring the educational progress of those students participating in home schooling programs should be approved by the state department of education." p. 21; similar to the National Education Association statement.
Oklahoma State Department of Education 1991 Oklahoma school testing program report--1991: Achievement test component, executive summary. Available from author at 2500 N. Lincoln Blvd., Oklahoma City OK 73105-4599. achievement, public school Compare to home educated students' scores in Ray, Brian D. (1992) Home education in Oklahoma...;
Olasky, Marvin 1996 Renewing American compassion: How compassion for the needy can turn ordinary citizens into heroes. New York, NY: The Free Press. sociology, welfare, philosophy, religion, biblical, Christian, Jewish Appendix B “A Biblical base” presents a quick survey of the Old and New Testaments regarding compassion and a governments’ and individuals’ roles in a just society.
Oliveira (de Oliveira), Paulo C. M., Watson, Timothy G., & Sutton, Joe P. 1994 Differences in critical thinking skills among students educated in public schools, Christian schools, and home schools. Home School Researcher, 10(4), 1-8. home education, private education, ACE schools, public education, critical thinking skills, research. Peer-reviewed Sample includes 789 first-time freshman students who were enrolled in a large liberal arts, Christian university. Students were categorized according to their predominate high school educational setting: public school, conventional Christian school, Accelerated Christian Education [ACE] school, and home school. Uses California Critical Thinking Skills Test. “Although the students who were educated in home schools had a slightly higher overall mean critical thinking score ... than that of students who were from public schools, Christian schools, and ACE schools, the results of the ANOVA test revealed that there were no significant differences among the groups on this critical thinking score ... The results of the two MANOVA tests ... that compared the groups across the three critical thinking scores of analysis, evaluation, and inference produced no significant differences ... Similarly, there were no significant differences among the groups across the deductive reasoning and inductive reasoning mean scores ... in the second MANOVA. Based on these findings, all three null hypotheses formulated for this investigation were retained” [p. 4]. That is, critical thinking skills of public, Christian, ACE, and home schooled college students are statistically comparable. “Combined with research that substantiates their above average achievement on standardized tests ... , our finding that home educated students do not differ significantly on critical thinking skills from their conventionally educated counterparts surely offers increasingly strong validation that home education is a viable and effective educational alternative” [p. 6]. Table 2 on p. 5 shows critical thinking scores of students from various types of schooling. Peer-reviewed.
Olsen, Darcy Ann 1999, February 9 Universal preschool is no golden ticket: Why government should not enter the preschool business. Policy Analysis, No. 333, 31 pp. [no volume, no issue]. Washington, DC: Cato Institute. preschool, education, policy, academic achievement, government control, private schools, public schools “Experience provides little reason to believe universal preschool would significantly benefit children, regardless of family income. For nearly 40 years, local, state, and federal governments and diverse private sources have funded early intervention programs for low-income children, and benefits to the children have been few and fleeting. There is also evidence that middle-class children gain little, if anything, from preschool. Benefits to children in public preschools are unlikely to be greater or more enduring. Public preschool for younger children is irresponsible, given the failure of the public schools system to educate the children currently enrolled. The desire to “do something” for young children should be tempered by the facts, and proposals for universal preschool should be rejected” [p. 1]. Summarizes and comments on research, e.g., Perry Preschool Project, The Carolina Abecedarian Project, and Head Start.
Olson, Craig Christopher 1985 Relationships of parenting and aspects of the home environment to achievement and self-concept of students in grades 3 to 5. Dissertation Abstracts International, 47(3), 1076A. Ph.D., The University of Wisconsin - Madison, 355 p. Considered over 100 qualitative and quantitative home environment variables (HEV's) as predictors of "... reading and mathematics achievement scores and self-concept scores obtained by 198 students..." (DAI). Used stepwise multiple regression. Findings included: "(1) In general, no single HEV or combination of HEV's contributed significantly and consistently to the prediction of any of the seven available indices of self-concept when coincidental associations with CAI [child's academic aptitude] were taken into effect. By the same token, neither did any of the self-concept indices contribute significantly to the prediction of achievement or growth in reading and mathematics. (2) The CAI was an extremely powerful predictor of both achievement and growth in reading and mathematics. ..... (4) A significant negative association was noted between maternal employment (in hours per day) and boys' achievement in both reading and mathematics" (DAI).
O'Neill, C. B. 1988 The perceptions of a selected group of Georgia superintendents and home-schooling parents on related issues. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Georgia State University, Atlanta.
Oplinger, Doug, & Willard, Dennis J. 2004, November 15 Claims of academic success rely on anecdotes, flawed data analysis. Akron Beacon Journal [daily newspaper]. Retrieved 11/17/04 online http://www.ohio.com/mld/ohio/news/special_packages/home_schooling/10185099.htm. http://www.ohio.com/mld/ohio/news/special_packages/home_schooling/10185099.htm
Oplinger, Doug, & Willard, Dennis J. 2004, November 16 Socialization study inaccurately promoted, researcher says. Akron Beacon Journal [daily newspaper]. Retrieved 11/24/04 online http://www.ohio.com/mld/beaconjournal/news/local/10193424.htm. http://www.ohio.com/mld/beaconjournal/news/local/10193424.htm
Oregon Department of Education 1984 A vision of education in the year 2000. January, Edugram.
Oregon Department of Education 1986, 1988 Homeschool Data Report.
Oregon Department of Education 1990 March 30, 1990 home school data report. Salem, OR: Author.
Oregon Department of Education 1990 Summary of home schooling data, 1986-1990. Salem, OR: Author. Achievement data, home school scores are getting better over the years.
Oregon Department of Education 1991 Home-schooling data summary for Oregon 1986-1991. Salem, OR: Author. home education, research data Gives number of students registered to home school and their scores on standardized tests for years 1986-87 through 1990-91. Numbers increasing significantly each year. Test scores are negatively skewed with about 20% of students scoring in the 91st to 99th percentile range.
Oregon Department of Education 1993, March 25 Personal communication with Susan Hawkins, ODE. 1991-1992 data on home educated students show their standardized achievement test scores to be higher than national average. 22.3% were in the 91-99th percentile range. 6,370 students (age 7 and above) were registered with the state and test scores were obtained for 4,868.) Descriptors: home education, test scores.
Oregon Department of Education 1999 Home school data collection 1998-99, test scores by percentiles. Retrieved March 28, 2014 from http://www.ode.state.or.us/teachlearn/specialty/home/1999/percen99.pdf http://www.ode.state.or.us/teachlearn/specialty/home/1999/percen99.pdf homeschooling, home education, population size, academic achievement, dataset, Oregon ODE provides academic achievement test scores and homeschool population size.
Oregon Department of Education 2000 1999-2000 home school statistics. Retrieved 3/19/03 online http://www.ode.state.or.us/cifs/homesch/homeschnum2000.pdf. Salem, OR: Author. http://www.ode.state.or.us/cifs/homesch/homeschnum2000.pdf
Oregon Department of Education 2001 2000-2001 home school statistics. Retrieved 3/19/03 online http://www.ode.state.or.us/cifs/homesch/homeschnum2001.pdf. Salem, OR: Author. http://www.ode.state.or.us/cifs/homesch/homeschnum2001.pdf
Oregon Department of Education 2014 Home schooling–data. Retrieved March 28, 2014 from http://www.ode.state.or.us/search/page/?id=2081 http://www.ode.state.or.us/search/page/?id=2081 homeschooling, home education, population size, academic achievement, dataset, Oregon This is main online page of the ODE for data on homeschooling, including number of registered students and academic achievement test scores over several years.
Oregon Department of Education [Office of Student Services] 1993, May 14 Number of registered home schooling students compared with number of tested home schooling students 1986-1992. Salem, OR: Author. achievement, numbers Shows increase in number registered from 2,671 in 1986-87 to 6,370 in 1991-92. Gives percent of home schooling students scoring at given percentiles 1986-1992: "Of 4,868 home schooled student tested for 1991-92, 72% tested at the 50th percentile or above. Twenty-two percent tested at the 90th percentile or above" (p. 1).
Oregon Department of Education [Office of Student Services] 1996 Home school statistics, 1995-96. Salem, OR: Author. home education, population size, academic achievement, state Reports population size and test scores of the home educated for several years. Reports 10,764 students registered as home schooled for 1995-96. Percent of 9,545 students scoring within various percentile ranges on standardized achievement tests: 22% in the 91-99%ile range, 15.5% in the 81-90%ile, 12.2% in the 71-80%ile, 10.9% in the 61-70%ile, and 9.6% in the 51-60%ile range, so 70% of the students scored above the 50th percentile and 37% percent of the home educated scored in the top 20% of the percentiles.
Oregon Department of Education [Office of Student Services] 1997 Home school statistics, 1996-97. Salem, OR: Author. home education, population size, academic achievement, state Reports population size and test scores of the home educated for several years. Reports 11,264 students registered as home schooled for 1996-97. Percent of 10,229 students scoring within various percentile ranges on standardized achievement tests: 22.8% in the 91-99%ile range, 16.0% in the 81-90%ile, 12.6% in the 71-80%ile, 10.9% in the 61-70%ile, and 9.3% in the 51-60%ile range, so 71.6% of the students scored above the 50th percentile and 38.8% percent of the home educated scored in the top 20% of the percentiles.
Oregon Department of Education [Office of Student Services] 1998 Home school statistics, 1997-98. Salem, OR: Author. home education, population size, academic achievement, public, state Reports population size and test scores of the home educated for several years. Reports 11,682 students registered as home schooled for 1997-98. Average academic achievement test scores are above the national average of 50th percentile; median percentile range is the 71st to 80th percentile; very similar to those in 1997 Oregon report.
Oregon Department of Education [Office of Student Services] 1999, May 20 Annual report of home school statistics [1998-99]. Salem, OR: Author. http://www.ode.state.or.us/search/page/?id=2081 http://www.ode.state.or.us/teachlearn/specialty/home/1999/percen99.pdf home education, population size, academic achievement, public, state Also retrieved 7/14/10 from http://www.ode.state.or.us/search/page/?id=2081, and similar data retrieved 3/27/12 from http://www.ode.state.or.us/teachlearn/specialty/home/1999/percen99.pdf. Reports population size and test scores of the home educated for several years. Reports 12,169 students registered as home schooled for 1998-99. Average standardized academic achievement test scores are above the national average of 50th percentile of the 11,405 students for whom the state had test scores; 73% of homeschool students scored above the 50th percentile, 53% above the 70th percentile; very similar to scores in past Oregon reports.
Oregon Department of Education [Office of Student Services] 1999 1998-1999 home school students registered by county. Retrieved 3/19/03 from http://www.ode.state.or.us/cifs/homesch/1999/county99.pdf ; and Home School Data Collection 1998-99: Test Scores By Percentiles, retrieved April 22, 2017, October 10, 2016 and 1/4/10 from http://www.ode.state.or.us/teachlearn/specialty/home/1999/percen99.pdf Salem, OR: Author. http://www.ode.state.or.us/cifs/homesch/1999/county99.pdf http://www.ode.state.or.us/teachlearn/specialty/home/1999/percen99.pdf These scores are state-mandated testing of homeschool students and the scores are collected and published by the State of Oregon. This was the last school year during which all homeschool students were required by law to be registered with the state every year. The median percentile achievement test range for homeschool students is the 71st to 80th percentile (0.55 to 0.84 SD above average), with n=12,169, grades K-12.
Oregon Home Education Network (OHEN) 2005, May 14 Concerns about children falling through the cracks. Retrieved January 4, 2010 and January 14, 2011 from http://www.ohen.org/?q=cracks. Portland, OR: Author. http://www.ohen.org/?q=cracks http://www.ohen.org/?q=search home education, homeschooling, child abuse, state control, regulation, law, legal, policy, philosophy, criticism Date of this article is given at http://www.ohen.org/?q=search “The most recent statistics on child abuse and neglect reports show that: 83% of reports of child abuse and neglect come from community and professional sources other than educators and childcare providers ….. Of the reports of child abuse and child neglect made by professionals, reports from educators, foster parents and childcare providers were most likely to be found to be unsubstantiated. ….. There are at least as many opportunities for child abuse or child neglect to be identified for children educated at home as there are for children in school, without the need for state monitoring.”
Oregon Legislative Assembly, 74th 2007 House Bill 2979, proposed. Retrieved 5/28/07 online http://www.leg.state.or.us/07reg/measpdf/hb2900.dir/hb2979.intro.pdf. http://www.leg.state.or.us/07reg/measpdf/hb2900.dir/hb2979.intro.pdf home education, policy, legal, philosophy, public schools, state schools Two state representatives sponsor a bill to increase the degree of state control of homeschooling, home-based education. “Directs parent, legal guardian or private teacher of homeschooled child to notify education service district each school year. Modifies examination requirements of homeschooled children. Directs district superintendent or designee, after issuing notification, to issue citation to parent or legal guardian of child who does not attend school and who is not homeschooled. Declares emergency, effective July 1, 2007.” One example of many that occur across the states of the US every year to increase state control of private homeschooling.
Oregon State System of Higher Education, Finance and Administration 1995, July 21 Latest projection of Oregon high school graduates. Eugene, OR: Author. home education, population size, research, policy Contains data on grade-by-grade K-12 enrollment, as well as information on recent private school and home schooling trends; estimates that for 1994-1995 year, 715 of 29,673 total “high school graduates” were “home school completers”; projects that for 1999-2000, 3.6% of high school graduates will be “home school completers.”
Ostlund, Karen, Gennaro, E., & Dobbert, M. 1985 A naturalistic study of children and their parents in family learning courses in science. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 22(8), 723-741. Science. Reports on the positive effects, cognitive and affective, of parents and children being involved together in science courses outside of the schools.
Overman, Christian 1988 Different windows. Wheaton, IL: Tyndale Publishers.
Page, Ronald E. 1997 Families growing together: A study of the effects of home schooling on the development of the family. Master’s thesis, Maryvale Institute, Birmingham, England, United Kingdom, 52 pp. home education, research, interviews, family, parent, parents, mother, father, generational, feminism, effects Focuses on the impact of homeschooling on the parents and families. Uses interviews to collect data on 20 families from 20 mothers and 11 fathers. Chapters on the family, the father, and the mother. “Home schooling is a growing movement in both this country and elsewhere, and has been the subject of a considerable amount of research particularly in the United States. Most of that research has focused on the academic success of home schooling and on the good social skills that have been found in the home schooled. The wider impact of home schooling upon the parents themselves and upon the family unit appear to have been overlooked, even though this impact is likely to be very significant. [new paragraph] This research aims to explore this wider impact upon a small number of families. In depth interviews were carried out in twenty home schooling families with the purpose of providing the parents with the opportunity to identify what impact the home schooling had had upon themselves and the family unit. ..... [new paragraph] The results based upon a limited, and perhaps unrepresentative sample, must be treated with some caution, but the consistency of the results is very persuasive. The sample of home schooling families used in this study all accept a traditional view of the family (i.e. father, mother and their children all living together as one unit). This provided the study with a reasonably cohesive sample. Within this sample there had been widespread reflection on the nature and purpose of education, and the problems of discipline; some reflection on the impact of home schooling on the family unit was also occasionally found; but there had been very little reflection on the impact of home schooling on the parents themselves. The effects of home schooling on the development of the family appear to be that the individual members of the family unit are more strongly bonded together, the father is drawn much more deeply into the whole life of the family, and the mother finds real fulfilment in her wider role. Within this sample it would be no exaggeration to say that the impact upon the mother appears to be very considerable indeed” [p. 5]. “Two things were particularly valued by these parents. First, the one-to-one contact with their children was seen as giving the children an academic advantage, and it was also valued by the parents for the deeper knowledge of their child and the closer personal relationship that developed in the process. This one-to-one contact appeared to encourage child-centred education and to give the child much greater freedom to grow as an individual, without promoting individualism. There was one clear case within this study where the sheer amount of adult contact may have been very significant in the transformation of the teenager concerned. Second, the parents enjoyed the freedom from school hours, peer pressure, and so on, that home schooling gave them. Family life seemed to be much more relaxed without these outside pressures. Having so much more time together the family units give the impression of being very united, to the extent that in some cases real friendships appear to have developed within the families, which will have considerable long-term consequences for the Family unit. Home schooling families tend to support each other and most of the families I met were part of a local group of home schooling families, which provided some teaching and activity support, but they have also become close family friends. [new paragraph] The involvement of the parents in the education of their children was seen by this group as a natural part of their role as parents. No mother saw any difference whatsoever between her role as mother and her role as teacher; in fact, they stressed how the two roles flowed naturally together” [p. 47]. “In this study I found an open admission by all the parents involved in the teaching of their own ignorance, even to their own children, but this was accompanied, certainly for the mothers, by a growing self-confidence in their own abilities. This self-confidence was revealed in other areas of their lives as well. One thing all the parents, who were deeply involved in the home schooling, had discovered was a new joy in learning; this was matched by their children’s own joy in discovery, which itself was said by some parents to be further fuelling their own enjoyment” [p. 48]. “This study questions the research that suggested that the ‘dominant discourse’ moulded young women to expect to gain emotional satisfaction from staying at home with their children.” [p. 48]. Author is disappointed could not interview more fathers but found, “The fathers’ personal growth due to home schooling was less obvious than the mothers’, perhaps because their outside roles provide them with opportunities for personal growth and achievement; this adds an uncontrolled variable into this study. Those research findings I was able to trace suggest that the father’s role is very significant in the lives of the children, and the mothers I interviewed agreed with this” [p. 48]. For the mothers and fathers, “... it had become a school of virtue, especially humility and selflessness; it was also encouraging deeper thought on the meaning not only of education but of life itself; thus it was also a school of wisdom. It had lead many of the parents to take a deeper interest in their own faith. The enjoyment or fulfilment that accompanied these things seems to have been addictive, to the extent that the parents were prepared to make greater sacrifices than they were already making. I began with the theological idea that we are not merely affected by our own actions, but actually formed by those actions. In [p. 48 ends] this study of home schooling I have found that the parents are not merely forming their children, but they are themselves being both formed and educated in the process” [p. 49].
Pagnoni, M. 1984 The complete home educator. Burdett, NY: Larson Publishers. home education Written by a public school teacher who took his sons out of school for one year to teach them at home; several chapters on using computers.
Pahler, Tom 1995 Title is related to physical education or psychomotor development of the homeschooled versus those schooled other ways. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Northern Arizona University, Flagstaff. home education, research, physical education Study on homeschooling and physical education.
Pankhurst, J. G., & Houseknecht, S. K. 1983 The family, politics, and religion in the 1980's: in fear of the new individualism. Journal of Family Issues, 4, 5-34. Family policy.
Pannapacker, William A. 2005, December 16 For Professors' Children, the Case for Home Schooling. The Chronicle, 52(17), p. B14, dated December 16, 2005. Retrieved 12/15/05 online http://chronicle.com/temp/email.php?id=zqwdtp61u63rakoasv4hgw0bzg27v7zd. http://chronicle.com/temp/email.php?id=zqwdtp61u63rakoasv4hgw0bzg27v7zd home education, reasons, philosophy, professor, academe, family Explains that most professors/academics are negative toward homeschooling. “Most professors are likely to be appalled [if you tell them you homeschool your children], and those who are not will keep their mouths shut.” Explains that he is a professor and his wife are neither religious extremist nor extreme or marginal practitioners of homeschooling, then explains the many reasons why he and so many others, including professors, homeschool their children. Presents the many advantages of homeschooling for the children, for the parents, and for the families.
Parham v. J.R. 1979 442 U.S. 584. law, legal Supreme Court case says, “That some parents ‘may at times be acting against the interest of their children’ ... creates a basis for caution, but it is hardly a reason to discard wholesale those pages of human experience that teach that parents generally do act in the child’s best interest. ... The statist notion that governmental power should supersede parental authority in all cases because some parents abuse and neglect children is repugnant to American tradition” (p. 602-603 cited/quoted in Christopher Klicka’s The right choice: Home schooling, 1993, p. 313.
Parke, Ross D., & Ladd, Gary W. (Eds) 1992 Family-peer relationships: Modes of linkage. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. socialization, schooling, research, parents Looks at family and other nonfamily social contexts as they affect children's social competence and peer relations development; has historical overview of factors and events related to socialization processes (such as historical events, cultural factors, changing theories of researchers, educators, and parents from the early 1900s to the present, and growth of public schools, kindergarten, and early childhood education); present data showing children's peer sociability is related to how parents manage or regulate children's participation in activities, use of time, or choice of playmates.
Parker, Ralph Duane 1992 Inside home schools: A portrait of eighty-four Texas families and the schools in their homes. Unpublished master's (M.Ed.) thesis, Texas Tech University, Lubbock. home education, research, demographics, achievement, reasons, philosophy, religion Comprehensive descriptive statistics of these families including information on demographics, reasons for home educating, views about the state and education profession, special challenges or problems related to home education, academic achievement, etc.. Review of literature is extensive.
Parsons, Cynthia 1985 Let children start school when they're ready! Phi Delta Kappan, 67(1), 61-62. Early childhood education. Followed by Moore's article, p. 62-64. Ages should not be the criteria for when children should start formal schooling; their abilities should.) Descriptors: early childhood education, formal schooling, age.
Parsons, Paul 1987 The fourth "R". Christianity Today, September 4, 21-27.
Parsons, Sarah. & Lewis, A. 2009, online The home-education of children with ds or disabilities in the UK: views of parents from an online survey. International Journal of Inclusive Education. http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13603110802504135?journalCode=tied20 home education, research, reasons, special needs, disabilities, barriers “Abstract: The home‐education of children is one ‘choice’ of provision that is often overlooked or unreported in the debate on inclusive education for children with disabilities or special educational needs. This study aimed to access the views of these hard‐to‐reach home‐educating families through an online survey. Twenty‐seven parents, with at least one child with special educational needs or disabilities/being educated at home, responded, and over two‐thirds identified ‘push’ factors away from the school as their main reasons for educating their children at home, such as bad experiences with formal provision and the perceived failure of schools to meet their child’s needs adequately. A majority of children had been at a mainstream school at the time of the decision to home‐educate and 48% of the children were described as having an Autistic Spectrum Disorder. Findings are discussed in relation to the ‘personalisation’ agenda of education in the UK” (retrieved January 7, 2016 from http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13603110802504135?journalCode=tied20 E-mail from lead author, February 24, 2010: “The home-education of children is one 'choice' of provision that is often overlooked or unreported in the debate on inclusive education for children with disabilities or special educational needs. This study aimed to access the views of these hard-to-reach home-educating families through an online survey. Twenty seven parents, with at least one child with special educational needs or disabilities being educated at home, responded, and over two-thirds identified 'push' factors away from the school as their main reasons for educating their children at home, such as bad experiences with formal provision and the perceived failure of schools to meet their child's needs adequately. A majority of children had been at a mainstream school at the time of the decision to home-educate and 48% of the children were described as having an Autistic Spectrum Disorder. Findings are discussed in relation to the 'personalization' agenda of education in the UK."
Passmore, B. 1982, October 15 Bovson floats home-teaching idea. Times Education Supplement, p. 16.
Patterson, Jean A.; Gibson, Ian; Koenigs, Andrew; Maurer, Michael; Ritterhouse, Gladys; Stockton, Charles; & Taylor, Mary Jo 2007 Resisting bureaucracy: A case study of home schooling. Journal of Thought, Fall-Winter 2007, 71-86. homeschooling, reasons, school structure, philosophy, public schooling, political resistance “Numerous educational researchers have pointed out the bureaucratic assumptions that underpin the way educational organizations are structured and have kept schools from adapting to a rapidly changing society …” (p. 74). “The contemporary home school movement has prompted a polarizing debate over the merits of home school versus the merits of more traditional places called schools. We do not wish to “take sides” in what we believe is an unproductive argument. Although we acknowledge our study included a small number of home school families, we do believe public education can gain from their insights and home grown educational practices” (p. 82). “It seems that home school families are neither the pawns of the political right, nor do they deserve to be demonized by public education researchers, policymakers, administrators, or teachers. As we gain a deeper understanding about the people behind the demographics of home schooling, a picture emerges of families who want what is best for their children; who desire to be involved with their children’s lives and education” (p. 83).
Patterson, Sue 1998, September/October Public school homeschooling programs. Home Education Magazine, 15(5), 25-27. home education, public school support, cooptation, cooperation, philosophy, politics Discusses tax-funded, state-controlled, public school programs designed for home schooling or education at home and philosophical and other concerns about the increasing number of these programs around the country. Explains that changes and controls that home schoolers do not want or expect come with state-controlled homeschool programs. Explains that the government wants the families to be accountable to the government and that pariticpation in such programs changes the philosophical thinking, motivations, and thinking of home educators, often before they are aware of it.
Paul, L. James, & Marfo, Kofi 2001 Preparation of educational researchers in philosophical foundations of inquiry. Review of Educational Research, 71(4), 525-547. philosophy, doctorates, professors, research Discussion of training education researchers in philosophy.
Payne, J. Scott, & Allen, Jeff 2020 ACT composite scores among homeschooled students trended up from 2001 to 2019. ACT Research & Policy, www.act.org/content/dam/act/unsecured/documents/R1831-act-homeschool-stats-2020-08.pdf http://www.act.org/content/dam/act/unsecured/documents/R1831-act-homeschool-stats-2020-08.pdf https://www.act.org/content/dam/act/unsecured/documents/R1832-ACT-homeschool-tested-2020-06.pdf ACT, college testing, college admission, homeschool, private school, public school, test scores, academic achievement, achievement see also https://www.act.org/content/dam/act/unsecured/documents/R1832-ACT-homeschool-tested-2020-06.pdf ). ("This report summarizes trends in ACT® Composite scores for homeschooled students compared with private- and public-school students. From 2001 to 2013, mean ACT Composite scores for homeschooled students fluctuated between a low value of 22.3 in 2007 and a high of 22.7 in 2013. The mean ACT Composite scores for homeschooled students trended upwards from 2013 to 2018 and have been consistently higher than those for public school students, with the difference ranging between 1.4 score points in 2007 to 2.7 score points in 2018. Compared to students enrolled in private schools, homeschooled students have scored lower since 2003, with the gap incrementally widening to 1.3 points by 2019. All three groups have experienced declines in mean ACT Composite score since 2017, marking the first time that scores dropped for all three groups. Figure 1. Mean ACT Composite Scores for Homeschooled and Private School Students Have Trended Up, Public School Student Scores Have Declined (2001-2019)."
Pearl, Michael, & Pearl, Debi 1994 To train up a child, 108 pp.. Book available from authors, 1010 Pearl Rd., Pleasantville TN 37147. child training, discipline, child rearing, Christian, biblical Provides a biblical perspective on child training; "this book is not about discipline, nor problem children. The emphasis is on the training of a child before the need to discipline arises. It is apparent that most parents never attempt to train a child to obey. They wait until the child becomes unbearable and then explode" [Introduction].
Pearl, Michael, & Pearl, Debi 2007 Jumping ship. Pleasantville, TN: No Greater Joy Ministries.
Pearlman-Avnion, Shiri; Grayevsky, Mor 2017 Homeschooling, Civics, and Socialization: The Case of Israel. Education and Urban Society, 51(mis???), 970-988. homeschooling, school, civic engagement, social self-efficacy, socialization, Israel “Abstract: The present study uses qualitative and quantitative methods to examine whether homeschooled youth in the largely urbanized social context of Israel differ in their level of civic engagement and social self-efficacy from that of their peers educated at school. Participants completed quantitative questionnaires on civic engagement and social self-efficacy and two personal questionnaires, one quantitative and one qualitative, pertaining to their opinions on various modes of education. No significant differences were found between the degree of civic engagement and sense of social self-efficacy among the two groups. However, within the homeschooling group, social self-efficacy decreased as the number of years they were schooled at home increased, indicating potential negative impact of extended homeschooling. The qualitative study gives insights into attitudes of youth from both groups regarding various modes of education. The findings are discussed in the context of the ongoing debate regarding the pros and cons of homeschooling.” “We sought answers to the following in the present study: Research Question 1: How does the level of civic engagement of Israeli homeschooled children compare with that of their peers educated in school? Research Question 2: How does the level of social self-efficacy of Israeli homeschooled children compare with that of their peers educated in school? Research Question 3: Is the number of years of homeschooling related to civic engagement and social self-efficacy?” (p. 8) Cross-sectional, explanatory study; participants ages 14-20, somewhat controlled for background variables of age and parents’ education level. No significant differences in degree of civic engagement and sense of social self-efficacy.
Peavey, S. M. 1987 The frontier of educational freedom: Home schooling. Home School Researcher, 3(2), 5-8.
Pennings, Ray; Seel, John; Van Pelt, Deani A. Neven; Sikkink, David; & Wiens, Kathryn L. 2011 Cardus education survey: Do the motivations for private religious Catholic and Protestant schooling in North America align with graduate outcomes? Hamilton, Ontario, Canada: Cardus. www.cardus.ca. http://www.cardus.ca home education, homeschooling, research, Roman Catholic, Christian school, Protestant, public school, outcomes, educational attainment, occupation, civic engagement, political engagement, spiritual formation, marriage, family, social psychological outcomes Explain that Christian schools “… have served a vital role in the educational landscape of North America for over 400 years …” and that from about 1600 “… until late in the 18th century, the purpose of education in the U.S. was centered on religion …” (p. 9). “As John Dewey, Robert Booth, and other historic and contemporary educators have argued, all schools are religious in nature, and therefore parents desire schools in which congruence can exist for their children between home, religious institution, and school” [p. 11]. “The Cardus Education Survey has just this purpose—to determine the alignment between the motivations and outcomes of Christian education, setting a benchmark for further study of Christian schooling” [p. 12]. Christian education, in this study, includes homeschooling by Christian parents but the study is not focused on home-based education. Their survey of graduates i.e., from secondary school, high school) – “… which included participants from Catholic, Protestant, non-religious private, public, and homeschool graduates – focused on educational and occupational attainment, civic and political engagement, spiritual formation, marriage and family as well as social psychological outcomes in the young adult years” [p. 44]. Present several findings about the adults in the study. Authors have developed a valuable research concept. They are trying to understand to what degree the outcomes of Christian education match the motivations of adults who design and conduct the Christian education for children. However, that this study has not “…allowed for the establishment of quality benchmarks …” [p. 36] regarding the thinking, religious beliefs, and actual behaviors of adults who were home educated. They might have “quality benchmarks” regarding those who attended state (public), Roman Catholic, and Christian schools but not for those who were homeschooled by Christian parents. This is how they determined what type of schooling the participant had received: “Again, schooling history information included whether the respondent had primarily attended a Catholic, conservative Protestant or “Christian school,” another type of Christian school, a non-Christian religious school, a nonreligious school, or a home school” (p. 44); that is, “primarily attended,” but authors do not define that.One problem with the methods is that “homeschooled” was defined as a participant reporting he was homeschooled in high school and therefore it is not known for how many of their K-12 years they were home educated. Further, the “home educated” were categorized as either “religious” or “nonreligious,” simply depending on whether their mothers attended religious services regularly. About 2,000 randomly selected Americans, aged 23 to 49, were sampled and studied; of those, less than 90 [personal communication with one of the authors] – and the sample size is not reported – were home educated at all, and only some of these less-than-90 had a “religious” homeschool mother during high school. This is a very small sample size from which very few dependable conclusions can be drawn about the adults who were “homeschooled” by “religious” mothers. Authors should have been much more careful to explain the notable limitations of their study regarding the home educated.
Pennings, Ray; Sikkink, David; Berner, A.; Smith, C.; Berends, M.; Dallavis, J.; and Skiles, S. 2014 Cardus Education Survey: Private Schools for the Public Good: 2014 Report. private schooling, private schools, public good, homeschooling, research, home education, Canada, United States “The Cardus Education Survey 2014 report explores the impacts of various school sectors on the academic, vocational, social, and civic development of graduates, and finds that in many measures of cultural goods, private schools are as attentive to the public good as public schools. Common myths of isolationism and intolerance are challenged by these results from private school graduates” (p. 5). Mention homeschooling in several places. Also, they write: “The remaining high school sector that deserves considerable attention is home education, which is only somewhat smaller than the nonreligious private school sector. The home school movement itself has several distinctive tracks, and we found a commensurate variety of outcomes in levels of commitment to faith and family and in educational attainment. Some of our homeschooling findings raise questions about the civic skills and engagement of homeschooling graduates. Given the many differences between home and school education, and the complexities of isolating the school effect in this scenario, we will provide an in-depth analysis of our homeschooling findings in a separate report” (p. 15). That is, the authors do not provide findings on those who were homeschoold. The “methodology” section on page 38 does not give the sub-sample size of those who were homeschooled. “Data are drawn from a representative sample of 1,500 American [U.S. and Canada?] high school graduates between the ages of 24 and 39” (p. 5). “About 1,000 of the respondents had primarily attended a private elementary or high school, and about 500 had primarily attended public school” (p. 38).
Pennings, Ray; Sikkink, David; Van Pelt, Deani; Van Brummelen, Harro; & von Heyking, Amy 2012 Cardus Education Survey: A Rising tide lifts all boats: Measuring non-government school effects in service of the Canadian public good. Hamilton, Ontario, Canada: Cardus. private education, public good, Roman Catholic schools, Protestant schools, homeschooling, home education, citizenship, occupation, life satisfaction The overall sample size was 2,054 Canadian residents. Of these, the analysis and findings included “… 34 religious home-educated students …” (p. 18). Ergo, findings and statistics about homeschooling are based on only “34 religious home-educated students” nationwide in Canada. Nationwide sample was based on random selection of Canadians. “Using the standards for educational outcomes grounded in provincial statutes, regulation, and policy, we conclude that various non-government schooling sectors—Separate Catholic, Independent Catholic, Independent Non-religious, Evangelical Christian, and religious home education—produce graduates who embody commonly desired excellences and characteristics in generally even higher proportions than do government-run public schools. These conclusions suggest that non-government schools are important contributors to education delivery in Canada and that they can be regarded to contribute to the public good. Various themes emerged from findings with respect to graduates of non-government schools, even when the results are controlled for family socioeconomic and religious background, and in many cases point to statistically significant effects of the schools they attended. Canada’s government schools perform very well in international rankings, but by many measures, Canada’s non-government schools perform at even higher levels. ….. Stronger families: Graduates of non-government schools are less likely to be divorced or separated. Evangelical Protestant school graduates and religious home school graduates are more likely to have more children” (p. 5). “Although showing comparatively high results in measures relating to life satisfaction, graduates of evangelical Protestant schools and of religious home education report that the dominant culture is hostile to their beliefs and values. Nonetheless, they continue to be engaged with the culture and contribute to it. ….. Graduates of Evangelical Protestant schools and of religious homeschooling have a strong sense of vocational calling, seek jobs that fulfill that calling and pay well, but are less rooted occupationally than their non-religious school counterparts. ….. This suggests that if students in these two sectors [evangelical Protestant school graduate and religious home education graduate] do decide to go to university they pursue education vigorously. It is quite possible that they are concerned about the utility of their degree and only leave when they have attained sufficient employment credentialing. ….. Whereas evangelical Protestant schools and religious home education graduates reflect attributes of religious conviction, spiritual formation, and practices that one would expect of those who are religiously motivated (with schooling effects having contributed positively to those results), graduates of separate Catholic schools appear almost identical to those of public schools in every measure.” (p. 6). “Graduates of religious home schooling tend to be furthest from the mean on many measures, ranging from being divorced or separated (much less) to donating to religious causes as well as boycotting products for ethical reasons (much more)” (p. 7).
Pennsylvania Homeschoolers [newsletter] 1996, Early Fall Homeschoolers score high on college boards. Pennsylvania Homeschoolers, 56, 1. academic achievement, college admissions, aptitude tests Reports that during the 1995-1996 school year 75 11th and 12th grade home schoolers, 39 female and 36 males, in a Pennsylvania home school organization took the SAT I and self-identified as home schoolers. “The middle PA Homeschooler scored 600 (80th percentile) in verbal and 550 (65th percentile) in math. These scores were very similar to the 1993-94 school year when 35 homeschoolers took the SATs and the middle homeschooler scored at the 79th percentile in verbal and 65th percentile in math” (p. 1).
Perelman, Lewis J. 1992 School’s out: A radical new formula for the revitalizaiton of America’s educational system. New York, NY: Avon Books. educational reform, technology, hyperlearning, home education “This book is not about education. It is about an economic transformation that is being driven by an implacable technological revolution. It is not about saving schools, or improving schools, or reforming schools, or even reinventing schools—it’s about removing altogether the increasingly costly barrier schooling poses to economic and social progress” [p. 7]. Emphasizes the importance of “hyperlearning” which “... is not a single device or process, but a universe of new technologies that both possess and enhance intelligence ...” that deals with new information technology, a connectedness of knowledge, media, and brains, and the transformation of knowledge and behavior through experience [p. 23]. Mentions home education a little; says, “... home schooling of children is an option that deserves your serious consideration” [p. 336].
Perkel, Frances Ellen 1979 The effects of a home instruction program on the cognitive growth of a selected group of 4-year-olds. Dissertation Abstracts International, 40, 1859A. University of Southern California will not lend).
Peshkin, A. 1984 Odd man out: Participant observation in an absolutist setting. Sociology of Education, 57, 254-264. Discussion of the problems of conducting research in a closed setting.
Peters, Barry 2004, circa Calling their bluff: The History of ICHE complaint assessments. Retrieved January 19, 2008 from http://iche-idaho.org/issues/05/. http://iche-idaho.org/issues/05/ home education, policy, regulation, child abuse, child neglect, educational neglect “Their mantra: "We support home education and know that you people here at "Pie Day" are all doing a fine job of teaching your children at home, but... what about those children whose parents are uneducated themselves. They are keeping their children out of school so that they can work on the family farm, or so that they can babysit the younger children in the family. We need home school accountability with mandatory registration and testing to catch those children who are falling through the cracks so that no child is left behind." Those reports alleged that there were a significant number of children in the state whose parents claimed that they were teaching their children at home when they were, in fact, giving them no education at all.” Private homeschool organization voluntary developed a reporting system in cooperation with Idaho state agencies. “Eventually, a cluster of twelve "complaints" was forwarded to ICHE in the second half of 2002. In 2003, the number of complaints forwarded to ICHE dropped back to just three. Each of those fifteen complaints was carefully investigated. The results of all of the reported cases for the entire four-year life of this program to date, each of which was reported back to the Department of Education as promised, were as follows: ….. In short, the massive problems with home education perceived by the professional education community now appear not merely to have been overblown, but to be essentially nonexistent. This new information has provided ICHE with a tremendous tool to dissuade legislators of the need for registration and testing. It effectively counters the "what if" scenarios offered by the opponents of home education.”
Peters, Barry 2009, Summer Legal update: The view from inside the horse. home education, homeschooling, Idaho, law, legal On homeschooling in Idaho.
Peterson, Andrew J. 1997, March/April The perspective of the American Psychological Association on home schooling: “Psychologists are wary of schooling children at home.” Home School Court Report, 13(2), 3. home education, psychology, socialization, research, opinion Describes the concern of psychologists as expressed in an article in a professional magazine, the American Psychological Association’s Monitor. Explains that the opinions are based on logical fallacies and limited research. Explains that home educators are raising their children to be different from the majority culture in which they live. Claims that citizens need to be free from the “tyranny of the experts.”
Phelps, Jack E. 1989 A literature reading list for Christian home schoolers. (Available from The Seventh Trumpet Ministries, P.O. Box 628, Talkeetna, AK 99676) home education, curriculum
Phelps, Jack E. 1990 Surrender v. obedience: A legal and historical perspective on educational vouchers and tax credits. Available from Seventh Trumpet Ministries, P.O. Box 628, Talkeetna AK 99676. vouchers, tuition tax credits, home education, choice Raises "...points worthy of response before the home school community plunges into what may well be a suicidal swim in government invested [sic] waters" (p. 14).
Phi Delta Kappa International 1998 The 30th annual Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup poll of the public’s attitudes toward the public schools. http://www.pdkintl.org/kappan/kp9809-1a.htm Online www.pdkintl.org/kappan/kp9809-1a.htm retrieved 4/13/00 and earlier. (Among other things, show majority of American parents would choose private [or home?] schooling rather than state-run schools if they thought they had authentic choice and Black parents appear to be more interested in this choice than do white parents.]
Phi Delta Kappa International 1999 The 31st annual Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup poll of the public’s attitudes toward the public schools. -- see under Rose & Gallup, 1999.
Phi Delta Kappa International 2000 The 32nd annual Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup poll of the public’s attitudes toward the public schools. -- see under Rose & Gallup, 2000.
Phi Delta Kappa International 2001 The 33rd annual Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup poll of the public’s attitudes toward the public schools. -- see under Rose, Lowell C., & Gallup, Alec M. (2001).
Phi Delta Kappa International 2013, August 21 The 2013 PDK/Gallup Poll on Public Schools: Change Agents: People Making a Difference. Retrieved April 3, 2015 http://pdkintl.org/blogs/change-agents/the-2013-pdkgallup-poll-on-public-schools/. http://pdkintl.org/blogs/change-agents/the-2013-pdkgallup-poll-on-public-schools/ homeschooling, public opinion “4. There is growing acceptance for alternative forms of teaching and learning. Americans’ support for public charter schools remains high at slightly less than 70%, and a majority of Americans believe that public charter schools provide a better education than other public schools. Sixty percent of Americans support allowing parents to homeschool their children, and an overwhelming majority of Americans favor having public schools provide services to homeschooled children. Three of four Americans favor allowing high school students to earn college credits via the Internet. We view this as a transition in perspectives among Americans; they are becoming more accepting of different forms of teaching and learning. However, 70% of Americans oppose private school vouchers — the highest level of opposition to vouchers ever recorded in this survey.”
Phillips, Daschell M. 2006, October More black families choosing homeschooling. School Reform News, 10(8), 9. home education, minorities, blacks, African Americans, academic achievement, reasons Reports that African Americans homeschool for many reasons. Cites research of National Home Education Research Institute and Brian Ray. "’African Americans, like so many others, are quickly coming to recognize the myriad benefits of parent-led home-based education,’ Ray said.”
Pierce v. Society of Sisters, 268 U.S. 510 1925 law, philosophy, education United States Supreme Court case; court declares that parents have the right to choose a private educational program for their children.
Pietersma, Douglas James 2020 The lived experience of homeschooling families and the transference of faith tradition: A narrative exploration. Doctoral dissertation (Ed.D.), Regent University, Virginia, USA. homeschooling, faith development, Christian, qualitative, research “Abstract: The purpose of this research was to examine the lived experiences of Christian homeschooling families in relation to the desire to pass on the families’ faith tradition to their children. The researcher chose a qualitative approach to explore the various elements of Christian homeschooling that provided either a positive or negative impact to faith transference. To examine these experiences, the researcher interviewed five mothers who homeschooled at least one child through high school. The researcher also interviewed one homeschool student from each of these families who had graduated at least two, but not more than 7 years prior to the start of the research project. Participants discussed various aspects of the Christian homeschooling experience that played a role in the transference of the family’s faith tradition from parent to student. After coding, the researcher triangulated the data between corresponding pairs of parent and student, analyzed the data across the range of participants, and categorized results for thematic analysis. The results and discussion are presented in narrative format” (p. iii).
Pitman, Mary Anne 1985, November Home schooling: A community survey. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Studies Association, Atlanta, GA.
Pitman, Mary Anne 1986 Home schooling: A review of the literature. Journal of Thought, 21(4), 10-24. A review, as title implies. Discusses compulsory education and key court decisions related thereto. Describes advocacy and resource literature. Describes "data-based studies" of home schooling: self-report surveys with information on "parents' views, procedures, motivations and sociodemographic variables" [p. 16] or case studies of one or more families. Brief description of author's 1985 survey of members of a New Age community, with many involved in home schooling. "Home Schoolers tend to fall into three broad categories: religious, progressive, and academic, or, alternatively, Fundamental Christians, New Agers, and the `Harvard-bounds'" [p. 12].
Pitman, Mary Anne 1987 Compulsory education and home schooling: Truancy of prophecy? Education and Urban Society, 19(3), 280-289. Points out that home school families, although representing a small proportion of school age youth and comprised of parents seriously and energetically endeavoring to educate children, are disproportionately pursued by truant officers who spend comparatively little time on students who do not attend school at all and the large number of "in-school" truants. Says there are three broad categories of home schoolers: "religious, progressive, and academic, or, alternatively, Fundamental Christians, New Agers, and the `Harvard-bounds'" (p. 281). "Parents' reasons for home schooling, then, in this community [rural, New Age] and in communities throughout America, are less defensive than has been commonly assumed. To these families, home schooling simply makes sense. What does not make sense is to send their young children off to an institution to join dozens of other youngsters in a round of activities largely unrelated to their lives at home in order to learn information that can be learned at least as well and probably better in their own home environment" (p. 283). Points out that home schooling is neither new nor unusual, an that "What is new in the context of American history is universal, compulsory schooling" (p. 286). The compulsory school phenomenon has served to fit into the historical context of an " ... increase in the size and complexity of industry and commerce" (p. 287). Pitman says that the skills of reading, writing, and figuring are the "skills of hearth and home" (p. 288) and are not esoteric, as they might have once been, and can be learned as well and usually better at home now. "And as far as the skills of the hidden curriculum such as competition and regimentation are concerned, they are viewed not as esoteric, but as obsolete" (p. 288). Philosophy of education.
Pitman, Mary Anne 1988, April Home based learning in a new intentional community: Applying the holistic model of cultural acquisition. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans.
Pitman, Mary Anne, & Smith, M. Lynne 1988 Culture Acquisition in an Intentional American Community: A single case. University of Cincinnati, Ohio.
Pitman, Mary Anne, & Smith, M. Lynne 1991 Culture acquisition in an intentional American community: A single case. In J. A. Van Galen & M. A. Pitman (Eds.), Home schooling: Political, historical, and pedagogical perspectives. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation.
Pitsch, Mark 1990, December 12 Cavazos creates outreach office to promote choice: Calls idea key to National Goals. Education Week, 10(15), 30. home education, improvement, vouchers
Planty, Michael, Hussar, William, Snyder, Thomas, Kena, Grace, KewalRamani, Angelina, Kemp, Jana, Bianco, Kevin, & Dinkes, Rachel 2009, June The condition of education 2009. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education. Report number NCES 2009-081. Retrieved June 15, 2009 from Uhttp://nces.ed.gov/pubs2009/2009081.pdfU. http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2009/2009081.pdfU Includes statistics on homeschooling. Table Table A-6-1, Number and percentage distribution of all school-age children who were homeschooled and homeschooling rate, by selected characteristics: 1999, 2003, and 2007, p. 134; 77.0% of homeschool students were white in 2003 and 76.8% were white in 2007; 45.8% of families had income of $50,001 or more in 2003 and 60.1% same in 2007; that much of this “increase in income” could have been due simply to inflation since $45k in 2003 was the same, adjusted for inflation, $51k in 2007.
Plass, Ewald M. (Compiler) 1959 What Luther says: An anthology, volume I. St. Louis, MO: Concordia Publishing House. philosophy, theology, education Quotes Martin Luther categorized by topic on which Luther wrote or commented. Luther supports “public” education — but it was within a definite context; Luther said, “My idea is to let boys go to such a school for an hour or two a day and spend the rest of the time working at home, learning a trade, or doing whatever their parents desire. . . . . . Just so a girl can surely find time enough to go to school one hour a day and still attend to all her duties at home” (Plass, p. 448). Furthermore, and perhaps most significantly, Luther warned, “But where the Holy Scripture does not rule I certainly advise no one to send his child. Everyone not unceasingly occupied with the Word of God must become corrupt; therefore we must see what people in the higher schools are and grow up to be. . . . I greatly fear that schools for higher learning are wide gates to hell if they do not diligently teach the Holy Scriptures and impress them on the young folk. . . . . . Above all things, the principal and most general subject of study, both in the higher and lower schools, should be the Holy Scriptures” (p. 449).
Plent, Malcolm, & Plent, Nancy An article on famous homeschoolers). New Jersey Unschoolers Network, 2 Smith Street, Farmingdale, NJ, 07727.
Podles, Mary Elizabeth Smith 1993? De-schooling the domestic church: Some thoughts on teaching at home. Available from 702 Saint John's Road, Baltimore MD 21210. Clearly written personal account of what led her family to home educate their six children. Weaves in limitations of conventional schools, both public and private, how her family home schools, and what Roman Catholics can do to teach their beliefs to their children.
Polivanova K.N., & Lyubitskaya K.A. 2017 Homeschooling in Russia and abroad. Journal of Modern Foreign Psychology, 6(2), 72–80, doi:https://doi.org/10.17759/jmfp.2017060208. Retrieved September 4, 2017 from http://psyjournals.ru/en/jmfp/2017/n2/86651.shtml http://psyjournals.ru/en/jmfp/2017/n2/86651.shtml https://doi.org/10.17759/jmfp.2017060208 “Abstract. The article presents a relatively new practice of home education for Russia. A survey of numerous studies shows that the transition to homeschooling is characteristic of families with a high value of family cohesion, for those who want to protect their children from the dubious influence of their peers, and for those who have a special idea of religious education. The most widespread home education ("homeschooling") has in the USA (up to 8% of schoolchildren), is allowed and is actively growing in many countries of Europe. The psychological aspect of the problem of home education is linked in the presented review mainly with the theme of family cohesion, although a number of researchers believe that homeschooling itself is only an additional and not the main factor of cohesion. According to the empirical study, Russian homeschoolers are faced with a large number of organizational problems in the transition to home education and with a lack of pedagogical competence of parents and a shortage of special methods of individual education, since only 16% have pedagogical education. The main psychological problems in choosing a homeschooling include a misunderstanding from the inner circle, and in the implementation - the difficulty in determining the parent role. If in traditional school education the parent is a welcoming and loving parent, then at home education the parent becomes demanding and controlling. Homeschooling provokes the creation of various kinds of associations and groups of mutual supports of parents, which indicates the ambiguity and difficulties in implementing this form of education for children. Keywords: homeschooling, home schooling, home education, Russia, reasons for choice, child-parent relations”
Pollack, Daniel 2012 Homeschooling and child protection. Policy and Practice, February 2012, 29, 35. http://repository.yu.edu/bitstream/handle/20.500.12202/4042/art%20APHSA%20Homeschooling%20and%20child%20protection%20Feb%202012.pdf?sequence=1 homeschooling, abuse, risk, CPS, law, legal Retrieved April 1, 2020 from http://repository.yu.edu/bitstream/handle/20.500.12202/4042/art%20APHSA%20Homeschooling%20and%20child%20protection%20Feb%202012.pdf?sequence=1 “Homeschool advocates note, however, that without definitive evidence that there is an increased risk of abuse, there should be no cause for undue scrutiny and suspicion of homes in which children are homeschooled. Indeed, they ask poignantly, how safe are children in public and private schools? In both cases, we dare not underestimate the formidable task faced by CPS [child protective services] workers” (p. 35).
Ponzetti, Peter, III 2010, December 23 Impact of homeschooling on public education part-time enrollment and extracurricular activities. A paper published by the author, impete80@yahoo.com.
Popenoe, David 1996 Life without father: Compelling new evidence that fatherhood and marriage are indispensable for the good of children and society. New York, NY: Martin Kessler Books, The Free Press. research, sociology, fathers, fatherhood, fatherlessness, mothers, motherhood, family, marriage This social scientist “... provides an analysis of the American experiment of fatherlessness. Drawing from the social sciences, history, and evolutionary psychology, it examines the nature and meaning of fatherhood and reviews the trend, the evidence, and the social consequences of the removal of fathers from families and the lives of their children. Regrettably, as I shall point out, America is at the vanguard of social trends and impulses that are affecting fatherhood and children in all modern societies” [p. 1]. Provides much research evidence for the decline of fatherhood and marriage and family. Examines motherhood to a lesser extent. Describes changes in gender roles for husbands/wives and fathers/mothers. Explains that good fatherhood is positively related to higher academic achievement in children [p. 148]. The empirical evidence “... shows that by far the best environment for childrearing is in the home and under the care of the biological parents. The more both parents can be in close contact with the child in the early years, the better. It also indicates that every infant needs one special person to whom he or she can become attached, a person who cares about the child beyond reason. That person typically has been the biological mother, the person most highly motivated for the task” [p. 214]. Extensively uses evolutionary theory to explain fathers and their behaviors (e.g., Ch. 6). Says that there are not yet enough good data and longitudinal studies to evaluate the effects on children’s wellbeing of homosexual couples raising children [p. 147]. One conclusion is, “The main source of happiness is having close, warm, and enduring relationships. And the main generator of such relationships is marriage and the family” [p. 215]. Accepts fornication in the form of cohabitation before marriage as common and a possibly beneficial practice in America but opposes sexual promiscuity [p. 204]—a rather paradoxical position. Makes five propositions: “1. Fathers have a unique and irreplaceable role to play in child development. Fathers are not merely would-be mothers. The two sexes are different to the core, and each is necessary--culturally as well as biologically--for the optimal development of a human being. ..... 2. More than just needing their fathers, children need a committed male and female couple--a mother and a father in a joint partnership--to provide them with dependable and enduring love and attention at least during their growing-up years” [p. 197]. 3. For men, more than for women, marriage and parenthood are strongly interlinked. Men need cultural pressure to stay engaged with their children, and that cultural pressure has long been called marriage. ..... 4. The most important and enduring dimension of fathering has to do with a child's feelings. Children need to feel recognized and accepted by their fathers; they need to feel that they are special. ..... 5. Biological fathers are more likely to be committed to the upbringing of their own children than are nonbiological fathers. Human beings have evolved to invest more readily in genetically related persons than in nonrelated persons. Being a father is much more than merely playing a social role. Engaged biological fathers care profoundly and seWessly about their own children, and such fatherly love is not something that can be transferred easily or learned from a script. [p. 198]. Offers “action implications” for each of the 5 propositions.
Popper, Karl R. 1934, original German Logik der Forschung 1934; English 1959 The logic of scientific discovery. London: Hutchinson & Co. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/popper/ philosophy of science, demarcation, falsifying, falsification “Popper draws a clear distinction between the logic of falsifiability and its applied methodology. The logic of his theory is utterly simple: a universal statement is falsified by a single genuine counter-instance. Methodologically, however, the situation is complex: decisions about whether to accept an apparently falsifying observation as an actual falsification can be problematic, as observational bias and measurement error, for example, can yield results which are only apparently incompatible with the theory under scrutiny. Thus, while advocating falsifiability as the criterion of demarcation for science, Popper explicitly allows for the fact that in practice a single conflicting or counter-instance is never sufficient methodologically for falsification, and that scientific theories are often retained even though much of the available evidence conflicts with them, or is anomalous with respect to them. In this connection, in the Logic of Scientific Discovery Popper introduces the technical concept of a “basic statement” or “basic proposition”, which he defines as a statement which can serve as a premise in an empirical falsification and which takes the singular existential form “There is an X at Y”. Basic statements are important because they can formally contradict universal statements, and accordingly play the role of potential falsifiers. To take an example, the (putative) basic statement “In space-time region k there is an apparatus which is a perpetual motion machine” contradicts the law of the conservation of energy, and would, if true, falsify it (2002: 48). Accordingly, Popper holds that basic statements are objective and are governed by two requirements: (a) the formal, that they must be both singular and existential and (b) the material, that they must be intersubjectively testable” (retrieved June 18, 2026 from https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/popper/ ).
Postlewaite, Charlotte C. 2004, February The home school debate. State Government News, 47 (2), 18-20. home education, research, policy, opinion, public schools, cooperation Gives quick, dispassionate, fact-based overview of homeschooling to state governments and policy makers.
Postman, Neil 1995 The end of education: Redefining the value of school. New York: Vintage Books. philosophy of education, sociology, public schools, purpose of schooling I read Part 1 (through page 87). He makes some excellent and true points about education – that is, schooling – needing a metaphysical purpose if it is going to be successful in helping the next generation and society. He offers some great sentences to quote. Page 4 – he appears to say that all education is religious; yes, it is. Page 7 - Without a narrative, a god, learning has no purpose. Yes. Page 14 – raised by Jews. Jewish? Does not appear to be a Christian by what he writes. Lays out what he thinks are today’s gods of schooling. – pretty good, maybe accurate. He is correct that without a unifying purpose, end, the public schools will further deteriorate and be further irrelevant to anything useful. His focus is public/statist schooling. Page 45 (also p. 57)– schooling is largely about making “good Americans” he seems to believe. Basically, he’s correct but one might disagree that we should have statist schools and have them molding children hearts/minds. Page 45 – implies that children cannot have good/proper social growth without schools. Wrong. Page 46 – his pitch for state-run schools appears parochial and too dogmatic. One may wonder whether he knows and understands homeschooling and what he thinks of it. He appears to think that state schooling is good and necessary to a good society; some would heartily disagree. Pages 65 – 72 – he offers some potentially new good gods for public/state schools. Christians would likely say that they will not work because they are false gods. Page 73 (bottom) – his proposed narrative, god, is the the USA as “the great experiment.” Clever, interesting. However, from a biblical/Christian perspective, this is a false god, for what should be the end/purpose of education.) Page 76, middle – he implies that Chrsitan homeschooling would be bad. I hold, however, that Christ/scripture-based home education is good for the public while hostile to public/statist schooling.
Preuss, Alison 2020, December 9 Why the barriers to home education are troubling: Covid should not be used by councils as an excuse to delay or refuse the right to home education, says Alison Preuss. Retrieved December 23, 2020 from https://www.tes.com/news/why-barriers-home-education-are-troubling https://www.tes.com/news/why-barriers-home-education-are-troubling home education, homeschooling, barriers, government regulation, law, legal “Following an investigation of local authorities’ home education policies and practices, our Home Truths report, published in March, highlighted the unnecessary, yet seemingly routine, gathering and sharing of personal information by councils when parents withdrew their children from state schools. Since home educators’ data subject access requests had already uncovered catalogues of unlawfully obtained information, factual errors, hearsay, professional bias and outright contempt for those who objected to their rights being infringed, we embarked on a deeper dive into council policies. Drawing on case studies and freedom of information responses, our Taking Local Authorities To Task report, published in October, exposed the routine collection and sharing of home educators’ personal information that far exceeded what was necessary or legally permissible. Many policies mandated such data processing, despite there being no lawful bases or safeguards to prevent overreach. The discriminatory legal anomaly that means some parents need council consent to withdraw children from school remains especially troubling. Although consent may not be unreasonably withheld, it is frequently exploited to obstruct parents as arbiters of their children's best interests.”
Pride, Mary 1985 The way home: Beyond feminism, back to reality. Westchester, IL: Crossway Books. education, homeschooling, parental authority, parental rights, home education Chapter 7 “Who owns our kids?” on the difference between discipling and teaching, child can be taught math without being discipled by teacher but spiritual discipling may occur, links education to Christian beliefs. In same chapter, p. 95, on education/schooling talks about discipling influence of peers over the child in both public or private schools, implies homeschooling is prescribed by the Bible by writing the following: “As I read the Scriptures, public education is not a legitimate function of government at all” [p. 98]. She cites Romans 13:3-4 as the proper role of civil government, cites Deuteronomy 11:19 and 6:7 that parents are to be the main educators of children.
Pride, Mary 1986 The big book of home learning, volume 1. publisher???
Pride, Mary 1988 Schoolproof: How to help your family beat the system and learn to love learning—the easy, natural way. Westchester, IL: Crossway Books, 204 pp.. home education Christian perspective.
Pride, Mary 1989 All the way home: Power for your family to be its best. Westchester, IL: Crossway Books. Home as the center of life, home education, anti-modern feminism, pro-biblical family.
Pride, Mary 1990 [and 1991] The big book of home learning, 4 volumes. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books. A review of home schooling resources. Available from The Teaching Home, listed below.
Pride, Mary (Editor) 1997, January/February Everything you need to know about getting into college and at home! [special topic for this issue]. Practical Homeschooling, January/February 1997, 36-65. home education, college, college admission and preparation, adults Discusses many topics including the articles entitled “Meeting college admission requirements” by Betty Berring and Vivian Young, an interview with Tom Rollins of Mirus University, “Getting college credit for your homeschool” by Susan Richman, “Going to college at home” by Paula Mann, “The independent learner” by Dr. Arthur Robinson, “Unit studies” by Jessica Hulcy, “Classical education” by Fritz Hinrichs, “A law school that caters to homeschoolers” by Paul Glader, “Unschooling” by Mary Ann Turner, and “Accelerated education” by Joyce Swann.
Priesnitz, Wendy 1980 Schooling at home. Orbit, 11, 3-5.
Priesnitz, Wendy 1998 School free. [book] [mis?? publisher]
Priesnitz, Wendy, & Priesnitz, Heidi 1990, March Home-based education in Canada: An investigation. Available from The Alternative Press, 195 Markville Road, Unionville, Ontario L3R 4V8, Canada. research, home education, descriptive, rationale, motivation, reasons, academic achievement, religion, income, demographic Creates profile of home educators in terms of socioeconomic status, political/religious orientation, motivation for home educating, relations with public school system, views on achievement testing of children, and curriculum usage; unclear, but appears 500 families included in data analysis; annual family income—51% less than $30,000/year, 41% at $31,000-60,000, and 8% more than $61,000; highest parent educational attainment—26% high school graduation, at least one parent has college degree in 66% of families, at least one parent without high school graduation 7%; 59% rural, 41% urban; 53% say formal religion is a major influence in lives, 13% have some commitment to formal religion, 12% have spiritual beliefs but no organized religion, 22% have no commitment to religious beliefs; main reasons for home educating—72% academic/philosophical, 25% religious, 3% location; attitude toward public school system—49% philosophically against, 6% against due to bad experience, 31% indifferent/neutral, 10% no opinion; had conflicts with public school system—18% yes, 82% no; children undergone psychological testing—15% yes, 85% no; children undergone standardized academic achievement testing—32% yes and are above average, 4% yes and below average, 64% no; feelings about standardized testing—38% say unnecessary, 26% say harmful/inaccurate, 36% are indifferent/in favor; use of a home study program—42% no, 30% Christian, 5% provincial correspondence, 22% other; home education style—32% formal, 30% unstructured, 20% child-directed, 18% combination of formal/informal.
Priewe, Rob 1988 Home schooling. Corvallis Gazette Times, April 3, pp. E1-E2.
Princiotta, Daniel, & Bielick, Stacey, and Chapman, Christopher 2006, February Homeschooling in the United States: 2003 statistical analysis report [NCES 2006-042]. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences Retrieved 3/8/06 and 5/28/07 online http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2006/2006042.pdf. http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2006/2006042.pdf home education, research, population size, population growth, demographics, reasons This is a much-expanded version of Princiotta, Bielick, & Chapman [2004, July]. It is one of the broadest and most methodologically sound studies of its type – but this is said with one significant caveat: one should keep in mind that the authors’ statistics, inferences, and conclusions are derived from data on families representing only 239 students in grades K through 12; this likely represents only about 120 homeschool families out of (according to the inferences made in this study) over 500,000 homeschool families in the United States. That is to say, the unit of analysis in some instances for some variables is very small and the margin of error might be relatively large, as the authors discuss in various ways. This study “… uses the Parent and Family Involvement Survey of the 2003 National Household Education Surveys Program (NHES) to estimate the number and percentage of homeschooled students in the United States in 2003 and to describe the characteristics of these students and their families. It reports on the race and ethnicity, income level, and educational attainment of students’ parents; compares the characteristics of homeschoolers to those of public and private schooled students; examines how homeschooling rates have changed between 1999 and 2003 for different segments of the student population; and describes parents’ primary reasons for homeschooling their children, as well as the resources and curricular tools homeschooled students use in their education. Children were considered to be homeschooled if their parents reported them being schooled at home instead of at a public or private school, if their enrollment in public or private schools did not exceed 25 hours a week, and if they were not being homeschooled solely because of a temporary illness. Interviews were conducted with the parents of 11,994 students ages 5 through 17 with a grade equivalent of kindergarten through 12th grade. Of these students, 239 were homeschooled. . . . the weighted estimate of the number of students being homeschooled in the United States in the spring of 2003 was 1,096,000, a figure which represents a 29 percent increase from the estimated 850,000 students who were being homeschooled in the spring of 1999 (table 1). In addition, the estimated homeschooling rate—the percentage of the student population being homeschooled—rose from 1.7 percent in 1999 to 2.2 percent in 2003” [p. iii]. Parents gave many reasons for homeschooling. “Parents were then asked which one of the applicable reasons they considered to be their most important reason for homeschooling—31 percent of homeschooled children had parents who cited concern about the environment of other schools, such as safety, drugs, or negative peer pressure, as the most important reason for homeschooling and 30 percent had parents who said the most important reason was to provide religious or moral instruction (table 4). While these were the two most common responses, another 16 percent of homeschooled students had parents who said dissatisfaction with the academic instruction available at other schools was their most important reason for homeschooling. Many of the 2003 survey findings concerning homeschooling rates by student and family characteristics paralleled those found in 1999. In 2003, as in 1999, the homeschooling rate for White students (2.7 percent) was higher than for Black students (1.3 percent) or Hispanic students (0.7 percent table 2). The homeschooling rate was also higher for students in families with three or more children in the household than for students in families with fewer children, higher for students in two-parent households than for students in one-parent households, and higher for students in two-parent households with only one parent participating in the labor force than for students with other parent labor force participation patterns. A multivariate analysis was conducted to determine whether these relationships held when controlling for all other demographic factors investigated in this report. In the multivariate analysis, most of the relationships held, but differences were not detectable between White and Black students and between students in two-parent households and students in one-parent households. Between 1999 and 2003, homeschooling rates increased for a number of groups. Homeschooling rates increased from 0.9 to 1.7 percent among students with parents who have a high school diploma or less, from 2.0 to 2.7 percent among White students, from 1.6 to 2.4 percent among students in grades 6–8; and from 0.7 to 1.4 percent among students in single-parent households where the parent was in the labor force. Finally, the 2003 report also investigates the sources homeschoolers used to obtain curricula or books for home education. A majority of homeschooled students had parents who used one or more of the following sources of curricula or books for their children’s home education: a public library (78 percent); a homeschooling catalog, publisher, or individual specialist (77 percent); a retail bookstore or other store (69 percent); and an education publisher that was not affiliated with homeschooling (60 percent table 5). Some students also used [p. iv ends] distance learning media. Forty-one percent of students who were being homeschooled in 2003 had engaged in some sort of distance learning (figure 3 and table 6)” [p. v]. In 1999, 16.7% of homeschool households had one parent and 17.9% one parent in 2003, a 7% increase [Table 3, p. 9]. Compared to all students nationwide in terms of geographical distribution, homeschooled are disproportionately common in the “south” (34% of all students and 41% of homeschool students) and slightly underrepresented in the “northeast,” “midwest,” and “west” [Table 3].
Princiotta, Daniel, Bielick, Stacey, & Chapman, Chris 2004, July 1.1 million homeschooled students in the United States in 2003. [NCES 2004–115] Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences. Retrieved 8/4/04 online http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2004/2004115.pdf. http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2004/2004115.pdf home education, research, population size, demographics, reasons Provides brief summary of findings from this study. “About 1.1 million students (1,096,000) were being homeschooled in the United States in the spring of 2003 (figure 1). This represents an increase from the estimated 850,000 students who were being homeschooled in the spring of 1999. In addition, the estimated homeschooling rate—the percentage of the school-age population that was being homeschooled—increased from 1.7 percent in 1999 to 2.2 percent in 2003 …” (p. 1). “The 95 percent confidence interval for the number of students who were homeschooled in spring 2003 is 915,000 to 1,277,000 (figure 1).2 The best estimate provided here—1,096,000—is the midpoint of that interval” (p. 2). “Thirty-one percent of homeschoolers had parents who said the most important reason for homeschooling was concern about the environment of other schools (figure 2). Thirty percent said the most important reason was to provide religious or moral instruction. The next reason was given about half as often; 16 percent of homeschooled students had parents who said dissatisfaction with the academic instruction available at other schools was their most important reason for homeschooling” (p. 2). “The increase in the homeschooling rate (from 1.7 percent to 2.2 percent) represents about 0.5 percent of the 2002–03 school-age population and a 29 percent relative increase over the 4-year period” (p. 3).
Private School Monitor 1993 Parent involvement [theme issue]. Private School Monitor, 14(1 & 2), 1-20. research, parent involvement Articles and research on parental involvement in nonpublic schools.
Prue, Irene M. 1997 A nation-wide survey of admissions personnel’s knowledge, attitudes, and experiences with home schooled applicants. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, University of Georgia, Athens. home education, research, college, university, success, academic achievement, college admissions, socialization, reasons Prue cited her own 1996 study by saying, “Perhaps one of the most shocking findings of Prue’s study was the animosity, even hostility in some cases, of student affairs professionals toward the home schooling process” [p. 5]. Objectives of this study were to find out what knowledge admissions personnel possess about home schooling, examine their attitudes toward home schooling, find out what experiences admissions officers had with home schooled applicants, and what were the admissions policies regarding the home educated. Surveyed largely experienced admission personnel with an average of 13 years of experience. “Admissions personnel are reporting that home schooled students are doing well academically. ... less than 2% of admissions personnel reported that few or none of the admitted home schooled students were academically successful” [p. 58]. “On the other hand, 49% of respondents reported that they did not know the academic status (success of home schooled students enrolled at their institutions” [p. 58]. 32% of respondents said they had a written policy established for admitting the home schooled. “Nearly 60% [of respondents] had fewer than ten encounters [with home schooled students during the past 12 months], but interactions were occurring [p. 59]. Doubts that solid and consistent experiences are guiding the policies and attitudes of admissions personnel. Reports personnel report they are familiar with parents reasons for home schooling, “... but appeared to be unaware of the breadth and scope of the home schooling movement at large. Only on-fifth of the respondents knew that there are presently over one million students being home schooled ... Only one-third ... knew that home schooling was legal in all 50 states” [p. 59]. Finds admissions personnel believe that parents have a right to educate their children as they see fit and to decide what values their children should be taught, “... have the responsibility to separate their children from undesirable peer groups; Students in the secondary grades can be adequately instructed at home; The home school movement will significantly impact higher education in years to come; and Admissions personnels’ attitudes will become more positive as they interact more with home schooled students and their parents” and these personnel do not believe “That parents are better able to motivate their children than public school teachers; That the teaching of values is solely a parental responsibility; and “That there are no better evaluators of a child’s growth, development and education than his/her parents” [p. 60]. “Eighty-nine percent of respondents agreed parents had the right to decide what values their child should be taught, yet only 50% agreed with the statement that parents have the right to decide content. This values/content incongruence is noted here because it is one of many compelling reasons why some parents choose to home school their children. Many parents who home school see content and values as extremely interconnected ...” [p. 60-61]. Respondents report that “Home schoolers are academically, emotionally, and socially prepared to succeed in college; Parental motivations and involvement are in the best interest of their children; and While documentation and evaluation of home schooled applicants is problematic, it is not insurmountable” [p. 62]. Suggests colleges develop tracking mechanisms to distinguish between home schooled and other applicants, develop tracking mechanisms to monitor progress of home schooled students in college “... to assess the factors that hinder or help their success at college; and Developing a home school admission policy specific to the institution based on the factors known to contribute to the success of previous hoe schooled students (e.g., incorporate known factors into admission’s criteria via regression procedures)” [p. 63].
Pruzan, Adam 1998 Toward tradition on educational vouchers/school choice. Mercer Island, WA: Toward Tradition (9311 SE 36th Suite 210, PO Box 58, Mercer Island WA 98040). education, public, private, reform, history, philoslophy, religion, voucher, vouchers, school choice Reports that the Anti-Defamation League [ADL] claims that public education should be strictly secular and quotes the ADL as saying, “The extent that [educational] vouchers encourage religious and/or ethnic groups to segregate their children, opponents contend that they will foster a ‘balkanization’ of our educational system, which can undermine the important role public schools play in teaching the same common national secular values and historical perspectives--and in producing American citizens with a shared national identity and purpose” [p. 1]. Pruzan writes, “We generally agree that promoting a shared national identity is a legitimate goal of education. However, ADL again fails to offer any evidence that the public schools are the best or only way to achieve this goal. In assuming such to be the case, ADL further implies that the public education establishment should determine the content of the ‘values’ and ‘historical perspectives’ to be instilled in children. Thus, in terms of their ability to control their children’s education, ADL’s view would effectively limit parents to the political influence they can exert as voters. [new paragraph] We reject all of this: The clear implication that our most important ‘common values’ are secular, the belief in public schools as the best vehicle for national cohesion, and the implicit attenuation of parental authority. And, once again, we note that there is nothing Jewish about any of these positions” [p. 1]. “With respect to education, however, the traditional Jewish sources speak unequivocally, laying down a number of clear principles relevant to the current debate: (1) Parents must have responsibility and control [over children’s education] ..... (2) Teachers and schools are agents of parents ... control and responsibility remain with the parents. ... The ‘education establishment’ always remains accountable to parents. (3) Education should inculcate values as well as knowledge. Because of this, the Jewish tradition does not see education as purely secular” [p. 2]. “Furthermore, ADL’s invocation of a historical theory about public schools (that they played a crucial role in integrating past generations of immigrants into American society), has little contemporary relevance, In fact over the past thirty years, the public schools have either served as the vehicle for, or functioned as the direct cause of, a massive assault on national unity: ... racial segregation of our cities ... exacerbated the cultural conflict between liberals and traditionalists ... undermined the natural integration of black and Hispanic children into the American mainstream. This disastrous record refutes ADL’s most significant argument for the unique importance of public-schools” [p. 4]. Presents a traditional and conservative Jewish view about education.
Puga, Lisa 2019 “Homeschooling is our protest:” Educational liberation for African American homeschooling families in Philadelphia, PA, Peabody Journal of Education, 94:3, 281-296, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617579. https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617579 homeschooling, home schooling, African American, Black, protest, philosophy, school choice “Abstract. As increasing numbers of researchers, parents, and youth are rethinking the traditional school system as the default educational option in the United States, homeschooling is not only growing in size but also in philosophical scope and demographic diversity. African Americans particularly have been one of the steadiest-growing homeschooling demographics. Among the few ethnographic accounts of black homeschooling families, youth perceptions tend to be overlooked. This article builds upon scholarship exploring racial injustices in education with new qualitative research: observations and interviews with 15 African American homeschooling families living in Philadelphia. This research reveals a variety of motivations undergirding African American families’ homeschooling decisions and perspectives, including commentary from youth homeschoolers. Previous research has critiqued homeschooling as a neoliberal exercise in privatization that entrenches the social reproduction of inequality, or operates as a destabilizing threat to public interest. Yet, findings from this study complicate these assessments by examining the ways African American homeschoolers enmesh themselves within educational reform conversations, some viewing homeschooling as a form of political protest.” “These critiques that suggest privatized educational practices perpetuate social inequalities are important contributions to contemporary understandings of homeschooling. However, the few existing studies with African-American homeschoolers suggest that these very inequalities, and the ways they translate into racial injustice in schools, often serve as the catalysts for why black families switch to homeschooling (Fields-Smith & Wells Kisura, 2013; Mazama & Lundy, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015). Underfunded schools, limited extracurricular options, lack of cultural and historical representation, and pervasive negative stereotypes are just some of the factors black youth encounter in schooling (Fields-Smith & Wells Kisura, 2013;Mazama & Lundy, 2012, 2015). African-American families who choose homeschooling as a critical response to the constraints of institutional racism showcase important variation among homeschooling motivations that may be overlooked in neoliberal critiques” (p. 282). “Insights from black feminist theory help to dismantle the ideological separation between “public” and “private” spheres that underpins many critiques of homeschooling. I argue that homeschooling spaces are deeply connected to and integrated with public education, whereby they actively engage and inform each other. When Daria Woodson asserts that “Homeschooling is Our Protest,” she transforms the seemingly private endeavor of homeschooling into a public stance of resistance. Daria compels us to view her homeschooling decision as not simply a retreat from the public system, but as a political critique of it” p. 283). (“Reframing homeschooling as a protest provides a proverbial “link of passage” between normative schooling ideologies and their critiques. In this sense, the act of the protest represents liberation itself” (p. 284). “Section I: “Like many parents, I began homeschooling because I was tired, angry, and frustrated...” (p. 286). “Section II: “The decision to homeschool for many families is far from easy.”(p. 288). “Many critics of homeschooling suggest that the movement stems from the same neoliberal ethos that typically characterizes ideologies of economic privatization and further perpetuates social inequalities in the public sphere (Avery-Grubel, 2009; Ball, 1998; Hanson-Thiem, 2007; Lubienski, 2003; Stein, 2001; Whitty & Edwards, 1998). However, all too often, these critiques paint too broad of a picture in their application to all homeschoolers, especially when generalizing homeschooling motivations across socioeconomic and racial backgrounds. Other scholars attempt to differentiate black homeschooling’s role in society as separate from the dominant role of white homeschooling, the latter being viewed as more influential in altering current social systems (Apple, 2000, 2013; Lubienski, 2003; Reich, 2002). This attempt to ideologically relegate black homeschooling perspectives into a marginal category among homeschooling trends resembles the oppressive “flattening” of black experiences that contribute to hegemonic systems of knowledge production (McKittrick, 2006: p. 56) Rather than view homeschoolers as existing within a stasis margin, a more nuanced reconceptualization defines a margin of fluidity where the black families who describe their homeschooling as [p. 293 ends] an act of resistance navigate across boundaries of marginalization into realms of power-through protest (Collins, 2002; McKittrick, 2006). Comparing homeschooling to an act of protest transcends and transforms the perceived boundedness of privately-operating processes of homeschooling into a new framework of publicly-operating processes of resistance. In this sense, homeschooling grants a unique lens of positionality for many black families to critique and challenge dominant systems of educational inequality” (p. 293-294).
Puma, Michael; Bell, Stephen; Cook, Ronna; Heid, Camilla; Broene, Pam; Jenkins, Frank; Mashburn, Andrew; & Downer, Jason 2012, October Third Grade Follow-up to the Head Start Impact Study, Final Report (OPRE Report 2012-45). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. early childhood education, Head Start, academic achievement, social-emotional development, health, policy Essentially find that Head Start has almost no long-term or lasting positive effects on children. “Key Findings: Looking across the full study period, from the beginning of Head Start through 3rd grade, the evidence is clear that access to Head Start improved children’s preschool outcomes across developmental domains, but had few impacts on children in kindergarten through 3rd grade. Providing access to Head Start was found to have a positive impact on the types and quality of preschool programs that children attended, with the study finding statistically significant differences between the Head Start group and the control group on every measure of children’s preschool experiences in the first year of the study. In contrast, there was little evidence of systematic differences in children’s elementary school experiences through 3rd grade, between children provided access to Head Start and their counterparts in the control group” (p. xvi). “In summary, there were initial positive impacts from having access to Head Start, but by the end of 3rd grade there were very few impacts found for either cohort in any of the four domains of cognitive, social-emotional, health and parenting practices. The few impacts that were found did not show a clear pattern of favorable or unfavorable impacts for children” (p. xvii).
Purdy, Bruce D. 2000 On-Line Charter Schools for Homeschool Families? The proverbial “wolf in sheep’s clothing.” A report distributed to educate families on Charter/Community Schools. (Available from ) home education, alternatives, government programs, cooperation, co-optation, philosophy Received from author via e-mail 9/1/00 Describes the dangers to parents’ educational sovereignty present in government-controlled, tax-funded “services” to home schoolers.
Purnell, Richard F., & Gotts, Edward E. 1987 School-family relations: Issues for administrators (Special issue). Education and Urban Society, 19(2). home-school relations, parent involvement Articles include "School-family relations and effective schools," Parent involvement: What research says to administrators," "Improving home-school relations: Implications for staff development."
Qaqish, Basil 2007 A comparison of home schooled and non-home schooled students on ACT mathematics achievement test. Home School Researcher, 17(2), 1-12, https://nheri.org/home-school-researcher-an-analysis-of-homeschooled-and-non-homeschooled-students-performance-on-an-act-mathematics-test/ https://nheri.org/home-school-researcher-an-analysis-of-homeschooled-and-non-homeschooled-students-performance-on-an-act-mathematics-test/ home schooling, homeschooling, home education, public school, private school, comparison, research, college aptitude, adults, academic achievement, college entrance exam, math, mathematics, matched-pair design, peer-reviewed Finds that nonhomeschoolers score better than homeschoolers, on average, on two items out of 60 on the ACT math test. “The proportion correct comparison graph below shows that non-homeschoolers had an overall proportion correct values higher than their counterparts of homeschoolers” [p. 4]. “This huge number of items exhibiting DIF stresses the fact that there is a marked difference of response patterns between the two groups on the item level. DIF is conceptualized as a difference in the probability of endorsing a keyed item response, when individuals with the same levels of ability possess different amounts of supplemental abilities that affect their responses to the item. The high number of items that exhibited DIF in this study may be indicative of the difference in mathematical training (i.e., teaching methods, teacher-learner interaction) between the two groups. Such a possible conclusion demands further research and investigation that is beyond the scope of the current study” [p. 5]. Author concludes the following: “On average, non-homeschoolers performed better than homeschoolers, by about two items, out of sixty items, on the ACT mathematics test that was analyzed. Comparing the two groups of examinees indicated a high number of items displaying DIF. This result may be due to the different teaching/learning media used in teaching each of the two groups, to different teacher/student interaction, or to the number of years homeschooled before taking the ACT mathematics test. More investigative research is needed in this regard” [p. 11]. “During the beginning of 2003, ACT Inc. was contacted to obtain two data sets of response vectors, for the same form of an ACT mathematics test for homeschooled and non-homeschooled students with four demographics included in the data (grade level, gender, ethnicity, and SES).” “This filtering resulted in the 1,807 student records represented in home schoolers.dat and records for 274,313 non-homeschoolers.” “In the end, two comparable files, with regard to the four demographics were obtained (N=1477). In short, matched samples were created through random selection. Those obtained files were, for the most part, the ones analyzed in this study.” “There are three distinct results from this study: On average, non-homeschoolers performed better than homeschoolers, by about two items, out of sixty items, on the ACT mathematics test that was analyzed. Comparing the two groups of examinees indicated a high number of items displaying DIF. This result may be due to the different teaching/learning media used in teaching each of the two groups, to different teacher/student interaction, or to the number of years homeschooled before taking the ACT mathematics test. More investigative research is needed in this regard. In general, there are more homeschoolers, who got a specific item correct than non-homeschoolers for total score categories less than 30. There are more non-homeschoolers who got a specific item correct than homeschoolers for total score categories more than 30” (p. 11). Score differences are not very large, practically speaking. Author shows accurate insight to suggest the home educated might be trained differently than those in institutional schools which might explain the difference on a test that is designed mainly, by far, for those attending institutional schools. Matched-pair design. Peer-reviewed.
Quade, Quentin L. 1993, March The family's values and educational choice. The Family in America, 7(3), 1-10. research, family, choice, moral development, values Logical and well-articulated critique of the Educational Finance Monopoly C "...by which is meant simply the policy of allocating all educational tax dollars noncompetitively to public schools, while withholding all such funds form the alternative independent schools. The effect of EFM, whether intended or not, is to make it difficult or impossible to maintain and educational environment in which family-sanctioned ethical standards can be taught or insisted upon. This arrangement subverts the family's right and duty to insure the moral formation of its children" [p. 2]. Uses philosophical, economic, and legal arguments. Argues for breaking EFM in order to empower parents.
Quine, David Neal, & Marek, Edmund A. 1988 Reasoning abilities of home-educated children. Home School Researcher, 4(3), 1-6. home education, research, cognitive development, formal thinking Compares students, ages 6 to 13, who were solely home educated to those who were home educated and received special private school instruction in terms of their development of formal thinking. The central purpose of the private school in this study was the promotion of maximum intellectual growth. Intellectual growth for the study was operationally defined as the development of cognition from preoperational thought through concrete and formal operational thought as has been described by Inhelder and Piaget. The two groups of students were matched in terms of age, gender, and intellectual development. After the nine months of treatment, pretest/posttest gains on intellectual development were measured. There was no significant difference in the gains between the two groups. Quine and Marek found that both groups moved into formal thought between the ages of 10 to l1, which far surpassed the national average in this respect. The findings indicated that parents of the solely home educated gave their children experiences that were necessary to foster intellectual development just as well as did the school that was purposely designed to foster the same.
Quine, David, & Quine, Shirley 1996 Let Us Highly Resolve: Families Living for Christ in the 21st Century. education, homeschooling, biblical, philosophical, worldview Argue that in order for children to be ready to stand for Christ in the 21st century their lives must be firmly established upon the Biblical worldview. The Quines set forth seven challenges to consider as parents disciple their family.
Quinn, Tom 2003, December 4 Web academy would cater to home-schoolers: Husband-and-wife educators apply for grant money to start an online charter school in the North Clackamas district. The Oregonian. Retrieved 12/8/03 online http://www.oregonlive.com/search/index.ssf?/base/metro_south_news/107028336737720.xml?oregonnian?smn. http://www.oregonlive.com/search/index.ssf?/base/metro_south_news/107028336737720.xml?oregonnian?smn cooperation, cooptation, public school, homeschool, home education Describes a tax-funded public school program that may be marketed to private homeschoolers.
Quist, Allen 2002 Fed Ed: The new federal curriculum and how it’s enforced. St. Paul, MN: Maple River Education Coalition. education, public schools, philosophy, politics, curriculum Examines idea that “... change agents are quietly and effectively restructuring education in a way that transforms schools from institutions of learning to centers of social engineering” [back cover of book].
Radcliffe, Jennifer 2010, May 10 Home-school is so popular, some are getting suspicious. Retrieved 6/18/10 from http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/metropolitan/6999109.html. http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/metropolitan/6999109.html home education, population growth, public school Author quotes some growth statistics from some public school districts in Texas. “While home-schooling's popularity has increased, the rate of growth concentrated in Texas' high school population is off the chart: It's nearly tripled in the last decade, including a 24 percent jump in a single year. “That's just ridiculous,” said Brian D. Ray, founder of the National Home Education Research Institute. “It doesn't sound very believable.” ….. Yet, a review of Houston-area figures shows that home-school withdrawal rates remain minuscule at middle schools in the region, raising a red flag among experts. If withdrawals were increasing for religious reasons, that should be apparent across grade levels, Ray said.”
Raico, Ralph 2010, August 16 What Is Classical Liberalism? Retrieved February 10, 2017 from https://mises.org/library/what-classical-liberalism https://mises.org/library/what-classical-liberalism liberalism, classical liberalism, philosophy, economics, politics “"Classical liberalism" is the term used to designate the ideology advocating private property, an unhampered market economy, the rule of law, constitutional guarantees of freedom of religion and of the press, and international peace based on free trade. Up until around 1900, this ideology was generally known simply as liberalism. The qualifying "classical" is now usually necessary, in English-speaking countries at least (but not, for instance, in France), because liberalism has come to be associated with wide-ranging interferences with private property and the market on behalf of egalitarian goals. This version of liberalism — if such it can still be called — is sometimes designated as "social," or (erroneously) "modern" or the "new," liberalism. Here we shall use liberalism to signify the classical variety.”
Railsback, Gary Lyle 1994 An exploratory study of the religiosity and related outcomes among college students. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, University of California, Los Angeles.
Rakestraw, Jennie F. 1987 An analysis of home schooling for elementary school-age children in Alabama. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa. home education, research, academic achievement, parent education, teacher certification, gender Found no relationship between Stanford Achievement Test scores of homeschool students and “teacher certification status of the parent-teacher” [p. 84-87, Table 7 on p. 87]. Finds no relationship between parent education level and homeschool student achievement [p. 80-84, Table 5 and Table 6 on p. 83 and 85].
Rakestraw, Jennie F. 1988 Home schooling in Alabama. Home School Researcher, 4(4), 1-6. http://www.nheri.org/Volume-04-Issue-4/HOME-SCHOOLING-IN-ALABAMA.html home education, research, academic achievement, parent education, teacher certification, gender, Alabama Academic achievement of the home educated is comparable to that of conventional school students. Gender of student, parent education level, and teacher-certification status of parent were not significantly related to children’s academic achievement [p. 5]. “The first set of comparisons was made using two-tailed t-tests to test the difference between the mean scores of the Alabama home-schooled children and the Alabama public-schooled children at grade levels 1, 2, 4, and 5. The findings were that the home-schooled children performed at comparable levels to the public-schooled children at each grade level. Other comparisons were made using analysis of variance to determine if significant differences existed in the achievement of groups of home-schooled children based on their SAT scores. The comparisons were made for the following groups using raw scores: (a) male and female, (b) level of education of the parent-teacher, and (c) teacher certification status of the parent-teacher. It was found that the home-schooled boys and girls performed comparably to one another on the standardized achievement tests. The level of education of the parent-teacher did not affect the performance of the children on the tests. And the home-schooled children whose parent-teachers were not certified to teach performed as well on the standardized achievement tests as those whose parent-teachers were certified to teach” (i.e., teacher certification status of parents was not correlated or associated) [retrieved 3/20/2011 from http://www.nheri.org/Volume-04-Issue-4/HOME-SCHOOLING-IN-ALABAMA.html.
Ranbom, Sheppard 1985, May 1 Four states, feeling pressure, loosen home-schooling rules. Education Week, 4(32), 1, 14.
RAND Corporation 2010 What teacher characteristics affect student achievement?Findings from Los Angeles Public Schools. Retrieved 7/5/10 from http://www.rand.org/pubs/research_briefs/2010/RAND_RB9526.pdf. http://www.rand.org/pubs/research_briefs/2010/RAND_RB9526.pdf http://www.rand.org/pubs/reprints/RP1410/ student academic achievement, public school, teacher qualifications licensure licensing “RAND researchers examined the relationship between teacher quality and student achievement by analyzing five years of math and reading standards tests and other records from students in elementary, middle, and high schools in the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD). LAUSD is the secondlargest public school district in the United States, …..” [p. 1]. “However, when the researchers analyzed student achievement data along with teacher qualifications, they found that a five-year increase in teaching experience affected student achievement very little—less than 1 percentage point. Similarly, the level of education held by a teacher proved to have no effect on student achievement in the classroom. ….. When the researchers compared teacher licensure test results with teacher performance in terms of student test scores, they found no relationship between student achievement and teachers’ test scores. The researchers also analyzed whether failing the exam before later passing it was related to student achievement and found no statistically significant link. These findings suggest that the measured basic skills, subject-matter knowledge, and reading pedagogy scores of elementary teachers do not contribute to improved student achievement, implying that new methods of teacher assessment might be needed. ….. Currently, most compensation systems reward teachers for their years of experience and education. The study’s findings suggest, however, that these factors do not accurately predict a teacher’s effect on student achievement” [ p. 2]. “This research brief describes work done for RAND Education documented in “Teacher Qualifications and Student Achievement in Urban Elementary Schools,” by Richard Buddin and Gema Zamarro in Journal of Urban Economics, Vol. 66, No. 2, September 2009, pp. 103–115; available as RP-1410 at http://www.rand.org/pubs/reprints/RP1410/ [p. 2]
Randall, E. Vance 1994 Private schools & public power: A case for pluralism. New York NY: Teachers College Press. private education or schools, research, law, legal, philosophy, parental rights, religion Makes case that "The arbitrary nature of [state] regulations is antipluralistic, attacks the dignity of parents and private school personnel as persons, intrudes into the delicate and sensitive parent-child relationship, violates the parents' sense of moral and religious duty toward their children, and calls into question the parents' competence and motivation without justification" [p. 132] and that the primary responsibility to prepare the child to be a productive and responsible citizen lies with the parents rather than the state, but the state does have a duty to require [through compulsory education laws, p. 138, 139] that children be provided certain educational opportunities.
Rapoport, Esta Milchman 2007 Seizing opportunity: Homeschool parents teaching social skills to their children with ADHD. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Boston University. homeschooling, homeschool, home education, ADHD, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, research, research, special needs, reasons “ABSTRACT Until this investigation, there has been a scarcity of research on parents’ teaching of social skills to their children who have ADHD, in homeschools. The participants included 10 families who resided in different regions throughout the United States. The social skills that parents taught in homeschools were compared to those that Elliott and Gresham (1991) implemented in traditional school settings, by employing within-case and cross case analyses. Videotaping documented the homeschool parents’ teaching methods. Separate interviews of homeschool parents and their children were voice recorded. Inter-observer reliability was 80%. The homeschool parents taught six of Elliott and Gresham’s (1991) social skills and 29 of the non-Elliott and Gresham social skills from a total of 61 social skills. These social skills incorporated Elliott and Gresham’s (1991) paradigm, minimally. The parents predominantly taught the non-Elliott and Gresham social skills to reduce the symptoms of their children’s ADHD. They taught 70% of the social skills to their children as unforecasted and 30% as forecasted. The parents taught a majority of both types of social skills on random rather than on successive days, indirectly and in opportunistic response to the socially inappropriate behavior that their children exhibited. They took advantage of the opportunity when their children exhibited socially inappropriate behavior and taught those social skills by using an “immediate situation” approach. This research considered whether homeschool parents taught their children these social skills by using interventions employed by Elliott and Gresham (1991) or through other interventions. The homeschool parents did not employ any of Elliott and Gresham’s (1991) social skills interventions. Instead, they modified the context, the homeschool, which then shaped the social skills that the parents taught; the modified conditions and the activities of the homeschool became part of the intervention that the homeschool parents employed to teach social skills to their children. Limitations of this research included a lack of checks on consistent applications of code definitions as well as on Elliott and Gresham’s (1991) social skills interventions” [p. x-xi].” For at least 1 hr a day for 5 consecutive days, observed families who homeschooled children diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Recorded each instance in which a parent taught any one of more than 60 specific social skills and how the parent did so. Found that most social skills were taught in unplanned moments, as a response to the child’s ongoing behavior. Results might not apply to other families but a refinement of this researcher's approach might serve as a useful starting point for future research.
Rasmussen Reports 2004, August 14 Public schools best or worst? Retrieved 3/10/2010 from http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/lifestyle/general_lifestyle/public_schools_best_or_worst. http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/lifestyle/general_lifestyle/public_schools_best_or_worst Telephone survey. “a plurality of Americans (42%) continues to believe that public schools provide the best education for children. Nearly as many, 39%, say private schools are best while 11% say home schooling is the top approach. At the same time, a plurality (43%) says that public schools provide the worst education for children. Thirty-four percent (34%) say home schooling is the worst option while only 9% say that private schools are the weakest link.” “Although home schooling is a relatively new phenomenon, 45% of Americans have close friends or family members who home school their children. Among those who have children, 51% have home schooled friends of family members. Among all adults, just 27% say the nation would be better off if more parents home schooled their children. Half (50%) say the nation would be worse off, while 23% are not sure. However, among those who know someone who is home schooled, the response is much more favorable. Thirty-seven percent (37%) say the nation would be better off while 42% say the opposite.” Descriptorss: home education, public school, private school, attitudes, survey, opinion
Rasmussen Research 2000, August 3 Public schools get low grade: Only 27% rate public schools as excellent. Matthews, NC: Author. Retrieved 8/4/00 online http://www.portraitofamerica.com/html/poll-1110.html. http://www.portraitofamerica.com/html/poll-1110.html education, public schools, private schools, home schooling, home education, quality, satisfaction, population size Data are from telephone interviews with 9400 randomly selected adults across the U.S. When asked, "Do your children go to public school, private school or are they home schooled?,” the responses were: 80% public, 15% private, 4% home schooled, and 1% not sure. When asked, “Generally speaking, who should make the most important decisions about a child’s education--teachers or parents?,” responses were: 14% teachers, 77% parents, and 9% not sure. “Portrait of America (POA) finds 64% of parents with children in private schools rate the education their youngsters are receiving as excellent. But, only 27% of parents with children in public systems rate the schools as excellent. As for home school parents, 76% say excellent.” Also asked questions about the quality of public, private, and home schooling.
Rathmell, Jennifer: & Collins, Gail 2013 A heuristic inquiry into the stress that home educators experience. Home School Researcher, 29(2), 1-8. homeschooling, homeschool, home education, stress, research “Abstract: The purpose of this study was to gain a better understanding of the stress that families incur when they choose home education as their primary educational method. Extensive studies exist regarding stress that traditional education teacher’s experience. However, research considering stress experienced by parents who are the primary educators of their children is limited. This study endeavored to provide insight and add to the home-education body of research. Using a heuristic inquiry research design, nine home educators participated in four data collection methods: a homeschool questionnaire, The Occupational Stress Inventory – Revised (OSI-R), a focus group, and individual interviews. The data revealed five primary unique home education stressors: (a) overwhelming responsibility, (b) dealing with behavior and discipline, (c) choosing curriculum, (d) stereotypes and stigmas, and (e) distractions and extracurricular activities. Additionally, the research revealed five primary flourishers in the home education experience. These included: (a) control and freedom, (b) poignant moments, (c) the right curriculum, (d) supportive spouses, and (e) the greater homeschooling community” (p. 1). “This heuristic inquiry has provided a much-needed in-depth look at the unique stressors that home educators experience. Furthermore, this study considered flourishing factors that strengthen home educators in light of these unique stressors. These findings add to the research conducted on home educators. It is my fervent hope that these findings will fuel further insight into the field of home education, as well as encourage and strengthen those who utilize this remarkable educational alternative around the world” (p. 7).
Ravitch, Diane 1992 The role of private schools in American education. In Pearl Rock Kane (Ed.), Independent schools, independent thinkers. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass Publishers. private education, public education, philosophy, history “Interestingly, as the democratic movement spread through Eastern Europe in the 1980s, democratic reformers complain4ed about the complete monopoly of education by the omnipotent state. They realized that control of the schools by the state bureaucracy and imposition of the state’s official ideology were linchpins of the Communists’ efforts to regulate thought” [p. 25]. Explains the value of private education to a free society.
Ray, Brian D. 1985, December Parent as tutor experimental program in Washington state. Home School Researcher, 1(4). research, home education, academic achievement Reviews research on home education.
Ray, Brian D. 1985, December Review of "It Depends on your Aim" by Raymond Moore in September 1985, Phi Delta Kappan. Home School Researcher, 1(4).
Ray, Brian D. 1985, June A review of "Why Teachers Fail" by John Holt. Home School Researcher, 1(2).
Ray, Brian D. 1985, March A critique of the philosophy of education of John Holt, a home school advocate. Home School Researcher, 1(1). Ray reviews Susan D. Franzosa's critique of Holt. See note at beginning of bibliography about availability of the journal Home School Researcher.
Ray, Brian D. 1985, September On Compelling Belief: The culture of American Schooling by Stephen Arons. Home School Researcher, 1(3).
Ray, Brian D. 1986 A comparison of home schooling and conventional schooling: With a focus on learner outcomes. Corvallis, OR: Oregon State University, Science, Math, and Computer Science Education Department. In partial fulfillment of exams for a doctoral degree; this is not Ray’s doctoral dissertation. ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 278 489 Available from National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Research. Achievement. Affective. Operationally defines home and conventional schooling then considers studies that have described various characteristics of home schooling, including demographics. Considers studies indirectly related to home schooling, then considers empirical studies directly related to home schooling. The research designs, methodologies, and statistical analyses of the studies are critiqued. "With respect to cognitive outcomes, then, the evidence suggests that those youth educated in the home school environment will generally do as well or better than their conventional school peers. ..... Likewise, the available empirical data suggest that home school youth are doing at least as well as those in conventional schools in terms of affective outcomes" (p. 43). Most up to date review of empirical data at the time. 57 pages. “The findings regarding home school learner outcomes are thus far based upon pre-experimental (Campbell & Stanley, 1963), causal comparative, and correlational research paradigms. It is difficult, although perhaps not impossible, to start with equivalent samples of youth when involved in an attempt to compare home school and conventional school "treatments." It is possible to hypothesize that the home school treatment is a causal factor of apparently elevated achievement and self-concept scores, but the research to date cannot be said to come close to proving such an hypothesis.” (p. 44). Available through ERIC or from author at address previously given.
Ray, Brian D. 1986, December On "A qualitative study of the characteristics of home schooling families in South Carolina and the perceptions of school district personnel toward home schooling" by Alan Barry Rose. Home School Researcher, 2(4).
Ray, Brian D. 1986, June Alaska's centralized correspondence study program. Home School Researcher, 2(2).
Ray, Brian D. 1986, June Comments on the self-concept study by John Wesley Taylor V. Home School Researcher, 2(2).
Ray, Brian D. 1986, March Home based leadership conference. Home School Researcher, 2(1).
Ray, Brian D. 1986, March Review of "Homes as Schools" by Jack McCurdy. Home School Researcher, 2(1).
Ray, Brian D. 1986, September Comments on Shepherd's home schooling movement study. Home School Researcher, 2(3).
Ray, Brian D. 1986, September On "Adults cognitive demands at home and at nursery school" by Tizard, Hughes, Pinkerton, and Carmichael. Home School Researcher, 2(3).
Ray, Brian D. 1986-1990 Research report. The Teaching Home. A regular column on home education research in The Teaching Home; see comments under "The Teaching Home" reference. Research.
Ray, Brian D. 1987 A comparison of home schooling and conventional schooling: With a focus on learner outcomes, part I. SKOLE The Journal of the National Coalition of Alternative Community Schools), 3(1), 69-85. (Research. Same as first part of Ray, Brian D. [1986], ERIC Reproduction Service No. 278 489, mentioned previously.
Ray, Brian D. 1987, December Barnebey's study of university admission requirements for home schooled applicants, and a follow-up study. Home School Researcher, 3(4).
Ray, Brian D. 1987, June Review of "Schooling in Private: A Study of Home Education" by Jane Van Galen. Home School Researcher, 3(2).
Ray, Brian D. 1987, March Comments on the 1986 report from Washington Home School testing and descriptive information by Jon Wartes. Home School Researcher, 3(1).
Ray, Brian D. 1987, March On Case Studies of Four Families Engaged in Home Education by Beverly Schemmer. Home School Researcher, 3(1).
Ray, Brian D. 1987, September Review of Home educated children's social/emotional adjustment and academic achievement: A comparative study by Mona Maarse Delahooke. Home School Researcher, 3(3).
Ray, Brian D. 1988 A comparison of home schooling and conventional schooling: With a focus on learner outcomes, part II. SKOLE The Journal of the National Coalition of Alternative Community Schools). (Research. Same as second third of Ray, Brian D. [1986], ERIC Reproduction Service No. 278 489, mentioned previously.
Ray, Brian D. 1988 Home schools: A synthesis of research on characteristics and learner outcomes. Education and Urban Society, 21(1), 16-31, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0013124588021001003 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0013124588021001003 home education, research, research agenda, review, synthesis, demographics, academic achievement, reasons Summarizes research on demographics, academic achievement, and affective and psychological development. Points out that research to date is pre-experimental and correlational. “The available evidence indicates that home school youth of compulsory education age have been scoring equal to or better than their conventional school peers on measures of cognitive achievement and desirable affective traits” (p. 25, 26). Emphasizes that most home educators are most concerned about the teaching of values, morals, and philosophy to their children, and that researchers should carefully ascertain these objectives and evaluate whether home schools achieve these goals (p. 27). Demographic characteristics, reasons, research.) The URL
Ray, Brian D. 1988, August 12 The kitchen classroom. Christianity Today, 32(11), 23-26. home education, religion, Christianity Reviews research, most home educators are Christian, reasons. Points out that there has been much focus on achievement test scores, self-concept, and social adjustment but "Perhaps what is needed, in addition to the other comparisons, is for researchers to question home-school parents carefully to find out more precisely what their objectives are for their children. They should then follow the youth over a long term to determine whether home schooling is actually effective in meeting the home schoolers' goals" [p. 26].
Ray, Brian D. 1988, August 29 Interview with National Broadcasting Company [NBC] "The Today Show" host]. National Broadcasting Company Television, New York, NY. (Regarding home schooling, the National Education Association's [of which Futrell was president] position, and research perspectives from Dr. Brian D. Ray of Seattle Pacific University at the time, and at Western Baptist College, Salem OR as of 9/91.
Ray, Brian D. 1989 An Overview of Home Schooling in the United States: Its Growth and Development and Future Challenges. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, March 27-31, 1989, San Francisco, California. Estimated 400,000 children home educated. Available from National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
Ray, Brian D. 1989 Setting the context for state regulation of home-schooling parents. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, March 27-31, 1989, San Francisco, California. home education, regulation, law, academic achievement Available from National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Describes past research and summarizes state laws. Suggests that directly measuring the learning of home educated children, rather than stipulating the level of education parents must have to be allowed to home educate their children, is a better way to ensure that the state's compelling interest in the education of children is met.
Ray, Brian D. 1989 Understanding public, private, and home school students' beliefs, attitudes, and intentions related to science learning. Home School Researcher, 5(3), 1-11. home education, theory of reasoned action, social capital, beliefs, values Uses the Theory of Reasoned Action and the concept of social capital to explain attitudes toward and academic achievement in science. Finds that the home educated are more likely to engage in laboratory science activities than are those in the private and public schools. No differences are found with respect to non-laboratory science. Suggests that an abundance of social capital may be the advantage for the home educated. Available from National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
Ray, Brian D. 1990 A nationwide study of home education: Family characteristics, legal matters, and student achievement. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute, www.nheri.org. http://www.nheri.org home education, research, achievement, parent teacher certification, parents education, income Analyzes standardized achievement scores of the home educated, and provides extensive demographic data and limited legal information in the largest nationwide study to date (1992). Sample of involved 1,516 families and 4,646 children is from the membership of the Home School Legal Defense Association. Students score, on average, at or above the 80th percentile in all subject areas. Student achievement is not related to whether the parents are certified teachers [p. 13 and p. 38/Table 28], in some cases is slightly related to parents' education level and family income, and is above average regardless of the degree of regulation in a given state. “Further, no difference was found in the achievement scores of students between three groups which represent various degrees of state regulation of home education” [p. 47]. Number of years home educated significantly positively correlated with language scores but not related to other four scores analyzed [p. 13, and Table 26 on p. 36].
Ray, Brian D. 1990 A review of home school research: Characteristics of the families and learner outcomes. Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
Ray, Brian D. 1990 Beliefs, attitudes, and intentions of science learners in public, private, and home schools. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching, April 8-11, 1990, Atlanta, GA. Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
Ray, Brian D. 1990 Beliefs, attitudes, and intentions of science learners in public, private, and home schools. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching, April 8-11, 1990, Atlanta, Georgia. Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
Ray, Brian D. 1990 Home education in Montana: Family characteristics and student achievement. Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
Ray, Brian D. 1990 Social capital, value consistency, and the achievement outcomes of home education. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 16-20, Boston, MA. Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
Ray, Brian D. 1990 Students' intentions to engage in science activities: Public, private, and home schools. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the National Science Teachers Association, April 5-8, 1990, Atlanta, Georgia. Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
Ray, Brian D. 1990 Students’ intentions to engage in science activities: Public, private, and home schools. Seattle, WA: Seattle Pacific University, School of Education. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 317 435)
Ray, Brian D. 1991 The determinants of grades three to eight students’ intentions to engage in laboratory and nonlaboratory science learning behavior. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 28(2), 147–161. ERIC #EJ460246. http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/cgi-bin/abstract/112752930/ABSTRACT?CRETRY=1&SRETRY=0 research, science education, public school Studies public school students only. “Data were collected from students in grades three to eight (N = 377) in order to identify the determinants of their intentions to perform laboratory and nonlaboratory science activities. Fishbein and Ajzen's theory of reasoned action was used as the basis for the study. The theory posits that the immediate determinant of behavior is intention. Intention is determined by the weighted attitude toward the behavior and the weighted subjective norm. Attitude toward behavior and subjective norm are determined by combinations of beliefs, evaluations, and motivations to comply. Cores of salient beliefs related to attitude toward laboratory and nonlaboratory behaviors and cores of salient beliefs related to subjective norm for laboratory and nonlaboratory behaviors were identified. Hypotheses generated from the theory were confirmed. Attitude toward behavior and subjective norm explained significant amounts of variance in behavioral intention for both laboratory and nonlaboratory behaviors. Attitude toward behavior had a greater relative weight than subjective norm for both laboratory and nonlaboratory. The correlations between adjacent constructs in the theoretical model were significant in all cases” [Abstract retrieved 8/8/07 online http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/cgi-bin/abstract/112752930/ABSTRACT?CRETRY=1&SRETRY=0]
Ray, Brian D. 1991 Home education in North Dakota: Family characteristics and student achievement. home education, research, achievement, demographics, parent education, income Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Family income not related to either of two scores analyzed, basic battery and complete battery, p. 13-15, with Table 6 on p. 15. Number of years home educated not related to either score analyzed, basic battery and complete battery [p. 13-16, and Table 6 on p. 15]
Ray, Brian D. 1991 Home schooling, science achievement, and parents' beliefs about God and the origin of species and life. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching, April 7-10, 1991, Lake Geneva, WI. home education, beliefs, science achievement, academic achievement, origins, evolution, biology, science, research Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
Ray, Brian D. 1991 Religious orthodoxy and student achievement in home education. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 3-7, 1991, Chicago IL. home education, research, achievement, religion, religious orthodoxy Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
Ray, Brian D. 1991 What home educators need, want, and use from various institutions: Results from an ongoing study in four western states. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 3-7, 1991, Chicago, IL. home education, research, needs, home education and public school interaction or cooperation Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
Ray, Brian D. 1991, January/February Contemplations on home education research by a researcher who is a home educator. Home Education Magazine, 8(1), 18, 19, 23. research, opinion "I am not aware of any serious incident in which research has been used to hamper the positive activities of home educators and their children. This is not to say this will never happen; we shouldn't be so naive. ..... Research can benefit home education n many ways. If what home educators do is good, then not only interesting and scholarly ideas will emerge from research, the [sic] positive outcomes of home education will also be manifest" (p. 23).
Ray, Brian D. 1992 Home education in Oklahoma: Family characteristics, student achievement, and policy matters. Salem, Oregon: National Home Education Research Institute. home education, achievement, research, demographics, parent teacher certification Analyzes standardized achievement scores of the home educated in Oklahoma and provides extensive demographic data. Students score, on average, at or above the 82nd percentile in all areas tested. Teacher certification status of parents and parents' educational attainment were not significantly related to students' learning [p. 25]. Only a few variables explained significant amounts of variance in test scores analyzed only for basic battery, science, and listening); the variance explained was small; none were correlated with basic batttery scores; family income was weakly correlated with listening scores but not the other scores, p. 26 and Table 12 on p. 28. Years home educated positively related to science scores but not to two other analyzed [Table 13 on p. 31].
Ray, Brian D. 1992 Marching to the beat of their own drum: A profile of home education research. Paeonian Springs, VA: Home School Legal Defense Association. home education, research, review Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Reviews the research, focusing on number of children home educated, learner outcomes (e.g., academic achievement), social and emotional adjustment, and other topics. Writes to the lay audience, but makes extensive use of endnotes and includes a lengthy reference list. Most comprehensive and current review as of late 1992.
Ray, Brian D. 1992 On the propriety of education professionals instructing home educators. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco CA, April 20-24. Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Evaluates whether it is propitious for persons who function within conventional school settings to attempt to instruct, or direct the activities of, home educators, and whether it is propitious for home educators to seek the advice and instruction of those in the conventional school setting. Uses elements of evaluation research and qualitative research to base discussion on interviews with stakeholders (i.e., teacher educators in schools of education, certified and practicing school teachers, home education leaders, and home educators) and author's experiences with home education research and the home education community. Categorizes stakeholders (e.g., confident, tentative, I-wash-my-hands attitude, freethinker). Provides helpful conclusions to both professional educators and home educators. Concludes with section, "Cooperation between home educators and conventional educators, or cooptation?," in which author states, "I believe that home educators are exploring the difference between cooperation with conventional school educators and government officials and cooptation by them. Home educators want to be sure that there is a respectful and candid exchange of ideas and resources. They want to be sure that, when they interact with conventional educators, they are not being taken over through assimilation into an established group or culture. Time and future research will give us more insight regarding the tenacity of the distinctive nature of the home education community" (p. 29).
Ray, Brian D. 1992 Student learning in home education and whether the education profession can (or should) help. A paper presented at the Fourth Annual International Roundtable on Families, Communities, Schools, and Children's Learning, April 20, San Francisco, CA. home education, cooperation, professionals Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Similar information to what is in Ray's 1992 On the propriety of education professionals...;
Ray, Brian D. 1993 Home education research fact sheet. home education, research, summary, demographics, academic achievement, and social and emotional adjustment Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Uses one page to summarize research on general characteristics of families, academic achievement, and social and emotional adjustment.
Ray, Brian D. 1993 Home education revitalized (chapter 7). In Thomas C. Hunt & James C. Carper (Eds.), Religious schools in the United States, K-12: A source book, pp. 243-287. New York, NY: Garland Publishing, Inc.
Ray, Brian D. 1993 Judging and assisting home education: Issues in research and policy [roundtable discussion topic sheet]. Presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 12-16, Atlanta, GA. research, home education, methodology Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Includes criticisms of past home education research, foci of past studies and potential new directions, dissemination of research findings to different groups, and developing a proper relationship between home educators and the education profession and the public.
Ray, Brian D. 1993 Learning at home in North Dakota: Family attributes and student achievement. Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Family income not related to either of only two scores analyzed, basic battery and complete battery scores, p. 18-19 and Table 8 on p. 19.
Ray, Brian D. 1993 Oregon home education. Portland, OR: Oregon Christian Home Education Association Network. home education, academic achievement, finances, economics, population growth Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Provides basic data on number of home educated children in Oregon, their academic achievement scores [which are above average], and costs of public tax monies that are possibly being saved by them being home educated.
Ray, Brian D. 1993 Practices and effects of home education in the United States of America: A synthesis of recent research. Journal of Research on Christian Education, 2(1), 135-154. research, review, achievement, learner outcomes, demographics Includes historical and demographic perspective, including home education population growth, points out that in some ways home school families are a part of mainstream America, reviews research on academic achievement and other cognitive outcomes and relationships between cognitive outcomes and demographic factors and social and emotional adjustment outcomes, discusses research limitations, and gives implications for the practice of Christian schoolroom education; lengthy reference section.
Ray, Brian D. 1993 Student learning in home education and the education profession. In Frederik Smit, Wil van Esch, & Walberg, Herbert J. (1993). Parental involvement in education. Published by and available from Institute for Applied Social Sciences, Katholieke Universiteit Nijmegen, Postbus 9048, 6500 KJ Nijmegen, the Netherlands.
Ray, Brian D. 1994 A brief statistical analysis of academic achievement test data from home educated students in Florida. Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. home education, academic achievement Finds that the home schooled scored, on average, at the 72nd percentile on the basic battery of standardized academic achievement tests. Other scores presented.
Ray, Brian D. 1994 A brief statistical analysis of academic achievement test data from home educated students operating under the Virginia religious exemption statute. Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. home education, academic achievement Finds that these home schooled scored, on average, at the 89th percentile on the basic battery of standardized academic achievement tests. Other scores presented.
Ray, Brian D. 1994 A brief statistical analysis of academic achievement test data from students in Maine’s home-based non-approved private schools. On average, homeschooled students score at the 71st percentile on basic battery on standardized academic achievement tests.) Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
Ray, Brian D. 1994 A nationwide study of home education in Canada: Family characteristics, student achievement, and other topics. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute, www.nheri.org. http://www.nheri.org home education, academic achievement, demographics, legal, correlates, predictors, income, teacher certification, parent education Descriptive and correlational study, basic information about home education families (n=808) and their children (n=2,594) throughout Canada in terms of (a) demographics, (b) selected educational characteristics of the families, 8 educational and post-secondary school characteristics of the students, (d) academic achievement of the students, (e) relationships between their academic achievement and factors such as educational attainment of parents, family income, and pedagogical practices, and (f) the relationship between selected physical and mental limitations and pedagogical practices. In general, the parents had somewhat higher educational attainment than the general population in Canada, and their total family income was 83% of that of all husband-wife families in Canada. The families had notably more children (3.5) than the national average. They made regular use of libraries, and engaged their children in numerous social activities. “Table 11 shows the types of activities in which children who had ever been home schooled were involved. For example, 60% were involved in group sports, 82% were in Sunday school, 48% were involved in music classes, and 93% engaged in play activities with people outside the family. Table 11 also indicates the number of hours that the students in these families spent in contact with persons other than their parents” [p. 36 circa]. Students' scores on achievement tests: (a) total reading, 80th, (b) total listening, 84th, 8 total language, 76th, (d) total math, 79th, (e) science, 82nd, (f) social studies, 81st, (g) basic battery (reading, language, and mathematics), 79th, and (h) complete battery (all subject areas in which student was tested), 82nd. None of the following variables explained a significant amount of variance in the students' total mathematics, total listening, science, and social studies scores: formal educational attainment of the parents, teacher certification status of the parents, family income, number of years the student was home educated, degree of structure in the home education environment, age of the student, time spent in formal education activities, age at which formal education commenced, gender of the student, extent to which the family uses public libraries, and amount of money spent on the home education of the child. Father's educational attainment was a significant predictor of reading and language scores, and the longer a child had been home educated, the better was his language score. Both variables were only weak to moderately strong predictors. None of the following variables explained a significant amount of variance in the students' farsightedness: degree of structure in the learning environment, time spent in structured learning, and age at which formal instruction commenced. Time in structured learning was a weak predictor of nearsightedness, and age at which formal instruction began was a weak predictor of attention deficit disorder.
Ray, Brian D. 1994 A summary of the academic achievement test scores http://www.nheri.org Iowa Test of Basic Skills) of over 16,000 home educated students from across the United States. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309, www.nheri.org On average, homeschooled students score at the 77th percentile on basic battery on standardized academic achievement tests.
Ray, Brian D. 1995 A nationwide study of home education in Canada: Apparently flourishing in size and successful in children's learning. A paper presented at the Seventh Annual International Roundtable on Families, Communities, Schools, and Children's Learning, April 17, 1994, San Francisco, California. Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
Ray, Brian D. 1995 Home education across Canada and comparisons to the home education phenomenon in the United States, 67 pp. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 18-22, 1995, San Francisco, California. home education, research, demographics, academic achievement Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Examines demographic characteristics of home education families in Canada, presents some of most significant educational characteristics of the families, and presents descriptive data regarding the academic achievement of the home educated. Based on Ray's 1994 A nationwide study of home education in Canada but includes only a portion of the information in the 1994 publication.
Ray, Brian D. 1995 Home education science learning in the context of family, neighborhood, and society, 41 pp. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 18-22, 1995, San Francisco, California. home education, research, science academic achievement, social capital, social environment Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Provides basic knowledge and insight about science learning and teaching in the home education environment while keeping in mind the social context of family, neighborhood [or community], and their larger society. Examines the science academic achievement of the home educated and selected social (and other) factors that may contribute to their science academic achievement. Home educated scored, on average, at the 85th percentile in science achievement. "... parents engage the students in science learning for at least as much time as do conventional schools" (p. 25). "... they [home education families] utilize many community resources in science teaching and learning C field trips to museums and science learning centers, courses outside of the home, science camps or academies, 4-H, science fairs, libraries, and volunteer and paid jobs" (p. 26). "All indications are that the home educated, as a group, are developing their scientific literacy at least as well as are students in conventional schools" (p. 27).
Ray, Brian D. 1995 Learning at home in Montana: Student achievement and family characteristics, 65 pp. home education, research, academic achievement, demographics, correlational, correlates, predictors, multivariate Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Uses descriptive and multivariate correlational techniques to examine (a) demographics, (b) selected educational characteristics of the families and students, 8 academic achievement of the students, (d) social and extracurricular activities of children, and (e) relationships between their academic achievement and various factors. The children are regularly involved in extracurricular activities in the community and their academic achievement scores were, on average, at the 70th percentile on the basic battery. Several predictor variables (i.e., father's educational attainment, father's teacher certification status, family income [no relationship to any of eight subject test scores analyzed, Table 17 on p. 48], number of children in the family, years child was home educated, presence of a computer in the home (69.8% had one), and amount of money spent on home education) were not significant in explaining variance in any of the testing areas [p. 45]. Mother's educational attainment, structure in the teaching and learning environment, gender of student, mother's teacher certification status, and use of libraries did, in some categories, serve as significant predictors of academic achievement. Mother’s certification status was related to only language scores [and it was a weak relationship, p. 35, Table 11] and was not related reading, math, science, social studies, basic battery, or complete battery; father’s teacher-certification status was not related to any scores. Number of years home educated not related to any scores [page 45 and Table 17 on page 48].
Ray, Brian D. 1995 Oregon home school research report: A Researcher's analysis of Oregon home education,. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute. home education, academic achievement, finances, economics, population growth Provides basic data on number of home educated children in Oregon, their academic achievement scores [which are above average], and costs of public tax monies that are possibly being saved by them being home educated. Four (4) pages in length.
Ray, Brian D. 1996 Home education research fact sheet Ib. Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309.
Ray, Brian D. 1996 Home education research fact sheet IIIb. home education, research, summary, demographics, academic achievement, social and emotional adjustment, social and political responsibility, population growth Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Uses one page to summarize research on general characteristics of families, growth of home schooling population, academic achievement, the home educated as adults, and social responsibility and political activity within society.
Ray, Brian D. 1997 Home education across the United States: Family characteristics, student achievement, and longitudinal traits. Purcellville, VA: Home School Legal Defense Association. Available from National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Also available in German, Erziehung in Heimschulen in den Vereinigten Staaten von Amerika: Familiencharakteristika, Leistungen der Schüler und Langzeitstudie der Charakteristika von Heimschulerziehung Summary of book Strengths of Their Own by Brian Ray.
Ray, Brian D. 1997 Home education in Indiana: Family characteristics, reasons for home schooling, and academic achievement. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. home education, homeschooling, research, academic achievement, reasons, demographics “Parents were asked to indicate the five most important reasons for deciding to home educate their children from a list of 18 reasons, one of which was “other reasons” (Table 5). The five reasons most frequently cited were (a) to control the moral environment of the child (selected by 16% of the parents), (b) because they believe home teaching accomplishes more academically (12%), (c) that the parents desire more contact with their children (12%), (d) to control the social environment of the child (11%), and (e) the desire to individualize instruction (9%). One might be able to infer, since these reasons were the most frequently cited, that these were the five most important reasons for home schooling for these families. Other reasons were also clearly important to many families. For example, parents in 224 families (of about 600 families) selected a “lack of the right religious curriculum” (in schools) and 206 said that they “believe education should be done by parents.” [p. 39]. “These home educated students’ performance on standardized academic achievement tests is quite strong (Table 7). The students scored, on the average, at the following percentiles on standardized academic achievement tests: (a) total reading, 88th, (b) total language, 82nd, (c) total math, 85th, (d) science, 84th, (f) social studies, 84th, (g) basic battery (typically, reading, language, and mathematics), 86th, and (i) complete battery (all subject areas in which student was tested), 87th. These are very high scores considering the fact that the average score on standardized tests for the norm group, conventional school students, in all of the preceding categories is the 50th percentile. The large effect sizes are rather noticeable. These home educated students performed, on average, from .91 standard deviation (in language) to a high of 1.17 standard deviations (in reading) above the national average” (p. 42).
Ray, Brian D. 1997 Strengths of their own—Home schoolers across America: Academic achievement, family characteristics, and longitudinal traits. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute home education, research, academic achievement, socialization, longitudinal, reasons for success, predictors of achievement, state regulation, legal, philosophy, unschooling, relaxed homeschooling PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309). (Provides largest U.S. nationwide and longitudinal study to date. Data were collected on 1,657 families and their 5,402 children—275 of the families participated in the author’s 1990 study. These families, with 3.3 children and 98% being headed by married couples, were much larger than the United States average. Ninety-five percent of family income was earned by the fathers; 34% of them were professionals and 11% were small business owners. Eighty-eight percent of the mothers were homemakers/home educators and only 16% of the mothers worked outside the home. A wide variety of religious affiliations was evident; about 90% of the parents were Christians. The parents had higher than average educational attainment; 46% of the fathers had a bachelor’s degree or higher and 42% of the mothers had the same. These families’ median annual income of $43,000 was a little lower than the median for all married-couple families in the United States. The parents spent, on average, $546 per child per year for home education. The mother did 88% of the formal teaching of the children while the father did 10% of the teaching. The large majority of these children were not being taught by professionally trained and government certified teachers. On average, the children had been taught at home for 5 years since age 5, 85% were in grades K through 8, and their parents planned to home educate them through their secondary school years. Parents hand picked curriculum materials—rather than purchasing complete programs—for 71% of the students. The social activities of these children were quite varied; for example, 47% were involved in music classes, 48% were involved in group sports, and 77% participated in Sunday school. “Table 8 presents some of the types of social activities in which the currently home educated children were involved. For example, 48% were involved in group sports, 77% were in Sunday school, 47% were involved in music classes, and 87% engaged in play activities with people outside the family. Table 7 indicates the number of hours that the students in these families spent in contact with persons other than their parents. For example, they spend, on average, 10 hours per week in contact with non-family adults and 11 hours per week with non-sibling children” [p. 49]. These students scored, on the average, at high percentiles on standardized academic achievement tests: (a) total reading, 87th, (b) total language, 80th, (c) total math, 82nd, (d) total listening, 85th, (e) science, 84th, (f) social studies, 85th, (g) study skills, 81st, (h) basic battery (typically, reading, language, and mathematics), 85th, and (i) complete battery (all subject areas in which student was tested), 87th. (The national average is the 50th percentile.) Several analyses were conducted to determine which independent variables were significantly related to academic achievement. There was no significant relationship between achievement and (a) whether the father was a certified teacher, (b) whether the mother was a certified teacher, (c) family income, (d) money spent on education, (e) legal status of the family, (f) time spent in formal instruction, (g) age formal instruction began, and (h) degree of state regulation of home schooling. Achievement was statistically significantly related, in some cases, to father’s education level, mother’s education level, gender of student, years home educated, use of libraries, who administered the test, and use of computers. The relationships were, however, weak and not practically significant. This and other studies indicate that very few background variables (e.g., socioeconomic status of parents, regulation by the state) explain the academic achievement of the home educated. “The degree of state regulation of home education had no effect on students’ basic battery test scores. States were categorized as having either low regulation, moderate regulation, or high regulation” [p. 81]. “I would like to suggest four elements that might explain the apparent learning success of the home educated and the lack of practically significant relationships between these students’ academic achievement and the independent variables examined in this study and in other studies. These elements may be interrelated” (p. 92). “There is great potential for individualization and flexibility in pedagogy, for mastery learning …” (p. 96). “Home Education May Ameliorate the Negative Effects of Background Variables on Students’ Achievement The fourth strength is that home education may be conducive to eliminating the potential negative effects of certain background factors. Low family income, low parental educational attainment, parents not having formal training as teachers, race or ethnicity of the student, gender of the student, not having a computer in the home, infrequent usage of public services (e.g., public libraries), a child commencing formal education relatively later in life, relatively small amounts of time spent in formal educational activities, and a child having a large (or small) number of siblings seem to have little influence on the academic achievement of the home educated. (Several references were provided earlier.)” (p. 99) The elements are (a) value consistency, value communities, and social capital, (b) tutoring, (c) academic learning time, and (d) social interaction and distraction. Posits that is possible that the home education environment ameliorates the effect of variables that are typically considered a detriment to students (e.g., low household income, low parental education level, certain minority status see also, Ray, 2000, Home schooling: The ameliorator of negative influences on learning?). Concludes that a variety of students in a variety of home education settings have performed very well in terms of academic achievement. Addresses “unschooling” or “relaxed homeschooling” via items on the survey and the conclusions that there was no correlation between time spent in “formal instruction” and reading, language, and math scores from standardized academic achievement tests (p. 66) and there was no correlation between “age began formal instruction” of student and reading, language, and math scores from standardized academic achievement tests (p. 66).
Ray, Brian D. 1998 Home education in Massachusetts: Family characteristics, academic achievement, and social activities. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute home education, research, academic achievement, demographics, socialization, social activities PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309). (Finds home school students’ average basic battery score on standardized academic achievement tests to be at the 85th percentile.
Ray, Brian D. 1998 Home education research fact sheet IIc. home education, research, population size Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Ray estimates there were 1.1 to 1.5 million students in grades K to 12 being home schooled during the 1997-1998 school year. Provides 1- to 2-sentence summaries of a variety of studies.
Ray, Brian D. 1998 Home schoolers across America: Family characteristics and student academic achievement. Paper presented at the 9th Annual International Roundtable on School, Family, and Community Partnerships, San Diego, California, USA, April 13, 1998. research, home education, academic achievement Presents findings similar to Ray [1997, Strengths of their own].
Ray, Brian D. 1999 A survey of research on home education: Context, concerns, children’s performance, and success in adulthood. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute. home education, research, academic achievement, adulthood, graduates Review of resear on many topics related to homeschooling, home education; 54 pages.
Ray, Brian D. 1999 Home schoolers’ academic achievement and does home schooling ameliorate negative background variables? Private School Monitor, 20 (3), 2-4.
Ray, Brian D. 1999 Home schooling after 20 years of resurgence in America. Private School Monitor, 20 (3), 1, 12.
Ray, Brian D. 1999 Home schooling on the threshold: A survey of research at the dawn of the new millennium. National Home Education Research Institute Publications, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. home education, research, summary, synthesis, review, history, pedagogy, reasons for home schooling, academic achievement, social and psychological development, special needs and talented and gifted students, and the success of the home educated as adults Synthesizes research on home schooling in many areas such as history, pedagogy, reasons for home schooling, academic achievement, social and psychological development, special needs and talented and gifted students, and the success of the home educated as adults. Provides the most extensive and up-to-date but succinct summary of research as of March 1999.
Ray, Brian D. 1999 Home schooling: The ameliorator of negative influences on learning? A paper presented on at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, April 19-23, 1999. home education, research, academic achievement, correlates, explanation Available from National Home Education Research Institute Publications, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Uses data from Ray’s 1997 nationwide study Strengths of their own—Home schoolers across America and examines factors that might be contributing to high academic achievement for the home educated and suggests that perhaps the home-based environment ameliorates the negative effects of certain family, child, social, and cultural characteristics that would be associated with low achievement in public schools.
Ray, Brian D. 1999 Home schools’ academic achievement across the United States. In Mary Alampi & Peter M. Comeau (Eds.) American education annual (academic year 1997-1998). Detroit, MI: Gale. home education, academic achievement, research Reviews Ray’s nationwide study findings.
Ray, Brian D. 2000 Home education research fact sheet IIe. home education, research, summary, demographics, academic achievement, social and emotional adjustment, social responsibility and mutual respect within society, population growth Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Uses one page to summarize research on general characteristics of families, bar graph of growth of home schooling population from 1978 to 1996, academic achievement, social and emotional adjustment, and social responsibility and mutual respect within society.
Ray, Brian D. 2000 Home schooling for individuals’ gain and society’s common good. Peabody Journal of Education, 75 (1 & 2), 272-293, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0161956X.2000.9681945 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0161956X.2000.9681945 home education, philosophy, research, opinion, criticism, critic, advocacy “[new paragraph] Proponents of compulsory schooling law and state-controlled schools, whether “leftists” or “rightists,” are working, perhaps unwittingly, to make sure that something called the “common curriculum”—the one approved by those in positions of power—is taught to all (or most) children. Advocates of these government institutions hope they will long be the ones in positions of power. Conversely, most proponents of home schooling and parental choice and authority only want to make sure that their personally chosen curriculum is taught to their children. These folks are not asking the state or anyone else for money or power to teach their curriculum to anyone else. They are asking the state and their neighbors to assume that they, the parents, have the best interests of their children and society’s common good in mind. In fact, these parents are only asking the state, and their neighbors and thinkers who empower and influence the agents of the state, to let them go about their lives peaceably and quietly in the privacy of their homes and communities with their children. Advocates of home-based education are familiar with the golden rule and the big issues of liberty and justice for all in society. These parents want the state to allow individual citizens to choose freely when and how they will help other parents. [new paragraph] Home schooling allows parents, in a context of nurture and high social capital, to choose freely a unique and effective education for their children. Each year a child grows older gives the parents and the child more opportunity to forge stronger bonds and a richer, relationally developed curriculum. [end p. 287] Parents and children in such an arrangement, under no compulsion or coercion from the state, are allowed to escape the hidden curriculum of others and of the state, choose texts for learning, and work together in their communities as they “see work—family—religion—recreation—-school as an organically related system of human relationships” (Tyack, 1974, p. 15). [new paragraph] The battles over power and domination that riddle state-run schools cannot sap home schooling parents and their children of their strength, consume their energy, and destroy their zest for learning. Zeal for social justice, liberty, the common good, and being right with one’s Creator can be approached from an environment of security, strength, and stability while the ever-maturing child year after year steps out into larger and more expansive spheres of challenge, democratic deliberation, and creative service to others. [new paragraph] The voices of those who are anti-home schooling, anti-parents’ rights, and antichoice and of those who assert that home schooling causes “balkanization,” “divisiveness,” “social anarchy,” “narrow-mindedness,” fundamentalism,” “segregationism,” and “possessive individualism” are increasingly hollow and impotent. Evidence supporting their claims is (and always has been) scarce to nonexistent (e.g., Caldwell, 1999; L. Berg, organizational specialist, National Education Association, personal communication, July 28, 1999). Furthermore--and tragically for this nation’s children and to the chagrin of the proponents of state-run schools--the power struggles, illegal drug deals, racism (Greene & Mellow, 1998), violence, philosophical contention, religious censorship, lack of parent involvement, low academic achievement, high dropout rates, premarital sexual activities, teachers’ and bureaucratic antiparental power (Baker & Soden, 1998), and greed-based high-stakes labor disputes that are associated with the halls and culture of public schools and so powerfully overshadow the significant incidents of success and joy therein make the common criticisms of parent-led home schooling look very wan and insignificant” [p. 288].
Ray, Brian D. 2000 Home schooling: The ameliorator of negative influences on learning? Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 71-106, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0161956X.2000.9681936 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0161956X.2000.9681936 home education, research, academic achievement, socialization, longitudinal, reasons for success, predictors of achievement, state regulation, legal, philosophy Examines (a) academic achievement of K-12 homeschool children in a nationwide study during the mid-1990s, compared to that in preceding research, and (b) whether selected background variables explain significant amounts of variance in the academic achievement of the home educated. This is the first publication in a refereed (juried) journal of Ray’s 1997 report entitled Strengths of their own—Home schoolers across America: Academic achievement, family characteristics, and longitudinal traits. The findings are essentially the same as presented in Ray, 1997. For example, homeschool students score, on average, well above national average of public-school students. The variables examined for relationship to academic achievement were the father’s and mother’s formal education level/attainment, whether the father or mother was a certified teacher, family income, money spent on education, legal status of the family, gender of student, years child was home educated, time spent in formal instruction, age formal instruction began, use of libraries, who administered the achievement test, use of computers, and degree of state regulation of home schooling. “Seven of the 12 independent variables did not explain statistically significant amounts of variance in students’ test scores. These 7 were (a) father’s certification status, (b) mother’s certification status [teacher certification status], (c) family income, (d) money spent on home education, (e) legal status of family, (f) time spent in formal educational activities, and (g) age at which formal education began” [p. 83]. Table 8 on page 90 summarizes all correlations. Parent teacher-certification status not related to achievement [p. 88-90, Table 8 on p. 90]. Five variables (father’s education level, mother’s education level, years taught at home, gender of student, and frequency of visits to public library) were significantly related to achievement in some cases. Number of years home educated positively related to reading and language scores but not to math scores [Table 8 on p. 90]. Regarding state regulation: “Degree of regulation of home education in the state and [standardized academic achievement] test scores. An analysis of variance was conducted to test whether the degree of regulation of home education by a state has an effect on students’ basic battery test scores. States were categorized as having either low regulation, moderate regulation, or high regulation (see Table 7). Low regulation was defined as [p. 84 ends here] no state requirement on the part of the home school parents to initiate any contact with the state. Moderate regulation was defined as the state requiring home school parents to send to the state notification or achievement test scores and/or evaluation of the student’s learning by a professional. High regulation was defined as the state requiring home school parents to send to the state notification or achievement test scores and/or evaluation by a professional and, in addition, having other requirements (e.g., curriculum approval by the state, teacher qualifications of parents, or home visits by state officials). There was no significant difference between students’ scores in the three groups” [p. 84-85]. “The following, therefore, is a brief consideration of certain features of effective schools that might be features of typical home school situations and may contribute to the apparent high academic achievement of the home educated” (p. 93) and then covered value consistency, value communities, and social capital, class size, tutoring, individualization, flexibility, academic learning time and academic engaged time, expectations of students, human capital, and parent involvement. Homeschooling ameliorate the negative correlates of academic achievement.)
Ray, Brian D. 2000 Homeschool leaders’ views on homeschoolers interacting and joining with the state, a roundtable presentation at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 24-28, New Orleans, Louisiana. home education, research, interviews, philosophy, public school, cooperation, government Interviews homeschool leaders about their views and rationales for or against homeschool families interacting and joining with state-controlled educational programs. “These homeschool leaders, a special subpopulation of the general homeschool population in the United States, are very active in civic life. Obviously, this activity includes things related to home-based and parent-led education. In addition, however, most of them are engaged in civic activities that range well beyond the arena of homeschooling. Their experiences lead them to believe that they are more involved in civic activities than are typical citizens of the United States. They also think that the typical homeschool father and the typical homeschool mother are more active in civic life than are the typical American father and typical American mother. Findings of Smith and Sikkink (1999) appear to confirm that this is true. These leaders’ reasons for participating in civic life are varied. ..... Most of these homeschool leaders’ spontaneous responses to defining the “common good” were articulate and thoughtful. Their definitions touched upon many variables. Common themes were that the common good exists or is enhanced when (a) the opportunities of the many are advanced without trampling on the rights of the individual, (b) each child and youth is taught to engage in his role as a citizen and a brother to his fellow man, (c) children and youth are urged to think about what they can contribute to society in a way that would be consistent with a biblical worldview, (d) the constitutional rule of law is advanced, (e) people are taught to engage in independent and critical thinking, and (f) the natural and traditional family social unit is advanced” [p. 14]. “Regarding the concept of selfishness, some of these leaders expressed disbelief that anyone would think they or other parents were selfish for homeschooling their children. They pointed out that homeschooling is hard work, it usually means that a family may have only one income, that one parent -- usually the mother -- forgoes any kind of career that she once might have wanted, and that parents are, in many ways, going against the norms of society by their practice of homeschooling. ..... That is to say, almost as if in response to the arguments of persons such as Lubienski (2000), these parents elucidate that they are not willing to sacrifice their own children’s lives to an experiment at best (i.e., maybe Lucinda will do well in the state-run schools in which she would be for 13 years if the parents work hard to get involved in her education and no bad or hurtful unforeseen things happen to her in them) or to an already-existent disaster at worst (i.e., state-run schools that by their very existence teach children and youth to be too dependent on the government for their needs and solving societal problems, teach a worldview that is antithetical to theirs, and systemically bring those children who might otherwise do well closer to the lowest common denominator)” [p. 15]. “Contrary to claims such as those made by Apple (2000), however, this study reveals that homeschool leaders and everyday homeschool parents think that they are (a) working hard to encourage and build a government that they regard as just, right, and advancing the United State’s historical respect for constitutional liberty, not attacking the state, (b) energetically engaging themselves and their children in discerning and servant-like ways in their communities, not “cocooning” themselves, and (c) teaching their children and others to be hard-working and [p. 16 ends] productive members of society and not financial and social drains on the efforts of their neighbors and fellow citizens, not harming disadvantaged groups. Finally, the voices of leaders interviewed in this study and the limited quantitative data available to date on the civic involvement of homeschoolers in general indicate that homeschool leaders and parents firmly believe that because home-based education will enhance their individual children’s academic success, moral development, social skills, and safety that it will therefore advance the common good of their society. It will be fascinating to watch history and research as they further reveal the extent to which parents, youth, and children who are engaged in home-based education participate in civic life and benefit the common good of their local communities, cities, states, and nations” [p. 17].
Ray, Brian D. 2000, December Homeschooling teaching strategies. ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED501189. Retrieved November 5, 2018 from https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED501189.pdf https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED501189.pdf home education, homeschooling, home schooling, educational research; teaching methods; parents as teachers; developmentally appropriate practices; tutoring Defines and describes teaching strategies used in homeschooling. Reviews several research and other literature sources from the homeschool community. Finds four themes from relevant research that inform the practices and seven major strategies used in the home-based education. Recommendations are made to parents who choose homeschooling for their children.
Ray, Brian D. 2000, December Homeschooling teaching strategies. ERIC Digest #EDO-SP-2000-6, 2 pp. Washington, DC: United States Department of Education, ERIC Clearinghouse on Teaching and Teacher Education. http://www.ericsp.org/pages/digests/home_schooling.html home education, homeschooling, research, teaching strategies, active teaching, developmentally appropriate practice, tutoring, classical education, lifestyle of learning, schooling at home, structured/mastery learning, unit studies, unschooling, worldview, choosing teaching strategies, philosophy Retrieved 3/6/01 online http://www.ericsp.org/pages/digests/home_schooling.html.
Ray, Brian D. 2001 Home education in New Mexico: Family characteristics, academic achievement, and social and civic activities. National Home Education Research Institute, PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. home education, research, academic achievement, demographics, social activities, socializatin, civic activities The homeschool students scored, on the average, at the following percentiles on standardized achievement tests: (a) total reading, 83rd, (b) total listening, 85th, (c) total language, 74th, (d) total math, 75th, (e) science, 82nd, (f) social studies, 79th, (g) study skills, 83rd, (h) basic battery (typically, reading, language, and mathematics), 85th, and (i) complete battery (all subject areas in which student was tested), 79th. Mixed results, correlations versus ANOVA, regarding whether family income significantly correlated with test scores, p. 30 and Appendix B on p. 50 and p. 55. No relationship between years home educated and test scores [p. 30].
Ray, Brian D. 2001 Home Education in Ohio: Family characteristics, academic achievement, social and civic activities, and college admissions officers’ thoughts. Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. home education, research, academic achievement, demographics, social activities, socializatin, civic activities invovlement, college, university, college admissions The homeschool students scored, on the average, at the following percentiles on standardized achievement tests: (a) total reading, 87th, (b) total listening, 84th, (c) total language, 80th, (d) total math, 83rd, (e) science, 85th, (f) social studies, 83rd, (g) study skills, 79th, (h) basic battery (typically, reading, language, and mathematics), 84th, and (i) complete battery (all subject areas in which student was tested), 85th.) Reports percent with computers in home. Surveyed 34 college admissions officers for views on homeschool students.
Ray, Brian D. 2001 Homeschool leaders’ views of home educators’ civic philosophy and activities: A preliminary report. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 10-14, 2001, Seattle, Washington. home education, research, civic activity/involvement, philosophy, politics Presents findings of interviews with homeschool leaders focus was on homeschool leaders and their (a) civic activities, (b) understanding about homeschool parents’ levels of civic involvement, (c) reasons for civic involvement, (d) understanding of why parents homeschool their children, (e) understanding of the “common good,” and (f) views on whether homeschoolers advance or hinder the common good. “These homeschool leaders, a special subpopulation of the general homeschool population in the United States, are very active in civic life. Obviously, this activity includes things related to home-based and parent-led education. In addition, however, most of them are engaged in civic activities that range well beyond the arena of homeschooling” [p. 14]. “Finally, the voices of leaders interviewed in this study and the limited quantitative data available to date on the civic involvement of homeschoolers in general indicate that homeschool leaders and parents firmly believe that because home-based education will enhance their individual children’s academic success, moral development, social skills, and safety that it will therefore advance the common good of their society. It will be fascinating to watch history and research as they further reveal the extent to which parents, youth, and children who are engaged in home-based education participate in civic life and benefit the common good of their local communities, cities, states, and nations” [p. 17].
Ray, Brian D. 2001, Spring Homeschooling in Canada. Education Canada, 41(1), 28-31, https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ641836 https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ641836 home education, Canada, academic achievement, demographics Provides brief general update on home education movement in Canada then gives details from a survey study of homeschooling in Canada including topics such as family demographics, children’s academic achievement, and inferences about why the home educated perform about average in terms of achievement. A survey of 808 Canadian homeschooling families representing 2,594 children examined family characteristics, academic achievement, and students' social activities. Families averaged 3.5 children. Generally, parents were well educated but had below-average incomes. Homeschooled children scored above average on standardized tests and were regularly engaged in various activities with peers and adults outside the home. “Perhaps it should be no surprise that homeschooled children and youth do well. There are elements of the home-based education environment which may well contribute to high academic achievement and healthy personal development into adulthood. Most teachers, administrators, and researchers know from experience and research that certain educational features help students learn and schools to be more effective in their mission -- these features which are, by nature, a part of the essence of homeschooling. In other words, home-based education may systemically and organically present a recipe for academic success. What classroom teacher would not like to: -- have only 2 to 5 students and basically tutor each one?-- be able to individualize the curriculum for each student, according to his or her particular strengths, weaknesses, interests, and dreams? -- spend more time on teaching/learning and less on classroom management? -- stop more often for the teachable moment?-- share core values and beliefs with her students? -- be able to integrate more ages in a smaller class? -- spend plenty of time making sure students master the basics of reading, writing, and arithmetic? and -- be able to say she has a deep, long-lasting, and sacrificial love for each of her pupils? Research suggests that these are common features of parent-led, home-based education. [new paragraph] Regardless of whether researchers will ever be able to determine that homeschooling does -- or does not -- "cause" high academic achievement and healthy social and psychological development, it has become a vibrant part of educational life in Canada, and its resurgence is increasing around the world” [p. 31]. Presents children’s and graduates’ social and other activties; e.g., 60% of the children were involved in group sports, 88% went on field trips, etc..
Ray, Brian D. 2001 The modern homeschooling movement. Catholic Education: A Journal of Inquiry and Practice, 4(3), 405-421. home education, research, history, academic achievement, philosophy, criticism Defines homeschooling and puts it into historical context. Explains homeschooilng is a popular and fast-growing trend in the U.S. and Canada. Provides comprehensive overview of research on the families’ demographic traits, the academic achievement of the children, whether their achievement is correlated with selected variables, the psychological, emotional, and social well-being of the children, civic involvement and leadership of homeschoolers, and adults who were homeschooled. Addresses political and philosophical antagonism toward homeschooling and presents a philosophical and social rationale for homeschooling. Explains contribution of homeschooling to civic welfare. “They were thought of as bizarre, fringe, isolationist, and selfish only 15 years ago (Hadeed, 1991; Knowles & Muchmore, 1995; Mayberry, Knowles, Ray, & Marlow, 1995). Now most Americans know at least one family who does it; and increasingly they are thought of as simply a little different, almost mainstream, thoughtful about how they raise their children, and hardworking as they give up a second income (Kantrowitz & Wingert, 1998; Ray, 1993, 1999). They are homeschoolers” [p. 405]. “As with their demographic characteristics, homeschoolers' pedagogical practices vary widely. Parents range in their approaches to the education of their children from ones that essentially reproduce conventional classroom schooling at home (Taylor, 1993; Van Galen, 1991), to very structured and workbook-oriented forms, to "lifestyle of learning" (Howshall, 1998) or "relaxed homeschooling" (Hood, 1994) styles which are explicitly based on a biblical understanding of the nature of children, to unschooling which focuses on reuniting living and learning without necessarily focusing on religious worldview (Sheffer, 2000)” [p. 408].
Ray, Brian D. 2002 Customization through homeschooling. Educational Leadership, 59(7), 50-54. home education, research, customization, individualization, parent involvement Quickly reviews that research shows the homeschooled doing well in terms of average academic achievement and social/emotional/psychological development and parents’ and youths’ reasons for homeschooling. “Differentiating instruction to meet the individual needs of student, family, and community is the ideal kind of education. ..... home-based education [homeschooling] is by nature friendly to customization. Flexible schedules, small class size, high parental involvement, and much feedback from adults are natural elements of home-based education” [p. 53]. Explains that the homeschool environment is a boon for both gifted children and learning disabled children [p. 52]. “In an environment that respects their individual traits, homeschooled students can take advantage of their flexible schedules and academic requirements to jump into internships, apprenticeships, field trips, volunteer service, jobs, trade schools, and college” [p. 52]. Peer-reviewed journal.
Ray, Brian D. 2003, January 17 Does homeschooling promote the public good? CQ Researcher [Congressional Quarterly], 13(2), p. 41. home education, research, opinion, philosophy Presents research findings and philosophical argument on liberty supporting thesis that homeschooling promotes the public good in any nation. “Americans agree that several things benefit society. First, freedom of choice applies to directing the upbringing and education of one’s own progeny, as the Supreme Court has affirmed. Second, having authentic educational choices is itself a democratic institution that protects citizens from government controlling knowledge and thought. Choice makes society richer and more diverse. Socially well-adjusted and educated citizens who are industrious and civically involved benefit society. Finally, particular values and principles, such as those listed above, as well as respectfulness and tolerance of others’ beliefs and those embodied in the Constitution and Declaration of Independence, advance the common good. Research shows that home schooling promotes these things. ….. Studies also show home schooling is accessible to a wide array of people. A rising tide of African-American and Hispanic families is flowing into home-based education and away from the public-good school experiment they discern can never make good on its promises. Many can afford the average $500 per student per year while saving taxpayers the burden of over $7,000 per public-school student.”
Ray, Brian D. 2003, February Facts on homeschooling. Retrieved 5/26/04 online http://www.nheri.org/modules.php?name=Content&pa=showpage&pid=21. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute http://www.nheri.org/modules.php?name=Content&pa=showpage&pid=21 PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309). (“There were an estimated 1,700,000 to 2,100,000 children (grades K-12) home educated during 2002-2003 in the United States. Homeschooling appears to still be the fastest-growing form of education.
Ray, Brian D. 2003, August Facts on homeschooling. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute PO Box 13939, Salem OR 97309). (“There were an estimated 1,700,000 to 2,100,000 children (grades K-12) home educated during 2002-2003 in the United States. Homeschooling appears to still be the fastest-growing form of education. One recent trend in parent-led home-based education is rapid growth among blacks and Hispanics. African-American and Hispanic families each represent an estimated 5% of the homeschool population.
Ray, Brian D. 2003, September/October Attacks from without and within: A response to erroneous thinking. Homeschooling Today, September/October 2003, 32-38. home education, philosophy, research Defines homeschooling based on a biblical Christian worldview perspective, including what it does for children, parents, and families. Explains what homeschooling is not (e.g., addresses allegation [by, e.g., Steven Schlissel] that home-based education is a stepping stone to secondary institutional schooling of children/youth done by experts). Discusses advantages of homeschooling, especially from a biblical perspective. Offers research evidence to support claims. Addresses the attacks on homeschooling and lures to homeschoolers that are offered by statists. Answers erroneous claims of supposed advocates of parent-led homeschooling.
Ray, Brian D. 2003 Home schooling. In International Encyclopedia of Marriage and Family Relationships, Second Edition, Volume 2, p. 822-828, ed. by James J. Ponzetti, Jr. New York, NY: Macmillan Reference USA.
Ray, Brian D. 2003 Worldwide guide to homeschooling: Facts and stats on the benefits of home school, 2003-2004. Nashville, TN: Broadman & Holman, Publ.
Ray, Brian D. 2004 Home educated and now adults: Their community and civic involvement, views about homeschooling, and other traits. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute, www.nheri.org https://www.nheri.org/product/home-educated-and-now-adults/ http://www.nheri.org https://www.nheri.org/product/home-educated-and-now-adults/ home education, research, adult, college, civic engagement, community involvement, socialization, academic achievement, college, occupation, demographics, beliefs, values, reasons for homeschooling, curriculum, pedagogy, long-term effects, religion, religiosity, spiritual “The aim of this study was to describe and gain more understanding about adults throughout the United States who were home educated during their elementary and secondary education years. The focus was on their general demographics, attitudes toward homeschooling, and successes in life. It was a cross-sectional descriptive and exploratory study conducted during the year 2003. This report focuses on the 5,254 respondents who were home educated for at least 7 years and had completed their secondary school years. (There was a total of 7,306 respondents who were homeschooled for 1 year or more). Of these, 48% had been homeschooled for 12 to 14 years. Their mean age was 21.3 (ranging from 16 to 69). The average number of siblings they had was 3.5. The formal educational attainment of 74.2% of these home-educated adults who were ages 18 to 24 (79% of the respondents) was some college courses or higher, while 46.2% of the same-age general U.S. population had this attainment. “Table 9 [on p. 37] shows the educational attainment of only the home-educated adults (all of whom reported that they had finished their secondary studies) who were ages 18 to 24 and those in the general U.S. population who were 18 to 24. In the general U.S. population in this age range, 46.2% had attained some college courses or higher; 74.2% of the home-educated had attained some college courses or higher” [p. 36]. Of homeschool graduates, 94% agree or strongly agree that “my religious beliefs are basically the same as my parents’” (Figure 15). These home-educated adults had very positive attitudes toward having been homeschooled. Ninety-five percent reported, “I am glad I was homeschooled”; 88% reported, “having been homeschooled is an advantage to me as an adult.” Of those who had school-age children, 74% had engaged in homeschooling their children. They were very involved in community and national life. For example, the home educated had higher rates of participation in activities such as being members of any organization (e.g., community group), participating in any ongoing community service activity (e.g., coaching a sports team), and attending religious services. Civic involvement was higher among these home-educated adults than among the average U.S. adult. “The direct civic involvement of home-educated adults and the general United States population is shown in Table 18 [on p. 53]. For all civic activities (e.g., working for candidate/political party/political cause, voting in national/state elections) and at all age groups, the home-educated adults in this study were more civically involved than the overall national population” [p. 49]. For example, they more frequently voted in national or state elections, worked for pay or as volunteers in political contexts, and attended public meetings. In addition, the data show that the home educated think that they can understand and affect society and government more than does the general public. Their commitment to or tolerance of free expression of viewpoints or beliefs is similar to that of the general public. The findings of this study indicate that parent-led, home-based education in the primary and secondary years is related to success in adulthood. Negative critics of homeschooling, however, may differently interpret the findings. One of their claims, that adults who were home educated would not be involved in public discourse, civically involved, or engaged in community activities, is contradicted by the findings of this study. On the other hand, their concern that children and youth who are home educated are strongly influenced by the values, beliefs, and worldviews of their parents and may publicly promote these is supported by the findings. In summary, the home-educated adults in this study were very positive about having been homeschooled and toward homeschooling in general, actively engaged in their local communities, keeping abreast of current affairs, highly civically involved, tolerant of others expressing their viewpoints, attaining relatively high levels of formal education, religiously active, wide-ranging in their worldview beliefs, holding worldview beliefs similar to those of their parents, and largely home educating their own children” [p. xv-xvi]. Briefly examines spiritual or religious beliefs of the adults.
Ray, Brian D. 2004 Home education in Louisiana: Homeschooling family characteristics, academic achievement, and social activities. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute. home education, research, demographics, academic achievement, social activities, socialization “The ‘typical’ homeschool family in this study was headed by a married couple and had more children than did the average American family. Thirty-four percent of fathers were professionals and 11% were tradespersons; 91% of the mothers were homemakers/home educators. Of children age 5 or older who were being home educated, the average age was a little over 11 and they have been homeschooled for almost 5 years since reaching age 5. The large majority of parents planned to homeschool their children completely through the secondary (high school) years. Many approaches to curriculum and pedagogy were used. The primary method of instruction used for 34% of the children was “traditional textbook and assignments,” while 32% used the “eclectic, directed by parents” approach, and about 7% used “relaxed homeschooling or ‘lifestyle of learning’ based on a Christian/biblical philosophy.” The large majority used computers for the education of their children and about half used the Internet for the education of their children. These homeschool students were performing well in terms of academic achievement. They scored, on the average, at the following percentiles on standardized academic achievement tests: (a) total reading, 82nd, (b) total listening, 82nd, (c) total language, 82nd, (d) total math, 79th, (e) science, 81st, (f) social studies, 80th, (g) study skills, 80th, (h) basic battery (typically, reading, language, and mathematics), 82nd, and (i) complete battery (all subject areas in which student was tested), 82nd, all significantly higher than the institutional school national average of the 50th percentile. They were also busy in social and civic activities outside their home with non-family members. For example, 83% were participating in field trips, 49% taking classes with students outside of the home, 41% engaging in group sports, and 24% doing volunteer work with people.About 64% of graduates of homeschooling in this study went on to some form of postsecondary academic study via a college or university, about 12% went on to study at a trade or business school, and 7% went into full-time employment” [abstract, p. vi-vii].
Ray, Brian D. 2004, Fall Homeschoolers on to college: What research shows us. Journal of College Admission, no. 185, 5-11. http://www.nheri.org home education, research, adults homeschooled, college admission, college attendance Peer-reviewed publication. Reviews research on homeschool families and children, particularly demographics, academic achievement, social and emotional development, and degree of success in the “real world” of work, college, and family life as adults. Presents six guidelines, based on author’s and others’ research and experience, on receiving applications from and admitting the home-educated: (1) if require SAT or ACT score of students in general, simply also require of the homeschooled, (2) ask for a high school transcript “… but have flexible guidelines for these records and documentation of courses of study completed” [p. 10], (3) “Ask the home-educated for a list of “extracurricular” activities” [p. 10], (4) “Ask them for a bibliography of what they read during their secondary years” [p. 10], (5) “Recognize the validity of homeschool high school completion or diplomas. Homeschooling is legal in all 50 states and, as explained in this article, the research shows that they are doing well academically” [p. 10], (6) “For more information, contact the National Home Education Research Institute (www.nheri.org)” [p. 10]. Included findings from Ray’s 2004 study entitled Home educated and now adults about civic involvement, book reading, and so forth. Peer-reviewed.
Ray, Brian D. 2004 Worldwide guide to homeschooling: Facts and stats on the benefits of home school, 2004-2005. Nashville, TN: Broadman & Holman, Publ.
Ray, Brian D. 2005 Be prepared: Would someone like to take over the education of your child? Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute.
Ray, Brian D. 2005 A homeschool research story. In Bruce S. Cooper (Ed.), Home schooling in full view: A reader, p. 1-19. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing. home education, research, review, summary academic achievement, socialization, adulthood “In other words, the design of most research to date does not allow for the conclusion that homeschooling necessarily causes higher academic achievement than does public (or private) institutional schooling. On the other hand, research designs and findings to date do not refute the hypothesis that homeschooling causes more positive effects than does institutional public (or private) schooling. Along these lines, Ray (2000b), after reviewing many studies on homeschooling and conducting several himself, gingerly wrote: “Assuming, for the sake of discussion and based on a multitude of studies, that home schooling is associated with high academic achievement (and possibly causes it), one could ask whether there is any link between the preceding list of positive factors and the nature of the educational ‘treatment’ known as home schooling” (p. 92) [p. 11].
Ray, Brian D. 2005 Worldwide guide to homeschooling: Facts and stats on the benefits of homeschool. Nashville, TN: Broadman & Holman, Publ. Most current copyright date of this title as of October 2010.
Ray, Brian D. 2006 Home centered learning annotated bibliography. home education, learning at home, family, parent involvement, research Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, , P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Ray first created this bibliography circa 1985 and has been updating it continually. Contains over 1,300 references, many of which are annotated, including the vast majority of research done and books written on home education, and some news media articles on home education; includes items both closely and tangentially related to what is known as "home education" in the United States in the 1990s.
Ray, Brian D. 2006 Homeschooling as “educational neglect” or neglected research standards? Home School Researcher, 17(1), 9-12. home education, research, educational neglect, philosophy, policy, law, legal, public school “Reviews Kelly, Barr, and Weatherby’s 2006 report entitled Educational Neglect & Compulsory Schooling: A Status Report in which they claimed that school-age children who are privately home educated and not registered with state agencies – even if the law does not require such registration – are “missing” and “educationally neglected,” and implies a connection between this educational neglect and child abuse. Explains significant philosophical and methodological weaknesses and errors in the report. “Since the authors of the report proposed that all homeschool parents should be compelled to register their children with the state and have them tested, they begged the following salient question that they ignored: Should not the state compel all private institutional schools and the children in them (e.g., Catholic schools, Islamic schools, Jewish schools, Lutheran schools, Mormon schools, New Age, and “nonsectarian” schools) to be registered with the state, controlled by the state, and tested by the state even if they are not funded by a state’s citizens’ tax dollars?” [p. 11].
Ray, Brian D. 2006, January 30 A Brief Review of "Educational Neglect and Compulsory Schooling: A Status Report.” Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute. Retrieved 2/20/06 online http://www.nheri.org/modules.php?name=Content&pa=showpage&pid=32. http://www.nheri.org/modules.php?name=Content&pa=showpage&pid=32 home education, research, educational neglect, compulsory schooling, philosophy, public school, private school Strongly critiques 2006 report by Philip Kelly, Robert Barr, & James Weatherby. Shows that their operational definitions are vague, methodology is lacking, and data do not support their conclusions and recommendations. For example, the authors suggest that if a school-age child is not registered with state education agencies then he is a “missing student” and “educationally neglected” in spite of the fact that the law in many states does not require such registration with state agencies for private school and homeschool students.
Ray, Brian D. 2006, July 10 Research facts on homeschooling. Retrieved 5/28/07 online http://www.nheri.org/content/view/199/. Salem, Oregon: National Home Education Research Institute. ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED494583. http://www.nheri.org/content/view/199/ “There are about 2 million homeschool students in the United States. There were an estimated 1.9 to 2.4 million children (in grades K to 12) home educated during 2005-2006 in the United States.”
Ray, Brian D. 2007, Fall Homeschooling systemically amenable to gifted and talented students? Mensa Research Journal, 38(3), 18-34. home education, gifted and talented, academic achievement, socialization, research “An increasing body of research, however, is beginning to paint a clearer picture of the relative benefits of parent-led home-based education for children in general, and the gifted in particular Many topics (e.g., academic achievement, social, emotional, and psychological development) have been addressed in the research, and the findings in some of these areas might shed light on the potential relationship between homeschooling and the education of gifted or talented children and youth. This article presents some broad contextual information regarding the homeschool community, then turns to a focus on homeschool students’ academic achievement” [p. 18].
Ray, Brian D. 2007 On blacks choosing home-based education. Home School Researcher, 17(4), 9-12. home education, opinion, philosophy, minorities, blacks, African American Offers perspective/opinion on why African Americans choose homeschooling and responds to those who do not think blacks should homeschool.
Ray, Brian D. 2007, April 17 Statement, testimony, and paper on House Bill 2629 “Home Education Equity Bill. A paper presented to the Oregon House Education Subcommittee on Innovation, Salem, Oregon, April 17, 2007. home education, homeschooling, law, policy, regulation, equity, private schooling, private education “It is neither constitutionally nor legally the state’s job to try to track down and find every student and his homeschool parents or private-school parents and school who might be out there not learning at the rate that the state decides is appropriate. If this is indeed the state’s job, then it is time for every member of this committee to start working on laws to track, find, and control the students in every Catholic, Lutheran, Waldorf, Muslim, Jewish, humanist, and pagan school in Oregon” [p. 4].
Ray, Brian D. 2008 Policy-related research on homeschooling. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute. home education, education, research, policy, best practices, industry standards, law, academic achievement, socialization, child abuse, educational neglect Studies show that a diverse assortment of families and children are involved in homeschooling for a complex variety of reasons while practicing a range of pedagogical approaches. Research reveals that home-based education is consistently associated with positive findings such as relatively high student academic achievement, healthy social, emotional, psychological, and physical development and well-being, and success in adulthood for those who were home educated. Empirical evidence shows that the degree of state regulation of homeschooling is not related to students’ academic achievement, and no research shows a relationship between degree of regulation of homeschooling and students’ social, emotional, psychological, and physical development and well-being. Neither among the homeschool community, nor among professional educators familiar with home-based education, nor among conventional school educators, nor among state governments is there consensus (general agreement), let alone unanimity, on best practices or industry standards regarding the practice of or regulation of homeschooling. It appears that neither research findings nor anything else has prompted such consensus. Philosophical, political, and theoretical claims have been made that policy should be formulated to increase the regulation of private homeschooling but empirical research on homeschooling does not support such a move. Due to its personal, familial, local, and private nature, homeschooling is not amenable to standardization by any entity, including the diverse homeschool community. It is not likely that state governments will ever reach consensus (general agreement), let alone unanimity, regarding home-based education policy. Therefore, research essentially suggests to policymakers that, at this point in time, parents who choose to homeschool their children are generally doing well at helping their children in terms of academic learning and their psychological and physical development and well-being, even with little or no oversight by the government” [abstract, p. 3].
Ray, Brian D. in press, likely 2008, mis?? Homeschooling. In James C. Carper (Ed.) & Thomas Hunt (Ed.), Praeger Handbook of Religion and Education. home education, religion, history, philosophy Short article on role of religion in modern homeschool movement.
Ray, Brian D. 2008, September 18 Research facts on homeschooling. Retrieved 7/10/09 from http://www.nheri.org/Research-Facts-on-Homeschooling.html. http://www.nheri.org/Research-Facts-on-Homeschooling.html
Ray, Brian D. 2008, December 23 U.S. homeschool population size and growth: Comments. Retrieved January 23, 2009 from http://www.nheri.org/Latest/Homeschool-Population-Size-and-Growth.html. http://www.nheri.org/Latest/Homeschool-Population-Size-and-Growth.html
Ray, Brian D. 2009 Home education reason and research: Common questions and research-based answers. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute. home education, research, review of research, academic achievement, socialization, social development, college success, adults, history, reasons ERIC Reproduction Service Number ED508160. ERIC abstract “Abstract: This is a brief review of research on a variety of topics related to home education and answers the most common questions asked regarding Homeschooling. Examples of the topics addressed are: the teaching parent's education level, academic achievement of students, population growth, philosophy, government (state) regulation and homeschool achievement, psychological and social development of students, and success of the home educated in adulthood. This booklet is a total 8 pages in length, full color, and in an 8.5" x 11" format. This report is excellent for many purposes (e.g., reading for a college course on alternatives in education, helping parents decide whether to Homeschool, to educate curious grandparents, and distribute to policymakers” [online 3/10/10].
Ray, Brian D. 2009, August 10 Research facts on homeschooling. Retrieved 3/11/2010 from http://www.nheri.org/Research-Facts-on-Homeschooling.html. http://www.nheri.org/Research-Facts-on-Homeschooling.html
Ray, Brian D. 2010, February 3 Academic achievement and demographic traits of homeschool students: A nationwide study. Academic Leadership Journal, 8(1). https://scholars.fhsu.edu/alj/vol8/iss1/7/ https://www.nheri.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Ray-2010-Academic-Achievement-and-Demographic-Traits-of-Homeschool-Students.pdf homeschooling, research, academic achievement, demographics, state control, state regulation, law, peer-reviewed journal Retrieved May 24, 2019 and June 15, 2018 from https://scholars.fhsu.edu/alj/vol8/iss1/7/ and from https://www.nheri.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Ray-2010-Academic-Achievement-and-Demographic-Traits-of-Homeschool-Students.pdf This nationwide cross-sectional, descriptive study examines the educational history, demographic features, and academic achievement of home-educated students and the basic demographics of their families, and to assess the relationships between the students’ academic achievement and selected student and family variables. Data on 11,739 homeschooling students and their families are analyzed. Students score, on average, at the 84th to 89th percentile on all subtests, which is 34 to 39 percentile points above the public school average. Very few independent variables explain much variance in test scores. There is no relationship between the degree of state regulation (control) of homeschooling and student achievement, in both an analysis of those homeschooled for 5 or more years and 12 or more years in any one state. “Major findings: Achievement. Homeschool student achievement test scores are exceptionally high. The mean scores for every subtest (which are at least the 80th percentile) are well above those of public school students. There are no statistically significant differences in achievement by whether the student has been home educated all his or her academic life [e.g., number of years homeschooled], whether the student is enrolled in a full-service curriculum, whether the parents knew their student’s test scores before participating in the study, and the degree of state regulation (control) of homeschooling (in three different analyses on the subject). The scores of all students (both participants and non-participants in the study for whom test scores were obtained) were only 2 to 4 percentile points (i.e., 0.10 to 0.16 z-score) lower than the scores of only the homeschool students who participated in the study. There are statistically significant differences in achievement among homeschool students when classified by gender, amount of money spent on education, family income, whether either parent had ever been a certified teacher (i.e., students of non-certified parents did better), number of children living at home, degree of structure in the homeschooling, amount of time student spends in structured learning, and age at which formal instruction of the student began. However, of these variables, only parent education level explained a noticeable or practically significant amount of variance, 2.5%, in student scores; the other variables explained one-half of 1% or less of the variance” (p. 27). Peer-reviewed journal.
Ray, Brian D. 2010 The harms of homeschooling? Where are the premises? (2010). Home School Researcher, 25(3), 11-16. home education, criticism, philosophy, legal, law, control, regulation, policy, research “The purpose of this article is twofold, to show that the “harms of homeschooling” that West [West, Robin, 2009, “The harms of homeschooling”] alleges basically have no foundation in research evidence and to note that West’s proposal for the state to control homeschool parents and their children is based on a worldview that it antithetical to one held by a significant portion of Americans [p. 11].
Ray, Brian D. 2010, September 25 Homeschooling across Maine: Academic achievement and demographic characteristics. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute. home education, homeschooling, academic achievement, demographics, Maine Based on a nationwide study of homeschool families and students [Ray, 2010]. Finds that the homeschool students’ achievement test scores are exceptionally high, with the mean scores for every subtest (74th to 85th percentile) being well above those of public school students nationwide. Finds there are no statistically significant differences in achievement by whether the parents knew the child’s test scores before participating in the study (but both groups were above the general national average), whether the student has been home educated all his or her academic life, whether the student is enrolled in a full-service curriculum, student’s gender, amount of money spent on home education, family income, whether either parent had ever been a certified teacher, parent education levels, the number of children living at home, degree of structure in the homeschooling, amount of time student spends in structured learning, and the age at which formal instruction of the student began.
Ray, Brian D. 2010 Homeschooling across New York: Academic achievement and demographic characteristics. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute, www.nheri.org. http://www.nheri.org
Ray, Brian D. 2011 2.04 million homeschool students in the United States in 2010. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute. Retrieved 2/18/2013 online http://www.nheri.org/research/nheri-news/homeschool-population-report-2010.html. http://www.nheri.org/research/nheri-news/homeschool-population-report-2010.html home education, homeschooling, population size, demographics “Most indications are that the homeschool population has grown in absolute terms during the past 3 to 5 years. This study shows there were an estimated 2.040 million K to 12 homeschool students in the United States in the spring of 2010, with high confidence that the true number lies between 1.734 million and 2.346 million. ….. The preceding information suggests that the number of homeschool children grew in terms of the percentage of all school-age children, as well as in absolute terms, during the past 3 to 5 years” [p. 3].
Ray, Brian D. 2011 Attachment theory and home-based education. Home School Researcher, 26 (1), 9-11. homeschooling, home education, attachment theory, peer orientation, parent orientation, adult orientation, psychology, sociology, socialization Explores the connections between Bowlby’s attachment theory, the recommendations of Neufeld and Maté in their book Hold on to your kids, and the modern homeschool movement. Concludes the following: “The preceding description of intergenerational everyday living and Neufeld and Maté's advocacy of parent- and adult-orientation of children has been a part of the warp and woof of homeschool articles and books for the entire life of the modern homeschool movement, and research indicates that such is also a main motive of a large portion of parents who never stop homeschooling their children, or begin it after having put them in institutional schools for some years. Research also finds that homeschool families are consistently and intentionally a part of teaching/learning cooperatives, sports programs, church functions, and other activities that support the environment of home-based education that encourages children to be parent-oriented rather than peer-oriented” [p. 11].
Ray, Brian D. 2011 The history, development, and philosophy of homeschooling [published in Polish]. In J. Piskorski (ed.). Between freedom and duty (pp. 19-26). Warsaw, Poland: Instytut Sobieskiego, https://www.sobieski.org.pl/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Piskorski-red.-Szko%C5%82a-domowa-PDF.pdf https://www.sobieski.org.pl/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Piskorski-red.-Szko%C5%82a-domowa-PDF.pdf homeschooling, home education, history, development, philosophy Covers history, development, and philosophy of home education, with a focus on a European audience. Published in Polish.
Ray, Brian D. 2011, January 11 Research facts on homeschooling. Retrieved December 27, 2011 http://www.nheri.org/Research-Facts-on-Homeschooling.html. Salem, Oregon: National Home Education Research Institute. http://www.nheri.org/Research-Facts-on-Homeschooling.html
Ray, Brian D. 2011, April 11 Homeschooling: Beneficial learner and societal outcomes but educators do not promote it. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 8-12, 2011, New Orleans, Louisiana LA).
Ray, Brian D. 2012 Evangelical Protestant and other faith-based homeschooling. In James C. Carper & Thomas C. Hunt (Eds.), Praeger handbook of faith-based schools in the United States, K-12 home education, homeschooling, history, religion, philosophy, Christianity, Protestantism chapter 12, pages 123-135). Santa Barbara, CA:Praeger, ABC-CLIO. (Definition of homeschooling: “Homeschooling is a form of private education that is the parent-led home-based education of school-age children, and it does not rely on either state-run public schooling or institutional private schooling for the children’s education [p. 123]. “Home-based education continued to be common for most of the time for most children’s lives through the nineteenth century. By one estimate, in 1870 only about 65 percent of 5- to 17-year-olds were enrolled in public elementary and secondary schools (a higher percent attended at the elementary level) and the average number of days the average pupil attended school per year was only 78 (United States Department of Education 2010, 63-64). And there is evidence that many of those school days lasted only a few hours. It is likely that many children were mainly at home with their families the other 287 days per year. During the 19th century “... the school was a voluntary and incidental institution: attendance varied enormously from day to day and season to season ...” (Tyack 1974, 16). For all children, whether they attended a school or not, schooling, or book learning, was only a small and often incidental part of the total education of a child since he …..” (p. 125). Exact or close quote: “A society-wide battle ensued, with many opposing such a plan (Ball 1994; Carper and Hunt 2007). The primary concern of many “… was with the potential for an inappropriate concentration, in the hands of the state, of responsibility and initiative for defining the objectives of education and thus of the character and convictions of the rising generation” (Glenn 1987 121). Those advocating state control ultimately held sway and Protestant and Roman Catholic schools “… were increasingly viewed as un-American and divisive” by the 1870s (Carper and Hunt, 2007, 200). Home-based, or domestic, education was headed for a rapid swift decline. By 1899-1900, 72 percent of 5- to 17-year-olds were enrolled in public schools, but their average attendance was still only 99 days per year (United States Department of Education 2010, 63-64). Until this time, it appears that the local community controlled the classroom of public (or common) schools, including both their explicit and hidden curriculums (Tyack 1974, 14, 49), but that was changing rapidly.”
Ray, Brian D. 2013 Discipleship, education, and schooling of children: A biblical perspective. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute.) education, philosophy, Christianity, discipleship, homeschooling, public schooling, private schooling
Ray, Brian D. 2013, March 13 Is there any solid evidence for expanding compulsory school age? Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute, www.nheri.org. http://www.nheri.org early childhood education, compulsory attendance age, compulsory school age, research, academic achievement, synthesis] “The author has been distressed to see that although there is no clear evidence that the myriad ECE [early childhood education] programs, younger compulsory school attendance ages, and older compulsory school ages help children in general in any appreciable and consistent long-lasting way into their youth or adulthood, many uninformed politicians and policymakers, and educators and other businesses with vested interests in ECE programs and expanded compulsory school attendance ages, continue to promote the state expanding compulsory ages and funding ECE programs” [p. 3].
Ray, Brian D. 2013 Homeschooling associated with beneficial learner and societal outcomes but educators do not promote it. Peabody Journal of Education, 88(3), 324-341. homeschoooling, home education, research, academic achievement, socialization, social skills, adulthood, autonomy, civic engagement, outcomes, philosophy, critique, opposition, anti-homeschooling “This article reviews research on homeschool learner outcomes and evaluates opposition to homeschooling. It synthesizes research on learner outcomes related to homeschooling in areas of students’ academic achievement and children’s social, emotional, and psychological development and the success of adults who were home educated and finds generally positive outcomes on a variety of variables are associated with homeschooling. The author identifies four classes of negativity expressed toward home-based education by the education profession, such as the claims homeschooling is bad for the collective good and that without much state regulation significant numbers of homeschooling (home schooling) parents will harm their children. The evaluation reveals that proactive opposition to homeschooling and calls for significant state control over homeschooling do not offer any empirical research evidence that homeschooling is bad for individual children, families, neighborhoods, or the collective good. The alleged harms of homeschooling or arguments for more control of it are fundamentally philosophical and push for the state, rather than parents, to be in primary and ultimate control over the education and upbringing of children so they will come to hold worldviews more aligned with the state and opponents of state-free homeschooling than with the children’s parents and freely chosen relationships” [abstract, p. 324]. “It is clear than many of these homeschool opponents want the state to act as a preemptive dragnet to screen and catch parents before they do evil things to their children or not offer their children all the advantages that the state can allegedly offer them (via the means of compulsory attendance at institutional state-controlled schools or more-controlled home-based education)” (p. 335). “After 30 years of research, that is largely cross-sectional and descriptive, studies have consistently found positive outcomes associated with parent-led home-based education (a.k.a., homeschooling), and an increasing number of studies that are explanatory or causal-comparative corroborate these findings. In addition, there is no empirical evidence linking home education, in general or on average, to negative things for individuals or society. Further, there is research evidence that home-based education systemically offers an environment that is beneficial to children’s and youth’s academic and social, emotional, and psychological development in ways that cannot be offered in institutional schooling (Murphy, 2012, Chapters 7–8; Ray, 2000b, 2010a). ….. Regardless of research findings, homeschoolers think it is their fundamental duty and right to direct the education and upbringing of their children and that there should be no burden of proof (e.g., state-approved achievement test scores, state-approved values taught; Murphy, 2012, p. 134; Ray, 2000a, pp. 287–289; Ray & Eagleson, 2008) on them to be free to do this” [p. 337]. “Many educators, policymakers, and theoreticians, however, either actively oppose home education or argue for more state control over this private form of education/schooling. It appears that most opponents of homeschooling are not basing their opposition on research or empirical evidence that home education harms individuals or society. Instead, it appears likely that opponents of home-based education do not [p. 337 ends] promote or argue against the practice because they either want the state to be in primary and ultimate control over the education and upbringing of all children (i.e., future adult citizens) or are upset that homeschooling is affecting children and youth to become adults who hold worldviews different than they, the opponents, and different from what home-education opponents want to promote to children and society via state-controlled education” [p. 338].
Ray, Brian D. 2013 Homeschooling rising into the twenty-first century: Editor’s introduction. Peabody Journal of Education, 88(3), 261-264. homeschooling, home education, research, history, review Introduces this special issue of the journal on the topic of homeschooling. “The renascence of parent-led home-based education caused people as recently as 15 years ago to wonder whether homeschooling was just a fad. Now, having grown from nearly extinct by the 1970s to more than 2 million K-12 students (Ray, 2011), homeschooling has become a well-considered choice for mainstream America. It appears that homeschooling will be a stable, if not growing, part of the educational landscape for many years to come. ….. Since the turn of the century, several changes have become apparent related to the homeschooling movement.” [p. 261].
Ray, Brian D. 2014 Homeschooling across America: Academic achievement and demographic characteristics. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute. http://www.nheri.org/Latest/Homeschooling-Across-America-Academic-Achievement-and-Demographic-Characteristics.html home education, research, academic achievement, demographics, correlates, public school Summary of study retrieved January 1, 2010 from http://www.nheri.org/Latest/Homeschooling-Across-America-Academic-Achievement-and-Demographic-Characteristics.html. Home-educated students involved in several academic achievement testing services from across the United States. The scores of 11,739 were carefully analyzed in this study. On average, the homeschool students scored at the 84th to 89th percentile in all subject areas (i.e., about 34 to 39 percentile points above the public-school national average). The following variables had none or a very weak relationship to homeschool students’ achievement: sex of student, household/family income, whether either parent had ever been a certified teacher, amount spent on home education, and degree of control/regulation of homeschooling by the state. Degree of control by the state showed no statistical relationship to achievement. Parent education level showed a small correlation with achievement, but even the homeschool students of parents with relatively low formal educational attainment scored above average.
Ray, Brian D. 2015, February 6 A brief report on homeschooling across Indiana: Academic achievement and demographic characteristics. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute. homeschooling, home education, research, academic achievement, demographics, Indiana Based on a nationwide study of 11,739 homeschool students and their families, this sub-study focused on 154 students and their families from Indiana. The “The income of these families ranged from the category of $20,000 to 24,999 to $150,000 or more. The median income for these home-educating families in Indiana ($75,000- $79,999) is about the same as for all married-couple families nationwide with one or more related children under age 18 median income $74,049 in 2006 dollars; or roughly $79,015 in 2008 dollars). Some of these homeschool parents had only graduated from high school and others had doctoral degrees. On average, they have more formal education than parents in the general U.S. population; 79.2% of the fathers and 75.3% of the mothers had a college degree (i.e., bachelor’s degree) or a higher educational attainment. In 2007, 29.5% of all adult males nationwide ages 25 and over had finished college and 28.0% of females had done so. These homeschool families are notably larger – 63.6% have three or more children living in the home during the study – than families nationwide. The percent of homeschool students in this study who are White/not-Hispanic (98.7%) is disproportionately high compared to public school students nationwide. Almost all homeschool students in this study (98.0%) are in married-couple families. Most of these homeschool mothers (76.6%) do not participate in the paid labor force; almost all homeschool fathers (97.4%) do work for pay. The median amount of money spent annually on educational materials is $600 to $799 per home-educated student” (p. 3). “Homeschool student achievement test scores are high in this study in Indiana. The mean scores for every subtest (which are at least the 84th percentile) are well above those of public school students. The achievement scores being well above average is consistent with the findings in the nationwide study previously mentioned and in studies by many other researchers (e.g., reviews of research by Murphy, 2012 and Ray, 2013). There are no statistically significant differences in achievement by (a) whether the parents knew the child’s test scores before participating in the study (but both groups were above the general national average), (b) the student has been home educated all his or her academic life, (c) whether the student is enrolled in a full-service curriculum, (d) student’s gender, (e) amount of money spent on home education, (f ) family income, (g) whether either parent had ever been a certified teacher, (h) the number of children living at home, (i) degree of structure in the homeschooling, (j) amount of time student spends in structured learning, and (k) the age at which formal instruction of the student began. There is a statistically significant difference in achievement among homeschool students according to the parents’ education level. However, parent education level explained only 4.8% of the variance in student scores” (p. 4). “The results of the present study in Indiana are consistent with previous studies of the achievement of home school students … That is, homeschool students in grades Kindergarten through 12 normally score, on average, well above the public school norm. Comparisons between home-educated students and institutional school students nationwide should be, however, interpreted with thoughtfulness and care. As stated at the beginning of this report, this is a cross-sectional, descriptive study ... It is not a controlled experiment and readers should be careful about assigning causation to anything. On the one hand, as Rudner (1999) wrote: “This study simply shows that those parents choosing to make a commitment to home schooling are able to provide a very successful academic environment.” On the other hand, it may be that something about the very nature and practice of home-based education in Indiana and across the nation causes higher academic achievement than institutional state-run schooling (Ray, 1997, 2000, 2013).” (p. 5).
Ray, Brian D. 2015 African American homeschool parents’ motivations for homeschooling and their Black children’s academic achievement. Journal of School Choice, 9:71–96. Also, retrieved January 23, 2021 from http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/15582159.2015.998966?needAccess=true http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/15582159.2015.998966?needAccess=true homeschooling, African American, Black students, motivation, academic achievement, school choice, parents as teachers, parent involvement, educational policy, peer-reviewed journal Abstract: This study explores the motivations of African American parents for choosing homeschooling for their children and the academic achievement of their Black homeschool students. Their reasons for homeschooling are similar to those of homeschool parents in general, although some use homeschooling to help their children understand Black culture and history. The average reading, language, and math test scores of these Black homeschool students are significantly higher than those of Black public school students (with effect sizes of .60 to 1.13) and equal to or higher than all public school students as a group in this exploratory, cross-sectional, and explanatory nonexperimental study” (p. 71). That is, the following was found while controlling for gender and socioeconomic status: Reading, black homeschool students 42 percentile points higher than black public school students; Language, African American homeschool students 26 percentile points higher than black African American students; Math, black homeschool students 23 percentile points higher than black public school students
Ray, Brian D. 2015, January 30 Gen2 Survey: A spiritual and educational survey on Christian millennials. Salem, Oregon: National Home Education Research Institute. Retrieved October 28, 2019 from https://www.nheri.org/gen2-survey-a-spiritual-and-educational-survey-on-christian-millennials/ https://www.nheri.org/gen2-survey-a-spiritual-and-educational-survey-on-christian-millennials/ homeschooling, home education, private schooling, public schooling, faith, beliefs, sexual abuse, community involvement, family life, church attendance See this study in a more detailed form below at Ray, Brian D., 2022, The transmission of culture, religion, and affinity for four school choices to adults who were homeschooled, public schooled, and private schooled. Many findings. One finding, in a purely correlational analysis, is that a student who attends Christian schools is 2.1 times as likely to be sexually abused as those who are homeschooled, and a student who is public schooled is 2.6 times as likely to be sexually abused as those who are homeschooled. One of first studies to gather data on the entire K-12 schooling-sector (e.g., public school, private school, homeschool) history of children or adults.) Need annotation
Ray, Brian D. 2015, January 6 Research facts on homeschooling. Retrieved May 23, 2015, http://www.nheri.org/research/research-facts-on-homeschooling.html http://www.nheri.org/research/research-facts-on-homeschooling.html
Ray, Brian D. 2016 A brief history of homeschooling in the United States, https://carm.org/homeschooling/a-brief-history-of-homeschooling-in-the-united-states/ https://carm.org/homeschooling/a-brief-history-of-homeschooling-in-the-united-states/ home education, homeschooling, history, America, United States “Home-based education (homeschooling) is millennia old. It has been the norm around the world for most of humankind’s history. Homeschooling has a rich history in the United States. During the colonial period, the family, that is, parents and siblings, was the normal, foundational, and predominant educational environment for most children. It is nearly impossible to uncover exact statistics or percentages regarding how many (what are now called) school-age children were engaged more of their time in home-based education than in school-based education. Evidence suggests that the large majority were mainly home educated, and this included both instructions in reading, writing, and arithmetic and faith, morals, and interpersonal relationships or social skills. Tutoring, typically in the child’s home, also was not uncommon in colonial times (Gordon and Gordon 1990, p. 245-73). Historians have found that colonial children were at least as likely to be taught reading at home as at a school. As two students of tutorial education observe: “Domestic education [i.e., home-based education, homeschooling] was common throughout the 1600s and 1700s” (Gordon and Gordon, p. 245). Historian Lawrence Cremin clearly and with fine detail explains the centrality of the household in colonial education: “The colonists were heir to Renaissance traditions stressing the centrality of the household as the primary agency of human association and education …” (Cremin 1970, p. 124). Regarding New England villages where population density was such that households were.”
Ray, Brian D. 2016 An international comparative study of the barriers to parents choosing to home educate their children. Paper presented at the Global Home Education Conference, March 9-12, 2016, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. homeschooling, home education, barriers, international “Abstract: The purpose of this study is to identify, understand, and compare the barriers to parents – in nations around the globe – choosing to home educate their children and to propose solutions for removing such barriers. Much research explores the reasons for homeschooling but little examines the obstacles or hindrances to parents beginning home education. Parents in nations from Europe, South America, Africa, Asia, Australia, and North America provide answers to what hurdles inhibit them from making homeschooling their educational choice. Their answers are explored from the perspective of what parents might learn from others and how homeschool leaders and policymakers can make home education more attractive and feasible to more families around the word. Analysis suggests that strongest barriers to homeschooling (among seven categories investigated) have much to do with the opinions or actions of various persons or groups” (p. 1-2). “The strongest barriers to homeschooling, around the globe, have much to do with the opinions or actions of various persons or groups (i.e., Opinions Actions scale). This group of hurdles includes items such as experts claiming that homeschooled children are not well socialized, homeschoolers being are discriminated against in one’s community and/or country, a person’s church (or religious group) being antagonistic toward homeschooling, public opinion in general, and university/college policies being not friendly to homeschool graduates [p. 27 ends]. Costs Resources was the second-strongest barrier category, globally. This group includes obstacles such as “both parents need a full-time job,” “lack of money to purchase curriculum materials,” and “parents do not have time to homeschool.” The least obstructive group of items was in Concerns Children scale (concerns regarding my children). Participants around the world are the least likely to say that items such as concern about social isolation of children, Resistance to homeschooling from my child/children, and my child will not have access to enough sports/athletic if homeschooled. It appears that public and community opinion about home education must be addressed in order to see homeschooling more accessible to more parents. Also, homeschool organizations should be working to educate parents on how they can homeschool their children with the resources, whether monetary, curriculum, or time, that they do have and educate parents on the value of the home-based education and training of their children in spite of challenges in the area of costs and resources” (p. 27-28.) “One important consideration about these data is that almost all respondents are already homeschooling parents. The research topic, however, is to uncover barriers to homeschooling. Homeschooling parents have, to some extent, overcome these barriers” (p. 28).) Revised notes
Ray, Brian D. 2016 Homeschooling and child abuse, child neglect, and child fatalities. Retrieved October 10, 2016 from http://www.nheri.org/research/homeschooling-and-child-abuse-child-neglect-and-child-fatalities.html http://www.nheri.org/research/homeschooling-and-child-abuse-child-neglect-and-child-fatalities.html homeschooling, home education, child abuse, child neglect, child fatalities “Conclusion. To date, there has been only one report of research utilizing original data directly related to homeschooling and child abuse, child neglect, and child fatalities. That study asked one question regarding sexual abuse and found that adults who had been home educated reported being abused at a lower rate than those in two other groups and at the same rate as a third group. One organization (in another article) worked to collect information from various sources in an attempt to estimate child fatality rates within the homeschool population. The authors of that article found no significant difference in fatality rates between the general public and the homeschool population. Based on this very limited base of information, one might say that there is no reliable, empirical evidence that homeschooled children experience any more abuse, neglect or fatalities due to neglect than do children who attend public or private institutional school.”
Ray, Brian D. 2016 Research facts on homeschooling. Retrieved April 6, 2016, http://www.nheri.org/research/research-facts-on-homeschooling.html http://www.nheri.org/research/research-facts-on-homeschooling.html
Ray, Brian D. in press, probably 2016 A brief history, learner outcomes, and two key issues on homeschooling in America. In R. Fox & N. Buchanan (Editors), Handbook of School Choice. New York, NY: Wiley & Sons Publishers.
Ray, Brian D. 2016 Introduction to recent changes in U.S.A. homeschooling. In Cooper, Bruce S.; Spielhagen, Frances R.; & Ricci, Carlo (Eds), Homeschooling in New View. Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing.
Ray, Brian D. 2016 The transmission of culture, religion, and affinity for home education to adults who were homeschooled, public schooled, and private schooled. A paper presented at the Global Home Education Conference, March 9-12, 2016, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. http://www.ghec2016.org/sites/default/files/ray_transmisssion_of_culture_religion.pdf Retrieved July 5, 2016 from http://www.ghec2016.org/sites/default/files/ray_transmisssion_of_culture_religion.pdf
Ray, Brian D. 2017 A review of research on Homeschooling and what might educators learn? Pro-Posições, 28(2). http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1980-6248-2016-0009 http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0103-73072017000200085&lng=en&tlng=en homeschooling, home schooling, home education, academic achievement, history, college, social development, socialization, university Retrieved June 11, 2020 and November 21, 2018 from http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1980-6248-2016-0009 Retrieved June 18, 2018 from http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0103-73072017000200085&lng=en&tlng=en “Abstract. This article reviews research on homeschool learner outcomes and then focuses on one study and one conceptual theme related to both home education and schooling in general. It synthesizes research on learner outcomes related to homeschooling in areas of students’ academic achievement, children’s social, emotional, and psychological development, and the success of adults who were home educated. The summary finds generally that positive outcomes on a variety of variables are associated with homeschooling. The first special focus is one study on African American homeschooling families that explores the parents’ reasons for homeschooling and their Black children’s academic achievement. The second particular focus is the issue of whether compulsory school attendance laws are necessary in light of the findings of research on teacher preparation and certification in state/public schools and three decades of research on modern homeschooling. Keywords homeschooling; home education; academic achievement; socialization; motivations; compulsory schooling.” “To date, no studies have found home-educated students to have lower achievement test scores, on average, than public school students. Further, the overall research base and state-provided data suggest the following three main things about home-educated students’ academic achievement: 1. The homeschooled consistently score well above the public school national average. Most studies find them scoring in the range of the 65th to 80th percentile. 2. Most demographic and other variables studied explain very little variance in the achievement scores of the home educated. 3. Parent formal educational attainment consistently explains statistically significant differences in achievement but, practically speaking, small amounts of variance, and the amount of variance explained is typically less than what this variable explains within the public school student population.” “First, after a century of the system of professional education/schooling, university and think tank scholars who study primary and secondary teaching and learning cannot firmly conclude that teacher certification and state control of public/state schools guarantees successful learning by children and adolescents. Second, parent-led home-based education is a substantively different education paradigm, environment, and practice than institutional public and private schools. Third, the evidence from research on the modern homeschool movement and community shows that it is very successful educationally and socially with children and adults who were educated by homeschooling. With these building blocks in place, why do any persons in the professional education system or policymakers want to limit or prohibit parents and children from accessing and executing homeschooling?” “Further, there is weak or no evidence that the state is effective at ensuring that all (or even most) children are well educated in public schools. There are mixed messages from research about whether state certification is worth the trouble and cost regarding children’s learning in state schools. There is no evidence that state control ove+r (or prohibition of) homeschooling will enhance children’s learning or improve society. There is, however, solid evidence that homeschool students do as well as or better than those in public schools and they do so at a significant financial savings to their fellow citizens and the state which does not need to collect taxes for their education. If the home education of children is good for the children and for a community and a nation, why do not more professional educators and policymakers support or promote private homeschooling?”
Ray, Brian D. 2017 A systematic review of the empirical research on selected aspects of homeschooling as a school choice. Journal of School Choice: International Research and Reform, 11(4), 604-621, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/15582159.2017.1395638 Retrieved December 12, 2017 from https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2017.1395638 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/15582159.2017.1395638 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2017.1395638 academic achievement, college students, homeschooling, home education, review of research, social development, socialization, adulthood; peer-reviewed journal Reviews only and all peer-reviewed research on three outcomes (i.e., academic achievement, social development, and success into college and adulthood) related to homeschooling, and it reviews other subject areas. “Abstract. This article gives the demographic characteristics of the U.S. homeschooling population and the reasons that parents choose to homeschool, summarizes the findings of studies on the homeschool learner outcomes of academic achievement, social development, and success in adulthood, and proposes future research on parent-led home-based education. The majority of peer-reviewed studies on academic achievement reveal a positive effect for the homeschooled students compared to institutional schooled students, while a few studies show mixed or negative results. Regarding social and emotional development, a large majority of studies show clearly positive outcomes for the homeschooled compared to those in conventional schools. A majority of the studies on the relative success of the home-educated who later became adults show positive outcomes for the homeschooled compared to those who had been in conventional schools. I recommend that the existing literature be enhanced by well-controlled non-experimental designs to examine adults who were homeschooled in terms of an array of knowledge, attitudes and behaviors regarding lifelong learning, rates of public welfare dependency, and degree of personal agency or self-efficacy.” “In 11 of the 14 [78%] peer-reviewed studies [on academic achievement], there was a definite positive effect on achievement for the homeschooled students. One of the 14 studies showed mixed results; that is, some positive and some negative effects were associated with homeschooling. One study revealed no difference between the homeschool and conventional school students, and one study revealed neutral and negative results for homeschooling compared to conventional schooling [this was for grade K students only, Aram et al., 2016]. Both state-provided data sets showed higher than average academic achievement test scores for the home educated” (p. 8). “Thirteen of the 15 [87%; studies on social development] showed clearly positive outcomes for the homeschooled compared to those in conventional schools. Two of those studies reported that some of the findings were more positive for homeschool students but some were more positive for institutional school students” (p. 9). “Eleven of the 16 [69%; studies on success into adulthood and college] showed positive outcomes for the homeschooled compared to those in conventional schools. One study found positive outcomes for conventional school students compared to homeschool students. Finally, four of the studies found no significant difference between those from homeschool backgrounds and the others from institutional school backgrounds” (p. 11). Overall, 78% (35) of the 45 peer-reviewed studies found that the homeschooled students or graduates performed significantly better than their conventional or institutional school peers in terms of academic achievement, social and emotional development, and success into adulthood (including at college/university); 11% (5) found no significant difference; 7% (3) found mixed results; conventional school students performed significantly better in 4% (2) of the studies.
Ray, Brian D. 2017 A description and brief history of home schooling in America. Pages 329-343, In, R. A. Fox & N. K. Buchanan (Ed.), Handbook of School Choice, Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Ray, Brian D. 2017 Home centered learning annotated bibliography. http://www.nheri.org home education, homeschooling, home schooling, learning at home, family, parent involvement, research Available from www.nheri.org the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Ray first created this bibliography circa 1985 and has been updating it continually. Contains over 1,400 references, many of which are annotated, including the vast majority of research done and books written on home education, and some news media articles on home education; includes items both closely and tangentially related to what is known as "home education" in the United States in the 1990s.
Ray, Brian D. 2018 African American homeschool parents’ motivations for homeschooling and their black children’s academic achievement. In Robert Maranto & Debra Bell (Eds.), Homeschooling in the 21st century: Research and prospects (98-123). Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon, United Kingdom: Routledge. homeschooling, home education, academic achievement, motivations, reasons, African American, black students Title explains the topic.
Ray, Brian D. 2018, March 15 The relationship between the degree of state regulation of homeschooling and the abuse of homeschool children (Students). Retrieved June 3, 2021 from https://www.nheri.org/degree-of-homeschool-regulation-no-relationship-to-homeschool-child-abuse/ https://www.nheri.org/degree-of-homeschool-regulation-no-relationship-to-homeschool-child-abuse/ Homeschool abuse, homeschool child abuse, child abuse, homeschool neglect, homeschool child neglect, homeschooling, home schooling, regulation, homeschool laws, legal, policy, public school child abuse, private school child abuse, abuse, scholarly articles Cross-sectional descriptive correlational non-experimental study. “Abstract: Various scholars and policymakers have claimed that homeschooling must be regulated or controlled by the civil government to make sure that life goes well for homeschool students. Others have argued that political philosophy and empirical evidence show that private homeschool education should be left alone. This study examined whether there is a relationship between the degree of state control of homeschooling and the rate of abuse or neglect by the parents (or other legally responsible caregivers) of homeschooled children ages 6 through 17. The investigation considered the homeschool laws by state and whether they had a relationship to homeschool child abuse. Regression analysis of 18 years of data from all the U.S. states found no relationship between the degree of state control or regulation of homeschooling and the frequency of homeschool abuse.” Uses words risk or at-risk several times but never applies them to homeschool students or families. Finds that homeschool students are no more or less at-risk of abuse according to different degrees of control/regulation of homeschooling by the state/government.
Ray, Brian D. 2019, in press A systematic review of the empirical research on selected aspects of homeschooling as a school choice. In Patrick J. Wolf (Ed.), School Choice: Separating fact from fiction. London, England: Routledge, Taylor and Francis Group. academic achievement, college students, homeschooling, home education, review of research, social development, socialization, adulthood; peer-reviewed journal This chapter gives the demographic characteristics of the U.S. homeschooling population and the reasons that parents choose to homeschool, summarizes the findings of studies on the homeschool learner outcomes of academic achievement, social development, and success in adulthood, and proposes future research on parent-led home-based education. The majority of peer-reviewed studies on academic achievement reveal a positive effect for the homeschooled students compared to institutional schooled students, while a few studies show mixed or negative results. Regarding social and emotional development, a large majority of studies show clearly positive outcomes for the homeschooled compared to those in conventional schools. A majority of the studies on the relative success of the home-educated who later became adults show positive outcomes for the homeschooled compared to those who had been in conventional schools. I recommend that the existing literature be enhanced by well-controlled non-experimental designs to examine adults who were homeschooled in terms of an array of knowledge, attitudes and behaviors regarding lifelong learning, rates of public welfare dependency, and degree of personal agency or self-efficacy.
Ray, Brian D. 2019 Discipleship, education, and schooling of children: A biblical perspective. Salem, Oregon: National Home Education Research Institute. education, philosophy, biblical, Christianity, research “If only it were easier to do. What is “it”? How about trying to look at the word of God on a particular topic as if it were the first time, and as if you had not been biased by your family growing up, your local churches, your favorite Bible teachers, your friends of the past and present, your elementary and secondary school experiences, TV, and what all the experts say? It is not easy. But it is imperative that every Christian consider doing this on the topic of the discipleship of children. If not, a core aspect of what it means to live a Christian life is ignored and part of God’s best plan is lost” (p. 1). “Scripture, taken piece-by-piece and as a whole, clearly prescribes that parents are responsible for the teaching, training, and indoctrination of children – that is, their discipleship – and that the civil government is not, while the church is to support parents in their educational and discipling duty and responsibility and not do the bulk of it in the place of the parents. And while parents persist in their biblical decision to lead, partake, and continue in the parent-led home-based education of their children, they will take part in untold shared experiences with their children and spouses that are not available otherwise, face many challenges, battle myriad moments of exhaustion, pray through periods of doubt, and eventually reap the rewards of hearing God compliment them for faithful obedience and running hard after the prize – that can be conferred only by God’s decree and generous grace – of being able to say” (p. 9). Provides many scriptures related to whose duty and responsibility it is to educate and disciple, and to whom that duty does not adhere. Provides empirical research evidence regarding the effectiveness or benefits of homeschooling or home education.
Ray, Brian D. 2020 A Homeschool researcher responds to Harvard professor’s criticism. In, Smith & Mason (Eds.), Homeschool freedom: How it works and why we must protect it. Purcellville, Virginia: Home School Legal Defense Association. homeschooling, home education, research, research design, critics of homeschooling, philosophy of research, philosophy of science, academic achievement, socialization, social development, adults, adulthood, college, Elizabeth Bartholet In the context of Elizabeth Bartholet’s (2020) call for a presumptive ban on homeschooling and various claims about what research on homeschooling does or does not show, Ray provides a brief lesson on the nature of social science research and what makes for sound research. Discusses research design such as related to correlational and causal approaches. Gives some history on homeschool research. Discusses how the worldview or conceptual framework of the researcher always influences or biases individual studies and reviews of research. Explains a review he did (2017) and writes, “Overall, 35 of the 45 peer-reviewed studies (78%) found that the homeschooled students or graduates of parent-led home-based education performed significantly better than their conventional or institutional school peers in terms of academic achievement, social and emotional development, and success into adulthood (including at college or university)” (p. 48). About himself, Ray writes, “People have asked me whether I am an advocate of homeschooling. My response is that because of my worldview and experience, I am an advocate of what helps children learn and enjoy learning so that they become adults who are literate and numerate, kind to their neighbors, and able and inclined to work hard and support themselves and their families and honor their Creator. I am a strong advocate of education in the classic sense.12 I have been a state-certified teacher, have taught in private and public schools, and have taught teachers as a former professor of education. Because of all this, I am an advocate of much dialogue and interchange between adults and children. I advocate for customizing pedagogical approaches and curriculum for each child, according to their strengths, weaknesses, dreams, and desires. Mentoring and one-on-one instruction are great for children (and adults). Much opportunity for positive social interactions, cooperation, and age integration are good for children and adolescents. More parental involvement, rather than less, is good. Children having time to know and enjoy peers, but being adult oriented rather than peer dependent, is good” (p. 49). Covers the many baseless claims and poor logic of Bartholet and agrees with Patrick Wolf and Matthew Lee who wrote, “Upon reviewing Professor Bartholet’s article, we conclude that it suffers from contradictions, factual errors, statements of stereotyping, and a failure seriously to consider that the alternative to homeschooling—public schooling—shares the problems that she attributes to home education” (p. 51). Under a section entitled “the real point,” Ray writes: “Perhaps more important than what Professor Bartholet claims about me is that her negative criticisms of me are actually red herrings and amount to an overall negative criticism of all researchers who have found positive things related to homeschooling. As mentioned above, 45 scholars (as of about 2016) across the span of 30 years had published peer-reviewed research reports on three different homeschool learner outcomes. Dozens, if not hundreds, more professors, doctoral students, and think tank academics have conducted and published research that has found positive things related to homeschooling. Very few have found negative things. Professor Bartholet’s and other academics’ and commentators’ criticisms of me and my studies are really criticisms of nearly every scholar and study that has ever found something positive related to homeschooling. Their charges against me are basically charges against all these scholars because most are working within the same genre of social science research. None of these studies on homeschooling that Professor Bartholet criticizes are “true experimental” in design, and [p. 52 ends] relatively few involve guaranteed representative samples. However, the researchers do clearly lay out their purposes, methods, findings, limitations, and conclusions. They continue to add to the socialscience body of research on homeschooling and inform and enrich our knowledge and understanding of parent-led home-based education.” (p. 52-53). “Concluding thoughts: A sound or respectable social-science study and its report is one in which the investigator clearly states the study’s purpose, methods, and findings, and the interpretations and conclusions that the scholar makes reasonably follow from all that preceded them. A sound evaluation of a study considers all of this. Everyone who reads a study, or an evaluation of a study, should remember that every researcher and reviewer has a personal worldview that affects, biases, or slants what he or she does, writes, and says. To date, the clear majority of research done on homeschooling finds positive things associated with the method of education. Consistently negative criticisms of various individual studies about homeschooling and homeschool parents and students or of a particular scholar who studies homeschooling are, in essence, a negative criticism of the large majority of homeschool researchers and their studies. The negative critics generally ignore or fail to recognize and explain what homeschool studies have legitimately contributed to the knowledge base and understanding of an important body of inquiry regarding a millennia-old and effective form of teaching and learning—homeschooling—in the United States and around the world” (p. 53).
Ray, Brian D. 2020 Perceived barriers to homeschooling in a fragile community, with a focus on black families. Paper presented the annual International School Choice and Reform Conference, January 18, 2020, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, https://www.nheri.org/perceived-barriers-to-homeschooling-in-a-fragile-community-with-a-focus-on-black-families-2/ https://www.nheri.org/perceived-barriers-to-homeschooling-in-a-fragile-community-with-a-focus-on-black-families-2/ homeschooling, black, African American, barriers, fragile community 39% of the fragile community (focused on black families) reported that the homeschool regulations were “burdensome.”
Ray, Brian D. 2020 What is “Good” Research? A Homeschool Researcher Responds to Harvard Professor’s Criticism: Research Methods 101, https://nheri.org/what-is-good-research-a-homeschool-researcher-responds-to-harvard-professors-criticism/ https://nheri.org/what-is-good-research-a-homeschool-researcher-responds-to-harvard-professors-criticism/ research, research methods, philosophy of research, homeschooling, homeschool, academic achievement, socialization, adult success Introduction: “The purpose of this paper is to place in context and evaluate the efforts of many of those who negatively criticize homeschooling, homeschool researchers, or particular research studies on parent-led home-based education. What is “good research” and how should one understand negative criticisms of homeschool research? Elizabeth Bartholet’s recent criticism of homeschool research and researchers, which originally appeared in the Arizona Law Review, will serve as a point of contextualization for this article.[i] Professor Bartholet called for a “presumptive ban” on homeschooling in the United States, such that parents would have to petition the civil government to get permission to home educate any child. Under her regime, the government would become the controller of all children’s educational lives, and parents would need government approval for their children to be allowed to have something different than an institutional state-run education. A significant portion of Professor Bartholet’s argument involved negative criticism of much homeschool research and the scholars who have conducted the studies. I will address Professor Bartholet’s claims in the second portion of this piece.” This is a mini-version of an explanation of research methods and a philosophy of research. The author taught research methods for several years at the graduate and undergraduate university levels. It is a solid article for anyone – whether a novice or seasoned scholar – who wants to understand research methods and philosophy better, from a seasoned scholar who has weathered compliments and criticisms from other scholars, advocates of this or that, and journalists.) .
Ray, Brian D. 2024 Research facts on homeschooling; Homeschooling, the research https://www.nheri.org/research-facts-on-homeschooling/ https://www.nheri.org/research-facts-on-homeschooling/ homeschooling, academic achievement, reasons, social development, psychological development, socialization, adulthood, college, demographics
Ray, Brian D. 2021 All education is spiritual and ergo homeschooling is resurging. Nauki O Wychowaniu: Studia Interdyscyplinarne, [Educational Sciences. Interdisciplinary Studies] 1(12), 244-259. homeschooling, home education, spirituality, religion, philosophy, public school, private school, peer-reviewed “Abstract: All education is spiritual and ergo homeschooling is resurging. Parent-directed, family- and home-based private education schooling – that is, homeschooling – is millennia old and has experienced a notable renascence around the world during the past 40 years. With respect to homeschooling, “Parent-directed means the parents have deliberately chosen to take responsibility for the education of their children, controlling both the education process and the curriculum (course of study). Family-based means the center of educational gravity is the home, with other resources being secondary” (homeschoolingbackgrounder.com, 2020). One of the key reasons that home education is growing is that more parents and more of the general public are recognizing that all education of children deals with values, beliefs, and, ultimately, an overall worldview (Weltanschauung). Because worldview is a comprehensive conception or apprehension of the world, especially from a specific standpoint, it is, de facto, spiritual. This paper shows that all education and schooling is the teaching, training, and indoctrination of children, that the worldwide rebirth of home education came with a focus on spirituality, that empirical evidence shows that all education is spiritual and spirituality is motivating many homeschoolers, and, finally, that scholarly theoretical arguments against homeschooling involve the spiritual” (p. 244).
Ray, Brian D. 2021, January 15 Research facts on homeschooling. Retrieved March 23, 2021 from https://www.nheri.org/research-facts-on-homeschooling/ https://www.nheri.org/research-facts-on-homeschooling/
Ray, Brian D. 2021, September 9 Research facts on homeschooling. Retrieved March 23, 2021 from https://www.nheri.org/research-facts-on-homeschooling/ https://www.nheri.org/research-facts-on-homeschooling/
Ray, Brian D. 2021, July 1 Research facts on homeschooling. Retrieved July 9, 2021, 2021 from https://www.nheri.org/research-facts-on-homeschooling/ https://www.nheri.org/research-facts-on-homeschooling/ homeschooling, home schooling, home education, population growth, academic achievement, socialization, social development, adulthood, research “There were an estimated 4.5 to 5.0 million homeschool students in grades K-12 in the United States during March of 2021 (roughly 8% to 9% of school-age children). There were about 2.5 million homeschool students in spring 2019 (or 3% to 4% of school-age children) [note 1]. The homeschool population had been growing at an estimated 2% to 8% per annum over the past several years, but it grew drastically from 2019-2020 to 2020-2021.”
Ray, Brian D. 2021 An overview of the worldwide rise and expansion of home education homeschooling (chapter 1). Pages 1-18, In Rebecca English (Ed.), Global perspectives on home education in the 21st century. Hershey, PA: Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global). homeschooling, home education, history, reasons, academic achievement, socialization, social development, adult success, philosophy “Abstract. This chapter outlines the current situation about homeschooling across the world today. It highlights its enormous growth over the last 40 or 50 years, since its reintroduction in the USA and the impact that has had on the world homeschooling movement. It describes the contested outcomes of home education, including the evidence that students’ academic, social, and emotional outcomes are higher while also providing a solid basis for ‘graduates’ of home education to experience success in adulthood. Theorizing the roots of this success, the chapter looks at the measures of success and the theoretical bases of the success of the mainstream schooled and explores how the features that make a successful graduate of mainstream schools are naturally and almost exclusively present in the home education setting, Finally, it considers how the current turn against home education and suggests how future research might be useful to counter these negative discourses about the practice while understanding this growing cohort of children across the world today” (p. 1). Provides very brief history of “… parent-directed, family- and home-based private education schooling – that is, homeschooling …” (p. 2); thus provides a succinct definition of homeschooling. Covers reasons and motivations for homeschooling, learner outcomes, characteristics and limitations of the research to date. “Theory regarding the cause of the relative success of homeschoolers, if they are in fact doing as well or better than their institutional school peers, is still conjecture. One hypothesis is that if all background demographic variables (e.g., household income, parent education level, student and parent ethnicity, money spent on schooling, student learning disabilities/limitations, state teacher licensing status of the teachers/parents) were carefully controlled in a non-experimental explanatory study that tries to identify [p. 10 ends] the causal factors (Johnson, 2001), then perhaps the home educated would do no better than government conventional school students in terms of academic achievement, social and emotional development, or success into adulthood. This might be true. If such a study were to turn out this way with no statistically significant differences, then the “null findings” might still be of notable practical significance (Kraft, 2020). As an example, consider the academic achievement of the homeschooled. No difference in achievement would mean that despite the fact that the public school students had state-certified teachers, university school of education-trained teachers, expert-designed curriculum materials, six to eight hours per day with similar-age peers, millions of dollars of tax-funded research and development by university education professors, and $15,000 per student per year of tax dollars (plus taxes for capital expenditures) from the citizens (National Education Association, 2020), public school students performed no better on standardized achievement tests than homeschool students. One might then wonder what was the value of all of these supposed beneficial inputs that are had by public school students” (p. 10-11). Points out the John Holt said the homeschool movement is a free experiment from which those working in the world of institutional schooling could learn some things for the sake of children learning. Raises questions about the validity and reliability of using institutional school tools for measuring the success of homeschool students and homeschooling. “The potential impact of the homeschool movement on education brings this author [sic, to] think of the impact of the home birth movement in the United States on the conventional biomedical model. Although only 1.61% of U.S. births in 2017 were out-of-hospital births (MacDorman & Declercq, 2018), the home birth movement and current arrangement of midwifery and home births have affected many practices in the medical field. More birth centers have opened, more mainstream physicians are open to working with parents outside of conventional buildings and systems, and more home births are occurring than 40 years ago. ….. As with the home birth movement, the homeschool movement has raised many issues to which others have given extra attention. Homeschool authors, parents, and leaders have asked important questions about dominant educational philosophy and practice in institutional schools and have offered insightful and weighty answers. They have and are dealing with orthodoxy and orthopraxy in the education of children. They ask many questions. Why should we do this? Who says? With what authority? Who determines the best practice or approach for each child or for each family? What is an expert? Who is the expert? How much part should a child have in determining his or her own education? Who is the state authority and why should it be followed?” (p. 12). Proposes lines of future research.
Ray, Brian D. 2021 How many homeschool students are there in the United States? Pre-Covid-19 and Post-Covid-19: New data, https://www.nheri.org/how-many-homeschool-students-are-there-in-the-united-states-pre-covid-19-and-post-covid-19/ https://www.nheri.org/how-many-homeschool-students-are-there-in-the-united-states-pre-covid-19-and-post-covid-19/ homeschooling, home education, population size, numbers, United States, Covid-19 “Abstract. The purpose of this study is to estimate the number of homeschool students in the United States during the 2020-2021 academic school year. The estimate is derived by establishing the size of the nationwide school-age population, ascertaining the percentage of all students that were homeschooled, and assuming a level of underrepresentation of homeschooling in the data that represent the portions of all students who were homeschooled. Homeschool registration and enrollment data from 16 states and data from the U.S. Census Bureau’s experimental Pulse Survey were used. The conclusion is that there were an estimated 3.721 million school-age (K-12) homeschool students in the United States during the 2020-2021 school year.”
Ray, Brian D. 2021 Should educators promote homeschooling? Worldwide growth and learner outcomes. Journal of Pedagogy, 12(1), 55–76. https://doi.org/10.2478/jped-2021-0003 https://doi.org/10.2478/jped-2021-0003 “Abstract: The purpose is to briefly summarize forty years of research on the learner outcomes of the modern homeschooling movement and address whether educators should be promoting home education. Studies show that homeschooling (home education) is generally associated with positive learner outcomes. On average, the home educated perform better than their institutional school peers in terms of academic achievement, social, emotional, and psychological development, and success into adulthood (including university). Certain pedagogical and familial elements that are systemic to freely chosen parent-led home-based private education homeschooling are may be the keys to the overall better performance and development of most children – not only the home educated – and into their lives as adults. If this is true, should professional educators be promoting homeschooling rather than criticizing it or trying to inhibit its growth? Are there certain categories of families for whom home education would not be a good idea? Is home education a pedagogical choice and approach about which educators should be skeptical and antagonistic or from which they can learn, be better informed about the needs and successes of students, and support according to the findings of empirical evidence?”
Ray, Brian D. 2022 Homeschooling in the United States: Growth with diversity and more empirical evidence. Oxford Research Encyclopedia, https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190264093.013.1643 https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190264093.013.1643 homeschooling, unschooling, home education, family-based education, history, philosophy, academic achievement, socialization, social development, success in adulthood, research questions Abstract: Homeschooling (home education) is parent-directed, family-based education, and is typically not tax-funded, with parents choosing assistance from other individuals or organizations. Home-based education was nearly extinct in the United States by the 1970s but grew rapidly during the 1990s to about 2.6 million K–12 homeschool students in March of 2020 to then about 5 million in March of 2021. The demographic variety among homeschooling families rapidly increased during the 2000s to the point that in 2016, 41% of homeschool students were of ethnic minority background, with about 79% of those living in nonpoor households, and with parents’ formal education levels similar to national averages. Since the early 2000s, parents’ main reasons for homeschooling have shifted from an emphasis on religious or moral instruction to a somewhat more emphasis on concern about institutional school environments and the academic instruction in schools. Empirical research shows that the home educated, on average, perform above average in terms of academic achievement, social and emotional development, and success into adulthood (including college studies). However, there is scholarly debate about whether enough well-controlled studies have confirmed these overall benefits. Some theories have been proposed to explain the apparent positive effects. They include the concept that elements such as high levels of parental involvement, one-on-one instruction, low student-to-teacher ratios, effective use of time, more academic learning time, customization of learning experiences, and a safe and comfortable learning environment that are systemically a part of home-based education are conducive to children thriving in many ways. However, more research is needed to test these theories.”) mis??? did I put in hclbib online
Ray, Brian D. 2022 How many homeschool students are there in the United States during the 2021-2022 School Year? https://nheri.org/how-many-homeschool-students-are-there-in-the-united-states-during-the-2021-2022-school-year/ https://nheri.org/how-many-homeschool-students-are-there-in-the-united-states-during-the-2021-2022-school-year/ homeschooling, home education, population size, numbers, United States “Abstract. The purpose of this study is to estimate the number of homeschool students in the United States during the 2021-2022 academic school year. The estimate is derived by establishing the size of the nationwide school-age population, ascertaining the percentage of all students that were homeschooled, and assuming a level of underrepresentation of homeschooling in the data that represent the portions of all students who were homeschooled. Homeschool registration and enrollment data from 14 states, data from the U.S. Census Bureau’s Pulse Survey, and findings from an Education Next nationwide survey were used. The conclusion is that there were an estimated 3.135 million school-age (K-12) homeschool students in the United States during the 2021-2022 school year. This is a decline of about 16 percent from the preceding year but still much higher than two years prior. There were more homeschool students than Catholic school students and slightly fewer homeschool than public charter school students during 2021-2022.”
Ray, Brian D. 2022 The transmission of culture, religion, and affinity for four school choices to adults who were homeschooled, public schooled, and private schooled, NHERI Working Paper 2022-02a, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4046167 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4046167 homeschooling, home schooling, home education, public school, private school, Christian school, religion, values, transmission of religion, attitudes, culture, adults, childrearing, school choice, faith, child abuse “Abstract: This study examines adults, ages 18 to 38, who were churched while growing up to understand the key influences (e.g., family relationships, church experiences, cultural inputs, and the school choices of their parents, such as years in homeschooling, Christian school, private secular school, and public school) that either encourage or deter them from believing and practicing the Christian faith of their parents and to determine their attitudes and actions toward the use of various school choices for their own children. The factors that stand out as the most dependable and significant positive predictors of Christian beliefs and behaviors in adulthood are Christian practices and experiences when young, relationship with parents during the ages of 16 to 17, and more years being homeschooled. In addition, these adults in general have positive attitudes toward homeschooling and plan to home educate their children at very high rates. Policymakers may gain insights from these findings about the relative benefits of choices for home education, public schooling, and private schooling in helping parents transmit culture inter-generationally.”
Ray, Brian D. 2023 A systematic review of 35 years of empirical research on the learner outcomes of homeschooling: Any evidence to ban home education? A presentation at the annual International School Choice and Reform Conference, Ft. Lauderdale, Florida, January 14, 2023. academic achievement, socialization, social development, psychological development, adulthood ??
Ray, Brian D. 2024 Private education welfare: School choice and tax-funded ESAs, vouchers, and refunds, https://nheri.org/private-education-welfare-school-choice-and-tax-funded-esas-vouchers-and-refunds/ https://nheri.org/private-education-welfare-school-choice-and-tax-funded-esas-vouchers-and-refunds/ school choice, tax funding, education savings accounts, vouchers, ESA, socialism, statism “Abstract: The School Choice discussion is about whether and how to expand the tax-funded education welfare system, including to private schools and homeschools. This article evaluates the wisdom of expanding government education welfare, from both a Christian worldview and a classical liberal perspective. Education Savings Account (ESA) is a misleading name for a mechanism of the redistribution of wealth (taxes) for the schooling of K-12 students. The presuppositions and principles of a Christian worldview and a classical liberal worldview, however, dictate private voluntary funding of services for the execution of children’s education. Both the Christian and classical liberal perspectives oppose School Choice via vouchers, ESAs or increased funding because it (a) violates the scriptural jurisdictions of individual, family, church, and state, (b) brings more children and families under the authority and control of the state (civil government), (c) increases taxes, (d) ignores the fact that research shows families do not need tax dollars to choose private education and for their children to do well in life, (d) forces citizens to promote the values of the state education system through forced taxation, (e) forces citizens to promote the values that any private school or homeschool teaches through forced taxation, and (f) further entangles church (philosophical/religious values and beliefs) and state. Christians and classical liberals embrace a statist worldview if they embrace government funding of education. Christians and classical liberals should instead be putting their thoughts, collaboration, energy, and money into expanding education that is free from civil government control, privately funding education for all children, and reducing, at every turn, government control over and the forced-tax funding of all education.”
Ray, Brian D. 2024, 2022 Homeschool abuse and neglect research: How many homeschooled kids are abused? https://www.nheri.org/homeschool-abuse-and-neglect-research/ https://www.nheri.org/homeschool-abuse-and-neglect-research/ homeschooling, abuse, neglect
Ray, Brian D. 2025 Defining homeschooling and why it matters. Social Science Research Network, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5211580 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5211580 Homeschooling, Definition, Research Methods, History, Philosophy, School Choice, Education Savings Accounts, Vouchers “This article articulates the need for a clear and consistent definition of homeschooling as parent-controlled home-based privately-funded private education (PCHBPE) to aid in research and in communication by the public at large. It explores scholarly, historical, philosophical, and general public definitions of homeschooling, primarily focusing on the United States context from 1985 onward. It addresses changes in homeschooling during the modern home education movement while finding that homeschooling consistently involves parents controlling their children’s education primarily from home. There is a focus on the ongoing debate over parental versus state authority and control in education and recent ambiguities and terms regarding homeschooling introduced by certain government programs and scholars. The implications of tax funding (e.g., tax-funded school choice education savings accounts (ESAs), vouchers, and refundable tax credits) and civil government regulatory definitions further complicate the landscape of homeschooling. Thus, the clear and consistent definition is needed and offered.”
Ray, Brian D., & Eagleson, Bruce K. 2007, June 25 State regulation of homeschooling and homeschoolers’ SAT scores [working paper, draft]. Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute.
Ray, Brian D., & Eagleson, Bruce K. 2008, August 14 State regulation of homeschooling and homeschoolers’ SAT scores. Journal of Academic Leadership, 6(3). Retrieved June 15, 2018 from https://scholars.fhsu.edu/alj/vol6/iss3/17/ https://scholars.fhsu.edu/alj/vol6/iss3/17/ http://www.collegeboard.com/prod_downloads/about/news_info/cbsenior/yr2001/NATL.pdf home education, research, college SAT test, academic achievement, state regulation, policy, law, legal, philosophy, peer-reviewed Peer-reviewed journal. “The purpose of this study was to determine whether there is a relationship between the college-admissions (or college-aptitude) SAT scores of students who were homeschooled and the degree of state regulation of homeschooling.” “The SAT publisher provided to the authors data related to all 6,170 of these students; 2,887 (46.8%) were male and 3,283 (53.2%) were female.” The home-educated students scored, on average, above the national norm on the SAT; e.g., in with the same degree of regulation of homeschooling for 5 years, the average total Verbal and Math score of the students was 1118 while the national average reported by the test publisher was 1020 the same year 2001 [retrieved 8/20/2010 from http://www.collegeboard.com/prod_downloads/about/news_info/cbsenior/yr2001/NATL.pdf]. “The group data, not individual student’s scores, were available and received for each of the 50 states and the District of Columbia.” “The SAT scores of homeschool students from low-, moderate-, and high-regulation states were first compared for states whose degree of regulation had not changed for the 10 years preceding and including the year of SAT testing. Tables 1, 2, and 3 present the descriptive information and ANOVA source tables for these analyses. There were no significant differences between students’ SAT scores in the three groups (of state regulation of homeschooling) for any of the three test scores (verbal, F(2, 40) = 0.58, p = .57; math, F(2,40) = 1.527, p = .23; total, F(2,40) = 1.070, p = .35). In all cases, the states with the highest degree of state regulation had the lowest average SAT scores. As previously explained, the unit of analysis was the state.” “At least the following three matters should be considered. First, the simple fact is that no significant statistical relationships were found between the degree of state regulation of homeschooling and students’ SAT verbal, math, and total scores. No p-values were under .05. In addition, no significant differences were found in SAT scores regardless of whether the same degree of state regulation of homeschooling existed in a given state for the periods of the past 5 years or past 10 years. Second, one must cautiously use the findings in light of at least two points pertaining to the study’s design and the nature of the data. One is that some notable limitations adhere to the data. For example, it was not possible to ascertain for how many years, on average, students in a particular state were home educated, nor was it possible to determine for how long, on average, students had lived in a particular state. Ergo, it was not possible to know, in experimental terms, these elements of the homeschooling ‘treatment’ that the students had experienced. ….. Third, the use of these findings in education policy largely depend upon the socio-political worldview of the person considering what policy should exist. At one of the most fundamental levels, the issue is whether the parents or the state should have primary authority over and responsibility for the education and upbringing of a child. If one believes that the state should be the default authority and responsible party rather than the parents, …”
Ray, Brian D., & Hoelzle, Braden 2024 Reasons for homeschooling and the correlates of home-educated students’ academic achievement: A new U.S. nationwide study. Paper presented at the annual International School Choice and Reform Conference, Madrid, Spain, January 4-7, 2024. homeschooling, reasons, academic achievement
Ray, Brian D., & Lloyd, William A. 2000 Homeschooling in 2000 and beyond: Cultural, social and economic factors in the light of educational sovereignty. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of Worlddidac World Association of Publishers, Manufacturers and Distributors of Educational Materials), March 30, 2000, Zurich, Switzerland.
Ray, Brian D., & Wartes, Jon 1991 The academic achievement and affective development of home-schooled children. In Jane A. Van Galen & Mary Anne Pitman (Eds.), Home schooling: Political, historical, and pedagogical perspectives. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation. homeschooling, home education, academic achievement, affective development, socialization Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Summarize research on academic achievement and affective, psychological, and social development of the children. Point out that the research is not experimental and would be difficult to do experimental research. Suggest that researchers should determine home educators' objectives for their children and assess the achievement of these objectives. In 1987 in Washington State, homeschool students’ standardized academic achievement median test scores “… were in the 65th and 66th percentile range” (p. 45). Their highest scores were in science and in a subscale of language. “These scores earned by home schoolers suggest that they are, as a group, doing well” (p. 45). Does not report that homeschool students were underperforming in mathematics; in the subscale of math computation the median score was the 42nd percentile while in the subscale of math application the median score was the 65th percentile.
Ray, Brian D., & Weller, Nick 2003, May Homeschooling: An overview and financial implications for public schools. School Business Affairs, 69(5), 22-26. home education, public schools, finances, budget, policy, public costs “To understand the impact on school funding, this analysis has looked at the aggregate financial picture of adding homeschool students to the public schools system [of any state, or nationwide]. Certain schools or districts would possibly benefit from the addition of homeschool students. ….. But from a fiscal perspective, depending on how various government bodies react, homeschooling clearly either saves taxpayers’ money or increases per-pupil spending for public schools. In the final analysis, taxpayers would incur considerable additional expense if homeschool students attended public schools” [p. 26]).
Ray, Brian D., Mayberry, Maralee, & Knowles, J. Gary 1992 What home educators need, want, and use from various institutions: Results from an ongoing study in four western states. Home School Researcher, 8(1), 9-20. home education, research, needs, home-community interaction Presents data from Washington State and interpretation. "This study illuminates the fact that home educators do have need of services and support. At the same time, however, they would like the liberty to educate their children and seek out and use services and support at their own discretion. They desire freedom from pressure to use unsolicited help and freedom from overt interference, especially from those associated with the state or federal government" (p. 17).
Ray, Brian D.; & Hoelzle, Braden 2026, in press The impact of school choice on the transmission of religious beliefs and practices. Journal of Unschooling and Alternative Learning. Preprint available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=6929238 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=6929238 peer-reviewed; homeschooling, home education, public school, private school, Christian school, religion, values, transmission of religion, attitudes, culture, adults, childrearing, worldview “Abstract; This study examines the transmission of values, beliefs, and religious practices from parents to children. It does so by gathering data from adults who attended church while growing up to understand the key influences (e.g., family relationships, church experiences, cultural inputs, and school choices-home, Christian, private-secular, public) that either encourage or deter them from believing and practicing the Christian faith of their parents. Many parents make school choices for their children out of a desire to transmit a set of beliefs and religious practices to their children. The current study employs multiple regression analyses to explore the factors that contribute to various aspects of faith transmission. The survey sample, gathered using both purposeful and representative sampling, includes 8,794 adults, ages 18 to 38, who were homeschooled (43%), public schooled (42%), private Christian schooled (11%), or private secular schooled (1%). The strongest predictors of Christian beliefs and behaviors in adulthood are Christian practices and experiences when young, relationship with parents during the ages of 16 to 17, and more years being homeschooled. This study confirms the findings of prior studies regarding the importance of parental religiosity and relational warmth in the successful.”
Ray, Brian D.; & Hoelzle, Braden R. 2026 A nationwide study on the academic achievement of homeschool students and parents’ reasons for homeschooling. Peabody Journal of Education, 1–19. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0161956X.2025.2605901 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0161956X.2025.2605901 homeschooling, achievement, academic achievement, reasons, school sector “Abstract: It has been over 15 fifteen years since a study has provided nationwide data on the academic achievement of homeschool students. It is rare that key demographic data are available to make comparisons between home-educated and institutionally schooled children. This study analyzes a nationwide sample of homeschool students’ standardized academic achievement test scores. One analysis is a within-sample consideration of predictors of achievement. The second analysis uses the demographic controls of socio-economic status (SES) and race/ethnicity to compare the homeschooled to the conventional-school test norm group. Further, the study gathers data from the homeschool students’ parents on their reasons for homeschooling. Findings show that homeschool students are scoring well above the national average in reading, language, math, social studies, and science (mean percentiles 75 to 79), relatively few predictors explain their scores, and, with two key controls, homeschool students score significantly higher than the conventional school test norm group (weighted mean percentiles 74 to 82). These new data and findings help scholars, educators, policymakers, and the public in evaluating homeschooling’s current outcomes, informing policy debates, and assessing whether trends observed in earlier decades remain true today.”
Ray, Brian D.; & Shakeel, M. Danish 2023 (online 2022) Demographics are predictive of child abuse and neglect but homeschool versus conventional school is a nonissue: Evidence from a nationally representative survey. Journal of School Choice, 17(2), 176-213, https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2022.2108879 (online 2022, paper 2023) https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2022.2108879 Homeschool, private school, public school, child abuse, neglect, abandonment “Abstract: Opponents of homeschooling associate it with unchecked and unreported abuse and neglect of children, often arguing for more regulation of or an outright ban of home education. Do homeschool students experience more maltreatment than those in schools and, if so, is it happening in or outside the home? Empirical evidence to answer this question is lacking, data collection during schooling age poses several constraints, and school-age children may under-report incidences due to fear. To address this gap in information and literature, we draw nationally representative data from 1,253 previously homeschooled and conventionally schooled (public and private schools) adults to anonymously report about their abuse and neglect experiences during school age. Cross-sectional findings suggest that school sector is a non-issue after considering the role played by demographics (e.g., family structure, years in foster care, large family size, and household poverty) in the maltreatment of children. The incidences of abuse and neglect for homeschool children are statistically significant only at community or some type of school, and the occurrence rates there are double or more than at family where the rate is not significant. Results suggest that policymakers should consider the larger role of demographics in framing policies to protect children from abuse and neglect.”)
Ray, Brian D.; & Valiente, Carlos 2020 The academic and social benefits of homeschooling. Retrieved November 20, 2020 from https://www.jamesgmartin.center/2020/05/the-academic-and-social-benefits-of-homeschooling/ https://www.jamesgmartin.center/2020/05/the-academic-and-social-benefits-of-homeschooling/ homeschooling, home education, academic achievement, social development, success in adulthood, child abuse, research Responds to negative claims about homeschooling by persons such as Elizabeth Bartholet and James Dwyer. “Yet, what does the evidence tell us about homeschool educational and social outcomes? Is there any sound corpus of evidence that homeschooled children are actually educationally deprived or maltreated? And what worldview drives anti-homeschoolers such as Bartholet and Dwyer? Most reviews of homeschooling research reveal generally positive learning outcomes for children.”
Ray, Brian D.; Hoelzle, Braden R.; & Pietersma, Douglas 2026 A systematic review of the empirical research on selected aspects of homeschooling: Updated 2017–2026. Peabody Journal of Education, 101(1). https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0161956X.2025.2605900 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0161956X.2025.2605900 academic achievement, adulthood, college students, emotional development, homeschooling, review of research, social development, socialization “Abstract: This article provides demographic characteristics of the U.S. homeschooling population and the reasons that parents choose to homeschool, summarizes the findings of studies on the homeschool learner outcomes of academic achievement, social and emotional development, and success in adulthood, and proposes future research on parent-led home-based education. The approach is novel as only peer-reviewed and representative-sample studies are used. Fifteen of 24 (62%) studies on academic achievement reveal a positive effect for the homeschooled students compared to institutional schooled students, while a few studies show mixed or negative results. Regarding social and emotional development, 16 of 25 studies (64%) show clearly positive outcomes for the homeschooled compared to those in conventional schools. Thirteen of 24 (54%) of the studies on the relative success of the home-educated who later became adults show positive outcomes for the homeschooled compared to those who had been in conventional schools. It is recommended that the existing literature continue to be enhanced by well-controlled non-experimental design research studies that examine adults who were homeschooled in terms of an array of knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors regarding areas of life such as lifelong learning, rates of public welfare dependency, and degree of personal agency or self-efficacy.”
Ray, Brian D.; Shakeel, M. Danish; Worth, Fred; & Bryant, Valerie 2021 Four key barriers affecting the choice to homeschool: evidence from a fragile community. Journal of School Choice: International Research and Reform, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2021.1924583. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/15582159.2021.1924583 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/15582159.2021.1924583 Homeschool, homeschooling, home schooling, home education; barrier, reasons, motivations, fragile communities, Black, African American “Abstract: Homeschooling has witnessed an upsurge in the United States since the movement for school choice gained momentum in the 1990s. Most research on homeschooling has been on non-representative samples of median-income white Americans, making it difficult for policymakers to accept its reliability. In addition, homeschoolers now include other ethnic groups and families with low socio-economic status, who existing research has largely ignored. We also know little about the families’ perceptions of barriers to homeschooling. In this paper, we address these gaps in homeschooling research by analyzing a state-representative sample of homeschooling families in Georgia belonging to a fragile community (e.g., household income $40,000 or less, disproportionately African American, children ages 2–18) recruited to the panel through randomized double-blind methods. Cross-sectional findings suggest that demographic variables do not explain much of the variation in homeschooling. Four perceived barriers stand out as significant negative predictors of both outcomes (i.e., now homeschooling and desire to homeschool). These barriers are parents not understanding homeschool laws, having various concerns about their children (e.g., concern social services agency may bother them if they homeschool), apprehensions about the socialization of their children, and unease about their own knowledge to homeschool. Findings suggest that policymakers should differentiate between the barriers to homeschooling faced by fragile families that do not already homeschool their children versus those that currently homeschool.”
Ray, Brian D.; Shakeel, M. Danish; Worth, Fred; Bryant, Valerie 2021 Four Key Barriers Affecting the Choice to Homeschool: Evidence from a Fragile Community. Paper presented at the International School Choice and Reform Conference, January 16, 2021. Online. www.iscrweb.org http://www.iscrweb.org homeschooling, barriers, choice, school choice
Raywid, Mary Anne 1983 Schools of choice: their current nature and prospects. Phi Delta Kappan, 64, 684-688. Report on an extensive study of alternative schools in North America. Alternatives enjoying steady and continued growth, suggesting that alternatives "... represent the acceptance and the institutionalization of diversity" (p. 688).
Raywid, Mary Anne 1987 Parents guide on choice. The right to choose. (ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED290237). home schooling, school choice Need wider range of choice in education, lists and reviews the varieties of public education available in the U.S., advantages and disadvantages.
Reader's Digest 1984, May Article on the National Education Association [NEA]?
Reavis, R., & Zakrinski, A. 2005 Are home-schooled children socially at-risk or socially protected? The Brown University Child and Adolescent Behavior Letter, 21(9), 1, 4–5. Retrieved March 11, 2015 http://www.childresearch.net/projects/past/brownU/2005_09.html. http://www.childresearch.net/projects/past/brownU/2005_09.html homeschooling, homeschool, schooling, peer relationships, socialization, peer victimization, attitudes, friendship Cross-sectional and descriptive design, convenience sample, compared homeschooled (HS) and conventional or traditionally schooled (TS) children, ages 9 to 13 (mean of 10.4), regarding their peer relations and psychological adjustment. They were asked about the number and quality of their friendships, experiences with peer victimization, and their psychological adjustment. The researchers concluded the following: “Although HS and TS children reported similar levels of exposure to peer victimization, HS children reported being less upset by these experiences. This finding suggests that although HS parents may be unable to control their children's exposure to peer victimization, they may be protecting them in other ways, by influencing the degree of importance their children assign to these experiences. Another possibility is that HS children report less distress because such experiences do not threaten their social status or future peer interactions at school in the same way they do for TS children.” At the same time, wrote that although “… both groups of children had the same number of close friends,” their findings also suggest that the homeschooled “… appear to be more vulnerable to psychological distress in the absence of a high quality friendship.” Also, “… the study also revealed many positive aspects of HS children's adjustment. HS children reported more positive attitudes towards teachers/coaches, more positive relationships with parents, higher self-esteem, and more positive interpersonal relationships (broadly defined).” Conclude, “In summary, our investigation suggests that there are few differences between the peer relationships of HS and TS children, and that there are many signs of positive adjustment in HS children. HS children have better attitudes towards teachers and parents. They also seem to have better attitudes about themselves and towards interpersonal relationships, although it is unclear whether these positive feelings extend to an academic sense of self. Our investigation also suggests that HS children are not strangers to peer victimization, nor are they immune to its harmful effects, although they report some ability to distance themselves from victimization distress. Most importantly, the study highlights one way in which HS children's different social experiences might make them more dependent, rather than less, on the success of their best friendships. As many have noted, there appears to be a universal need for peer acceptance and support in the developing child. Without the peer network available to TS children, HS children may be more vulnerable to breakdowns in peer support, especially in late childhood and early adolescence. Thus, it may be particularly important for parents to actively foster the friendships of their home-schooled children.” Peer-reviewed journal??
Redford, Jeremy; Battle, Danielle; & Bielick, Stacey 2016, November Homeschooling in the United States: 2012 (NCES 2016-096). National Center for Education Statistics, Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education. http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2016096 homeschooling, home education, population size, demographics, reasons, motivations, growth Washington, DC. Retrieved November 14, 2016 from http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2016096 This report includes careful adjustments to statistics and estimates. “Part I of this report uses an adjusted estimate for the total number and rate of students who were homeschooled in the United States in 2012. The adjusted estimate uses a statistical adjustment to include 303 students who were reported on the PFI-Enrolled survey as homeschooled in the analytic sample used for generating homeschooling estimates, as well as the 347 homeschooled students who were reported on the PFI-Homeschool survey. The adjusted estimate is NCES’s most accurate estimate of the true number and percentage of students who were homeschooled in 2012. A change in the NHES design between 2007 and 2012 (described in the technical notes) resulted in measurement error which NCES believes led to an undercount of the total number of homeschooled students. In all years of the NHES data collection where data on homeschoolers has been collected for kindergarten to grade 12 and for both part-time and full-time homeschoolers, the number and percentage of homeschoolers has increased between collections. Additionally, we conducted analysis to look at the change in the number of homeschooled students between 2007 and 2012 in eight states where information on the number of homeschooled students was available for that time period; there was an increase in 6 of these states and a decrease in 2 states. Therefore, the estimate of homeschooled students appears too low and requires adjustment” (p. 3). “In this report, students are considered to be homeschooled if their parents reported them as being schooled at home instead of at a public or private school for at least part of their education and if their part-time enrollment in public or private school did not exceed 25 hours a week” (p. 2). Table B-2 shows that, in 2012 for adjusted statistics of the 1.77 million homeschool students, 89% of the students were “homeschooled only,” 8% were “enrolled in school for less than 9 hours a week,” and 3% were “enrolled in school for 9 to 25 hours a week.” “In this Statistical Analysis Report, students are considered to be homeschooled if their parents reported them as being schooled at home instead of at a public or private school for at least part of their education and if their part-time enrollment in public or private school did not exceed 25 hours a week. Students who were schooled at home primarily because of a temporary illness are also excluded, resulting in an analytic sample of 347 students. In 2012, the estimate of the total number of homeschoolers includes these 347 students and a weight-adjusted number based on 303 students whose parents completed the PFI-Enrolled questionnaire and marked that the students were schooled at home instead of at school for some classes or subjects (see technical notes for details). When weighted to include homeschoolers reported on both the PFI-Homeschool and PFI-Enrolled questionnaires, data represent the experiences of approximately 1,773,000 [1.77 million, 1.8 million] homeschooled students ages 5 through 17 with a grade equivalent of kindergarten through grade 12 in the United States, which is NCES’s most accurate estimate of the true number of students who were homeschooled in 2012. The unadjusted number of homeschooled students is 1,082,000” (p. i). “Table 2 shows some characteristics of homeschooled students in 2012 and the homeschooling rate among all students with those characteristics. Comparisons are made using the unadjusted estimates because of potential bias in adjusted estimates based on small samples sizes, as described in the data and measures section and in the technical notes. However, both estimates are provided for interested readers” (p. 8). The statistically adjusted data show that mis??? “• Most homeschooled students were White (83 percent) and nonpoor (89 percent), lived in cities or suburban areas and rural areas. Homeschooled students spanned all grade equivalents (table 2). The Learning Context of Homeschooled Students • Nine in 10 homeschooled students’ parents reported that concern about schools’ environments was an important reason for their decision to homeschool (table 3). • Websites, homeschooling catalogs, public libraries, and bookstores were the more frequently cited sources of curriculum for homeschooled students in 2012. Curricula from public and private schools were among the least cited (figure 2). • About a quarter of homeschooled students had parents who took a course to prepare for their child’s home instruction (figure 3). • About a third of middle school-level homeschooled students (35 percent) and a third of high school-level (34 percent) homeschooled students took online courses (figure 4). • Most high-school level homeschooled students had home instruction that included basic algebra (88 percent), earth sciences or geology and biology (69 percent each figures 5 and 6)” (p. ii). “In 2012, the most commonly selected reason was a concern with other schools’ environments, which includes factors such as “safety, drugs, or negative peer pressure” at schools (91 percent). Other commonly reported reasons included, “a desire to provide moral instruction,” “a dissatisfaction with academic instruction at other schools,” and “a desire to provide religious instruction” (77 percent, 74 percent, and 64 percent, respectively). Table 3 shows the list of reasons and the number and percentage of students whose parents indicated each one was important in their decision to homeschool. A follow-up question asked respondents to select the reason they considered the most important out of the reasons they had indicated were important. The number and percentage distributions of the “most important” reasons are shown in table 3. Concern about other schools’ environments, desire to provide religious instruction, and dissatisfaction with academic standards were cited most frequently as most important” (p. 11).
Redford, Jeremy; Battle, Danielle; & Bielick, Stacey 2017, April Homeschooling in the United States: 2012 (NCES 2016-096.REV). National Center for Education Statistics, Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education. Washington, DC. Retrieved April 17, 2017 from https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2016/2016096rev.pdf https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2016/2016096rev.pdf
Reese, W. J. 1982 The public schools and the great gates of hell. Educational Theory, 32, 9-17. Historical discussion of the traditional support of evangelical Christianity for public education and analysis of why this support is now waning.
Regnier, Jan P. 1986 An analysis of legal provisions for satisfying compulsory education requirements in nonpublic schools. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Indiana University, Bloomington.
Reich, Rob 2001, August 30 - September 2 Testing the boundaries of parental authority over education: The case of homeschooling. Paper prepared for delivery at the 2001 Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, San Francisco, August 30-September 2, 2001. https://docplayer.net/10561154-Testing-the-boundaries-of-parental-authority-over-education-the-case-of-homeschooling.html http://pro.harvard.edu/abstracts/002/002021ReichRob00.htm http://pro.harvard.edu/papers/002/002021ReichRob00.pdf http://www.hazpolitica.org/pdfs/homeschooling2002.pdf http://pro.harvard.edu/abstracts/002/002021ReichRob00.html home education, philosophy, law, sociology, parental rights, state rights, negative criticism, public-school-at-home, PSAH Retrieved online April 3, 2024 from https://docplayer.net/10561154-Testing-the-boundaries-of-parental-authority-over-education-the-case-of-homeschooling.html and other date from http://pro.harvard.edu/abstracts/002/002021ReichRob00.htm retrieved 3/25/2002 from http://pro.harvard.edu/papers/002/002021ReichRob00.pdf Also, the document retrieved 4/15/2011, http://www.hazpolitica.org/pdfs/homeschooling2002.pdf appears to be identical. Abstract: “This paper discusses parental authority over education and attempts to move beyond the obsessive focus of political theorists on the Yoder and Mozert cases. I do so by examining the increasingly popular phenomenon of homeschooling in the United States. Should, and if so, how should the liberal state regulate homeschooling, the arrangement that gives parents the most control over the education of children? In the first section, I look at the recent history of homeschooling in the United States, showing that beyond its interest in purely theoretical terms, the actual practice of homeschooling also provides powerful reasons to focus attention on it. In section two, I canvas a trilogy of interests in education -- the parents’, the state’s, and the child’s -- as a prelude to considering the justifiability of homeschooling. I argue here that while each party shares an interest in the development of children into normal adulthood, the state has an independent interest in educating for citizenship and the child has an independent interest in an education for autonomy, neither of which may be shared by parents. On the basis of these three interests and a consideration of what to do when interests clash, I argue in section three that at a bare minimum one function of any school environment must be to expose children to and engage students with values and beliefs other than those they are likely to encounter within their homes. Because homeschooling is structurally and in practice the least likely to meet this end, I argue that while the state should not ban homeschooling it must nevertheless regulate its practice with vigilance. I conclude by briefly offering a few suggestions about the best means at the state's disposal to exercise regulatory authority and by considering some problems with regulation.” “Moreover, recent studies of homeschooled children show that they often outperform their public and private school counterparts in scholastic achievement. It appears possible, therefore, that with respect to the child’s and the state’s shared interest in academic achievement, homeschools can sometimes be more effective than traditional campus-based schools” (p. 27). “The state must therefore ensure that all children, regardless of the environment in which they are schooled, receive an education that exposes them to and engages them with values and beliefs other than those they find at home” [p. 32]. “First, the state must require that any homeschooling parents register their homeschools with local educational authorities, who in turn should be required to collect this information and report it to the state” [p. 35]. ….. Second, the burden of proof that homeschools will satisfy the state’s and the child’s interest in education must rest with the parents who express the desire to homeschool. Parents must demonstrate to relevant education officials that their particular homeschooling arrangements are up to determined educational standards. ….. Third, because the state must ensure that the school environment provides exposure to and engagement with values and beliefs other than those of a child’s parents, the state should require parents to use curricula that provide such exposure and engagement. ….. And fourth, the state should require homeschooled children to take annual standardized tests to measure academic progress. If a child repeatedly fails to make academic progress relative to his or her peers in public or private schools, the state should intervene and compel school attendance” [p. 36].” Reich presupposes that an institutional education operated by state-licensed educators in a state-controlled school or a state-approved private school is best for all children and that the state is the best judge of what meets the interests of the child, the state, and the parents; why should not the presupposition be that parents are the best judges of what meets the interests of the child, the state, and the parents and thereby put the burden of proof on the state that something other than a continuation of parent-led home-based education circa five years of age is better for any given child? “….. homeschool-public school partnerships ….. In fact, finding ways to draw homeschooling families back to the public school system seems to me a necessary complement to the passage of effective regulations [of homeschoolers] [emphasis added]" [p. 39-40]. Implies that government-school-at-home programs (i.e., school at home), such as state-run charter or cyber schools, are a good idea as a way to for the State to have more control and regulation over all home-based education, including private homeschooling.)
Reich, Rob 2002 Testing the boundaries of parental authority over education: The case of homeschooling. In, Stephen Macedo &Yael Tamir (Eds.), Political and Moral Education, NOMOS XLIII, New York: New York University Press, 2002. homeschooling, philosophy, theory, law, legal, regulation, risk “To be sure, exposing children to and engaging children with diverse values and beliefs is potentially threatening to some parents. As bell hooks has written of her own childhood: “School was the place of ecstasy -- pleasure and danger. To be changed by ideas was pure pleasure. But to learn ideas that ran counter to values and beliefs learned at home was to place oneself at risk, to enter the danger zone.” ….. But in the interest of [homeschool and other] children, these are risks that must be accepted, for parents cannot be entitled as a matter of justice to ensure that their child grows up to become exactly the kind of person they want him or her to be. To prevent the risk is to ask that the child become ethically servile to the parent. The state must therefore ensure that all children [e.g., homeschool children], regardless of the environment in which they are schooled, receive an education that exposes them to and engages them with values and beliefs other than those they find at home. It does not require that children engage always with values and beliefs that conflict with those of the home, nor does it require that children receive maximal exposure in order to provide them with maximal options in life.” (p. 31). Author argues that the state must compel by control all homeschool students to be exposed to certain values and beliefs because if not they will be at risk of being ethically servile. “What [government, state] regulations [controls] are most appropriate to this task? Regulations are properly a matter of democratic politics, not deduction from theory, but at a bare minimum, I imagine the following will be necessary. First, the state must require that any homeschooling parents register their homeschools with local educational authorities, who in turn should be required to collect this information and report it to the state. Such action will allow states to collect more accurate data on homeschooling, help make decisions about how to distribute resources for homeschoolers, and enable simplified communication between school leaders and homeschooling parents. At the moment, since many parents have never notified districts of their homeschooling intentions and arrangements, states have few means to regulate such parents. By requiring registration with local officials, the state can more effectively distinguish between truants and homeschooled children. Second, the burden of proof that homeschools will satisfy the state’s and the child’s interest in education must rest with the parents who express the desire to homeschool. Parents must demonstrate to relevant education officials that their particular homeschooling arrangements are up to determined educational standards. Aligning the burden with parents is important, because if the homeschooling arrangements were presumed to be satisfactory unless the state were to show otherwise, the state would have to resort to difficult and intrusive means to make such a case. Especially in light of the number of homeschooled students today, school officials cannot be expected personally or closely to monitor the activities of all homeschools. Third, because the state must ensure that the school environment provides exposure to and engagement with values and beliefs other than those of a child's parents, the state should require parents to use curricula that provide such exposure and engagement” (p. 35). “There are a host of open questions about the consequences of homeschool-public school partnerships, but to the extent that bringing children back within a campus-based school environment conduces to meeting the interests of the state and the child in education – especially to the extent that it brings children into social and intellectual contact with other children of diverse backgrounds – such partnerships should not be summarily dismissed or discouraged. In fact, finding ways to draw homeschooling families back to the public school system seems to me a necessary complement to the passage of effective regulations” (p. 39).
Reich, Rob 2002 The civic perils of homeschooling. Educational Leadership, 59(7), 56-59. home education, democratic society, philosophy, political science, negative critic, negative criticism Argues, without basic premises to support his claims, that although the practice of homeschooling does customize education, more dangerously it damages society. “The ability to custom-tailor an education for their children is often the motivation for parents to homeschool. No other education arrangement offers the same freedom to arrange an education designed for an individual student; in homeschools, parents are responsible not only for selecting what their children will learn, but when, how, and with whom they will learn. In this sense, homeschooling represents the apex of customization in education. ..... But considered from the standpoint of democratic citizenship, the opportunity to customize education through homeschooling isn't an unadulterated good” [p. 56]. “What's to worry about either kind of customization? Let me put the matter quite simply. Customizing a child's education through homeschooling represents the victory of a consumer mentality within education, suggesting that the only purpose that education should serve is to please and satisfy the preferences of the consumer. Education, in my view, is not a consumption in the same sense as the food we select from the grocery store. ..... And this attitude is the crucial point. Homeschooling is the apogee of parental control over a child's education, where no other institution has a claim to influence the schooling of the child. Parents serve as the only filter for a child's education, the final arbiters of what gets included and what gets excluded. ..... Schooling is one of the few remaining social institutions--or civic intermediaries--in which people from all walks of life have a common interest and in which children might come to learn such common values as decency, civility, and respect. ..... But to be free is not simply to [p. 58 ends] be free from coercion or constraint. Democratic freedom requires the free construction and possible revision of beliefs and preferences. To become free, students must be exposed to the vibrant diversity of a democratic society so that they possess the liberty to live a life of their own design. [new paragraph] Because homeschooled students receive highly customized educations, designed usually to accord with the preferences of parents, they are least likely in principle to be exposed to materials, ideas, and people that have not been chosen in advance; they are least likely to share common education experiences with other children; and they are most likely to have a narrow horizon of experiences, which can curtail their freedom. Although highly customized education for students may produce satisfied parents us consumers, and even offer excellent academic training to the student, it is a loss from a civic perspective” [p. 59]. “My claim is about the potential civic perils of a homeschooled education, where schooling is customizable down to the tiniest degree” [p. 59]. The author’s claim -- that public schools are “... one of the few remaining social institutions ... in which children might come to learn such common values as decency, civility, and respect” -- is made with no premises and ludicrously implies that homeschooling will do this to a lesser degree. Unfortunately, the author ignores research on the civic and community engagement of homeschool families such as that by Smith & Sikkink 1999, Sikkink 2001, Ray 2001 [Home education in New Mexico], and Ray 2001 Home education in Ohio].
Reich, Rob 2003, personal communication Comments made by Reich, panelist, in presence of Brian Ray and public audience on the panel discussion entitled “Home Schooling: The Ultimate in Educational Quality Accountability?” at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Chicago, Illinois, April 21-25, 2003.
Reich, Rob 2005 Why home schooling should be regulated. In Bruce S. Cooper (Ed.), (2005), Homeschooling in full view: A reader, pp. 109-120.  Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing. home education, philosophy, politics, law, opinion, policy, regulation, negative criticism Reich is concerned that, among other things, home-educated children will become “ethically servile” (p. 114) or might be less likely than those who attend State-run schools or home-based education not regulated by the State to become “… free or autonomous individuals, that is to say, persons who can decide for themselves how they wich to lead their lives and what sort of values they wich to endorse” [p. 113]. “As a result [of research on homeschooling to date], the very best we can say about the academic outcomes of home schooling is that we have no evidence to suggest that home schooling fails. But neither do we have any evidence that it succeeds” (p. 115). “Why does an absence of evidence about the academic outcomes of home schooling lead to an argument in favor of regulating home schools? Children whose parents fail to teach them to read and to write, to be capable of minimum basic skills, are suffering educational harm” [p. 117]. “In short, these regulations [that should be imposed by the state] amount to the following: The state registers who is being home schooled. The state insists upon a curriculum that meets minimal academic standards and that introduces students to value pluralism. The state tests students periodically to ensure that minimal academic progress is being made” (p. 119). Authors recommendation of state control over private homeschooling begs the questions: If public school students suffer the same educational harm author is concerned some homeschool children suffer, will the public school children be state-mandated to be moved, against their parents’ wishes, to private institutional schooling or private homeschooling for remedy of the harm? and, If private homeschooling should be state-controlled this way, why not all private institutional schooling also?
Reich, Rob 2008 On regulating homeschooling: A reply to Glanzer. Educational Theory, 58(1), 17-23. home education, philosophy, politics, regulation, law, legal, negative criticism “… there are tripartite interests at stake in the education of children: interests of the child, the parents, and the state. Traditional legal analyses of schooling, by contrast, consider only the interests of parents and the state” [p. 17]. His “tripartite interests” scheme simply shifts the power to the state while claiming it is the child’s – it is not tripartite but still bipartite since the state will decide what is in the best interest of the child in terms of his/her becoming “autonomous.” “Beyond requirements like these, there is no such thing as a philosophically derived set of homeschooling regulations” [p. 20]. Author fails to recognize that all state laws, regulations, and controls are philosophically-based (p. 18) and that his statement, “Unless one believes in Platonic philosopher kings, a complete blueprint of public policy is not to be derived from arguments about philosophical principle. “Regulations,” I wrote in my analysis of homeschooling policies, “are properly a [p. 18 ends] matter of democratic politics, not deduction from theory, …” shows he puts primary value on democratism e.g., majority rules by force) over constitutionalism or scripturalism (e.g., biblical) in determining state control over a child’s education and upbringing and that he is, therefore, apparently inadvertently, playing the role of a philosopher king. Reaffirms his earlier publications that promote state control over homeschooling and writes, “I described my list of proposed homeschooling regulations as ‘‘tentative and provisional” (p. 19). “The reason is not that homeschool students consistently fare worse than their public school peers when it comes to academic performance. The reason is that we simply have no good evidence about the performance, academic or otherwise, of homeschool students. Contrary to the claims of its advocates (though Glanzer is not guilty here), the studies on homeschoolers do not demonstrate that homeschoolers outperform public school students. Social science research on the actual performance of homeschoolers is in its infancy and what little research exists is either of very poor quality or can reach only limited conclusions” [p. 22].
Reich, Rob 2016 Why home schooling should be regulated. In Bruce S. Cooper, Frances R. Spielhagen, & Carlo Ricci (Eds.), Homeschooling in new view (second edition). Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing.
Reilly, Lucy; Chapman, Anne; & O'Donoghue, Tom 2002 Home schooling of children with disabilities. Queensland Journal of Educational Research, 18(1), 38-61. Retrieved February 27, 2017 from http://www.iier.waier.org.au/qjer/qjer18/reilly.html http://www.iier.waier.org.au/qjer/qjer18/reilly.html disabilities, academic progress, homeschooling, home education, research, special needs, learning disabled, disabilities Uses case-study approach to examine how six Western Australia families manage the homeschooling of children with disabilities. Presents 8 propositions.) “This paper reports a study which responds to the lack of research pertaining to the home schooling of children with disabilities. A case study approach was adopted, utilising grounded theory methods of data analysis, to examine how six Western Australian parents manage the home schooling of their children with disabilities. One of the case studies is presented in detail. The paper then outlines eight propositions which were developed from the six case studies conducted in relation to the central research question.” “Proposition One: Home schooling parents typically assume responsibility for the education of their children with disabilities for a number of reasons. These reasons are predominantly concerned with the negative socialisation encountered in schools, insufficient academic progress and a failure by schools to understand their child's academic and social capabilities or the nature of their child's disability.” “Proposition Two: Having established the need for home schooling, the initial step in managing the process requires parents to determine the level of their child's educational understanding through prior experience, research or testing, in order to ascertain the content that will be taught.” “Proposition Three: The majority of parents adopt a loose home schooling structure without a set timetable because flexibility is required when teaching children with disabilities due to the greater occurrence of unforeseen circumstances and the ability to teach new concepts when the student is ready.” “Proposition Six: Parents find it easier to manage the process knowing that the one-on-one teaching and the flexibility available to them through home schooling enables their child's specific learning needs to be addressed, allowing social and academic progress to prevail.” “Proposition Seven: The varying educational needs of children with disabilities are often not accommodated within the system because schools lack an individual approach to teaching and the prevalence of bullying creates an environment adverse to learning.” Peer-reviewed, refereed.
Reilly, Reilly, Lucy 2004 How Western Australian parents manage the home schooling of their children with disabilities. A paper presented at a conference of the AARE. home education, research, learning disabilities, pedagogy Studies parent experiences managing home schooling with children with disabilities. Reilly is is from the University of Western Australia.
Reilly, Steve 2016 Teachers who sexually abuse students still find classroom jobs: Despite decades of scandals, America’s schools still hide actions of dangerous educators. Retrieved March 16, 2017 from http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2016/12/22/teachers-who-sexually-abuse-students-still-find-classroom-jobs/95346790/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2016/12/22/teachers-who-sexually-abuse-students-still-find-classroom-jobs/95346790/ public schools, sexual abuse, teachers
Repetski, Joe 2001 Effects on services to home-based educators following changes to legislation and policy. Master’s (M.Ed.) thesis, University of Regina (Canada), 130pp. (Retrieved 7/19/13 from http://www.nlc-bnc.ca/obj/s4/f2/dsk3/ftp04/MQ60245.pdf). http://www.nlc-bnc.ca/obj/s4/f2/dsk3/ftp04/MQ60245.pdf homeschooling, Canada, public schools, public school at home, needs “Hence, research about the needs of parents was of particular interest to me, because needs and services are complementary to each other” (p. 81-82). “First, participants spoke about the need for moral support. ….. Second, home-schoolers need to receive curriculum support and resources” (p. 82). “Third, Clendening (1996) cited the need to monitor and/or assess learners in a manner that is fair to home-schooling parents and al1 stakeholders in education. This need had a low profile by the parents who participated in this study. ….. Fourth, parents need to have their rights to home-school affirmed without innuendoes that children should return to conventional schooling. ….. Fifth, the need to receive financial assistance for the purchase of resources was the most recurring theme with the participants” (p. 83). “This study found that four needs are consistent with Clendening's findings on home-based educators' most immediate needs” (p. 84). Promotes collaboration between government/public schools and homeschoolers. Promotes public school at home, tax-funded schooling at home, and, therefore, more state control of homeschooling. Author’s recommendations include the following: “3. Keep trying to reach out to home-based educators who are resistant to a working relationship with the [state, public, provincial] school division” (p. 87) and “4. Consider increasing direct [tax, government] funding for home-based education programs” (p. 88). “Abstract: This study examines home-based educators' perceptions of a school division's services to them in Regina School Division #4 in the province of Saskatchewan, Canada. Within a relatively recent legal framework in Saskatchewan, parents who chose to homeschool their children are generally required to register with their local school division. Those who register with Regina School Division #4 are supported by an array of services that are provided according to the new legislation. In late 1 999, the school division conducted a survey concerning twenty services offered to home-based educators. Using data from the survey results as a background, I used a qualitative research design to probe into parental perception about the usefulness of the services offered, particularly in comparison to the "before and after" of the legislative changes. The participants in this study were four long-term home-based educators. The research design involved two stages: first, individual semi-structured interviews with the home-based educators were conducted; and second, a focus group discussion was held with the same four participants. Two themes emerged from the findings: 1) the existing tensions, and 2) the fear of moving forward. Direct funding to support home-based education programs was the most sought after service expressed by the participants in this study. Recommendations to both the school division and home-based educators are intended to assist in forging a stronger educational partnership. Although the research is specific to Regina School Division #4, the literature review and findings would be beneficial to both urban and rural administrators who wish to learn about home-based education at the turn of the millennium” (p. i).
Resetar, Mark A. 1990 An exploratory study of the rationales parents have for home schooling. Home School Researcher, 6(2), 1-7. home education, reasons, motivations Finds that the reasons for home schooling are subject to change over time. Many may begin with "defensive reasons," such as fear of anti-Christian influences and concerns about public education. Later, a significant proportion of these reevaluate their motives, and many may move from ideological reasons to more pedagogical reasons.
Resetar, Mark A. 1990 Home Schooling: Some new findings and some new questions. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 16-20, Boston, MA.
Resetar, Mark A. 1991 Home education as an expression of religious belief. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 3-7, 1991, Chicago IL.
Resetar, Mark A. 1993 Thinking has taken wings: A study of home educated pre- and early adolescents who are formal thinkers. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 12-16, 1993, Atlanta GA.
Reyenga, Henry, Jr. 2006 The spontaneous spread of home-discipleship Christianity. Published by Home Discipleship Press, 6645 West Steger Road, Monee IL 60449. religion, church, local church life, family, Christianity “Imagine a church where there is no Sunday School or children’s church, where families are charged with providing spiritual instruction and remain together during the service to celebrate and reinforce all that is learned throughout the week in the home. . . . . . . Through daily Bible reading and prayer, Scripture memorization, singing, hospitality, and unity in purpose as a church body, home discipleship supports a Christianity that is active, alive, and truly attractive to those who are seeking after God” [back cover].
Reynolds, Peter L., & Williams, David D. 1986, February 4 & 5 Understanding family schools as alternatives to public education. Paper presented at the Conference on Education and the Family, Brigham Young University, Provo, UT.
Reynolds, Peter Levi 1985 How home school families operate on a day-to-day basis: Three case studies. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Brigham Young University, Provo, UT. Or, see Dissertation Abstracts International, 47, 408A. Author says "naturalistic case study procedures" were used. Provides detailed descriptions of daily activities of families, discusses socialization and academic achievement, infers 11 patterns from his observations related to initiating a home school, selection of subject areas, amount of child-regulated study time, achievement, socialization, and commitment on part of parents. Gives personal comments on thoughts about home education and its consequences. Descriptor: home education, research, daily operations, qualitative.
Reynolds, Peter Levi, & Williams, D. D. 1985 The daily operations of a home school family: a case study. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Chicago, IL. Or, ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 256 080. home education, descriptive, qualitative research Discusses potential strengths of home schools and potential hardships facing those operating such schools. Explains curriculum materials used by families, describes student achievement, and examines the socialization of children. Reynolds (1985) refers to homeschooling for his study as “… families where the parents have taken over the entire responsibility for educating their children” (p. 3). In each of the families he studied, “… the home school was a family enterprise which was sponsored by both parents” (p. 7).) Authors' address: Brigham Young University, Provo, UT 84602.
Rice, Gail, & Gillespie, V. Bailey 1992 Valuegenesis: A megastudy of faith maturity and its relationship to variables within the home, school, and church. Journal of Research on Christian Education, 1(1), 49-67. research, home, school, and church, religion, religiosity, academic achievement Studied students in Seventh Day Adventist schools. Grouped family effectiveness factors into five categories: family practices, mother, father, support, and control; within these, Christian faith maturity was most strongly correlated with family engaging in projects to help other people, family worship being interesting and meaningful, mother talks with child about faith, father talks with child about faith, and family life is experienced as loving, caring, and supportive. Also examined congregational and school effectiveness factors. "Families appear to remain the predominant influence for strong Christian youth. The family seems to be the most positive venue for the enforcement of standards, particularly those that relate to popular culture. The family is encouraged to plan carefully for high-quality worship experiences together. This is one of the four central effectiveness factors for all youth in the study" (p. 65-66). Includes a table showing summary of 38 items on Faith Maturity Index instrument.
Rich, John Martin 1988, Spring Competition in education. Educational Theory, 38(2), 183-89. Competition, Cooperation, Educational Change, Educational Philosophy, Intellectual History, Socialization Suggestions on fostering other forms of motivation within education.
Richard, Howard B. in press, probably 1993 or 1994 Chapter title unknown. In Educational entrepreneurship: A bold agenda to frame the future, organized by the Commonwealth Foundation, Pennsylvania. Commonwealth Foundation is a conservative think tank.
Richardson, Charles M. 2000, April 27 New research tool reveals teacher ed lowers pupil scores. New York: The Literacy Council. Retrieved 12/10/04 online http://www.tlc.li/articles/new_tool.htm. http://www.tlc.li/articles/new_tool.htm academic achievement, teacher education, teacher preparation, research, public school “Executive Summary: A unique computer analytical technique yields a new high in precision in evaluating school district performance factors. Parental education and teacher experience show as the most positive factors; teacher education shows a strong negative effect on pupil Regents' exam scores. Corroborative evidence and system remedial needs are discussed, linking general literacy and African-American under-achievement issues.”
Richardson, Sharon Nalbone, & Zirkel, Perry A. 1991 Home schooling law. In Jane A. Van Galen & Mary Anne Pitman (Eds.), Home schooling: Political, historical, and pedagogical perspectives. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation.
Richardson, Virginia (Ed.) 2001 Handbook of research on teaching, fourth edition. Washington, DC: American Educational Research Association. teacher training, teacher traits, teacher qualifications, teacher certification, student academic achievement Research finds none to small correlations between teacher preparation and certification and students’ academic achievement. See especially pages 7-8.
Richman, Howard 1997-1998, Winter Results of survey of homeschool graduates [press release]. Pennsylvania Homeschoolers, Issue no. 61, p. 4. (Available from Pennsylvania Homeschoolers, RR 2 Box 117, Kittanning PA 16201.) college, graduates Finds that “... 43% of the 129 [1996 homeschool] graduates attended college full-time in the fall of 1996, while 32% found employment outside of the family, 7% were self-employed or went into businesses with other family members, 6% engaged in other forms of training including paramedic training, part-time college, and college correspondence courses, 3% found apprenticeships, 6% engaged in volunteer work, and 4% were unemployed. Two of the five who where unemployed during the fall term went on to enter college during the spring term” [p. 4].”
Richman, Howard 2000, Summer Possible homeschool bills proliferate. Pennsylvania Homeschoolers, No. 71. (Available from Pennsylvania Homeschoolers, RD 2 Box 117, Kittanning PA 16201) home education, law, legislation, philosophy, opinion, state control, regulation Discusses several bills that may be proposed to the PA legislature. Authors’ views reveal the diversity of opinion among homeschoolers about the best way to approach changes in legislation and what should be key elements of law that is viewed as good by homeschoolers. Author, a homeschooler, advocates “accountability” to the state while he argues against those who advocate more complete liberty from state regulation for those parents and families who choose to home educate their children.
Richman, Howard 2002, Spring TEACH cyber-charter on verge of collapse. Pennsylvania Homeschoolers, Number 78, 1-2. home education, charter school, law Describes the way a state-controlled, tax-funded charter school called TEACH in Pennsylvania quickly attracted the enrollment of 3,300 students, then how administrative, political, legal, and philosophical problems set in, how “reality set in” regarding the facts that parents would retain a lot less authority over their children’s [homeschool] education than they thought they would, and that 40% of the students had left TEACH by the beginning of March 2002 during the program’s first year.
Richman, Howard B., Girten, William, & Snyder, Jay 1990 Academic achievement and its relationship to selected variables among Pennsylvania homeschoolers. Home School Researcher, 6(4), 9-16. home education, research, academic achievement, policy, teacher certification Available from the National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309. Presents the reading and math standardized achievement test scores (86th and 73rd percentiles) in this Pennsylvania study and compares them to scores found in other studies. Examines the weak relationships between the two variables of parent educational attainment and family income and student scores, and the absence of relationships between the two variables of teacher certification status of parents [p. 13] and level of structure in the home schooling and student scores. Family income correlated with reading achievement (0.11) and negatively correlated with math achievement (-0.11) [p. 12 and Table 3 on p. 13].
Richman, Howard, & Richman, Susan 1988 The Three R's At Home. Kittanning, PA: Pennsylvania Homeschoolers R.D. 2, Box 117, Kittanning PA 16201), 230pp.
Richman, Howard, Girten, William & Snyder, Jay 1992 Math: What works well at home. Home School Researcher, 8(2), 9-19. home education, research, mathematics Sample from Pennsylvania. Home educated students in the 3rd through 8th grade scored, on average, at the 73rd percentile on standardized achievement tests. Found that older students scored higher in math, parents who attended seminars on teaching math had students who scored higher in math, more correcting of students' mistakes by parents and more requiring students to correct their mistakes correlated with lower math achievement by students, and students exposed to geometric concepts scored better in math than students not so exposed.
Richman, Sheldon 1994 Separating school and state: How to liberate America’s families. Fairfax, VA: The Future of Freedom Foundation, 128 pp. education, reform, privatization, home education, politics, sociology Argues that schooling and education must be separated from state control. Addresses constitutional, historical, social, political, educational issues. Logically, carefully documents claims. “When Germany emerged as a unified nation, the Prussian school system was enlarged. As Franz de Hovre wrote in 1917: ‘The prime fundamental of German education is that it is based on a national principle. . . . A fundamental feature of German education: education to the State, education for the State, education by the State. The Volksschule is a direct result of a national principle aimed at national unity. The State is the supreme end in view’” [p. 41]. “The themes of obedience and the deficiencies of the family pervade the thinking of the early proponents of public schools. In 1816 Archibald D. Murphy [sic, should be Murphey], founder of the North Carolina public schools [and, for a time, a college professor], wrote: ‘In these schools the precepts of morality and religion should be inculcated, and habits of subordination and obedience be formed. … Their parents know not how to instruct them. … The state, in the warmth of her affection and solicitude for their welfare, must take charge of those children and place them in school where their minds can be enlightened and their hearts trained to virtue’” (p. 46). [Horace] Mann put it in 1845, “We who are engaged in the sacred cause of education are entitled to look upon all parents as having given hostages to our cause” (p. 46). “William H. Seawell, professor of education at the University of Virginia, got caught in that position in 1981. He said, ‘Public schools promote civic rather than individual pursuits’ and, ‘We must focus on creating citizens for the good of society.’ But most startlingtly, he said, ‘Each child belongs to the state’” [p. 51]. Uses a libertarian and limited-government perspective to explain that regardless of which “civic virtues” are taught in state-controlled and coercively-funded public schools (and whether they are fundamentally valid or the truth), “What is crucial is that they cumulatively represent the ‘court history’ and ‘politically correct’ views that rationalize and justify and particular cultural ideology and a set of government policies and powers over the society. They represent the official ‘Party line’ of contemporary American politics and culture that is taught in every public school. They legitimize the existing order of things and the particular political agenda of those who control the monopoly system of compulsory education. Whether we like to admit it or not, its function is essentially the same as it was in Soviet Russia, Fascist Italy, and Nazi Germany” [p. xix]. “Home schoolers are routinely involved in community activities [p. 4]. In common conception of education and public schools today “… casts children in a fundamentally passive role” [p. 4].) “Isabel Paterson wrote circa 1943: "Every politically controlled educational system will inculcate the doctrine of state supremacy sooner or later. … Once that doctrine has been accepted, it becomes an almost superhuman task to break the stranglehold of political power over the life of the citizen. ….. A tax-supported, compulsory educational system is the complete model of the totalitarian state” [p. 73].
Riegel, Sarah 2001, Summer The home schooling movement and the struggle for democratic education. Studies in Political Economy, No. 65, 91-116, https://www.academia.edu/1621887/The_home_schooling_movement_and_the_struggle_for_democratic_education https://www.academia.edu/1621887/The_home_schooling_movement_and_the_struggle_for_democratic_education http://spe.library.utoronto.ca/index.php/spe/index homeschooling, democratic education, public schools, statism Studies in Political Economy appears to be published by the University of Toronto, Canada – see http://spe.library.utoronto.ca/index.php/spe/index. Author does not focus on Canada but homeschooling in general, basically North America. Argues that “universal public education” is the best way to advance “democratic education” and that homeschooling is an undesirable form of education. She wants to “… go about building the progressive, democratic side of public schooling while reducing the capitalist hegemonic side” (p. 109). Promotes statism, progressivism, and neo-Marxism. “Unfortunately, the existing literature on home schooling provides little critical analysis of the political aspects of the movement. Most academic studies of home schooling have focused on questions about the academic performance or socialization of home schooled children and adolescents or on developing profiles of the "typical" home schooling family. While these are certainly important questions, they do not [p. 92 ends] offer much guidance in determining the democratic potential of the movement. What is necessary therefore is an examination of the home schooling movement with particular focus on questions of democracy and political struggles. This paper seeks to address these questions through an examination of the theory and practice of home schooling and with a foregrounding of their implications for democratic struggle. In particular, I will examine the arguments of Ivan Illich and John Holt, who offer the most sustained theoretical exploration of the political ramifications of home schooling and build the strongest philosophical case for it. I will argue that the movement cannot be a tool of democratic struggle, because despite the best intentions of home schoolers, both the theory and practice of home schooling ultimately rest on anti-political and anti-democratic assumptions. This paper will reassert the central role of universal public education in democratic movement. The best strategy for progressives concerned with the hegemonic content of education is thus to work to revitalize and reform public education, not to abandon it in favor of home schooling” (p. 92-93).
Riemer, Joel 1994 Perspectives from a home-schooling educator. Educational Leadership, 52(1), 53, 54.
Rifat, Mohammad Rashidujjaman; Yahya, Nouran; Khan, Ayla; & Sabie, Samar 2026 Homeroom: A value-aligned and community-centered homeschooling platform. Proceedings of the 2026 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, Article No.: 654, pp 1 – 19. https://doi.org/10.1145/3772318.3791698 https://doi.org/10.1145/3772318.3791698 homeschooling; value-alignment; human-LLM co-creation; community support; Muslim “Abstract: We present Homeroom, a homeschooling platform that treats parents as reflective partners in collaboration with LLMs, integrates culturally responsive personalization for generating schooling materials, and supports the formation of small, trusted circles. Homeroom provides plan-then-generate story and curriculum creation, alignment, and comparison to local school standards, and resource sharing in invite-only groups. We conducted a summative usability study with 15 Muslim homeschooling parents in the Greater Toronto Area. Findings show that previewable, editable drafts preserve parental agency; values work best as revisable “soft constraints” integrated into the platform; and parents prefer private circles with clear lineage. Parents also requested lightweight infrastructure (e.g., rubric libraries, portfolio builders) to reduce paperwork. We discuss opportunities and challenges in positioning AI as a deliberative partner in family- and community-shaped pedagogy.”
Ritter, Marion 1979 Read this before you veto home-education requests. American Journal, October 1979, 38-40. Law.
Rivero, Lisa 2007, Fall Progressive digressions: Home schooling for self-actualization. Mensa Research Journal, 38(3), 47-54. home education, talented, gifted, special needs
Riverside Insights 2015 Research and Development Guide, Iowa Assessments, Forms E and F. “About This Guide. Purpose: This Research and Development Guide summarizes the development and analysis of research data for the Iowa Assessments™ Form E and Form F. It also details test-construction procedures, including selecting and weighting samples, collecting national comparative data, establishing national norms, and gathering validity evidence for the new tests” (p. 1). Explains technical information about Iowa Assessments tests. Prepared at The University of Iowa under the direction of Stephen Dunbar and Catherine Welch with contributions from H. D. Hoover, Robert A. Forsyth, David A. Frisbie and Timothy N. Ansley” [inside the cover]. This test instrument has been used numerous times in the study of the academic achievement of homeschooled students.
Roach, V. 1989 Home schooling in times of educational reform. Education Digest, 54(6), 58-61.
Roach, Virginia 1988, November Home schooling in an era of educational reform. School Business Affairs, 54(11), 10-14. Board of Education Policy, Home Schooling, Parent School Relationship, Politics of Education, State Standards A report detailing the recommendations of the National Association of State Boards of Education concerning criteria standardization and evaluation procedures.
Robb, Matthew 2005, September/October The ABCs of homeschoooling: Is homeschooling getting a bad rap or are critics justified? Social Work Today, 5(5), 14-18. home education, sociology, social work, overview, research, opinion Presents overview on homeschooling; attempts to focus on issues of interest to social workers; attempts to dispel stereotypes about homeschooling.
Robbins, John W. 1997/1998 The educational establishment versus civilization. The Trinity Review, December 1997, January 1998. Retrieved August 16, 2010 from http://www.trinityfoundation.org/PDF/154a-TheEducationalEstablishment.pdf. http://www.trinityfoundation.org/PDF/154a-TheEducationalEstablishment.pdf philosophy, theology, home education, homeschooling, private schools, public schools “Today we face a new wilderness, not an uninhabited geographical wilderness, but a cultural and spiritual wilderness. It is our job as Christian educators to tame the wilderness by building a shining university on a hill. Already Christian parents are removing their children from government schools and educating them at home and in Christian schools. That movement, which still has a long way to go, is well underway. It will not have succeeded until the last public school is sold to the highest bidder, and no government—federal, state, or local—spends any money on education. [paragraph ends] But long before that happens, we must offer the graduates of these Christian schools and home schools a Christian University. Unfortunately, some putatively Christian writers have attacked higher education, saying that the next generation of Christians should be taught a trade; they should not pursue the illusion of college degrees, and certainly not advanced degrees. They need something "practical" instead. These anti-intellectuals—some of whom sport Ph.D.s—deprecate diplomas and advanced degrees. This Amish view of education is both anti-Christian and suicidal. Any parent who listens to them is sealing the fate of his child” [p. 8].
Roberts, Francis 1984, July The home-schooling question. Parents, pp. 112, 117.
Robertson, Heather-Jane 2002 Going with the flow. Phi Delta Kappan, 83(5), 349-350. ERIC Document No. EJ640843. http://www.eric.ed.gov http://www.questia.com/library/1G1-81835753/in-canada-going-with-the-flow http://www.eric.ed.gov/ homeschooling, educational change; elementary secondary education; foreign countries; home schooling; public education; public opinion; public policy, statism Author is probably opposed to public/tax funding of homeschooling. “Abstract: Criticizes report by Fraser Institute, located in Vancouver, British Columbia, on home schooling [homeschooling] in Canada. Report advocates government funding of home schooling.” (retrieved 7/16/13 from http://www.eric.ed.gov). “As a result, this corporate-funded think tank [Fraser Institute] has assumed predictable positions on tougher standards (good), charter schools (very good), public funding of private schools (very, very good), and so forth. ….. Three jurisdictions provide some funding to parents, including Alberta, where school boards are required to rebate to parents a share of the per-pupil grant - usually $400 - for each student registered as home schooled. In exchange, subsidized Alberta home-schooled students must take that province's applicable standardized achievement tests. It's an unacceptable tradeoff for some Albertans, who gladly forgo the cash to keep their unregistered children safe from the clutches of …” (retrieved 7/16/13 from http://www.questia.com/library/1G1-81835753/in-canada-going-with-the-flow).
Robertson, Heather-Jane 2007 Going with the flow. Our Schools/Our Selves, 16(4), 149-154. http://www.policyalternatives.ca homeschooling, educational change; elementary secondary education; foreign countries; home schooling; public education; public opinion; public policy, statism Published by Canadian Centre For Policy Alternatives www.policyalternatives.ca; personal communication with publisher reports this article identical to 2002 article in Phi Delta Kappan by same author. Criticizes the Fraser Institute’s, located in British Columbia, Canada, report on homeschooling. Very pro-statism/state/public schools. Implicitly negative, if not explicitly, toward homeschooling. Equates supporting homeschooling with being anti-public schooling. “As a result, this corporate-funded think tank [Fraser Institute] has assumed predictable positions on tougher standards (good), charter schools (very good), public funding of private schools (very, very good), and so forth” (p. 149). “Three jurisdictions provide [p. 149 ends] some funding to parents, including Alberta, where school boards are required to rebate to parents a share of the per-pupil grant —usually $400—for each student registered as home schooled. In exchange, subsidized Alberta home-schooled students must take that province’s applicable standardized achievement tests. It’s an unacceptable tradeoff for some Albertans, who gladly forgo the cash to keep their unregistered children safe from the clutches of government interference” (p. 150). “So for the Fraser Institute, it is political rather than practical mainstreaming that is the real goal. Using public resources to fund home schooling would set a useful precedent for using public resources to fund private schools. Such policies would provide a windfall to the wealthy families that would benefit from tuition tax credits and still be able to afford the tuition charged by “elite” private schools. Not that public schools would cease to exist, at least in the short term, but their costs and the tax burden to support them could be reduced. After all, legitimizing home schooling means de-legitimizing teachers’ skills and knowledge: if nonteachers can be viewed as more effective than professionals, then the cost of teachers’ training and labor can be forced down, their certification can be made meaningless, and public education will be further compromised. In other words, the price of mainstreaming home schooling is selling public education down the river” (p. 153).
Romanowski, Michael H. 2002 Home-schooled students’ perceptions of the transition to public school: Struggles, adjustments, and issues. Home School Researcher, 15(1), 1-12. “Findings indicate that most of these home schooled students who transitioned into public schools do extremely well but face various issues and adjustments” [p. 9]. “Finally, there are multiple factors that shape and influence the home school experience for each individual student. This, in turn, will affect the individual student’s experience as they enter public school. These include, but are not limited to, the primary reasons the family home schools, the number of siblings that were simultaneously home schooled, the personality and maturity of the home schooled child, and the specifics as to the structure and style of the home schooled environment” [p. 11].
Romm, Tracy 1993 Home schooling and the transmission of civic culture. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Clark Atlanta University, Atlanta, GA, 383 pp. home education, research, values, socialization, civic culture, reasons, democracy, minorities, African-American, Black, religion Describes the process of socialization in home schooling families, with particular attention given to the transmission of civic culture with the claim in mind that schools are a means of social mobility for the individual and are developers of democratic values and practices. Does case studies of eight families, including a variety of religious and ethnic backgrounds (e.g., African-American [Black], Muslim, Christian, White-Anglo). "While all of the families are resisting the acculturating mission of the school and redefining the role of the family relative to other social institutions in the raising of their children, these parents express their unwillingness to conform to societal expectations in explicitly political terms. In effect their pedagogy is a political act or, as one mother put it, `the personal is the political.'" [p. 303]. "In summary, in all of these families the cultivation of strong character traits is viewed as the central goal of the home schooling effort" [p. 307]. Author's worldview seems to have strong influence on his interpretation and explanation of his observations when he implies that the Ideologue parents who strongly use a Biblical worldview may not be imparting as many democratic values to their children and not providing as many "... pedagogical experiences consonant with the goals of independent thinking and action" [p. 329] as do the Pedagogues studied [p. 326-331].) These parents, “. . . representing a variety of ideologies and motivations, are concerned primarily with the character-building function of education. As used here, character refers to religious or moral traits and to mental abilities that serve to preserve the distinctive qualities of each individual child. Schools are rejected as the referent for this process; they are viewed as serving more as a force for social conformity than as a protector of individual integrity” (p. 351). One reason for home educating is moral safety of children (e.g., p. 137). Notes that these parents value the American system, do not want to undermine it, and express their allegiance to God or to moral and ethical beliefs rather than to a government (p. 354-355). “It is in regard to civic education that the parental desire for independent thinking and action is most clearly expressed” (p. 355). The parents maintained that “. . . the strength of the nation rests in the ability of the individual to act from his own convictions, and that home-based education is best suited to allow the unimpeded development of these” (p. 355). Concludes that the parents’ willingness to not be conformist and to home educate their children is itself an effective model for their children of independent thought and action and “In a sense, all home schooling parents are ideological in that they want to instill strongly-held beliefs in their children and want to maintain some measure of control over outside influences that might compete with their attempt to transmit these” (p. 350). .
Rose, Alan Barry 1985 A qualitative study of the characteristics of home schooling families in South Carolina and the perceptions of school district personnel toward home schooling. Doctoral dissertation, University of South Carolina, Columbia. Dissertation Abstracts International, 47, 377A. Demographics, reasons for home schooling, and public school personnel attitudes toward home schooling. Methodology involved interviewing five families, setting hypotheses, then interviewing five more families to test and revise hypothetical statements. Same procedure was used with school personnel. Findings included the following: (a) Family income of $25,000 or more per annum, (b) fathers have job security and established professions, 8 mothers are homemakers, (d) procedural difficulty obtaining permission to home school, (e) reasons for home education include religion, discipline in public schools, and wrong values being taught in schools, (f) children ranked above 50th percentile on achievement tests, and (g) superintendents/designees state (g1) home schooling is parental right, (g2) public schools meet needs better than home schooling, (g3) religion is main reason for home schooling, and (g4) home schoolers receive less education than at public schools. Not "qualitative research" in pure sense of the phrase.
Rose, Brenda 2002 How home education contributes to adult success: A case study of the Fletcher Collins family. Master’s (M.A.) thesis, Mary Baldwin College. home education, research, adults, graduates, success The names used are actual names. Fletcher and Margaret Collins homeschooled their four sons in the years from 1946 to 1961. “These men [sons] are all successful adults, with outstanding academic, career, and community achievements. Strong family values, farm life, and arts were an integral part of their curriculum. Creativity, individuality, and discovery learning are examined in light of their experiences. Beneficial and detrimental factors in homeschooling are considered, with recommendations for replicating positive aspects in current home and public schools. Future studies might investigate the importance of music, drama, or meaningful work experiences in student education. Studies of other succesful individuals who were homeschooled should be undertaken. [p. 2].” The youngest, Dr. Francis Collins, currently is the director of the Human Genome Project and has become world-renowned for that work.) “This case study examines the effects of home education provided by Fletcher and Margaret Collins to their four sons: Christopher, Brandon, Fletcher, and Francis. These men are all successful adults, with outstanding academic, career, and community achievements. Strong family values, farm life, and the arts were an integral part of their curriculum. Creativity, individuality, and discovery learning are examined in light of their experiences. Beneficial and detrimental factors in homeschoo]ing are considered, with recommendations for replicating positive aspects in current home and public schools. Future studies might investigate the importance of music, drama, or meaningful work experiences in student education. Studies of other successful individuals who were homeschooled should be undertaken” (abstract, p. 2).
Rose, Lowell C., & Gallup, Alec M. 1999 The 31st annual Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup poll of the public's attitudes toward the public schools. Online http://www.pdkintl.org/kappan/kpol9909.htm. Also, retrieved October 19, 2015 from http://www.pdkmembers.org/members_online/publications/GallupPoll/kpoll_pdfs/pdkpoll31_1999.pdf . http://www.pdkintl.org/kappan/kpol9909.htm http://www.pdkmembers.org/members_online/publications/GallupPoll/kpoll_pdfs/pdkpoll31_1999.pdf poll, research, public schooling, home schooling, attitudes, public Asks many things about the public’s attitude toward various aspects of education. Among these, addresses home schooling. “The percentage of those feeling that home schooling is a ‘bad thing’ dropped from 73% in 1985 to 57% in 1997. This year's poll asked about the services that public schools should make available to children who are schooled at home.” “As is the case with vouchers and tuition tax credits, the public is not willing to endorse home schooling without some strings attached. Ninety-two percent believe children schooled at home should be required to take all the state and national assessments required of public school students." “..... Another alternative to public schools is home schooling. Previous polls have established that the public is becoming more receptive to the idea of home schooling. The percentage of those feeling that home schooling is a "bad thing" dropped from 73% in 1985 to 57% in 1997. This year's poll asked about the services that public schools should make available to children who are schooled at home. The findings indicate that the public generally approves of the concept of providing such services. The percentages in favor in the five services proposed range from a high of 92% for special education courses for disabled or handicapped children to a low of 53% for transportation services. [new paragraph] As is the case with vouchers and tuition tax credits, the public is not willing to endorse home schooling without some strings attached. Ninety-two percent believe children schooled at home should be required to take all the state and national assessments required of public school students. ..... Home Schooling An alternative available to parents is home schooling. When the question as to whether home schooling is a good or bad thing was last put to parents in 1997, 57% felt it was a bad thing for the nation. This year's poll asked two questions about home schooling: one explores what services should be made available to home-schoolers, and the other asks about the standards to which home-schooled children should be held. The public expresses majority support for providing all five listed services to home-schooled children, with special education courses at the top (92% in favor). Giving home-schooling teachers the opportunity to participate in local public school teacher development activities draws 80% approval; participation in school extracurricular activities, 74% approval; driver's education, 73% approval; and transportation services, 53% approval. Support for making the top four services available is strong among all demographic groups. The first question: Would you favor or oppose making the following public school services available, at public expense, to children who are schooled at home?” Favor %, Oppose %, Don't Know % Special education courses for disabled or handicapped children, 92, 7, 1; The opportunity for home-schooling teachers to participate in local public school teacher development activities, 80, 18, 2; The opportunity to participate in public school extracurricular activities, 74, 25, 1; Driver's education, 73, 26, 1; Transportation services, 53, 44, 3; With regard to holding home-schooled children to the same academic standards as public school students, 92% believe that home-schooled children should take all the state and national assessment tests that public school students are required to take. This belief is uniform across all groups. The second question: Would you favor or oppose requiring children who are schooled at home to take all the state and national assessment tests that public school students are required to take? National Totals %, No Children In School %, Public School Parents %, Favor, 92, 92, 92; Oppose, 7, 6, 8; Don't know, 1, 2, * *Less than one-half of 1%. .....”
Rose, Lowell C., & Gallup, Alec M. 2000 The 32nd annual Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup poll of the public's attitudes toward the public schools. Retrieved 1/4/01 online http://www.pdkintl.org/kappan/kpol0009.htm. http://www.pdkintl.org/kappan/kpol0009.htm public schools education, opinion, research, attitude "Three questions in the poll offered respondents the opportunity to express an opinion regarding the means of seeking improvement in the education students receive. The first gave a choice between reforming the existing system and finding an alternative system. This question was first asked in 1997, and 71% of respondents chose reforming the existing system. The percentage remained the same in 1999 and drops to 59% this year."
Rose, Lowell C., & Gallup, Alec M. 2001, September The 33rd annual Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup poll of the public's attitudes toward the public schools. Retrieved 3/21/03 online http://www.pdkintl.org/kappan/k0109gal.htm. Also Retrieved 7/2/07 online from http://www.pdkmembers.org/e-GALLUP/kpoll_pdfs/pdkpoll33_2001.pdf. http://www.pdkintl.org/kappan/k0109gal.htm http://www.pdkmembers.org/e-GALLUP/kpoll_pdfs/pdkpoll33_2001.pdf public schools, attitudes, research, vouchers, home education Report: “For the first time in the 33-year history of these polls, a majority of respondents assign either an A or a B to the schools in their communities. And, as has been the case in all past polls, the closer people are to the public schools, the better they like them. The percentage of A's and B's rises from 51% for all respondents to 62% for public school parents and to 68% when these same parents are asked to grade the school their oldest child attends. These high marks may explain why, when asked to choose between improving schools by reforming the existing system or by finding an alternative to that system, 72% of Americans choose reforming the existing system. This percentage, while up from 59% in the 2000 poll, is consistent with the 1999 and 1997 findings, in which 71% preferred to reform the existing system. ..... While falling short of majority approval, home schooling continues to gain public support. Forty-one percent of respondents this year regard home schooling as a good thing, while 54% regard it as a bad thing. However, the 41% figure is up from 16% when the question was first asked in 1985.”
Rosenzweig, Beth O. 1993 The Lake Wobegone report. Available from author at Educational Consulting and Testing Service, 513 N.E. 205th St., Seattle WA 98155. home education, research, academic achievement, parent education level [attainment] Examines grades 4 to 8 home educated students who score post-high school on achievement tests by administering to them the 12th grade level Stanford Achievement Test. Finds no relation between parent education level and student achievement; this higher grade level testing provides more accurate assessment of their true academic ability.
Ross, Catherine 2010 Fundamentalist challenges to core democratic values: Exit and homeschooling. William and Mary Bill of Rights Journal, 18 (May 2010), 991-1014. homeschooling, home education, private schooling, private education, theory, philosophy, law, legal, opinion, statism, state regulation, statism “This Essay explores the choice many traditionalist Christian parents (both fundamentalist and evangelical) make to leave public schools in order to teach their children at home, thus in most instances escaping meaningful oversight. ….. Instead, my comments focus on civic education in the broadest sense, which I define primarily as exposure to the constitutional norm of tolerance. I shall argue that the growing reliance on homeschooling comes into direct conflict with assuring that children are exposed to such constitutional values” [p. 991]. Many, if not most, of these parents do not “leave public schools” but never choose to send their children to be taught, trained, and indoctrinated by the State in public schools. “In order for the norm of tolerance to survive across generations, society need not and should not tolerate the inculcation of absolutist views that undermine toleration of difference. Respect for difference should not be confused with approval for approaches that would splinter us into countless warring groups. Hence an argument that tolerance for diverse views and values is a foundational principle does not conflict with the notion that the state can and should limit the ability of intolerant homeschoolers to inculcate hostility to difference in their children—at least during the portion of the day they claim to devote to satisfying the compulsory schooling requirement” [p. 1005]. “Some of these concerns [of the author] apply to organized schools [e.g., “evangelical schools”] as well” [p. 1007]. Author reveals her intolerance of views opposed to hers and holds that the State shall not tolerate the beliefs of some that there is absolute truth and therefore recommends the State should control by force the curriculum of home-educated students, as follows: “I propose that we add to the civics education goals of the state, including lessons on mutual respect for diverse populations and viewpoints as a mandatory curricular requirements. As I observed above, some homeschoolers doubtless are committed to diversity, and this requirement would not conflict with their educational agenda, but this is not the group that concerns me. Imposing curricular requirements about respect for diverse viewpoints will be seen as undermining the most authoritarian conservative homeschoolers—those who believe in an absolute truth which forms the basis of the education they provide their children. Unfortunately, the unavoidable counterpart of a belief in absolute truth is that other belief systems are mistaken at best, and at worst, evil” [p. 1008]. Author again clearly reveals her intolerant worldview of statism when she recommends the following: “A better—and perhaps more forthcoming–approach would be to adopt a rebuttable presumption that, all other things being equal, where the parents disagree [e.g., in custody disputes, family court], the state prefers public school to homeschooling because public schools serve the state’s interest in exposure to diverse viewpoints and people” [p. 1012]. Ross makes two policy recommendations: “First, states should require homeschoolers to include curricular materials that promote tolerance for diversity. ….. The state should engage in curricular oversight and testing, and should be prepared to withdraw consent to homeschooling where families flagrantly violate this requirement. ….. Second, where parents involved in custody disputes disagree about the choice of school for their children, states should adopt a rebuttable presumption favoring licensed schools (whether public or private) over homeschooling” [p. 1013].
Roszak, Theodore 1974 Educating contra naturum. In William Van Til (Ed.), Curriculum: Quest for relevance, 2nd ed.. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin Co., 432 p. School criticism.
Rothbard, Murray N. 2002, online edition; 1973, 1978 For A New Liberty: The Libertarian Manifesto. education, classical liberalism, libertarian, libertarianism, philosophy, compulsory education, compulsory attendance, law, legal Author claims this is the classical liberalism perspective: “Going hand in hand with the spread of public education have been compulsory attendance laws, which have forced all children up to a high — and continually increasing — minimum age, to attend either a public school or a private school certified as suitable by the state apparatus. In contrast to earlier decades, when a relatively small proportion of the population went to school in the higher grades, the entire mass of the population has thus been coerced by the government into spending a large portion of the most impressionable years of their lives in public institutions. We could easily have analyzed compulsory attendance laws [p. 120] in our chapter on involuntary servitude, for what institution is more evidently a vast system of incarceration? . . . . . A crucial fallacy of the middle-class school worshippers is confusion between formal schooling and education in general. Education is a lifelong process of learning, and learning takes place not only in school, but in all areas of life. When the child plays, or listens to parents or friends, or reads a newspaper, or works at a job, he or she is becoming educated. Formal schooling is only a small part of the educational process, and is really only suitable for formal subjects of instruction, particularly in the more advanced and systematic subjects. The elementary subjects, reading, writing, arithmetic and their corollaries, can easily be learned at home and outside the school.”
Rothbard, Murray N. 1999; originally published 1971 in magazine The Individualist Education: Free and compulsory. Auburn, AL: Ludwig von Mises Institute; and, retrieved January 8, 2015 from http://mises.org/library/education-free-and-compulsory-1 and retrieved December 29, 2009 from http://mises.org/rothbard/newlibertywhole.asp#contents. http://mises.org/library/education-free-and-compulsory-1 http://mises.org/rothbard/newlibertywhole.asp#contents http://mises.org/books/Education.pdf education, history, philosophy, compulsory attendance, compulsory education, state, statism, Plato, public schooling, schooling, compulsory attendance, compulsory education, history, state power, parents, home, family, philosophy, classical liberalism, libertarianism Reviews the history of State compulsory education/schooling around the world, especially Europe and the United States. Provides many quotes of the early advocates of state control of education and schooling. “ It is clearly absurd to limit the term ‘education’ to a person’s formal schooling He is learning all the time” [p. 2]. “Since each person is a unique individual, it is clear that the best type of formal instruction is that type which is suited to his own particular individuality. Each child has a different intelligence, aptitudes, and interests. Therefore, the best choice of pace, timing, variety, and manner, and of the courses of instruction will differ widely from one child to another” [p. 6-7]. “It is obvious, therefore, that the best type of instruction is individual instruction. A course where one teacher instructs one pupil is clearly by far the best type of course. It is only under such conditions that human potentialities can develop to their greatest degree. It is clear that the formal school, characterized by classes in which one teacher instructs many children, is an immensely inferior system. . . . . . [I]t is evident that every school class must cast all the instruction into one uniform mold. Regardless how the teacher instructs, at what pace, timing, or variety, he is doing violence to each and every one of the children. Any schooling involves misfitting each child into a Procrustean bed of unsuitable uniformity” [p. 7]. “What then shall we say of laws imposing compulsory schooling on every child? . . . . . Whatever the standards that the government imposes for instruction, injustice is done to all . . . . . Obviously, the worst injustice is the prevention of parental teaching of their own children. . . . . . The effect of the State’s compulsory schooling laws is not only to repress the growth of specialized, partly individualized, private schools for the needs of various types of children. It also prevents the education of the child by the people who, in many respects, are best qualified – his parents. . . . . . The key issue in the entire discussion is simply this: shall the parent or the State be the overseer of the child?” [p. 7-9]. Explains the importance of the individuality and uniqueness, the talents and limitations of each person. “The key issue in the entire discussion is simply this: shall the parent or the State be the overseer of the child? [p. 9]. “Furthermore – and this is a most important consideration – for each person to be ‘educated,’ to develop his faculties to the fullest, he needs freedom for this development. We have seen above that freedom from violence is essential to the development of a man’s reason and personality. But the State! The State’s very being rests on violence, on compulsion. ….. The child would have to grow up [p. 10 ends] under the wings of an institution resting on violence and restriction. What sort of peaceful development could take place under such auspices? [p. 10-11]. Retrieved January 1, 2010 from http://mises.org/books/Education.pdf : “We need not linger long over the status of education in ancient Greece and Rome. In Athens, the original practice of compulsory state education later gave way to a voluntary system. In Sparta, on the other hand, an ancient model for modern totalitarianism, the State was organized as one vast military camp, and the children were seized by the State and educated in barracks to the ideal of State obedience. Sparta realized the full logical conclusion of the compulsory system; absolute State control over the "whole child"; uniformity and education in passive obedience to State orders. The most important consequence of this system was that it provided the ideal for Plato, who made this educational system the basis of his ideal State, as set forth in the Republic and the Laws. Plato's "Utopia" was the first model for later despotisms ??? compulsory education and obedience were stressed, there was "communism" of children among the elite "guardians" who also had no private property, and lying was considered a proper instrument for the State to use in its indoctrination of the people.” “The State can adhere strictly to the function of defending everyone from the aggressive violence of everyone else. This will include children as well as adults, since children are potential adults and future freemen. Simple failure to ‘educate,’ or rather, instruct, is no grounds whatever for interference [by the State]” [p. 13]. “The idea that the school should not simply teach [academic] subjects, but should educated the ‘whole child’ in all phases of life, is obviously an attempt to arrogate to the State all the functions of the home. It is an attempt to accomplish the molding of the child without actually seizing him as in the plans of Plato or Owen” [p. 55]. Classical liberal or libertarian theoretical framework, worldview.
Rothermel, Paula 1999, Summer A nationwide study of home education: Early indications and wider implications. Education Now, Issue 24, p. 9. [More information is online at http://www.btinternet.com/~p.bell/] http://www.btinternet.com/~p.bell/ home education, research, academic achievement, reasons, socialization, psychology Studies home-based education in the United Kingdom, involves 1,000 families and focuses on children under age 11. Includes family demographics; finds majority of parents involved in manual and semi-skilled occupations, children from lower socioeconomic families fared better than the others. Reasons for home schooling are studied. Studies literacy of children. "Tentative results suggest that the children assessed, demonstrated high levels of ability and good social skills" [p. 9].
Rothermel, Paula 2004 Home-education: Comparison of home-and school-educated children on PIPS baseline assessments. Journal of Early Childhood Research, 2(3), 273-299. home education, research, early childhood Abstract: “This article reports on the performance of reception-aged, home-educated children. Media reports tend to focus on older home-educated children withdrawing from school but very little is known about younger children many of whom have never been to school. This research sought insight into the learning experience of these young children. The study involved 35 home-educated children aged between four and five years of age, from diverse socio-economic backgrounds. The children were assessed using the Performance Indicators in Primary Schools (Start and End of Reception). Whilst the home-educated children outscored their school counterparts, those from lower socio-economic groups outperformed their middle class peers. It appeared that a flexible approach to education, and a high level of parental attention and commitment, regardless of their socioeconomic group and level of education, seemed the most important factors in the children’s development and progress. Key Words: alternative, attainment autonomous learning, child-centred, early learning, homeschooling, informal learning” “All the children scored good marks, whatever their background and family structure. However, contrary to the findings of Tymms et al. (1997) the homeeducated children from the lower socio-economic groups scored significantly higher than those with professional parents on the Registrar General’s classification (Rose and O’Reilly, 1998)” [p. 293].
Rothermel, Paula Jane 2012 Home educated children’s psychological well being. Estudios Sobre Educación, V. 22, 13-36. home-educated children, homeschooling, research, socialization, psychological problems, validity, validity of instruments measures, Revised Rutter Scale, Goodman Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire Questions validity, for use with homeschooling families and children, of one of the instruments, used in the study. “Abstract: Contrary to popular belief, children educated at home during the early years make better educational progress than children educated at school (Rothermel 2002). However, even if this is recognised, numerous educationists and Local Government officers assert that home educated children are at risk of developing psychological problems. This research used the Revised Rutter Scale (RRS) and the Goodman Strengths & Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ) scales to investigate whether home-educated children experience psychological problems over and above what is considered normal. The research involved 83 home-educated children aged between 4 and 11 years old. The Revised Rutter Scale (RRS) and the Goodman Strengths & Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ) are both widely accepted measures of behaviour difficulties. Whilst the RRS is the more traditional instrument the SDQ has, by virtue of it being freely available, gained popularity in recent years. Whilst the home educated children were judged as psychosocially healthy by the RRS, they were defined by the SDQ as experiencing problems. The research concluded that there were substantial differences between the design and scoring of the two measures and that health professionals using behavioural scales with home-educated children should either avoid doing so altogether, or do so with extreme caution, taking particular note of the standardisation sample. Tests normed on school samples, are very likely to identify children educated out of school as abnormal.” (p. 13). Raises issue of validity of the instruments when used with homeschool children. “These supplementary comments highlight the difficulties involved when home-educators are expected to conform to standards expected from school children. Normally, rating scales might be both parent and teacher completed so that comparisons can be made but for home-educated children no such corroboration is possible” (p. 29). “The results showed that the children did not experience behaviour problems outside the expected parameters. However, the two scales used gave some contrasting results. The RRS rated the children’s behaviour as more problematic (16.6%) than did the SDQ, where just 2.4% of the children were rated as having problems. In addition, the prosocial scales of both instruments were totally at odds with each other. The RRS indicated that the sample was socially adjusted, in contrast with the SDQ outcome showing the children to have poor social adjustment. Closer analysis suggested that the RRS with twice as many statements to rate as the SDQ, was the broader and more useful instrument. Finally, this research sounds a caution to any professional using rating scales with home-educated children. Such scales are mostly likely to be standardised with school children and it is almost inevitable that where school style behaviour is expected, home-educated children are going to be different” (p. 31). Raises important doubts about the validity of instruments developed with institutional school students being used with homeschool children.
Rothermel, Paula. (Ed.) 2015 International perspectives on home education: Do we still need schools? London, United Kingdom: Palgrave Macmillan. homeschooling, home education, international, research, academic achievement, philosophy, policy, politics, social movement, parents, parental rights, parental involvement Table of contents: PART I: HOME-EDUCATION: THE LEARNING PROCESS, 1. Home Educating Parents: Martyrs Or Pathmakers?; Leslie Safran Barson, 2. Reflections On Australian Home Education Research And Vygotskian Learning Theory; Glenda Jackson, 3. Parental and Children's Views on Mathematical Learning within the Home-Environment; Noraisha Yusof, 4. The Informal Acquisition And Development Of Literacy; Alan Thomas and Harriet Pattison, 5. How are New Technologies impacting Elective Home Learners?; Andew McAvoy, PART II: HOME-EDUCATION: TENSIONS AND CRITICISMS, 6. Home Education And Social Integration; Christian Beck, 7. A Case Of Mistaken Identity: Perspectives of Home Educators and State Officials in England, Wales, and Florida, USA; Samantha Eddis, 8. Validity of High Stakes Standardized Test Requirements for Homeschoolers: A Psychometric Analysis; Nicky Hardenbergh, 9. Does Home Education 'Work'? Challenging the Assumptions behind the Home Education Movement; Christopher Lubienski and Jameson Brewer, PART III: POLITICAL CONFLICT, 10. Home Education Versus Compulsory Schooling In Germany; Thomas Spiegler, 11. Home Education: a Human Right?; Daniel Monk, 12. Home Education and the European Convention on Human Rights; Joke Sperling, 13. Home Education: 'A Desperately Dangerous Notion'; Paula Rothermel, PART IV: HOME-EDUCATION: LIFESTYLE AND CHOICE, 14. Home Schooling: the Choice and the Consequences; Ari Neuman and Professor Aharon Aviram, 15. Reflections and Comparative Assessments on Home Education in Three Colombian Families; Erwin Fabian Garica Lopez, PART V: HOME-EDUCATION: MODELS: WAR, POVERTY AND NECESSITY, 16. Home-Based Schools: Increasing the Access of Education to Afghan Girls and Women; Ulrike Hanemann, 17. What can Children Teach Themselves?: Lessons from a Hole in the Wall in India; Sugata Mitra, 18. Black Homeschoolers: Nowhere left to go; Cheryl Fields-Smith, 19. Education as God Wants it; Michael Apple, PART VI: HOME-EDUCATION: CULTURAL AND INTERCULTURAL RELATIONS, 20. Carnival of Blogs: An Example of Facilitating Intercultural Relations in Hispanic Home Education; Madalen Goiria, 21. Homeschooling and the Intercultural World in Which I Live; Carlo Ricci.
Rothstein, Richard 2002, January 2 Augmenting a home-school education. New York Times, p. B11 of New York edition. Retrieved 1/8/02 online http://www.nytimes.com/2002/01/02/national/02LESS.html. http://www.nytimes.com/2002/01/02/national/02LESS.html home education, public cooperation, philosophy Explains the blurring of public and private in homeschooling. Discusses how homeschool students take a few classes or participate in extracurricular activities in public schools.
Rowe, Jonathan 1987 Alternative education. The Christian Science Monitor, April 24, pp. B1-B2, B5.
Rowland, Howard S. 1975 No more school. New York, NY: E.P. Dutton and Co., Inc., 296 p.
Rozon, Gina 2001 Education for self-determination. American Review of Canadian Studies, 31(1-2), 61-70. http://www.questia.com/library/1G1-79408132/education-for-self-determination Aboriginal education, Aboriginal, self-determination, hidden curriculum, home education, home-based education, homeschooling, barriers Presents that state/public education is not promoting self-determination for Aboriginal people, and probably for no one. Is discussing a barrier to homeschooling. “Control over education is seen as an element of Aboriginal self-government. In the Report of the Aboriginal Justice Inquiry of Manitoba [Canada], it states, "When Aboriginal people seek the right to self-government, they mean the right to determine how matters such as health care, education, and child welfare are provided to their people, in their own communities" (Manitoba Public Inquiry 1991, 258). However, if Aboriginal people, in gaining control over education, replicate the schooling system, they will be perpetuating a system that robs people of self-determination. That is, whether it is band-controlled or state controlled, no school system can meet the goals of self-determination in education for Aboriginal people. As a system specifically designed by the dominant society to inhibit such self-determination, it should be scrapped and replaced with a model favoring a home-based education approach [like homeschooling?]. ….. This school system [set up in the mid-nineteenth century in Canada], geared to teach passivity and submission, was aimed not at Aboriginal people, but at the general public. Aboriginal control of education, if it continues to be delivered in a schooled environment, will not eliminate the lessons of this "hidden curriculum." We fail to question school as the only means of delivering education because it is all we have ever known. "For most of us who experienced state schooling, the contours of the educational map were drawn when we arrived. School practices preceded us and neither we, nor those we knew, had experienced an alternative reality" (Curtis 1988, 16). Schooling and education are not synonymous. "The construction of this Educational State was accomplished only through the destruction of a prior organization and the marginalization of the structure of educational possibilities it presented. Education was certainly not synonymous with state schooling in the 1830s and 1840s. That we often equate the two today is another accomplishment of the Educational State" (Curtis 1988, 15 retrieved 7/11/13 from http://www.questia.com/library/1G1-79408132/education-for-self-determination).
Rudner, Lawrence M. 1999 Scholastic achievement and demographic characteristics of home school students in 1998. Educational Policy Analysis Archives, 7(8), https://epaa.asu.edu/index.php/epaa/article/view/543 https://epaa.asu.edu/index.php/epaa/article/view/543 http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v7n8/ home education, academic achievement, demographics, correlations, policy, research and 5/16/08, 4/13/00, and earlier from http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v7n8/). (Analyzes spring of 1998 Iowa Test of Basic Skills (for grades K-8) and Tests of Achievement and Proficiency (for grades 9-12) test scores of 20,760 home-school students from 11,930 families and demographic data about the families. Author never explicitly defines homeschooling in this peer-reviewed journal because everyone knew what it was, parent-directed home-based, private education. On that note, Rudner writes: “This study describes the academic achievement levels and some basic demographic characteristics of a large sample of students and their families. While the academic levels of home school students are described in terms of public and private school norms, this study is not a comparison of home schools with public or private schools. Such comparisons would be fraught with problems. Home schooling is typically one-on-one. Public schools typically have classes with 25 to 30 students and an extremely wide range of abilities and backgrounds. Home school parents are, by definition, heavily involved in their children's education; the same, unfortunately, is not true of all public or private school parents. Home schools can easily pace and adapt their curriculum; public and private schools typically have a mandated scope and sequence. The list of differences could continue” (p. 2). What the author does not say is that these differences are at the core of homeschooling compared to institutional schooling and, therefore, in some ways, a comparison of test scores is appropriate. “It is readily apparent from Table 3.3 that the median scores for home school students are well above their public/private school counterparts in every subject and in every grade. The corresponding percentiles range from the 62nd to the 91st percentile; most percentiles are between the 75th and 85th percentile” [p. 15]. Does not pre-set alpha but does report p level for each finding. Finds significant positive relationship between dependent variable of achievement and years home educated, money spent on homeschooling, family income, and parent’s formal education level/attainment. Finds significant inverse relationship between achievement and amount of TV/television watched. Finds no significant relationship between achievement and student gender, whether the student used a full-service curriculum and whether at least one parent in the household holds a state-issued teaching certificate. “Table 3.6 shows that students who are home schooled for their entire academic life do better than students who have been home schooled for only a few years (F academic life =108.2; df=1,9750; p<.01).” Family income is correlated with achievement [Table 3.10] and at all income levels, and the homeschooled are scoring well above the national average at all income levels; at the lowest income category, the lowest grade level composite score average is the 65th percentile. “As shown in Table 3.11, the achievement levels across groups are remarkably similar. Controlling for grade and parent education level, there is no significant difference in the achievement levels of home school students whose parents are certified and those that are not (F for certification=2.9; df=1,7587; n.s.).” Reports, however, “It is worthy to note that, at every grade level, the mean performance of home school students whose parents do not have a college degree is much higher than the mean performance of students in public schools” (p. 25). “The correlation between money spent on educational materials and income is significant (r=.24, p <.01), indicating that this effect may be due to family characteristics rather than expenditures” (p. 22). Personal communication, December 22, 1998, Larry Rudner says in this study he examines the ITBS scores of about 21,000 home educated students, nationwide; he finds that “At each grade level, the percentile corresponding to the median scaled score was typically in the 70-80th percentile range [personal communication, 12/22/98]. In the discussion section, he writes, “Even with our conservative approach, the achievement levels of the home school students in this study are exceptional. Within each grade level and each skill area, the median scores for home school students fell between the 70th and 80th percentile of students nationwide and between the 60th and 70th percentile of Catholic/Private school students. For younger students, this is a one year lead. By the time home school students are in 8th grade, they are four years ahead of their public/private school counterparts. Our results are consistent with previous studies of the achievement of home school students.” Rudner then reviews past research. “Parent Education Levels. The National Assessment of Educational Progress has consistently shown marked differences in the performance levels of students nationwide as a function of parent's educational level. Similar differences appear in the performance levels of home school students. As shown in Table 3.12, at every grade level, children of college graduates out perform children whose parents do not have a college degree (F=566.4; df=2,9744; p < .01). There is also a significant interaction between grade and parent education (F=8.7; df=18,9744; p < .01), indicating that the effect of parent education is more pronounced in some grades. It is worthy to note that, at every grade level, the mean performance of home school students whose parents do not have a college degree is much higher than the mean performance of students in public schools. Their percentiles are mostly in the 65th to 69th percentile range.” “Major findings: Achievement. Almost 25% of home school students are enrolled one or more grades above their age-level peers in public and private schools. Home school student achievement test scores are exceptionally high. The median scores for every subtest at every grade (typically in the 70th to 80th percentile) are well above those of public and Catholic/Private school students. On average, home school students in grades 1 to 4 perform one grade level above their age-level public/private school peers on achievement tests. The achievement test score gap between home school students and public/private school students starts to widen in grade 5. Students who have been home schooled their entire academic life have higher scholastic achievement test scores than students who have also attended other educational programs. There are no meaningful differences in achievement by gender, whether the student is enrolled in a full-service curriculum, or whether a parent holds a state issued teaching certificate. There are significant achievement differences among home school students when classified by amount of money spent on education, family income, parent education, and television viewing” (p. 27-28). “These comparisons between home school students and students nationwide must be interpreted with a great deal of caution. This was not a controlled experiment. Students were not randomly assigned public, private or home schools. As a result, the reported achievement differences between groups do not control for background differences in the home school and general United States population and, more importantly, cannot be attributed to the type of school a child attends. ….. This study simply shows that those parents choosing to make a commitment to home schooling are able to provide a very successful academic environment” (p. 29).
Rudner, Lawrence M. 1999, September The scholastic achievement of home school students. ERIC/AE Digest. http://www.ed.gov/databases/ERIC_Digests/ed435709.html home education, academic achievement, demographics Source: ERIC Clearinghouse on Assessment and Evaluation Washington DC. ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED435709. Retrieved 7/25/01 online http://www.ed.gov/databases/ERIC_Digests/ed435709.html. Summarizes Rudner’s 1999 nationwide study published in 1999 in Educational Policy Analysis Archives.
Rudner, Lawrence M. 2002, October 10 The achievement levels of New York home schooled students. Available from author at Graduate Management Admission Council, McLean VA 22102, www.gmac.com. http://www.gmac.com home education, research, academic achievement, New York “It is readily apparent from Tables 3 and 4 and Figure 1 that the median scores for home school students in New York and the nation are well above their public school counterparts in every subject and in every grade. The corresponding percentiles range form the 69th to 98st [sic] percentile; most percentiles are in the 80th to 85th percentile range” [p. 5]).
Ruf, Deborah. (Ed.) 2007, Fall Homeschooling for the gifted [special issue]. Mensa Research Journal, 38(3), 1-96. home education, talented, gifted, special needs, research, opinion, philosophy Dedicates entire issue to various aspects of homeschooling and its relationship to gifted and talented students. Comprised of several articles.
Rumberger, Russell W. 1987 High school dropouts: A review of issues and evidence. Review of Educational Research, 57(2), 101-121. dropout rate, drop out, predictors, research "Particular family-related factors associated with dropping out include low educational and occupational attainment levels of parents, low family income, speaking a language other than English in the home, single-parent families, and the absence of learning materials and opportunities in the home..." (p. 110). In addition, poor academic test scores are clearly related to dropping out; based on Rumberger's findings, research findings on home education would suggest that the home educated would be very likely to complete high school if they were viewed as part of the general population.
Rupp, Becky 1986 Home schooling: Families have many reasons for educating their children at home. Country Journal, 13(12), 67-74. Some history and examples of home schooling. Summary of 43 questionnaires returned by home schoolers across the U. S.; concerning topics such as ages of children, reasons for home schooling, methods used, social experiences for children, scores on standardized achievement tests. Written in conversational, human-interest story format.
Rushdoony, Rousas J. 1963 The messianic character of American education. Nutley, NJ: Craig Press. http://www.firstthings.com/ftissues/ft0108/opinion/edgar.html education, philosophy, religion, worldview, public schools, home education, private schools, Christianity Circa 2003, available from Ross House Books, Vallecito, CA “In all of this, education becomes radically divorced from learning [academics, reading, writing, math] and becomes an instrument of state and a means of social advancement. Academic freedom is an impossibility, because the laissez-faire presupposition inherent in it, i.e., the independence of education and learning from the state and its own integrity as a separate sphere of activity, is totally rejected. In the United States, and throughout the Western world, there has been an equally strong emphasis on the group or the state, and on education in terms of utility to the state or group, as against the traditional faith in education in terms of utility to God” (p. 309). “The increasing hostility to local control of education in the United States, and the demand for federal aid, has in part behind it a distrust of the local power of anti-democratic and methodologically uneconomic and non-functional groups, such as the family, the church, local clubs, lodges, business and other interests” (p. 311-312). “But man cannot live by bread alone, nor by methodology alone. As a result, the exaltation of the group, whether humanity, democracy, the proletariat of the folk, has steadily become religious, and the state school a religious institution. As pointed out in Intellectual Schizophrenia, the public school is the established church of today and a substitute institution for the medieval church and dedicated to the same monolithic conception of society. Some years ago, Dewey very candidly dis- [p. 314 ends, discussed] cussed “Education as a Religion”” (p. 315). “The issue lies deeper, however. If education is in any sense a preparation for life, then its concern is religious. If education is at all concerned with truth, it is again religious. If education is vocational, then it deals with calling, a basically religious concept. It would be absurd to reduce preparation for life, truth and calling to an exclusively religious meaning in any parochial sense, but it is obvious that these and other aspects of education are inescapably religious. As Whitehead observed, “The essence of education is that it be religious”” (p. 315). “Statist education increasingly assumes that (1) the child is the child of the state or the property of the state, which can therefore interfere extensively with parental authority. (2) The state “priesthood” of educators are best able to rear the child and prepare him for life, viewed as statist life. (3) Statist education is alone “objective” and hence true, the state having the impartiality and transcendence of a god. Statist education is thus entrance into the true catholicity of the civil religion of the modern state. It is the religious ideal of the French Revolution realized” (p. 323). “Many have credited Rushdoony with being an early inspiration behind the home school movement. He certainly was the strongest possible advocate of religious education, consistently favoring private over public schooling. In The Messianic Character of American Education (1963) Rushdoony decried the American public school system, tracing its ideology back to John Dewey and other secular thinkers who believed in the natural goodness of children and the role that education could play in liberalizing society” [in William Edgar, The Passing of R. J. Rushdoony, 2001, First Things, no. 115 (August/September 2001): 24-25, retrieved 3/18/03 online http://www.firstthings.com/ftissues/ft0108/opinion/edgar.html]).
Rushdoony, Rousas John 1961 Intellectual schizophrenia: Culture, crisis and education. Vallecito, CA: Ross House Books. education, schooling, statism, public schooling, philosophy, presuppositions, state schooling, purpose of education Author is “… able to identify the basic contradiction that pervades a secular society that rejects God’s sovereignty but still needs law and order, justice, science, and meaning to life. Secular man wants to use the things of creation while denying their creator without. ….. And so, modern man has become schizophrenic. He wants to assert his autonomy while rejecting the divine order that gives meaning to life” (p. iii, in foreword by Samuel Blumenfeld).”
Rushdoony, Rousas John 1982 Larceny in the heart: The economics of Satan and the inflationary state [first published under the title The Roots of Inflation]. Vallecito, CA: Ross House Books. private education, economy, inflation, state power, indoctrination, home education “The same is true of modern man’s approach to inflation: the evil one is Washington D.C., the international bankers, or anyone other than themselves. Men whose lives are geared to inflationary living, and who run from one conference to another, unconcerned about the destruction to their country by inflation but eager to learn of a new way to make money out of inflation, will with consummate hypocrisy sit back and blame the politicians or bankers for inflation. True, politicians and bankers have their guilt, but who demands inflation from them by their envy, their debt-living, and their heart full of larceny? Is it not the voters? (p. 54)” “The modern state seeks total power by means of the control, among other things, of two key areas of life, education and economics. Statist control of either is a great moral evil. By controlling education, the state seeks to reshape the minds of future citizens into a predetermined mold. The increasing pattern of totalitarianism is power through control of education” (p. 63). “Home education, if only in the field of economics, will determine futur5e events. Our young learn, in the home, what it is like to live in a debt-free family, or in a family environment burdened by debt ….. Teach economics in the home. This is the old “hand that rocks the cradle” theory, but that hand dies not of necessity have to be, nor should it be, an exclusively feminine hand. You men should do more cradle rocking” [p. 144, in appendix written by Elizabeth McEachern Miller]. Author is forthright about his Christian presuppositions and explains that all other philosophies of economics and education are also based on select presuppositions, that are often hidden by those holding them.
Russell, Glenn 2003 The potential and problems of virtual schooling. Welsh Journal of Education, 12(1), 40-52. http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/uwp/wjoe/2003/00000012/00000001/art00005 virtual schooling, Wales, problems, homeschooling, socialization I am fairly sure author refers to homeschooling but it probably does not receive significant attention in this article. “Abstract: Virtual schools enable students to replace some or all of their traditional classes with a virtual equivalent, and their continued growth prompts a reflection on their advantages and disadvantages. Factors such as socialization, pastoral care, learning style, cost, access and equity, views of school education, democracy and computer technology all help to explain the possible consequences of implementing virtual schools. It may be necessary to consider what skills, knowledge and values students should have in a future society before it is possible to decide whether virtual schools are ultimately beneficial” (retrieved 7/11/13 from http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/uwp/wjoe/2003/00000012/00000001/art00005).
Russell, Terry 1993, June Cross-validation of a multivariate path analysis of predictors of home school student academic achievement. Unpublished competency paper [for doctorate] submitted to the Faculty of the School of Social Work, University of Pittsburgh, PA. research, home education, academic achievement Provides sophisticated path analysis to determine whether factors such as family income, parents' educational attainment, grade level, number of years home educated, prior attendance at a conventional school, parents' training in how to home educate, religious content of curriculum, amount of structure in the home education, and hours per week spent in academic instruction affect academic achievement. Re-analysis of data gathered by Jon Wartes.
Russell, Terry 1994 Cross-validation of a multivariate path analysis of predictors of home school student academic achievement. Home School Researcher, 10(1), 1-13. academic achievement, home education, correlations, effects, multivariate analysis, peer-reviewed; academic achievement, home education, correlations, effects, multivariate analysis, peer-reviewed Similar to Russell, T., 1993, June. Concludes: “Most of the variables in this study [i.e., family income, parent’s level of education, student’s grade level, number of years student home educated, previous type of education [i.e., public or private school], whether the parent has had training in home schooling, amount of religious content in the curriculum, amount of structure in the home schooling, and number of hours per week spent in home schooling] were not found to be predictors or causes of home school student academic achievement” [p. 9]. Concludes family income is not a predictor of achievement; “... parent’s level of education is the single best predictor of academic achievement for home school students, although the effect is not large” [p. 10]; student’s grade level is not a predictor; number of years home schooled is not a predictor; previous type of education was a weak predictor; parent training had a slight effect; amount of religious content had no effect; amount of structure had some small, positive effect on achievement; number of hours spent per week in home schooling had no effect. Peer-reviewed. “The largest potential direct effect on academic achievement found in the analysis of subset A was parent's education with a path coefficient of .23, (p < .01; see Figure 1), followed by degree of structure (path coefficient of .22, p < .01), and hours per week (path coefficient of -.22, p < .01). Hours per week, interestingly, had a negative direct effect. This seems to indicate that an increase in the hours per [p. 5 ends] week causes a slight decrease in test scores, or that slower learners need more time, but at this point it was premature to speculate since the intermediate results remained to be tested on data subset B” (p. 6). “Of the remaining direct effects, the type of previous education being private school had a negative path coefficient next highest to the three just mentioned, -.20. As a dummy variable, this was coded as a one (1) for those who were previously private schooled and all others were coded as zero (0). Thus, students who were previously private schooled scored slightly lower than others as a group, in the pre-cross-validated analysis A. The two remaining direct variables are having always been home schooled, with a small path coefficient of .08, and student's current grade level, with a path coefficient of .05. These are low and are not statistically significant, but it was decided at the outset that any path coefficients over .05 would remain in the model” (p. 6).
Rust, V. D., & Reed, F. 1979 Home teaching and Herbart. Educational Horizons, 58, 75-81. Account of philosopher Herbart's views on
Rymarz, Richard 2011 A study of Albertan Catholic homeschoolers: Some implications for intergenerational transfer of religious culture within families. INTAMS review: Journal for the Study of Marriage & Spirituality, 17(1), 48-60, DOI: https://doi.org/10.2143/INT.17.1.2126631. https://doi.org/10.2143/INT.17.1.2126631 homeschooling, home education, research, Catholic, Catholicism, Roman Catholic, family, religion Abstract: Contemporary culture in post-industrial Western societies places great pressure on the capacity of the family to act as a conduit for intergenerational transfer of religious belief and practice. This seems to be an especial problem for Catholic families attempting to move, by way of functional specialties, from the strong ideology of Catholic family life to an effective praxis. The paper explores a particular sub-type of Catholic family, namely, those who elect to homeschool their children. By examining homeschooling families from Alberta, Canada, the capacity of the family to act as both a religious community of practise and as an agent that reinforces religious plausibility is explored. Homeschooling families are described as communities that are intentional and well networked.” “This study examines an alternate structure for intergenerational transfer of religious culture. It asks the question: Can Catholic families who follow unconventional practices such as homeschooling provide one means of passing on religious culture in a world where more conventional models are under considerable stress?” Uses qualitative methods, grounded theory approach, including the in-depth interview. Several themes emerged, such as the following: intentional parenting, networked individuals that developed a community of practice, “The mothers in this study were responsible not only for the day-to-day logistics of homeschooling (and here there was a considerable variation in practice); but these women also took on the role as the educational visionaries in the family …” “In nurturing religious commitment, the intersection of intention, belief, and action is critically important. The participants in this study seemed to demonstrate the presence of these formative factors. This is not to say all are utilized, but at least at a structural level they exist; and, more to the point, because of the life design of homeschooling parents these factors can be used. In Taylor’s terms, the functional specialties that allow for the realization of ideology are available.”
Sacken, Donald M. 1988, May Regulating nonpublic education: A search for just law and policy. American Journal of Education, 96(3), 394-420. Constitutional Law, Court Litigation, Parent Rights, School Attendance Legislation, State Standards A listing of state policies concerning both private and home education with criticisms of the courts about the protection of parental interests.
Safley, Lee 1998, September 11 Minorities out to consider home-schooling. The State [newspaper of Columbia, SC]. (Available online at www.thestate.com/opinion/opcolumn/safley.htm) http://www.thestate.com/opinion/opcolumn/safley.htm home education, opinion, minorities, minority, research “... perhaps it is time for more in the minority community to examine why parents of all races choose to home-school.” Suggests that not many minorities have considered home schooling because (a) “Most minority parents have not been presented with the opportunity to seriously consider the home-school option. They have not witnessed first-hand this tremendous opportunity to teach character and valuable life lessons, while achieving academic and social success with their children” and (b) personnel in “... the education establishment have been quick to discourage parents from considering this very successful method of education ...” even though the same persons in the education establishment say that parental involvement is necessary for a student’s success. Cites Brian Ray’s research.
Safran, Leslie 2009 Situated adult learning: The home education neighbourhood group. The Journal of Unschooling and Alternative Learning, 3(2), Issue #6. home education, homeschooling, research, situated learning, United Kingdom “Abstract: Many families who home educate turn to a neighbourhood home education group for support, resources and guidance. The purpose of this paper is to first outline briefly the context of home education in the UK and US, to analyse three different types of home education neighbourhood group as communities of practice and then to theorise how these parents learn some of what it is to be home educators through participation in such groups as members. The analysis is based on evidence from long-term home educating parents collected through thirty-four in-depth interviews and the Community of Practice framework (Wenger, 1998). It will be argued that although communities of practice have variable features depending on the type of neighbourhood home education group a parent joins, they all engage in a form of collective situated life learning which helps transform parents to the point where they become ‘home educators’.”
Sagario, Dawn 2004, December 14 Home-schooled do well at Iowa's universities. Des Moines Register [newspaper], retrieved 12/14/04 online http://desmoinesregister.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20041214/NEWS02/412140374/1004. http://desmoinesregister.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20041214/NEWS02/412140374/1004 home education, college, admissions, academic achievement, adulthood “Two Iowa universities say they've seen an increase in the number of home-schoolers applying to college, and the students are doing academically as well, or better, than those from traditional high schools.”) .
Saghir, Aneela 2011, July 29 An introduction to homeschooling for Muslim parents. A master’s [M.A.] thesis in Education, California State University, Sacramento. http://csus-dspace.calstate.edu/xmlui/handle/10211.9/1252 homeschooling, home education, reasons, religion, philosophy, Muslim, Islam “This study examines factors that Muslim parents use in choosing to homeschool their children and determines if homeschooling offers a competitive option compared to public or private schooling. Additionally, it explores the effects of home-schooling in the area of academia, social values, and moral and religious world views. Sources of Data The study utilizes interview data from ten Muslim homeschooling mothers and from two Muslim homeschooling organizations. Conclusions Reached The interview results validated much of the existing research on the reasons why parents choose to homeschool their children. The interview results also identified four major reasons for homeschooling: lack of academic rigor, lack of individualized attention, negative social environment and lack of religious teaching in public and private schools” [Abstract retrieved 2/15/2012 from http://csus-dspace.calstate.edu/xmlui/handle/10211.9/1252
Salganik, L. H., & Karwett, N. 1982 Voluntarism and governance in education. Sociology of Education, 55, 152-161. Discussion on the differences between private and public education, with emphasis placed on the importance of the voluntary nature of the relationships between private schools and the families of their students.
Saligman, Jean 1988 From homespun to Harvard (Colfax family). Newsweek, 111, February.
San Diego Country Office of Education, 1988 Home education parent handbook. San Diego, CA: San Diego County Office of Education.
Sauer, James Leslie 1986 The new little one-room school. Eternity, April, 13-17.
Saunders, M. K. 2009-2010 Previously homeschooled college freshmen: their first year experiences and persistence rates. Journal of College Student Retention, 11, 77-100. Peer-reviewed
Saunders, William L., Jr. 2010 Committees gone wild: How U.N. bureaucrats are turning ‘human rights’ against the family. The Family in America: A Journal of Public Policy. Retrieved 2/10/11 from http://www.profam.org/Special/thc.saunders.fia.winter10.pdf. http://www.profam.org/Special/thc.saunders.fia.winter10.pdf family, education, education choice, parental rights, policy, law, international Among other things, addresses the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights and quotes from it. “Echoing the recognition that the family is prior to the state, the Declaration acknowledges that parents are the primary educators of their children: “Parents have a prior right to choose the kind of education that shall be given to their children.” (Article 26.3) This clear recognition of the priority of the wishes of parents regarding the education of their own children over any designs of the state is reinforced by Article 16, which calls upon the state to protect the family. If the state presumes to usurp the rights of parents to choose the education of their children, it damages the family, violates its own obligations as outlined in the Declaration, and undermines the foundation of a just society and state” [p. 54]. “After all, the European and Asian totalitarian regimes—whose actions sparked the Second World War—came to, and remained in, power by a systematic denial of political and civil rights and freedoms, such as press and speech. What about parental rights in education? Professor Glendon provides the answer: ‘In the article on education [26] . . . [the drafting committee of the Declaration] made an important change, influenced directly by recollections of the National Socialist regime’s efforts to turn Germany’s renowned educational system into a mechanism for indoctrinating the young with the government’s program. . . . After Beaufort of the Netherlands recalled the ways in which German schools had been used to undermine the role of parents, a third paragraph was added: “Parents have a prior right to choose the kind of education that shall be given to their children.’5 In other words, one of the most important lessons drawn from the experience of the Second World War is that parental choice in education is a fundamental plank of international peace and security. To combat totalitarianism and to protect human freedom, the framers of the Declaration wanted to ensure that parents, not bureaucrats or social engineers, have the final word in the education of their own children” [p. 54-55].
Savage, Patricia 1982 In love with learning: A homeschool story. Mothering, Fall, 85-87.
Scale, Mark-Shane E. 2017 Internet Access to Caribbean Government Information on Homeschooling: A Preliminary Case Study of Barbados. Africology: The Journal of Pan African Studies 10(10), 70-87. Retrieved January 10, 2018 from http://www.jpanafrican.org/docs/vol10no10/10.10-7-Scale-final.pdf http://www.jpanafrican.org/docs/vol10no10/10.10-7-Scale-final.pdf homeschooling, Barbados, government, access to information, transparency, law, legal “Abstract: This article reports on a preliminary study investigating access to government information obtainable on the Internet about homeschooling in Barbados. Barbados has one of the highest Internet usage in the English-speaking Caribbean and ranks high in the region in e-government services. As such, a search query aimed at obtaining government information on homeschooling in Barbados was conducted of both Government Web sites and a popular search engine. The central issue was whether there was access to government information on legally homeschooling in Barbados. The study utilized a qualitative approach to analysing and studying the information sources retrieved from the search results of the top ten sources retrieved from an Internet search as well as the results from the Government portals and websites. The findings indicate gaps in Barbadian government information availability and dissemination via Internet on homeschooling that restrict citizens from accessing information for legal homeschooling. It also reveals that gaps in the government provided information is filled by non-government providers on the Internet including those that provide inaccurate information to the public” (p. 70).
Schabner, Dean 2001, August 10 Looking for an answer: Home schooling offers alternative, challenge for parents and kids. Published 8/10/01 and retrieved 8/20/01 online http://abcnews.go.com:80/sections/us/DailyNews/home_school010810.html. http://abcnews.go.com:80/sections/us/DailyNews/home_school010810.html home education, opinion News article mentions opinions on negative and positive aspects of homeschooling. Tells of research showing the home educated perform better than average in academic achievement.
Schacter, John 2000 Does individual tutoring produce optimal learning? American Educational Research Journal, 37(3), 801-829. tutoring, tutor, academic achievement Examines “... relative impact on student achievement when students were paired with one other student or a large group of same-age peers, and when students worked with a teacher or did not ... in a computer-supported collaborative learning context. The results reported here demonstrated that access to a teacher or a large group of same-aged peers were equally potent learning resources in computer supported [sic] collaborative learning environments. Analyses further confirmed that students working in groups and students individually tutored by a teacher learned and achieved more on a battery of tests than children who worked with only one other child partner. These results differ substantially from a large body of research reported to date ...” [abstract, p. 801].
Schaeffer, Adam 2010, March 10 They spend what? The real cost of public schools. Policy Analysis, Number 662. Washington, DC: Cato Institute. Retrieved Decemb 10, 2010 from http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa662.pdf. http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa662.pdf cost, finance, economics, public schools, private schools, per pupil expenditure “Executive Summary. Although public schools are usually the biggest item in state and local budgets, spending figures provided by public school officials and reported in the media often leave out major costs of education and thus understate what is actually spent. To document the phenomenon, this paper reviews district budgets and state records for the nation’s five largest metro areas and the District of Columbia. It reveals that, on average, per-pupil spending in these areas is 44 percent higher than officially reported. Real spending per pupil ranges from a low of nearly $12,000 in the Phoenix area schools to a high of nearly $27,000 in the New York metro area. The gap between real and reported per-pupil spending ranges from a low of 23 percent in the Chicago area to a high of 90 percent in the Los Angeles metro region. To put public school spending in perspective, we compare it to estimated total expenditures in local private schools. We find that, in the areas studied, public schools are spending 93 percent more than the estimated median private school. Citizens drastically underestimate current per-student spending and are misled by official figures. Taxpayers cannot make informed decisions about public school funding unless they know how much districts currently spend. And with state budgets stretched thin, it is more crucial than ever to carefully allocate every tax dollar. This paper therefore presents model legislation that would bring transparency to school district budgets and enable citizens and legislators to hold the K–12 public education system accountable” [p. 1].
Schaeffer, Francis A. 1982 A Christian manifesto (revised edition). [Original, 1981] Westchester, IL: Crossway Books. worldview, philosophy, religion, politics, law, government, education, civil disobedience, Christian worldview, biblical worldview, abortion “In the United States the materialistic, humanistic world view is being taught exclusively in most state schools. But then, those holding the humanistic world [p. 111 ends] view move to control (through the curricula and other ways) the Christian or other private schools – even though these schools were set up at private cost by the parents in order to give their children an education based on the world view of a universe created by a God who objectively exists” (p. 112). “As a result the humanistic, material-energy, chance world view is completely intolerant when it presents itself through the political institutions and especially through the schools. In his book Leftism, Erik von Kuehnelt-Leddihn writes that as humanism begins to dominate the state ‘religion is then removed from the market place and the school, later from other domains of public life. The state will not tolerate any gods [p. 112 ends] besides itself.’ The school is their special target” (p. 113). “This principle is that there is a bottom line [in italics] that must be faced squarely if the state is not to become all-powerful and usurp God’s primacy. We must recognize that there is a bottom line if we are to have real freedom of thought and action at the present time – even if, happily, we never reach that bottom line [last 26 words in italics]. If we have not faced the possibility of civil disobedience, if needed, our thinking and action at the present time will lack the freedom they should have” [p. 126].
Schalinske, Connie 1999 Home schooling and art education in Ohio: A case study. Doctoral (Ph.D.) disseration, The Ohio State University, Columbus. home education, research, art education, qualitative and quantitative data “This study investigated the demographic characteristics of the Ohio and urban central Ohio home schooling populations and examined art education practices within the home school setting. Case study methodology was selected incorporating: technology-assisted research; participant / observation; interviewing; and survey research methods. The qualitative and quantitative data created a descriptive picture of Ohio home schoolers and art education. The research questions derived for this study were: 1) What are the basic characteristics of the Ohio population and urban central Ohio population of home schooled families? 2) How do these characteristics compare or differ from a nationwide study that examined the basic demographics of home schooled families? 3) Who teaches homeschoolers art and how often? 4) How are instruction and learning assessed? 5) What community and curriculum resources were utilized? and 6) What art media and content areas were utilized? [p. 1]. In the state of Ohio, it was found that there is a large group of home educators who belong to the Christian Home Educators of Ohio (CHEO). In general, the CHEG population reflected many similar characteristics reported in a national study. Within the central urban Ohio home school population, family demographics were unlike the statewide and national samples. Dissimilar characteristics were found in the areas of: mothers’ education; mothers’ occupation; formal academic instruction; race! ethnicity; and reasons for homeschooling. A primary issue of this study, was how the Ohio home education population complied with and/or interpreted the rule for including ‘fine arts?’ This study determined how home schooling parents defined the inclusion of art instruction in the home education of their child(ren). Eindings were categorized in the areas of: art instruction; teacher training; frequency of instruction; community and curriculum resources; technology, art expression/studio orientation, art history and response to art, and assessment. By creating a general picture of Ohio home educators with a clear focus on art education, it was possible to uncover potential important implications for art education and suggestions for future research. Implications for art educators included an emerging demand for home schooling art education programs, services and resources. Future research and inquiry included investigating Ohio home schooling populations such as: the “unschooled;” urban mothers; minorities; art teachers; and student artists” [p. 2].
Schemmer, Beverly Ann Sollenberger 1985 Case studies of four families engaged in home education. Dissertation Abstracts International, 46, 2560A-2561A or University Microfilms International No. 8525190. Doctoral dissertation, Ball State University, Muncie, IN. "The purpose of the study was to give a description of the curriculum and methods used in the home schools of home educators and to evaluate by means of case studies the effects of home education upon those included in the study" [p. 2560A]. Answers were given to five research questions: (1) Achievement - "Forty percent of the home educated students scored equal to the median national score." (2) Achievement gain per year - "Students showed inconsistencies in average gains for the tear." (3) Curricula and methods - "Three of the four families used curriculum materials commercially prepared for home educators." (4) Reasons for home schooling - "The parent educators appeared motivated by socialization concerns and desires for values training." (5) Legal actions - "Legal action was taken against one of the four families in the study" [p. 2561A].
Schepis, Ty; McCabe, Sean Esteban, & Ford, Jason A. 2020 Substance Use and Mental Health in Homeschooled Adolescents in the United States. Adolescent health brief, 67(5), 718-721. schepis@txstate.edu “Abstract: ….. Results: Substance use rates were lowest in adolescents at low dropout risk, with significantly lower past-year prescription opioid misuse, tobacco use, nonmarijuana illicit drug use, and nicotine dependence rates than homeschooled adolescents. Psychopathology treatment prevalence was lowest in homeschooled adolescents. Those at risk for dropout had the highest rates of substance use.” What is the education-sector treatment? “The independent variable was past-year educational status: (1) homeschooled; (2) public/private school, low dropout risk; (3) public/private school, at risk for dropout; and (4) not in school. Homeschooled adolescents were “homeschooled at any time” in the past year” [circa 2015??] (p. 719). That is a dubious homeschool treatment, any time during past year. Findings differ from Vaughn et al (2015).
Schimmel, David, & Fisher, Louis 1977 The rights of parents in the education of their children. Columbia, MD: The National Committee for Citizens in Education.
Schlafly, Phyllis (Ed.) 1984 Child abuse in the classroom. Alton, IL: Pere Marquette Press. public schooling, public education, psychological abuse, experimentation, religion, values, philosophy, moral education “This book consists of selected excerpts from the Official Transcript of Proceedings before the United States Department of Education in the matter of the Proposed Regulations to Implement the Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment (Section 439 of the General Education Provisions Act, 20 U.S. Code s1232h), also known as the Hatch Amendment. Section 439(a) was enacted in 1974, and Section 439(b) was enacted in 1978” [p. 5]. “More than 1,300 pages of testimony were recorded by court reporters as parents, public school teachers, and interested citizens spelled out their eye-witness accounts of the psychological abuse of children in the public schools. They related how classroom courses have confused schoolchildren about life, about standards of behavior, about moral choices, about religious loyalties, and about relationships with parents and peers. There is no good way to summarize the anger and disappointment expressed by these grieving parent about what is going on inside public schools today. Each testimony should be read itself to learn the specific facts of what has actually happened – and to hear the authentic expressions of parental love overlaid with indignation at what is being done “in the name of education.”” [p. 11]. “These Hearings explain why the American people are so dissatisfied with schools today. These Hearings explain why we have 23 million adult illiterates who graduated from public schools, and why young people are experiencing high rates of teenage suicide, loneliness, premarital sex, and pregnancies. These Hearing explain how schools have alienated children from their parents, from traditional morality such as the Ten Commandments, and from our American heritage. These Hearings explain why children are so emotionally and morally confused and why, in the apt colloquialism, they need to “search for their identity.” These Hearings explain what children have been doing in their classrooms instead of learning to read, write, spell, add, subtract, and the essentials of history, geography, and civics. These Hearings explain how children learn in school to be “sexually active”, take illegal drugs, repudiate their parents, and rationalize immoral and anti-social conduct when it “feels” good in a particular “situation”. These Hearings speak with the thunderous voice of hundreds of parents who are angry at how their children have been emotionally, morally, and intellectually abused by psychological and behavioral experiments during classroom hours when the [p. 12 ends] parents thought their children were being taught basic knowledge and skills. Parents are indignant at the way that educator “change agents,” spending federal tax dollars, have used children as guinea pigs for fads and experiments that have been substituted for real learning” [p. 13].
Schlissel, Steve M. 2003 The end of home-schooling. Published 1/17/03, retrieved 2/10/03 & 6/17/04 online http://www.christianculture.com/cgi-local/npublisher/viewnews.cgi?category=3&id=1042827993. http://www.christianculture.com/cgi-local/npublisher/viewnews.cgi?category=3&id=1042827993 home education, private schools, Christian education, philosophy, public schools, history This essay reportedly appeared originally in the Dec., 2002 issue of Christian Culture. “[Christian] Covenant community schools were nearly obliterated by public education. However, the spirit of these schools was kept alive by the home-schooling movement. And the movement will reach its goal with the revivification of covenant community schools. But just as some Jewish Christians violently opposed the end of the Law, so we can expect some home-schoolers to militantly oppose the movement coming to fruition in a new (recovered and improved) norm. The purpose of this article is to encourage us to see home-schooling as a necessary but transitional phenomenon. It is also offered to encourage rejoicing, not consternation, at the thought of covenant community schools being the goal.” Mistakenly asssumes that all or most of the modern homeschool movement was reactionary and not proactive, or that it cannot be proactive. Assumes that parent-led home-based education is not the biblical norm for educating children. In his section “downsides,” he writes, “But the downsides are no less real. Heading the list is the dreadful inefficiency of the home-schooling enterprise” and in this section shows a reductionistic, humanistic, pragmatic, and modern psychological orientation toward academic education and little understanding of home-based education as a way of life and of discipling children and youth in the ways of God. Promotes the claim that institutional schools were once very good from a pedagogical and religious worldview perspective and wants to see the homeschool movement end in a revival of such schools.
Schmidt, Steven 1989 A report of North Carolina home school parents on certain variables associated with social studies instruction. A master's (M.Ed.) thesis, Wake Forest University.
Schnorbus, Frank 2014 Whose children? Rethinking schools and education. Home School Researcher, 30(1), p. 1-6. schools, public education, compulsory education, economic externalities, cameralism, Prussia, German schools, social contract, progressive education, homeschooling “Abstract: Schooling and education are defined, and then the Christian origin of our modern school system in the 17th century Kingdom of Prussia is reviewed. The social and economic values of the Pietist school graduate were recognized by Prussian administrators, prompting these cameralists to engineer the state takeover of all schools within the kingdom. Other countries sought to duplicate the Prussian system, but were forced to manufacture externality arguments to justify state compulsion in a free society. These externality arguments, the difference between selective and universal compulsion, as well as the often-conflicting educational objectives of parents, the Church, and the state are discussed. The impact of the progressive movement and the resulting strangulation of true education are surveyed before concluding that the current public school system cannot be repaired, but must be replaced” (p. 1).
Schnorbus, Frank 2014 Whose children? Rethinking schools and education. Home School Researcher, 30(1), 1-6. schools, public education, compulsory education, home education, homeschooling, economic externalities, cameralism, Prussia, German schools, social contract, progressive education “Schooling and education are defined, and then the Christian origin of our modern school system in the 17th century Kingdom of Prussia is reviewed. The social and economic values of the Pietist school graduate were recognized by Prussian administrators, prompting these cameralists to engineer the state takeover of all schools within the kingdom. Other countries sought to duplicate the Prussian system, but were forced to manufacture externality arguments to justify state compulsion in a free society. These externality arguments, the difference between selective and universal compulsion, as well as the often-conflicting educational objectives of parents, the Church, and the state are discussed. The impact of the progressive movement and the resulting strangulation of true education are surveyed before concluding that the current public school system cannot be repaired, but must be replaced” (p. 1). “The objectives of all parties in our American society can be better attained if we return to the principles of individual responsibility and liberty by disestablishing the state monopoly in education. John Hood states, “By any reasonable measure, America's monopolistic, bureaucratic, over-regulated system of public schools is woefully unprepared to meet the challenges of the twenty-first century” (Hood, 1993, p. 50), and concludes that political, business, and education leaders should be discussing replacing, not reforming, the present system. His advice should be heeded. Compulsion and coercion, the trademarks of totalitarian governments and our government public school systems, are anathema to true education” (p. 5).
Schoenthaler, Stephen 2000 Violence and behavioral problems linked to diet. Journal of Longevity, 6(2), 6-9. education, nutrition, ADD, ADHD, diet, achievement, intelligence Concludes that some research suggests that simple nutritional treatment with vitamins and minerals in diet may reduce violent behavior of children, raise their I.Q., reduce other behavioral problems, and reduce the incidence of attention deficit disorder (ADD) or attention deficit hyeractivity disorder (ADHD). Provides several research references.
Schofield, Mary 1997 The high school handbook: Junior and senior high school at home. Norwalk, CA: Christian Home Educators Press home education, high school, secondary, college, academics PO Box 2009, Norwalk CA 90651). (Explains how to home school through high school years, provides ideas on how to set goals and standards and create transcripts, discusses college admissions and reading suggestions to prepare for college.
Schofield, Mary 2002 Charter schools: What is allowed, what is not, and why Christian parents should think twice before signing up, 31 pp. Norwalk, CA: Christian Home Educators Association of California and Family Protection Ministries.
School Administrators of Montana 1994 SAM delegate assembly resolutions. Helena, MT: Author.
Schramm, Michael 1985, June 21 Masters thesis research proposal: A questionnaire survey of the members of the Utah Home Education Association. Logan, UT: Utah State University.
Schroeder, Cheryl Ann 1986 The relationship of a child's home environment to academic achievement. Dissertation Abstracts International, 47(9), 3272A, Order No. DA8623106. Ed.D., University of Wyoming. Major findings included: "(1) There were significant relationships between the measure of the home environment [as measured by the HOME Inventory], sex of the child, and the child's academic achievement [as measured by Stanford Achievement Test]. (2) There was a significant relationship in females between the subscale, emotional and verbal responsivity in the home, on the HOME Inventory, and academic achievement as measured by the complete battery total score on the Stanford Achievement Test" DAI abstract.
Schroeder, Richard L. 1984 Home schools: A viable alternative? Unpublished master's thesis, Central Baptist Theological Seminary.
Scogin, Lauri A. 1986 Home School Survey. Available from The Home School Legal Defense Association, PO Box 3000, Purcellville VA 20134.
Scott, Stuart 2002 The exemplary husband. Bemidji MN: Focus Publishing. marriage, Christian, biblical, husband Excellent biblical book on a solid, sound, excellent husband; loving his wife with sacrificial love
Scott-Jones, Diane 1987, Winter Mother-as-teacher in the families of high- and low-achieving low-income black first-graders. Journal of Negro Education, 86(1), 21-34.) Academic Achievement, Black Students, Educational Environment, Grade 1, Parent Participation, Readiness
Scouras, Chelsiah 2021 Homeschoolers and four-year institutions: The application and admissions process. Doctoral dissertation (Ed.D.), Alliant International University, San Diego, California. homeschooling, adults, graduates, college, college admissions, barriers “Abstract: A number of studies have investigated the social development and academic performance of the homeschool student. Also, limited studies have examined the homeschooler and higher education; however, little to no research has investigated the homeschooler’s experience through the application and admissions process by following up with the homeschooler post matriculation. This study provides data to help better understand the homeschooler’s experience during the application and admissions process. This study focused on barriers faced during the application and admissions process, how homeschoolers receive information about 4-year institutions, what specialized support homeschoolers receive (or not receive) during the application and admissions process, and what most influences the homeschooler to accept or decline an admissions offer. Using a convergent mixed-methods design, the research for this study included two instruments for data collection—surveys and one-on-one, open-ended interviews from homeschool students who were homeschooled at least part time during high school; are currently enrolled in, or have attended, a 4-year institution; and are 18 years of age or older. The results of the study found that, overall, homeschoolers feel supported during the application and admissions process, but do not feel like they receive services specialized to help the homeschool applicant. This study did not include specific demographic information such as gender, location in which the participant was homeschooled, institutional location or ranking of the 4-year institution(s) applied to, and so forth. For these reasons, future research is recommended” (p. v).
Sears, James T., & Carper, James C. (Eds.) 1998 Curriculum, religion, and public education: Conversations for an enlarghing public square. New York, NY: Teachers College Press. education, philosophy, religion, curriculum, public schools Discuss controversies and how to address debates, based on anywhere from liberal secular religious and conservative ecclesiastical religious belief worldviews, concerning science and human evolution, textbook selection, secxuality instruction, character development, and outcome-based education. Gilbert T. Sewall [in chapter 5, “Religion and the textbooks,” p. 73-84] says one reason some families--including Christian, Jewish, and Muslim--turn to home schooling is because public school textbooks and the schools in general have been secularized; “Organizations such as the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), the National Education Association [NEA], and even the National Council of Churches [NCC] have been effective in using the federal courts to secularize public education” [p. 75]. Authors include Richard Baer, Nancy Brickhouse, James Carper, Charles Glenn, Maxine Greene, Phillip Johnson, George Marsden, Martin Marty, Michael McConnell, Peter McLaren, Richard John Neuhaus, Nel Noddings, Alan Peshkin, Eugene Provenzo, James Sears, Gilbert Sewall, Kenneth Strike, and Paul C. Vitz.
Seel, John, & Van Pelt, Deani 2008, February 22 The California Table: Connecting education and culture [convened December 6 - 7, 2007, Ontario, California, USA]. Retrieved 6/23/08 and earlier from www.wrf.ca/education/WRF.CaliforniaTable.pdf. http://www.wrf.ca/education/WRF.CaliforniaTable.pdf education, Christian education, home education, homeschooling private schools, public schools, philosophy, worldview, culture Objectives of the meeting were included the following stated objectives: “To advance our collective understanding of how 1. cultural movements happen and the place of education in that process, To constructively critique the current state of 2. Christian education with a view to improving its capacity to contribute to positive social and cultural change, and To facilitate networking and the capacity to 3. follow-up so that the ideas generated stimulate implementation strategies and an ongoing conversation” [p. 7]. “Christian schooling must not minimize the significance of a parent-led, home-based education. Schools need to connect more consistently with families. They must be intentionally complementary. Such an effort raises the question of authority and capability – who does what when? Not every parent knows what is required of a Christian mind. And yet, parents remain responsible for the education of their child. Ideally, parents and schools must mutually reinforce and respect each other. . . . . . Christian schools are not consistently graduating students with a Christian mind. Their actual results are a long way from their public rhetoric. Most students in Christian schools continue to follow cultural patterns that are foreign to the reality of God’s world and Word. Christian schools are not sufficiently reframing their students’ engagement with culture. Students are overwhelmed with information and yet are starved for wisdom. “If fathers aren’t turned, neither will be their children.” [last is a quote from an attendee]” [p. 9]. “There is disagreement on which assumptions and practices Christian schooling should be borrowing from culture. What is required to attract students? What is required to equip them? Churches often begin where their students are and then do little to move them toward maturity. Many take a posture of relevance that simply legitimates the cultural status quo. The result is that they squander their spiritual capital and fail to replenish it in succeeding generations. Evangelicals, in particular, have not been successful in transferring a traditional biblical perspective from one generation to the next” [p. 11]. “Homeschooling advocates tend to suggest that culture changes by changing individual hearts and minds. Others question whether homeschooled students are given a coherent vision for cultural engagement, a vision that motivates them to be involved in the wider [p. 11 ends] structures and patterns of cultural life beyond the sphere of the family. Does homeschooling reinforce a private faith based in an insulated family? If so, it may fail to foster agents of cultural change even while it may protect the faith of children” [p. 12]. “Likewise, Christian schools are criticized for creating a hidden curriculum – the invisible but influential peer culture existing beneath the formal school culture. Many question the effectiveness of these educational institutions to socialize students in biblical discipleship. Christian schools need better integration with their students’ families” [p. 12]. “Christian schools are often part of the problem, not part of the solution. We may want to talk about the wine (the content of the curriculum), but we need also to talk about the wineskins (the structures of the institutions)” [a quote from an attendee; p. 12]. “Parents can delegate their responsibility to educate and disciple their children to schools if they choose, but they are never to delegate this responsibility to a secular system” [a quote from an attendee; p. 14].
Seibert, Edward B. 2002, Spring Homeschooling: A comprehensive study of practice in Delaware and the Milford School District. home education, research, reasons, assessment and evaluation, academic achievement, cooperation, public schools Study’s goal “… is to improve the understanding of homeschooling in Delaware and within the Milford School District” [p. 3], while asking questions such as Why do Milford residents decide to homeschool their children, How do they homeschool, “… how do homeschooling parents assess or monitor the progress and academic achievement of their children?” [p. 4], “… how can public school districts best prepare for homeschooled children when families decide to stop homeschooling and enroll their children in public schools?” [p. 4], and “Fifth, how can (and should) public school districts help homeschooling parents and students?” [p. 5].
Seiver, Jillene Grove; & Pope, Elisa A. 2022 The kids are alright II: Social engagement in young adulthood as a function of k-12 schooling type, personality traits, and parental education level. Home School Researcher, 37(2), 1-9, https://www.nheri.org/the-kids-are-alright-ii-social-engagement-in-young-adulthood-as-a-function-of-k-12-schooling-type-personality-traits-and-parental-education-level/ https://www.nheri.org/the-kids-are-alright-ii-social-engagement-in-young-adulthood-as-a-function-of-k-12-schooling-type-personality-traits-and-parental-education-level/ homeschooling, socialization, extracurriculars, personality, volunteerism, civic involvement, , peer-reviewed “Abstract. To examine the issue of socialization, a survey study of 112 18-25 year olds who were homeschooled (n=52), publicly schooled (n=51), or privately schooled (n=9) during K-12 was conducted. Information about extracurricular activities during K-12 and young adulthood was collected, the Big Five Inventory was completed, and information about leadership, political participation, and parents’ levels of education was collected. ANOVAs revealed no difference in extracurricular participation during K-12 due to schooling type, but there were higher levels of volunteer activity and political participation among formerly homeschooled young adults, with large effect sizes. Former homeschoolers were higher in openness, conscientiousness, and agreeableness, and lower in neuroticism. There were no effects of parent’s level of education, and no effect of personality traits on levels of participation in extracurriculars. These findings suggest that formerly homeschooled young adults have been adequately socialized so that they can fit in within their social milieu, and that their personalities may have been positively affected by their family’s homeschool strategy” (p. 1).
Seiver, Jillene; & Pope, Elisa A. 2021 The kids are alright I: Social engagement in young adulthood as a function of k-12 schooling type. Home School Researcher, 36(4), 1-7, https://www.nheri.org/the-kids-are-alright-i-social-engagement-in-young-adulthood-as-a-function-of-k-12-schooling-type/ https://www.nheri.org/the-kids-are-alright-i-social-engagement-in-young-adulthood-as-a-function-of-k-12-schooling-type/ homeschool, home education, socialization, community involvement, peer- reviewed “Abstract: A common concern about homeschooled children is socialization. To examine this issue a survey study of 94 18-25 year olds who were homeschooled (n=30), publicly schooled (n=53), or privately schooled (n=11) during K-12 was conducted. Respondents provided the number and types of extracurricular activities that they engaged in during K-12 and in young adulthood. ANOVAs revealed that participation was equal during the K-12 years among schooling types, but that former homeschoolers reported higher levels of community engagement, namely in clubs and volunteer work. Contrary to many stereotypes about the social adjustment of homeschooled children, these findings suggest that being predominately homeschooled during the K-12 years was associated with greater community engagement during the young adult years. This positive outcome indicates that formerly homeschooled young adults have been adequately socialized so that they can fit in within their social milieu.” Cross-sectional explanatory design; some variables were controlled
Seligman, J., & Zabarsky, M. 1979, April 16 Home is where the school is. Newsweek, p. 99.
Seligmann, J. & Abramson, P. 1988, February 1 From homespun to Harvard: The California Colfaxes teach their children well. Newsweek, p. 49.
Sendor, Benjamin 1983 Advice for lawsuit-weary board members: learn these lessons about labor relations, liquor, and legislative laxity. The American Journal, January, 34-35. Law. Board members and superintendents must keep abreast of applicable laws.
Seton Magazine 2018, April 4 Boom in Religious Vocations…From Catholic Homeschoolers! Retrieved November 5, 2018 from http://www.setonmagazine.com/catholic/boom-in-religious-vocations-from-catholic-homeschoolers Boom in Religious Vocations…From Catholic Homeschoolers!, by Krista Schmid Thomas. http://www.setonmagazine.com/catholic/boom-in-religious-vocations-from-catholic-homeschoolers homeschooling, research, home education, Catholic, Roman Catholic, priesthood, religion “Catholic homeschoolers have known for years that religious vocations are one of the many fruits of homeschooling. A new CARA Georgetown study confirms it. Across the country, a noticeable trend is on the rise. Data indicates young men with a homeschool background are four-times more likely to enter seminaries than those educated in Catholic institutions. Data collected for the 2017 survey, conducted by Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate (CARA) at Georgetown University, found the following: Eight percent of seminarians on schedule for ordination had homeschooled for a length of seven years, on average, with discernment occurring approximately at the age of 16. Compare survey data against the estimated 100,000 Catholic homeschool students to the 2 million educated in Catholic schools. “The evidence is highly encouraging. Going forward, the impact could be enormous,” said Draper Warren. Warren, admissions director at Seton Home Study School in Front Royal, Virginia says this new data is an occasion to recognize the positive influence of the Catholic homeschool movement toward religious vocations.”)
Sexson, B. 1988 Home schooling: A socio-educational analysis of an emergent cultural shift in consciousness. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Oklahoma State University. University Microfilms International No. 8900435.
Shackleford, Luanne, & White, Susan 1988 A survivor's guide to home schooling. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books, 177 pp.. home education Christian perspective.
Shade, Leslie Reagan 1999 Roughing it in the electronic bush: Community networking in Canada. Canadian Journal of Communication, 24(2). Retrieved 7/15/13 from http://cjc-online.ca/index.php/journal/article/view/1095/1001. http://cjc-online.ca/index.php/journal/article/view/1095/1001 community networking, Canada Mentions homeschooling only once: “A variety of educational resources are provided on the NCF, from information on K-12 schools and school districts, to college and university information. Other information provided includes discussion areas provided for Christian education, home schooling, Russian-language teachers, supply teachers, and Native-language study; forums for high school tutoring, a students' SIG, and a Parent School Association area.” Homeschoooing is not a notable focus of this paper. “Abstract: This paper provides an overview of the community networking movement, with a closer look at community networking in Canada and, in particular, an examination of the National Capital FreeNet in Ottawa. It explores ways that community networks in Canada are envisioned to support and sustain community and contribute to the continuance of Canadian content and cultural sovereignty, and concludes with issues regarding sustainability.”
Shaghaghi, Abdolreza; Bhopal, Raj S.; & Sheikh, Aziz 2011 Approaches to Recruiting “Hard-To-Reach” Populations into Re Hard-to-reach populations; hidden populations; time-location sampling; time-space sampling; respondent driven sampling; capture-recapture Easily applies to homeschooling or homeschoolers. Reviews methods and techniques such as and apply methods such as respondent-driven sampling (to mitigate some of the problems with chain-referral or snowball sampling), targeted sampling (to include specific pre-defined subgroups of population), time-location (space) sampling (to recruit groups of homeschoolers at locations where they are likely to be found), and conventional cluster sampling (which is a reasonable method reasonable when there is no list of people to be selected, but a good list of locations, such as social media groups and blogs, where individuals from hard-to-reach group are gathered).
Shakeshaft, Charol 2004 Educator sexual misconduct: A synthesis of existing literature. Washington, DC: United States Department of Education. http://www2.ed.gov/rschstat/research/pubs/misconductreview/report.pdf http://www.ed.gov/rschstat/research/pubs/misconductreview/report.pdf http://www.sesamenet.org/images/documents/EducatorSexualMisconduct-ASynthesisofExistingLiterature.pdf sexual abuse, sexual misconduct, sexual harassment, teachers, public school, private school Retrieved February 7, 2017, January 18, 2015, and December 18, 2012 from http://www2.ed.gov/rschstat/research/pubs/misconductreview/report.pdf Retrieved 7/19/05 online http://www.ed.gov/rschstat/research/pubs/misconductreview/report.pdf. and October 10, 2016 from http://www.sesamenet.org/images/documents/EducatorSexualMisconduct-ASynthesisofExistingLiterature.pdf “1.1 Definitions. The phenomena examined in this synthesis include behavior by an educator that is directed at a student and intended to sexually arouse or titillate the educator or the child. In this review, “educator” includes any person older than 18 who works with or for a school or other educational or learning organization. This service may be paid or unpaid, professional, classified or volunteer. Adults covered by this review might be teachers, counselors, school administrators, secretaries, bus drivers, coaches, parent volunteers for student activities, lunchroom attendants, tutors, music teachers, special education aides, or any other adult in contact in a school-related relationship with a student. “Students” include any person, whatever age, in an educational institution up through 12th grade. This review does not examine the literature on postsecondary or higher education educator-to-student sexual misconduct. The behaviors included in the review are physical, verbal, or visual. Examples include … [p. 1].” “Prevalence in the United States. As a group, these studies present a wide range of estimates of the percentage of U.S. students subject to sexual misconduct by school staff and vary from 3.7 to 50.3 percent (Table 5). Because of its carefully drawn sample and survey methodology, the AAUW report that nearly 9.6 percent of students are targets of educator sexual misconduct sometime during their school career presents the most accurate data available at this time [p. 20].”
Shakeshaft, Charol 2025 Organizational betrayal: How schools enable sexual misconduct and how to stop it. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press. sexual misconduct, sexual maltreatment, sexual abuse, criminal, teachers, coaches, administrators, bus drivers, students, prevention Most current research shows that 11.7% of school children (students) experience school employee sexual misconduct during their K-12 years (p. 24-27, 30); this is a higher percent (roughly 10%) than was found circa 2004. This 11.7% would be about 5.7 million of the approximately 48.4 million K-12 public school students during the 2025-2026 school year. “Many people continue to deny, diminish, or deflect the reality of educator sexual misconduct. Despite decades of abuse, the behavior continues. School administrators often believe that misconduct won’t happen in their schools. They are likely wrong” (p. 115.) “For the sake of this example, I am estimating the number of students in each case who might have experienced school employee sexual misconduct using 11.7 percent as the proportion” (p. 30).
Shanahan, Timothy, & Lonigan, Christopher J 2010 The National Early Literacy Panel: A summary of the process and the report. Educational Researcher, June 3, 2010 vol. 39 no. 4, 279-285. early childhood education, preschool, kindergarten, literacy, early intervention, long-term effects, phonics, family, parent involvement] “Abstract: This article summarizes Developing Early Literacy: Report of the National Early Literacy Panel, which was published in 2008. That report provides an extensive meta-analysis of approximately 300 studies showing which early literacy measures correlate with later literacy achievement. It also provides a series of meta-analyses of a comprehensive collection of experimental and quasi-experimental studies of ways of teaching early literacy (preschool and kindergarten) that have been published in refereed journals. These analyses examine the effects of code-based instruction, shared book reading, home/parent interventions, preschool/kindergarten interventions, and early language teaching” [p. 279]. “Few interventions had evidence that their use resulted in improved conventional literacy skills or the precursor skills most related to later literacy growth, the exception being code-emphasis interventions. One reason that other interventions were not usually found to foster improvement in these measures is that few intervention studies with young children included such outcome measures. Code-focused programs, book sharing, parent/home programs, and language enhancement instruction all improved children’s oral language skills; the preschool and kindergarten programs did not” [p. 283]. Study offers no notable findings about the long-term (longitudinal) effects of the interventions. “Also, given the complementary findings for the various types of intervention, it would be helpful if researchers undertook longitudinal studies of more complex interventions (such as combinations of the types of efforts that have worked in the past), making it possible to evaluate the long-term value of more ambitious and complete efforts to develop early literacy skills” [p. 284].
Shannon, Charles K. 1995 The religious content of secondary school American history textbooks. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Pennsylvania State University. public schools, curriculum, religion Documents a gradual shift from a Christian or theistic worldview to a more secular, “democratic” orientation between 1865 and 1935.
Shannon, Mary M. 1987 Staying home for school. Lake Oswego Review, March 10, A1 and B1.
Shannon, Thomas 1979 Should parents be allowed to educate their kids at home? No. Instructor, 89(3), 30. Emphasizes society's needs. "Isn't it a simple fact that generations of experience have shown that schools are the most convenient, effective, and inexpensive place for children to learn these lessons [reading, composition, computation, history, American institutions, arts, sciences, and physical education]?" Offers no support for this "simple fact."
Shapiro, Arthur H. 1978 An analysis of individual (home) instruction for classified handicapped children in New Jersey 1974-1975. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Rutgers, State University of New Jersey.
Shapiro, Judy 1982, July 26 Home is where the school is. MacLean's, 45-47.
Shapiro, Laura 1997, May 12 The myth of quality time. Time, 129(19), 62-65 & 67-69. +(Explains that children do need much time and attention from their parents in order to be psychologically healthy in spite of the myth that “quality time” is more important than the quantity of time. Mentions Hochschild book The Time Bind) psychology, sociology, parenting, time
Sharick, Hannah Meeks, & Medlin, Richard G. 2012 Compliance in homeschooled children. Home School Researcher, 26 (3), 1-9. home education, homeschooling, compliance, socialization The purpose of this study was to measure homeschooled children’s compliance while they worked on an academic task with their mothers. Participants were 24 homeschooled children (mean age 12.2 years) and their mothers. Maternal directives and children’s reactions to them were recorded as mothers and children worked together on an academic task for 30 minutes. Randomly selected mothers were instructed to give their children both positive (“do this”) and negative (“don’t do that”) directives during the task. Mothers also completed a measure of their perception of their children’s everyday compliance. Both boys’ and girls’ compliance during the task was very high and was not affected by instructing their mothers to give directives. However, the more directives mothers gave their children, the more likely it was that negative behavior such as questioning or complaining accompanied children’s compliance. Mothers who believed their children to be noncompliant in general gave them more negative directives. The results suggest that homeschooling parents are successfully teaching their children this important social skill” [p. ].
Sharing Success Technical Assistance Center 2001/2002 Research Brief: Home schooling in New York. Retrieved 3/11/2010 from http://www.sharingsuccess.org/code/bv/homeschlbrief.pdf. http://www.sharingsuccess.org/code/bv/homeschlbrief.pdf home education, New York, population size “According to the NYS Education Department, there were 28,000 reported home-schooled students, K-12 for the year 1999-2000, representing less than 1% of the state’s school age population.”
Sharp, Carol 2002 School starting age: European policy and recent research. Paper presented at the Local Government Association [LGA] Seminar 'When Should Our Children Start School?', Local Government Association [LGA] Conference Centre, London, 1 November. https://www.nfer.ac.uk/publications/44414 early childhood education, school start age, compulsory school age, Head Start, High/Scope, policy Retrieved 12/11/17 from https://www.nfer.ac.uk/publications/44414 that says: “This paper reviews school starting ages for children across the world in the light of national policies beginning with a brief outline of starting ages in 33 European countries where age ranges are from 4 to 7 - the UK having one of the earliest at 5. Issues involved are considered in some detail in the light of extensive recent research evidence. They are: the influence of season of birth and length of schooling on later attainment, citing several recent UK studies; the impact of flexible or delayed entry, based on Swiss and US studies; an overview of international comparative studies on the same issue; and the later effects of different early childhood curricula approaches - such as early reading and the influence of English pre-schools. Main findings are summarised and conclusions reflect a lack of definitive evidence on the beneficial or otherwise effects of early or late start, except that a late start appears to have no adverse effect on children’s progress.” “The issues posed at the outset are apparently simple, but are difficult to answer from the research evidence. As far as I am aware, there is no definitive evidence from randomised control trials charting the progress of children who started school earlier or later and it would be difficult to envisage parents agreeing to participate in such a trial). International comparisons are indirect evidence at best, because they involve such different cultures and educational systems. What we can say is that a later start does not appear to hold back children’s progress (although it is important not to forget the important contribution made by children’s experiences at home and in preschool). Certainly, there would appear to be no compelling educational rationale for a statutory school age of five or for the practice of admitting four-year-olds to school reception classes” (p. 20).
Sharp, David 1997, March 14-16 Is home schooling good for America? Your kids’ education is at stake. USA Weekend, 4-6. home education, criticism, research, opinion Presents the comments of home school parents and children, professional educator spokespersons, and researchers. Provides findings and statistics from Ray’s 1997 nationwide study.
Sharpton, Beth 1999 Peace within your borders: Devotions for home school teachers. Enumclaw, WA: Wine Press Publishing.
Sheehan, Michele 2007, Fall Dancing with Monica: Personal perceptions of a home-school mom. Mensa Research Journal, 38(3), 40-46. home education, talented, gifted, special needs
Sheffer, Susannah 1989, May They do it their way, but . . . These `home schoolers' just might be able to teach your board a thing or two. The American School Board Journal, 176(5), 34-35.
Sheffer, Susannah 1995 A sense of self: Listening to homeschooled adolescent girls. Portsmouth, NH: Boynton/Cook Publishers, Heinemann. home education, research, qualitative, gender roles, woman studies, feminism, family, siblings, mother, father, stereotypes, reasons for home schooling, safety, protection Qualitative study of 55 adolescent/teenage home-educated girls finds that they do not lose their self-confidence as they pass into womanhood. Encourages those who study changes in girls as they move into womanhood in the context of institutional schooling and what effects they systems and structures of such schooling might have on them. Suggests that home schooled girls experience significantly different pressures, systems, and expectations than do girls in conventional schools that might help the home schooled to more effectively develop a sense of internalized authority and a strong sense of self-confidence and self-directedness. Susannah Sheffer’s book on her study of home schooled adolescent girls is replete with these girls’ own words and interpretive comments by the researcher. Sheffer begins her report by citing and later frequently refers to the work of Carol Gilligan and her colleagues in the Harvard Project on Women’s Psychology and Girls’ Development who, lamenting, “... have written about girls’ ‘loss of voice’ and increasing distrust of their own perceptions. At about age twelve or thirteen, these researchers say, girls begin to doubt themselves and what they know” [p. 2]. Sheffer suggests that the great difference in structure and function—the way things work, the relationships people have, expected behaviors, and the roles people play—between home schooling and conventional schooling may explain why she found so many of these adolescents to have not lost their personal voice and personal sense of identity. Meredith, a 14-year-old, said, “I was worried that I would become a typical teenager if I went to school” [p. 122] and “I think some people would have seen [school] as my opportunity to ‘be like everybody else.’ But I didn’t want to be like everybody else.” [p. 123] “‘I like how I’ve learned, I like who I am, I like what I know,’ says Andi. ‘I’m not going to let what people think I ought to be influence what I’m going to be,’ says Gabrielle. ‘I know what I think and feel and I have my beliefs and don’t let myself get pushed around,’ says Claudia. Throughout this book the homeschooled girls I’ve interviewed have echoed these statements. They have talked about trusting themselves, pursuing their own goals, maintaining friendships even when their friends differ from them or disagree with them” [p. 176]. “I agree that the internal feelings and perceptions of girls and women should not be ignored, but I do not see how they can be considered in a productive way if the external structures [e.g., of the school or educational setting] are not also examined” [p. 177]. “If, in thinking about these issues [e.g., students’ thought, feelings, and self-esteem], we discover that there is a contradiction between what we say to young people and what the school system itself communicates, that contradiction is what needs our attention” [p. 177]. Compulsory, institutional schooling is about ‘getting’ an education. “The homeschooled girls I have described are outside this framework. They are not waiting to get something; rather, they are getting it or, more aptly, making it for themselves” [p. 178]. “Homeschooling can give young people the chance to ask the question, ‘Who am I? What do I really want? It is through the process of asking and then gradually answering that question that the girls I’ve interviewed have developed the strengths and the resistance abilities that give them such an unusually strong sense of self” [p. 181]. Provides some glimpses into the role of parents regarding the development of these girls and the parents’ thoughts regarding their daughters and home schooling. Includes reasons for home schooling. Describes a mother concerned for the safety of her 11-year-old daughter Debbie and wants to protect her from bad peer influences toward and her 11-year-old daughter’s involvement in drugs, alcohol, and shoplifting and takes her out of school because it was a peer situation that was encouraging her involvement in these activities; getting out of conventional school allows the student “... to grow into someone who viewed herself as someone who can sustain real, close friendships, and who is worthy of such relationships” [p. 138] with people other than those who are involved in drugs, alcohol, and theft. Debbie said she felt peer pressure to do these things; Sheffer concludes, “Yes, she benefited from being removed from the situation, but not simply because now the ‘influences’ could no longer reach her. Rather, being out of school allowed Debbie to grow into someone who viewed herself in a different way” [p. 138]. In chapter “More aware of my femaleness,” discusses girls and women resisting society’s stereotypical gender roles and behaviors; “And as Sasha wrote, `Once you question one aspect of society, you begin to question all of it,’ and homeschooling can become a crack in the established structure that then calls the rest of the building into question” [p. 147]. “Hilary’s homeschooling facilitates this independent attitude [about having to meet stereotypes about behavior of the genders] in two ways. Homeschooling encourages a general acceptance of the idea that developmental milestones can be reached at a variety of ages. ..... Also, because she is homeschooling, Hilary is not immersed in the traditional social milieu (although she does indeed have friends), and this may insulate her somewhat from the general pressure to date, even though she is not free of it entirely. She is not surrounded every day with girls who expect her to date...” [p. 150-151]. “... many women in this sort of family [i.e., homeschooling] see homeschooling as making their lives as ‘housewives’ or ‘stay-at-home mothers’ more meaningful [p. 49] because they are involved with their children’s growth and learning and not just cooking for them and cleaning up after them. “Homeschooling can allow a mother to use her intellect and creativity in ways that [p. 49 ends] she hadn’t when she viewed herself only as a caretaker or custodian, and many women report this perspective” [p. 50]. Homeschooling often “empowers” mothers/women [p. 56].
Shein, Esther 2001, October Teaching at home? Your PC can make a difference Web PCs-For School and Play). Gateway Guide, pp. 16-19.
Shellenberger, Eve C. 1998 An ethnographic case study of three homeschooling families in central Pennsylvania and their socio-cultural support groups. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Pennsylvania State University. home education, research, qualitative, support group, socialization, culture “The purpose of this study was to examine the homeschooling movement in Central Pennsylvania as a distinct subculture set apart from the dominant educational culture of contemporary institutionalized schools, and to provide a better understanding of the homeschooling community for those who are not members of this subculture.The overarching research question which guided this study was: How does the worldview of homeschooling parents in Central Pennsylvania influence their decision to homeschool their children from grades K-12, their selection of curriculum, and their actual instructional strategies? Related research questions include: (1)What are the cultural expectations of homeschooling parents for their children, (2) what do homeschooling parents perceive to be the role of the family in the education of their children, (3) how do the parents’ personal educational experiences and background influence their initial decision to homeschool and their actual implementation of the homeschooling process, and (4) how does the culture of homeschoolers come into conflict with traditional school culture? The research design for this study was the ethnographic case study which allowed for an in depth understanding of how and why a select group of families in Central Pennsylvania homeschool their own children from kindergarten through twelfth grade. The key informants in this study were three long term homeschooling families who are committed to homeschooling their children continuously from kindergarten through twelfth grade. The primary data sources were from audiotaped non-standardized interviews and field notes written during and after observations of homeschooling in [p. iii ends here] progress. In addition to home observations and personal interviews with the mothers, fathers, and homeschool graduates, the researcher collected extensive field notes while attending some 162 hours of homeschool support group meetings, curriculum fairs, camps, rallies, and other homeschool group activities. The data collected represent approximately 260 hours of observations and interviews on 96 different occasions over a span of 24 months. The researcher, her spouse, and two daughters assumed the role of participant observers during this two year study of the homeschooling community. The data was analyzed by classification into categories through analytic induction. This technique involved scanning the data for categories of phenomena and for relationships among these categories. Negative instances were sought to refine the original categories. The categories that emerged from the analysis of interview data were then compared to the categories derived through analysis of field notes and artifacts. In this way the researcher was able to triangulate the data sources to provide a richer understanding of the participants’ worldview and experiences as members of the homeschooling community. Data analysis revealed the following research assertions: (I) The reasons for homeschooling are complex and multi-faceted. (2) Cultural conflict exists between these homeschooling families and the public school system. (3) The personal and educational background of these homeschooling parents influences the homeschooling process. (4) The homeschool network fulfills the role of a school community. (5) These home-schooling families are “doing school” efficiently and effectively. (6) These homeschooling parents do not reach their full potential of educational creativity and innovation [p. iv ends here; abstract].
Shepherd, Dan 2010 Mommy is my teacher: Qualitative case studies of three families' homeschooling experience. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Ball State University Muncie, Indiana. homeschooling, case studies, qualitative, research, reasons “Abstract: This dissertation is a qualitative case study of three homeschooling families. Because of the relative recentness of homeschooling as a widespread educational option for parents and because of the relatively few students participating in homeschooling, educators and others interested in this approach may benefit from the close qualitative consideration of homeschooling families of differing sizes, economic statuses, educational backgrounds, and other demographic differences. The primary research methodology for this dissertation is extensive and comprehensive interviews with three practicing homeschool families selected primarily because of their willingness to participate in the intensive interview process for this dissertation. The literature reviewed and the research questions considered include information about the estimated number of homeschooled students currently in the United States, the rationale behind parents’ choice to homeschool, a review of the basic demographics of homeschoolers, the legal and professional educators’ opinions about homeschooling, the instructional methods and curricular materials of homeschoolers, the academic achievement of homeschooled students, and the eventual college and career success of homeschooled students. The dissertation found that, while homeschooling parents would agree with much of the literature available to describe them, there were emphases and challenges to homeschooling that have not been fully studied and are applicable to individual families” (p. 4). “In summary, this research identifies primarily four fundamental reasons for homeschooling. First, many parents are concerned about the environment of other schools. Second, many parents desire to provide religious or moral instruction to their children, instruction that is denied in a secular public school that resides in a very pluralistic society. Some researchers conclude that this is the most prevalent or most important reason that some parents homeschool. Third, many parents believe that the academic instruction at other schools is substandard. Fourth, some parents choose to homeschool because their child or children have special needs that cannot be adequately or properly met in a public school system” (p. 98)
Shepherd, Michael S., B.A., M.A., Ed.D. Fall-Winter 1990-1991 Home schooling: Dimensions of controversy. Educational Freedom, 24(1), 3-14. home education
Shepherd, Michael Steven 1986 The home schooling movement: An emerging conflict in American education. Unpublished doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, East Texas State University, Commerce TX. See also Dissertation Abstracts International, 47(4), 1216A. Historical analysis. Home schoolers "...are forcing a redefinition of compulsory education in America" (p. 2) and have rekindled the debate over the rights of the individual/family versus the rights of the state in about why and how home education has recently experienced a resurgence. "The social activism of the sixties as well as the social tensions of the seventies and eighties help explain the attraction of parents to home education" (p. 25). He surveys the social issues of the 60s, 70s, and 80s. During the 60s and 70s, the New Left desired more individual freedom and delved deeply into experimenting with alternative schools, Shepherd explains. “Several people who promoted alternative schools in the 1970s would come to advocate home schooling ...” [p. 39, 40]. "It was natural for alternative schools to accommodate home schooling as one more alternative approach to education" (p. 47). Documents the rapid growth of Christian home education in the 1980s, with parents wanting to indoctrinate their children with the truths of the Bible. Associates Raymond Moore, Gregg Harris, Christian Liberty Academy (in IL), Accelerated Christian Education (in Garland, TX [now in Lewisville, TX]), Dayton (OH) Christian School, Michael Farris (of HSLDA), and others with the Christian home education community. Shepherd predicts that home schooling will continue on but it will be limited by the increasing number of divorces and one-parent families and the number of families in which both parents work outside of the home. Further, he reasons that conflicts over home education will "drag on" for several years. "Home schooling offers the prospect of ongoing litigation pitting the modern regulatory state against the individual choices of do-it-yourself parents" (DAI). Shepherd suggests that perhaps the most reasonable and constitutionally defensible means for states to ensure their interests would be to legislate the use of standardized tests to monitor and control home schoolers.
Shepherd, Michael Steven 1986, September The home schooling movement: An emerging conflict in American education (an abstract). Home School Researcher, 2(3), 1. An abstract of his dissertation.
Shepherd, Mike 1994 Home schoolers as public school tutors. Educational Leadership, 52(1), 55, 56.
Sheppard, Sharon May/June 1991 The mom at the front of the class. Christian Parenting Today, pp. 42-47. home education
Sherfinski, Melissa 2014 “Contextualizing the tools of a classical and Christian homeschooling mother–teacher.” Curriculum Inquiry, 44(2):169–203. homeschooling, Christian, classical education, bricolage qualitative research “Abstract: This article reports on the resurgence of classical and Christian education in the United States. This education has been especially popular with evangelical homeschooling mother-teachers. It seeks to cultivate the biblical virtues of truth, goodness, and beauty through contemplating scripture. The curriculum relies on the ancient Trivium tools of knowledge, understanding, and wisdom in order to do this. The inquiry seeks to examine the contexts surrounding a mother-teacher's classical and Christian educational practice guided by two questions: (1) Why and how does an evangelical homeschooling mother-teacher use classical and Christian tools? (2) What are the possibilities and challenges of classical and Christian homeschooling for an evangelical mother-teacher? This curriculum is illustrated with the portrait of April Greene, an evangelical homeschooling mother-teacher of two preteen boys. April enacted agency through the complex and dynamic development of her children and herself. April engaged the Trivium using bricolage, making educational meanings by picking and choosing from available resources and tactics to suit her purposes of intellectual and Christian identity formation. She moved beyond the borders of the official curriculum to create unofficial practices as well. These choices allowed her to negotiate the requirements of evangelical identity and the fact that living and leading in the world may require some knowledge of popular culture. April experienced possibilities related to classical and Christian curriculum, pedagogical tools, and mother-teacher identity. Classical and Christian education also presented a number of difficulties for April regarding cost, time, child agency, perspective taking, isolation, and gender burden. April's identity and agency as a mother-teacher reflected her intense devotion. She struggled with competing roles and expectations while thriving on the unique challenge of becoming an evangelical homeschooling mother-teacher.”
Sherfinski, Melissa, & Chesankoa, Melissa 2014 Disturbing the data: Looking into gender and family size matters with US Evangelical homeschoolers. Gender, Place & Culture: A Journal of Feminist Geography. DOI:https://doi.org/10.1080/0966369X.2014.991703. http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0966369X.2014.991703 Barad, Quiverfull, Evangelical, homeschooling, gender, feminist materialism, posthuman, assemblage, geography “Abstract: This qualitative study draws on the theory of feminist physicist Karen Barad to examine how gender matters in Evangelical homeschooling families of various sizes, with an emphasis on large families. The two-phase data collection includes interviews with 18 participants and observations of several participants over one year. We use a Baradian analytic process called diffractive analysis to read the messy borders between the discursive and material for mothers, fathers, daughters, sons, and elements of homeschooling environments. We find that materiality intra-acted with gender in complex and sometimes surprising ways but that gendered possibilities in homeschooling are steeped in the terrains of politics, history, culture, economics, and environment. In addition, we see possibilities for using this method of analysis as a way to more carefully and complexly read data in the micro,” (retrieved December 27, 2014 from http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0966369X.2014.991703).
Shirkey, B. T. 1987 Students' perspectives of home schools: A descriptive study. Doctoral dissertation, University of Florida, Gainesville.
Shortt, Bruce N. 2006, May 3 'Public Education Against America'. Retrieved 5/3/06 online http://wnd.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=50013. http://wnd.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=50013 philosophy, home education, public schools, private schools, reasons Concisely presents the view of many Christians who believe that homeschooling and Christian institutional schools are clearly the preferred method of educating children and that public (government) schools are, essentially, working against Christian beliefs and values. “Despite claiming to be value-neutral, non-directive approaches to teaching moral reasoning actually indoctrinate children with the view that all moral values are purely subjective and that none are transcendent and universally applicable. The real purpose behind all of this is to separate children from the values they have learned in their families so that they will be "open" to new values consistent with some variant of cultural Marxism. Thus, the "values curriculum" in public schools is rather like AIDS – it destroys a child's moral immune system and renders him vulnerable to opportunistic worldview infections. . . . . . As a general proposition, local teachers and administrators have no idea that they and their curricula are promoting cultural Marxism. Moreover, they would undoubtedly deny that they are doing any such thing if questioned about it. Nonetheless, they have been taught these ideas while getting their education degrees, during their in-service training, and by their unions. The moral and cultural relativism that is imbedded in all of the claptrap about "respecting differences," diversity, and so on is simply what seems obviously right and decent to the typical public-school employee. On the other hand, those who teach in schools of education, elements of the union leadership, and others typically have a quite explicit understanding of what they are doing. . . . . . The fact is, schools of education have been catechizing prospective teachers and administrators in the creeds of globalism, multiculturalism, social justice and diversity for years. These students are now our children's teachers, and they are now catechizing our children with the worldview they have been taught.”
Shortt, Bruce N. 2004 The harsh truth about public schools. Vallecito, CA: Chalcedon Foundation. public school, Christian school, private school, homeschooling, home education, curriculum, philosophy, Christianity Author uses a strong Bible-is-inerrant perspective to evaluate the curriculum and practice of public or state schools. The chapter titles are as follow: Why are you educating your children at a pagan seminary?; Do you like your daughter’s nose-ring and tongue stud?; My child is on the honor roll; A blackboard jungle; School reform: A popular delusion; Government schools: The wages of Christian sin; ?Are your children unequally yoked?; Leading your children into the promised land of homeschooling and Christian schools. A key thesis is that all schooling, whether public school, private school, or homeschooling, is philosophically driven and value-laden. Claims are carefully well-documented with specific examples and references. Strongly critical of public schooling. Online description: “Bruce Shortt's book, The Harsh Truth about Public Schools, combines a sound Biblical basis, rigorous research, straightforward, easily read language, and eminently sound reasoning. Whether one is a parent or parent-to-be, pastor, church staff member, or educator, this book has much to offer. It is based, first of all, upon a clear understanding of God's educational mandate to parents. Its second foundation is a thoroughly documented description of the inescapably anti-Christian thrust of any governmental school system and the inevitable results: moral relativism (no fixed standards), academic dumbing down, far-left programs, near absence of discipline, and the persistent but pitiable rationalizations offered by government education professionals.”
Shulman, Lee S. 1986 Paradigms and research programs in the study of teaching. In M. C. Wittrock (Ed.), Handbook of research on teaching (3rd ed.). New York, NY: MacMillan Publishing Co.
Shute, Valerie J., Hansen, Eric G., Underwood, Jody S., & Razzouk, Rim 2011 A review of the relationship between parental involvement and secondary school students' academic achievement. Education Research International, v. 2011. Retrieved February 8, 2012 from http://www.hindawi.com/journals/edu/2011/915326/. http://www.hindawi.com/journals/edu/2011/915326/ academic achievement, parental involvement, secondary school students “This paper reviews the research literature on the relationship between parental involvement (PI) and academic achievement, with special focus on the secondary school (middle and high school) level. The results first present how individual PI variables correlate with academic achievement and then move to more complex analyses of multiple variables on the general construct described in the literature. Several PI variables with correlations to academic achievement show promise: (a) communication between children and parents about school activities and plans, (b) parents holding high expectations/aspirations for their children's schooling, and (c) parents employing an authoritative parenting style. We end the results section by discussing the findings in light of the limitations of nonexperimental research and the different effects of children's versus parents' perspectives on academic achievement” [abstract].
Shyers, Larry E. 1992 A comparison of social adjustment between home and traditionally schooled students. Home School Researcher, 8(3), 1-8. home education, research, socialization, self-concept, social development, clinical, matched subject design, peer-reviewed Condensed version of Shyers, 1992 dissertation. Studied children ages 8 to 10. “For the purpose of this study the Piers Harris Children's Self Concept Scale (PHCSCS) was chosen to measure a child's self-concept and feelings of social comfort” (p. 2). “Due to a large population of traditionally schooled students in the three county area, it was possible to match a traditional student with a home schooled student as to race, gender, age, family size, number and frequency of out of school activities, and socioeconomic status. Although church attendance and frequency of involvement in church activities were included as part of the matching criterion, religious affiliation was not a consideration in matching subjects for this study” (p. 3). “The final research group, therefore, consisted of two subgroups of 70 children from each schooling experience. There was an equal number of males and females in each subgroup. Each subgroup contained children between the ages of 8 and 10. For all practical purposes, the subgroups were equal to each other” (p. 3). Does not explain whether “traditional school includes public school, private school, or both. Compared entirely homeschooled students with entirely conventionally/traditionally schooled students using Piers-Harris Children’s Self-Concept Scale (PHCSCS) and Children’s Assertiveness Behavior Scale (CABS), and observed all of them in free introductory time, free play time, and a time of structured “group interaction activity” that “… required the children to work together in small groups putting together puzzles” [p. 4]. No differences between the two groups on self-esteem or passivity. Then measured their behavior using the Direct Observation Form of the Child Behavior Checklist. Found no statistical differences on PHCSCS or CABS; both groups had above-average PHCSCS scores. “The most significant results of this study were found in actual observed behaviors. The DOF records problem behaviors by type and frequency. Home schooled students received significantly lower problem behavior scores than did their agemates from traditional program” (p. 5). “Home schooled (H.S.) students had lower problem behavior DOF scores than did the traditional school (T.S.) students” [p. 5]. Peer-reviewed.
Shyers, Larry E. 1992 Comparison of social adjustment between home and traditionally schooled students. Published doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, University of Florida, Gainesville. home education, research, socialization, social development, clinical Compares home educated [n=70] and traditionally (public school only, p. 124, conventionally) schooled [n=70] students. Both groups had positive self-concept scores that were above the national average. Both groups were not aggressive, but choose slightly passive responses to social situations. They differed in their actual observed behaviors in free play [with toys, games, and one another] and group interaction activities [working in small groups to put together puzzles with prizes awarded to members of each team according to the speed with which the team completes the puzzle]. Apparently students were kept with other students from their own type of schooling: “The subjects were divided into groups of at least 6 students from the same schooling population, ...” [p. 126]. Conventional school students received significantly higher problem behavior (e.g., loud talking, teasing others, excessive activity, withdrawal) scores than did the home educated. The traditionally schooled were more aggressive, loud, and competitive than were the home educated. “... the most significant influence in this study appears to be schooling (p < .001) Home schooled children, regardless of age or gender, consistently received lower problem behavior scores on the DOF [Direct Observation Form] (see Figure 1). All three home school age groups were observed to separate from their parents easily for the group activities” [p. 194]. “... it was observed that traditionally schooled children tended to be considerably more aggressive, loud, and competitive than were the home schooled children of the same age” [p. 196].
Sikkema, Keith 2002 Home schooling in view of John Calvin: A study in education and communion of saints. Master’s thesis (M.Ed.) Brock University, St. Catharines, Ontario, Canada. homeschooling, private schooling, Christianity, faith, reformed Christianity, Canada, reasons, church culture, opinion, attitude Appears to fairly and dispassionately present the findings, such as the views of homeschool parents and private school personnel. Shows solid understanding of the tensions between some homeschool families and church associates, and about arguments for or against homeschooling and for and against institutional private schooling. Studies those who are a part of The Niagara Peninsula Canadian Reformed (NPCR) community. It is the bibliography author’s view that the following is a common and accurate explanation of how many Christian homeschoolers think about things: “Home Schoolers on School and Church: Several home schoolers expressed concern that the school is made to be too much like the church, or, with Paula, as “just a little bit under the church.” She linked this to undue emphasis on “the triangle of home, church, and school . . . to support the school, even though the Bible gives the responsibility (to raise the children) squarely to the parents.” While recognizing that the school does promote a sense of community, Jerry also asserted that the church is the covenant community: Church and school must be separate, even if 99 or 100% of school members are from the church. He felt that the schools have become too much extensions of the church, and that not sending children to the school is not the same as dividing the church, or “withdrawal of positive influence” (p. 94).“Abstract: This study explores the tension that has emerged around the rise of home schooling in a faith-community strongly committed to establishing and maintaining day schools in the tradition of John Calvin. It aims to identify and understand factors that contributed to this tension and to find ways to bridge, diffuse, reduce, or eliminate it. In line with Calvin, personal convictions, and the nature of the community, the study takes a Christian epistemological and axiological stance. Its premise is that the integrity of the community is more important than the manner in which its children are taught. The study reviews relevant literature and several interviews. It considers both secular and Christian literature to understand communities, community breakdown, and community restoration. It also examines literature about the significance of home, school, and community relationships; the attraction of Reformed day schools; and the appeal of home schooling. Interviews were conducted with 4 home schooling couples and 2 focus groups. One focus group included local school representatives, and the other home schoolers and school representatives from an area with reputedly less tension on the issue. Interviews were designed for participants to give their perspectives on reasons for home schooling, the existing tension, and ways to resolve the issues. The study identifies the rise of home schooling in this particular context as the initial issue and the community=s deficiency to properly deal with it as the chief cause for the rising tensions. However, I argue that, within the norms the community firmly believes in, home schooling need not jeopardize its integrity. I call for personal, social, and spiritual renewal to restore the covenant community in gratitude to God” (p. iii). “This chapter illustrates the tension around home schooling by giving voice to both home schoolers and school representatives. Although school representatives recognized most of the reasons home schoolers had for their choice, they often failed to differentiate between reasons for starting and for continuing. While home schoolers often cited social, psychological, pedagogical, policy, program, personal, and personnel stressors as triggers, school representatives tended to think more of benefits as triggers. Especially in Niagara, school representatives would seek to re-incorporate home schoolers. People agreed that the public schools do not meet the standard required for covenantal education, which views God’s Word, the covenant, the family, and the parents= baptismal vows as principle elements. However, they diverged on the application of these principles, and the respective roles of the family and the community” (p. 99). “School representatives were concerned that the school and church are weakened by home schooling, as not all talents are used for building up the church, and some people get overburdened” (p. 101). “Principles of Orthodoxy and Conduct: Home schoolers and school representatives agreed that it is necessary to go back to Scripture as the basis for orthodoxy, and to regain unity and harmony. Somewhat reminiscent of Sande (1997), four key principles emerged: Go back to Scripture; Show him his fault; A man must examine himself; and Care for one another” (p. 102). “For the Churches: This study’s findings may find general application in controversies among the communion of saints, in any of the places where I have been employed during the last 25 years. It would also suggest a reconsideration of the wording of Article 58 of the Church Order. As it portrays the school as the route of choice, and does not recognize that the responsibility of the parents and of the community goes well beyond the academic focus of the school, clarity and Scriptural correctness could be enhanced. At home visits, elders should do more than just press the good school button” (p. 123)
Sikkink, David 2012 Religious school differences in school climate and academic mission: A descriptive overview of school organization and student outcomes. Journal of School Choice, 6(1), 20-39. http://www.eric.ed.gov http://www.eric.ed.gov/ Catholic schools; private schools; protestants; Catholics; academic achievement; graduates; school organization; foreign countries; educational experience; outcomes of education; comparative education; educational environment; surveys; institutional mission; educational attitudes; administrator attitudes; principals, homeschooling, Canada Fairly sure it contains very little on homeschooling, and that homeschooling is not a notable focus of the study. “Abstract: School sector differences have been the subject of much debate in the literature, but there is limited data that allows careful consideration of differences within the religious school sector. The extensive Catholic school effects literature focuses on issues of school climate, especially an emphasis on persons-in-community, or communal organization (Bryk, Lee, & Holland, 1993). But less is known about sector differences in school climate across evangelical Protestant, Catholic, and nonreligious private schools, particularly as these differences vary between the United States and Canada. This study uses descriptive analysis of national-level survey data from the Cardus Education Study to show average differences across detailed school sectors on several measures of school climate and mission. It finds a strong focus on relational goals in evangelical Protestant schools and an emphasis on academic outcomes in Catholic schools. The findings also point to nearly uniformly positive evaluations from private school graduates of their high school experience, which is particularly characteristic of evangelical Protestant and nonreligious private schools” (retrieved 7/19/13 from http://www.eric.ed.gov; ERIC Document No. EJ957159). Peer reviewed.
Sikkink, David 2018 Bringing “thou” back in: Religious schools in the United States and pro-social orientations. Cardus Education Survey, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada. Retrieved March 6, 2018 from https://www.cardus.ca/research/education/publications/5195/bringing-thou-back-in/ https://www.cardus.ca/research/education/publications/5195/bringing-thou-back-in/ private schools, private education, homeschooling, home education, religion, social engagement, civic involvement, adults “The survey data we consider in this report is from a large-scale, government-funded panel survey of American families with school-aged children, the National Longitudinal Study of Youth 1997 (NLSY97). This survey is funded through the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics, and is widely regarded by education and family researchers as one of the top two or three US studies in terms of the breadth and quality of panel data. This study includes a random sample of about 8,400 children in 1997, most of whom were in the sixth to eleventh grade. These students have been re-interviewed at least every other year since that time” (p. 7). “RELIGIOUS HOMESCHOOLERS The religious-homeschooling sector is not strongly or consistently related to measures of pro-social and civic commitments and practices. Religious homeschoolers are not different from public schoolers on measures of pro-social attitudes. They are not more likely to support community obligations. The only significant difference with public schoolers is a negative relation between religious homeschoolers and obligation to vote. On informal helping behaviour, results do not show religious homeschooler differences. Community-meeting participation is not related to religious homeschooling. Religious homeschoolers are strongly negatively related to voting, and this is consistent across nearly all elections. The relation of this sector to giving blood is negative but not significant. Interestingly, religious homeschoolers in the 2008 survey are negatively related to breaking rules in school, and they are positive on a measure of whether they support long-established rules and traditions. Overall, we notice the countercultural orientations of homeschooling, especially as expressed in much lower support for voting. The other outcomes are not significantly different from public schoolers. The lack of significance is no doubt partly due to the lack of strong distinctive orientations and practices among religious homeschoolers, but note that the relatively small sample size makes it more difficult to detect significant differences. NON-RELIGIOUS HOMESCHOOLERS Similarly, for the few non-religious homeschoolers the results do not show many differences with public schoolers. Pro-social attitudes are not significantly different. Non-religious homeschoolers exhibit strong support for the claim that people need to take care of themselves, but this is not statistically significant. On informal helping behaviours, there appears to be a positive effect on giving to the homeless and allowing strangers to cut in line, but a negative relationship to loaning a valuable item to another person. But these are not statistically significant. The influence on blood donation is positive, but not significant either. The findings for voting tend to be negative, but not consistently significant. The non-religious homeschoolers report that they are less calm and emotionally stable. Non-religious homeschoolers tend to agree that they will not be rule followers. They are also agree that they tended to flaunt school rules, but this is not statistically significant. While some of the findings for non-religious homeschoolers seem consistent with what we would expect, there are few statistically significant findings. This reflects in part the very small sample size available in the NLSY97. Our conclusions about this sector, therefore, remain very tentative” (p. 12). “Homeschoolers present a mixed picture. Overall, however, community obligations do not appear to be high on their list of priorities. The countercultural orientations of the homeschooling movement, while laudable in many ways, do not seem to have any distinctive effect on whether homeschoolers are active in civic life. We should keep in mind, however, that the homeschoolers are not significantly different from public schoolers on any measure but voting, and that voting in a majoritarian electoral system perhaps gives way to direct action in petitioning officials and protesting policies for an educational minority. Homeschoolers may be active in community and political life in ways not measured in this report” (p. 13).
Sikkink, David H. 2001 The shape of homeschoolers’ political action. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 10-14, 2001, Seattle, Washington.
Sikkink, David; & Skiles, Sara 2015 Homeschooling and young adult outcomes: Evidence from the 2011 and 2014 Cardus Education Survey. Notre Dame, IN: Cardus Religious Schools Initiative, University of Notre Dame. Retrieved June 25, 2015 http://crsi.nd.edu/assets/168208/crsi_homeschool_report_ces2014.pdf http://crsi.nd.edu/assets/168208/crsi_homeschool_report_ces2014.pdf homeschooling, graduates, adults, effects, religion, religiosity, Christianity, research Focuses on the 201 subjects (“… 141 in the religious category [i.e., their mothers attended religious services at least once per month], and 60 in the nonreligious [i.e., the other participants] category …” (p. 5) “… who were primarily homeschooled during their high school years” (p. 4) from a broader study of much larger sample size. It is important to note that the study did not present data on how many years each participant was homeschooled, public schooled, or private schooled during their K-12 school years. On this note, the authors write: “To account for the possibility that respondents were not homeschooled for all high school years, the analyses include a measure indicating whether or not the homeschooled respondent ever attended a public school” (p. 5). Also, on a related note, the authors write: “Respondents who reported that their mothers attended religious services at least once a month were categorized as part of the “religious homeschool” group, while others were considered as “nonreligious homeschoolers.” Of course, this is not perfect, since we can’t for example consider religious tradition differences ([Amish], Catholic, conservative Protestant, [Unitarian], etc.) in homeschooling outcomes. As with other studies, we are limited by the small samples of homeschoolers available in random samples of American adults” (p. 4-5). Following is a good summary of much of their findings on those who were home educated in high school: “The religiosity and religious belief findings from our survey, however, are difficult to summarize” (p. 6). “While the findings on personal religiosity are somewhat mixed, the church involvement figures are more clear-cut. What we find is that in addition to being reticent about institutional schooling, religious homeschoolers are not strongly oriented to institutional religion” (p. 6). The authors write in their conclusions: “The findings on homeschooling outcomes in young adulthood provide only broad directions, which will have to be honed and confirmed in future research” (p. 13). Here is one conclusion: “The lower levels of involvement in civic organizations and churches are consistent with relatively high boundaries that homeschoolers place between themselves and dominant institutions. Second, family and immediate personal relationships take precedence over other life goals for homeschoolers. Perhaps this explains why congregational involvement is lower among homeschoolers” (p. 13).
Silberman, Charles E. 1970 Crisis in the classroom: The remaking of American education. Random House Trade Paperbacks.
Silva, Moises 1983 Biblical words and their meaning: An introduction to lexical semantics. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan Publishing House. Some cautions on what you can and cannot say about words in the New Testament.
Silverman, Julia 2002, November 3 Charter schools struggle in Eugene on several fronts. The Oregonian. Retrieved 11/07/02 online http://www.oregonlive.com/education/oregonian/index.ssf?/xml/story.ssf/html_standard.xsl?/base/exclude/1036241776255960.xml. http://www.oregonlive.com/education/oregonian/index.ssf?/xml/story.ssf/html_standard.xsl?/base/exclude/1036241776255960.xml charter schools, problems “Charter schools are publicly funded schools run by teachers, parents or community members, subject to some, but not all, of the regulations that govern the state's regular schools. Twenty-three such schools have formed in Oregon since the Legislature approved charter schools in 1999.” “The district and Lay's charter school also have clashed over what the district says is loose financial accounting, as well as a refusal by the military academy to pay into Oregon's Public Employees Retirement System. There are persistent questions over whether the school is providing adequate special education programs.”
Silverman, Julia 2005, April 8 Home-schooled students at a premium. The Register Guard [newspaper, Eugene, OR]. Retrieved 4/18/05 online http://www.registerguard.com/news/2005/04/08/c4.or.homeschool.0408.html. http://www.registerguard.com/news/2005/04/08/c4.or.homeschool.0408.html home education, public school, cooperation, finances, money, philosophy Finds public school districts are actively putting pressure on homeschool students to enroll in public-school courses in order to increase public-school enrollment and thereby increase tax funding to the state-run schools. “Since Oregon bases its state school funding on enrollment, every home-schooled child Myrtle Point can woo means an extra $5,000 or so. An estimated 100 youngsters living in the district are home- schooled. Already, 18 percent of the nation's 1.1 million home-schooled students are enrolled at least part-time in public school, usually for specialty courses such as music, art or science that are more difficult for parents to teach at home. But that is usually the parents' choice, not the result of a recruitment effort by strapped-for-cash public schools.” “In Walla Walla, Wash., school officials have launched plans for a new learning center that they hope will attract at least 30 home-school students, to help cope with a projected $200,000 in budget cuts next school year. A school district in Fort Collins, Colo., started a program aimed at drawing home-schooled youngsters into the system with two days a week of art, science and music. In 2003, it earned the district an extra $203,341 in state funding. There are no guarantees the strategy will work. Many home-school parents are fiercely loyal to the lifestyle, and to the educational benefits they see for their children. Some want to protect their youngsters from the peer pressure and drugs they fear are rampant in public schools. Others, like the Wilsons, home-school their children in part for religious reasons. ``I like instruction where the instructor, not just the body of knowledge, is important,'' Teckla Wilson said. ``Home-schooling allows you to work out the pace that is best for them. And, we are Christians, and for me, it is important that I teach them to think with a biblical world view.''”
Silverman, Linda. (Ed.) 1992, September/October Focus on home schooling [Entire special issue]. Understanding Our Gifted, 5(1), 1-20. The issue explores home education as it applies to the gifted in a positive and balanced manner. Articles include "Homeschooling for gifted primary students" by Patricia Linehan, "Learning to fly: A homeschooling retrospective" by Elye Alexander, "Questions and answers about homeschooling" by Kathi Kearney, "The highly gifted: Homeschooling highly gifted children" by Kathi Kearney, “From parent to parent” by Mary Lynn Baum.
Simmons, Betty Jo 1994, February Classroom at home: What should your board say to parents who choose home schooling for their children? The American School Board Journal, 181(2), 47-49. policy, opinion, home education, negative critique, negative critic, negative criticism Begins article by listing “possible problems with home schooling” [p. 47] such as parents not being qualified teachers, social isolation of children, lack of science laboratories, and parental abuse and neglect; none of these problems are discussed in the context of research or documented facts regarding home education. Begins the section on “home schooling strengths” by saying, “Most families have neither the desire nor the ability to teach their children at home” [p. 48]. She says the strengths include parental involvement, freedom to teach morals and values, flexibility with respect to curriculum and scheduling, giving individual attention to children, and cross-age tutoring. She ignores the fast-growing body of research that indicates that home education appears to have positive effects on children in most areas of their lives. d ends, “After all, home schooling is not a subversive activity” [p. 49].
Simonds, Kathi 1991 A critique of America 2000: An education strategy, 55 pp. Published by and available from Citizens for Excellence in Education, Box 3200, Costa Mesa CA 92628. educational improvement, reform, religious, religion Addresses the topic of the title; CEE believes in helping children achieve academic success, develop godly morals, and understand the importance of traditional American values.
Simonds, Robert L. 1993 A guide to the public schools: For Christian parents and teachers, and especially for pastors. Published by and available from Citizens for Excellence in Education, Box 3200, Costa Mesa CA 92628. parental involvement, religious schools, public schools, Christianity Emphasizes the scriptural responsibility of parents for the education of their children; explains how to help make public schools a spiritually safe place; describes the biblical support for home schooling [(and its academic advantages, p. 3, 4] and Christian schools. Says Christians can do “indirect evangelism” in public schools by helping select curriculum materials that give a biblical view and omit materials that promote nonbiblical views. Along with basic courses in reading, writing, English grammar and composition, and math, “Students should be taught patriotism and the traditions of Western culture, as well as principles of self-goevernment and democracy” [p. 109] and “The Judeo-Christian philosophy of life and the traditional educatoin of America’s children is an essential part of all educational issues and should be included in textbooks and the teaching process as a matter of history and the basis for our values, and ethical practices” [p. 109].
Sink, Mindy 1999, August 11 Shootings intensify interest in home schooling. The New York Times, p. A18). http://search.nytimes.com/search/daily/bin/fastweb?getdoc+site+iib-site+11+0+wAAA+shootings%7Eintensify Online http://search.nytimes.com/search/daily/bin/fastweb?getdoc+site+iib-site+11+0+wAAA+shootings%7Eintensify Says a more rapidly increasing number of parents are interested in home schooling as a result of the shootings and murders in public schools such as the one in Littleton, Colorado in the spring of 1999. Quotes Dr. Brian Ray.
Sire, James W. 1988 The universe next door: A basic world view catalog (updated and expanded ed.). Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press. philosophy, religion, worldview, world view Gives a Christian's explanation of Christian theism, deism, naturalism, nihilism, existentialism, Eastern pantheistic monism, and the New Age.
Sivin-Kachala, Jay, & Bialo, Ellen 2009, May IESD comprehensive technical report, evaluation of the social skills of full-time, online public school students. New York, NY: Interactive Educational Systems Design, Inc. Retrieved October 5, 2011 from http://jhauge.tie.wikispaces.net/file/view/IESD-Socialization-Study-May-2009.pdf. http://jhauge.tie.wikispaces.net/file/view/IESD-Socialization-Study-May-2009.pdf online schooling, public schools, socialization, social skills, homeschooling, research In section “Socialization in the Absence of Face-to-Face Contact: Results from Home-Schooling Research” (p. 5), gives a fairly accurate summary of research done on the social, emotional, and psychological development of homeschooled children/students. “Summary Conventional schooling has traditionally been viewed as a primary vehicle for socialization of children. This perception has resulted in concerns that children who do not receive conventional schooling may lack adequate opportunities to develop their social skills. Despite these concerns, most of the limited research on children who have been home-schooled has found that these children’s socialization is equal, and in some cases superior, to that of children who attend conventional schools. While this research is not directly applicable to students in other schooling situations—such as online public schools—it suggests that at least in some cases, students appear to acquire adequate social skills from settings that do not include face-to-face interaction with other children and teachers in a traditional classroom environment [p. 6 ends here]. Thus far, no substantial body of research exists on the question of how online schooling impacts students’ socialization. The present study was designed to help address this research gap by comparing parent, state certified public school teacher, and student self-assessments of the socialization skills of students who have been attending online public schools (more than 250 students total) to national norms for the same nationally recognized assessment. This study also collected important information about the reasons students attend online public schools, student social and individual activities outside of school, and parents’ perceptions of the impact of online public schooling” [p. 7].” “In general, the results of this evaluation suggest that typical, mainstream students enrolled in full-time, online public schools—i.e., students without the kinds of special needs that might result in pulling them out of regular public school classrooms—are either superior to or not significantly different than students enrolled in traditional public schools with respect to social skills and problem behaviors. There is also preliminary evidence suggesting that students enrolled in full-time, online public schools might have an advantage in their social skills development if they are highly engaged in activities outside of the school day—including activities involving peer interaction and activities not involving peer interaction. Furthermore, the results indicate parent perceptions of important benefits to online public schooling, related to academics and other aspects of their children’s education. These and other findings are discussed in detail below” [p. 31].
Skerry, P. 1980 Christian schools versus the I.R.S. Public Interest, 61, 18-41. Discussion of the role of the state in the regulation of private and religious education.
Skillen, James W. 1998 Justice and civil society. The Civil Society Project, 98(2), 1-6. justice, education, family, parent rights, school choice Available from The Civil Society Project, 3544 N Progress Ave Suite 101, Harrisburg PA 17110 Focuses on the family and education as related to justice in a nation. “According to the Romans, justice meant ‘giving to each its due.’ Plato and Aristotle conceived of justice as the proper ordering of society, resulting from the rule of reason over passion in public deliberation. The biblical tradition ties justice to righteous conduct--that which is consistent with God’s commandments, a proper respect toward the Creator and His creatures. Many today stress the concept of justice as ‘fairness’” [p. 1]. There is an emerging conflict in law in our society today that is pushed by those who promote the ever-increasing autonomy of individuals without accountability to others and these folks “... have pushed the law in the direction of giving minor children more and more freedom over against their parents” [p. 3]. “While it is true that public law should not misidentify the family as a totalitarian enclave in which parents may do anything and everything whatever to their children, it is also true that every public-legal attempt to ‘liberate’ minor children from parents makes the minors subject to whatever legal, medical or other authority is then authorized to direct or influence their actions. Thus, not only are the children not liberated from all external authorities, but one of the most important non-governmental institutions of society is thereby weakened by the overwhelming power of the state. The family as an [p. 3 ends here] institution suffers injustice, as does the child who was created first for family life and, via the family, for eventual adult maturity and personal independence. [new paragraph] In sum--and going back to points made earlier--I would argue that the failure to identify human beings correctly as persons-in-community and the family as the foremost community for children, when combined with the failure to discriminate properly in law between adults and minor children, leads to the publicly unjust treatment of families and children. ..... [new paragraph] Legally, parents are free to select the means of schooling for their children. In fact, however, parents who choose agents of education other than the local public (government-provided) schools are treated quite unequally. Their taxes are still collected for public education, but little or no tax support is dedicated to the education of their children. ..... [new paragraph] Now, the question of justice is this: Why should parents, who fulfill both the legal principalship for their children and the public obligation to educate their children, be treated in quite unequal ways depending on whether they send their child to a government-run school or an independent school? ..... [new paragraph] This argument (and the system it created) does injustice to the equal principalship of all parents, violates the First Amendment’s guarantee of equal religious freedom to all citizens, and contradicts the law’s own allowance that independent schools adequately fulfill a public educational purpose. The violation of parental principalship and religious freedom shows up especially in the fact that parents who are too poor either to move to a better school district or to purchase independent schooling have no choice but to send their children to the local government-provided school even when that school is judged to be inadequate for, or contradictory of, their parental responsibility. In other words, the government, presuming authority as educational principal, displaces or overwhelms parental principalship. ..... [new paragraph] Government’s legitimate public interest in the education of its citizens has overreached itself in the direction of claiming some of the responsibility of principalship for children that properly belongs to parents” [p. 5].
Slater, Eileen V.; Burton, Kate; & McKillip, Dianne 2020 Reasons for home educating in Australia: who and why? Educational Review. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00131911.2020.1728232 Home school, homeschooling, home education, reasons, motivations, disability, ADHD, ASD “ABSTRACT Home education is a legal educational option in Australia that continues to rise in popularity. This paper summarises the demographics and influences upon the decision to home educate of 385 home education families from Australia, representing 676 children who were home educated at the time of questionnaire completion. The research suggests female caregivers with higher levels of educational achievement than the general population predominantly coordinate home education. Some families eschewed mainstream education for philosophical reasons whilst others home educated due to perceived necessity. However, characteristic of both groups was the belief that the current education system was unable to provide a learning environment that would meet the educational and psychosocial needs of their children. This was not specific to a particular population of students but included those who were gifted children, or those who had a mental health or neurodevelopmental disorder such as autism spectrum disorder, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), learning disabilities, intellectual disability and/or impairment in vision and hearing. This has clear implications for policy and resourcing, including in-service teacher training. It also raises questions in relation to the provision of funding for families who home educate their children.”) Retrieved March 2, 2020 from https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00131911.2020.1728232
Smedley, Thomas C. 1992, May The socialization of home school children: A communication approach. Master's thesis, Radford University, Radford, Virginia. home education, socialization, communication skills, daily living skills Used the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales to evaluate the communication skills, socialization, and daily living skills of demographically matched public school and home educated students. The scores were combined into one composite which reflected the general maturity of each subject. Smedley's data revealed that "... the home educated children in this sample were significantly better socialized and more mature than those in public school. The immediate implication is that home school families are providing adequately for socialization needs" (abstract).
Smedley, Thomas C. Socialization of home school children 1992 Home School Researcher, 8(3), 9-16. http://www.nheri.org/home-school-researcher/ research, home education, socialization, communication, peer-reviewed Uses conceptual framework based on communication theory and the interactional school of thought to test hypothesis that social competence can best be fostered in a conventional school. Compared homeschool to public school students. Causal-comparative but did not statistically control background variables; something of a matched-group design. “The populations studied for this thesis consisted of 33 children of white, middle class, Protestant families. These included 16 females and 17 males. Subjects were evaluated by their parents. Most of these parents were recruited by the researcher while attending child-centered recreational activities. Two families were enlisted through a mutual friend. The larger sample (20 cases) came from families belonging to the Greater Roanoke Home Educator's Association (GRHEA), which sponsors regular social events for members. For a control group, this study tested children who attend the same kind of Protestant churches as the home school students, but go to public school. Most of these parents were enlisted through an AW ANA children's program at a local Baptist church. This study surveyed twelve Baptist children, nine who attend the Christian and Missionary Alliance Church (C.M.A.)., nine children from charismatic churches, and three in mainline churches (Disciples of Christ and Presbyterian Church in America)” (p. 10). “The Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales has been in use since 1935, and is frequently used in studies of juvenile and special-education populations. Originally created as the Vineland Social Maturity Scale ... The VABS is a robust and well-tested diagnostic tool. In hundreds of studies over the decades, it has established its reliability and validity for measuring the communication domain, the daily living skills domain, and the socialization domain of test subjects” (p. 10). “The mean Adaptive Behavior Composite score of 115.55 for the home schooled children is in the 84th percentile; compared to the nationwide norm, they score in the top 16%. The control group score placed them in the 23rd percentile, among the top 77% of the nation. In terms of the socialization subcategory score, the home school students rank in the top 27%. The public school students ranked with the top 75%” (p. 12). Concludes "... that children kept home are more mature and better socialized than those who are sent to school" [p. 12]. “An unnatural aspect of the public school environment is the age segregation. Learning to get along with peers does not necessarily prepare the student for interactions with older and younger people in real life. In the home school family, on the other hand, people of various ages and generations mix easily together in a variety that more accurately mirrors the outside society” [retrieved 4/1/13 from http://www.nheri.org/home-school-researcher/]. Peer-reviewed.
Smedley, Tom 2005 Homeschooling for liberty. In Bruce S. Cooper (Ed.), Home schooling in full view: A reader, p. 69-74. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing. home education, philosophy, opinion
Smelser, N.J., & Halpren, S. 1978 The historical triangulation of family, economy, and education. In J. Demos & S. S. Boocock (Eds.), Turning points: historical and sociological essays on the family. American Journal of Sociology 84, supplement. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. History.
Smiley, Henry T. 2010 She’s leaving home: The effect of college experiences on homeschooled students (Doctoral dissertation (Ed.D.), University Of Arkansas at Little Rock, 158 pages, # 3413965). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 3413965) http://gradworks.umi.com/34/13/3413965.html homeschooling, home education, postsecondary, adults, values, beliefs, worldview "Abstract: Most existing homeschool research focuses on one of two concerns: the efficacy of home education and the socialization of the homeschooled student. The purpose of this study was to examine how the beliefs, values, and worldviews of homeschooled students were affected by their experiences at the post-secondary level, specifically in the multicultural environment of public four-year colleges and universities. Data were collected through interviews with eleven participants: six homeschooling parents and five homeschooled students. Homeschooled students who formed close relationships with students unlike themselves and who were involved in leadership roles in their respective post-secondary institutions seemingly assimilated different worldviews and, in the process, broadened their own perspectives to a greater degree than did those students who were less engaged. While some degree of assimilation of other perspectives occurred, most of the student participants’ self-perceptions remained relatively unaffected; indeed, most of the participants described a strengthening of the values inculcated through home education in response to their college and university experiences. Keywords: education, homeschool, intellectual development, post-secondary experiences, self-perception" (Retrieved March 11, 2015 from http://gradworks.umi.com/34/13/3413965.html
Smit, Frederik, van Esch, Wil, & Walberg, Herbert J. 1993 Parental involvement in education. Published by and available from Institute for Applied Social Sciences, Katholieke Universiteit Nijmegen, Postbus 9048, 6500 KJ Nijmegen, the Netherlands. parental involvement, home education, research, academic achievement, history, school choice, economics Designed to be an impetus for a "...further discussion on the changing role of parents in regard to future developments" [Preface]. Divisions are "parental choice and school involvement," "school and family partnerships," "the effect of the home and family on the learning environment" (with chapters by Brian Ray and Roland Meighan on home education), and "parental involvement and student achievement." A variety of opinions and philosophies are expressed and implied in these chapters, but a general theme seems to be that parental involvement, in some form, is valuable to the best education of children.
Smith, Bruce M. 1993, February A big "butter and egg" man. Phi Delta Kappan, Feb. 1993, 427. opinion, gender differences, adult-child interaction, parent-child interaction Quotes Lasch who wrote, "`In most societies known to historians or to anthropologists, the young get an education by working alongside adults. The requirement that adolescents spend most of their time in school is a fairly recent innovation, closely linked to the rise of modern nation states.'" "This separation of the young from the adult world, though necessary to a degree in industrial societies, does handicap our children to some extent. How are they to learn the possibilities that adult world holds for them? How are they to learn what work is like in offices, factories, or hospitals?," writes Smith. Adolescent girls experience more emotional distress, negative body image, discrimination, etc. than do boys.
Smith, Christian, & Sikkink, David 1999, April Is private schooling privatizing? First Things, No. 92, April, 16-20. https://www.firstthings.com/article/1999/04/is-private-schooling-privatizing http://www.firstthings.com/article/2009/02/001-is-private-schooling-privatizing-36 http://www.firstthings.com/ftissues/ft9904/articles/smith.html home education, private education, public schools, research, civic involvement, socialization, politics, family Retrieved December 11, 2017 from https://www.firstthings.com/article/1999/04/is-private-schooling-privatizing and retrieved March 1, 2012 from http://www.firstthings.com/article/2009/02/001-is-private-schooling-privatizing-36 and 2/7/00 & 7/31/00 http://www.firstthings.com/ftissues/ft9904/articles/smith.html. (Uses data from the 1996 National Household Education Survey conducted by the U.S. Department of Education which differentiates public schoolers from Catholic schoolers, non-Catholic church-related schoolers, nonreligious private schoolers, and home schoolers and asks parents “... about the extent of family involvements in a variety of civic activities” [p. 17]. “In addition to questions about schooling, the survey asked parents questions about the extent of family involvements in a variety of civic activities. Parents reported whether they were members of a community organization; participated in an ongoing community service activity; went to the public library for books, tapes, lectures, story hours, or to use library equipment; voted in a national or state election in the previous five years; wrote or telephoned an editor or public official or signed a petition in the previous twelve months; attended a public meeting in the previous twelve months; contributed money to a political candidate, party, or cause in the previous twelve months; worked for a political cause in the previous twelve months; or participated in a protest or boycott in the previous twelve months. By comparing differences in family participation in these nine forms of civic involvement, we are able to determine empirically whether private schooling actually is or is not privatizing.” Based on the data, “In other words, there appears to be something particular about religious private schooling and home schooling in and of themselves that increases families’ participation in mostly non-school-related civic activities in the public square” [p. 18]. “Far from being privatized and isolated, home schooling families are typically very well networked and quite civically active” [p. 18]. “The empirical evidence is clear and decisive: private schoolers and home schoolers are considerably more civically involved in the public square than are public schoolers even when the effects of differences in education, income, and other related factors are removed from the equation. Indeed, we have reason to believe that the organizations and practices involved in private and home schooling, in themselves, tend to foster public participation in civic affairs. . . . . . the challenges, responsibilities, and practices that private schooling and home education normally entail for their participants may actually help reinvigorate America's civic culture and the participation of her citizens in the public square” [p. 20].
Smith, D. S. 1996, February Parent-generated home study in Canada. The Canadian School Executive, 15(8), pages? Retrieved 12/4/00 online http://user.fundy.net/fplace/overview.htm. http://user.fundy.net/fplace/overview.htm home education, research, policy, population, foreign, Canada “Sources of information-Two strategies were used to obtain data (Smith, 1993): a questionnaire directed to each of the provincial and territorial Deputy Ministers of Education and a survey of home schooling associations.” “I was surprised at the length to which the various provincial and territorial Departments of Education have gone to accommodate the relatively few home schoolers. In light of the legislative and regulative climate that exists in some of the American states, the degree of cooperation and accommodation that exists, for the most part, in Canada is remarkable.” “When dealing with home schoolers, legislators, educators and administrators should remember that just as parents cannot match or provide all the infrastructure of a school within the home, a school cannot provide the attention and care of a loving, concerned and responsible parent.” “Who Home schools? - Home schoolers are, by any classification, a diverse lot: doctors, back-to-the-landers, lawyers, francophones, anglophones, fundamentalist ministers, farmers, housewives, teachers and just plain parents - of all faiths and creeds. And all are united in one common way: They are concerned about their children and the nature of their children's education. And concerned enough to do something about it themselves. [paragraph] A majority of parents, it is true, undertake home schooling because they have a deep conviction that the school system no longer upholds their religious and moral convictions. Others home school for pedagogical reasons, having a deep-seated dissatisfaction with the school system and the quality of education it offers. Still others undertake to home school because of their conviction that their child's welfare and education are their responsibility.” Estimates there were about 10,000 officially registered homesschool K-12 students in 1990-91 (out of a total 1990-91 Canada-wide K-12 public and private school enrollment of 5,141,003, so about 0.02%) but “For example, estimates obtained from home schooling sources for Ontario and Alberta suggest home school student populations of 5,000 for Ontario and 5,000 for Alberta, with a national total of around 30,000.”
Smith, David E. 1989 An analysis of the decision-making processes used by Washington public school superintendents in resolving conflicts associated with the home schooling law. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Gonzaga University, Spokane WA. University Microfilms International, Order No. 8926352
Smith, David S. 1993, September 30 Parent-generated home study in Canada. Available from The Francombe Place/Research Associates, Box 2000, Westfield R.R. 1, New Brunswick, E0G 3J0, Canada. home education, research, descriptive, legal, law, numbers or population size Focuses on statutes and legislation governing home education in Canada, views of public officials, and number of children home educated in Canada.
Smith, Elizabeth 1991, October 12 Home schoolers go to college. home education
Smith, Gerald R., Gregory, T. B., & Pugh, R. C. 1981 Meeting student needs: Evidence for the superiority of alternative schools. Phi Delta Kappan, April, 561-564. Alternative education.
Smith, J. Michael 2004, November 24 Response to Akron Beacon Journal homeschool series. Retrieved 11/24/04 online http://hslda.org/docs/news/hslda/200411/200411240.asp. http://hslda.org/docs/news/hslda/200411/200411240.asp home education, opinion, philosophy, research, law Smith, president of the Home School Legal Defense Association [HSLDA], writes: “Although Home School Legal Defense Association is confident that homeschooling's success can withstand intense scrutiny, we are concerned about the potential these articles have to mislead readers who are unfamiliar with the movement. It's always dangerous to attribute motives to actions, but one has to question why the two authors of these articles would devote seven days in the paper to homeschooling. A good guess is they want to see homeschooling more regulated. Almost all of the stories concluded that there is some good in homeschooling, but there is some bad and government oversight is needed to correct the bad.”
Smith, J. Michael 2017 Thank you, Michael Farris! The Home School Court Report, 33(1), 6-7, 62; published by HSLDA. Retrieved February 12, 2021 from https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/hslda/2017q1/index.php#/p/6 https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/hslda/2017q1/index.php#/p/6 homeschooling, history, advocacy, research, HSLDA, Michael Farris Michael P. Farris (Mike Farris), in the early years of the modern homeschool movement, promoted two very important things to advance the movement: (a) "Have the legislators get to know homeschooling families personally and encourage families to visit the legislators in their offices and invite them to their homes --- since homeschooled children are really the best argument for homeschooling" (p. 6); and (b) “Present reliable, scientific evidence that homeschooling children are receiving an outstanding [p. 6 ends] education from their parents. ..... "Mike [Farris] commissioned an initial study [by Brian Ray and NHERI], and soon a growing body of research revealed that homeschooled students tested way above their public school counterparts on all subjects. These studies crushed the myth that homeschooling parents can't provide a quality education for their children" (p. 62).
Smith, J. Michael, & Farris, Michael P. 2002, June 26 The problem with home-based charter schools: HSLDA's position in the charter school debate. Retrieved January 19, 2008 from http://www.hslda.org/docs/nche/000010/200206260.asp. http://www.hslda.org/docs/nche/000010/200206260.asp home education, charter schools, philosophy, law, regulation, control, public school “Limits parental freedom & brings regulation. The state must hold recipients of taxpayer dollars accountable for how they use the funds. The flip side of the "free benefits" coin is not Lady Liberty—it's a door to increased "accountability checks": certified teacher oversight, curriculum approval, mandatory testing, and sometimes even home inspections. Ultimately, as these requirements grow, they will squelch one of the greatest benefits to home education—flexibility to accommodate each child's learning style and interest. Rather than more control, HSLDA believes there should be less control and interference with parents' rights to direct the education of their children. Nationally normed standardized test results indicate that home schooled students score on average 30 percentile points above the national average. Private home schoolers have demonstrated that state funding and regulation are not necessary to achieve academic excellence. Restricts religious freedom. Some 30 states already prohibit public schools and public school-funded programs from using sectarian materials. Because home-based charter schools are tax-funded, parents cannot use Christian or other religious curriculum, nor will the home-based charter school give their children credit for religious courses/materials.”
Smith, J. Michael; & Mason, James R., III 2020 Homeschool freedom: How it works and why we must protect it. Purcellville, VA: Home School Legal Defense Association. homeschooling, home education, law, legal, regulation, philosophy, research, academic achievement, socialization, social development, adulthood, success, book From publisher’s website: “Just when COVID-19 was closing America’s schools and making homes the primary place of learning, Harvard law professor Elizabeth Bartholet made headlines by arguing that homeschooling should be banned. For 37 years, HSLDA has advocated for homeschooling freedom because we believe homeschooling works—and is good for kids. Professor Bartholet’s Arizona Law Review article reveals her low opinion of homeschooling and outlines her state-centric prescription for fixing the “problems” she’s identified—problems that are contrary to our experience and the evidence. In 14 chapters, the HSLDA attorneys and two researchers address many of Professor’s Bartholet’s erroneous claims and presumptions and show how homeschooling can only work effectively in an environment of freedom.”
Smith, Steven D., Bannink-Misiewicz, Jilanne, & Bareman, Shelly 1992 A comparison of the fundamental motor skill abilities of home school and conventional school children. Home School Researcher, 8(2), 1-8. home education, research, psychomotor or motor domain, locomotor, affective, self-perception, self-concept Researchers set alpha = .10 to be sensitive to any between-group differences that might exist in this exploratory study. Based on their sample from Michigan, "...the home school group performed at a significantly lower level than the conventional school group in fundamental motor skill ability [p < .059]. ...the differences between groups were more marked in the area of locomotor skills than in object-control skills" (p. 5). Both Michigan groups scored lower than the national average. "The home school group perceived competence scores were significantly lower in many of the domains [e.g., cognitive and maternal acceptance] tested when compared to the conventional school group" (p. 5). Sample size was n=56 home school and n=44 conventional school students. Suggests this research needs to be expanded to the national level.
Smith, T. L. 1967 Protestant schooling and American nationality, 1800-1850. The Journal of American History, 53, 679-695. History of the support of the evangelical church in the development of the common school.
Smith, Tom E. C 1990 Introduction to education (2nd ed.). St. Paul, MN: West Publishing Co.. general education, home education Discusses the ideas of proponents and opponents of the public, government-controlled, common school movement of the 19th century [p. 55-57]. Includes 2 pp. on home education, saying home education used to be considered a subversive activity, majority are religious fundamentalists but overall they represent a cross-section of our society, suggest cooperation by public schools, p. 25-27
Smith, V. H. 1983 An endorsement of home schooling as a civil right and vehicle for social change [a book review of John Holt’s Teach your own]. Phi Delta Kappan, 64, 441. Law. Social change, reasons, home education, educational reform.
Smith, Vernon H., & Barr, R. C. 1976 Where should learning take place? In William Van Til (Ed.), Issues in secondary education. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 153-177.
Smithwick, Dan 2001, September One school generation to go, and then the end. Chalcedon Report, p. 7. worldview, home education, research, philosophy, values, beliefs Author states: "In the mid nineteen eighties it was common to find Christian youth both in Christian schools and public schools scoring in the Moderate Christian worldview classification [of the PEERS Test, Politics, Economics, Education, Religion, and Social Issues]. Home school students generally scored 15-20% higher than average from day schools" [p. 7].
Smithwick, Dan 2008, August 1 Where are we going? Lexington, KY: Nehemiah Institute, Inc. Retrieved 4/14/10 from http://www.nehemiahinstitute.com/articles/index.php?action=show&id=35. http://www.nehemiahinstitute.com/articles/index.php?action=show&id=35 home education, research, religion, religiosity, public schools, private schools, Christian schools, worldview, philosophy, curriculum “In 1986 our ministry developed a unique biblical worldview assessment tool called the PEERS Test. The assessment was designed to reflect an individual’s basic ‘worldview position’ in five key areas of life: Politics, Economics, Education, Religion and Social Issues (P-E-E-R-S). Using a scale of +100 to -100, results of the 70-item test ranked the individual into one of four worldview categories- Biblical Theism (70-100), Moderate Christian (30-69), Secular Humanism (0-29) and Socialism (scores less than 0). The PEERS test has been through several forms of validity measurements most significantly a professionally conducted Validity & Reliability study performed in 1995. In all cases the PEERS Test has received high marks as a valid instrument for the measurement of ‘worldview’ understanding. ….. PEERS results from these three particular high school settings have been tracked since 1988. With 20 years of assessment data, from approximately 60,000 students, the following results have occurred: 1988 2007 Average change per year Public school students 38.9 5.4 [an average annual change of] -1.65 points Traditional Christian schools 49.7 17.3 [an average annual change of] -1.62 “Worldview-based schools 62.1 69.4 [an average annual change of] +0.37” In all three groups the results have varied year-to-year with slight increases or decreases, but with noticeably consistent trend lines. Homeschool students generally have ranged between the Traditional Christian school students and the Worldview-based school students, average score for high school level at 48.65 for the past three years. A small percentage of home school students have scored very well, above 80.0 (about 8%) but a surprisingly higher percentage score low, less than 30.0 (about 25%). Using this classification of schools and the assessment data of each group, it is the position of Nehemiah Institute that at least 90% of youth from Christian homes are attending either public schools or traditional Christian schools and are consistently abandoning the Christian worldview in favor of the Humanist/Socialist worldview. Results are fairly good in the worldview-based schools but the rate of improvement could be stronger. It is estimated that there are less than 500 ‘worldview-based’ Christian schools in the U.S. out of the approximately 12,000 private Christian & parochial schools in existence. These trends do not bode well for the health of the Christian church in America over the next 20-40 years.”
Smithwick, Daniel J. 1999 Teachers, curriculum, control: A ‘world’ of difference in public and private schools. Nehemiah Institute, 3735 Harrodsburg Rd. Ste. 150-115, Lexington KY 40513. private education, public education, research, worldview, philosophy, Christian Provides data from the PEERS Test, that measures the extent to which one has a biblical worldview--in politics, economics, education, religion, and social issues -- on public versus private school students from families that attend Christian churches. Shows that those in Christian schools have a stronger biblical Christian worldview, but even the Christian school students’ worldview should be stronger. Makes case that state-run public schools are not a good place for training students in Christian thinking and promotes private and home schooling.
Smollar, D. 1990, January 14, County helps family do their homework. Los Angeles Times, San Diego section.
Sneath, Robyn 2013 Be not wise - A study of Old Colony Mennonite educational beliefs and practices in Canada and Mexico. Sneath, R. (2013). Doctoral student paper, Oxford University, Oxford, UK. http://www.fondationtrudeau.ca/en/community/robyn-sneath philosophy, religion, Mennonites, public school, private school, homeschooling, research, qualitative, state authority Personal communication 7/18/13 with author says paper is based on “unpublished raw data.” Appears very respectful of the religious values and beliefs of the Mennonite people who are faced with state authority regarding their children, and of private schooling and homeschooling. “Drawing on over a century of history of Mennonite communities in Canada, Robyn Sneath is learning about how government education policies may have conflicted with Mennonites’ vision of citizenship” – retrieved 7/8/13 from http://www.fondationtrudeau.ca/en/community/robyn-sneath. “Abstract: This study comprises an archival and multi-sited ethnographic analysis of the Old Colony Mennonites’ perceptions of the purpose of schooling and the extent to which this understanding has remained constant across time and space. In the 1920s conflict over schooling prompted the exodus of 8,000 Mennonites from Manitoba, Canada to Chihuahua, Mexico; since then at least 50,000 Old Colonists have returned to Canada, where tensions over schooling persist. For the Mennonites, schooling serves as the primary locus through which their language, faith, and worldview are transmitted and these goals have often conflicted directly with concepts of schooling as a vehicle through which autonomy and social mobility are promoted. Ethnographic accounts—composed through participant-observation in two Old Colony private schools in Manitoba and two in Mexico, as well as interviews with teachers, community leaders, parents of children in private, public, and home schools [homeschools], and with Old Colony children (50 interviews in total)— will complement the rich archival record, which includes school inspector reports, court records, memoirs, newspapers, and personal correspondence. The archival analysis as well as the Mexican Mennonite ethnography will be used to inform and contextualize the current state of Old Colony education in Manitoba. Canada has had a long and contentious history on the topic of religious and ethnic minorities and schooling, and yet there exists a paucity of research in the area. This powerful and relatively unknown story of Old Colony Mennonite schooling has the potential to make significant contributions to the field of intercultural education by illustrating how minority groups have used education to preserve the religious and linguistic boundaries of their group vis a vis the dominant culture. My hope is that by elucidating Old Colony Mennonites’ attitudes towards education, light may be shed on current issues surrounding education, citizenship, and religion, especially given the increasingly diverse religious commitments of Canadian citizens” (p. 2). “By approaching my project with an ethic of respect and thinking of my research as ‘with’ and ‘for’ the Old Colony Mennonite communities, then hopefully issues of reciprocity, access, consent, and the application of theory to the data will be easier to navigate. For many Old Colony Mennonites, to relinquish control of their children’s education to the authorities was to deny their godly duty to raise their children within the protective fold of the community. From the perspective of Canadian lawmakers, to allow Mennonites full control of the education of their children was an affront to their understanding of what it meant to be Canadian and was perceived as an act of subversion against the state. Ultimately, an archival analysis, combined with interviews with those who have experienced firsthand the tensions between state and sect—Old Colony parents, teachers, pupils, and leaders—will provide a powerful triangulation with potential to shed considerable light on a heretofore underexamined issue” (p. 19).
Snow, Catherine E., Barnes, Wendy S., Chandler, Jean, Goodman, Irene F., & Hemphill, Lowry 1991 Unfulfilled expectations: Home and school influences on literacy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 251 pp. literacy, achievement, family factors, home Examines home and family characteristics, school teaching practices, and family-school relationships that affect the literacy development of an ethnically diverse of low-income children in grades two, four, and six, the 32 subjects of an intensive two-year study and a follow-up study five years later; original two-year study had optimistic findings while follow-up documented declining achievement and lowered expectations for the children as they continued through secondary school.
Snyder, Marc 2013 An evaluative study of the academic achievement of homeschooled students versus traditionally schooled students attending a Catholic university. Catholic Education: A Journal of Inquiry and Practice, 16(2), 288-308. home education, research, academic achievement, GPA, SAT scores, ACT scores, adulthood, college, adults, Descriptors: Academic Achievement, Grade Point Average, Home Schooling, Church Related Colleges, peer-reviewed Provide an evaluation of the academic achievement of homeschooled students compared to traditionally/conventionally schooled students attending a Catholic university. Cross-sectional descriptive and comparative study, with no multivariate analyses controlling independent variables to compare groups on a dependent variable. “Using archival data, 408 students were evaluated based on their four-year secondary school type: 137 public-schooled students; 142 Catholic-schooled students; and 129 homeschooled students. Equally weighted criteria were overall SAT or ACT scores, overall college grade-point average (GPA), GPA by major, and core GPA. A statistically significant difference was found between homeschooled students and traditionally schooled students in ACT and SAT scores and overall GPA, showing value to the institution and supporting the literature with regards to the academic viability of homeschooled students in college” (p. 288). Homeschool students’ SAT and ACT scores and overall GPAs were significantly higher than those of both Catholic and public school students. There was no difference between the core and major GPAs of homeschool students and the other two school types of students. “Since the results of homeschooling can be seen at the highest level in a college or university, there is no reason to doubt that the home is as effective as a traditional school in preparing students for academic success in higher education” (p. 305). Peer-reviewed.
Soencksen, Keith 2011 Indoctrinating children. The Paper MACHÉ, August/September 2011, pp. 4-5. home education, homeschooling, philosophy, opinion, worldview, indoctrination “Are Christian homeschoolers guilty of that [indoctrinating one’s children to the biblical worldview]? Do we teach our children through a biblical filter? Absolutely. Do we teach certain things in certain ways that the world doesn’t consider mainstream? Most definitely. Do we teach our children with the expectation that they will accept our ideology uncritically? If we’re honest, we do at times, especially with younger children” [p. 5]. “Does the government school system [public schools] indoctrinate students? Oh yeah! Do they teach children through a specific filter? Most certainly. It’s the filter of secular humanism, which means anything biblical gets filtered out. Do they teach certain things in certain ways that a Bible-believeing Christina would consider immoral, and do they expect students to swallow them without question? Of course” [p. 5].
Soling, Cevin 2017, circa Does compulsory schooling cause cognitive and biological harm? Received September 11, 2017 from author. captivity, stress, coping, helplessness, compulsory schooling, truancy, bullying, school refusal, achievement gap “This paper reviews studies on captivity and its potential to induce stress among the captive population. The adverse health consequences of chronic stress are well documented. This includes emotional responses, such as depression, anxiety, antisocial and aggressive behavior, as well as physical debilities, such as damage to the brain and circulatory system. In addition, mental faculties are often impaired, and health consequences are frequently witnessed in this kind of environment. The coping mechanisms of individuals within the captive audience play a role in the expression of observable symptoms of stress. Given compulsory schooling is designed to operate with a captive population, children confined in compulsory schools should be expected to exhibit signs of chronic stress in accordance with factors such as each student’s coping ability. Keywords: Captivity, stress, coping, helplessness, compulsory schooling, truancy, bullying, school refusal, achievement gap ” (p. 1).
Solomone, Rosemary 2004, October 20 Home Schooling and Religious Freedom: Who Owns the Child? Education Week, 24(8), 41, 52. Retrieved 10/21/04 online http://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2004/10/20/08salomone.h24.html. http://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2004/10/20/08salomone.h24.html home education, philosophy, state control, parental control, rights Expresses concern that many states are compromising too much and giving parents too much authority over the education of children, as expressed via homeschooling. “At the heart of the controversy is a compromise reached almost a century ago over the shared responsibility of parents and the state to educate future citizens. In Pierce v. Society of Sisters, the U.S. Supreme Court in 1925 recognized the right of parents to opt out of public education in favor of private schools. Yet the justices also affirmed the right of the state to “reasonably” regulate those schools.” Claims that some states are ignoring the welfare of children and the interest of the state. “But it is equally troubling that nearly half the states have legislatively unraveled the Pierce compromise and ceded almost unfettered authority to parents while minimizing the good of society and of the children involved. Religious-freedom protection laws, unless thoughtfully applied, can push this deregulatory trend to a dangerous extreme.” Ignores the fact that throughout history of US, including since the Pierce case, the states have had virtually no regulatory control over the education of children in private schools and thus does not explain why she is not concerned about this or why she is not warning reader that the state must intervene more in private institutional schooling.
Solorzano, Lucia 1985, August 19 Teaching kids at home stirs new uproar. U. S. News and World Report, p. 59. Reports estimated 30,000 American families home school. Law. Many home school as fundamentalist Christians. Other reasons.
Somerville, Scott 1996, December 10 Personal communication from Somerville to B. Ray. Somerville was an attorney for Home School Legal Defense Association, Paeonian Springs, VA. home education, urban, race, racial, ethnicity, white, black, Hispanic, minority, minorities Somerville wrote regarding urban homeschooling and the Urban Homeschool Movement: "White and black home schoolers in the DC metropolitan area have been meeting together since April, 1996 to find ways for the existing home school community in the suburbs to serve the newer generation of home schoolers in the city."
Somerville, Scott W. 2005 Legal rights for homeschool families. In Bruce S. Cooper (Ed.), Home schooling in full view: A reader, p. 135-149. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing.
Songe, Alice H. 1982 Private school education in the U.S., an annotated bibliography, 1950-1980. Jefferson and London: McFarland, 89 p.
Sorey, Kellie; & Duggan, Molly 2008, Summer Homeschoolers Entering Community Colleges: Perceptions of Admission Officers. Journal of College Admission, Summer 2008, 22-28. Retrieved April 22, 2017 from http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ829457.pdf http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ829457.pdf Home Schooling, College Admission, Community Colleges, Admissions Officers, Peer reviewed An estimated 1.1 million students were homeschooled in the United States in spring 2003, according to the U.S. Department of Education's National Center for Education Statistics (2006). This figure represents a sizeable increase from the homeschooling rate of 1.7 percent--or 850,000 students--in 1999. With the popularity of homeschooling strengthening, particularly homeschooling at the secondary level, the prevalence of homeschoolers attempting to enter higher education is escalating. Despite this trend, many college admission officers across the U.S. seem unprepared in evaluating these candidates for admission. This article describes an empirical research which provides a general overview of the collegiate performance of homeschoolers and highlights the perceptions of college and university staff members now serving this growing population. (Contains 3 tables.) Not a measure of learner outcomes, but of perceptions of college personnel. Peer reviewed.
Sorokin, Ellen 2003, February 9 Blacks turn to home-schooling. The Washington Times. Retrieved 2/9/03 online http://www.washtimes.com/national/20030209-93364246.htm. http://www.washtimes.com/national/20030209-93364246.htm home education, minorities, black, African American Cites NHERI’s research
Sorooshian, Pam 1998, September/October All homeschoolers are welcome. Home Education Magazine, 15(5), 31-32. home education, public school support, cooptation, cooperation, philosophy, politics Discusses tax-funded, state-controlled, public school programs designed for home schoolers or education at home and philosophical and other concerns about the increasing number of these programs around the country. Argues that tax-funded programs for homeschoolers should be welcomed and those who participate in them should be welcomed by the homeschooling community.
Sotés-Elizalde, María Ángeles, & Urpí, Carmen 2015 Family involvement, autonomy, and social competency in homeschooling. US-China Education Review B, 5(11), 714-723, doi:https://doi.org/10.17265/2161-6248/2015.11.003. https://doi.org/10.17265/2161-6248/2015.11.003 home education, homeschooling, parental engagement, family involvement, competency development, social and civic competency, social cooperation, service learning Abstract “Educational agents’ demand on family involvement as a key to improve learning achievements raises home education model up to the top ranking of learning modalities, meanwhile, educational policies go to great pains to overcome school crisis. Family involvement affects children learning as much in the individual aspects as in the social participation into a world characterised by diversity. Consequently, a reflexive correspondence between individual diversity and social diversity is promoted for the improvement of personal development and social family context. In this way, family involvement and diversity are home-school keys to develop competencies; specially focussing on the autonomy and personal initiative competency and on the social and civic competency, which are included in the official curriculum of the educational system in Spain. Finally, we must emphasize the positive effects of service learning on the development of social competency of homeschoolers and the effects of technology on the development of autonomy” (p. 714). “After discussing two basic competencies that are more directly related to students’ individual and social elements, namely, the “autonomy and personal initiative competency” and the “social and civic competency,” we may conclude that both can be attained through either traditional school or homeschooling. There are procedures, content, and activities that, being approached for common objectives, are able to develop the two types of competencies, since it is possible to work autonomously in pursuing social project initiatives, with community or civic participation purposes. The present study has examined pedagogical aspects more than legal, historical, or country-comparison issues, which have been addressed in other contexts. In short, the teaching-learning process is a universal question that in and of itself allows for many variations regardless of the situation at each moment, even though the issues mentioned above affect this process greatly. In the knowledge society, where many borders are becoming increasingly blurred, learning must not only be guaranteed for the whole population with no exception, but at the same time, be considered in all its breadth and diversity. Homeschooling has proven to be one of those possibilities for consideration, as (p. 720) long as it enables the acquisition of the competencies that at any given moment in history are considered to be key for the individual and social development of persons” (p. 721).
South Dakota Department of Education and Cultural Affairs 1998, February 18 Personal communication with Dean Buchanan. academic achievement, home education, public Buchanan provided me with documents showing standardized achievement test score of home school students in March 1997. Stanford Achievement Test scores in basic battery in grades 4 and 8 were 81 and 73, respectively. Metropolitan Achievement Test scores in basic battery in grades 4 and 8 were 78 and 77, respectively.
Sowell, Thomas 1993 Inside American education: The decline, the deception, the dogmas. New York, NY: The Free Press. education, educational reform, research, philosophy, politics, law, alternatives Using much documentation, this African-American explains topics with chapter titles such as at K-12 schools: "impaired faculties," "classroom brainwashing," "assorted dogmas" [e.g., multicultural diversity; bilingual education; sensitivity; the flow of racism—Is it into or out of the schools?; relevance; the whole person; role models; self-esteem], and at colleges: "damaging admissions" [at college admissions offices], "`new racism' and old dogmatism," "ideological double standards," "teaching and preaching," and "athletic support," and in general: "the empire strikes back" and "bankruptcy"
Spangler, J. R. 1984, March Teach your child at home? Ministry. Interview with Raymond S. Moore. Reasons; early childhood education; socialization; law.
Spiegler, Thomas 2009, November Why state sanctions fail to deter home education: An analysis of home education in Germany and its implications for home education policies. Theory and Research in Education, 7(3), 297-309. homeschooling, policy, philosophy, theory, Germany “Abstract: Home education in Germany is a contravention to the school law, and severe sanctions are applied against it. Despite this, a small home education movement has developed within the last 25 years. This article, after a short overview of home education in Germany, examines the reasons why a policy with sanctions fails to deter homeschooling. Then I point out why the legitimate interests of the state and the child, which are usually given to justify the prohibition of home education, might be better served if home education were legal but regulated and controlled” (p. 297). Spiegler’s statist and democratist worldview/personal conceptual framework/philosophy is clearly evident, although he never forthrightly lays it on the table, as he promotes ultimate state control over the education of home-educated children – even though he appears to approvingly refers to the idea that “… ‘the care and upbringing of children is the natural right of parents and the duty primarily incumbent upon them’” – by arguing for R. Reich’s “triad of interests (of parents, state and child)” so that the “party” of the parents cannot “unilaterally” control the educational process (p. 306). He claims that in “… a democratic society the most appropriate way to handle home education might be to legalize and regulate it in order to promote its success” (p. 306) but never gives a foundation for this being the right thing in a “democratic” society. In other words, the author’s implied statism again fulfills itself.
Spiegler, Thomas 2010, October Parents’ motives for home education: The influence of methodological design and social context. International Electronic Journal of Elementary Education, 3(1), 57-70. home education, homeschooling, research, meta-analysis, parents’ motives, motives, reasons “Abstract: Parents’ motives for home education are one of the most researched topics within home education research. The focus of this article is on the question of the degree to which the results regarding these motives are influenced and shaped by the applied methods and the social context. The empirical basis is a meta-analysis of twelve research examples from the last two decades. It is concluded that the diversity within the results can partly be traced back to fundamental differences in the methodological design, to the absence of detailed theoretical modelling and remarkable differences of the survey instruments and that the role of the social environment and the process of the construction of motives in a certain social context deserve more attention. Keywords: home education, home schooling, parents’ motives, reasons”
Spittal, Martha 1992 Home schooling in Erie County, Pennsylvania and the attitudes of public-school administrators toward it. A project for master's degree, Edinboro University, Eerie, PA. home education, academic achievement, research, public school, attitudes Abstract describes survey of 57 home education families in Erie County, PA; have same demographic characteristics of county in general; students home educated three or more years had median standardized test percentiles of 84 in reading, 79 in mathematics, and 74 in total battery; no correlation between scores and independent variables of years home educated and educational attainment of parents; survey of 77 public school administrators found their attitudes neutral toward home schooling.
Splitt, David A. 1984 School law. Executive Educator, 6(4), 9. Also in ERIC's CIJE, No. EJ 295 066. First Amendment, Supreme Court. Reviews recent court decisions on home schooling. Author suggests home schooling should reflect public school classroom activities.
Splitt, David A. 1987, June School law. Executive Educator, 9(6), 12. Communicable Diseases, Compulsory Education, Court Litigation, Home Schooling, Legal Problems, School Law An article that discusses the right of sick employees to continue to work in the same way as any other handicapped employee might.
Spring, Joel 1990 The American school: 1642-1990 (2nd ed.). White Plains NY: Longman. education, history, family Among other things, discusses centrality of the family in colonial America in terms of being a business, school, vocational institution, church, house of correction, and welfare institution; contrasts biblical, colonial view of children with that of Rousseau; explains differences between pre- and post-Revolutionary education; "It was not until education was viewed as a government function, as opposed to a family function, that organized systems of schooling appeared. This occurred when government leaders began to see education as a useful tool for governing society" [p. 31]. For Horace Mann, a Unitarian and the most prominent of the early advocates of common schools, the term “common” in common school meant children in them “... were to receive a common moral education based on the general principles of the Bible and on common virtues, and such education was to eliminate crime and corruption in society” and he believed that not too many different political ideas should be taught in the common schools so that there would not be too much political strife let loose on the common schools; to avoid such strife, “His answer was to have schools teach only those articles of republican faith that were approved by ‘all sensible and judicious men, all patriots, and all genuine republicans.’ This political education, he proclaimed, would contain ‘articles in the creed of republicanism, which are accepted by all, believed in by all, and which form the common basis of our political faith’” [p. 89] and “... the result would be the creation of a society with a consensus of political and moral values” [p. 90]. “Common schooling was to create a common social class by the extension of a common class consciousness among all members of society. By mixing the rich and the poor within the same schoolhouse, social-class conflict would give way to a feeling of membership in a common social class and thus would provide society with a common set of political and moral values” [p. 92] and Mann justified using taxes for these schools by saying they would be a capital investment for the nation and increase the wealth of the entire community [p. 92].
Spring, Joel, 1988 Conflict of interests: The politics of American education. New York, NY: Longman. education, philsophy, politics, reform, public schools Describes education’s major interest groups and examinies potential areas of educaoinal discord (e.g., culture, language, religion, equal opportunity, power, money) and looks at politics of education at local, state, and federal levels. Discusses politics of textbook publishing and standardized testing. Examines the problem of majoritarian control. Proposes how to restructure control of America’s schools. Will. U. library.
Sproul, R. C., Jr. circa 2004 When you rise up.
St. John, Olivia 2008, January 21 Homeschoolers to nosey bureaucrats: 'Bug off!' WorldNetDaily.com. Retrieved January 21, 2008 from http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=59785. http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=59785 home education, public school, child abuse, safety, legal, law, philosophy “Anti-homeschool pundits are on the attack after a Washington, D.C., mother, Banita M. Jacks, brutally murdered her four children several months after pulling them out of public school. The children's godmother claimed that they were to be "homeschooled," but so far there has been no evidence that this ever happened. ….. The New York Times editorialized that lax homeschool regulations afforded this mentally ill mother the power to keep her children from the "prying eyes of teachers, social workers and other professionals who otherwise might have detected signs of abuse and neglect of the girls." But while it is important for adults to be aware and able to respond to any child in need, does a government school teacher's job description include the use of "prying eyes"? An associate professor at New York University, Mitchell L. Stevens, was quoted by the New York Times as saying that school officials are "society's best watchdogs of how parents treat children." Stevens stated that "home schooling removes children from a lot of that surveillance." ….. Constitutional ignorance aside, this tragic event and the succeeding media/academic/governmental pontificating bring up a valid point – Are home-educated children in greater danger of violence than public-schooled children? Let's look at the evidence. ….. Perhaps it's time for American parents to do some "prying," "surveillance" and "monitoring" of the public schools they so eagerly send their children to.”
Staff 1983, September From home schooling to Harvard. Country Journal, 25-27.
Staff 1988 Washington state's laws regulating home-based instruction. (Report No: SS-801-88). Olympia, Washington: Washington Office of the State Superintendent of Public Instruction (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED298664). Home Programs, Home Schooling, Nontraditional Education, School Attendance Legislation
Staff 1988, June Home schooling. Alexandria, VA: National Association of State Boards of Education. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED300883). Communication Problems, Educational Quality, Home Schooling, Parent Rights, School Attendance Legislation, State Boards of Education A document produced for state board members listing trends of home schooling that decision-making might be made more factually.
Staff 1991 Home schoolers beat national averages on achievement tests. Home School Legal Defense Association. home education, testing
Staff Fall 1991 OERI bulletin, pp. 1-12. research, educational improvement . Parents as teachers, p.4. (home education)., schools have key role in nurturing parent involvement, p.4. (parent school relationships)., parent publications, p.4. (research)., a look at other OERI activities for parents, p.5. (parent school relationships, research)., data indicate lack of parent involvement, p.5. (parent school relationships)., focus on families, p.6. (parent school relationships)., labs help educators involve parents, p.6. (parent school relationships).
Staff Fall-Winter 1990-1991 Home schooling: An interview with Michael Farris. Educational Freedom, 24(1), 18-23. home education
Stahl, Robert J. 1994 The essential elements of cooperative learning in the classroom, ERIC Digest. ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. 370881. Retrieved 7/2/07 from http://www.ericdigests.org/1995-1/elements.htm. http://www.ericdigests.org/1995-1/elements.htm
Statistics Canada 2001, December 4 Youth in Transition Survey, 15 year-olds (Reading Cohort) (YITS). youth, education, training, work, schooling, homeschooling Study/report does not include homeschool students. “Schools on Indian reserves were excluded, as were various types of schools for which it would be infeasible to administer the survey, such as home schooling and special needs schools. These exclusions represent less than 4% of 15-year-olds in Canada.” (p. 2). “The Youth in Transition Survey (YITS) is undertaken jointly by Statistics Canada and Human Resources and Skills Development Canada. This survey is designed to examine the major transitions in the lives of youth, particularly between education, training and work.” (p. 1).
Statistics Canada 2004, December 7 Youth in Transition Survey, 15 year-olds (Mathematics Cohort) (YITS). youth, education, training, work, schooling, homeschooling Study/report does not include homeschool students. “Target population: The target population for the Math Cohort (15 year-olds) comprises students who were born in 1987 and were attending any form of schooling in the ten provinces of Canada. Schools on Indian reserves were excluded, as were various types of schools for which it would be infeasible to administer the survey, such as home schooling and special needs schools. These exclusions represent less than 4% of 15-year-olds in Canada” (p. 2). “The Youth in Transition Survey (YITS) is undertaken jointly by Statistics Canada and Human Resources and Skills Development Canada. This survey is designed to examine the major transitions in the lives of youth, particularly between education, training and work” (p. 1).
Statistics Canada 2004, June 10 Information and Communications Technologies in Schools Survey (ICTSS). Retrieved 7/18/13 from http://www23.statcan.gc.ca. http://www23.statcan.gc.ca http://www23.statcan.gc.ca/ information and communications technologies, schools, homeschooling Study/report does not include homeschool students. “The target population for ICTSS is all elementary and secondary schools in Canada, excluding continuing education/adult day schools, trade/vocational schools, language and cultural educational schools, home schools, community education centres and social service centres” (p. 2). “The main purpose of this survey is to obtain critical benchmark data on the integration of ICT in education. The Information and Communications Technologies in Schools Survey (ICTSS) collects data on the infrastructure, reach and use of information and communications technologies in all elementary and secondary schools in Canada” (p. 1).
Statistics Canada 2006, June 26 Survey of Principals (SOP). http://www23.statcan.gc.ca http://www23.statcan.gc.ca/ principals, schools, opinion Study/report does not include homeschool students. Retrieved 7/18/13 from http://www23.statcan.gc.ca . “The target population of the Survey of Principals consists of all principals of elementary and secondary schools in Canada who held their jobs at the start of the 2004-05 school year, excluding principals of continuing education/adult day schools, trade/vocational schools, language and cultural educational schools, home schools, community education centres, social service centres, distance education centres, virtual schools and schools located in First Nations communities” (p. 2). “The main objective of this survey is to evaluate the impact of different changes observed in education such as curriculum changes, budget reductions, new policy directives on teaching and the work of principals in Canadian schools” (p. 1).
Statistics Canada 2010, December 7 Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA). Study/report does not include homeschool students. “Schools on Indian reserves were excluded, as were various types of schools for which it would be infeasible to administer the survey, such as home schooling and special needs schools. These exclusions represent less than 4% of 15-year-olds in Canada” (p. 2). “Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) is an international assessment of the skills and knowledge of 15 year-olds which aims to assess whether students approaching the end of compulsory education have acquired the knowledge and skills that are essential for full participation in society” (p. 1).
Statistics Canada, Tourism and Centre for Education Statistics Division 2013 Summary elementary and secondary school indicators for Canada, the provinces and territories, 2006/2007 to 2010/2011. Published by the Minister of Industry, Canada. elementary school, secondary school, population sizes, public school, private school, homeschooling Defines homeschooling as follows: “Home Schooling [homeschooling] is an alternative method of learning that takes place outside of the public or private school environment. Parents choosing homeschooling have the primary responsibility of managing, delivering and supervising their children’s courses and program of learning, which can vary from a very structured curriculum to free‑form learning” (p. 60). “Home Schooling Data Collection: In the summer of 2011, Statistics Canada conducted a jurisdictional review and was able to ascertain that the data collected on the ESES for public schools, Enrolment (grade), Enrolment (age) could be provided by jurisdictions for home schooling. Therefore, in January 2012, Statistics Canada started collecting home schooling data for the 2011/2012 collection period” (p. 11). This author cannot find any place in the report that homeschooling-specific data or statistics are provided, since homeschooling appears to be consistently grouped with private institutional schooling. Regarding various tables (e.g., Table 1.1), author notes: “Other: includes private schools and/or home schooling data as provided by the jurisdictions” and “Care should be taken with cross-jurisdictional comparaisons [sic]. Depending on the jurisdiction, home schooled students register with the local public school the public school board, the department of education or with an accreditated funded independent [sic] or private school” (p. 12).
Staver, Mathew D. 1987 Home education: A critical review of the statutes and case law. Home School Researcher, 3(3), 5-9.
Staver, Mathew D. date unknown, pre-1991 Evidence of Religious Bias in Public School Textbooks--a paper.
Stecklow, Steve 1994, May 10 Fed up with schools, more parents turn to teaching them at home. The Wall Street Journal, 130(91), A1, A12. Subtitle is "As numbers grow, students join in sports leagues, field trips, science labs; will they be social misfits?"; cites Brian Ray as saying about 500,000 children home schooled in U.S.
Steffenhagen, Janet 2004, April 22 Religious materials banned for B.C. home schooling. Vancouver Sun. Retrieved 4/23/04 online http://www.canada.com/vancouver/vancouversun/news/story.html?id=446fa316-11c7-41fc-a24e-f9a24bc331ce. http://www.canada.com/vancouver/vancouversun/news/story.html?id=446fa316-11c7-41fc-a24e-f9a24bc331ce home education, cooperation, public school, philosophy, politics, policy Clearly explain facts that state-run tax-funded school at home programs will not tolerate parents choosing and purchasing “religious” materials with tax money for educating their children and many parents who use these programs are realizing that they have invited government control into the education of their children that they wish they had not invited. “Home-schooling parents are fuming after the B.C. Education Ministry ordered thousands of them to stop using faith-based materials -- or any other "unofficial" resource -- when teaching their children at home. Many parents, including some who aren't religious, say they will cut their ties with the school system rather than obey the directive. "They can't tell me what to do in my own home," said Pamela Nagle, whose son is home-schooled but attends a Langley school one day a week. ….. Nagle is one of many home-schooling parents lured into the public school system in recent years through an electronic distance-education program. After starting as a pilot project with 2,200 kids, the program ballooned to 6,800. ….. To encourage the electronic programs, the ministry boosted its per-pupil funding of distance-education students in public schools to the same level as regular students ($5,408 in 2003-04). Cash-hungry districts responded by aggressively courting home-schooling families. ….. "I'm definitely not going back and I don't know anyone who is," said Anita Kosovic, who has two children in U-Connect. Although her family isn't religious, she said she doesn't want to be held to B.C.-approved resources, some of which she says are awful. "I don't think anyone should be able to tell me what I can do in my own home and that's what they're telling us.””
Steffens, Sara 2007, May 31 Danville kid snags national spelling bee title with "serrefine." Retrieved 6/1/07 from http://www.mercurynews.com/breakingnews/ci_6033601?nclick_check=1. http://www.mercurynews.com/breakingnews/ci_6033601?nclick_check=1 home education, national spelling bee competition “In the end, 13-year-old Evan O'Dorney's hours of incessant writing, recitation and word memorization came down to this: "serrefine," a small forcep for clamping a blood vessel. The Danville [California] resident won the Scripps National Spelling Bee on Thursday night by beating 15 other kids in the finals. ..... As Evan hoisted his trophy, his mother Jennifer and father Michael beamed from the audience. Jennifer, who is his homeschool teacher and devoted herself to helping him prepare, blinked back tears.”
Sternberg, Robert 2007, Fall Our research program validating the triarchic theory of successful intelligence: Reply to Gottfredson. Mensa Research Journal, 38(3), 71-79. home education, talented, gifted, special needs
Stevens, Mitchell L. 2001 Kingdom of children: Culture and controversy in the homeschooling movement. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. http://pup.princeton.edu/titles/7135.html home education, research, sociology, philosophy, religion, history, reasons Book. Publisher says 9/6/01 online http://pup.princeton.edu/titles/7135.html “Sociologist Mitchell Stevens goes behind the scenes of the homeschool movement and into the homes and meetings of home schoolers. What he finds are two very different kinds of home education--one rooted in the liberal alternative school movement of the 1960s and 1970s and one stemming from the Christian day school movement of the same era. Stevens explains how this dual history shapes the meaning and practice of home schooling today. In the process, he introduces us to an unlikely mix of parents (including fundamentalist Protestants, pagans, naturalists, and educational radicals) and notes the core values on which they agree: the sanctity of childhood and the primacy of family in the face of a highly competitive, bureaucratized society. Kingdom of Children aptly places home schoolers within longer traditions of American social activism. It reveals that home schooling is not a random collection of individuals but an elaborate social movement with its own celebrities, networks, and characteristic lifeways. Stevens shows how home schoolers have built their philosophical and religious convictions into the practical structure of the cause, and documents the political consequences of their success at doing so. Ultimately, the history of home schooling serves as a parable about the organizational strategies of the progressive left and the religious right since the 1960s. Kingdom of Children shows what happens when progressive ideals meet conventional politics, demonstrates the extraordinary political capacity of conservative Protestantism, and explains the subtle ways in which cultural sensibility shapes social movement outcomes more generally.” “Home schoolers also are wary of state intrusion into family life and generally are skeptical of the ability of bureaucracies and “experts” to meet the task of child rearing” (p. 5). “… home schoolers arguably are exemplars of effective, grassroots activism” [p. 14]. Chapter Five (Politics) shows that the Christians/exclusives got much more organized and accomplished more politically and legislatively that did the secularists/inclusives, much to the chagrin of the latter. The former created more organizations and were more effective at getting many things done. Regarding the concern of critics that homeschooled children will not be socialized or learn how to have relationships with those who are different or “other” or that homeschool parents are selfish, Stevens finds: “Thus the believers’ [i.e., Christian homeschoolers] conception of childhood [i.e., it includes a sin nature and needs direction from authoritative parents] checks some of the more untoward and unpredictable features of contemporary individualism. ….. “But they [believers’ children] also are taught early on that their lives will develop in relationship with many others, that individuals will sacrifice some measure of comfort to the group as a matter of course, and that all selves, big and small, must develop within clearly prescribed moral boundaries” [p. 190]. Stevens offers new insights and generally accurate and evenhanded portrayals of the major philosophical and pedagogical camps within the homeschool movement. Stevens, however, erroneously describes and defines some elements of Christianity and “Protestant theology” [e.g., that “… the unsaved self, while sinful, is regarded also as having a measure of goodness” [p. 186] and partially erroneously explains and interprets homeschoolers’ “believer pedagogy” as being based in some way on a child’s goodness or that believers’ homeschooling is based on a “kingdom” of children [p. 186-192]; this author, contrary to Stevens, understands from his own and others’ research and his experience with homeschoolers that most “believer” homeschoolers’ homeschooling is based on a belief in the kingdom [absolute reign and sovereignty] of God as described in the Bible. Stevens’ conclusion that “It was not their [i.e.., inclusives’ and believers’] ways of life or religious beliefs that divided them in the end, but rather their different sensibilities about how to organize” [p. 198] is also faulty; that is, their different beliefs essentially drive their ways of life and their ideas about how to organize, teach, learn, live, and behave.) revise annotation narrative
Stevens, W. Charles 1979, September 13 Angry at schools, more parents try teaching at home. Wall Street Journal, pp. 1, 33.
Stewart, Mahala Dyer 2020 Pushed or pulled out? The racialization of school choice in black and white mothers’ (home) schooling decisions for their children. https://doi.org/10.1177/2332649219901130 color-blind racism, segregation, school choice, homeschool, homeschooling Sociology of Race and Ethnicity, 6(2). https://doi.org/10.1177/2332649219901130 “Abstract: Homeschooling is an increasingly common schooling option for middle-class black families yet is often overlooked in research on race and education. Drawing on interviews with 67 middle-class black and white mothers living in one northeastern metropolitan area—half of whom homeschool, while the other half enroll their children in conventional school—the author examines how race influences mothers’ decisions to homeschool or conventional school. The findings show that mothers’ schooling explanations reflect their experiences as shaped by the racial hierarchy constituted in schools. Black mothers respond to a push out of conventional schools on the basis of their children’s experiences of racial discrimination. In contrast, white mothers respond to a pull out of conventional schools to individualize their children’s academic programs. Building on racialized organizations and critical race theory, these findings elucidate how the formal structure of schools is racialized in ways that constrain black mothers’ agency, while enabling the agency of white mothers to activate school choice. The findings underscore how homeschooling, often assumed to be race neutral, is racialized in ways that reproduce inequalities under school choice and appears to redress discrimination in schools.”) Mis???
Stockard, Jean, & Mayberry, Maralee 1992 Effective educational environments. Newbury Park, CA: Corwin Press effective education, effective practices, conventional school of Sage Publ.). (Reviews research and summarizes effective educational environments. Many of traits are consistent with home education.
Stocklin-Enright, Brendon 1982 The constitution of home education: The role of the parent, the state and the child. Willamette Law Review, 18(4), 568-611.
Stollar, R. L. 2014, December 2 A complex picture: Results of a 2014 survey of adult alumni of the modern Christian homeschool movement: Installment 1: Descriptive summary. Canton, MA: Coalition for Responsible Home Education. Retrieved December 10, 2014 from https://hareachingout.files.wordpress.com/2014/12/survey1.pdf. https://hareachingout.files.wordpress.com/2014/12/survey1.pdf homeschooling, home education, research, adults, graduates, academics, socialization, demographics, religion, Christian, Christianity, abuse, mental health, attitudes, advocacy Survey research on graduates of homeschooling who were raised in Christian homes. Examines demographics, attitudes toward having been homeschooled, practicing homeschooling with their children, sexuality, social services, and more. Gathers data on rate at which these adults were abused and have been diagnosed with mental illnesses. Is totally descriptive within the non-random and probably non-representative (of homeschool graduates) sample of adults. “The purpose of this survey was to investigate the life experiences of Christian homeschool alumni by collecting information that past surveys of homeschool alumni had not. The data collected will be used to advocate for the interests of current and future homeschooled children” (p. 3). “….., this study did not seek to compare homeschool alumni to graduates of other types of education—rather, it sought to determine how best to advocate for homeschooled children’s interests, in keeping with HARO’s mission to renew and transform homeschooling from within” (p. 3). “Survey respondents were required to affirm that they were 18 years old or older, had been homeschooled for at least 7 years, were homeschooled in an environment which was classifiable as Christian (including Christian‐influenced new religious movements), and were taking the survey through completion for the first time. A total of 6,249 people started the survey; 3,702 respondents completed the survey before it closed on September 15, 2014. Only the completed responses were recorded and analyzed” (p. 3). Does good job of presenting the limitations of the study at the beginning of the report but does poorly of explaining or applying the limitations in the conclusions section. This survey of homeschooled adults reached mostly white women born in the late 80s and early 90s. Many respondents were raised in fundamentalist homes and most reported that they are still Christian, married and have or intend to have children. Most of them are positive towards homeschooling and would homeschool their kids. Authors says that the “… results of the survey do indicate that there are suffering children in the homeschool community whose needs need to be addressed” (p. 29) but offers no evidence that the rates of GLBTQ children, mental health issues, emotional abuse, physical abuse, and educational neglect are the same, lower, or higher than in the general U.S. population. Author makes it fairly clear that this is advocacy research: “The data collected will be used to advocate for the interests of current and future homeschooled children” (p. 3).
Stop Educator Sexual Abuse Misconduct and Exploitation (SESAME) 2016 “One out of ten k-12 students are a victim of educator sexual misconduct.” Retrieved October 10, 2016 from http://www.sesamenet.org/educators/reporting http://www.sesamenet.org/educators/reporting
Stough, Lee 1992 Social and emotional status of home schooled children and conventionally schooled children in West Virginia. Master’s thesis, University of West Virginia. ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED353079. home education, conventional school, research, socialization, social, emotional, psychological, development, comparison This study compared home-schooled children to conventionally schooled children in West Virginia. A total of 30 homeschool families and 32 conventional school families with children of 7 to 14 years of age participated in the study. Included homeschool students who were being home educated and had been homeschooled for a minimum of two years; the conventional school children were currently in such schools and had been in conventional schools a minimum of two years. Used a quasi-experimental cohort group (similar to match-pair) comparison design. Participating homeschool families “… were asked to choose a family similar to their own whose children were conventionally schooled and request that they participate in the study” [p. 6] and this is how the conventional school families were identified for participation. The Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales Classroom Edition was used to gather parent perspectives on the social sufficiency of their children. The children's self-evaluations were recorded on the Piers-Harris Children's Self-Concept Scale. A projective instrument, the Kinetic Drawing System for Family and School, was used to explore child-family-school interaction patterns for evidence of emotional indicators (i.e., categories of anxiety, low self-concept, impulsivity, anger, aggression, insecurity, shyness, timidity, defensiveness, low academic achievement). “Results indicate that there is no statistically significant difference between the homeschooled versus the conventionally schooled sample in terms of social sufficiency, self-concept, or presence of emotional indicators. Home education does not adversely influence a child’s affective development and may contribute to such development” [p. iii]. “Therefore, one can infer that within the educating home there appears to exist an environmental press which fosters social development and simultaneously provides a set of experiences which gives the child the needed competencies, [sic] and attitutdes for success in society” [p. 19].
Strebel, Hanniel 2011 Home education. Verteidigung eines alternativen, Bildungskonzepts und Lebensstils, unter besonderer Berucksichtigung der Schweiz. Hamburg, Germany: Verlag fur Kultur und Wissenschaft, VKW. (Book is written in German) homeschooling, home education, Germany
Strom, Robert D., Wurster, S., & Rees, R. J. 1983 Parents as teachers of their exceptional children. Journal of Instructional Psychology, 10, 21-39.
Suarez, Paul, & Suarez, Gena. (Eds.) 2006 Homeschooling methods: Seasoned advice on learning styles. Nashville, TN: Broadman & Holman Publishers.
Sun, Xiadong 2015 Can homeschooling be an alternative schooling choice? Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, University of Hawaii at Manoa. homeschooling, home schooling, characteristics, academic outcomes, first marriage age “This paper taps the NLSY97, a longitudinal data set purposely avoided by all other researchers due to its limited numbers of homeschoolers. The reasons I see more benefits than risks in analyzing this data set are four-fold. First, this data set followed closely about 9,000 [p. 10 ends] young children, age 12-16 in the first survey in 1997 and age 26-30 in the latest survey in 2011, with consistent questions regarding their family and individual characteristics over the years. Compared with cross section data, these longitudinal data can provide a more comprehensive understanding of the homeschoolers. Second, the data offer an accurate count of when a child’s homeschooling starts or ends. Cross section data such as CPS only repeatedly select similarly representative samples from a population without keeping track of specific individuals. It might be able to offer information about in which grade homeschooling occurs but is never able to tell how long it has lasted and when it is going to end. Third, the NLSY data provide income and postsecondary education outcomes for homeschoolers. The cross section data, while serving well to study the trend in overall homeschooling, cannot provide this firsthand information by their very nature. Finally, even in the cross section data set mentioned above, the number of homeschoolers is relatively small. For example, I identified 265 homeschoolers in NLSY’97, as opposed to 251, 301 and 262 [emphasis added] homeschoolers in NHES’s 1996, 1999 and 2003 surveys (Isenberg 2007)” (p. 11). “Abstract. Chapter 1: This chapter reviews the literature on homeschooling’s historical and social origins, and, for the first time, uses the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth 1997 dataset to study the characteristics of homeschooling families and their homeschooled youth. I use probit and multinomial regression models to investigate if these characteristics have any correlations with homeschooling. I found that parents’ education level, religion, child health and number of children have significant roles in the choice of homeschooling. The structure of homeschooling family is more fragile and both parents’ education attainments are lower than parents of children attending regular schools. Finally, the homeschooled population is more homogeneous than previously thought. Chapter 2: How homeschooling affects homeschooled youth is critical to the public acceptance of homeschooling as a viable education choice. I focus on homeschoolers’ college admission tests, college enrollment and degree, and labor income in their early career. I found that generally homeschoolers fall behind regular school students. I also use OLS and probit models to test for a relationship between homeschooling and college degree and labor income. I found negative and statistically significant effects of homeschooling on both completion of college degree and labor income. To control for selection issue I use propensity score matching and a methodology developed by Altonji et al in 2005 to reexamine the relationship between college degree and homeschooling. The results confirm the negative effect from homeschooling. Chapter 3: Previous empirical studies have not considered whether schooling type such as public, private or homeschooling influences age at first marriage. Homeschooling could be an important factor in this decision, as it could allow parents to mold their attitudes toward marriage more closely. I use Cox Hazard Model to explore the relationship between schooling style and the timing of marriage along with other factors widely used in other literatures. As I find comparable results for many other factors that could have impact on the age of marriage, it shows little evidence that different schooling modes affect the age at first marriage. I argue the reason behind this phenomenon might be due to homeschooling efficiency and homeschoolers’ sociability” (p. 5).
Sunshine, Catherine 2026 Happy at Home? A Comparative Study of Psychological Well-Being and Psychiatric Risk in Home- and School-Educated Children. Journal of School Choice, 1–21. https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2026.2664325 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2026.2664325 Bioecological systems, theory, home education, homeschooling, Pediatric Symptom Checklist, psychiatric risk, psychological well-being, Ireland “Abstract: This study examined well-being and psychiatric risk between home- and school-educated children. Caregivers of 130 children aged 6–16 years from the UK or Ireland completed the Pediatric Symptom Checklist (PSC-35). Group differences were examined using linear and logistic regression models, adjusting for demographic covariates. School- educated children showed greater psychosocial difficulties than home- educated children (d = 1.04). Education type was the strongest predictor of PSC total scores (β = .44). School-educated children were more likely to meet PSC subscale at-risk criteria, and overall (OR = 5.70). Findings indicate school-educated children are at greater psychiatric risk than home-educated children.”
Sutton, Jennifer 2002, January/February Homeschooling comes of age. Retrieved 5/28/04 online http://www.brownalumnimagazine.com/storyDetail.cfm?ID=672. http://www.brownalumnimagazine.com/storyDetail.cfm?ID=672 Home education, college, adults, graduates, opinion “Although the number of homeschoolers applying to college is still small, it represents only the first wave. The next homeschooled generation—the real boom—is just hitting puberty. A school like Brown, with its reputation for valuing independence and self-direction, may be particularly attractive to homeschoolers accustomed to charting their own course. Brown’s curriculum, too, may be a good academic match for homeschoolers, many of whom have shaped their own curriculum with their parents or have simply followed their own interests with their parents as guides.” ““These kids are the epitome of Brown students,” says Joyce Reed, who became an associate dean of the College twelve years ago. “They’ve learned to be self-directed, they take risks, they face challenges with total fervor, and they don’t back off.”” “When Brown admission officers come across a homeschooler’s application, they look for evidence of good writing skills and some sort of “outside assessment,” such as courses taken at a community college or standardized test scores. “We take recommendations from family members with a grain of salt,” Michael Goldberger says. Otherwise the evaluation process for homeschoolers is not much different from that of other applicants.”
Sutton, Joe P., & de Oliveira, Paulo C. M. 1995 Differences in critical thinking skills among students educated in public schools, Christian schools, and home schools. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 18-22, San Francisco CA. home education, research, adult, college, critical thinking skills, private schools, public schools, causal comparative Compares critical thinking skills of students at a Christian university who graduated from public schools, Christian schools, Accelerated Christian Education [ACE] schools, and home schools. Finds no significant differences, using ANOVA and MANOVA, in various critical thinking skills among the four student groups (total N=789). "Combined with research that substantiates their above average achievement on standardized tests (Ray, 1993), our finding that home educated students do not differ significantly on critical thinking skills from their conventionally educated counterparts surely offers increasingly strong validation that home education is a viable and effective educational alternative" [p. 11].
Sutton, Joe P., & Galloway, Rhonda 2000 College success of students from three high school settings. Journal of Research and Development in Education, 33(3), 137-146. home education, homeschool, public school, private school, college, graduates, success, academic achievement, leadership, professional aptitude, social behavior, and physical activity, comparison Compares homeschool, public-school, and private-school graduates in terms of success (i.e., academic achievement, leadership, professional aptitude, social behavior, and physical activity) at a private liberal arts college. “There were no significant differences among the three groups in 33 of the 40 variables. However, results from multivariate analysis of variance showed college graduates from home schools held significantly more leadership posts for significantly greater periods of time than did the private school group” while there was no significant difference on these variables between the homeschooled and public-schooled [p. 137, abstract]. “… tested for differences among the groups on professional aptitude, social behavior, and physical activity [e.g., athletic sports teams, athletic cheerleading, extracurricular drama] indicators, respectively. All resulting Wilks’ lambdas for these tests were statistically nonsignificant” [p. 141].
Swanson, Kevin 2006 Upgrade: 10 secrets to the best education for your child. Nashville, TN: Broadman & Holman, Publ. education, private, philosophy, home education, public schools, history Delinieates and explains 10 principles that are key to a child’s education, defining education in the broad sense of academic, social, emotional, and spiritual development. Uses biblical worldview. Emphasizes the essential nature of the relationships between parents and their children to the education of children. Suggests home-based education is (one of?) the best way to educate children.
Swanson, Kevin 2008 mis?? The second Mayflower.
Syman-Degler, Candace 1984 Our home school. Mothering, Spring, p.89-91.
Talbot, Margaret 2000, February 27 A Mighty Fortress. New York Times Magazine. Describes a Christian family with seven children trying to teach their children a way different from the public schools’ worldview. Description: home education, opinion, evolution, creation
Talbot, Margaret 2001, November The new counterculture [a book review of Kingdom of children by Mitchell Stevens]. The Atlantic Monthly, p. 136-141. Retrieved 4/9/04 online http://www.theatlantic.com/issues/2001/11/talbot.htm. http://www.theatlantic.com/issues/2001/11/talbot.htm
Tallman, David A. 1998, January/February Home schooling. Kansas Association of School Boards Journal, 37(1), 16-19, 21. home education, opposition, law, legal, opinion, critique of home schooling Says “The Kansas legislature should ban ‘home schools’ altogether, on the grounds they are bad public policy, that no precedent of the Kansas or United States Supreme Courts [sic] requires tolerating them, and that it is impractical for the State, in a time of dwindling resources, to properly monitor the operations of mushrooming ‘home schools’” [p. 16]. Provides a very pro-state and anti-parental rights worldview and interpretation of law. Provides much opinion about the social effects of home schooling on young people, adults, and society.
Talluto, Rebecca 2001, August Accountability for home-schoolers [subtitle: Who’s responsible for making sure home-schooled students get the best possible education?]. American School Board Journal, 188(8), 20-21. Also available 7/20/01 online http://www.asbj.com/current/coverstory2.html. http://www.asbj.com/current/coverstory2.html home education, law, accountability, measurement, academic achievement, state regulation and control, cooperation, philosophy Addresses the variability in the 50 states’ laws related to homeschooling. Criticizes alleged low standards of accountability to the state in some states. Claims that sometimes homeschool students are treated differently -- in perhaps a less stringent way -- than are students from public and private schools when applying to take courses at colleges. Claims the following: “The most important question: Are we as [professional] educators and school leaders doing enough to make sure home-schooled students are getting the best education possible?” [p. 20]. Implies the author’s underlying presupposition is that the state-run schools have authority over all school-age children, including those who are in private schools and in private homeschooling as author urges state school district school boards and administrators: “It might be time for school boards to review their districts’ plan for evaluating home-education programs. All of your students -- those who learn in classrooms and those who learn at home -- would benefit” [p. 21].
Tavares, Jonathan 2022 Why homeschooling shouldn’t be banned: The resurgence of home education in the 21st century. New England Law Review, https://www.newenglrev.com/forum-56/9-2022-desperate-measures-for-desperate-times-can-physicians-refuse-to-treat-unvaccinated-patients-bny73 https://www.newenglrev.com/forum-56/9-2022-desperate-measures-for-desperate-times-can-physicians-refuse-to-treat-unvaccinated-patients-bny73 homeschool, homeschooling, education, law, legal, philosophy “This Note will argue that homeschooling should not be banned in the United States because banning interferes with the fundamental right of parents to direct the education of their children and is antithetical to America’s long-standing history of protecting individual rights. Part I of this Note will explore the current legal framework for parental rights in the context of education by examining key United States Supreme Court cases. This section will also discuss notable actions taken by state legislatures since the 1980s that established clear protections and regulations for homeschooling in several states. Part II will explain why the right to homeschool is so critical in a post-COVID-19 world as many families consider home education as a way to address their unique opportunities and challenges, as well as prioritize their values. Part III of this Note will analyze and respond to the main arguments in favor of banning homeschooling. Part IV will propose several approaches to establishing the right to homeschool under current Supreme Court case law. And lastly, Part V will consider how other countries have addressed the issue of homeschooling much differently than the United States.”) ??
Taylor, Denny 1991? Learning denied. City unknown?: Heineman publishers Reportedly about the mismanagement of labels in school; son was mislabeled Learning Disabled so parents decided to home educate him).
Taylor, Isaac 1838 Home Education. London: Jackson and Walford, 380 p. home education, homeschooling, history Book. Historical. Maybe one of the first books in the modern era explaining and or promoting or supporting what those in the USA and England began calling homeschooling in the 1980s.
Taylor, John Wesley, 5th 1986 Self-concept in home-schooling children. Doctoral dissertation, Andrews University, Berrien Springs, Michigan, 331 p. Socialization of home educated children addressed. Administered Piers-Harris Self-Concept Scale to random sample of home school children nationwide. Home school children scored significantly (statistically) higher than public norm group on global scale and all six subscales.
Taylor, John Wesley, 5th 1986, June Self-concept in home-schooling children. Home School Researcher, 2(2), 1-3. home education, research, socialization, self-concept Evaluates the self-concept, as an aspect of socialization, of the home educated in a study with a nationwide scope. Uses Piers-Harris Children's Self-Concept Scale (PHSCS). First study to directly address the topic of "socialization" in the home educated. Finds that the home educated have a positive self-concept that is stronger than that of the conventionally schooled. Concludes that it appears the home educated are not socially deprived.
Taylor, John Wesley, 5th 1992 The self-concept of home schoolers: A nationwide study. Journal of Research on Christian Education, 1(1), 23-34. self-concept, socialization, home education, research Based on his 1986 dissertation.
Taylor, Lesley 1992 At home in school: An empirical, observational, and interpretative study of home education. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco CA, April 20-24, 1992. home education, Christian, criticism She uses an educational criticism research method to study Christian home schools; "I have been in a number of Christian home schools and most have more of the flavor of institutional school that my in-depth studies one and two have... ..... What has perhaps been given less attention is whether there is a specific Biblical mandate on how to teach mathematics or geography for example, and if there is not, (and I have not yet found such a mandate in the Bible), is such a rigid segmented curriculum really appropriate? [sic] Is there a less formal way to teach that would still permit adherence to whatever biblical truth is relevant?" (p. 10, 11); she saw differences in her study three family in which "... the parents appear to keep the curriculum firmly in place as a tool and have the insight, or perhaps the courage, to reject all the criteria by which institutional schools and thus the wider culture measure what is truly of value in education" (p. 11).
Taylor, Lesley 1997 Home in school: Insights on education through the lens of home schoolers. The Theory into Practice Journal, 36(2), 110-116. Special issue of journal entitled, Exploring the margins: Lessons from alternative schools. home education, research, opinion, public schools, cooperation between schools and home schoolers Describes institutional schools and why many people will never choose them for their children. “To date, for most home schoolers, the best they have hoped for in a relationship with public educators is to be left alone. Some may prefer a complete separation from the public schools, but others would welcome a positive relationship rather than no relationship, an extension of friendship rather than animosity, and to be the focus of genuine interest rather than uninformed criticism. Conversation about a vital role such as helping children learn can be important in opening up new possibilities or reaffirming old convictions. Sympathetic and meaningful conversations about children learning are surely valuable even if, or perhaps especially if, there are disagreements” [p. 113-114]. Recognizes the uninformed criticism of home schooling by public school advocates and guardedness of home schoolers about interacting with public schools but encourages open and friendly interaction on the part of all.
Taylor, Lesley Ann 1993 At home in school: A qualitative inquiry into three Christian home schools. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Stanford University, Stanford, CA. home education, research, qualitative, educational criticism, philosophy, religion Available from National Home Education Research Institute, P.O. Box 13939, Salem OR 97309 Insightful educational criticism of three Christian home school families. Carefully explored what they actually do on a daily basis in their homes, asking, "Is the education provided in these homes so very different from public schools and if so, in what ways?" Examined the extent to which the intentions of the parents match their actions, curriculum, and so forth in their homes. As a Christian home educator herself, Taylor offers much to reflect upon by both home educators and others.
Taylor, Lesley Ann, & Petrie, Amanda J. 2000 Home education regulations in Europe and recent U.K. Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 49-70.
Taylor, Peter & Tomlinson, Derrick 1984 Primary distance education population: Problems and prospects. Research series no. 2. Access to Education, Distance Education, Elementary Education, Enrollment Trends, Parent Role Nedlands (Western Australia): National Centre for Research on Rural Education. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service NO. ED257595). A report dealing with primary distance education in Western Australia.)
Taylor, Venus 2005 Behind the trend: Increases in homeschooling among African American families. In Bruce S. Cooper (Ed.), Home schooling in full view: A reader, p. 121-133. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing. home education, minorities, African American, black “An increasing number of African American families are choosing to homeschool their children. ….. The 50 years since the Brown [v. Board of Education] decision have seen a persistence of the Black-White achievement gap in U.S. public school systems, and a growing number of African American parents have determined they can better educate their children at home, employing strategies that are not available in most classrooms: low pupil-teacher ratio, focused attention on academic problem areas, elimination of “tracking,” and deeply committed teachers with high expectations. Higher academic achievement regardless of parental educational attainment and the flexibility to conform to a variety of family conditions and income levels make homeschooling one of the best options to prepare African American children to compete in the twenty-first century (p. 121). Many African American parents have tired of waiting for traditional schooling to overcome its limitations. The persistent Black-White achievement gap is evidence of a chronic, systemic failure of the traditional school system to address the needs of African American children. One assumption held by the proponents of Brown v. Board of Education was that equal access would ensure equal education. However, the education of Black and White students has proven to be, persistently, less than equal (p. 122). The legacy of Brown is not only about access but is also about options. We African Americans owe it to our children to exercise all available opportunities to ensure their current and future success. We are not obligated to wait for schools to improve to better meet our needs; we [p. 131 ends here] are obligated to provide our children the best education available. Homeschoolers secure a brighter future for their children by giving them the educational foundation they deserve. Those of us who take the reins in pursuit of a sound, equal (or better) education for our children, in an effort to help them achieve their maximum potential, do so in the spirit of the proponents of Brown v. Board of Education” (p. 132).
Taylor, Venus 2008, March Homeschooling as civic engagement. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, March 25, 2008, New York, NY. home education, civic engagement, minority, African American, black Gives perspective from research and own life as a black African American woman and homeschool mother.
Teaching Home, The 1988, February/March Ten common approaches, pp. 27-35.) philosophy, home education, pedagogical and/or philosophical approaches to home education or home schooling
Teaching Home, The 1992, February/March Home schoolers and the church, special section. Pages 33-48. religion, church, home education, philosophy Several perspectives about how home schoolers should participate and serve in the church, how the church must minister to and understand home schoolers, age-integrated learning, et cetera ...
Teaching Home, The 1998, March/April Choosing curriculum: Special section [on educational approaches, materials, learning styles, a family’s needs and resources], pp. 41-53. http://www.teachinghome.com/qa/methods.htm http://www.teachinghome.com/qa/material.htm philosophy, teaching strategies, models of teaching, curriculum, home education See also: The Teaching Home. (2000). What methods do home schoolers use? Retrieved 8/17/00 online http://www.teachinghome.com/qa/methods.htm, What educational materials are available? http://www.teachinghome.com/qa/material.htm Describes and evaluates educational approaches, teaching strategies, and models of teaching, philosophy, curriculum materials, children’s learning styles, and a family’s needs and resources.
Teaching Home, The 1998, March/April Do your homework: Learn about different educational approaches, pp. 41, 42, 44, 45. http://www.teachinghome.com/qa/methods.htm http://www.teachinghome.com/qa/material.htm philosophy, home education, pedagogical and/or philosophical approaches to home education or home schooling, teaching strategies, models of teaching See also: The Teaching Home. (2000). What methods do home schoolers use? Retrieved 8/17/00 online http://www.teachinghome.com/qa/methods.htm, What educational materials are available? http://www.teachinghome.com/qa/material.htm Explains several common approaches [or teaching strategies, models of teaching, educational philosophies] that parents take to home schooling their children. Covers the following approaches: classical, traditional textbook, “The Principle Approach,” worktexts, programmed instruction, unit studies, oral reading, and unschooling.
Tennessee Department of Education 1988 Tennessee statewide averages, home school student test results, Stanford Achievement Test, grades 2, 5, 7 and 9. Nashville, TN: Author. home education, academic achievement, state department For the 1987-1988 school year, weighted mean percentile in total reading was the 78th percentile and in total math it was the 69th percentile for home schooled students.
Tenney, Merril Chapin 1965 New Testament times. Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Co. General history of New Testament times with some reference to social conditions.
Terpstra, Mary 1994 A home school/school district partnership. Educational Leadership, 52(1), 57, 58.
Thernstrom, Abigail 1991 Education alternatives hold growing appeal. Choice doesn't guarantee the needed quality. San Diego Union, p. C-5. educational quality
Thomas, Alan 1998 Educating children at home. London, England (and New York, NY): Cassell. home education, research, pedagogy, practice at home, individualization, conversation, book Book. Presents his exploratory research on “... how parents actually go about teaching their children at home, the main focus of this book” [p. 3] using interviews and observations with families in Australia and England. Bases research on two theoretical backgrounds: one is the importance teaching children individually (e.g., small group, tutoring) and the second is important factors regarding learning in the early years (e.g., everyday social conversation with adults). “Most people, when they try to visualize home education, tend to see it as an imitation of school, with children working at desks or the kitchen table, for the equivalent of the school day, in front of their teacher-parents who teach carefully prepared lessons which cover the school curriculum -- ensuring their children are kept on task, asking questions, regularly marking their work and assessing progress. Few conform to this image. [new paragraph] The greater flexibility which home education allows means that a timetable is unnecessary and is usually dropped altogether. Moreover, lessons can be put off for another time if a child is obviously not learning effectively for whatever reason. Parents are able to take advantage of those times when their children are most receptive, including the evenings and weekends. [new paragraph] At home, lessons are concentrated and intensive. This is mainly due to extra individual attention and also because very little time is spent on the kind of peripheral activities which take up much of classroom time. In consequence, lessons are short and so is the working day, generally restricted to the morning or part of it. This is in stark contrast with the current educational fashion of more and more homework in addition to school and more and more school for children who are failing, including school in the holidays. [new paragraph] By far the most important difference between more formal, structured learning at home and in school, though, is that learning at home becomes an interactive process rather than a series of tasks to be tackled. Parents repeatedly refer to being able to strike while the iron’s hot, to deal with problems as they arise, not going on to something new until the prerequisite knowledge or concepts have been acquired. If children get stuck they do not proceed until the problem has been dealt with. In fact, any mistakes they make, rather than creating barriers to learning, simply inform their parents of their thinking processes. Errors, therefore, simply become steps on the route to enlightenment. Because they experience little failure, children become confident in their ability to learn. ..... [new paragraph] A more fundamental pedagogical change occurs as parents gradually discover the potential of informal teaching and learning. There is nothing in the way children learn in school to suggest how powerful informal learning might be. Two influences impel parents toward informal styles of learning. The first is the result of their own observations. They find themselves talking a lot with their children, following through their interests, answering questions, drawing their attention to things which might arouse their curiosity, even during more formal learning sessions” [p. 127]. “The initial worries which home educators have concerning social development gradually fade as they see their children growing up, confident and relaxed in adult company and able to relate to children of all ages. This leads some to question the popular assumption that school is the best preparation for entry into the social world of adults. They ask if the playground is the best place to learn social skills and why it is supposedly beneficial to spend so much of the day with age-mates. They point to the lack of opportunity there is in school to learn social skills from adults by actually [p. 130] practising them. In consequence, some parents suggest that it is school which is cut off from the real world. [new paragraph] Home educators give us a view of education which, in many respects, is markedly different from that is on offer in school. What they have learned from their pioneering experiences has the potential to bring about the most fundamental change in education since the advent of universal schooling in the nineteenth century” [p.131].
Thompson, C. Bradley 2016 Education in a free society. The Objective Standard. Retrieved September 11, 2023 from https://www.theobjectivestandard.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/TOS-Freedom-Of-Education.pdf https://www.theobjectivestandard.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/TOS-Freedom-Of-Education.pdf classical liberalism, libertarian, free market, education funding, School Choice, ESA, voucher, education savings account, law, legal, philosophy A truly clear and consistent classical liberal (or libertarian) few on education showing the schooling and education should all be under a private free-market arrangement and system and not in any way under government control or funding (e.g., taxes). One of few voices that firmly argues this position in the 21st century in the United States.) ?
Thomson Jr., Robert A.; & Jang, Sung Joon 2016 Homeschool and Underage Drinking: Is It More Protective than Public and Private Schools? Deviant Behavior, 37(3), 281–301. homeschooling, home schooling, comparison, alcohol use, substance abuse “Abstract. This article examines differences in alcohol use between homeschool and both public and private school students. Applying regression analyses to two waves of the National Study of Youth and Religion, we found that homeschoolers were less likely to drink alcohol and get drunk than nonhomeschoolers, which was explained in part by variables of social bonding, social learning, and, to a greater extent, religiosity. Specifically, parental monitoring helped explain differences between homeschool and private school students, while association with deviant friends partially accounted for differences with public school students. Religiosity, however, explained differences between homeschoolers and both types of non-homeschoolers” (p. 281). Peer-reviewed.
Thornburg, Kathy R., Ispa, J., Gray, M. M., & Ponder, H. 1983 Parent as a teacher inventory: A statistical factor analysis. Journal of Experimental Education, 50(Summer), 200-202. Research. Instrument.
Thorpe, E.L., Zimmerman, R.K., Steinhart, J.D., Lewis, K.N., & Michaels, M.G. 2011, December 13 Homeschooling parents’ practices and beliefs about childhood immunizations. Vaccine, 2011 Dec 13. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22178729 home education, homeschooling, health, medical, vaccines, vaccinations, research, attitudes “Source Department of General Pediatrics, Division of Emergency Medicine, Pittsburgh, PA, United States; Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh of UPMC, Pittsburgh, PA, United States. Abstract OBJECTIVE: Concern over the rise of vaccine preventable diseases (VPD) coupled with the increasing popularity of homeschooling makes understanding the attitudes and behaviors of homeschoolers regarding immunizations a critical area of investigation. This study was a pilot to investigate the immunization attitudes of homeschooling parents and the vaccination status of their children. METHODS: In the spring of 2010, online surveys were sent to a convenience sample of 707 homeschooling parents in Western Pennsylvania with children ages 0-18 years of age. Information was collected on demographic characteristics, vaccination status of children, and attitudes toward vaccination. RESULTS: Surveys were returned by 18 percent of respondents, representing 396 homeschooled children. Demographic characteristics mirrored national homeschooling trends. The majority (95%) surveyed felt that education about vaccines was important. Thirty-eight percent of families had fully vaccinated children while 56% reported partial vaccination and 6% said children had received no vaccines. Respondents who fully vaccinated their children were more likely to agree that vaccinating according to the American Academy of Pediatrics was a good idea (OR: 4.8 [95% CI: 2.0-11.7]) and were more likely to comply with the recommendations of their health care provider (OR: 8.3 [95% CI: 3.6-19.1]). Respondents who vaccinated their children were more likely to believe that vaccines are safe (OR: 7.6 [95% CI: 1.0-56.2]). Beliefs about autism, thimerosal and learning disabilities did not vary significantly with vaccination status in regression analysis. CONCLUSIONS: While specific factors influencing vaccination practices were not identified, this study demonstrated that recommendations of physicians and the AAP do not significantly influence homeschooling vaccination practices in the pilot population. Given the results of this pilot study, more research is called for, particularly a larger study with public school controls” [retrieved 12/26/2011 from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22178729].
Tilhou, Rebecca C. 2019 Contemporary homeschool models and the values and beliefs of home educator associations: A systematic review. Journal of School Choice: International Research and Reform, 14(1), 75-94. Homeschool associations; home schooling, homeschool groups; values; beliefs; culture, peer-reviewed “Abstract: Home education support groups and associations are increasingly becoming hubs for home learning communities to share resources and knowledge. This literature review examined (a) motivations for joining homeschool groups; (b) values and beliefs that led to the formation of homeschool groups; and (c) how the culture of homeschool groups aids in children’s development. Findings indicated that homeschool families sought groups to share resources, expertise, and common values. Values included the desire for strong family bonds, teaching faith, closely guided social interaction, and responsive pedagogy. Home educators believed that public schooling cannot meet those values. Implications suggest the need for more empirical research exploring how the culture of homeschool groups shapes the development of its members, and additionally, what public education can learn from these alternative educational models” (p. 1). “This systematic review of homeschooling literature had three overarching goals: (1) understand home educator reasons for joining homeschool groups; (2) discover underlying personal, social, and political beliefs on which homeschool groups are formed; and (3) unearth descriptions of culture within homeschool groups and determine if and how that culture aids the development of children. Findings suggested, just as Collom asserted at the closing of his study, that simply categorizing motivations, values and beliefs cannot justly capture the complexity of homeschool families’ decisions related to their children’s education. However, consistencies were evident across studies that will be discussed here” (p. 15-16). Reasons for joining support groups varied, from shared teaching responsibility based on personal areas of expertise, shared resources and teaching materials, opportunities for pedagogical development, fulfilling social-emotional and experiential needs for their children, camaraderie for parents for encouragement and to build confidence, children’s needs to socialize with other children of all ages, and extracurricular activities, various personal, social, and political beliefs, conscientious objection toward government public schools. “What was not found in the literature was an indication that homeschool groups embodied a culture of ‘deliberate political protest’ against institutionalized education that Gaither (2009) suggested could be found amongst homeschool groups. The studies found for this literature review showed that families focused on providing their children with a quality educational experience through the choice to homeschool, but shared their choices and experiences with a sense of excitement for the unbounded learning homeschool provides, reciprocity within homeschool communities, acceptance of one another, and deep familial bonds within these cultures, shown through quantitatively and qualitatively identified motivations” (p. 17).
Tillman, Vicki D. 1995 Home schoolers, self-esteem, and socialization. Home School Researcher, 11(3), 1-6. home education, research, socialization, self-esteem, Cross-sectional, descriptive. Peer-reviewed “The Self-Esteem Index is an 80-item self-report instrument designed to elicit children's perceptions of their personal traits and characteristics. It yields four subscales: (1) Familial Acceptance (which measures the child's self-esteem at home and within the family context), (2) Academic Competence (which measures the child's self-esteem in reference to their feelings about academic competence, intelligence, and other scholarly pursuits), (3) Peer Popularity Scale (addresses the quality, importance and nature of relationships and interactions with individuals outside the family unit), and (4) Personal Security Scale (which contains statements to assess the child's feelings about physical appearance and personal attributes such as distinctive traits of body, character, conduct, temperament and emotions). Overall self-esteem is measured by the Self-Esteem Quotient (SEQ)” (p. 3). Results from the Socialization Opportunities Questionnaire The subjects were 11- to 14-year-old homeschool students and their families (n=475 families). “... show that these home schoolers are not isolated but active, contributing members of society, even in childhood. Ninety-eight percent are involved in weekly church meetings and other activities which require interfacing with various ages and settings” and “Scores in all five scales of the SEI [Self-Esteem Index] are above the norms. As rated by the SEI, these home schoolers have above-average self-esteem.” [p. 5]. “How Home Schooled 11- to 14 -year-olds Compare to the Norms on Self-Esteem as Measured by the Self-Esteem Index? Delaware Valley home schooled 11- to 14- year-olds scored above average (50th percentile) with a mean Self-Esteem Quotient of 73.05. Their scores on the four subscales of the SEI, Family Acceptance, Perception of Academic Competence, Perception of Peer Popularity, and Perception of Personal Security, had means of 70.3, 70.0, 64.2, and 67.9, respectively. The results were also evaluated in the form of z-scores. In this form the Total Scale mean was .61. The Familial Acceptance, Academic Competence, Peer Popularity, and Personal Security scales had mean z-scores of .52, .52, .36, and .44 respectively (all above the mean of 0.00 of the norm group Table 1)” (p. 4). Cross-sectional, descriptive. Peer-reviewed.
Times Education Supplement 1982, October 15 [? Home teaching idea.] p. 16.
Tipton, Mark 1990 An analysis of home-schooled children's Comprehensive Test of Basic Skills Results and demographic characteristics of their families. Master’s thesis, Antioch University. (ERIC Document Reproduction No. ED 336208.) http://www.eric.ed.gov research, home education, homeschooling, public school, academic achievement Studies 81 homeschool children in grades 3, 6, 9, and 11 in West Virginia, and compared means of each sub-section of CTBS scores to West Virginia public school means for the respective grades and subsections. Finds that “… third-grade home-schooled children scored significantly higher than the public school means in vocabulary, reading comprehension, mathematics concepts, science, and total mathematics; significantly lower in spelling; and similarly in other areas. Sixth-grade home-schooled children scored significantly higher in composite, vocabulary, reading comprehension, and total language means, and similarly in other areas. Ninth-grade home-schooling means were significantly higher in reading, lower in mathematics, and similar in other areas. Eleventh-grade home-schooling means were significantly higher in reading and similar in the rest. Survey results showed that family income, education and size differed from the state average, while families' occupations and locations were similar. Intended length of home schooling and children's CTBS performance correlated positively, while age at which children began formal studies and CTBS results correlated negatively” (retrieved quote 7/11/2011 from http://www.eric.ed.gov).
Tizard, Barbara, & Hughes, Martin 1984 Young children learning. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 286 p. http://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674965959 early childhood education, ECE, parental involvement, parents teaching, research, language development, cognitive development Based on research study of 4-year-old preschool girls, comparing conversations at morning nursery school with afternoon conversations with mothers; authors impressed with the home as a learning environment, finding many aspects of home significantly (statistically) more conducive to cognitive development; seven-page statistical appendix with references to their articles published in Journal of Child Psychiatry and Psychology. “The book challenges the widely held belief that parents need to learn from professionals how to educate and bring up their children; above all, it persuades us to value parenting more highly and to have respect for the intellectual capabilities of young minds” (Retrieved December 26, 2014 from http://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674965959. Startlingly to many, Tizard and Hughes reported that working-class (i.e., lower-class) girls were more disadvantaged by being in preschool then were middle-class girls. That is, the working-class children were benefited more by being with their mums (mothers) than in schools run by professionals. Much research on modern-day homeschooling seems to be echoing what Tizard and her colleagues were finding over three decades ago, and contradicts the thinking of those who consistently and constantly promote Head Start and other preschool programs in the United States.
Tizard, Barbara, Hughes, M., Carmichael, H., & Pinkerton, G. 1983a Children's questions and adults' answers. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 24(2), 269-281. Preschool. "Our findings thus confirmed, in a naturalistic setting, the social class differences in children's questions and mothers' answers which earlier studies have found in experimental or interview situations. However, we found no indication that schools were playing a compensatory role: this role was impossible for them, because the children, especially the working class [as opposed to middle class] children, did not ask their teachers curiosity questions" (p. 280).
Tizard, Barbara, Hughes, M., Carmichael, H., & Pinkerton, G. 1983b Language and social class: Is verbal deprivation a myth? Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 24(4), 533-542. Preschool. "Despite the widespread belief, enshrined in the Bullock Report, that working class children benefit from nursery school attendance because of the teacher's `measured attention to the child's language needs' (p. 540), the evidence suggests that they are much more likely to receive this from their mothers" (p. 541).
Tizard, Barbara, Hughes, M., Pinkerton, G., & Carmichael, H. 1982 Adults' cognitive demands at home and at nursery school. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 23(2), 105-116. Preschool. "At school over 75% of adult-child conversations were sustained by the teachers' questions, whereas at home mothers and children played a nearly equal role in questioning each other and sustaining conversations"(p. 113, 114). "... most children at nursery school seem likely to receive plenty of cognitive demands at home... " (p. 115).
Tobak, James W. 1983 The law of home instruction. The School Administrator, February, 40, 22-24.
Tobak, James W. & Zirkel, Perry 1983, February The law of home instruction. School Administrator, 40(2), 22-24. Home Schooling, School Attendance Legislation, State Standards A history of attempts to change laws in Nebraska, South Carolina, Indiana and New Jersey which limit home schooling.
Tobak, James W., & Zirkel, Perry A. 1982 Home instruction: An analysis of the law. University of Dayton Law Review, 8, 1-60. Law.
Toch, Thomas 1991 In the name of excellence: The struggle to reform the nation’s schools, why it’s failing, and what should be done. New York, NY: Oxford University Press. education reform, teacher certification, teacher unions, academic achievement, public schools, choice, alternative education, vouchers, magnet schools Presents a report card on the nation’s drive during the 1980s to reform its troubled public schools. Bases his evaluation and suggestions on research studies and his visits to about 60 public schools nationwide. Is rather critical of schools of education, education professors, public educators, and teacher unions. Explains the success of New Jersey’s alternative teacher certification program in terms of attracting and hiring successful teachers who do not have to complete the traditional school-of-education college programs and how this is opposed by teacher unions; implies that traditional teacher certification is not effective in preparing good teachers who are successful at getting students to learn. Analyzes problems with the validity of and use of standardized achievement tests and the reporting of the scores on them. “Score reporting on norm-referenced tests, the tests used most frequently to gauge the performance of schools and school systems in the name of accountability, is full of obscurities and rife with abuses that lead to a badly distorted picture of academic achievement in the nation’s schools” [p. 214]; explains that an unreasonable percentage of states report that their public school students are scoring above average. Critiques the dumbing down and watering down of academic courses in public schools in chapter 4.
Toch, Thomas 1991, December 9 The exodus [from public schools]. U.S. News & World Report, 111(24), 66-68, 71-74, 76,77. home education, parental involvement, alternatives, educational reform, parent attitudes, educational quality, Parochial schools: An evolving mission "Many parents view the public schools as ineffective and dangerous, and are exploring other options before it's too late" [p. 66, sub-caption]; discusses five leading alternatives: parochial, for-profit schools, prep, Afrocentric, and home education; says over 300,000 home education students today and still growing rapidly, with about 75% being "conservative Christians who stress the Bible in their teachings and who lament what they see as a decline in traditional values in public schools. Still others believe that public schools don't set high enough academic standards. But all home schoolers seem to share a belief that education is integral to family life" [p. 73]; quotes some home educators and Michael Farris of HSLDA. p. 68-71), religious beliefs, private education, Preparatory schools: Shaking off an elitist past (p. 72-73), private education)., Home schooling: Schooling in family values (p. 73-74) Afrocentric schools: Fighting a racist legacy (p. 74-76), private education, For-profit schools: Investment in learning (p. 76-77), Can public schools survive? (p. 78), educational quality).
Tollefsen, Christopher O. 2010, February 23 Are there harms of home schooling? Critics of home-schooling need to be tutored about the nature of education and the family. Retrieved March 4, 2010 from http://www.thepublicdiscourse.com/2010/02/1156. http://www.thepublicdiscourse.com/2010/02/1156 home education, parental rights, philosophy, policy, Christian worldview On this latter view, children are not property of their parents, for the family is a society of mutual service, and is not for the good of parents alone. But neither are children independent agents, existing only in association with their parents but ontologically apart. The good of the children is now a part of the good of their parents as parents. Thus parental care of children, before they have fully separated from their parents, is continuous with parents’ care for themselves, and their concern for the common good within the family is, as Germain Grisez puts it, a concern for “the child’s good considered insofar as it also perfects the parent precisely as parent.”
Tomlinson, Carol Ann 1995 Differentiating instruction for advanced learners in the mixed-ability middle school classroom, ERIC Digest E536. ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED389141. Retrieved 1/3/02 online http://ericec.org/digests/e536.html. http://ericec.org/digests/e536.html customization, differentiated instruction, individualization, classroom schools, talented and gifted, gifted May help homeschool parents think about how to customize the education of their children, especially those who are academically or intellectually especially gifted. ERIC system’s abstract says: “This brief paper summarizes guidelines for adapting instruction for advanced learners in inclusive, mixed-ability middle school classrooms. A rationale for differentiating instruction is followed by consideration of what differentiation is and is not. Characteristics of a differentiated class are enumerated, including: instruction is concept focused and principle driven, on-going assessment of student readiness and growth are built into the curriculum, and flexible grouping is consistently used. Suggested ways to differentiate instruction are grouped into interest-based adjustments, adjustments based on learning profile, and readiness-based adjustments. These last adjustments involve offering students a range of learning tasks developed along eight continua as follows: (1) concrete to abstract, (2) simple to complex, (3) basic to transformational, (4) fewer facets to multi-facets, (5) smaller leaps to greater leaps, (6) more structured to more open, (7) less independence to greater independence, and (8) slower to quicker. Suggested strategies for managing a differentiated classroom include: use of multiple texts and supplementary materials, interest centers, learning contracts, compacting, and group investigation. Teachers are urged to prepare students and parents for a differentiated classroom, attend to issues of classroom structure and management, and plan with team members and other colleagues interested in differentiation.”
Tomlinson, Carol Ann 2000 Differentiation of instruction in the elementary grades, ERIC Digest. ERIC Document Reproduction Service No.ED443572. Retrieved 1/3/02 online http://www.ericeece.org/pubs/digests/2000/tomlin00.html. http://www.ericeece.org/pubs/digests/2000/tomlin00.html customization, differentiated instruction, individualization, classroom schools May help homeschool parents think about how to customize the education of their children. ERIC system’s abstract says: “In most elementary classrooms, some students struggle with learning, others perform well beyond grade-level expectations, and the rest fit somewhere in between. Within each of these categories of students, individuals also learn in a variety of ways and have different interests. To meet the needs of a diverse student population, many teachers differentiate instruction. This Digest describes differentiated instruction, discusses the reasons for differentiating instruction and what makes the approach successful, and suggests how teachers can start implementing this type of instruction. The Digest notes that teachers can differentiate at least four classroom elements based on student readiness, interest, or learning profile: (1) content--what the student needs to learn or how the student will get access to the information; (2) process--activities in which the student engages in order to make sense of or master the content; (3) products--culminating projects that ask the student to rehearse, apply, and extend what he or she has learned in a unit; and (4) learning environment--the way the classroom works and feels. The Digest also discusses reasons for differentiating instruction, including the ample evidence that students are more successful in school and find it more satisfying if they are taught in ways that are responsive to their readiness levels. Noting that there is no recipe for differentiation, the Digest suggests broad principles and characteristics that are useful in establishing a defensible differentiated classroom. The Digest concludes with suggestions for teachers as they begin to differentiate, begin to differentiate more proactively, or seek to refine a classroom that can already be called ‘differentiated.’”
Tomlinson, Carol Ann 2001 How to differentiate instruction in mixed-ability classrooms, 2nd edition. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. http://askeric.org/plweb-cgi/fastweb?getdoc+ericdb2+ericdb+1076368+0+wAAA+%28ED451902%29 customizing, customization, differentiated instruction Written to an audience of institutional and classroom teachers and personnel but may be helpful to home educators. Description by ERIC retrieved 1/7/02 online http://askeric.org/plweb-cgi/fastweb?getdoc+ericdb2+ericdb+1076368+0+wAAA+%28ED451902%29 says, since teachers in mixed-ability classrooms face multiple challenges, provides “... guidance for teachers who are interested in creating learning environments that address the diversity typical of mixed-ability classrooms. The principles and strategies included can help teachers address a variety of learning profiles, interests, and readiness levels. The goal of the book is to help teachers determine what differentiated instruction is, why it is appropriate for all learners, how to begin to plan for it, and how to become comfortable enough with student differences to make school comfortable for each learner. Numerous practical examples assist teachers to use instructional strategies such as curriculum compacting, entry points, graphic organizers, contracts, and portfolios.” Chapters are: (1) What Differentiated Instruction Is--And Isn't; (2) The Rationale for Differentiated Instruction in Mixed-Ability Classrooms; (3) The Role of the Teacher in a Differentiated Classroom; (4) The Learning Environment in a Differentiated Classroom; (5) A Look Inside Some Differentiated Classrooms; (6) Strategies for Managing a Differentiated Classroom; (7) Preparing Students and Parents for a Differentiated Classroom; (8) The How To's of Planning Lessons Differentiated by Readiness; (9) The How To's of Planning Lessons Differentiated by Interest; (10) The How To's of Planning Lessons Differentiated by Learning Profile; (11) Differentiating Content; (12) Differentiating Process; (13) Differentiating Products; and (14) Grading in a Differentiated Classroom. Gives list of resources for further reading.
Torcaso v. Watkins, 367 U.S. 488 1961 United States Supreme Court. No. 373. Retrieved 3/30/2011 from http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/cgi-bin/getcase.pl?court=us&vol=367&invol=488. http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/cgi-bin/getcase.pl?court=us&vol=367&invol=488 law, legal, religion, definition of religion, secular humanism “Footnote 11: Among religions in this country which do not teach what would generally be considered a belief in the existence of God are Buddhism, Taoism, Ethical Culture, Secular Humanism and others.”
Tortorello, Michael 2016, October 7 Predators in the classroom: Individual cases of sexual abuse by teachers receive a great deal of attention, but how widespread is the problem? Why we still know, and are doing, so little. http://www.sesamenet.org/single-post/2016/10/07/Predators-in-the-Classroom https://www.wsj.com/articles/predators-in-the-classroom-1475872085 sexual abuse, public schools, teachers Wall Street Journal. Retrieved March 16, 2017 from http://www.sesamenet.org/single-post/2016/10/07/Predators-in-the-Classroom and https://www.wsj.com/articles/predators-in-the-classroom-1475872085
Toward Tradition 1999, circa Public statement of Toward Tradition. Mercer Island, WA: Author. education, Judaism, religion, family This traditional and conservative Jewish organization believes that “... Jewish tradition encourages deep respect for parents and teachers” [p. 1] and believes in “... the right of parents to direct the education and upbringing of their children” [p. 1] and “We believe that the single most important domestic priority for America is the strengthening of the traditional American family as a nuclear unit in which one man is committed to one woman and the two are committed to the raising of their children” [p. 1].
Travers, R. M. W. 1982 Essentials of learning (5th ed.). New York, NY: Macmillan Publishing Co., Inc.
Traviss, Mary Peter 1998, Fall Racial integration and private schools: A summary of two of Dr. Jay Greene’s articles. Private School Monitor, 20(1), 9-10.
Treat, Elizabeth Baurle 1990 Home school literacy: An ethnographic study of parents teaching reading and writing. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation at the University of Pennsylvania. home education, literacy, writing, reading University Microfilms International Order No. 9026662
Treat, Elizabeth Baurle 1990 Parents teaching reading and writing at home: An ethnographic study. Home School Researcher, 6(2), 9-19, www.nheri.org . http://www.nheri.org home education, research, qualitatitve, ethnographic, reading, writing, literacy Performs ethnographic study of the literacy teaching/learning in a homeschool family with an eight-year-old girl. “Although the parents did not envision themselves to be reading and writing teachers, but rather parents in the role of teacher, each knew the importance of the written word, and so designed curriculum to include frequent reading and writing. They created a specialized form of literacy this researcher calls ‘home school literacy.’ It will be defined as the intellectual development of people in a family system, who grow and change while in the process of learning and sharing textual material through home schooling. Through reading and writing interactions, not only is the individual family member [i.e., the child] involved in the pursuit of knowledge, but the entire family by definition becomes involved. As any single person changes, so too, [sic] does the system in which that person is a member change in response. The home school family designs its own special form of literacy through its teaching [p. 17].
Treleaven, Lisa M. 2022 Quantitative insights into the academic outcomes of homeschools from the Classic Learning Test. Home School Researcher, 38(1), 1-13, https://nheri.org/quantitative-insights-into-the-academic-outcomes-of-homeschools-from-the-classic-learning-test/ https://nheri.org/quantitative-insights-into-the-academic-outcomes-of-homeschools-from-the-classic-learning-test/ homeschools, homeschooling, academic achievement, Classic Learning Test, assessment, quantitative, achievement testing, aptitude test “Abstract. Homeschools have grown in prevalence in recent decades in the United States, including an unprecedented increase in homeschooling rates during the COVID-19 pandemic. The present quantitative study sought to add to the growing homeschool research by examining an existing depersonalized data set of test taker demographics and scores on the Classic Learning Test (CLT) from 2016 through March 2021 (n = 12,972). IBM SPSS 27 and 28 were used to assess how the CLT scores of homeschool students compare to the CLT scores of students from other school types. Results showed that on the adjusted total score, homeschool students scored significantly higher than students from all other school types aside from “other” at the p = .05 level, ranging from a 3 to 12.1 point difference. On the adjusted verbal section, homeschool students scored significantly higher than students from all other school type groups aside from “other” at the p = .05 level by 1.296 to 4.454 points. On the adjusted writing section, homeschool students scored significantly higher than students from all other school type groups aside from “other” at the p = .05 level by 1.6 to 5.4 points. On the quantitative section, homeschool students scored significantly higher than only the public school students and “not provided” groups at the p = .05 level by 1.436 to 2.310 points. This is consistent with prior research findings of superior academic performance of homeschool students as compared to other school types” (p. 1).
Trevaskis, Roseanne 2005 Master’s thesis, Monash University, Australia. home education, research, learning disabled Describes role author played as a homeschool mother with her own learning disabled children.
Tripp, Ted 1995 Shepherding a child's heart. Shepherd Press. On raising children from a biblical worldview).
Tschiderer, Christine; Sire, Henry; Lansell, Allison; Moore, Stephanie; & Block, Andrew 2012 7,000 Children and counting: An analysis of religious exemptions from compulsory school attendance in Virginia. Charlottesville, Virginia: Child Advocacy Clinic, University of Virginia School of Law. homeschooling, home education, religion, religious exemption, Virginia, statism, law, legal, philosophy “Virginia’s General Assembly, along with every other state legislature, has passed compulsory attendance laws requiring all school-age children to attend school, either in a public, private, parochial or approved homeschool setting. Like all 50 states, and as required by the United States Constitution and the Supreme Court, Virginia allows parents whose religious beliefs conflict with the idea of sending their children to public school to excuse their children from compulsory school attendance. Unique among the 50 states, however, is the fact that Virginia grants parents the ability to exempt their children from education altogether if they assert that their religious beliefs conflict with public school attendance. Indeed, once parents in Virginia are granted a religious exemption, they are no longer legally obligated to educate their children at all. ….. While this does not necessarily mean that religiously exempted children are not receiving an education, it does mean that Virginia law contemplates and allows for this possibility. ….. [p. 4]. It is the view of this report, however, that based on what is discussed in the following pages, Virginia needs to examine whether its current system of granting religious exemptions is constitutional, applied in a lawful manner by local school divisions, and serving as the most effective method for balancing the rights and choices of parents with other important, and even constitutional, interests of the state and the children themselves. Should Virginia’s educators and policymakers not engage in this examination, school divisions will continue to violate a law that may well be unconstitutional, and thousands of Virginia’s children will potentially, and unnecessarily, face uncertain and unverifiable educational futures.” [p. 6]. Authors appear to be attempting an argument that says the state law or practice is illegal or unconstitutional as at least partial cover for their personal worldview that promotes statism and its claim of premier authority over a child’s education and upbringing.
Tucker, C. Jack, Marx, Jonathan, & Long, Larry 1998, April “Moving on”: Residential mobility and children’s school lives. Sociology of Education, 71, 111-129. academic achievement, family The percentage of children in intact families whose parents report academic-behavioral problems is considerably lower than those in stepfamilies, famlies in which the biological mother alone is present, and other family types. The more children moved residences, the more poorer school performance/achievement they had. If the mobile children live with both biological parents then the school performance is not worse.
Tuma, John 2010 Pierce v. Society of Sisters: Catholic nuns save homeschooling from the Ku Klux Klan. The Paper MACHE, June/July 2010, 14-15. education, parental rights, public school, civil rights, Ku Klux Klan, philosophy, legal, law, political “On the heels of World War I, the KKK [Ku Klux Klan] was wielding great power in places like Oregon and, in conjunction with other forces, was able to place on that state’s 1922 ballot an initiative requiring all students to attend only public schools. The movement was to ensure that all children were appropriately Americanized to protect our country from communism and the influences of Catholicism. The campaign was an overt attempt to take students away from education by the Catholic Church and Jewish synagogues. Riding on the wave of this nationalistic movement, Walter Pierce was elected governor of Oregon. Pierce was the 1922 Democratic candidate for goyernor and openly embraced the KKK endorsement along with the 1922 compulsory attendance ballot initiative. On November 7, 1922, the voters of Oregon passed the compulsory attendance initiative that was set to take effect in September of 1926; Pierce made it very clear his administration would strictly enforce the provision. ….. It was through the decision in Pierce v. Society of Sisters (1925) and the Meyer v. Nebraska case (1923), which overturned a Nebrask law that required only English to be taught in schools, that the courts dearly started to develop individual civil rights protected under the Constitution through the 14th amendment. The courts stated in Meyer that an individual had the right “to contract, to engage in any of the common occupations of life, to acquire useful knowledge, to marry, establish a home and bring up children, to worship God according to the dictates of his own conscience, and generally to enjoy those privileges . . . essential to the orderly pursuit of happiness by free men." It was this case that the court cited as the main precedent for overturning the Oregon law [in Pierce v. Society of Sisters, 268 U.S. 510 (1925)] Pierce v. Society of Sisters] and guaranteeing the right of parents to direct the education of their children without state interference” [p. 15].
Turano, Frank 1982 A need to be free: An experience in home education. Provo, UT: Modern Media Publishers.
Tursman, Cindy 1983 Home-instruction: Hot issue in some areas. The School Administrator, 40(2), 23-24.
Tyack, D. 1966 The kingdom of God and the common school. Harvard Educational Review, 36, 447-468. History of religious influences on the development of the common school.
Tyack, D. 1970 Onward Christian soldiers: religion in the American common school. In Nash, P. (Ed.), History and education: the educational uses of the past. New York, NY: Random House. History of religious influences on the development of the common school.
Tyack, D. 1976 Ways of seeing: an essay on the history of compulsory schooling. Harvard Educational Review, 46, 355-389. history, compulsory education A discussion of four major historical interpretations of the implementation of compulsory attendance laws and the shortcomings of each; extensively referenced.
Tyack, D. B., Kirst, M. W., & Hansot, E. 1985 Educational reform: retrospect and prospect. In J. Ballentine (Ed.), Schools and society: A reader in education and sociology. of the precedents of today's declining support of public schools.)
Tyack, D., & Hansot, E. 1981 Conflict and consensus in American public education. Daedalus, 110, 1-25.
Tyack, David B. 1974 The one best system: A history of American urban education. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 353 p. history, curriculum, compulsory attendance Summarizes that until about 1900, the community controlled the classroom schools (p. 14) and “A child growing up in such a community could see work-family-religion-recreation-school as an organically related system of human relationships. ..... During the nineteenth century the country school belonged to the community” (p. 15); hidden curriculum of public schools (p. 49). Before 1900, schooling or book learning was only a small and often incidental part of the total education of a child, since he “... acquired his values and skills from his family and from neighbors of all ages and conditions.” [p. 14, 15]. During the 19th century “... the school was a voluntary and incidental institution: attendance varied enormously from day to day and season to season ...” [p. 16].
Tyler, Zan 2005 7 tools for cultivating your child’s potential. Nashville, TN: Broadman and Holman, Publishers.
Tyler, Zan P., & Carper, James C. 2000 From confrontation to accommodation: Home schooling in South Carolina. Peabody Journal of Education, 75(1 & 2), 32-48.
U.S. Department of Health & Human Services, Administration for Children and Families, Administration on Children, Youth and Families, Children’s Bureau 2026 Child Maltreatment 2024, https://acf.gov/cb/data-research/child-maltreatment ? https://acf.gov/cb/data-research/child-maltreatment
Uecker, Jeremy E. 2008 Alternative schooling strategies and the religious lives of American adolescents. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 47(4), 563 – 584. public education, private education, homeschooling, home education, research, religion, religious practice, religiosity, youth, peer influence, peer-reviewed Abstract: “I analyze the effects of Catholic schooling, Protestant schooling, and homeschooling on adolescents’ religious lives and test three mechanisms through which these schooling strategies might influence religiosity: friendship networks, network closure, and adult mentors. Data from Wave 1 of the National Survey of Youth and Religion suggest that Catholic schoolers attend religious services more frequently and value their faith more highly than public schoolers, but attend religious education classes and youth group less often. Protestant schoolers’ involvement in their local congregation is similar to public schoolers’, but their faith plays a more salient role in their life and they are more active in private religious activities. Homeschoolers do not differ significantly from public schoolers on any outcome considered. Moreover, friendship networks, network closure, and adult mentors play a very limited role in mediating the relationships between schooling strategies and adolescent religiosity. Interpretations of these findings are presented and discussed [p. 563].” Based on “… a nationally representative telephone survey of 3,290 American adolescents ages 13–17” and their parents during July 2002 through April 2003 [p. 568].Total N for study is 3,217, and n=76 for the currently homeschooled . Number of years these youth had been homeschooled was M= 0.13 (SD=1.02, range 0 to 13). “There is also an evident cumulative effect of homeschooling on private religious activities. Each additional year of homeschooling results in a 0.17 unit increase in private religious activities” [p. 579]. “Surprisingly, I find very little effect of homeschooling on any aspect of adolescents’ religious lives. Despite the fact that a significant minority of these students are homeschooled for explicitly religious reasons (Bielick, Chandler, and Broughman 2001), there appear to be scant religious benefits to this schooling strategy. On one hand, this may speak to the great diversity of motivations for homeschooling. There are a large number of nonreligious (or at least not extremely religious) homeschool parents, and religious benefits should not be expected from that type of homeschooling situation. But even when I tested for interaction effects between homeschooling and parent religiosity, no positive effects of homeschooling were apparent. These findings, together with the findings for Catholic-school and Protestant-school adolescents, highlight the importance of religious community for cultivating and maintaining adolescent religiosity. Furthermore, if the religiosity of homeschoolers, net of confounding factors, can be interpreted as the religiosity of adolescents absent of any schooling context (which it may not be), this study’s findings could suggest that public schooling is neither detrimental to nor beneficial for adolescent religiosity. ….. Table 1 shows that only 8 percent of adolescents are in Catholic schools, Protestant schools, or are homeschooled, so the potential overall explanatory power of these variables is rather limited from the start. The findings here also shed light on the role parents play in transmitting their religion to their adolescents. Parents retain strong influence on their adolescents’ religiosity, even after accounting for adolescents’ schooling situation, friends’ religiosity, network closure, and extrafamilial adult mentors. In fact, none of these factors seems to attenuate the role of parents at all. Thus, I find little support that parents are indirectly influencing their adolescents by “channeling” them into religious schooling environments or networks of religious friends and adults. Rather, parents [p. 581 ends] directly influence their adolescents. Social learning, spiritual modeling, and spiritual capital explanations may all explain this direct influence, but this study has not directly tested these theories. ….. With respect to homeschoolers, the NSYR did not ask parents why they choose this schooling method. An analysis of adolescents homeschooled for religious reasons may reveal differences between these students and public schoolers [p. 582].” The findings and reasons appear complex: peers are at the core of schools; how does one separate the influence of schools from the influence of peers that comprise a significant portion of school life? Seems that not much can be said about the influence of homeschooling in these adolescents’ lives since only n=76 were currently home educated and the average number of years all had been home educated was 0.13. Importantly, what will be long-term effects on their lives? If participation in a youth group is a “positive” sign of religiosity, the author does not point out that many Christian homeschool parents are not fond of youth groups. Peer-reviewed.
Ungerleider, Charles 2006 Government, Neo‐liberal Media, and Education in Canada. Canadian Journal Ofeducation, 29(1), 70‐90. education, media, public schools, Canada, not homeschooling Homeschooling is mentioned on page 74 by quoting another author but homeschooling is not, in any way, a significant topic in this article.
United States Bureau of the Census 1985 Statistical abstract of the United States, 1986 (106th ed.). Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
United States Bureau of the Census 1995, July 18 1994 Current Population Survey October School Enrollment Supplement.Washington DC: Author. home education, census, population size, research Reports for ages 5-14 children the number who were "primarily schooled at home," and these data are result of respondent being asked whether child was attending or enrolled in "regular school"; questionnaire should be examined for proper interpretation of numbers to evaluate whether items would elicit valid responses regarding home education; relatively small sample size.
United States Census Bureau 2021, March 22 Census Bureau’s Household Pulse Survey Shows Significant Increase in Homeschooling Rates in Fall 2020. Retrieved July 8, 2021 from https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2021/03/homeschooling-on-the-rise-during-covid-19-pandemic.html https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2021/03/homeschooling-on-the-rise-during-covid-19-pandemic.html homeschooling, population size, growth Number of adults living in households with homeschool students doubles from March 2020 to March 2021. by Casey Eggleston & Jason Fields. (“In the first week (April 23-May 5) of Phase 1 of the Household Pulse Survey, about 5.4% of U.S. households with school-aged children reported homeschooling. By fall, 11.1% of households with school-age children reported homeschooling (Sept. 30-Oct. 12). A clarification was added to the school enrollment question to make sure households were reporting true homeschooling rather than virtual learning through a public or private school. That change represents an increase of 5.6 percentage points and a doubling of U.S. households that were homeschooling at the start of the 2020-2021 school year compared to the prior year.”
United States Census Bureau 2021 Household Pulse Survey: Measuring Social and Economic Impacts during the Coronavirus Pandemic. Retrieved March 23, 2021 from https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/household-pulse-survey.html https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/household-pulse-survey.html homeschooling, population size, growth
United States Commission to Eliminate Child Abuse and Neglect Fatalities [CECANF] 2016 Within our reach: A national strategy to eliminate child abuse and neglect fatalities. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office. Retrieved February 1, 2017 from https://www.acf.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/cb/cecanf_final_report.pdf https://www.acf.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/cb/cecanf_final_report.pdf child abuse, child neglect, child fatalities, child abuse fatalities, child neglect fatalities “All of our recommendations should be implemented as soon as possible, but throughout the report we have identified specific steps that will be critical to build infrastructure and the body of knowledge needed to accelerate the rest. If these steps are taken, children will be safer today and tomorrow: ■ Identifying children and families most at risk of a maltreatment fatality is key to knowing when and how to intervene. Therefore, we recommend that states undertake a retrospective review of child abuse and neglect fatalities to help them identify family and systemic circumstances that led to child maltreatment deaths in the past five years. States will then use this information to identify children at highest risk now, and they will develop a fatality prevention plan to prevent similar deaths both now and in the future. Ensuring that the most vulnerable children are seen and supported is a critical element of this process. ■ Sharing data electronically and in real time will have an immediate impact on improving child protection decision-making by state and local entities. ■ Reviewing life-threatening injuries from abuse and neglect is an important part of the picture when it comes to preventing maltreatment fatalities and should be included in the child death review process. [p. 13 ends] ■ Accountability is a critical component for success and is relevant to almost all of our recommendations. A range of providers, including CPS, must work together and hold each other accountable. Mandated reporters, too, should be held to minimum standards and receive quality training. ■ Enhancing the structure of the federal government and its authority and oversight of state policy and practice was an area of focus for our work. We recommend elevating the Children’s Bureau to report directly to the Secretary of HHS and giving the Bureau the stature and authority to partner with states and local jurisdictions as they work together to prevent child maltreatment fatalities. ■ Funding for the 21st century child welfare system generated lively discussions in our meetings. In the end, we did not all agree on one specific strategy, but we spelled out options to ensure our recommendations move forward” (p. 13-14). There is no use or mention in this report of the terms homeschooling, home schooling, or home education, and there is no mention of type of schooling for a child being related to risk factors.
United States Department of Education 1984 The nation responds: Recent efforts to improve education. Washington, DC: Author.
United States Department of Education 1987 What works: Research about teaching and learning (2nd ed.). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office. "Parents are their children's first and most influential teachers. What parents do to help their children learn is more important to academic success than how well-off the family is" p. 5.
United States Department of Education March 1988 Becoming a nation of readers. D.C. Health and Company. educational improvement
United States Department of Education 1989, January Educating our children: Parents and schools together. Washington, DC: Author. parental involvement, choice Parental involvement is a key to children's learning success, parents must be involved in selecting educational environment that matches child's needs.
United States Department of Education 1990, July National goals for education. Washington, DC: Author. reform, excellence, academic achievement Developed by the President and the Governors.
United States Department of Education 1990a, December Choosing better schools: The five regional meetings on choice in education. Washington, DC: Author. choice, home education, reform, improvement Meetings as forum to hear from parents, teachers, administrators, and policy makers. Home schooling mentioned.
United States Department of Education 1991 America 2000: An education strategy. Washington, DC: Author. reform, choice, excellence Delineates National Education Goals, how to make existing schools better.
United States Department of Education 1991, September The ERIC review, pp. 1-28. parent-school relationships Parents and schooling in the 1990s, p.2., department of education parent involvement initiatives, p.7., resource list, p.8. organizations and associations, p.8., federal agencies, p.9., clearinghouses, p.9., general reading list, p.10., for your information, p.15., 1992 calendar and publications catalog available, p.15., be an ERIC author, p.15., parent involvement at the middle school level, p.16., los padres tambien deben participar en la escuela intermedia, p.18., research in action, p.21., important announcement--New EDRS contractor, p.23., new titles in education, p.24.
United States Department of Education 1994 Strong families, strong schools: Building community partnerships for learning. Washington, DC: Author. research, parental involvement, family, academic achievement Research shows that strong families and parental involvement are crucial to successful children’s learning. Provides practical steps that parents can take to help their children learn such as reading together, using television wisely, and talking with children and teenagers. “Thirty years of research show that greater family involvement in children’s learning is a critical link to achieving a high-quality educaiton and a safe, disciplined learning environment for every student” [p. III]. Many of the factors related to family involvement that are connected with high levels of student success and are discussed in this report are the same factors present in the home school environment—perhaps suggesting that it is no surprise that home educated students are generally successful students.
United States Department of Education 2010 Digest of Education Statistics, 2009, Table 33. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics. Retrieved April 2, 2020 from https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2010/2010013.pdf https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2010/2010013.pdf demographics, United States, public schooling In 1900 in the United States, public schooling became the norm for most school-age children by 1900 when 72 percent attended government-run schools for only 99 days per year.
United States Department of Education 2009 Homeschooled students. http://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/2009/section1/indicator06.asp#info http://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/2009/section1/table-hsc-1.asp http://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/2009/section1/table-hsc-2.asp home education, homeschooling, research, reasons Participation in Education, elementary/secondary education, indicator 6, 2009). Retrieved January 19, 2010 from http://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/2009/section1/indicator06.asp#info. (“This indicator examines the number and characteristics of homeschooled students in the United States. Homeschooled students are school-age children (ages 5-17) in a grade equivalent to at least kindergarten and not higher than 12th grade who receive instruction at home instead of at a public or private school either all or most of the time. In 2007, the number of homeschooled students was about 1.5 million, an increase from 850,000 in 1999 and 1.1 million in 2003 (see table A-6-1).” “Table A-6-1: Number and percentage distribution of all school-age children who were homeschooled and homeschooling rate, by selected characteristics: 1999, 2003, and 2007,” retrieved 1/15/10 from http://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/2009/section1/table-hsc-1.asp. “Table A-6-2: Table A-6-2. Number and percentage of school-age children who were homeschooled, by reasons parents gave as important and most important for homeschooling: 2007. Retrieved 1/15/10 from http://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/2009/section1/table-hsc-2.asp. “Figure 6-1: Number and distribution of school-age children who were homeschooled, by amount of time spent in schools: 1999, 2003, and 2007.” Homeschool statistics are from Bielick 2008 study. Reasons for homeschooling. Homeschool statistics are from Bielick 2008 study.
United States Department of Education 2014, November Table 206.10. Number and percentage of homeschooled students ages 5 through 17 with a grade equivalent of kindergarten through 12th grade, by selected child, parent, and household characteristics: 2003, 2007, and 2012. https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d15/tables/dt15_206.10.asp Prepared by U.S. Departement of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, Parent and Family Involvement in Education Survey of the National Household Education Surveys Program PFI-NHES:2003, 2007, and 2012). (Important note: Table 2 in Redford, Battle, & Bielick 2016 should be more accurate and reliable than this table which was prepared November 2014.) Retrieved February 9, 2017 from https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d15/tables/dt15_206.10.asp (Reports that there were an estimated 1,773,000 homeschool K-12 students in the U.S. in the spring of 2012. Breaks down the demographics by race/ethnicity, grade equivalent, sex, number of children in the household, number of parents in the household, parent participation in the labor force, highest education level of parents, household income, and locale (e.g., city, suburb).
United States Department of Education 2019, December Homeschooling in the United States: Results from the 2012 and 2016 Parent and Family Involvement Survey (PFI-NHES: 2012 and 2016). Retrieved January 6, 2020 from https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2020/2020001.pdf (Reports 1,690,000 (1.69 million) homeschool students in USA in 2016.) https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2020/2020001.pdf homeschooling, home schooling, population size, demographics, reasons, motivations
United States Department of Education [National Center for Education Statistics] 1997, February Mini-digest of education statistics, 1996. Washington, DC: Author. education, school enrollment population, public, private, home school Fall 1996 there were a projected in public schools 32,837,000 in K-8 and 13,049,000 in 9-12 (total 45,885) and in private schools 4,493,000 in K-8 and 1,304,000 in 9-12 (total 5,798,000; publication does not state whether the private school enrollment numbers include home school students) [and the National Home Education Research Institute estimated there were 920,000 in home schooling K-12 fall of 1996].
United States Department of Education [National Center for Education Statistics] 1998, February Mini-digest of education statistics, 1997. Washington, DC: Author. education, school enrollment population, public, private, home school Fall 1997 there were a projected in public schools 33,216,000 in K-8 and 13,138,000 in 9-12 (total 46,353,000) and in private schools 4,544,000 in K-8 and 1,320,000 in 9-12 (total 5,863,000; publication does not state whether the private school enrollment numbers include home school students); therefore, 89% of conventional, classroom-school students are in public schools [and the National Home Education Research Institute estimated there were 1,300,000 in home schooling K-12 fall of 1997].
United States Department of Education [Office of Educational Research and Improvement 1991, Fall ]. Special parent section. OERI Bulletin, Fall, 4-6. Articles on "Parents as Teachers," "Schools have key role in nurturing parent involvement," "Data indicate lack of parent involvement," "Parent publications," "Focus on families," "Labs help educators involve parents"
United States Department of Education [Office of Educational Research and Improvement (OERI)] 1989 Choosing a school for your child. Washington, DC: Author. home education, choice, parental involvement "How to" publication; mentions home schooling.
United States Department of Education [Office of Educational Research and Improvement] 1991, September Schools have key role to play in nurturing parent involvement (executive summary). Washington, DC: Author. parent involvement, social capital This is a summary of a policy paper by James S. Coleman; talks about need to rebuild social capital in the community. Full report, Parental involvement in education, available from U.S. Government Printing Office, Order No. 065-000-00459-3
United States Department of Education [Office of Educational Research and Improvement] 1997, October Fathers’ involvement in their children’s schools. Washington, DC: Author. research, parental involvement, father, fathers, achievement, school outcomes and success “... provides a broad overview of the extent to which resident (excluding foster) and nonresident fathers are involved in their children’s schools and examines the influence their involvement has on how children are doing in school” [p. v]. Finds that fathers’ involvement is positively related to number of A grades that child earns in school. Many other variables explored such as class standing, enjoyment of school, participation in extracurricular activities, repetition of a grade level, and suspension or expulsion from school.
United States Department of Education [Office of Educational Research and Improvement] 1997, November The elementary school performance and adjustment of children who enter kindergarten late or repeat kindergarten: Findings from national surveys [National Household Education Survey]. Washington, DC: Author. kindergarten entry, age of entry, late enterers, academic achievement, early childhood education, kindergarten, research Summarizes previous research findings on delayed kindergarten entry and kindergarten retention, including school performance (e.g., academic achievement). Uses national surveys and samples for present study. Concludes, among other things: “Implications of delayed kindergarten entry for student performance in elementary school Children whose parents had held them out of kindergarten for a year were found to be doing at least as well in first and second grade as their younger classmates who had entered school at the prescribed age. On several of the school performance and adjustment measures available in the surveys, they were doing better. Specifically, parents reported that fewer of the delayed enterers were described by teachers as not learning up to their capabilities or as having problems paying attention in class. They were also only half as likely to have had to repeat first or second grade. Given that most parents who delay their children's kindergarten entry do so because of the child's perceived lack of maturity at the time (McArthur and Bianchi 1993), the survey results suggest that their strategy for bolstering the child's school performance usually has the desired result. ..... At the least, our findings suggest that the extra year before starting kindergarten is not harmful to the children who are held out. Parents reported that children who are older when they start school seem to perform better than younger students. The multivariate analysis of the 1995 data suggest more modest effects for delayed school entry, but even these findings indicate that the delayed children were doing just as well as their classmates. Nowhere in the survey results is there an indication that the delayed students were doing less well. ..... [p. 38 ends here] Implications of kindergarten retention for student performance in elementary school The picture was very different for children who had been required to stay in kindergarten for a second year. These children were reported by their parents to be doing worse than their younger classmates on most of the school performance indicators that were available in the two surveys. ..... When the comparisons between retained and non-retained students were controlled by multiple logistic regression for the differing characteristics of the two groups, the two surveys produced somewhat disparate results [i.e., some statistically significant differences and some not]. ..... Despite these somewhat disparate results, the best that can be said about the school performance of retained pupils is that they are doing less well than most other first- and second-graders, but no worse than would be expected, given their other developmental and background characteristics. ..... [p. 39 ends here]. Why does the older age and greater maturity seem to have a beneficial effect for delayed enterers, but not for retained pupils? There are several possible answers to this question, and further research is obviously needed to determine which is correct. One potential explanation ..... [p. 40 ends here].
United States Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Evaluation and Regional Assistance 2003, December Identifying and implementing educational practices supported by rigorous evidence: A user friendly guide. Retrieved February 8, 2012 from http://www.classsizematters.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/rigorousevidence_guide_IES__3_1.pdf. http://www.classsizematters.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/rigorousevidence_guide_IES__3_1.pdf public school, academic achievement, one-on-one tutoring, tutoring, class size, life-skill training, phonemic awareness, phonics instruction “As illustrative examples of the potential impact of evidence-based interventions on educational outcomes, the following have been found to be effective in randomized controlled trials – research’s “gold standard” for establishing what works: One-on-one tutoring by qualified tutors for at-risk readers in grades 1-3 (the average tutored student reads more proficiently than approximately 75% of the untutored students in the control group).1 Life-Skills Training for junior high students (low-cost, replicable program reduces smoking by 20% and serious levels of substance abuse by about 30% by the end of high school, compared to the control group).2 Reducing class size in grades K-3 (the average student in small classes scores higher on the Stanford Achievement Test in reading/math than about 60% of students in regular-sized classes).3 Instruction for early readers in phonemic awareness and phonics (the average student in these interventions reads more proficiently than approximately 70% of students in the control group).4” [p. iii].
United States Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Statistics 2011, retrieved online National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) state comparisons. Retrieved August 9, 2011 from http://nces.ed.gov/nationsreportcard/statecomparisons/. http://nces.ed.gov/nationsreportcard/statecomparisons/ academic achievement, state level, public school, National Assessment of Educational Progress, NAEP Offers state-by-state comparisons of student performance, academic achievement, on NAEP tests.
United States Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Statistics 2024 Parent and Family Involvement in Education: 2023, First Look, https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2024/2024113.pdf https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2024/2024113.pdf homeschooling, population, population estimate “[footnote] 2. This column provides the percentage of the total subgroup that is homeschooled. For example, in 2023, some 3.7 percent of all school-age males were homeschooled. The total number of homeschooled students in 2023 was approximately 1,765,000” (p. A-20, referring to Table A-6). Note that this is significantly different from the U.S. Department of Education, 2022, estimate “… the data [from the U.S. Bureau of Census, analyzed by Census] show that 5.4 percent of students were reported to be homeschooled in 2020–21.”
United States Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics 1998 Common Core of Data, State Nonfiscal Survey. Public School Student, Staff and Graduate Counts by State, School Year 1996-97 / Table 1.-- Public school membership, by grade and state: Fall 1996. http://nces.ed.gov/pubs98/98219t01.html Available online http://nces.ed.gov/pubs98/98219t01.html, retrieved 4/13/00 and earlier
United States Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics 1999 The condition of education, 1999 http://nces.ed.gov/pubs99/condition99/Indicator-45.html school enrollment, public, private, statistics Table 45-1 Elementary and secondary school enrollment (in thousands), by control and grade level of school, with projections: Fall 1970–2008). [SOURCE: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, Digest of Education Statistics, 1998, table 3 (based on Common Core of Data) and Projections of Education Statistics to 2008, 1998, table 1.] Retrieved 12/22/00 online http://nces.ed.gov/pubs99/condition99/Indicator-45.html. (Reports that number of preK-12 students in 1990 in private schools was 5,232,000 and in public schools it was 46,448,000; for 2000, projected 6,006,000 and 53,445,000 respectively, p. 220.
United States Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics 2001 Homeschooling in the United States: 1999. Retrieved June 11, 2020 from https://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2001033 https://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2001033 homeschooling, research, demographics, population size, reasons The five reasons (out of ten reasons offered) most given by homeschool parents in the USDE’s 1999 survey were, in descending order of importance, can give child better education at home, religious reasons, poor learning environment at school, family reasons, and to develop character/morality, p. 10.
United States Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics 2022 Homeschooled children and reasons for homeschooling. Condition of Education. U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences. Retrieved [date], https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/tgk/homeschooled-children https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/tgk/homeschooled-children homeschooling, demographics, population size, numbers ““As mentioned in the introduction, the HPS [Household Pulse Survey, by the Bureau of Census] data can shed light on the prevalence of homeschooling during the 2020–21 school year, the first full school year after the emergence of the coronavirus pandemic.10 In 2020–21, among adults 18 years old and over who had students under 18 years old in the home, 6.8 percent reported having at least one child homeschooled. When examined at the student level, the data show that 5.4 percent of students were reported to be homeschooled in 2020–21 [emphasis added].”
United States Department of Education, Office of Education Research and Improvement, National Center for Educatio Statistics 2000, May School-level correlates of academic achievement: Student Assessment Scores in SASS [The Schools and Staffing Survey] public schools. Document No. NCES 2000-303. Retrieved 6/8/07 online http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2000/2000303.pdf. http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2000/2000303.pdf
United States Department of Health and Human Services 2010, January Head Start impact study final report, executive summary, January 2010. Retrieved February 22, 2010 from http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/opre/hs/impact_study/reports/impact_study/executive_summary_final.pdf. Prepared by Westat, Rockville, MD 20850. Washington, DC: Author. http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/opre/hs/impact_study/reports/impact_study/executive_summary_final.pdf Head Start, preschool, early childhood education, academic achievement, socialization “Providing access to Head Start has a positive impact on children’s preschool experiences. There are statistically significant differences between the Head Start group and the control group on every measure of children’s preschool experiences measured in this study. Access to Head Start has positive impacts on several aspects of children’s school readiness during their time in the program. ….. However, the advantages children gained during their Head Start and age 4 years yielded only a few statistically significant differences in outcomes at the end of 1st grade for the sample as a whole. Impacts at the end of kindergarten were scattered and are mentioned below only when they appear to be related to the 1st grade impacts” [page iv]. Only one of these was “cognitive” (e.g., directly related to academic learning; in this case, doing better on one measure of vocabulary on one standardized test). Other outcomes that might be related to “1st grade impacts” had to do with things such as one narrow measure of “social-emotional outcomes” and that there was “an impact” on “health insurance coverage.” “These impacts on children’s experiences translated into favorable impacts at the end of one year in the domains of children’s cognitive development and health, as well as in parenting practices. There were more significant findings across the measures within these domains for 3-year-olds in that first year (and only the 3-year-old cohort experienced improvements in the social-emotional domain. Yet, by the end of 1st grade, there were few significant differences between the Head Start group as a whole and the control group as a whole for either cohort” [p. xxv].
United States Department of Health and Human Services, Administration on Children, Youth and Families 1999 Child maltreatment 1997: Reports from the states to the National Child Abuse and Neglect Data System. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office. Retrieved January 19, 2008 from http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/cb/pubs/ncands97/s3.htm#figure31. http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/cb/pubs/ncands97/s3.htm#figure31 Finds 84% of reports of child abuse and neglect come from community and professional sources other than educators.
United States Department of Health and Human Services, Administration on Children, Youth and Families 2007 Child maltreatment 2005. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office. Retrieved January 19, 2008 from http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/cb/pubs/cm05/index.htm and http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/cb/pubs/cm05/figure2_1.htm. http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/cb/pubs/cm05/index.htm http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/cb/pubs/cm05/figure2_1.htm Eighty-four percent 84% of reports of child abuse and neglect come from community and professional sources other than educators.
United States Government Accountability Office 2014, January Federal agencies can better support state efforts to prevent and respond to sexual abuse by school personnel. Retrieved October 10, 2016 from http://www.gao.gov/assets/670/660375.pdf http://www.gao.gov/assets/670/660375.pdf educator sexual misconduct, schooling, public schools, school personnel, child abuse, sexual abuse “Over the last decade, a number of media reports were made across the country about sexual abuse1 of students by public K-12 school personnel. A report prepared for the U.S. Department of Education in 2004 stated that nearly 9.6 percent of students are victims of sexual abuse by school personnel —such as teachers, principals, coaches, and school bus drivers—sometime during their school career.3 Definitions of sexual abuse may vary from state to state. For example, sexual abuse may be defined in general terms or by specifying various acts as sexual abuse, such as rape, molestation, or sexual assault. For purposes of this report, we consider sexual abuse to include any sexual activity involving a child that is a crime under applicable state law. However, the prevalence of sexual abuse by school personnel remains unknown, in part, because some cases go unreported. Further, the term sexual abuse may not capture the full spectrum of the issue. While child sexual abuse typically refers to the criminal act of forcing a child to engage in sexual activity with the perpetrator, other inappropriate behaviors with children may eventually lead to sexual abuse. For example, while not generally criminal, behaviors often referred to as “grooming” may be carried out by the perpetrator with the aim of establishing trust to facilitate future sexual activity with the child. These behaviors could lead to sexual misconduct, including unwelcome or sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, and other verbal, nonverbal, or physical conduct of a sexual nature. Further, the growing use of technology and social media as a new and convenient way for adults and students to interact may pose questions about what interactions between school personnel and students are considered appropriate. Early signs of inappropriate behavior with a child can be the key to identifying and preventing the criminal act of sexual abuse” (p. 1-2).
United States Supreme Court 1954 Brown v. Board of Education, 347 U.S. 483 (1954).
Unknown author 1987 The evolution of parental rights in education. (1987). Journal of Law and Education, 16(3), 339-349. Law, educational history, home schooling English and American common law recognizes parents' natural right to control their children's education. As long as academic standards are satisfied, education should be matter of parental discretion.
Ury, Logan R. 2007, February 28 In a class of their own. Retrieved 3/6/07 online http://www.thecrimson.com/printerfriendly.aspx?ref=517372 [The Harvard Crimson magazine]. http://www.thecrimson.com/printerfriendly.aspx?ref=517372 home education, college, adults, ivy league university, college, anecdotes Describes three home-educated freshman Harvard students and their experiences in homeschooling and at Harvard University. Cites research findings by Ray and NHERI and others. Shows that the home educated come from a variety of backgrounds.
Valdez, K. 2005 Social perception of home schooled students (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Kansas, Lawrence.
Valery, Lina 2011 Homeschool technology and online communication. Home School Researcher, 26 (1), 1-7. homeschooling, home education, technology, research, online communication “Online communication and resource sharing between elementary homeschool families was examined. Through Action Research 16 homeschool families participated in a web site devised for the purpose of generating greater communication between families in between homeschool events and activities. It also served to establish a platform where parents could share online resources and technology tools. Three cycles of research were conducted, the first targeted improved online communication, the second presented digital storytelling as a teaching resource, and the third explored educational blogging. Data was collected by means of survey, email, and face-to-face communications. The results indicated that elementary homeschool families choose hands-on and face-to-face instruction, over the use of technology tools for teaching. Online tools were used mainly as a means to prepare content for lessons. The findings were analogous with the available literature regarding the preferred practices of homeschool parents and teaching methodologies” [p. 1].
Valiente, Carlos; Ray, Brian; Hoelzle, Braden; & Spinrad, Tracy L. 2026 Examining Homeschoolers’ Academic Achievement: The Role of Family and Child Characteristics. Journal of School Choice. https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2026.2684337 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2026.2684337 Homeschooling, self-regulation “Abstract: Little is known about what relates to homeschoolers’ achievement. To begin filling this gap, we collected data from 709 children. Language, reading, math, science, and social studies scores were obtained from the Iowa Tests of Achievement. Parents reported on income-to-needs, parental education, the number of years the child was homeschooled, the child’s age, sex, and self-regulation. At the zero-order level, self-regulation was positively related to each achievement index. Income-to-needs and parental education were often positively related to academic outcomes. In a series of regression analyses, children’s self-regulation emerged as the most consistent predictor of homeschoolers’ high achievement.”
Valiente, Carlos; Spinrad, Tracy L.; Eisenberg, Nancy; & Ray, Brian 2024 A heuristic model to guide the study of homeschoolers’ academic competence. Journal of School Choice, 18(4), 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2024.2422249 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2024.2422249 Academic competence, homeschooling, learning environment “Abstract. Studies exploring homeschooling typically focus on comparing homeschoolers to conventionally schooled peers on a range of academic outcomes. Largely absent from the literature are within-group studies designed to identify experiences that facilitate (or hinder) homeschoolers’ academic outcomes. The aim of this paper is to describe a heuristic model outlining ways the home environment, instructional practices, parent characteristics, child characteristics, and the broader context might relate to homeschoolers’ academic competence. The heuristic model is attentive to the possibility that these relations might vary as a function of child characteristics. In addition, the potential for transactional and mediated relations is considered.”
Valiente, Carlos; Spinrad, Tracy L.; Ray, Brian D.; Eisenberg, Nancy; & Ruof, Ariana 2022 Homeschooling: What do we know and what do we need to learn? Child Development Perspectives, https://doi.org/10.1111/cdep.12441 https://doi.org/10.1111/cdep.12441 academic achievement, homeschooling, home schooling, home education, social-emotional outcomes, child development, peer-reviewed “Abstract: In this article, we identify approaches for understanding more thoroughly the academic and social experiences of homeschooled students. The growth of the homeschooling movement in the United States, questions about the need for additional regulation, and the importance of high-quality education for children motivate this scholarly effort. We begin by defining homeschooling and outlining why it is a topic worthy of study. Next, we describe who is homeschooled, motivations for homeschooling, and ways parents engage in homeschooling. Preliminary evidence suggests that homeschoolers perform equal to or better than their conventionally schooled peers on measures of achievement and socioemotional functioning, but methodological limitations, especially selection effects, make it premature to draw definitive conclusions. Throughout the article, we offer suggestions for advancing knowledge on homeschooling” (p. 1). “Laypeople and scholars often struggle to define homeschooling. We define it as parent-directed education that largely takes place in the home. Parents who homeschool are responsible for their child’s education, but they may elicit others’ assistance to help teach their child; consequently, our definition affirms that homeschoolers can take part in learning activities outside the home. Students who take some in-person or online classes (e.g., flexischoolers) could be considered homeschoolers if their overall education is directed by their parents (Schafer & Khan, 2017)” (p. 1). “In a recent review, across the elementary to high school years, homeschoolers scored as well as or higher than (i.e., effect sizes ranged from small to large) conventionally schooled students on standardized measures of achievement (and other related measures, but see subsequent discussion of selection biases; Ray, 2017). Two studies suggest that the differences between homeschoolers and conventionally schooled students might not be as large in math as they are in language arts (Frost & Morris, 1988; Ray & Wartes, 1991); more data are needed to evaluate this issue. A cautious reading of the literature suggests that it is either too early to conclude that homeschoolers outperform their peers or that few to no differences are apparent” (p. 3-4).)
Valle, James Paul 1998 Their choice: How homeschooling makes sense to fundamentally Christian parents. Doctoral dissertation, Pennsylvania State University. home education, research .
Van Galen, Jane A. 1986, October Becoming home schoolers. (ERIC Document Reproduction NO. ED284325). Christianity, Home Schooling, Parents, Religious Education, Social Theories, Social Values A study concerning the socialization of new home schooling parents.
Van Galen, Jane A. 1987 Explaining home education: Parents' accounts of their decisions to teach their own children. The Urban Review, 19 (3), 161-177, https://psycnet.apa.org/record/1989-06716-001 ) https://psycnet.apa.org/record/1989-06716-001 Educational Needs, Elementary Secondary Education, Home Schooling, Moral Development, Parent Attitudes, Values Education, Reasons “This paper analyzes the reasons that parents choose to teach their children at home. From data collected over 18 months of qualitative research in a state in the southeast, three broad explanations for choosing home schooling emerged. First, the parents believe that home education will strengthen their families. Second, many home-schooling parents (particularly those who are fundamentalist Christians) believe that schools teach values and beliefs that directly contradict those they want their children to learn. Third, many of the parents believe that only they, as parents, understand their children's unique educational needs well enough to effectively teach them. The failure of educational policy makers to consider the extraeducational issues raised by home-schooling parents is then discussed.”
Van Galen, Jane A. 1987, April Home schooling in context. (ERIC Document Reproduction No. ED284324). Educational Assessment, Home Schooling, Ideology, Parent Role, Parent School Relationship, Social Influences How parents who choose to home school their children function within the larger social context that often seeks to dissuade them from their choice.
Van Galen, Jane A. 1987, December Review of Home schooling: a review of the literature by Mary Anne Pitman. Home School Researcher, 3(4).
Van Galen, Jane A. 1988 Ideology, curriculum, and pedagogy in home education. Education and Urban Society, 21(1), 52-68. Reasons, home education, research
Van Galen, Jane A. 1988, April Becoming home schoolers. Urban Education, 23(1), 89-106.) Home Schooling, Parent Attitudes, Parent Grievances, Parent Role, Teacher Effectiveness
Van Galen, Jane A. 1991 Ideologues and pedagogues: Parents who teach their children at home. In J. A. Van Galen & Mary A. Pitman (Eds.), Home schooling: Political, historical, and pedagogical perspectives, p. 63-76. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation.
Van Galen, Jane A. & Pitman, Mary Anne (Eds.) 1991 Home schooling: Political, historical, and pedagogical perspectives. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation. home education, research, anthropology, achievement, socialization, reasons, law, legal, history, philosophy, critique, book Presents first collection of scholarly writing on home education in book form. Authors (P. Lines, B. Ray and J. Wartes, J. Van Galen, M. Pitman and M. Smith, J. Cibulka, S. Franzosa, J. Kirschner, and S. Richardson and P. Zirkel) provide chapters on size and growth of the movement, academic achievement and affective development, ideological and pedagogical parents, anthropological understanding of culture acquisition, state regulation of home education, a critique of Holt's philosophy, historical perspective of families and schools as educators, and home schooling law. Van Galen writes in her chapter, “They object to what they believe is being taught in public and private schools and they seek to strengthen their relationships with their children. These parents are Christian fundamentalists (although not all the Christians in the study are Ideologues), and they have specific values, beliefs, and skills that they want their children to learn. Beyond traditional subject matter, the parents want their children to learn fundamentalist religious doctrine and a conservative political and social perspective. Not incidentally, they also want their children to learn (both intellectually and affectively) that the family is the most important institution in society." [p. 71]
Van Galen, Jane Ann 1986 Schooling in private: A study of home education. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, 289 pp. Also, Dissertation Abstracts International, 47(5), 1683A. home education, research, qualitative, reasons, motivations "This study documents and analyzes the values, beliefs, and practices of home schooling families in the state of North Carolina" [p. iii] based on interviews with 23 parents and ten state and local education officials involved in the home education issue. “Two broad types of home-schooling parents were identified. The first, identified as the Ideologues, home school because they believe that public schools teach values that are anti-family and anti-Christian” [p. iii]. Ideologue parents want to teach Christian ideas and a conservative political view. “The second type, the Pedagogues, home school primarily because they believe their children learn best in the informal environment of the home" [p. iii]. "Parents in both of these groups are drawn to home schooling because they believe that it will strengthen their families, because they fear that their children will be damaged by the teachings of public schools, because they believe that their child learn in unique ways, and because acceptable schools were not available” [p. iii].
Van Galen, Jane Ann 1986, April The social context of home education. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco, CA. Research.
Van Pelt, Deani 2003 Home education in Canada: A report on the pan-Canadian study on home education 2003. Medicine Hat, Alberta: Canadian Centre for Home Education, https://cche.ca/home-education-in-canada-a-report-on-the-pan-canadian-study-on-home-education-2003/ https://cche.ca/home-education-in-canada-a-report-on-the-pan-canadian-study-on-home-education-2003/ home education, research, demographics, academic achievement, adults who were home educated, Canada Presents demographics of homeschool community, academic achievement and life satisfaction of currently home-educated students, and correlations between academic achievement and sundry variables, and finding on select variables regarding adults who were home educated. Some of the findings follow: 96.4% are two-parent families; average number of children per family is 3.6 with average of 2.4 being home educated at any one time; 83.9% of mothers and 79.8% of fathers have at least some college or university education; 11.2% of mothers and 5.2% of fathers are certified teachers; both parents are generating income in 31.4% of the families, with the mother generating, on average, 26.3% of the household income; average annual household income of home-educating families is less than Can$35,000 in 26.1% of families and above Can$65,000 in 30.4% of families; the religious preference of 83.6% of mothers and 83.1% of fathers is Protestant Christian, while about 9.5% of parents were Roman Catholic, 1.6% agnostic, 1.5% atheist, and other such as Buddhist, Jewish, Mormon, Muslim, and “other.” Homeschool students’ average scores on standardized academic achievement tests were as follows: for grades 1 to 8, 81st percentile in reading, 76th percentile in language, and 74th percentile in mathematics; for grades 9 to 12, 85th percentile in reading, 84th percentile in language, and 67th percentile in mathematics. Among several correlations noted, the following were included: (a) “If elementary students had been entirely home-educated, their reading, language and mathematics scores were higher than those who had experienced a mix of school and homeschool over the years” [p. 7]; (b) “For elementary students, the unschooling approach gives some indication of resulting in higher reading and mathematics scores than the traditional textbook approach to education” [p. 7]; (c) “As mothers’ and fathers’ education increased, elementary students’ mathematics scores improved” [p. 8].
Van Pelt, Deani 2003 Report on the Pan-Canadian Study on Home Education 2003, executive summary. Retrieved 12/9/04 online http://www.alternative-learning.org/altlearn_map/articles/pan-canadian-study-on-he2003.html. http://www.alternative-learning.org/altlearn_map/articles/pan-canadian-study-on-he2003.html
Van Pelt, Deani 2004, March The choices families make: Home schooling in Canada comes of age. Fraser Forum, March 2004, p. 15-17. http://www.fraserinstitute.org/Commerce.Web/product_files/The%20Choices%20Families%20Make~~%20Home%20Schooling%20in%20Canada%20Comes%20of%20Age-Mar04ffpelt.pdf home education, research, academic achievement, demographics, adults, success in adulthood, Canada Retrieved 5/29/08 and 5/13/08 from http://www.fraserinstitute.org/Commerce.Web/product_files/The%20Choices%20Families%20Make~~%20Home%20Schooling%20in%20Canada%20Comes%20of%20Age-Mar04ffpelt.pdf Fraser Institute: Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. Author releases some of research findings from her full-length report. “The students scored, on average, at the following percentiles: (a) first to eighth graders in reading, 81st; language, 76th; and mathematics, 74th; and (b) ninth to twelfth graders, in reading, 85th; language, 84th; and mathematics, 67th” [p. 16]. Presents findings on young adults who were home educated. “This report, also one of the first Canadian studies to survey home-educated adults, found that responsible citizenship ranked high: 72 percent had voted in the last 5 years, less than 7 percent had ever collected employment insurance benefits and none had ever received any social security assistance. Over 80 percent volunteered in one or more capacities” [p. 17]. And “… formerly home-educated students, now adults, filled in the satisfaction With Life Scale (Pavot and Diener, 1993) to determine their level of contentment and satisfaction with life” [p. 16]..
Van Pelt, Deani 2015 Home Schooling in Canada: The Current Picture—2015 Edition. Vancouver, BC, Canada: Fraser Institute. Retrieved June 16, 2015 http://www.fraserinstitute.org/uploadedFiles/fraser-ca/Content/research-news/research/publications/home-schooling-2015.pdf. http://www.fraserinstitute.org/uploadedFiles/fraser-ca/Content/research-news/research/publications/home-schooling-2015.pdf Finds that 21,662 Canadian children were registered as ‘home-school students’ (with likely more not officially registered) in 2012, an increase of 29 per cent over a five-year period. Moreover, it appears that policymakers are paying attention to the jump in numbers: Since 2007, at least five provinces have updated or expanded regulations with regard to home schooling.
Van Pelt, Deani A. Neven, Allison, Patricia A., & Allison, Derek J. 2009 Fifteen years later: Home-Educated Canadian Adults. London, Ontario, Canada: Canadian Centre for Home Education. Retrieved 7/15/13 from http://www.hslda.ca/assets/pdf/2009-study.pdf. http://www.hslda.ca/assets/pdf/2009-study.pdf home education, homeschooling, research, adults, college students, educational attainment, community service, civic engagement, religion, religiosity Present an in-depth study of adults in Canada who were home educated. Addresses formal educational attainment, occupations, civic engagement, religious affiliation and participation, physical activities, leisure activities, family life, and more. The adults who were home educated are engaged at a much higher rate in religious activities that than the general population. “… [T]hree-quarters (76%) of our respondents said that religious beliefs were very important in their lives, compared with only one-quarter (26%) of similarly aged Canadians” (p. 15), and 95% of the respondents reported they were “Christians.” “These findings are consistent with those Ray (2004) found in his study of 5,254 Americans (home educated for seven or more years of their K-12 education) in terms of the demographic characteristics of the adults such as education achieved and civic engagement. He summarized his findings thus: “The home-educated adults in this study were very positive about having been homeschooled and toward homeschooling in general, actively engaged in their local communities, keeping abreast of current affairs, highly civically involved, tolerant of others expressing their viewpoints, attaining relatively high levels of formal education, religiously active and wide-ranging in their worldview beliefs, holding worldview beliefs similar to those of their parents, and largely home educating their own children”” (p. 44). “In terms of their highest level of education attained when compared to the general population, the formerly home-educated students attain higher levels. Their occupations are more oriented to health, to social services such as education, religious, and government, to arts and culture, and to participation in trades and transportation than the comparable population, and less oriented to sales and service, and natural and applied sciences. They are equally engaged in business, finance, and administration. They are much more likely to be civically engaged and to vote in federal, provincial, and municipal elections. Their religious affiliation and observance tends to be high, and their charitable donations tend to be oriented to religious obligations or beliefs. Their income tends to be slightly higher than that of their peers and none rely on government payments as their main source of income. Their life satisfaction is higher than that of their peers. They are more physically and recreationally active, and more engaged in culture and the arts than their peers. They are more likely to be married and to marry earlier than their peers, less likely to have children early but when they do, they tend to have larger families than their peers. They come from homes where their parents have a higher academic education and are more religious than their peers’ parents” (p. 44). “When pushed for the single most important reason that they were home educated, they claimed first most frequently, educational reasons, second, religious reasons, third, family reasons and fourth, other, largely idiosyncratic, reasons. Note the slight move away from the dominance of ideological and/or religious motivations. This can then be compared with what the respondents said was the best part about being home educated. They claim that rich relationships, extensive enrichment, schedule flexibility, individualization of pace and program, development of independence and superior academics were the best aspects of home education. Thus, as they reflect, it is not the strong ideological and/or worldview that emerges as a best aspect of home education, but rather the academic opportunities and the personal enrichment. Nevertheless, 89% of them also said that religion was somewhat or very important to how they live their daily lives. Thus, the religious motivations of their parents for home educating must also have had an influence although it did not emerge as the “best” part about being home educated” (p. 45).
Van Pelt, Deani A. Neven, Allison, Patricia A., & Allison, Derek J. 2009 Fifteen Years Later: Home-Educated Canadian Adults, A Synopsis. Retrieved 7/15/13 from http://www.hslda.ca/assets/pdf/2009-study-synopsis.pdf: “In comparison with the same age groups in the general population, home-educated adults, had parents who had a higher academic education and were more religiously committed; attained higher levels of academic education; were more likely to be occupied in health and social services; were just as likely to be involved in business, finance, and administration; were much more likely to be civically and politically engaged; were typically very religiously committed; earned slightly more; were more satisfied with their lives; were physically more active and culturally more involved; were more likely to marry and unlikely to live common-law. http://www.hslda.ca/assets/pdf/2009-study-synopsis.pdf home education, homeschooling, research, adults, college students, educational attainment, community service, civic engagement, religion, religiosity Discussion. They were also very happy that they had been home educated, and for the most part felt that it had given them an advantage in life and in future education. Drawbacks included stigmatization and social prejudice, curriculum limitations and, for some, fewer opportunities to participate in group activities such as sports. The benefits included rich relationships, opportunity for extensive curricular enrichment, flexibility, individualized pace and program, development of independence and confidence, and superior academic education” (p. 10).)
Van Pelt, Deani A. Neven; Sikkink, David; Pennings, Ray; & Seel, John 2012 Private religious Protestant and Catholic Schools in the United States and Canada: Introduction, overview, and policy implications. Journal of School Choice: International Research and Reform, 6(1), 1-19. Protestant schools, Catholic schools, graduate outcomes, academic achievement, spiritual formation, cultural engagements, homeschooling, Canada Probably similar or same information as in Pennings, Seel, Van Pelt, Sikkink, & Wiens, 2011, and maybe includes limited information on homeschooling. “Abstract: This article introduces the research initiated by Cardus on private religious Protestant and Catholic schools in North America [United States and Canada] and provides an overview of the succeeding articles presented in this special section of the Journal of School Choice. Through mixed method study by multiple research teams the inquiry was designed to seek to better understand the academic, spiritual, and cultural outcomes of private religious Christian education in Canada and the United States. This article introduces the conceptual variables under investigation and the approaches to inquiry employed in the various studies. The article reflects on several of the findings and comments on the possible policy implications of this research.”
Van Schalkwyk, Lizebelle; & Bouwer, Cecilia 2011 Homeschooling: Heeding the voices of learners. Education as Change, 15(2), 179-190. Retrieved April 2, 2020 from https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/16823206.2011.619147 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/16823206.2011.619147 homeschooling, home schooling, learner, student perspective, qualitative, case study, homeschool learner, learner perspective, bio-ecological Qualitative case study. “Abstract: Homeschooling research to date has focused mainly on the perspective of homeschool educators. However, heeding the voices of homeschool learners is essential for a reliable understanding of the homeschool context. This article focuses on findings regarding one homeschool learner who was a participant in a qualitative, multiple case-study of four homeschools. Homeschool educators and learners were interviewed concerning their discourses and perspectives regarding their respective homeschools. Projections were used that explored participants’ meanings at a deeper level, and there were three sessions of non-participating observation in each homeschool. The views of the homeschool learners corresponded, to a certain extent, with those of the homeschool educators, but also indicated some significant differences. Although the limited scope of the investigation prohibits generalisation, the homeschool educators all appeared to be convinced that they were acting in their children's best interests, and yet often without accommodation or awareness of their particular needs. The homeschool learners did not communicate their needs or feelings on a conscious level, but instead bowed to the educators’ wishes. The lack of congruence on a deeper level between the views of the homeschool educators and learners is discussed from a bio-ecological perspective, thus giving due regard to both the entire context of each homeschool and developmental factors. We shall consider the implications of the findings for homeschool practice, further research and policy.”
Van Til, William (Ed.) 1974 Curriculum: quest for relevance, 2nd ed. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin Co., 432 p. School criticism.
Vaughan, Tricia S. 2006, February 19 Your child needs to be in school. Retrieved 2/20/06 online http://americandaily.com/article/11945. http://americandaily.com/article/11945 home education, reasons, philosophy Homeschool parent responds to a “caring mom” who told her that her child needed to be in school. Makes excellent presentation of reasons for homeschoooling. Her theoreticla framework appears to be based on free thinking, critical thinking, and US constitutional and biblical liberty.
Vaughn, Michael G.; Salas-Wright, Christopher P.; Kremer, Kristen P.; Maynard, Brandy R.; Roberts, Greg; & Vaughn, Sharon 2015 Are homeschooled adolescents less likely to use alcohol, tobacco, and other drugs? Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 155, 97-104. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2015.08.010 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2015.08.010 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0376871615016014 Adolescents; Substance use; Substance use disorders; Tobacco; Alcohol; marijuana; Illicit drugs; Homeschool; homeschooling; research, risk, at-risk “Abstract Background Nearly two million school-aged children in the US are currently homeschooled. This study seeks to examine homeschooled adolescents’ attitudes toward, access to, and use of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Other Drugs (ATOD) compared to their non-homeschooled peers. Methods The study uses data between 2002 and 2013 from the National Survey on Drug Use and Health (NSDUH) for school-attending respondents aged 12-17 (n = 200,824). Participants were questioned regarding peer use of licit and illicit substances, ease of accessing illicit substances, and past 12-month substance use. Survey adjusted binary logistic regression analyses were systematically executed to compare non-homeschooled adolescents with homeschooled adolescents with respect to views toward, access to, and use of substances. Results Findings indicate that homeschooled adolescents were significantly more likely to strongly disapprove of their peers drinking (AOR = 1.23) and trying (AOR = 1.47) and routinely using (AOR = 1.59) marijuana. Homeschooled adolescents were significantly less likely to report using tobacco (AOR = 0.76), alcohol (AOR = 0.50), cannabis (AOR = 0.56) and other illicit drugs and to be diagnosed with an alcohol (AOR = 0.65) or marijuana (AOR = 0.60) use disorder. Finally, homeschooled adolescents were also less likely to report easier access to illicit drugs and to be approached by someone trying to sell drugs compared to non-homeschooled peers. Conclusions Homeschooled adolescents’ views, access, use and abuse of ATOD are uniquely different from those of non-homeschooled adolescents. Findings point to the need to more extensively examine the underlying mechanisms that may account for these differences.” Retrieved August 25, 2015 from http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0376871615016014 “3.4. Are homeschooled adolescents less likely to use tobacco, alcohol, and illicit drugs? As presented in Table 4, controlling for age, gender, race/ethnicity, and household income, homeschooled adolescents are significantly less likely than non-homeschooled adolescents” [p. 100 ends] to report use of tobacco (AOR = 0.76, 95% CI = 0.63–0.93), alcohol (AOR = 0.50, 95% CI = 0.42–0.60), and cannabis (AOR = 0.56, 95%CI = 0.43–0.73). Notably, no significant differences were observed with respect to crack/cocaine, inhalants, stimulants, or tranquilizers; however, homeschooled adolescents were significantly less likely to have used ecstasy (AOR = 0.41, 95% CI = 0.21–0.81), and hallucinogens (AOR = 0.61, 95% CI = 0.38–0.98)” (p. 101). “With respect to substance use disorders, home-schooled adolescents were significantly less likely to have met criteria for alcohol (AOR = 0.65, 95% CI = 0.43–0.90) and cannabis (AOR = 0.60, 95% CI = 0.37–0.98) use disorders, but no significant association was observed for other illicit drug use disorders” (p. 101). “Moreover, homeschooled adolescents were less likely to report using alcohol, marijuana, ecstasy and hallucinogens as well as less likely to report alcohol or marijuana abuse or dependence than their non-homeschooled peers” (p. 102). Concepts of risk and at-risk are implicitly addressed.
Vaughn, P.A. 2003 Case studies of home school cooperatives in southern New Jersey. (Doctoral Dissertation, Widener University, 2003). Dissertations Abstract International, 64(9), 3184. homeschool, homeschooling, co-ops, cooperatives
Vedantam, Shankar 2001, April 19 Kid care, behavior linked in study: Aggression, defiance seen across the board. Washington Post. Published 4/19/01 and retrieved 4/20/01 online http://www.dallasnews.com/national/342967_daycare_19nat..html http://www.dallasnews.com/national/342967_daycare_19nat..html childcare, daycare, behavior, education “The more hours that toddlers spend in child care, the more likely they are to turn out aggressive, disobedient and defiant by the time they are in kindergarten, according to the largest and most authoritative study of child care and development ever conducted. Researchers said Wednesday that this correlation held true regardless of whether the children came from rich or poor homes, were looked after by a relative, a nanny or at a center, and whether they were girls or boys. It remains unclear whether reducing child care would reduce the risk that a child will turn into a mean-spirited bully. And complicating matters further, good child care is associated with increased skills in intellectual ability such as language and memory, leading some academics to suggest that child care turns out children who are "smart and nasty." The government-sponsored research, which has tracked more than 1,300 children at 10 sites across the country since 1991, is bound to rekindle the debate over child care, a debate that resonates across every income group and every demographic: How should people balance work and family? And how should parents, especially mothers, resolve the demands that are placed on them to be both breadwinners and supermoms?” Jay Belsky of Birkbeck College in London was one of the lead investigators; Sarah Friedman, a developmental psychologist at the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, was one of the other lead scientists on the study.
Veith, Gene Edward 2000, July 22 Finally, a conservative movie: The Patriot strikes all the right chords, to the outrage of the left. World, p. 13-14. Reviews the new film/movie The Patriot about the American Revolution in which are portrayed “... the passionate commitment to family; the celebration of America and its heritage; the cultural impact of Christianity. Even the subtler issues that non-conservatives can never understand--the dangers of gun control, the impulse to honor the flag--are here, in a Hollywood summer blockbuster. Conservatives are not used to seeing a movie in which their values are presented positively. neither are the Hollywood establishment and mainstream liberal movie critics. ‘The Patriot is right-wing hogwash,’ harrumphed Arion Berger of the Washington City Paper. ‘Now the disgruntled, home-schooling, SUV-buying, pro-militia-but-cautious-suburban-family-values working man has a movie to call his own’” [p. 13].
Veith, Gene Edward 2000, December 2 Out-Clintoning Clinton. World, 15(47), 21-22. modernism, postmodernism, education, philosophy, worldview Explains that “Bill was our nation’s first postmodern president [p. 21].” “One response to the end of modernity is to recover what was of value in the premodern era and to apply old worldviews in new, creative ways to our contemporary times. Thus, we have a new classicism in education and in some sectors of the art world, and the new cultural relevance of conservative Christianity. Postmodern America also saw a revival of conservative politics, with the success of Ronald Reagan. ..... The other response to the end of modernist rationalism is to take the next step and deny rationalism altogether. These postmodernists maintain that truth-claims and moral absolutes are nothing more than a personal or social construction [p. 22]. ..... But, however the [U.S. presidential] election goes, Americans should be asking whether political institutions that originated in a worldview resting on transcendent absolutes can survive if the culture no longer believes in any of them. What were for the founders “self-evident truths”--belief in a Creator who endowed “inalienable” rights--are no longer self-evident. Indeed, in many circles they are routinely dismissed as unworthy of discussion. Rights are a social construction, not grounded in any kind of transcendent God. But, as postmodernists have shown, what is constructed can be deconstructed, and rights created by the state can be taken away by the state” [p. 22]. This author’s thinking about and views of modernism underlie much of the motivation for many parents to homeschool their children in today’s culture.
Vernon, L. 1984 Who is responsible for our children's education? Childhood Education, 60, 274, 276.
Vesneski, William; Breen, Breen; Hansen, Ulcca; Reisman, Fredrika; & Anselm, Holly 2022 American families’ attitudes to unschooling: A national survey. International Journal of Progressive Education, 18(5). Self-Directed Education, SDE, Unschooling, Education Alternatives, Homeschooling, Student-Centered Education “Abstract: A national survey of American families was conducted to ascertain the extent of interest in self-directed education (SDE) in the United States. Our research took place in the midst of the Covid-19 pandemic - a moment when we required a much better understanding of what parents need from the US education system. Data were gathered using an online survey aimed at parents or caregivers of young people aged 4-18. A total of 1009 adults completed the caregiver survey. Resulting data were analyzed using SPSS. Results suggest a high degree of openness to SDE. The data also elucidate several questions and concerns that parents and caregivers have about the approach. Data also highlighted differing perceptions of and attitudes towards SDE as a function of race. As the first nationwide survey about SDE, this study has made an important contribution to the existing literature on the subject. Directions for further research are discussed.”
Vicry, Madalyn Doucet 2017 That kind of girl: Effects of homeschooling on the sexual health of women and girls. The Georgetown Journal of Gender and the Law, 18(103), 103-129. homeschooling, home schooling, sex, sexuality, sex education, religion, worldview, statism, secularism, law, regulation, private schools “First, a disclaimer: the parameters of this Note will focus on what most people refer to as “conservative Christian homeschoolers”11. ….. [footnote] 14. I was homeschooled for religious reasons from Grades 1–12” (p. 105). It is telling to see how she wordsmiths her views of Christian homeschoolers. For example, Vicry labels Christian homeschoolers as “anti-government” (p. 108) instead of as pro-limited government, pro-individual liberty, or pro-U.S. Constitution in regard to government’s role in citizens’ live. She labels Christian homeschoolers as "anti-progressive" (p. 109) instead of as pro-conservative, pro-Christian, or pro-biblical. Finally, she labels them as “counter-cultural” (p. 110) instead of as cultural change agents, as many university professional educators argue that public school teachers should be. The following, on the other hand, is true for many Christian homeschool parents, as Vicry writes: “For these parents, homeschooling was not only an educational choice but an entire way of living. These parents were unwilling to have children raised in the ‘American cult of the child’ and brought up under a worldview of secular humanism imposed on them by strangers" (p. 110). Vicry never clearly states her personal worldview or Weltanschauung that is plainly driving the direction of her paper. On this note, she “pulls” from the “The CDC [U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention] [which] has adopted the 2002 definition of sexual health from the World Health Organization [WHO] …” to focus on her “… three ‘building blocks’ of sexual health …” (p. 111). Vicry is committing the fallacy of appeal to questionable authority. She never tells her readers why they should accept the philosophy of sexuality education of the CDC or the WHO. Why does Vicry follow the beliefs of the CDC and WHO, and why should the reader, homeschool families, and those who are considering placing more government regulations onto private homeschooling accept the values, beliefs, and religious-philosophical worldview of these two government-controlled entities? Vicry fails to mention that both the CDC’s and her building blocks are based on a religious-philosophical worldview that is eminently secular and anti-Christian. This is one of her key lacks in this paper – a failure to acknowledge to the reader the philosophical and religious presuppositions behind her entire thesis. THE DATABASE FOR Vicry’s conclusions about the sexuality education of the children of Christian homeschoolers is gaunt and strained. For example, she presents the following to her readers: “This anonymous homeschooled student’s story is one common to many homeschoolers. When ‘Holly’ left home and arrived at college, she had no basic knowledge of her own anatomy, sexual or reproductive functioning, or what constitutes healthy sex” (p. 113); Vicry pulled this anonymous story from a blog of a website of a group that is consistently and constantly advocating for increased government regulation of homeschooling which is a form of private education in the United States. In the end, despite the fact that Vicry’s article title includes the word “effects,” she provides no evidence of legal, philosophical, or diagnosable emotional harm to children who are being home educated or adults who were home educated by the typical biblical teachings on sexuality that most Christian homeschool parents give to their children at a rate that is less than, the same as, or higher than for other populations. Furthermore, Vicry offered no evidence that graduates of homeschooling by Christian parents are at any greater risk of psychological or emotional harm or problems such as sexually transmitted diseases or sexual dysfunction than children who are raised in government public schools. However, author talks about her article’s “… analysis of the harms of homeschooling on the sexual health of women and girls …” (p. 128). Regarding the Christians to whom author refers, she writes: “The risks to a woman’s physical or mental health,184 or the family’s financial stability,185 are ones these homeschoolers are willing to take” (p. 125); ergo, they are engaging in risky behaviors. Author claims, “Conservative Christian homeschoolers have fallen far short of the sexual health ideal. Instead of teaching a model of knowledge, positivity, and equality, homeschoolers have remained rooted in an ideology of censorship, shame, and patriarchy. This sexual worldview has bred generations of women and girls who now live with the consequences of sexual dysfunction, unhealth, or abuse 199” (p. 129) but offers no empirical evidence that this is true, or that the homeschooled are subject to “sexual dysfunction, unhealth, or abuse” at any higher rate than the general public. Vicry’s recommendations are based on her religious-philosophical worldview of statism and humanism. The author begins by selecting Christian homeschool parents and their beliefs about sexuality. Vicry ends her article by asserting that people of her religious-philosophical-political worldview should use the state (government) to force – i.e., use coercion – a different set of beliefs about sexuality into the curriculum that all homeschoolers use with their children. One should note that Vicry’s view would put the state in authority over the curriculum and schooling of all homeschoolers and unschoolers and not just of Christian homeschoolers. This author’s perspective should concern every person, whether in the United States and any other nation, who holds to a worldview that includes educational freedom and parents having more authority in a child’s education and upbringing than the state
Vieux, Andrea 2014, July The politics of homeschools: Religious conservatives and regulation requirements. The Social Science Journal. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.soscij.2014.06.004 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.soscij.2014.06.004 homeschooling, politics, education policy, religion, regulation “Abstract: Over the last few decades, the number of homeschools in the United States (US) has grown, and a large proportion is attributed to increases in religiously affiliated homeschools (Kunzman, 2009). However, empirical analyses of the relationship between religion and homeschooling are lacking. This analysis begins to fill that void using a culture wars framework, and indicates that states with higher percentages of evangelical residents are less likely to regulate homeschooling. Consistent with Deckman's (2004) claim, these findings demonstrate the culture wars are active in education policymaking.
Villanueva, Brian D. 1995 An investigation of the admissions standards of U.S. colleges and universities for home schooled students. home education, research, college admission requirements Completed as part of requirements for a master’s degree. Available from the author at 12411 Rosehill Ln., Houston TX Texas 77070. Finds all colleges and universities in study consider the home schooled for admission, the majority had home educated students enrolled, the most common and most vital deciding factor in admitting a home schooled student was acceptable SAT or ACT scores, and several directors of admissions were very interested in knowing how other colleges and universities were handling admission procedures for the home schooled.
Villanueva, Brian D. 1999 An investigation of the admissions standards of United States colleges and universities for home-schooled students. Home School Researcher, 13(2), 1-6.
Vine, William Edwyn 1963 Expository dictionary of New Testament words. London: Oliphants. Easy to use dictionary; giving some insight into New Testament words on children and education; in contract to Kittle, above, this book uses English words to key the articles and the articles are much briefer.
Vitz, Paul C. 1985 Religion and traditional values in public school textbooks: An empirical study. Washington, DC: National Institute of Education. (NIE Grant 84-0012.) (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 260 019). Also, retrieved 2/18/2011 from http://www.eric.ed.gov/PDFS/ED260019.pdf. http://www.eric.ed.gov/PDFS/ED260019.pdf public school, textbooks, curriculum, bias, religion, controversial issues “This section, from a larger report describing a project designed to systematically investigate how religious and traditional values are represented in today’s public school curricula, presents seven studies intended to examine how religion, religious values, and family and family values are presented in the typical textbooks used in the nation’s public school. ….. The general finding of the studies is that public school textbooks present a biased representation both of religion and of many traditional values” [p. 1]. Studies find that, in many ways, religion is ignored or treated as if it were unimportant in the lives of Americans.
Vitz, Paul C. 1986 Censorship: Evidence of bias in our children’s textbooks. Ann Arbor, MI: Servant Books. public school, textbooks, curriculum, bias, religion, controversial issues Based on Vitz’s 1985 study funded by the National Institute of Education.
Volante, Louis, & Jaafar, Sonia Ben 2008 Educational assessment in Canada. Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 15(2), 201-210. educational assessment, policy Only briefly mention homeschooling: “While the vast majority of students attend public schools within this system, a small minority of Canadian children are home-schooled by parents and/or tutors, or attend private schools run by independent operators. Nevertheless, both home-schooling and private schools must follow provincial/territorial guidelines” (p. 203).
Vos, Jo; Delacueva, Sarah; Jacobson, Dan; & Kirchner, David 2011, September Evaluation report: K-12 online learning. St. Paul, MN: Office of the Legislative Auditor, State of Minnesota. online learning, public school, home education, homeschooling, socialization, social skills Write, in section on “social skills”” “For most students, school is where many social skills are modeled and learned, and it is often the primary venue for socialization. Socialization is the process through which “people acquire the rules of behavior and systems of beliefs and attitudes that equip a person to function effectively as a member of a particular society.”20 Because online learning may diminish a student’s face-to-face contact with teachers and other students, some question its impact on socialization. Similarly, some people have suggested that online students might feel more socially isolated than traditional students. We found that: Although little research has addressed the effects of online schooling on student socialization, available research on both home schooling and online learning suggests no difference in social skills between students in traditional schools and those learning at home. While research is currently lacking on socialization in the online learning environment, literature regarding home schooling suggests that students can gain adequate social skills even if they are educated outside the traditional classroom environment. As in online learning, home schooling does not take place in a traditional classroom setting, and students learn largely in the absence of face-toface interaction with other students. Also like online learning, critics of home schooling have voiced concerns about student isolation and the lack of opportunities for socialization. Research suggests, however, that the socialization experienced by home-schooled children is “equal, and in some cases superior, to that of children who attend conventional schools.”21”
Wachob, David A. 2015 Cardiovascular health and physical activity levels in homeschooled children. Health Behavior and Policy Review, 5(7), 401-407. Retrieved December 2, 2020 from https://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/psp/hbpr/2015/00000002/00000005/art00008 https://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/psp/hbpr/2015/00000002/00000005/art00008 homeschooling, home education, cardiovascular health, physical activity, physical fitness “Objective : The objective of this study was to establish a baseline of variables that potentially influence homeschooled children's health status. Methods : Children ages 8-16 were tested to determine indicators of cardiovascular health including, aerobic capacity (VO2); body composition (body fat %); and weight status (BMI). Their activity levels were measured by wearing accelerometer devices for one week. Parents of the children also completed a survey identifying family routines and behaviors. Results : Significant relationships were found between cardiovascular health variables, activity levels, parental perceptions of family behaviors, and the sex of the children. Conclusions : The uniqueness of the homeschooling environment has a potentially positive influence on the physical activity levels and cardiovascular health of homeschooled children.”
Wachob, David A.; Alman, Robert E. 2015 Parental influence on the cardiovascular health and body composition of homeschool children. International Journal of Child and Adolescent Health, suppl. Special Issue: A Birthday Tribute to the Pediatrician, 8(3), 305-311. homeschooling, research, Family health, cardiovascular health, child health “Abstract. It has been well established that parents can influence their children’s physical activity levels and health status. These findings often report on public school children and their parents due to the easy access to this population. However, due to the structure of home education, collecting data on this group is often difficult and is underrepresented in the literature. Objective: The purpose of this study was to determine the relationship between the cardiovascular health and body composition within homeschooling families. Study group: Homeschooling children and their primary caregiver. Method: 30 children were tested to determine their cardiovascular health (VO2 Max) and body composition (BMI and body fat %). Those results were then compared to their parent-teacher’s (n=14) cardiovascular health (VO2 Max), and body composition (BMI and body fat %). Relationships were determined by comparing mean scores, and by running Pearson’s correlation tests when controlling for each family group. Results: General comparisons within each family group revealed moderate correlations between VO2 levels (r = .599, p < .01); BMI (r = .743, p < .01); and body fat (r =.616, p < .01). Furthermore, when comparing the parents’ health status to their children it was determined that moderate relationships were found between the two groups’ VO2 levels (r =.667, p < .01), BMI (r = .663, p < .01), and body fat (r = .451, p < .01). Conclusion: The parent-teacher’s health status is a notable variable when determining factors that influence homeschooling children’s cardiovascular health and body composition” (p. 305).
Waddell, Timothy B. 2010 Bringing it all back home: Establishing a coherent constitutional framework for the re-regulation of homeschooling. Vanderbilt Law Review, 63(2), 541-598. Retrieved April 1, 2020 from https://scholarship.law.vanderbilt.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1419&context=vlr https://scholarship.law.vanderbilt.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1419&context=vlr homeschooling, philosophy, law, legal, theoretical, statism Theoretical article arguing for more government regulation of homeschooling. “In addition to putting the health of homeschooled children themselves at risk, "the growing number of homeschooled children [also] puts herd immunity," the primary value of compulsory vaccination, "at risk."" (p. 557). “Even if homeschooled children are no more likely to be abused, because homeschooling avoids the mechanism that states most commonly rely upon to discover abuse, it may be used to avoid detection of abuse, placing homeschooled children peculiarly at risk and potentially giving abusive parents a perverse incentive to homeschool in the first place” (p. 558). “If, as the Supreme Court has stated, institutional education is the "primary vehicle for transmitting 'the values upon which our society rests' "162 and "has a fundamental role in maintaining the fabric of our society,"163 states that maintain no curricular requirements or oversight run the risk of being forced to confront a subset of the citizenry who were schooled without even an opportunity to overcome antisocial indoctrination” (p. 564) – that is, homeschool children are at-risk of being indoctrinated in antisocial values and ideas. Overall, argues that the state must control (regulate) homeschooling more to ensure that children learn their academic subjects and skills, are not abused by their parents, and meet the interests of the state.
Wade, Theodore E., Jr. 1989, June There's no place like home school. Bookstore Journal, 115-118.
Wade, Theodore E., Jr., and others 1991 The home school manual (4th ed.): For parents who teach their own children. Auburn, CA: Gazelle Publications. home education, methodology, philosophy, Christian "How to do it" book, Christian perspective. General. Practical "how to teach" information, some contributed by other home schooling authors; resource list and state by state legal section is quite complete.
Wade, Theodore E., Jr., and others 1995 The home school manual (6th ed.): Plans, pointers, reasons, and resources. Niles, MI: Gazelle Publications. home education, methodology, curriculum, philosophy, Christian See description above for 4th ed..
Wade, Theodore E., Jr., and others 1998 The home school manual (7th ed.): Plans, pointers, reasons, and resources. Berrien Springs, MI: Gazelle Publications (11580 Red Bud Trail, Berrien Springs MI 49103)
Wade, Theodore E., Jr., Moore, D. N., & Bumstead, R. A. 1980 School at home: How parents can teach their own children. Colfax, CA: Gazelle Publications.
Wagenaar, Theodore 19mis?? Dissertation or thesis at Miami University? home education, research Finds that from an early age homeschooled children are more likely to experience someone in the family doing the following activities with them three or more times a week: tell a story, teach letters, teach songs, do arts and crafts, play with toys and games indoors, play games and sports outdoors, take child on errands, and involve child in household chores.
Wagner, Michael 1999 Charter schools in Alberta: Change or continuity in progressive conservative education policy? Alberta Journal of Educational Research, 45(1),52-66. ERIC Document No. EJ584539. http://www.eric.ed.gov http://www.eric.ed.gov/ charter schools; educational change; educational history; educational policy; foreign countries; government school relationship; homeschooling, home schooling; politics of education; private schools; privatization; school choice, Canada Author gives notable attention to homeschooling at several places in paper. “By examining PC [Progressive Conservative] government [in Canada] policy toward alternative schools, private school funding, home schooling, and the School Act of 1988, it becomes clear that there has been a consistent direction in support of school choice” (p. 54). “The recent growth of home schooling has largely been accommodated by, and some would say encouraged by, the PC government. Home schooling was included in the 1988 School Act, the first time it was explicitly dealt with in legislation in Alberta. Interestingly, the School Act "stipulated that home education students must be supervised by a board, but did not specify which school board a parent must choose. Parents are free to choose any school board in the province of Alberta to monitor their program" (Clendening, 1996, p. 35). This gave rise to the phenomenon of the " w i l l i n g nonresident board" whereby home schoolers could shop around and register with the school board most willing to accommodate their needs. The boards would receive the per-pupil grant for each child of $2,100 to $2,500 (depending on the child's age). Some of the boards would return a portion of this money to the home schooling parents. The nonresident provision enabled small rural boards with little money to improve their financial situation by catering to home schoolers outside their jurisdiction” (p. 63). “The Progressive Conservative government has been upportive of choice in education right from the start. This is not to say that the PCs came to power with an agenda to promote private schools and other alternatives, but that whenever this issue has arisen in its various forms, the government has come out on the same side of the question. Whether it is alternative schools, private school funding, home schooling, or charter schools, the PC government has made educational choice available” (p. 65). “Abstract: The recent establishment of charter schools in Alberta (Canada) has prompted allegations of a radical change towards privatization by the Progressive Conservative (PC) government. However, policy decisions since the 1970s demonstrate that the PC government has consistently supported private alternatives to public education; charter schools extend the party's longstanding policy of educational choice. Contains 37 references” (retrieved 7/16/13 from http://www.eric.ed.gov).
Wake, Wake, Bev 2000, September 7 Home-schooling gets top marks. Ottawa Citizen. Published 9/7/00 online www.ottawa.com. http://www.ottawa.com Reports on homeschoolers learning online. A mother reports how CD-ROMs and online resources help her children learn better. All about how computers help homeschooling. Quotes Dallas Miller of the Home School Legal Defence Association of Canada as saying there are more than 80,000 homeschool students in Canada in the 2000-2001 school year and that, according to Statistics Canada, there has been a 10% increase in registered homeschoolers in western Canada from 1995-96 to 1996-97.
Walberg, Herbert J. 1981 A theory of educational productivity, In F. H. Farley & N. Gordon (Eds.), Psychology and education: The state of the union, p. 36-77. Berkeley, CA: McCutchan. research, cause and effect, family, environment, home, peers Presents a global model of educational productivity holding that cognitive, affective, and behavioral learning is a function of four essential factors—student's ability and motivation as well as quality and quantity of instruction—and possibly four supplementary factors—the social-psychological environment of the classroom, academically stimulating conditions in the home and peer group outside school, and exposure to mass media, especially television.
Walberg, Herbert J. 1984 Families as partners in educational productivity. Phi Delta Kappan, 14(1), 397-400.
Walberg, Herbert J. 2010 Advancing student achievement. Stanford, CA: Education Next Books, Hoover Institution Press. academic achievement, teacher certification, teacher licensure, student achievement, policy “Overall, it appears that certified teachers perform very little or no better than those who are uncertified [p. 61].” “As discussed in the introduction, the first of the international achievement surveys published in the early 1960s showed American schools lagging behind those of other countries. Since then, evidence has accumulated showing a lack of substantial progress despite the world’s highest or near highest per-student spending. Even with substantial and steady increases in funding and many reforms, schools have made little progress. ….. It is no longer a mystery how to advance achievement. The practices described in the preceding chapters include: ….. [p. 97 ends] The problem is that the responsible parties – legislators, state and local school boards, and public school educators – failed to institute such reasonable policies and practices [p. 98].”
Walberg, Herbert J., & Paik, Susan J. 2000 Effective educational practices. Brussels, Belgium: International Academy of Education http://www.ibe.unesco.org/publications/EducationalPracticesSeriesPdf/prac03e.pdf academic achievement, educational policy, research, elementary education, secondary education, learning, performance factors, student characteristics, synthesis, public schools and International Bureau of Education in Geneva, Switzerland), 24 pp. Retrieved 7/2/2007 from http://www.ibe.unesco.org/publications/EducationalPracticesSeriesPdf/prac03e.pdf. (“The practices described in this booklet can generally be applied to classroom subjects in primary and secondary schools. They show large, positive learning effects for students in widely varying conditions” [p. 6].) Provide several references as concludes the following introducing 10 practices: “As mentioned above, the practices in this booklet are generally powerful and consistent in promoting important aspects of academic learning. Some other practices are nearly as good. For further reading on many effective practices, the following works may be consulted: Husén & Postlethwaite, 1994; Lipsey & Wilson, 1993; Walberg, 1984; Walberg & Haertel, 1997; Wang, Haertel & Walberg, 1993b; and Waxman & Walberg, 1999” [p. 6]. The 10 practices are the following: “1. Parent involvement. Learning is enhanced when schools encourage parents to stimulate their children’s intellectual development. [p.7] ….. 2. Graded homework. Students learn more when they complete homework that is graded, commented upon and discussed by their teachers. [p. 9] ….. 3. Aligned time on task. Students who are actively focused on educational goals do best in mastering the subject matter. [p. 11] ….. 4. Direct teaching. Direct teaching is most effective when it exhibits key features and follows systematic steps. [p. 12] ….. 5. Advance organizers. Showing students the relationships between past learning and present learning increases its depth and breadth. [p. 13] ….. 6. The teaching of learning strategies. Giving students some choice in their learning goals and teaching them to be attentive to their progress yield learning gains. [p. 14] ….. 7. Tutoring. Teaching one student or a small number with the same abilities and instructional needs can be remarkably effective. [p. 16] ….. 8. Mastery learning. For subject-matter to be learned step by step, thorough mastery of each step is often optimal. [p. 17] ….. 9. Co-operative learning. Students in small, self-instructing groups can support and increase each other’s learning. [p. 18] ….. 10. Adaptive education. A variety of instructional techniques adapting lessons to individual students and small groups raises achievement. …..” [p. 20].
Walberg, J. 1984 Improving the productivity of America’s schools. Educational Leadership, 41(8), 19-27.
Wallace, Eric 1999 Uniting church and home: A blueprint for rebuilding church community. Lorton, VA: Solutions For Integrating Church and Home.
Wallace, Nancy 1983 Better than school. Burdett, NY: Larson Publications.
Wallace, Nancy 1985 Homeschooling's unique structure. Mothering, Summer, 77-81. Anecdotal, human interest.
Walsh, Mark 1991, February 13 Home-schooled pupils fare well on test, survey of parents finds. Education Week, 10(21), 9. academic achievement, home education, demographics Report on the National Home Education Research Institute's nationwide study of the Home School Legal Defense Association's membership.
Walsh, Mark 1998, November 25 Court sends girl to public school against parents’ wishes. Education Week, 18(13), 6. home schooling, parental rights, child rights, public school, law, legal “A legal battle in Virginia is pitting a teenager’s wish to attend public high school against her parents' desire that she be educated at home. In what home schooling advocates call an unprecedented intrusion on parental rights, a juvenile-court judge ruled that it was in the best interest of 16-year-old Jennifer Sengpiehl of Round Hill, Va., to allow her to attend her local public high school this fall.” “‘The reason Jennifer behaved badly was because of a dispute with her parents about where she was going to go to school,’ said Michael Farris, the president of the Home School Legal Defense Association. ‘What the juvenile-court judge did was basically reward her bad behavior by giving her exactly what she wanted,’ added Mr. Farris, whose Purcellville, Va.-based organization is representing the parents.” Farris said the decision was unprecedented. “‘But in that circumstance, the family unit is broken,’ he said. ‘But when there is no finding that anyone has done anything wrong, that's different. Juvenile judges are not authorized to substitute their wisdom for the wisdom of parents.’” Decision was being appealed.
Walston, Jill, & West, Jerry 2004, June Full-day and half-day kindergarten in the United States: Findings from the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study, kindergarten class of 1998–99. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics, U.S. Department of Education. http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2004078 kindergarten, public school, private school, academic achievement Available in paper copy and 8/2/04 online http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2004078 Offers many descriptive statistics about full- and part-time kindergarten in both public and private schools and compares academic achievement between part-time and full-time students. Does not compare the academic achievement, either short-term or long-term, of those who are versus those not in kindergarten. “The differences in achievement gains associated with program type are not only apparent when simple comparisons of gains are made (figures F and G), they persist when the comparisons take into account other important child and class characteristics. Findings from a multi-level regression analysis indicate that children in full-day classes make greater gains in both reading and mathematics compared to those in half-day classes after adjusting for gain score differences associated with race/ethnicity, poverty status, fall achievement level, sex, class size, amount of time for subject area instruction, and the presence of an instructional aide. The positive effect associated with full-day programs after accounting for these other variables represents a difference in the reading gain scores of about 32 percent of a standard deviation. Findings from this analyses indicate that children in very large classes (25+) make gains in reading that are slightly smaller than those made by children in medium size classes (18–24). Furthermore, there is not a differential effect associated with class size by program type—a smaller class size does not mitigate the difference in gains found between children in half-day and full-day programs. Additionally, the presence of a classroom aide is not associated with differences in reading gain scores among White children in either half-day or full-day programs; however, Black children in full-day classes with an aide make greater reading gains compared to Black children in fullday classes without an aide. After accounting for the same class and child characteristics as for reading, children in full-day programs make gains in mathematics that represent about 22 percent of a standard deviation more than the gains made by children in half-day programs” (p. xxi).
Walters, Letitia A. 2015 Relationships of parental homeschooling approaches including technology integration. Doctoral dissertation (Ph.D.), The University of Southern Mississippi. homeschooling, research, technology, demograhics “Abstract: This study examined the factors influencing parental selection of homeschooling approaches for their children and the utilization of technology integrated. Factors explored were parental motivators for selecting homeschooling approaches, parental reasons for choosing to homeschool, technology device usage, and instructional technology integration. The population consisted of parents with at least one year or more of experience in teaching homeschooling and the primary educator being involved in answering the survey. Participants in this study responded to items from a researcheradapted questionnaire. The majority of the participants were from Louisiana, Mississippi, and Kentucky. A Bachelor's degree was reported as the highest education attainment. The highest average household income indicated was $70,000-$100,000 and Christianity, including Protestant and Catholic, was the preferred religion reported. Classical education was the highest in the child's performance of the suggested homeschooling approaches. Cooperative schooling, computer-based schooling, and traditional school at home were identified in this order as the next most performed homeschooling approaches. The main three chosen parental reasons for homeschooling are religion and moral instruction, values, and school environment concern. The researcher identified the laptop, desktop, and smartphone as the most used technology devices with the iPod being used the least. Lastly, conducting research, learning or practicing drill skills, and performing calculations were the most frequently used technology activities. Partial statistical, significant correlations were found between parents’ select homeschooling approaches and parents’ reason for homeschooling, usage of technology devices, and instructional technology activities. Implications are described for homeschooling parents and higher education personnel. Future research concepts, including particular attention to age groups, homeschooling groups, and technology are recommended” (p. ii-iii).
Walton, S. Ernie 2021 The Fundamental Right to Homeschool: A Historical Response to Professor Bartholet. Texas Review of Law and Politics, 25, 377-436, https://www.trolp.org/blog/2021/9/16/the-fundamental-right-to-homeschool-a-historical-response-to-professor-bartholet [also at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3639394] https://www.trolp.org/blog/2021/9/16/the-fundamental-right-to-homeschool-a-historical-response-to-professor-bartholet https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3639394 Homeschool, Homeschooling, Home Education, Fundamental Rights, Constitutional Law, Fourteenth Amendment, Founders “Abstract: The fundamental right of parents to homeschool their children is under attack. Harvard Law Professor Elizabeth Bartholet recently published an article that proposes to ban homeschooling with a few carefully delineated exceptions. She argues that the ban is necessary to protect children from abusive parents, fulfill children’s right to an education, and guarantee children the autonomy right to determine their own futures, among other things. Professor Bartholet’s arguments directly contradict Supreme Court precedent, and more critically, the historical record. While the Supreme Court has never made it clear that homeschooling is a fundamental right, the historical record does. A deeply rooted, unbroken tradition—beginning in England and continuing in the colonies through the founding generation—recognizes not only the fundamental right but also the duty of parents to educate their children. Home education was the dominant form of education in England and the colonies; the educational right was the exclusive right of parents. Blackstone called the educational duty of parents the “greatest importance of any,” and under the common law, third parties could never exercise the educational power over children until the parents voluntarily delegated it to them. Even then, they acted in loco parentis. The colonies also recognized the fundamental right of parents to educate their children, and some even began enforcing this parental duty by law. Home education continued as the predominant form of education through the founding, and the Founders and early jurists including James Wilson, Joseph Story, St. George Tucker, and James Kent affirmatively recognized the fundamental right of parents to educate their [p. 377 ends] children. And while many of the states and Founders supported some form of public education, they never advocated for or implemented compulsory attendance laws. In fact, Thomas Jefferson expressly rejected the State’s power to force children to attend public school against the wishes of the father, noting that such action would “shock the common feelings and ideas.” Instead, the Founders conceived of state public education as complementary to the primary right of parents, intended to create an educated citizenry that could protect its own liberty and serve poor parents by providing a free option to those who could not educate their children at home nor afford to hire private tutors. Accordingly, “history and tradition” confirm that the right of parents to homeschool their children is a fundamental right that should be subject to strict scrutiny review” (p. 377-378).
Wang, Linda 2007, April 16 Science of homeschooling. Chemical and Engineering News, 85(16), 49-51. home education, chemistry teaching and learning Addresses the issue of homeschooling and chemistry education. Points out that there is a growing demand for a broader spectrum of chemistry curricula.
Wang, Margaret C, Haertel, Geneva D. & Walberg, Herbert J. 1997 What helps students learn: Spotlight student success. ERIC Reproduction Service Number ED461694. research, academic achievement, performance, variables, correlates Synthesis of research on what aspects of which variables influence learning and performance.
Ward, Lauren 2004 A different kind of home room. “Northwest Voice” [of Bakersfield, CA]. Retrieved 6/5/13 from http://www.bakersfieldvoice.com/node/7655. Retrieved 8/10/2004 from http://www.northwestvoice.com/page.asp?item=46415. [begin quote] http://www.bakersfieldvoice.com/node/7655 http://www.northwestvoice.com/page.asp?item=46415 home education, negative critic, negative criticism, philosophy, opinion “Dr. Louis Wildman, professor of educational administration at Cal State Bakersfield, agrees. "It is my personal belief that a decision to home-school a child is a mistake. Too often it is a cover for child abuse and violations of child labor laws. While the decision to home-school a child may be part of a well-intentioned effort to shield that child from the sins of the world, a good home upbringing is the best protection a child can have against that," said Wildman, who suggests that parents consider Saturday school, Sunday school and special lessons if they wish to supplement their child’s education.”
Waring, Diana 2002 Reaping the harvest: The bounty of abundant-life homeschooling. Spearfish, SD: Diana Waring-History Alive!
Warner, Lucy 1981, May 4 Home study doubles in popularity in the United States. Times Education Supplement, 10.
Warren, W. J. 1988, August 10 For many children, home is school. The New York Times, p. B7.
Wartes, Jon 1984 Survey of home schooling families relative to proposed changes in legislation in Washington State. Teaching Parents Association, 16109 N. E. 169 Pl., Woodinville, WA 98072, 66 p.
Wartes, Jon 1985 One educator's observations about homeschooling. 16109 N. E. 169 Pl., Woodinville, WA 98072: Author. Author has been a public school teacher and counselor for 21 years; presently head counselor at a large suburban area high school; and a home schooling parent. Clearly discusses stereotypes about home schooling. Summary statements included: "Although first impressions are frequently negative, homeschooling almost always produces a favorable response among those who are willing to take a closer look." "By any reasonable academic standard, homeschooling does work!" "Concerns about socialization are, for the most part, based upon misconceptions." "Homeschooling is a manifestation of the larger issue of parental involvement. Cooperation is in the best interest of public education and of children." (p. 1)
Wartes, Jon 1987 Washington Homeschool Research Project report from the 1986 homeschool testing & other descriptive information about Washington's homeschoolers. Available from the author at 16109 N. E. 169 Pl., Woodinville, WA, 98072. 535 Washington home schoolers are represented in the "... report through the contribution of test scores, a questionnaire, or both" (p. 3). Findings included: (1) "As a group, these 426 homeschoolers scored as well or better than their peers across the nation on virtually all of the 6 tests scales measured by the Stanford Achievement Test series that were utilized in this research" (p. 3). (2) "The major reasons [for home schooling] relate to religion or philosophy, a desire to avoid peer pressure, a preference for a greater parent/child relationship, and the facilitation of student self-confidence" (p. 3). (3) "This evidence suggests that homeschoolers are not being socially isolated" (p. 3). Other findings relate to general descriptive data, how home schooling relates to private schooling, and what type of relationship their might be between home and public education. Much data provided, data properly presented, and careful attention to sampling error given.
Wartes, Jon 1987, March Report from the 1986 home school testing and other descriptive information about Washington's home schoolers: a summary. Home School Researcher, 3(1), 1-4. home education, academic achievement, research, social activities Home educated score as well or better than conventional school students on the Stanford Achievement Test. Children are not being socially isolated.
Wartes, Jon 1988 Correspondence Regarding Homeschooler Outcomes from Oregon, Tennessee, and Arkansas. WA: Washington Homeschool Research Project.
Wartes, Jon 1988 Homeschooler Outcomes. Woodinville, WA: Washington Homeschool Research Project.
Wartes, Jon 1988 The relationship of selected input variables to academic achievement among Washington's homeschoolers. home education, research, academic achievement, policy, teacher certification, parent education level, structure Available from the Washington Homeschool Research Project at 16109 N. E. 169 Pl., Woodinville, WA, 98072). (Analyzes data related to topics of particular interest to policy makers. Finds no relationship between the standardized achievement test scores of the home educated and the variables of level of structure and number of hours of schooling, number of years home educated, grade level, family income, and degree of religious content of the home education program. Detects a weak relationship between student scores and parent educational attainment. Children who had no contact with a certified teacher scored, on average, at the 70th percentile on tests.
Wartes, Jon 1988 The Washington home school project: Quantitative measures for informing policy decisions. Education and Urban Society, 21(1), 42-51. The study was of Washington State homeschool students and their families. Presented findings on the families demographics and the parents’ reasons for choosing homeschooling. In 1986, there were n=424 homeschool students in the study and in 1987, n=873. Stanford Achievement Tests were used. Median test scores in all subject areas (i.e., reading, language, math, science, and social studies) were 68th (0.47 z-score) and 65th-66th (0.39 z-score) percentiles in 1987 and 1988, respectively. Cross-sectional, descriptive study.
Wartes, Jon 1988 Washington Homeschool Research Project report from the 1987 Washington homeschool testing. Available from the author at 16109 N. E. 169 Pl., Woodinville, WA, 98072. Woodinville, WA
Wartes, Jon 1988, June Summary of two reports from the Washington Home School Research Project, 1987. Home School Researcher, 4(2), 1-4. Also retrieved January 1, 2009 from http://www.nheri.org/Volume-04-Issue-2/SUMMARY-OF-TWO-REPORTS-FROM-THE-WASHINGTON-HOMESCHOOL-RESEARCH-PROJECT-1987.html. http://www.nheri.org/Volume-04-Issue-2/SUMMARY-OF-TWO-REPORTS-FROM-THE-WASHINGTON-HOMESCHOOL-RESEARCH-PROJECT-1987.html
Wartes, Jon 1989 Report from the 1988 Washington Homeschool Testing. Available from the Washington Homeschool Research Project at 16109 N. E. 169 Pl., Woodinville, WA, 98072).
Wartes, Jon 1989 Report to the Washington State Senate Education Committee. Woodinville, WA: Washington Homeschool Research Project.
Wartes, Jon 1990 Recent results from the Washington Homeschool Research Project. Home School Researcher, 6(4), 1-7, https://nheri.org/home-school-researcher-recent-results-from-the-washington-homeschool-research-project/ https://nheri.org/home-school-researcher-recent-results-from-the-washington-homeschool-research-project/ homeschooling, home schooling, home education, academic achievement Cross-sectional, descriptive study of grades K-12 homeschool students and their standardized achievement test scores in reading, language, math, and listening. Their median scores were at the 65th to 68th percentile (z-score of 0.41) on the tests. Peer-reviewed.
Wartes, Jon 1990, September Report from the 1986 through 1989 Washington homeschool testing. Available from the Washington Homeschool Research Project at 16109 N. E. 169 Pl., Woodinville, WA, 98072).
Wartes, Jon 1990, September The relationship of selected input variables to academic achievement among Washington's homeschoolers. home education, academic achievement, research Available from the Washington Homeschool Research Project at 16109 NE 169 Place, Woodinville WA 98072). (“The children of parents who earn more money tend to do better than those where the parents earn less” [in public schools] [p. 50]. Finds that parent education level [p. 79], previous success in a conventional school, and previous attendance at a private school were slightly positively related to the academic achievement of the home schooled. Level of structure in the schooling, hours of schooling, grade level, family income, gender of student, religious content in the home schooling, and intent to discontinue home schooling apparently have no [or a very weak] relationship to academic achievement. A few other relationships were explored. About 97% of students from Christian families, p. 64. In two of 35 statistical tests, number of years home educated was positively correlated with achievement; no significance in other tests p[p. 48, Figure 5.2].
Wartes, Jon 1991, December Five years of homeschool testing within Washington State. home education, research, academic achievement Available from the Washington Homeschool Research Project at 16109 N. E. 169 Pl., Woodinville, WA, 98072). (Data are from state-mandated testing of homeschool students. "These students scored at or above the 50%ile in 533 out of 600 test cells defined by the Stanford Achievement Test series over this five year sampling. The median cell each year varied from the 64%ile to the 68%ile on national norms. It would appear that, as a group, these homeschoolers are doing well" [p. 5].
Wartes, Jon 1991, January/February A pragmatic approach to looking at the value of research in homeschooling. Home Education Magazine, 8(1), 20-21. home education, opinion "It is my contention that homeschooling research helps society. It happens to be true, because the results have so far been positive, that it also helps homeschoolers by creating a more accepting climate among policy makers, educators, relatives, and neighbors. ... It [research on home education] is causing thoughtful and caring people to rethink the conventional wisdom. ..... The effect is good for society. It is good for children" (p. 21).
Wartes, Jon 1992, February Effects of homeschooling upon the education of the parents: Comments from the field. parents, effects on parents/adults, learning, adult learning, effects, family, home education Available from the Washington Homeschool Research Project at 16109 NE 169 Place, Woodinville WA 98072). (Studies 883 comments from 123 homeschool parents. “A collection of comments from parents describing what they feel they have learned as a result of their homeschooling experience” [cover page]. “[Six] major themes contained in parent comments were identified by the writer: 1. Personal improvement, ... 2. Family, ... 3. Community, ... 4. Pedagogy, ... 5. Academic content areas, ... 6. Religion, ...” [p. 11]. “I have learned that education is not found, necessarily, by completing a series of books. Instead, education is found by being interested in the world around us, by being fascinated by people, places, and things. I began homeschooling because I wanted my kids to regard learning as a lifelong fun project. By being home, and with me when I am in town, or on a ‘field trip,’ they have taught me to enjoy people, to be curious about places and things. If they maintain this curiosity and pursuit of how, why, who, what, they will learn all their lives. Although this was my goal, I wasn’t sure it was obtainable. Now I am sure. It is obtainable” (p. 17). “Our children enjoy being with their parents and are not ‘ashamed’ to be together as a family” (p. 25). “Our teen age daughter wants us to be her role models and closest friends, not her peers. Our relationship with her has been strengthened in a way I never thought possible” (p. 25). “I think the main benefit too is the cohesiveness of our family unit. My son said yesterday, ‘Mom, I appreciate all that you do for me ... and I love you.’ The children know you are really ‘for them’ and that you are sacrificing for them” (p. 25). “Math: I am learning all over again things I had forgotten” (p. 54). “I feel that my weak area, grammar, has been and is being greatly strengthened. ..... I have been re-learning along with him [my son]” (p. 50). “I’ve learned about our government and the constitution -- some positive things and some negative” (p. 46). “Ah -- history. How I hated that subject in school. It consisted of memorizing dates and facts and didn’t seem to have any relation to anything. I just couldn’t tie it all together! So now I am relearning this subject and I find it fascinating! We have made a time line. I can finally see where everything goes and how it relates. We read interesting books -- biographies and a good general text as well” (p. 46). “The other area is history. I never had any interest in what happened before. Now I feel like it is all so fascinating as I see the puzzle pieces fit together. In school, history was taught by reading a chapter in a book, then answering questions at the end and taking a test. Now we read interesting books and talk about it -- it has come alive and is exciting” (p. 46). “The rich Christian heritage of America and a lot of historical truth that was ignored in my high school and college history classes” (p. 62). “When reviewing science, I am relearning and learning new information of the last 20+ years” (p. 57). “Science -- how snow, rain, sleet and hail are formed. I must have learned it at sometime in school but now I won’t forget it” (p. 57). “I’ve learned we are qualified to teach and guide our own children. That no one cares for your child and his future more than you” (p. 35). “I have learned that we do not need to turn our kids over to the ‘experts’ because we, as parents, are the experts. God intended for parents to participate in every aspect of their children’s growing up experience” (p. 35). “I’ve become more interested and a little involved in politics because of our concern for children and family” (p. 34) “How politics works -- how it affects the family” (p. 34). “Social/political struggle of parents vs government in the homeschool arena is not a question of educational credentials, method or doctrine but power and who will control the future” (p. 34).).
Washburne, Thomas W. 2002, April 22 The boundaries of parental authority: A response to Rob Reich of Stanford University. Purcellville VA: Home School Legal Defense Association/National Center for Home Education. Retrieved 4/22/08 from http://www.hslda.org/docs/nche/000010/200204230.asp. http://www.hslda.org/docs/nche/000010/200204230.asp home education, law, legal, philosophy, politics Responds to Rob Reich paper, dated, August 30-September 2, 2001. “The real root of the problem home education presents to Reich is that home educators have removed themselves from America's educational system and its underlying values. Their children are beyond the reach of the elite and the predominate worldview of relativism or secular humanism. As home schooling continues to grow and prosper, this will become increasingly troublesome to the educational establishment. But more than being beyond the intellectual elite, the children of home educators are largely beyond the reach of the state. It will take novel legal theories to break this constitutional protection. And it is here that Reich's theories are most concerning, indeed dangerous. [new paragraph] What Reich is doing, intentional or not, is setting an academic framework by which an activist judge might rule in favor of heavy restrictions on home education, while at the same time avoiding the obvious assault on precedent and the Constitution. By extending what are in essence adult rights of choice to children, and declaring children to have an interest in education separate from the state's and separate from their parent's, Reich provides the opportunity to take away freedoms which Americans, indeed humans in general, have deemed fundamental for thousands of years.”
Washburne, Thomas W., 2002 Serving homeschoolers at the state level: Current perceptions. A paper presented at the National Christian Home Educators Leadership Conference, October 2002, Rapid City, South Dakota. Paper available from Home School Legal Defense Association, Purcellville, VA.
Washington State Superintendent of Public Instruction 1985 Washington State's experimental programs using the parent as tutor under the supervision of a Washington State certificated teacher 1984-1985. Olympia, WA: Author, 44+ p. homeschooling, state schools, academic achievement Descriptive and empirical. Report that home taught children scored, in general, equal or better than their public school peers on all the standardized achievement tests used. Included scores of students in a state where testing of homeschool students was required. The average percentiles for all grade levels, K-8, combined, were about 62 (0.30 SD above average) in reading, 56 (0.15 SD above average) in language, and 53 (0.08 SD above average) in math.
Washington State Superintendent of Public Instruction 1999, March 1998-99 home-based instruction annual report. Olympia, WA: Author. Reports that there were 19,353 compulsory-age home school students, from 11,393 families, registered with the state during the 1998-1999 school year.
Waters, Tim; Marzano, Robert J.; & McNulty, Brian 2003 or 2004, probably McREL’s balanced leadership framework: Developing the science of educational leadership. Retrieved 7/10/13 from http://www.mdecgateway.org/olms/data/resource/4878/0404mcrel.pdf. http://www.mdecgateway.org/olms/data/resource/4878/0404mcrel.pdf leadership, effective schools, research Mentions homeschooling but in no way focuses on homeschooling. “This article will appear in the upcoming Winter 2004 issue of ERS Spectrum, a journal of research and information for K-12 public educators.”
Watson, Angela 2024 Homeschool participation: Post-pandemic persistence and growth trends, Journal of School Choice, 18(4), 444-460, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2024.2422742 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2024.2422742 Homeschool; home education; participation data; pandemic Abstract: United States homeschooling participation increased dramatically during the disruptions of the COVID-19 pandemic. Education scholars theorized that homeschool participation would recede along with pandemic disruptions. This study examines whether that theory proved true. I use longitudinal annual state-reported homeschool participation counts supplemented with other data in states and years where state data is not publicly available. I find a small and brief decline in homeschool participation one- and two-years post-pandemic. However, the majority of states for which data are available report increased homeschool participation three years after the pandemic height. Within this growth, I will discuss three interesting trends.
Watson, Angela R. 2018 Is homeschool cool? Current trends in American homeschooling. Journal of School Choice: International Research and Reform, 12(3), 401-425, https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2018.1490378 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2018.1490378 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/15582159.2018.1490378 home education, homeschool, homeschool population size, NCES, school choice “ABSTRACT: Homeschooling in America enjoyed significant and dependable growth for decades. However, federal estimates of homeschool participation failed to show statistically significant growth for the first time in 2012. Many dismissed this as measurement error and awaited the next round of federal estimates. In the fall of 2017 those estimates were released, and homeschooling once again not only failed to grow; rather it declined, significantly. This was an historic and important first for the pioneer of American school choice. What caused homeschooling to cool? Or is it just as hot as ever? This article uses data from 22 state departments of education to examine official reports of homeschool participation instead of using more readily available and commonly referenced survey estimates, and these numbers tell a very different story. Based on the available data, homeschooling actually appears to continue its growth. KEYWORDS: home education, homeschool, NCES, school choice” (retrieved August 13, 2018 from https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/15582159.2018.1490378 ).
Watters, Georgia George 2105 Phenomenological Study of Military Parents Homeschooling Using Online Resources. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Walden University, Ann Arbor, Michigan. homeschooling, military, curriculum, socialization, qualitative research methods Abstract (summary). U.S. military members and their families relocate from one duty station to another on average once every 3 years. Children in military families change schools often, introducing potential problems such as struggling to make new friends, having trouble adjusting to new teaching styles, and losing academic credits due to the transition from one school to the next. Homeschooling that incorporates online resources can provide instructional continuity, social interaction opportunities, and submission of required periodic assessments. The primary purpose of this phenomenological study was to examine the experiences of military parents involved in homeschooling their children using online resources. The research questions were designed to explore these experiences and to create recommendations for other military families. A conceptual framework based on a constructivist learning approach and change theory informed this study. Data were collected from 9 parents with many years of experience homeschooling. The parents were interviewed via phone, e-mail, and Skype. Data were analyzed using open coding, axial coding, and hierarchical coding. Parent participants chose homeschooling due to dissatisfaction with available schools, family location, and flexibility. Online resources were described as making it easier and more engaging for students to learn and as simplifying the parents' instructional and management tasks. These alternative methods replaced or augmented traditional educational methods. Parent participants encouraged other parents to reach out and seek help early in the process. This study promotes positive social change by providing resources for alternative ways children can be educated while one or more military parent is serving and defending the United States of America.
Wayne, Israel 2000 Homeschooling from a biblical worldview. Covert, MI: Wisdom’s Gate. homeschooling, home education, religion, Christianity, philosophy Makes a biblical scriptural argument for homeschooling.
Wayne, Israel 2017 Education: Does God have an opinion? Green Forest, AR: Master Books.
Wayne, Israel 2018 Answers for Homeschooling: Top 25 questions critics ask. Green Forest, AR: Master Books.
Wayne, Janet 1993, May/June Early intervention or home schooling for your special needs preschooler? National Center for Home Education Special Report. Available from NCHE, P.O. Box 125, Paeonian Springs VA 22129. special needs, home education, learning disabled, handicapped Summarizes early intervention programs, suggests that home education is possibly a very good choice for special needs children.
Wayson, W. W., Mitchell, B., Pinnell, G. S., & Landis, D. 1988 Up from excellence: The impact of the excellence movement on schools. Bloomington, IN: Phi Delta Kappa Educational Foundation.
Wearne, Eric 2016 A descriptive survey of why parents choose hybrid homeschools, Journal of School Choice, 10(3), 364–380, https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2016.1202075 https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2016.1202075 education policy, homeschool online learning, school choice, surveys, hybrid homeschool Abstract: “Hybrid home schools” are schools in which students attend school with other students for 2 or 3 days per week in traditional classroom settings, and are homeschooled the balance of the week. This exploratory study presents self-reported reasons parents choose these schools, using an electronic survey of parents from four such schools (n = 136; 19% return rate). Findings indicate that families in these schools are relatively wealthier and more suburban than parents using tax credit programs, that they value school structures more than particular student achievement outcomes, and that they seek information on accreditation, curriculum, and the religious nature of schools in making their choices.”
Wearne, Eric 2019 A survey of families in a charter hybrid homeschool. Peabody Journal of Education, 94:3, 297-311, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617581 . https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2019.1617581 homeschooling, home schooling, charter schools, hybrid schools, school choice, peer-reviewed “Abstract. “Hybrid homeschools” generally operate as formal schools 2–3 days per week. The rest of the week students are homeschooled. These entities therefore share some aspects of conventional schooling along with some aspects of homeschooling and are classified in a variety of ways by their states, local districts, and even their own administrations. Most hybrid homeschools around the nation tend to be private and religiously affiliated, though some public models have emerged. The purpose of this study was to better understand parents’ stated preferences for choosing to enroll their children in a charter school that is organized as a hybrid homeschool network in southern California. An electronic survey was sent through the network’s CEO to all enrolled families asking questions regarding demographics, stated values, and desired sources of information. The results of this survey find that these hybrid homeschool families are on average slightly more ethnically diverse, less wealthy, and less educated compared to private, religious hybrid homeschoolers, but are also more ethnically diverse, more wealthy, and more educated compared to their sponsoring school district. These families tend to place more value on individualized attention and the learning environment than on religion, safety, or formal academic issues when choosing a hybrid homeschool compared to their private, religious counterparts.” Author’s definition of “hybrid homeschools”: “Introduction “Hybrid homeschools,” as institutions, tend to operate as physical schools 2–3 days per week. As schools, they enroll students, hire faculty, teach classes in group settings, and follow a specified curriculum (either published or created independently). The rest of the week, students work through their curriculum at home, with their families, and their experiences on these days look like those of students who are homeschooled. A “hybrid homeschooler,” then, is usually described as a student whose schooling experience looks partially like that of a student at a brick-and-mortar school, and partially like that of a homeschool student. Some hybrid homeschool families consider themselves homeschoolers who simply go to a campus a few times a week. Others consider themselves private school students who are simply working from home a few days per week. Still others consider themselves to be in a different category from either group. The structure and level of rigidity varies by school. Some schools require students to follow detailed lesson plans written by their teachers, whereas others are much more flexible and rely on parents for curriculum and teaching on home days. Most hybrid homeschools around the nation tend to be private and religiously affiliated” (p. 297).
Wearne, Eric 2021 Defining hybrid homeschools in America: Little platoons. Lexington Books. homeschooling, hybrid schools, hybrid homeschooling Homeschooling is its own thing, parent-directed home-based education. Hybrid homeschooling is a misleading term because it basically refers to alternative schooling that is education for children directed and controlled by an entity or group that is not the child’s parents; hybrid homeschooling is not homeschooling but a form of institutional schooling with more-than-average parental involvement. Not, whatever is in your head: Wearne (2021), “Another school founder who sees herself as a homeschooler talked about the complications of schools’ self-descriptions [regarding whether they are school or homeschooling]. ….. [quote of the founder begins] “So maybe it’s a blend of both whatever you think, and what is communicated through the culture” (p. 49).
Wearne, Eric 2021 Hybrid homeschools: Organization, regulatory environments and reactions to COVID-19. Journal of Pedagogy, 12(1), 99-118. https://doi.org/10.2478/jped-2021-0005 https://doi.org/10.2478/jped-2021-0005 homeschooling, school choice, education policy, COVID-19 “Abstract. This study reports the results of a survey conducted with a set of “hybrid homeschool” leaders (principals or directors) from around the United States who were asked to describe 1. how their families categorize themselves (as homeschoolers, or as members of private schools), 2. the ways in which their schools operate in terms of scheduling, hiring, etc., 3. how their schools are regulated in the various states, and how they work within those regulatory frameworks, and 4. how they were affected by COVID-19, both in the spring of 2020 and the fall of 2020. Respondents provided a variety of names to describe their schools and a split in how families see themselves. In terms of staffing, schedules, tuition, and similar issues, the schools provide several arrangements, within some consistent constraints. Respondents noted a variety of regulatory situations in their respective states, but none felt over-burdened. Neither did any respondents point out particular problems that required regulatory relief. Regarding COVID-19, most schools reported feeling much less disruption compared to nearby conventional (5-day per week) schools.”
Weaver, Roy A., Negri, A., & Wallace, B. 1980 Home tutorials vs. the public schools in Los Angeles. Phi Delta Kappan, 62(4), 251-255. It is a school sponsored program. "We found academics and socialization successful in small groups where people knew one another very well. ..... the infrequent cross-age groupings appeared to have some advantages. ..... Finally, achievement results for children in the Home Tutorial Program were encouraging, if not startling" (p. 255).
Webb, Christine 1998, September/October Homeschooling or public schooling? It’s more than a matter of semantics. Home Education Magazine, 15(5), 30-31. home education, public school support, cooptation, cooperation, philosophy, politics Discusses tax-funded, state-controlled, public school programs designed for home schoolers or education at home and philosophical and other concerns about the increasing number of these programs around the country. Explains why tax-funded programs aimed at providing education at home are not, in reality, “homeschooling” and why such programs will harm private homeschooling endeavors and should be properly labelled “alternative public school programs” [p. 31] in order to clarify “... the important distinction between ‘homeschooling’ and ‘publicly funded alternative programs’” and all of the different traits of the two.
Webb, Julie 1990 Children learning at home. England: Falmer Press (also Bristol, PA, U.S.A.: Taylor and Francis).
Webb, Julie 1990 Children learning at home: Findings from case studies. Education Now, No. 8, 10-11.
Webb, Julie 1999 Those unschooled minds: Home-educated children grow up. Bramcote Hills, Nottingham, United Kingdom: Educational Heretics Press. home education, research, qualitative, adults, older persons, reasons, success Bases her writing on interviews with 20 home educated people who are now in their 20s or 30s; she first spoke to about a quarter of them in the 1980s when they were teenagers. They come from families with different reasons for home schooling but “The common factor in their approach is the intention of replacing the ‘one size fits all’ philosophy with learning that emerges from the abilities and interests of the individual, deepening and expanding as the child matures. This learning is partly planned and partly serendipitous, and it can take place anywhere” (by Webb, the author, in a flyer describing the book.
Webster, Rebecca 2013 The Relationship Between Homeschooling and Child Abuse. Symposium of University Research and Creative Expression [Central Washington University] (SOURCE). 137. Retrieved April 1, 2020 form https://digitalcommons.cwu.edu/source/2013/oralpresentations/137 https://digitalcommons.cwu.edu/source/2013/oralpresentations/137 homeschooling, child abuse, risk, interviews “Abstract [of an oral presentation]: Due to the lack of records and regulation on homeschooling, it is difficult to determine if homeschooling poses any more risk for child maltreatment than a child attending regular school and if there is a relationship between homeschooling and child abuse. Here, I look at the risk factors and the reasons why people homeschool their children and compare those to the risk factors involved with child abuse. Also I look into the criticisms of homeschooling and the stigmas attached to it. Among the greatest criticisms leveled are isolation and the deficits of regulating homeschooled children. Despite the risk factors, the interviews imply that child abuse and homeschooling are not similar enough to suggest a pattern. It is clear that homeschooling provides an opportunity to conceal child abuse, but it is not clear that abuse is more prevalent than what occurs to children who attend public schools. Due to the lack of information and records concerning homeschooled children, more investigation is needed to determine if there is a relationship between homeschooling and child abuse. Through interviewing social workers, I examined the relationship between homeschooling and child abuse and found no evidence of their relationship, but there was strong evidence to suggest that parents engaging in maltreatment and educational neglect are more likely to use homeschooling as a guise.”
Wehrmann, Lorrance Ann 2015 Stress levels of parents of homeschooled versus public-schooled special needs children. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Walden University. http://scholarworks.waldenu.edu/dissertations/1831/ special needs, schooling, stress, parents, homeschooling, home education, public schooling, research “Abstract. Although all families in the United States experience stress, families of children with special needs frequently experience prolonged periods of stress. Prolonged exposure to stressful circumstances increases their vulnerability to financial, physical, and social strain. With the continuing increase in the prevalence of children who have special needs, it is vital to examine the efficacy of different educational approaches on parental stress. It is unclear whether there are differences in stress levels for families of homeschooled versus public-schooled children with special needs. Using the family adjustment and adaptation response model, the purpose of this quantitative, ex post facto study was to investigate the degree to which parental stress reported by parents of a school-aged child with special needs could be predicted by school approach and severity of learning disability. Seventy parents of children participating in either public special education or homeschooling completed self-administered questionnaires, including the Family Impact of Childhood Disability Scale, the Educational Stress Survey, the Cognitive Processing Inventory, and demographic questions. Results from the descriptive analysis and multiple regression analyses indicated that the severity of the learning disability significantly predicted both overall parental stress as well as stress contributed by schooling. However, the type of special education setting did not significantly predict parental stress. The results from this study can promote positive social change by increasing parental awareness so that parents can make informed decisions about schooling for their children with special needs. It can also provide valuable information about additional stress related to special education programming services based on the severity of the child's learning disability.” Retrieved February 27, 2017 from http://scholarworks.waldenu.edu/dissertations/1831/
Weishart, Joshua E. 2016, in press Reconstituting the right to education. Alabama Law Review, 67, 1-63. Retrieved January 23, 2016 from http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2711910. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2711910 children’s rights, education, education rights, homeschooling, legal, theory Abstract: Confronting persistent and widening inequality in educational opportunity, advocates have regarded the right to education as a linchpin for reform. In the forty years since the Supreme Court relegated that right to the domain of state constitutional law, its power has surged and faded in litigation challenging state school finance systems. Like so many of the students it is meant to protect, however, the right to education has generally underachieved, in part because those wielding it have not always appreciated its distinctive forms and function. Deconstructed, the right to education held by children has been formulated doctrinally as both a claim-right, imposing affirmative duties on the state to act, and an immunity, disabling certain state action. These two strands—oft manifested as the claim-right to educational “adequacy” and an immunity entailing “equality” of educational opportunity—once considered irreconcilable are actually interlocked by the right’s core, historical function to protect children’s liberty and equality interests. And yet the right to education is ill-equipped to fulfill its protection function. Education clauses in state constitutions do not fix the standards for mutually enforcing equality and adequacy. This encumbers already-reluctant courts in addressing educational disparities and emboldens legislative resistance when they do. Appreciating that the right to education has a protection function entailing equality and liberty interests nevertheless suggests that it can be adjudicated in a way that unifies the demands and guarantees of substantive due process and equal protection. That union holds the potential to ameliorate the enforcement standards thereby deconstituting the right to education as a mainstay of reform. (p.1) Issues to homeschooling show up in the article’s footnotes. Weishart misses two fundamental things in his theoretical piece. First, he fails to clearly state his agenda and his worldview and where it is taking him in terms of defining education, to which he apparently wants a child to have a right. In other words, it appears he never defines education. A theoretician should define the construct to which he wants Americans to have a right before proceeding with his case. Maybe footnote 261 was his effort to define education, in which he writes ….. This definition, however, is about public school children and it is so vague that a committee of twenty randomly selected full professors of education might never be able to reach consensus on a practical application of this definition. Even if they did, a state legislature would have much trouble voting on one. Second, Weishart fails to note that all children as Homo sapiens young, ipso facto, receive an education. Further, parents do, de facto, and as parents, ipso facto, provide an education to and for their children, whether or not it meets Weishart’s standards or the criteria that legislators or experts or bureaucrats in any given state might contrive for children who will become adult citizens. For example, a boy (whether public schooled, private schooled, or homeschooled) who grows to be a man and cannot read a book and never votes in elections but has a strong work ethic as a welder, is respectful of his neighbors, obeys the laws of the land, enjoys creating watercolor paintings of landscapes, and diligently provides food, shelter, and clothing for his family is an educated man. For another example, a girl (whether public schooled, private schooled, or homeschooled) who grows to be a woman who cannot do multiplication facts and never wanted to go to college but lead’s a book club in her neighborhood, nurtures her three children, and lives frugally on a meager household income is an educated woman.
Weiss, Adele Barbara 1984 Effects of a telephone-managed home-school program using parents as tutors on the academic achievement of learning disabled students. Dissertation Abstracts International, 46, 125A. "Following a four week baseline period parents attended a workshop which trained them to access material [sight word identification, spelling, and math fact recognition] via an automatic telephone-answering machine, to tutor their children over this material, to conduct assessments, and to leave messages concerning assessment results on the telephone-answering machine." A multiple baseline design was used. "The study suggests that a program which uses parents as tutors of academic material accessed via an automatic telephone-answering machine is a viable means of increasing student performance while involving parents in their child's education."
Welk, Gregory J; Schaben, Jodee A.; Shelley, Mack 2004 Physical activity and physical fitness in children schooled at home and children attending public schools. Pediatric Exercise Science, 16, 310-323. home education, research, homeschooling, health, physical fitness, physical activity, public school, comparison “Homeschooling is increasingly popular, but little is known about how homeschooling affects physical activity patterns or fitness levels. This study compares patterns of physical fitness, physical activity, and psychosocial correlates of physical activity in homeschooled youth and youth attending public school. Fitness levels were obtained using the PACER aerobic fitness test, physical activity levels were assessed with 3 days of accelerometry, and psychosocial correlates were assessed with the Children’s Physical Activity Correlates scale. There were no significant main effects for fitness comparisons, but significant age and gender interactions indicate that variability exists within these samples for fitness. No school-type effects were evident for the physical activity measures or the psychosocial correlate measures, but trends in the data suggest the possibility of age-related interactions for the psychosocial measures. Additional research on possible differences between homeschooled youth and youth attending public school is needed to better understand these trends” (p. 310). “This study is the first effort to directly compare physical fitness and physical activity measures in homeschooled children and children attending public school (ages 9-16). We found that homeschooled males had significantly lower fitness levels than public school males, but no differences were evident in females. Follow-up analyses using a three-way analysis (Age X Gender X School Type) revealed that the difference was evident only for the older male group. The overall effect sizes are small for all of these comparisons and probably not of clinical significance. The data on physical activity are generally consistent with the lower fitness scores because there was a trend for homeschooled children to be less active than public school children. The mean differences were small and nonsignificant, but the pattern was consistent for all 3 days of monitoring” (p. 317). Peer-reviewed probably mis??
Welner, Kariane M [years later by surname Nemer] 2000 Goodbye public schools: Homeschoolers who want to dismantle the system. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, April 24-28, New Orleans, Louisiana. home education, homeschooling, negative criticism, negative critic, philosophy, policy, politics
Welner, Kariane Mari [years later by surname Nemer] 1999 Homeschooling and democracy: Exploring the tension between the state and parents (working draft). A paper presented on at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, April 19-23, 1999. home education, homeschooling, theory, politics, democracy, civic involvement, negative criticism, negative critic Examines three prevailing democratic theories: “liberal,” “communitarian,” and “deliberative” and what home schoolers may have to say about these. Explains that some scholars note that self-centeredness in public schools may erode a sense of citizenship and cause people to privilege themselves (and others like them) on the basis of some trait such as race, gender, sexual practices, or religion [p. 11]. All three models, apparently, result in constant conflict and debate among adult citizens within a state-run system of education.
Welner, Kariane Mari [years later by surname Nemer], & Welner, Kevin G. 1999, April 11 Contextualizing homeschooling data: A response to Rudner [Lawrence M. Rudner. 1999. Scholastic achievement and demographic characteristics of home school students in 1998. http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v7n13.html home education, research, critique, negative criticism, negative critic, academic achievement, demographics, sampling, representativeness Education Policy Analysis Archives]. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 7(13). [online at http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v7n13.html, retrieved 4/13/00 and earlier] “Abstract.Rudner (1999) presents the results of a survey and testing program, administered by Bob Jones University (BJU), for homeschooling students. In this response, we applaud Rudner's contribution to building a greater understanding of the homeschooling movement. However, we also voice a strong concern that what Rudner contributed with one hand, he took back with the other. We contend that Rudner's analysis of the BJU data fails to offer a straightforward explanation of important and striking limitations. The unfortunate result is an inaccurate portrayal of homeschoolers as a white, Christian, monolithic population. Although the results of Rudner's analyses are likely valid for the particular population he studied, his insufficient attention to the data's bias has led to an erroneous picture of homeschooling.” “Finally, as mentioned previously, the fact that the demographics reported by Rudner showed an almost exclusively white, Christian population could also be an artifact of the data source. As Dr. Rudner noted, family income is strongly correlated with children's test scores. However, we do not know whether the general population of homeschoolers has the same high level of income as the families in the BJU data base. Further research is needed to demonstrate whether or not this difference in test scores would hold up if a lower income sample of homeschoolers were tested.”
Welner, Kariane Mari. [other years by surname Nemer] 2002, June Understudied education: Toward building a homeschooling research agenda, Occasional Paper No. 48. New York, NY: National Center for the Study of Privatization in Education Teachers College, Columbia University. Retrieved 12/6/04 online http://ncspe.org/publications_files/114_OP48.pdf. http://ncspe.org/publications_files/114_OP48.pdf home education, homeschooling, research, reasons, critique, negative criticism, negative critic Considers existing research about the characteristics and motivations of homeschoolers and offers her own suggestions for a slightly more detailed typology [than Van Galen’s] arising from her own homeschool research. Concludes with brief sampling of the types of knowledge and insight that homeschooling research may offer concerning the strengths, weakness, and future of American schooling.
Welner, Kevin G 2012 Scholars as policy actors : Research, public discourse, and the zone of judicial constraints. American Educational Research Journal, 49(1), 7-29. education policy, law/legal, research use, social context, homeschooling but not a focus Mentions homeschooling in an endnote but there is no notable focus on homeschooling in the article.
Welsh, D. J. 1981 Title I parents as compensatory reading instructors: is there no place like home? Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Los Angeles, CA. ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED 204 073. Home-school relationship. School-district sponsored program; parents enthusiastic.
Wendel, Josef 1985 Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, Kent State University, Kent, OH. Dissertation Abstracts International, 46, 1477A-1478A. Law. Data were sought primarily in a library. "... the increased number of court challenges and the increased activism relating to home schooling might well produce a Supreme Court ruling in the near future" (p. 1478A). "Parents have found that individual rights conflict with various aspects of the state right to compel education. The dispute concerning the education of our youth has been, and most likely will continue to be, an unresolved issue" and "The manner in which the questions concerning home schooling are resolved should be consistent with our commitment to providing a quality education for all children in a fundamentally pluralistic society" [p. 1478A]. Claims the state retains the power to impose minimal, uniform curriculum requirements (p. 99). Contends that standardized testing should be regular and required by law (p. 103).
Wendel, Josef, Konnert, William, & Foreman, Charles 1986 Home schooling and compulsory school attendance. School Law Bulletin, 17(3), 1-8. Also in CIJE, January 1987, p. 22. CIJE No. 341 187. "Parental rights and state compulsory school attendance requirements are limited by constitutional constraints, as shown in three benchmark cases. The article also cites cases to show the impact of compulsory education laws on home schooling, which is increasing. The state retains the power to impose minimum curriculum requirements. Cites references." [CIJE abstract]. Law.
Wenders, John T., & Clements, Andrea D. 2005 Homeschooling in Nevada: The budgetary impact. Las Vegas, NV: Nevada Policy Research Institute. Available in hard copy, and online [as of 4/05/05] http://www.npri.org/mgraphs/NvHomeschooling.pdf. http://www.npri.org/mgraphs/NvHomeschooling.pdf home schooling, homeschooling, home education, research, economics, economy, costs, budget, public school, taxes, taxation, taxpayer, peer-reviewed “Homeschool children in the state [of Nevada] now make up about 1 percent of all school-age children. Public school advocates have argued that homeschooling “costs” the school system money through lost per-pupil taxpayer funding whenever a child is homeschooled rather than public schooled. In fact, home school students benefit school districts in the long run by relieving them of the far greater total costs of educating them. In Nevada, these cost savings are well in excess of the “lost” state aid. By not being educated in public schools, homeschool children either save taxpayers money, or make additional tax money available for other uses, including bolstering the educational opportunities for children who remain in public schools. Similar savings result from private school students. The present analysis measures the extent of this saving home- and private school students were placed in public schools. Based on 2003 data, the analysis shows an annual potential cost savings to Nevada taxpayers ranging from $24.3 million to $34.6 million attributable to homeschool students, and another $101.9 to $147 million attributable to private school students, for a combined total of $126.2 million to $181.7 million. This total amounts to an annual potential cost savings ranging from $327 to $471 per Nevada public school student. Local educators should look at home and private school students as assets, not as liabilities. Because of them, Nevada public schools’ expenses decrease by a greater amount than their revenues decrease, producing a net gain. We calculate the net gain to local school districts to be between $25.9 million and $42.7 million. Moreover, if taxpayers’ cost savings are used to enhance the educational opportunities of those students who attend public schools, the benefit to public schools would be even greater [p. 1, executive summary].” Peer-reviewed.
Wenders, John T., & Clements, Andrea D. 2007 An analysis of the economic impact of home and private schooling in Nevada. Home School Researcher, 17(2), 13-35. home education, public schools, private schools, research, economics, finances, policy, philosophy, peer-reviewed “Based on 2003 data, the results show an annual potential cost savings in the range of $24.3 million to $34.6 million attributable to homeschool students, $101.9 million to $147 million attributable to private school students, and $126.2 million to $181.7 million combined. These are the costs avoided by Nevada public schools by not having to educate the home- and private school students. These totals amount to an annual potential cost savings ranging from $327.48 to $471.64 per public school student” [p. 27]. “Local educators should look at home- and private school students as an asset that can make increased monies available for their local schools on a per-student basis. Indeed, if all of the savings were used to enhance the education of the state’s public school students, this would amount to an additional $327.48 to $471.64 per public school student” [p. 30]. “The bottom line is that home- and private schooling is a “win-win” arrangement for both taxpayers and individual public school districts” [p. 32]. “Finally, in addition to being logically flawed, the argument that students who fail to enroll in public schools are a “cost” implies that public schools are somehow entitled, as a property right, to every child and are being deprived of something that is their due. This is eminent domain in the extreme. The underlying assumption here is statist—one characteristic of totalitarian societies. In America, it is parents who are legally entitled to manage the upbringing of their children, not the public schools. The notion that homeschool children somehow “cost” the public schools turns reality on its head. In truth, the situation could be more accurately characterized as one in which Nevada’s public education establishment profits from unwarranted taxes on parents who choose to exercise their parental rights” [p. 32]. Peer-reviewed.)
Werle, Sonja 2001, circa John Holts Einflub auf die homeschooling-Bewegung. Master’s thesis, Matrikelnummer 4527925. (In German. Examines John Holt’s influence on the homeschooling movement.) home education, philosophy, pedagogy
West Virginia Department of Education 2010 Enrollment in nonublic schools school year 2009-10. Retrieved August 8, 2011 from http://wveis.k12.wv.us/ses/StatSum/NonPub_enroll.cfm. http://wveis.k12.wv.us/ses/StatSum/NonPub_enroll.cfm homeschooling, population size, West Virginia Reports 7,027 “home schools” in West Virginia during the 2009-10 school year; does not specify whether one of the “home schools” might consist of more than one student.
West, Cassiette Angela 1986, January 28 Parents, children lobby to continue home education. Columbia Missourian, p. 4B. Legal, Law
West, Diana 2004, May 21 There's no place like home: The secular case for home-schooling. Retrieved 6/9/04 online http://www.opinionjournal.com/taste/?id=110005109 [Wall Street Journal]. http://www.opinionjournal.com/taste/?id=110005109 home education, reasons, religion, secular, philosophy Wonders why Christians have waited so long to urge one another to get their children out of America’s public schools. “Maybe it is this new religious devotion to a leftist cultural ideology--which today's [public] schools preach and which yesteryear's schools did not--that Baptists now find "anti-Christian."” Explains her decision was largely that she could provide a better academic and intellectual education for her children than could even the “… excellently rated, wealthy and very white public elementary school in Montgomery County, Md., that my daughters attended last year, …” “In the end it proved that school isn't necessarily the best place for learning. And that, for Baptist and humanist alike, may be what is most inspiring of all.”
West, E. G. 1994 Education and the state. [mis??]
West, Robin 2014 A tale of two rights. Boston University Law Review, 94(3), 893–912. Retrieved December 15, 2014 from http://www.bu.edu/bulawreview/files/2014/08/WESTDYSFUNCTION.pdf. http://www.bu.edu/bulawreview/files/2014/08/WESTDYSFUNCTION.pdf rights, parents, children, democracy, equality, homeschooling, home education, philosophy Includes homeschooling in a philosophical and legal analysis. Never clearly lays out for the reader her theoretical framework or worldview that drives her assumptions and conclusions. It appears that she is a democratist, statist, and/or communitarian. Rather than presenting homeschool parents as not choosing to send their children away to State/government-controlled teaching, training, and indoctrination, she presents such parents as ones who “…pull their kids out of public education …” (p. 900-901). She is oblivious to the fact that many (if not most) homeschool parents never choose to place their children in public schools so they never pulled them out. Paper is riddled with other logical problems. Author is clearly antagonistic toward private education in general and makes unsubstantiated claims that healthy community, equality, and democracy cannot be had unless almost all children are placed under the educational oversight of State/government schooling. West is one of the most vocal current opponents of parent-led home-based education (a.k.a., homeschooling).
West, Robin L. 2009, Summer/Fall The harms of homeschooling. Philosophy and Public Policy Quarterly, 29(3/4), 7-12, https://philpapers.org/rec/WESTHO-6 Retrieved December 17, 2009 from http://www.puaf.umd.edu/files.php/ippp/vol29summerfall09.pdf https://philpapers.org/rec/WESTHO-6 http://www.puaf.umd.edu/files.php/ippp/vol29summerfall09.pdf home education, law, policy, philosophy, state control or regulation, negative criticism, negative critic, accountability, statism “The main purpose of this essay is to criticize this “right to homeschool” that the religious parents and their lawyers and lobbyists have claimed, or created, over the past couple of decades. My criticism will rest primarily on the basis of the [seven] harms such a right might inflict upon the children so educated” (p. 8). “My target is not the practice of homeschooling, whether religious or secular. My target, rather, is unregulated homeschooling—the total abdication of responsibility by the states for regulating the practice. The right to unregulated homeschooling visits quite concrete harms on the homeschooled children themselves, the mothers who are teaching them, and the often rural and isolated communities in which they are raised and taught” (p. 9). “First, children who are homeschooled with no state regulation are at greater risk for unreported and unnoticed physical abuse, when they are completely isolated in homes” (p. 9). “Second, there’s a public health risk. ….. Thus, deregulated homeschooling means that homeschooled children are basically exempted from immunization requirements. They are more susceptible to the diseases against which immunization provides some protection” (p. 9). “Third, public and private schools provide for many children, I suspect, although I have yet to see studies of this, a safe haven in which they are both regarded and respected independently and individually. ….. Children are loved in a family because they are the children of the parents in the family. The “unconditional love” they receive is anything but unconditional: it is conditioned on the fact that they are their parents’ children. School—either public or private—ideally provides a welcome respite. ….. The child is regarded with respect equally to all the children in the class. In these ways, the school classroom, ideally, and the relations within it, is a model of some core aspects of citizenship” (p. 9). “Fourth, there are political harms. Fundamentalist Protestant adults who were homeschooled over the last thirty years are not politically disengaged, far from it [p. 9 ends]. ….. They are as effective as they are, and as successful as they are, because they engage in politics in the same way that soldiers participate in combat. They don’t question authority, and they can’t go AWOL. With little education, few if any job skills, and scant resources, their power either to influence the lines of authority within their own sphere, or to leave that sphere, is virtually nil” (p. 10). “The remaining three sorts of harms—ethical, educational, and economic—are much discussed in critical literature both on homeschooling and on child-raising in devout households, and I won’t belabor them here other than to note them. Child-raising that is relentlessly authoritarian risks instilling what developmental psychologists call “ethical servility”: a failure to mature morally beyond the recognition of duties of obedience. In the most devoutly fundamentalist households, ethical servility might not be regarded as a bad outcome; it may be the desired goal. But whether a virtue or a disability, homeschooling—where the parents have full responsibility for the extent and substance of the child’s education as well as upbringing—clearly multiplies the risk” (p. 10). “The educational harm is the most immediate, direct risk of unregulated homeschooling. It is also the only one in this litany of possible risks adamantly denied by homeschooling advocates. There is indeed no credible evidence that homeschoolers as a group do worse on standardized tests, but contrary to their claims, there is also no credible evidence that they do better” (p. 10). “Finally, the economic harms” (p. 10). “These families are not living in romantic, rural, self-sufficient farmhouses; they are in trailer parks, 1,000-square-foot homes, houses owned by relatives, and some, on tarps in fields or parking lots. Their lack of job skills, passed from one generation to the next, depresses the community’s overall economic health and their state’s tax base” [p. 10]. Argues for significant state control over homeschooling in the form of curricular review, mandatory academic achievement testing, home visits “…would give the state a window into the quality of home life, and a way to monitor signs of abuse as well as immunizations. The sanction for failure to comply with minimal curriculum, content, visitation, and testing requirements would simply be enrollment in a certified private or public school” (p. 12). Author provides no empirical evidence or research findings that homeschool children are at any risk or more at-risk than institutionally schooled children.
Western Australia Department of Education 1979 Innovations in rural education: The Isolated Students Matriculation Scheme in Western Australia and the Chidley Educational Centre. Studies in Rural Education, no. 3, October, 41p. Western Australia: Author.
Weston, Susan Perkins 1989, May Choosing a School for Your Child. (Report No: PIP-89-833). Washington, DC.: Office of Educational Research and Improvement (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED302872). Decision Making, Nontraditional Education, Parent Participation, Parent School Relationship, School Choice
Weston, W. J. 1988 Conference on Education and the Family report to the public. Conference was held June 17 & 18, 1988 in Washington, DC. Available from United States Department of Education, 1990 Office of Educational Research and Improvement, Washington DC. Paper presentations entitled: "The historical role of families in education" by N. Ray Hiner, "Family structure and education" by Ann Milne, "Family process and education" by Sanford Dornbusch, "The content taught in families: Two case studies" by Hesung Chun Koh and Allan Carlson & Bryce Christensen, "Communities of families and education" by Laurence Steinberg.
Weston, W. J. (Ed.) 1989 Education and the American family: A research synthesis. New York, NY: New York University Press. Similar to Weston, W. J. [1988) above
Wettach, Jane R., & McGuire, William B. 2020 Protecting homeschoolers: A proposal to protect homeschooled children in North Carolina from educational neglect. Duke Law School Public Law & Legal Theory Series No. 2021-11, http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3652544 http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3652544 legal, homeschool, home education, risk, neglect, abuse, educational neglect Provides claims about various dangers to which homeschool children might be exposed. Does not provide any empirical evidence or data that the homeschooled are at risk or at more risk than are children in institutional schools.
Wexler, Richard 2017 Protect homeschooled children from child savers. Retrieved March 17, 2026 from https://imprintnews.org/blogger-co-op/protect-homeschooled-children-child-savers/25824 and retrieved April 5, 2017 from https://chronicleofsocialchange.org/blogger-co-op/protect-homeschooled-children-child-savers/25824 and retrieved July 7, 2022 from https://www.socialjusticesolutions.org/2017/03/30/protect-homeschooled-children-child-savers/ https://imprintnews.org/blogger-co-op/protect-homeschooled-children-child-savers/25824 https://chronicleofsocialchange.org/blogger-co-op/protect-homeschooled-children-child-savers/25824 https://www.socialjusticesolutions.org/2017/03/30/protect-homeschooled-children-child-savers/ https://chronicleofsocialchange.org/blogger-co-op/liberal-dilemma-child-welfare-reform/18701 https://chronicleofsocialchange.org/blogger-co-op/protect-homeschooled-children-maltreatment/25708 homeschooling, home schooling, home education, child abuse, state regulation, law, legal, statism, liberalism, libertarianism, classical liberal, policy, profile, profiling The author, who calls himself a liberal, explains why it is a bad idea to try to reduce homeschool child abuse by laying more state regulations and tighter state controls on homeschooling. “And now, we have a classic case in point. Self-proclaimed liberal Marie Cohen’s latest column in The Chronicle calls for requiring that every parent who homeschools a child bring that child before a mandated reporter of child abuse for periodic inspection. Try substituting “terrorism” for “child abuse” and “Muslim” for “Homeschooler” and the problems here should be obvious.” “The singling out of homeschoolers is odd for other reasons as well. The children most at risk of abuse or neglect are the youngest. So the same logic behind this proposal requires that every child from birth to at least kindergarten age also be presented for periodic inspection.”
Weyrich, Paul M. 1999, March 2 How to win the cultural war. CNS Commentary from the Free Congress Foundation (online, www.conservativenews.org). http://www.conservativenews.org home education, opinion, politics, sociology, values, religion “At the end of the day, home-schoolers, for example, have made an enormous contribution to our nation's future by dropping out of the system. Home-schooled children, by and large, are being educated in the right values. They will be able to read and write and add and subtract. Here are a million kids upon whom we will be able to depend for the future. Their parents home-schooled them without government subsidies. They didn't depend on the state. In that sense, they simply returned to an earlier time in this nation before we had a public school system. The home-schoolers and the rest of us have to stay involved in politics to see to it that the state doesn't take away the right of parents to educate their own children. But these parents are not waiting for politics and government to help win the culture war.”
Wheeler, Richard “Little Bear.” 1997 Warning: Public schools aren’t for Christians: A Biblical Perspective on the Dangers of Public Schools. Published by and available from Mantle Ministries, 28 Still Ridge, Bulverde TX 78163. http://ceanet.net/warn1.htm home education, reasons, Christian, religious, apologetics Well-known advocate of home schooling and popular home-school conference speaker provides rationale for not placing children in public schools. Answers common questions and arguments of parents who are opposed to home schooling. Author says he deals with several reasons Christian parents give for not homeschooling their children and putting them in public schools, as follow: “We do not really want to place our children in a public school, but we are in a financial crunch and there are no other alternatives. The real world is full of sinners; therefore, I need to place my children in the public school system to help them cope with real situations that arise in life. I keep my children in public schools because I want them to be, as the Bible says, "salt and light"-and to be a Godly example to the lost around them. Isn't this what Christ has commanded us to do? My son/daughter loves sports, and the public schools offer the best programs. This is why I allow my children to go to public schools. I do not feel qualified to teach my children at home, and I cannot afford a Christian school; therefore, I have no choice but to place my children in a public school. Look at me! I made it through the public school system and turned out all right, so I am sure my children will turn out OK in the end.”-- retrieved May 30, 2017 from http://ceanet.net/warn1.htm
Wheeler, Richard B. 2000, circa [no date in book] The Little Bear story: The adventures of a retarded gopher skinner. Published by Mantle Ministries, 28 Still Ridge, Bulverde TX 78163. education, biography, home education, philosophy “My early school years were like being in the military. In those days, the Roman Catholic schools were rough places where “Sisters” surely learned their teaching methods from military drill sergeants. These Sisters looked like Darth Vader in Star Wars before the movie was ever thought of. The most feared and dreaded Sister was Sister Superior. I could hardly discern their faces since they were covered with a huge black and white starched shroud. This was very intimidating to a little first grader. From what I’ve been told, I was definitely a handful, even for those Sisters who were trained to combat and deal with problem children. They had to bring out their entire arsenal of dastardly tools to shape, mold, and break the wild stallion in my undisciplined nature. [paragraph] We didn’t have fancy medical terms that labeled dysfunctional children in those days. I am convinced that it was because of my behavior that medical science invented terms like hyperactive, attention deficit disorder, and dyslexia, as well as the drug Ritalin to sedate children. I still have my elementary Catholic school report cards with horrible grades and notes written on the back informing my mother that I was “retarded.” This caused my mother to take me to the family doctor so he could tell her what to do with her “retarded” son. The doctor psychoanalyzed me and [p. 9 ends] declared to my mother that I was a “normal” child. He further related his suspicion that perhaps she was the one with brain damage since she had brought me to see him for my “retardation.” Needless to say, we were both relieved to find out that we were sane. Note that we were “sane” but not necessarily “normal” individuals. [paragraph] Meanwhile back at boot camp -- err I mean school -- the Sisters were literally going to knock some sense into me even if it killed one of us. Today the Children’s Social Services Division would have had those teachers arrested for the things they put me through. I can personally testify that our ears cannot be pulled off! What I considered to be a my best behavior was most intolerable to the Sisters. [paragraph] The Sisters had learned maneuvers in holy boot camp -- such as sneaking up behind my desk and grabbing my ears as if they were handles and pulling me up to the front of the class. Next, they would twist my ear to a point that would drive me to my knees, which they believed would bring me to sorrow and repentance. However, at seven years of age, it only brought me to pain, humility, and fear. After a few minutes of this, I was lifted by my armpits and given a good shaking accompanied by a hell-fire and brimstone lecture.. All this came with that huge shroud looking into my face. Goliath couldn’t have looked any more ferocious at that moment. Then the coup de grace began when my arms and hands were forced to be fully extended so that the oak chalkboard pointer could be lifted by the Sister to full height and brought down upon the top of my hands in full execution style. I was then sent back to my desk to hang my head in shame and wonder what was wrong with me. In my mind, as well as my mother’s and the doctor’s, I was perfectly normal. I guess I was just too “retarded” to consider that something was wrong with me” [p. 10]. The author is one of the favorite speakers at homeschool conferences all across the United States and in other countries.)
White, Barbara J. 1987 A demographic analysis of parents in Virginia who choose home instruction to educate their children. Dissertation Abstracts International, 48(5), 1113A, VPI and State University, 152pp.
White, John S. 1994 How to help home schoolers: Suggestions for church leaders. Unpublished doctoral dissertation (major writing project), Luther Rice Seminary, Atlanta, GA. home education, church, religion, clergy, leadership, research "What will the Church's role be [in home education]? Not many local churches are actively involved in the home school movement. If this persists, both church and home will suffer?" (p. 83).
White, Linda A. 2004 “Trends in child care/early childhood education/ early childhood development policy in Canada and the United States.” American Review of Canadian Studies, 34(4), 665-687. early childhood education, early childhood development, policy, trends, public schools Mentions homeschooling at least once: “Yet while charter schools, private schools, and home schooling has grown tremendously in the United States especially, approximately 89 percent of children in the United States still attend a public school rather than a private school (National Center for Education Statistics, 2003), and approximately 94 percent attend in Canada (OECD, 2003)” (p. 666). No notable attention is given to homeschooling.
White, Michael J., Kaufman, Gayle 1997 Language usage, social capital, and school completion among immigrants and native-born ethnic groups. Social Science Quarterly, 78, 385-398. education, research, dropout rates, school completion, ethnicity, race, social capital, parents, parent involvement, family Examine effects of ethnicity, generational status, duration in the United States, language usage, and social capital on high school completion and find “... living with both parents instead of one parent decreases the odds of being a dropout by 38 percent ...” and “... having two parents instead of one monitor schoolwork decreases the odds of being a dropout by 14 to 18 percent.” Social capital traits may outweigh the effects of ethnicity and generation, duration in the U.S., and English language usage, and can buffer the risks of lower socioeconomic status.
White, Paul E. 1992 Understanding the homeschooling movement. A paper presented at the Second International Congress on Christian Counseling, Atlanta, GA, November 13, 1992. review of research, opinion Purpose of aid helping professionals in better understanding the home education movement and its families; explains basic characteristics of the families, why and how they home educate; warns professionals about making assumptions about these families; discusses potential advantages and risks involved in home education.
White, Scott; Moore, Megan; & Squires, Josh 2009 Examination of previously homeschooled college students with the Big Five model of Personality. Home School Researcher 25(1), 1-7. Retrieved 3/4/2010 from http://www.nheri.org/Volume-25-Issue-1/Examination-of-Previously-Homeschooled-College-Students-with-the-Big-Five-Model-of-Personality.html. http://www.nheri.org/Volume-25-Issue-1/Examination-of-Previously-Homeschooled-College-Students-with-the-Big-Five-Model-of-Personality.html home education, research, socialization, personality development “Interestingly, the dominant personality taxonomy in the field of personality psychology today (Digman, 1990; McAdams, 2000; Friedman & Schustak, 2006), the Big Five personality factors, measures dimensions that help examine some of the various concerns addressed above. The five factors represent the most basic dimensions underlying the personality traits identified in both natural languages and in psychological questionnaires. The five personality factors include: Openness to Experience (O), Conscientiousness (C), Extraversion (E), Agreeableness (A), and Neuroticism (N)” (p. 1).“Subjects in this study were 51 previously homeschooled college students, 12 males and 39 females, at a private Christian college in the southern United States. Our operational definition for previously homeschooled, required that college students had to have been homeschooled for at least 50% of their education during the first through twelfth grades. Ethnic backgrounds of the subjects were reported to be 94.12%” (p. 3). “The NEO-FFI Form S, College Age was used as the self-report measure of personality” (p. 3). “College students who were previously homeschooled were found to be significantly more Agreeable, Conscientious and Open as compared to their peers in the national college-aged norms. No difference was found between the homeschooled sample and the national college aged norms on the Extraversion or Neuroticism domains. Because this is a correlational study, this study cannot establish whether the environmental differences homeschooled students experienced caused these differences in personality dimensions” [p. 4]. “The finding that homeschooled students were more Open than the national sample was the opposite of our hypothesis. In addition, it would appear to be antithetical to the concern of critics who have expressed concern that removing these children from the influence of traditional schooling might produce closed-minded individuals (Wright, 1988). These findings, however, must be closely analyzed. The Openness scale measures a variety of dimensions. This domain includes openness to new experiences, the arts, ideas, values and pursuit [p. 5 ends] of intellectual interests. It may be that previously homeschooled students, as a result of their educational experiences, are more open to a variety of intellectual pursuits, artistic interests, creative ideas, etc.” [p. 5-6].
White, Scott; Williford, Elizabeth; Brower, John; Collins, Terance; Merry, Roman; & Washington, Maryam 2007 Emotional, social and academic adjustment to college: A comparison between Christian home schooled and traditionally schooled college freshmen. Home School Researcher, 17(4), 1-7. Retrieved 3/4/2010 from http://www.nheri.org/Volume-17-Issue-4/Homeschooled-Students-Adjustment-to-College.html. http://www.nheri.org/Volume-17-Issue-4/Homeschooled-Students-Adjustment-to-College.html home education, research, matched-sample, causal-comparative, college, graduates, adjustment, socialization, emotional, academics, achievement, psychological, emotional, peer-reviewed “The participants included 36 first-time freshmen college students attending their first semester at a small, private, Christian liberal arts college in Jackson, Mississippi. The study was conducted with two samples, matched for age, race, gender, and having been raised in a Christian home. These two groups were: (a) previously home schooled students (n=18) and (b) previously traditionally schooled students from both private and public high schools (n=18)” (p. 3). “The College Adjustment Scales (CAS) [which has nine subscales] is a tool specifically designed to identify and evaluate “the experience and expression of adjustment problems in college students throughout the college years” (Anton & Reed, 1990, p. 13)” (p. 3). “Home schooled students were found to be significantly less anxious than traditionally schooled students. All other t-scores were found to be insignificant. However, it should be noted that on the FP (family problems) scale, the level of significance was narrowly missed before rounding (.059)” (p. 4). “The present study compared Christian college freshmen who had previously been home schooled with a matched sample of traditionally schooled Christian freshmen on the College Adjustment Scale” (abstract). “Home schooled students’ ability to successfully adjust to college life is one important criterion to demonstrate a positive outcome of home schooling. The present study compared Christian college freshmen who had previously been home schooled with a matched sample of traditionally schooled Christian freshmen on the College Adjustment Scale. Employs a causal-comparative design.. The mean scores of the two groups were compared across the nine CAS scales designed to measure emotional, behavioral, social and academic problems typically presenting to university counseling centers. The home schooled students scored significantly lower on the anxiety subscale, while no difference was found between the two groups on the remaining scales. In addition, it was noted that there was a general trend characterized by home schooled students reporting fewer symptoms of emotional distress and social problems, and achieving higher first semester GPAs. The results suggest that home schooled college freshmen successfully adjust to the social and academic and social environment of a Christian college with a diverse student population. The limitations of this study in addressing key questions regarding the effect of home schooling upon socialization are discussed” [abstract, p. 1]. Peer-reviewed.
Whitehead, John W., & Bird, Wendell R. 1984 Home education and constitutional liberties: The historical and constitutional arguments in support of home instruction. Westchester, IL: Crossway Books, 143 p. home education, law, legal, history Consider the historical and constitutional aspects of home education. Authors support conventional non-public education for their own children, but recognize the importance of issues related to the constitutional rights and the right to parental liberty that are raised by home education. Conclude that home educators need to educate the public, pass legislation that affirms home education, and pursue courtroom litigation with caution. “Home education and constitutional liberties: The historical and constitutional arguments in support of home instruction.” “The authors personally support conventional non-public education rather than home education for their children; thus, they are not biased in favor of home education by their own family decisions. However, they recognize the importance of the constitutional rights involved, and the ramifications for the family raised, in the state’s frequent assertion of control [emphasis added] over home education and ultimately over the child” (p. 10). “Therefore, whereas public education involves open-ended group instruction (or mass teaching), home education is the structured, individual instruction of a child (or children) by parents in basic living skills as well as in traditional and additional courses of academic study. Generally, home instruction is from a specific religious or philosophical viewpoint” (p. 16).
Whitehead, LeRoy E. 2007 Toward a re-thinking of mass public schooling: A personal exploration. Encounters on Education, 8(Fall), 203 – 219. Retrieved 7/15/13 from http://library.queensu.ca/ojs/index.php/encounters/article/view/581/769. http://library.queensu.ca/ojs/index.php/encounters/article/view/581/769 bureaucracy and schooling, education and schooling, school organization, alternative education, Canada, mass schooling, institutional schooling, philosophy, homeschooling There is no notable focus on homeschooling in this article. Mentions homeschooling 3 or 4 times; e.g.: “There are a proportionally small but continually growing number of families and individuals who are abandoning the public school system and migrating to private schools, home schooling and online academies. These families and individuals cite a variety of reasons, …” (p. 205). “Indeed, part of the evidence for the existence of dysfunction in the public school system is the growing number of people who are already opting for other means of achieving education, such as private schools, home schooling and online academies. Some are also promoting plans that would fund individual students by means of vouchers to be used at any school, public or private, rather than funding the system” (p. 216). “I want everyone to be well-educated, because an educated citizenry is the bedrock of a free society, which I value highly. It does not follow, however, that I necessarily want everyone to attend school. Nor does it follow that one must attend school to be educated. Indeed, for some people, the technology of schooling impedes the attainment of their education” (p. 216). Argues publicly funded education must offer a wide variety of alternatives” (p. 216). “Abstract: Mass public schooling as we know it was one result of the industrial revolution. Its organizational form was heavily influenced by the ‘code’ of industrialism, the scientific management movement and industrial bureaucracy. While the promise of the philosophy underlying the use of the bureaucratic form in social institutions is tempting, the literature of bureaucracy indicates that bureaucratic organizations are most successful when certain preconditions are met, less successful when they are not. These preconditions are increasingly absent from our schools, school systems and the environment in which they operate. Hence, the bureaucratic form is increasingly counter-indicated, and its continued use may be a contributing factor in what appears to be a growing level of dissatisfaction with the system and dysfunction in the system. By recognizing a distinction between the terms ‘education’ and ‘schooling’ we may be able to move beyond mass public schooling to a situation in which the public is well-educated” (p. 203). “Though this essay has provided only a brief outline of the argument, I believe it demonstrates the need for a full examination and discussions of the dysfunctions and limitations of bureaucracy for effective education in a dynamic and constantly changing, heterogeneous society such as the one in which we now live. It indicates the nature of the case that has yet to be fully made that other conceptions of education and schooling, as well as other forms or organization for the purpose of achieving an educated society, must be considered” (p. 217).
Wiebe, R. H. 1969 The social functions of public education. American Quarterly, 21, 147-164. Historical analysis of the role of public schools in society.
Wiechers, Bettie; & Bester, Dierdre 2006 How does the academic performance of South African home school learners compare to that of learners in state schools? Suid-Afrikaanse Akademie vir Wetenskap & Kuns, 46(4), 456-467.
Wiggin, Gladys A. 1962 Education and nationalism: An historical interpretation of American education. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc. education, public schools, state, philosophy, history The author, from the University of Maryland, writes about herself: “She is a liberal in religion, being of the same persuasion as Thomas Jefferson, and is probably as liberal politically in her time as the third President was in his. Her commitment to a public school establishment is also as deep as his. ..... she is firmly in accord with her New England ancestors, who believed that the proper place for a child or youth in a republican society is in a public elementary or secondary school” [p. viii]. Explains that the family as an institution has been throughout history extremely important in the development of a child but its role is and should be less comprehensive in modern nation-states. “Though the American people, including some of the educators, rail at the school (all levels) for its inadequacies, they have consistently allowed school people to carry the burden of culture transmission” [p. 31]. “Who is an American? ..... What should this American know and what should be his behavior? ..... [and] How may he be a good American citizen? ..... Both [i.e., the first two and the third] questions have necessitated describing the proportions of the good American, developing the role of the school in the making of the American, and charting the curricular processes by which the desired behaviors under the guidance of the school might emerge. This continuous making of choices respecting the direction in which behavior should be guided to develop the ideal American has made schools into a gigantic moral enterprise” [p. 36]. Shows she is very comfortable with and advocates the public school as a nation builder, character former, and controller of people. Will. U. library.
Wilhelm, Gretchen M.; & Firmin, Michael W. 2009 Historical and contemporary developments in home school education. Journal of Research on Christian Education, 18(3), 303-315. http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10656210903333442#.Ud9iGkHbOSo homeschoooling, home education, history, religion, philosophy “Abstract: Home school [homeschool] education has a rich history. It is embedded in America's most early form of education practice, with character education being a central component. By the 1960s, however, home school education developed mostly into adoption by extreme groups. First, the Left adopted the protocol as a means of implementing their non-traditional approach to societal milieu. Following court cases that removed religion from the public schools, home education became dominated by fundamental, then evangelical parents. Presently, home schooling is a significant movement that public school educators cannot simply ignore as ‘fringe’. The wide spread use of the internet likely will propel home education's popularity via distance education mediums” (retrieved 7/11/13 from http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10656210903333442#.Ud9iGkHbOSo).
Wilkens, Christian P., & Kalendra, Peter J. 2019 Correspondence schools in Alaska: Enrollment and cohort graduation rates, 2010-17. Journal of School Choice: International Research and Reform, 13(4), 509-536. Retrieved November 30, 2020 from https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/15582159.2019.1683263 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/15582159.2019.1683263 correspondence schools, public schooling, public school at home, Alaska, homeschooling, graduation, graduation rate, peer-reviewed This is a study of students in a public school correspondence program, not a study of homeschooling, despite the fact that the authors use the term homeschooling. “Abstract: The State of Alaska, by some measures the United States’ most rural state, has long supported correspondence schools, a popular school choice option available to all students statewide and used primarily by homeschooled students. This paper first explores Alaska correspondence schools in historical context, and then quantifies capture rate, enrollment by race/ethnicity, grade distributions, and cohort graduation rates for the years 2010–17. Findings include a steady increase in the proportion of Alaskan students enrolled in correspondence schools between 2010 and 2017; disproportionate enrollment of Alaskan students identified as White in correspondence schools between 2010 and 2017; enrollment peaks in late high school during 2014–17; and significantly lower 4- and 5-year cohort graduation rates among students enrolled in correspondence schools compared to those enrolled in traditional public schools.” The authors confuse terms in this study and are actually doing research on government/public correspondence schooling and students in such schools but the authors also refer to these as homeschool students, which is an obscuring of reality. Homeschooling is parent-directed, family-based education with parents deliberately choosing to to take responsibility for the education of their children, controlling both the education process and the curriculum (course of study), and it is not controlled and operated run by the government or its school system and is not mainly funded by tax dollars; ergo, this study is one of public school at home called correspondence school in Alaska and students in this form of public schooling.
Wilkens, Christian P.; Wade, Carol H.; Sonnert, Gerhard; & Sadler, Philip M. 2015 Are homeschoolers prepared for college calculus? Journal of School Choice: International Research and Reform, 9(1), 30-48, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2015.998963. https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2015.998963 school choice, homeschool, homeschooling, home education, research, mathematics, calculus, FICSMath, peer reviewed “Homeschooling in the United States has grown considerably over the past several decades. This article presents findings from the Factors Influencing College Success in Mathematics (FICSMath) survey, a national study of 10,492 students enrolled in tertiary calculus, including 190 students who reported homeschooling for a majority of their high school years. The authors found that, compared with students who received other types of secondary schooling, students who homeschooled: (a) were demographically similar to their peers, (b) earned similar SAT Math scores, and (c) earned higher tertiary calculus grades” (p. 9). “Fourth, in Table 3 we examined final course grades in single-variable college calculus. We found that, among first-time calculus students who had not taken college precalculus, students who homeschooled earned significantly higher final grades (Mean: 87.2 out of 100) than students who attended all other school types (Means ranged from 78.9–82.3 out of 100).” (p. 44). “We were somewhat surprised to see controls such as race, Hispanic origin, and parent education levels contribute little to the initial model—particularly given that parent education levels could conceivably contribute to a homeschooled student’s experiences in mathematics” (p. 45). “Our main interest in this article was the path of students by high school type—particularly those students who reported homeschooling. Homeschooling demonstrated significance as a predictor and is included in the final model (no other school type demonstrated significance), and the magnitude of the effect of homeschooling (versus not) appears to be considerable. A predicted final college calculus score gain of more than 5 points, or roughly half a grade, is certainly meaningful for students and worth consideration in future work” (p. 45). Peer-reviewed journal).
Willard, Dennis J., & Oplinger, Doug 2005, January 4 [homeschool] Parents want to control influences; critics see need for wide exposure. Retrieved 1/6/05 online http://www.fortwayne.com/mld/newssentinel/living/10562249.htm. http://www.fortwayne.com/mld/newssentinel/living/10562249.htm home education, socialization, opinion “Steve Beck begs to differ with anyone who believes his children are not properly ``socialized.'' ``Our philosophy is to engage the world - not lead a secluded life. We want to have an impact on the culture,'' said Beck, who, along with his wife, Kerry, home-schools their three children … As the Beacon Journal examined the state of home schooling in America, no issue sparked more debate or stronger emotions than socialization. The Becks epitomize the independent streak found in many home educators.” “Rob Reich, a Stanford University professor who maintains that he supports home schooling, believes that many parents wield too much control over their children and don't want them exposed to contrary ideas. ….. ``Children can grow up to become ethically servile to their parents, which is incompatible with them being free persons,'' Reich said. In his speeches and writings, Reich talks about two concepts of society: one in which citizens vote their own interests and the majority rules; and one in which citizens are involved, talk to each other and exchange ideas in the public forum before taking a majority vote. He believes that home-schooling parents are preventing their children from being part of the public forum, and that the children are being raised in isolation. If they're not part of that forum, they may not know that other views on life exist. ``I think that is a potentially disabling aspect of home schooling,'' Reich said. The state cannot mandate that children from diverse backgrounds come together, but Reich said government can and should insist upon curricula that expose children to different religions, cultures and points of view. ``Not all home schoolers are going to like this, but this will be part of the aim of regulation - to ensure that even within a home-school environment, children are introduced to and exposed to the world of diversity in a liberal democracy,'' Reich said at the same discussion of education research that Sorooshian attended.”
Williams, Anne 2001 Home-school center grows. Eugene, Oregon. The Register-Guard. [Eugene, OR newspaper] Retrrieved 1/9/02 online http://www.registerguard.com/news/20011217/1b.cr.edextra.1217.html http://www.registerguard.com/news/20011217/1b.cr.edextra.1217.html
Williams, Anton Dewan 2018 Parents’ perceptions on negative experiences in institutional schools and decision to homeschool in northwest Arkansas. Doctoral dissertation (Ed.D.), Grand Canyon University. Retrieved May 10, 2018 from https://search.proquest.com/openview/882b4cda8cf2965423943f4a22fcd4c7/1?pq-origsite=gscholar&cbl=18750&diss=y https://search.proquest.com/openview/882b4cda8cf2965423943f4a22fcd4c7/1?pq-origsite=gscholar&cbl=18750&diss=y parents perceive, negative experiences, institutional schools, homeschool, children, home education, home schooling Abstract. It is not known how parents perceive the influence of negative experiences in institutional schools on their decision to homeschool their children. The purpose of this qualitative, descriptive study was to explore how parents perceive the influence of negative experiences and more specifically, the role of bad influence of peers, safety, and educational leaders in institutional schools on their decision to homeschool their children in Northwest Arkansas. Albert Bandura’s social learning theory was the theoretical framework used to guide this study. The study was guided by three-research questions: How do parents perceive the influence of their children’s peers on their decision to homeschool their children; what is the influence of safety in institutional schools on the parents’ choice to homeschool children; and what is the role of educational leaders on the influence of parents’ choice to homeschool children? Using a qualitative descriptive study design, the researcher triangulated the data from surveys via SurveyMonkey®, interviews, and document review from 21 participants. Data analysis produced seven themes: (a) culture, (b) peer pressure, (c) distractions, (d) bullying, (e) violence, (f) caring educator, and (g) non-caring educator. The findings and conclusions from this study demonstrated that parents perceive the influence of peer experiences, safety, and educational leaders negatively in institutional schools on their decision to homeschool their children in Northwest Arkansas.”
Williams, David 1984, April Understanding home education: Case studies of home schools. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans, LA.
Williams, Donald T. The great divide: The church and the postmodernist challenge. Retrieved 12/6/04 online http://www.equip.org/free/OP331.htm. http://www.equip.org/free/OP331.htm Discusses postmodernism and Christianity; published by Christian Research Institute.
Williams, Karen Marie 1990 A study of home schooling parents in Ohio. Doctoral dissertation (Ed.D.), The University of Akron, Akron, OH, 172pp., Adviser: Richard Viering. Dissertation Abstracts International, 51(5), 1473A. (Order No. DA9024249) home education, reasons, religion, demographics Demographics, attitudes, beliefs, religious factors very important to them when making decision to home educate, frequent social interactions for children, few sought assistance from public schools.
Williams, Lawrence T. 1989 Home schooling: A review of research. Paper presented at the Eastern Educational Research Association Annual Conference, Savannah, Georgia, February 22-25, 1989.
Williams, Lawrence T. 1990 The relationship of family characteristics and instructional approach to creativity in home school children. Home School Researcher, 6(3), 1-10. home education, research, creativity Finds the home educated more creative than those in conventional schools on three of five subscales and the global mean of the test of creativity used, the Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking (TTCT). Examinations of correlations, however, do not clarify cause and effect between variables of type of schooling and creativity. Hypothesizes that an environment with a moderate amount of freedom within a clear structure and adequate opportunities for interaction with other adults and children provide the optimum context for creativity in the home educated.
Williams, Meca R. (Presenter & Author) 2009, August 6 Collective action and sense of community among African American homeschool families. American Psychological Association Conference Annual Meeting, American Psychological Association, Toronto Canada. homeschooling, black, African American, community
Williams, Rodger 1999 When the law hinders education. Retrieved May 14, 2016 from http://www.hstuac.org/hinders.html http://www.hstuac.org/hinders.html
Williams, Rodger 2014, July 5 The homeschool effect. Retrieved November 28, 2018 (and February 4, 2016) from http://thehomeschooleffect.com/the-homeschool-effect.html http://thehomeschooleffect.com/the-homeschool-effect.html homeschooling, academic achievement, research “The Homeschool Effect clearly exists. It was boosting Oregon homeschooled students to higher academic achievement levels in 1998 and 1999. In 2011-2013 the effect was even greater. Homeschooled students benefit across the whole ability spectrum, including those who have the most difficulty learning. The Homeschool Effect is an equal-opportunity aid to upward mobility through excellent education” (last 3 paragraphs).”
Williams, Rodger 2015 Regulating homeschoolers: The missing effects. Retrieved mis?? from http://thehomeschooleffect.com/regulation.html http://thehomeschooleffect.com/regulation.html
Williams, Rodger 2016, November 3 Homeschool child fatalities: A data analysis. Retrieved February 3, 2017 and October 10, 2016 from http://thehomeschooleffect.com/child-fatalities.html http://thehomeschooleffect.com/child-fatalities.html homeschooling, home education, child abuse, child neglect, child fatalities, research “HIC claims to "have documented a higher rate of fatalities among school-aged children in homeschool settings than among school-aged children as a whole." But this so-called documentation is based on data which is not statistically significant. For the most recent ten years' worth of data, the HIC-defined "homeschool" child fatality rate is 0.20 unexpected fatalities per year, for the entire nation. The average state-level deviation is 0.004 fatalities per year. That is one every 250 years. And HIC includes truants, murders unrelated to homeschooling and abducted children in their count of "homeschool child fatalities." HIC's fatality data fails to meet either of the criteria by which statisticians judge the usefulness of data: The data is not statistically significant. And their data does not indicate a practical difference in outcomes. The HIC data cannot be considered credible evidence for advocating the regulation of actual homeschoolers." The HIC data cannot be considered credible evidence for advocating the regulation of actual homeschoolers.”
Williams, Rodger 2017, July 28 Homeschool child fatalities fewer than the national average, https://homeschoolingbackgrounder.com/homeschool-child-fatalities-fewer-than-national-average/ Retrieved January 23, 2018 from http://thehomeschooleffect.com/child-fatalities-regulation.html https://homeschoolingbackgrounder.com/homeschool-child-fatalities-fewer-than-national-average/ http://thehomeschooleffect.com/child-fatalities-regulation.html homeschooling, home schooling, home education, child fatalities, abuse, research “Legally homeschooled students are 40% less likely to die by child abuse or neglect than the average student nationally.”
Williams, Rodger 2025 Why Has This Homeschooled Child Been Singled Out? (Connecticut). Retrieved March 17, 2026, https://homeschoolingbackgrounder.com/connecticut-homeschooled-child-singled-out/ https://homeschoolingbackgrounder.com/connecticut-homeschooled-child-singled-out/ homeschooling, home education, child abuse, child neglect, child maltreatment “Why Has This Homeschooled Child Been Singled Out? (Connecticut) [diagram/picture of one small dot/circle] Jacqueline “Mimi” Torres-Garcia 2024 [line break] 201 nameless and forgotten Connecticut children --- not being homeschooled --- killed by their parents or caregivers in 2000-2024 [diagram/picture of 201 small dots/circles].
Williams, Walter 1999, May 23 Untitled. The Washington Times [newspaper]. Discusses the many negative things now being descriptive of the Black/African-American population, such as illegitimacy rate close to 70%, high number of single parent families, high crime rates, and so forth and argues these maladies are not because of a legacy of slavery but of some other fundamental problem. Implies to me that public education has not improved the lot of Blacks in America. Williams is a Black man.
Williams, Walter E. 2008 Liberty versus the tyranny of socialism: Controversial essays. Stanford, CA: Hoover Institution Press. education, home education, economics, teacher education “Most of these inept teachers are graduates of the nation’s schools of education. Unfortunately, for the most part, schools of education, either graduate or undergraduate, are home to students who have the lowest academic achievement test scores when they enter college and they score the lowest among college graduates taking tests, such as [p. 40 ends] GRE, MCAT, or LSAT, to enter professional schools. If we’re really serious about improving public education, we’d shut down schools of education. There is absolutely no relationship between teacher quality and having graduated from a teacher’s college and being teacher certified. There may even be a negative relationship as suggested by the fact that students who are home-schooled by parents who’ve had no teacher training have achievement scores higher than 85 percent of all other students ….. The long-term solution to our education problem is to break the education monopoly by introducing the kind of competition that can come from school vouchers, tuition tax credits, and other school choice programs. Of course the powerful education establishment fights tooth and nail against anything that even smacks of competition.” [p. 41].
Williams-Johnson, Meca, & Cheryl Fields-Smith 2022 Homeschooling among Black families as a form of parental involvement: A focus on parental role construction, efficacy, and emotions. Educational Psychologist, https://doi.org/10.1080/00461520.2022.2129648 https://doi.org/10.1080/00461520.2022.2129648 homeschooling, Black, minorities, parental involvement, parental role construction, racism, discrimination “Abstract: Experiences with racism and other emotionally laden encounters are intricately entangled with parents’ motivations to take direct action that can lead to voluntary separation from school or homeschooling. Using the Hoover-Dempsey and Sandler (HDS) model, this article expands parental involvement by including homeschooling and examines the usefulness of including emotion as a discernible motivator of parental involvement. Research on Black homeschooling is used as an example to explore the psychological and socio-emotional dilemmas parents face when preparing their children to become self-sufficient in an anti-Black lived context. Particular focus is given to parental role construction and efficacy beliefs to describe the intersection of emotions leading to parental actions toward involvement. Marchand et al.’s process of critical action is detailed to further illustrate the complexities of Black parents who actively engage in activities to combat discrimination. New insights on theory adaptation and pathways to inform practice, and recommendations for future research on parental involvement and Black homeschooling are also provided.”
Williamson, Darcy 1979 School at home: An alternative to the public school. Bend, OR: Maverick Publications.
Willingham, Theresa 2009, January The Law of Homeschooling by Brian D. Schwartz home education, homeschooling, law, legal published: Dayton, OH: Education Law Association, Monograph Series no. 78). Journal of School Choice, 3(1), 101 – 105. (This book review considers Schwartz’s book. Reports, “… The Law of Homeschooling was met with doubt and limited expectations by the homeschool community, and apparently with little notice altogether in the public education sphere.” “With the appropriate caveats noted, this can be a useful book for a local library to carry and potentially helpful as a reference to help homeschooling families moving to and from different states as long as they double check with state homeschool groups and state departments of education for up-to-date information and the firsthand experience and know-how of local homeschoolers.”
Willis, Scott 2002, April Customization and the common good: A conversation with Larry Cuban. Educational Leadership, 59(7), 6-11. http://www.ascd.org/portal/site/ascd/template.MAXIMIZE/menuitem.459dee008f99653fb85516f762108a0c/?javax.portlet.tpst=d5b9c0fa1a493266805516f762108a0c_ws_MX&javax.portlet.prp_d5b9c0fa1a493266805516f762108a0c_journaltypeheaderimage=%2FASCD%2Fimages%2Fmultifiles%2Fpublications%2Felmast.gif&javax.portlet.prp_d5b9c0fa1a493266805516f762108a0c_viewID=article_view&javax.portlet.prp_d5b9c0fa1a493266805516f762108a0c_journalmoid=6e436c6e66eaff00VgnVCM1000003d01a8c0RCRD&javax.portlet.prp_d5b9c0fa1a493266805516f762108a0c_articlemoid=64736c6e66eaff00VgnVCM1000003d01a8c0RCRD&javax.portlet.prp_d5b9c0fa1a493266805516f762108a0c_journalTypePersonalization=ASCD_EL&javax.portlet.begCacheTok=token&javax.portlet.endCacheTok=token Retrieved 7/2/07 from http://www.ascd.org/portal/site/ascd/template.MAXIMIZE/menuitem.459dee008f99653fb85516f762108a0c/?javax.portlet.tpst=d5b9c0fa1a493266805516f762108a0c_ws_MX&javax.portlet.prp_d5b9c0fa1a493266805516f762108a0c_journaltypeheaderimage=%2FASCD%2Fimages%2Fmultifiles%2Fpublications%2Felmast.gif&javax.portlet.prp_d5b9c0fa1a493266805516f762108a0c_viewID=article_view&javax.portlet.prp_d5b9c0fa1a493266805516f762108a0c_journalmoid=6e436c6e66eaff00VgnVCM1000003d01a8c0RCRD&javax.portlet.prp_d5b9c0fa1a493266805516f762108a0c_articlemoid=64736c6e66eaff00VgnVCM1000003d01a8c0RCRD&javax.portlet.prp_d5b9c0fa1a493266805516f762108a0c_journalTypePersonalization=ASCD_EL&javax.portlet.begCacheTok=token&javax.portlet.endCacheTok=token. Larry Cuban recognizes that public schools are generally segregated along class and ethnicity and not really “common schools” with all kinds of students mixing on a regular basis; it is a myth that all kind regularly mix. “[Willis:] Do we risk eroding citizenship and the common good if we customize education offerings? [Cuban:] I really don't think so. We don't have a common school per se now. How many big cities have students from all social classes, from different ethnic and racial groups, attending school together? Perhaps that happens in parts of some cities and small towns, but that pattern is atypical. The “common school of all classes, all groups” attending school together doesn't exist very much. What we do have are ideals of a common education that will make people productive workers and civic-minded adults, but a system of practices pitched toward earning credentials to advance each child's economic future. Customizing schools won't cut into that terribly” (online 7/2/07).
Wilson, Douglas 2001 Excused absence: Should Christian kids leave public schools? Mission Viejo, CA: Crux Press. http://www.discerningreader.com/exabdougwil.html home education, private education, public schools, philosophy, religion, reasons “God calls Christian parents to raise their kids for Him, loving Him with all their heart, soul, mind, and strength. But does this divine calling require a distinctively Christian education? Should Christian parents send their kids to public schools as "salt" and "light" or should they take their kids out of public schools to form distinctively Christian schools or home schools dedicated to holding forth Christ as Lord of all? Because our kids belong to God, are we called to surround them with a biblical worldview from the time they get up to the time they go down, including the hours from 8:30am to 2:30pm?” [description retrieved 2/11/03 online http://www.discerningreader.com/exabdougwil.html].
Wilson, Stephanie 1988 Can we clear the air about home schooling? Instructor, 97(5), 11. reasons, socialization, home schooling
Winstanley, Carrie 2009 Too cool for school? Gifted children and homeschooling. Theory and Research in Education, 7(3), 347-362. alternative education, gifted, highly able, homeschooling, parents, talented “Abstract: Homeschooling can be a last resort for frustrated families where gifted children are not having their complex needs met through mainstream schooling. Unlike many other groups of homeschoolcrs, parents of highly able children take this option for pragmatic reasons rather than as a kind of moral stance. This article explores some of the ways that standard schools fail gifted children and presents the perspectives of families who have made the choice to remove their gifted children from the mainstream education system. The difficulties inherent in researching both homeschooling and gifted education are also highlighted” (p. 347).) .
Winter, Phoebe C. 1989 Regulation of home schooling parents in South Carolina: The state's perspective. A symposium presentation at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco, March, 1989.
Winters, Rebecca 2000, September 11 From home to Harvard: Homeschooled kids have earned a college of their own--and admission to elite, traditional campuses. Time, 156(11). Retrieved 9/14/00 online http://www.time.com/time/magazine/articles/0,3266,53959,00.html. http://www.time.com/time/magazine/articles/0,3266,53959,00.html home education, adult, college admission
Wisconsin v. Yoder, 406 U.S. 205 1972 https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/406/205/ https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/406/205/ https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/268/510/ https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/268/510/#534 https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/390/629/ https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/390/629/#639 https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/262/390/ https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/397/728/ https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/268/510/#535 homeschooling, constitutional issues, Constitution, parental rights, philosophy, law, legal, control Supreme Court case; seminal in case that present the idea that the U.S. Constitution highly respects parental authority in the education of children. Often used to bolster the recognized right to homeschool. “There is no doubt as to the power of a State, having a high responsibility for education of its citizens, to impose reasonable regulations for the control and duration of basic education. See, e.g., Pierce v. Society of Sisters, 268 U. S. 510, 268 U. S. 534 (1925). Providing public schools ranks at the very apex of the function of a State. Yet even this paramount responsibility was, in Pierce, made to yield to the right of parents to provide an equivalent education in a privately operated system. There, the Court held that Oregon's statute compelling attendance in a public school from age eight to age 16 unreasonably interfered with the interest of parents in directing the rearing of their offspring, including their education in church-operated schools. As that case suggests, the values of parental direction of the religious upbringing and education of their children in their early and formative years have a high place in our society. See also Ginsberg v. New York, 390 U. S. 629, 390 U. S. 639 (1968); Meyer v. Nebraska, 262 U. S. 390 (1923); cf. Rowan v. Post Office Dept., 397 U. S. 728 (1970). Thus, a State's interest in universal education, however highly we rank it, is not totally free from a balancing process when it impinges on fundamental rights and interests, such as those specifically protected by the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment, and the traditional interest of parents with respect to the religious upbringing of their children so long as they, in the words of Pierce, "prepare [them] for additional obligations." 268 U.S. at 268 U. S. 535.” (p. 406). “We must not forget that, in the Middle Ages, important values of the civilization of the Western World were preserved by members of religious orders who isolated themselves from all worldly influences against great obstacles. There can be no assumption that today's majority is "right," and the Amish and others like them are "wrong." A way of life that is odd or even erratic but interferes with no rights or interests of others is not to be condemned because it is different” (p. 406). The Court’s opinion suggests that this is all about state versus parental authority or right to control a child’s education: “… the interest of parents in directing the rearing of their offspring.”
Wise, A. E. 1977 Why educational policies often fail: the hyperrationalization hypothesis. Curriculum Studies, 9, 43-57. Criticism of current trends in educational policymaking.
Wise, A. E. 1978 Minimum competency testing: another case of hyper-rationalization. Phi Delta Kappan, 59, 596-598. Criticism of current trends in educational policy making.
Witt, Portia J. 2026 A qualitative examination of the motivations for homeschooling among black Americans. Doctoral Ph.D. dissertation, Louisiana State University. “ABSTRACT This qualitative phenomenological study explored the motivations and lived experiences of African American homeschooling families. Twelve Black parents from multiple states participated in semi-structured interviews. Data were analyzed using Moustakas’ (1994) Modified Stevick–Colaizzi–Keen method and coded thematically using NVivo. Nine themes emerged: autonomy, holistic education, community belonging, online networks, public resources, curriculum gaps, personal values, effective learning, and legacy of harm. While racialization in schools—including tracking, microaggressions, and misidentification—contributed to participants’ decisions, motivations also reflected intersectional factors such as faith, disability, mental health needs, giftedness, and a desire for cultural protection and flexible learning. Findings suggest homeschooling serves as a pathway for self-determination, cultural preservation, and emotional safety. Implications include developing culturally responsive homeschool networks, strengthening policy protections for Black homeschoolers, and training social workers and educators to recognize homeschooling as a valid educational and therapeutic intervention, and educational autonomy for Black families is a necessary right, not an option. This study contributes empirically by centering Black American homeschooling families’ lived experiences and identifying homeschooling as a values-driven, child-responsive educational practice. Theoretically, it extends Critical Race Theory and Bronfenbrenner’s Ecological Systems Theory by showing how educational self-determination functions as an intersectional, non-monolithic form of ecological redesign and counter-narrative agency in response to structural inequities. Keywords: African American; Black; Critical Race Theory (CRT); Home Education; Home Schooling; Qualitative Methodology; Race; Racism; School Choice)” (p. viii).
Witt, Valerie Lynn 1994 A descriptive study and needs assessment of the typical Washington homeschool family. Unpublished master's thesis, Saint Martin's College, Lacey, WA. home education, research, cooperation, public schools, private schools, professional educators, needs assessment and wants "While most of those [home educators] surveyed believe that public schools are doing a poor job of educating students, they do not necessarily view school districts as antagonists and are not averse to using public school resources if designed to encourage and help them in their task. They are more than willing to access services outside of the home, and would welcome opportunities for participation in programs and activities designed for homeschoolers by public and/or private schools interested in the success of their children. Creative educators and school districts would be doing themselves and homeschoolers a great service by developing and implementing programs to meet the needs of the growing number of families who are choosing to take on the enormous and admirable task of educating their own children (p. 22-23).
Wnek, Madilee C. 1995, March Teach your children well: Home-schooling's flexibility attracts more families. Military Lifestyle, 2(3), 20-22, 80. home education, anecdotes, military Mentions research, anecdotes, written to the military audience.
Wolf, Patrick J.; Lee, Matthew H.; & Watson, Angela R. 2020 Harvard law professor’s attack on homeschooling is a flawed failure. And terribly timed, too. Retrieved December 29, 2020 from https://www.educationnext.org/harvard-law-professors-attack-on-homeschooling-flawed-failure-terribly-timed/ https://www.educationnext.org/harvard-law-professors-attack-on-homeschooling-flawed-failure-terribly-timed/ homeschooling, home education, research, philosophy, law, legal, abuse, Bartholet, ban “Upon reviewing Professor Bartholet’s article, we conclude that it suffers from contradictions, factual errors, statements of stereotyping, and a failure seriously to consider that the alternative to homeschooling–public schooling–shares the problems that she attributes to home education. One need not have personal experience with homeschooling to identify the article’s many flaws.” “The article contains a number of assertions about homeschooling that are clearly undermined by the facts and unsupported by her sources.” “She [Bartholet] criticizes parents who homeschool for having values that run counter to those of the larger society, thus undermining the values of pluralism and toleration of people with views of the good life that differ from one’s own. She demonstrates prejudice against immigrants by asserting that non-English-speaking parents are incapable of homeschooling their children. ….. These are some of the statements that leapt out as offensive to us.”
Wood, Patricia 2003 Homeschooling and higher education. ERIC Digest. ERIC Reproduction Service Number ED480468. Retrieved 4/18/08 from http://www.eric.ed.gov/. http://www.eric.ed.gov/ “Current evidence indicates that homeschoolers' college academic performance is comparable to that of traditionally educated students.”
Woodard, Joseph 2026 The state of the homeschool movement: Canada 2019-2024. Published by Canadian Centre for Home Education (CCHE). Canada, homeschooling, home education, population size, demographics “Here [in Canada], the [homeschool] movement total has grown from 102,200 to 157,000 kids: 2.6 percent of school-aged children, pre-Covid, to 4.4 percent during the lockdowns, to 3.9 percent immediately following, to 3.7 percent, three years later (or 4.0 percent, if immigrant-based population growth is discounted).”
WorldNetDaily 2008, July 25 Ban on aid for Christian college students tossed: '1st Amendment does not permit government to judge theology classes'. Retrieved 7/24/08 from http://www.worldnetdaily.com/index.php?pageId=70453. http://www.worldnetdaily.com/index.php?pageId=70453 Federal court’s decision shows that all education is in some ways religious or full of beliefs and worldview. “A federal court has ordered the state of Colorado to stop discriminating against students of a Christian college, a facility that state officials determined provided too much religion. The state for years has provided grants to students of secular institutions as well as students at a Methodist university and a Roman Catholic university, according to yesterday's opinion from the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. However, students at Colorado Christian University, a non-denominational evangelical Protestant university, were banned from the grant program after state officials decided the school was too pervasively sectarian. "We find the exclusion unconstitutional for two reasons: The program expressly discriminates among religions without constitutional justification, and its criteria for doing so involves unconstitutionally intrusive scrutiny of religious belief and practice," the opinion said.” “Further, "The line drawn by the Colorado statute between 'indoctrination' and mere education, is highly subjective and susceptible to abuse. Educators impart information and perspectives to students because they regard them as true or valuable. Whether an outsider will deem their efforts to be 'indoctrination' or mere 'education' depends as much on the observer's point of view as on any objective evaluation," the court said.”
Worona, Jay 1989 A legal analysis of home schooling in the United States: A summary of remarks. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco, CA, March 27-31, 1989.
Wright, Cheryl 1988, November Home school research: Critique and suggestions for the future. Education and Urban Society, 21(1), 96-113. Educational Research, Family Characteristics, Family Environment, Home Schooling, Research Needs, Research Problems While earlier studies have concentrated only on the home environment, future studies should instead look at the forces which surround the home.
Wright, Rebecca 2010 The state of homeschooling in the State of Tennessee. Paper presented in a college course at Peabody College – Vanderbilt University, Spring 2010. home education, homeschooling, Tennessee, policy, philosophy “Executive Summary ….. The main problem is that there is very little research on homeschoolers in Tennessee (TN) and homeschooling in general, and there is little communication and collaboration between homeschoolers and public school districts. One reason for this is the simple fact that homeschooling is a contentious issue, and there are many stakeholders. Homeschoolers as a group are not united but most are against additional government regulation and monitoring of homeschooling, while public schools/districts want increased accountability for homeschoolers. The general public is also largely uninformed about homeschooling which has allowed negative stereotypes of homeschoolers to pervade the public mind set, and has further complicated this political quandary. All these factors have led to another problem in many states (such as TN) in which stakeholders are at odds over what homeschool policies and laws should be in place. TN is fortunate in that it has a strong homeschool organization base and a teachers union that is willing to work with homeschoolers. The main barrier that stands between these two factions working together is that no one from either side has actually tried to collaborate and communicate with the other side. Granted, both sides do not completely agree on homeschool policy, and even homeschoolers themselves are divided on some of the issues, but one thing that links them all together is the desire to give children a great education. The key is for all stakeholders (policy makers, homeschoolers, public schools/districts, the teachers union, the school boards association, the school superintendents association) to work together to come up with policy solutions that can be accepted by all sides. As of right now, this may seem impossible, due in part to a lack of collaboration. When bills that deal with homeschooling pass the state legislature, one side ―wins‖ and one side ―loses‖ and that is how the policymakers and other stakeholders look at it. One way to bridge the divide is to educate the general public, public schools/districts, and policy makers about homeschooling, its history, practice, and philosophies. By doing so, they will be able to better understand homeschoolers and thus be able to communicate better with homeschoolers. The TN Department of Education could foster this communication and collaboration through implementing homeschool information professional development sessions, providing resources and information on homeschooling, and facilitating meetings to discuss homeschooling. If all homeschoolers and public schools/districts and policy makers can come together from a place of mutual understanding of one another, then perhaps policies can be created that will satisfy all sides and most importantly, enhance the education of homeschool and public school students. History has shown us that fighting about education won’t solve anything, but coming together, understanding one another, learning from each other, and communicating across all that divides has the potential to build an education system that benefits all children and unites a nation [p. 3-4].”
Wright, Stuart A. 1986 Home Schools, Value Conflict, and Socialization: An analysis of the Christian Home School Movement. Lamar University. Paper presented at the annual meetings of the Society for the Scientific Study of Religion, Washington D.C., November 15, 1986.
Wright, Tricia 2016 Comparing the financial literacy of public school, Christian school, and homeschooled students. Journal of Research on Christian Education, 25(1), 56-75. “Abstract. The 2008 recession underscored public concern that financial illiteracy has costs that are not limited to the individual who makes poor financial decisions. Considering that college students with limited financial experience are making legally binding decisions, this study explored the personal finance literacy and behavior of Christian college students. The research involved administering an objective item financial literacy and behavior survey. Findings showed a significant positive correlation between financial literacy and behavior. Furthermore, there was no significant difference among Christian college students based on their secondary education experience—Christian, public, or home school [homeschool]. This finding implies that students enter college with similar financial literacy levels, and senior students with inadequate financial literacy demonstrate poor personal financial behavior.”
Wrigley, E. A. 1977 Reflections on the history of the family. Daedalus, 106, 71-85.
Wuthnow, Robert 1988 The restructuring of American religion: Society and faith since World War II. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Growth of Christian schools to propagate ideas, p. 198.
Wyatt, Gary 1999 The homeschool movement in the postmodern age. Home School Researcher, 13(4), 23-30. home education, research, theoretical, sociology Examines home schooling as a social movement.
Wyatt, Gary 2008 Family ties: Relationships, socialization, and home schooling. Lanham, MD: University Press of America.
Wynn, Donald E. 1988 A study of the development of home schools as an alternative to public school education. Dissertation Abstracts International, 48(11), 2767A.
Wynn, Donald E. 1989 A study of the development of home schools as an alternative to public school education. Home School Researcher, 5(1), 11-20.
Yarnall, Louise 1998, October 29 Where the kitchen is also the classroom: Online courses have given a new impetus to the home-schooling movement. New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/1998/10/29/technology/where-the-kitchen-is-also-the-classroom.html?scp=1&sq=Where%20the%20kitchen%20is%20also%20the%20classroom%20yarnall&st=cse home education, technology, distance education Retrieved 3/11/2010 from http://www.nytimes.com/1998/10/29/technology/where-the-kitchen-is-also-the-classroom.html?scp=1&sq=Where%20the%20kitchen%20is%20also%20the%20classroom%20yarnall&st=cse. Suggests that technology, including computers and the Internet, and distance-education courses will significantly increase the numbers of families home schooling in America.
Yastrow, Sybil 1990 Home instruction: A national study of state law. Home School Researcher, 6(1), 13-18. home education, law
Yeager, E.T. Yeager 1999 A study of cooperation between home schools and public and private schools, K-12. Doctoral (Ed.D.) dissertation, Texas A & M University.
Yeager, Evan T., & Yeager, Joleen L. 1992 Texas home school primer. Available from Proverbs 22:6 Consulting, 1302 Monroe St., Commerce TX 75428. home education, research, how to, opinion, religion Reviews research and nonacademic sources, heavily relies on writings of Raymond Moore, provides biblical scriptures and rationales for home education, gives ideas on how to get started in home education and resources available.
Yu, Martin C.; Sackett, Paul R.; Kuncel, Nathan R. 2016 Predicting College Performance of Homeschooled versus Traditional Students. Educational Measurement: Issues and Practice, 35(4), pp. 31–39. admissions, college, homeschooling, home schooling, home education, homeschool, predictive bias, academic achievement, Peer reviewed “In this study, we aim [purpose of study] to expand and to improve on the existing research on the academic outcomes of homeschooled students as compared to traditional students, and to address the lack of knowledge as to what predicts performance during college or university for homeschooled students” (p. 32). “The prevalence of homeschooling in the United States is increasing. Yet little is known about how commonly used predictors of postsecondary academic performance (SAT, high school grade point average [HSGPA]) perform for homeschooled students. Postsecondary performance at 140 colleges and universities was analyzed comparing a sample of traditional students matched to a sample of 732 homeschooled students on four demographic variables, HSGPA, and SAT scores. “Data for this study were provided by the College Board on 825,672 first-year students from 2009 to 2011 at 195 postsecondary institutions across the United States, of which 732 students at 140 of these postsecondary institutions were homeschooled prior to admission (specifically, at the time they took the SAT)” (p. 32). “From the overall sample of 824,940 traditional students, a subset was matched to the homeschooled students on postsecondary institution, gender, ethnicity, HSGPA, SAT, and SES. For the purposes of the matching procedure only, HSGPA, SAT, and SES were standardized within institution so that they would all be on the same scale with a mean of 0 and SD = 1. The matching procedure was carried out sequentially for each homeschooled student” (p. 33). The carefully matched sample was drawn from 824,940 traditional students attending the same institutions as the homeschooled students, which permitted a very precise level of matching. This comparison did not show a difference in first-year college GPA (FGPA) or retention between homeschooled and traditional students. SAT scores predicted FGPA and retention equally well for both groups, but HSGPA was a weaker predictor for the homeschooled group [emphasis added]. These results suggest that, among college students, those who were homeschooled perform similarly to traditionally educated students matched on demographics and academic preparedness, but there are practical implications for college admissions in the use of HSGPA versus standardized test scores for homeschooled students” (p. 31). “Indeed, when we compared our sample of homeschooled students who were enrolled in college to a more representative group of traditional students matched on postsecondary institution, gender, race, academic preparedness, and socioeconomic status, performance differences between homeschooled and traditional students effectively disappeared. Therefore, while homeschooled students can be as successful as traditional students in college or university, simply having been homeschooled does not appear to be an advantage or disadvantage among students enrolled in college” (p. 36). “As it stands, the only differences observed in this study between homeschooled and traditional students who were enrolled in college is the differential prediction of first-year college GPA and retention by high school GPA. In sum, while the SAT composite score predicts FGPA and RET equally well for both groups, HSGPA is a drastically worse predictor of FGPA and RET for the homeschooled group. Furthermore, when homeschooling is accounted for, if SAT is used to predict FGPA, adding HSGPA provides a smaller incremental prediction ([delta]R2 =.03) when compared to adding SAT to HSGPA ([delta]R2 = .09). In other words, the SAT is a substantially more useful predictor of college success for homeschooled students than is HSGPA.” (p. 37). “Further research will be needed to address these other areas of comparison, and we suggest that future research comparing homeschooled students to traditional students should use a sample of traditional students matched to as many characteristics of the homeschooled students as possible [matched-pair design, in a way]” (p. 38). “In summary, the results of his study provide positive support that college students who were homeschooled can perform as well as those who received a traditional education. However, while SAT scores predict college performance equally well for both homeschooled and traditional students, the high school GPA of homeschooled students should be carefully considered because it may not be as predictive of their performance in college compared to the high school GPA of traditional students. Ultimately, this suggests that the high school GPA of homeschooled students should always be considered in conjunction with standardized measures such as the SAT, and supports some implementation of different admissions policies for homeschooled and traditional students” (p. 38) Peer reviewed.) p
Yudof, Mark G., Kirp, David L., Van Geel, Tyll, & Levin, Betsy Kirp & Yudof's Educational Policy and the Law: Cases and materials. briefly mentions home education, pragmatic on what works in education.
Yuracko, Kim 2007, April 14 Education off the grid: Constitutional constraints on homeschooling. Northwestern University School of Law, Northwestern Public Law Research Paper No. 07-11. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=980100 home education, policy, law, legal, opinion, philosophy, sexism, negative criticism, negative critic Retrieved 4/29/08 from http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=980100. [probably same article as follows: Yuracko, K. A. (2008). Education off the grid: Constitutional constraints on home schooling. California Law Review, 96, 123-184.] “Homeschooling in America is no longer a fringe phenomenon. Estimates indicate that well over one million children are currently being homeschooled. Although homeschoolers are a diverse group, the movement has come to be defined and dominated by its fundamentalist Christian majority. Many Christians who choose to homeschool do so in order to shield their children from secular influences and liberal values. In response to political pressure from this group, states are increasingly abdicating control and oversight in this realm. Modern-day homeschooling thus raises important questions concerning the obligations of states toward children raised in illiberal subgroups. Surprisingly, the legal and philosophical issues raised by homeschooling have been almost entirely ignored by scholars. This Article seeks to begin to fill this void by examining the constitutional implications of state abdication in this area. The Article relies on federal state action doctrine and state constitution education clauses to argue that states must regulate homeschooling to ensure that parents provide their children with a basic minimum education. Further, the Article argues that the Equal Protection Clause imposes limits on the degree of sexist homeschooling that states may permit. In other words, while there is an upper constitutional limit on states’ ability to regulate and control children’s education, there is a lower limit as well. States may not avoid this mandated minimum with constitutional impunity” [abstract, p. 1]. Expresses strong concerns that homeschool parents and their children have far too much freedom in the United States. Posits that religious homeschoolers have “… a belief in parental control— [p. 5 ends] indeed ownership—of children” [p. 6]. “Surprisingly, the social and legal implications of this phenomenon have received almost no scholarly attention. For decades political theorists have worried and argued about what steps a liberal society must take to protect children being raised in illiberal communities. They have focused their attention on the extent to which a liberal society must permit or condemn such practices as polygamy, clitoridectomy, and child marriage. Virtually absent from the debate has [p. 9 ends] been any discussion of the extent to which a liberal society should condone or constrain homeschooling, particularly as practiced by religious fundamentalist families explicitly seeking to shield their children from liberal values of sex equality, gender role fluidity and critical rationality” [p. 10]. “First, it [this paper] argues that states must—not may or should—regulate homeschooling to ensure that parents provide their children with a basic constitutionally mandated minimum education. Second, it argues that states must check rampant forms of sexism in homeschooling so as to prevent the severe under-education of girls by homeschooling parents who believe in female subordination” [p. 11].
Yuracko, Kimberly A. 2008 Education off the grid: Constitutional constraints on homeschooling. California Law Review, 96, 123-184. homeschooling, home education, law, legal, philosophy, rights “[abstract] “Homeschooling in America is no longer a fringe phenomenon. Estimates indicate that well over one million children are currently being homeschooled. Although homeschoolers are a diverse group, the movement has come to be defined and dominated by its fundamentalist Christian majority. Many Christians who choose to homeschool do so in order to shield their children from secular influences and liberal values. In response to political pressure from this group, states are increasingly abdicating control and oversight in this realm. Modern-day homeschooling thus raises important questions concerning the obligations of states toward children raised in illiberal subgroups. Surprisingly, the legal and philosophical issues raised by homeschooling have been almost entirely ignored by scholars. This Article seeks to begin to fill this void by examining the constitutional implications of state abdication in this area. The Article relies on federal state action doctrine and state constitution education clauses to argue that states must regulate homeschooling to ensure that parents provide their children with a basic minimum level of education. Further, the Article argues that the Equal Protection Clause imposes limits on the degree of sexist homeschooling that states may permit. In other words, while there is an upper constitutional limit on states' ability to regulate and control children 's education, there is a lower limit as well. States may not avoid this mandated minimum with constitutional impunity” (p. 123-124). “A review of popular Christian homeschooling curricula, books and websites reveals an ideology of female subservience and rigid gender role differentiation” (p. 156).
Yusof, Noraisha c. 2004 An investigation into the teaching of mathematics by home educators. Paper presented at the British Educational Research Association conference, September 15-18, 2004 at UMIST. mailto:n.f.yusof@warwick.ac.uk home education, research, mathematics education, parental involvement Available from author, Mathematics Education Research Centre, University of Warwick, COVENTRY CV4 7AL, UK, n.f.yusof@warwick.ac.uk “This study investigates the nature of mathematics education through the eyes of a home educating parent. As an exploratory study, we consider how the home-educating parents’ educational beliefs affect their mathematical pedagogy. Their educational philosophies, conceptions of mathematics and teaching practices are discussed. Parents’ views of mathematics education strongly influenced their choice of mathematical activity and curriculum. A home education gave parents the flexibility to design a curriculum based on their personal beliefs of mathematics, and also the perceived interests and abilities of their children. Further research will address the effects of such an education on the children’s mathematical understanding and development.”
Zakarian, Fiaba; Murphy, Nora A.; & Fisher, Emily S. 2025 Perceptions of homeschooled students among U.S. adult populations Implications for school psychologists. Contemporary School Psychology, https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40688-025-00541-y https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40688-025-00541-y “Abstract. Though homeschooled students comprise more than 2 million of all U.S. grade-school students, little research exists on how they are viewed by the general U.S. population, which has implications for their interactions with public school personnel, including school psychologists. Two studies assessed potential stereotypes. Study 1 participants (N = 182) listed terms associated with a homeschooled student. As predicted, negative topic groupings emerged, including being awkward and sheltered; yet, positive topic groupings also emerged. Study 2 participants (N = 249) read about a fictional student whose reasons for homeschooling were manipulated (religion, safety, parental dissatisfaction, no reason). Compared to a public-school condition, students in all homeschooled conditions were rated lower on positive social characteristics. Implications for school psychologists are discussed.” Keywords Homeschool · Student · Stereotypes · School psychologists · Special education
Zakariya, Sally Banks 1988, May Home schooling litigation tests state compulsory education laws. American School Board Journal, 175 (5), 45-46. Compulsory Education, Court Litigation, Home Schooling, School Attendance Legislation, State Legislation In the interest of court peace, local school boards are given the advice to work with parents, with the advice of their local attorney.
Zeitlin, Solomon 1969 The rise and fall of the Judean state: a political, social, and religious history of the second commonwealth. Vol 2: 37 B.C.E. to 66 C.E. Philadelphia, PA: The Jewish Publication Society of America. Vol 1: 332-37 B.C.E., Vol 3: 66-120 C.E. Comprehensive survey of the Jewish state in the centuries surrounding the writing of the New Testament; much discussion describes the political events and their repercussions in a readable way. Each of the volumes had one or two chapters that discuss more the social and religious developments; with much to be learned about childhood and education at the time.
Zhang, Chun 2015 Challenging the tiger mother stereotype? Christian Chinese immigrant homeschooling mothers’ parenting practices. Doctoral (Ph.D.) dissertation, University of Minnesota. Cross Cultural Parenting, Parent-child conflict, parent-child relationship, Parenting values, Parenting practice, Tiger mother, homeschooling, home education Abstract. Good parenting has a major influence on positive child outcomes (Baumrind1983; Darling & Steinberg, 1993), and parents often seek information about how to raise their children according to their personal and cultural values. Young Chinese parents tend to seek information and materials originating in the West for good parenting references because of the lack of indigenous parenting studies (Goh, 2011) and because of their higher regard for Western society (Fong, 2004; Goh, 2011). However, Chinese immigrant families who live in the United States increasingly choose to homeschool their children for academic reasons and/or religious reasons (Fu, 2008; Sun, 2007). The purpose of this ethnographic study is to explore three evangelical Christian Chinese immigrant homeschooling mothers’ cross-cultural parenting practices in the United States. This study addresses three research questions: (1) What does it mean for evangelical Christian Chinese immigrant mothers to home educate their children? (2) How do evangelical Christian Chinese immigrant homeschooling mothers and their children interact with each other when confronting conflicts in the homeschooling setting? and (3) What stories do evangelical Christian Chinese immigrant homeschooling mothers tell regarding their parenting beliefs and practices in the homeschooling setting in the U.S.? These research questions emerged from an extensive literature review. Three evangelical Christian Chinese immigrant homeschooling mothers were recruited to participate in this study. Data were collected through intensive participatory observation, interviews, and selective documentary collection at each mother’ home. The findings suggested that identity is subjective and context oriented. Additionally, three parenting patterns were illustrated from these Christian Chinese immigrant homeschooling mothers’ parent-child conflict management: (1) pushing for obedience and immediate discipline, if needed; (2) negotiated child obedience; (3) letting go without pushing for obedience. Implications from this study suggest the need for individualized and cultural-sensitive parent education programs.”
Ziegelman, Elinor G. 1986 The effects of home-based and center-based teaching strategies on Head Start children's language development. (ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED287606) Home schooling, parent participation 27 boys and 26 girls, pretest-posttest control group design was used. Experimental group consisted of 23 home-based subjects and 30 center-based subjects over seven months, parents received training, language development measured by Learning Accomplishment Profile, home-based program had a significantly greater effect on children's language, with home-based boys making greatest gains.
Ziegelman, Elinor G. 1986 The Effects of Home-Based and Center-Based Teaching Strategies on Head Start Children's Language Development. 12pp. A research report).
Zirkel, Perry A. 1985, October 30 Defense of home instruction not warranted. Education Week, p. 19.
Zirkel, Perry A. 1991 Home schooling. Phi Delta Kappan, 72(5), 408-409.
Zirkel, Perry A., & Gluckman, Ivan B. 1983 A legal brief: home instruction. NASSP Bulletin, 67, 118-120. "The matter of home instruction primarily depends upon interpretation of state statutes" [p. ?]. "Home instruction is one of the subjects that illustrates the degree to which the education of children is still recognized by the law to be a societal as well as a parental concern" [p. 120].
Zirkel, Perry, & Gluckman, Ivan 1983 Home instruction: When it's legal. Principal, 62(3), 37-38.
Blumenfeld Education Letter, 2408 Main St., P.O. Box 45161, Boise, ID 83711. education, home education Keeps people current on educational issues from strong, biblical perspective, frequently mentions home education in positive fashion.
Author Date / Year Title URL Keywords / Descriptors Annotation / Notes